id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02333v1 | Why do LLaVA Vision-Language Models Reply to Images in English? | 2024-07-02T15:01:55 | 2024-07-02T15:01:55 | Musashi Hinck, Carolin Holtermann, Matthew Lyle Olson, Florian Schneider, Sungduk Yu, Anahita Bhiwandiwalla, Anne Lauscher, Shaoyen Tseng, Vasudev Lal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We uncover a surprising multilingual bias occurring in a popular class of
multimodal vision-language models (VLMs). Including an image in the query to a
LLaVA-style VLM significantly increases the likelihood of the model returning
an English response, regardless of the language of the query. This paper
investigates the causes of this loss with a two-pronged approach that combines
extensive ablation of the design space with a mechanistic analysis of the
models' internal representations of image and text inputs. Both approaches
indicate that the issue stems in the language modelling component of the LLaVA
model. Statistically, we find that switching the language backbone for a
bilingual language model has the strongest effect on reducing this error.
Mechanistically, we provide compelling evidence that visual inputs are not
mapped to a similar space as text ones, and that intervening on intermediary
attention layers can reduce this bias. Our findings provide important insights
to researchers and engineers seeking to understand the crossover between
multimodal and multilingual spaces, and contribute to the goal of developing
capable and inclusive VLMs for non-English contexts. | [
-0.4217601717,
-0.5338863134,
0.5078175068,
0.25352332,
-0.3912621737,
-0.0050376011,
0.1577858776,
-0.8669065237,
0.1553331763,
0.5217744112,
-0.6020604968,
-0.0335057229,
-0.5505982637,
0.0857614428,
-0.3746896982,
0.4714965522,
-0.3999893665,
0.3637590706,
-0.529737711,
-0.3356151879,
-0.5100178719,
-0.5042597651,
-0.5128392577,
-0.3305153847,
0.8519791961,
0.1038678959,
0.5453344584,
0.2355451435,
0.5471479893,
0.1979980916,
0.0774449185,
0.2970968783,
-0.3627336323,
0.110213697,
-0.1078746319,
-0.7709642053,
-0.0625921339,
-0.3695762455,
0.5192614198,
0.5126502514,
0.1620404869,
0.2120583206,
0.1830521226,
0.6862155795,
-0.7411689162,
0.2024010569,
-0.5268650651,
0.0227875002,
-0.3903535306,
-0.2830626369,
-0.642524004,
0.4113676846,
-0.1604654342,
-0.2839954495,
-0.1299216002,
0.209633112,
1.0624493361,
0.2217876464,
-0.6476414204,
-0.0906217769,
-0.6886779666,
0.84960711,
-0.3821638227,
0.7694401145,
0.2186233103,
0.2426134348,
0.1677752435,
-0.1192430854,
-0.5608108044,
-0.1516454667,
-0.2263841927,
0.2441349924,
-0.349185735,
-0.015639646,
-0.0255842563,
-0.1415949762,
-0.5697673559,
0.1478617042,
-0.540271461,
-0.2569568455,
0.5224923491,
0.0907010213,
0.3709740341,
0.1042728946,
-0.237174511,
-0.1748916358,
-0.8253384233,
0.0973011777,
0.4117122293,
0.1972183734,
-0.2305391729,
0.8461555243,
0.1377313286,
0.8313201666,
-0.2169705331,
-0.3186211884,
0.1194645613,
-0.2969022989,
-0.1783182472,
-0.1902087331,
0.6092441082,
0.9423204064,
0.4369011819,
0.206317082,
-0.2170794904,
0.323076576,
0.0515853465,
-0.4602858424,
0.1108215973,
0.0760028362,
-0.3874628544,
-0.098641932,
-0.4478084445,
-0.5280566216,
-0.3929041922,
-0.1365864277,
0.1558526456,
-0.0753366128,
-0.2254043519,
0.0083873197,
-0.0997411907,
0.4048232138,
0.431733042,
-0.809366405,
-0.0900429264,
0.0580721945,
0.5109003186,
-0.1308670491,
-0.4750375748,
-0.1886247993,
0.1307278425,
-0.5395382047,
1.2050825357,
-0.5656304359,
-0.3123550713,
0.1539233327,
0.2313091606,
-0.0126510281,
-0.3982793093,
0.1049075499,
-0.6088634729,
0.3039835691,
-0.3224335909,
0.108005695,
-0.1642063111,
0.281047374,
-0.6130132675,
0.7282227874,
-0.2911061049,
-0.7969838381,
0.4410910606,
-0.2611632347,
-0.3923572004,
-0.2237518579,
-0.5255619884,
-0.2241924703,
0.4321509004,
0.2962145805,
0.0609042905,
-0.4196374714,
-0.0326907933,
-0.3196438253,
-0.194681406,
0.1617836505,
-0.5651240349,
0.6974265575,
0.2058862448,
-0.0384652801,
-0.075834237,
-0.5203377008,
-0.2232038677,
0.57481879,
-0.4031791091,
-0.781309545,
0.1564648598,
0.3557196259,
0.3134645224,
0.095734857,
-0.5538945198,
-0.0044145645,
-0.1884483844,
0.026916055,
0.6932250857,
-0.3268256187,
0.6100780368,
-0.1053856239,
0.5613541007,
0.2749594152,
0.2250199467,
-0.3271049857,
-0.5982095003,
-0.7521588206,
-0.1054392308,
-0.1308827996,
0.6591674685,
-1.1270155907,
-0.6443663239,
-0.0833247975,
-0.0337562673,
-0.9447466731,
0.2595029771,
0.4830319881,
0.4631316662,
0.0399585478,
-0.3589133322,
-0.5341848135,
-1.6313874722,
-0.4057427347,
-0.3200048506,
0.1448742896,
0.4968448281,
0.2844957411,
-0.3490610123,
0.5160362124,
-0.1174512058,
-0.3669658005,
-0.3940466344,
-0.4102592766,
0.1091664359,
0.0082320655,
0.9114409089,
-0.8740983605,
-0.5238027573,
0.2825999558,
-0.8333066702,
-0.2008604258,
-0.2049085945,
-0.0070488551,
0.494317323,
0.2947846055,
-0.5074653625,
0.680495441,
0.7503456473,
-0.2317335308,
0.5095325112,
-0.0434309095,
0.2965093255,
-0.8384733796,
-0.3246822655,
0.1772519648,
-0.0946373641,
-0.3916463852,
0.3690111637,
0.4174223244,
0.0755414739,
-0.9088052511,
0.8929062486,
-0.7034903765,
-0.2963433266,
-0.2382017672,
0.0274758544,
0.5028383136,
0.4678741395,
-0.0177555475,
0.8981396556,
0.5601422191,
-0.350538969,
0.3494703174,
0.2625919878,
-0.1560399383,
0.8034384847,
-0.586926043,
-0.0697742328,
-0.608733654,
-0.1168960407,
-1.3446879387,
-0.1860737801,
0.2228169441,
-0.3370708525,
0.5059806108,
-0.1947471201,
-0.4079222381,
-0.4423663616,
-0.2985793948,
0.6961066127,
0.3479725718,
-0.6197729707,
0.703971386,
0.3318546712,
-0.0037044524,
-0.684620738,
-1.2896522284,
0.3110086024,
-0.0567993298,
-0.876640141,
0.0909340307,
0.0052167326,
-0.6356344819,
0.0360823944,
0.0408822522,
-0.1779782921,
-0.0997491628,
-0.1199178249,
0.4186848998,
-0.2322750241,
0.0480789952,
0.003806422,
0.252659291,
0.1300843805,
-0.1293988973,
0.4092587531,
0.0889448971,
-0.6646727324,
-0.3693039119,
0.6202355027,
0.7775762677,
-0.2836437523,
0.6807900071,
0.0893618688,
-0.0934014767,
0.0221884791,
-0.504046917,
0.0220846497,
-0.430762738,
0.7229070067,
-0.5036020279,
-0.4843760729,
0.6076313853,
0.3822632134,
0.2033843398,
0.2290052921,
0.6577835083,
-0.5214274526,
1.020228982,
0.7860485315,
0.3128358424,
0.5218384266,
-0.0232229829,
0.3114725947,
-0.901850462,
-0.4101468623,
-0.211234957,
-0.2516374886,
-0.3950186372,
-0.3192695081,
0.4615714848,
-0.6376626492,
0.3018976748,
-0.0393083356,
-0.2222863436,
0.5060765147,
0.436825037,
-0.049951978,
0.0665236264,
0.5104126334,
-0.1927795112,
-0.4196154773,
-0.69510746,
-0.2202225029,
0.9576324821,
0.2827281654,
1.1571527719,
0.1888516694,
0.3708943129,
0.0062205526,
0.134131521,
-0.7122899294,
0.5044843554,
-0.1766602844,
-0.6358222365,
0.0545619056,
0.1190352291,
-1.0242468119,
0.6274782419,
-0.1422374398,
-0.4331524074,
0.1399692446,
0.343985945,
0.2357552946,
0.361531049,
-0.7460768223,
0.4741871357,
-0.579361856,
-0.9927459955,
-0.116961509,
-0.2856060863,
0.5538290143,
-0.1338065565,
0.7423658967,
0.1898016334,
0.0237818025,
0.2602720857,
-0.0995260328,
0.9906398058,
0.0136510311,
-0.4635598958,
0.1572575569,
0.2114160061,
0.3739507198,
-0.2284999937,
0.2888340652,
0.3008286357,
-0.3648617268,
-0.6228266954,
-0.3974189162,
0.4807994664,
-0.6886755824,
-0.8264009356,
-0.2186929584,
-0.5908293724,
-0.2152241617,
0.0501409881,
0.3708415329,
0.4765113294,
0.1210686415,
0.0500343814,
0.6284193397,
-0.5299420357,
0.5000277162,
0.3085147142,
-0.573184073,
0.0143687902,
0.4794955552,
0.2209469229,
0.3938902617,
0.3567941189,
-0.1721465737,
-0.3799516857,
-0.3855228126,
-0.7411805987,
0.5199629664,
-1.0511068106,
0.0719825178,
-0.4606759846,
0.0177076496,
-0.39417997,
-0.160169214,
-0.4046969116,
-0.168579042,
-0.1489022672,
-0.0627745092,
0.0524531715,
0.7017022371,
0.3079257309,
0.1442700177,
-0.4969480932,
0.3104763329,
0.3416320682,
0.3145430088,
-0.0444764793,
-0.7120105624,
-0.1840821952,
0.0564955808,
-0.1459978819,
-1.1390074492,
0.4634742141,
0.261438638,
0.6707861423,
0.0708474591,
-0.35812819,
0.6291822791,
-0.7679979801,
0.8044786453,
0.2037290484,
-0.267210871,
0.5285829902,
-0.2090756446,
0.5930731893,
-0.0132381702,
0.1368326545,
-0.4973466396,
-0.5653471947,
-0.1094079614,
-1.005142808,
0.2536404431,
-0.1022262722,
0.3993086517,
-0.0807575732,
-0.0654463544,
0.0765780136,
0.0978607014,
-1.1536442041,
-0.2240368277,
-0.1696711183,
-0.0761649385,
0.0971059054,
-0.5633143783,
-0.1815431416,
0.0226946808,
0.4710394442,
-0.1655772924,
0.2495741844,
0.2790312469,
-0.5110941529,
-0.1281599998,
0.1746015847,
0.8323740959,
0.5641428828,
0.2327862829,
0.2747759223,
0.0661665052,
-0.2917652726,
0.1184030473,
-0.381996274,
-0.3999676704,
0.3218151629,
0.5519583225,
0.9493964911,
0.1801825464,
-0.6949039102,
0.3929425776,
-0.1675162464,
-0.2628847361,
-0.2271478772,
-0.4836307764,
0.0803872272,
0.2061314285,
0.588306129,
0.257955879,
0.0849049389,
-0.4874720871,
-0.1369950175,
0.746932745,
-0.1580316573,
-0.4177507162,
0.8462709188,
0.2118625194,
-0.1548140049,
0.251406461,
0.2141957432,
-0.2589677572,
0.6243153811,
0.5779358149,
0.7815833092,
-0.0530257002,
0.146803692,
0.1730998904,
0.7525754571,
0.2862386703,
0.3075763285,
0.2891184688,
-0.7400048375,
-0.483712256,
-0.4611037672,
-0.141168043,
-0.028040126,
-0.3612779677,
0.2556634843,
-0.2182429284,
-0.076087445,
-0.1159187183,
-0.7021539807,
-0.8995336294,
0.2020823509,
0.645462513,
0.7515044212,
-1.0887525082,
0.7283955216,
1.1277990341,
-0.3678284883,
-0.4979654849,
-0.2896467447,
0.1609108597,
-1.2479979992,
0.9314004183,
0.0466574058,
-0.2033668607,
-0.4136944413,
-0.5055090189,
-0.9063971639,
0.5832793713,
0.5539793968,
-0.5956389904,
0.0057520787,
0.2327681333,
0.4533015788,
-0.463768065,
0.1640019119,
0.0943248346,
0.3922808766,
0.0939347148,
-1.1439555883,
-0.2516043782,
-0.4003348649,
0.2824689448,
0.1057077646,
-0.7289015651,
0.8445258141,
-0.4216502309,
-0.1797755212,
-0.3840281665,
0.416362375,
0.2502483726,
0.3908147216,
0.2648423314,
0.2961324155,
0.2707956433,
0.01347249,
1.4320757389,
-0.0924018323,
-0.0807025507,
0.6462447643,
-0.4239197671,
0.8064776063,
1.2517943382,
-0.2320576906,
0.444904983,
0.6846477985,
0.156004101,
0.8096892238,
-0.1920419186,
-0.0221775118,
-0.0815896243,
-0.3018170893,
-0.2062919736,
0.4705372453,
0.230860427,
-0.3303784132,
-0.2138783038,
0.3637410998,
-0.1260877252,
0.0655102283,
-0.376675874,
0.51181072,
-0.0036873464,
-0.4753701389,
0.7568879724,
-0.3519886732,
0.7469288111,
-0.4201238155,
0.072735481,
-0.5937194824,
0.0182725135,
-0.2083037198,
-0.8509351015,
0.3627603948,
-0.2053175122,
-0.2578401268,
-0.3538838923,
0.6948378086,
-0.5329220891,
-0.7305900455,
0.6236355305,
0.5572943687,
0.1650455594,
0.3389905989,
-0.6445417404,
0.4259416461,
0.2588151991,
-0.3819150627,
0.3372300565,
0.2236509621,
-0.5421733856,
0.6857514381,
0.383374244,
0.1262388825,
0.1827069372,
0.1488966495,
0.7734917998,
-0.3065948486,
-0.2378943115,
-0.8475237489,
0.775105834,
0.0431469828,
0.0221913271,
0.6483661532,
0.3603487909,
0.9759052396,
-0.4030071795,
0.9396036863,
0.2877974212,
-0.0537919216,
-0.7038396001,
0.462582618,
-1.1960911751,
0.3562512994,
-0.0928553119,
-0.9809026718,
-0.3425228596,
0.4794825912,
-0.0569767356,
-0.1324034184,
0.6799417734,
0.637406528,
-0.0253279265,
-0.752900362,
0.7448282242,
0.2813761234,
0.365125984,
0.6204266548,
0.9192051888,
-0.4613167942,
0.5839741826,
-0.0038443438,
-0.2349671423,
-0.2882977426,
-0.8022891879,
-0.8542419672,
-0.5084276199,
-0.1415841579,
-0.1462861896,
0.1524633765,
0.3603446484,
0.3640689552,
-0.4511728883,
-0.2814399898,
0.4610313177,
0.0581880063,
0.1998127103,
-0.1364512742,
-0.1191028282,
-0.0484431498,
-0.6684792638,
0.217299059,
0.6203023791,
0.3324982822,
-0.4528296292,
0.0921840072,
-0.1601793766,
0.206746757,
0.6345302463,
0.2804001868,
-1.1670401096,
-0.1299477965,
0.5102919936,
-0.2439605296,
0.1280235201,
0.2249720246,
-0.5877798796,
0.5707126856,
0.311894387,
0.5553063154,
0.4482022822,
-0.5938901901,
0.6650370359,
-0.873336494,
0.8854805827,
-0.1786295027,
0.7361306548,
0.6320155263,
-0.3765334487,
0.4005922973,
0.2849985659,
-0.167789951,
-0.8480844498,
0.5145453811,
-0.6939651966,
-0.3924143016,
1.1777982712,
0.2953683436,
-0.7377054691,
0.1397283226,
-0.6131162047,
-0.3710121512,
-0.0184480306,
0.6960688829,
1.0040382147,
-0.0291407295,
-0.7117051482,
-0.7877717018,
0.0473888256,
0.6415089965,
-0.3950772882,
-0.0258079879,
0.6934361458,
0.1034579724,
0.2281648964,
0.7408625484,
-0.0818009973,
0.5405362248,
-0.0749325231,
0.3300318122,
0.1946772486,
-0.3709775507,
-0.2640469372,
-0.0297824554,
0.2895653546,
-0.1356223077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02328v1 | Efficient Sparse Attention needs Adaptive Token Release | 2024-07-02T14:58:44 | 2024-07-02T14:58:44 | Chaoran Zhang, Lixin Zou, Dan Luo, Min Tang, Xiangyang Luo, Zihao Li, Chenliang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities across a wide array of text-centric tasks. However, their `large'
scale introduces significant computational and storage challenges, particularly
in managing the key-value states of the transformer, which limits their wider
applicability. Therefore, we propose to adaptively release resources from
caches and rebuild the necessary key-value states. Particularly, we accomplish
this by a lightweight controller module to approximate an ideal top-$K$ sparse
attention. This module retains the tokens with the highest top-$K$ attention
weights and simultaneously rebuilds the discarded but necessary tokens, which
may become essential for future decoding. Comprehensive experiments in natural
language generation and modeling reveal that our method is not only competitive
with full attention in terms of performance but also achieves a significant
throughput improvement of up to 221.8%. The code for replication is available
on the https://github.com/WHUIR/ADORE. | [
-0.2063909769,
-0.6976152062,
0.2887862325,
0.4649944305,
-0.228360042,
-0.0328502245,
-0.5846236944,
-0.2434616983,
0.3953634501,
0.4302416444,
-0.4779613018,
-0.0666495338,
-0.7422309518,
0.0455410406,
-0.5577358603,
1.0141775608,
0.0136109926,
-0.3842369616,
-0.0628040284,
-0.3121488094,
-0.6694486141,
-0.2585909367,
-0.8453409076,
-0.0138680656,
0.7727425694,
0.4243615866,
0.6973980665,
0.891735673,
0.5886073709,
0.3713360429,
-0.4534085393,
0.1597042382,
-0.8199474216,
0.0874297172,
-0.2389859557,
-0.3370969296,
-0.7944723368,
-0.3033886552,
0.6670972109,
0.7041451335,
-0.2137006819,
0.2801586092,
0.1682529747,
0.6629055738,
-0.8680153489,
0.0183288045,
-1.0180003643,
-0.0929743424,
0.0780048966,
-0.1768848896,
-0.5975479484,
-0.1092869639,
-0.0354789793,
-0.8768250942,
0.1618572026,
0.0419792086,
0.5947309136,
0.6921267509,
-0.242203027,
-0.0256802384,
-0.5946413875,
0.8850562572,
-0.4737205207,
0.380417943,
0.21639283,
0.0488867201,
-0.2180000097,
-0.768111527,
-0.3135451078,
-0.0362595282,
-0.0299521293,
0.0564104207,
-0.3588322699,
0.024337491,
0.1615388095,
0.3234602511,
-0.2099869549,
-0.075441651,
-0.2348081321,
-0.315103054,
0.2609868646,
0.2894805372,
0.1492068917,
-0.1294147521,
-0.2179520875,
0.0605276078,
-0.6476131082,
-0.3420423865,
0.0908064544,
0.3646101356,
-0.100915581,
0.500556767,
-0.0780867562,
0.5567927361,
0.4684261382,
0.0284454487,
0.116401054,
-0.4231293499,
-0.3479063213,
0.0879221782,
0.4731458127,
0.3020080626,
0.0817625001,
-0.5686812401,
-0.2981694341,
-0.0125969099,
0.6913805008,
-0.5932815075,
-0.0437646545,
0.4402032197,
-0.3606321514,
-0.2157053351,
-0.4159788489,
-0.8443689942,
-0.3056831956,
-0.3137451112,
0.4955261946,
-0.2761505842,
-0.2096701711,
0.1417548209,
0.0746012852,
0.0991408974,
0.4450520277,
-1.2617281675,
0.4444965422,
0.5480370522,
1.0404738188,
-0.4713950157,
-0.0825065821,
-0.8261258602,
0.4184708595,
-0.3215120435,
0.6638368368,
-0.2072096318,
-0.0911178514,
-0.1436975002,
-0.0184873361,
-0.2420314848,
-0.7212921977,
0.4711665213,
-0.6604341269,
-0.2841584384,
-0.3210425377,
-0.1091216058,
0.3390955031,
0.2670476139,
-0.8582347631,
1.0660700798,
0.2135510147,
-0.8369791508,
0.1470272243,
-0.5987958908,
-0.4590065777,
-0.0105830263,
0.3761206269,
-0.3137090206,
0.2744580507,
0.2484807372,
0.3533515632,
-0.0777012259,
0.2367202789,
-0.0137273045,
-0.5201277137,
0.2686166763,
-0.5047725439,
0.4303226769,
0.3455459177,
-0.3960106075,
0.3833706081,
-0.8331053257,
-0.2435546815,
0.1072390601,
-0.5487272143,
-0.0384924673,
-0.0490896478,
0.4847431183,
-0.2336711735,
0.4864534736,
-0.4428492486,
0.2892803848,
-0.6012820005,
0.6832951903,
0.8976615071,
0.076127626,
0.7142002583,
-0.1796142608,
0.4140440524,
0.1295997947,
0.1771994233,
-0.3040215671,
0.0433909446,
-1.0907882452,
-0.622726202,
0.3456632793,
0.2503494024,
-0.6263406873,
0.4770661891,
-0.4060724378,
-0.1420845687,
-0.7429984808,
0.3315052092,
0.3492919803,
0.2886125147,
0.3788252473,
-0.0957655832,
-0.3106458485,
-0.7397006154,
-0.1333007216,
0.097565867,
0.0904046446,
0.4419686198,
0.2501744926,
-0.3163298368,
0.8730767965,
-0.6263287067,
-0.4459144175,
-0.3921440542,
-0.0140279839,
-0.0382955112,
0.507294476,
0.3932250142,
-0.6315155625,
-0.2973470092,
0.0289930236,
-0.1354857385,
-0.0425499864,
-0.332005173,
-0.451191783,
0.3073628843,
0.4565962553,
-0.8190621138,
0.1415437907,
0.4033405483,
-0.1225240454,
0.2245688289,
-0.326661855,
-0.0607860461,
-1.2339545488,
0.5256677866,
-0.1516640633,
-0.3324694932,
-0.4603295624,
0.1345130503,
0.0944023654,
-0.1282312721,
-0.4382312894,
0.665297091,
-0.5530719757,
-0.167170465,
-0.3900731504,
0.3143580258,
-0.0820575953,
0.7646394968,
-0.2904058397,
0.7183392048,
0.4106260538,
-0.5232485533,
0.4722839296,
0.1921328157,
-0.1060513109,
0.121289432,
-0.71484375,
0.0890651047,
-0.3036170304,
0.086193122,
-1.2437666655,
-0.5880805254,
0.2879890203,
-0.340582341,
0.7977055311,
-0.0051796301,
-0.5252868533,
-0.2087822855,
-0.3889251053,
0.4223213494,
0.334423691,
-0.4948711395,
0.6341027021,
0.5392658114,
-0.2753182054,
-0.5561187863,
-0.8320870399,
0.2311083823,
-0.0293518286,
-0.0827762857,
0.065724425,
-0.0342725217,
-0.1087198406,
0.3203651011,
-0.2608095706,
-0.0146774873,
0.2349893898,
-0.1093956456,
0.0143572427,
-0.0970506445,
0.2122622877,
0.0861037299,
-0.447455287,
-0.1876075566,
-0.3599045873,
0.3751108646,
0.1875391752,
-0.2105488032,
-0.3628157377,
0.3752904236,
1.0366569757,
-0.2774368525,
0.6380776167,
0.4493359625,
-0.5714196563,
-0.260796845,
-0.6091371775,
-0.1747035384,
-0.4925515056,
0.6773681641,
-0.0630338192,
-0.9401600957,
0.5922237039,
0.1321830153,
0.1785196811,
0.3733137548,
0.8193508387,
0.237788856,
1.0751321316,
0.8384856582,
-0.4629902244,
0.5663559437,
-0.1856203228,
0.2021800727,
-0.8342937827,
-0.0262048095,
-0.4476582706,
-0.5143556595,
-0.2153914124,
-0.4699767232,
0.3018804789,
0.0062250295,
-0.0381015688,
0.2942379117,
-0.7703102231,
0.4105570316,
0.2586301863,
0.0758566409,
0.2306000143,
-0.0526696704,
-0.0256522465,
-0.1898314208,
-0.8621900082,
-0.2606937289,
0.8504872322,
0.2331753075,
0.969547689,
0.0822986662,
0.3420967162,
0.1187820062,
0.519993186,
-1.0331634283,
0.4200247824,
-0.1522782743,
-0.3594840467,
-0.3864934146,
-0.6121953726,
-0.8598998785,
0.1744866073,
0.0827593952,
-0.864433825,
-0.0772408918,
0.4654074013,
-0.6955153942,
0.1470029652,
-0.8131404519,
1.0432398319,
0.1099195778,
-0.4984586537,
-0.3518840075,
-0.5661706924,
0.3669889867,
-0.2357600033,
0.028222803,
0.1319777966,
-0.4744808376,
0.5514717698,
-0.2969032228,
0.9789945483,
-0.0552396365,
-0.2673674524,
0.3308840692,
0.096758604,
0.7423243523,
-0.11066515,
0.1158839762,
-0.4087396562,
-0.2567913234,
-0.496873647,
-0.6269327402,
0.8997849822,
-0.7876279354,
-0.458712846,
-0.1677887142,
-0.824449122,
-0.1710563898,
0.1275350749,
0.0117482068,
0.6975054145,
-0.0921792388,
0.222723484,
0.9930274487,
-0.2024913728,
0.6062355638,
0.2583106756,
0.1909172237,
-0.6589850783,
0.9944235682,
0.2457209677,
0.3425234556,
0.5750923753,
0.0135644944,
-0.1927443594,
-0.5844489932,
-0.5808951855,
0.1671769917,
-0.510017097,
-0.560141325,
-0.9843806624,
-0.1033315286,
-0.3641148806,
-0.3290707171,
-0.6030817032,
-0.4738301039,
-0.4339303076,
-0.0325979479,
0.6931949258,
0.709189713,
0.0281503145,
0.5343216658,
-0.7685939074,
0.5238589048,
0.217746824,
0.4597530663,
0.4725899696,
-0.7158321142,
-0.5616930723,
-0.1585030258,
-0.2215908617,
-0.5435494781,
0.3991872072,
0.2010956109,
0.4596223831,
0.2091026455,
-0.0274435859,
0.8274703622,
-0.6258588433,
0.646746695,
0.1029548794,
-0.9947510958,
0.4118847251,
-0.5145863891,
0.7316321135,
0.5297073126,
0.0511583015,
-0.5860921741,
-0.8543309569,
-0.3443439901,
-1.2622630596,
1.0669260025,
0.070207499,
0.425031662,
-0.2753875852,
0.5773600936,
-0.2640254796,
0.1780474484,
-0.5305463672,
-0.1323027909,
-0.0943641067,
-0.696521163,
0.0715081617,
-0.5341989398,
0.0026262638,
-0.0093530323,
0.6473506689,
-0.447157383,
0.2836404741,
0.1470906883,
-0.2646339536,
-0.5080742836,
0.2221137583,
0.6289169192,
0.5356490612,
-0.0902300403,
0.2905579805,
0.2435485125,
-0.818960309,
0.1003300622,
-0.0800253078,
-0.2077282816,
-0.3768734634,
0.2966242433,
0.5757967234,
0.9545149207,
-0.84582901,
0.5839682817,
-0.080163382,
-0.0362941958,
0.3444234133,
-0.0765759647,
0.2388516814,
0.0099431844,
0.4882273078,
0.2632200122,
-0.0199890286,
-0.3092289269,
0.4400808513,
0.2047982663,
-0.4308732748,
-0.4508457482,
1.0302504301,
0.3999512494,
0.1686156094,
0.2421036363,
-0.0812068284,
-0.4965354502,
0.4962351322,
0.5643358827,
0.9850903749,
0.0615020618,
-0.0202235021,
0.4787598252,
0.4266212285,
-0.126723662,
0.1810961515,
-0.2027639747,
-0.5142412782,
-0.8546566963,
-0.7936960459,
-0.1004869044,
0.0006447193,
-0.5396358967,
-0.0359781049,
-0.5778390765,
-0.159448415,
-0.2431282699,
0.0719643757,
-0.1906201243,
-0.0265798345,
-0.0754927024,
0.9679858088,
-0.636677742,
0.6031569242,
0.5994043946,
-0.1768690199,
-0.5868397355,
0.0689624473,
-0.1473622918,
-0.4987451732,
0.4700656831,
-0.0393154994,
-0.0969205275,
0.4006320238,
-0.4374509454,
-1.2291365862,
0.9671494365,
0.6841146946,
-0.6515718102,
0.1419339627,
-0.2203750312,
0.5578507781,
-0.0176948663,
0.0006059824,
0.4040401578,
0.3689653873,
0.2515075803,
-0.9630821347,
0.0641186312,
-0.0732316896,
0.0942792296,
0.4391028583,
-1.1747937202,
0.4566996098,
-0.4439164996,
-0.298304379,
0.323418051,
0.8218092918,
-0.0079144454,
-0.3759300709,
0.500084281,
0.8523250222,
0.6096435785,
0.0397506133,
0.8757464886,
-0.4429412186,
0.3452861309,
0.958538115,
-0.2681904435,
0.8988553882,
0.6452736259,
0.0859160647,
-0.2389596701,
0.3268175423,
0.3083004951,
0.8203081489,
0.1505627334,
-0.2505987883,
-0.1892948449,
-0.3688726425,
0.0664118305,
0.287830025,
0.1710121632,
-0.0642351583,
-0.2260843366,
0.0679648891,
-0.0051661157,
0.034400966,
-0.6955417991,
0.9832987785,
-0.0137601653,
-0.7129158378,
0.5958441496,
0.0626176968,
0.5232916474,
-0.568987608,
0.0054752091,
-0.2534072995,
0.5799049139,
-0.0532594211,
-0.3053367436,
0.4100006521,
0.3778857589,
-0.3617957532,
-0.4491192698,
0.7850118279,
-0.7058769464,
-0.4038966,
0.2579975128,
0.2181209773,
-0.2277685404,
0.1728446186,
-0.3982152939,
0.6100789905,
-0.0258866288,
-0.4469204843,
0.4378791749,
0.4967168272,
0.1409834623,
0.7071615458,
0.4301097095,
0.243902877,
0.4856498539,
0.0382088684,
1.2687700987,
-0.4617792964,
-0.372739017,
-0.6710307002,
0.6160281301,
0.2245095968,
-0.2951202393,
0.5823947191,
0.5947691202,
0.4265245199,
-0.0371154621,
0.6253882051,
-0.0578431785,
0.323924005,
-0.423016876,
0.7430878282,
-0.6030117273,
-0.0100518195,
-0.1378203034,
-0.855130434,
-0.3619816005,
0.3859985471,
0.2638834119,
-0.1994190067,
0.4841852188,
0.7675870657,
-0.2703911364,
-0.393319279,
0.3460700512,
0.5566372275,
0.033350151,
0.857837677,
0.5172227621,
-0.5793303251,
0.8514694571,
0.033645913,
-0.3541900516,
-0.2539904118,
-0.7596635818,
-0.6166606545,
-0.2738324404,
-0.3705506027,
-0.0472084843,
0.0801839978,
0.9743512273,
0.549225986,
-0.9034854174,
0.1385890543,
-0.0040642186,
0.0899368376,
-0.2054968029,
-0.2517814934,
0.4742621481,
-0.8593156934,
-0.8431231976,
0.2183330208,
0.6096500754,
-0.0696586221,
-0.4144553244,
0.050112769,
-0.0344191715,
0.0829650238,
0.567759037,
0.1182351485,
-0.6264841557,
-0.5301158428,
0.1641836464,
-0.4951918125,
-0.0753313825,
0.8991284966,
-0.6077565551,
0.4147630632,
0.4913937449,
1.1969673634,
0.3559091985,
-0.0104015088,
0.4698929787,
-1.0240597725,
0.4093310237,
0.1918186992,
0.4040282369,
0.3630733788,
-0.5052973628,
0.2270070463,
0.2999842763,
-0.4368261397,
-0.99632442,
-0.0150975259,
-1.2683787346,
0.0102837337,
1.219111681,
-0.0076710568,
-0.6427430511,
0.019673584,
-0.4325453043,
0.237951085,
-0.4516686797,
0.725767076,
0.5958695412,
0.3856984079,
-0.1950673014,
-0.4156752527,
0.3933678865,
0.4044802785,
-0.5340402126,
0.8493523002,
0.4649218917,
0.1555798352,
0.2563173175,
0.8381813169,
-0.1501084864,
0.3078944385,
0.0074811117,
0.0573095381,
0.1284502298,
-0.5273880959,
-0.4322079718,
0.1817460209,
0.0728351325,
-0.0536636263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02320v1 | Exploring the Role of Transliteration in In-Context Learning for Low-resource Languages Written in Non-Latin Scripts | 2024-07-02T14:51:20 | 2024-07-02T14:51:20 | Chunlan Ma, Yihong Liu, Haotian Ye, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Decoder-only large language models (LLMs) excel in high-resource languages
across various tasks through few-shot or even zero-shot in-context learning
(ICL). However, their performance often does not transfer well to low-resource
languages, especially those written in non-Latin scripts. Inspired by recent
work that leverages transliteration in encoder-only models, we investigate
whether transliteration is also effective in improving LLMs' performance for
low-resource languages written in non-Latin scripts. To this end, we propose
three prompt templates, where the target-language text is represented in (1)
its original script, (2) Latin script, or (3) both. We apply these methods to
several representative LLMs of different sizes on various tasks including text
classification and sequential labeling. Our findings show that the
effectiveness of transliteration varies by task type and model size. For
instance, all models benefit from transliterations for sequential labeling
(with increases of up to 25%). | [
0.2762855887,
-0.1984396428,
0.5886780024,
0.0326714255,
-0.3157382309,
0.2385885119,
-0.5644662976,
-0.260317862,
0.0766984522,
0.2554094791,
-0.3991058767,
-0.5556884408,
-0.5465000272,
0.7303721905,
-0.1270924211,
0.7422485352,
-0.155594632,
0.3917318285,
-0.13614209,
-0.1096689403,
-0.4470531344,
-0.2756506503,
-0.6439967752,
-0.2759097815,
0.9066922665,
0.7824679017,
0.233625859,
0.8338013887,
0.4700211585,
0.2123988718,
0.0755710676,
0.0762280151,
-0.5107537508,
0.4321849644,
-0.1947595477,
-0.5821514726,
0.2123990059,
-0.0872327685,
0.9421918988,
0.7236008644,
0.0520939194,
0.3675904274,
0.1803544611,
0.3991114497,
-0.7061439753,
0.3180677295,
-0.6824592352,
0.0021469099,
-0.3768925071,
-0.4595800042,
-0.8400290608,
-0.2387624979,
0.0376345366,
-0.5663205385,
0.0653016716,
0.3851082325,
0.2531479597,
0.2968564332,
-0.2093761116,
-0.364040345,
-0.7058585286,
1.1554809809,
-0.4356649816,
0.2668177187,
0.2751325667,
0.3225506842,
0.0423236601,
-0.3843050301,
-0.2049782723,
-0.0845731869,
-0.2446121871,
-0.1744942218,
-0.2062422335,
0.0785975382,
0.614767611,
0.1701155752,
-0.422537148,
0.5315508842,
-0.2581975162,
-0.3268185258,
-0.0078726253,
0.128411293,
0.4653054774,
-0.3461206257,
-0.2353166342,
-0.0880124047,
-1.2066375017,
0.1133371666,
0.1099227741,
0.9514489174,
-0.232244581,
0.4177216589,
0.1673142463,
0.8420855403,
0.2017826736,
-0.7170370817,
0.0519070067,
-0.2808625996,
-0.2335987687,
0.3144646287,
0.5464632511,
-0.0905940011,
-0.069679901,
-0.4366151989,
-0.3097317517,
-0.3714923859,
-0.0356498547,
-0.9286563993,
0.265111953,
-0.2062258273,
-0.599121511,
0.1426766068,
-0.2350304723,
-0.5071366429,
-0.5447080135,
-0.1721656322,
0.4281032085,
-0.555585444,
0.0961616486,
-0.1544252485,
-0.1793966293,
0.4415897727,
0.5862717628,
-0.9092162251,
0.0589358658,
0.3546536565,
1.003298521,
-0.0690519512,
-0.1447613835,
-1.0784556866,
0.0384500846,
-0.334792614,
0.7268503904,
-0.7675964236,
-0.3619501591,
0.3603973985,
-0.0098120226,
-0.2871345282,
-0.5863122344,
0.5240074396,
-0.4792161286,
-0.0424365401,
-0.7203907967,
-0.4070100188,
-0.1100137159,
0.0262288637,
-0.6393011808,
0.843665123,
0.3751129508,
-0.7340657115,
0.3295198977,
-0.5246174932,
-0.7269691825,
0.3087418079,
-0.1780041307,
0.1377877593,
0.3415764868,
-0.0978484079,
0.3356423676,
-0.7189412713,
-0.1684695035,
0.2300815284,
-0.8747954369,
0.1480451524,
-0.4481491745,
0.6337441206,
0.2820339799,
-0.3623494208,
-0.0070331655,
-0.6333729029,
-0.0619989559,
-0.0328691565,
-0.6449477077,
-0.2756038606,
-0.2394083589,
0.1760040969,
0.3130893409,
0.180466935,
-0.6599062085,
0.2769034207,
-0.3342721164,
0.3337707222,
0.666682899,
-0.308447361,
0.9084761739,
-0.3722137809,
0.8491638303,
0.0629099756,
-0.4251097739,
-0.6092095375,
-0.119507201,
-0.7957856655,
-0.6742658019,
0.4138300717,
0.301309824,
-1.2694075108,
-0.1112491041,
-0.3402465582,
-0.3469034433,
-0.6402615905,
0.232404694,
0.6013227105,
0.8524381518,
0.3562976718,
-0.1203371361,
-0.5531840324,
-0.7544428706,
-0.3512033522,
-0.2999511659,
-0.0141898748,
0.303126514,
0.3404490948,
0.0380657725,
0.6308630705,
0.0872364491,
-0.2380202711,
-0.8041500449,
0.1177531704,
0.2465658039,
0.270126462,
0.4798467159,
-0.3211020529,
-1.0434826612,
-0.1840075105,
-0.4653888047,
-0.2344030142,
-0.1623030454,
0.1078244299,
0.3420743644,
0.454203397,
-0.4336014092,
0.057321921,
0.3509503603,
0.1533403248,
0.4451776147,
-0.3058584332,
0.1117238775,
-0.9823957086,
0.2241683006,
0.1282638013,
-0.2493455559,
-0.7513617277,
-0.1078798845,
0.261285454,
-0.1994950324,
-0.8259211183,
0.9189564586,
-0.6147614121,
-0.189470768,
-0.2766387463,
0.0041010296,
-0.156076625,
0.3183394074,
0.249245435,
1.1068686247,
0.771346271,
-0.4397434294,
-0.067704536,
0.0415350273,
-0.7295120955,
0.5064406395,
-0.3062010407,
0.0395880938,
-0.3867752254,
0.5416545272,
-0.899528861,
-0.2434801012,
0.3335086107,
-0.1388785094,
0.6102753282,
-0.4905050397,
-1.0092273951,
0.1307409555,
-0.2145395577,
0.6568647027,
0.732473731,
-0.7362519503,
0.4081169367,
-0.1262692511,
0.0914638191,
-0.5859542489,
-0.600628078,
-0.0686405152,
-0.3927980363,
-0.2676796615,
0.3355220556,
-0.0846994594,
-0.3433743417,
-0.431024909,
0.0122250579,
0.0959907547,
-0.0605890192,
0.2152800262,
0.1535420418,
-0.2901303172,
0.1922868639,
-0.1517903358,
-0.0537405089,
-0.413767159,
-0.5405292511,
0.4755308926,
0.1796414256,
-0.2896068394,
-0.6943195462,
0.4182096422,
0.5956196785,
-0.1196382418,
1.0792213678,
0.5127482414,
-0.241656214,
-0.2709034085,
-0.3333587646,
-0.1390323192,
-0.4686219394,
0.0684775412,
-0.2582940757,
-0.8788204193,
0.5367125273,
-0.112275742,
0.0862566978,
0.3027211726,
0.5402520299,
-0.2702365816,
0.5894626379,
0.8172860146,
-0.0517282225,
0.8406999707,
-0.1660933048,
0.2707710266,
-0.9084331393,
-0.0276342444,
-0.7146113515,
-0.4602208138,
-0.6462110281,
-0.644500792,
0.3690291047,
-0.1707764268,
-0.2299920768,
0.4624923766,
-0.0477596447,
0.653991878,
0.6039279699,
-0.2159352452,
0.1562620848,
0.4025910497,
-0.2121539116,
-0.2999963164,
-0.9313978553,
-0.4470140338,
0.9335276484,
0.1092753261,
0.9173189998,
0.0395687446,
0.9527255893,
0.0961291343,
0.2890545726,
-0.9704092741,
0.4027106166,
-0.2724043727,
-0.4376195669,
-0.1246448085,
-0.472192049,
-0.9472975731,
0.3499707878,
0.0699736327,
-0.6477233768,
0.1248662248,
-0.0499634594,
-0.5384966135,
0.3129288852,
-0.4670378566,
0.6924299598,
0.0623698942,
-0.3314966261,
0.0182509478,
-0.5789883733,
-0.0419452563,
-0.1287071407,
0.1870748848,
0.1361873001,
-0.0892389491,
0.6336043477,
-0.1166535243,
0.8940361142,
-0.105657354,
-0.0758439824,
0.4504247606,
0.2984521389,
0.6702874303,
-0.2306730896,
-0.304258436,
0.1128238663,
-0.2817544341,
-0.3395017385,
-0.4621602595,
0.5703005195,
-0.614631474,
-0.6106778979,
-0.5953977704,
-0.6427330971,
-0.0980391875,
0.1728452891,
0.489844054,
0.700543344,
0.0838521346,
0.2790030539,
0.7535817623,
-0.471375674,
0.5617662072,
0.88076967,
0.2785605192,
-0.0639622584,
0.8858773112,
0.1843723506,
0.2987793982,
0.7493413687,
-0.1113882363,
-0.2630335391,
-0.4642422795,
-0.6650536656,
0.5024037361,
-0.9982257485,
-0.5249439478,
-0.3998689651,
-0.0874838829,
-0.2482657135,
-0.4650205374,
-0.1710170954,
-0.3057541251,
-0.5402231812,
-0.0430054329,
0.1020409688,
0.4444870949,
-0.0832394585,
0.50731498,
-0.6953752637,
-0.0869779512,
-0.1173431054,
0.0939893872,
0.1451928616,
-0.8858148456,
-0.5482807159,
-0.1761650294,
-0.1337003112,
-0.7175463438,
0.4444276094,
0.136126861,
0.3943219185,
0.2834650278,
0.0301196687,
0.6938241124,
-0.8741052151,
0.6850143075,
0.302411586,
-0.7114726901,
0.2314023823,
-0.3109960854,
0.5607799888,
0.5280038714,
0.3201963305,
-0.8749099374,
-0.2573422194,
-0.1559654623,
-0.5628336072,
1.2385630608,
0.0336176232,
0.2707112432,
-0.3029986024,
0.3438906372,
0.4144117236,
0.1094530597,
-0.7099049091,
-0.2472117692,
0.238052085,
-0.331844449,
-0.1451465487,
-0.3345746994,
0.1084797978,
0.0541832037,
0.4928126335,
-0.2910631895,
0.213210687,
-0.006550862,
-0.5792276859,
-0.4895722568,
0.4949442744,
0.4269273579,
0.4115153253,
-0.0035118768,
0.2252338529,
0.0625220165,
-0.0580018535,
0.3501403034,
-0.229207024,
-0.3987652957,
0.090849258,
0.6162897944,
0.7153952718,
0.6889510155,
-0.7506716251,
0.3952247202,
-0.1581975073,
0.3625527024,
-0.0609900616,
-0.0193716846,
-0.1610717773,
0.1789457947,
0.5044407248,
0.0373937674,
-0.0237464607,
-0.6674515605,
-0.2223406583,
0.4424284697,
-0.3287920952,
-0.479723841,
0.3657286763,
0.2057912946,
-0.2341246009,
0.7491170764,
-0.226023525,
-0.2753998637,
0.5222759247,
0.9868691564,
0.8446602225,
-0.1692370176,
0.4361390471,
0.7295852304,
0.2675189376,
-0.262901783,
0.0565577336,
-0.327273488,
-0.4140180349,
-0.4470873177,
-0.8735601306,
-0.4438616931,
-0.0358467177,
-0.4997163713,
0.3704890013,
-0.4257051647,
0.0148995221,
-0.2015081942,
-0.0656656399,
-0.9196767807,
-0.1227778867,
0.2647939324,
0.9557629824,
-0.705793798,
0.8424057961,
0.6226712465,
-0.3383048475,
-0.5672481656,
0.1925386041,
0.0289132688,
-0.7179184556,
1.2089357376,
0.4818193913,
-0.2930009961,
0.0683339164,
-0.3114874661,
-1.1695691347,
1.1077237129,
0.8172059059,
-0.42162624,
-0.1770032346,
0.1536871642,
0.5219362378,
-0.5471292734,
0.3533602059,
0.1870760918,
0.3350873888,
0.2411878556,
-0.9757571816,
0.0141686117,
0.2032658607,
0.2247004956,
-0.0443902165,
-0.6471992135,
0.7976709008,
-0.3497699499,
-0.7240106463,
0.2477058023,
0.6729998589,
0.0987977684,
-0.1142715216,
0.2030875087,
0.0840757787,
0.67996943,
0.0391437635,
1.1782482862,
-0.3680937886,
-0.0141178891,
0.9732244611,
-0.3094596565,
0.6638146639,
0.5349043608,
0.1065476313,
0.6315959096,
0.7338759899,
0.2778608203,
0.6646216512,
0.1201217696,
-0.2624885142,
-0.3259820938,
-0.533226788,
0.0222228188,
0.4085713029,
0.0771005526,
-0.5468195081,
-0.4830957651,
0.0736782029,
0.0668810904,
-0.1104297042,
-0.4613999426,
0.6421306729,
0.1777696908,
-0.7337695956,
0.67093575,
0.3396333754,
0.6608445644,
-0.6265386939,
0.0645266548,
-0.2926259041,
-0.0298594479,
0.0332198068,
-0.3014623523,
-0.0516294837,
0.3794846237,
-0.4521120787,
-0.5797430277,
0.5245268941,
-0.6265181899,
-0.422899425,
0.2223340273,
0.4755078852,
0.2757477462,
0.259889096,
-0.3797156811,
0.0961004719,
-0.1381145716,
0.1618306935,
0.7420274615,
0.3309653103,
0.0521078855,
0.5383182764,
0.3701389134,
0.0872475281,
-0.0048299534,
0.0522331297,
0.56892699,
-0.4973489344,
-0.2779854834,
-0.9060364366,
0.3773988783,
0.3666805327,
0.0361992121,
1.0157781839,
0.5531901121,
0.777485013,
-0.2737084627,
0.7553389668,
0.0723294839,
0.2915768027,
-0.5400588512,
0.4004606307,
-0.6530949473,
0.1278471202,
-0.028541686,
-0.9759464264,
-0.2817694545,
0.5799910426,
-0.2497074455,
-0.0867230818,
0.8307481408,
0.5446856022,
0.0205674674,
-0.325378418,
0.5293632746,
-0.0818185657,
0.1037453264,
0.59741503,
0.7032968998,
-0.31341061,
0.4878848791,
-0.0743598938,
-0.0901057869,
-0.3408202827,
-0.7189319134,
-1.0103774071,
-0.6205632091,
-0.2335544825,
-0.2426970899,
-0.1818189025,
1.2511804104,
0.4555492997,
-0.5494881868,
-0.4029464424,
0.4770097136,
0.2664458454,
-0.0381830484,
-0.1164915711,
0.2979029417,
-0.7228528857,
-1.0155379772,
0.7421026826,
0.5304954052,
-0.0183819365,
-0.1885934472,
-0.0714504868,
0.1546533108,
0.155873239,
0.5733790398,
0.3704437613,
-0.7562461495,
-0.147300154,
0.1787211746,
-0.4391747713,
0.2983501256,
1.0862336159,
-0.7398463488,
0.4915750623,
0.4697867334,
0.4766887128,
0.0702378005,
-0.1340038776,
0.4455893338,
-0.9267000556,
0.2331180722,
0.1333379447,
0.5312842131,
0.728507936,
-0.317861855,
0.1257772595,
0.0136637092,
-0.2258297652,
-0.8638294935,
0.3190048039,
-0.4979857802,
0.0079323826,
1.560161829,
-0.2573537827,
-0.3941873014,
0.1229347065,
-0.076820083,
0.1892218441,
-0.5503884554,
0.5506212115,
0.7570869327,
0.0186832398,
-0.0132687679,
-0.2249699086,
0.6642808914,
0.1181911752,
-0.3797214329,
0.2786513865,
0.5350231528,
0.4765561521,
0.0654181316,
0.8346794248,
-0.0910115242,
0.2597579658,
-0.1967016757,
-0.2726475,
0.0908717811,
-0.5742737055,
-0.5985273123,
-0.1654290259,
0.2298314124,
0.1625867933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02317v1 | Soft Language Prompts for Language Transfer | 2024-07-02T14:50:03 | 2024-07-02T14:50:03 | Ivan Vykopal, Simon Ostermann, Marián Šimko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual knowledge transfer, especially between high- and low-resource
languages, remains a challenge in natural language processing (NLP). This study
offers insights for improving cross-lingual NLP applications through the
combination of parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. We systematically
explore strategies for enhancing this cross-lingual transfer through the
incorporation of language-specific and task-specific adapters and soft prompts.
We present a detailed investigation of various combinations of these methods,
exploring their efficiency across six languages, focusing on three low-resource
languages, including the to our knowledge first use of soft language prompts.
Our findings demonstrate that in contrast to claims of previous work, a
combination of language and task adapters does not always work best; instead,
combining a soft language prompt with a task adapter outperforms other
configurations in many cases. | [
-0.4628509283,
-0.571660459,
0.3761490583,
0.4321980774,
-0.0891417116,
0.0778660923,
-0.7030120492,
-0.3947251439,
-0.0685499832,
0.2921988964,
-0.562533915,
-0.1796786487,
-0.3765607774,
0.4058837891,
0.1395723969,
1.13446486,
-0.0652570277,
-0.2797544599,
0.2391069382,
-0.4154934585,
-0.9259342551,
-0.1336438954,
-0.8152327538,
-0.2266913503,
0.6884786487,
0.7022356391,
0.8183807135,
0.0646057948,
0.2748422921,
0.2762538195,
-0.0688074678,
0.4007543921,
-0.3860358894,
0.0637853891,
-0.8630077839,
-0.5013988614,
-0.05525003,
-0.3810085952,
0.5452109575,
1.0743485689,
0.2214008123,
0.0558125712,
0.3826789558,
0.7353134751,
-0.6847781539,
0.0868876278,
-0.5980321169,
0.1612671912,
-0.1412400901,
-0.4214583039,
-0.2623668015,
-0.2861813605,
0.2371828258,
-0.7966524959,
0.071827732,
0.0395641662,
0.5415649414,
0.2085706145,
-0.3325743079,
-0.4087457955,
-0.7034609914,
1.0354521275,
-0.4705345929,
0.5215685964,
0.1901340187,
0.2495902926,
-0.1081830338,
-0.5560773015,
-0.3881371319,
-0.0527928062,
-0.3181115687,
-0.3064768612,
-0.2698286772,
0.0462174602,
0.1525722742,
0.0278108045,
-0.4804710746,
0.2729170918,
-0.3212629557,
-0.2994616926,
0.377353996,
0.0742054507,
0.6706523895,
-0.0939506441,
-0.1416635513,
-0.0226243157,
-0.6511942744,
0.3321184218,
0.1013051644,
0.9645431042,
-0.082748428,
0.3805561364,
-0.3349831998,
1.0761140585,
0.313898176,
-0.1993649304,
-0.0576081052,
-0.7149165869,
0.111769028,
0.1191107854,
0.5584623218,
0.4714637995,
0.4191213846,
-0.5101211071,
-0.2080744952,
-0.3106645942,
-0.0655165985,
-0.6326028109,
0.1165203601,
-0.1512020379,
-0.3729644716,
0.1202067584,
-0.4875710905,
-0.8418356776,
-0.4709932804,
-0.5003420711,
0.3330720961,
-0.458460927,
-0.248024106,
0.2444969714,
-0.3194007277,
0.287997961,
0.4362674057,
-1.3734681606,
0.4026796222,
0.6863316298,
0.8488230705,
-0.3540478349,
-0.3342216909,
-0.9027991295,
0.129805848,
-0.210071668,
0.949926734,
-0.6185404062,
-0.1926437765,
0.3296718597,
0.2204361409,
-0.3591133654,
-0.5676918626,
0.4784442186,
-0.1906784624,
0.4211533368,
-0.6737293601,
-0.0656660646,
-0.2126485109,
0.1121429503,
-0.5967962742,
0.9513428211,
0.4130411744,
-0.4487118423,
0.4416653216,
-0.7117019296,
-0.9376627207,
0.1761091202,
0.0823933929,
0.4545310438,
0.2034234107,
0.2975698113,
0.4710075557,
-0.3340751231,
0.0311826877,
0.1905196011,
-0.3963325024,
-0.0298294816,
-0.3167131543,
0.8272314072,
0.1879526228,
-0.4624198675,
0.0032841046,
-0.6685876846,
0.0468512177,
-0.1274323612,
-0.5457947254,
-0.6523521543,
-0.5486174822,
0.3132396638,
0.3071579635,
0.3797835112,
-0.1409425288,
0.2858205438,
-0.4606664777,
0.2513939738,
0.5005574226,
-0.3181793988,
0.8157171607,
-0.3149596155,
0.6272588968,
-0.0586150214,
-0.0891751945,
-0.0987075567,
-0.4841695428,
-0.5795016885,
0.1457802504,
0.3076433539,
0.8545832634,
-1.2875871658,
0.081883505,
-0.0683028847,
-0.3039228618,
-0.6005322933,
0.8071244359,
0.4148916602,
0.4733836055,
0.40637815,
-0.1415919363,
-0.2766807079,
-0.8174271584,
-0.740634501,
-0.0651562437,
-0.0256515201,
0.2835413218,
-0.0676927492,
0.0491854958,
0.7725458145,
-0.1075749248,
-0.2340551168,
-0.6636151671,
0.2786383033,
0.4398587942,
0.4907638729,
1.027564764,
-0.7348482609,
-0.8035453558,
0.2044729441,
-0.3180657029,
-0.4044148028,
-0.296969533,
-0.0995050222,
0.3949774206,
0.501472652,
-0.3724301457,
-0.1259516478,
0.6939998865,
-0.6713291407,
0.3676067293,
-0.351424545,
0.2788836956,
-0.7203785777,
0.047895357,
0.0816382617,
-0.1983908117,
-0.9178557992,
-0.0693257898,
-0.1854094863,
0.1050472036,
-0.8224207163,
0.897510767,
-0.553249836,
0.227819249,
-0.3134239912,
0.190286085,
0.080747053,
0.6371451616,
-0.0200906042,
0.9305564761,
0.6201550961,
-0.6633601189,
0.2752800286,
0.1300518662,
-0.1084781438,
0.9304696321,
-0.5916523933,
0.2599723339,
-0.0413265191,
-0.2469640225,
-0.8994263411,
0.2616961598,
0.2644336522,
0.0993604511,
0.4396356344,
-0.3077790439,
-0.432748735,
0.133763805,
-0.3993349969,
0.5983068943,
0.3836438656,
-0.545060575,
0.7215920091,
0.0806901976,
-0.5625866652,
-0.3561964631,
-0.7514168024,
0.1870101541,
-0.2224303186,
-0.6942391396,
0.3633657098,
-0.097230345,
-0.266584456,
-0.0098968958,
0.1290344,
-0.0238296296,
-0.0084933368,
-0.1380071044,
0.0722540021,
-0.5316296816,
-0.1389641762,
0.282245487,
-0.2595534027,
-0.2486418635,
-0.3447220325,
0.3661685288,
-0.335216701,
-0.1285682023,
-0.3004716039,
0.5847718716,
0.4216633141,
0.0704551786,
0.7652866244,
0.9689003229,
-0.2341944277,
-0.2267047614,
-0.5039835572,
-0.042031955,
-0.5312709808,
0.1454628855,
-0.5000152588,
-0.9683529139,
0.4992203712,
-0.3883838058,
0.2209752798,
0.1970635951,
0.5184941888,
0.3289286494,
1.0456151962,
0.9094620943,
-0.0733390152,
0.7663240433,
0.2042391002,
0.2496632934,
-0.6448692083,
0.1223751158,
-0.7042631507,
-0.4946289957,
-0.7117778063,
-0.4510480464,
0.1269093901,
0.1583227962,
0.1041628197,
0.5421203375,
-0.2776388824,
0.437894702,
0.8245082498,
-0.176208511,
0.3218891919,
-0.0032931112,
-0.1218721792,
-0.1328864545,
-1.1573038101,
-0.2699441612,
0.5373337269,
0.064056091,
0.6742758751,
0.1886905283,
0.3864141703,
0.0258158166,
-0.1079035401,
-0.847612679,
0.5890072584,
-0.7233781219,
-0.3961437941,
-0.3410559893,
-0.2407323867,
-1.1786015034,
0.1847619116,
-0.2803944647,
-0.8377197981,
0.4690827131,
0.0383174792,
-0.5708589554,
0.0988850072,
-0.990239799,
0.9211888313,
-0.256177187,
-0.6031407118,
-0.1538547426,
-0.4319102764,
-0.0548713952,
-0.0247960985,
0.3613383174,
-0.0918660015,
-0.261842519,
0.7679594159,
-0.1288218349,
0.8410174847,
-0.3057051897,
-0.4032993913,
0.1532453746,
0.2239866257,
0.5174580216,
-0.0402427614,
-0.1737785339,
0.0053776093,
-0.0096520483,
-0.4001000226,
-0.8666141629,
0.713906467,
-0.4763583541,
-0.5003127456,
-0.0588626862,
-0.9234269857,
-0.5213809609,
0.4221543372,
-0.0332891233,
0.4817602634,
0.0962412208,
0.032782834,
0.6219927669,
-0.5205748081,
0.5137021542,
0.7973966599,
0.0260568429,
-0.0526873991,
1.0224024057,
0.1505465358,
0.3365849257,
0.4025846422,
0.389779985,
-0.1424852461,
-0.5539188981,
-0.7694710493,
0.1966825873,
-0.7104910612,
-0.2033734024,
-0.3439829051,
0.1074995399,
-0.5635026693,
-0.6073479652,
-0.2104264498,
-0.6097154021,
-0.268294096,
0.1957308054,
0.4816943109,
0.4155329168,
-0.1919032782,
0.2581658661,
-1.0944442749,
0.6812484264,
0.4167269766,
0.4432527423,
-0.4050238132,
-0.4491201043,
-0.2733006775,
-0.0439579301,
0.3116393387,
-0.7079336047,
0.1815029532,
0.4723565578,
0.6917552352,
0.1650751382,
0.2531546354,
0.5994179845,
-0.4826456904,
0.8695085049,
0.2453386933,
-0.9022119641,
0.5842692256,
-0.3797735572,
0.6021981835,
0.9365348816,
0.377863884,
-0.7675063014,
-0.3173840642,
-0.1632741243,
-1.0403254032,
0.9125241637,
-0.1211241707,
0.3295629025,
0.2903117537,
0.2315880805,
0.4099831879,
-0.0944812,
-0.3512058258,
-0.2186026126,
0.0908717811,
-0.2990288436,
0.0700208023,
0.0573107824,
-0.1688949466,
-0.3460997343,
0.4100761712,
-0.6425741911,
-0.1197801456,
0.0111326957,
-0.3640521467,
-0.3864465654,
0.5336761475,
0.4270004332,
0.6681416631,
0.1753629148,
0.2510742247,
0.6443458796,
-0.4412326813,
-0.0327125527,
0.2047200054,
-0.3108181953,
0.193220064,
0.4024139345,
0.9122184515,
0.7156837583,
-0.6695787907,
0.1885879487,
-0.2127943486,
0.0024754673,
0.4382733107,
0.411550492,
-0.0990573391,
0.3279705048,
0.2270831317,
0.0854629502,
0.2530872226,
-0.7413452268,
-0.0906456038,
0.4438745081,
-0.3923588991,
-0.4055534005,
0.3694541752,
0.4078660905,
-0.4657088518,
0.2487391233,
-0.1414355338,
-0.5496212244,
0.121991396,
0.6284954548,
0.7391952872,
-0.1950510293,
0.2497077286,
0.1054472104,
0.2672480941,
0.028744461,
0.4484215379,
-0.2890833318,
-0.556237042,
-0.6608832479,
-0.5180891752,
-0.4622836411,
-0.183950156,
-0.4676309526,
0.4717714787,
-0.2254538387,
0.0465486683,
0.0164042767,
0.236710012,
-1.034330368,
-0.1482924819,
0.251429528,
1.0786888599,
-0.8818363547,
0.6114243269,
1.0443254709,
-0.0963131636,
-0.8110491633,
-0.1652887464,
-0.1696702391,
-0.942974627,
0.5836826563,
-0.1415126175,
-0.306945771,
-0.0355564728,
-0.1552897245,
-0.560752511,
0.624992609,
0.5510389805,
-0.5735967755,
-0.0525984056,
0.4844668806,
0.4418591261,
0.0368007123,
0.1313157678,
0.8754083514,
0.9082824588,
-0.0996631309,
-1.3347287178,
0.6027498245,
-0.2306816727,
-0.0059598847,
0.1742135137,
-0.471211642,
0.4936161041,
-0.2133892328,
-0.1520731598,
-0.2035998553,
0.6662797928,
0.0595732629,
0.3564746976,
0.9377835393,
-0.0224803779,
0.6715724468,
0.0545840971,
0.7124558091,
-0.5533195138,
-0.1642596275,
0.7638465762,
-0.2017709464,
0.5812479854,
0.8711922765,
-0.0753679276,
0.6142076254,
0.0972560644,
0.2929241657,
0.5547756553,
-0.0743212104,
-0.2452806532,
-0.1348163188,
-0.5988539457,
-0.2796979547,
0.2162751704,
0.5712891221,
0.0013321514,
-0.429774791,
0.2925226688,
-0.0616405867,
-0.0550120324,
-0.3953779936,
0.976954937,
0.1254596412,
-1.0720757246,
0.7124431729,
0.0042056399,
1.1955909729,
-0.6515135765,
-0.1524189413,
-0.2430729717,
0.06117687,
-0.2803385258,
-0.9901627302,
0.4607812762,
0.0325168595,
0.0082737608,
-0.8381499648,
1.1929869652,
-0.6178231239,
-0.2638753057,
0.3436088562,
0.7727555633,
-0.0401603468,
-0.0561915562,
-0.7205450535,
-0.2309579402,
-0.1155546829,
-0.2320913225,
0.5783783197,
0.9454051256,
-0.0323684402,
0.3002399504,
0.7841678262,
0.2902140617,
0.0717536435,
0.3782421052,
0.9023207426,
-0.7019128799,
-0.4992451668,
-0.5591009259,
0.4534287453,
0.2617408335,
-0.4696737826,
0.7376656532,
0.1782895476,
0.6959911585,
0.0254212487,
0.7479568124,
-0.2077935934,
0.3243623376,
-0.6717827916,
0.4481998682,
-0.6015334725,
0.1656054258,
-0.2875454426,
-0.7531872988,
-0.2078528851,
0.461407572,
-0.2639402151,
-0.1091148183,
0.6318382025,
0.6646674275,
-0.1499016434,
0.036107894,
0.2040620595,
-0.0583241396,
0.1471122205,
0.8173813224,
0.6424480677,
-0.1865666807,
0.7266017795,
-0.5685589314,
-0.1815651506,
-0.4036424458,
-1.0462458134,
-0.8525791168,
-0.6166449785,
-0.345220238,
-0.3790294528,
0.2825128436,
0.9470521808,
0.6657205224,
-0.9784562588,
-0.2573126554,
0.1163382977,
0.4008966386,
-0.4863148034,
-0.2753766477,
0.178409934,
-0.8241863847,
-0.790797472,
0.609529078,
0.2062043399,
-0.1685921997,
-0.299606353,
-0.0466215238,
-0.1053755358,
-0.0700340718,
0.7937133312,
0.5396333933,
-0.3284050524,
-0.3089539707,
0.1878466457,
-0.0920985192,
-0.1720540375,
1.1864850521,
-0.9234927893,
0.0370226167,
0.8911525607,
0.6857703328,
-0.0498752594,
-0.2163482159,
0.9711508751,
-0.7784083486,
0.2924821079,
0.1228262782,
0.3181772232,
0.4731010795,
-0.3911203742,
0.328846097,
0.080293037,
-0.283195734,
-0.7607216835,
-0.0012667192,
-1.0918953419,
-0.47657305,
1.3770279884,
0.0392787643,
-0.3081888556,
-0.6316481829,
-0.5156759024,
0.1981633902,
-0.3676708043,
0.4947403967,
0.6414549351,
-0.2974404693,
-0.0938645452,
-0.5668277144,
0.644226253,
0.6953881383,
-0.7740105987,
0.0182964113,
0.1887894273,
0.3290199041,
0.3939668834,
0.5722528696,
0.3328103423,
0.3605554998,
-0.2568191886,
-0.469527185,
0.0628826097,
-0.3119869828,
-0.4775238037,
0.1047798693,
0.0243932661,
0.2095523179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02310v1 | Evaluating the Ability of LLMs to Solve Semantics-Aware Process Mining Tasks | 2024-07-02T14:44:49 | 2024-07-02T14:44:49 | Adrian Rebmann, Fabian David Schmidt, Goran Glavaš, Han van der Aa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The process mining community has recently recognized the potential of large
language models (LLMs) for tackling various process mining tasks. Initial
studies report the capability of LLMs to support process analysis and even, to
some extent, that they are able to reason about how processes work. This latter
property suggests that LLMs could also be used to tackle process mining tasks
that benefit from an understanding of process behavior. Examples of such tasks
include (semantic) anomaly detection and next activity prediction, which both
involve considerations of the meaning of activities and their inter-relations.
In this paper, we investigate the capabilities of LLMs to tackle such
semantics-aware process mining tasks. Furthermore, whereas most works on the
intersection of LLMs and process mining only focus on testing these models out
of the box, we provide a more principled investigation of the utility of LLMs
for process mining, including their ability to obtain process mining knowledge
post-hoc by means of in-context learning and supervised fine-tuning.
Concretely, we define three process mining tasks that benefit from an
understanding of process semantics and provide extensive benchmarking datasets
for each of them. Our evaluation experiments reveal that (1) LLMs fail to solve
challenging process mining tasks out of the box and when provided only a
handful of in-context examples, (2) but they yield strong performance when
fine-tuned for these tasks, consistently surpassing smaller, encoder-based
language models. | [
-0.2572419345,
-0.6573785543,
1.1628158092,
-0.0988998488,
-0.213110134,
-0.1794359535,
-0.3057851195,
-0.5639233589,
-0.0654426515,
0.7675205469,
-0.8617943525,
-0.6755596399,
-0.8234173656,
0.1636710167,
-0.5459858775,
0.8476433754,
-0.3408352435,
-0.1048198417,
-0.3224755228,
0.166150853,
-0.4449374676,
-0.666054666,
-0.5611400604,
-0.5308455825,
0.2017680556,
0.3546021879,
0.3429789841,
0.3822277784,
0.4221129715,
0.3123997152,
-0.1592032015,
0.3007650077,
-0.3018174767,
0.4619294107,
-0.1856388748,
-0.5650757551,
-0.5134202838,
0.0654318556,
0.5305967927,
0.9261279106,
-0.0055246712,
0.2973769307,
0.1315414011,
0.3117703199,
-0.5032329559,
0.4319106042,
-1.0878704786,
0.0279888771,
-0.3575054109,
-0.369633317,
-0.1167870313,
0.1652145833,
0.0054420326,
-0.4228857756,
0.2284521013,
0.0495584346,
0.5565595627,
0.3683196306,
-0.0890426114,
-0.5644901395,
-0.6193355918,
0.9039021134,
-0.7033991218,
0.2732419372,
0.6094384193,
0.081497699,
-0.5496788025,
-0.7843834758,
-0.369376272,
-0.1358141154,
-0.1121705472,
-0.1282650232,
-0.0180025753,
0.0089191506,
0.5226563811,
0.4410630763,
-0.1727301627,
0.2989056706,
0.0543429069,
-0.1671279222,
0.2285319865,
0.5891206264,
0.1106789261,
-0.1236684322,
-0.2165281773,
0.2907910943,
-0.5051353574,
-0.0336463712,
0.297770381,
0.3655483127,
0.2491099089,
0.6768863201,
-0.5122283697,
0.5435220599,
-0.3630536497,
-0.0419863425,
0.0285211038,
-0.1191568822,
-0.3916942477,
-0.1067684144,
0.406303972,
0.106834583,
0.1458339095,
-0.4226932824,
-0.4282674491,
0.1974866837,
0.1464575529,
-0.844592154,
-0.0733894557,
0.2197328508,
-0.3529574275,
-0.0956337005,
0.029424144,
-0.1899602115,
-0.370811522,
-0.4465427697,
0.4330512285,
-0.3741693497,
-0.2834296823,
0.1687492728,
-0.313518852,
0.1573606879,
0.1905193478,
-0.7910224199,
0.4859852493,
1.1843014956,
0.8316953778,
-0.3531973064,
-0.2435225695,
-0.9482222199,
-0.0120012509,
-0.244483456,
0.8439125419,
-0.7012922764,
-0.3597559333,
-0.1306687593,
0.2798898816,
0.0155763272,
-0.7752510309,
0.7471168041,
-0.5574399233,
-0.3705309927,
-0.2407738715,
-0.8159149885,
-0.0861812681,
0.44112432,
-0.4529556632,
1.1423377991,
-0.0783465654,
-0.6615778208,
0.6150413752,
-0.5462086201,
-0.2528285086,
0.0648308769,
-0.0966021568,
-0.251370728,
0.4300127625,
-0.1387564391,
0.9121654034,
-0.2897119224,
-0.1000019386,
-0.4825031459,
-0.2479837984,
0.5009797812,
-0.2401003391,
0.3267392814,
0.3666605353,
-0.198888883,
0.1749589741,
-0.604036808,
0.0000668417,
-0.0960028246,
-0.1057056114,
-0.4022581875,
0.296502471,
-0.2168293893,
0.331235975,
0.1102218628,
-0.5000506639,
-0.1319421828,
-0.4876493514,
0.4435536861,
0.7703094482,
0.0611569658,
0.2324136198,
-0.1418702751,
0.4024126232,
0.0384600312,
-0.0823298022,
-0.3736339808,
-0.4194941223,
-0.6887592077,
-0.2727989852,
0.0687085912,
0.473068893,
-0.3653253615,
0.4547348619,
-0.1617160738,
-0.3927632868,
-0.096962966,
0.5615774393,
0.0243481118,
0.4429442883,
0.09685947,
-0.5505328178,
-0.6252599955,
-0.5951612592,
-0.4205237031,
-0.0458848402,
-0.2488507479,
0.2744285464,
0.4089003801,
-0.4854092002,
0.9270992875,
-0.3113687634,
-0.3027260303,
-0.0847100616,
0.1651539207,
0.5093426704,
0.1441185921,
-0.1802019179,
-0.480034411,
-0.1390595585,
-0.035603635,
-0.8305726051,
-0.2619028091,
0.1713702083,
0.0189149622,
0.4561041594,
0.7189070582,
-0.5068742037,
0.273840934,
0.4678841531,
-0.3100297451,
0.4571835399,
-0.3346257508,
-0.2151707411,
-0.6694105268,
-0.0395242125,
-0.0267364178,
-0.4208849669,
-0.6708567739,
-0.0342771113,
-0.1112991124,
-0.0725656003,
-0.4995654821,
0.3610439897,
-0.6277371049,
-0.3353758752,
-0.7393485308,
-0.0910654217,
-0.3526639342,
0.2205080539,
0.2924016416,
0.2914870977,
0.7926197648,
-0.8483012915,
0.2776722014,
-0.2362443507,
-0.6501073241,
0.4140306413,
-0.2425384521,
0.0087342625,
0.0537761003,
-0.0749495253,
-0.8666731119,
-0.1846136004,
0.1191344783,
-0.243360281,
0.140471071,
-0.2590964437,
-0.8021931648,
-0.1112341806,
-0.2994649112,
0.0734972432,
0.5349091887,
-0.5161876082,
0.6315959096,
0.4865683615,
0.0599700399,
-0.2289617658,
-0.6692888737,
-0.0088247191,
-0.6207151413,
-0.5039470196,
0.2530153692,
0.0211573951,
-0.2802875936,
0.1464856267,
-0.5169466138,
0.0922926888,
0.5399906039,
0.5775660276,
0.0735774413,
0.2291858196,
0.08538872,
-0.3972969949,
-0.4541373253,
0.3526392281,
-0.1608739644,
0.5696154833,
-0.2129746974,
-0.5408142805,
-0.2487359196,
0.0592722744,
0.3827308118,
-0.0141850859,
0.6855458617,
0.5759875178,
-0.7148948312,
-0.2229288071,
-0.5494473577,
-0.2732083499,
-0.476182431,
0.309746325,
-0.4203540087,
-0.9558057785,
0.5910565853,
-0.5919672251,
0.1018276215,
0.2973861098,
0.6763221622,
-0.2016157955,
0.8920150399,
0.5688431263,
-0.013726199,
0.278342098,
-0.1756109893,
0.2647616267,
-1.0175949335,
-0.173322916,
-0.4148316085,
-0.1739145517,
-0.7762756944,
-0.4110150635,
0.4035334587,
0.1512952596,
-0.1424116045,
0.1862326413,
-0.0136480266,
0.3340791166,
0.4118189216,
-0.0969020203,
0.5276287198,
0.0200050976,
0.1880693436,
0.0401854627,
-0.6315281391,
-0.8262887597,
0.9924647808,
0.3529511392,
0.7865044475,
-0.1921333224,
0.6579589248,
0.1723282337,
0.2576138973,
-0.8812304735,
0.6765092015,
-0.0885568708,
-0.3322933316,
-0.4064813256,
-0.1467279792,
-1.1149437428,
0.0817406252,
-0.3004848957,
-0.8388606906,
-0.158934623,
-0.003125642,
-0.1021666974,
0.4399661422,
-0.5435527563,
0.8189492226,
-0.2432388067,
-0.3396592736,
-0.3415782154,
-0.3310737014,
0.2239556909,
-0.1432016343,
0.5307728052,
-0.5288364291,
-0.1981102377,
0.545855701,
-0.5254335403,
0.9635020494,
-0.0627556965,
-0.1034796908,
0.1391784847,
0.185139209,
0.6488331556,
0.1223117635,
-0.188995257,
0.4160948098,
0.1455636621,
-0.1400439888,
-0.5409446359,
0.9697221518,
-0.3183318973,
-0.8244439363,
-0.5238413215,
-0.4501969218,
-0.2947063148,
0.1632262319,
-0.0531640947,
0.0732322931,
-0.1317099333,
0.0381125249,
0.7831094861,
0.1089838594,
0.5563406348,
0.5262801051,
-0.0068316148,
0.3893884718,
0.6918051839,
0.067154184,
0.0275234263,
0.2111897171,
0.1082260534,
-0.0798250064,
-0.7667921185,
-0.1633567065,
-0.0139650181,
-0.7349371314,
-0.2411236763,
-0.7512587905,
-0.0734030902,
-0.0163900219,
0.0867936164,
-0.2160571516,
-0.1830420494,
-0.2467977256,
-0.094880648,
0.4302129745,
0.4809942245,
0.0652536005,
-0.0340768248,
-0.7482200861,
0.2877189815,
0.3009288907,
0.7682085037,
-0.0686834157,
-0.2126504779,
-0.206852451,
-0.3116883934,
-0.098562412,
-0.7947109938,
0.1267385483,
0.0259179976,
0.8715329766,
0.255433023,
-0.1115654707,
0.4561047554,
-0.4596377611,
0.6812489033,
-0.3671905398,
-0.8907694817,
0.6625745893,
-0.0466031954,
0.0298165344,
0.2500659227,
0.3815966845,
-0.5455231071,
-0.5176618099,
-0.7208442092,
-1.0778100491,
0.942396462,
0.2469786108,
0.0277573448,
-0.1731019765,
0.5406021476,
0.2845101357,
0.0979306847,
-0.4191561043,
-0.1149145886,
0.2450768501,
-0.0094855856,
-0.078981407,
-0.3302040994,
-0.0382285789,
0.0549869649,
0.8470523953,
0.0169304106,
-0.0189156029,
0.023164032,
-0.4378744364,
-0.0165921934,
0.3178227544,
-0.0195873417,
0.5796072483,
-0.1075514257,
0.324392885,
0.7389347553,
-0.1061884463,
-0.1752435863,
0.0695372149,
0.1351814717,
-0.1481325924,
0.3720406294,
0.7610894442,
0.1198814139,
-1.0804482698,
0.1790447682,
0.0654702038,
-0.0574235469,
-0.4640728831,
0.4076741338,
0.194792226,
0.3928466439,
0.1741753668,
-0.1419371516,
0.4927481711,
-0.9085296392,
0.0471097939,
0.8984213471,
-0.3032153845,
-0.1489694417,
0.3631611764,
-0.1281877905,
-0.3232057393,
0.497333914,
-0.201568976,
-0.3839658797,
0.4617596865,
0.3905052245,
0.7819517255,
0.0447187535,
-0.408929348,
0.027669156,
0.3643717468,
-0.1320315301,
0.1916750968,
-0.2731157541,
-0.7618507147,
-0.5195972919,
-0.7548413873,
-0.5191901326,
0.1884433478,
-0.3932017386,
0.423210144,
-0.2100939304,
-0.1386736631,
-0.1577474624,
0.085078232,
-0.8240058422,
0.1082090512,
0.3105068803,
0.8074879646,
-0.8733687997,
0.7410671711,
0.8399578333,
0.0676342696,
-0.3778293133,
-0.0999753028,
-0.1196129024,
-0.7013733387,
0.5566604733,
0.3282028437,
-0.1920750886,
-0.3122322261,
-0.0807092637,
-0.7998026609,
1.0589102507,
0.2587105632,
-0.3440994918,
0.5317274332,
0.2517753541,
0.5923441648,
-0.3097280264,
0.1844094992,
1.0251387358,
0.4145495296,
0.0226092767,
-0.7941581607,
0.2424708903,
-0.1478369981,
0.1221468449,
0.3013962507,
-0.146646902,
0.5227922201,
0.1132883281,
-0.2952141762,
-0.1381589621,
0.7486410737,
0.4879543185,
0.5077061057,
0.8218715787,
0.5971058607,
0.7393745184,
-0.1114358306,
1.1034743786,
-0.2913293839,
0.0333100185,
0.9362319112,
-0.4063895643,
0.7130393982,
0.4263271689,
-0.0002553658,
0.5070747733,
0.7527436614,
0.3931398392,
0.3424680233,
0.352137506,
-0.3526869118,
-0.565705955,
-0.0690657869,
0.0008321128,
0.2148467153,
0.6887088418,
-0.1983276755,
-0.3024868965,
-0.2324859053,
-0.1091359705,
0.0566612184,
-0.6032887697,
0.8071897626,
0.1915941238,
-0.6694083214,
0.0676119402,
0.2919046879,
0.7694032192,
-0.669757545,
-0.0181834027,
0.0687648207,
0.3034336567,
-0.3608057499,
-0.8986873031,
0.7048453689,
0.2220476717,
-0.1993921101,
-0.4173033237,
1.0380862951,
-0.0819591209,
-0.488286227,
0.329744935,
0.46198681,
0.4013238847,
-0.2878870666,
-0.3679406643,
0.0878095403,
-0.5084678531,
-0.2418536991,
0.6006106734,
0.7082490921,
-0.3828536272,
0.6218645573,
0.6484894156,
0.1883050948,
0.0045082415,
0.0514080524,
0.707446456,
-0.6457085609,
-0.3427560329,
-1.1861368418,
0.2452579141,
0.090733707,
0.1834431887,
0.803663373,
0.6697966456,
0.989510715,
0.1474603713,
0.7404542565,
0.0980591103,
0.4564506114,
-0.790425241,
0.0714396462,
-0.3604311943,
0.5634528995,
-0.0980087444,
-0.8122169375,
-0.2784359753,
0.4862453043,
-0.3329935372,
-0.0812100694,
0.629086256,
0.8401945829,
-0.137593776,
0.1268284321,
0.1801402867,
0.0559051856,
0.2352855206,
0.534740448,
0.9141361117,
-0.1049479321,
0.3852160573,
-0.1741243303,
-0.3107922673,
-0.0646276921,
-1.2749592066,
-0.9084975123,
-0.4738186598,
-0.1177862063,
-0.1293528676,
-0.1521659493,
0.861658752,
0.5488499403,
-0.6631676555,
-0.3960529864,
-0.2787085772,
0.1532835662,
-0.2973648906,
-0.1246313229,
0.1501049548,
-0.77168262,
-0.7477562428,
0.4652132392,
0.4085846543,
-0.2804001272,
-0.1609590352,
-0.1382481754,
0.1055680439,
-0.0441154689,
0.7127858996,
0.0935452878,
-0.6501857638,
-0.1609948128,
-0.0444300659,
0.3543320596,
-0.2520121634,
1.0900275707,
-0.6955729723,
0.2550825775,
0.5575091839,
0.6985244155,
1.0359836817,
-0.337723881,
0.2923342586,
-0.7072554231,
0.0308442451,
0.0035549963,
0.6198490262,
0.2585479617,
-0.317784369,
0.5608744621,
0.1516261697,
-0.5440351367,
-0.714035809,
0.2470649481,
-0.9372603297,
-0.3268071115,
1.2200106382,
0.0137200886,
-0.1322060078,
-0.3058146536,
0.1122932956,
0.2921840549,
-0.0071856538,
0.69291085,
0.9532543421,
-0.5575333834,
0.277682066,
-0.8028634787,
0.4573185146,
0.432277441,
-0.6832771897,
0.3416700065,
0.3121451735,
0.5008678436,
-0.1617165655,
0.6631223559,
-0.131768018,
-0.0289076362,
-0.6060488224,
-0.0953442827,
-0.1672326177,
-0.0372252613,
-0.3577089608,
0.1516243964,
0.430711925,
0.0617973842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02302v1 | Towards Human Understanding of Paraphrase Types in ChatGPT | 2024-07-02T14:35:10 | 2024-07-02T14:35:10 | Dominik Meier, Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Bela Gipp | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Paraphrases represent a human's intuitive ability to understand expressions
presented in various different ways. Current paraphrase evaluations of language
models primarily use binary approaches, offering limited interpretability of
specific text changes. Atomic paraphrase types (APT) decompose paraphrases into
different linguistic changes and offer a granular view of the flexibility in
linguistic expression (e.g., a shift in syntax or vocabulary used). In this
study, we assess the human preferences towards ChatGPT in generating English
paraphrases with ten APTs and five prompting techniques. We introduce APTY
(Atomic Paraphrase TYpes), a dataset of 500 sentence-level and word-level
annotations by 15 annotators. The dataset also provides a human preference
ranking of paraphrases with different types that can be used to fine-tune
models with RLHF and DPO methods. Our results reveal that ChatGPT can generate
simple APTs, such as additions and deletions, but struggle with complex
structures (e.g., subordination changes). This study contributes to
understanding which aspects of paraphrasing language models have already
succeeded at understanding and what remains elusive. In addition, our curated
datasets can be used to develop language models with specific linguistic
capabilities. | [
-0.2245072722,
-0.7131720781,
0.5229058862,
0.0332784466,
-0.5290142298,
-0.127895385,
-0.0720934272,
-0.1509701312,
-0.1146576032,
0.486402601,
-0.17292808,
-0.4359292984,
-0.3944756389,
0.5418645144,
-0.3322459161,
1.0162656307,
-0.000180702,
-0.1831768006,
-0.074409768,
-0.0877652094,
-0.3289552033,
-0.4999736845,
-0.5039486289,
-0.2970056534,
0.4475879967,
0.6226642728,
1.2670434713,
0.6629661322,
0.4603444934,
0.2515002787,
-0.2556932867,
-0.1877718717,
-0.175576821,
0.1321876645,
-0.1956914216,
-0.5010801554,
-0.1549315304,
-0.183641091,
0.4423303604,
0.6207284927,
-0.1925254017,
0.0834059492,
0.0698848143,
0.6046715379,
-0.4098010957,
0.5208870173,
-0.7666486502,
0.0828844458,
-0.1877668649,
-0.0354436748,
-0.3214152753,
-0.3631548882,
0.3965136707,
-0.4541739821,
0.3063237965,
0.1635535657,
0.5163857341,
0.1288135648,
-0.4306407273,
-0.4253044128,
-0.339943856,
0.413623929,
-0.8352871537,
0.2963064015,
0.5189851522,
0.2945595086,
0.1164423302,
-0.7117530107,
-0.4540122747,
-0.5712223053,
-0.3033814728,
0.0250842646,
0.0778347999,
0.2362434566,
-0.1196022853,
0.3939875364,
-0.6391271949,
-0.1484712958,
-0.2611033022,
-0.1383951455,
0.4228253961,
0.189572677,
0.5507057905,
-0.7305853367,
-0.1497375965,
-0.1121822,
-0.5372846127,
-0.1210971624,
0.0656731576,
0.1613708884,
0.1154246554,
0.7191167474,
-0.4731953442,
0.4481368661,
-0.2210019529,
0.2544940412,
-0.0634408221,
-0.2496864498,
0.0610407181,
-0.2290887982,
0.7057256103,
0.3645157516,
0.5120931268,
-0.4603334367,
-0.0882208347,
-0.0360899717,
-0.0389578529,
-0.626134336,
-0.5254061222,
0.151713565,
-0.5201535225,
-0.2771778405,
-0.076816678,
-0.7879597545,
-0.3206404448,
-0.2741686404,
0.2823613882,
-0.7840079665,
-0.051657524,
0.343734175,
-0.5334756374,
0.2554370761,
0.1969016194,
-0.8735877872,
0.1179787293,
0.6114230156,
0.8038234711,
-0.091985479,
-0.7185742259,
-0.0566688068,
0.0819488838,
-0.2829894722,
1.0664322376,
-0.6349255443,
-0.4318696558,
-0.169802025,
-0.4620954394,
-0.2390975356,
-0.6020801067,
0.5918094516,
-0.3931133151,
0.3135153055,
-0.2785708606,
-0.5535517931,
-0.2397836,
-0.0171180852,
-0.4812687635,
0.7191047072,
0.0314564817,
-0.7715418339,
0.244560346,
-0.7025949359,
-0.3230579197,
0.3917888999,
-0.1520579457,
-0.13138403,
0.3141720295,
0.4198696911,
0.4295048714,
-0.2417148501,
0.3559312224,
-0.1738699228,
-0.087101534,
0.5328564048,
-0.5797644854,
0.2212218195,
0.5313391089,
-0.2362690717,
-0.1420027167,
-0.5065336823,
-0.1069656834,
0.1300854981,
-0.2665805221,
-0.3102591634,
0.1684657037,
0.041250892,
0.3436299264,
0.3909379542,
-0.2169606537,
-0.081116192,
-0.1534274668,
1.0543198586,
0.6474401951,
0.5355191231,
0.1836742014,
-0.5514900088,
0.5544860363,
-0.1154036149,
0.1487953067,
0.0202667825,
-0.5782386065,
-0.3537125885,
-0.0591255315,
0.0461592488,
0.4048890769,
-0.6887543201,
0.118487455,
-0.4123125076,
-0.5671413541,
-0.4769518077,
0.0240435693,
0.4736786485,
0.4677750468,
0.3639955223,
0.0207957961,
-0.0381686166,
-0.9511966109,
-0.6512895823,
-0.3530813456,
-0.048499804,
0.3652435243,
0.4740917683,
-0.0942256451,
1.0701721907,
-0.4209493101,
0.3927690089,
-0.5164168477,
0.4019134343,
-0.2566881776,
0.0033045118,
0.2512724102,
-1.1266795397,
-0.6018810272,
0.0551356375,
-0.6846173406,
-0.1979923844,
-0.1051878706,
-0.2119278908,
-0.3270938396,
0.3397499919,
-1.019164443,
0.192835331,
0.1244300753,
-0.4564556479,
0.5311837196,
-0.0676926449,
0.3556120992,
-1.1868652105,
-0.0766997784,
-0.1889625788,
-0.1692676693,
-0.5072296858,
0.2903342843,
0.0860327482,
-0.4577522874,
-0.69104141,
0.5469257832,
-0.3166252375,
-0.0877788141,
-0.1967888623,
0.3165480793,
0.0517332442,
0.379719466,
0.2793072164,
0.8917964101,
0.2756749094,
-0.4234070182,
0.0239978898,
0.6248860955,
-0.1682504714,
0.1687752903,
-0.85831213,
0.1725198179,
-0.318312645,
0.2490400374,
-1.1666307449,
-0.459253341,
0.2330990881,
-0.4768815339,
-0.1540157646,
-0.13918598,
-0.4182479084,
0.0024903307,
-0.438067019,
0.2366212606,
0.6449255347,
-0.1536788195,
0.2544578314,
0.1209786609,
-0.4537040889,
-0.3176558018,
-0.4015969336,
0.4279600382,
-0.5984838605,
-0.3552829623,
0.1067880616,
-0.0805477872,
-0.430403322,
-0.1490285099,
-0.1501584053,
-0.1568275541,
0.0792752281,
0.0659418479,
-0.0142614674,
-0.0279222224,
-0.0699894726,
0.0592070632,
-0.0736037493,
-0.1016710401,
-0.0023838263,
0.6549178958,
-0.2398392558,
-0.1013880968,
-0.5614452362,
0.42189762,
0.7388064861,
-0.2693919837,
0.4391809404,
0.3567720354,
-0.0442655124,
0.2499943078,
-0.2063798457,
-0.3063513935,
-0.4591360092,
0.4218765795,
-0.4444998801,
-0.6585602164,
0.5221511126,
0.1774493754,
0.1986978799,
0.4612706602,
0.652195394,
0.1296787709,
0.850938797,
-0.0627664402,
0.004827919,
0.5025855303,
0.2267863899,
-0.1658745855,
-0.6342073083,
0.1610563397,
-0.504550457,
-0.0766678527,
-0.3960301578,
-0.2252739072,
0.3300316632,
0.2425749302,
-0.1538212746,
0.511423111,
-0.4211495519,
0.4892135262,
0.5059145689,
0.364189446,
0.3212505877,
-0.1846079975,
0.3485161662,
0.109464027,
-0.7103513479,
-0.7767410278,
1.0363653898,
0.2152029574,
0.6770727038,
0.1018054858,
0.8579239249,
0.3941784799,
-0.0577869266,
-0.5620331168,
0.7151705623,
-0.0924829841,
-0.597759366,
-0.3570077419,
-0.4508748651,
-1.0419851542,
0.2579247952,
0.1215723902,
-0.671253562,
-0.0797726363,
0.2434588671,
-0.2036371976,
-0.155034855,
-0.9414823055,
1.0013816357,
0.011755297,
0.1944379658,
-0.15162085,
-0.9208569527,
0.0535848886,
0.1394450217,
0.1954111755,
-0.1713499725,
-0.1492308825,
0.7375124693,
-0.2559943795,
0.6741064191,
0.100811854,
0.1643225104,
0.4974922836,
0.4469522536,
0.4923664629,
0.2776979804,
-0.2141263783,
0.1302744597,
0.0420388095,
-0.4103787839,
-0.4701329768,
0.3077007532,
-0.7345975637,
-0.6578100324,
0.0043249247,
-0.8203203678,
-0.0274396408,
0.0174565855,
0.5439127684,
0.5172160268,
0.0660323575,
0.2402993888,
0.3706954122,
0.0116859656,
0.4037304223,
0.2290139198,
0.0445963107,
-0.4154808223,
0.8468779325,
-0.0751900375,
0.5641461015,
0.7082603574,
0.6327980757,
-0.3262168467,
-0.7400391102,
-0.3062494397,
0.2711589038,
-0.9942775369,
0.0602114834,
-0.634469986,
0.2201394886,
-0.6354777217,
-0.2332997918,
-0.1161165386,
-0.6848448515,
-0.1841948628,
-0.047634013,
0.7156322598,
0.5681611896,
0.2766356468,
0.3453087211,
-0.8839172721,
0.6146008372,
0.5416488647,
-0.1168099791,
-0.203926459,
-0.5861214399,
0.013785474,
0.1070845947,
-0.2619329095,
-1.0933207273,
0.4246805608,
0.5709502697,
0.3137272894,
0.090351738,
0.1819227785,
0.5792250633,
-0.5907592177,
1.1164990664,
-0.4244016111,
-0.9816988111,
0.5865365267,
-0.6745253205,
0.1824426204,
0.6102989316,
0.4498471618,
-0.7053928971,
-0.5822876692,
-0.6616281867,
-0.9122856259,
0.5110603571,
0.4557125866,
0.1929771006,
-0.441066891,
0.6448988318,
0.297362268,
0.2882559299,
-0.8151842356,
-0.1348252892,
-0.1748882085,
-0.3675366938,
-0.086012736,
-0.0258016754,
0.0330739617,
0.200546667,
0.2769111395,
0.0396082439,
0.1845334619,
0.1170503572,
-0.3823888004,
0.1936068982,
0.6244872212,
0.32330966,
0.7715875506,
-0.353710711,
0.2279174477,
0.1383931935,
-0.3608734906,
0.0715671331,
-0.052941341,
-0.1003115922,
0.0747911334,
0.524255693,
0.702063024,
0.3342788517,
-0.8334005475,
0.2048791647,
-0.0648739934,
-0.0204080809,
0.1830584854,
0.0908055082,
-0.0033000163,
0.0821209326,
0.1661462039,
-0.1425232291,
0.4172980487,
-0.5868411064,
0.243949011,
0.2578532398,
0.0359337032,
-0.4901167154,
0.7683227658,
-0.0046467562,
-0.6098632216,
0.5125419497,
-0.0848895162,
-0.3640827537,
0.2374819368,
0.4965648353,
1.0034618378,
-0.0190340374,
0.464797914,
-0.2066342384,
0.0340934992,
-0.2711494267,
0.0262464806,
-0.296522826,
-0.6880673766,
-0.1265797615,
-0.4892998338,
-0.7941737771,
-0.0361424237,
-0.7584806681,
0.2511849701,
-0.0432061814,
0.2101839334,
0.1061676964,
-0.5373055935,
-0.4170228541,
0.0226018336,
-0.0301298052,
0.5569262505,
-0.9405940771,
0.6051510572,
0.9196504354,
-0.5841444135,
-0.7171477079,
0.2949752808,
-0.3395521045,
-0.963373661,
0.457678616,
0.0132729542,
0.2856335044,
0.2937478125,
-0.0945416912,
-0.5881204009,
0.9899522066,
0.407137543,
-0.0461962633,
-0.4434547424,
0.3860941827,
0.4902164936,
0.0111624757,
0.3330676556,
0.667106092,
0.2658691406,
-0.1676654071,
-0.8877446055,
0.0120099392,
0.0270292368,
0.2694156766,
0.3092700243,
-0.4808342755,
1.1323750019,
0.2562258542,
0.051175341,
-0.0618701838,
0.316254884,
0.2352975607,
0.1867717057,
0.3015170991,
0.3833209276,
0.0739163533,
0.3805903494,
1.0246790648,
-0.3986638784,
0.5499127507,
0.8863834143,
0.0012637435,
0.9482197165,
0.4039121866,
-0.2132629305,
0.2902416587,
0.6500986814,
0.6461642385,
0.5786456466,
-0.0995834619,
-0.2617733777,
-0.2504709661,
0.2355133891,
-0.1832584888,
0.4904819131,
0.3176964223,
-0.2411663979,
-0.6469327807,
0.2128221542,
0.050614927,
-0.0207907483,
-0.2251756191,
1.0700240135,
0.039288342,
-0.8713202477,
0.7969998717,
-0.1660885066,
0.3292945325,
-0.4697962403,
-0.0645839572,
-0.3463732898,
-0.1534208655,
0.0484321937,
-0.9537278414,
0.2203445286,
-0.1094615757,
0.0995828658,
-0.133512795,
0.5736889243,
-0.3349201977,
-0.1023115218,
-0.3139869869,
0.4684433341,
0.5266267061,
-0.4012410343,
-0.8860249519,
-0.3316358328,
0.1873251647,
-0.4615940452,
0.3927237093,
0.7881330252,
-0.1874103695,
0.7439632416,
0.3001063764,
-0.0009664113,
0.0274672583,
-0.2961252332,
0.4843625426,
-0.7089549303,
-0.5487344265,
-1.1076534986,
0.3261914253,
0.2173411399,
-0.6146482825,
0.9031432271,
0.2559728622,
0.3609084487,
-0.3789385855,
0.9067377448,
-0.1199331433,
0.3971291184,
-0.551440835,
0.483020097,
-0.04295763,
0.0465643108,
-0.4283424914,
-0.8416671753,
-0.0850098953,
0.6167215705,
-0.3641772866,
-0.1569871008,
0.619753778,
0.6787709594,
0.018324459,
0.0961676016,
0.2201575637,
-0.1219763681,
0.407335788,
0.4720121622,
0.9592154026,
-0.2571924627,
0.7596150637,
-0.2192934304,
-0.1280808896,
-0.2859329879,
-0.7432881594,
-0.7609711289,
-0.5935394764,
-0.4313577414,
-0.0736879259,
-0.0253541097,
0.9854915738,
0.3454662263,
-0.5052976012,
-0.0585100017,
-0.6664388776,
0.0481723659,
-0.1667218357,
-0.273905158,
0.4430613518,
-0.6125856638,
-0.6277611852,
0.1903591901,
0.1531767845,
0.0112706488,
0.1762175411,
0.0997890681,
-0.0380300954,
0.1254071444,
0.5156333447,
0.2718839645,
-0.7683445215,
-0.646882534,
-0.0075692544,
0.1596468538,
0.1644942313,
0.7791159749,
-0.4474651217,
0.1359292716,
0.5754756927,
0.5130189657,
0.062043976,
0.2599070966,
0.4859054983,
-0.6639283895,
0.1259927154,
0.447342366,
0.3164325058,
0.2319281995,
-0.2471372634,
0.215259403,
0.1868653893,
-0.9669271111,
-0.6874107122,
0.3188164532,
-0.7696551681,
-0.500434041,
1.4016674757,
-0.1927863061,
-0.0584305115,
-0.3165827394,
-0.5691469312,
0.2125764489,
-0.4661928117,
0.9463666677,
0.7026239634,
-0.3867605925,
-0.1810960323,
-0.4211868346,
0.5315341949,
0.4701327384,
-0.7966905832,
0.5817857385,
0.3969942033,
0.3605437279,
-0.1244957596,
0.4975919127,
-0.1366714239,
0.4112122059,
-0.0095029604,
-0.0530096292,
0.0894521624,
-0.0103727914,
-0.2230036259,
0.0628387928,
0.5751660466,
-0.2767460644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02301v1 | CFinBench: A Comprehensive Chinese Financial Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T14:34:36 | 2024-07-02T14:34:36 | Ying Nie, Binwei Yan, Tianyu Guo, Hao Liu, Haoyu Wang, Wei He, Binfan Zheng, Weihao Wang, Qiang Li, Weijian Sun, Yunhe Wang, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance on various
NLP tasks, yet their potential in more challenging and domain-specific task,
such as finance, has not been fully explored. In this paper, we present
CFinBench: a meticulously crafted, the most comprehensive evaluation benchmark
to date, for assessing the financial knowledge of LLMs under Chinese context.
In practice, to better align with the career trajectory of Chinese financial
practitioners, we build a systematic evaluation from 4 first-level categories:
(1) Financial Subject: whether LLMs can memorize the necessary basic knowledge
of financial subjects, such as economics, statistics and auditing. (2)
Financial Qualification: whether LLMs can obtain the needed financial qualified
certifications, such as certified public accountant, securities qualification
and banking qualification. (3) Financial Practice: whether LLMs can fulfill the
practical financial jobs, such as tax consultant, junior accountant and
securities analyst. (4) Financial Law: whether LLMs can meet the requirement of
financial laws and regulations, such as tax law, insurance law and economic
law. CFinBench comprises 99,100 questions spanning 43 second-level categories
with 3 question types: single-choice, multiple-choice and judgment. We conduct
extensive experiments of 50 representative LLMs with various model size on
CFinBench. The results show that GPT4 and some Chinese-oriented models lead the
benchmark, with the highest average accuracy being 60.16%, highlighting the
challenge presented by CFinBench. The dataset and evaluation code are available
at https://cfinbench.github.io/. | [
-0.2087731808,
-0.4731833935,
0.2854616344,
0.5197515488,
-0.1464485526,
0.2573193014,
-0.5573135018,
-0.5278818607,
-0.3077367842,
0.4145088792,
-0.3419702649,
-0.670350492,
-0.2933991551,
-0.1699958146,
-0.6340841651,
0.8634377718,
0.0601557642,
0.2883245051,
-0.1084537655,
0.1531338543,
-0.1147124022,
-0.3589791059,
-1.0094923973,
-0.4968080819,
0.3591247201,
-0.0973811448,
0.5237540603,
0.2813036442,
0.7502877712,
0.2827240527,
-0.1808971763,
-0.2647188306,
-0.3755370677,
-0.422013402,
-0.4053644538,
-0.2537795603,
-0.3973338604,
-0.0234330203,
0.5300525427,
0.8031692505,
-0.4672353268,
0.2776077092,
0.2396466285,
0.5725781918,
-0.526671052,
0.3774891496,
-0.6167378426,
0.0816854835,
-0.4139418304,
0.0637411699,
-0.2996192276,
-0.3597522974,
0.2362451106,
-0.32464692,
0.0454137549,
-0.0242270194,
0.8412435651,
0.0655327514,
-0.6556127667,
-0.0962856337,
-0.2819710076,
0.6053632498,
-1.0593115091,
0.5498789549,
0.206463322,
0.6179921627,
-0.1684747189,
-0.9225130081,
-0.3602609336,
-0.5003022552,
-0.1449630111,
0.3073761463,
-0.0325803198,
0.149316147,
0.3174899817,
0.5733217597,
-0.5805740356,
0.2386696786,
-0.2205677927,
-0.2767401934,
0.7083226442,
0.2284280211,
0.0336408466,
-0.0297695287,
-0.5035709739,
-0.4266781807,
-0.4403764009,
0.1933885813,
0.2727549672,
0.3782021701,
-0.2209431827,
0.1856008172,
-0.1710531414,
0.8236123323,
-0.0771189705,
-0.4027922451,
0.2275521904,
-0.3029919565,
-0.3211170137,
0.037147034,
0.7571573853,
0.3298399448,
0.1279167235,
-0.0798293576,
-0.5196278691,
-0.3863103688,
0.0480755307,
-0.6236433983,
-0.0285578649,
0.3027636409,
-0.436837554,
-0.0378580056,
0.4009019136,
-0.7066453099,
-0.3937255442,
-0.3080026209,
-0.0698867515,
-0.2310487777,
-0.2401595563,
0.060357172,
-0.1314551979,
0.8248797059,
0.2577917278,
-0.9222486615,
0.463748157,
1.282217741,
0.7960265875,
-0.1843933314,
-0.2135554105,
-0.4080357552,
-0.0131791271,
-0.5160406232,
0.8931295872,
-0.2660375237,
-0.1274493635,
0.1027743891,
-0.0838718489,
-0.1411298215,
-0.7449454069,
0.5117432475,
-0.3585508764,
-0.2558760643,
-0.3531704843,
-0.7502723336,
-0.1718103588,
0.557500124,
-0.6618664265,
0.9320375323,
0.3079658747,
-0.6881389618,
0.3875001967,
-0.3411976993,
-0.3109881282,
0.1373786032,
-0.2810715139,
0.0162889026,
-0.1913802028,
-0.0582995526,
0.5743974447,
-1.0060946941,
0.748598814,
-0.4552547038,
-0.4497632384,
0.2076135576,
-0.5265424848,
0.7669196725,
0.049430944,
-0.4987074733,
0.0516607836,
-0.8330246806,
0.122420691,
-0.0779678077,
-0.3312900364,
-0.2214774042,
-0.1258294284,
0.3860094249,
0.3278758526,
0.4559341967,
-0.4395384192,
-0.1199958548,
-0.7256299853,
0.3535780013,
1.020373106,
-0.2321915627,
-0.1057401076,
-0.1968712062,
0.4703221321,
-0.28687644,
0.0004961871,
-0.0034235658,
0.047970634,
-0.5702524185,
-0.0467759371,
0.5186824799,
0.6213997006,
-0.4503464997,
0.5521798134,
-0.0956550986,
-0.894954741,
-0.0410759933,
0.4825153053,
0.4119355679,
0.3703263402,
0.05719053,
-0.1356423944,
-0.0951272175,
-1.099596858,
-0.4385958016,
-0.2123634964,
-0.2068050653,
0.0877190977,
0.5493980646,
0.1578430831,
0.541405499,
-0.4435860813,
-0.2664520144,
-0.3248643279,
-0.155157581,
0.6449812651,
0.365570426,
0.8851015568,
-0.6609076858,
-0.4864428937,
0.392677933,
-0.5165137649,
-0.0153911132,
-0.4608549476,
-0.2953564227,
0.1010181531,
0.6330729723,
-0.3408633471,
0.0766116902,
0.5172348619,
-0.33430776,
0.5446815491,
-0.0306180045,
-0.2333150208,
-0.7430300117,
0.6123936176,
0.166172266,
-0.0875499547,
-0.3433867395,
0.277983278,
0.3113864064,
0.1696017683,
-0.249231413,
0.9428557158,
-0.1583718807,
-0.2987260222,
-0.1397079676,
0.4321810603,
-0.3210968375,
0.5089595318,
-0.1432254612,
0.5534030795,
0.4148144722,
-0.2576922476,
0.7871669531,
-0.0462329015,
-0.8109940886,
0.5848869681,
-0.6849880219,
-0.2038992196,
0.3753110766,
0.3533779085,
-0.925478518,
-0.0042545293,
-0.0535057262,
0.1198277175,
0.1827388257,
0.327411294,
-0.7920403481,
-0.5100215077,
-0.156423226,
0.0745943636,
0.0823776573,
-0.6396394372,
0.645016849,
0.0374089256,
-0.3267436326,
-0.7048386931,
-0.5853940248,
0.0359890237,
-0.0587445386,
-0.6930425763,
0.3803460598,
-0.14915362,
-0.4025559723,
-0.2215432525,
-0.3975599706,
0.015483737,
0.2936394811,
-0.1771037728,
0.4620491862,
-0.3558838964,
0.0706343055,
-0.0821264088,
-0.1595926136,
0.2591825426,
-0.13883771,
0.6259147525,
-0.2686695158,
-0.4412187934,
-0.1289327294,
-0.1803133488,
0.1866063774,
-0.4266656637,
0.5977999568,
0.4629368484,
-0.3787920773,
-0.3478833437,
-0.7956773639,
0.1865550876,
-0.5021148324,
0.4281232059,
-0.256662339,
-0.8896158934,
0.7067288756,
-0.1130512729,
0.494371295,
0.7449074984,
0.6136866808,
0.464925617,
0.4110966325,
0.6166481972,
-0.5263118744,
0.2523935139,
-0.1064847857,
0.148039788,
-0.3015169501,
-0.1461981535,
-0.4792648256,
-0.1910254359,
-0.3071505129,
-0.3316401541,
0.1823691279,
0.032366205,
-0.4610580802,
0.326813221,
0.0175355822,
0.5230454803,
0.2845513225,
-0.1510961652,
0.2491793931,
-0.3214076757,
-0.3633801639,
0.1630217731,
-0.3898859322,
-0.307320714,
1.0293120146,
0.4059770405,
0.4987843931,
-0.0508816317,
0.353684634,
0.0350352377,
0.617187798,
-0.5984506011,
0.4534806907,
-0.4498318732,
-0.7185879946,
-0.2275070846,
-0.5894102454,
-0.3637081385,
0.3459778726,
0.0081391549,
-0.6609352827,
-0.0172547456,
-0.1405846626,
-0.6128714085,
0.3338225782,
-0.099329412,
1.0508183241,
-0.7527349591,
-0.4571415484,
-0.1765287369,
-0.4805458188,
0.8289692998,
-0.6747671962,
0.2900233567,
-0.1529880166,
-0.0975850672,
0.7344661355,
-0.4684907794,
0.6429153681,
-0.1600781232,
-0.4811813533,
0.1309838891,
-0.1863163859,
0.3304688632,
0.0793686509,
-0.4578907788,
0.2289498746,
0.3530585468,
-0.3066729307,
-0.5058114529,
0.7721803784,
-0.4008928239,
-0.5292397738,
-0.5878350735,
-0.2634537816,
-0.435646832,
0.2991014421,
-0.0711011514,
0.0393128097,
-0.6414750814,
0.3562265635,
0.0848084018,
-0.5567765832,
0.3380366564,
0.6404240727,
-0.3366967738,
-0.3478267193,
0.7194084525,
0.0440174006,
0.1424896717,
0.4009275138,
0.1472029686,
-0.2594189346,
-0.3003792465,
-0.1926296502,
0.3391648829,
-0.9651923776,
-0.2930018902,
-0.3086115718,
-0.5785011053,
-0.3528559506,
-0.2052792758,
-0.5056798458,
0.0685923845,
0.0378203094,
-0.4145973921,
0.0543143786,
0.3918944001,
-0.0500614718,
0.1420843601,
-0.7743695378,
0.2441767305,
0.2062180936,
0.7201399803,
0.4116021395,
-0.4176160097,
-0.3525406122,
-0.270996958,
-0.2415370047,
-0.3003062606,
0.2542130649,
0.0874945149,
0.8958216906,
1.0776561499,
-0.0068005333,
0.9512370825,
-0.0887517184,
0.6403229833,
0.131588012,
-1.0926173925,
0.0923119262,
-0.2654974163,
0.25343889,
0.7626100779,
0.1549577862,
-0.850854516,
-0.4001947045,
-0.449038893,
-1.0390939713,
0.7230146527,
-0.0258073583,
0.1785225421,
0.1436413229,
0.4773516953,
0.1052778438,
0.3059332371,
-0.6442030072,
-0.1491259485,
0.0030571993,
-0.0065003787,
-0.3259227276,
-0.1072401628,
0.0178749878,
-0.2261092812,
0.6149694324,
-0.2561534941,
-0.3887265921,
-0.1168671548,
0.3434869945,
0.0563794002,
0.0809521675,
0.3891295195,
1.0316812992,
-0.2754939497,
-0.2111879885,
0.3072139323,
-0.1659832001,
-0.2080223262,
0.4494991004,
0.2223990262,
-0.1254549176,
0.7657461762,
0.3950709701,
0.5617636442,
-1.262668252,
0.6323779225,
0.0116351694,
-0.3217321336,
-0.8587382436,
0.1060174331,
0.4468075633,
0.3285975754,
0.4883200824,
-0.2873906493,
0.0978222713,
-0.521163106,
0.1868583113,
0.4287694395,
-0.3604306281,
0.0746830329,
0.5993210673,
0.0990512148,
0.3518436849,
0.7246960402,
0.1968372315,
-0.3672922254,
0.8913770914,
0.2777900696,
0.8273277879,
-0.2144078165,
0.0149824899,
0.539693296,
0.4131141007,
-0.5125106573,
0.2389065325,
-0.0559983589,
-0.5805527568,
-0.1960216165,
-0.9261165857,
-0.5612027645,
0.132939294,
-0.7558749318,
0.3540324569,
-0.9817150235,
-0.0769016147,
0.1079293489,
0.1296730638,
-0.6108890772,
0.1918110251,
0.3346329927,
1.5764403343,
-0.3433590531,
0.7010064125,
0.313110888,
-0.0407634415,
-0.7417574525,
-0.0200849976,
0.2780730128,
-0.6616956592,
0.6308880448,
0.2635900378,
0.1227509603,
-0.3905023932,
-0.4703921974,
-0.9013857841,
1.2683300972,
0.5434959531,
-1.0668815374,
-0.0853709802,
0.287668258,
0.6900947094,
-0.2581934035,
0.3611573577,
1.0078943968,
0.8827598691,
0.1573575586,
-1.0570704937,
-0.1126416624,
-0.5589501262,
-0.0189965833,
-0.0282202885,
-1.2008444071,
0.9252056479,
0.1908056736,
-0.1224616095,
0.2145366222,
0.5980440974,
0.4156746566,
0.36126405,
0.6105514765,
0.2131444216,
0.7740504742,
-0.3188750744,
1.1203821898,
-0.8065348268,
0.2923666239,
1.0446214676,
-0.5440087914,
1.0221710205,
0.106907241,
-0.3294273317,
0.359888792,
0.880114615,
-0.55207479,
0.0180733278,
0.6185591221,
-0.0098701417,
-0.5799044371,
-0.0240463074,
-0.3879872262,
0.623988986,
0.2268063724,
-0.3295834363,
-0.2186598182,
-0.2770659626,
0.0490403362,
0.0444095582,
-0.2829437256,
0.5416153669,
0.477765739,
-0.5798285007,
0.3115598559,
0.4051451385,
0.6355870366,
-1.1731475592,
0.2018872499,
-0.4562489986,
0.380610615,
-0.1724400818,
-0.5542182326,
0.1543951184,
0.1298242062,
0.340359807,
0.0966985747,
0.4125554562,
-0.18328996,
-0.8169828057,
0.7865040898,
0.3018457294,
-0.0277036801,
-0.34825176,
-0.8386061192,
-0.1840192378,
-0.0690757334,
-0.4893130958,
0.3687030673,
0.3868602216,
-0.0023391417,
0.7111079693,
0.7728115916,
0.0154482881,
-0.3255210519,
0.2066086382,
0.9142132401,
-1.1416120529,
-0.6264910698,
-0.8339586258,
0.1452285498,
-0.0299442671,
-0.4720826745,
0.7040065527,
0.8962734342,
1.1154059172,
0.1640895456,
0.7053830624,
0.2051992863,
0.1982683092,
-0.5518399477,
0.8905671239,
-0.7532949448,
0.4463303685,
-0.6387411952,
-1.1111352444,
-0.3035497069,
0.4203224778,
-0.3292885125,
0.1625924557,
0.5696026087,
0.5493642092,
0.0061524226,
0.1960397959,
0.5439642072,
0.1628410369,
0.1946074665,
0.7803255916,
0.5186758041,
-0.1285104603,
0.6572163701,
-0.5574502945,
-0.0706607923,
-0.0272202622,
-0.7172428966,
-0.9897551537,
-0.2137323767,
-0.1108597741,
0.085224703,
-0.3056086898,
0.9626235366,
0.3098802567,
-0.9004419446,
-0.9032717347,
0.3916640878,
-0.1223537177,
-0.5280768275,
-0.2088354826,
0.609716475,
-0.234443903,
-0.6161770225,
0.3321472704,
0.3669749498,
-0.0707700998,
-0.4877750874,
0.0525921807,
0.0501362719,
0.0283211004,
0.4737220109,
0.0177810844,
-0.7360705137,
0.1146763861,
-0.1135253012,
-0.2502510846,
-0.2126723081,
0.9099200368,
-0.3075591922,
0.1783539206,
0.3905249834,
0.7525081038,
0.2994680405,
-0.071943298,
0.671387434,
-0.2321167141,
0.1636714637,
-0.1031794548,
0.5261877179,
0.1168475375,
-0.2445745617,
0.6744437218,
-0.0122260926,
-0.2237162292,
-0.5888679028,
-0.3924671412,
-1.0440142155,
-0.4561491013,
0.7661329508,
-0.3971739709,
-0.2986765802,
0.1183042824,
-0.0947095901,
-0.09608116,
-0.3428716063,
0.5812118053,
0.9670696259,
0.2996962368,
-0.1995713562,
-0.8333677649,
0.3425361216,
0.4127168655,
-0.6942266226,
0.426818192,
0.2958253026,
0.25162673,
-0.0428968482,
0.6366454363,
-0.0866864994,
0.4313672185,
0.0654821023,
0.0105826184,
0.0938919187,
-0.0061778366,
-0.1914825439,
0.2693637908,
0.042763412,
0.7712597251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02284v1 | Renard: A Modular Pipeline for Extracting Character Networks from Narrative Texts | 2024-07-02T14:14:59 | 2024-07-02T14:14:59 | Arthur Amalvy, Vincent Labatut, Richard Dufour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Renard (Relationships Extraction from NARrative Documents) is a Python
library that allows users to define custom natural language processing (NLP)
pipelines to extract character networks from narrative texts. Contrary to the
few existing tools, Renard can extract dynamic networks, as well as the more
common static networks. Renard pipelines are modular: users can choose the
implementation of each NLP subtask needed to extract a character network. This
allows users to specialize pipelines to particular types of texts and to study
the impact of each subtask on the extracted network. | [
-0.3173169792,
-0.5690563321,
0.1371574849,
-0.1638707072,
0.0125852181,
0.2262527049,
0.2299411893,
-0.6362681389,
0.7533705831,
0.8090083003,
-1.03746593,
-0.1502240598,
-0.5290558934,
0.5360311866,
-0.5293445587,
1.151870966,
0.0575562045,
-0.4516679645,
0.1374106705,
-0.1271909922,
-0.4681560695,
-0.4200931489,
-0.7700791359,
-0.4928108752,
1.1535543203,
0.6697999239,
0.6826581359,
0.9051021934,
0.9453151822,
0.430121392,
0.1939836591,
0.2566424906,
-0.5241289735,
1.0352094173,
-0.4894679189,
-0.5126305223,
-0.317361623,
-0.1470589936,
0.665987432,
0.2505277693,
0.2674939632,
0.6351411343,
-0.2522096634,
1.012031436,
-0.6351494193,
0.2833251655,
-0.3570545018,
0.2006359994,
-0.3120793998,
-0.4614048898,
-0.368938148,
-0.4727060795,
0.3782226443,
-0.3607955873,
0.2937296927,
0.4205820262,
1.1962376833,
-0.0139218401,
-0.2117396146,
-0.3286087513,
-0.5890741348,
0.866771996,
-0.6398504376,
-0.0096007325,
0.2016239166,
0.6533520222,
-0.0525893196,
-1.6892029047,
-0.4327881932,
0.3076853156,
-0.6812144518,
-0.1502774507,
-0.1048508883,
0.2977999747,
0.3339959383,
0.5690393448,
-0.3804976344,
-0.013526802,
-0.5799328089,
-0.0670942813,
0.8928994536,
0.5358798504,
0.8068926334,
-0.6491363645,
-0.2026370019,
-0.180843994,
-0.2074273676,
0.0933848768,
0.586496532,
0.2570203841,
0.283690989,
0.6627115011,
-0.0127921952,
0.5900366306,
-0.1687401682,
-0.1600756049,
0.2355445623,
0.0319100805,
-0.5774928331,
0.0200190116,
1.1252856255,
0.1292939037,
0.672819376,
-0.0802575573,
-0.3175829351,
-0.4968251288,
0.1962265372,
-0.8009303212,
-0.7649794221,
0.4809828401,
-1.1288058758,
-0.752538383,
0.2132597566,
-0.9360904694,
-0.385269165,
-0.0752433985,
0.063804768,
-0.1501934379,
-0.3602463305,
-0.2322407663,
-0.9154806137,
0.080284588,
0.0219469201,
-1.1375253201,
0.3714183867,
0.643814981,
0.9890019298,
-0.4899916053,
-0.4228756726,
-0.6680672169,
0.0394083299,
0.0921847597,
0.9365469217,
-0.6517521143,
-0.0761967972,
-0.0669362023,
0.6239176989,
-0.0404338613,
-0.3550337553,
0.6943826079,
-0.6287220716,
0.1778559238,
-0.2056546211,
-0.3948046267,
-0.638399303,
0.3095671535,
-1.1118779182,
0.8615571856,
0.1898273528,
-1.1597771645,
0.1333399564,
-0.4031753242,
-0.3689393401,
0.3233932853,
-0.0284128841,
0.0341105238,
-0.0688159466,
0.1992635876,
0.7253624201,
-0.482783407,
0.4089236259,
-0.0958384871,
-0.2584534883,
0.318351239,
-0.3310586214,
1.0122244358,
0.4273906052,
0.1004865542,
0.2783933282,
-0.7724567652,
0.1635262072,
-0.0926691815,
-0.2090439647,
-0.4395841658,
0.358089149,
0.1934200227,
0.0347507969,
0.104542613,
-0.4534373879,
0.4699355364,
-0.5122824907,
0.6422079802,
0.7018048763,
0.3763379157,
0.2818415165,
-0.5539847612,
0.7570456862,
-0.419142276,
-0.1182298213,
-0.8514050245,
-0.5690306425,
-0.792023778,
-0.5603353977,
0.315702647,
0.7142625451,
-0.9544295073,
0.2526169419,
-0.0649024099,
-0.4299039543,
-0.5495694876,
-0.0620568991,
0.15791215,
0.4915182889,
0.2726780176,
-0.3429251313,
-0.797347188,
-1.0779685974,
-0.4638630748,
-0.4775990844,
0.0517340638,
0.1582067162,
0.4105668962,
-0.4611219466,
1.1963174343,
-0.7227338552,
-0.2845454216,
-0.5771010518,
0.3773333132,
0.5910024643,
0.3702135086,
0.1594966054,
-0.7182194591,
-0.6344798803,
0.2566832006,
-0.9651557207,
-0.3107984066,
-0.3129691482,
-0.0237443428,
-0.2724280655,
0.5888181329,
-0.0513419323,
0.3616012037,
0.5370696783,
-0.4052064717,
1.0509474277,
-0.1136438474,
0.1735865921,
-1.053958416,
0.2558668852,
-0.3242037892,
-0.4769474268,
-0.6382223964,
0.3496002853,
-0.1932417601,
-0.0717449859,
-0.2682198584,
0.7123817801,
-0.6998015046,
0.0109605994,
0.0429481156,
0.0375845954,
0.1576132774,
0.3958328068,
0.2363621294,
0.3149261475,
0.4998234212,
-0.2102045268,
0.9335301518,
0.1963886917,
-0.0535513796,
0.3625539243,
-0.8669317365,
-0.0387143604,
-0.1683775932,
-0.2030334473,
-1.3085782528,
-0.3737423718,
0.207718417,
-0.1909700483,
0.3299331069,
-0.5494743586,
-0.3938322067,
-0.3028341532,
-0.2999918461,
0.4464590847,
0.3506080508,
-0.4759982526,
0.5838067532,
0.5285243392,
-0.4567019045,
-0.8170375228,
-1.0443854332,
0.1110626683,
-0.2480685264,
-0.6881231666,
-0.0791139156,
0.2658506632,
-0.4245353639,
0.0856192932,
0.2687457502,
-0.7215880752,
-0.2100206167,
0.5257630944,
0.1078694537,
-0.2737740278,
0.1826569438,
0.159219414,
-0.3254919946,
-0.0446667522,
0.0470028147,
0.3722441792,
-0.0097168153,
-0.0279965606,
-0.7785481215,
0.3693881035,
0.7606547475,
-0.1159672588,
0.5440665483,
0.6360353827,
0.0182312671,
-0.4109301865,
-0.4975189269,
-0.3554169834,
-0.5632391572,
0.2467839718,
-0.2418098599,
-0.8467658162,
0.6289650798,
-0.2562646866,
0.2384001762,
0.6419225931,
0.1033038646,
-0.2020980716,
0.3137653172,
0.5667081475,
-0.2587075233,
0.332116574,
-0.3967960477,
0.1504314095,
-0.8687133193,
-0.3865995407,
-0.5250877142,
-1.015627861,
-0.4988365769,
-0.2469961941,
-0.2232835889,
0.1450125277,
-0.13941136,
0.8155539036,
-0.7753711939,
0.5322421193,
0.3901806772,
-0.379496187,
0.6802581549,
0.2923837602,
0.0843909755,
-0.342358619,
-0.7071605921,
-0.6860191226,
0.8137425184,
0.4773465097,
0.9285597801,
-0.0455244109,
0.9180002213,
0.5867606401,
0.2345648557,
-1.0329465866,
0.439276427,
-0.1716815084,
-0.886777699,
-0.4145344198,
-0.4263150096,
-1.1356647015,
0.1822618991,
-0.4355620146,
-1.0183286667,
0.7426152825,
-0.2340236008,
-0.0208893642,
0.6254899502,
-0.6665943861,
0.7343658209,
0.0096614603,
-0.0706454888,
0.0416419394,
-0.7257629037,
0.5086935759,
0.0607552528,
-0.0262444187,
-0.0697906539,
0.0268228762,
0.8895305991,
-0.3126926124,
0.8307460546,
0.3209806383,
0.2255399674,
0.652749002,
0.8192343116,
0.5195874572,
0.2740990818,
-0.3655981421,
0.2649128735,
0.6019288301,
0.0132582588,
-0.507281363,
0.659394443,
-0.615568161,
-0.107702814,
-0.7239118814,
-0.7705542445,
0.3446878791,
0.5784941912,
0.1096895486,
0.7793135643,
-0.2584215105,
0.1286057681,
0.1882877499,
-0.2469984144,
0.8625398874,
0.1825793386,
-0.5014879704,
-0.4633503854,
0.9071524739,
0.0628108084,
0.2285057008,
0.6349653006,
0.1662960052,
0.078820698,
-0.233579874,
-0.0073577003,
0.3214949369,
-0.58869344,
-0.2417191416,
-0.89583987,
-0.6123002172,
0.1051273793,
-0.2762991488,
-0.3398478031,
-0.8208137155,
-0.4448370636,
-0.0010347128,
0.1718216091,
1.0650327206,
-0.0535054654,
0.1638210714,
-1.1910872459,
0.4812726676,
0.663836956,
-0.1423449516,
0.0350392051,
-0.3041894138,
0.0926666111,
-0.3287353814,
-0.1472365409,
-0.8846407533,
0.964227438,
0.3604175448,
0.4093970656,
0.641497612,
0.0528254397,
0.7927539349,
-0.5107880831,
0.9215043187,
0.2432388216,
-0.6145483255,
0.4444228709,
-0.4156503975,
0.151337713,
0.6513425708,
0.5527514815,
-0.9649161696,
-0.0916250646,
-0.7280902863,
-0.7380139828,
0.7433989644,
0.1581863463,
-0.1626788527,
-0.2461828738,
0.7431294322,
0.1170773506,
0.2653610408,
-0.7000083327,
-0.4250726998,
0.2390891016,
-0.0355709791,
0.2612142563,
-0.6779469252,
-0.1597697288,
-0.3092829883,
0.2275141031,
0.0431318022,
0.3686475456,
0.4584869444,
0.0185672306,
-0.1493698359,
-0.1585682929,
-0.0036255845,
0.6863712668,
-0.3955100477,
0.2684014738,
-0.1681799442,
-0.7634394765,
0.0007726382,
-0.2800115645,
0.0610279664,
0.1430801898,
1.2480287552,
0.3656778336,
-0.0315380618,
-0.6387399435,
0.3278106749,
-0.3059830368,
-0.1411889642,
-0.1329824924,
0.1557985991,
-0.1903546602,
0.7201940417,
0.4046912491,
0.2539438009,
0.2326580286,
-0.7232142687,
0.5767521858,
0.0445177406,
-0.7539895773,
-0.3789634109,
0.3368454576,
0.2299961895,
-0.7584849596,
1.0253924131,
-0.0147151928,
-0.2144894302,
0.7217918038,
0.5921673179,
1.418086648,
0.1620612592,
0.5893476605,
0.636184752,
0.4708562493,
-0.1564554721,
0.0752445608,
0.2326440662,
-0.712824285,
-0.6380408406,
-0.7266879678,
-0.1125736088,
-0.2759085596,
-0.7950186729,
0.3932223022,
-0.4494832754,
-0.0903112516,
-0.3890510499,
-0.0624336451,
-0.2393758297,
-0.1182927564,
-0.2791220546,
0.9124367237,
-0.7038177848,
0.9608194828,
0.4795356393,
-0.2359538078,
-0.9113797545,
-0.1402415931,
0.0451403596,
-0.7018222809,
1.3611106873,
-0.0411584936,
-0.0219213404,
0.0336192437,
-0.3541121781,
-0.916154325,
1.2786067724,
0.2464888394,
-0.7038933039,
-0.2708161771,
-0.284689188,
0.5900720358,
-0.6930954456,
0.3770523071,
0.461733371,
0.5595488548,
-0.0402099825,
-0.5394585133,
0.0217468012,
-0.320435375,
-0.2311783731,
0.3298181891,
-0.3467221856,
1.006038785,
0.0614166856,
-0.4661471844,
0.1526485831,
0.5024989247,
0.0478485636,
-0.0502169691,
0.2611449659,
0.1977114528,
0.8964942694,
-0.0382872522,
1.1353802681,
-0.1148575842,
0.3914176524,
1.1494642496,
0.1763788015,
0.7599244118,
0.5549138784,
0.1144780964,
1.2001742125,
0.4985532761,
0.0760374218,
0.4909565449,
0.0671883374,
0.0516612604,
-0.0234714784,
0.1623001099,
-0.1721772701,
0.208815679,
0.2539366484,
-0.6273841858,
-0.036885336,
-0.4683842063,
-0.1124647036,
-0.1586404145,
-0.2183454186,
0.5635906458,
0.2265198231,
-0.4823954701,
0.2993440628,
-0.1777409315,
0.4292871952,
-0.8579905629,
-0.2970092595,
-0.0500328057,
0.1678734571,
-0.7055746317,
-0.9739093781,
0.5609727502,
-0.3508710861,
-0.3285537064,
-0.3344841003,
1.0957956314,
-0.4780709743,
-0.4661347568,
0.2144077718,
0.3272322714,
0.284591943,
0.241043359,
-0.9391514063,
0.0339677036,
0.0959397703,
-0.3314361572,
0.057585407,
0.6935639381,
0.2520519495,
0.8574253917,
0.6902267337,
0.4528414905,
-0.1958946586,
-0.1603148729,
0.82291013,
-0.7582301497,
-0.2542482316,
-1.0979604721,
0.8418172002,
-0.3671179414,
-0.448748827,
0.9211543798,
0.1872887313,
0.0719770044,
-0.0874433964,
0.6229735017,
-0.4692829847,
0.2736053765,
-0.1410154253,
0.7876492739,
-0.3469256163,
0.2616136968,
-0.5804610252,
-1.1602820158,
-0.37538293,
0.6800351143,
0.1480719298,
-0.5778545737,
1.3341898918,
0.6635049582,
-0.1573499739,
0.1903156936,
0.1541945934,
0.0405558906,
0.4060019851,
0.3006442189,
0.5617636442,
-0.4692130089,
0.3067685366,
-0.011697703,
-0.279638499,
0.0905453637,
-1.1495479345,
-1.4170585871,
-0.6904627085,
-0.097268343,
-0.2574130595,
0.0619151033,
0.5581197739,
0.7116339803,
-0.8824980259,
-0.7625735998,
-0.0284415353,
0.4520888031,
-0.2887662351,
-0.3698114157,
0.4333841801,
-0.5898643732,
-0.609292984,
0.4028829336,
0.5818498135,
-0.4727922082,
-0.4823935926,
0.0136476075,
-0.600759387,
-0.1553704739,
0.4870826304,
0.5631290674,
-0.1907969713,
-0.3995831311,
-0.1999126226,
0.0827760696,
-0.1697829068,
1.1693056822,
-0.7617427111,
0.9105898738,
1.3054503202,
0.5469229221,
0.6846496463,
-0.0419911146,
1.0468876362,
-0.7042745948,
0.3680727482,
0.2437809855,
0.2693337798,
-0.0556142889,
-0.4471341074,
0.8034940958,
0.585768044,
-0.9497070909,
-0.8087622523,
0.425699532,
-0.8563756347,
-0.430339396,
1.0745600462,
-0.1633111537,
-0.3598852754,
-0.4510665238,
-0.446634531,
-0.1275426149,
-0.2382294536,
0.3299387395,
0.6476292014,
-0.1560986191,
-0.2850696146,
-0.7110358477,
0.6242718101,
-0.204560712,
-0.5570090413,
0.0499286838,
0.1436571032,
0.0505446978,
0.3292360306,
0.6089631319,
-0.2694229782,
-0.2462156415,
-0.0891677886,
0.1616113633,
-0.2952054441,
-0.5572446585,
0.0227087568,
0.5920695662,
-0.3080120087,
0.1976002604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02273v1 | Multilingual Trolley Problems for Language Models | 2024-07-02T14:02:53 | 2024-07-02T14:02:53 | Zhijing Jin, Sydney Levine, Max Kleiman-Weiner, Giorgio Piatti, Jiarui Liu, Fernando Gonzalez Adauto, Francesco Ortu, András Strausz, Mrinmaya Sachan, Rada Mihalcea, Yejin Choi, Bernhard Schölkopf | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) are deployed in more and more real-world
situations, it is crucial to understand their decision-making when faced with
moral dilemmas. Inspired by a large-scale cross-cultural study of human moral
preferences, "The Moral Machine Experiment", we set up the same set of moral
choices for LLMs. We translate 1K vignettes of moral dilemmas, parametrically
varied across key axes, into 100+ languages, and reveal the preferences of LLMs
in each of these languages. We then compare the responses of LLMs to that of
human speakers of those languages, harnessing a dataset of 40 million human
moral judgments. We discover that LLMs are more aligned with human preferences
in languages such as English, Korean, Hungarian, and Chinese, but less aligned
in languages such as Hindi and Somali (in Africa). Moreover, we characterize
the explanations LLMs give for their moral choices and find that fairness is
the most dominant supporting reason behind GPT-4's decisions and utilitarianism
by GPT-3. We also discover "language inequality" (which we define as the
model's different development levels in different languages) in a series of
meta-properties of moral decision making. | [
-0.4565191269,
-0.4725697041,
0.7022837996,
0.3912529349,
0.0071955635,
0.048944585,
-0.2718064785,
-0.5434831977,
-0.0052572191,
0.5300863385,
-0.2726924717,
-0.1168599799,
-0.5492495894,
0.2433839589,
-0.1778342277,
1.0278525352,
0.0133422744,
0.6428674459,
-0.1648254097,
-0.4987437129,
-0.2276588082,
-0.83025527,
-0.8678837419,
-0.4982706904,
0.7337352037,
0.3958342373,
0.7931625247,
0.2245552391,
0.5712223053,
0.376322329,
-0.1907577217,
-0.1815113723,
-0.2291310728,
-0.1754274368,
-0.4085693061,
-0.4335877001,
-0.3929997385,
0.1169219986,
0.20028238,
0.644289434,
-0.1300508678,
0.3080293834,
-0.0000148125,
0.7711871266,
-0.4763076007,
0.0302265845,
-0.4404618144,
0.1131482124,
-0.1461271942,
0.2492372841,
-0.279233247,
-0.6573141813,
-0.11053662,
-0.209571287,
0.0319329426,
0.057306394,
1.015712142,
0.0274258237,
-0.8961842656,
-0.4987117648,
-0.5803031325,
1.0610922575,
-0.5622524023,
0.3443828523,
0.4397853017,
0.2020081729,
-0.0084101763,
-0.3308882415,
-0.8513401151,
-0.1422104388,
-0.0772262588,
0.1641739458,
0.0746385083,
-0.0454947054,
0.1536067724,
0.0855733156,
-0.5866239667,
0.2330255806,
-0.3768655062,
-0.0952714905,
0.6475691795,
0.2073361129,
0.2603540421,
-0.4595938027,
-0.2557767928,
-0.1729568839,
-0.5231801271,
0.2091059387,
0.839051187,
0.1361021996,
-0.1730256677,
0.5296038985,
0.3850557804,
0.6912337542,
-0.1931284815,
-0.2508731484,
0.350238055,
-0.4016321003,
-0.1782094687,
-0.1271543056,
0.9277501702,
0.726521492,
0.857093215,
0.4381048381,
-0.3746337295,
-0.0411015339,
0.0213471074,
-0.4794289768,
0.1824253947,
0.238220498,
-0.4806750417,
-0.2494058609,
-0.2054555267,
-0.7910586596,
-0.4271073937,
-0.3631238341,
0.0569131821,
-0.2401152551,
-0.3586879075,
0.568007946,
0.0917393789,
0.4577436447,
0.1932314038,
-0.9142584801,
-0.1806858629,
0.4495972395,
0.769138813,
0.0596289597,
-0.2455747724,
-0.3506144881,
0.1458451301,
-0.280192852,
0.752032578,
-0.6468990445,
-0.5696942806,
0.0885622054,
0.1567451954,
-0.0504087023,
-0.3315166533,
0.8914062381,
-0.2251339257,
0.182408005,
-0.5683258176,
-0.022093242,
-0.2819100916,
0.3805758357,
-0.605900228,
0.7421594262,
-0.1377446651,
-0.6729441285,
0.2086124867,
-0.5583860278,
-0.5166196227,
-0.2782364786,
-0.2547115684,
-0.3391570151,
0.2240946591,
0.0731864348,
0.3088038266,
-0.3912675381,
0.673838079,
-0.4166942537,
-0.0035885267,
0.2090279162,
-0.5375282168,
1.2372124195,
0.323354274,
0.0385498516,
0.0280801915,
-0.4336054921,
-0.031249946,
0.4113014638,
-0.3909857273,
-0.5149563551,
0.154332146,
0.20160456,
0.4911769629,
0.3827604353,
-0.4645037949,
0.1864209771,
-0.2016751617,
0.3988447785,
1.0088666677,
-0.5735426545,
0.2811899483,
-0.3095448315,
0.6510459185,
0.0073116212,
0.5245888829,
0.2184064984,
-0.6252951026,
-1.1135854721,
0.2597696185,
0.0259500649,
0.760667026,
-0.6515378356,
0.0487634614,
-0.0239233058,
-0.1162828729,
-0.4410296381,
-0.0879746601,
0.4768941402,
0.1693909019,
0.1540063769,
-0.1090409905,
-0.5088053942,
-1.2797058821,
-0.3445491493,
-0.3967524469,
0.1021252647,
0.3702325225,
0.7162503004,
-0.2147470713,
0.7564629912,
-0.348602742,
-0.2054877579,
-0.3535465002,
-0.118549414,
0.3795380592,
0.3359703124,
0.805444479,
-0.8645023704,
-0.3660972714,
0.3924049735,
-0.6338822246,
-0.0809118971,
0.0243435185,
-0.0422825888,
0.2239070982,
0.2824102044,
-0.378526032,
0.0760380626,
0.8343912363,
-0.2586226463,
0.7173253894,
-0.3361133635,
0.0750763938,
-1.0520399809,
-0.2654982805,
-0.0322879776,
-0.0665829629,
-0.4210421145,
-0.07014025,
0.0986458436,
0.0397513956,
-0.5485135913,
0.6013690233,
-0.2497906387,
-0.2470216006,
0.1332802027,
0.4226483405,
-0.0265414696,
0.4877078533,
-0.1838543266,
0.8094645143,
0.4005191326,
-0.5911765099,
0.2714985907,
0.318847537,
-0.193903625,
0.6988509297,
-0.602451086,
0.0282840617,
-0.2741657794,
0.1081548333,
-0.6868917346,
-0.1189442277,
0.062892966,
-0.2812269628,
-0.2121298611,
-0.2258306891,
-0.5196868181,
-0.5092375278,
-0.112460658,
0.4337545037,
0.3154028654,
-0.4301171005,
0.6186314821,
0.6649309993,
-0.1834068447,
-0.8999781609,
-0.6198484302,
0.1286391616,
-0.3990378678,
-0.6844953895,
-0.2369056344,
-0.2332422882,
-0.5526332855,
-0.3144651651,
-0.0056958403,
-0.1146190464,
0.0245014001,
-0.2369942218,
0.097463131,
0.0325544402,
0.2011604756,
0.0628442466,
-0.2441297472,
0.2080429792,
-0.4773322642,
0.5620233417,
-0.6500775814,
-0.4401957393,
0.0679006353,
0.4932626486,
0.5431786776,
-0.4526547492,
0.4212910235,
0.668697238,
-0.1349883676,
0.2437745929,
-0.4551405013,
0.2586792409,
-0.548725009,
0.2329693139,
-0.410054177,
-0.9331134558,
0.7394481897,
0.1956457943,
0.1260041744,
0.2424710244,
0.6373313069,
-0.1570777446,
1.3098216057,
0.6209011078,
0.0708627775,
0.4058499336,
-0.167100817,
0.3840066195,
-0.5072997212,
-0.2656070292,
-0.8218514919,
-0.2931553721,
-0.9829362035,
-0.4092916846,
0.4906781018,
0.1286545992,
-0.5311380625,
0.1359761059,
-0.2635222673,
0.8038372397,
0.3057415485,
-0.3425411284,
0.5623862147,
-0.0432165191,
-0.6020388007,
-0.0722964779,
-0.6672741771,
-0.9331640005,
0.7363980412,
-0.0113763092,
0.7268385291,
0.4781807959,
0.4039136171,
-0.0585014559,
0.2559168339,
-0.6749575138,
0.6119858623,
-0.5677680373,
-0.7177073359,
-0.0333649553,
-0.3382264376,
-1.1066116095,
0.4186514616,
0.0376483425,
-0.6606352329,
0.2877155542,
0.0345857367,
-0.1465974301,
0.5548925996,
-0.7452889681,
0.7699243426,
-0.8333001137,
-0.3280183077,
-0.2256342471,
-0.7236020565,
0.6275478005,
-0.1678633243,
0.7276286483,
-0.259893626,
0.0913846716,
0.6258453727,
-0.2669339776,
0.710442245,
0.1562785655,
-0.5970571637,
0.0345122442,
0.1397127807,
0.4289871454,
0.3819721043,
-0.1800929457,
0.3312557638,
-0.0504169576,
-0.4969895184,
-0.3615394235,
0.7427933216,
-0.7762144804,
-0.9753540158,
-0.6049789786,
-0.4201363921,
-0.1625507176,
0.2567317784,
0.1265153736,
0.2174844444,
-0.0180553831,
0.0266099609,
0.4258813858,
-0.8351914883,
0.7138053179,
0.6000435352,
-0.7334215641,
-0.293787539,
0.7767517567,
-0.1143731922,
0.5263055563,
0.1269839406,
0.3822977841,
-0.4082553685,
-0.4035691917,
-0.5775880814,
0.3260933161,
-0.7487596273,
-0.0028544548,
-0.692495048,
0.0681717619,
0.0578255653,
-0.4594815373,
-0.4907463789,
-0.2386672646,
-0.1358376294,
-0.105308488,
0.3613354266,
0.9887399077,
-0.3016771078,
0.2502355278,
-0.9159828424,
0.123317562,
0.1798630357,
0.4492812157,
-0.0050440915,
-0.2838767469,
-0.3010727763,
0.1065623239,
-0.459420085,
-0.6373119354,
0.3464131355,
-0.3330979943,
0.3794239163,
0.4908165038,
-0.0583273396,
0.8259812593,
-0.5703017712,
0.7243067622,
0.3200652599,
-1.0931048393,
0.1676633805,
-0.5281043649,
-0.0800705552,
0.2784982324,
0.449852705,
-0.7852010727,
-0.4847888947,
-0.3433296084,
-0.784952879,
0.6159091592,
0.3596103191,
0.4601992369,
-0.2663773596,
0.1132105812,
0.0363601111,
0.0267183371,
-1.1878365278,
-0.2732734382,
-0.2206563354,
-0.0515623428,
-0.2274624407,
-0.0753559768,
-0.0430432521,
-0.2637161314,
0.3272470832,
-0.0773826838,
0.0270509291,
0.0548803844,
-0.0815778449,
-0.0529881716,
0.4310396612,
0.8412964344,
0.8215984106,
0.1020541713,
0.0613775849,
0.3715121746,
-0.3658929765,
0.557659328,
-0.3470009863,
0.0616819076,
-0.0538153537,
0.2775000334,
0.7473944426,
-0.0335557163,
-0.8028638363,
0.3447237313,
-0.3621338904,
-0.0890139341,
-0.6348090172,
-0.0243733134,
0.3568632305,
0.3308253586,
0.1989432275,
0.0081719812,
-0.0461621284,
-0.4064713717,
-0.0066861673,
0.5989837646,
-0.3442427814,
-0.2036949992,
0.681845963,
0.4639616907,
-0.6480441689,
0.5427233577,
-0.3789780736,
-0.7376628518,
0.751583159,
0.2641181052,
0.7710026503,
-0.24491629,
0.437827915,
0.3422335088,
0.5914054513,
-0.2381982058,
0.3439497054,
0.4818265736,
-1.0902998447,
-0.6257756352,
-0.6989955306,
-0.3174702823,
0.0647607297,
-0.7370058894,
0.3804293275,
-0.1302901655,
-0.3155997992,
-0.4787468612,
-0.1360467374,
-0.5167864561,
-0.10153649,
-0.1982471645,
0.3533947766,
-0.7243811488,
0.8372641802,
0.574506104,
-0.5202131867,
-0.592094779,
0.0360957012,
-0.1561881304,
-0.7923314571,
0.7871941328,
0.0789366961,
-0.3332645595,
0.0199161023,
-0.4197957516,
-0.7038034201,
0.7070125937,
0.6270602942,
-0.8510096669,
0.0110662272,
0.2681746483,
0.499350965,
-0.2081531584,
0.3162014782,
0.6029388905,
0.8965903521,
-0.2780053914,
-1.1241180897,
-0.3812268078,
0.0264379177,
-0.0223357975,
0.4821411669,
-0.9765164256,
1.1227970123,
-0.59044379,
-0.1387720108,
-0.0903474614,
0.1937326342,
0.337644875,
0.2732414901,
0.6282486916,
0.3211891651,
0.7605314255,
-0.1176962927,
1.2413278818,
-0.2224889249,
0.6690530181,
0.8159137964,
-0.5601019263,
0.3027332425,
0.523673892,
-0.202469185,
0.3758488595,
0.6643334627,
0.1416677535,
0.0256536957,
0.2687379122,
-0.0817911178,
-0.4538315833,
-0.2414811105,
-0.2922693789,
0.562030673,
0.2281770259,
-0.0195843074,
-0.1787673384,
0.1099555343,
0.2680105865,
0.052107241,
-0.1909710467,
0.442068696,
0.2416481674,
-0.3941923678,
0.6611077189,
0.12266431,
0.5262044668,
-0.5013845563,
0.2929612696,
-0.4914069474,
0.1970662773,
-0.0984355658,
-1.0876026154,
0.2868456244,
0.2337698042,
-0.0903077871,
-0.3963493407,
0.1160000488,
-0.4201357961,
-0.757543385,
0.8338218927,
0.8072100878,
0.1995781809,
0.4900048673,
-0.9108685255,
-0.0247292295,
0.2123659253,
-0.2298123091,
0.2761182785,
0.609136939,
-0.4719147682,
0.9840792418,
0.7408812046,
-0.1157567129,
-0.164103657,
0.2828291953,
0.5272458792,
-1.0214984417,
-0.3697632551,
-0.9685126543,
0.4282584786,
-0.0270128939,
-0.3791271448,
0.6572628617,
0.4454905987,
1.1360253096,
-0.1474198848,
0.8888653517,
0.0194998756,
-0.0504150093,
-0.8000196218,
0.628220439,
-0.7943109274,
0.4053843915,
-0.4011720717,
-0.7204456925,
-0.1706044525,
0.9057643414,
-0.3157433569,
0.377913177,
0.9831193089,
0.728192091,
0.0540715978,
-0.0264087357,
0.4058741629,
0.2229676545,
0.4685612917,
0.7768565416,
1.1141949892,
-0.2119761109,
0.824709475,
0.1518054008,
0.2303104997,
0.0685304776,
-0.9646167159,
-0.9053089023,
-0.5306737423,
0.1252980083,
-0.2940884829,
-0.0696764067,
0.8005911112,
0.3511136174,
-0.7525510192,
-0.8204776049,
0.0731289983,
0.8144876361,
0.0459620059,
-0.1677185148,
0.1336617172,
-0.1810709834,
-1.0306016207,
-0.0631032959,
0.244864583,
0.1633605957,
-0.4139478505,
-0.2650239766,
-0.3577564657,
0.1559209228,
0.7688083649,
-0.2560670078,
-0.8032214046,
-0.4892985225,
-0.1088994145,
-0.082833387,
0.2240906656,
1.1687651873,
-0.259663105,
0.1998033375,
0.3222956359,
0.2424856275,
0.2393323481,
-0.2409764081,
0.8013923168,
-0.4291083515,
0.3570280373,
0.2307506651,
0.6182363033,
0.3446906805,
0.0044183847,
0.496494621,
0.1642349213,
-0.6320243478,
-0.7300568819,
0.650782764,
-0.6018923521,
-0.3561667204,
1.2223228216,
0.07814008,
0.0711466819,
-0.4458854795,
-0.2698293924,
0.0901412219,
-0.4233872294,
0.4573930204,
0.9626672268,
-0.0482396558,
-0.0414272435,
-0.9876024723,
0.4100232422,
0.4504558742,
-0.5998647213,
0.0693528205,
0.536029458,
0.1554714888,
0.0936666057,
0.4074561,
-0.0767682791,
-0.1372825801,
-0.5060551763,
0.2615423203,
0.321909368,
-0.2363104522,
-0.4104118049,
0.0009122241,
-0.1089642346,
0.2836982608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02243v1 | Robust Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis with Reverse Inference Optimization | 2024-07-02T13:04:04 | 2024-07-02T13:04:04 | Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Siyin Wang, Eng Siong Chng, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this paper, we propose reverse inference optimization (RIO), a simple and
effective method designed to enhance the robustness of
autoregressive-model-based zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) systems using
reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). To assess the quality of
speech produced by the TTS system without human annotations, RIO introduces a
novel concept termed as reverse inference based on the Bayesian principle,
which suggests that a high-quality generated speech should be able to be used
as a prompt for subsequent generation using the same TTS model. By leveraging
reverse inference as the standard to select exemplars used in RLHF from the
speech samples generated by the TTS system itself, RIO steers the subsequent
optimization towards a direction of enhancing the TTS robustness. The RIO
framework, comprising sampling, automatic annotating, and learning, obviates
the need for a reward model or pairwise preference data, and significantly
improves the stability of zero-shot TTS performance by reducing the
discrepancies between training and inference conditions. Our experimental
results verify that RIO can effectively improve both subjective and objective
metrics, including mean opinion scores, word error rates, and speaker
similarity. Remarkably, RIO can also diminish the incidence of bad outputs to
nearly zero percent, rivalling the robustness when using ground-truth speech as
the prompt. | [
-0.3510698676,
-0.8750119805,
0.4029688239,
0.0773537308,
-0.4893665612,
0.0468471982,
-0.0285891164,
-0.1884273291,
0.1960491538,
0.5247559547,
-0.7327876091,
-0.6324223876,
-0.4106019139,
0.0581150129,
-0.4390605986,
1.1664518118,
0.3864904046,
0.0147394817,
0.1752738804,
0.0137126623,
-0.3124444187,
-0.3036274314,
-0.8388126493,
-0.2602039874,
0.5756756067,
0.2803213596,
0.56666255,
0.6803970337,
-0.2260948569,
0.1434722096,
0.0229720678,
-0.0597922765,
-0.5016668439,
0.5576255918,
-0.339817524,
-0.3064181507,
-0.208946079,
-0.1100029498,
0.628079772,
0.3282927573,
-0.1034081876,
0.2089405507,
-0.0182638671,
0.3713404536,
-0.9443927407,
-0.2066189945,
-0.6394785643,
0.1702434123,
0.3132798076,
-0.3384524882,
-0.4279720485,
-0.5232884288,
-0.0083203753,
-0.4182756841,
0.3483939171,
-0.0678467527,
0.7131655812,
0.4769683778,
-0.0179928485,
0.2872602642,
-1.0227333307,
1.0402189493,
-1.0501945019,
0.6990943551,
0.2892195284,
0.1952634007,
-0.2384478003,
-0.3583113849,
-0.6089851856,
-0.4215309918,
0.2249284536,
0.4335748255,
-0.0411232263,
0.2475076616,
0.0476039536,
-0.1812150329,
-0.693991363,
0.1888388246,
-0.1013675332,
-0.3012571335,
0.6379480362,
-0.0152345905,
0.1533544511,
-0.0189379416,
-0.1287599951,
-0.3373460174,
-0.9079187512,
-0.2037536651,
0.5180640221,
0.6619684696,
0.0335361026,
0.4101747572,
-0.2788798809,
0.7350562215,
-0.0419587269,
-0.4019563794,
0.1231120154,
-0.0679814145,
-0.4406097531,
0.0908210352,
0.8857961297,
0.1115510538,
0.0326091573,
-0.4089522958,
-0.3297109902,
0.1161525548,
0.3163161576,
-0.6802595258,
0.2624418139,
0.5231825113,
-0.1181597859,
-0.5397111773,
-0.0173922647,
-0.9812300801,
-0.1065090895,
-0.1669410467,
0.7095260024,
-0.1864783019,
-0.1018449962,
-0.1716127396,
-0.2443207055,
0.1725142598,
0.2221632451,
-0.81912148,
-0.0491748378,
0.5859488845,
0.7011753917,
-0.0168985687,
-0.4771987796,
-0.9504686594,
0.2864443362,
-0.6648657918,
0.8098476529,
-0.2035304159,
-0.6882719398,
-0.1881066263,
-0.2937583029,
-0.0647289082,
-0.2659776211,
0.764875412,
-0.2716265619,
0.4639513493,
0.2030464262,
-0.145798862,
0.0999430418,
0.1516950428,
-0.2366163135,
0.8683617711,
-0.1076873541,
-0.506903708,
0.4386677146,
-0.3911540806,
-0.5927735567,
-0.3369241655,
-0.2358845919,
-0.6840814352,
0.131539911,
0.3896467388,
0.0980888084,
-0.2861244977,
0.4252798259,
-0.4261893928,
-0.5163473487,
-0.0404750668,
-0.6132888198,
0.5103480816,
0.4704240561,
-0.5399612188,
0.2584623396,
-0.7460462451,
0.1058624163,
-0.0628197789,
-0.2668465674,
-0.0369376056,
0.1989298016,
-0.181216225,
-0.0347438864,
-0.3242858946,
-0.6689491272,
0.0031003554,
-0.8423066735,
0.4187519848,
0.4892803729,
0.2787635028,
0.4012991786,
-0.2750755548,
0.6767598987,
-0.2137411088,
0.189872086,
-0.0939659849,
-0.3867627084,
-0.3910588622,
-0.3080377877,
0.4458981454,
0.8300055265,
-0.7915498614,
0.5153028965,
-0.1763661355,
-0.5130345821,
-0.6461561918,
-0.3431715071,
0.5756777525,
1.02000916,
0.3749229908,
-0.2303416729,
-0.5133758783,
-0.8621385098,
-0.4284080565,
-0.5678347945,
-0.288680017,
0.0350259617,
0.3284981549,
0.0331179537,
1.0661076307,
-0.296421349,
-0.0453123301,
-0.2943044305,
0.561632216,
0.1463490278,
0.5572841763,
0.4510298073,
-0.4784150124,
0.0279382933,
-0.3496829569,
-0.3447984159,
-0.4939364195,
-0.3812648952,
-0.0784139186,
0.4562242925,
0.3887533844,
-0.2561517954,
0.5995854139,
0.3270016909,
-0.0257575903,
0.5451817513,
-0.1034377217,
0.3438257575,
-0.8548781872,
0.210874632,
-0.0019114689,
-0.172072351,
-0.4838727713,
-0.098894693,
-0.3551366627,
-0.2643475533,
-0.4584548175,
0.5509974957,
-0.1328013092,
-0.2783571482,
-0.2964453101,
0.3712171912,
0.24372603,
0.5788799524,
0.3464249671,
1.0045142174,
0.3854233027,
-0.4598440826,
0.1011670008,
0.1774550825,
-0.014599991,
0.6183770895,
-0.85616678,
0.1427023262,
-0.3773903847,
0.3212636411,
-1.1575715542,
0.0120776528,
0.3887703419,
-0.9525929689,
0.4020022452,
-0.3667217493,
-0.0406611674,
-0.1724767536,
-0.5551546216,
0.0392718911,
0.6101436019,
-0.3227449954,
0.4934418201,
0.3007926941,
-0.2382553369,
-0.7630516887,
-0.9907774925,
0.1717869341,
-0.3657462597,
-0.198282972,
0.3161354363,
0.3237390816,
0.0723510832,
-0.1839845031,
-0.1043795273,
-0.0001705768,
-0.0258124471,
0.0952017531,
0.1755278856,
-0.0574333891,
0.0870306641,
0.5867868066,
-0.28488639,
-0.132649079,
-0.4210870862,
0.1414753944,
0.254147023,
-0.2832021117,
-0.6356928349,
0.3986715972,
0.4971829355,
0.0538711436,
0.4128755629,
0.593396306,
-0.0905717388,
-0.2861813903,
-0.3137647808,
-0.5340932012,
-0.3549857736,
0.3389662802,
-0.2900191247,
-0.6331027746,
0.2541975975,
0.1014390066,
0.1458568573,
0.2635761499,
0.4526545703,
0.023259012,
1.0484074354,
0.1374956667,
-0.2531520724,
0.6631449461,
-0.1624730974,
0.0811197013,
-0.662188828,
0.1204982549,
-0.8497904539,
-0.0732279345,
-0.6291252375,
-0.0121161966,
0.4495002031,
0.0128457621,
-0.6306120753,
0.5018116236,
-0.6799553037,
0.1710558683,
1.0517294407,
0.1287791282,
0.213012442,
0.0666495115,
-0.1268278211,
0.0412707254,
-0.7885418534,
-0.4855583906,
0.9177695513,
0.1672950238,
0.8787416816,
-0.03033855,
1.0928052664,
0.3582884371,
0.1775019616,
-0.7474673986,
0.4564450681,
0.2366377264,
-0.5147969127,
-0.5791367888,
-0.5355994105,
-0.9486962557,
0.296276927,
-0.5354136229,
-0.9414042234,
0.0343499742,
0.3544591665,
-0.6397493482,
0.0739725828,
-0.7512874603,
0.6377975941,
-0.086045146,
-0.8485725522,
-0.0860208571,
-1.0096110106,
0.0006911379,
0.234941572,
0.1738853604,
0.2064757049,
0.0749863163,
0.85989362,
-0.13276802,
0.774302125,
-0.3161214292,
-0.2092860788,
0.630309701,
0.1914092749,
0.4468246698,
0.1456939429,
-0.1271099895,
0.0169251952,
0.2036765665,
-0.2485329807,
-0.8413167,
0.5718072653,
-0.8202537894,
-0.7087649703,
-0.1736065745,
-0.0611985736,
-0.6313769817,
0.1882214844,
0.4221328497,
0.5033960342,
-0.1429256797,
-0.0285319909,
0.3158477247,
-0.5021804571,
0.5941444635,
0.333758384,
-0.1201102808,
-1.1465985775,
0.9020851851,
-0.0085392278,
0.3123779893,
0.661922276,
0.3470185399,
-0.6964336634,
-0.8218299747,
-0.7962329388,
0.2836716473,
-0.2455437332,
-0.2352025211,
-0.2748751342,
0.0384850651,
-0.7218185067,
-0.1787283421,
-0.45417431,
-0.6998003125,
-0.4734077752,
-0.1826388985,
-0.0874619782,
0.2854309678,
-0.2455553859,
0.5348118544,
-0.9742289782,
0.5101385117,
0.2333170623,
0.1891466826,
-0.1870003194,
-0.9613937736,
-0.026682185,
0.28664428,
-0.4853186905,
-1.0629860163,
0.5311694741,
0.0426019244,
0.5405246019,
0.2947052717,
0.3105686009,
0.5428053141,
-0.1430006623,
0.9170212746,
0.1584688574,
-0.974951148,
0.7915989757,
-0.5657272339,
0.2110577226,
0.5479700565,
-0.0633561835,
-0.3341031373,
-0.5631093383,
-0.6655498147,
-0.8479194045,
0.6957167387,
0.3017526865,
0.0262432881,
0.0687681511,
0.3279222548,
-0.0038576357,
0.3848900199,
-0.579664588,
0.0042713513,
-0.4137233496,
-0.1609349251,
0.0624460578,
-0.1114122123,
-0.068996489,
-0.0703995004,
1.1352373362,
-0.1820103675,
0.3164202273,
0.5021595359,
0.2244201601,
-0.2104401141,
0.5227279067,
0.9317817092,
0.4094855189,
-0.3610895872,
0.0006093103,
0.1936552525,
-0.3331274688,
0.1798246503,
-0.0978439674,
-0.490426898,
-0.0649705902,
0.3226231039,
0.9353737831,
-0.1042040437,
-0.5547602177,
0.2898169756,
0.1809952855,
-0.2070346773,
0.0232938118,
0.2142238468,
-0.2570700347,
0.248878479,
0.3754944205,
-0.0927945971,
0.1323535442,
-0.3426628113,
0.2068159431,
0.4389365315,
-0.3986443579,
-0.2739202678,
0.9748405218,
0.2320044637,
-0.5443149805,
0.2190039456,
-0.0494058467,
-0.2759492099,
0.3960924447,
0.5031532645,
1.2674742937,
-0.1986386031,
0.4231097102,
0.5078194141,
0.3031749427,
-0.1053942069,
0.2562066615,
-0.3161410093,
-0.6024751067,
-0.6245227456,
-0.4374289513,
-0.7575993538,
0.113240853,
-0.5086548924,
0.4147274792,
-0.3111987412,
-0.4285159707,
-0.3435743451,
-0.2531055808,
0.1406619996,
0.6575404406,
0.0450302102,
0.4469840527,
-0.7666891217,
0.7609379292,
0.323818326,
-0.4902805984,
-0.5624542832,
0.0041129654,
-0.1483697146,
-0.7119401693,
0.3050573766,
-0.2957461476,
-0.6060039997,
0.1604689807,
-0.6638773084,
-0.5100085139,
0.8755298257,
0.7331815958,
-0.5095707774,
0.0378954634,
0.1258691996,
0.6272147894,
-0.1722431481,
0.431394875,
0.4834071398,
0.3057286143,
0.4566460252,
-0.8118394017,
-0.1740802377,
0.2252295762,
0.1479281783,
0.1801473349,
-0.4038289785,
0.3028000593,
-0.4675567746,
-0.2315336168,
0.1489713043,
0.705909729,
0.5475642085,
0.5270073414,
0.3445548713,
0.7137482166,
0.1312848628,
0.0283586662,
0.6570498347,
-0.1800293773,
0.6066564918,
1.3700746298,
-0.0543021895,
0.834625423,
0.7193242311,
-0.2136486173,
0.2861788273,
0.4371778667,
0.1875195503,
0.7325619459,
0.1304921061,
-0.1553843021,
-0.1872212142,
0.0148372045,
-0.3194509447,
0.3976194859,
0.0854905993,
-0.567617774,
-0.4548284709,
-0.1225923151,
0.0550626926,
0.0735842511,
-0.0770462751,
0.8546904922,
-0.2232355773,
-0.9397939444,
0.7841284871,
-0.1328644454,
0.4721543491,
-0.4264115691,
-0.073612541,
-0.3609047234,
-0.1115140095,
-0.10836,
-0.5488637686,
0.5740865469,
-0.0544986539,
0.215488717,
-0.2396970689,
0.6533357501,
-0.3342707753,
-0.1859394312,
0.0502911136,
0.4697206616,
0.1101238206,
-0.0814797431,
-0.6022669077,
0.0013717773,
0.040704757,
-0.4904047847,
0.1532113999,
0.1840899289,
0.0931393355,
0.5419323444,
0.5659042597,
0.3995013237,
-0.2923706472,
0.177291438,
0.503097713,
-0.8341732621,
-0.5788645148,
-0.9380898476,
0.3008729517,
0.1645228863,
-0.3157339394,
0.435958147,
0.3612551391,
0.6422843933,
-0.0855386704,
1.0719126463,
0.2229044884,
0.8189756274,
-0.3713155389,
0.6676974297,
-0.4461277723,
0.1781390756,
-0.6475601792,
-0.8307914734,
-0.4450694025,
0.5808842778,
-0.4902499914,
0.0308998134,
0.2781932652,
1.1287363768,
0.2789566815,
0.1034814045,
0.702575922,
-0.0089320093,
0.3789318502,
0.3933019936,
0.8071636558,
-0.5290166736,
0.6798583269,
-0.0181903336,
-0.2047664523,
-0.0457640551,
-1.0289736986,
-0.492424041,
-0.4727565944,
-0.4229699373,
-0.5083342195,
0.254420042,
0.9232020378,
0.6828682423,
-0.8724159002,
-0.1343508661,
-0.5245800614,
0.3567065597,
-0.1513516605,
-0.280852735,
0.1959160864,
-0.2068773061,
-0.8746168613,
0.4993580282,
0.4698479772,
0.312446326,
-0.1193862781,
0.0519550033,
0.0368764549,
0.3774515986,
0.5530541539,
0.7176093459,
-0.6740227342,
-0.5591544509,
-0.1670728624,
0.1254514307,
-0.032310579,
0.6197138429,
-1.1490950584,
0.3973121643,
0.7298282385,
0.6091725826,
0.5285156369,
0.2856533825,
0.5582567453,
-0.586063683,
0.2695632279,
0.4547443688,
0.1014394015,
0.1883374006,
-0.0009721678,
0.4668309391,
0.3591295481,
-0.5542140007,
-0.8774638176,
0.4167021811,
-0.8991969228,
-0.2798769474,
1.3154755831,
-0.0755046159,
-0.2149308473,
-0.1300831735,
-0.4605325162,
0.6050758362,
-0.7103013396,
1.0212734938,
0.1519700736,
-0.4773512185,
-0.2492660731,
-0.0678505749,
0.2353645712,
0.5147114992,
-0.7166352868,
-0.031335216,
0.6086018085,
0.1477331966,
0.0355886556,
0.4730347693,
-0.0867267996,
0.0289562196,
0.0984532833,
-0.0807989165,
-0.0824038908,
-0.3124318123,
-0.3525583744,
0.2834675908,
-0.0486879535,
-0.4743476808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02235v1 | Towards a Holistic Framework for Multimodal Large Language Models in Three-dimensional Brain CT Report Generation | 2024-07-02T12:58:35 | 2024-07-02T12:58:35 | Cheng-Yi Li, Kao-Jung Chang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Hsin-Yu Wu, Wenting Chen, Hritik Bansal, Ling Chen, Yi-Ping Yang, Yu-Chun Chen, Shih-Pin Chen, Jiing-Feng Lirng, Kai-Wei Chang, Shih-Hwa Chiou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) have been given free rein to
explore exciting medical applications with a primary focus on radiology report
generation. Nevertheless, the preliminary success in 2D radiology captioning is
incompetent to reflect the real-world diagnostic challenge in the volumetric 3D
anatomy. To mitigate three crucial limitation aspects in the existing
literature, including (1) data complexity, (2) model capacity, and (3)
evaluation metric fidelity, we collected an 18,885 text-scan pairs 3D-BrainCT
dataset and applied clinical visual instruction tuning (CVIT) to train BrainGPT
models to generate radiology-adherent 3D brain CT reports. Statistically, our
BrainGPT scored BLEU-1 = 44.35, BLEU-4 = 20.38, METEOR = 30.13, ROUGE-L = 47.6,
and CIDEr-R = 211.77 during internal testing and demonstrated an accuracy of
0.91 in captioning midline shifts on the external validation CQ500 dataset. By
further inspecting the captioned report, we reported that the traditional
metrics appeared to measure only the surface text similarity and failed to
gauge the information density of the diagnostic purpose. To close this gap, we
proposed a novel Feature-Oriented Radiology Task Evaluation (FORTE) to estimate
the report's clinical relevance (lesion feature and landmarks). Notably, the
BrainGPT model scored an average FORTE F1-score of 0.71 (degree=0.661;
landmark=0.706; feature=0.693; impression=0.779). To demonstrate that BrainGPT
models possess objective readiness to generate human-like radiology reports, we
conducted a Turing test that enrolled 11 physician evaluators, and around 74%
of the BrainGPT-generated captions were indistinguishable from those written by
humans. Our work embodies a holistic framework that showcased the first-hand
experience of curating a 3D brain CT dataset, fine-tuning anatomy-sensible
language models, and proposing robust radiology evaluation metrics. | [
-0.3240409195,
-0.5965498686,
0.7783859372,
0.2542543709,
-0.3060709834,
-0.3733683228,
-0.2500911653,
-0.5657589436,
-0.2743851542,
0.469097048,
-0.2552787066,
-0.5980070233,
-0.5641160607,
0.0225915108,
0.0794423148,
1.0480145216,
0.0869527683,
0.3955006301,
-0.3777031302,
-0.1158414036,
-0.8239972591,
-0.2883649766,
-0.5800572634,
-0.0082410816,
0.558441937,
0.1277361959,
0.7668548226,
0.7694783807,
0.6272463202,
0.1339375824,
0.2706432641,
0.2132226974,
-0.0623097755,
-0.1217897832,
0.1021334529,
-0.0503864065,
-0.7070287466,
-0.1650507301,
0.3151768744,
0.8501102924,
0.0703341365,
-0.2051602304,
0.1265252382,
0.4728893042,
-0.5971758366,
0.495613277,
-0.448225081,
-0.0377979018,
-0.0403607674,
-0.3846580386,
-0.3698464632,
-0.0518020913,
0.4555351436,
-0.5378979445,
0.1437741965,
-0.0380396359,
0.8284782171,
0.0087818336,
-0.4423008859,
-0.2685781419,
-0.3790205717,
0.5830442309,
-0.6082217693,
0.2272939682,
0.3502671421,
0.3651023209,
0.2636671066,
-0.6693838835,
-0.3570567071,
-0.4288003743,
-0.0624865294,
0.4029417932,
-0.1241304576,
0.1094298065,
0.2011383325,
0.1473625153,
-0.9232252836,
0.0706223994,
-0.3955956101,
-0.4311724603,
0.5132746696,
0.3885733485,
0.3429988921,
-0.2191361338,
-0.4898096919,
-0.102236554,
-0.6916765571,
-0.3309586048,
-0.1047084108,
0.3193485141,
-0.2598512173,
0.6858123541,
-0.0852252617,
0.9960445166,
-0.0794046894,
-0.3055187166,
0.2703426778,
-0.1684659719,
-0.1135801822,
-0.0109839113,
0.7813954949,
0.6398317814,
0.1288583726,
-0.1736363769,
-0.152003184,
-0.0781324059,
0.5191620588,
-0.854383707,
-0.2786360085,
0.2814968824,
-0.5360753536,
-0.0907711014,
0.007718591,
-0.4882054031,
-0.6080725193,
-0.3769419491,
0.5841028094,
-0.7598882318,
-0.2414970547,
0.4398981929,
0.2726418376,
0.0539288744,
0.3996217847,
-0.5964258313,
-0.1336428225,
0.3510218859,
0.8000238538,
-0.173945412,
-0.4031700194,
-0.3735761344,
0.2055101693,
-0.1065556407,
0.7887821794,
-0.2323646992,
-0.182096839,
-0.2059145421,
-0.203627646,
-0.1761824489,
-0.2597690523,
0.2309740782,
-0.3398910463,
0.2746855915,
-0.1354874671,
-0.057166215,
-0.3031198382,
0.4204174876,
-0.6335190535,
0.5236879587,
0.3069075942,
-0.7516742349,
0.4974036515,
-0.7792840004,
-0.6150848866,
0.1245228127,
-0.2174504995,
-0.3175085783,
-0.0741977841,
0.3739839196,
0.8127704263,
-0.4981041551,
0.4317160547,
-0.082104072,
-0.2719518542,
0.2194731683,
-0.5570032597,
0.5942867398,
0.0872265249,
-0.37070629,
0.131553337,
-0.5125932097,
0.0308749098,
0.1187743619,
-0.1919440925,
-0.0580651686,
-0.1892620325,
0.2975213528,
0.3611609638,
0.1780551672,
-0.5827999711,
0.0142099764,
-0.3636085987,
0.4276539981,
0.1398348957,
-0.0633373857,
0.0702752098,
-0.5844046474,
0.453944087,
0.3695155084,
0.1766530424,
-0.2501403689,
-0.5141679645,
-0.4679839015,
-0.6209970713,
0.192233786,
0.4731094241,
-0.6042485833,
0.2395537049,
-0.8156477809,
-0.606747508,
-0.4029479325,
-0.4301747978,
0.4521335065,
0.5738083124,
0.4119544327,
-0.318526566,
-0.3375739157,
-1.341830492,
0.0248497855,
0.07864099,
-0.2323158979,
0.2770376801,
0.2504857481,
-0.096686855,
0.7415621281,
-0.5057771802,
-0.6193667054,
-0.2545647919,
0.2500661314,
0.0179184042,
0.3180915713,
0.4756139517,
-0.6978919506,
-0.4368578494,
0.3835206628,
-0.8452740312,
0.1931460798,
-0.173932299,
0.2267150879,
0.3914906681,
0.3184877336,
-0.6651349068,
0.4275635779,
0.3519139886,
-0.1287709475,
0.2416852862,
-0.3843066096,
0.3604281843,
-0.8995884657,
0.3183961213,
0.0615979731,
-0.1802119315,
-0.2553440928,
-0.1041932777,
0.1379263252,
-0.1881019026,
-0.3622269332,
0.334877342,
-0.6049957275,
0.0256810766,
-0.119907707,
0.2021200508,
0.1625985503,
0.6626776457,
0.2473865002,
0.4003665745,
0.6710041761,
-0.3826744854,
-0.0320380665,
0.0864516124,
-0.2498324215,
0.7277066708,
-0.511927247,
0.1404616982,
-0.2465841621,
0.1446720958,
-0.8098245859,
-0.35799101,
-0.0682865456,
-0.3874979913,
0.4344495535,
-0.1134670228,
-0.4339052439,
-0.2936339676,
-0.0112579605,
0.4549494088,
0.2217360139,
0.0090074399,
0.6950971484,
0.5424851179,
-0.2471996546,
-0.4005093277,
-0.7987449765,
0.2732131481,
-0.0963002518,
-0.7046855688,
0.3707095087,
-0.0463687144,
0.1429325491,
-0.1359176785,
0.0763761997,
-0.2197795063,
-0.1585521251,
0.318860054,
0.2907631099,
-0.3294659257,
-0.0503226295,
-0.0076665189,
0.0395613052,
0.151989758,
-0.2077961117,
0.4563141167,
-0.5163235664,
-0.5173677206,
-0.2299341112,
0.3935565054,
0.829434514,
-0.2301443666,
0.2479067892,
0.8482962251,
-0.6114181876,
0.2797739506,
-0.5632520318,
-0.1395893395,
-0.275931716,
0.786224544,
-0.5968185067,
-0.9123988748,
0.3096186817,
0.3466292322,
0.032560572,
0.4233416915,
0.8319721222,
-0.008077044,
1.1781840324,
0.3202864528,
0.3850849271,
-0.2738007307,
-0.0290202256,
0.2708989978,
-1.0280665159,
-0.3467221558,
-0.1026143059,
-0.0631462038,
-0.2960226834,
-0.2681699693,
0.8827556968,
-0.2359085083,
-0.0420140289,
0.1321079582,
-0.7736920118,
0.3045473993,
0.1308722198,
0.3626597226,
0.1379908025,
0.0888454989,
-0.1524440199,
-0.3184390366,
-0.8590174317,
-0.4145906568,
1.265715003,
0.1928617805,
0.2879969478,
0.0066965367,
0.1720115691,
0.1573793143,
0.5736802816,
-0.8217861056,
0.4417047799,
-0.116623871,
-0.4992539883,
-0.3875234425,
-0.0956967846,
-1.0983419418,
0.3497811556,
-0.1429409385,
-0.4907217622,
-0.1607847363,
0.0337105356,
-0.740152359,
-0.0004514559,
-0.4177983403,
1.0754826069,
-0.3702014387,
-0.529607892,
-0.1265220195,
-0.6920349002,
0.4089747667,
-0.2054482549,
0.2875540257,
-0.0295598507,
-0.0461582318,
0.345912993,
-0.0402496532,
0.8463071585,
-0.1472914517,
-0.1476963907,
0.1664648354,
0.397620827,
0.0177359637,
0.2362329811,
0.1552322358,
0.3258351684,
0.2172821015,
-0.1681674719,
-0.439206332,
0.762317121,
-0.5849214196,
-0.337818861,
-0.3485263884,
-1.0787676573,
-0.47605744,
0.3499982953,
0.3763634861,
0.6008281708,
-0.2082227021,
0.2508588135,
0.5116541386,
-0.3184446096,
0.2725530565,
0.391086787,
-0.0686290786,
-0.4985234439,
1.0060290098,
0.0163367018,
0.0412532613,
0.5298424959,
0.1676612943,
-0.2401736826,
-0.7997767329,
-0.5639842749,
0.2429930568,
-0.7363734245,
-0.4212245941,
-0.8379024267,
-0.2068964839,
-0.2299945951,
-0.1669332832,
-0.3811381757,
-0.0988017023,
-0.0211977381,
0.3305293918,
0.1580775082,
0.6805731654,
0.0434086658,
0.1974973381,
-0.856885314,
0.047379449,
-0.0029549105,
0.2156152129,
-0.0694147795,
-0.3663517237,
-0.5534698963,
0.2835913002,
-0.392413497,
-0.6596633792,
0.5119293928,
-0.1573711336,
0.2966786027,
0.031882368,
-0.2419246137,
0.7056452632,
-0.2747615874,
0.7188788652,
0.334413141,
-0.7954941988,
0.4518702626,
-0.7518690825,
0.5045374036,
0.37919119,
0.1574000269,
-0.2706751525,
-0.2889230847,
-0.5019048452,
-0.8540769815,
0.5925149322,
0.0698167235,
-0.0250921864,
-0.2843393981,
0.1528072953,
0.2112340927,
0.1141926423,
-0.8577544093,
0.2743688524,
-0.3488876522,
-0.2955147922,
0.0920868888,
-0.0288972333,
-0.294333756,
-0.2667894661,
0.2532954812,
-0.5494247079,
0.5464806557,
0.3876780868,
-0.2308939397,
0.2407453507,
0.0996116623,
0.8986907005,
0.9100034237,
-0.1178754792,
0.1568858027,
0.1215065494,
-0.565408349,
-0.2517705262,
0.0079543833,
0.2279437482,
-0.1308977902,
0.4556643963,
0.7543212771,
0.1904347539,
-0.5946292877,
1.0076663494,
0.0512602888,
-0.4491228461,
-0.2681639791,
-0.2482178956,
0.1806086153,
-0.0676883087,
0.2262478173,
0.3308598697,
0.2481603771,
0.076778084,
0.1548522115,
0.4830216467,
-0.7178173661,
-0.2023414224,
0.715390563,
0.101726003,
0.3189327717,
0.7108083367,
0.0667715594,
-0.1270350963,
0.4821794033,
0.3842955232,
0.8021709919,
0.1424601376,
-0.0249225628,
0.5091602206,
0.4493728578,
-0.1543735415,
0.1946660876,
0.1531993896,
-0.5790079236,
-0.5980604291,
-0.3779125512,
0.053081505,
0.5138543844,
-0.836161375,
0.4134985805,
-0.3955038786,
-0.2563990355,
-0.0503027216,
-0.4301840663,
-0.7445794344,
0.4653144181,
0.1524833292,
0.5665704012,
-0.4290258586,
0.8162210584,
0.7668359876,
-0.5226988792,
-0.7117902637,
-0.0046937619,
-0.1398949474,
-0.7672749162,
0.549541533,
0.4309419394,
0.0564984903,
0.0683721751,
-0.2572254837,
-0.6253557801,
1.1683498621,
0.3747411668,
-0.3792211413,
-0.0945508927,
0.3743107915,
0.5481219292,
-0.6772758365,
0.4184771478,
0.4341054261,
0.58050704,
-0.1261782944,
-1.0801049471,
0.3777270615,
-0.1619606912,
0.0853077322,
-0.1498827636,
-0.4313744605,
0.7240421772,
-0.3783327937,
-0.1384134144,
-0.1409899741,
0.470192045,
0.3023799062,
0.1553224474,
0.508911252,
0.3503556848,
0.3167085648,
-0.0556999743,
1.2579864264,
-0.4344682992,
0.0472755395,
0.8110693693,
-0.3264357448,
0.4822825193,
0.4861755073,
0.1503650993,
0.2333886921,
0.5291963816,
-0.0890031531,
0.4778275192,
0.2229364067,
-0.0199368037,
-0.479690671,
-0.0191164017,
-0.2867893875,
0.7872781157,
0.3644651175,
-0.3014298677,
-0.3761878908,
0.2729668021,
0.0229817592,
-0.0669299662,
-0.0650311783,
0.5813210011,
0.0290067382,
-0.7825133204,
0.7677950263,
0.0057881135,
0.3946816921,
-0.5269694924,
-0.0746732056,
-0.0350940861,
0.06633313,
-0.1027756035,
-0.7945574522,
0.4930337667,
-0.227447629,
-0.2872820795,
-0.1541870981,
0.185553804,
-0.3677220941,
-0.3150560558,
-0.0103205945,
0.5290563703,
0.2074477077,
-0.3679676652,
-0.5618990064,
0.1802392155,
0.000156306,
-0.244273454,
0.5038502812,
0.4488174915,
-0.3849844635,
0.5514336228,
0.3069218695,
0.046460066,
-0.4489131272,
0.036954198,
0.7124835253,
-0.3274453878,
-0.314150244,
-0.6906840801,
0.8215684295,
0.086319074,
-0.5290954113,
0.3444770277,
0.8658121228,
0.5172814727,
-0.3146750629,
1.0479571819,
-0.169124946,
0.2454125583,
-0.6407008171,
0.9016243219,
-0.5732696056,
0.2818580866,
0.0281782802,
-0.7346634865,
-0.6923764944,
0.5022684336,
-0.307366401,
0.3112641573,
1.0898035765,
0.9373930097,
-0.1886369735,
-0.1331513971,
0.573325038,
0.1893702149,
0.0298780538,
0.9596449733,
0.6600468159,
-0.37225914,
0.710550487,
-0.065432474,
-0.2336530089,
-0.0734765381,
-0.8999824524,
-0.9266859293,
-0.7858351469,
-0.4489138424,
-0.3991262317,
-0.2092429399,
0.4330481887,
0.7966079116,
-0.4025180042,
-0.0368102416,
0.0914463997,
-0.5301684737,
-0.3225637078,
-0.2255292535,
0.7234980464,
-0.1633441746,
-0.574256897,
0.1814960092,
0.6009716392,
-0.0378995277,
-0.4150947928,
0.1156261042,
0.1956605315,
-0.3243971467,
0.8580455184,
-0.2230736017,
-0.9232642651,
-0.363997668,
0.1505024135,
-0.5430793166,
0.1231501028,
0.839115262,
-0.6940889955,
0.4853231907,
0.0760296434,
0.5232968926,
0.5119972825,
-0.4448483586,
0.5942234397,
-0.4549049735,
-0.0005281629,
0.4615412951,
0.2166889608,
0.5359916091,
-0.4723400474,
0.2875293791,
0.1055345312,
-0.4131212533,
-0.6318573952,
0.0890880674,
-1.4794626236,
-0.2769040167,
1.1687283516,
-0.161697343,
-0.0895223767,
-0.3323583901,
-0.3930512667,
0.0893666521,
0.0455887057,
0.8191959858,
0.6095554233,
-0.3301562965,
-0.3310975432,
-0.6524655819,
0.3744804263,
0.2497050315,
-0.7167437077,
-0.0328185782,
0.8099420071,
0.3945167065,
0.1812542826,
0.6498248577,
-0.534006238,
0.5879890323,
-0.1367895454,
0.3955904841,
-0.5825583339,
-0.2304423451,
-0.070862487,
0.4784014523,
-0.075945504,
0.0574530512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02233v1 | Synthetic Multimodal Question Generation | 2024-07-02T12:57:42 | 2024-07-02T12:57:42 | Ian Wu, Sravan Jayanthi, Vijay Viswanathan, Simon Rosenberg, Sina Pakazad, Tongshuang Wu, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multimodal Retrieval Augmented Generation (MMRAG) is a powerful approach to
question-answering over multimodal documents. A key challenge with evaluating
MMRAG is the paucity of high-quality datasets matching the question styles and
modalities of interest. In light of this, we propose SMMQG, a synthetic data
generation framework. SMMQG leverages interplay between a retriever, large
language model (LLM) and large multimodal model (LMM) to generate question and
answer pairs directly from multimodal documents, with the questions conforming
to specified styles and modalities. We use SMMQG to generate an MMRAG dataset
of 1024 questions over Wikipedia documents and evaluate state-of-the-art models
using it, revealing insights into model performance that are attainable only
through style- and modality-specific evaluation data. Next, we measure the
quality of data produced by SMMQG via a human study. We find that the quality
of our synthetic data is on par with the quality of the crowdsourced benchmark
MMQA and that downstream evaluation results using both datasets strongly
concur. | [
-0.7426634431,
-0.9966772199,
0.4012434483,
-0.0661773384,
-0.0887153521,
0.1743575633,
-0.0445055589,
-0.1388121992,
0.3001061082,
0.44081074,
-1.0457345247,
-0.0722419545,
-0.1440378875,
0.3675413728,
-0.4056221247,
1.0158526897,
0.1388653368,
0.1440527886,
-0.4737781882,
-0.1885184795,
-0.1952709705,
-0.4327670932,
-0.3797796369,
-0.0014654999,
0.7542276978,
0.434453398,
0.7386131287,
0.3611523509,
0.2945812941,
0.3671423793,
0.5075683594,
0.8895695806,
-0.575109005,
0.3133632839,
-0.0674706474,
-0.2753831744,
-0.2720329165,
0.2319541723,
0.7555379272,
0.343791157,
-0.098264657,
0.5674270988,
-0.1542784423,
0.4445545375,
-0.4472530186,
-0.2993769944,
-0.7807393074,
0.0795892626,
-0.3174878359,
-0.4690740108,
-0.2845906317,
-0.2268936038,
-0.3295382261,
-0.7373247743,
0.4574969709,
0.2609092593,
0.6221186519,
0.3087907135,
-0.7832891345,
-0.3678773344,
-0.630256772,
0.6488961577,
-0.4297014773,
0.5418242216,
0.3995700479,
0.6340016723,
-0.2712279558,
-1.0829561949,
-1.2493168116,
-0.2250739038,
0.0145485383,
0.3513830304,
0.090909712,
-0.2571161091,
0.3369634449,
0.4796818495,
-1.0509008169,
-0.5222136378,
-0.7744383216,
-0.2361861467,
0.7979541421,
0.4639514089,
0.3406122029,
-0.7743361592,
-0.5203636885,
-0.2230752259,
-0.5178906918,
-0.018294923,
0.5812243819,
-0.0320833735,
0.322009474,
1.0397028923,
-0.396920532,
0.603851974,
0.2456420213,
-0.34986341,
0.3035208881,
-0.8042231798,
-0.044423148,
-0.2637736797,
1.0388430357,
0.6998223662,
-0.1008279696,
-0.0284608137,
-0.1068929359,
0.0579955131,
0.5849477053,
-0.8516067863,
-0.1848559827,
0.4457525611,
-0.3032640517,
-0.2954879999,
0.0279477313,
-0.752050221,
-0.2563616335,
-0.5255747437,
0.7406369448,
-0.3900730908,
-0.2793675661,
-0.1263352036,
-0.4353998899,
0.0231030956,
0.1087134108,
-0.7236142755,
-0.1607587487,
0.4106740654,
0.6048557162,
-0.21160914,
-0.2870208323,
-0.5642353296,
0.372013092,
-0.2996245325,
0.7792790532,
-0.4119784534,
-0.4663819969,
-0.3468511701,
0.2231792063,
-0.0989092216,
-0.5005444884,
0.5474229455,
-0.4748532772,
0.8202700019,
-0.3094811141,
-0.3316534758,
-0.0452899709,
0.5809292197,
-0.7061946988,
1.1946558952,
0.2469397187,
-0.7990069389,
0.4412130415,
-0.5467250943,
-0.0310308672,
0.1364241838,
-0.4267911315,
-0.1452665627,
-0.0124372998,
0.3027303815,
0.3355326355,
-0.4097985923,
0.3777318895,
-0.2155760825,
-0.1658059955,
0.5665485263,
-0.6075359583,
0.4679097235,
0.408863008,
-0.0085536242,
0.204654634,
-0.9976289868,
0.3987467885,
0.0034571935,
-0.6116653681,
-0.0080347778,
-0.1331743449,
0.1992818415,
0.4719934165,
0.1347146183,
-0.6535579562,
0.0260067955,
0.049828466,
0.4121307135,
0.6883097291,
0.1597070992,
0.3084426522,
-0.8039714694,
0.7695490718,
-0.0561192892,
0.1487241238,
-0.2385012358,
-0.4536989629,
-0.5897262096,
-0.1644863784,
0.3052452505,
0.2443382442,
-1.3645533323,
-0.1650073826,
-0.1727842242,
-0.6525390148,
-0.8570237756,
0.1343640089,
0.1442251503,
0.5442695022,
0.3509468436,
-0.0915757045,
-0.5361514688,
-0.9904285073,
0.0311270114,
-0.1377594173,
-0.2373286486,
0.5913204551,
0.3722097278,
-0.5167135596,
0.8894231319,
-0.4899524748,
0.183253184,
-0.0146366432,
0.4716288149,
-0.0976127908,
0.5228911638,
0.5612675548,
-1.1201280355,
-0.28252092,
-0.1833802462,
-0.6207220554,
-0.1475118995,
-0.15999116,
-0.4465890229,
-0.0375151932,
0.4080900848,
-0.947255075,
-0.245266825,
0.76287359,
-0.0650572404,
0.9905003905,
-0.0852035806,
0.6949704289,
-1.5024365187,
0.2404463738,
-0.3622430861,
-0.1494635344,
-0.4955956638,
0.2948148251,
0.1335617751,
-0.5180950761,
-0.4711838067,
0.7949391007,
-0.1937610209,
0.1036650017,
-0.0237005707,
0.0804303139,
0.3784539104,
0.4692800641,
-0.3680059612,
1.0026657581,
-0.0298762862,
-0.5246211886,
0.7734102011,
0.1707916111,
-0.1827011108,
0.7097132206,
-0.7465766668,
0.3331779242,
-0.4208982289,
0.2302929312,
-1.2456692457,
-0.7914184928,
0.1316222996,
-0.7693502307,
0.1855580509,
-0.0781583264,
-0.7327472568,
-0.4424735606,
-0.4539711177,
0.4925868809,
0.1975972205,
-0.4623743892,
0.5217407942,
0.3746252358,
-0.324500829,
-0.4960729182,
-0.3772892356,
-0.1141934246,
-0.2397782207,
-0.9531151652,
0.3422933519,
-0.5142939091,
-0.167336911,
-0.1572262347,
0.044689741,
-0.086710453,
-0.3441602588,
0.3213953078,
0.1367390007,
-0.3127269745,
0.3339462876,
0.2900629342,
0.1886697561,
0.0790015534,
0.0931727886,
0.6522658467,
0.2688718736,
-0.3879048824,
0.1298299581,
0.4996293783,
0.7331823707,
-0.4209896624,
0.4212242961,
1.1765693426,
-0.1067449301,
-0.2400593907,
-0.6154313087,
-0.2950982451,
-0.5514350533,
0.1116646156,
-0.5563403964,
-0.8445793986,
0.1230567023,
0.0418604128,
0.1640176177,
0.3609342575,
0.84617275,
-0.3624839187,
1.2721819878,
0.1323368102,
0.4761182368,
0.2195760161,
-0.1565779895,
-0.2249405086,
-0.6121214032,
-0.4042193592,
-0.2993385196,
-0.4744975865,
-0.8534477949,
-0.8829894662,
0.8309878111,
0.0254999641,
0.0139700156,
0.0832871273,
-0.3376644552,
0.2809860408,
0.7301859856,
0.2446015924,
0.3093915582,
0.0250758193,
-0.2857451141,
-0.106924884,
-0.7178006172,
-0.4424373507,
1.3626484871,
-0.1626861989,
0.5786136389,
0.1525049657,
0.5446953177,
0.4086484909,
0.2179890275,
-0.4729700983,
0.5038747191,
0.1849085093,
-1.0633063316,
-0.2935141921,
-0.7117491364,
-0.961181581,
0.517957747,
-0.5384109616,
0.0116298664,
-0.135597229,
0.1021273062,
-0.3368081748,
-0.2129903585,
-0.6628894806,
0.7753173113,
-0.090743348,
-0.5237495899,
-0.1810855418,
-0.5523594022,
0.843097806,
-0.2033035457,
0.2272759676,
-0.1946167201,
0.1029778421,
0.5722419024,
-0.3323286176,
0.1481434256,
0.0494565442,
0.0474496,
0.6064420342,
0.1106810719,
0.1697020233,
0.2693459392,
-0.0972809047,
-0.305757463,
0.3107391596,
-0.4056386352,
-0.7789796591,
0.8360498548,
-0.6318279505,
-0.4714332223,
-0.1047965735,
-0.7971634865,
-0.3653840721,
0.1790302694,
0.2905113697,
0.6393191218,
-0.1472007781,
0.260356009,
0.3406512439,
-0.4294666052,
0.3100682795,
0.3483535349,
-0.3375397921,
-0.6723275185,
0.9220651388,
0.1545021981,
0.2648307979,
0.08784201,
0.1415546089,
-0.5839336514,
0.0963365436,
-1.1298444271,
0.1513681412,
-0.4266234934,
-0.2083582729,
-0.7729103565,
-0.232940495,
-0.3568927944,
0.2042512745,
-0.0785151795,
-0.7237382531,
0.0133628175,
-0.0340506807,
0.1875557899,
0.37536937,
-0.1158456057,
0.0276822764,
-1.013292551,
0.713432312,
0.687761724,
-0.135354355,
-0.3094641268,
-0.2792839408,
0.0137919141,
0.4721142948,
-0.6355342269,
-0.8388113379,
0.4214249253,
0.2181915939,
0.5288889408,
0.2993291914,
0.1876285821,
0.8344473243,
-0.7158097625,
0.8360392451,
0.0903489888,
-0.4041568339,
0.444072783,
-0.7147452831,
0.2224362195,
0.4441110492,
0.7430719733,
-0.4969590604,
-0.356736511,
-0.6320542693,
-0.4963603318,
0.3126152456,
0.2048570216,
0.4878089726,
-0.2688777149,
0.1636893451,
0.2039227486,
0.6452178955,
-0.6302000284,
0.0941499695,
-0.3588398099,
-0.1323127449,
-0.0593684092,
-0.1793617606,
-0.2635883689,
-0.1704242378,
0.3049967289,
-0.3323709965,
0.2515463531,
0.041259449,
-0.0555234663,
-0.2299078405,
0.2825272977,
0.7018500566,
0.6993584037,
-0.1822475344,
0.2983534336,
-0.0473785549,
-0.3463507593,
0.1761197746,
-0.016303055,
-0.2817746997,
0.2225205749,
0.0300326217,
0.3201289773,
-0.1030424088,
-1.0534067154,
0.3028843701,
-0.0882307738,
-0.2140938044,
-0.2346504778,
0.2906619608,
0.0760486349,
0.3072423041,
0.4440758228,
-0.0862993151,
0.1968079805,
-0.8230031133,
0.3997447193,
0.5796506405,
-0.0147535522,
-0.2519219518,
0.780442059,
0.0201852378,
-0.0591326654,
0.5238588452,
-0.2890342772,
-0.2945750356,
0.3303409517,
0.3896368146,
0.2074972838,
-0.2168158889,
0.444329083,
0.6007500887,
0.2423214465,
0.2065584213,
0.6243741512,
-0.2144406289,
-0.5318828821,
-0.4104787111,
-0.8519744873,
-0.3327983022,
0.1992256343,
-0.4080441296,
0.1746274233,
-0.3820376992,
-0.4220397174,
-0.0497791879,
-0.0546124317,
-0.4903154075,
0.414596796,
-0.0401185192,
0.4298234284,
-0.4627370238,
0.5062106848,
0.5417641997,
-0.4900279939,
-0.6313835979,
-0.1560457796,
0.0084187333,
-0.6649790406,
0.5975158215,
0.0358852074,
0.0243658666,
0.080908224,
-0.5600594878,
-0.8088507056,
1.3536417484,
0.299161613,
-0.1468122602,
-0.1085430309,
0.3410543203,
0.4477796853,
-0.0468934439,
0.2166196853,
0.1749166399,
0.4615741074,
0.2838402092,
-0.9035093188,
-0.1480621248,
-0.4954160154,
-0.2893684804,
0.2423795164,
-0.6795834899,
1.1314359903,
-0.0998228937,
-0.3726285994,
0.0361533798,
0.4461757243,
0.6488418579,
0.4834517241,
0.2070622146,
0.5941100717,
0.6733424067,
-0.0290516932,
1.0370981693,
-0.2018143088,
0.073250711,
0.981947124,
-0.0335287601,
0.928556025,
0.5805761814,
-0.0642540753,
0.1907059699,
0.5572887659,
0.0246460997,
0.3281494975,
0.2185046971,
-0.3219071031,
-0.2110275477,
-0.1971637905,
-0.4077516496,
0.677844584,
0.173252508,
-0.3485848308,
-0.1101082861,
0.0653131828,
-0.1413544416,
-0.0716982782,
-0.2649852633,
0.576839149,
-0.2657957077,
-0.758435905,
0.6579450369,
0.2382104099,
0.4821052253,
-0.4505004287,
-0.0884341449,
-0.4170357585,
-0.1999394298,
-0.1768851429,
-0.5811100006,
0.3006465435,
-0.0459443405,
-0.3776785433,
-0.2716062963,
0.6487853527,
-0.7226338983,
-0.7870624661,
-0.4600213468,
0.9189755917,
0.0859444439,
-0.0621474162,
-0.5657559037,
-0.1709855944,
-0.2024041861,
-0.1047330499,
0.4490044415,
0.6971653104,
0.0908799246,
0.7045642734,
1.1094175577,
-0.1694341898,
0.5380958915,
-0.2241164297,
0.9140595198,
-0.3450465798,
-0.2876519859,
-0.6412811875,
0.6999820471,
-0.1028593183,
-0.3427862227,
0.9725287557,
0.7165919542,
0.8161689043,
-0.1849931926,
0.570884943,
-0.0861355588,
0.6696097851,
-0.7125951648,
0.8583110571,
-0.8226568103,
-0.2445493639,
-0.248864308,
-0.8948999047,
0.3507614136,
0.4775751829,
0.2058897763,
-0.0296749156,
0.4257294536,
1.214116931,
-0.3514149487,
-0.0551184677,
0.4355366826,
-0.1846467108,
0.213672176,
0.3148338497,
1.2517565489,
-0.5215887427,
0.596767664,
-0.2156182826,
0.1324945241,
0.0215529408,
-0.4959726036,
-0.7447687984,
-0.9411946535,
-0.041127868,
-0.3926576674,
-0.359995693,
0.930578649,
0.7683436275,
-0.320243746,
-0.1254815608,
0.4534471035,
-0.1586836874,
0.3106515408,
-0.3230618834,
-0.0577910319,
-0.1772987992,
-0.7168841362,
0.5521959066,
0.0658161715,
0.0947902128,
-0.5123237967,
-0.0681742206,
-0.1150551438,
0.2640834451,
0.8757801652,
-0.0951712206,
-0.5191761255,
-0.1431411207,
0.2475765944,
-0.166495204,
-0.148047924,
0.9117301106,
-0.7114483714,
0.5196529627,
0.5570041537,
0.686498642,
0.6046106815,
0.4496504366,
0.6116951704,
-1.0653465986,
-0.0505908988,
0.2126504481,
0.1034959108,
0.3038436472,
-0.1123054549,
0.3761182129,
0.199485898,
-0.5730991364,
-0.8826668262,
0.2591501176,
-0.8235368133,
-0.1961266249,
1.2268289328,
0.2460022569,
-0.045393914,
0.0692611262,
-0.5247503519,
0.1249495149,
-0.0758150741,
0.8434177637,
0.6502381563,
-0.2176790535,
-0.4518564641,
-0.8426276445,
0.5672112703,
0.0571979955,
-0.9232255816,
-0.2684191763,
1.0327173471,
0.2424097955,
0.3031406701,
0.5771110058,
-0.0988730118,
0.4633093476,
0.1344242096,
-0.2129805237,
-0.2830322087,
-0.2671699524,
0.3257445395,
0.5368334651,
-0.2601346076,
-0.0944809467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02211v1 | PromptIntern: Saving Inference Costs by Internalizing Recurrent Prompt during Large Language Model Fine-tuning | 2024-07-02T12:21:14 | 2024-07-02T12:21:14 | Jiaru Zou, Mengyu Zhou, Tao Li, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have played a fundamental role in various
natural language processing tasks with powerful prompt techniques. However, in
real-world applications, there are often similar prompt components for repeated
queries, which causes significant computational burdens during inference.
Existing prompt compression and direct fine-tuning methods aim to tackle these
challenges, yet they frequently struggle to strike an optimal balance between
cost-efficiency and performance effectiveness, especially in complex tasks such
as NL2Code. In this paper, we propose a novel method namely PromptIntern to
internalize the prompt knowledge into model parameters via progressive
fine-tuning. Our method enables LLMs to emulate the human learning process for
a new task, where detailed templates and examples in a prompt are gradually
internalized and phased out progressively as the model grows accustomed to the
task. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method reduces inference
tokens over 90%, speedups inference by 4.2 times, and saves 88.3% monetary
cost. | [
-0.3735494316,
-0.7524256706,
0.4737497568,
0.2308021784,
-0.3464777768,
-0.2768718898,
-0.5256492496,
-0.1971999407,
-0.3616127372,
0.5924435854,
-0.9314060807,
-0.349842757,
-0.2369691283,
0.3540491164,
0.1303243786,
0.6105132103,
0.1179208979,
0.0791575611,
-0.1467270106,
0.0391349234,
-0.8636919856,
-0.1632841974,
-1.3515411615,
-0.2045967281,
0.5065960288,
0.576875031,
0.2320286334,
0.5002109408,
0.1115525886,
0.2699485123,
-0.3714768887,
0.5934267044,
-0.4769839644,
0.6457268596,
-0.3655709326,
-0.7487537861,
0.1137473956,
-0.1611500531,
0.7955197692,
0.7391782403,
-0.063622728,
0.1797511876,
0.4132121205,
0.6890915632,
-0.5059279799,
0.2225302309,
-0.7214933634,
-0.0774531141,
0.0454540923,
-0.270863384,
-0.6089732647,
-0.5450526476,
-0.0290628243,
-0.4675734341,
0.4429620206,
0.1752809435,
0.5954796672,
0.6097681522,
-0.0431133024,
-0.1911819726,
-0.4490888715,
0.6776157618,
-0.9135042429,
0.1825671494,
0.2868465483,
0.214602828,
-0.4412522316,
-0.7821135521,
-0.4419757128,
-0.4321178198,
-0.1563482136,
-0.2214983404,
-0.3087972999,
0.1427850276,
0.5248453021,
-0.0114937611,
-0.4314350486,
0.3849317729,
-0.0656702891,
-0.1150734797,
0.2773055434,
0.3814802766,
0.2012834251,
0.0142843975,
0.0061892187,
-0.0122233946,
-0.8789486289,
0.3374815583,
0.1855822057,
0.643430233,
0.0873072371,
0.3908764422,
-0.4231138825,
0.6599101424,
0.4445601106,
-0.0773823112,
0.0389551409,
-0.2494705915,
-0.1591010243,
0.0560515895,
0.5054597855,
0.5206818581,
0.487493515,
-0.0542504117,
-0.2211319059,
0.0684519932,
0.0578618757,
-1.1159502268,
-0.0801676363,
0.130530268,
-0.4822678864,
0.0346910506,
-0.2729569674,
-0.7693007588,
-0.5502041578,
-0.7016547918,
0.0987978578,
-0.512481451,
0.1722143888,
0.1250620335,
-0.0976108536,
0.0195280071,
0.6378372312,
-0.673332572,
0.0604728982,
0.6254601479,
0.9572290778,
0.0360411927,
-0.1640199274,
-1.1396940947,
-0.2104981989,
-0.1083710045,
0.8626902699,
-0.6266680956,
-0.4624402225,
0.0256491136,
0.167286247,
0.0775024146,
-0.6843719482,
0.6277669072,
-0.3284314573,
0.2318554819,
-0.3224000335,
-0.7318903208,
-0.0741683245,
0.2111230493,
-0.6099941134,
0.9945641756,
-0.0560141057,
-0.5388305783,
0.2354552448,
-0.3569659293,
-0.3880753219,
0.1014907435,
0.1019257009,
-0.1478732377,
0.3703605533,
0.5076704025,
0.5228149295,
-0.6494202018,
0.3550762236,
-0.1120239794,
-0.3233743608,
-0.0278531648,
-0.5716149807,
0.6268277764,
0.2220467329,
-0.3065611124,
0.2899889052,
-0.6194698215,
-0.2014785856,
-0.1349590868,
-0.2695350945,
-0.5299558043,
-0.0794285834,
-0.4392138124,
0.0034106087,
0.2393699586,
-0.538890481,
0.6051725745,
-0.64485991,
0.4048579037,
0.7300197482,
0.3005059659,
0.5568121076,
-0.2145358622,
0.5073002577,
-0.0807204768,
0.2248194814,
-0.5933114886,
-0.4733068943,
-0.7870264649,
-0.235776335,
0.1125436723,
0.5664439201,
-0.7056336999,
0.4235411286,
-0.0847776383,
-0.344925344,
-0.6487082839,
0.0640205666,
0.3041560352,
0.8100284338,
0.4312339425,
0.2489218563,
-0.2643748522,
-0.8797745109,
-0.4357767999,
0.1022189856,
-0.3908758759,
0.2965642512,
0.2075621784,
-0.1648031771,
0.9164665341,
-0.4707325399,
-0.0809688568,
-0.3127619326,
0.4652324021,
0.5058254004,
0.7217460275,
0.3663656116,
-0.4065774679,
-0.3419856131,
-0.3095624745,
-0.3220579922,
-0.5955193043,
-0.5271622539,
-0.1300995201,
0.1520777643,
0.8164249063,
-0.729003489,
0.2463957518,
0.2330695391,
-0.6123324633,
0.5590639114,
-0.4217652678,
0.095828481,
-0.8569104671,
0.0060715219,
0.0760683566,
-0.1491545737,
-0.4492529035,
0.1647724509,
0.3575988412,
-0.0120389406,
-0.249383837,
0.9369680882,
-0.653840363,
0.4590033293,
-0.3458054066,
-0.0291086026,
0.1794801056,
0.4849195778,
-0.3129726052,
1.1485753059,
0.3767848313,
-0.8728692532,
0.1318993866,
0.1360476017,
-0.488310039,
0.4565270543,
-0.8137050271,
0.0991473794,
-0.4219525754,
0.3180523217,
-0.9626019001,
0.0603487641,
0.2460886687,
-0.1504495889,
0.4876259565,
-0.3048958182,
-0.700948894,
-0.1596983671,
-0.293502599,
0.2435836941,
0.647572279,
-0.8028688431,
0.6269857287,
-0.0705798864,
-0.4200837016,
-0.2891854048,
-0.4700981081,
0.1334965676,
-0.1783425361,
-0.4718917012,
0.3158330321,
-0.2103329301,
-0.1838437468,
-0.2492009103,
0.0239480287,
0.2812190354,
0.1204787567,
0.2056152821,
0.0792917907,
-0.1754031628,
0.3906355202,
0.5224408507,
-0.1452579945,
-0.0278070141,
-0.4575206339,
0.7293316126,
0.1521199942,
-0.1340609491,
-0.7299000621,
0.4120842516,
0.3666115999,
-0.3385694623,
0.8158153892,
0.3771096766,
-0.3000541925,
-0.5266621113,
-0.7832194567,
-0.4686897993,
-0.519308269,
0.2004121989,
-0.3100636005,
-1.0212779045,
0.4576761723,
-0.5557560325,
0.2139333338,
0.2925553322,
0.3870316744,
0.1324870288,
0.8901554346,
0.3438643813,
-0.0161725581,
0.588981092,
-0.0247061048,
-0.1230879948,
-0.8529472947,
-0.2192460001,
-0.8021286726,
-0.3574716151,
-0.2105485052,
-0.5175899267,
0.2861863077,
0.3742896616,
-0.5668497086,
0.0559020452,
-0.4939298928,
0.6328615546,
0.7907570004,
0.2933988571,
0.2129469216,
-0.1135285199,
-0.0825111493,
-0.0805253536,
-0.6296038628,
-0.2333566546,
0.6948696375,
0.2420058101,
0.7802700996,
-0.044562187,
0.3417332172,
0.1855686903,
0.1029111445,
-0.7483697534,
0.5477725267,
-0.1606549174,
-0.0598442666,
-0.3330505192,
-0.6132318974,
-0.9751199484,
0.0808175653,
-0.0363146253,
-0.7369663715,
0.3321455121,
0.360059917,
-0.4451934993,
0.1872945279,
-0.7114815116,
0.6210898757,
0.0536402352,
-0.5029602051,
-0.2854873538,
-0.5709726214,
0.1900713146,
0.0499538183,
-0.0831743032,
-0.2572226822,
-0.1556906402,
0.4948272407,
-0.3795711696,
1.1968294382,
-0.4748425186,
-0.106795013,
0.1593927592,
0.2595887184,
1.0522162914,
0.3173195124,
-0.3475722969,
-0.0386130624,
-0.4732060432,
-0.2047617882,
-0.7418212891,
0.6878326535,
-0.2398231924,
-0.5910004377,
0.0375274904,
-0.5324648619,
-0.2687612474,
0.2003767937,
0.3941134512,
0.8209101558,
0.0933050886,
0.0197711922,
0.9285664558,
-0.5247026682,
0.5061219931,
0.5012376904,
0.0784204155,
-0.4300989211,
0.3820393384,
-0.1515417546,
0.1836247593,
0.5369585752,
0.4452592731,
-0.3806014061,
-0.6120634675,
-0.3330850005,
0.3377822042,
-0.6544683576,
-0.5446456671,
-0.6491926312,
0.2821756899,
-0.3859645128,
-0.1243928894,
-0.2706771791,
-0.1232293472,
-0.5682256222,
0.0865823925,
0.6400437951,
0.2638721764,
0.1247580796,
0.5824673176,
-0.85876894,
0.2526493967,
0.2491036654,
0.2990974486,
0.1277585179,
-0.8044079542,
-0.0502435938,
-0.0091899717,
0.1757000685,
-0.5331687927,
0.4990691543,
0.4210351408,
0.4831385016,
0.4729872346,
0.4720629752,
0.7943299413,
-0.7381058931,
0.8225679398,
0.1189082861,
-0.9675754905,
0.579416275,
-0.1000139713,
0.972953558,
0.8334780931,
0.1543055475,
-0.6123898029,
-0.3081694245,
-0.0989718735,
-1.0438556671,
0.5079319477,
-0.0741703957,
0.2461735904,
-0.2663232386,
0.7164817452,
0.3168918192,
0.0964630768,
-0.0298972521,
-0.1445934623,
0.2293913662,
-0.2588133812,
-0.0487645529,
-0.5746035576,
0.1044880748,
-0.4643374979,
0.5720598102,
-0.2585831285,
0.131032303,
0.2218582928,
-0.1190758869,
0.06795647,
0.1661364883,
0.62714535,
0.3653963804,
-0.0520688966,
0.0411067195,
0.3844421804,
-0.3428917229,
0.0311251059,
0.141336143,
-0.3228841424,
0.1304381788,
0.3842883408,
1.0479323864,
0.5194571614,
-0.8084659576,
0.1890597045,
-0.3219730854,
0.0759415478,
-0.198083505,
0.2112197876,
0.0294105187,
0.5353669524,
0.2588937581,
0.1114324704,
0.1993623823,
-0.2749543786,
0.1529940814,
0.2844496667,
-0.2002989501,
-0.1303944886,
0.6318483353,
0.3525800705,
-0.3953049183,
0.8332787156,
-0.2870541811,
-0.3197788894,
0.4662798941,
0.5566799641,
1.0945968628,
-0.321239382,
-0.0443318076,
0.7738831639,
0.1730953306,
-0.476010263,
0.1849137098,
-0.0986659974,
-0.4695872962,
-0.6764739752,
-0.7057557702,
-0.2511135638,
0.0383850485,
-0.6108767986,
0.2647413909,
-0.4647876024,
-0.0665560886,
-0.1689311266,
-0.157878235,
-0.6817548871,
-0.0590409636,
0.0955408067,
1.2786896229,
-0.2891084552,
0.7694880366,
0.3036275804,
-0.1672496647,
-0.7967597842,
-0.0038525742,
-0.1286873817,
-0.5251396298,
0.7418069243,
0.4601969719,
-0.2160928845,
0.2124257833,
-0.6807667017,
-0.6751728654,
0.8034989834,
0.5063803792,
-1.1400259733,
-0.136330992,
-0.3828243315,
0.2451633513,
-0.3080928922,
0.3348093033,
0.7728155255,
0.5477231741,
0.0219810829,
-0.6976741552,
0.3528316617,
-0.2239312679,
0.1295370162,
0.4418190122,
-0.2798781991,
1.0095682144,
-0.2871598601,
-0.5263941884,
0.3047976494,
0.6249866486,
0.1522117853,
0.076032266,
0.637308836,
0.2683023512,
1.1040959358,
0.0315010175,
0.9404289722,
-0.4415465891,
0.2538534105,
1.410377264,
-0.2220663428,
0.6574178338,
0.4076986313,
0.0600436181,
0.2972744405,
0.5107392073,
-0.0476122871,
0.4735868871,
0.3944916129,
-0.4313740432,
-0.362655282,
-0.2218551487,
-0.2031100541,
0.0231161732,
0.3533127308,
-0.3050097823,
-0.325850606,
0.2003587484,
0.3126963377,
0.0914997607,
-0.460262835,
0.9054530859,
0.0341939256,
-0.9519047141,
0.6549073458,
-0.1207286417,
0.8396288753,
-0.7212453485,
-0.1801513582,
-0.5989459157,
0.2027567625,
0.2382666469,
-0.5603464246,
0.089325197,
0.0638626516,
-0.2427893281,
-0.221736595,
0.4072290659,
-0.4904061258,
-0.4049118161,
0.1611724645,
0.2095030397,
-0.0704185143,
-0.5106976628,
-0.5001995564,
-0.1520976275,
0.1143026277,
-0.3886694312,
0.1509895176,
0.7071690559,
0.0648960397,
0.8242607713,
0.74675107,
0.1179476529,
-0.2051810622,
0.3372248709,
0.9619271755,
-0.7647561431,
-0.5952013731,
-1.0720514059,
0.5456220508,
-0.1805751175,
-0.5620361567,
0.5734817982,
0.3485644758,
0.4963351786,
-0.2034664452,
0.5735622644,
0.3489843905,
0.5299884081,
-0.8846354485,
0.6056732535,
-0.4721556604,
0.4088849723,
0.0462533273,
-0.7292920947,
-0.3703006506,
0.2537950575,
-0.0841232315,
-0.3567601144,
0.5479941368,
0.9044836164,
0.1354058087,
-0.0786741301,
0.1097298712,
0.2405830473,
0.3732714355,
0.3280024827,
0.6910943985,
0.0804586038,
0.2508584559,
-0.3312073946,
-0.2464784533,
-0.2695394158,
-0.9177183509,
-1.0904625654,
-0.3787967861,
-0.2606236041,
-0.1775552779,
0.152829662,
1.2919704914,
0.4227508605,
-0.8152305484,
0.084265925,
-0.3224866092,
-0.0724505186,
-0.2856919765,
-0.1959457994,
0.3376507461,
-0.8461714983,
-0.8312511444,
0.5854603052,
0.0880093277,
-0.1285389364,
-0.0450195149,
0.1204259768,
0.0502831377,
0.1133717746,
0.7010356784,
0.1968820691,
-0.7337217331,
-0.2346301526,
-0.1164222807,
0.0890876055,
-0.1237132549,
0.9757917523,
-1.0418351889,
0.3574241102,
0.6766707301,
0.6824572086,
0.1934928,
0.1653795838,
0.8115894794,
-0.7933807969,
0.326407522,
0.3493492007,
0.4633151591,
0.2303768098,
-0.6039617658,
0.4036376774,
0.0090005761,
-0.5648662448,
-0.8375057578,
0.3228635192,
-0.8657067418,
-0.6502936482,
1.2365101576,
-0.093190372,
-0.1151553467,
-0.0448659509,
-0.6010094881,
0.3053236604,
-0.8109608293,
0.5108500719,
0.1206867471,
0.0603661053,
-0.383271575,
-0.4812494218,
0.6078517437,
0.3040357828,
-0.703684628,
0.4044596255,
0.5787269473,
0.1878911853,
-0.2539058626,
0.1309120506,
0.4571151733,
0.0772376582,
-0.0005486599,
0.1882267743,
-0.3044383526,
-0.2760606408,
-0.6210380793,
0.2239310741,
0.0022908628,
-0.0744606555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02209v1 | Generative Monoculture in Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T12:17:07 | 2024-07-02T12:17:07 | Fan Wu, Emily Black, Varun Chandrasekaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce {\em generative monoculture}, a behavior observed in large
language models (LLMs) characterized by a significant narrowing of model output
diversity relative to available training data for a given task: for example,
generating only positive book reviews for books with a mixed reception. While
in some cases, generative monoculture enhances performance (e.g., LLMs more
often produce efficient code), the dangers are exacerbated in others (e.g.,
LLMs refuse to share diverse opinions). As LLMs are increasingly used in
high-impact settings such as education and web search, careful maintenance of
LLM output diversity is essential to ensure a variety of facts and perspectives
are preserved over time. We experimentally demonstrate the prevalence of
generative monoculture through analysis of book review and code generation
tasks, and find that simple countermeasures such as altering sampling or
prompting strategies are insufficient to mitigate the behavior. Moreover, our
results suggest that the root causes of generative monoculture are likely
embedded within the LLM's alignment processes, suggesting a need for developing
fine-tuning paradigms that preserve or promote diversity. | [
-0.5305419564,
-0.6078157425,
-0.0854099318,
0.1741988659,
-0.3159658313,
0.1402415037,
-0.4376484752,
-0.2832970619,
0.2391430438,
0.5414179564,
-0.7315234542,
-0.6568490863,
-0.5115257502,
-0.011800372,
-0.4891825318,
1.3624823093,
0.0832389295,
-0.02892139,
-0.5603966117,
-0.3818593919,
-0.4025212228,
-0.7065507174,
-0.6624843478,
-0.38989079,
0.6586686373,
0.3956705332,
0.7167041898,
0.6240522265,
0.3540269136,
0.2292349339,
-0.2939312756,
0.0333686508,
-1.0637546778,
0.4332664013,
-0.0496713147,
-0.4795644879,
-0.3076354563,
-0.1643489301,
0.6997730732,
0.8576021194,
-0.2631156445,
0.2483393103,
0.527308166,
0.8537835479,
-0.4450494051,
-0.190271467,
-0.2255051434,
0.3090605438,
-0.3597083092,
-0.1734995991,
-0.4859931767,
-0.2380802482,
-0.0656898096,
-0.4415744841,
0.3181572556,
-0.2213159949,
0.5928397775,
0.0934105068,
-0.4856721759,
-0.2623927891,
-0.9686613679,
0.9268113375,
-0.448443085,
0.1065096408,
-0.0329011008,
-0.1765868515,
-0.0137380222,
-0.0369688049,
-0.4956948459,
-0.0091974447,
-0.0370163843,
0.2559607029,
-0.1661767513,
0.0750775337,
0.2743863463,
0.6128324866,
-0.5901700258,
0.3771364093,
-0.4237111211,
-0.1829063743,
0.4946941137,
0.2590400577,
0.3529853821,
0.0399480946,
-0.421575278,
-0.236287728,
-0.832559526,
0.1794526577,
0.6313022971,
0.1387872994,
-0.0830640942,
0.3368735313,
-0.1624942273,
0.4417103529,
-0.3947102427,
-0.043446999,
0.3436546028,
-0.5868730545,
-0.0988734066,
-0.2354734242,
0.6713526845,
0.2944217324,
0.3586153686,
0.1702940315,
-0.1946045756,
0.1318120956,
0.3430071175,
-0.665250361,
0.1199709922,
0.0551419035,
-0.6424852014,
-0.4780811071,
0.0758638084,
-0.9418792725,
-0.4182932675,
-0.1861018836,
-0.0829667896,
-0.1052381247,
-0.3960717022,
0.1717306674,
-0.3582392633,
0.1166721731,
0.1480216086,
-0.9311330914,
0.1048075706,
0.5788298845,
0.7061669827,
-0.5315746665,
-0.4108769894,
0.0091827745,
0.1290702224,
-0.4374391437,
0.3488402367,
-0.3956438601,
-0.6839280725,
0.1860335916,
-0.3589241505,
0.2365628332,
-0.7768003345,
0.3888743222,
-0.4965469539,
-0.0823530704,
-0.3169401586,
-0.2815666795,
0.0745702162,
0.3403646648,
-0.6017952561,
0.6323122978,
0.0496738814,
-0.6724401712,
0.7068535089,
-0.4114056826,
-0.6096696258,
0.0747643188,
-0.236790508,
-0.3956874907,
0.1880948991,
-0.0925395042,
0.0028320651,
-0.1571993381,
0.1066635624,
-0.4465434551,
-0.2524718642,
0.1547208428,
-0.5831503868,
0.7909560204,
0.269044131,
-0.1022461355,
0.2286995649,
-0.4001713693,
-0.1848500222,
0.099279359,
-0.6444125772,
-0.6942103505,
0.1307097822,
-0.2479605824,
0.1243516505,
0.1128875539,
-0.3506227434,
0.5823295116,
-0.180333212,
0.0722581968,
0.8889547586,
0.118210718,
0.430871129,
-0.7325794697,
0.8146244287,
0.3582081497,
0.4311410189,
-0.2719199955,
-0.3854821622,
-1.0580815077,
-0.2489402592,
-0.0578776561,
0.2140898108,
-0.7060833573,
0.1926383972,
-0.3318886161,
-0.4544171691,
-0.452996552,
0.5355032086,
0.3786337376,
0.0303632859,
0.1059149429,
-0.606292367,
-0.4582439065,
-0.9370765686,
-0.0866785049,
0.0532532297,
0.1696529835,
0.0476802662,
0.2492230386,
-0.4718590975,
0.7048054338,
-0.3233643174,
-0.30484128,
-0.3396669328,
0.3882077932,
0.3188532293,
0.5854578614,
0.4684492648,
-0.7806816697,
-0.3405802846,
-0.1045325249,
-0.8370138407,
0.0289724059,
-0.1046508104,
-0.2298786938,
0.3330031335,
0.5050863624,
-0.4430361986,
0.2151025534,
0.7495396137,
-0.1623561829,
0.5266728997,
0.0615186542,
0.0348121338,
-1.0206254721,
-0.3468694389,
0.0868332982,
0.0864410251,
-0.5494419932,
0.4542202652,
-0.3505296111,
-0.0344987176,
-0.0391066633,
0.1485814005,
-0.4821725488,
0.3107565045,
-0.1549651325,
-0.2343583703,
-0.077313602,
0.2128336281,
-0.0541386306,
0.7769089341,
0.6326622963,
-0.7587020397,
0.2280299366,
0.2289902419,
-0.4663204253,
0.1040422842,
-0.2215482742,
-0.0231653154,
-0.4132741988,
0.1004541367,
-0.888163209,
-0.0827003866,
-0.054227449,
-0.1324383765,
0.369869113,
-0.0313609913,
-0.4999695122,
-0.4327312112,
-0.5147181749,
0.6649973989,
0.6571959853,
-0.501049459,
0.134395957,
0.3217236996,
-0.3119526803,
-0.6673609614,
-0.7765382528,
-0.1427702308,
-0.1524117887,
-0.6885583401,
-0.1080894545,
-0.2378928065,
-0.1696517169,
-0.2085974813,
-0.2923858464,
0.2864337862,
0.1900427788,
0.0439963713,
0.1973822117,
-0.4672615528,
0.2810702026,
0.2185333967,
0.3245702684,
-0.038675759,
-0.3827595413,
0.7249982953,
0.1131892577,
-0.5115357637,
0.0479713082,
0.564322412,
0.7705000639,
-0.2049645633,
0.9144983888,
0.2197171003,
0.0845505297,
-0.8460246921,
-0.3715177178,
-0.2732181251,
-0.4777888358,
0.4107303321,
-0.1093623787,
-1.1876388788,
0.5055958033,
0.1334113926,
-0.0834719986,
0.3264933228,
0.7056215405,
-0.0989641771,
0.89771384,
0.8200250864,
-0.1814069301,
0.5889977813,
-0.2227893323,
0.0821098909,
-0.5166941881,
-0.1135180593,
-0.4051165879,
-0.4081385732,
-0.9118354917,
-0.3248474896,
0.5659365058,
0.0433799624,
-0.0685368553,
-0.038280353,
-0.5063294768,
0.5558543205,
0.7441549897,
-0.0404657014,
0.4623216987,
0.1746664494,
-0.1790446043,
0.1026511565,
-0.9882639647,
-0.5256478786,
1.1427369118,
0.3178635836,
1.1488959789,
0.3169170618,
0.9946060181,
0.3985007107,
0.7746654749,
-0.7375611067,
0.5072086453,
-0.4974582195,
-0.7630764246,
-0.4203164577,
-0.6215717196,
-0.8259291053,
0.1836161166,
-0.1019329503,
-0.4658450782,
0.3669396341,
0.5019892454,
-0.1093944311,
0.2767889798,
-0.5428190231,
1.0487464666,
-0.1439003199,
-0.5264394283,
-0.2163547873,
-0.1271535456,
0.6146143675,
-0.2367201596,
0.3014701605,
0.2059390396,
0.2416277379,
0.4818803072,
-0.0159489624,
1.10896945,
0.0473426171,
-0.4076051116,
0.2492004931,
0.3790991902,
0.3205781281,
-0.0320928842,
-0.0996304154,
0.2335963696,
-0.065402776,
-0.4436070919,
-0.2155819833,
0.7455146313,
-0.9073457718,
-0.9626752138,
-0.3486777544,
-0.6150949001,
-0.1470436603,
0.1539694965,
0.5732980967,
0.2350561917,
-0.3275227845,
0.4533289969,
0.8756520748,
-0.3726532161,
0.0897832587,
0.2171141207,
-0.5103936195,
-0.0082153603,
1.033570528,
0.1652013808,
0.6376932859,
0.1531425714,
0.11028824,
0.1536673009,
-0.8074413538,
-0.1858101189,
-0.1446677297,
-0.8623422384,
-0.0510091297,
-0.365252912,
-0.1637469083,
-0.4277240336,
0.0144420881,
-0.1338818669,
-0.1220209897,
-0.2507627606,
-0.1485442817,
-0.2013101429,
0.862107873,
0.1376762688,
0.1988950074,
-0.767721951,
0.1578801274,
0.3328540921,
0.5290738344,
0.1385109872,
-0.3690783381,
-0.3607738912,
0.0603495091,
-0.5253228545,
-0.6552733779,
0.1731420308,
0.1167928278,
0.4819042683,
0.6991048455,
0.012866931,
0.2634178996,
-0.2253096849,
0.7179346681,
0.2050460428,
-0.6957288384,
0.249169305,
-0.6083832383,
0.569378376,
0.3960336447,
0.4775786996,
-0.8765996695,
-0.9233853221,
-0.1061487868,
-0.9509955049,
0.6864283681,
0.0222013351,
0.7419938445,
-0.2445041835,
-0.0851238146,
0.3607161641,
0.4781894982,
-1.1111645699,
-0.339923501,
-0.3847100735,
-0.027512474,
-0.2026712447,
-0.621193409,
-0.3880537748,
-0.2640544176,
0.6595993042,
0.0211785547,
-0.0833525658,
0.0121869976,
-0.0662939176,
-0.3852836192,
0.5100851059,
0.696739316,
0.5945409536,
0.0357140005,
0.1239300743,
-0.2491776943,
-0.2038787305,
0.2072002888,
-0.2408487946,
-0.5675657392,
-0.241008848,
0.3986299932,
0.7167529464,
-0.1567371935,
-0.4470199347,
0.3846161962,
0.2343715131,
-0.1116167158,
-0.2301682085,
0.3185459971,
0.0247857682,
-0.0295480471,
0.2652916312,
0.1460278034,
0.0275378954,
-0.9179279804,
0.2075809985,
0.6453230977,
-0.1206389889,
-0.0358113907,
0.4151495993,
0.4210238755,
0.0088894134,
0.6403240561,
-0.4705771208,
-0.4335524738,
0.771609962,
0.5443770885,
0.8571403623,
-0.053572081,
0.238303557,
0.3816486299,
0.7242226601,
-0.0470309108,
-0.0315775387,
0.0353183635,
-1.0809130669,
-0.3989786804,
-0.9554624557,
-0.2177451998,
0.2264102101,
-0.6704905033,
0.2527760267,
-0.36922279,
-0.141373843,
-0.0632498413,
-0.8191447258,
-0.2849607766,
-0.0704119653,
0.5576905608,
0.8036673665,
-0.9728973508,
0.7175415754,
0.7088021636,
-0.6621752977,
-0.3858154118,
0.3547716737,
0.1286911368,
-0.5333685279,
0.678417623,
0.1299816519,
-0.1382827163,
-0.1446406543,
-0.5435154438,
-0.6880493164,
0.6279343367,
0.2667141259,
-0.7335603237,
-0.0126163643,
0.31993258,
0.7674771547,
-0.3104226887,
-0.3333486915,
0.2470549941,
0.281042546,
-0.084461242,
-0.6121607423,
-0.0466847755,
-0.2806365192,
0.2353927642,
0.4581631422,
-0.8128855824,
0.8549795151,
-0.0912996382,
-0.320286721,
0.1303132474,
0.4122155011,
0.119556196,
0.1425491571,
0.3776770532,
0.5360301733,
0.4594656527,
-0.1535664201,
1.1550270319,
-0.2296370119,
0.5130486488,
0.9564259052,
-0.2407818139,
0.3597409427,
0.5506930947,
-0.0563948341,
0.4584002197,
0.463534683,
-0.2394472957,
0.2151559591,
0.6115258932,
-0.4978144765,
-0.4180727601,
-0.1848416179,
-0.2306837142,
0.356810838,
0.1761611849,
-0.3927912116,
-0.0692691579,
0.2024286091,
-0.1309808493,
0.1564436406,
-0.3553600013,
0.8517439961,
0.044992324,
-1.0292235613,
0.6543792486,
-0.2711022496,
0.9632116556,
-0.763227582,
0.0749508962,
-0.6068187952,
0.0716336519,
-0.3487576246,
-0.5973944664,
0.249039337,
-0.0815505981,
-0.7522795796,
-0.5383539796,
0.4908530414,
-0.6309714317,
-0.3499304354,
0.5941035748,
0.547926724,
-0.2291442901,
0.3007069528,
-0.269515872,
0.1445596665,
0.1528295875,
-0.3338849545,
0.447614789,
0.443110913,
-0.1305817217,
0.6349952817,
0.5893037915,
0.2300113142,
0.3410398066,
0.2010734677,
0.939445734,
-0.3039179146,
-0.3554338217,
-0.9264830947,
0.3389707506,
-0.0254465919,
-0.1817640811,
0.7834566236,
0.5866903067,
1.3275655508,
-0.3494662046,
0.9496078491,
0.0609626509,
0.077711679,
-0.3729431629,
0.8128558993,
-0.7213852406,
0.4321360886,
-0.1237395853,
-0.8851490617,
-0.0438260064,
0.0602504089,
-0.0686344877,
0.2609895468,
0.6245856881,
0.8342849612,
-0.1305074394,
-0.0443796255,
0.5452905893,
0.3907409906,
0.0141517958,
0.0956777483,
1.0900623798,
0.3458070457,
0.7203409076,
-0.216166988,
-0.3115335405,
-0.0019727889,
-0.7100247145,
-0.6501920223,
-0.3897979856,
-0.4596038461,
-0.3665692508,
-0.0104159117,
0.765879035,
0.5628285408,
-0.9148320556,
-0.6530580521,
-0.1719004214,
0.3193996251,
-0.2436727583,
-0.2414428145,
-0.3038185537,
-0.6424438953,
-0.678093195,
0.0303515494,
0.2953262627,
0.055151213,
-0.3884424269,
0.0270053111,
-0.0239624139,
0.0588230193,
0.6149555445,
0.2417753339,
-0.3562009931,
-0.1221512854,
-0.1353942305,
-0.2298221588,
0.1777027845,
0.9283643961,
-0.130607754,
0.8134500384,
0.3787257671,
0.5242671371,
0.1615255475,
-0.1063168719,
0.6257965565,
-1.0075116158,
0.0173947811,
0.2967728972,
0.3226962984,
0.2580631971,
-0.1509836614,
0.1986707002,
0.4559741318,
-0.374160409,
-0.719871521,
0.6255944967,
-0.6602743268,
-0.2987139225,
1.2898439169,
0.0637017041,
-0.054777272,
0.1605119556,
0.0249574147,
0.2939175963,
-0.3277209401,
0.8841745257,
1.1504291296,
0.0933517516,
-0.0476947799,
-0.4772521853,
0.5629273653,
0.6770023108,
-0.7101051807,
0.2561021745,
0.5591813326,
0.3134199083,
0.4148895442,
0.445121944,
-0.1519079953,
0.2776545584,
-0.2225266099,
0.3608885109,
0.1679649502,
-0.2591426373,
-0.5500617027,
0.3776069582,
0.4981420636,
0.1263661683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02208v1 | How to Learn in a Noisy World? Self-Correcting the Real-World Data Noise on Machine Translation | 2024-07-02T12:15:15 | 2024-07-02T12:15:15 | Yan Meng, Di Wu, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The massive amounts of web-mined parallel data contain large amounts of
noise. Semantic misalignment, as the primary source of the noise, poses a
challenge for training machine translation systems. In this paper, we first
study the impact of real-world hard-to-detect misalignment noise by proposing a
process to simulate the realistic misalignment controlled by semantic
similarity. After quantitatively analyzing the impact of simulated misalignment
on machine translation, we show the limited effectiveness of widely used
pre-filters to improve the translation performance, underscoring the necessity
of more fine-grained ways to handle data noise. By observing the increasing
reliability of the model's self-knowledge for distinguishing misaligned and
clean data at the token-level, we propose a self-correction approach which
leverages the model's prediction distribution to revise the training
supervision from the ground-truth data over training time. Through
comprehensive experiments, we show that our self-correction method not only
improves translation performance in the presence of simulated misalignment
noise but also proves effective for real-world noisy web-mined datasets across
eight translation tasks. | [
-0.1432160139,
-0.6385335922,
0.3155628145,
0.2089848071,
-0.2326544821,
-0.2868331969,
-0.2525452077,
-0.55194664,
-0.0025060833,
0.4337285161,
-0.8170878291,
-0.5107380748,
-0.6188063622,
0.2632877231,
-0.5806437731,
0.9718401432,
0.0663522929,
0.2985774279,
-0.0846914425,
-0.014734678,
-0.4170792699,
-0.4816585183,
-0.4403859079,
-0.1883523166,
0.4981853366,
0.425511241,
0.8018534184,
0.8910737634,
0.5327236652,
0.321389854,
0.0816294327,
0.3109875917,
-0.6391942501,
0.3130186498,
-0.2869923711,
-0.5504879951,
-0.1224741563,
-0.0009029027,
0.3828882277,
0.4451103508,
-0.242333129,
0.0696606636,
0.0940693095,
0.5923823118,
-0.2781966329,
0.1479535401,
-0.5938404202,
0.2479700148,
-0.2231838405,
-0.011951373,
-0.1351582408,
0.0720015392,
-0.2161601186,
-0.9238377213,
0.3883714378,
0.197092697,
0.9388526082,
0.8812687397,
-0.2202663571,
-0.1214762926,
-1.0589116812,
0.8704778552,
-0.6315789223,
0.7228574753,
0.5361304283,
0.2185842842,
-0.3698446453,
-0.5340054631,
-0.4702471495,
0.2774173319,
0.0151471924,
0.3375942707,
0.0388513841,
-0.2300016582,
0.2522318065,
0.1769853085,
-0.4796049893,
0.1656615734,
-0.5524879098,
-0.284953028,
0.4796248972,
-0.023503026,
0.2074858546,
0.2134292722,
-0.1694372445,
-0.4217291772,
-0.5454890728,
-0.290006429,
0.3623172343,
0.3997151554,
0.0211500973,
0.071121648,
-0.3316639066,
0.6108919382,
0.222349301,
-0.35022524,
0.2719257474,
-0.3072367311,
-0.0288453903,
0.2095051855,
0.6268268824,
0.3598131239,
0.292234391,
-0.3931505084,
-0.33805722,
-0.0845091343,
0.6496397853,
-0.6099420786,
-0.3607918918,
0.0576480888,
-0.4475709796,
-0.3443880379,
-0.1331412643,
-0.5469747186,
-0.1840320826,
-0.6385638118,
0.6276893616,
-0.2997609675,
-0.2446386963,
0.3562453091,
0.2596213222,
-0.0212788768,
0.4714651704,
-0.6523203254,
0.2299982756,
0.4891830683,
0.6954504251,
0.0446455181,
-0.5324026346,
-0.4630772769,
0.2120258361,
-0.3902201056,
0.8402129412,
0.0239322335,
-0.1832554638,
-0.0847059265,
-0.0700844154,
-0.1222053394,
-0.8685618043,
0.498880893,
-0.3486571312,
0.1360851973,
-0.2319618016,
-0.4087156057,
0.0705269054,
0.1972143501,
-0.4356380105,
0.9618386626,
-0.0189702623,
-0.64294976,
0.3969674408,
-0.4235367477,
-0.5338435769,
-0.377515763,
0.056386549,
-0.7732714415,
0.0262376536,
0.2875642478,
0.237595588,
0.1874980181,
0.2633841932,
-0.1068818942,
-0.3884434402,
0.2334134579,
-0.4606210589,
0.5373314023,
0.590816319,
-0.2825116813,
-0.1589201689,
-0.6089693308,
-0.2299821228,
-0.0105408402,
-0.2008896172,
-0.3520430923,
0.1095454395,
-0.288377434,
0.5006607175,
0.048214756,
-0.4742713571,
0.201362282,
-0.5258423686,
0.1021321639,
0.6801654696,
-0.1803047061,
0.2802956104,
-0.3313933611,
0.2583419383,
0.6126423478,
0.326823324,
0.0945351943,
-0.2937768102,
-0.8408911824,
0.1577285081,
0.5503979921,
0.4975667596,
-0.4906650186,
0.2364979833,
-0.3706693947,
-0.2107900083,
-0.993743062,
0.5854818225,
0.3255367577,
0.6757067442,
0.8200333714,
-0.1615720391,
-0.6511492133,
-0.6071229577,
-0.695530951,
-0.0829684138,
0.1564468145,
-0.2724051774,
0.3989448845,
-0.4425051212,
0.7601061463,
-0.3617968261,
-0.6549092531,
0.2662275434,
0.3431685865,
-0.1658190042,
0.7987411022,
0.1037815809,
-0.7656735778,
-0.3453115225,
-0.1910093874,
-0.7856505513,
-0.3225651681,
-0.1865720749,
-0.2468775511,
-0.0399147011,
1.0471231937,
-0.3873918056,
0.3359665275,
0.4360785782,
-0.0374636427,
0.5706634521,
-0.4565608799,
-0.0265846755,
-0.9270725846,
-0.1033346802,
-0.1023604348,
-0.4577190876,
-0.4231177568,
-0.210314706,
0.0724446177,
0.0458592623,
-0.3284289241,
0.3043776453,
-0.423160255,
0.1910894215,
-0.3900458217,
0.252969414,
-0.1836799234,
0.2581523061,
-0.2049556971,
0.8758220673,
0.2147129029,
-0.9765145779,
0.0386138372,
0.2433191836,
-0.3296999633,
0.5330357552,
-0.2577508986,
-0.1173591167,
-0.3040687144,
0.21558173,
-0.7342620492,
-0.1359417737,
0.3435381353,
-0.4609993994,
0.3773938715,
-0.2585305572,
-0.6151062846,
-0.3763467669,
0.4243636727,
0.3210855424,
0.4203843474,
-0.6063899398,
0.1108768508,
0.3311085105,
0.093278423,
-0.5810126066,
-0.7808775306,
0.0446836539,
-0.1609269232,
-0.4446211159,
0.3340375125,
-0.0485829115,
-0.1377732456,
-0.0402733907,
-0.4791978598,
-0.1805808544,
0.2484541833,
0.3705703914,
-0.2184607685,
0.014556665,
0.5671172738,
-0.0250156503,
-0.4049604237,
0.1171175614,
-0.6599624753,
0.2705114782,
-0.0427103415,
-0.41220662,
-0.480109185,
-0.054194171,
0.3452958763,
-0.0148449503,
0.5530305505,
0.779094398,
-0.3365473747,
-0.1962697208,
-0.6001362205,
-0.3245436847,
-0.5033050179,
0.4252764583,
-0.4288706481,
-0.4171657264,
0.2295435518,
-0.5393178463,
0.053632915,
0.5366309285,
0.1943694651,
-0.5753132105,
1.1669124365,
0.6125386357,
-0.1554462463,
0.5069710016,
-0.2506408691,
0.3750067949,
-0.5172813535,
-0.1065458879,
-0.5805522203,
-0.6010715365,
-0.4826470315,
-0.5951176882,
0.2579925954,
0.3186089694,
-0.1669271886,
0.4200039804,
-0.3116255701,
0.4758172929,
0.643779695,
0.053285934,
0.5641371012,
0.330117166,
-0.3167031109,
-0.4909988642,
-0.7908543944,
-0.2235217839,
0.793371141,
0.1038116515,
0.9976571202,
-0.0593515076,
0.8589641452,
0.1080607697,
0.1952293068,
-0.516725719,
0.1101526245,
-0.1381864548,
-0.4627680779,
-0.3838777542,
-0.5755597353,
-1.0800807476,
0.3545749485,
-0.3123686314,
-0.170792222,
0.0587758832,
0.4654629529,
-0.0936446562,
0.3467459381,
-0.4728001654,
1.0151532888,
-0.3658265173,
-0.19132258,
-0.4254183769,
-0.8168796301,
0.0894602984,
-0.1361332685,
0.7568486929,
-0.0269305538,
0.2913698256,
0.5780493021,
-0.3471149206,
1.0445713997,
-0.2441146523,
-0.2035534978,
0.1730839014,
0.3230501413,
0.5785739422,
-0.3237577975,
0.0816851929,
0.2816594541,
-0.1222645342,
-0.3263254166,
-0.6106184125,
0.5286568999,
-0.9774122834,
-0.4742887616,
-0.2710173726,
-0.5205381513,
-0.1431337148,
0.3152586222,
0.5249193311,
0.0413192175,
-0.2733753324,
-0.0225028731,
0.7210844755,
0.1106791943,
0.1644632816,
0.7069214582,
-0.2781732678,
-0.1973428726,
1.2861030102,
0.5267643929,
0.0594838671,
0.2394589931,
0.200036332,
-0.3651480973,
-0.3504098058,
-0.5258325934,
0.1788844317,
-0.5385118723,
-0.3734021783,
-0.7357978821,
-0.1543053985,
-0.5791176558,
0.0084404862,
-0.7438585162,
-0.4623451531,
-0.1783097088,
-0.098071754,
0.1499082297,
0.840860486,
-0.5467038155,
0.6847246885,
-0.8321064711,
0.2718359232,
0.1683823317,
0.4914318025,
-0.2282309085,
-0.7276659012,
-0.7546631694,
0.4233464599,
-0.5087346435,
-0.5238060355,
0.4945602119,
0.2389995903,
0.4428741038,
0.2580901086,
0.2637004554,
1.1964832544,
-0.4888408482,
0.4104143381,
0.0570398569,
-0.8296267986,
0.5801261663,
-0.0993195474,
0.2311446071,
0.6197220087,
0.1988963336,
-0.779296875,
-0.6297857165,
-0.7566070557,
-0.6579010487,
0.6997529268,
0.2622382045,
-0.0550593138,
0.1093478799,
0.5347518325,
-0.0502621196,
0.0663037971,
-0.7977758646,
-0.2782277465,
-0.4051857889,
-0.4361618459,
-0.0937694311,
0.1836597323,
-0.014419606,
-0.3217735887,
0.9038158655,
-0.058919739,
0.0305891335,
0.5093986988,
-0.5886940956,
-0.4392451346,
0.0199878234,
0.378960073,
0.1316592842,
0.0764228925,
0.1749984622,
0.2325531244,
-0.4049747884,
0.1986643672,
-0.1517637521,
-0.3842193484,
0.1137070507,
0.0785442591,
0.536598146,
0.3257569373,
-0.4330090284,
0.6116402745,
0.0179014467,
-0.1987372339,
-0.1733403653,
0.0324334577,
0.1048624068,
0.0028226657,
-0.0042256922,
0.4575308263,
0.1636320204,
-0.2207888514,
0.3117738962,
0.0382852182,
-0.6052598357,
-0.2453626543,
0.6405063868,
0.1390044391,
-0.1594334692,
0.7260776162,
-0.2678501904,
-0.5911253095,
0.4873230159,
0.8302786946,
0.5470712185,
-0.4328142405,
0.0984912813,
0.5579838157,
0.4380805492,
-0.5572519302,
0.0377628841,
-0.1029531658,
-0.7444170713,
-0.4904368818,
-0.5853700638,
-0.2314798981,
-0.1358788013,
-0.536115706,
0.213413015,
-0.1662036926,
-0.1178847775,
-0.3772113919,
-0.2288028449,
-0.7208380103,
0.4991367459,
-0.0285814777,
0.5159941316,
-0.9029656649,
0.8699263334,
0.5505163074,
-0.3188888729,
-0.6639260054,
0.1884242445,
0.0745083913,
-0.7874063253,
0.6822804213,
0.2260167599,
-0.3017337918,
0.1070556417,
-0.8072847128,
-1.0983929634,
0.7368048429,
0.3189254999,
-0.6499202251,
0.2044256032,
0.3682630062,
0.6252584457,
0.009131032,
-0.3550555408,
0.3339411616,
0.5381509066,
-0.1732316762,
-0.7919822335,
-0.2645899057,
-0.0624639392,
-0.2259621322,
0.2441339493,
-0.9045834541,
0.546995163,
-0.09529569,
-0.3290758431,
-0.2513666153,
0.6552128196,
-0.334977746,
0.0768386498,
0.5710780621,
0.8504652977,
0.9185134172,
0.0029503431,
0.5619974136,
-0.4673862457,
0.4412479401,
1.5570474863,
-0.0815748572,
0.657592237,
0.4264434576,
0.0617750958,
0.3632757664,
0.4800905883,
-0.0677441284,
0.4444221854,
0.2542982996,
-0.0566877127,
-0.6353181601,
0.1062894538,
-0.3943978846,
0.3685581088,
0.4482861161,
-0.1115438044,
-0.4429409504,
0.0689239204,
-0.1964775175,
0.229722023,
-0.0895927772,
0.9927552938,
0.2134792209,
-0.5647657514,
0.5051491261,
0.1672523767,
0.5761079192,
-0.3261388242,
0.0307138283,
-0.1900396645,
0.3893496394,
-0.1836119592,
-0.4610777795,
0.6965056658,
-0.21312581,
-0.2455320209,
-0.5058760643,
0.6884986758,
-0.6734349728,
-0.3894700408,
0.4114261568,
0.5593157411,
0.4600299299,
-0.3447347879,
-0.7116445899,
-0.0696117207,
-0.0774129406,
0.1520207971,
0.4581369162,
0.7141427994,
0.1347597837,
0.8618851304,
0.6262133121,
0.1057388857,
0.3611504138,
0.0099093439,
0.5441101193,
-0.7214432359,
-0.5023248792,
-0.5992838144,
0.1380961686,
-0.0071928306,
-0.3177930117,
0.5989255309,
0.5834878087,
1.2715719938,
-0.1305797696,
0.5789709091,
0.3969194889,
0.6700009108,
-0.4582361579,
0.7086346149,
-0.5587581396,
0.1615656465,
-0.0890314355,
-0.6363403201,
-0.4831210077,
0.9537692666,
-0.1748659611,
-0.3231485784,
0.5004780293,
1.0603039265,
-0.2987504601,
-0.1297756732,
0.5892115235,
0.8197449446,
0.1450383663,
0.047405798,
0.6773023009,
-0.9380834103,
0.9102224708,
-0.5011052489,
0.2614979148,
-0.2360513359,
-0.6057032347,
-0.3491946161,
-0.461117655,
-0.5565422177,
-0.460724771,
0.2939769626,
0.949753046,
0.8841904402,
-0.8546599746,
-0.2188756019,
-0.2447462082,
0.2437868863,
-0.4780104756,
-0.1407371312,
0.0040514111,
-0.8919674158,
-0.7635398507,
0.5342543125,
0.0435620509,
0.3498277366,
0.1542256027,
-0.2365733832,
0.0234886985,
-0.2950092554,
0.3159260154,
0.2773859799,
-0.6084127426,
-0.1137320399,
-0.3497068584,
-0.4658207297,
0.2565433681,
0.6438029408,
-0.7144794464,
0.733207047,
0.1078929901,
0.5411373973,
0.5899451375,
0.1533725709,
0.5431727171,
-0.9045960307,
0.1876012981,
-0.0990746319,
0.1907478869,
0.2827978134,
-0.5327976346,
0.617590785,
0.4297676682,
-0.6377145648,
-0.5567051172,
0.0463581197,
-0.4724758863,
-0.3624688089,
0.8021469712,
-0.0990163535,
-0.2170988172,
-0.4838323295,
-0.2877330184,
0.6934600472,
-0.2105675936,
1.1603953838,
0.7417982221,
0.1603490412,
0.2175299674,
-0.5446594954,
0.6365604997,
0.6960945129,
-0.3671425283,
0.2639400661,
0.5081595778,
0.5040974021,
0.1465081275,
0.3429816067,
-0.190614894,
0.0392117687,
0.0338049233,
0.1884501576,
0.09324985,
-0.4546174705,
-0.4396539629,
-0.3601504862,
-0.0415904187,
-0.129610613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02203v1 | Automatic Adaptation Rule Optimization via Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T12:06:40 | 2024-07-02T12:06:40 | Yusei Ishimizu, Jialong Li, Jinglue Xu, Jinyu Cai, Hitoshi Iba, Kenji Tei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Rule-based adaptation is a foundational approach to self-adaptation,
characterized by its human readability and rapid response. However, building
high-performance and robust adaptation rules is often a challenge because it
essentially involves searching the optimal design in a complex (variables)
space. In response, this paper attempt to employ large language models (LLMs)
as a optimizer to construct and optimize adaptation rules, leveraging the
common sense and reasoning capabilities inherent in LLMs. Preliminary
experiments conducted in SWIM have validated the effectiveness and limitation
of our method. | [
-0.3143674731,
-0.6044090986,
0.7163339853,
0.4911649227,
-0.4214349687,
-0.2665762603,
-0.3172854483,
-0.3492308259,
-0.1583052427,
0.6587969661,
-0.616163075,
-0.3240387738,
-0.4208760858,
0.2790181935,
-0.1545292139,
0.5400404334,
-0.1808887869,
-0.233799234,
-0.017256815,
0.0262690708,
-0.6973744631,
-0.33572191,
-0.656342268,
-0.3950583637,
0.2065673172,
0.6053544879,
0.5648921728,
0.9086821079,
0.6213436127,
0.2503472865,
-0.002797086,
0.3731505275,
-0.5624561906,
0.2777799368,
-0.4741990566,
-0.4503632188,
-0.3953776062,
-0.4304774702,
0.5268957019,
0.3706581891,
-0.2050579637,
0.1209908798,
-0.0549011938,
0.7424194813,
-0.992561996,
0.4261466861,
-0.6480350494,
0.1024967432,
0.3173704743,
-0.4950599968,
-0.4665887058,
-0.2953814864,
0.1961366832,
-0.8256116509,
-0.2606621683,
0.2397246659,
0.314214319,
0.4654902816,
-0.3381780684,
-0.6147034764,
-0.8206080794,
0.8112470508,
-1.0541472435,
0.5442119241,
0.1806132197,
0.1346941143,
-0.5483477712,
-0.3075958192,
-0.537476182,
-0.2009821683,
0.189748168,
0.0183990486,
-0.1636245102,
0.0667088851,
0.1455350071,
-0.0594017729,
-0.5818391442,
0.3018150628,
0.0259683877,
0.0452426486,
1.0701951981,
0.2436034977,
0.4317062497,
-0.0829367042,
-0.1432029009,
-0.0386356302,
-0.5797038674,
-0.0607044771,
-0.0837974921,
0.5018591285,
-0.1676815003,
0.3830227256,
-0.2026218623,
0.7898882627,
0.1302752644,
-0.5649886131,
0.0650482997,
-0.093480289,
-0.107851021,
-0.0167284701,
0.3575905263,
0.5751671791,
0.7182084918,
-0.1577755362,
-0.4964977801,
-0.2957887948,
0.190688163,
-0.8405606151,
-0.0115369819,
-0.0928272456,
-0.4630127549,
-0.1243156418,
-0.2822036445,
-0.754381597,
-0.498950541,
-0.7686102986,
0.8602152467,
-0.2816574574,
-0.1795283407,
0.485117048,
-0.0582504123,
0.581296742,
0.4976045489,
-0.9584243894,
0.6535230279,
0.6090111732,
0.8837545514,
-0.2724337578,
-0.2648768425,
-0.4979529679,
0.4183261395,
-0.406835109,
0.7341010571,
-0.3259514272,
-0.4096203446,
-0.0397303253,
-0.0003502897,
-0.4735429287,
-0.3946795464,
0.5510852933,
-0.5692637563,
-0.1226347759,
-0.0599479526,
-0.8159655929,
-0.2693028152,
-0.1409763247,
-0.4877102375,
0.5821415782,
0.0372850858,
-0.4031597972,
0.3067786098,
-1.1162230968,
-0.7666483521,
0.0122659206,
0.2855532169,
-0.2622834742,
0.2781528831,
0.3578622043,
0.6454863548,
-0.3940016627,
-0.0119754421,
-0.4645295143,
-0.4204311669,
0.2277093977,
0.0467095822,
0.6306581497,
0.4334000349,
-0.413998723,
0.1052550226,
-0.5474621654,
0.0043461011,
0.3569660485,
-0.6533197165,
-0.5016135573,
0.6050338149,
-0.0635458156,
-0.0813439414,
0.1215201914,
-0.042513933,
0.3056889772,
-0.3131439686,
0.501091063,
0.924996376,
0.1845581532,
0.5132542849,
-0.3431920707,
0.460485518,
-0.3295232952,
0.1999209076,
-0.1174217761,
-0.0728611052,
-0.786839664,
-0.3833842874,
0.063578859,
0.6976367235,
-0.3565149009,
0.8151816726,
-0.2312332988,
-0.3391375542,
-0.1801701635,
0.5547701716,
0.0277212411,
0.2500326335,
0.2933014333,
-0.1301907152,
-0.5216501355,
-0.5684819818,
-0.2794950008,
-0.016203085,
0.1357158571,
0.3478907347,
0.6674849391,
-0.4152242541,
0.7655121684,
-0.6880139112,
0.0899865031,
-0.3204263151,
-0.3198880255,
0.4226012826,
0.1690669507,
0.9593942761,
-0.6436773539,
-0.5071634054,
-0.1347216964,
-0.7277949452,
-0.3260440528,
-0.2270600796,
-0.1747136712,
0.0776553527,
0.8292882442,
-0.2994828224,
0.1974268109,
0.756490469,
-0.3692754805,
0.5889873505,
-0.524654448,
-0.1435302496,
-0.9627085328,
0.0431594923,
0.2981337905,
-0.354149133,
-0.5466035008,
0.2841603756,
0.1080626547,
0.0427253768,
-0.091377005,
0.8018032908,
-0.6785385013,
-0.108343184,
-0.5261964202,
0.0378497131,
-0.1168269292,
0.3728482127,
0.1728060246,
0.7714990973,
0.6466033459,
-1.1529057026,
0.4891772866,
0.2065883428,
-0.3603903949,
0.5682444572,
-0.680362165,
0.0949161574,
-0.281358391,
0.1943910122,
-0.8832111359,
-0.5085554123,
0.1465159059,
0.141760692,
0.3260753155,
-0.146556735,
-0.3225442767,
-0.5020781159,
-0.2626382411,
0.3163876534,
0.5526175499,
-0.7856211662,
0.7750918865,
0.4308912754,
-0.2548582256,
-0.113551341,
-0.2828663588,
0.027227534,
-0.4735704362,
-0.6228889823,
0.051388707,
-0.5318862796,
-0.328936547,
-0.4190096855,
0.0817020237,
0.0281021968,
0.3723117113,
0.1522569805,
0.0463408493,
-0.4493259788,
-0.0189580023,
-0.0239667334,
0.2233528048,
0.0729611441,
-0.2803563178,
0.494884491,
-0.2122794986,
-0.3183412552,
-0.4405082166,
0.3054633439,
0.9283254147,
-0.1841012388,
0.6774556041,
0.0506522059,
-0.179516837,
-0.6012611985,
-0.5022107363,
-0.0899309143,
-0.532666862,
0.6528109312,
-0.5477847457,
-0.5396398306,
0.4965076149,
-0.3497422338,
-0.0944130495,
0.3439131975,
0.673261404,
0.0029336039,
0.9425442815,
0.7031597495,
-0.239788115,
0.5892474055,
0.1423673481,
0.1373704076,
-0.8057892323,
0.0217422899,
-0.6334373951,
-0.1031496376,
-0.5251600742,
-0.5416872501,
0.2705276012,
0.046619501,
-0.4454620779,
0.4228090346,
-0.3972047269,
0.5060189366,
0.4642039835,
0.35249421,
0.2072722912,
-0.1724002361,
-0.1073671058,
0.0987481177,
-0.8523119092,
-0.1943795681,
1.1464354992,
0.5770509243,
1.2219395638,
0.3712334037,
0.6108570695,
0.375608474,
0.1174699739,
-1.1375640631,
0.5152103305,
-0.167894721,
-0.4653072059,
-0.5370536447,
-0.400556922,
-0.87571913,
0.1767789423,
-0.4164194763,
-0.6616283059,
0.1311808825,
0.0892962962,
-0.1407834589,
0.1189046949,
-0.8589609265,
0.5991559625,
-0.5398151278,
-0.0693288967,
-0.2413356006,
-0.4515660107,
0.2093070149,
-0.7630768418,
0.6290831566,
-0.04510298,
-0.0986401886,
0.752707839,
-0.2091512084,
0.8314859271,
-0.1228246316,
-0.1005871817,
0.2214682102,
0.1736532748,
0.6334050894,
-0.4117637873,
-0.1317667216,
-0.3158091605,
0.0566538908,
-0.4198227525,
-0.4189710021,
0.4851399064,
-1.0960986614,
-0.5366336107,
-0.2570024729,
-0.7203128934,
-0.2973282933,
0.4077423811,
-0.1707487702,
0.1414533108,
-0.290671885,
0.1727529317,
0.7422621846,
-0.2695765197,
0.7146584392,
0.8277547956,
-0.2555024028,
-0.368583858,
0.7025967836,
-0.0960419849,
0.1622910798,
0.3629725277,
0.6046358347,
-0.4916828573,
-0.9393319488,
-0.210032016,
0.5301134586,
-0.7228048444,
-0.1312347949,
-0.098817654,
-0.2422988266,
-0.4473874569,
-0.2528686225,
-0.0536653623,
-0.0626266003,
-0.36553213,
0.2546946406,
0.4328168333,
0.7733023763,
-0.2263498455,
0.3808315992,
-0.6659357548,
0.4641863704,
0.5721016526,
0.4050391614,
-0.0911419243,
-0.9631844759,
-0.2445301414,
-0.1809248179,
0.0146086989,
-0.8345587254,
0.2701626122,
0.6460615993,
0.9973913431,
0.4342158139,
0.1055922285,
0.5284335613,
-0.6132920384,
0.1043033823,
0.2672115564,
-1.0348297358,
0.6182444692,
-0.5155923367,
0.3906673789,
0.2310513258,
0.4104945958,
-0.5488447547,
0.0841357484,
-0.1209952831,
-0.6484582424,
0.44505319,
-0.041112002,
0.3455887437,
0.23499538,
0.8552626967,
-0.1174205244,
0.0099427365,
-0.5671178102,
0.198911801,
0.0393421836,
-0.3848995864,
-0.1445974708,
-0.3812941909,
0.0888107419,
-0.3471337855,
0.7338045835,
-0.6315723062,
0.0659578666,
0.0869741812,
-0.4105573297,
-0.3989814818,
0.0453454144,
0.8059209585,
0.7432748675,
-0.1477099359,
-0.0941748917,
0.5156915784,
-0.5023266077,
0.1468461901,
-0.1791521609,
-0.2017924935,
-0.4224013686,
0.6011351347,
0.7230581641,
0.3856302798,
-0.6150408387,
0.4776367247,
-0.0415595397,
-0.2774581313,
-0.1486729234,
0.5903234482,
0.2604905963,
0.5704758167,
0.3914532959,
-0.1800771505,
-0.0913155451,
-0.6290568113,
0.2605414689,
0.3932687342,
0.2578489482,
-0.0287053287,
0.4228969812,
0.3604922295,
-0.4448384643,
0.2479129732,
0.2330696434,
-0.5073136091,
0.3636036217,
0.8210138083,
0.8229238391,
-0.5135304332,
-0.1119576395,
0.3917843699,
0.1523167491,
-0.3802004457,
0.1661781669,
0.1974023134,
-0.9548991919,
-0.7019160986,
-0.8127512336,
-0.4249359369,
-0.1091661602,
-0.563544929,
0.4283058345,
-0.7581562996,
-0.0358037427,
0.118556805,
0.0196191296,
-0.6945648193,
0.4033234715,
0.3953188956,
1.2634564638,
-0.9760711193,
0.5640761852,
0.5117465258,
-0.0891312361,
-0.835647583,
-0.0276689753,
-0.1165606156,
-1.2136625051,
0.4433724284,
-0.235198155,
-0.3205768168,
-0.0993037671,
-0.7893933058,
-1.0351155996,
1.0256723166,
0.5255566835,
-0.7593451142,
-0.1308587939,
-0.108457312,
0.5330648422,
-0.7304431796,
-0.0874604657,
0.6635289192,
0.6257860661,
0.2755066454,
-1.1545894146,
0.1641237885,
-0.0217739884,
0.1032623053,
0.0434363,
-0.6859077811,
0.4485556781,
-0.4100309908,
0.3890771866,
0.0236188918,
0.5378755927,
0.2762344182,
0.0827384293,
0.7392492294,
0.2193413228,
0.8419318199,
0.3809241951,
0.8484671712,
-0.3219746947,
0.441909641,
1.1090897322,
-0.3364551961,
0.955619514,
0.4282020628,
-0.0797313303,
0.6136679053,
0.5533027053,
-0.1305213273,
0.6476471424,
0.3935824335,
-0.2197798193,
-0.4825909138,
0.2061669081,
-0.0492501855,
0.7020548582,
0.4509478211,
-0.420013994,
-0.1034578905,
-0.3119949996,
0.1221045852,
0.0402841642,
-0.6153162718,
0.9931502938,
0.0887865126,
-0.5962814093,
0.6382555366,
0.1967147738,
0.4020047784,
-0.3741101921,
0.1335089803,
-0.0326878317,
0.3437750041,
-0.172012791,
-0.6751566529,
0.0100880172,
-0.1008924842,
-0.1893132478,
0.1843923479,
0.9127581716,
-0.1300419271,
-0.5199514031,
0.4594042301,
0.5134921074,
0.0421876051,
0.0034669125,
-0.851965785,
0.1205086559,
-0.0414459407,
-0.2966376841,
0.2485950142,
0.4887844324,
-0.0408819988,
1.0810502768,
0.621358633,
0.1566928476,
0.0507724881,
-0.0758086815,
0.7640908957,
-0.8062524199,
-0.6108571291,
-0.956671834,
0.2685872912,
0.1483616084,
0.038890142,
0.559404552,
0.4602098465,
0.3863511384,
-0.2240671068,
1.0115430355,
0.3716345131,
0.3252326548,
-0.7957718372,
0.5388357639,
-0.6475688815,
0.0274296813,
-0.4916273952,
-1.1945366859,
-0.5434234142,
0.9628692865,
-0.514716804,
0.0825936869,
0.540130496,
0.7546248436,
-0.2669273019,
-0.0801759288,
0.4288032055,
0.2125200778,
0.2563274801,
0.754850626,
0.570510447,
-0.1204464287,
0.2820957005,
0.1563620567,
-0.4359936118,
-0.6593512893,
-1.2516691685,
-1.0009639263,
-0.3937036693,
-0.3924249411,
-0.2358807772,
0.2231114507,
1.1845360994,
1.0355011225,
-0.8565108776,
-0.5465897918,
-0.1250348091,
0.0471331514,
0.112134859,
-0.1754282564,
0.2970280051,
-0.4256104827,
-0.4088400602,
0.5072766542,
0.1713261753,
0.3024715781,
-0.1829441041,
-0.6220950484,
-0.1874509305,
0.5587317944,
0.6782634854,
0.3898898065,
-0.3047086,
-0.5559636354,
-0.0353866331,
-0.0127748121,
-0.0964029059,
0.6952482462,
-0.2613639235,
0.3922895789,
0.3320773244,
0.6279072165,
0.6404213905,
-0.0925276875,
0.765309751,
-0.1996446699,
-0.076622881,
-0.0145623796,
0.3893524706,
0.2080822587,
-0.1071813479,
0.5602344871,
0.1304778159,
-0.6185224652,
-0.688187778,
0.132665962,
-0.9715420008,
-0.4798244834,
1.5201259851,
-0.0227541961,
-0.4876237512,
-0.0549651384,
-0.358071357,
0.0435580611,
-0.2383970618,
0.8237885237,
0.6052712798,
-0.4086302519,
-0.2581363916,
-0.4225905538,
0.4053866267,
0.0230450518,
-0.9465597272,
0.0985040292,
0.3803471327,
0.8973084688,
-0.1124074534,
0.3818866313,
0.3978464305,
0.2531049848,
-0.2560860813,
-0.0803241953,
0.2593275309,
-0.2929530442,
-0.4140332341,
-0.008755927,
0.6690671444,
0.2261725515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02147v1 | LlamAr & GemmAr: Enhancing LLMs Through Arabic Instruction-Tuning | 2024-07-02T10:43:49 | 2024-07-02T10:43:49 | Hasna Chouikhi, Manel Aloui, Cyrine Ben Hammou, Ghaith Chaabane, Haithem Kchaou, Chehir Dhaouadi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have greatly impacted the natural language
processing (NLP) field, particularly for the English language. These models
have demonstrated capabilities in understanding and generating human-like text.
The success of language models largely depends on the availability of
high-quality instruction datasets, which consist of detailed task descriptions
and corresponding responses that are essential for training the models to
accurately address a variety of prompts. However, the availability and quality
of these resources vary by language. While models perform well in English, they
often struggle with languages like Arabic, due to the lack of datasets for
fine-tuning Arabic-specific tasks. To address this issue, we introduce
InstAr-500k, a new Arabic instruction dataset created by generating and
collecting content that covers several domains and instruction types. We then
assess this dataset by fine-tuning two open-source models, Llama-3-8B-Instruct
and Gemma-7B-IT, on several downstream tasks to scale improvements in their
functionality. Based on multiple evaluations, our fine-tuned models achieve
state-of-the-art performance on several Arabic NLP benchmarks. These outcomes
emphasize the effectiveness of our dataset in elevating the capabilities of
language models for Arabic. Our instruction dataset bridges the performance gap
between English and Arabic language models by providing resources that amplify
Arabic NLP development. Building on this foundation, we developed two
state-of-the-art models, LlamAr-8B and GemmAr-7B, which are specifically tuned
to excel at a wide range of Arabic NLP tasks. | [
-0.2757284641,
-0.5519686341,
0.2288364172,
0.2582500875,
-0.2343309373,
0.4418310225,
-0.3109799922,
-0.4974994063,
-0.1669850349,
0.5641787052,
-0.3565537035,
-0.8494845033,
-0.85742414,
0.2215119451,
-0.514021039,
1.1240910292,
-0.1639189124,
0.2053665817,
-0.0420227088,
-0.1218092516,
-0.6459199786,
-0.3579338491,
-0.7309148908,
-0.3188929558,
0.3347239494,
0.8270942569,
1.0302371979,
0.9960482121,
0.596878469,
0.190228045,
-0.1110070944,
0.5778034925,
-0.4276019335,
0.1689422429,
-0.0678522885,
-0.2996376455,
-0.4468363523,
-0.4844261706,
0.7041957378,
0.6191412807,
-0.310112983,
0.3999034464,
0.278083086,
0.8088135719,
-0.738551259,
0.1377404034,
-0.474078536,
-0.1815991253,
-0.2977021933,
-0.2243127823,
-0.3703500926,
-0.3966468871,
-0.1936871707,
-0.1766989529,
0.1764201373,
0.0204333123,
0.7459733486,
0.4759989977,
-0.3591308892,
-0.6287391186,
-0.6958886981,
0.7522605658,
-0.8165873289,
0.354985863,
0.5361166596,
0.1630126685,
-0.4755986333,
-0.5539498925,
-0.2815941274,
-0.379431963,
0.0761573613,
-0.1545695215,
-0.320363611,
0.0963218361,
-0.0145795634,
0.4875594676,
-0.3800089359,
0.4665639699,
-0.125586018,
0.0568245351,
0.5372517705,
0.3973032236,
0.2803373039,
0.2783670723,
-0.0448136367,
-0.0626998991,
-1.135355711,
0.0512361377,
0.3918812871,
0.2478637695,
-0.2106315047,
0.6212691069,
-0.2521767914,
0.8072336912,
0.0950590149,
-0.3314130008,
-0.2601086497,
-0.1738922,
-0.1237071231,
0.3700710535,
0.3892340362,
0.1085567474,
0.1879248172,
-0.2596331835,
-0.4486317337,
0.029200064,
0.2025865316,
-1.1261394024,
-0.2051044554,
0.125239864,
-0.1810467094,
-0.0642213151,
-0.1056434959,
-0.3370800018,
-0.3598019779,
-0.4288623929,
0.3251317739,
-0.3528907597,
0.1095397174,
0.4980921745,
0.4654616117,
0.3154258132,
0.1902837753,
-1.2930709124,
0.5004262924,
0.7798858881,
0.7310078144,
-0.1683667153,
-0.0617719218,
-0.4682055414,
0.3250783682,
-0.5446996689,
0.7847387195,
-0.9862540364,
-0.3989531994,
0.3221881092,
-0.1571658105,
0.0708315521,
-0.8559997082,
0.6235849261,
-0.7056280375,
-0.0967662111,
-0.0586240478,
-0.7393972874,
-0.3807175457,
0.0431536175,
-0.6115060449,
1.3013938665,
0.1221077666,
-0.4753734469,
0.0976265073,
-0.800039053,
-0.4496149421,
0.0194342472,
0.0412064642,
-0.3443689942,
0.2113489509,
0.6552479267,
0.5621079206,
-0.6104367375,
0.0203710273,
0.2692132294,
-0.6858633161,
0.117207475,
-0.4435773492,
0.5224523544,
0.0750786886,
-0.3670514822,
0.1230302677,
-0.778102994,
0.0212261975,
-0.1873618364,
-0.5399311781,
0.0302003566,
0.0604511388,
-0.0294413045,
-0.0570000112,
0.4455517828,
-0.3639543355,
0.2134486586,
-0.5740684271,
0.0808394849,
0.5926730037,
-0.0001619396,
0.3443599939,
-0.422162801,
0.8779423833,
-0.0923705548,
0.0115563134,
-0.3017102778,
-0.3842724562,
-1.1474711895,
-0.4153640866,
0.2811927795,
0.462343514,
-0.4976198971,
0.2394970506,
-0.1837358922,
-0.5238161683,
-1.0078845024,
0.4863397181,
0.4687800705,
0.3936804235,
0.4796499908,
-0.2347839624,
-0.4974401295,
-0.8244386315,
-0.1960112303,
0.2177964598,
0.0350256264,
0.1098049805,
0.3362009227,
-0.2458410263,
0.5387468934,
-0.2508725822,
-0.2156873494,
-0.4483693838,
-0.1124925911,
0.5632377863,
0.2402615696,
0.3676234782,
-0.3320305049,
-0.8085675836,
0.174404636,
-0.522679925,
-0.172746554,
0.1428837776,
-0.1289950758,
0.3396179676,
0.3643285632,
-0.3939216137,
0.5191399455,
0.6649149656,
-0.283516556,
0.4456996918,
-0.1948913634,
0.1699472368,
-1.1670106649,
-0.4351614714,
-0.2464897782,
-0.099169828,
-0.4944334626,
0.2291407883,
0.0336139724,
0.1239039823,
-0.4457082152,
0.4862065911,
-0.5017192364,
0.0516384877,
-0.6049256921,
-0.2553974092,
-0.1299182773,
0.2535696924,
-0.1744045168,
1.3768544197,
0.4631824493,
-0.664849937,
0.1269771606,
0.358227849,
-0.7839971185,
0.168859601,
-0.7850727439,
0.4083673656,
-0.0105885556,
-0.0335218124,
-0.7676523924,
-0.37971434,
0.2512063682,
-0.0592733845,
0.4229037762,
-0.1599373072,
-0.7315853238,
0.2071205527,
-0.0415537953,
0.3603872061,
0.4214142859,
-0.7963914871,
0.5605501533,
0.2341018915,
-0.2532373071,
-0.9028512836,
-0.2222107053,
0.2373704463,
-0.1314793378,
-0.4195975065,
0.4838966727,
0.1354232281,
-0.2023014724,
-0.0158168934,
-0.1191447899,
-0.1311541498,
-0.0130434725,
0.4771080315,
0.2414259315,
-0.4186661541,
0.2370161861,
0.3727070391,
-0.1560506672,
0.0510982014,
-0.176955089,
0.5577332377,
-0.084958002,
-0.5088036656,
-0.5811968446,
0.2965505719,
0.2696299851,
-0.5508761406,
1.1232461929,
0.5970419049,
-0.1764794737,
-0.351526469,
-0.4670885205,
-0.1106908694,
-0.5236608386,
0.6453794837,
-0.2406673282,
-0.9690334797,
0.0965950564,
-0.1475708932,
0.4199935794,
0.1181542501,
0.8343505859,
-0.129959926,
1.1788372993,
0.8596870303,
-0.3956364989,
0.3363572061,
-0.1634100527,
0.2072889805,
-0.7420691252,
-0.1778388917,
-0.5804463029,
-0.3845372796,
-0.4804404676,
-0.4117612541,
0.4365606606,
0.0233835876,
-0.4442034066,
0.0978227854,
-0.3556393385,
0.8726130724,
0.4945244193,
0.0841711387,
0.379424125,
0.3136645555,
-0.0136027681,
-0.1013858467,
-0.8710707426,
-1.1054699421,
1.3544306755,
0.1959991306,
0.8249794245,
0.4041059613,
0.6122720242,
0.3949101567,
0.5261690617,
-0.6423133612,
0.4046009779,
-0.2836840749,
-0.3034742475,
-0.0243604276,
0.0351992548,
-1.0013371706,
-0.0110801868,
-0.119690761,
-0.5177182555,
-0.3011655807,
0.2729370892,
-0.3328359425,
0.2712486684,
-0.5620794892,
0.5257027149,
-0.1407329589,
-0.4416391551,
-0.5132679343,
-0.2342082411,
0.1613724679,
0.0609213971,
-0.0055675302,
-0.2273160219,
-0.2440825701,
0.6108032465,
-0.27245906,
0.7979040146,
0.1318792403,
-0.345528245,
0.3260873854,
0.1735545248,
0.5854603648,
0.0111275679,
-0.2425094396,
0.206280306,
-0.169413507,
-0.5401521325,
-0.5979912281,
0.6811990738,
-0.9844430685,
-0.7689942718,
-0.1965648383,
-0.8077731133,
-0.2351528853,
-0.2615098953,
-0.0329033993,
0.4479894936,
-0.0928730071,
0.2081666142,
0.6353626251,
-0.1873551011,
0.4294704497,
0.6712052226,
-0.1716922969,
-0.280118376,
0.750728786,
-0.0820349604,
0.1543800533,
0.5832484365,
-0.1424717456,
-0.2751354277,
-0.8096548319,
-0.5902722478,
0.2295242548,
-0.7349581122,
-0.4703330398,
-0.1558774412,
-0.3168624341,
0.0587430485,
-0.1248186827,
-0.3085072637,
-0.297866106,
-0.5360904336,
-0.0792285353,
0.53371346,
1.0874949694,
0.239748165,
0.6583648324,
-0.8584651947,
0.2067946792,
0.038612213,
0.1793530881,
0.0900961608,
-1.149109602,
-0.786677897,
0.118631199,
-0.4630177319,
-0.6921750903,
0.4435481727,
0.4905377328,
0.0908738971,
0.4245971143,
-0.1816729903,
0.7688681483,
-0.7999765277,
0.4267248213,
-0.3458400369,
-0.7931858897,
0.3829180002,
-0.1647998244,
0.4433200359,
0.3672322929,
0.5760989189,
-0.3625193536,
-0.3623615205,
-0.0748028383,
-0.7772657871,
0.6082551479,
0.1250171512,
0.4078300893,
-0.0025705558,
0.5430980325,
0.3364064991,
0.1236817911,
-0.2456872761,
-0.2573587596,
0.0353027359,
-0.6136214137,
-0.1021274477,
-0.5217245221,
0.0009775802,
-0.2859475315,
0.8761910796,
-0.0100672739,
0.0294079371,
-0.3803455234,
-0.2582319081,
-0.1268580407,
0.3188656569,
0.4629437327,
0.8527269363,
-0.155057013,
-0.0006244723,
0.2967251241,
-0.7772443295,
0.4204578698,
0.0712904707,
-0.1280674785,
-0.0585895255,
0.6197986603,
0.6926329732,
0.4567031562,
-0.8192350268,
0.0570788756,
0.0677255318,
0.1996386796,
-0.3882913291,
0.534363687,
0.2571786344,
0.330363363,
0.3137579262,
-0.1225394234,
-0.1032377258,
-0.1416989565,
0.0400878526,
0.3635589182,
-0.2509806156,
-0.3363337219,
0.5838164091,
0.0096119922,
-0.5331099629,
0.7699745297,
-0.0030813266,
-0.1541083604,
0.6248218417,
0.8905240893,
0.6213286519,
-0.3318814933,
0.1835772842,
0.3166008294,
0.3578293324,
0.1068395749,
0.3708909452,
0.0246376991,
-0.8255493641,
-0.6160691381,
-0.7623204589,
-0.6225115657,
0.1838607639,
-0.7572355866,
0.1295605898,
-0.50764817,
-0.0581539236,
-0.2398816645,
0.1540941894,
-0.8273479342,
0.130096212,
-0.0890528187,
0.854911685,
-0.6263615489,
0.9568216205,
0.7671940923,
-0.1505877525,
-0.772400856,
-0.1861968338,
-0.2213876545,
-1.0104387999,
0.6474324465,
0.2003604472,
-0.4572605193,
0.2795428932,
-0.5768179297,
-1.0151319504,
0.9922457933,
0.7203729153,
-0.7830958962,
0.2236199081,
0.532791853,
0.4344857633,
-0.5184849501,
0.2539045215,
0.778424561,
0.1959217489,
-0.1373619288,
-0.590262413,
-0.1643152833,
-0.0476221889,
-0.0786780566,
0.3301763833,
-0.5390252471,
0.5859642029,
-0.345662564,
-0.1765342951,
0.2705135345,
0.9629412293,
0.2747875452,
-0.0387648828,
0.0553871095,
0.5884406567,
0.6816117167,
0.0426071435,
1.0355098248,
-0.6496937871,
-0.1780025661,
1.2266088724,
-0.2062712163,
1.1395913363,
0.4315611422,
-0.2697717845,
0.6943252087,
0.62333709,
0.1834273785,
0.3450665772,
0.0447548293,
-0.7956997156,
-0.2234644294,
-0.475459367,
-0.2378266603,
0.7535982728,
0.5149267316,
-0.3318963945,
-0.1958604008,
-0.2922451496,
0.2763183117,
0.3112724721,
-0.3786740303,
0.6361854076,
0.0097998157,
-0.4296433628,
0.8314510584,
0.375449419,
0.3947983086,
-0.6506335139,
-0.406239599,
-0.4867774546,
0.1611003131,
-0.2382322997,
-0.4366706908,
0.067829974,
0.4837350249,
-0.160721153,
-0.0421167053,
0.3227263987,
-0.4727377594,
-0.8108664155,
0.0313966908,
0.3375842273,
0.1896616817,
0.2115916014,
-0.4174833298,
0.1794542372,
0.0694344863,
-0.0300573893,
0.4078858197,
0.2706647515,
0.0027172435,
0.8434143066,
0.5628345013,
0.2473476678,
0.0996037945,
0.1857667863,
0.7579389811,
-0.5216522217,
-0.0176531225,
-1.0296773911,
0.3352618814,
0.3167169094,
-0.4987186491,
0.876288414,
0.6176612973,
0.8779238462,
-0.0862275511,
0.4368539751,
0.4417229295,
0.4782017171,
-0.7517564297,
0.6289070249,
-0.3047553301,
0.5131314993,
0.1801600307,
-1.0286072493,
-0.2243050337,
0.5236879587,
-0.1380580813,
0.0389927179,
0.4997457266,
1.2813817263,
-0.0624361746,
-0.0204808097,
0.2293497026,
0.1107845381,
0.1834170222,
0.614730835,
0.9686483741,
-0.3094211519,
0.379889071,
-0.2391483784,
-0.0392348655,
-0.1018475443,
-0.7807119489,
-1.0632191896,
-0.3105403185,
-0.1831430942,
0.0277403388,
0.3625628054,
1.2422212362,
0.4483595788,
-0.994189918,
-0.6545757055,
0.0349316075,
0.0805366933,
-0.2040509284,
-0.1040041521,
0.6883813143,
-0.5663412213,
-0.7924164534,
0.6644444466,
0.3632475436,
-0.0527185313,
-0.1052130908,
-0.1895624995,
-0.0250437353,
0.1899413913,
0.5429917574,
0.1262659431,
-0.7047955394,
-0.1163413003,
-0.0690213963,
-0.0021694133,
0.2120833695,
0.4734992683,
-0.7141811848,
0.2501044869,
-0.2731113732,
1.0904115438,
0.3326959312,
-0.1212379783,
0.5473759174,
-0.7934052348,
0.238870129,
0.200294137,
0.1832580715,
0.552441299,
-0.2703030407,
0.542906642,
-0.6253474355,
-0.6419032812,
-0.5958951712,
0.1707674563,
-0.3702127039,
0.137690112,
0.9671714902,
-0.0865756795,
0.0773395821,
-0.1076683402,
-0.3592145741,
0.2440759093,
-0.3977914155,
1.1820641756,
0.7890378237,
-0.1650811732,
-0.126595661,
-0.7615159154,
0.5587449074,
0.6928738952,
-0.8168814778,
-0.2618788779,
0.3042443693,
-0.0063630501,
-0.5285263658,
0.1283643544,
0.1931891739,
0.3732223511,
-0.2082428038,
0.0538323857,
-0.2516953945,
-0.4467220306,
-0.321521163,
0.0418529138,
0.5757141709,
-0.251187861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02138v1 | Efficient Nearest Neighbor based Uncertainty Estimation for Natural Language Processing Tasks | 2024-07-02T10:33:31 | 2024-07-02T10:33:31 | Wataru Hashimoto, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Trustworthy prediction in Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), including Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs) is important for safety-critical applications in the
real world. However, DNNs often suffer from uncertainty estimation, such as
miscalibration. In particular, approaches that require multiple stochastic
inference can mitigate this problem, but the expensive cost of inference makes
them impractical. In this study, we propose $k$-Nearest Neighbor Uncertainty
Estimation ($k$NN-UE), which is an uncertainty estimation method that uses the
distances from the neighbors and label-existence ratio of neighbors.
Experiments on sentiment analysis, natural language inference, and named entity
recognition show that our proposed method outperforms the baselines or recent
density-based methods in confidence calibration, selective prediction, and
out-of-distribution detection. Moreover, our analyses indicate that introducing
dimension reduction or approximate nearest neighbor search inspired by recent
$k$NN-LM studies reduces the inference overhead without significantly degrading
estimation performance when combined them appropriately. | [
-0.4259023964,
-0.6021699309,
0.8458245397,
-0.0650792196,
-0.1680387408,
-0.0076075736,
-0.361758858,
-0.5097399354,
0.1119297594,
0.3284019828,
-0.4328775406,
-0.5168430805,
-0.7227167487,
0.0673863888,
0.2601214945,
0.3088418543,
0.2686108053,
0.0175671447,
-0.1615476757,
-0.0006654974,
-0.0505041257,
-0.3449113965,
-0.6547686458,
-0.1343865842,
0.4714446664,
0.32817626,
1.0266312361,
0.377525121,
0.4834446013,
0.3125572503,
-0.35505867,
0.3141764104,
0.0573356338,
0.0810777619,
0.1526222229,
-0.4951222539,
-0.2734730542,
0.0019887763,
0.7681382895,
0.8163640499,
-0.0016924902,
-0.0758938491,
-0.1931583732,
0.9741239548,
-0.8646579385,
-0.0832104757,
-0.3786496222,
0.3866857588,
-0.0540769696,
0.3699676394,
-0.2433041185,
-0.7421358824,
0.5210658312,
-0.4767491519,
-0.0904426649,
0.0126802288,
0.8447740674,
0.5778442621,
0.0297938082,
-0.1726897657,
-0.611349225,
1.0998746157,
-1.0897586346,
0.7667561173,
0.9813389778,
0.3036455512,
-0.538582027,
-0.6725931168,
-0.6487072706,
-0.4218352735,
-0.0437688194,
0.1070615277,
-0.0043720566,
0.4127367437,
0.0110256271,
0.4351331294,
-0.2686169744,
0.3042654097,
0.1146167964,
-0.4565940201,
0.3581257164,
-0.2582697868,
-0.1291766018,
-0.3924445212,
-0.3467372358,
-0.1023366526,
-0.2398376018,
0.0724411905,
0.6383638978,
0.2504623234,
0.0227424689,
0.1802225411,
-0.3430207372,
0.6924895644,
-0.099867925,
-0.4011829495,
0.1488832384,
-0.3615100384,
-0.4355567098,
-0.0105189206,
1.1306340694,
0.3512075543,
0.2666431963,
-0.2582066059,
0.0367004424,
-0.1943600923,
0.0954362676,
-0.7038657665,
-0.5204673409,
0.1904962808,
-0.4590561688,
-0.5309278965,
0.0050314856,
-1.2246390581,
-0.3537627459,
-0.1611666679,
0.180078879,
-0.4799927175,
-0.3547390997,
-0.1451129615,
0.1834626943,
-0.3343059719,
-0.0202694833,
-0.3504656255,
0.1298769712,
0.2724428773,
0.8960813284,
0.0578075573,
-0.1036460847,
-0.4576926827,
-0.243757233,
-0.424218148,
0.3936353028,
-0.6540392637,
-0.1259365231,
-0.3092620671,
-0.4474707246,
-0.0568219051,
-0.4914731383,
0.6318017244,
-0.672950387,
-0.0278736334,
-0.0554849654,
-0.6896961331,
-0.1884901971,
0.1884078979,
-0.8584781289,
1.4137717485,
-0.0219994225,
-1.0258977413,
0.3596090674,
-0.3830170035,
-0.1082365215,
-0.4000122249,
0.0702204183,
-0.67067945,
0.4372505844,
0.5357138515,
0.4475371838,
-0.1102496833,
0.2357193381,
-0.5711628795,
-0.1591441482,
0.2395218313,
-0.7270701528,
0.5556172132,
0.3700964451,
0.0171669573,
-0.0804298669,
-0.7984986305,
0.2328727543,
-0.2203007191,
-0.1615210921,
-0.490160197,
-0.0928134471,
-0.5542370677,
0.1107554138,
0.2633477747,
-0.5858738422,
-0.1996716857,
-0.835034132,
0.2346582413,
0.5908130407,
0.118435666,
0.8747469783,
0.0174220651,
0.3698215485,
0.0962419435,
0.1958324313,
0.4108886719,
-0.6064133644,
-0.3473648727,
-0.2693240643,
0.7542699575,
0.3581267595,
-0.8537809253,
0.4899686575,
-0.2976746559,
-0.5421844125,
-0.642993629,
0.100241743,
0.4000427723,
0.6090934873,
0.2948507369,
0.0807060003,
-0.5497174859,
-0.7321148515,
-0.2526349425,
-0.2478662729,
-0.2243480831,
0.091796428,
0.251262337,
-0.098736085,
1.1794331074,
-0.3508167565,
-0.1422196925,
0.0775197148,
0.3069263697,
0.0602729917,
0.3193521202,
0.2910941541,
-0.7095986605,
-0.6891437173,
-0.182024017,
-0.3756806552,
0.0333985053,
0.023007568,
-0.0766538531,
0.2767605484,
0.3436569273,
-0.4945519865,
0.601698339,
0.7922533154,
0.293934226,
0.4755291343,
-0.3541525304,
-0.047218442,
-1.1313401461,
-0.3771283031,
0.3138330579,
-0.2822366357,
-0.6920385361,
-0.1502964646,
-0.0120543372,
0.3758013248,
-0.1545489281,
0.283970356,
-0.496221751,
-0.1978238225,
-0.1927382499,
0.3518921137,
0.1184651777,
0.2385370135,
0.3908278644,
0.8073621988,
0.6668619514,
-0.5940810442,
0.1540610939,
-0.1758324802,
-0.5219044685,
0.6159557104,
-0.1650990546,
0.3142202199,
-0.0537972264,
0.1121008471,
-0.636844933,
0.0353282504,
0.2642588019,
-0.5835184455,
0.423809737,
-0.2751919925,
-0.5874843597,
-0.476231724,
-0.3003683388,
0.2255805284,
0.2054233253,
-0.5833213925,
0.4789031446,
0.3504668474,
-0.0270660147,
-0.6144917011,
-0.9048079848,
0.1856030226,
-0.2326855361,
-0.497382015,
0.2169561982,
0.0548903123,
-0.2742202282,
-0.0520054847,
-0.4936736524,
-0.6421495676,
0.0546113625,
0.1773801148,
-0.0677772462,
-0.2033047974,
0.2269495726,
0.0234693941,
-0.3297244608,
-0.0354838707,
-0.3333312273,
0.1192510352,
-0.18754673,
-0.2416498065,
-0.6344099641,
0.0870268941,
0.3649568856,
-0.0104759764,
0.8630692363,
0.7879402637,
-0.6255616546,
-0.2086132616,
-0.7160536647,
-0.263455987,
-0.4941954613,
0.3546426594,
-0.3846352398,
-0.7962502241,
0.409814477,
-0.145562008,
-0.4500001967,
0.0167441443,
-0.0108213136,
-0.3626020551,
0.5837033391,
0.273586154,
-0.3825071156,
0.2339596003,
0.119381845,
0.6790676117,
-0.6993157268,
0.0522879884,
-0.5610775352,
-0.2583007514,
-0.583163023,
-0.7876240611,
0.2183708847,
0.3039279282,
-0.0241547469,
0.229710266,
-0.4358676374,
0.5247175097,
0.9804968834,
0.2129819095,
0.3433105946,
0.2168916911,
-0.3039708734,
-0.5397439003,
-0.6438649893,
-0.4635902047,
0.8645629883,
0.5408491492,
0.4202471972,
0.0335662216,
0.7891899943,
-0.0395699851,
0.1560861766,
-0.6424292326,
0.3379340768,
-0.0763752833,
-0.3014425933,
-0.5469782352,
-0.9596789479,
-0.5516728759,
0.0686985776,
0.0451264977,
-0.9864118695,
0.159795329,
-0.0011239294,
-0.6742213964,
0.7902584076,
-0.6230900884,
0.5570936799,
0.0091483025,
0.0136324419,
0.0890347883,
-0.8025121093,
0.1192064807,
-0.0741734058,
0.2694831192,
-0.2387494743,
0.073775962,
0.5135038495,
-0.5398998857,
0.7130527496,
-0.3421858549,
0.0470553637,
0.511555016,
0.2557354271,
0.7915687561,
0.2852231562,
-0.5543285608,
0.4168355167,
-0.107436493,
-0.1068846062,
-0.5354906917,
0.7657566071,
-0.4681558907,
-0.0471981578,
-0.3463284075,
-0.719235599,
-0.5036334991,
0.1694452465,
0.4764461815,
0.0909430161,
0.1319479942,
0.059695065,
0.5431605577,
-0.1534636468,
0.7927863002,
0.0400664248,
0.2497208714,
-0.6776493192,
0.9276992083,
0.1943255067,
0.4395044446,
0.5811297297,
0.4250530601,
-0.6002403498,
-0.8713137507,
-0.2952318788,
-0.1349060237,
-0.4757897854,
-0.3014636636,
-0.4641932249,
-0.055857759,
-0.2264683694,
-0.0606258772,
-0.8075845838,
-0.1560302377,
-0.361331135,
-0.2739200294,
0.4875791371,
0.4833993316,
-0.195887506,
0.5204488635,
-0.8453710675,
0.2315954417,
0.292952776,
0.8523442149,
-0.1100175604,
-0.4400033057,
-0.0648458079,
0.5402745008,
0.2052332461,
-0.9480608106,
0.3847376406,
0.2985759676,
0.480237484,
0.2907220125,
0.4738200009,
0.6702925563,
-0.0148715479,
0.6366338134,
0.1198829412,
-0.6892322898,
0.3769682646,
-0.041677922,
0.2606819272,
0.9968161583,
0.2402294874,
-0.0781169683,
-0.3336584866,
-0.4798602462,
-0.5552448034,
0.5480211973,
0.5886201262,
-0.1807281375,
-0.0296851117,
0.2446201593,
-0.212751776,
0.31728369,
-0.6156935096,
-0.5508974195,
0.022449607,
-0.388774246,
0.198472321,
-0.3783327341,
0.3916942775,
-0.2075034082,
0.6527869701,
-0.1310788244,
0.2047857344,
0.361767143,
-0.1099183485,
-0.0157947391,
0.173287496,
0.3232539594,
0.1715900153,
-0.5077347755,
0.3376986682,
0.5951446295,
-0.6444647908,
-0.0242701396,
0.1367978901,
-0.1153939068,
0.3162716329,
-0.0205415301,
0.4673111141,
0.3403889835,
-0.3136069775,
0.5049920082,
-0.1761823446,
-0.2098161578,
-0.3420343399,
-0.4071188271,
0.2064397335,
0.2073945552,
0.0343286805,
0.3531011045,
0.1357268244,
0.1735054702,
0.2768324912,
0.2451957315,
-0.8299735785,
-0.1715767235,
0.2958580554,
-0.1945550144,
-0.1907203943,
0.4943262339,
-0.6591315866,
-0.4418361485,
0.5614007115,
0.1308321506,
0.8810713887,
-0.3692917526,
0.3980417252,
0.4376761019,
0.4961131513,
-0.2802256048,
0.1250243038,
0.1262551844,
-0.8476656079,
-0.5592079163,
-0.9513092637,
-0.2941193581,
0.1260527819,
-0.5149284005,
-0.331730783,
-0.4236141145,
-0.4090440869,
-0.3066900969,
0.1560508758,
-0.4978916645,
0.2760700285,
0.148833409,
0.68375808,
-0.5637026429,
0.8203113079,
0.5609886646,
-0.1043108627,
-0.763166368,
0.1611155719,
-0.1217545941,
-0.209828496,
0.4438860118,
0.181906119,
-0.2505506873,
-0.1441538483,
-0.1067742258,
-1.0683066845,
0.8322736025,
0.3951214552,
-0.563891232,
0.1675954312,
0.3231672049,
0.5182230473,
-0.0600917041,
0.2360830009,
0.6639425159,
0.6756871343,
-0.0687001273,
-0.9473508596,
-0.1849514395,
0.1859751046,
0.2588404417,
0.4105599523,
-0.2290541381,
0.52691257,
-0.2053483278,
-0.1659401953,
0.108268328,
0.9675219059,
0.1793304682,
0.4177518189,
0.667023778,
0.9014641643,
1.1592704058,
0.0166215003,
0.84368366,
-0.157390222,
0.3045459092,
1.5406407118,
0.0238707345,
0.8450136781,
0.5880085826,
-0.5115221739,
0.3078397214,
0.6155760288,
0.2975400984,
0.5323247313,
0.0464048833,
-0.4098877311,
-0.3163829446,
-0.0931639597,
-0.1631454676,
0.2621523738,
0.3901163638,
-0.4761942327,
-0.1220205724,
-0.2889594436,
0.057964284,
0.2578175068,
-0.1079242453,
0.5748807788,
0.3534119129,
-0.3682135344,
0.101777859,
-0.1260140389,
0.7412385345,
-0.2332341075,
0.1965727359,
-0.054768417,
0.0187345911,
-0.0072319368,
-0.5438996553,
0.3459173739,
-0.3102081418,
-0.1443903595,
0.0739615187,
0.9597494006,
-0.3064081669,
-0.71493572,
0.2935092151,
0.3908321857,
0.0938877091,
-0.6357411742,
-0.5845936537,
-0.3138985932,
-0.06742125,
-0.3449130952,
0.3801953495,
0.467164278,
0.2798523009,
0.7231929898,
0.65581882,
0.306776315,
0.3519056141,
-0.0184934232,
0.3492886722,
-0.1770557612,
-0.4759036303,
-0.7811229825,
0.318008244,
-0.2293721884,
-0.197968483,
0.6947179437,
0.1110682711,
0.758951664,
0.0752225742,
0.5571283698,
0.2090544999,
0.5133197308,
-0.4296285212,
0.6043815017,
-0.1970193982,
0.2140280753,
-0.3785512447,
-1.1092522144,
-0.4711616933,
0.9572797418,
-0.426679194,
0.2165776044,
0.6276714206,
0.9321792126,
-0.0087287556,
0.3449727595,
0.416555047,
0.0376029201,
-0.0324803367,
0.3101914525,
0.5489316583,
-0.5482420921,
0.5273947716,
-1.2418262959,
0.1555142701,
0.089944236,
-1.3190245628,
-0.7501857281,
-0.181701228,
-0.3323613405,
-0.089371331,
-0.1491489112,
0.8491442204,
0.8367272615,
-0.9396862984,
0.3510204256,
-0.4233117104,
0.2821085751,
-0.2800625265,
-0.2218598574,
0.4957796037,
-0.2298475355,
-0.7623906732,
0.6225739121,
0.1428761333,
0.0550784618,
-0.0568500198,
-0.1899964362,
-0.2484416217,
-0.1195757985,
0.2245790213,
0.0804765373,
-0.7994115353,
-0.5642905235,
-0.1171313152,
-0.1702342629,
0.081967026,
0.1163496673,
-0.5361662507,
0.7289211154,
0.5804883242,
0.7809605002,
0.11408142,
0.0426322669,
0.5437107086,
-1.2383848429,
0.1611770391,
0.4136226773,
0.2931963205,
0.3767368197,
-0.3346223235,
0.4461194873,
0.0525686741,
-0.692974925,
-0.8130909204,
0.2142411321,
-0.5621912479,
-0.0470308997,
0.8701356649,
-0.2664048374,
-0.1136651114,
-0.3100321591,
0.2058057487,
0.2569024563,
-0.5698251724,
0.5215430856,
0.7255115509,
0.1747658849,
-0.2542027831,
-0.9023563266,
0.6572120786,
0.6077370644,
-0.4796546102,
-0.1877826005,
0.3920215368,
-0.076648809,
0.3137090504,
0.2699733078,
0.2307001799,
-0.1091919243,
0.0760136545,
-0.0271373056,
-0.1243951172,
-0.4456506073,
-0.1471553892,
0.1486695558,
0.1575840265,
-0.352211237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02136v1 | Black Big Boxes: Do Language Models Hide a Theory of Adjective Order? | 2024-07-02T10:29:09 | 2024-07-02T10:29:09 | Jaap Jumelet, Lisa Bylinina, Willem Zuidema, Jakub Szymanik | cs.CL | cs.CL | In English and other languages, multiple adjectives in a complex noun phrase
show intricate ordering patterns that have been a target of much linguistic
theory. These patterns offer an opportunity to assess the ability of language
models (LMs) to learn subtle rules of language involving factors that cross the
traditional divisions of syntax, semantics, and pragmatics. We review existing
hypotheses designed to explain Adjective Order Preferences (AOPs) in humans and
develop a setup to study AOPs in LMs: we present a reusable corpus of adjective
pairs and define AOP measures for LMs. With these tools, we study a series of
LMs across intermediate checkpoints during training. We find that all models'
predictions are much closer to human AOPs than predictions generated by factors
identified in theoretical linguistics. At the same time, we demonstrate that
the observed AOPs in LMs are strongly correlated with the frequency of the
adjective pairs in the training data and report limited generalization to
unseen combinations. This highlights the difficulty in establishing the link
between LM performance and linguistic theory. We therefore conclude with a road
map for future studies our results set the stage for, and a discussion of key
questions about the nature of knowledge in LMs and their ability to generalize
beyond the training sets. | [
-0.5538183451,
-0.8625294566,
0.6438359618,
-0.0581679754,
0.1013383567,
-0.0376008786,
-0.2117712051,
-0.7194774151,
0.1947448999,
0.4740929306,
-0.2041307986,
-0.2882308066,
-0.6571221352,
-0.0526493266,
-0.2674952149,
0.7563884854,
0.1729988754,
0.1669337302,
-0.0826522559,
-0.1868021935,
-0.0418234132,
-0.6674751043,
-0.6197658181,
-0.5349248648,
0.6942941546,
0.1032441333,
1.2201653719,
0.9546474218,
0.374853909,
0.3007187545,
-0.2881281972,
0.0759268254,
-0.2446758002,
0.0235590804,
-0.319788605,
-0.8010916114,
-0.5988736153,
0.2104803324,
0.5206301212,
1.1129934788,
0.0380204506,
0.0266416539,
-0.1809441149,
0.7420966625,
-0.6799460649,
0.2143609375,
-0.4513318837,
0.1817828119,
0.1423688531,
-0.290500313,
-0.4309977889,
0.0048184134,
0.3423065543,
-0.1483385116,
0.3020711541,
0.4239419699,
1.1432967186,
-0.0878824145,
-0.7654710412,
-0.1861033142,
-0.8810837865,
0.7342004776,
-0.6413622499,
0.4536541998,
0.613882184,
0.104758963,
-0.2753116488,
-0.2488854975,
-0.5557717085,
-0.4553171098,
-0.2843082845,
-0.1781832427,
-0.1742603183,
0.484211117,
0.2425976992,
0.5943781137,
-0.4986926019,
0.4124669731,
-0.2978268564,
0.1373628974,
0.6461029053,
0.2120930851,
0.3505418599,
-0.0807872862,
-0.2123880982,
0.0784483254,
-0.5779005289,
0.2532499135,
0.3263036609,
0.1746450812,
-0.0075975903,
0.6790191531,
-0.282856673,
0.707577765,
0.0387982801,
-0.0762486607,
0.3245340288,
-0.1275893748,
-0.0758787319,
-0.3891257942,
0.8898018599,
0.3187374175,
0.2031245977,
-0.327250272,
-0.404299885,
0.4746036828,
0.3859100342,
-0.4637824595,
-0.1899492592,
0.0530633479,
-0.3310178518,
-0.4454994202,
0.0243380647,
-0.6161521673,
-0.377702564,
-0.4498049915,
0.5346420407,
-0.1195110455,
-0.3367559314,
0.275883168,
0.0573085174,
0.239492029,
0.0434997045,
-1.0602192879,
0.5761814713,
0.822684288,
0.3913414776,
-0.1769331694,
-0.4710280895,
-0.0764969513,
-0.0876767784,
-0.7840054035,
0.7632545829,
-0.6338503957,
-0.2129076421,
0.1889301687,
0.0885105506,
0.0963547528,
-0.4532029331,
0.2906391323,
-0.510904789,
0.3652654886,
-0.0044221231,
-0.5759317875,
-0.379311204,
0.0174867511,
-0.4786818624,
0.7475650907,
-0.371214062,
-0.4771879911,
0.3392474949,
-0.2758451402,
-0.3995246291,
-0.1639951766,
-0.2876401842,
-0.2734205723,
0.5341898799,
-0.2033097297,
0.6861919761,
-0.1420524269,
0.2070916146,
-0.5438039899,
-0.1292811781,
0.4434269965,
-0.1703363806,
0.5585256815,
0.0215780213,
-0.4631576836,
-0.0856326595,
-0.6489742398,
0.1286276579,
0.2201745659,
-0.3479699194,
-0.5718064308,
0.1492495388,
-0.4942798018,
0.3558915555,
0.103675589,
-0.254286319,
0.1450523734,
-0.4952324927,
0.2350130677,
0.7307960391,
-0.1757347137,
0.748008132,
-0.2628766,
0.6718400121,
-0.0419470482,
0.138212651,
0.0449938998,
-0.533308804,
-1.1278988123,
0.0438337736,
0.3034026325,
0.3502087295,
-0.3134403527,
0.5051891208,
-0.1391523331,
-0.3181468844,
-0.6620278955,
0.2629548311,
0.8049463034,
-0.1601419002,
0.0696148649,
-0.6638264656,
-0.1235203296,
-1.2807699442,
-0.3548600972,
-0.2159487754,
0.0460584499,
0.378955394,
0.5046644211,
-0.1236580387,
0.6996041536,
-0.7640244365,
0.0158705376,
-0.2235719115,
0.2777056992,
0.0715622678,
0.0605222248,
0.7759532332,
-0.8254362345,
0.103477791,
-0.0990950167,
-0.4530976415,
0.1488652229,
0.4369499087,
-0.1913074255,
0.1618672907,
0.5941585898,
-0.5416449904,
0.3536215425,
0.5847603679,
-0.6059877872,
0.6328990459,
-0.3574654162,
-0.2395546287,
-0.8812615275,
-0.2196149975,
0.1999920607,
-0.1007063985,
-0.9563415051,
0.3034365177,
-0.0485892817,
0.0954800844,
-0.0859491527,
0.6094323993,
-0.5990843773,
-0.1683636904,
-0.2801349461,
-0.0888394639,
0.1546154618,
0.8468192816,
0.1568051279,
0.0789470077,
0.6949481964,
-0.9075039625,
0.0728570223,
-0.2024781257,
-0.3484269083,
0.4042494297,
-0.4706012905,
0.0461517945,
-0.5127370954,
-0.1174462736,
-1.174164176,
-0.1565843076,
-0.0410521701,
-0.3060435653,
0.6974590421,
-0.2078672051,
-0.4512912631,
-0.2776385844,
-0.0667182729,
0.2399177104,
0.5697038174,
-0.1704077274,
0.3296684325,
0.6397523284,
-0.2346652001,
-0.7084619999,
-0.4418176711,
-0.1603052318,
-0.2219916284,
-0.093975246,
-0.0247777402,
-0.1644864976,
-0.8340253234,
-0.1381553113,
-0.0827502012,
-0.3355308175,
0.3378328383,
0.3129318357,
0.2660578787,
-0.3797299266,
0.366746217,
-0.3412999213,
0.1103768274,
0.2582537532,
-0.2904276252,
0.3430431783,
-0.2300293148,
0.1534710526,
-0.0023569991,
0.0184864514,
0.586877048,
-0.253257215,
0.8470038176,
0.2583462894,
-0.1565345526,
-0.4916396439,
-0.4497909844,
-0.0835423842,
-0.4356752038,
0.4549690783,
-0.323892653,
-0.5738112926,
0.189264074,
0.1853780448,
0.2010987401,
0.144360438,
0.4155091047,
-0.1333163828,
1.3904095888,
0.9439956546,
0.0680149347,
0.7825551629,
-0.4295384288,
0.3161025941,
-0.4829293787,
0.0574051403,
-0.4644473195,
-0.3867352903,
-0.6849192977,
-0.1906174868,
0.1708434969,
0.1853285581,
-0.1142957211,
0.0040536034,
-0.2149482518,
0.8048552871,
0.3290362358,
0.2370366752,
0.2886318564,
-0.0481379926,
-0.0966708064,
0.2905032635,
-0.6841837764,
-0.4799625874,
1.0090199709,
0.4681591392,
0.5567057133,
0.1692811251,
0.3356077671,
0.0685903579,
-0.0328671932,
-1.0768355131,
0.7875429988,
-0.1726412922,
-0.7702151537,
-0.2331810445,
-0.3037950695,
-1.2865486145,
0.522498548,
-0.3570983112,
-0.558395505,
0.3143306673,
0.335676074,
-0.1955866814,
0.174058646,
-0.8887888789,
0.7476996779,
-0.3696805537,
-0.3870455027,
-0.2283076644,
-0.701690197,
0.4901513159,
0.2385964245,
0.5323921442,
-0.1892851889,
-0.0786314905,
0.7849476337,
-0.2404021025,
0.6651543975,
0.2059565336,
-0.3144185543,
-0.103684932,
0.594379127,
0.1429033875,
-0.4445068538,
0.1688627452,
0.1284959912,
-0.2877491713,
-0.5879507065,
-0.5147309899,
0.887393713,
-0.8930885196,
-0.7695941925,
-0.3360359967,
-0.4670577943,
-0.2289418876,
0.2830933928,
0.1231250688,
0.6940954924,
0.0557603277,
-0.0957632065,
0.6815058589,
-0.097078003,
0.2145888656,
0.6732715368,
-0.33016482,
0.075465031,
0.9877415299,
0.3682637215,
0.6517708302,
0.5136443973,
0.3782790303,
-0.0972825289,
-0.6943938136,
-0.0187352169,
0.5919603109,
-0.7235885859,
0.3543575406,
-0.6250033379,
0.0717832372,
-0.3744791448,
-0.0800242275,
-0.2511579394,
-0.6565765142,
-0.0424251817,
-0.2831919193,
0.1596350521,
1.2487676144,
0.3222232759,
-0.0452357009,
-0.1293781102,
0.5746135712,
0.5006098747,
0.5231284499,
0.0523841493,
-0.5274260044,
-0.2622426748,
0.0693144277,
-0.348641634,
-0.7239127755,
0.548541069,
0.0947603807,
0.4218400717,
0.6338678598,
-0.0988759771,
0.5447282791,
-0.5595869422,
0.6856535077,
0.0356831253,
-0.5448459983,
0.2632020414,
-0.4124017954,
-0.0064571202,
0.1520165205,
0.5320606828,
-0.2516395748,
-0.6031878591,
-0.8877431154,
-0.8374192119,
0.6790519953,
-0.0426126271,
-0.0903748497,
-0.0149041582,
0.3021140099,
0.0676735491,
0.4877374768,
-0.8086487651,
-0.6434262991,
0.0573549643,
-0.0006751316,
-0.7130842209,
-0.2879992425,
-0.1717398316,
-0.1550280005,
0.5227571726,
0.0508654602,
0.1398153007,
-0.1374131739,
-0.0094528217,
-0.1889750957,
0.6620802283,
0.5126128793,
0.7890372276,
-0.1809582412,
0.5416371822,
-0.2125213444,
-0.2196796238,
0.1612250209,
-0.248145476,
-0.0516811199,
0.046897158,
0.3128840923,
0.8320716619,
0.453608036,
-0.4442286789,
0.4410474598,
0.1275170147,
-0.0427084006,
-0.3358466029,
0.1612812579,
-0.0521571077,
0.1216948479,
-0.0319260284,
0.0532032624,
0.1043253765,
-1.1769840717,
-0.1667149812,
0.6685382724,
-0.3266125917,
-0.6402373314,
0.4187624753,
-0.0142471781,
-0.6496741176,
0.0222292151,
-0.1982485801,
-0.4944649041,
0.4802905023,
0.115064472,
0.8011520505,
-0.2588799596,
0.1394078881,
-0.102962628,
0.2450463772,
-0.3645091355,
0.1434196234,
0.0535165258,
-0.9326785207,
-0.1073062047,
-0.7127847075,
-0.2628229856,
0.2550983429,
-0.7523425817,
0.3275024891,
-0.5419860482,
-0.1903077364,
0.4432013035,
-0.1375034899,
-0.6478494406,
0.094684653,
0.3474266827,
0.459118247,
-0.9229854345,
0.5263118148,
0.9657816291,
-0.3301475346,
-0.6730112433,
-0.0635053366,
0.0149419475,
-0.8163768649,
0.6022700071,
-0.0455810018,
-0.0431963243,
-0.1617382169,
-0.6079688072,
-0.7419256568,
0.5963804126,
0.1092780828,
-0.1817147136,
-0.4419205785,
-0.0729489625,
0.8706014752,
-0.3329413533,
0.393340379,
0.5334599614,
0.2229595035,
-0.2553464174,
-0.9932760596,
-0.2452028692,
-0.3390489519,
0.0025943366,
0.4991131425,
-0.6694004536,
0.8325217962,
-0.4069415629,
-0.0630244687,
0.0410188474,
0.2667072117,
-0.1657637656,
0.1856739521,
0.4568607211,
0.5179032087,
0.2879514396,
0.0126912408,
1.32204175,
-0.2339166254,
0.2154257894,
0.7733428478,
-0.0635206029,
0.8958163261,
0.347889781,
-0.1686678082,
0.6668688655,
0.401914835,
0.2314060777,
0.3670429587,
0.3072339892,
0.1068477109,
-0.3321268559,
-0.2105981112,
-0.0614526682,
0.43797189,
0.4757573009,
-0.5623353124,
0.2116466165,
-0.1505702734,
0.2829377651,
0.0382672995,
-0.5312902331,
0.9656188488,
0.2055027187,
-0.8165503144,
0.8665475249,
-0.1973263174,
0.5223391056,
-0.6569263339,
0.0191572141,
-0.0857924223,
0.3364846408,
-0.1812258959,
-0.7796674371,
-0.3828926384,
-0.4716590047,
-0.3128814697,
-0.1998170614,
0.2947619557,
-0.6375962496,
-0.4090972245,
0.3241943717,
0.4172470868,
0.2349043041,
0.3988815844,
-0.525609076,
-0.4425153732,
-0.2894893587,
-0.5021213293,
0.6433630586,
0.5480290651,
-0.0187374186,
0.7694720626,
0.3658016324,
0.5475713015,
0.236652419,
-0.1565116793,
0.4725200832,
-0.7134866714,
-0.5550208688,
-0.6526781917,
0.1441102177,
0.177961722,
-0.3200311959,
0.7592778802,
0.1948141307,
1.0276885033,
-0.1319217384,
0.5225158334,
0.2378073633,
0.3409572542,
-0.470713526,
0.4467116892,
-0.7074093819,
0.2801843584,
-0.388081938,
-0.7244433761,
-0.2567383945,
0.3974764347,
-0.526358366,
0.0320952125,
0.7890480757,
0.8790456653,
-0.0361111425,
-0.1041940153,
0.5155979991,
0.8038406372,
0.07984557,
0.356443733,
0.8244930506,
-0.1449197233,
0.3664071262,
-0.5213118196,
-0.2709722817,
-0.3330819607,
-0.3270747066,
-1.0897485018,
-0.5653275251,
-0.2356075495,
-0.3542038798,
0.0597224943,
0.985668838,
0.6823617816,
-0.581137836,
-0.584882915,
0.0303476565,
0.2712003589,
-0.3904363215,
-0.2498901635,
0.2608895302,
-0.1772878021,
-0.7510590553,
0.2853531539,
0.1009587944,
0.2912553251,
-0.374623239,
-0.031250108,
-0.21217978,
0.1911387146,
0.6599506736,
0.4007432163,
-0.9775343537,
-0.2322460413,
-0.2040392607,
-0.1178385988,
0.0075534945,
0.8642090559,
-0.6254104972,
0.4666436017,
0.6439316273,
0.0025891636,
-0.1304028034,
-0.1481333971,
0.8217288256,
-0.7043280602,
0.2913101315,
0.1373511404,
0.576178968,
0.0338811278,
-0.1214803085,
0.278535068,
0.2137649953,
-0.5361433029,
-1.1064095497,
0.6132341027,
-0.7161685228,
-0.5521894097,
1.367762804,
0.0480358154,
-0.301826179,
-0.2835762501,
-0.0440378413,
-0.1479900032,
-0.4043259919,
1.0437322855,
0.6517615914,
-0.1717683077,
-0.1378495991,
-0.6914727688,
0.7027814984,
0.5152391195,
-0.3767879605,
0.1248339117,
0.4663173556,
0.2313586324,
0.4465330839,
0.2398771346,
-0.0140547659,
0.2466480732,
-0.2776599526,
0.0416385457,
0.1592511833,
-0.5284545422,
-0.5792760849,
0.2343408465,
0.4523300529,
-0.0341873206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02122v1 | Fake News Detection: It's All in the Data! | 2024-07-02T10:12:06 | 2024-07-02T10:12:06 | Soveatin Kuntur, Anna Wróblewska, Marcin Paprzycki, Maria Ganzha | cs.CL | cs.CL | This comprehensive survey serves as an indispensable resource for researchers
embarking on the journey of fake news detection. By highlighting the pivotal
role of dataset quality and diversity, it underscores the significance of these
elements in the effectiveness and robustness of detection models. The survey
meticulously outlines the key features of datasets, various labeling systems
employed, and prevalent biases that can impact model performance. Additionally,
it addresses critical ethical issues and best practices, offering a thorough
overview of the current state of available datasets. Our contribution to this
field is further enriched by the provision of GitHub repository, which
consolidates publicly accessible datasets into a single, user-friendly portal.
This repository is designed to facilitate and stimulate further research and
development efforts aimed at combating the pervasive issue of fake news. | [
-0.2573316693,
-0.8356801867,
0.482888937,
0.0583578125,
-0.2995285988,
0.5100967288,
0.2747082412,
-0.2944332957,
0.3263531029,
0.4652299583,
-0.2186808139,
-0.565748632,
-0.5220139027,
-0.0202437844,
-0.8047790527,
1.2074943781,
0.0770036951,
0.2402481288,
-0.2299201488,
-0.118399635,
-0.1235113516,
-0.3949258924,
0.0676360801,
0.0262313262,
0.604075551,
0.4428816736,
0.5548202991,
0.6898924112,
0.2344022691,
0.0932294205,
0.1175274327,
0.2420129478,
-0.6326054335,
0.0151204895,
-0.2274038941,
-0.2923548818,
-0.1507987976,
0.4243761003,
0.5089734793,
0.3954285085,
-0.067856133,
0.5449097157,
-0.274102062,
0.6024782658,
-0.757781148,
-0.2078095526,
-0.5064846277,
-0.2365521044,
-0.6919761896,
0.0785185546,
-0.1268295199,
-0.7079120874,
-0.2067635953,
-0.5443489552,
0.4424014986,
-0.0418284088,
0.8401607871,
-0.1465919018,
-0.7805613279,
-0.421394974,
-0.6433575153,
0.3802198768,
-0.4489489198,
0.2960185409,
0.1964312941,
0.4524739087,
-0.0179244,
-0.6191349626,
-0.6662541032,
0.0435735472,
0.2308670282,
0.1009141281,
-0.3898845613,
-0.2422630638,
0.1571951956,
0.6161914468,
-0.7775272131,
-0.0127445534,
-0.62771523,
-0.3124474585,
0.4611408114,
0.004138391,
0.3297577202,
-0.2623889446,
-0.1028744653,
-0.2278741151,
-0.5667675138,
-0.1194364801,
0.9747264981,
0.2838232815,
-0.0941526368,
0.435656935,
-0.4763943255,
0.7644726038,
-0.0908227637,
-0.0440672264,
0.3451601863,
-0.694283843,
-0.2690134645,
-0.0663651302,
0.4306646585,
0.224659279,
0.0520997792,
0.1973612607,
-0.3879075944,
0.2840575278,
0.4738882184,
-0.3823663294,
-0.5143443346,
0.114755474,
-0.6978505254,
-0.7184999585,
0.4801041186,
-0.7985131145,
-0.6042314768,
-0.3117062449,
0.2079185545,
-0.0036598372,
-0.6656106114,
-0.04395907,
-0.449749887,
-0.0836170167,
0.3033487797,
-0.0124598658,
0.1273203343,
0.4909680188,
0.6103503108,
0.0406637192,
0.146613881,
-0.4184602499,
-0.1828543097,
-0.5951831341,
0.9670760632,
-0.4811452925,
-0.2763095796,
-0.0243096333,
0.1521462202,
0.2986590564,
-0.662604928,
0.8285403848,
-0.5543562174,
0.4673039615,
-0.4617353678,
-0.6380777955,
-0.3256085813,
0.4900483489,
-0.9730809331,
0.9362975359,
0.4387928247,
-0.6081323624,
0.472899735,
-0.5608149171,
-0.3662441373,
-0.0223913249,
0.0426218063,
-0.6876431704,
0.2642505467,
0.3213321269,
0.1536407918,
-0.0453028195,
0.4331834316,
-0.4014502466,
-0.2679828405,
0.3472189903,
-0.4711555839,
0.9455242157,
0.3523697853,
-0.1104474962,
-0.0966941714,
-0.6482198834,
-0.2093331218,
0.3013344407,
-0.1481959075,
-0.3375771642,
-0.453257829,
0.3825978637,
0.1221288592,
-0.0543802455,
-0.6056119204,
0.2982103527,
0.110186033,
0.0606797785,
0.6514390707,
0.120548144,
0.5007938147,
-0.5445737839,
0.6481366754,
0.3945020735,
0.5639585257,
-0.1429762244,
-0.4306663573,
-0.3997548521,
-0.099130109,
0.7074980736,
0.4509657025,
-0.6611559391,
0.4003198445,
-0.1690623313,
-0.6251971126,
-0.5309640169,
-0.0625657961,
0.2648942769,
0.4615831077,
0.2202084213,
0.0311311558,
-0.5614716411,
-0.8634223342,
-0.5993430018,
-0.1179278344,
-0.0245478265,
-0.0603953451,
1.0478141308,
0.0455754548,
0.9677150846,
-0.3078834713,
-0.1245134696,
-0.1523518413,
-0.0500742123,
0.4463999271,
0.4795490503,
0.7637971044,
-1.2761808634,
-0.413836509,
-0.5221296549,
-0.6385728717,
-0.0807277709,
0.0572690964,
-0.0826431215,
0.204468444,
0.0550445169,
-0.518681407,
0.6324133277,
0.5643650889,
-0.3777019382,
0.605304718,
0.4158815444,
0.5968336463,
-0.9228357077,
0.0027509765,
0.0545551106,
-0.4036867619,
-0.7987844348,
0.0375538655,
0.2872751057,
-0.065506883,
-0.403231293,
0.407635659,
-0.2427656204,
-0.1042604595,
-0.1508064717,
-0.1483425349,
0.4823952019,
-0.3161892891,
-0.4412963986,
0.5696049333,
0.6812976599,
-0.1896850467,
0.7207431197,
0.1120345294,
-0.4796942174,
0.6698069572,
-0.5573542714,
-0.087879099,
-0.1958274692,
0.8573925495,
-0.8486363292,
-0.6776856184,
0.9355080128,
-1.0240482092,
-0.011933363,
-0.3190947473,
-0.8732116222,
-0.3247042298,
-0.338139683,
0.194648236,
0.3647982478,
-0.5803370476,
0.3287861645,
0.7120114565,
0.378798008,
-0.4341323972,
-0.6756414175,
0.2135481238,
-0.248440668,
-0.3128958642,
-0.0304177999,
0.1598507166,
-0.4932215214,
0.1327854395,
-0.2688901126,
-0.2693184316,
-0.1745378822,
-0.0188902169,
0.1708221585,
-0.1290707439,
0.2071055174,
-0.1418316066,
0.1879429668,
-0.1216194257,
-0.2485488951,
0.0912886113,
0.1756493598,
-0.4520478249,
-0.5605946779,
0.4775898457,
0.6680069566,
0.0512351058,
0.630153656,
0.4520992935,
-0.5949046612,
-0.2173967212,
-0.5954410434,
-0.2787146568,
-0.3797566295,
0.0185897835,
0.0552481823,
-0.4795005322,
0.5458719134,
0.1200350896,
-0.0680024102,
0.1814450473,
0.114736028,
-0.1182909384,
0.8186045885,
0.3896223307,
-0.4369750321,
0.2277450413,
-0.1032389626,
0.3979430497,
-0.3069033623,
-0.2693341374,
-0.6391118765,
-0.126579389,
-0.5140587687,
-0.4485442638,
0.0687288344,
-0.0896183178,
-0.0617892258,
0.1098112613,
-0.8494185805,
0.5911967158,
0.5878069997,
0.2758033276,
0.405234009,
0.1353287995,
0.5508416891,
0.0181419831,
-0.4797846973,
-0.5995847583,
1.2901279926,
0.2786498964,
0.5729733706,
-0.0034217685,
0.3175955713,
0.6886931658,
0.3131696284,
-0.4746367633,
0.1753360182,
-0.0603401326,
-1.2123793364,
-0.0949740186,
-0.4195823073,
-0.7464639544,
0.2329838276,
0.154214412,
-0.1216316223,
0.358902216,
0.036870148,
-0.061603006,
0.6988518834,
-0.4382007718,
0.5906863809,
-0.1031560749,
-0.0102222655,
-0.1570817679,
-0.4434603155,
0.7271928787,
-0.2180963755,
0.3318752348,
-0.346196413,
0.0709172338,
0.4605768621,
0.0943167955,
0.6379334331,
-0.2710833848,
0.1171691865,
0.2340209186,
-0.130323112,
0.4573857188,
0.1383066028,
0.170985058,
0.43145594,
-0.2215166837,
-0.6138715744,
-0.1740793288,
0.6526728868,
-0.4403254688,
0.0441722572,
-0.8275676966,
-0.4287271202,
0.0294495542,
0.0098467236,
0.2148404419,
0.3687538207,
-0.4379259944,
0.2423294932,
0.8501378298,
-0.38956815,
-0.030212326,
0.6365885735,
-0.2914544642,
-0.336553812,
0.8448275328,
0.6084389687,
-0.1674456,
-0.2347671837,
-0.0892415494,
-0.5272724032,
-0.4530843198,
-0.4807890952,
0.1122086942,
-0.7365204692,
-0.2774111629,
-0.6155874729,
-0.1236699596,
-0.578648746,
-0.0065261745,
-0.4587336183,
-0.3179372549,
-0.5664556623,
-0.2402830422,
0.3934497237,
0.8618366718,
-0.2244803607,
0.3997212052,
-0.6515159607,
0.7979769111,
0.0846063495,
0.3460408151,
-0.4826986194,
-0.6354990602,
-0.2596091926,
0.3563089967,
-0.3354929388,
-0.8845940828,
0.4426190257,
-0.2609908879,
0.6617540121,
0.4587653279,
0.34640944,
0.3977537751,
0.2111002952,
0.9583724141,
-0.1312483847,
-0.6854013205,
0.6087130308,
-0.8335933089,
-0.0177603364,
0.6727386117,
0.7583507895,
-0.3547306657,
-0.3078982532,
-0.8352615833,
-0.5768474936,
0.4857959747,
0.4018865228,
0.0392059796,
0.2977502048,
0.0394783169,
0.2739529908,
0.4356654286,
-0.8408944607,
-0.2032119632,
-0.2928262949,
-0.093012698,
0.266109556,
0.0613215975,
-0.5377906561,
-0.4099431634,
0.6171302795,
0.0681909546,
0.0806032643,
-0.0930408016,
-0.2364782542,
-0.1151988953,
-0.1167406514,
0.4806751609,
1.1464809179,
0.0079664662,
-0.1915180087,
-0.2656339109,
-0.5155715346,
0.053416539,
-0.0402893983,
-0.3241329491,
0.5477414131,
0.1710148305,
0.3820204139,
-0.1713678688,
-0.4327183366,
0.7577980161,
-0.0419430695,
-0.2911533117,
-0.4474181235,
-0.1588950306,
-0.0340780579,
0.0450298116,
0.9105447531,
0.2746295035,
0.3724140823,
-0.5871011019,
0.2177175134,
0.1188082471,
-0.2298918813,
-0.3707172275,
0.5077116489,
0.2095244825,
-0.046646826,
0.8514736295,
-0.0741336644,
-0.4027536809,
0.8481081724,
0.1633859426,
0.4096206427,
-0.0842596292,
0.6817719936,
0.090669319,
0.5308147669,
-0.4697245657,
0.0841326788,
0.218700707,
-0.7805773616,
0.0333892182,
-0.5059759021,
-0.4499708414,
0.5479574203,
-0.6958817244,
0.1790878028,
-0.2065474689,
-0.0752763152,
-0.0736677796,
-0.062272504,
-0.4010570645,
0.3910823464,
0.3220637441,
0.9652884007,
-1.2201684713,
0.5733183026,
0.5341283083,
-0.5223910809,
-0.2818063498,
0.2603058517,
0.7045006156,
-0.3555319905,
0.1934244931,
0.1812775582,
0.2732684612,
-0.0632164925,
-1.0405533314,
-0.569065392,
0.6240537763,
0.4390311241,
-0.4034214616,
0.1742955893,
0.2822474539,
0.1896532774,
-0.1802695245,
0.1317521334,
0.6534225345,
0.7569279075,
-0.2320933491,
-0.5119562745,
-0.2868745625,
-0.2825734615,
-0.1158116236,
0.0711480305,
-0.6363950372,
0.8427228928,
0.3623765707,
-0.2675203383,
-0.2948732078,
0.4536297023,
0.4670183361,
0.7093439102,
0.307629019,
0.585524261,
0.7463360429,
-0.4286386371,
0.9031369686,
-0.0991587937,
0.2643719912,
0.6735313535,
0.0026088047,
0.0618280917,
0.1402524263,
-0.1937321275,
0.3182224929,
1.0107243061,
-0.521838665,
0.3682835102,
0.2523330152,
-0.241153419,
-0.1618473232,
-0.3735796809,
-0.537969768,
0.5059089661,
0.4839619398,
-0.3740079701,
-0.3445281386,
0.3925458491,
0.2197163105,
0.1268777251,
-0.3772077858,
0.2468494177,
-0.2694853842,
-0.098070249,
0.1535764933,
-0.2703869939,
0.7930132151,
-0.5796976686,
-0.1880083829,
-0.4222739339,
-0.1417090595,
-0.2832057178,
-1.0491827726,
0.3803234398,
-0.0743079409,
-0.3946163952,
-0.3992390037,
0.9886269569,
-0.1067078263,
-0.3634978235,
0.1562039703,
0.6869851351,
0.3266496062,
-0.543530941,
-0.7247494459,
0.3426879346,
-0.1530509144,
-0.3680939674,
0.2706159055,
0.2491423339,
-0.1731926054,
0.6202538013,
1.0238704681,
0.1840093285,
-0.0075238356,
0.1456781626,
1.0890443325,
-0.4762488604,
-0.5732235312,
-0.3959394395,
0.5878841877,
-0.6356731057,
-0.459921509,
0.9195669889,
0.8768537641,
1.1221519709,
-0.2359050661,
1.0510553122,
-0.1294385642,
0.9475164413,
-0.1161493808,
0.9663201571,
-0.3782081008,
-0.0125769386,
-0.0853194445,
-0.7820925117,
-0.2260578275,
0.349947989,
0.1129020751,
0.0381726325,
0.2841796577,
0.7122232318,
-0.3361540437,
0.0458341204,
0.2178123295,
0.0517241843,
0.2230384499,
-0.0897863209,
1.0233640671,
-0.6109987497,
0.728259325,
-0.0102397399,
-0.0627234206,
-0.4392219186,
-0.4283393919,
-0.5500807166,
-0.4998661876,
-0.4293847084,
-0.3969537318,
0.2807968557,
0.2884492278,
0.8633598089,
-0.9578115344,
0.1164667532,
0.1051223502,
0.163262859,
0.0230108947,
-0.3414939046,
0.0301071964,
0.168500334,
-0.6657621861,
0.4833235741,
-0.0587702207,
0.0904664397,
-0.4153383076,
0.1650851965,
-0.2966608703,
0.1698643267,
0.2987782359,
0.4197645783,
-0.4715160131,
0.009693251,
0.0111274105,
-0.3723223805,
-0.0616572015,
0.7764965892,
-0.8767371774,
0.312969774,
0.7705481648,
0.4014362991,
0.2840462327,
0.2932195365,
0.4099364579,
-0.7003520727,
-0.0040745577,
0.357522428,
-0.0425887406,
0.4539260864,
-0.6514669061,
0.6053886414,
0.5778567791,
-0.6756445169,
-1.358112216,
0.1453904659,
-0.771246314,
-0.5535724759,
0.9098328948,
0.2603174448,
-0.1006603241,
-0.7386974096,
0.0108945277,
0.338552624,
-0.7064577341,
0.8010272384,
0.714037776,
-0.0783487037,
-0.183390528,
-0.8256095648,
0.3587310314,
-0.3405884802,
-0.9787367582,
-0.1678580642,
0.8725758791,
0.5312685966,
-0.0631268099,
0.6008393168,
-0.2159968466,
0.3539385498,
0.0317501687,
0.0114275822,
0.0145463785,
-0.4306882918,
-0.3144118488,
0.1338399351,
-0.7903847694,
-0.3961933851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02119v1 | Cost-Effective Proxy Reward Model Construction with On-Policy and Active Learning | 2024-07-02T10:09:19 | 2024-07-02T10:09:19 | Yifang Chen, Shuohang Wang, Ziyi Yang, Hiteshi Sharma, Nikos Karampatziakis, Donghan Yu, Kevin Jamieson, Simon Shaolei Du, Yelong Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF), as a widely adopted
approach in current large language model pipelines, is \textit{bottlenecked by
the size of human preference data}. While traditional methods rely on offline
preference dataset constructions, recent approaches have shifted towards online
settings, where a learner uses a small amount of labeled seed data and a large
pool of unlabeled prompts to iteratively construct new preference data through
self-generated responses and high-quality reward/preference feedback. However,
most current online algorithms still focus on preference labeling during policy
model updating with given feedback oracles, which incurs significant expert
query costs. \textit{We are the first to explore cost-effective proxy reward
oracles construction strategies for further labeling preferences or rewards
with extremely limited labeled data and expert query budgets}. Our approach
introduces two key innovations: (1) on-policy query to avoid OOD and imbalance
issues in seed data, and (2) active learning to select the most informative
data for preference queries. Using these methods, we train a evaluation model
with minimal expert-labeled data, which then effectively labels nine times more
preference pairs for further RLHF training. For instance, our model using
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) gains around over 1% average improvement
on AlpacaEval2, MMLU-5shot and MMLU-0shot, with only 1.7K query cost. Our
methodology is orthogonal to other direct expert query-based strategies and
therefore might be integrated with them to further reduce query costs. | [
-0.3701806962,
-0.5543727279,
0.38978073,
0.0691432729,
0.0293486454,
0.0199360941,
-0.1548317522,
-0.4928977191,
0.4448914826,
0.7778259516,
-0.6001574993,
-0.1927342117,
-0.2176388949,
-0.1712777019,
0.3417108953,
0.8717247248,
0.0324051566,
-0.128333956,
0.0254408866,
-0.2238886207,
-0.0881315842,
-0.6018258333,
-1.1139765978,
-0.3505268991,
0.8275716305,
0.5026488304,
0.6298112869,
1.0889850855,
0.258818835,
0.1578989178,
-0.1161214486,
0.5676804781,
-0.5357414484,
0.1319604814,
-0.1884138733,
-0.4326347411,
-0.5322217941,
0.2699367404,
0.3728888929,
0.6590877771,
-0.5100300312,
0.0279754419,
-0.2265930176,
0.927546978,
-0.9917986989,
0.3505375981,
-0.7504041791,
0.2108944654,
-0.1189403981,
-0.1112058535,
-0.4984125495,
-0.4369715452,
0.2395359278,
-0.6769329906,
0.1153737679,
0.1525455713,
0.8610897064,
0.3291249573,
-0.5119172335,
-0.3519961238,
-0.3981823325,
0.7690263391,
-0.5304324031,
0.4143220484,
0.6958068609,
0.3270684779,
-0.1961586475,
-0.7527762651,
-0.2797217965,
-0.3862099051,
0.150641188,
0.3012342453,
0.1744318306,
0.2489649206,
0.0571100675,
0.2281162441,
-0.204262659,
0.2535981238,
-0.1605521142,
-0.2281657457,
0.723828733,
0.0824852511,
-0.2919799387,
-0.1232383475,
-0.5144231319,
-0.4909032881,
-0.908973217,
0.3811149597,
0.7114624977,
0.5567448139,
0.1991651356,
0.3297273219,
-0.4914005399,
0.7464196682,
0.3625169694,
-0.1777202338,
0.0870446488,
-0.1327791214,
0.1203290373,
0.1486963928,
0.5500767231,
0.1576296687,
0.1411599815,
-0.1809957176,
-0.4094363153,
-0.1200989187,
0.4258537889,
-0.6435734034,
-0.3107884228,
0.1705322415,
-0.4782922566,
-0.4447106421,
-0.0536004677,
-0.6855994463,
-0.4501284063,
-0.1188271046,
0.3579571843,
0.2488265932,
-0.301813066,
0.1275647283,
0.0547590777,
-0.0144582046,
0.3312651813,
-0.9993704557,
0.2760026157,
0.4323698282,
0.6662338972,
-0.4354583323,
-0.1595383584,
-0.9266080856,
0.0515127704,
-0.2564218938,
0.8094890118,
-0.4365211129,
-0.3300673664,
0.342574954,
0.0141012529,
0.0753768459,
-0.6366958618,
0.5465292335,
-0.8012590408,
0.0688964427,
-0.3478371799,
-0.5513803959,
0.1121027693,
0.1908097863,
-0.9792330861,
1.1000393629,
-0.0022211575,
-0.520298779,
0.4978680015,
-0.7451856136,
-0.2036400586,
0.0238332544,
0.0912356749,
-0.4735925198,
-0.2598797977,
0.2183847278,
0.3895851076,
-0.1687386781,
0.353495419,
-0.4001832306,
-0.1650453806,
0.1899044663,
-0.2715833187,
0.5583555102,
0.4316373169,
-0.5950418115,
0.2742820084,
-0.8300369978,
0.0018295681,
0.1726549715,
-0.7552126646,
-0.3868526816,
0.248905763,
-0.2208539844,
0.0970604718,
0.0802798942,
-0.5348441601,
0.4327054322,
-0.5122891068,
0.2810013592,
0.8973234296,
-0.0643751696,
0.5661910176,
-0.0157696698,
0.476436466,
-0.4326081276,
0.4347382486,
0.0441744961,
-0.4586453736,
-0.8113202453,
-0.1500106305,
0.3671957552,
0.3484508693,
-0.8654384017,
0.122760348,
0.073196128,
-0.3566178381,
-0.7021096349,
0.0609790124,
0.6656633019,
0.5970538259,
0.4609942138,
-0.235167712,
-0.1629661173,
-0.886734724,
-0.1594632715,
-0.4315218329,
0.1924792528,
0.5946156979,
0.1819049865,
0.1878150851,
0.9868245125,
-0.8782371879,
-0.1617267132,
-0.1325414926,
0.2770334184,
0.2026778907,
0.2309114188,
0.3383904696,
-0.7797952294,
-0.5938626528,
-0.2609524131,
-0.1599843204,
-0.1306895018,
0.0576806143,
-0.0838595554,
0.4216388166,
0.1517916471,
-0.3697646558,
0.2699923217,
0.4224775732,
-0.4837093949,
0.2978406549,
-0.2906439304,
0.0970726907,
-0.4358458519,
0.0111845573,
-0.008451486,
-0.2372344136,
-0.4316591024,
0.2170545757,
0.2558487058,
-0.0032962291,
-0.8572961092,
0.8485724926,
-0.342502743,
0.0829866678,
-0.4436125457,
-0.1340771466,
-0.2075767815,
1.1209993362,
0.4016751945,
0.6350830793,
0.1444983482,
-0.7550944686,
0.5077490807,
-0.0442769267,
-0.1146636531,
0.25660941,
-0.6573211551,
0.1892347932,
0.0511521772,
0.5078863502,
-0.8117589355,
-0.2488191426,
0.4706106186,
-0.2385611385,
0.1337865591,
-0.201525569,
-0.2258583456,
-0.166937843,
-0.49738428,
0.260351032,
0.4517121315,
-1.0886385441,
0.3165789545,
0.7074302435,
0.0806772038,
-0.8113605976,
-0.3396242559,
-0.2065165639,
-0.1136172265,
-0.2317986637,
0.4751591384,
0.0574550293,
-0.034215562,
0.1086377949,
-0.0921450779,
-0.081433624,
0.0788991004,
0.1238126606,
0.2678354681,
0.260029912,
0.2595880032,
0.0804620385,
-0.2670812309,
0.1137246266,
-0.2846865058,
0.411148876,
-0.0082895057,
-0.3814645708,
-0.0943871364,
0.1174923927,
0.2518134415,
-0.1849807948,
0.8077542186,
0.4773684442,
-0.1126767993,
-0.4440002441,
-0.6316236854,
-0.4766211212,
-0.4151262939,
0.2407225668,
-0.3305624425,
-0.9468218684,
0.2976443172,
-0.0800586119,
0.3510483801,
0.2706822455,
0.4832966626,
0.1733087897,
1.339931488,
0.275283277,
0.0351061597,
0.4385278523,
-0.1181957722,
-0.1442493051,
-0.3443466127,
-0.496410042,
-0.4213208258,
-0.1304000467,
-0.5246872306,
-0.3385119736,
0.3732782602,
-0.0877061859,
-0.4808018506,
0.0282867495,
-0.6266723871,
0.2473294884,
0.9261611104,
0.348633498,
0.1125053614,
0.0620698147,
-0.0755652413,
0.1267838925,
-0.9968276024,
-0.0800799951,
1.2715598345,
0.5104590654,
0.8605738282,
0.0950005502,
0.4633090794,
0.4923455715,
0.0978247672,
-0.8856890798,
0.4514370263,
0.0894463807,
-0.5179082155,
-0.5039845109,
-0.5497769713,
-1.1051962376,
0.2570891082,
-0.4666529,
-0.2115717083,
0.3448189199,
0.6235179305,
-0.3221981823,
0.4236586094,
-0.5468277335,
0.6898028255,
-0.4363020957,
-0.8743203282,
-0.1856244355,
-0.7674762607,
0.1864956021,
0.1555352956,
-0.0656399801,
0.0409744941,
-0.2373751402,
0.893124938,
-0.620903492,
0.8622626066,
-0.4691461027,
0.0245584566,
0.2629123628,
-0.191287145,
0.9645040035,
0.0881741047,
-0.1140314564,
-0.2094948292,
-0.3446566761,
-0.5365988612,
-0.5404646993,
0.7047236562,
-0.9777579904,
-0.4770531952,
-0.5789858699,
-0.3326233327,
-0.4102362096,
-0.1325383633,
-0.0896724537,
0.2861803174,
0.0971718431,
0.0557429381,
1.0280153751,
-0.3386287093,
0.352863282,
0.7502757907,
-0.1096335277,
-0.7538790703,
0.9225934148,
0.0468589887,
0.3332461119,
0.3337320685,
0.4030192792,
-0.6557522416,
-0.1889915019,
-0.621786654,
0.3646611273,
-0.5101969242,
-0.1757428348,
-0.5994118452,
-0.0458046719,
-0.4675003886,
0.0216870308,
-0.8510993719,
-0.5804591179,
-0.0200250335,
-0.1555886269,
0.4573837817,
0.5643208027,
-0.1643502116,
0.2702562213,
-0.5080196857,
0.0846215189,
0.6653885841,
0.4935219288,
0.3086618185,
-0.2789520025,
-0.3960072994,
-0.075476408,
-0.2836741209,
-0.7620148659,
0.4667404294,
0.1017027721,
0.8516240716,
0.6698721051,
0.4652172327,
0.4849003851,
-0.260890305,
0.7525103688,
0.1549420804,
-0.5995197296,
0.5389897823,
-0.2118471414,
0.1009861976,
0.5548372269,
0.5194299817,
-0.3202683032,
0.0416092277,
-0.6951523423,
-1.1380842924,
1.0399138927,
-0.064253509,
-0.1539303064,
-0.0247324463,
0.7173076868,
0.1449154317,
0.2721597254,
-0.840110302,
-0.4957225919,
-0.2468639612,
0.2229618728,
0.1710599959,
-0.2749667764,
-0.1536954492,
-0.1270030588,
0.8854077458,
-0.2523411512,
0.2065117806,
-0.0490888096,
0.2366446704,
-0.1221042871,
0.1597954482,
0.3186413348,
0.4638954699,
-0.5712863803,
0.2257391065,
0.0469914973,
-0.2503758669,
0.1343929172,
-0.1302608699,
-0.2783018351,
-0.3327762783,
0.0839580223,
1.3162713051,
0.2078225911,
-0.7533125877,
0.4243843853,
-0.0102833146,
-0.4344151318,
-0.2272986174,
0.2125277817,
-0.0042183292,
0.0769006982,
0.3292095363,
-0.3061321378,
0.1339703351,
-0.5161293745,
0.0223834645,
0.3902139962,
-0.7432871461,
-0.0286537819,
0.621209383,
0.5026424527,
-0.1938692629,
0.6587247252,
-0.2400100529,
-0.4545785487,
0.5310406089,
0.5739344954,
0.5612848401,
-0.2454121709,
0.5768535137,
0.4908327758,
-0.0120811714,
-0.5455636978,
0.1750580519,
-0.2419372499,
-0.6908254027,
-0.2631973624,
-0.539391458,
-0.8805552721,
0.1631498635,
-0.8527611494,
0.1581322551,
-0.3452205062,
-0.2464863658,
-0.3568153083,
0.1330343187,
-0.4219465256,
0.1918019056,
-0.1878329515,
0.7255749106,
-0.8665567636,
0.8392571211,
0.9572632909,
-0.5899345875,
-0.9246683717,
-0.4242789745,
-0.0824219286,
-0.8824863434,
0.7596703768,
-0.1471820325,
-0.088013716,
-0.0283392537,
-0.4811765254,
-0.8188481927,
0.9160174131,
0.2191862613,
-0.2601868212,
-0.0347872823,
-0.1162581742,
0.3924726546,
-0.3160794079,
0.5032948852,
0.403412044,
0.5543682575,
0.3763780594,
-0.7181386352,
-0.0313782059,
-0.1478952765,
-0.2775121033,
0.3972231746,
-0.8265930414,
0.8943741918,
-0.0055942368,
-0.1241796613,
-0.3296329379,
0.5914075375,
0.4450553358,
0.3911218941,
0.8246617317,
0.5736070275,
0.5810242891,
0.1137204468,
1.0745332241,
-0.2317720801,
0.3215107322,
0.888943851,
-0.3190619051,
0.9867227077,
0.5547271371,
-0.2851558626,
0.218377769,
1.0026142597,
0.0818325654,
1.0223237276,
0.3180346787,
-0.1823262721,
-0.5572454333,
-0.4969997704,
-0.2803247273,
0.1184924394,
0.0802485719,
-0.0735087246,
-0.1181907207,
-0.0341461115,
0.1516854167,
0.1224288791,
-0.4375987351,
0.8352633119,
-0.1918517202,
-1.1671880484,
0.4528001249,
0.1443765908,
0.7304497957,
-0.8249756098,
-0.1995600462,
-0.3828516006,
0.2281015962,
-0.1353065223,
-0.5616924763,
-0.1100190356,
-0.1753935218,
-0.0847482905,
-0.3747240007,
0.7006269693,
-0.5137353539,
-0.1201085001,
0.339210391,
0.5058678389,
0.0793334991,
0.0051200776,
-0.8980379105,
-0.1985184997,
0.0530160666,
-0.4909239709,
0.5983471274,
-0.0594787709,
-0.2400346845,
0.6808499694,
0.8012099266,
0.5198036432,
-0.0109827956,
0.0495519191,
0.8494715095,
-0.4791264236,
-0.7604404092,
-0.3785016239,
0.3600229919,
-0.2284233272,
-0.3160392046,
0.5241577625,
0.3754167557,
0.9151515961,
-0.0897106156,
0.6106435657,
0.1932122558,
0.640381515,
-0.5452390313,
0.550581634,
-0.7579519153,
0.3034043312,
-0.0716304928,
-0.8917566538,
-0.1379598081,
0.6725840569,
-0.1421841234,
-0.1245392039,
0.5808882117,
0.8901863694,
0.0513223857,
-0.2287718803,
0.0337492004,
-0.2941457033,
0.3074800968,
0.5008528829,
0.7844572067,
-0.0853338391,
0.6137127876,
-0.3865152597,
-0.508749187,
-0.2952192724,
-0.9367192984,
-0.8930895925,
-0.4709883332,
-0.3613965511,
-0.4192781746,
0.4294812381,
1.3699319363,
0.7471593618,
-0.8641040325,
-0.4650114179,
-0.0251543969,
0.189007923,
-0.507252574,
-0.2292930633,
0.7481805086,
-0.408608973,
-0.7681524158,
0.4578352869,
0.0892644897,
-0.2925091684,
-0.4188705385,
-0.487233609,
-0.408703357,
0.1961310655,
0.4648533463,
0.6338892579,
-0.730687201,
-0.1604154706,
0.0726138949,
-0.1103848368,
-0.1182084009,
0.8483926058,
-0.9215379357,
0.6286312342,
0.5572044253,
0.9255720973,
0.7544690371,
0.1353491247,
0.4642429054,
-0.3920023739,
0.021598801,
0.009260674,
0.0456720367,
0.004449239,
-0.4034188986,
0.8412519693,
0.3744418919,
-0.6104847789,
-0.9344769716,
0.23437953,
-0.9152146578,
-0.3705198765,
1.1644271612,
-0.3448796272,
-0.0949805975,
-0.1917358339,
-0.1431915462,
0.212294206,
-0.8525246382,
1.0350528955,
0.355540812,
-0.5792369246,
-0.0090176817,
-0.3866541684,
0.7418891788,
0.49980551,
-0.6596165895,
-0.0591598749,
0.5863080025,
-0.0545978546,
-0.108278051,
0.650806129,
0.1738371402,
0.1927915961,
-0.0018085137,
0.281368196,
-0.5511776209,
-0.4634642601,
-0.0497536846,
0.6209729314,
0.2698402405,
-0.2906914949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02118v1 | Breaking Language Barriers: Cross-Lingual Continual Pre-Training at Scale | 2024-07-02T10:06:41 | 2024-07-02T10:06:41 | Wenzhen Zheng, Wenbo Pan, Xu Xu, Libo Qin, Li Yue, Ming Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant strides
towards Artificial General Intelligence. However, training these models from
scratch requires substantial computational resources and vast amounts of text
data. In this paper, we explore an alternative approach to constructing an LLM
for a new language by continually pretraining (CPT) from existing pretrained
LLMs, instead of using randomly initialized parameters. Based on parallel
experiments on 40 model sizes ranging from 40M to 5B parameters, we find that
1) CPT converges faster and saves significant resources in a scalable manner;
2) CPT adheres to an extended scaling law derived from Hoffmann et al. (2022)
with a joint data-parameter scaling term; 3) The compute-optimal data-parameter
allocation for CPT markedly differs based on our estimated scaling factors; 4)
The effectiveness of transfer at scale is influenced by training duration and
linguistic properties, while robust to data replaying, a method that
effectively mitigates catastrophic forgetting in CPT. We hope our findings
provide deeper insights into the transferability of LLMs at scale for the
research community. | [
-0.4064359069,
-0.5224465132,
0.5087665915,
0.3365008235,
-0.2645144165,
0.2153892964,
-0.5718576908,
-0.2846513391,
0.0840643421,
0.4511388838,
-0.4670717716,
0.0270578116,
-0.6985043287,
0.031706091,
-0.2305365205,
0.9309397936,
-0.2973640561,
0.0174160544,
-0.2106544375,
-0.147368446,
-0.3533830345,
-0.718378365,
-0.8032014966,
-0.3144144118,
0.7001430392,
0.260727942,
0.5745152235,
0.7508315444,
0.2478202581,
0.3122060299,
0.3053625524,
-0.1924035251,
-0.6511985064,
-0.2072718143,
-0.2506084144,
-0.5756732821,
-0.2110151947,
0.0994613618,
1.0131373405,
1.0161123276,
-0.0210468434,
-0.0065045259,
0.2907144725,
0.7032902837,
-0.4236249626,
0.0804597512,
-0.6579449177,
0.0329712816,
-0.446143508,
0.0434957892,
-0.3714859188,
-0.242871359,
0.1725750417,
-0.6636757255,
0.0323377475,
-0.0151462732,
0.8224271536,
0.1707289815,
-0.1094603911,
-0.2239666432,
-0.8092814684,
0.9148759246,
-0.4288338721,
0.7374803424,
0.2468302995,
0.1014713421,
0.2050092369,
-0.898006618,
-0.4135324955,
-0.5835638046,
0.0951865539,
-0.2228038013,
-0.0325409509,
-0.1540394127,
0.0919666067,
0.0578194074,
-0.5715739131,
0.2675444186,
-0.3607563376,
-0.1346539706,
0.4633273482,
-0.0652708709,
0.4501838386,
0.4461015463,
-0.19587183,
-0.0187342558,
-1.0901770592,
-0.0914114788,
0.0766960829,
0.4066322148,
-0.078725867,
0.1047607437,
0.1346463263,
0.4363827407,
0.1523475796,
-0.1279658377,
0.2135431916,
-0.5051862597,
0.2411005646,
-0.0550260432,
0.8102644682,
-0.1471316516,
0.6612353325,
-0.4594764411,
-0.0052996748,
-0.1448767781,
0.2360937148,
-0.8210578561,
-0.3589070141,
-0.2752047181,
-0.1953185797,
0.1495268792,
-0.3494107127,
-0.4986729324,
0.0265054461,
-0.5699675083,
0.417208612,
-0.3963777125,
-0.2901018858,
-0.0840837955,
0.5337123275,
0.0427298322,
0.1410150528,
-1.096113205,
0.2801455259,
0.4268676937,
0.9463065863,
-0.2816011012,
-0.6726350784,
-0.5538419485,
0.0323359221,
-0.5302804708,
0.5523427129,
-0.5012360811,
-0.4072604775,
-0.1105559543,
0.0796371549,
-0.1999616772,
-0.5738276243,
-0.0222417861,
-0.5660731196,
0.0429962091,
-0.2287181318,
-0.3700250685,
0.230306074,
0.3759945035,
-0.5830149055,
0.7700094581,
0.1882789135,
-0.5532200336,
0.4268467724,
-0.387891233,
-0.5884658694,
0.2402602583,
-0.1404746175,
-0.2623312771,
-0.0557671748,
0.2449114919,
0.1797689497,
-0.476916194,
0.2317563146,
-0.3592959642,
-0.1953536123,
-0.1171320453,
-0.3973011374,
0.6785308123,
0.0699734986,
-0.2797433734,
-0.1957766712,
-0.6060473323,
0.0470094904,
0.0948358923,
-0.5083182454,
-0.3586027622,
-0.1157411188,
-0.2550712824,
0.2103179693,
0.5185367465,
-0.5471041799,
0.1177078784,
-0.2724094987,
0.3157763779,
0.6527620554,
-0.2418946922,
0.635355413,
-0.3977692723,
0.682298243,
-0.1482653916,
0.047153879,
-0.0837433264,
-0.0669844151,
-0.7830838561,
-0.2539522052,
0.3281698525,
0.5847353339,
-0.7182706594,
0.3244444728,
-0.4931306839,
-0.5114387274,
-0.311644882,
0.4997745156,
0.3122587204,
0.2308050543,
0.3396002352,
-0.426389724,
-0.5817189217,
-0.6144809127,
-0.2813393474,
-0.1905629039,
-0.2815644145,
0.1272219867,
0.2757526636,
-0.2118717879,
0.8745738268,
-0.0620473139,
-0.0204039086,
-0.4223273993,
0.1253921241,
0.0499395803,
0.6350951195,
0.5092972517,
-0.4395298064,
-0.7662534118,
0.0600012019,
-0.63702178,
-0.1591894925,
-0.348112613,
-0.0418368317,
0.1088408604,
0.8906643391,
-0.4016450346,
0.0499625877,
0.5852989554,
0.0369983688,
0.5909424424,
-0.4411977232,
-0.0985766798,
-0.8797136545,
-0.0218255147,
-0.2596921921,
-0.085004881,
-0.7016996145,
-0.1942579001,
0.0273987129,
-0.1079794094,
-0.5202009082,
0.7259536386,
-0.6749011278,
0.1469120532,
-0.2323517203,
0.0891798958,
-0.2987411916,
0.5119640827,
0.1159701124,
0.6290804148,
0.6804718971,
-0.6819664836,
0.1787615418,
-0.0126421573,
-0.125371173,
0.6225341558,
-0.5890125632,
0.2988148928,
0.0248460304,
0.2779538631,
-0.5897969007,
0.1734761745,
-0.0053356807,
-0.1809020936,
0.4027136862,
-0.0572495759,
-0.4499002397,
-0.1977220476,
-0.0095875449,
0.7989304066,
0.6059913635,
-0.6818082929,
0.6208359003,
0.3483245969,
-0.5442069769,
-0.1758565456,
-0.7025225163,
0.2160307169,
-0.2509694695,
-0.4742129445,
0.2393116951,
-0.1972851753,
-0.1202930734,
-0.0531095453,
0.1216150075,
-0.0964425355,
-0.0558145791,
0.0142283672,
0.0845257491,
-0.3492856324,
0.1362041831,
-0.2392683029,
-0.050327532,
0.1624289304,
-0.6842310429,
0.7107887864,
-0.2338502854,
-0.2472985536,
-0.2981564999,
0.2695976496,
0.5687775016,
-0.3177736104,
0.7600985765,
0.4128844738,
-0.1715367287,
-0.3189807832,
-0.3422473371,
0.003355175,
-0.4782105088,
0.4978770912,
-0.3761923611,
-1.0781469345,
0.3886986673,
-0.2350445539,
0.0502392128,
0.2666565478,
0.5953151584,
0.2098214626,
0.7087939382,
0.9567777514,
-0.3964935243,
0.597227037,
0.1622755677,
0.3021277487,
-0.5094899535,
-0.0924223736,
-0.4135783315,
-0.1677146703,
-0.5056703687,
-0.5963431001,
0.3197002709,
0.2145705223,
-0.5955491662,
0.3595359921,
-0.0825462267,
0.5399971008,
0.3377562165,
-0.0696429238,
0.129246816,
-0.0898184702,
-0.1175146177,
-0.0083655259,
-0.9435596466,
-0.1395606399,
1.2878206968,
0.2965593636,
0.7382906079,
-0.1446438879,
0.7316533923,
-0.0767760798,
0.739536643,
-0.4112845659,
0.5493318439,
-0.2964406312,
-0.4687523246,
-0.6454640627,
-0.6364878416,
-1.0153363943,
0.1669474542,
-0.0219149068,
-0.6628139615,
-0.1338178515,
0.1143770367,
-0.1893320531,
0.4830870032,
-0.4330362082,
0.6163805723,
-0.5529401898,
-0.4078911543,
-0.2741679847,
-0.5505365133,
0.1703271121,
-0.6738459468,
0.3623925745,
0.0572293289,
-0.0822806507,
0.8206181526,
-0.5285349488,
0.8754765987,
-0.0897125378,
-0.23447299,
0.2628697753,
-0.032539364,
0.4837360084,
-0.0002717514,
0.1273274273,
0.2421312779,
-0.1909661293,
-0.6686093807,
-0.475091815,
0.5832320452,
-0.7639455199,
-0.6368641257,
-0.1046165153,
-0.7976120114,
-0.4907253981,
0.3866511583,
0.2564722002,
0.1960111707,
-0.2678241134,
0.2518697083,
0.5671578646,
-0.2787329257,
0.3602126241,
0.5145416856,
-0.1615614742,
-0.3061078489,
1.018316865,
0.4182698727,
0.5529116392,
0.3397651017,
0.2778544724,
-0.2330262661,
-0.5928083062,
-0.3091002405,
0.4121679068,
-0.3763995171,
0.2305075824,
-0.546995163,
-0.3937827647,
-0.4217134714,
-0.438726306,
-0.7219224572,
-0.072489664,
-0.051045727,
0.0920243636,
0.1568623334,
0.5359246731,
-0.4658944905,
0.2984285951,
-0.9176058173,
0.1538998783,
0.4607684016,
0.3170338571,
0.0096754869,
-0.6630592942,
-0.4999575615,
0.0364999436,
0.0676984489,
-0.3616382778,
0.3110448122,
0.3338172138,
0.6432168484,
0.2853267789,
-0.0588744842,
0.6068009138,
-0.8277848959,
0.7212471962,
0.4727383852,
-0.9598098993,
0.2355042547,
-0.2942930162,
0.7477632761,
0.6549297571,
0.6758403778,
-0.5160219669,
-0.4327817559,
-0.4929876924,
-0.9433790445,
0.4615525603,
-0.1127175838,
0.3264113963,
0.0665476918,
0.3912156224,
0.1012813449,
-0.1212732419,
-0.7954385281,
0.1196016222,
-0.1056313515,
-0.0112446556,
-0.4430044889,
-0.0525322445,
-0.0426376835,
-0.3931362629,
0.5266796947,
-0.0202728473,
-0.1352817118,
-0.1225581393,
-0.3467777073,
0.1830500066,
0.0515506752,
0.3247970939,
0.7358606458,
0.1475591213,
0.2306639999,
0.5968821049,
-0.6328562498,
0.4584487081,
0.0521519892,
0.0487129129,
-0.1659987569,
0.6260967255,
0.6312152743,
0.2414304167,
-0.6709392071,
0.302937746,
0.0998401865,
-0.4680042863,
-0.2418824285,
-0.1426668763,
0.2123491466,
0.2001485378,
0.0283597838,
-0.2796294987,
-0.6433613896,
-0.6212615371,
0.5884033442,
0.155699417,
-0.3190171719,
-0.4462894499,
0.7159212232,
0.2359128296,
-0.2144220471,
0.8401677012,
-0.092206955,
-0.4304401875,
0.4352121651,
0.5876252651,
0.6310529709,
-0.4832684398,
0.0768554583,
0.2746575773,
0.4874292314,
-0.4248205721,
-0.1715399921,
-0.1521817595,
-0.8088561893,
-0.527841568,
-0.682531476,
-0.3520970643,
0.175958842,
-0.366989702,
0.0385800339,
-0.7987359166,
0.1777369231,
-0.2902698815,
0.0077111046,
-0.7022359371,
0.25487867,
0.2693973482,
0.6759275198,
-0.777482152,
1.1301127672,
0.3716287911,
-0.237977013,
-0.8904957175,
0.0307183061,
-0.1001444012,
-0.8296275735,
0.6295751333,
0.0612133667,
-0.1965176016,
-0.0227267593,
-0.4447883368,
-1.0360324383,
0.8475627899,
0.5505121946,
-0.8402660489,
-0.1391208768,
0.4771001041,
0.5090199709,
-0.4727641642,
-0.1419177204,
0.8993558884,
0.3927989006,
0.0317158662,
-1.0181381702,
0.1401496679,
-0.1678164005,
-0.0480339341,
0.2391170859,
-0.5875913501,
1.1012387276,
-0.1774699241,
-0.1868515462,
0.062807709,
0.6832386255,
0.2456932515,
-0.0627087429,
0.7741472721,
0.6062743068,
0.7284623384,
0.1892646253,
0.7937566042,
-0.4607162178,
0.1077774987,
1.1467204094,
-0.3897484541,
0.7049586773,
0.3877551556,
-0.3052792251,
0.3974782228,
0.519575119,
0.0741421506,
0.3481352329,
0.6343253851,
-0.3933459818,
-0.2771577835,
-0.0293552671,
-0.4232658148,
0.1559926867,
0.1411885619,
-0.030346239,
-0.3350926936,
0.3422246873,
0.3659779131,
0.0603422038,
-0.4297138453,
0.4106613696,
0.2768924236,
-0.6007005572,
0.8528026342,
-0.3816044033,
0.7369607687,
-0.7863130569,
0.4114477038,
-0.424341619,
0.2648133039,
0.1778405309,
-0.3069656193,
0.3235217631,
0.1705909818,
0.0081157237,
-0.5531201363,
0.2354515195,
-0.6628009677,
-0.5446283817,
0.4455076158,
0.4423753917,
0.3338072896,
-0.095370926,
-0.50811553,
-0.0130269732,
-0.0336160846,
-0.2864117026,
0.6558558345,
0.5869905353,
-0.2482923865,
0.6854203939,
0.6580587626,
0.3480404615,
0.2101203352,
0.0855828151,
0.9194463491,
-0.5137703419,
-0.6088497043,
-0.6546938419,
0.1949632317,
0.341270119,
-0.3516210318,
0.5701419711,
0.3849544227,
0.9866377711,
0.1676531732,
0.901695013,
-0.0353827141,
0.3271302283,
-0.491371125,
0.8396671414,
-0.5291475058,
0.2579540908,
0.024403451,
-0.8061484694,
-0.2963145673,
0.1902037114,
-0.388551563,
0.0915979818,
0.8131136298,
0.7023671865,
0.0755562931,
-0.3804961145,
0.3780843914,
0.2377411872,
0.404737711,
0.8393482566,
0.6829299331,
0.1771722585,
0.7370615602,
0.0252069756,
-0.3302816749,
0.2112096995,
-0.6653246284,
-0.9327485561,
-0.4530497193,
-0.201624766,
-0.0647979751,
0.2026728839,
0.6526615024,
0.7587577701,
-0.5929200649,
-0.4433372319,
-0.3129677176,
-0.225207299,
-0.0398456119,
-0.0783404484,
0.2574743032,
-0.7033082843,
-0.6294116974,
0.4652370811,
0.1944082528,
-0.0508069992,
-0.3816391826,
-0.3436512649,
-0.2608056664,
0.2774749696,
0.5066714883,
0.689809382,
-0.2831614614,
-0.5003592968,
-0.2396037132,
0.0005078124,
0.0422823764,
0.8294708729,
-0.6668179631,
0.303178072,
0.3266942799,
1.0751489401,
0.584215939,
-0.353569746,
0.911862731,
-0.5429595113,
0.3762735426,
0.2548875511,
0.1050018147,
0.261343807,
-0.1104545146,
0.3107205927,
0.3429189622,
-0.5593640804,
-0.6835529804,
0.3576722443,
-0.584189415,
-0.4321552813,
0.9414167404,
-0.383197844,
-0.1374741793,
-0.0860206634,
0.1870243102,
0.2089105099,
0.2089866102,
0.6187754869,
0.7452173233,
-0.1812651306,
-0.3426294327,
-0.392847538,
0.3807356358,
0.6463255882,
-0.9358823299,
0.0628480837,
0.0845298022,
0.4910853207,
0.0703226179,
0.8912133574,
-0.1814210266,
0.0187913459,
0.324834913,
0.049726028,
0.140669778,
-0.6894691586,
-0.2708108723,
0.1720886976,
0.1111126915,
-0.0231283698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02099v1 | Helpful assistant or fruitful facilitator? Investigating how personas affect language model behavior | 2024-07-02T09:36:54 | 2024-07-02T09:36:54 | Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | One way to personalize and steer generations from large language models (LLM)
is to assign a persona: a role that describes how the user expects the LLM to
behave (e.g., a helpful assistant, a teacher, a woman). This paper investigates
how personas affect diverse aspects of model behavior. We assign to seven LLMs
162 personas from 12 categories spanning variables like gender, sexual
orientation, and occupation. We prompt them to answer questions from five
datasets covering objective (e.g., questions about math and history) and
subjective tasks (e.g., questions about beliefs and values). We also compare
persona's generations to two baseline settings: a control persona setting with
30 paraphrases of "a helpful assistant" to control for models' prompt
sensitivity, and an empty persona setting where no persona is assigned. We find
that for all models and datasets, personas show greater variability than the
control setting and that some measures of persona behavior generalize across
models. | [
-0.2044105232,
-0.7839562297,
0.6468048692,
0.4288926423,
0.1470885575,
-0.2042266577,
-0.0037676706,
-0.3349665999,
0.0246075019,
0.5455827713,
-0.5698422194,
0.110601075,
-0.5469497442,
0.2223680764,
-0.2439728379,
1.0963003635,
0.3447134495,
0.2519030571,
-0.4544833004,
-0.1387468427,
-0.682772398,
-0.4686886668,
-0.9477656484,
-0.3624685407,
0.7847890854,
0.4366167188,
1.0095347166,
0.3169077337,
0.1947477907,
0.4420700371,
-0.0522818416,
-0.1861056536,
-0.2237052768,
0.5324321389,
-0.3151552081,
-0.7113572955,
-0.556394875,
-0.0046206401,
0.2366625965,
1.0350644588,
0.0898595229,
0.1522315443,
0.4108495712,
0.395336628,
-0.406956315,
0.2710268795,
-0.3100454211,
-0.2185549289,
-0.2771774232,
-0.1126808673,
-0.3872195184,
-0.4411541224,
0.2580341399,
-0.7280268073,
0.268964231,
-0.0650336668,
0.2790342569,
0.1371672451,
-0.8435912132,
-0.4158195853,
-0.9697168469,
0.9014283419,
-0.3727722168,
0.1486006379,
0.6429743171,
0.1231853366,
-0.3416302502,
-0.2077554464,
-0.307805568,
-0.1950217485,
-0.1836206764,
-0.2130446136,
-0.3640207648,
-0.012898122,
0.2952914834,
0.3147316873,
-0.3231132925,
0.1271493137,
-0.0895535573,
-0.2016117871,
0.4572123289,
0.2965439856,
0.4341730773,
-0.2438937426,
0.1046290472,
0.1275511235,
-0.4536112547,
0.220794782,
0.692281127,
0.2399680465,
-0.0507143922,
0.5272321701,
-0.1067567095,
0.7805860639,
0.3215134144,
-0.3214306235,
0.0906106234,
-0.286560446,
-0.0801500976,
-0.3829216361,
0.4951212108,
0.2880012095,
0.7134216428,
-0.1548756361,
-0.1523182243,
-0.309045583,
0.2797399163,
-0.4133305252,
-0.3986729681,
-0.0572111271,
-0.4668672979,
-0.0287191309,
-0.1143912971,
-0.74156183,
-0.8750742078,
-0.4296436012,
0.2848192155,
-0.2791225016,
-0.1372645795,
-0.3301106989,
-0.0563113466,
0.4538972974,
0.5827219486,
-1.2771859169,
0.4704710543,
0.414879024,
0.4480378926,
-0.0644100904,
-0.3385261297,
-0.8712975383,
0.0442667753,
0.0326526873,
0.618558526,
-0.938331306,
-0.7351940274,
-0.0573375486,
0.0417884476,
-0.2903032005,
-0.6284531355,
0.3043098748,
-0.1761751473,
0.5224842429,
-0.6937975883,
-0.2138254791,
0.0894353092,
-0.1367650032,
-0.4992006123,
0.6156648397,
0.4162936807,
-0.7284183502,
0.2851346731,
-0.4775398076,
-0.3960810602,
0.0737748146,
-0.3592506051,
0.009026044,
0.3745634854,
0.1771335155,
0.5730865598,
-0.2203508466,
0.1106485128,
-0.2384566218,
-0.1599300951,
0.7723650336,
-0.3821116686,
1.0123659372,
0.0411482826,
-0.2222462147,
0.2576422989,
-0.6228168011,
-0.5051355958,
0.2108222544,
-0.3221997917,
-0.6387525797,
-0.1643576473,
0.0029057635,
0.298325628,
0.1623834968,
-0.2495924383,
0.4221092165,
-0.0221070927,
-0.1557005793,
0.9592226744,
0.3173045218,
0.5718795657,
-0.4996001422,
0.9475048184,
-0.294683218,
0.2253194451,
-0.3018078506,
-0.8209164143,
-0.8091446161,
-0.1189099923,
0.03240747,
0.479027003,
-0.7354905605,
0.1715537012,
0.0755189657,
-0.2813020051,
-0.5778133869,
0.4307730794,
0.2827325761,
0.4713707566,
0.0510476194,
-0.1696245223,
-0.0927498341,
-1.1353287697,
-0.3247738779,
-0.2442820519,
-0.2934878767,
0.558111012,
0.2866023779,
0.0417346992,
0.7808540463,
-0.4717188776,
-0.1847001612,
-0.3945359588,
-0.1447260678,
-0.1635352075,
0.3108244538,
1.0053873062,
-0.754336834,
-0.5749665499,
-0.3333263695,
-0.3358044326,
-0.5271092057,
-0.2795746326,
0.1094540358,
0.006058115,
0.1480759382,
-0.3366714418,
0.2088574022,
0.4430644214,
-0.6755705476,
0.4988870621,
-0.2786629796,
0.1683071703,
-1.0697493553,
0.1356526613,
0.3226264417,
-0.0596388206,
-0.9898100495,
-0.0240803547,
-0.3148861229,
0.1539892703,
-0.2410588562,
0.6280412078,
-0.4416816533,
-0.1462581307,
-0.3836258948,
0.0393839665,
-0.220024243,
0.4313988686,
-0.0478587598,
1.016497612,
0.5307331085,
-0.8143514395,
0.0852383971,
0.4411072731,
0.1198204607,
0.8754810691,
-0.5843696594,
0.4210781455,
-0.067747958,
0.0030238582,
-1.1686581373,
-0.3701176643,
0.3775940537,
-0.3739563823,
0.1127168164,
0.1079870015,
-0.4784525931,
0.0592859201,
-0.2392897308,
0.0991580263,
0.2573123276,
-0.262899965,
0.7869276404,
0.3665789664,
-0.5752426386,
-0.162834689,
-0.7228047252,
-0.037920054,
-0.5025045872,
-0.3659276962,
0.1138096154,
-0.4628441632,
-0.6051167846,
-0.4102214575,
-0.0743752196,
-0.2017426491,
0.4819147289,
0.314499557,
0.2351512611,
0.0509839468,
-0.1108646616,
-0.0349084362,
-0.0052866042,
0.2642475069,
0.3357661963,
0.5959550142,
-0.0215959046,
-0.2200096101,
-0.249200359,
0.4082863629,
0.6012665033,
-0.1686495692,
0.8308364153,
0.3587174714,
-0.0604677685,
0.2178760916,
-0.5143162012,
-0.120962292,
-0.512547195,
0.1136815995,
-0.3953888714,
-0.8233602047,
0.8117941618,
0.4419647753,
0.0927544832,
0.1372918189,
0.4732574821,
0.1217964739,
0.9769660234,
0.689614892,
-0.1264944971,
0.6561579108,
0.0723150298,
0.1285763532,
-0.866902709,
-0.4514623284,
-0.810190618,
-0.294909656,
-0.550871253,
-0.1644866616,
-0.0014085473,
-0.3001451194,
0.0005603014,
0.1147402823,
-0.2042921782,
0.052511774,
0.5892156959,
-0.1503702849,
0.215880096,
-0.1951995939,
0.1449859887,
-0.2452518195,
-0.6321760416,
-0.7152331471,
0.8827630877,
0.43049106,
0.8465938568,
0.5484697223,
0.4957370758,
0.1523046643,
0.3017546833,
-0.7551125884,
0.8549494147,
-0.1801498979,
-0.5999785066,
0.0681084022,
-0.3020910323,
-1.0233540535,
0.018413594,
-0.0504693985,
-1.0428463221,
0.4487803876,
0.517236352,
-0.43723768,
-0.1167648882,
-0.7719956636,
0.7414540648,
-0.3014401793,
-0.5145608187,
0.1107792407,
-0.6714978218,
0.2679107189,
-0.0634116456,
0.1952537596,
0.100222975,
-0.1912458539,
0.7291822433,
-0.0098506957,
1.0840991735,
-0.4454803467,
-0.1994370073,
-0.0819304958,
0.4304360747,
0.2994376123,
-0.2499410361,
-0.2753587961,
-0.5101399422,
-0.1272767484,
-0.4377184808,
-0.5932769179,
0.9257432818,
-0.7747005224,
-1.0623503923,
-0.3773948252,
-0.8082821965,
-0.5351347327,
0.0696475133,
0.0454374999,
0.2729374468,
-0.1622537225,
0.5268216133,
0.7212594748,
-0.4415200055,
0.3038366139,
0.5047292113,
-0.211724788,
0.0238483958,
0.6072335839,
-0.0063382518,
0.5631486177,
0.176882118,
0.4153079093,
-0.1801229715,
-0.1630927622,
-0.1548724174,
0.1659617573,
-0.8287114501,
0.0882333666,
-0.6955603957,
0.2467399836,
-0.6224123836,
-0.0993539318,
0.2279597521,
-0.3265831172,
-0.6508517265,
0.0288060512,
0.3391580582,
0.7677496076,
0.4958140254,
0.6435745358,
-0.4252710342,
0.1707372814,
0.6537579298,
-0.0706807077,
0.0259297006,
-0.6263363361,
0.1535684615,
-0.2106642127,
-0.3288607299,
-1.1353961229,
0.0656610653,
0.2447559237,
0.9376519322,
0.5669901967,
-0.1696579754,
0.5393127203,
-0.1799835116,
1.1767987013,
-0.1275714338,
-0.7850170135,
0.4778772891,
-0.5549263954,
0.5305358768,
0.5294814706,
0.3052041531,
-0.5391485691,
-0.6583006978,
-0.5877249837,
-0.5725738406,
0.9249716401,
0.1940646768,
0.6318510175,
0.0154482471,
0.5025447011,
0.298203975,
0.3652072549,
-0.869651556,
-0.7069296837,
-0.1873948574,
0.0552619882,
0.076827094,
-0.3927854896,
0.242541045,
-0.1435136944,
0.4992388487,
-0.0650094748,
0.3308058679,
-0.1069482863,
0.1756333858,
-0.2371172011,
0.5756138563,
0.5043874979,
0.5903732777,
0.1640808284,
-0.0025695032,
0.1292332113,
-0.2614062726,
0.0980078131,
0.1113301218,
-0.27286309,
-0.2115416527,
0.3905510604,
0.9111793637,
0.3536803424,
-0.2337815464,
0.406108737,
-0.1733099967,
0.066675581,
-0.0512931123,
0.7992814779,
-0.0045227944,
0.0389675498,
0.521723628,
-0.0530099422,
0.2150139064,
-0.7895988822,
-0.1265950799,
0.482049495,
0.0624465868,
-0.5502927899,
0.7338495255,
0.3368459344,
-0.7893767357,
0.4640610218,
0.0194332171,
-0.3683386743,
0.4055446386,
0.6672163606,
0.8614675999,
-0.9046099782,
0.3358573318,
-0.1448300332,
0.1123385057,
0.2612628937,
0.0398152471,
-0.1563345343,
-0.6583065391,
-0.0850007683,
-0.3233891726,
-0.4204724133,
0.5325078368,
-0.6957007647,
-0.0029178238,
-0.2769882083,
-0.0816531107,
0.1802252233,
0.0904807374,
-0.8564674258,
0.2096574157,
-0.0971211269,
0.7505319715,
-1.1584020853,
0.8325545788,
1.0337529182,
-0.450415194,
-0.7570279837,
0.5535759926,
0.1501287967,
-0.3650738001,
0.3664103448,
-0.1764039993,
-0.1047115326,
-0.1335779428,
-0.1527156383,
-0.6341226101,
0.9032537937,
0.7437559962,
-0.2657271922,
-0.1791462153,
0.114390932,
0.75889498,
-0.4504867494,
0.0338689797,
0.536044538,
0.5078902245,
-0.0123440772,
-1.0696378946,
-0.1176389977,
-0.3444384038,
-0.0042713783,
-0.2072631568,
-0.7033634186,
0.7470500469,
-0.120821327,
0.2812523246,
0.3588450551,
0.555634141,
0.3101392388,
0.3096640706,
0.7708696127,
-0.3801388443,
0.7433488369,
0.1243773997,
1.287396431,
-0.0815876946,
-0.2308445275,
1.216452837,
-0.3069455922,
0.3308444023,
0.817302525,
-0.0607520193,
0.4619703889,
0.4330580533,
0.1036190689,
0.3534168303,
-0.1123187691,
-0.3708509207,
-0.0925366431,
-0.3000968099,
0.0117572444,
0.3973458707,
0.2949749827,
-0.541110754,
-0.0820459649,
0.3988969326,
0.0764931291,
0.343821764,
-0.1819204539,
0.6220771074,
0.0583855174,
-0.945894599,
-0.227842167,
0.0492509156,
0.381398052,
-0.7426092625,
0.1284343302,
-0.4687693715,
0.1408835202,
-0.2904826403,
-0.7501739264,
0.2584353387,
0.1346451044,
-0.1119003445,
-0.3507740498,
0.8161905408,
-0.1514382213,
-0.3235287666,
0.1242362633,
0.7186359167,
0.1254630536,
0.1745648384,
-0.7312554121,
-0.097847335,
0.2357344925,
-0.4582076371,
0.4363436103,
0.2931084633,
-0.2619674504,
0.8293100595,
0.317735076,
-0.0431107543,
-0.0008712929,
0.1439347565,
0.7995914817,
-0.3286785185,
-0.3384697735,
-0.6829069257,
0.6585119367,
0.1431411952,
-0.6007741094,
1.2936865091,
0.3374034762,
0.5048581362,
-0.3510083854,
0.5309584141,
-0.174058795,
0.3024687767,
-0.217052862,
0.2544576526,
-0.3879746497,
0.4610358775,
-0.5697441101,
-0.9309005141,
-0.154099986,
0.7748090029,
-0.6043145657,
0.624717772,
0.2462823242,
0.6747391224,
-0.1059462801,
0.0107223829,
0.2620732784,
0.0715288892,
0.5369326472,
0.1642993838,
0.7081900239,
0.207236737,
0.2173338383,
-0.3440386951,
-0.1663870364,
-0.0795473009,
-0.587787807,
-0.9552220106,
-0.7216274738,
-0.4859936833,
-0.1052941307,
-0.1704749167,
1.0099835396,
0.349365443,
-0.7233657241,
-0.2696635127,
0.06495478,
0.0133096557,
0.0192681346,
-0.2709625661,
0.0075537395,
-0.0331393927,
-1.1025445461,
0.3448426127,
-0.006942776,
0.0907265469,
-0.6715198755,
0.0191459954,
-0.161014244,
0.1528207511,
0.3976948857,
0.1292560399,
-0.7928070426,
-0.5025528669,
0.3975630105,
-0.0114905741,
-0.1043107882,
1.0001044273,
-0.551279366,
0.3869965971,
0.1422173083,
0.2848726213,
-0.0407019705,
0.0740444884,
0.79753232,
-1.0710531473,
0.1314828247,
0.1707547009,
0.4023271799,
0.6779975295,
-0.8084772229,
0.1728660315,
0.0177842807,
-0.6602990627,
-0.5307801366,
0.135969907,
-0.8620818257,
-0.1902496666,
1.3530100584,
-0.1218129322,
-0.033235915,
-0.3689385653,
-0.5808623433,
0.0095818508,
-0.5377866626,
0.6425374746,
0.9659994841,
-0.5636214614,
-0.490408808,
-0.6641879082,
0.5036323071,
0.5399748087,
-0.7601966262,
0.1449882984,
0.781142056,
0.6041696668,
0.1394496262,
0.7460948229,
0.2890961766,
0.2636079192,
-0.4794180691,
-0.364608556,
-0.086284548,
-0.3568042517,
-0.7151829004,
0.1215847209,
0.6038818955,
-0.0773147494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02067v1 | Crossroads of Continents: Automated Artifact Extraction for Cultural Adaptation with Large Multimodal Models | 2024-07-02T08:55:41 | 2024-07-02T08:55:41 | Anjishnu Mukherjee, Ziwei Zhu, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we present a comprehensive three-phase study to examine (1) the
effectiveness of large multimodal models (LMMs) in recognizing cultural
contexts; (2) the accuracy of their representations of diverse cultures; and
(3) their ability to adapt content across cultural boundaries. We first
introduce Dalle Street, a large-scale dataset generated by DALL-E 3 and
validated by humans, containing 9,935 images of 67 countries and 10 concept
classes. We reveal disparities in cultural understanding at the sub-region
level with both open-weight (LLaVA) and closed-source (GPT-4V) models on Dalle
Street and other existing benchmarks. Next, we assess models' deeper culture
understanding by an artifact extraction task and identify over 18,000 artifacts
associated with different countries. Finally, we propose a highly composable
pipeline, CultureAdapt, to adapt images from culture to culture. Our findings
reveal a nuanced picture of the cultural competence of LMMs, highlighting the
need to develop culture-aware systems. Dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/iamshnoo/crossroads | [
-0.6819188595,
-0.2347607911,
0.6407597065,
0.3518048823,
-0.3078132868,
0.3003929257,
-0.2566845119,
-0.9539195299,
0.0312729962,
0.3981854618,
-0.5616371632,
-0.6420762539,
-0.6716227531,
0.3899737,
-0.3826399446,
0.4437713027,
-0.3241158426,
-0.0350371972,
-0.1506744474,
-0.4664643705,
-0.501345098,
-0.1189503297,
-0.1379494071,
-0.1936138719,
0.098679617,
0.660607934,
0.6086362004,
0.5737047195,
0.5229950547,
0.3223058283,
0.2948417068,
0.1814177632,
-0.4783751369,
0.0700598583,
-0.3654804826,
-0.0606020689,
-0.4649900198,
0.0772168562,
0.3341889083,
0.5917602181,
0.1884654164,
0.4343631268,
0.1811654717,
0.4425491691,
-0.6128042936,
0.1692741811,
-0.6666868329,
-0.0558654666,
-0.1575470269,
-0.258150965,
-0.3605363965,
-0.1780248731,
0.3086781502,
-0.8388842344,
0.0088743912,
-0.085068211,
0.4702985585,
0.3510824442,
-0.9699062109,
-0.4850094914,
-0.9213234782,
0.7815185189,
-0.1451046765,
0.5388182402,
0.2366366982,
0.4502572715,
-0.1733383834,
-0.9141987562,
-0.4454532564,
0.4904275835,
0.247552678,
0.5119692683,
0.146686852,
-0.3112899661,
0.1726963222,
0.4395658672,
-0.5056856275,
-0.0542081557,
-0.450545162,
-0.3063668609,
0.8676627278,
0.4098102152,
0.3562601805,
-0.3124394417,
-0.6623569727,
-0.1387825161,
-0.5741484761,
0.1140138134,
-0.1157784835,
0.1725041121,
-0.4754766226,
0.0520560965,
-0.3438762426,
0.7021048069,
-0.0144105935,
-0.4317122698,
0.2327435315,
-0.2958296239,
0.0940819159,
-0.1505628973,
0.4134686291,
0.9028193355,
0.1103093326,
0.0464352444,
0.0462419018,
-0.1932806671,
0.1949317008,
-0.5561065078,
-0.3587590158,
0.3173829019,
-0.7998425961,
0.0941706896,
-0.1436423957,
-0.8382472992,
-0.9552834034,
-0.5021929741,
0.3807550073,
-0.324991256,
-0.3682692349,
0.0984489247,
-0.1522208601,
0.446151346,
0.6046457291,
-0.5570813417,
0.0907564908,
0.3682525456,
1.0089292526,
-0.4467778802,
-0.3805707991,
-0.0010161418,
0.0974114686,
-0.244203344,
0.7542960048,
-0.3819016218,
-0.6205559373,
0.1042974591,
0.6450028419,
0.1060928255,
-0.4377732873,
0.7937533259,
-0.5543943048,
-0.2296756059,
-0.6625860333,
0.1656171829,
-0.6325182915,
0.4166864455,
-0.9731864929,
0.7022485733,
0.0215053894,
-0.3606121242,
0.5525141358,
-0.3086677194,
-0.3825858235,
0.0367667191,
-0.1034956947,
0.0455338322,
-0.0661470965,
0.4517105818,
0.2396372706,
-0.3568851054,
-0.1668382585,
-0.3711771667,
-0.319280982,
-0.0970987976,
-0.3750103116,
1.0792962313,
0.3506075144,
-0.2901766896,
-0.1323790699,
-0.9250096679,
-0.3528809547,
0.1936586499,
-0.2632469535,
-0.5386756063,
-0.0145975081,
0.444099158,
0.5994434953,
0.2120525539,
-0.4889811873,
0.1833718866,
0.430434376,
0.3349393606,
0.8168467283,
-0.0560283028,
0.5318468809,
-0.2760727704,
0.4593958855,
0.2965887785,
0.3779791296,
-0.2417898178,
-0.3745818138,
-0.5702654123,
-0.2318715453,
0.3535603881,
0.4247939587,
-1.3156052828,
-0.0315342322,
-0.4686090946,
-0.5528312922,
-0.3618628681,
-0.2073421478,
-0.3327906728,
0.2393128276,
0.1952290535,
-0.9787616134,
-0.7106129527,
-0.6112350821,
0.1159708723,
-0.1207374111,
0.0154303992,
0.1493652314,
0.5981461406,
0.0298117734,
0.9600378275,
-0.2811851501,
-0.1530620754,
0.053482879,
0.1047466844,
-0.0220024399,
0.524766326,
0.5005335212,
-0.9596177936,
-0.5283598304,
0.0505424552,
-0.9915171862,
-0.0092555666,
-0.2311889678,
-0.318949312,
0.0346306227,
0.2970402241,
-0.1434520185,
0.2691840231,
0.825334549,
-0.1723852754,
0.4006069899,
-0.0936458558,
0.4989586174,
-1.0489023924,
-0.065691568,
0.0662860572,
-0.2345268875,
-0.6336005926,
0.0364541337,
0.2470036149,
-0.2116967291,
-0.458606571,
0.3892366886,
-0.6181740761,
-0.3377732635,
-0.1223565713,
0.2720825374,
0.2030061036,
0.255743742,
0.4008815587,
0.4300641418,
0.3927587271,
-0.3705675304,
0.2864665985,
0.3943527341,
-0.6585710645,
1.1298797131,
-0.1143739969,
0.2207411975,
0.1153438166,
0.7610311508,
-0.958414495,
-0.3058634698,
0.3455980718,
0.0322582051,
-0.2609601021,
-0.435664475,
-0.2641532421,
-0.3374001086,
-0.0613479614,
0.8604339361,
0.4644973874,
-0.6571065784,
0.9055218697,
0.5077393055,
-0.3061157763,
-0.2513471842,
-0.3909543157,
0.2587812543,
-0.463341713,
-0.7204630375,
0.1288256049,
-0.2370182872,
-0.320022285,
-0.4730345905,
0.0180774238,
-0.2131721526,
0.2946841121,
0.3755446076,
0.1734901667,
-0.0656153187,
-0.0088687614,
-0.2925184667,
0.0592967011,
-0.1277616024,
-0.4536910951,
0.4363957047,
-0.0124783292,
-0.5477219224,
-0.1663448811,
0.2140374929,
0.9909440279,
-0.4795457721,
0.1263153553,
0.9700696468,
-0.384856075,
0.149632439,
-0.5188665986,
0.0726464614,
-0.3999938369,
0.2623483539,
-0.520265162,
-0.3103440404,
0.902528584,
-0.4662623107,
0.108152017,
0.3615971208,
0.5535840392,
0.2151735276,
0.8498478532,
0.6897156239,
0.051942721,
0.0957697704,
-0.3030063212,
-0.0577293076,
-0.9117231965,
-0.3260990381,
-0.3444092572,
-0.5045822859,
-0.8241122365,
-0.6555720568,
0.729880929,
-0.3828741908,
0.0995001271,
-0.0691195056,
-0.2277632356,
0.5214424729,
0.3121193647,
0.2491815984,
0.7328389287,
-0.1128801703,
0.2929275334,
-0.0176604763,
-0.6199979782,
-0.4320943654,
1.0337674618,
0.3753261864,
0.5815326571,
0.0741558895,
0.5606772304,
0.3806637228,
0.2308342308,
-0.6782010198,
0.3098446727,
-0.3393545151,
-0.6583834887,
-0.089373,
0.20944646,
-0.70557338,
0.508684516,
-0.4087421,
-0.423386097,
0.8744235635,
-0.2291789502,
-0.616469264,
0.3793871105,
-0.4594568312,
0.6374091506,
-0.2390360683,
-0.3927841187,
-0.0554217584,
-0.819388926,
0.3988335729,
-0.3410587013,
0.8639755249,
-0.2317805886,
0.1007344797,
0.4797967672,
0.2575850785,
0.831050396,
-0.2152441889,
-0.3765486181,
0.2895397544,
0.4026024342,
0.2685942948,
-0.0931782722,
-0.1213202253,
0.6111090779,
0.2070188224,
-0.5549957156,
-0.193362996,
0.5861232877,
-0.7818860412,
-0.4682587981,
-0.1565145701,
-1.0479738712,
-0.0344592109,
0.027426349,
0.0106994109,
0.6868104339,
-0.2740424275,
0.0664495006,
0.1860358417,
-0.2513583302,
0.4538858533,
0.3274102211,
-0.007610234,
-0.4027650952,
0.7844673395,
0.172633782,
0.2469333559,
-0.391487509,
-0.2442033142,
0.0539522581,
-0.5437661409,
-0.845679462,
-0.1016079858,
-1.1788237095,
0.0790641233,
-0.3154184222,
0.1982791722,
-0.1810272783,
-0.3347427249,
-0.1070777848,
-0.4177915454,
0.1181099415,
0.2381851524,
0.1760759503,
1.0167149305,
-0.5051164627,
0.1413439959,
-0.836399734,
0.0715713799,
0.2342391014,
0.0609932095,
0.0507567003,
-0.3475497067,
-0.5349325538,
-0.0098295044,
-0.3218419552,
-0.6326622963,
0.2146057636,
-0.0249755345,
0.3052068055,
0.3529728055,
0.3256786764,
0.8941947222,
-0.5136452317,
1.0926506519,
-0.0125843994,
-0.8536801934,
-0.0055270111,
-0.3161079884,
0.6437852383,
0.5532140136,
0.6128067374,
-0.8252078295,
-0.1812741309,
-0.3635043502,
-0.8734471798,
0.5940706134,
-0.216433242,
-0.1485982686,
0.089423269,
-0.0580004193,
0.5867696404,
-0.1721829474,
-0.686491549,
0.1621583551,
-0.2343720645,
-0.2615043223,
-0.06030019,
0.0640298948,
-0.4849039614,
-0.0631352291,
0.4086486101,
-0.2101362348,
-0.2471703291,
0.4122121334,
-0.6829602122,
-0.1932700872,
-0.0777400285,
0.4761560559,
1.1106715202,
-0.0375522897,
0.1201771945,
0.4740392268,
-0.6363201737,
0.211644277,
-0.0117228338,
0.0721693933,
-0.1148335859,
0.526406765,
0.4446427226,
-0.0904813334,
-0.3486364782,
0.2242430151,
-0.2292246372,
-0.0720037892,
-0.535194695,
-0.4806328118,
-0.1823951751,
0.787174046,
0.6427593827,
-0.0647841394,
0.3006005585,
-0.584818542,
0.0379544124,
0.149093762,
-0.4342218041,
-0.4021206498,
0.4908694327,
0.672023952,
0.162321806,
0.6528787017,
0.0421411358,
-0.5431720614,
0.6576006413,
0.1614986062,
0.6610418558,
-0.245514676,
0.2667853534,
0.3693304658,
0.4067094922,
-0.0758880824,
0.0271461941,
0.0469509177,
-0.7101251483,
-0.4030261338,
-0.3899319768,
-0.3296699226,
-0.1887736768,
-0.5711351037,
0.2901138663,
-0.1223260313,
-0.1123476475,
-0.456092149,
-0.1537532508,
-0.8547261357,
0.2936976552,
0.4802395999,
0.995685041,
-1.4173483849,
0.5149099827,
0.6328100562,
-0.2354614437,
-0.3832755089,
0.2377524823,
0.3762018979,
-0.6755838394,
0.6380093694,
-0.064591825,
-0.029276384,
-0.063819468,
-0.384126544,
-1.0086481571,
1.5873118639,
-0.2103578746,
-0.4155145288,
0.2125259489,
0.2199778706,
0.2982741594,
-0.6525958776,
0.298179239,
0.8741443753,
0.5259261131,
0.0879152939,
-1.1264266968,
0.1014547199,
0.0218790881,
-0.0765028,
0.0453318767,
-0.6342595816,
0.9468978047,
-0.0037184858,
-0.2355411053,
0.2545799017,
0.31087327,
0.1966489851,
0.4704589844,
1.0820285082,
0.1793487072,
0.6409745216,
-0.410122782,
0.7829313874,
-0.5638566613,
0.1787783653,
0.7082949877,
-0.4502930343,
0.5029420853,
0.4361222386,
0.0261158887,
0.8412310481,
1.2305985689,
0.2021639943,
0.5997858644,
-0.1206185967,
-0.2055732608,
-0.4729356766,
-0.3170635402,
-0.4300302267,
0.9332934618,
0.4000699222,
-0.0683970377,
-0.2750605047,
0.2594762146,
-0.2548606992,
-0.2760229707,
-0.4157324433,
0.6751798987,
0.0264776647,
-0.4317442477,
0.7974548936,
-0.3623825908,
0.2664491534,
-0.3730325401,
-0.1729314476,
-0.2770210505,
0.0341087319,
-0.2198114395,
-0.5873017311,
-0.005600309,
-0.4259952307,
-0.0266577881,
0.0365923271,
0.7282238007,
-0.3983170986,
-0.3562335968,
0.2715653777,
0.5520617962,
0.1691153646,
0.1808476597,
-0.506859839,
0.5319404006,
-0.0058669006,
0.1066620797,
0.2107955813,
0.6739578247,
-0.4565748274,
0.3374369442,
0.4968689978,
-0.0912327319,
-0.2130134404,
-0.0819596648,
0.4248032868,
-0.4819479883,
-0.3860862851,
-0.5632183552,
0.8947089314,
-0.2925889194,
-0.0432363003,
0.5736421943,
0.2820596695,
1.07441926,
-0.2470177412,
1.0987688303,
-0.256865561,
-0.0588080809,
-0.5390192866,
0.5185607076,
-0.7515919209,
-0.0838147625,
-0.3950412273,
-0.9449179769,
-0.185825482,
0.2355329096,
-0.4125185907,
-0.279388696,
0.7641195655,
0.495675087,
-0.3411641717,
0.1749633104,
0.185880512,
0.2642925084,
0.1473870277,
0.4742518067,
0.92556566,
-0.3125813901,
0.5560471416,
-0.3505501747,
-0.3786742389,
-0.1349245608,
-0.9426339865,
-0.3544079065,
-0.997563839,
-0.1486059278,
-0.2350312173,
-0.0952965841,
0.8694731593,
0.7618890405,
-0.680539906,
-0.6640583277,
0.8640828133,
0.0300836507,
-0.3055103719,
-0.0750566348,
0.3578814268,
0.1144720018,
-0.9843905568,
0.2705202997,
0.3685002625,
-0.1033725515,
-0.4487073123,
0.0468438454,
-0.1644574702,
-0.2022731155,
0.9480112791,
0.1750151515,
-0.6155698895,
-0.6120176315,
-0.2393202484,
0.239309594,
0.0922278911,
0.8250451684,
-0.4639579356,
0.7291120291,
0.4193118215,
0.4308166504,
0.3224313259,
0.1482775509,
0.7808737159,
-0.4848034978,
0.4837884009,
-0.2159211487,
0.6016762257,
0.6485594511,
0.0296951793,
0.7376574278,
0.296453625,
-0.762775898,
-0.5134031177,
0.4601364434,
-0.8626247048,
-0.3900818825,
1.029976964,
-0.1251294017,
-0.256303817,
-0.6264356971,
-0.219926402,
0.3337483406,
0.0623372793,
1.0561416149,
0.9124076962,
0.1288221925,
0.0768176913,
-0.8040947914,
0.3038721085,
0.051122319,
-0.6594142318,
-0.0052878782,
0.7755677104,
0.3016286492,
0.5109299421,
0.4121373296,
-0.1868656278,
0.3336143494,
-0.1828302145,
0.4459405541,
0.3597703874,
-0.3152992725,
-0.4035066068,
0.0317172222,
0.1801946163,
-0.1392178535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02066v1 | BiasDora: Exploring Hidden Biased Associations in Vision-Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:55:40 | 2024-07-02T08:55:40 | Chahat Raj, Anjishnu Mukherjee, Aylin Caliskan, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Ziwei Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing works examining Vision Language Models (VLMs) for social biases
predominantly focus on a limited set of documented bias associations, such as
gender:profession or race:crime. This narrow scope often overlooks a vast range
of unexamined implicit associations, restricting the identification and, hence,
mitigation of such biases. We address this gap by probing VLMs to (1) uncover
hidden, implicit associations across 9 bias dimensions. We systematically
explore diverse input and output modalities and (2) demonstrate how biased
associations vary in their negativity, toxicity, and extremity. Our work (3)
identifies subtle and extreme biases that are typically not recognized by
existing methodologies. We make the Dataset of retrieved associations, (Dora),
publicly available here https://github.com/chahatraj/BiasDora. | [
-0.4033276737,
-0.6632187366,
0.6655756235,
0.1423653811,
0.038597405,
-0.0618803948,
0.036509797,
-0.8599520922,
0.4945672452,
0.686989367,
-0.7002727985,
-0.6886026263,
-0.8462122679,
-0.2010035515,
-0.7403799295,
1.132245779,
0.1501639336,
0.4600055516,
-0.1345098913,
-0.4460735619,
-0.512036562,
-0.4361952543,
-0.3093138039,
-0.0321924537,
0.5099883676,
0.1293033212,
0.4573349953,
0.403712213,
0.6078438759,
0.1410659105,
-0.3146962821,
-0.0409325995,
-0.6611653566,
0.0369483605,
-0.3869768679,
-0.436082691,
-0.4165121019,
0.3267687559,
0.3616618216,
0.7409209609,
0.2242937386,
0.7704328895,
0.0688849017,
0.8346982598,
-1.2027286291,
0.2256198525,
-0.6754666567,
0.3856199682,
-0.5318031311,
0.1115538701,
-0.1082248762,
-0.4563487172,
0.4710221887,
-0.3505743444,
0.5647326708,
-0.0189805329,
0.8140774965,
0.3860290647,
-0.5109532475,
-0.4045136869,
-0.8057261109,
0.8389697671,
-0.2125069946,
0.1420799643,
0.3810377717,
0.4150591195,
0.4203246236,
-0.5648540258,
-0.4071288109,
-0.0364166573,
-0.1662911922,
0.0625922531,
-0.5017194748,
-0.2028814554,
0.4876327813,
0.2830781043,
-0.3457294106,
-0.2551005483,
-0.7129431963,
-0.3509742916,
0.4478504062,
0.3600797951,
0.2432009578,
0.0320763141,
-0.2292950153,
0.0279017799,
-0.8693058491,
0.0071795275,
0.7011686563,
-0.0068467711,
-0.221043095,
0.6118736267,
-0.120455578,
0.6860006452,
-0.0158875696,
0.2050597072,
0.4533216059,
-0.4945182502,
-0.2499582916,
0.0164784826,
0.7679494619,
0.444974184,
0.2082879096,
0.1697385907,
-0.075594075,
0.565901041,
0.2828968167,
-0.3346995711,
-0.1217275485,
-0.0473808385,
-0.6776564717,
-0.9555056095,
-0.1548118144,
-1.235809207,
-0.8954056501,
-0.1247072294,
0.4168934524,
-0.0137273176,
-0.3458976448,
-0.0225260649,
-0.4138197601,
0.4994164407,
0.2741057575,
-0.7190641761,
0.5011174679,
0.390663594,
0.6590052843,
0.0993576124,
-0.2680542767,
-0.6913067102,
-0.0566302426,
-0.5138273835,
0.3538437188,
-1.0061610937,
-0.2755503654,
0.3150324821,
-0.1167199984,
0.1549628228,
-0.6696176529,
0.7695287466,
-0.3273591697,
0.3126143217,
-0.6577017307,
0.0222646054,
-0.126785025,
0.1095478833,
-0.6890054345,
1.1854342222,
-0.0628348663,
-0.9607846737,
0.6481112242,
-0.4668833017,
-0.2076720744,
-0.3857090473,
-0.3865593672,
-0.3225753009,
0.3993370533,
0.3506436646,
0.2908975184,
-0.2162375152,
0.3096086681,
-0.6736902595,
-0.2476117611,
0.0787639394,
-0.415681541,
1.0829073191,
-0.0270910431,
-0.5750132203,
0.396681577,
-0.8117908835,
-0.6278823018,
0.2104913592,
0.1149171069,
-0.7830097675,
0.0202177837,
0.1762275845,
0.1887455136,
0.335875839,
-0.5273000598,
0.1406089813,
0.0403824039,
0.0342160612,
0.9896463752,
-0.4810942709,
0.5434914827,
0.0873668343,
0.4536884427,
0.3494470417,
0.7133942246,
0.1395474821,
-0.4995267093,
-1.1533564329,
-0.1268595308,
0.0259807818,
0.2800795734,
-0.5391592979,
-0.2433116734,
0.063945502,
-0.3639014363,
-0.963526845,
0.1774828881,
0.7328894734,
0.6630312204,
0.3096316755,
-0.6411650777,
-0.7124847174,
-1.3008280993,
-0.3320215344,
0.0645644516,
0.0608746,
0.5104528069,
0.6078606844,
-0.4834309816,
0.8333137035,
-0.5485234857,
-0.949660778,
-0.1080279052,
-0.0159845725,
0.2089394778,
-0.0231012199,
1.0007771254,
-0.7287279963,
-0.4308166504,
-0.3487043977,
-0.8082714677,
-0.3386436701,
0.3503275812,
-0.3083874881,
-0.0451995209,
0.3581050336,
-0.2722117901,
0.734272182,
0.7954117656,
-0.5498375297,
0.5226041079,
0.0700683743,
-0.2658036351,
-0.6380470395,
0.0345196202,
0.3264046609,
-0.1290519089,
-0.7067916393,
0.012884249,
0.1591374427,
0.1415963918,
-0.5467364788,
0.4362065494,
-0.7600476146,
-0.4672777951,
0.0072418656,
0.1276977658,
-0.0730041265,
0.4344347417,
0.2890001237,
0.6444732547,
1.1134598255,
-0.5192291737,
0.0142525146,
0.094649069,
-0.2218045145,
0.5072413087,
-0.6628823876,
0.0378872566,
-0.3814941645,
-0.1125045717,
-0.4832977057,
0.000416106,
0.5130273104,
-0.2382685542,
0.0251053516,
-0.3772557378,
-0.0111193471,
-0.2309371233,
-0.6477407813,
0.5049242973,
0.4506617188,
-0.4669110477,
0.7078924775,
0.9281393886,
0.2982215285,
-1.0224457979,
-0.3692007065,
0.0205444898,
-0.3241835535,
-0.3536333442,
0.0648326576,
-0.0031666693,
-0.7492285371,
-0.1209952235,
0.0471746847,
0.0296475645,
-0.1005632579,
0.4970861375,
0.2794343233,
-0.1890643239,
-0.2128837407,
-0.0725783557,
0.1488158554,
0.1381970793,
-0.0420869142,
0.6646542549,
-0.212700516,
-0.1886894703,
0.1291912347,
0.3573540747,
0.8139640689,
-0.6339848042,
0.7785600424,
0.8501552343,
-0.2923074663,
-0.133400768,
-0.4991242886,
-0.0160800647,
-0.4302491844,
0.3166927397,
-0.1703624427,
-0.7327273488,
0.7131664157,
0.4234678149,
-0.1527519822,
0.2688302398,
0.659229219,
0.3075532615,
1.0234453678,
1.0585664511,
-0.4999889731,
0.6101124287,
-0.2701173425,
0.0625618547,
-1.1270498037,
-0.221157819,
-0.4130272865,
0.0565615557,
-0.5942205191,
-0.5852626562,
0.5110852718,
-0.3989190757,
0.1275605857,
-0.0869961306,
-0.4384661913,
0.4727615416,
0.8544240594,
0.0826806799,
0.0680709332,
-0.2539614439,
0.0800300688,
-0.1020338759,
-0.4724082351,
-0.5394369364,
1.5169453621,
0.5816141963,
0.664316535,
0.2338801622,
0.6092162132,
0.4079521894,
0.4623365104,
-0.618401587,
0.5085401535,
0.1172661334,
-0.9586555362,
-0.14904131,
-0.0860685557,
-0.7235800624,
0.3692376614,
-0.3110903502,
-0.779121995,
0.4864287972,
0.427608341,
-0.0327417366,
0.036822211,
-0.5656189322,
0.781423986,
-0.0202560481,
-0.91863662,
0.0175987035,
-0.6329117417,
0.8285152316,
-0.0431831852,
0.4049644172,
-0.1875128448,
0.1935094893,
0.801682055,
-0.1932016015,
1.1742144823,
-0.0929082409,
-0.1148875803,
0.08218804,
0.1622460037,
0.5257979035,
-0.0470656268,
0.3542678654,
0.4123324156,
-0.1011143699,
-0.4647598267,
-0.2396117151,
0.7149885297,
-0.7842534184,
-0.5029818416,
-0.7156496644,
-0.4569990039,
-0.2281932384,
0.2984220386,
-0.0118168872,
0.5965135694,
-0.4186591506,
-0.2573184371,
1.0278936625,
-0.3439165354,
0.267315954,
0.8139337897,
-0.5308439732,
0.0345054343,
0.7559549809,
-0.0562742352,
0.0327485055,
0.2114695609,
0.1522662044,
-0.0939377323,
-0.4580614269,
-0.226914376,
0.2619665563,
-0.5860081911,
0.2852324545,
-0.7336999178,
0.0713666007,
-0.66988796,
0.1264683753,
-0.3509497643,
-0.1400180757,
-0.3718727529,
-0.1706455946,
0.1455339789,
1.1273008585,
-0.0116002196,
-0.0282196533,
-0.3467331231,
0.3607909381,
0.4748610258,
0.2596389949,
-0.0122266049,
-0.1086592227,
-0.013349955,
-0.1290504187,
-0.1650398672,
-1.2586547136,
0.7039264441,
-0.1504742056,
0.4532150626,
0.7845456004,
-0.1648838818,
0.5417724252,
-0.6337543726,
0.805305779,
0.1895230711,
-1.0298246145,
0.6864737272,
-0.5201611519,
-0.1972356886,
0.319947958,
0.3643411398,
-0.3113539517,
-0.4856117666,
-0.4649645388,
-0.8049654961,
0.5308393836,
0.2586943209,
0.1757198721,
0.1037839726,
-0.1484432966,
0.0684782192,
0.3517563939,
-0.8784451485,
-0.5759609938,
-0.106688723,
-0.2205466181,
-0.11871133,
-0.7192705274,
-0.4542441368,
-0.2196042538,
0.4571912289,
-0.1710094362,
0.1377798915,
0.0937784016,
-0.3292862177,
-0.1519167721,
0.0253492277,
0.8325368166,
0.7264689207,
-0.3639226258,
0.4560687542,
0.056685254,
-0.9227663875,
-0.2344130874,
-0.1936025172,
-0.4015487731,
0.1559279114,
0.5024217367,
0.8401303887,
-0.07285133,
-0.6676091552,
0.7844024301,
-0.2486572415,
0.033910308,
-0.6994459629,
0.136261031,
-0.250223577,
0.4163418412,
0.3658315539,
0.2248042077,
0.5785183311,
-0.7954664826,
-0.1584517211,
0.7098493576,
-1.1809843779,
-0.36227718,
0.8213223815,
0.2001867294,
-0.0253730416,
0.2193058729,
0.1474903971,
-0.5826331377,
0.5419893265,
0.00500722,
0.7868845463,
0.1807177514,
0.3739307523,
0.1034522057,
0.7995539904,
0.2677458823,
0.2063156813,
-0.0430113561,
-0.8854702711,
0.0699012652,
-0.7720255256,
-0.1884073019,
0.3767744005,
-0.9475215077,
0.1978511661,
-0.2092911452,
-0.2225104868,
0.0432976037,
-0.2074094117,
-0.9332090616,
0.0130505962,
0.1896188557,
0.9066591859,
-1.3542840481,
0.6914992332,
0.4687771499,
-0.6799414158,
-0.3768408895,
0.0561501272,
0.3607275486,
-1.0317935944,
1.0209115744,
-0.0561744049,
-0.2337380648,
-0.4113393724,
-0.6511013508,
-0.9595921636,
0.9140272737,
0.060319595,
-0.5849809051,
-0.0069411858,
0.0549662784,
0.666271925,
-0.3967303634,
0.3692534268,
0.6402919292,
0.304009676,
-0.2900547385,
-0.9171962142,
-0.0195396524,
-0.3318791091,
0.0928732976,
0.0544601642,
-0.5543143153,
0.8449679017,
-0.2509895861,
0.0564362444,
-0.3173688352,
0.483554095,
0.1592515856,
0.5391287804,
0.1177373528,
0.4746017158,
0.7293078303,
0.059261024,
1.0926139355,
-0.1378960609,
0.3077672124,
1.1184928417,
-0.535128653,
0.3987209201,
0.8225364685,
-0.1354094446,
0.3283252716,
0.4273776412,
0.2086277157,
0.6596886516,
-0.0003472922,
-0.2584171295,
-0.0109786047,
-0.384578526,
-0.3339945674,
0.3733680248,
0.3550594747,
-0.879544735,
0.0123123573,
-0.1179101989,
0.004186166,
-0.1872934103,
-0.5746964216,
0.537637949,
-0.0745401606,
-0.3458647728,
0.1061213836,
-0.3182661533,
0.8710927367,
-0.495077759,
-0.1982274055,
-0.3164982796,
0.2667015493,
-0.0795197561,
-0.7240730524,
0.1710937321,
0.0766818225,
-0.4568012059,
-0.2116964906,
1.0065838099,
-0.2522361279,
-0.5826541185,
0.5152767897,
0.5145055056,
0.0186748598,
0.1033418253,
-0.469881624,
0.2810986042,
0.0897502825,
-0.0897279382,
0.4581567943,
0.2069815546,
-0.2905716002,
0.7173279524,
0.5691760778,
0.4010517597,
0.5391916633,
0.2546651661,
0.8823134899,
-0.4157268405,
-0.1226491854,
-0.7703742385,
0.3236911893,
-0.3145136833,
-0.5367987752,
1.1018188,
0.5863409638,
0.9776082635,
-0.3782859147,
0.8051545024,
0.1645036638,
0.4413540065,
-0.4952864051,
0.6506481767,
-0.4889467359,
0.3034442067,
-0.8127324581,
-0.7472951412,
-0.1531710178,
0.6530722976,
-0.6039457917,
-0.1645701379,
0.341629833,
0.9911583066,
-0.2602741122,
-0.2518796325,
0.4910902381,
0.2516437471,
0.117151849,
0.3708469868,
1.0730206966,
-0.281763494,
0.2724021077,
-0.1601778418,
-0.3757146895,
-0.3884480298,
-0.7096185088,
-1.1770251989,
-0.5698091388,
-0.1897887588,
-0.4126430452,
0.0483548529,
0.4498946965,
0.6029324532,
-0.6768017411,
-0.2169118375,
0.1177670136,
0.3279906809,
-0.0503577404,
-0.2730100453,
0.144736439,
0.091990158,
-0.7678288817,
-0.0745484307,
0.2591172457,
-0.0247833822,
-0.9536217451,
-0.0119237248,
0.101688236,
0.3435525894,
0.7643069029,
-0.0123280082,
-0.6139686704,
-0.1520415694,
0.0224620737,
-0.0080614854,
-0.1801464409,
0.8815054297,
-0.910941422,
0.4641032219,
0.451972127,
-0.1023676544,
0.6230902672,
-0.6053468585,
0.5651447773,
-0.6974623799,
0.2305322289,
0.1327504218,
0.5813082457,
0.2176757753,
-0.2196265161,
0.5608549714,
0.2869523168,
-0.0029441949,
-0.9995253682,
0.5018858314,
-0.7690424323,
-0.1796255857,
1.279984951,
0.3088138402,
-0.499497503,
-0.0811649263,
-0.5124265552,
-0.0135419909,
-0.2471008748,
0.9189385772,
0.3928596973,
0.0413173065,
-0.1830860823,
-0.8187439442,
0.8556516171,
0.1601822376,
-0.4956156909,
-0.0406092107,
0.8185631037,
0.5354159474,
0.390543431,
0.8210682273,
-0.3233142197,
0.1928581446,
-0.0422192328,
-0.0411035791,
0.1666716486,
-0.6118064523,
-0.3866665065,
0.2301802337,
-0.1729671359,
-0.2124186009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02062v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02062v1 | Are Data Augmentation Methods in Named Entity Recognition Applicable for Uncertainty Estimation? | 2024-07-02T08:49:43 | 2024-07-02T08:49:43 | Wataru Hashimoto, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This work investigates the impact of data augmentation on confidence
calibration and uncertainty estimation in Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks.
For the future advance of NER in safety-critical fields like healthcare and
finance, it is essential to achieve accurate predictions with calibrated
confidence when applying Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), including Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs), as a real-world application. However, DNNs are prone to
miscalibration, which limits their applicability. Moreover, existing methods
for calibration and uncertainty estimation are computational expensive. Our
investigation in NER found that data augmentation improves calibration and
uncertainty in cross-genre and cross-lingual setting, especially in-domain
setting. Furthermore, we showed that the calibration for NER tends to be more
effective when the perplexity of the sentences generated by data augmentation
is lower, and that increasing the size of the augmentation further improves
calibration and uncertainty. | [
-0.1686921567,
-0.3246684968,
0.5832023025,
-0.0348980241,
-0.1489948928,
0.2434328198,
-0.2159357071,
-0.7374933362,
0.1247119382,
0.3619183302,
-0.3372526169,
-0.2850474119,
-0.6097437739,
0.3134309351,
-0.201682061,
0.6174666286,
-0.067554988,
0.4022803307,
-0.2813483775,
0.2143701017,
-0.4531980455,
-0.5419753194,
-0.6618529558,
-0.2466629893,
0.5104023814,
0.1588125825,
0.7205157876,
0.4042105973,
0.7211657166,
0.3009953499,
0.0624150075,
0.3509371281,
-0.1249705553,
0.1422788352,
-0.1166655421,
-0.5708267689,
-0.3386709392,
-0.1494939476,
0.87404567,
0.8900767565,
-0.0343567431,
-0.2420347929,
-0.0163101479,
0.6715132594,
-0.6422679424,
0.1405499876,
-0.624545753,
0.0808891878,
-0.0526601151,
-0.2520116568,
-0.0595714562,
-0.4246747494,
0.5368635654,
-0.8955417275,
-0.0984025151,
0.1643976867,
0.9203842282,
0.6510014534,
-0.2970827818,
-0.374278307,
-0.9514434338,
0.8171589375,
-0.8095636368,
0.5834698081,
0.4253935516,
0.2832702398,
-0.3837226033,
-0.6810971498,
-0.7804546356,
0.052067548,
-0.0342078395,
-0.0207833387,
-0.1151085272,
0.3633745611,
0.4618762434,
0.5912129879,
-0.0427603759,
0.3378127515,
-0.2424613833,
-0.4263189733,
0.8116874695,
-0.0796673447,
0.1577143073,
-0.1002533287,
-0.3887580335,
-0.2061644047,
-0.6115586162,
0.1124781296,
0.585691452,
0.2474906445,
0.0432786271,
0.3982278705,
-0.3168517351,
0.7195753455,
0.1818614006,
-0.4438209832,
0.5282160044,
-0.2635688186,
-0.4011075795,
0.3760514557,
0.526566565,
0.2362665534,
0.3919805884,
-0.2564635575,
-0.2058672458,
-0.2212312818,
0.1670631766,
-0.593272388,
-0.3211499751,
0.1917132586,
0.1664649397,
-0.2660141289,
0.2446594238,
-0.7574055791,
-0.5968557596,
-0.4709613323,
0.4865502119,
-0.5126045346,
-0.103804335,
0.0994758978,
0.1231475696,
0.2179435939,
0.5149389505,
-0.4157835245,
0.1938429922,
0.668320477,
0.2718144357,
0.0481380932,
-0.0112785455,
-0.4704636037,
-0.0263913423,
-0.4424695373,
0.3587872684,
-0.5336263776,
-0.2378230095,
-0.3685477078,
-0.0283690356,
-0.3259143829,
-0.3789401054,
0.5941591263,
-0.7237221003,
-0.0091513805,
0.0113944104,
-0.8609458804,
-0.3388634026,
0.1658271104,
-0.9085757136,
0.8424960375,
-0.0049369857,
-0.8744155765,
0.7990570664,
-0.2147081494,
-0.4504236579,
0.190735504,
-0.3299541473,
-0.5288000703,
0.170141533,
0.4465052485,
0.3728393018,
-0.1837982684,
0.4118923545,
-0.2066477984,
-0.4171434045,
0.777764678,
-0.7743381262,
0.3140124977,
-0.0775416419,
-0.2021894008,
-0.3551298976,
-0.8311085105,
0.3104663789,
-0.3566787243,
-0.2225331962,
-0.4874346256,
-0.1278487444,
-0.1679129899,
0.05670093,
0.145221591,
-0.6404641867,
-0.2015966326,
-0.8065956235,
0.040775016,
0.4382223189,
0.242410928,
0.4997590482,
-0.1287522167,
0.517746985,
0.1724014729,
-0.2308829725,
0.1231796071,
-0.4380773604,
-0.6365876794,
-0.1174290106,
1.164039135,
0.7206121087,
-0.8645658493,
0.4694790542,
-0.519960463,
-0.4730580747,
-0.5321362019,
-0.2103036791,
0.1143983677,
0.7735139132,
0.2979209423,
-0.0543189719,
-0.8709572554,
-0.6700164676,
-0.2041354775,
-0.1707953662,
-0.0586615652,
0.5111002326,
0.3613955975,
-0.1117902473,
0.9177092314,
-0.2307659984,
-0.0564806573,
0.1434198469,
0.1231388077,
0.0203443952,
0.674133718,
0.2194590569,
-1.1644448042,
-0.2719381154,
-0.1643256396,
-0.4247332215,
0.295737654,
-0.3432701826,
0.1996754557,
0.0175247993,
0.0233803727,
-0.3289990127,
0.7513617873,
0.3911342621,
0.2682181895,
0.3212604523,
-0.3747632205,
0.3266606331,
-1.2240718603,
-0.2340059429,
0.200067535,
-0.3134715855,
-0.7793234587,
-0.268098563,
0.2421699017,
0.2589472234,
-0.3033265471,
0.3519107401,
-0.7396544814,
-0.0641387776,
-0.1589849293,
0.0534401797,
0.2168839872,
-0.2458060384,
0.3765694797,
0.9174727201,
0.9543109536,
-0.7447179556,
0.315220803,
0.0351929143,
-0.657377243,
0.5786214471,
-0.3622705638,
-0.069212392,
-0.104207322,
0.164582625,
-0.6378626227,
-0.3928453028,
0.3387301862,
-0.5471253991,
0.7881168723,
0.0045796745,
-0.2272712737,
-0.3485394418,
0.0327618681,
0.5124836564,
0.2409825027,
-0.3583211303,
0.6054510474,
0.5813885927,
-0.0594983138,
-0.8375260234,
-1.179989934,
0.2994650006,
-0.3456668854,
-0.2868611217,
0.6173402667,
0.0409940332,
-0.1611330509,
-0.2316678911,
-0.3870921433,
-0.3752077818,
0.0726529583,
0.4808576703,
0.3396015763,
-0.0557662472,
0.4908767343,
0.1518127173,
-0.0715165883,
0.0409356505,
-0.0511977337,
0.0587992445,
0.0649980158,
-0.4148578644,
-0.5154706836,
-0.0833446234,
0.0872221068,
-0.0633887276,
0.681052804,
0.6214763522,
-0.8780417442,
0.0759774894,
-0.798373878,
-0.1427719146,
-0.4286855459,
0.2086921483,
-0.4568428993,
-0.889888227,
0.4828444719,
-0.1875645965,
-0.5205239058,
0.4810664654,
-0.0008569548,
-0.1010264605,
0.6866835356,
0.4815429151,
-0.0824920908,
0.2574163377,
-0.068265304,
0.4683661163,
-1.1510511637,
-0.2619428635,
-0.2332986146,
-0.4447118342,
-0.7653832436,
-0.6081317663,
0.2110306174,
-0.0432488881,
0.2059633732,
0.3000071645,
-0.4324688017,
0.202913329,
0.3927148879,
0.2662323415,
0.1621373147,
0.1085029468,
0.0998126417,
-0.4917187393,
-0.3782867491,
-0.3621158898,
1.1227656603,
0.5146359801,
0.8016580939,
-0.2259034961,
0.8998612761,
0.0156364236,
0.0849492401,
-0.7975739241,
0.2903575301,
0.1082405597,
-0.4536459744,
-0.4236700237,
-0.7506418228,
-0.7764738202,
-0.2694989443,
-0.3150797784,
-0.9233050346,
0.929338336,
-0.0246982835,
-0.9230774045,
0.2432056963,
-0.4440368712,
0.3298401535,
-0.3109054863,
0.1281189919,
0.2436227351,
-0.6670202613,
0.0283086319,
-0.3777618408,
0.0573511831,
-0.0678928569,
-0.3467055857,
0.6662297249,
-0.3607305884,
0.5905025005,
-0.0490319468,
-0.0694985613,
0.2936396897,
-0.3554357886,
0.7023892999,
0.4563827813,
-0.6190353632,
0.3457123935,
-0.2014623284,
0.1898722649,
-0.722646296,
0.8641762137,
-0.3910468817,
-0.5180120468,
-0.6355416775,
-0.9077207446,
-0.3405643404,
0.0438550636,
0.2048264891,
0.3975010216,
0.0436981954,
0.2549313605,
0.7280187607,
-0.0764169246,
0.4723431468,
0.2973047197,
0.2975816429,
-0.6443564892,
0.7895845771,
0.4902003407,
0.1099801213,
0.645411253,
-0.2196047604,
-0.3474928141,
-0.817872107,
-0.5356155038,
-0.1381263584,
-0.4367602468,
-0.4480324984,
-0.6564778686,
-0.4267782867,
-0.5665602684,
0.1222839728,
-0.1191344038,
-0.6876286268,
-0.5656486154,
-0.3096003532,
0.6137767434,
0.2936369181,
-0.0716236308,
0.3490875959,
-0.6299481988,
-0.031609267,
0.0888838246,
0.48228845,
-0.5117544532,
-0.4571842849,
-0.2004524171,
0.5481021404,
0.3928087354,
-1.0282120705,
0.4432295263,
0.4128398299,
0.6165565252,
0.1455957443,
0.2805835903,
1.0107098818,
-0.1735972613,
0.4760168493,
-0.0650191307,
-0.7151005864,
0.3226201832,
0.21380274,
0.0215914119,
0.9632015228,
0.3058624268,
-0.1120675653,
0.1566659659,
-0.5305885673,
-0.9232577682,
0.6067917347,
0.2240987122,
0.2605100572,
0.1903570592,
0.6309390664,
-0.1337162852,
0.5753413439,
-0.4481508136,
-0.5464805365,
0.1906820983,
-0.3207193315,
0.0492809303,
-0.1313436031,
0.2192556709,
-0.2303092927,
0.8651899099,
-0.0674689934,
0.0692586675,
0.4323208928,
-0.0573037229,
-0.1622251719,
0.3196003437,
0.1777631342,
0.3699037433,
-0.1288060546,
-0.1079162285,
0.4759519994,
-0.6881625652,
0.0562268347,
0.8022793531,
-0.3748016357,
0.1360721737,
-0.045954302,
1.0118730068,
0.4178857803,
-0.515173912,
0.3992644846,
-0.0186966322,
0.053750664,
-0.5503054261,
0.017791599,
-0.2398162633,
0.2586463392,
0.4886099994,
0.3055554926,
0.4379655719,
-0.0344826914,
0.3340864182,
0.463553369,
-0.6243607402,
0.1395468414,
0.4337824583,
-0.2188905478,
-0.0799864605,
0.5588275194,
-0.2296591699,
-0.3975501359,
0.6741022468,
0.3794776201,
0.7591099739,
-0.4147511423,
0.2070773542,
0.3157456517,
0.3444421291,
-0.1294333041,
0.3841096461,
0.0021807055,
-0.9481297731,
-0.4703666866,
-0.7393408418,
-0.5249350071,
0.0476317294,
-0.6040244102,
0.1411407888,
-0.2911713421,
-0.5159192681,
0.149500221,
0.1581922024,
-0.852376163,
0.8388465643,
0.3615439832,
0.6264597178,
-0.3591542542,
0.6049384475,
0.929289937,
-0.3353070617,
-1.2968047857,
0.1927093565,
-0.1492573917,
-0.4160916507,
0.5176402926,
0.3528518081,
0.0906585455,
0.1916462183,
0.0857013389,
-1.29377985,
1.2981622219,
0.3208647668,
-0.6942418814,
-0.2996490896,
0.5559921265,
0.4957449436,
-0.5594061017,
0.3864460588,
0.4167088568,
0.6855508089,
0.1859529465,
-0.9856379628,
-0.0665718019,
-0.1165629402,
0.1197866127,
0.1834850162,
-0.0303712487,
0.6841394305,
-0.3111104667,
-0.4282085299,
-0.0649131015,
0.7269870043,
0.0591222644,
0.4672861993,
0.5966890454,
0.6774739623,
1.0593215227,
-0.4432236254,
0.9581106305,
-0.414591819,
0.1218426824,
1.3252338171,
-0.37787655,
0.5791225433,
0.5148880482,
-0.2645489872,
0.6376479864,
0.8293656707,
-0.0274468362,
0.2671987712,
0.1665194035,
-0.3547934294,
-0.1564580351,
-0.2464691997,
-0.3999213576,
0.3475869298,
0.7728062868,
-0.523265481,
0.1297903657,
0.2142543197,
-0.1041270196,
-0.2954715788,
-0.3335677683,
0.7356829047,
0.2531048954,
-0.4693336189,
0.1148064658,
-0.1290210932,
0.593327105,
-0.2735431492,
0.0468276106,
0.430608511,
0.1345211416,
-0.3280256689,
-0.7766087651,
0.0847033709,
-0.2238212824,
-0.0116503229,
0.1960425973,
1.1268013716,
-0.5640089512,
-0.8676278591,
0.036421448,
0.4766196609,
0.175326243,
-0.4263178408,
-0.5678052306,
-0.3342032433,
-0.2107577473,
-0.320340544,
0.1644619703,
0.3666058481,
0.0767654255,
0.5908403993,
0.5367560387,
0.2975769341,
0.1092567593,
0.1828057468,
0.689135015,
-0.2603738308,
-0.4363889992,
-0.5833256245,
0.5594744086,
-0.2474997491,
-0.094498679,
0.7878050208,
0.5703876615,
0.8318147063,
0.1014302373,
0.6694241166,
-0.0171386227,
0.6268948913,
-0.3992826343,
0.5176497698,
-0.3615659177,
0.4254271388,
-0.4584213495,
-0.8265072703,
-0.5383346677,
0.5009683371,
-0.8191252947,
0.2427190542,
0.3245893717,
0.7462425828,
0.1472101808,
0.1871111095,
0.3526826501,
-0.1099718884,
-0.2657826543,
0.3674074411,
0.4097748697,
-0.893874526,
0.2773186862,
-0.8600006104,
0.0075953919,
-0.0021479654,
-0.9629895091,
-0.3611746132,
-0.319439739,
-0.6233780384,
-0.0081362743,
0.164316982,
0.822339654,
0.633440733,
-1.0478076935,
0.3492471278,
-0.1735411286,
0.1425857246,
-0.1773376614,
-0.267873913,
0.2600563765,
0.0775292441,
-0.9974407554,
0.569866538,
0.2681240737,
0.3819742203,
-0.0954260752,
-0.003434256,
-0.2682434022,
0.1533953696,
0.0033370224,
0.163110882,
-0.6685140133,
-0.4075790048,
0.0623973422,
-0.088689521,
0.0985444784,
0.4023453295,
-0.9548476934,
0.7326233983,
0.4208041131,
1.0356773138,
0.0877277255,
0.334725827,
0.5839700103,
-0.8698818684,
-0.0992878377,
0.3916635513,
0.5151804686,
0.7471722364,
-0.9253025055,
0.5412188768,
-0.0157875344,
-0.5553154349,
-0.8325878978,
-0.063222371,
-0.7321624756,
0.4812776744,
0.8076571226,
-0.3256218135,
-0.0970678031,
-0.1953926384,
0.0603459775,
0.4588834643,
-0.4786784947,
0.4104447365,
0.5804110169,
-0.1280007213,
-0.3214446306,
-0.445599407,
0.5568808317,
0.3092465103,
-0.7839878201,
-0.3730875552,
0.4385777116,
0.1206659451,
0.451418519,
0.1258094758,
0.0266140793,
0.2213508785,
-0.1337628812,
-0.0602773726,
-0.1017227024,
-0.2643990815,
-0.437045604,
-0.1310507208,
-0.1147370338,
-0.2044072449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02056v1 | Integrate the Essence and Eliminate the Dross: Fine-Grained Self-Consistency for Free-Form Language Generation | 2024-07-02T08:38:31 | 2024-07-02T08:38:31 | Xinglin Wang, Yiwei Li, Shaoxiong Feng, Peiwen Yuan, Boyuan Pan, Heda Wang, Yao Hu, Kan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-consistency (SC), leveraging multiple samples from LLMs, shows
significant gains on various reasoning tasks but struggles with free-form
generation due to the difficulty of aggregating answers. Its variants, UCS and
USC, rely on sample selection or voting mechanisms to improve output quality.
These methods, however, face limitations due to their inability to fully
utilize the nuanced consensus knowledge present within multiple candidate
samples, often resulting in suboptimal outputs. We propose Fine-Grained
Self-Consistency (FSC) to addresses these limitations by extracting and
integrating segment-level commonalities from candidate samples, enhancing the
performance of LLMs both in open-ended and reasoning tasks. Based on this, we
present two additional strategies: candidate filtering, which enhances overall
quality by identifying highly similar candidate sets, and merging, which
reduces input token requirements by combining similar samples. The
effectiveness of FSC is demonstrated through extensive experiments on various
tasks, including summarization, code generation, and mathematical reasoning,
using GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4. The results indicate significant improvements
over baseline methods, showcasing the potential of FSC to optimize output
quality by effectively synthesizing fine-grained consensus knowledge from
multiple samples. | [
-0.4414921701,
-0.366015166,
0.6907177567,
0.1564585567,
-0.1917401254,
0.1389365792,
-0.4817405939,
-0.308552891,
0.1716903895,
0.4781725407,
-0.2272380292,
-0.5211538672,
-0.429325223,
-0.0187924616,
-0.4068658352,
0.7866420746,
-0.3147743046,
-0.3107500374,
-0.3358288407,
-0.0896397904,
-0.3033821285,
-0.3903838992,
-0.3066996932,
-0.3388396204,
0.2563071251,
0.6828450561,
0.530636549,
0.8810649514,
0.2627496421,
0.3191505075,
0.3091146052,
0.5090737343,
-0.5487906337,
0.2799093425,
-0.2868977487,
-0.1333749741,
-0.3905848563,
0.2034032494,
0.636998117,
0.327922076,
-0.3581524491,
0.0014362895,
0.5242649913,
0.6963569522,
-0.7366325259,
0.1644003093,
-0.7364801168,
-0.1916813701,
-0.475286305,
0.0008181087,
-0.2373507321,
-0.4032627046,
-0.5198306441,
-0.3735574186,
0.3941380084,
-0.4261510968,
0.7457370162,
0.4337794483,
0.0378774218,
-0.2684515715,
-0.6541797519,
0.7618849277,
-0.8467005491,
0.5283526778,
0.228905946,
0.3048284352,
-0.38126266,
-0.6219520569,
-0.5401815772,
0.0001393451,
-0.0842907131,
0.1936103553,
-0.1129272357,
0.1943808496,
-0.2650804818,
0.6829533577,
-0.3667660654,
0.1500298232,
-0.2491772771,
-0.4185525179,
0.5698850155,
-0.1036337465,
-0.0171816107,
-0.1469437182,
0.0537714176,
-0.0191778038,
-0.6618227959,
0.2467481643,
0.2781645656,
0.658310771,
0.0474917032,
0.6593161821,
-0.6603187323,
0.5095974803,
0.4093153477,
-0.2281278074,
0.0014853104,
-0.539708972,
-0.3306557238,
-0.2068927735,
0.9879171848,
0.1313884407,
0.0607640669,
-0.0203785487,
-0.4012501836,
0.0468884669,
0.0744159296,
-0.7785360813,
-0.3291356862,
0.3450388014,
-0.4184603393,
-0.1513057351,
0.1156721041,
-0.4615666866,
0.2095931321,
-0.6485129595,
0.0939667448,
-0.556750834,
-0.1060251966,
-0.0374973193,
0.0443350188,
-0.057151217,
0.472097367,
-1.1103739738,
0.3104134798,
0.6548432708,
0.6412975192,
-0.2946535051,
-0.349722743,
-0.721888423,
0.1921263784,
-0.3795029521,
0.9003698826,
-0.3136484921,
-0.2088931203,
-0.3767300844,
-0.3898178637,
0.097811684,
-0.6687439084,
0.0551670082,
0.0809634179,
0.126355812,
-0.1382118762,
-0.5099515319,
0.3283442557,
-0.0059703635,
-0.3509335816,
1.3084242344,
0.384026587,
-0.3069091737,
0.4437205493,
-0.2660293281,
-0.291337043,
-0.0163340755,
-0.7578536868,
-0.0501994118,
0.4994746745,
0.1573004723,
0.4882589281,
0.0267929751,
0.456969291,
-0.2894373536,
-0.2567135394,
-0.2646164,
-0.5542015433,
0.1846969277,
0.5919201374,
-0.4262784421,
0.1661459804,
-0.8716732264,
0.4793776572,
-0.1198990196,
-0.4668323994,
-0.1566742808,
-0.0489266254,
-0.4919310212,
0.2938069105,
0.4432779849,
-0.5481604338,
0.1903184801,
-0.3255490363,
0.2546889484,
0.7679302096,
-0.167076692,
0.4952010214,
-0.3124455214,
0.0986863375,
0.1735333949,
-0.0271267444,
-0.1106353179,
-0.23674196,
-0.8574367166,
-0.299062103,
0.223014906,
0.2218437344,
-0.5011273026,
0.4886126518,
0.1119435355,
-0.6260196567,
-0.5859220624,
0.5078118443,
0.3663235605,
0.2770379484,
0.4936467111,
-0.4117994606,
-0.4714067578,
-0.934707284,
-0.176672861,
-0.0470044911,
0.007792322,
-0.0046197264,
-0.0448027886,
-0.0853379667,
1.3593975306,
-0.4332809746,
-0.2244420946,
-0.2100000829,
0.2421974391,
0.1821539402,
0.8315625191,
0.4214811921,
0.0296471883,
-0.4701170027,
-0.1238527149,
-0.4403897226,
-0.3359662294,
-0.0710411519,
-0.1557744443,
0.3015708327,
0.5411848426,
-0.1265700758,
0.2345209122,
0.7313687205,
0.068489939,
0.3989412189,
-0.4107135534,
0.1560143232,
-1.0245476961,
-0.2735185325,
0.0116966851,
-0.2238105386,
-0.4825698435,
-0.0345783159,
0.0781564787,
0.269883126,
-0.3215707839,
0.6498653889,
-0.4228609502,
-0.1192125455,
-0.3506998122,
0.3075977266,
0.1376217008,
0.2417555004,
-0.2063896954,
1.119063139,
0.2412679493,
-0.5594277978,
-0.0596379116,
-0.1270626038,
-0.0233923811,
0.4074589312,
-0.4584698081,
0.0709010735,
-0.1427837312,
0.0789139196,
-0.9728499055,
-0.3198612928,
0.0079963375,
-0.1262604594,
0.3322621286,
-0.0718436837,
-0.3095033169,
-0.2468497157,
-0.2171248347,
0.121080257,
0.4027445316,
-0.4964902699,
0.4321086705,
0.0851843879,
-0.1470908225,
-0.4668459594,
-0.6712753177,
-0.1819344312,
0.2830233276,
-0.5615416169,
0.178215459,
-0.1203441992,
-0.1990057826,
-0.1350251287,
-0.458014816,
-0.0775942728,
0.0640017986,
-0.0594471842,
-0.0360439122,
-0.3768787384,
-0.1164981276,
0.5248464942,
-0.051459305,
-0.5216768384,
-0.3562118113,
0.5372464061,
-0.3226463199,
-0.624966979,
-0.506588161,
0.5993309617,
0.3644246459,
-0.2189362347,
0.0803126916,
0.3835973144,
-0.1556215733,
-0.3278650343,
-0.7015734911,
-0.1191257313,
-0.4495858252,
-0.1229217798,
-0.6955339909,
-1.295640111,
0.5364128947,
-0.0169743188,
0.3625562489,
0.6977719069,
0.4407585859,
-0.1013895646,
0.7612521648,
0.4677779973,
0.1319924593,
0.3832202256,
-0.043360468,
0.0897501856,
-0.6049866676,
-0.0795873478,
-0.522030592,
-0.0571356341,
-0.5725448132,
-0.7002049685,
-0.0922491699,
0.5222919583,
-0.1440948844,
0.2985648513,
-0.8502875566,
0.5343933105,
0.837469101,
-0.0289771743,
0.5266910195,
0.0737991482,
-0.4529984891,
-0.0978721157,
-0.5804509521,
-0.6756116152,
0.7426847816,
0.1701477468,
0.8785309792,
0.0342614651,
1.471601963,
0.1329713166,
0.3306160569,
-0.4849940836,
0.5530144572,
-0.7117573023,
-0.2552857995,
-0.313205719,
-0.4693511128,
-0.7787473798,
0.280731529,
0.0710486248,
-0.6005396843,
0.1445338279,
0.4197550714,
-0.4258005917,
0.2095800489,
-0.5818540454,
0.7195296884,
-0.127556026,
-0.333589524,
-0.1881367415,
-0.3185736835,
0.4805441201,
-0.0604543872,
0.1476234049,
-0.4411661923,
0.3409043252,
0.4494104981,
-0.5845779181,
0.9056009054,
-0.092540361,
-0.3130110204,
0.7238304019,
0.2186223865,
0.3606630862,
0.0002392662,
-0.0366106965,
0.3722411394,
-0.0055670799,
-0.3490875065,
-0.5081908703,
0.8722012043,
-0.8001813293,
-0.7128335834,
-0.1604064703,
-0.505397141,
-0.1455185115,
0.4881926179,
0.1584648341,
0.4060756862,
-0.3065843284,
0.1083648428,
0.3638153076,
0.2340895683,
0.5627666116,
0.1665769666,
-0.0164645743,
-0.8437028527,
0.8988255262,
0.180818215,
0.4984650612,
-0.0071375733,
0.3198500872,
-0.269259721,
-0.7244401574,
-0.6246144772,
0.201329723,
-0.5994371176,
-0.4949588478,
-0.4708998203,
-0.3950034976,
-0.8786953688,
-0.3038787842,
-0.7287697196,
-0.6406981945,
-0.3615849018,
0.2613290846,
-0.0299345851,
0.9328878522,
-0.4946685433,
0.3716231585,
-0.9349404573,
0.3793109655,
0.3225605488,
0.6707108617,
-0.1551281214,
-0.2456226349,
-0.030196771,
0.1870073974,
-0.5611858964,
-0.4583188593,
-0.0841007158,
0.3211319745,
0.8645631075,
0.4299790561,
-0.0357629098,
0.9981554747,
-0.5026266575,
0.7448880672,
0.3637147248,
-1.1364153624,
0.6838113666,
-0.2415116876,
0.2432802618,
1.0935301781,
-0.1351536065,
-0.4051036239,
-0.9665786624,
-0.7171630263,
-0.5849349499,
0.5577600002,
0.2814888656,
-0.1944562644,
-0.3530798554,
0.3399978578,
0.3292903006,
0.1127011478,
-0.4426558316,
-0.0602000505,
-0.5362204313,
-0.6264556646,
0.1184576452,
-0.0061896103,
-0.0397829562,
-0.1037058607,
0.5945475698,
-0.4446170628,
-0.1584842652,
0.4008229077,
0.2352410555,
-0.0454154424,
0.5613957047,
0.6964486241,
0.3990952075,
0.011186908,
0.471529007,
-0.139532879,
-0.2434450686,
0.270146817,
0.0192453321,
-0.3436605036,
0.0280750003,
-0.0267019328,
0.2988417149,
0.0670133382,
-0.2198765725,
0.2653745115,
0.1685814857,
-0.3729993105,
0.1118720919,
0.4978203177,
-0.0589538366,
0.1319339424,
0.1689472347,
0.243256703,
-0.05492815,
-0.577367425,
0.5978409052,
0.467040807,
-0.0956082121,
-0.0299838427,
0.5836097002,
0.2219867706,
0.1009328514,
0.3712553978,
-0.3944703639,
-0.0181606356,
0.2649349272,
0.636952579,
0.7534029484,
-0.4297752678,
0.0723679513,
0.4435751736,
0.0907257199,
-0.5807525516,
0.4585261345,
-0.194492355,
-0.7236286998,
-0.6194727421,
-0.7222287059,
-0.4908243716,
0.0080962079,
-0.3405611515,
0.247821331,
-0.5278909802,
0.0770884305,
-0.2290441394,
0.0369086638,
-0.277310431,
0.1979064941,
0.0258089919,
0.8572756052,
-0.7527120113,
0.8674890995,
0.240493238,
-0.4859468639,
-1.2199971676,
-0.135369122,
-0.093247667,
-0.7236839533,
0.1813376248,
0.0629565567,
-0.1852771938,
-0.1518778205,
-0.4635589719,
-1.1971255541,
1.0193096399,
0.3323631585,
-0.6462277174,
-0.033813756,
0.2192293406,
0.2584661841,
-0.5962249637,
0.0254580602,
0.7096502185,
0.4567610323,
0.4226624966,
-1.0092332363,
0.1065263301,
0.1205486581,
-0.1021612361,
0.4140614569,
-0.7585391402,
0.6814137697,
-0.1370222718,
-0.3249329925,
0.2037743032,
1.0419511795,
0.6846779585,
0.3479100168,
0.4232999086,
0.6444760561,
1.0062433481,
-0.244664073,
0.4727033973,
-0.4208449721,
0.2587962449,
1.628041625,
-0.2295705974,
0.7704214454,
0.4489280581,
-0.1019374281,
0.6009017825,
0.349865675,
-0.0705277547,
0.3635864854,
0.2419355959,
-0.1698237807,
-0.3762274683,
0.1119476855,
-0.3009048998,
0.6659092307,
0.169851914,
-0.054356277,
-0.687828064,
-0.3566306531,
-0.0557502471,
0.4391908348,
-0.1435028613,
0.7803742886,
0.0043654586,
-0.9651248455,
0.5576118827,
-0.1379255354,
0.7817789316,
-0.4227223098,
-0.1020398661,
-0.3919656575,
0.1309538633,
-0.3100643456,
-0.9215402007,
0.5353221893,
-0.0860328972,
-0.286724478,
-0.3176984787,
0.7857610583,
-0.6545827389,
-0.2539989948,
-0.0268575381,
0.8150925636,
0.362944901,
0.0644764602,
-0.3808454275,
0.0673716739,
0.1861687601,
0.1285392046,
0.3873454332,
0.734696269,
0.0081920475,
0.260750711,
0.7279422283,
0.3061520457,
-0.0273359027,
0.1869273335,
0.8832691908,
-0.5849254727,
-0.3011505604,
-0.6836335063,
0.3523313105,
-0.2111926228,
-0.2132900953,
0.6035854816,
0.8712545633,
0.9016541243,
0.3031179309,
0.8196206689,
-0.1466762722,
0.4149957597,
-0.4413977861,
0.4757312536,
-0.4805901647,
0.1116793603,
-0.1659345031,
-0.8535909057,
-0.1915174872,
0.5552993417,
0.1227435172,
-0.0243819505,
0.6052696705,
0.4877668917,
-0.2115743756,
-0.1353428215,
0.470736295,
-0.0613812432,
0.5662094355,
0.3872005641,
0.4508020878,
-0.2871693373,
0.560115695,
-0.3373555541,
-0.3517355025,
-0.0000321297,
-0.9696103334,
-0.4612405598,
-0.3575593233,
-0.2024835646,
-0.3956858814,
-0.1801569313,
0.9307272434,
0.7521814108,
-0.8485085368,
-0.2339699119,
-0.3229946196,
-0.0280928593,
-0.1113929823,
-0.2182153314,
0.0920150951,
-0.9808388948,
-0.7549179792,
0.6503961682,
0.4802049398,
0.3501457274,
-0.2355311364,
-0.0452188551,
0.2249970287,
0.216626212,
0.558904767,
0.3331940174,
-1.0227329731,
-0.6427224874,
0.0329429246,
-0.3576759398,
0.4042946398,
0.8471052051,
-0.7670669556,
0.1866787076,
0.4577517211,
0.4862414598,
0.170001328,
0.2724336386,
0.4786458313,
-0.8243632913,
-0.1937421411,
0.0570902824,
0.4650145173,
0.2291478664,
-0.296453923,
0.4752857685,
0.0598734841,
-0.6945493221,
-0.3622291684,
0.3549792171,
-1.1570321321,
-0.3251447976,
1.0990655422,
-0.1246020198,
-0.0208156183,
-0.113460362,
-0.0730709434,
0.2939413488,
-0.7674692869,
0.6423178911,
0.6592782736,
-0.5045313835,
0.0591949783,
-0.1470999122,
0.5264925361,
0.3283164799,
-0.8074734211,
0.4888975322,
0.7543455362,
0.4670204222,
0.2984133661,
1.0961847305,
-0.2060461342,
0.0127523309,
-0.0761275366,
0.1117937639,
-0.0339375027,
-0.3588555157,
-0.1636044979,
0.4125006199,
0.1753221899,
0.0400292501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02049v1 | Accompanied Singing Voice Synthesis with Fully Text-controlled Melody | 2024-07-02T08:23:38 | 2024-07-02T08:23:38 | Ruiqi Li, Zhiqing Hong, Yongqi Wang, Lichao Zhang, Rongjie Huang, Siqi Zheng, Zhou Zhao | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Text-to-song (TTSong) is a music generation task that synthesizes accompanied
singing voices. Current TTSong methods, inherited from singing voice synthesis
(SVS), require melody-related information that can sometimes be impractical,
such as music scores or MIDI sequences. We present MelodyLM, the first TTSong
model that generates high-quality song pieces with fully text-controlled
melodies, achieving minimal user requirements and maximum control flexibility.
MelodyLM explicitly models MIDI as the intermediate melody-related feature and
sequentially generates vocal tracks in a language model manner, conditioned on
textual and vocal prompts. The accompaniment music is subsequently synthesized
by a latent diffusion model with hybrid conditioning for temporal alignment.
With minimal requirements, users only need to input lyrics and a reference
voice to synthesize a song sample. For full control, just input textual prompts
or even directly input MIDI. Experimental results indicate that MelodyLM
achieves superior performance in terms of both objective and subjective
metrics. Audio samples are available at https://melodylm666.github.io. | [
-0.2173559666,
-0.6737293005,
0.5007807016,
0.8716262579,
-0.3775415719,
0.3816324472,
-0.0520330109,
-0.1588041633,
0.2172631323,
0.5643365383,
-1.0096366405,
-0.912054956,
-0.2818828821,
0.140940696,
-0.5727212429,
1.1680408716,
0.4188432992,
-0.1779815555,
-0.0921282843,
0.3124807179,
-0.3368202448,
-0.5343145728,
-0.7978175282,
-0.2241956294,
0.7302350998,
0.1423409432,
0.3264930844,
0.260794282,
0.0506848283,
0.2204722017,
-0.3244672418,
0.0558722354,
-0.4562713206,
0.5591807961,
0.1182436571,
-0.4337081015,
-0.7665895224,
0.30526039,
0.5036683679,
0.4531846642,
-0.1342314035,
0.3431873322,
0.2837646604,
0.6034183502,
0.0885941982,
-0.1725094914,
-0.5644823313,
0.3272882402,
-0.3278392255,
-0.30954054,
-0.444126606,
-0.5426695347,
0.27640903,
-0.818145752,
0.2468748689,
0.0938460305,
0.5282673836,
0.3692699671,
-0.2558201849,
-0.3798782527,
-0.8435531855,
0.7519925237,
-0.449958533,
0.4150951505,
0.4210603535,
0.2406309694,
-0.1824911833,
-0.9670789242,
-0.1318317354,
-0.4307932556,
0.1103949174,
0.5118118525,
0.0528806075,
0.2314445227,
0.2466933876,
0.259352833,
-0.6086984277,
-0.4587385356,
-0.2535590231,
-0.0790998414,
0.5345979333,
0.1094631776,
0.3191001713,
-0.3778711557,
-0.6265466809,
0.196173355,
-0.6259436607,
0.1769689023,
0.4860875309,
0.5853463411,
-0.3666502535,
0.683131516,
0.4992842078,
0.8937879205,
0.5120748878,
-0.0426433086,
0.1041595489,
-0.4854975343,
-0.4481467605,
0.3227952421,
0.9506283998,
-0.0115113035,
-0.1341897249,
-0.3151644468,
-0.4676817656,
-0.1834130585,
0.3592146337,
-0.3853233159,
-0.2534701824,
0.303740412,
-0.4516209662,
-0.3916673958,
-0.0299457964,
-0.6248529553,
-0.2311374247,
-0.6512537599,
0.5774534941,
-0.4231582582,
-0.2943448424,
-0.4134403765,
-0.187991187,
-0.2958543599,
0.1890122145,
-0.4129772484,
-0.0064310054,
0.505207181,
1.1939437389,
-0.3953894079,
-0.3147969246,
-0.6886326671,
0.318977356,
-0.5661864877,
0.6114553809,
-0.1752053648,
-0.7387316227,
-0.407338351,
-0.2397172898,
-0.1107795984,
-0.6386566758,
0.269967854,
-0.3091024458,
0.5482485294,
-0.0360846035,
-0.6562849879,
0.070537895,
-0.2552954555,
-0.8517671824,
1.0476263762,
0.5417348146,
-0.4916504025,
0.2687600851,
-0.7526530623,
-0.7180214524,
0.0186117981,
0.08298219,
-0.5286860466,
0.4088929594,
-0.1838859767,
0.2528113723,
-0.2327618152,
0.3944836259,
-0.1451758146,
-0.3998890519,
0.3050898015,
-0.2421210259,
0.662394762,
0.4446298182,
-0.1276050359,
0.4124370515,
-0.7496548295,
0.2345688194,
0.1467469782,
-0.4995345175,
-0.1486924291,
-0.005550914,
0.6169441938,
0.2509057224,
0.3756351769,
-0.1910764277,
-0.0626559108,
-0.3445037901,
0.3931997418,
0.4318672717,
0.0687685683,
0.549764812,
-0.7468560338,
0.7722552419,
-0.3648862839,
0.0453869551,
-0.1280564964,
-0.3955528438,
-0.2451407909,
-0.3204556704,
0.5413558483,
0.4539561868,
-0.4382508099,
0.633721292,
0.1225496158,
-0.3022137582,
-0.7456264496,
0.0934380889,
0.1741871238,
0.302244395,
0.2318577617,
0.1866712868,
-0.8038362265,
-0.4611876905,
-0.045197621,
-0.248883754,
-0.4512024522,
0.0321525671,
-0.1824667007,
0.3885118961,
0.9797832966,
-0.0649895221,
-0.4860767424,
-0.5483728647,
0.0277037863,
0.2564928234,
0.5774396062,
0.7694438696,
-0.8377686739,
-0.4524688125,
-0.2297497094,
-0.4707770944,
-0.6604294777,
-0.1937044561,
-0.3536027074,
0.1585128158,
0.4344399571,
-0.5364924073,
0.0523380823,
0.9167023897,
-0.4851002693,
0.5236930251,
0.1038100868,
0.3020131588,
-1.2940106392,
0.2535248697,
-0.1181494594,
-0.6023167372,
-0.8888813257,
-0.188171491,
-0.2854835987,
-0.3220230043,
-0.3079880774,
0.169854641,
-0.2628169656,
-0.1953088343,
-0.358152926,
0.0576902293,
0.1259580106,
0.3216407001,
0.1239994839,
0.8875734806,
0.5065201521,
-0.5150139928,
0.18515791,
0.1480024606,
-0.2175015807,
0.5645473003,
-0.7697630525,
0.3030042946,
0.2369436324,
0.0708887801,
-0.9972035289,
-0.2205905318,
0.0214459635,
-0.7769950628,
0.391461283,
-0.2750254571,
-0.5268067122,
-0.2467518151,
0.1876754761,
0.2416621745,
0.9860789776,
-0.44343099,
0.7412953377,
0.1010746807,
-0.48962605,
0.3692266643,
-0.6120265126,
0.0871876329,
-0.5010486841,
-0.2653509676,
0.39657107,
-0.1743375361,
-0.0050500608,
-0.1318610609,
-0.2398330718,
0.057591103,
-0.074219659,
0.3085393906,
0.2873085141,
-0.1238901094,
0.300735414,
0.2851327658,
0.0025662296,
-0.025931431,
-0.6960460544,
0.7044457197,
0.4912952781,
-0.1815163791,
-0.5163787603,
0.752702713,
0.6872374415,
-0.1928019226,
0.1509921402,
0.4121791124,
-0.0952696279,
-0.4924886227,
-0.1258220971,
-0.0035182608,
-0.4659094214,
0.1015422717,
-0.1679958254,
-0.7735889554,
0.3740280569,
-0.1220712289,
0.2643033564,
0.3606935441,
0.35222435,
-0.630081594,
1.3244071007,
0.4571363926,
0.1895172298,
0.8206902742,
0.0324263461,
-0.3229238391,
-0.6610793471,
-0.4163331985,
-0.5427299738,
-0.3750734329,
-0.3580551445,
-0.4146996439,
0.7939767241,
0.1666601598,
-0.3406600654,
0.1617634594,
-0.5999447703,
-0.0642972365,
0.8037862182,
0.2584063411,
0.1504091322,
0.0175635312,
-0.2537013292,
-0.089066565,
-0.5896144509,
-0.2676811516,
1.0557384491,
-0.0010460649,
0.7964224219,
-0.0115294643,
0.939121604,
0.5035436153,
-0.01327811,
-0.7079110742,
0.4349268377,
-0.3737244904,
-0.4819329083,
-0.1113471985,
-0.5216332078,
-0.5106638074,
-0.1228094399,
-0.3742494881,
-0.5339682698,
-0.6861887574,
0.4526733458,
-0.3601180613,
0.069141306,
-0.6094459891,
0.372479409,
-0.3364022076,
-0.1829848737,
0.210460946,
-0.5352184772,
0.2630114555,
-0.30405882,
-0.0856739208,
-0.131267786,
-0.0391320027,
0.6864114404,
-0.2478292584,
0.6774384379,
-0.2624101341,
-0.1817589551,
0.2351405472,
0.2106128186,
0.3293634653,
-0.1597976089,
-0.0120524568,
-0.0754945278,
-0.1507120878,
-0.3849091232,
-0.6158180833,
0.7711000443,
-0.4797154963,
-0.6094917655,
-0.0521484576,
-0.5626370907,
-0.449280113,
0.174211055,
0.6512759328,
0.3441080153,
0.0134446975,
0.1191854626,
0.6560589671,
-0.2790628672,
0.3557249308,
0.1232675612,
-0.7584351301,
-0.8123811483,
0.5578461885,
-0.1881148964,
0.5725261569,
0.3244594038,
0.3166000247,
-0.6842791438,
-0.6807240844,
-0.6172553897,
0.0310758501,
-0.213619113,
-0.0035368605,
-0.496298492,
-0.397530973,
-0.2649511397,
-0.0017141667,
-0.39719069,
-0.3533487022,
-0.5324344039,
0.0602846146,
0.5074267387,
0.7860181928,
0.0640647858,
0.4001526535,
-0.9567722678,
0.6132269502,
0.2049002796,
0.395735085,
-0.2075683922,
-0.3969528377,
-0.2092992514,
-0.1233068407,
-0.050020963,
-1.0406838655,
0.0935496166,
0.1907439381,
0.3624125421,
0.1438785493,
-0.0547040477,
0.6598752141,
-0.5775507092,
1.2001410723,
0.4575214088,
-1.0701963902,
0.7883594036,
-0.6013666391,
0.5157778263,
0.1596412957,
-0.1448061615,
-0.4587622583,
-0.7805351615,
-0.2783233821,
-0.7366020083,
0.6866309047,
0.6787648201,
-0.0896207616,
0.285568893,
0.1821426004,
0.17966263,
0.4779074788,
-0.5121620893,
-0.336651355,
-0.5077679753,
-0.5308798552,
-0.3309225142,
0.2511100173,
-0.0276833996,
-0.1001458988,
0.6090812087,
0.0558079891,
0.4128305614,
0.2530815899,
0.3320356905,
-0.3877566755,
0.0932951644,
0.5285331011,
0.239349395,
-0.0444175005,
-0.1019159704,
-0.4094201326,
-0.4177708924,
0.2337126583,
0.23957178,
-0.5330227017,
0.1922682971,
0.3112769127,
0.9898333549,
0.1477618665,
-0.4939812124,
0.2378949076,
-0.0944494456,
-0.2463180274,
-0.4119387865,
0.2431147546,
0.2760528028,
0.2491940409,
0.4983932078,
0.0946863294,
0.0479621626,
-0.1066611186,
0.3271890879,
0.2198131084,
-0.622781992,
-0.3363637626,
1.23189044,
-0.0536592677,
-0.4596660733,
0.1127563491,
0.1838494092,
-0.3287802041,
0.6078810096,
0.7143523097,
1.2291535139,
-0.5215414166,
0.1875767112,
0.1161069423,
0.0757093951,
0.1732346117,
0.6418854594,
-0.2822284997,
0.0979893953,
-0.4399906099,
-0.7786223292,
-0.0555215254,
0.3549310267,
-0.6387137771,
0.2692331076,
-0.5287088156,
-0.3926928639,
0.0296736732,
-0.285644263,
-0.3651517928,
0.3665272295,
0.0017877381,
0.9416770339,
-0.659812808,
0.6000588536,
0.655046463,
-0.1001084,
-0.959397316,
0.3858997524,
0.1780823022,
-0.2930566669,
0.1364694685,
-0.0513365157,
-0.164116472,
0.4907664955,
-0.5772253871,
-0.517062068,
0.8712874651,
0.1839038581,
-0.5922164321,
-0.3488709927,
0.0843234137,
0.5598607063,
-0.3360719681,
-0.3389313519,
0.4687711895,
0.418874532,
0.6356024742,
-0.8095878363,
-0.3386594653,
-0.3685401082,
0.0985557809,
0.2874524593,
-0.4110142589,
0.805734396,
0.0700916275,
-0.2326642126,
0.7187008858,
0.6225875616,
0.5059362054,
0.5390689373,
0.7732741237,
0.3237342238,
0.5585815907,
-0.4087086022,
0.8240074515,
-0.2553470731,
0.060272079,
1.2406386137,
-0.2983315885,
0.3802093565,
0.4198234975,
-0.1835517585,
0.0576518774,
0.7753586769,
0.1853931397,
0.8348488212,
0.2341418266,
-0.4636372626,
-0.3674454987,
-0.0442930385,
-0.1794838905,
0.4189460278,
0.3061275482,
-0.7190070152,
0.08013919,
0.334325254,
-0.3260068297,
0.1084374934,
-0.4092229605,
1.1000216007,
0.0382913277,
-0.8405743241,
0.3312948644,
-0.4106525183,
0.4016744494,
-0.9701561332,
-0.0836070105,
-0.1293476075,
-0.362475127,
-0.0438692048,
-0.8349844217,
0.127601862,
0.2530525923,
-0.2128050178,
-0.3280359209,
0.4662877321,
-0.8901708126,
-0.4458760321,
0.2968438566,
0.5490205884,
-0.2496105283,
-0.1032633483,
-0.4989722073,
-0.1825311184,
0.1355329305,
-0.19157888,
0.075568065,
0.4149511158,
0.1688688099,
0.3167677522,
0.7474595308,
0.5788466334,
0.3431410789,
0.4786514342,
0.5485388041,
-0.7598612309,
-1.0368900299,
-0.4700833261,
0.5439642668,
0.0868897438,
-0.0815927088,
0.5671460032,
0.6686534882,
0.3727443516,
-0.1341365278,
1.3133803606,
-0.1256957054,
0.9382391572,
-0.8917759061,
0.802749753,
-0.8966153264,
-0.0485953577,
-0.5679011345,
-0.9359329343,
-0.0850571841,
0.1380286366,
0.4776786864,
0.2171774656,
0.4335091412,
0.4670689404,
-0.1956577003,
0.2823360562,
0.5818740726,
0.0126489308,
0.1715319753,
0.7354753017,
1.1654808521,
0.001346022,
0.4577927589,
-0.2109791785,
0.0189100318,
0.1598319411,
-0.8083958626,
-1.0584880114,
-0.84471035,
-0.1724661589,
-0.4601700902,
-0.1358297318,
1.2866938114,
0.8559871316,
-0.7036758065,
-0.102726534,
-0.1061474904,
0.0757201388,
-0.4117565155,
-0.2267754376,
0.2279374897,
-0.0701298788,
-0.9087298512,
0.716789782,
0.270183295,
0.6785424948,
-0.2102854401,
-0.1352021098,
0.3596617281,
0.1501064599,
0.4492221475,
-0.2007443011,
-0.7325746417,
0.0090943128,
0.1682881415,
-0.105802156,
0.0934131518,
1.192789793,
-0.3446077108,
0.4146832824,
0.3907569945,
0.1065875441,
0.3170327842,
0.3065344095,
0.622173667,
-1.0486072302,
-0.1380627602,
0.4411741793,
-0.0581662133,
0.2741016448,
-0.270359695,
0.0245412681,
0.2217901051,
-0.2947435081,
-0.4905031919,
0.3040758967,
-1.3007404804,
-0.039411962,
1.1107578278,
-0.064882569,
-0.1446496993,
-0.0237776972,
-0.4840815961,
0.5680304766,
-0.4146679044,
0.5815801024,
0.4459229708,
-0.0282538217,
-0.2543812394,
-0.4330641031,
0.8943812847,
-0.0541896261,
-0.7334610224,
-0.0734700635,
0.7816170454,
0.2547399402,
-0.0760096461,
0.5787408352,
-0.2850685418,
0.567976594,
-0.1649533808,
-0.0954439417,
-0.3313180208,
-0.5705622435,
-0.3368332982,
0.4784251451,
0.0654469207,
-0.313413769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02043v1 | Concise and Precise Context Compression for Tool-Using Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:17:00 | 2024-07-02T08:17:00 | Yang Xu, Yunlong Feng, Honglin Mu, Yutai Hou, Yitong Li, Xinghao Wang, Wanjun Zhong, Zhongyang Li, Dandan Tu, Qingfu Zhu, Min Zhang, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Through reading the documentation in the context, tool-using language models
can dynamically extend their capability using external tools. The cost is that
we have to input lengthy documentation every time the model needs to use the
tool, occupying the input window as well as slowing down the decoding process.
Given the progress in general-purpose compression, soft context compression
is a suitable approach to alleviate the problem. However, when compressing tool
documentation, existing methods suffer from the weaknesses of key information
loss (specifically, tool/parameter name errors) and difficulty in adjusting the
length of compressed sequences based on documentation lengths.
To address these problems, we propose two strategies for compressing tool
documentation into concise and precise summary sequences for tool-using
language models. 1) Selective compression strategy mitigates key information
loss by deliberately retaining key information as raw text tokens. 2) Block
compression strategy involves dividing tool documentation into short chunks and
then employing a fixed-length compression model to achieve variable-length
compression. This strategy facilitates the flexible adjustment of the
compression ratio.
Results on API-Bank and APIBench show that our approach reaches a performance
comparable to the upper-bound baseline under up to 16x compression ratio. | [
-0.3441960514,
-0.5814520121,
0.4175571203,
0.0930332243,
-0.6108159423,
-0.0297324974,
-0.618118763,
-0.4100218713,
-0.015012403,
0.4878914952,
-0.4839174151,
-0.4240299165,
-0.3592272997,
0.1272342801,
-0.5087477565,
0.7925701737,
-0.0525674522,
-0.198903814,
-0.0729677081,
-0.1355450004,
-0.8209093809,
-0.6347420812,
-0.5127022862,
-0.0994170457,
0.3485907018,
0.3151315749,
0.6625778675,
0.9562826753,
0.3652051091,
0.2825413048,
-0.2120877653,
0.1114631444,
-0.2738132775,
0.4293639064,
-0.119453311,
-0.3584013879,
-0.400672406,
-0.2366932184,
0.5923972726,
0.7550631762,
-0.2639564574,
0.2576260865,
0.2208096236,
0.2803344727,
-0.5340134501,
0.1251094937,
-0.3438860774,
-0.1515575945,
-0.2404132187,
-0.5434946418,
-0.6207494736,
-0.0180285964,
0.0258967672,
-0.3189176321,
0.4926838279,
-0.2054677308,
0.7757843733,
0.3527890444,
-0.261801064,
-0.1862707436,
-0.8688805699,
0.6514452696,
-0.7459392548,
0.3751931489,
0.4096616507,
0.2217164487,
0.0890863538,
-0.7641072869,
-0.2249353081,
0.0622812919,
-0.1729919463,
-0.3274483383,
0.1303141266,
0.2917097509,
0.5352227092,
0.3635237813,
-0.473210901,
0.0708095729,
-0.5657539964,
-0.4772364795,
0.5938528776,
0.0317353383,
-0.0145262899,
-0.0734030753,
-0.172257334,
-0.5630264878,
-0.6765902638,
0.0889764801,
0.5181788802,
0.4438863993,
-0.0351832919,
0.330601722,
-0.2212654948,
1.0140544176,
-0.0686195046,
-0.4680620432,
0.0517446548,
-0.6339949965,
-0.2254311144,
0.0121294754,
0.4255640209,
0.4780980647,
-0.1386068612,
-0.4256685972,
-0.4781423211,
-0.0824293792,
0.492192626,
-0.9306729436,
0.141614005,
0.3753532469,
-0.451934427,
-0.1576303244,
0.0723780841,
-0.5401846766,
-0.1920365989,
-0.477263689,
0.1898020953,
-0.3191854954,
-0.091646418,
0.1618735343,
-0.4988263547,
-0.0187211335,
0.4129057825,
-0.7729792595,
0.3106162846,
0.5962144136,
1.1064736843,
0.1013934761,
0.1716870517,
-0.7221415639,
0.2692933679,
0.1085502207,
0.8542355895,
-0.5030462146,
-0.7171618938,
0.0574428812,
0.0857815966,
0.4193685949,
-0.3334442973,
0.6741729379,
-0.1548350304,
0.0909203663,
-0.0906189457,
-0.5487352014,
-0.0956933349,
0.1143217981,
-0.8788384199,
0.7731797695,
0.4301517308,
-0.6453307867,
0.1501945555,
-0.3709402382,
-0.5141400099,
0.1072760001,
-0.1048619747,
-0.1165842637,
0.3922266364,
0.1405977011,
0.5177907944,
-0.4137598574,
0.283495605,
-0.1260565519,
-0.5994125605,
0.0627504736,
-0.4007723331,
0.5042420626,
0.3163412213,
-0.0487009063,
0.2789863646,
-0.5473683476,
-0.0078048143,
-0.0569315664,
-0.5933892727,
-0.3386904597,
-0.0616854206,
0.136985153,
0.1677970886,
0.2505090833,
-0.3718903363,
0.6590242386,
-0.4762014449,
0.4135012925,
0.7101194263,
-0.1656052768,
0.5866849422,
-0.1914139986,
0.6116827726,
-0.3685258329,
0.3789123297,
-0.4147620797,
0.004672226,
-0.6805768609,
0.0951471254,
0.7069398165,
0.4979854822,
-0.7155225873,
0.4263052344,
-0.5301200151,
-0.4156956673,
-0.3639986217,
0.0505104885,
0.3395199776,
0.6176597476,
0.1960431188,
-0.6854934096,
-0.5567998886,
-0.7587680221,
-0.1409617811,
-0.1505898982,
-0.3140670061,
0.3444871604,
0.0651334152,
0.112872608,
0.9379392862,
-0.4147046804,
0.0468979552,
-0.4155965447,
0.3294790685,
0.3286086619,
0.560715735,
0.4048907161,
-0.9164896011,
-0.3183338344,
-0.3092972636,
-0.1696974039,
-0.3214274049,
-0.2830354571,
0.1684931964,
0.2416076362,
0.4658226073,
-0.6371122003,
0.5865151286,
0.5015096068,
-0.2818741202,
0.7338651419,
-0.2738774419,
-0.1590726376,
-0.8781442642,
0.2246356308,
-0.1612537354,
-0.4734228551,
-0.656057775,
0.336261183,
0.3162781894,
-0.0446557552,
-0.5251300931,
0.644136548,
-0.5534415841,
0.1512586027,
-0.4236852229,
-0.0240974631,
0.159217149,
0.458388865,
0.2160960734,
0.7702778578,
0.3419997394,
-0.63097471,
0.2714424133,
-0.0062045865,
-0.1822238266,
0.4461386502,
-0.6538567543,
0.4150514305,
0.0196275637,
0.6100157499,
-0.3102589548,
-0.074559845,
0.1449716687,
-0.1810100526,
0.7404001951,
-0.4235491455,
-0.924254775,
-0.2293573171,
-0.6198740602,
0.2813889384,
0.5921469331,
-0.0811664537,
0.5160476565,
0.1663894653,
-0.2559280694,
-0.4881515503,
-0.6460296512,
0.2187021524,
-0.304366976,
-0.6307600141,
0.7824178934,
-0.4049823284,
0.1077761427,
-0.1014842987,
-0.5661782026,
-0.0511476845,
0.0816600323,
0.0947609171,
0.0654874817,
-0.0459050499,
0.2516157329,
0.0849103183,
-0.2343150526,
-0.228335306,
-0.3224522173,
0.7484148741,
0.1140472665,
-0.0895775482,
-0.1087055206,
0.7810048461,
0.3147142529,
0.0410527736,
0.7209214568,
0.4658123255,
-0.2826970518,
-0.0785765499,
-0.6267117262,
-0.3136042953,
-0.4927681983,
0.0266493391,
-0.4503068626,
-0.7306092978,
0.554695487,
-0.4212117195,
0.2724380791,
0.1850575358,
0.2864584029,
0.3409905434,
1.0138885975,
1.0571752787,
-0.0177065022,
0.6217156649,
-0.2178964764,
0.2069295198,
-0.7832151651,
-0.0490231626,
-0.7658916116,
-0.2486550212,
-0.0643882528,
-0.4609804451,
0.1652837098,
0.398339808,
0.2604686916,
0.6114922762,
-0.75670439,
0.4297536016,
0.5464883447,
-0.043384932,
0.1011080667,
0.0774496719,
-0.0782766789,
0.3379666507,
-0.9104920626,
-0.6206443906,
0.9567826986,
0.3822531998,
0.7376155257,
0.188762188,
0.6280739307,
0.0927933529,
0.118058905,
-0.7911784053,
0.4174410999,
0.0348988436,
-0.3657766581,
-0.2682129145,
-0.2595990896,
-0.8878574967,
-0.1392248124,
0.2676369846,
-0.8625448346,
0.2088610083,
0.1364849955,
-0.4687394202,
0.0307399351,
-0.7516261935,
0.6955524087,
0.0077774883,
-0.2129160464,
-0.1274493188,
-0.8443082571,
-0.0028134228,
-0.1794339865,
0.2897927761,
0.1081424505,
-0.2137113214,
0.5251753926,
-0.8853669763,
0.7741109133,
-0.1529268324,
-0.1246100813,
0.0526908636,
0.0370801091,
0.6478339434,
-0.0376863591,
-0.1524862796,
0.0224744249,
0.2090670466,
-0.4165204167,
-0.8945215344,
0.3222531974,
-0.1917106509,
-0.679592967,
-0.1312883049,
-0.8137131333,
0.0784572214,
0.2058993578,
0.3229120374,
0.9472154975,
0.0392194353,
0.2989746332,
0.4982326925,
-0.1648055166,
0.4926592112,
0.5396765471,
0.1824757457,
-0.1093353033,
0.5856826901,
0.182872355,
0.274122715,
0.2682340443,
0.0950203612,
-0.2912063599,
-0.6629133821,
-0.5481815934,
0.0846163481,
-1.0604672432,
-0.5691511631,
-0.307501018,
-0.1016091257,
-0.6501521468,
-0.4567764401,
-0.1703072786,
-0.6319777966,
-0.1641791016,
0.0811558962,
0.2972224057,
0.3610703647,
0.043883279,
0.48677665,
-0.9852441549,
0.2168432474,
-0.1938317716,
0.4944709241,
-0.1678732336,
-0.4076176882,
-0.3847101629,
-0.0255800877,
-0.1050609797,
-1.0228207111,
0.3705189526,
0.2134658992,
0.4541295469,
0.5057801008,
0.4149353206,
0.8589410782,
-0.438231945,
0.7710127831,
-0.0814729556,
-0.8268859386,
0.6167814136,
-0.0399238057,
0.706808269,
0.5386732221,
0.1067328751,
-0.6795729399,
-0.479821533,
-0.6962078214,
-1.177721858,
0.7396796346,
0.1686948985,
0.3064317405,
0.0369953811,
0.5654816031,
0.228903845,
0.1389165223,
-0.4276709855,
-0.0311851911,
-0.0982488021,
-0.3968954682,
0.0898405015,
-0.3011175096,
-0.4116443992,
-0.1048515439,
0.4126076102,
-0.2621525526,
0.1768882424,
0.1829474717,
-0.3041195571,
0.2229554504,
0.4255263507,
0.5838515162,
0.6157360673,
-0.2877589762,
0.2928704023,
0.1735636741,
-0.4269201458,
0.0741555393,
0.1787739694,
-0.1797432899,
0.2995452881,
0.2753578126,
0.7424398661,
0.2471046448,
-0.8639967442,
0.3925670683,
-0.3297108412,
0.0933578461,
0.0222067274,
0.1858883947,
-0.0114145391,
0.0535925776,
0.2363528162,
-0.1079097986,
0.3596895933,
-0.3649291992,
-0.0054586856,
0.1709715128,
-0.1480503827,
-0.1734649837,
0.1390016973,
0.3432982862,
-0.4976231754,
0.4632993042,
-0.1726823896,
-0.2699478269,
0.4150975049,
0.4998016655,
0.7340199351,
-0.1650401354,
-0.1754058152,
0.2718398869,
0.1897799224,
-0.3916358054,
0.0997643024,
-0.6925914884,
-0.1996796429,
-0.6459688544,
-0.5855311751,
-0.3514657021,
0.0893397927,
-0.7238479257,
0.4953660667,
-0.373800844,
-0.2152277678,
-0.2376883924,
0.0408092067,
-0.769938767,
-0.0414218195,
-0.0199752469,
1.5032273531,
-0.4059835076,
0.9121534228,
0.270793587,
-0.4584780633,
-1.0530998707,
-0.1619155705,
0.0398209803,
-0.0514752753,
0.1282071471,
0.4570459127,
-0.126329124,
-0.186809063,
-0.5030235052,
-0.8453038931,
0.9549381137,
0.4383350313,
-0.6487802863,
-0.2850067019,
-0.1714151651,
0.301980108,
-0.1220070273,
-0.0706261694,
0.5355419517,
0.5280492306,
0.047073666,
-1.1827967167,
0.4287945032,
-0.366320014,
0.1394462287,
0.2323271036,
-0.2199053019,
0.391428709,
0.3328265846,
-0.6270099282,
0.2803028822,
0.3655115068,
-0.0285807494,
-0.0639653057,
0.6251617074,
0.2976391315,
0.6770766973,
0.1044860184,
1.378603816,
-0.5225920081,
0.1625707448,
0.9794162512,
0.0859033763,
0.6510657072,
0.4988543689,
0.1799724847,
0.5253814459,
0.8174312711,
0.0756743848,
0.3917406201,
0.0748704895,
-0.3156792819,
0.097580865,
-0.3044740856,
-0.35059461,
0.1398536414,
0.3556657434,
-0.3287989795,
-0.1153185219,
-0.1109503359,
0.162515834,
-0.2456558049,
-0.0581575148,
0.5960647464,
-0.0100517739,
-0.870474875,
0.7018693089,
0.4938119352,
0.682733357,
-0.7337164879,
0.0774909481,
-0.079063803,
-0.1957151145,
-0.0133216679,
-0.5800281763,
0.6141164303,
0.170196265,
-0.2117057741,
-0.6876286268,
0.9088439941,
-0.4383985996,
-0.2651223242,
-0.1160705835,
0.1464108378,
0.3137233555,
-0.1608065367,
-0.4709467292,
0.3821722269,
-0.2141795754,
-0.2668208778,
0.2719851136,
0.3267471194,
-0.1727745533,
0.4455521703,
0.6232588291,
0.1788517535,
-0.3318819106,
0.3437101543,
1.0600732565,
-0.6165446043,
-0.625274837,
-0.7540977597,
0.6884868741,
-0.4556563199,
-0.0307366271,
0.5172018409,
0.3455646336,
0.8231873512,
0.1014154479,
0.6238296628,
-0.0964273289,
0.1939819753,
-0.6103459597,
0.3801778853,
-0.4688368142,
0.2787572742,
-0.1228787154,
-0.7289491296,
-0.3592881858,
0.4887595475,
0.1290532798,
-0.1910862029,
0.741492331,
0.6329607964,
-0.2102373689,
-0.4060352445,
-0.0524477847,
-0.1532311589,
0.3205999732,
0.4425827563,
0.2226036489,
-0.1169882491,
0.8570241928,
-0.4103380144,
-0.0685152933,
-0.4381517768,
-1.045774579,
-0.5147278309,
-0.5800325871,
-0.4297316968,
-0.2202367187,
-0.294521898,
0.6979267597,
1.2301005125,
-0.2078993469,
-0.1605268121,
0.0386534445,
0.1934717596,
-0.3026708663,
-0.1926456392,
0.2879904807,
-0.2758607864,
-0.6719528437,
0.4376044273,
0.4962637126,
0.1010904238,
-0.4635626078,
-0.1507608593,
0.2683165967,
0.261125356,
0.4554027021,
0.32461375,
-0.8189065456,
-0.2975333631,
-0.1173403561,
0.0660529435,
-0.0702656135,
1.1298750639,
-0.9473145008,
0.5115066767,
0.6499391198,
0.3196566105,
0.4123434722,
0.0719419494,
0.9662863612,
-1.3749982119,
0.5189740062,
0.1550397575,
0.3781344593,
0.4789073169,
-0.5594995618,
0.7334754467,
-0.0441182218,
-0.2837876976,
-1.1282821894,
0.3549384773,
-1.1793725491,
-0.7169908285,
1.1252857447,
-0.304074496,
-0.3114922047,
-0.2759511769,
-0.5231420398,
0.5255481601,
-0.368470639,
0.7130084634,
0.8765054941,
-0.0477522463,
-0.1965414286,
-0.5571269989,
0.4395366907,
0.0051276176,
-0.4516404271,
0.1686834991,
0.4440995455,
0.1249700263,
0.3058372438,
0.4693276286,
0.0213042963,
0.3742811382,
0.086620301,
-0.0140041439,
-0.2455747873,
-0.1993622035,
-0.5120723248,
0.3039949536,
0.0307184272,
0.1625608802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02042v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02042v1 | Fake News Detection and Manipulation Reasoning via Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:16:43 | 2024-07-02T08:16:43 | Ruihan Jin, Ruibo Fu, Zhengqi Wen, Shuai Zhang, Yukun Liu, Jianhua Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fake news becomes a growing threat to information security and public opinion
with the rapid sprawl of media manipulation. Therefore, fake news detection
attracts widespread attention from academic community. Traditional fake news
detection models demonstrate remarkable performance on authenticity binary
classification but their ability to reason detailed faked traces based on the
news content remains under-explored. Furthermore, due to the lack of external
knowledge, the performance of existing methods on fact-related news is
questionable, leaving their practical implementation unclear. In this paper, we
propose a new multi-media research topic, namely manipulation reasoning.
Manipulation reasoning aims to reason manipulations based on news content. To
support the research, we introduce a benchmark for fake news detection and
manipulation reasoning, referred to as Human-centric and Fact-related Fake News
(HFFN). The benchmark highlights the centrality of human and the high factual
relevance, with detailed manual annotations. HFFN encompasses four realistic
domains with fake news samples generated through three manipulation approaches.
Moreover, a Multi-modal news Detection and Reasoning langUage Model (M-DRUM) is
presented not only to judge on the authenticity of multi-modal news, but also
raise analytical reasoning about potential manipulations. On the feature
extraction level, a cross-attention mechanism is employed to extract
fine-grained fusion features from multi-modal inputs. On the reasoning level, a
large vision-language model (LVLM) serves as the backbone to facilitate
fact-related reasoning. A two-stage training framework is deployed to better
activate the capacity of identification and reasoning. Comprehensive
experiments demonstrate that our model outperforms state-of-the-art (SOTA) fake
news detection models and powerful LVLMs like GPT-4 and LLaVA. | [
-0.541969955,
-1.188395977,
0.7685533762,
-0.1050965339,
-0.2780309021,
-0.0016872105,
-0.0135259526,
-0.6288369298,
0.1804858893,
0.5387177467,
-0.4359472096,
-0.2239038944,
-0.4339075685,
-0.1299101561,
-0.6142849326,
0.5430731773,
-0.039466992,
0.1233715564,
-0.0223595146,
-0.2628494501,
-0.3037174046,
-0.684422493,
-0.1189776957,
-0.1242447123,
0.6077188253,
0.1992381811,
0.5435940027,
0.6468405724,
0.3409127593,
0.3378350735,
0.1780483723,
0.4200485647,
-0.2307351232,
-0.3256318867,
-0.5188985467,
-0.3737227917,
-0.2504589558,
0.3693115711,
0.3664513826,
0.2385036796,
0.0297731571,
0.1551907063,
-0.2548092604,
0.3731838763,
-0.6749018431,
-0.0807374418,
-0.6795440912,
-0.2875249684,
-0.293554455,
-0.1766222864,
-0.4181707799,
-0.1445667595,
-0.2774059474,
-0.5860729814,
0.1604516357,
0.2682853639,
1.0051862001,
0.1950875223,
-0.5492290258,
-0.0479263589,
-0.6279247403,
0.6707078815,
-0.4079666436,
0.7257645726,
0.2140427679,
0.5357769728,
-0.0470013209,
-0.494577527,
-1.12540555,
-0.2321626395,
-0.0765553489,
-0.082904622,
-0.1503271461,
-0.1538389474,
0.4325655401,
0.2394333035,
-0.4726197422,
-0.1013762504,
-0.3690295219,
-0.5013295412,
0.529720664,
-0.1302029938,
0.2858135104,
-0.3736611605,
-0.6942683458,
-0.1026206389,
-0.5332264304,
-0.1568837315,
0.5421017408,
-0.0537410863,
-0.0044854553,
0.5803608894,
-0.3683489263,
0.745208025,
0.0326956101,
-0.4534117579,
0.1492621154,
-0.4404687285,
-0.4395157099,
-0.0709669814,
0.5807161927,
0.4331917465,
-0.0574389882,
0.0280988626,
-0.1087473407,
0.526725471,
0.4001007974,
-0.4399124384,
0.2313459516,
0.1063092202,
-0.6400727034,
-0.483812511,
0.3276801109,
-0.7528104186,
-0.4009758532,
-0.6384077668,
0.7917092443,
-0.4818316698,
-0.4639058411,
0.2062977999,
-0.1945242733,
0.2363079786,
0.6172122359,
-0.1773561984,
-0.132592991,
0.8067507148,
0.5061064959,
-0.2193316221,
-0.5229644179,
-0.6604028344,
0.031831868,
-0.214041695,
0.7291564941,
-0.3405461907,
0.3929941058,
-0.0598126277,
0.0115600536,
0.0706113949,
-0.3763695955,
0.8093731999,
-0.8870826364,
0.3201643825,
-0.3959438503,
-0.4223330915,
-0.5330045819,
0.7176237106,
-0.7672362328,
0.6493575573,
0.054499615,
-0.8294740319,
0.4854896367,
-0.5536726713,
-0.5363858938,
-0.3221337795,
0.0653175265,
-0.3445882797,
-0.2247021198,
0.2360256612,
0.2417195737,
-0.1919412464,
0.5553531051,
-0.4381211698,
-0.3808881342,
0.5169022679,
-0.659953475,
0.7184641361,
0.2187275887,
-0.3576888144,
0.2322182506,
-0.5680424571,
-0.3774011135,
-0.002701415,
-0.3197870553,
-0.2828543186,
-0.3072597086,
-0.0380424708,
0.5734318495,
0.0294904057,
-0.5781337619,
0.2824299335,
-0.010639783,
0.2835530341,
0.4542016685,
0.0780353993,
0.4715871513,
-0.335234195,
0.0936214551,
0.3660764992,
0.4795376062,
-0.3762793839,
-0.2036332637,
-0.6244643927,
-0.2251476347,
0.33108145,
0.6306618452,
-1.2040730715,
0.2667441666,
-0.1323674321,
-0.2395476848,
-0.5511145592,
-0.0068991873,
0.2840002477,
0.6438486576,
0.5709715486,
0.1126517132,
-0.509974122,
-0.8335452676,
-0.8563026786,
0.0884636864,
0.2537352145,
-0.2298561782,
0.6080772877,
-0.1372733265,
0.8558111787,
-0.1645165384,
-0.3792113364,
-0.1759421527,
0.2522242367,
0.0617681332,
0.1425641477,
0.4692480564,
-1.4927948713,
-0.084000662,
-0.1704495847,
-0.72827667,
0.0199356768,
-0.4394890666,
-0.143631205,
0.5060930848,
0.51799649,
-0.9564428329,
0.7693641782,
0.3820995688,
-0.3492747545,
1.0004212856,
0.1995877624,
0.6446934938,
-0.8425824642,
-0.0332012884,
0.2218020111,
-0.6145715714,
-0.6734029651,
0.3998406827,
0.1266029924,
0.0576367751,
-0.7054495811,
0.593527019,
-0.4419196248,
-0.1787302196,
-0.5246873498,
0.1207409576,
0.123639293,
0.4619125128,
-0.0824393183,
0.400351584,
0.3466611505,
-0.4094342887,
0.7767598629,
-0.1935989112,
-0.5749710798,
0.5763536692,
-0.3202992976,
-0.2302309424,
0.0125402706,
0.4532446861,
-0.6396991611,
-0.4882436097,
0.5648558736,
-0.6020867825,
0.0584401898,
-0.1598687768,
-0.9405758381,
-0.2994939089,
-0.1468425691,
0.216187492,
0.2308703363,
-0.746960938,
0.7110102773,
0.1548880786,
0.4769410193,
-0.5421658158,
-0.6182686687,
0.179892838,
-0.12886329,
-0.6944274306,
0.3447163701,
0.0297131445,
-0.4997664988,
0.2308507413,
-0.2934250236,
0.083221592,
-0.1224700958,
0.1749428809,
0.188425228,
-0.0900714323,
0.0646591559,
0.0497173779,
-0.073036097,
-0.1144190356,
-0.0019236761,
0.4481957853,
-0.0511241443,
-0.7341151237,
-0.6157947183,
0.2915376425,
1.022454977,
-0.39863047,
0.7521117926,
0.8436505795,
-0.5427448153,
0.0480047986,
-0.9544794559,
-0.4885489941,
-0.3600861132,
0.1416998655,
-0.3724361062,
-0.6519985795,
0.3013893664,
-0.1483179778,
-0.2525213063,
0.2229619622,
0.6825999022,
0.1887005121,
1.0060191154,
0.3007572293,
-0.0733273253,
0.3315598965,
-0.1174286157,
0.2565281987,
-0.4271630049,
-0.1008789092,
0.0076897587,
-0.2763246894,
-0.1651481539,
-0.7735470533,
0.4438113868,
0.1064144671,
-0.0691002309,
0.2195764184,
-0.1109590977,
0.5320436954,
0.5663211942,
0.1781457514,
0.547657907,
0.1628938913,
0.0251991861,
0.1822034717,
-0.4196916223,
-0.2716266811,
0.5437150598,
0.447001785,
0.6139678359,
0.1482376158,
0.1162920818,
0.3925009668,
0.3953085542,
-0.7116223574,
0.4847117662,
0.1757343262,
-0.8331460953,
-0.3272967935,
-0.4351359904,
-0.3884350955,
0.672686398,
-0.277343452,
-0.4391985238,
0.1642829329,
0.0288077891,
-0.0708954632,
0.6283512712,
-0.6502809525,
0.6227555275,
-0.2881424427,
-0.4626062214,
-0.6774269938,
-0.6503565907,
0.7870929241,
-0.0733277872,
0.5940662622,
-0.0228814539,
0.2337061912,
0.047229059,
-0.2818983197,
0.8587571383,
-0.1136301458,
-0.0098668272,
0.178360194,
0.3589923084,
0.314866215,
0.1209842786,
0.0594564229,
0.2789772749,
-0.2538825572,
-0.2935791612,
-0.5812062621,
0.6871871948,
-0.3158347607,
-0.7968128324,
-0.5841841698,
-0.5422747731,
-0.0463748537,
0.2594400346,
0.2063108832,
0.4026851952,
0.0546021052,
0.2159755081,
0.4476600587,
-0.0584168956,
0.304333508,
0.5750998855,
-0.4646253586,
-0.1157767475,
0.8797425032,
0.0372478254,
0.19763951,
0.3809404373,
0.2921772897,
-0.290445298,
-0.036889825,
-0.8149572015,
0.2077565342,
-0.5775002241,
-0.1974278539,
-0.5830482244,
-0.1828913987,
-0.3636994362,
0.0553368516,
-0.2894772887,
-0.2807551324,
-0.0425332561,
0.0832274854,
0.0605214052,
0.1386162937,
-0.1972073615,
0.0497470051,
-0.6769477725,
1.0735468864,
0.4250015318,
0.2575134933,
-0.1196443811,
-0.6020144224,
-0.1886747181,
0.3360843062,
-0.4038569629,
-1.2388010025,
0.2213604301,
-0.2935276628,
0.7047495842,
0.4877811372,
0.0261893701,
0.2276616246,
-0.0688472092,
0.5833617449,
0.2078273445,
-1.0071747303,
0.5071259141,
-0.4587400556,
-0.0581176132,
0.1489984393,
0.4074801505,
-0.367220521,
-0.2729595304,
-0.5596153736,
-0.2352775335,
0.7008849382,
0.0139592355,
-0.1399812549,
0.4022624791,
0.2139743268,
0.1808566302,
0.3646324277,
-0.9341423512,
-0.1311204135,
-0.3549067676,
0.1501784623,
0.2589829862,
-0.0674230233,
-0.2574737668,
-0.5380828977,
0.6318594813,
-0.2932036221,
0.0025595019,
0.1526004374,
-0.4274331927,
-0.0762792155,
0.2511930764,
0.7643105388,
0.9176109433,
0.111984849,
0.3245058358,
0.004437685,
-0.2158680856,
0.0753678605,
0.1069887877,
-0.2152486295,
-0.0937879533,
0.391514957,
0.7808936834,
0.1303866953,
-0.4778303504,
0.8768181205,
0.0719058588,
-0.3354767561,
-0.1327135265,
0.0094493087,
0.0280222166,
0.3270644248,
0.499537915,
0.4224930704,
0.1674112529,
-0.9442586303,
0.2195007056,
0.2779345512,
-0.1043723151,
-0.3844515383,
0.4755990505,
-0.0071253893,
-0.0021093735,
0.3407863975,
-0.3984845579,
-0.9670113325,
0.4390471876,
0.4295759201,
0.3237383068,
-0.2239831835,
0.501909852,
0.1309873611,
0.488070786,
-0.3073593974,
0.1575473696,
0.1175393462,
-1.1467761993,
-0.7800156474,
-0.4696621597,
-0.1925004423,
0.4387680292,
-0.3536242843,
0.5238249302,
-0.2221061736,
0.1524794102,
0.1846067458,
-0.1706688106,
-0.4177121818,
0.2056141496,
0.2355275899,
1.0880154371,
-0.9270793796,
0.9173064828,
0.6130101085,
-0.5357833505,
-0.5228895545,
0.2503204346,
0.4171646833,
-0.545183599,
0.4708379805,
0.3126652241,
-0.15120399,
-0.3781835437,
-0.8439543843,
-0.4498269558,
0.7239570618,
0.5850244164,
-0.4983641505,
0.0705795735,
0.0397366174,
0.2965740263,
-0.2465562075,
-0.1746155769,
0.6000845432,
0.8712152243,
0.1775678396,
-0.7004173994,
0.1172461733,
0.0296501089,
-0.448640883,
0.2637518942,
-0.910187602,
0.9550856352,
-0.1877022237,
-0.1339283139,
-0.3064551651,
0.5178535581,
0.4105296731,
0.7192931175,
0.7736622095,
0.7694552541,
0.3538187742,
-0.1094304621,
1.1003183126,
-0.160302788,
0.2770424485,
0.7669606805,
-0.310965687,
0.546184063,
0.5370444655,
0.1634280682,
0.6788061261,
0.2912501097,
-0.16689457,
0.235612154,
-0.1031966507,
-0.178270638,
-0.6706536412,
0.0179205257,
-0.1808926612,
0.9921138883,
0.4136589468,
-0.150775075,
-0.2852299511,
0.342605263,
0.1851203889,
0.11881423,
-0.2498952001,
0.4082120359,
-0.0235840268,
-0.6953283548,
0.3794531822,
0.390929848,
0.6100042462,
-0.2527892292,
-0.172992453,
0.0913065076,
0.0987349078,
-0.1541422009,
-0.7002635002,
0.2851457596,
-0.1458296925,
-0.3868093193,
-0.2642225921,
1.3160344362,
-0.4417654574,
-0.2617077231,
0.2736031115,
0.719678998,
-0.0688055381,
-0.6834844947,
-0.6763670444,
0.355247438,
-0.1653714478,
-0.3120643497,
0.3970024288,
0.4388741851,
-0.3048998415,
0.6089110374,
1.1202189922,
0.1430459172,
-0.1260941625,
0.1185849681,
0.9093577862,
-0.5305966139,
-0.6426675916,
-0.8066022396,
0.1934415102,
-0.3632116616,
0.0228546746,
0.7977792025,
0.5395524502,
0.6380953789,
-0.1457973272,
0.7259088755,
0.061957173,
0.821896553,
-0.6445691586,
0.7036348581,
-0.6606585979,
0.0509242602,
-0.0246927869,
-0.8504619002,
-0.2339122444,
0.3460721374,
-0.3175438344,
-0.0385892577,
0.6007679701,
0.8117784262,
-0.5189234614,
0.2137096077,
0.4694494307,
0.3523765206,
0.2299449742,
0.2064403594,
1.0359913111,
-0.3738650978,
0.5560672283,
-0.2958662212,
-0.1858379692,
-0.6762563586,
-0.9617938995,
-0.7072064877,
-0.6106797457,
-0.2558954954,
-0.4326941073,
-0.0992066935,
0.604921639,
1.0029239655,
-0.5217354298,
0.3193817437,
0.1400204748,
0.5776492953,
-0.4399257302,
-0.3265600801,
0.3461024165,
0.130000785,
-0.4387596846,
0.4473321736,
0.2559039295,
-0.1089325771,
-0.624222517,
0.0778411105,
-0.4697799981,
0.1659530699,
0.8715569973,
0.2735584676,
-0.9923492074,
-0.4604682326,
-0.0289475918,
-0.0904843584,
-0.1213125587,
1.0482401848,
-1.0020543337,
0.2903672755,
0.5567168593,
0.4137512743,
0.5102462769,
0.3545360267,
0.1016908661,
-0.8387661576,
0.2378631085,
-0.1825596541,
0.3058589399,
0.4111964405,
-0.4067148268,
0.1442046911,
0.7048121691,
-0.340477407,
-0.8598511815,
0.4403958917,
-0.9187537432,
-0.6687541604,
1.3018604517,
0.2138831615,
-0.4916184545,
-0.2745885849,
-0.3458743989,
0.3353936076,
-0.2341484576,
0.78163445,
0.7668542862,
-0.135762468,
-0.5339249372,
-0.6637370586,
0.345864892,
0.0543210097,
-0.9908903241,
-0.0318095796,
0.6087602973,
0.2584021986,
0.4787885547,
0.2573618591,
-0.2437964529,
0.5278087258,
0.0053509315,
0.0380478017,
-0.3517577052,
-0.6524668336,
-0.093507506,
0.1847914606,
-0.6713438034,
-0.1602938324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02039v1 | Prompt Stability Scoring for Text Annotation with Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:11:18 | 2024-07-02T08:11:18 | Christopher Barrie, Elli Palaiologou, Petter Törnberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Researchers are increasingly using language models (LMs) for text annotation.
These approaches rely only on a prompt telling the model to return a given
output according to a set of instructions. The reproducibility of LM outputs
may nonetheless be vulnerable to small changes in the prompt design. This calls
into question the replicability of classification routines. To tackle this
problem, researchers have typically tested a variety of semantically similar
prompts to determine what we call "prompt stability." These approaches remain
ad-hoc and task specific. In this article, we propose a general framework for
diagnosing prompt stability by adapting traditional approaches to intra- and
inter-coder reliability scoring. We call the resulting metric the Prompt
Stability Score (PSS) and provide a Python package PromptStability for its
estimation. Using six different datasets and twelve outcomes, we classify >150k
rows of data to: a) diagnose when prompt stability is low; and b) demonstrate
the functionality of the package. We conclude by providing best practice
recommendations for applied researchers. | [
-0.2694195211,
-0.7679952383,
0.5963835716,
0.5549971461,
-0.0229657013,
-0.2037983388,
-0.3662934303,
-0.2139432877,
0.1379388273,
0.3047127426,
-0.2803513408,
-0.3842977583,
-0.4994269609,
0.5603808165,
-0.3021983206,
1.2334551811,
0.0547985919,
0.1384044141,
-0.6386120319,
-0.3528367877,
-0.7148143053,
-0.717258513,
-0.7138665318,
0.024712326,
0.6139764786,
0.254273206,
0.8487039208,
0.4986088574,
0.5249082446,
0.3366795778,
-0.3057363033,
-0.0297744013,
-0.0677449852,
0.6239634752,
0.066359736,
-0.2912875116,
-0.302302897,
-0.0489975139,
0.7212554812,
0.7190315723,
0.057536196,
-0.0084035806,
0.3505309224,
0.1559521258,
-0.2858117521,
0.2062952816,
-0.2047338933,
-0.1808551848,
-0.1398230344,
-0.2570352256,
-0.7608437538,
-0.7730550766,
0.2237123549,
-0.2731851041,
-0.0568564385,
0.015508011,
0.5368447304,
0.2309882045,
-0.1210237592,
-0.3124251068,
-0.5154326558,
0.6502071619,
-0.5685599446,
0.0175664872,
0.5318952799,
0.3120661676,
-0.2917377651,
-0.3771029711,
-0.2966917753,
-0.6624763012,
-0.2096230984,
-0.2321867347,
-0.00582129,
0.0676212236,
0.5599611998,
0.1329819858,
-0.4298737943,
0.2722758353,
-0.1653186232,
-0.5857912898,
0.2801366448,
0.3428913057,
0.5320057869,
-0.1114156991,
-0.3308006227,
0.1275702715,
-0.5186474323,
0.3815415502,
0.292781502,
0.6334531307,
0.1153158993,
0.6368176341,
-0.0359764919,
0.5447075963,
0.2409700155,
-0.2244344354,
0.2299376577,
-0.3330847025,
0.2734736502,
0.1474387199,
0.8467526436,
0.6143748164,
0.1335562021,
-0.0483745039,
-0.4473407567,
0.1433958411,
0.3119087815,
-0.6622138619,
-0.3799468875,
0.2467504442,
-0.5727664232,
-0.1313908547,
0.0768238828,
-0.6569610834,
-0.7925179005,
-0.0659933686,
0.4055407047,
-0.556152463,
-0.1907391995,
-0.204596445,
0.0664607286,
-0.1373911351,
0.4545249343,
-0.7089714408,
0.247775808,
0.5580112934,
1.182063818,
-0.1167064235,
-0.54115206,
-0.998001039,
-0.5655088425,
-0.407720685,
0.9256368876,
-0.3232754767,
-0.2880192101,
0.2219447792,
0.3820717037,
-0.0497583523,
-0.2121426761,
0.7521797419,
-0.2725285292,
0.3862855434,
-0.5168502331,
-0.709253788,
0.1113283783,
0.3226846755,
-0.7044522762,
1.0853267908,
0.1908175945,
-1.094746232,
0.3210879266,
-0.240648821,
-0.1749373227,
0.1015210152,
0.0180488862,
-0.6336501837,
0.1198646948,
-0.09703549,
0.3941796422,
-0.041571673,
0.3039709926,
-0.4980968535,
-0.5586721301,
0.3714928329,
-0.2817354798,
0.6605989337,
-0.0611710586,
0.0440623462,
0.2799156904,
-0.6995311975,
-0.1076639816,
-0.2616155744,
-0.4167158902,
-0.3964545429,
0.1836399287,
-0.1668743044,
0.2634752095,
0.0890638158,
-0.4714239538,
0.3250471354,
-0.0992705822,
0.3120301366,
0.5808061361,
0.089892827,
0.4057789445,
-0.4768627584,
0.8603553176,
-0.0288849454,
-0.0486673377,
-0.8006461859,
-0.6374620199,
-0.5552153587,
-0.1789728403,
0.1809820384,
0.6046469212,
-0.6719863415,
0.6530428529,
-0.2257616073,
-0.4634197652,
-0.3516218662,
-0.265429914,
0.4304686487,
0.6519162655,
0.2478521466,
-0.0481333993,
-0.3654595315,
-0.6880299449,
-0.2374579459,
-0.4912088811,
0.0499458574,
-0.3471444547,
0.33803159,
-0.2360055298,
1.1752599478,
-0.19749479,
0.0421495065,
-0.1844638884,
0.3977669179,
0.243061319,
0.533703208,
0.8392727375,
-0.2624201179,
-0.1511897445,
-0.2908780873,
-0.4034894109,
-0.4185113907,
-0.1038229167,
0.2248721868,
0.5866472721,
0.474770993,
-0.5797753334,
0.3385765254,
0.5466535091,
-0.6072819233,
0.9610598087,
-0.3539927006,
0.3822589815,
-0.9518398046,
0.2439745367,
0.3427445292,
-0.3262740076,
-0.5021162629,
-0.3916165829,
0.1753514558,
-0.1285315752,
-0.0713263601,
0.3477656841,
-0.1147091463,
0.1735559702,
-0.4535197914,
-0.0566240996,
-0.0928373039,
-0.0240739137,
0.0198824275,
0.7804277539,
0.5099872351,
-0.6435269117,
0.4117826819,
0.189167574,
-0.2428495884,
0.6888058782,
-0.9915913343,
0.142102167,
-0.2342270315,
0.2426719517,
-1.2722234726,
-0.0454275124,
0.314865768,
-0.5375548601,
0.0954658836,
-0.3773147464,
-0.582818687,
-0.2839600146,
-0.4847767353,
0.2613012195,
0.3093703687,
-0.4813461602,
0.2985613942,
0.2937064469,
-0.5089101195,
-0.5558601022,
-0.4902381003,
-0.1249922439,
-0.2508473098,
-0.610663414,
-0.1967159957,
-0.2480205148,
-0.3605193496,
0.0775640681,
0.1002054363,
0.0225097742,
0.2982127666,
0.6152355671,
0.2487475276,
-0.2317229658,
0.2680038214,
-0.0809262618,
-0.4630402923,
0.1451316327,
-0.0057829875,
0.4105579853,
-0.1621681303,
-0.1080963761,
-0.3745157719,
0.335332185,
0.6597235203,
-0.1761271954,
0.9463875294,
0.2829378545,
-0.3937645555,
-0.1809763908,
-0.2489257604,
-0.0077791335,
-0.4411373138,
0.3015244603,
-0.3391613066,
-0.7250829935,
0.836540103,
0.0977390036,
0.1463256776,
0.419020474,
0.4055698514,
-0.0956162363,
1.0143897533,
0.8293229938,
-0.0346804932,
0.3639902771,
0.4249903858,
0.1528749019,
-0.2922947705,
-0.2558370233,
-0.9837274551,
0.1368716061,
-0.3796925545,
-0.1761389971,
0.1732885092,
0.2522520423,
-0.2543978989,
0.3186748922,
-0.4188123345,
0.5219522119,
0.4583409429,
-0.1363490522,
0.0748779103,
-0.2444197834,
-0.1232141331,
-0.1033095121,
-0.3983462751,
-0.9535665512,
0.4393085241,
0.4901931882,
0.5982174277,
-0.1475083977,
0.3244050145,
0.469263196,
0.1650170684,
-0.6752007604,
0.5346522331,
-0.131028071,
-0.1718074083,
-0.311437279,
-0.5274198651,
-0.8220945001,
-0.1130535677,
-0.1997602433,
-0.7161718011,
-0.0303809959,
0.2713296115,
-0.6134895682,
-0.1243822053,
-0.5735967755,
1.003929019,
-0.0986426324,
0.0261648186,
0.3682012558,
-0.6907908916,
0.0717850477,
-0.0336039513,
0.1854966283,
-0.1503107697,
-0.1351638585,
0.8876696825,
-0.5737323165,
0.8091850281,
-0.2847834229,
-0.3152143359,
0.2128191143,
0.2673842609,
0.3470937312,
0.112887755,
-0.403329879,
-0.0486498363,
0.2230208665,
-0.2465893328,
-0.5952825546,
0.7844106555,
-0.573040247,
-0.1526619494,
-0.7891033292,
-0.3313951194,
-0.1628232002,
0.1436770856,
0.3733642995,
0.664098084,
0.0233277734,
0.052695103,
0.4942019284,
-0.3284396231,
0.718789041,
0.3217852712,
-0.3678857088,
-0.6757224798,
0.6237002015,
0.3177196681,
0.1193282083,
0.0180036221,
0.2800855935,
-0.3627592921,
-0.5688339472,
-0.3730877638,
-0.1651836336,
-0.8492805362,
-0.3417335451,
-0.4351572692,
-0.0308530051,
-0.1323257238,
-0.2209777534,
-0.2026807666,
-0.4871519208,
-0.3288093209,
-0.1917454451,
0.694796145,
0.750932157,
0.2191341668,
0.3331438899,
-0.9125348926,
-0.0514608584,
-0.1242961958,
0.6102072001,
-0.3818406463,
-0.5855018497,
-0.2120573521,
-0.1546297222,
0.1081258431,
-0.9771882892,
0.1126548871,
0.1532990634,
0.606965661,
0.2728683352,
0.4209292531,
0.3684647083,
-0.4603191614,
1.1326874495,
0.2574030459,
-1.1235338449,
0.7409168482,
-0.5441622138,
0.2190964371,
0.7378568649,
0.426056385,
-0.7570551634,
-0.4733754992,
-0.1759726703,
-0.8293270469,
0.6931553483,
-0.2614062428,
0.0604701228,
-0.2732467949,
0.6579079032,
0.4980586171,
-0.0369024724,
-0.5791520476,
-0.1003913209,
-0.2434698045,
-0.4528939426,
-0.2763572931,
-0.5033082366,
0.0956150368,
-0.0732957125,
0.4560643435,
-0.3915634155,
-0.0629445389,
-0.0023465625,
-0.1339166909,
-0.1726548374,
0.0416917428,
0.5561423898,
0.8337756991,
-0.1458409429,
0.3428419232,
-0.2098287195,
-0.4974797666,
0.3703260124,
0.024181312,
-0.4917907417,
0.0274055135,
0.5280217528,
0.642451942,
0.2120371759,
-0.7035210729,
0.6880329251,
-0.3419416547,
0.1727179885,
-0.21062693,
-0.1413272768,
-0.3118764162,
0.0243474711,
0.2389625609,
0.3200969994,
-0.2436912209,
-0.3562792838,
0.4508410096,
0.2109215111,
-0.4160428047,
-0.5968561172,
0.5018773079,
0.4269783795,
-0.4770445228,
0.5969343185,
-0.4139890075,
-0.6070837975,
0.435955584,
0.5738413334,
0.9704427123,
-0.3899610043,
0.5075227618,
0.4589939117,
0.4649625421,
-0.5975750089,
0.3962596953,
0.3938031793,
-0.4775577188,
-0.3889543414,
-0.5499092937,
-0.4672239423,
-0.2217083126,
-0.7202547193,
0.4590680897,
-0.551191926,
-0.3764926195,
-0.3456940949,
-0.0255669914,
-0.0591953993,
0.0673759878,
0.0787905082,
0.7987748384,
-1.2295392752,
0.6738157272,
0.9105271101,
-0.5481312275,
-0.501958251,
0.1538664997,
-0.1065806597,
-0.3033639789,
0.3657082617,
0.532269299,
-0.0236108918,
-0.520917356,
-0.3854736686,
-0.806766808,
0.7789658904,
0.6891393065,
-0.57141155,
0.34406811,
-0.2097428888,
0.7606832981,
-0.1785788685,
0.462369889,
0.4256291986,
0.3129950464,
-0.1757930815,
-1.156057477,
0.2394984663,
-0.4395453334,
-0.027946068,
0.2168647349,
-0.4371461272,
0.7444655299,
-0.2281466424,
-0.1759430766,
0.5862833858,
0.524833858,
0.5333604217,
0.5396169424,
0.5501201749,
0.4755099118,
0.9655247331,
-0.4082083702,
1.0501563549,
-0.3592912555,
0.424197793,
0.7946658731,
-0.0379509255,
0.8237856627,
0.3034885824,
0.0014022948,
0.3986014724,
0.7661546469,
-0.0881009847,
0.3089984357,
0.2453484684,
0.0744992197,
-0.2727350593,
-0.1996284723,
-0.3218959868,
0.1208834052,
0.0442618243,
-0.3513987064,
-0.0235002302,
0.2236747742,
0.0868927762,
0.1274190545,
-0.3274906576,
0.5532402396,
-0.0808817744,
-0.647763133,
0.4027778804,
-0.4131430387,
0.5304918289,
-0.5261631012,
-0.0380698554,
-0.1401646435,
0.2637923062,
-0.1997960806,
-0.9909180999,
0.2521597445,
0.0798907354,
-0.5423859954,
-0.1884177625,
0.678471148,
-0.3228182197,
-0.5551015139,
0.2302847505,
0.200193435,
0.0785850435,
0.1645041406,
-0.2423058152,
0.5510668159,
-0.4717961848,
-0.2013067454,
0.3404993117,
0.7395820022,
-0.0311902035,
0.6991545558,
0.1356676519,
0.0876237154,
0.173598364,
0.0349314697,
0.7337970138,
-0.6321116686,
-0.4819819629,
-0.9198856354,
0.6715291142,
-0.0618796945,
-0.7124844193,
1.1089158058,
0.2584857941,
0.3467633724,
0.1356133968,
0.7846173048,
0.0613132715,
0.4406625628,
-0.4593988955,
0.5371049643,
-0.0056709042,
0.4710533023,
-0.5519494414,
-0.9600660801,
-0.6683966517,
0.4783912301,
-0.1809780598,
-0.1537561715,
0.62906003,
0.457327038,
0.4346189201,
0.1744072735,
-0.0225386787,
0.1688185632,
0.3804804981,
0.1945604831,
1.2941004038,
-0.0767309293,
0.4625625014,
-0.3733919561,
-0.4209721088,
-0.2322368324,
-1.1154618263,
-0.881377697,
-0.692687273,
-0.640735209,
-0.7380332947,
0.1038844958,
0.9828488827,
0.4258238971,
-0.8479123712,
0.1772938669,
0.0420638993,
-0.090357706,
-0.3547793031,
-0.1719891131,
0.543566823,
-0.730278492,
-0.3599081039,
0.2305408865,
0.3784468472,
0.0037855997,
-0.1431931108,
0.0366502777,
0.3724424243,
-0.1062432826,
0.4393514097,
0.3406678438,
-0.5802149177,
-0.6706386805,
0.0130282845,
-0.0921136588,
-0.1417505741,
0.8330618739,
-0.7880985737,
0.4178502858,
0.6726419926,
0.6903962493,
-0.5966596603,
0.2348122448,
0.6623737812,
-0.6847083569,
-0.0799477473,
0.4206209779,
0.7218977213,
0.4484600425,
-0.2565916777,
0.1047905833,
0.2502779663,
-1.0379818678,
-0.9445235133,
0.0697214305,
-0.9544068575,
-0.0125688184,
1.2360954285,
-0.5843286514,
-0.129126668,
-0.3082957566,
-0.4750610888,
-0.0959017053,
-0.5858116746,
0.8354820013,
0.7108929753,
-0.0549427979,
-0.2441129535,
-0.0075855525,
0.5529178977,
0.1986171901,
-0.5720472336,
0.2673682272,
0.6780300736,
0.3648819327,
0.591349721,
0.6445222497,
0.0440742746,
0.3718637526,
0.0693091378,
-0.2425666749,
0.0489623211,
-0.4362926781,
-0.7858717442,
0.4292673469,
0.2776521742,
-0.237610206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02030v1 | Breaking Bias, Building Bridges: Evaluation and Mitigation of Social Biases in LLMs via Contact Hypothesis | 2024-07-02T07:58:46 | 2024-07-02T07:58:46 | Chahat Raj, Anjishnu Mukherjee, Aylin Caliskan, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Ziwei Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) perpetuate social biases, reflecting prejudices
in their training data and reinforcing societal stereotypes and inequalities.
Our work explores the potential of the Contact Hypothesis, a concept from
social psychology for debiasing LLMs. We simulate various forms of social
contact through LLM prompting to measure their influence on the model's biases,
mirroring how intergroup interactions can reduce prejudices in social contexts.
We create a dataset of 108,000 prompts following a principled approach
replicating social contact to measure biases in three LLMs (LLaMA 2, Tulu, and
NousHermes) across 13 social bias dimensions. We propose a unique debiasing
technique, Social Contact Debiasing (SCD), that instruction-tunes these models
with unbiased responses to prompts. Our research demonstrates that LLM
responses exhibit social biases when subject to contact probing, but more
importantly, these biases can be significantly reduced by up to 40% in 1 epoch
of instruction tuning LLaMA 2 following our SCD strategy. Our code and data are
available at https://github.com/chahatraj/breakingbias. | [
-0.4306692481,
-0.9230830073,
0.5321646929,
0.3012520671,
-0.127657339,
0.3790343404,
-0.2089899331,
-0.4628309608,
0.4785515368,
0.5283440351,
-0.4711803198,
-0.5447405577,
-0.6307036877,
-0.0693017989,
-0.23166278,
0.685387671,
0.0363560766,
0.4450680315,
-0.3017721772,
-0.1432393193,
-0.2502693236,
-0.4917989969,
-0.4178782403,
-0.5385423899,
0.6914288998,
0.7302042842,
0.4911089242,
0.4021382332,
0.382234931,
0.1814335585,
-0.4134260714,
0.1050895005,
-0.6405546069,
-0.0406478122,
-0.2303108722,
-0.7288886905,
-0.0888383761,
0.2953181565,
0.4752106071,
1.0050886869,
0.0954224244,
0.3319045901,
0.347173661,
0.7578255534,
-0.5247222185,
0.1332373321,
-0.438883841,
0.0161781833,
-0.5017178655,
-0.0232884549,
-0.3947939575,
-0.5445789695,
-0.0443886817,
-0.0308375526,
0.3345906138,
0.0652802214,
0.5705195069,
0.1411457807,
-0.548838079,
0.0405003093,
-0.464259088,
0.6167660952,
-0.5593047142,
0.447243154,
0.7390786409,
-0.0400742404,
-0.1193707287,
0.0987942666,
-0.361939162,
-0.396166712,
0.2714006603,
-0.1698869765,
0.2678708136,
0.1784895211,
0.7209122181,
0.1453514546,
-0.0519506112,
0.0204466134,
-0.6025705934,
0.148933202,
0.683440268,
0.0307948329,
0.3136428297,
-0.0456675813,
-0.2497740984,
0.0468581654,
-1.0704905987,
0.0046450696,
0.6941017509,
0.0945994705,
-0.4628167748,
0.6065411568,
-0.2754517794,
0.260017395,
0.3055611253,
0.023354169,
0.3529483378,
-0.0103949606,
0.0475596339,
0.0907007679,
0.5971642137,
0.7541514039,
0.6261786222,
-0.2522886992,
0.2058986872,
0.4765012264,
0.0090057189,
-0.5912397504,
0.0858532414,
-0.0974088609,
-0.4030743539,
-0.6633580923,
-0.1863420457,
-0.8540256619,
-0.7980132699,
-0.2855208218,
-0.0598178096,
-0.1452433467,
-0.3443345428,
-0.0410632044,
-0.0354668237,
0.3055524528,
0.1099909917,
-0.8954616785,
0.3120653927,
0.4115979671,
0.8847401142,
-0.1088324264,
-0.1909994781,
-0.5773512721,
-0.0271185786,
-0.2229519337,
0.7222509384,
-0.678486228,
-0.6689500213,
0.1716546267,
-0.0865921155,
0.1078714579,
-0.6310997605,
0.3900318146,
-0.4064193964,
-0.1801894307,
-0.6450951099,
-0.3516434729,
0.2231869847,
0.3134545684,
-0.5816422105,
0.9832193851,
-0.104315117,
-0.9177809358,
0.2809564769,
-0.5025717616,
-0.509224534,
-0.2450824529,
-0.2210034132,
-0.0887946784,
0.2012583315,
0.0578566901,
0.132021755,
-0.5623084307,
0.1969697177,
-1.0671713352,
-0.3566367626,
0.0909325555,
-0.1953875273,
0.9287503362,
-0.0300854202,
-0.6514716148,
0.0353463106,
-0.4876990616,
-0.4178772271,
0.1450663954,
-0.2479714304,
-0.5341447592,
0.1104107425,
-0.1473614126,
0.1959707588,
-0.0799278766,
-0.7757251859,
0.2552746534,
-0.2911690772,
0.2321543694,
0.9846801758,
-0.0634818971,
0.5077742338,
-0.3517647982,
0.4170188308,
0.1448789984,
0.2742406428,
0.3223320842,
-0.1665156484,
-0.9183054566,
0.2107174993,
0.1886891425,
0.3880499303,
-0.8216910958,
0.0345500298,
0.1089409217,
-0.5997290015,
-0.4709028304,
0.4805491567,
0.4896851778,
0.3787364662,
0.1369080544,
-0.449633956,
-0.555788815,
-0.8205159307,
-0.5045186281,
-0.1475602835,
0.0165522974,
0.2803651094,
0.2675504088,
-0.2236754745,
0.7418630719,
-0.3200007677,
-0.0962918103,
-0.1240679622,
-0.2395446301,
-0.1046456471,
0.2197208405,
0.2705284357,
-0.4786855578,
-0.5612162352,
-0.4969719946,
-0.8170691133,
-0.5313633084,
0.2779395282,
-0.1680606604,
0.1954310387,
0.7562820911,
-0.5357791185,
0.5479403734,
0.4666911066,
-0.5408484936,
0.6352157593,
0.3255053759,
0.1152889282,
-0.8653914928,
-0.368783921,
0.4763430357,
0.1844561994,
-0.4375751019,
-0.3046248555,
-0.1090808213,
0.1693698913,
-0.4558849633,
0.537712276,
-0.7019506097,
0.0170596465,
-0.1157629043,
0.2441424578,
-0.1325291544,
0.2073601037,
-0.1404366046,
0.4130176306,
0.4556096494,
-0.3687966764,
0.234882772,
0.4235959351,
-0.5940958261,
0.6805281639,
-0.8277735114,
0.4225168228,
-0.1841397732,
0.2387669086,
-0.9868904948,
-0.0359352008,
0.291244626,
-0.2214037031,
-0.0366053879,
-0.163179636,
-0.4299238622,
-0.2171490043,
-0.6514569521,
0.4658844471,
0.27349177,
-0.69449687,
0.3250958025,
0.6364338994,
-0.1746582389,
-0.5221354961,
-0.5683236718,
0.1349458843,
-0.4283098876,
-0.669511199,
0.159089461,
-0.1538821906,
-0.8169365525,
-0.3439795673,
-0.147508204,
0.3032167554,
0.1006772071,
0.4476734996,
0.3033831716,
0.2828141749,
-0.0858794749,
0.0652898848,
0.1008927077,
0.3878333271,
0.3090491593,
0.7737159133,
0.179040134,
-0.7502046824,
-0.0679672584,
0.1699045151,
0.6940963864,
-0.0683702305,
0.5438422561,
0.1270804703,
-0.210854724,
-0.1225585341,
-0.9706411958,
-0.4749703407,
-0.472427696,
0.1073134318,
-0.2148090154,
-0.9392248392,
0.3645337224,
-0.2292116731,
-0.1185846776,
-0.2496795058,
0.4590830505,
-0.0901994035,
0.8466236591,
0.7678104639,
-0.5121602416,
0.65262568,
0.0405599996,
0.2855013609,
-0.9619568586,
-0.2047929168,
-0.3794552386,
-0.349016428,
-0.4600288868,
-0.6342796087,
0.2397734523,
0.2073241621,
-0.1841686964,
-0.0815254524,
-0.2052980214,
0.7014998198,
0.6197067499,
0.4089484215,
0.2969681323,
-0.07185027,
-0.2380407453,
-0.0438470654,
-0.5273599029,
-0.5426480174,
1.1913107634,
0.5265337229,
1.0022740364,
-0.0232202951,
0.7963298559,
0.438278079,
0.5093010068,
-0.5365396738,
0.6156545877,
0.4151406884,
-0.4615544081,
-0.2209351659,
-0.3455982208,
-0.6136340499,
0.1526746899,
-0.2155658007,
-0.8643732667,
0.3341851532,
0.0386013575,
-0.0164802838,
0.4156742096,
-0.5300896764,
0.3508191109,
-0.1930714101,
-0.8287616968,
-0.3269077241,
-0.6606016159,
0.6233166456,
0.1145133749,
0.3496648073,
-0.3200811446,
0.4713837206,
0.7267186642,
-0.3476511538,
1.526337862,
-0.3462428451,
-0.3543685377,
0.2847336233,
0.0038857944,
0.5396856666,
-0.0074608615,
-0.2409933656,
0.4102457464,
-0.1002116501,
-0.4183462262,
-0.2832990587,
0.6294501424,
-0.6808045506,
-0.6049793363,
-0.2514812052,
-0.6508495212,
-0.3703412414,
-0.0694423765,
0.007377571,
0.1259133667,
-0.4204235375,
0.1077436879,
0.7163273096,
-0.1582017392,
0.1910381764,
0.5398902893,
-0.1624834687,
-0.2967006564,
0.4741906226,
0.2133996338,
0.4679802358,
-0.2695461512,
0.0697219521,
-0.3128229082,
-0.2213583142,
-0.1815479249,
0.3797293901,
-0.3735007644,
-0.0131962877,
-0.3989340365,
-0.0170952231,
-0.6663283706,
-0.0442219339,
-0.1151338965,
-0.0705266967,
0.1859949231,
-0.461987108,
0.2164431214,
0.8173757195,
-0.38714692,
0.2949987054,
-0.526186347,
0.2826007009,
0.2106107026,
0.4219846129,
-0.0555122606,
-0.3287684619,
-0.3176369071,
0.0500014424,
-0.369638294,
-1.1735773087,
0.0684462041,
-0.34428671,
0.4230982959,
0.5362821221,
0.2802841365,
0.2940262556,
-0.5601723194,
0.4477310181,
0.2184577137,
-1.0320640802,
0.4422182739,
-0.5372937918,
-0.0004640123,
0.6155853868,
0.3796885312,
-0.6972091198,
-0.4237647057,
-0.7694804668,
-0.7790945172,
0.4409417212,
-0.3032040894,
0.0614073761,
-0.3048811257,
0.3506242931,
-0.4118362367,
0.1751984954,
-0.6159663796,
-0.3175991476,
0.3470482528,
-0.084663339,
-0.0790168494,
-0.8357050419,
-0.480201304,
-0.2230224758,
0.5655768514,
0.0061821551,
-0.3138349056,
0.19238998,
-0.2161584049,
-0.2919146121,
0.1055333018,
0.3832907975,
0.4875287414,
-0.0102897324,
0.2651149333,
0.5039656162,
-0.3732828498,
0.2987993956,
-0.1330941916,
-0.3634934723,
-0.0363478698,
0.0681909546,
0.5863456726,
0.1063785255,
-0.5084219575,
0.3268848658,
0.1483090818,
-0.1926479936,
-0.1263693273,
-0.0318865851,
0.3658108711,
0.4254061282,
0.0868632719,
-0.4301981926,
-0.1164055467,
-0.5532090664,
0.279394865,
0.6293746829,
-0.6138094068,
-0.3160665929,
0.5178964734,
0.6366031766,
-0.5667080283,
0.2753131986,
-0.0765612647,
-0.5673955083,
0.4787403941,
0.5421288013,
0.6169567108,
-0.4431520402,
0.2107714713,
0.2019270509,
0.5996341109,
-0.0611688904,
0.1039487571,
-0.1141879484,
-1.1443605423,
-0.4863686562,
-0.4128185809,
-0.7898407578,
0.115477711,
-0.8249557018,
0.3992705047,
-0.5146995783,
-0.0366877578,
-0.3096655011,
0.1163370162,
-0.4136581123,
-0.1340652108,
0.3088440001,
1.0643627644,
-1.2122817039,
0.7668703794,
0.485206008,
-0.4486377239,
-0.4673617184,
0.1026509553,
0.4118184745,
-0.7687783241,
0.7805099487,
0.3388266861,
-0.1971819103,
-0.1931172311,
-0.7107216716,
-0.6312441826,
0.6972548962,
0.5688102841,
-0.7202920914,
0.0468616039,
0.4335340559,
-0.0031242415,
-0.1181446686,
0.3799926043,
1.0952150822,
0.4725230336,
-0.2686356604,
-0.9168239236,
0.2366696745,
-0.353972584,
-0.108894527,
0.0980583429,
-1.0835077763,
0.4084249735,
-0.49067536,
-0.0089896945,
-0.2439711392,
0.3853853047,
0.5077260733,
0.3992854357,
0.8714585304,
0.7087585926,
0.7246466279,
0.0322389416,
0.528177321,
-0.4707551003,
0.1774015874,
1.1720452309,
-0.7552530766,
0.3619133532,
0.80954355,
-0.1405822933,
0.5245384574,
0.5859834552,
0.1281724274,
0.2926001847,
0.8514708877,
-0.5570911169,
-0.0257794559,
-0.473475337,
-0.364359051,
0.3506905437,
0.2579029799,
-0.2368216962,
-0.2695472538,
-0.0545978621,
0.3643633723,
0.1843891442,
-0.109720476,
0.5175452828,
0.283542335,
-0.3802165091,
0.3083219826,
-0.3327131569,
0.884354949,
-0.3929821253,
-0.0661492646,
-0.4775542617,
0.1416769773,
-0.3180236816,
-0.4673494995,
0.2273419052,
0.0554140806,
-0.3545986712,
-0.2008189857,
0.8603785038,
-0.537147522,
-0.2775193751,
0.7312954664,
0.6224424839,
0.1319368333,
-0.1747231632,
-0.5006585717,
0.4840631783,
0.2026320696,
-0.3331117928,
0.5771052837,
0.3587415516,
-0.0196858253,
0.666816771,
0.7162674069,
0.1841832101,
-0.1563098878,
0.4072164893,
0.9272807837,
-0.7722508311,
0.045129247,
-0.9572798014,
0.3497843742,
-0.3649537563,
-0.18449682,
0.9817064404,
0.4305064082,
0.7800933719,
0.2291889191,
0.9012006521,
0.2080885768,
0.4914365113,
-0.199953571,
0.6619965434,
-0.0415947847,
0.3576369584,
-0.4869415164,
-0.9406654835,
0.0430454947,
0.5895514488,
-0.700421989,
-0.1781398505,
0.466673553,
1.0308121443,
0.1631525457,
-0.0058518457,
0.292039752,
0.288983345,
0.3065806627,
0.3654348254,
1.0763435364,
-0.189387098,
0.3061498702,
-0.3060309589,
-0.5364797115,
0.0090386141,
-0.6961906552,
-1.1878550053,
-0.1645636111,
-0.2858156562,
-0.8369435668,
0.1882162988,
0.9163542986,
0.4374044538,
-0.3534255922,
-0.5591769814,
0.1240511984,
0.3531036079,
0.330232352,
-0.2661037147,
0.0906590223,
-0.5348426104,
-0.7392588258,
0.4572326243,
0.1568750739,
-0.1763455123,
-0.4787961245,
-0.0251079928,
-0.2014861703,
0.0935178921,
0.7646218538,
0.2049553245,
-0.3402185142,
-0.4372437894,
-0.0522070676,
0.0040078531,
-0.0283059701,
0.4979567826,
-0.5244580507,
0.0692094862,
0.2574644387,
0.5236088634,
0.5209600329,
0.0061100442,
0.6940671206,
-0.4904069602,
0.2427659035,
-0.0830137283,
0.4293576479,
0.4570725262,
-0.3179644048,
0.8586645126,
0.44580248,
-0.4840215147,
-1.1145138741,
0.4725569189,
-0.6890662313,
0.0608349256,
1.5831184387,
0.1248121336,
-0.2455506325,
-0.2650070786,
-0.2591031492,
0.2504123151,
-0.2601337135,
1.2438822985,
0.7321608663,
0.01830074,
-0.0006761375,
-0.4847822487,
0.3696196675,
0.7516469359,
-0.7480576634,
0.1935537159,
0.5276782513,
0.5303092599,
0.1570691019,
0.822185874,
-0.0852433965,
-0.0559043884,
-0.1505901814,
0.4440181553,
0.2405438274,
-0.1797158718,
-0.1335368156,
-0.1391266733,
0.1124649867,
-0.1743835509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02028v1 | Why does in-context learning fail sometimes? Evaluating in-context learning on open and closed questions | 2024-07-02T07:52:30 | 2024-07-02T07:52:30 | Xiang Li, Haoran Tang, Siyu Chen, Ziwei Wang, Ryan Chen, Marcin Abram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | We measure the performance of in-context learning as a function of task
novelty and difficulty for open and closed questions. For that purpose, we
created a novel benchmark consisting of hard scientific questions, each paired
with a context of various relevancy. We show that counter-intuitively, a
context that is more aligned with the topic does not always help more than a
less relevant context. This effect is especially visible for open questions and
questions of high difficulty or novelty. This result reveals a fundamental
difference between the treatment of close-form and open-form questions by
large-language models and shows a need for a more robust evaluation of
in-context learning on the variety of different types of questions. It also
poses a new question of how to optimally select a context for large language
models, especially in the context of Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems. Our results suggest that the answer to this question can be highly
application-dependent and might be contingent on factors including the format
of the question, the perceived difficulty level of the questions, and the
novelty or popularity of the information we seek. | [
-0.4609948099,
-1.0000936985,
0.6813960075,
0.0272441413,
-0.1444939524,
-0.1564316452,
-0.5586750507,
-0.3165846169,
-0.4415407181,
-0.0401292294,
-0.3469853699,
-0.1271962374,
-0.3431183696,
0.3051954508,
-0.2400034964,
1.1489126682,
-0.2353367656,
0.0640250817,
-0.9417273402,
-0.5714076757,
-0.5716536045,
-0.575442791,
-0.6695398092,
-0.3503694236,
0.4150467217,
0.6259920001,
0.1754445285,
0.0743565857,
0.6850073934,
0.1943621337,
-0.2944653332,
0.1310729533,
-0.6433955431,
0.4217658341,
-0.3684290051,
-0.58331424,
0.3078106344,
-0.0159085076,
0.751450479,
1.4116319418,
0.1178143844,
0.3059590161,
0.2982390523,
0.6538947225,
-0.8905664086,
-0.1189555377,
-0.6822730303,
-0.0409880392,
-0.2535556555,
-0.2656247616,
-0.2475230992,
-0.3380322158,
0.4261748791,
-0.3551849127,
0.3539180756,
-0.1589601785,
0.6127535105,
0.2303041816,
-0.6267103553,
-0.5774364471,
-0.7905544639,
0.8746501207,
-0.168309629,
0.3831035793,
0.1929553002,
0.4294447303,
-0.3366209269,
-0.5114820004,
-0.3967466354,
-0.3955464661,
0.1247082204,
0.1008941606,
0.1481851637,
-0.5048524141,
0.542478323,
0.2735334039,
-0.4339728057,
-0.199655056,
-0.5080522299,
0.1987506449,
0.1616835445,
0.1890480816,
0.0359021947,
-0.0365446806,
-0.5738230348,
-0.2646313608,
-0.8568745852,
0.5992099643,
0.2508276999,
0.304933995,
0.0778278038,
0.4267585576,
-0.1959489882,
0.8727166057,
0.0419074409,
-0.0486386344,
0.152551055,
-0.0848940313,
0.013510637,
-0.2041415125,
0.3853924274,
0.197290957,
-0.0765117779,
-0.1343417317,
-0.3244798481,
-0.2705623806,
0.2529396415,
-0.6581519842,
0.2102951109,
0.167010814,
-0.2352933139,
0.0079879239,
0.3733094931,
-0.555039227,
-0.0342791863,
-0.1470787376,
0.6164489388,
-0.2985012233,
0.0008842292,
-0.0972432196,
-0.2740645707,
0.239901185,
0.4281128049,
-0.7893416882,
0.4416208565,
0.5434733033,
0.632017076,
-0.5061989427,
-0.2564121485,
-0.6009581685,
-0.1149502322,
-0.3149324656,
0.8111461997,
-0.5820797682,
-0.3614434302,
-0.1697446257,
0.1079084352,
-0.2644864619,
-0.9171004295,
0.2438301146,
-0.5855306387,
0.4717490971,
-0.6984606385,
-0.4218209386,
-0.0853584856,
0.3894236386,
-0.3690338731,
0.9293735623,
0.3300571144,
-0.7628650069,
0.7211721539,
-0.5938507318,
-0.2872161269,
0.008303727,
-0.317109257,
-0.1731024534,
0.362273097,
-0.4112904966,
0.2433246523,
-0.4407198131,
0.2141164839,
-0.2069647163,
-0.6363363862,
0.6231395602,
-0.2907349467,
0.6551815867,
0.2185685784,
-0.4848846793,
-0.1797832996,
-0.5969541669,
0.0437908843,
0.1588947475,
-0.5592210293,
-0.8178364038,
0.0323430598,
0.002861494,
-0.0236718841,
0.2573170066,
-0.7348249555,
0.0390198268,
-0.3090907633,
0.2718799114,
0.496720612,
0.0324815921,
0.4052379727,
-0.2974113822,
0.315348506,
0.044197645,
-0.0689328089,
-0.098648943,
-0.5261799693,
-0.2134271562,
0.3826253414,
0.1707128286,
0.315744549,
-0.4799969196,
-0.2456096858,
0.1276411116,
-0.5734657049,
-0.1614031047,
0.1993516535,
0.6580585241,
1.1131983995,
0.4133167267,
-0.5601810813,
-0.292879045,
-0.6455417871,
-0.3148254752,
-0.0289104749,
0.0840746909,
0.8747173548,
0.7795463204,
0.0424382761,
1.0628199577,
-0.4818330109,
0.1269579977,
0.0149961747,
0.0214927904,
0.1901863962,
0.4877230823,
0.5179889202,
-1.1659470797,
-0.5298633575,
0.1196109876,
-1.0550458431,
0.0085973628,
0.1588284522,
0.2617566288,
0.1900826097,
0.6400259733,
-0.4680312574,
0.1665804535,
0.1998421848,
-0.1071193591,
0.5247180462,
-0.249534443,
0.1168277487,
-0.8447318673,
0.4486479163,
-0.0186946914,
0.2236212641,
-0.576495111,
0.2437123954,
0.1928689033,
-0.0929697379,
-0.7152348161,
0.7195621729,
-0.2544223964,
-0.0874505118,
-0.1238567382,
0.1680846065,
-0.0813841298,
0.2330428958,
-0.3072743714,
0.7603051662,
0.4150741994,
-0.8484643698,
0.1152176484,
0.1879712343,
-0.5318347812,
0.5947439671,
-0.84717381,
0.2210762203,
-0.423243165,
0.2750009894,
-0.9250218272,
-0.5919039845,
-0.033651147,
-0.2053895444,
0.4296005964,
0.0983852595,
-0.1179778874,
-0.2040737867,
-0.0786651969,
0.961186111,
0.3458265364,
-0.8089217544,
0.0083397729,
0.0874349922,
0.1827463955,
-0.7818896174,
-0.4484495521,
-0.373072803,
-0.4053686261,
-0.4600420296,
0.2619795203,
-0.2457884848,
-0.5870198011,
0.1686985195,
-0.41002056,
-0.0265306775,
0.4037194848,
0.1638753712,
-0.0030311241,
-0.3452711403,
0.3039183021,
-0.1317825466,
0.1990031004,
0.074218519,
-0.1756523997,
0.3176015615,
-0.3315862119,
-0.5600850582,
0.3057744801,
0.5869210958,
0.4147930741,
-0.0781314448,
0.8357922435,
0.1427874863,
-0.3984309733,
-0.3704138696,
-0.3427094221,
-0.2940803766,
-0.4022764862,
0.3366692364,
-0.4701866508,
-1.0786480904,
0.5421515703,
-0.0331679694,
-0.1349089444,
0.4457318783,
0.4666781723,
-0.3315546811,
0.7751241326,
0.4911750257,
0.51836586,
0.3546065986,
-0.307734251,
-0.0102928663,
-0.8688986897,
-0.4917973578,
-0.704934895,
-0.2217233479,
-0.6195303798,
0.0206283461,
0.7654538155,
0.2910581529,
-0.3749622107,
0.1377577782,
-0.4511520565,
0.4763377607,
0.5826840997,
0.1109486818,
0.1531749815,
-0.0858054683,
-0.2558880448,
0.0915845111,
-0.7488654852,
-0.4677526355,
1.2069919109,
0.0761957392,
0.6909255385,
0.1895680428,
0.6162913442,
-0.3019513786,
0.4573597908,
-0.6273807883,
0.283750087,
0.0076692747,
-0.7593594193,
-0.4927616417,
-0.5149751306,
-1.2459478378,
0.4057742655,
0.0165191367,
-0.5819174051,
0.2725412846,
-0.0171197038,
-0.2517580092,
0.2125363201,
-0.8422020674,
0.9582934976,
-0.0877480283,
-0.5375789404,
0.3215199709,
-0.7793582082,
0.3793787956,
-0.3765542805,
0.1815784127,
0.2658103108,
-0.0460968688,
0.7837343216,
-0.2645922005,
0.5773745775,
-0.1760194451,
0.2240964174,
0.4816706181,
-0.1515973955,
0.0119016878,
0.1535748094,
-0.0010241523,
-0.1969730854,
-0.0092285499,
-0.3902937472,
-0.9491065741,
0.6167454123,
-0.548625946,
-0.7655779123,
-0.5118735433,
-0.4462682307,
-0.3548910916,
0.0934446529,
0.529327333,
0.7043879628,
-0.2761715353,
0.7459157109,
0.9606007338,
-0.2742411196,
0.4549005926,
0.3894591331,
0.1908525527,
-0.0576160625,
0.8051983118,
0.211983487,
0.5714471936,
0.2841866612,
0.3996987939,
-0.1141462028,
-0.3727323413,
-0.427836597,
0.1603472382,
-0.862623632,
-0.0967369303,
-0.4930785596,
0.0110055441,
-0.0559779145,
-0.04048777,
-0.0660656169,
-0.1174866557,
-0.318079412,
0.3231604099,
0.0654394925,
0.8500955105,
0.0923571736,
-0.2058361918,
-0.5154998302,
0.0784575343,
0.5663152933,
0.4658333659,
0.13252756,
-0.5933535099,
-0.3321269155,
-0.0634748042,
-0.6300852895,
-0.8218584061,
-0.1841455996,
0.2745779455,
0.6652610898,
0.1969909072,
0.063619554,
0.2929443121,
-0.5047255754,
0.8096970916,
-0.0622066259,
-0.5445916057,
0.487731576,
-0.2944189906,
0.4802337289,
0.8374968171,
0.7672946453,
-0.4199543595,
-0.1941049546,
-0.6007309556,
-0.8468288183,
0.5926954746,
-0.0470228381,
0.2059314996,
-0.358071357,
0.5788404346,
0.4876797795,
0.2622053027,
-0.5504368544,
-0.2464083284,
-0.0691646561,
0.1139842942,
-0.204666391,
-0.0952493474,
-0.2903025746,
-0.2449109703,
0.2657744288,
-0.3376727402,
0.1289400458,
0.4368842244,
-0.0434190258,
-0.4143980443,
0.4005227685,
0.8670811057,
0.8191261292,
-0.5371398926,
-0.0549624264,
0.3322769701,
-0.3982641399,
0.0563233942,
-0.170358777,
-0.244878605,
-0.2292243391,
0.3949589431,
0.6739228368,
0.5930337906,
-0.8142516613,
0.5886824131,
0.0108186379,
-0.3050719798,
-0.1662641019,
0.1325717121,
-0.1147165895,
0.0423072316,
0.7830470204,
0.1266887039,
-0.0342968106,
-1.1320759058,
0.0569626838,
0.731120944,
-0.3195133507,
-0.0210681576,
0.7080681324,
-0.2387475222,
-0.4074881077,
0.4072976112,
-0.128524065,
-0.5458399057,
0.7087160349,
0.7810285091,
0.7154718041,
0.0160602294,
-0.0209483504,
0.2940694094,
0.0431221016,
-0.1584273279,
0.4657709301,
-0.3436463177,
-0.4086486101,
-0.2005498856,
-0.6080319881,
-0.8949311376,
0.1593827754,
-0.6679803133,
-0.00744256,
-0.233748734,
-0.0577643961,
-0.3249019086,
-0.1352044195,
-0.7769165039,
0.5559787154,
-0.4244582951,
0.9175947309,
-0.800026834,
0.3644975722,
1.0985037088,
-0.5782232881,
-0.5176374316,
0.0848755836,
-0.4424027503,
-0.2010573447,
0.905400753,
0.2797684371,
0.0508238263,
-0.4254566431,
-0.8343743682,
-1.0695890188,
0.8562718034,
0.1682928503,
-0.0314294472,
0.0527463891,
-0.089742288,
0.7049638033,
-0.589600265,
0.2439024448,
0.2360952795,
0.227146551,
0.1945192367,
-1.0930720568,
0.0403582193,
-0.1619912684,
-0.2888590693,
0.2069717199,
-0.7335218191,
1.1743781567,
-0.2670691311,
-0.1362376064,
-0.1800588369,
0.4523013532,
0.2948235869,
0.9906150103,
0.4995260835,
0.4101292491,
0.6402595043,
-0.2088520825,
1.1167199612,
0.2630139887,
0.3593957126,
0.9286291599,
-0.2265453488,
0.9065127373,
0.5825632215,
-0.0403745584,
0.6266898513,
0.7682514191,
0.132402882,
0.680272162,
0.294627279,
-0.1525443941,
0.094296515,
0.0461528227,
-0.5772691965,
0.4989827871,
0.3011242151,
0.0287182406,
-0.5044421554,
0.4272130728,
-0.402908355,
0.3906922936,
-0.0801938698,
0.6448336244,
0.1566521525,
-0.9674611092,
0.6923652887,
-0.2428653389,
0.4083118737,
-0.419370383,
-0.0788486153,
-0.2500469983,
0.0196938068,
-0.2448060811,
-0.6724464297,
0.2575344443,
-0.0937602222,
-0.3025173843,
0.0348617546,
0.4175135195,
-0.2696346939,
0.0288006011,
0.0963657871,
0.6509668231,
0.3773158491,
0.0801932961,
-0.3566836715,
0.0744149983,
-0.392537117,
-0.4027769864,
0.6876718998,
0.5560516715,
-0.1486370862,
0.6760454178,
0.5339387059,
-0.2071869969,
-0.0374154672,
-0.2495967299,
0.7858191729,
-0.4690608084,
-0.2536140084,
-0.5700749159,
0.3503194451,
-0.0285633095,
-0.6475451589,
0.8787276745,
0.4961861372,
1.3656973839,
0.0094457287,
0.6042197347,
-0.0649252981,
0.5042443871,
-0.3145394921,
0.5063821673,
-1.0639203787,
0.1876817346,
-0.3477903008,
-1.2568840981,
-0.0604161695,
0.2689813673,
-0.4189661443,
0.2298860699,
1.0626331568,
0.4012333155,
-0.1149170101,
0.0553198531,
0.264082104,
-0.2015881836,
0.1950216293,
0.6619991064,
0.8706137538,
-0.3460622132,
0.3969811797,
-0.3111197054,
-0.4519104362,
-0.2466718704,
-0.7690998316,
-0.8699421883,
-0.9841402173,
-0.0567949787,
-0.4566714466,
-0.0030786684,
0.8346556425,
0.3081674576,
-0.798730731,
-0.318485558,
0.0050885826,
0.3057625294,
-0.1350600421,
-0.258810401,
0.4487279356,
-0.5871273279,
-0.63441962,
0.6722092032,
0.029727025,
-0.0120945303,
-0.1431100368,
0.2220170796,
-0.0955622643,
-0.1106770635,
0.4278120697,
0.7424387336,
-0.5236576796,
-0.3201939166,
0.1570991725,
-0.2315144241,
-0.07856673,
0.8234098554,
-0.7987659574,
0.5743821263,
0.3566937149,
0.8067356348,
0.4995290637,
0.1157085225,
0.398165375,
-0.677077949,
-0.1045965031,
0.2837648392,
0.1340165138,
0.4221444726,
-0.3129552901,
0.3864048421,
0.4852641225,
-0.7368205786,
-1.1860090494,
0.1635391414,
-0.7686662674,
-0.383466512,
1.0934249163,
0.0621885285,
-0.3199345171,
-0.1642270535,
0.1299198717,
-0.1077803448,
-0.0345253609,
0.7890378237,
0.8124671578,
-0.348362267,
0.3373816907,
-0.8223494887,
0.555121839,
0.614392519,
-0.2777046561,
-0.3749809563,
0.1452864856,
0.3664511442,
0.2544699907,
0.3894587159,
0.0741553083,
0.5907799602,
-0.2258619815,
-0.5395711064,
0.0835118368,
-0.4576923251,
-0.380450666,
0.8034049869,
0.0758092105,
-0.0689372718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02005v1 | An End-to-End Speech Summarization Using Large Language Model | 2024-07-02T07:22:57 | 2024-07-02T07:22:57 | Hengchao Shang, Zongyao Li, Jiaxin Guo, Shaojun Li, Zhiqiang Rao, Yuanchang Luo, Daimeng Wei, Hao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Abstractive Speech Summarization (SSum) aims to generate human-like text
summaries from spoken content. It encounters difficulties in handling long
speech input and capturing the intricate cross-modal mapping between long
speech inputs and short text summaries. Research on large language models
(LLMs) and multimodal information fusion has provided new insights for
addressing these challenges. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end SSum model
that utilizes Q-Former as a connector for the audio-text modality and employs
LLMs to generate text summaries directly from speech features. We adopt a
multi-stage training approach that includes LLM based ASR and Text
Summarization (TSum) tasks as auxiliary tasks. ASR tasks are used to align
feature spaces and enhance the LLM's ability to handle longer speech. Then, we
utilize a curriculum learning strategy to facilitate the model's transition
from TSum to SSum. Finally, our model achieves competitive performance on the
How-2 dataset. | [
-0.2809814513,
-0.6579253674,
0.4706164002,
-0.3294049501,
-0.6139538884,
0.3286122382,
-0.4162771106,
-0.364453882,
0.2194991559,
0.3748123944,
-0.540353179,
-0.4850418866,
-0.6337461472,
-0.0245859604,
-0.4921852052,
1.1379891634,
0.1051316112,
0.1037314013,
-0.3119415641,
-0.0017765813,
-0.4437082112,
-0.6423972845,
-0.5413836241,
-0.2084507495,
0.3435500562,
0.613068521,
0.3726558685,
0.3413593471,
0.2060941905,
0.2266328782,
-0.3231411576,
0.1466958821,
-0.6266919374,
0.2720494568,
-0.0703935251,
-0.4401235282,
-0.6108026505,
-0.1248115152,
1.0373260975,
0.5817793012,
-0.0745586082,
0.371034205,
0.0214838013,
0.4185765088,
-0.3321865201,
0.0976724327,
-0.463501513,
-0.2651044428,
-0.218569845,
-0.3817293942,
-0.2917345166,
-0.138700828,
0.0557945855,
-0.2380088717,
-0.0740185976,
-0.0430843532,
0.6408270597,
0.1653608084,
-0.7494826913,
-0.2342481017,
-0.9100937247,
0.7395269871,
-0.9306058288,
0.4979277849,
0.3081207871,
0.5726821423,
0.0149079058,
-0.4801709056,
-0.6302787066,
-0.1742958874,
0.3232379258,
0.2821394205,
0.1254281551,
-0.0021574476,
-0.0467700399,
0.2289723158,
-0.6509935856,
0.2417577654,
-0.5949282646,
0.1471038312,
0.6047710776,
0.2966533005,
0.3482439816,
-0.0938121974,
-0.298034668,
0.0086838426,
-0.5535840988,
-0.0689192265,
0.2025722265,
0.4794953763,
-0.5308097005,
0.7864969373,
-0.2332982421,
0.4583443105,
-0.2370899618,
-0.504981041,
0.2554186583,
-0.4996244907,
-0.1405177563,
0.3103269935,
0.5637563467,
0.4605288208,
0.1826487929,
-0.1687576026,
-0.2260395288,
0.044408638,
-0.2197574526,
-0.7507926226,
0.3319653869,
0.2839128971,
-0.3675753474,
0.0505975075,
-0.2671512961,
-0.5714930296,
-0.003396028,
-0.689099133,
0.5061491728,
-0.5137791634,
-0.3199038208,
0.0023098423,
-0.1139388457,
0.3160184622,
0.2185281813,
-0.7023311257,
0.3190354109,
0.5560093522,
1.0555611849,
-0.180077374,
-0.221597001,
-0.6441873312,
0.697860539,
-0.118061386,
0.6307613254,
-0.5718895793,
-0.4932308197,
-0.0574405082,
-0.2243800163,
-0.0760521069,
-0.2939769328,
0.3383580148,
-0.3532112539,
0.5440837145,
0.0808258131,
-0.7001322508,
-0.1886126101,
0.1425568908,
-0.3578885496,
0.7650527358,
-0.012430381,
-0.6334071755,
0.0210541468,
-0.5044066906,
-0.6120789647,
-0.0663043186,
-0.3073584735,
-0.4637568891,
0.1044032425,
0.1223491356,
0.5767843723,
-0.4827528,
0.5547472239,
0.0497520119,
-0.3478070498,
0.1853899658,
-0.2003018409,
0.430302918,
0.0722217411,
-0.065278396,
0.3436191976,
-0.8327621222,
-0.2965602577,
0.1442697644,
-0.2930217087,
-0.217133984,
0.0261618588,
0.248910442,
0.4644363821,
0.358823806,
-0.3884085715,
-0.1412116885,
-0.2762759626,
0.5787943602,
0.4736947119,
-0.1027929932,
0.4454282224,
-0.5670679808,
0.4291411936,
0.0334195904,
-0.1767686456,
-0.5297656059,
-0.2417615354,
-0.5803034902,
-0.3991690576,
0.3200512826,
0.5620893836,
-0.6987084746,
0.4790358245,
-0.5522089601,
-0.4891619384,
-0.2156442702,
-0.0927520767,
0.3613446057,
0.4115101397,
0.2421571165,
-0.1322566718,
-0.5682976246,
-0.7463288307,
0.1183462963,
-0.1615594476,
-0.2824835479,
-0.1086208299,
0.4400018752,
-0.1609366685,
0.9075654149,
-0.3125716448,
-0.6736447215,
-0.8566147089,
0.285328418,
0.1506593227,
0.2494570762,
0.2019127905,
-0.5880819559,
-0.0916870534,
-0.1103468984,
-0.5739306211,
-0.0239543747,
-0.3153636754,
0.1082025245,
0.1093860641,
0.5601206422,
-0.4704976678,
0.0277855024,
0.432793498,
-0.1141776368,
0.4570961297,
-0.1693182439,
0.2221112698,
-1.6123561859,
0.1432033181,
0.0863798112,
-0.2950376272,
-0.7344292998,
0.0185108222,
-0.0904353112,
-0.3744753897,
-0.4184461534,
0.3016252816,
-0.4323498011,
-0.3627987504,
-0.5323001742,
0.4928458929,
-0.2110595405,
0.6326152682,
0.1503218114,
0.7700063586,
0.2567155361,
-0.5745254159,
0.21243532,
0.2148649096,
-0.1626113355,
0.4020746052,
-0.5742217302,
-0.1996566206,
-0.3439701498,
0.4679996669,
-1.1268945932,
-0.3209273517,
-0.2428946793,
-0.701135993,
0.4406882823,
0.1974037588,
-0.4690771997,
0.112712115,
-0.4627247751,
0.4797103703,
0.5355476737,
-0.1078905761,
0.8891224861,
0.5508899689,
-0.8125158548,
0.004017849,
-0.5832623243,
0.3324532211,
-0.280857861,
-0.6406058669,
0.5669307113,
-0.054576125,
-0.0273405369,
-0.3488201797,
0.1956667155,
0.0309080109,
-0.3056232631,
0.1369391978,
0.3674548566,
-0.1424904317,
0.0438219979,
0.4013398886,
-0.0467373207,
0.0429746993,
0.2760803699,
0.6368434429,
0.280398339,
-0.2315085977,
-0.6831970215,
0.754901886,
0.7779942751,
-0.3216681182,
0.468293488,
0.4351285398,
-0.4377347231,
0.1727017462,
-0.491991967,
-0.0637592301,
-0.2885546684,
0.8060903549,
-0.1598255336,
-0.9545500278,
0.5273374915,
-0.0965729132,
0.4144850373,
0.2822607756,
0.721543014,
-0.074794963,
1.0564539433,
0.6630445123,
-0.2676436603,
0.6411342621,
-0.1884947717,
0.1182406247,
-0.9326856136,
-0.4583223462,
-0.3431794345,
-0.1568616331,
0.0173634402,
-0.5064426661,
0.5676491261,
-0.059936583,
-0.1019940004,
0.2321628481,
0.1101098284,
0.2265808135,
0.4693087339,
0.0252774935,
0.3586010635,
-0.0027842179,
0.2635935247,
0.0314554721,
-0.4836150706,
-0.2880377769,
0.8409965634,
0.529127419,
0.6013647318,
0.3703452647,
0.6729906797,
0.2320977747,
-0.1755165607,
-0.7258902788,
0.6381592751,
-0.1623979807,
-0.1347039193,
-0.5403270125,
-0.4463785291,
-0.379922539,
0.2546001375,
-0.2153561264,
-0.3899751902,
-0.2907030284,
-0.1042575613,
-0.2363472283,
0.1092835069,
-0.4591926336,
0.2622949779,
-0.2481116802,
-0.1258263737,
-0.3667802513,
-0.9632522464,
0.5234894753,
-0.0966766551,
0.5302842855,
-0.0277338531,
-0.0464232787,
0.8658412099,
-0.2286958843,
0.8310996294,
0.0666710883,
-0.1706495583,
0.118107684,
-0.1932508796,
0.3343490362,
-0.1269507259,
0.2357916087,
0.0169649906,
-0.2536624968,
-0.1261010915,
-0.3700764477,
0.3953923285,
-0.784101069,
-0.3369237483,
-0.3697403669,
-0.6234792471,
-0.3517941236,
-0.0009061891,
0.221244663,
0.7277625799,
-0.1767650098,
0.0346878693,
0.7013878226,
-0.1805071235,
0.5637361407,
0.4928402007,
-0.2112656534,
-0.6161236763,
1.0442357063,
0.1380409598,
0.4442859888,
0.5161100626,
0.0345422216,
-0.5528905988,
-0.5230153203,
-0.6011961699,
0.481347084,
-0.4740969539,
-0.1822129935,
-0.659394145,
-0.5215488672,
-0.7313750386,
-0.1369514018,
-0.2001443952,
-0.4058553874,
-0.3982072175,
0.0122014908,
0.1257781684,
0.3875225484,
0.0930211246,
0.5547495484,
-0.8850055933,
0.5657362342,
0.2776242793,
0.0020702819,
0.0429968648,
-1.1201364994,
-0.4050809145,
0.0462576076,
-0.154628545,
-0.8535507321,
0.497743547,
0.6019513011,
0.4762753248,
0.4080863595,
-0.1006959602,
0.5978121758,
-0.5563772321,
0.9299725294,
0.5914334655,
-0.9630832672,
0.4561596811,
-0.5064633489,
0.7206301093,
0.3034799397,
0.2628929317,
-0.827250421,
-0.6151654124,
-0.0816002563,
-1.1139982939,
0.5599526763,
0.145835802,
-0.0529735424,
0.0736522749,
0.0208141375,
0.0456623249,
0.1472881883,
-0.5101287961,
0.026539389,
-0.1328911185,
-0.4332419038,
-0.2306379229,
-0.4708661437,
-0.0038679759,
-0.0108923893,
0.9001435041,
-0.0523485206,
0.038651865,
-0.1685326248,
-0.3335120678,
0.0611922182,
0.6359622478,
0.9573732615,
0.6053193808,
-0.1240393519,
0.0451917686,
0.2457846552,
-0.2274770588,
0.0358752199,
0.0615072958,
0.154247731,
-0.0137680061,
0.403762728,
0.6622678041,
0.5004755855,
-1.0165417194,
0.6121743917,
-0.0566944517,
-0.2898309827,
-0.4910283387,
-0.2324897051,
0.3109557033,
0.3710842133,
0.6413885355,
-0.5070211887,
0.2628411055,
-0.6334574223,
0.1918462813,
0.2171933651,
-0.1786910444,
-0.2039089501,
0.8214728236,
0.20857656,
-0.0817084983,
0.2708206475,
0.158800602,
-0.4257889688,
0.4241741598,
0.7142658234,
0.6340837479,
-0.435554564,
0.0858586282,
0.1383380145,
0.0648548752,
0.0526315458,
0.3238711059,
-0.15003784,
-0.1390075088,
-0.825247705,
-0.5380288363,
-0.4239295125,
0.0962027311,
-0.6718407869,
0.427631408,
-0.1799376011,
-0.0483027734,
-0.1708454639,
-0.3110415637,
-0.0541219264,
0.3443711102,
0.3912909031,
0.6145583987,
-1.0161645412,
0.7175961733,
0.49867028,
-0.539722681,
-0.4287112653,
-0.2748252749,
0.0667707399,
-0.4902963042,
0.3618566096,
0.1362118423,
-0.2127527446,
-0.1395111382,
-0.1983664036,
-0.8606718183,
1.206887722,
0.2679029405,
-0.8787934184,
-0.5143034458,
0.2426759154,
0.356472373,
-0.4443890452,
0.317387104,
0.3602108955,
-0.1697170585,
0.4463300109,
-0.9001428485,
-0.1436967403,
-0.1908047348,
0.16676265,
0.2818911076,
-0.6899850965,
0.8330758214,
-0.2649091482,
-0.2370127439,
0.007295467,
1.2023953199,
0.3586860001,
0.3942857981,
0.436758101,
0.3522655368,
0.2748849392,
0.2869288921,
0.4236092567,
-0.3120978177,
0.1137607992,
1.5404366255,
-0.3539620638,
1.1317044497,
0.3875164986,
0.0726279542,
0.2736248672,
0.6431911588,
0.3284307122,
0.559815824,
0.0967571884,
-0.3564736545,
-0.2597438395,
-0.2320474982,
-0.5352576375,
0.6533015966,
0.468906492,
-0.3666502833,
-0.4439503551,
0.2614875436,
-0.0034657575,
0.0519469269,
-0.4375491142,
1.0020422935,
0.1266704798,
-0.2389547974,
0.1930033416,
0.1245888174,
0.7346114516,
-0.6929843426,
-0.0336116552,
-0.0383765996,
-0.2808704376,
-0.0416985303,
-0.4728569984,
0.1907604784,
0.0861954987,
-0.341585815,
0.1370588094,
0.4152352214,
-1.0016175508,
-0.439539969,
0.1696998179,
0.4424788058,
0.33976686,
0.0820184201,
-0.1807574928,
0.0370887816,
-0.1392798424,
-0.0267619118,
0.5921216607,
0.2500432432,
-0.1399172395,
0.6377658844,
0.5093938112,
0.1429455131,
-0.0133990273,
0.41978091,
0.9071621895,
-0.6309677362,
-0.9251289368,
-0.7463275194,
0.5239180923,
-0.0753212646,
-0.1290539205,
0.4021937549,
0.8978224397,
0.6482269168,
0.2018260658,
0.967877984,
0.1812496781,
0.8922134638,
-0.6684737802,
0.6513211131,
-0.6294406652,
0.0646647289,
-0.2125569135,
-0.910792172,
-0.0492007509,
0.2497462034,
0.0775559545,
0.0716159642,
0.4934468865,
0.4253439307,
0.0581737198,
0.0927598774,
0.6135936379,
0.0855860338,
0.3602587581,
0.6901001334,
0.5883589983,
-0.2805674672,
0.571911931,
0.1584028155,
-0.4533225596,
-0.3099802732,
-0.639827311,
-0.950719595,
-0.890670836,
-0.1693606377,
-0.1480298638,
0.0838829726,
1.0422616005,
0.4621875882,
-0.4644675851,
-0.4874472022,
0.4585010111,
-0.2860983908,
0.0834215134,
-0.1712093949,
0.402449429,
-0.0979961455,
-0.7643455863,
0.5213631392,
0.3680872917,
0.1682943106,
-0.2792998254,
0.0126451729,
-0.2095971853,
0.1311469823,
0.8672832251,
0.1359981447,
-0.6489116549,
-0.0667532384,
-0.3077819645,
-0.0216285866,
-0.0898052678,
0.8197085857,
-0.6014671326,
0.2431572229,
0.3858242631,
0.6473568678,
0.5246426463,
-0.061145518,
0.7122384906,
-0.6811382771,
-0.0611002743,
0.0508309267,
0.4045191109,
0.2450417727,
-0.2480562627,
0.1231814176,
-0.1567330658,
-0.5230697393,
-0.7700327039,
0.1826806366,
-1.2708756924,
-0.2739685774,
1.2521407604,
0.0935812145,
-0.2185424268,
-0.1829811484,
-0.2734260857,
0.8420171142,
-0.5192380548,
0.765004158,
0.3621308804,
-0.0655219182,
-0.3674044311,
-0.3786402643,
0.0997625962,
0.2889904082,
-0.9545766115,
0.0809704959,
0.6224378943,
0.2328225374,
-0.0403376073,
0.7006253004,
-0.1761692911,
0.2642871141,
-0.2350994498,
0.0768540651,
-0.3649939299,
-0.491709739,
-0.3745721877,
0.2569077909,
-0.1121495292,
-0.3541416824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02543v1 | Towards the Next Frontier in Speech Representation Learning Using Disentanglement | 2024-07-02T07:13:35 | 2024-07-02T07:13:35 | Varun Krishna, Sriram Ganapathy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | The popular frameworks for self-supervised learning of speech representations
have largely focused on frame-level masked prediction of speech regions. While
this has shown promising downstream task performance for speech recognition and
related tasks, this has largely ignored factors of speech that are encoded at
coarser level, like characteristics of the speaker or channel that remain
consistent through-out a speech utterance. In this work, we propose a framework
for Learning Disentangled Self Supervised (termed as Learn2Diss)
representations of speech, which consists of frame-level and an utterance-level
encoder modules. The two encoders are initially learned independently, where
the frame-level model is largely inspired by existing self supervision
techniques, thereby learning pseudo-phonemic representations, while the
utterance-level encoder is inspired by constrastive learning of pooled
embeddings, thereby learning pseudo-speaker representations. The joint learning
of these two modules consists of disentangling the two encoders using a mutual
information based criterion. With several downstream evaluation experiments, we
show that the proposed Learn2Diss achieves state-of-the-art results on a
variety of tasks, with the frame-level encoder representations improving
semantic tasks, while the utterance-level representations improve non-semantic
tasks. | [
-0.224717319,
-0.3799399734,
0.305729568,
-0.034835279,
-0.2489054203,
0.2990491092,
-0.0815284178,
-0.2966409326,
0.4517810941,
0.0984450504,
-0.5789376497,
-0.2570616007,
-1.0047068596,
-0.088754639,
-0.2508821189,
0.5472677946,
0.2384785265,
0.3315431476,
-0.4560647607,
0.1152985692,
-0.5160204172,
-0.4201444387,
-0.4290480614,
-0.5287169814,
0.4054264426,
0.2836797237,
0.070938684,
0.5320856571,
-0.0715525076,
0.3781498671,
-0.0620054118,
0.0939042196,
-0.6228939295,
0.2891049385,
-0.3493464291,
-0.5853660107,
0.0075421529,
0.2340082228,
0.5555694699,
0.7004544735,
-0.408808887,
0.1710682213,
0.3773941994,
0.7056879401,
-0.4941280484,
0.6589372754,
-0.5472958088,
0.1989442557,
-0.3528466225,
0.00540881,
-0.4141653776,
0.2151139379,
0.1490721852,
-0.3889945745,
-0.0156541411,
-0.3423967063,
0.3320450783,
0.5510314107,
-0.4342028797,
-0.3692418337,
-0.7701386809,
0.5757121444,
-0.432936579,
0.7243403196,
0.7830876112,
0.4355252385,
-0.0499595627,
-0.7446711659,
-0.3622698784,
0.2535990477,
-0.2115889639,
0.1926816851,
-0.4393847883,
-0.079754509,
0.2029371709,
0.2448154986,
-0.6183601022,
0.3655481637,
-0.4827980995,
-0.3695851564,
0.6141473651,
-0.1660886109,
-0.0623269975,
-0.1017297506,
-0.4565201402,
-0.2030969858,
-0.3852028847,
0.1681222916,
0.1850273162,
0.109782733,
-0.319067508,
0.2491386384,
-0.207455799,
0.4097820818,
0.5503132343,
-0.1974465251,
0.5712683797,
0.1686534286,
0.1129368916,
0.5240933299,
0.5891218781,
-0.0799222514,
-0.2541893125,
-0.3185520768,
-0.2312783897,
0.0383606739,
0.0990525782,
-0.5106022358,
-0.4350595772,
0.0845064148,
-0.4767133892,
0.1125999317,
0.0663696453,
-0.7116901875,
-0.3730843961,
-0.6523242593,
0.5619871616,
-0.3483111858,
-0.8246608973,
-0.1257643253,
-0.0716325194,
0.0928053856,
-0.0415317006,
-1.2457146645,
0.3075144589,
0.5318295956,
0.7917839885,
-0.105525054,
-0.0784688368,
-0.7066886425,
0.2135658562,
-0.482567966,
0.2848313749,
-0.3764820993,
-0.2151346803,
-0.1787265092,
-0.0119674644,
-0.0492847972,
-0.5055907965,
-0.1735083014,
-0.5196873546,
0.1094736159,
-0.1654199809,
-0.7997916937,
-0.2620844245,
-0.2912129164,
-0.7285804152,
0.6510720849,
0.1206080541,
-0.6756975651,
0.2890416384,
-0.2433398664,
-0.3929072917,
-0.0002695822,
-0.6399291158,
-0.6327482462,
0.2269570827,
0.1366263926,
0.5854337215,
0.0519304201,
0.1664316207,
-0.1606616229,
-0.3167710304,
0.0209897459,
-0.4344884455,
0.6702467799,
0.3304080963,
-0.6095611453,
-0.1734224409,
-0.6675099134,
-0.2401161194,
0.0822093859,
0.1040148214,
-0.3281388283,
0.079852961,
-0.5534749627,
0.2600999773,
0.2926267385,
-0.7112368941,
-0.4542603493,
-0.4902327359,
0.8128128052,
0.5487368703,
-0.0180420615,
0.6636546254,
-0.0172142647,
0.1767433435,
0.4270758629,
-0.2759537101,
-0.0900727287,
-0.3271975815,
-0.4907828271,
-0.3356245756,
0.4025190175,
0.3382819891,
-0.7716463804,
0.5287753344,
-0.0797993988,
-0.3996839821,
-0.6437088847,
0.1904918104,
0.5500486493,
0.3929884136,
0.4934731722,
-0.1772731841,
-0.4277948141,
-0.6907846332,
0.0645151362,
-0.2200099081,
-0.0185396764,
-0.2572667003,
0.1973848641,
-0.1524002403,
1.1646332741,
-0.2031456083,
-0.7542355061,
-0.1909430027,
0.3521336913,
0.0203311741,
0.6642355323,
0.2100321203,
-1.007319808,
-0.2368885577,
-0.2272409201,
-0.7109175324,
0.2483298928,
-0.0110246055,
0.2840557694,
0.0534144677,
0.8603695631,
-0.2367444187,
0.2908611298,
0.6576046348,
0.1207340136,
-0.0660586506,
-0.4317850769,
-0.2985850871,
-1.0337432623,
-0.4698840678,
-0.0066768955,
-0.4289891422,
-0.6157928705,
-0.6059865952,
0.1602730602,
-0.2080525756,
-0.3332013786,
0.0444148034,
-0.7374671102,
-0.2327534258,
-0.2859887481,
0.2518592775,
-0.0238680728,
0.6776582003,
0.2357148379,
0.7484943867,
1.0610604286,
-0.4148820043,
0.4759866297,
0.1860612035,
-0.1707351208,
0.315146327,
-0.5058425069,
0.3980698287,
-0.4246616066,
0.2894099951,
-1.0449557304,
-0.2070412338,
0.0036556062,
-0.6893835664,
0.7803127766,
-0.2413543761,
-0.2396055013,
-0.1660848409,
0.0822534487,
0.350890398,
0.8498260379,
-0.850278914,
0.6059717536,
0.8984047174,
0.0105757825,
-0.3510075212,
-1.0372495651,
-0.1661645472,
-0.2296718359,
-0.2619055212,
0.4705922902,
0.6105362177,
0.2178857028,
0.1155720875,
-0.4065470099,
0.0860711113,
-0.1539645195,
0.454665482,
-0.2566091418,
0.0744156986,
0.3198696673,
0.4010564983,
-0.3206838667,
0.247973308,
-0.5045517683,
0.4653136134,
0.1146637946,
-0.5516824722,
-0.590585351,
0.4935224354,
0.1215130538,
-0.5255386233,
0.3471673727,
0.8698428273,
-0.5585093498,
-0.4131752551,
-0.3805046976,
-0.382055074,
-0.5291013122,
0.6953160763,
-0.6050284505,
-1.2265404463,
0.2399281859,
-0.4451982677,
-0.3541049063,
0.3847606182,
0.5627501607,
-0.4613654613,
0.9149141312,
0.558427155,
-0.1971999556,
0.3553483784,
-0.5680294037,
0.2497953176,
-0.8595457077,
-0.6934610605,
-0.1069721952,
-0.3135403097,
-0.7186399102,
-0.6742710471,
0.4010869265,
0.4589883983,
0.0318423659,
0.5748499632,
-0.4174791873,
0.2834574878,
0.5990518332,
0.2706436217,
-0.1536575854,
0.1846254915,
-0.0049787597,
-0.0423853062,
-0.7601304054,
-0.1838942021,
0.8759444356,
0.6247314215,
0.7277877331,
0.2894058824,
1.2280794382,
0.6321668625,
-0.7126357555,
-0.4599137902,
0.3229374886,
-0.3183688521,
-0.3079327047,
-0.4341993332,
-0.6568728685,
-0.928250432,
0.2609508038,
-0.0433262251,
-0.8313497305,
0.5340355039,
0.1097042486,
-0.2039280087,
0.1447298676,
-0.6877679229,
0.5507574081,
-0.0332110785,
-0.3142699897,
-0.5792151093,
-0.8309736252,
0.0236979052,
0.0411633216,
0.1851112396,
-0.0879693106,
0.2039200366,
0.9650753736,
0.0898834169,
1.151578784,
-0.6325724125,
-0.1610850543,
0.4325124025,
0.1710995883,
0.2527882159,
0.3188687563,
0.0667196289,
0.4950072169,
0.1133414581,
-0.1830271631,
-0.6403686404,
0.6565843225,
-0.6906707883,
-0.6175966263,
-0.3631966114,
-0.111200504,
-0.5271987319,
0.0320009477,
0.1897137165,
0.9404059052,
-0.012412848,
-0.0025705427,
0.8735389113,
0.1679423004,
0.5535219312,
0.1769900173,
0.0383212976,
-0.4161865115,
1.3054234982,
0.0907474086,
0.3057602346,
0.5024830699,
-0.02690004,
-0.881529808,
-0.4159967601,
-0.4303656816,
0.2071623951,
-0.7214035988,
-0.1916687638,
-0.3250154853,
-0.4295323789,
-0.5555772185,
0.4988549352,
-0.5047659874,
-0.3100476861,
-0.793916285,
-0.3003205955,
0.0552905463,
0.8237785697,
-0.7692239881,
0.1130344719,
-0.5112280846,
0.4058493972,
0.6885432005,
0.2830098271,
-0.1011354774,
-0.6898958087,
-0.3771532774,
0.2758727074,
-0.2109589428,
-0.8370962143,
0.0698983967,
0.4179498851,
0.7384260893,
0.5408377647,
0.3061308265,
0.5029150248,
-0.5745155811,
0.6788594127,
0.578558445,
-0.9478445649,
0.6171761751,
0.1484540403,
0.0757466853,
0.3460311592,
0.5108818412,
-0.2821279168,
-0.2854301631,
-0.4107142985,
-0.3777123094,
0.9616467953,
0.1835110486,
0.375140816,
0.0128312074,
0.1542690694,
0.2056685537,
-0.0530513152,
-0.4179033637,
-0.2749691308,
-0.4971336424,
-0.2280979902,
-0.1395933181,
-0.4921198189,
-0.0745124444,
-0.1265315861,
0.3559582531,
-0.0196874049,
0.5164187551,
0.2788143754,
-0.158969447,
0.1532134712,
0.0681675225,
0.1939584762,
0.4208879769,
-0.0468731634,
0.5270658135,
0.0072092977,
-0.2153382003,
0.3937864006,
0.1860652715,
0.2898951769,
0.0693534464,
0.4634257853,
1.1601793766,
-0.0720497295,
-0.2641117573,
0.7039301991,
0.1491363496,
-0.3199955523,
-0.3806961179,
-0.0051315385,
0.2420670092,
0.5926861167,
0.3571228087,
-0.0085656224,
0.3777530789,
-0.4501371682,
0.5987217426,
0.2852333486,
-0.7222607732,
-0.3949786127,
0.7289298773,
0.3153950274,
-0.2221006304,
0.3058115244,
-0.6517392993,
-0.3468097448,
0.2190476954,
0.585120976,
0.716334641,
-0.5972146392,
0.3954682648,
0.3518980443,
-0.08204557,
0.0192819126,
0.0486801229,
-0.6820197105,
-0.4150902331,
-0.3065850735,
-0.4841478765,
-0.0409594961,
-0.1009842381,
-0.8433686495,
0.0517187119,
-0.0906719714,
-0.1915577799,
-0.2320385575,
-0.3227913082,
-0.2088751644,
0.078095898,
0.6608750224,
0.3808504343,
-0.6955739856,
1.0600485802,
0.2889386714,
-0.2752099037,
-0.7794978619,
0.0533702634,
0.205612421,
-0.5086010098,
0.6509087682,
0.3572915196,
-0.4913664758,
0.2252997011,
0.1346761882,
-1.1083660126,
1.2552987337,
0.5674033165,
-1.130946517,
-0.0264796913,
0.3936944008,
0.2411906123,
-0.1326142102,
0.1455635875,
0.4982924461,
-0.2214416862,
0.1332363635,
-0.9545316696,
-0.1772084981,
-0.0295244418,
0.3179009557,
-0.0588160232,
-0.44407022,
0.7552212477,
0.0391421989,
-0.5305367708,
-0.3101401031,
1.114759922,
-0.0143345641,
0.37703529,
0.6766796708,
0.4608835578,
0.6281288266,
-0.2185673863,
0.3580241203,
-0.0163984261,
0.4441668391,
1.2995374203,
-0.150734663,
0.7595834732,
0.4547349513,
-0.3782251179,
0.4979045391,
0.5272635221,
0.2258154601,
1.2528039217,
0.3811951578,
-0.2015702277,
-0.2451642454,
0.2172397524,
-0.4823119044,
0.9230446815,
0.5245159864,
-0.0501235537,
-0.3964815438,
0.5719870925,
-0.3443497419,
0.3577920198,
-0.1986240298,
1.2238355875,
0.2641138434,
-0.2481522113,
0.6789233685,
-0.0721465945,
0.5834422708,
-0.5715876222,
-0.3248451948,
-0.0728981271,
0.1127892733,
-0.2430336475,
-0.549829185,
0.4566721916,
-0.2857176065,
-0.1389339864,
-0.3405486047,
0.5109760165,
-0.8122163415,
-0.179609254,
0.7151002884,
0.1812239885,
0.1425211877,
0.0180320088,
-0.5505993366,
0.121149227,
-0.045787625,
0.1545513719,
0.5021216869,
0.5144794583,
0.1959481984,
0.3870668709,
0.2290857583,
0.0644640326,
0.2001402229,
0.0623292252,
0.9300318956,
-0.2287286967,
-0.7040550113,
-0.6181539297,
0.3730510473,
-0.0849122554,
0.1426792592,
0.4446353912,
0.4457811117,
1.1015056372,
0.1460455209,
0.5515259504,
-0.1629571319,
0.7849726081,
-0.7745910883,
0.7335130572,
-0.4580079615,
0.1585942954,
-0.0514774919,
-0.6707714796,
0.1135509312,
0.7135545015,
-0.2259061933,
-0.1113399342,
0.3947147131,
0.8184235096,
-0.1901484728,
0.1690323949,
0.4899902344,
-0.036495056,
0.3376424611,
0.5292421579,
0.823397696,
-0.3058864474,
0.2268538475,
-0.5011600852,
-0.5477547646,
0.2452503443,
-0.3886663318,
-0.9060890675,
-1.3844838142,
-0.3811050951,
0.0729776993,
0.0449025631,
0.795591712,
1.0214290619,
-0.6795253754,
-0.2544697523,
-0.2098757476,
-0.1649352461,
-0.2342841029,
-0.1430237293,
0.4053044915,
-0.5889287591,
-0.630253315,
0.8188197613,
0.2831392884,
-0.1441033185,
-0.4961457849,
-0.422524333,
-0.0611484386,
-0.3279147148,
0.3933384717,
0.1162232533,
-0.754000783,
0.0284044854,
-0.4747751653,
0.0271463636,
-0.1116657779,
0.6262851357,
-0.8932265043,
0.6440283656,
0.1188882813,
0.7789830565,
0.9401146173,
-0.1595845073,
0.2397737801,
-0.8754185438,
0.3785918653,
0.2619328201,
0.2275339365,
0.2921159565,
-0.20089975,
0.0130796265,
0.1082037389,
-0.2128667235,
-0.5527334809,
0.3335547447,
-0.7973603606,
-0.2427913696,
0.9495941997,
-0.4632166326,
-0.1269403547,
-0.0895601511,
0.0771988034,
0.493509233,
-0.3501004577,
0.6229597926,
0.3074910343,
-0.2257130891,
-0.3581734896,
-0.0506618917,
0.5716168284,
0.4658332765,
-0.3840564787,
0.1353594363,
0.3482721746,
0.2331002355,
0.2102455646,
0.5050969124,
-0.2865166366,
0.0937431604,
0.1388463676,
-0.2673400342,
-0.3920218349,
-0.4849423468,
-0.5108774304,
-0.1234942824,
-0.1475675851,
-0.8658914566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01994v1 | Simple Augmentations of Logical Rules for Neuro-Symbolic Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-07-02T07:07:59 | 2024-07-02T07:07:59 | Ananjan Nandi, Navdeep Kaur, Parag Singla, Mausam | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | High-quality and high-coverage rule sets are imperative to the success of
Neuro-Symbolic Knowledge Graph Completion (NS-KGC) models, because they form
the basis of all symbolic inferences. Recent literature builds neural models
for generating rule sets, however, preliminary experiments show that they
struggle with maintaining high coverage. In this work, we suggest three simple
augmentations to existing rule sets: (1) transforming rules to their abductive
forms, (2) generating equivalent rules that use inverse forms of constituent
relations and (3) random walks that propose new rules. Finally, we prune
potentially low quality rules. Experiments over four datasets and five
ruleset-baseline settings suggest that these simple augmentations consistently
improve results, and obtain up to 7.1 pt MRR and 8.5 pt Hits@1 gains over using
rules without augmentations. | [
-0.3877383471,
-0.4613704681,
0.6113488078,
-0.102566421,
-0.3702938259,
-0.3739098907,
-0.052034609,
-0.4751684666,
0.5268464088,
0.8731879592,
-0.7533665299,
-0.4384091794,
-0.7349372506,
0.1687434614,
-0.3661088943,
0.9200544357,
0.1516486108,
-0.0625860095,
-0.2763776481,
-0.188090086,
-0.6424133182,
-0.0982882157,
-0.3309143186,
-0.8066051006,
0.5381654501,
0.3570017517,
0.9524214268,
0.9959331751,
0.4960548878,
0.273309201,
-0.3487363458,
0.7541894913,
-0.3426786065,
-0.0564352684,
0.1261103153,
-0.4706976414,
-0.5048899651,
-0.0604078062,
0.2874191999,
1.0713592768,
-0.0806134716,
-0.2021567672,
-0.0615035333,
0.6750140786,
-0.6424827576,
0.290720284,
-0.3178858161,
0.160060063,
0.2745785415,
-0.268345654,
-0.5152419806,
-0.7103660107,
-0.0234294143,
-0.969540894,
-0.1023314074,
-0.1092868298,
0.7129434943,
0.1427923292,
-0.8041635156,
-0.101983346,
-0.4765057564,
0.2363382578,
-0.9447099566,
0.3404399455,
0.617559731,
0.3776582778,
-0.2901267111,
-0.6920248866,
-0.3960727155,
-0.2648380101,
-0.7316326499,
-0.0036597226,
-0.2752505839,
0.4068564773,
0.8890308738,
-0.0801406056,
0.0234509502,
-0.0130361337,
-0.4699335396,
-0.2232026309,
0.4825434685,
0.1510847956,
0.26840958,
-0.5043045282,
0.0514345169,
-0.1352142543,
-1.1654533148,
-0.0802637637,
0.4792521894,
0.2815937102,
0.2111582458,
0.9796593189,
-0.6960979104,
1.0227484703,
0.0591214597,
-0.0895067081,
0.4362444878,
-0.6490848064,
-0.148008734,
0.0520091727,
0.3294967711,
0.2625514567,
0.3435495198,
-0.4969620109,
-0.2913040221,
-0.1388319433,
0.3400759995,
-0.7839869857,
-0.4994412065,
-0.354844749,
-0.4563936591,
-0.2712725401,
0.0847744346,
0.0113276942,
-0.6426457167,
-1.0783866644,
0.720723629,
-0.9108434319,
0.0378673375,
0.1434105933,
-0.5839668512,
0.2449204624,
0.7031227946,
-0.5138077736,
0.4224270582,
0.7318129539,
0.4402666986,
0.4023112059,
-0.1606108695,
-0.5591313839,
0.0327987485,
-0.6501449347,
0.5726246238,
-0.4367961884,
-0.0688921511,
-0.288446188,
-0.0776548758,
0.1426633596,
-0.4328083992,
0.5197591186,
-0.6560684443,
0.0577375256,
-0.7732759714,
-0.373319447,
-0.4319638908,
0.2964596152,
-0.6032462716,
0.6171425581,
0.0268619973,
-0.4814977348,
0.5042544603,
-0.5406973958,
-0.9976902008,
-0.0940281823,
0.0564761721,
0.0859518945,
0.2768284976,
0.289016217,
0.2674566507,
-0.0378726907,
-0.114943102,
-0.2565207183,
-0.3250845969,
0.1031690463,
-0.0110264216,
0.9627347589,
0.0162805989,
-0.2498682588,
0.035844788,
-0.8664941788,
0.2307847887,
-0.1701196581,
-0.092569828,
-0.5796362758,
0.1412986517,
-0.4938713014,
0.4716434479,
-0.1008726656,
-0.4468497932,
0.3315927088,
-0.5656279922,
0.3245056868,
0.8584894538,
0.1390442252,
0.605253458,
-0.5238371491,
0.0214926377,
0.1820807606,
0.0573040023,
-0.0922858715,
-0.5199595094,
-0.8352393508,
-0.3848871589,
0.3688232303,
0.1611247659,
-0.9564063549,
0.7362143397,
-0.470421046,
-0.4754153192,
-0.3508298397,
0.0732885674,
0.2111805826,
0.6137741804,
0.397580117,
-0.2876819074,
-0.6322807074,
-1.0521867275,
-0.1394226402,
-0.033374317,
0.0006372091,
0.4103612602,
0.3836418092,
-0.2218296081,
0.9152173996,
-0.6028963327,
-0.2603664398,
-0.1200913042,
0.0728672147,
0.3127902448,
0.2627846897,
0.4240992367,
-0.5337384939,
-0.1265424043,
0.0397086404,
-0.7169432044,
-0.0887862891,
0.0105426963,
-0.2927368283,
-0.3081378639,
0.3911434114,
-0.8732174039,
0.7002218962,
-0.0976693481,
-0.3138841689,
0.4927020669,
-0.1465948969,
0.2678923309,
-0.7540397644,
-0.1776897013,
-0.1871356219,
-0.3998451531,
-0.8477722406,
0.0416863672,
0.0269390978,
0.0711319596,
-0.1610826403,
0.2875886858,
-0.2597483695,
0.1514155865,
-0.3696202636,
0.184416309,
-0.0845507532,
0.3998797238,
-0.2303435951,
0.1326822788,
0.4618212581,
-0.8490886092,
0.2428767681,
0.3729884923,
-0.098963663,
0.4749419391,
-0.6459298134,
-0.146815151,
-0.4931425452,
0.3149729073,
-0.9281591177,
-0.396520853,
0.4457445145,
-0.2070685029,
0.1194695979,
-0.2254127264,
-0.7379835844,
-0.2375558913,
-0.0984373763,
0.2342627347,
1.1023938656,
-0.7701882124,
1.0216172934,
0.2038356364,
0.3887992799,
-0.3924632072,
-0.7069086432,
0.0065365853,
0.1302716136,
-0.6370868683,
0.3463219404,
0.1644647866,
-0.1329299957,
0.2459990233,
-0.2588039041,
0.158464998,
0.034499485,
0.4681744277,
-0.1061222106,
-0.1030182987,
-0.0394648723,
0.228478536,
0.0080972742,
0.2548499405,
-0.2907547355,
0.5032917261,
0.2478465885,
-0.5990204811,
-0.4586809278,
0.0462945402,
0.4018282294,
-0.1536290795,
0.3591426313,
0.0965857953,
-0.7101595998,
-0.279073894,
-0.46219033,
-0.813613236,
-0.4540053904,
0.192010656,
-0.4620906711,
-0.349311322,
0.4117689729,
-0.0178279486,
-0.2157907784,
0.5055532455,
0.0143958749,
-0.1299544871,
1.0723028183,
0.2956461608,
0.4031204581,
0.2963866293,
-0.2232560515,
0.0953491777,
-0.6602451205,
-0.3199098706,
-0.3310285509,
-0.4643926024,
-0.6229999065,
-0.1118153706,
0.3671299815,
0.1799972951,
-0.2954175174,
0.7739278674,
-0.4574038684,
0.653834641,
0.7533857226,
0.7427453995,
0.3686543703,
0.2465220988,
-0.1573447734,
-0.0591320023,
-0.9220793247,
-0.0544586182,
0.9787988663,
-0.0250694957,
0.6278034449,
0.2502256036,
0.7792778611,
0.1694191992,
0.3320105672,
-0.7468599081,
0.7779330015,
-0.2323539555,
-0.3283465207,
-0.1136666685,
-0.7723161578,
-0.5727778673,
0.1420506239,
-0.4380643368,
-0.4307030439,
0.2486303151,
0.294100374,
-0.2834352553,
0.1855824441,
-0.5265714526,
0.4700542092,
0.0221876167,
0.093767114,
-0.4615795314,
-0.6715373993,
0.6319102049,
0.0902227163,
-0.3708165884,
-0.0567969605,
0.2194522768,
0.6539309621,
-0.756446898,
0.8344576359,
-0.2215425223,
0.3423376977,
0.3522566259,
0.1509268135,
0.9296830893,
-0.2823347449,
0.1670758426,
-0.0702781156,
-0.1962245107,
-0.1968348622,
-0.9716892242,
0.4721033275,
-0.6818439364,
-0.3955153227,
-0.1926951855,
-0.4870698452,
-0.1571005434,
0.4344299436,
0.0108057735,
0.3970353603,
0.2520550191,
0.3629728258,
0.6753817201,
0.2488082945,
0.0973484591,
0.2384703606,
0.0067041493,
-0.6469263434,
0.7357005477,
0.4244104624,
0.2284007519,
0.0037387665,
0.1475050002,
-0.3209327161,
-0.4494692683,
-0.1597342491,
0.3422477245,
-0.885800004,
-0.3824775815,
-0.6775818467,
-0.5998722315,
-0.5754371285,
0.1130685061,
0.0896621123,
-0.8427659273,
-0.1023409888,
-0.1957122833,
0.5944153666,
0.7543967962,
-0.3175270259,
0.480563283,
-0.4118098319,
0.6207618713,
0.308355242,
0.0829681754,
0.0071135778,
-0.5234199762,
0.0287012514,
0.4759968817,
-0.2281196266,
-1.0054191351,
0.0942196548,
0.1374009997,
0.5922668576,
0.446790874,
0.0173415896,
0.9276581407,
-0.5935459137,
0.1689929664,
0.4410164356,
-0.4792127609,
0.3373322189,
-0.3717648089,
0.1223695204,
0.6202412844,
0.3469039798,
-0.5310048461,
-0.0117217004,
-0.7368969917,
-0.6802191138,
0.7695249319,
0.3978107572,
0.1487845927,
0.0698656365,
0.4747353494,
-0.1796047688,
0.3290276527,
-0.462886095,
-0.1469352543,
-0.3417876363,
-0.1598471999,
0.1601373404,
0.0329620987,
-0.4823728502,
-0.4230666757,
0.8590216041,
-0.1758937389,
0.0995167643,
-0.0534017421,
-0.0336473025,
0.1071023121,
0.0310782474,
0.4644873738,
0.538279593,
-0.1216733381,
0.2530025244,
0.2483511567,
-0.2572374344,
0.0650127754,
0.3662284613,
-0.5413959026,
-0.2576795816,
0.3188062012,
0.7225193977,
-0.003795298,
-0.2499377578,
0.3538380265,
0.2778306901,
-0.3863115013,
-0.0655885488,
0.4070864916,
-0.0188602805,
-0.1044701636,
0.0487667285,
0.638651669,
0.1052963063,
-0.3325520754,
0.3882639706,
0.3934507072,
-0.4969048202,
-0.1558855176,
0.2733977735,
-0.0751530752,
-0.0127545223,
1.0145719051,
-0.4289346635,
-0.4808125794,
0.599024117,
0.561191678,
0.4940394163,
0.4655236602,
0.2787794471,
0.4843663275,
0.6595717072,
-0.3235259354,
0.1457376927,
-0.1861001849,
-0.7576317191,
-0.6570274234,
-0.2716373205,
-0.0145109911,
-0.2689090967,
-0.2911430299,
0.4386909306,
-0.4073453844,
-0.1273252964,
-0.0127060069,
-0.2777902484,
-0.6017081141,
0.1643897295,
-0.236236617,
1.0656549931,
-0.9747755527,
0.5087392926,
0.5118119717,
-0.5806191564,
-0.9072713256,
-0.3233166337,
0.0058125397,
-0.6898986697,
0.8406581879,
0.1144828796,
0.1038880199,
-0.0597369522,
-0.428658694,
-0.6850859523,
0.9854249358,
0.4038035572,
-0.0924566612,
-0.3280626833,
0.4020595849,
0.4801071286,
-0.1506287009,
0.4320360124,
0.4712752104,
0.830791235,
0.3933027685,
-0.3905088902,
0.4024780989,
-0.1829874814,
-0.3247909248,
0.4079988003,
-0.2982993126,
0.5164176226,
-0.2365729064,
-0.0155231589,
-0.0259851459,
0.6164735556,
0.3830954432,
0.2288595289,
0.6205582023,
1.0194420815,
0.600327909,
-0.3826356828,
1.0798393488,
-0.1479050815,
-0.1770814508,
1.1068938971,
-0.0228440333,
0.3844827116,
0.2983574271,
0.1873568594,
0.3530366421,
0.4612089992,
0.0420542285,
0.5159742236,
0.2628756464,
-0.0129745658,
-0.6130545735,
-0.2889585197,
-0.3400934339,
0.3546985388,
0.1580895483,
-0.4106580615,
-0.408192873,
-0.1485511214,
0.1011119932,
-0.1231238246,
-0.4668087661,
0.866381824,
0.0226497091,
-0.8407345414,
0.4530584514,
0.0597547516,
0.2895705104,
-0.7711527348,
-0.3243173361,
-0.2561452091,
-0.0019826216,
-0.4305804968,
-0.6502923965,
0.1731103361,
-0.4523662031,
-0.2428245395,
-0.0890097097,
1.0159175396,
-0.3090458512,
-0.3693718016,
0.0134900091,
0.3175903857,
-0.1138587743,
-0.0384084545,
-0.2305070162,
-0.6696377397,
-0.0651464388,
0.0298794899,
0.1114428788,
0.5243396163,
-0.1705021262,
0.5977092385,
0.8073055744,
0.3179068267,
0.2313240618,
-0.1239966378,
1.0859621763,
-0.4961824119,
-0.1859239638,
-0.6480757594,
0.4950465262,
-0.3910664618,
-0.1380842179,
0.9342818856,
0.554689765,
0.5446885228,
-0.1102461368,
0.4549872279,
-0.2441799492,
-0.1395113915,
-0.5172919631,
0.8658164144,
-0.4996449053,
-0.0352634825,
-0.0925949514,
-0.8203561902,
-0.4753769338,
0.4985909462,
-0.2742666304,
0.1637140065,
0.5538380742,
0.9911759496,
-0.4630960226,
0.1781579107,
0.2924922109,
0.2196274251,
0.2287961841,
0.34850353,
0.767539084,
-0.5039435625,
0.3686755598,
-0.5953427553,
-0.0833491609,
-0.0437500067,
-0.9637681842,
-0.575640738,
-0.3050661683,
-0.326094836,
-0.8434017897,
0.0814679712,
1.0120568275,
0.9745658636,
-0.588822186,
0.1341581345,
-0.3240326047,
0.3391353488,
-0.5535895824,
-0.1895307153,
0.360776782,
-0.3997340202,
-0.107590273,
0.4432835579,
-0.124666281,
0.0869478658,
0.4417893589,
-0.3033239841,
-0.1650594026,
0.0888437629,
0.7324416041,
0.2578621805,
-0.4851798713,
-0.2754995823,
0.1519474387,
-0.0819146857,
-0.0914837494,
0.8470703363,
-1.0141814947,
0.3001187146,
0.9661425352,
0.6640415788,
0.3864760101,
0.1740231663,
0.2304016948,
-0.8108340502,
-0.1933747083,
0.2381265908,
0.4805865586,
-0.0275383219,
-0.0033744643,
0.6134192944,
0.4429142475,
-0.1815887392,
-0.8500391245,
0.3712763488,
-1.0281003714,
-0.0819496214,
1.1131688356,
0.3066363335,
-0.2802921832,
0.3381472826,
-0.192404747,
0.0521265902,
-0.1216341853,
0.4846023917,
0.4358951747,
-0.4404698312,
0.2196006328,
-0.2107351422,
0.5249552131,
0.2192131877,
-0.8437234759,
0.1002294868,
0.9165062308,
0.3040264547,
0.4150388241,
0.3361501396,
-0.1801836044,
0.5726223588,
-0.1380958408,
0.0093144579,
-0.5499833226,
-0.5499513149,
-0.0115972375,
0.2108299881,
-0.0807562098,
0.3024483621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01992v1 | Is Your Large Language Model Knowledgeable or a Choices-Only Cheater? | 2024-07-02T07:06:53 | 2024-07-02T07:06:53 | Nishant Balepur, Rachel Rudinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work shows that large language models (LLMs) can answer
multiple-choice questions using only the choices, but does this mean that MCQA
leaderboard rankings of LLMs are largely influenced by abilities in
choices-only settings? To answer this, we use a contrast set that probes if
LLMs over-rely on choices-only shortcuts in MCQA. While previous works build
contrast sets via expensive human annotations or model-generated data which can
be biased, we employ graph mining to extract contrast sets from existing MCQA
datasets. We use our method on UnifiedQA, a group of six commonsense reasoning
datasets with high choices-only accuracy, to build an 820-question contrast
set. After validating our contrast set, we test 12 LLMs, finding that these
models do not exhibit reliance on choice-only shortcuts when given both the
question and choices. Thus, despite the susceptibility~of MCQA to high
choices-only accuracy, we argue that LLMs are not obtaining high ranks on MCQA
leaderboards just due to their ability to exploit choices-only shortcuts. | [
-0.38209939,
-0.620911777,
0.8391388059,
-0.1362141967,
-0.0956669375,
0.1225268543,
-0.079499796,
-0.2672028542,
0.222496897,
1.0398285389,
-0.3302865922,
-0.4656539261,
-0.7734777927,
0.0361138955,
-0.0784125626,
0.8522465229,
0.0685482025,
0.073860392,
-0.4620607793,
-0.3405479789,
-0.2808977664,
-0.571103394,
-0.8560528159,
-0.543520391,
0.8212817907,
0.5721865892,
1.1526942253,
0.598457098,
0.1741836816,
0.2663618624,
-0.3926157653,
0.1799198985,
-0.5104725361,
-0.0152922478,
-0.4050526917,
-0.5133398175,
-0.1362600774,
0.0229798071,
0.3857367039,
0.6982122064,
0.156139493,
0.2275155634,
0.0645209625,
0.538282156,
-0.5931727886,
0.1140941009,
-0.8081936836,
-0.1464605331,
-0.4130218923,
0.0715703517,
-0.4508248866,
-0.1107278541,
-0.1919213086,
-0.2149717063,
-0.0599285141,
0.0816992968,
0.7885015607,
0.349529177,
-0.8962712288,
-0.3727911115,
-0.2266768366,
0.9780449867,
-0.6979242563,
0.3229722679,
0.5434368253,
0.3620561659,
-0.2652863264,
-0.5392451286,
-0.3579124212,
-0.4142419994,
-0.1501932889,
0.0736006498,
0.0208356772,
0.085598439,
0.3751191795,
0.0664009526,
-0.2694137096,
0.5267066956,
-0.3824166059,
-0.3348488212,
0.4940772951,
0.1192233562,
0.3652659953,
-0.2589107156,
-0.1732576638,
0.0292309448,
-0.7778232098,
0.1841497123,
0.4398816526,
0.4735928476,
0.2111589909,
0.8520687819,
-0.2978785336,
0.8022833467,
-0.3578448892,
-0.2627694607,
-0.0525234714,
-0.0024513805,
-0.2248206437,
-0.1580867022,
0.7398412228,
0.2418224663,
0.4883089662,
-0.1092800871,
-0.0897188485,
-0.112328127,
-0.0615848079,
-0.7253553271,
-0.5756523609,
0.3268856406,
-0.220422253,
-0.2703308463,
-0.1435138136,
-0.5167971253,
-0.5457003713,
-0.0632229894,
0.4102188647,
0.0788039267,
-0.0951585099,
-0.0499066114,
-0.2826035023,
-0.0249545854,
0.2061632425,
-0.5896348953,
0.2097754776,
0.4648534358,
0.7900910378,
-0.1610708535,
-0.4274730086,
-0.6222203374,
-0.0543446504,
-0.3928774595,
0.7598692775,
-0.7285015583,
-0.5276754498,
-0.1655369848,
-0.035863135,
-0.0804615393,
-0.7004044652,
0.7214355469,
-0.7427250147,
-0.0646890923,
-0.687943697,
-0.553937912,
-0.0094203996,
0.0175216086,
-0.940664649,
0.7559986115,
-0.107371524,
-0.9068174362,
0.3712648451,
-0.4009792209,
-0.4030111432,
-0.0962733477,
-0.323207736,
-0.3080082536,
-0.1882396787,
0.3325060308,
0.3016778827,
0.0854754448,
0.1509485543,
-0.6502795815,
-0.4200516641,
0.6010833979,
-0.316610992,
1.0713015795,
0.0856993943,
-0.1912996769,
-0.1800417602,
-0.4215699732,
0.1754079312,
0.1724798828,
-0.6143141389,
-0.2493475825,
0.0945042372,
-0.376645267,
0.7030034065,
0.1507808566,
-0.3780569136,
0.1342082769,
0.0697928593,
0.1180986613,
1.2095220089,
-0.1141945943,
0.2546474934,
-0.5536208153,
0.4512175918,
0.0991880968,
-0.1454175562,
0.4918563962,
-0.6419735551,
-0.8494492173,
-0.3771235645,
0.5216758251,
0.4678068757,
-0.9453669786,
0.2164575905,
-0.0787776932,
-0.392559737,
-0.6058629155,
0.4646308124,
0.5992479324,
0.5632229447,
0.1782044917,
-0.0368760191,
-0.3211604953,
-1.1559587717,
-0.601865828,
-0.0057044448,
0.1273364574,
0.7883719206,
0.5988363028,
-0.0119494312,
0.7364042997,
-0.7594624758,
-0.0480224527,
-0.2410338521,
-0.3249799609,
0.3957199454,
0.1514901072,
0.380512923,
-0.7812931538,
-0.4452390969,
-0.3664443493,
-0.5802320838,
-0.1468695849,
0.2640534043,
-0.3152304888,
-0.0357549675,
0.6094893813,
-0.44648242,
0.0793627873,
0.6386116743,
-0.3998112679,
0.6200729609,
0.0062757782,
0.038145192,
-0.7250316143,
0.0089942208,
-0.1775800735,
-0.1483904719,
-0.4716085494,
0.031927269,
-0.070130147,
0.0779709667,
-0.5333530307,
0.9742377996,
-0.1996546388,
-0.1027335376,
-0.21612598,
0.2500397563,
-0.0020310131,
0.4791324139,
0.0171822347,
0.7123810053,
0.5985289216,
-0.8241416216,
0.1406495124,
0.3531962335,
-0.4643050432,
0.3227723539,
-0.4947078228,
0.2838017642,
-0.0726373121,
0.3534498513,
-0.9016994238,
-0.3257160187,
0.0550245941,
-0.2355113775,
-0.0796548724,
-0.2609058619,
-0.5047485232,
-0.3468352854,
-0.1728433818,
0.0239377301,
0.375299871,
-0.8194494247,
0.3605414331,
0.3902672827,
-0.3001879156,
-0.9117263556,
-0.7156001329,
-0.100298129,
-0.0117196776,
-0.433814615,
-0.0584458336,
-0.3849331141,
-0.4967472851,
-0.1810532808,
-0.1484366059,
-0.0770396292,
0.2148457319,
0.3631580472,
0.1996520162,
0.0111747654,
0.1748606116,
0.0604222268,
0.0750805065,
-0.0506064184,
0.1420679986,
0.4299625754,
0.0016286469,
-0.4025846422,
0.0789261907,
0.2441441864,
0.6195015907,
-0.2566662133,
0.7717100978,
0.1489788443,
0.0088513633,
-0.3475003541,
-0.4634755552,
-0.0207323283,
-0.4799948037,
0.493868202,
-0.5548309088,
-1.1236258745,
0.6882663965,
0.0846569836,
0.1799741685,
0.3343355358,
0.3907338977,
-0.1808854491,
1.2769550085,
0.2841042578,
-0.1962145418,
0.299887985,
0.0144485189,
-0.0388585068,
-0.7191467285,
-0.0328295603,
-0.6662735343,
-0.4041441083,
-0.7765795588,
-0.1341338307,
0.2780885398,
0.0867068693,
-0.4998601675,
-0.1671793163,
-0.2403371781,
0.9043652415,
0.6447656155,
0.3939775825,
0.3562194407,
-0.2541031539,
-0.2436512858,
0.1430260837,
-0.803979516,
-0.411885947,
1.3828727007,
0.0250654276,
0.6667232513,
0.3462181687,
0.6949653029,
-0.030926751,
0.1335282624,
-0.6315034032,
0.6687391996,
-0.340919584,
-0.9646174312,
-0.3661647439,
-0.7294152379,
-0.7723028064,
0.4279935658,
-0.2107805908,
-0.6206693053,
0.0181413461,
0.1695573777,
-0.2567479014,
0.5710054636,
-0.590457499,
0.7609577179,
-0.3259673715,
-0.2520095706,
0.3246783316,
-0.6133643389,
0.6773318648,
-0.1206190586,
0.3447853923,
-0.0003183472,
0.0848195031,
0.8693295717,
-0.1638918668,
0.8327125907,
0.0039798133,
0.1416524649,
0.1982923448,
0.1679277718,
0.4518606067,
-0.0256525893,
-0.3156622946,
-0.0016323056,
-0.2202152312,
-0.8556057811,
-0.4502606988,
1.0383505821,
-0.8507760763,
-0.6817939281,
-0.3725491464,
-0.4136754274,
-0.4059209228,
0.3969392478,
0.3452810943,
0.4216561913,
-0.0624633804,
-0.0486738794,
0.658739686,
-0.0631998256,
0.2742586136,
0.2803404033,
-0.4023639858,
-0.2251504809,
0.7411803007,
0.3443911672,
0.5402379632,
0.0052784411,
0.3568556011,
-0.3607816994,
-0.6136220098,
-0.3898707032,
0.4681266248,
-1.1701985598,
-0.064211309,
-0.5359331965,
-0.2947006524,
-0.1989722252,
-0.1710522473,
-0.2135536522,
-0.3624615371,
-0.2879724503,
-0.2811565697,
0.0826827809,
0.8793022633,
0.2179959565,
0.0984594822,
-0.5203126669,
0.3877229393,
0.8382670283,
0.4097468853,
-0.0670152381,
-0.5011327863,
-0.1534183323,
-0.066494599,
-0.2589150369,
-0.8185403943,
-0.0363131836,
0.0117175113,
0.7842717171,
0.3563928902,
0.0973700881,
0.3296358585,
-0.2164015323,
0.8154066205,
-0.1893047094,
-0.7402176857,
0.1100094244,
-0.1173251718,
0.3656407297,
0.8445606232,
0.3759084642,
-0.421192497,
-0.5559743643,
-0.8373651505,
-0.333140105,
0.6490638852,
0.0253304895,
0.0709608421,
-0.0397748463,
0.2645298839,
0.0350588933,
0.2896301448,
-0.9843847156,
-0.3915557861,
-0.0375531763,
0.014364507,
-0.3672825694,
-0.1634683907,
-0.2822668254,
-0.0673100874,
0.6884981394,
-0.2508940697,
-0.1642073691,
-0.2648712397,
-0.087594822,
0.117412813,
0.5290332437,
0.3238582313,
0.8647553921,
-0.2333844006,
0.445443958,
0.3357877433,
-0.2783496082,
-0.0916403159,
-0.0818592981,
-0.1811412424,
0.0686343461,
0.2814625204,
0.5718998313,
0.1127522662,
-0.7589457035,
0.5180160403,
0.1936824471,
-0.1946751475,
0.1342063248,
0.2728815973,
0.4098723531,
0.1830095351,
-0.1749622673,
0.0544587113,
0.0064449161,
-0.6714886427,
0.1021720991,
0.7099571228,
-0.4158768952,
0.1359141022,
0.3174642622,
0.0857218057,
-0.2112573236,
0.8300378323,
-0.0263708401,
-0.71569103,
0.7724669576,
0.4305849671,
0.3616503477,
-0.1621556431,
0.3354672492,
0.1489116549,
0.1682944894,
-0.250744909,
0.2486825585,
0.2095712423,
-0.9121394157,
-0.2438214123,
-0.3893249035,
-0.6640974283,
0.2833701074,
-0.587056756,
0.418572098,
-0.4223600328,
-0.1002187878,
0.0508249775,
-0.0172295477,
-0.6083195806,
0.5209444761,
-0.0861531273,
0.8036053181,
-0.901023984,
0.8633753657,
0.4457909763,
-0.2809983194,
-0.7345775366,
-0.0899575874,
-0.0416232497,
-0.8961358666,
0.5327404737,
-0.0468496867,
-0.0945608914,
-0.1450107992,
-0.8676240444,
-0.6683725715,
1.0900954008,
0.3218409717,
-0.3555856049,
-0.0654749349,
0.0611688457,
0.2057182044,
-0.139285475,
0.3718971312,
0.7568712234,
0.5435094237,
0.3052255213,
-0.7927156687,
-0.0667141303,
0.0077328365,
-0.3520954251,
0.2664914131,
-0.8889985085,
0.9928122163,
-0.3827227056,
-0.0257734563,
-0.1806385964,
0.1528455615,
0.5391871333,
0.1758872271,
0.5625708103,
0.4207113385,
0.8941134214,
0.0783022717,
1.1142429113,
-0.0196928419,
0.218660444,
1.3974065781,
-0.1851434708,
0.9083682299,
0.4873239398,
0.0194982588,
0.4061211944,
0.6432335377,
0.0956750438,
0.5514544249,
0.3468609452,
0.0371866412,
-0.7933553457,
-0.0884964168,
-0.0897886455,
0.5740369558,
0.0607473738,
-0.4535501003,
-0.1604966074,
-0.2058124244,
0.4615347087,
0.0294204447,
-0.4034163654,
0.5909744501,
0.2720250785,
-0.7932705283,
0.4230489433,
-0.0767478719,
0.5095458627,
-0.6552380323,
0.0565170608,
-0.2177381665,
-0.1539316773,
-0.2820837796,
-0.9987643361,
-0.2462008446,
-0.0937570781,
-0.0592915565,
0.0039953897,
0.6336612701,
-0.262619704,
-0.4539817572,
0.2065288126,
0.7320798039,
0.1465043277,
-0.0780450478,
-0.7686247826,
-0.2248005718,
0.141462341,
-0.1320970505,
0.4990436435,
0.0266596638,
-0.103962265,
0.7487136126,
0.6595895886,
0.2205268443,
-0.0901849866,
0.0516515374,
1.0150972605,
-0.6837695241,
-0.4600318968,
-0.8673692942,
0.4317313731,
-0.248035565,
-0.4818525314,
0.7940884233,
0.5766970515,
0.6986188293,
0.134180367,
1.0320566893,
0.4070844054,
0.5827592015,
-0.8673525453,
0.8006203175,
-0.6132893562,
0.3900881708,
-0.1870735884,
-0.6923537254,
-0.1355231106,
0.1486491263,
-0.5710116029,
0.2963429093,
0.6489655972,
0.8896945119,
-0.1913045198,
-0.1392709166,
0.4172047079,
0.2999811172,
0.3711257875,
0.6693971157,
0.9044310451,
0.1063740924,
0.7427939773,
-0.0582804047,
-0.300962925,
-0.1907009184,
-0.7284131646,
-1.2687608004,
-0.2519851327,
-0.1079946011,
-0.5764558315,
-0.0529694408,
0.5017399192,
0.3218795061,
-0.6419141293,
-0.20502837,
0.3148604631,
0.6972744465,
-0.042360954,
-0.1551298797,
0.4902925789,
-0.028251797,
-0.5866353512,
0.2446850985,
-0.168294847,
-0.0146047706,
-0.0963620469,
-0.0613265894,
-0.1986470073,
0.4697713256,
0.2906526029,
0.258205235,
-0.6528325081,
-0.4913779199,
0.0444470048,
-0.2506805956,
0.2608346343,
0.7042899132,
-0.456243366,
0.4462925196,
0.3926623166,
0.3785488009,
0.4566624761,
-0.2270682901,
0.0979204103,
-0.6231895089,
-0.1850897223,
0.2151148915,
0.4733955562,
0.3596181273,
-0.1787294447,
0.1798370034,
-0.0993151069,
-0.787883997,
-0.593809545,
0.6164490581,
-0.8506243229,
-0.5792978406,
1.4372850657,
0.0264575016,
-0.2043690979,
-0.3450003564,
-0.3441712856,
-0.0353373773,
-0.3219586015,
0.4915336967,
1.0113936663,
-0.3622301221,
-0.0062227892,
-0.6950577497,
0.6065368652,
0.3242255747,
-0.7357504964,
-0.0327131748,
0.4382788539,
0.5532120466,
0.0942314789,
0.7382727265,
0.0346235558,
0.1481125057,
0.0469482504,
-0.3083414137,
-0.2787633836,
-0.3301528394,
-0.3559889197,
0.3056123555,
0.5071285963,
0.0312143303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01976v1 | A Bounding Box is Worth One Token: Interleaving Layout and Text in a Large Language Model for Document Understanding | 2024-07-02T06:29:05 | 2024-07-02T06:29:05 | Jinghui Lu, Haiyang Yu, Yanjie Wang, Yongjie Ye, Jingqun Tang, Ziwei Yang, Binghong Wu, Qi Liu, Hao Feng, Han Wang, Hao Liu, Can Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM | Recently, many studies have demonstrated that exclusively incorporating
OCR-derived text and spatial layouts with large language models (LLMs) can be
highly effective for document understanding tasks. However, existing methods
that integrate spatial layouts with text have limitations, such as producing
overly long text sequences or failing to fully leverage the autoregressive
traits of LLMs. In this work, we introduce Interleaving Layout and Text in a
Large Language Model (LayTextLLM)} for document understanding. In particular,
LayTextLLM projects each bounding box to a single embedding and interleaves it
with text, efficiently avoiding long sequence issues while leveraging
autoregressive traits of LLMs. LayTextLLM not only streamlines the interaction
of layout and textual data but also shows enhanced performance in Key
Information Extraction (KIE) and Visual Question Answering (VQA). Comprehensive
benchmark evaluations reveal significant improvements, with a 27.0% increase on
KIE tasks and 24.1% on VQA tasks compared to previous state-of-the-art document
understanding MLLMs, as well as a 15.5% improvement over other SOTA OCR-based
LLMs on KIE tasks. | [
-0.3758614659,
-0.8895351291,
0.8260195255,
0.3376349807,
-0.3925743699,
0.0806275532,
-0.2790771127,
-0.3880849183,
-0.1364239603,
0.8132226467,
-0.3921509087,
-0.6631445289,
-0.6452035308,
-0.0929643512,
-0.3135512471,
0.6194296479,
-0.3815959394,
0.0532591455,
-0.4892375767,
-0.1837079525,
-0.6955400705,
-0.4639852643,
-0.0906040817,
-0.1841724813,
0.1945833713,
0.3510750234,
0.8278657794,
0.9902406931,
0.5052325726,
0.3353730738,
-0.3015407622,
0.2469892651,
-0.3750563264,
0.0489561781,
-0.2285559624,
-0.4718979597,
-0.3029451668,
-0.0315189958,
0.5877099037,
0.7011446953,
0.0876442119,
-0.2539625168,
0.0787721127,
0.6511660814,
-0.4071331918,
0.3665554821,
-0.3681102097,
0.3352715969,
0.0610803328,
-0.356983453,
-0.6692627072,
-0.2794623971,
0.2077428699,
-0.8150060773,
0.0655280426,
-0.006755169,
0.6689603329,
0.4377497733,
-0.5012205839,
-0.6411083937,
-0.3533855975,
0.4220712781,
-0.5862149,
0.7203293443,
0.5867673755,
0.0855349973,
-0.0718799233,
-0.6796539426,
-0.5122473836,
0.0763641819,
-0.4228726327,
0.4105164707,
-0.0778128281,
0.0489193276,
0.4575639367,
0.3684879839,
-0.76603055,
0.2557439506,
-0.3930296004,
0.0319418423,
0.3486001492,
-0.0709901601,
0.6689166427,
-0.3223288059,
-0.4186753631,
-0.2208744884,
-0.5765058398,
-0.0701849312,
0.0879663378,
0.0727581903,
-0.119422026,
0.6255205274,
0.207726568,
0.7916553617,
-0.1869075894,
-0.103258729,
-0.0852228329,
-0.3177374005,
-0.3475229144,
-0.1251658499,
0.6431617737,
0.161030829,
0.1507744938,
-0.3844290674,
0.158251062,
-0.2789332569,
0.2770494521,
-0.8908735514,
-0.0080908239,
0.2214110643,
-0.588291347,
0.2655639648,
0.2175290883,
-0.7901448011,
-0.3378901482,
-0.4497877359,
0.3370868862,
-0.8602446318,
0.115285635,
0.4159689546,
-0.1295990944,
0.3990260959,
0.7005411983,
-0.6409705281,
0.2283932865,
0.7972635031,
0.9558101296,
-0.1224184185,
-0.2981152833,
-0.8294195533,
0.1649689078,
-0.2781385779,
0.7632732391,
-0.4462088346,
-0.3345670402,
0.1494396627,
0.059442021,
0.0301065315,
-0.5060817599,
0.4798757434,
-0.7924001813,
0.5752731562,
-0.1444253623,
-0.7147212029,
-0.1586349905,
0.1051170826,
-0.7110590935,
0.8235687017,
-0.1277270317,
-0.5510042906,
0.3145270348,
-0.5259698629,
-0.4617383182,
0.2972142994,
-0.3575230539,
-0.4691714346,
0.2195750028,
0.3579670489,
0.5452145934,
0.0705530792,
0.286949724,
-0.1680009216,
-0.3296513855,
0.1963673234,
-0.2577360272,
0.5430892706,
0.2406374663,
-0.275775224,
-0.2137137651,
-0.6027988195,
0.033341337,
-0.0938799381,
-0.4197279811,
-0.5154425502,
-0.0798463821,
0.0714817941,
0.2309324294,
0.271789372,
-0.3098509014,
0.3774859607,
-0.3057320118,
0.3665117919,
0.479891181,
-0.3598390222,
0.8969525099,
0.0018683503,
0.6266763806,
0.0316344798,
-0.1849300265,
-0.6839618683,
-0.1310569048,
-0.4566939771,
-0.4565000832,
0.2353345007,
0.4755311906,
-0.8115301728,
0.6090050936,
-0.2254349738,
-0.1735390723,
-0.1994648874,
0.0630243719,
0.5011657476,
0.1637317687,
0.3119960129,
-0.0931145325,
-0.2618350685,
-0.727737844,
-0.2903263271,
0.1879014075,
0.1228896827,
0.2948814631,
0.3976529539,
-0.0907172188,
0.976260066,
-0.6531267166,
-0.4457891285,
-0.1488426179,
0.2247072607,
0.3361089826,
0.3076414466,
0.2617369294,
-1.0412844419,
-0.8678619266,
0.1048989296,
-0.8456346989,
-0.138552174,
-0.0759183094,
-0.351242125,
0.0785104632,
0.9363853335,
-0.5896943808,
0.9275061488,
0.4989891648,
-0.6537930369,
0.1122686267,
-0.5475723743,
0.1019990072,
-1.0668526888,
-0.1720511168,
-0.0235878862,
-0.3429572582,
-0.673787415,
0.1998519748,
0.6676797271,
-0.268012017,
-0.1873160154,
0.7211103439,
-0.9498052001,
-0.3687368333,
-0.2390795201,
0.495642662,
0.4504007697,
0.2902268171,
0.3924866021,
0.9699041247,
-0.0217486732,
-0.3025624156,
-0.2560044825,
0.698122561,
-0.6507798433,
0.584081471,
-0.3870206773,
0.0853372067,
-0.5622871518,
0.3897299469,
-1.1195474863,
-0.0534827672,
-0.1828000396,
-0.2520156205,
0.4676184058,
0.0075004119,
-0.5989850163,
-0.2011788338,
-0.2271191627,
0.3818852305,
0.3980732858,
-0.86994946,
0.8274694681,
0.2451650053,
-0.2748076022,
-0.5505259037,
-0.7491499782,
0.1070041731,
-0.1361038983,
-0.7944763899,
0.3956314921,
-0.1506978869,
-0.2445093244,
-0.0300163664,
0.0857756138,
-0.0833206698,
0.0006022164,
0.2393123806,
0.0684669986,
-0.2501027584,
0.4273134172,
-0.0361139067,
-0.163857609,
-0.2137049586,
-0.452611059,
0.6620134115,
0.2181311548,
-0.4068333805,
-0.200171873,
0.7494930029,
0.7650991082,
-0.3850549459,
0.9821088314,
0.3424371183,
-0.4172553718,
-0.2253381312,
-0.5844241977,
0.2299693674,
-0.4507441521,
0.6433904767,
-0.7328364253,
-0.921854794,
0.4606238902,
-0.1063873097,
0.1339309812,
0.1625745893,
0.3352198899,
-0.4285672605,
0.804079473,
0.8709968328,
0.1687479168,
0.5476508141,
-0.1795461327,
0.4701482654,
-0.9395216703,
-0.2417306155,
-0.6203935146,
-0.192036137,
-0.2336376309,
-0.9203725457,
0.4506376386,
0.3357512951,
0.2068959326,
0.1903625727,
-0.3769487441,
0.7559492588,
0.4301579297,
0.2355880737,
0.516643405,
0.2167157829,
-0.0154738342,
-0.3730325699,
-0.6298309565,
-0.5645052791,
0.6127181649,
0.5072020292,
0.9081705213,
0.2689788938,
0.5123463869,
-0.0135906553,
0.1983385235,
-0.6578575373,
0.4497430325,
-0.6617483497,
-0.0296596028,
-0.3192091584,
-0.2922158837,
-1.0020033121,
0.4706065953,
0.1215558797,
-0.8765754104,
0.2318449467,
-0.1530524492,
-0.1476114541,
0.32833305,
-0.6421952844,
0.7244899273,
-0.3120709658,
-0.3669253588,
-0.0086483471,
-0.2187381983,
0.1707765609,
-0.0036641844,
0.3749457598,
0.2280602902,
-0.143992424,
0.5945232511,
-0.6313427091,
0.6946687102,
0.1118647978,
-0.4517610073,
-0.0378821678,
0.1198610887,
0.5877138376,
-0.0893050358,
-0.1602506489,
-0.120772928,
-0.0333150104,
-0.2925851941,
-0.7965813279,
0.631405592,
-0.7969286442,
-0.4690198898,
-0.2400263846,
-0.9130751491,
-0.1885022223,
0.1733776778,
0.4155523777,
0.8274403811,
-0.2657108605,
0.4100615382,
1.2716672421,
-0.6084730625,
0.3685792089,
0.4735686779,
-0.3888517916,
-0.4954181612,
0.5151276588,
0.2386221141,
0.2470472604,
0.8896110654,
0.0947382152,
-0.6042550206,
-0.3943941295,
-0.4296011329,
0.4495263994,
-0.8848289847,
-0.1971969008,
-1.2704529762,
-0.2959716916,
-0.3777631819,
-0.5917453766,
0.0325955413,
-0.1302766502,
-0.4098693728,
-0.1216102019,
0.2557373643,
0.9418933988,
0.0401534066,
0.5358089805,
-0.7915503383,
0.3896666765,
0.1890154481,
0.4214788377,
0.010432072,
-0.6330881715,
-0.302745223,
-0.3220428526,
-0.0601868145,
-0.9482921362,
0.4735502601,
-0.1350583583,
0.4130083919,
0.1808496565,
-0.2981939018,
0.9074206948,
-0.5108271241,
0.3945506513,
0.1657103598,
-1.0117412806,
0.3134931624,
-0.3443116844,
0.9830554724,
0.4787761271,
0.3027382195,
-0.6723415852,
-0.3832425773,
-0.4518018067,
-0.621465683,
0.823266387,
-0.0507614762,
-0.1166450009,
0.2270670086,
0.5104897618,
0.2565198243,
0.134692952,
-0.9170005918,
0.1479685158,
0.1404641867,
-0.6048998237,
-0.3015452623,
-0.5971027613,
0.087819241,
-0.051019568,
0.5508667231,
-0.2549391389,
0.2116262615,
0.2894759178,
-0.6574622393,
0.071868442,
0.283007443,
0.4045721889,
0.6157300472,
-0.0422662199,
0.2506220043,
0.0291693825,
-0.5809619427,
0.0502107441,
0.2386205941,
-0.1461617798,
-0.0431401171,
0.6190026402,
0.7246546745,
0.1725865304,
-0.6307300329,
0.5754237771,
-0.3083740473,
-0.4208437502,
-0.0158237088,
-0.3179298639,
0.1107881367,
0.2648599148,
0.1665890664,
-0.5607108474,
0.0315307826,
-0.624792099,
0.3197042346,
0.5404345989,
-0.4303178191,
0.1074462533,
0.4883703589,
0.0745709389,
-0.4514539838,
0.6051639318,
0.1165089011,
-0.7583574057,
0.6990568638,
0.7305842638,
0.6377243996,
0.1123969778,
0.2015719712,
0.3747733235,
0.3852986991,
0.0731048957,
0.2165288627,
-0.378452152,
-0.4305846095,
-0.5544429421,
-0.6323756576,
-0.2422400415,
0.1400067657,
-0.5226655006,
0.1474137455,
-0.3026412129,
0.2821301818,
-0.2424617708,
0.0777709037,
-0.7979941964,
0.1826665103,
0.0042842599,
1.2567955256,
-0.6835928559,
0.5932801962,
0.6678509712,
-0.1071732715,
-0.6804485917,
0.1850240678,
-0.2545552254,
-0.6960171461,
0.7820039392,
0.4149184227,
0.1152751893,
-0.1550930887,
-0.3972581625,
-0.9393191338,
0.9279347062,
0.0859424546,
-0.7203059196,
-0.0163893178,
0.3443237543,
0.4299626052,
-0.246685192,
0.5546494722,
0.3445970416,
0.4586794376,
-0.0180998351,
-0.6911568642,
0.0488251895,
-0.1680418104,
0.1491646618,
0.4968333542,
-0.7133220434,
0.5787177682,
0.0552362166,
-0.3920617104,
0.2059572786,
0.7161937952,
0.068457596,
0.2222480327,
0.5582057834,
0.6912299395,
0.7953471541,
-0.1926762015,
0.8488240838,
-0.0266676173,
0.1036844477,
1.3502879143,
-0.1708172858,
0.683455646,
0.4046804607,
-0.0626751557,
0.4207305908,
0.3616321683,
0.5724707246,
0.5235574841,
0.1606157124,
-0.1004053056,
-0.141093567,
0.1027042121,
-0.3072119355,
0.4127861261,
0.5951613784,
-0.3536463082,
-0.3333326578,
0.4137480855,
0.0452578999,
0.5032920241,
-0.0545794815,
1.1286230087,
0.1435070336,
-0.8699402809,
0.0542598031,
-0.2112647891,
0.5341666937,
-0.604192853,
-0.150746271,
-0.3094203174,
0.196185112,
-0.0811496302,
-1.0982391834,
0.1069833487,
-0.0972988084,
-0.4201844335,
-0.6630017757,
0.7009439468,
-0.8464588523,
-0.2508497238,
0.4359742105,
0.4679036438,
0.0239912979,
0.0993504971,
-0.4014607966,
0.4036231637,
0.0821574181,
-0.0618068874,
0.4574200511,
0.7321153879,
-0.0017385789,
0.4309461713,
0.5369387269,
-0.1656423956,
0.0767207071,
0.0429226868,
0.5820541382,
-0.7595478892,
-0.8911507726,
-0.8178796172,
0.5294334292,
-0.3804920018,
-0.024883857,
0.5614129305,
0.6110103726,
0.5115975142,
-0.0031618292,
0.77232337,
0.2039221823,
0.202235952,
-0.94368577,
0.5815690756,
-0.6374242902,
0.0545644611,
-0.2119958848,
-0.9290267229,
-0.2705186605,
0.6544950008,
-0.5960564017,
-0.3558799624,
0.8341574669,
0.4124744236,
-0.239720419,
0.0470111966,
0.5124000907,
0.3766297102,
0.5233860016,
0.5076612234,
1.0015761852,
-0.4508509338,
0.3380509913,
-0.1849416047,
-0.5050674677,
-0.1806823909,
-0.8497719169,
-1.0126494169,
-0.8279627562,
-0.2462674081,
-0.4527007341,
-0.1469133645,
0.4989545643,
0.7954218984,
-0.3152126074,
-0.1591632217,
0.0127771609,
0.182657972,
0.337000221,
-0.2668794394,
0.6028636098,
-0.2875237465,
-0.7952101827,
0.2616266012,
0.7807388902,
0.155456692,
-0.1901834458,
0.0674869046,
-0.2161912918,
0.072970055,
0.6951820254,
0.2396875471,
-0.6003623009,
-0.1821093559,
-0.0890583172,
-0.3803805411,
0.1640863866,
0.8462077975,
-0.660309732,
0.5699216127,
0.6194584966,
0.850030899,
0.680526495,
0.157234937,
0.7421810627,
-0.4737674892,
0.3752215803,
-0.0557179935,
0.6119940877,
0.2621316314,
-0.7687285542,
0.5170652866,
-0.4083861411,
-0.5504262447,
-0.6629603505,
0.1737177223,
-0.7841981053,
-0.5103145838,
0.99041152,
-0.0052156537,
-0.4179750383,
0.0614985451,
-0.4369523525,
-0.0108723035,
-0.0892382637,
0.393772155,
0.7440749407,
0.097737439,
-0.1445224285,
-0.4359292388,
0.2468577325,
0.6235572696,
-1.247145772,
0.0959347636,
0.5189411044,
-0.0815732479,
0.2662298679,
0.8241749406,
-0.1231862605,
0.2733663619,
-0.3424521089,
-0.1370313019,
0.1851607114,
-0.3540832698,
-0.4155422151,
0.1674084067,
-0.2180142999,
-0.0246872921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01965v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01965v1 | AdaCQR: Enhancing Query Reformulation for Conversational Search via Sparse and Dense Retrieval Alignment | 2024-07-02T05:50:16 | 2024-07-02T05:50:16 | Yilong Lai, Jialong Wu, Congzhi Zhang, Haowen Sun, Deyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Conversational Query Reformulation (CQR) has significantly advanced in
addressing the challenges of conversational search, particularly those stemming
from the latent user intent and the need for historical context. Recent works
aimed to boost the performance of CRQ through alignment. However, they are
designed for one specific retrieval system, which potentially results in poor
generalization. To overcome this limitation, we present a novel framework
AdaCQR. By aligning reformulation models with both term-based and
semantic-based retrieval systems, AdaCQR enhances the generalizability of
information-seeking queries across diverse retrieval environments through a
dual-phase training strategy. We also developed two effective approaches for
acquiring superior labels and diverse input candidates, boosting the efficiency
and robustness of the framework. Experimental evaluations on the TopiOCQA and
QReCC datasets demonstrate that AdaCQR significantly outperforms existing
methods, offering both quantitative and qualitative improvements in
conversational query reformulation. | [
-0.2114809304,
-1.0013141632,
0.2457662374,
-0.1922227591,
-0.0878056735,
0.2294447869,
-0.0271008499,
-0.0654611662,
0.3157703876,
0.3697595894,
-0.516196847,
-0.4699112177,
-0.1609124839,
-0.2109141648,
-0.4774939716,
0.8897624612,
0.2787590623,
0.2748592794,
-0.201770857,
-0.4677715302,
-0.6644278169,
-0.7188826203,
-0.8120164871,
0.0044431803,
0.5457060337,
0.4573941827,
0.99978441,
0.7275608182,
0.4893079102,
0.1923790872,
-0.3100649714,
0.3922079802,
-0.7887951136,
0.6088161469,
0.091514349,
-0.3483350575,
-0.1521342397,
-0.4959030747,
0.7048014402,
0.7870140076,
-0.7156903148,
-0.2065731138,
0.163419202,
0.6994711161,
-0.7911478877,
0.0397763997,
-0.9577892423,
-0.0765242502,
0.0525588207,
-0.3462433815,
-0.0616909266,
-0.4219020903,
-0.0195777249,
-0.7720967531,
0.4607211351,
0.172112003,
0.7994806767,
0.1503199041,
-0.8251838088,
-0.3026872277,
-0.8373721242,
0.5503587723,
-0.298755914,
0.684998095,
0.126735121,
0.5510661006,
-0.1421726495,
-0.8134260178,
-0.3823066354,
0.1084360629,
-0.051448755,
-0.026246015,
-0.1452999413,
0.1539689302,
0.0250601284,
0.5156749487,
-0.7048299909,
-0.2060034722,
-0.437256515,
-0.2726705968,
0.4943837821,
0.42655316,
0.3479270041,
0.2923431396,
-0.4022071064,
-0.243427977,
-0.5871827006,
0.2595102191,
0.2450170815,
0.5723717809,
0.481408298,
0.5862329602,
-0.595204711,
0.6889101863,
0.3859887719,
0.2082191706,
-0.0141214365,
-0.7902274132,
0.1463636011,
0.194105342,
0.7420691252,
0.2890236378,
-0.4397633374,
-0.2577883899,
-0.2680823207,
-0.2204537541,
0.3619115949,
-0.7991978526,
-0.2250890732,
0.18852368,
-0.2923637927,
0.0008225631,
0.1611185521,
-0.6370792389,
-0.1583924741,
-0.4146989286,
0.4219665229,
-0.3247069418,
0.0004979933,
0.007040502,
-0.0118710389,
0.6061715484,
0.3443763554,
-0.9684010148,
0.6113464832,
0.8873692155,
0.6160268188,
-0.1757031083,
0.313562274,
-0.7643734813,
0.1493130177,
-0.3502416313,
0.6656734943,
-1.011457324,
-0.4484275281,
0.0331696533,
-0.1351410002,
-0.2304724455,
-0.7259674668,
0.6941398382,
-1.0833866596,
0.2435287833,
-0.3742501438,
-0.2613858879,
-0.124802731,
0.4399928749,
-0.6787571907,
1.2571742535,
-0.0815377086,
-0.5956707001,
0.2440792769,
-0.3977015913,
-0.3302533627,
0.1188383251,
-0.2334528714,
-0.2731624544,
-0.3050765097,
0.4065547585,
-0.135768339,
-0.2006475031,
0.2949919105,
-0.167265892,
-0.6371212006,
0.1861825436,
-0.1373290569,
0.5477567911,
0.3121854365,
-0.0172701571,
0.1615474671,
-0.4171376824,
0.341137737,
-0.0313550904,
-0.3551511168,
-0.4639840722,
0.0508196801,
-0.1279166043,
0.0538251437,
0.3776287138,
-0.4978653789,
0.1924279928,
-0.3739746213,
0.4560637176,
0.1660343707,
0.1007575467,
0.5569012165,
-0.3725947142,
0.5212442279,
0.1267186701,
0.0414361469,
-0.2334464043,
-0.1623483151,
-0.7692353725,
-0.1361913234,
0.5218605399,
0.7134506106,
-0.6120910645,
0.3747799993,
-0.3046058714,
-0.1918857843,
-0.7532373071,
0.1933854818,
0.4453225732,
0.5516708493,
0.5954540968,
-0.5442776084,
-0.5929231644,
-0.7698159814,
-0.2268886119,
-0.1642605215,
0.0043868651,
0.6250417233,
0.0305307843,
-0.1397100389,
0.8723878264,
-0.5756443143,
-0.3765158653,
-0.0277461968,
-0.0271074828,
-0.0367572606,
0.6081354022,
-0.0860574692,
-1.2172123194,
-0.3388544917,
-0.1318745613,
-0.2364837974,
0.1102536321,
0.0311789066,
-0.5204309821,
-0.081029065,
0.5981109738,
-0.4729664624,
0.4248152375,
0.0760458931,
-0.2049449831,
0.3348632753,
-0.0316389576,
0.5701348186,
-0.8707337379,
0.1457076669,
-0.1778357476,
-0.2134319693,
-0.5913025737,
0.0561845899,
0.0459460616,
-0.2084506303,
-0.1021511778,
0.4191860259,
-0.4403055608,
0.221243307,
-0.1527229249,
0.2956803739,
0.2544198632,
0.398981452,
-0.0279619563,
0.8992931843,
0.3213391602,
-0.8135020733,
0.3814433217,
0.6704767942,
-0.0475986823,
0.6583430767,
-0.8912556171,
0.4541482329,
-0.3858772516,
0.3154662549,
-1.2823858261,
-0.0414082035,
0.1843351573,
-0.3881107271,
0.4035751522,
-0.403813839,
-0.2806714177,
-0.1279028654,
-0.2546222508,
0.9312087297,
0.329031229,
-0.5534754395,
0.633639276,
0.4248946607,
-0.3567572832,
-0.8050519824,
-0.4877469242,
0.1245934889,
-0.1762413085,
-0.7207473516,
0.5344324708,
-0.1334783137,
-0.0885220617,
-0.2038321793,
-0.4536882043,
-0.3921403289,
-0.1506146044,
-0.2098280191,
0.1706364453,
-0.3281862438,
0.0805107951,
0.0760212392,
0.2439452708,
-0.3567840159,
-0.2157299519,
0.6226266623,
0.0187482722,
-0.4192222655,
-0.429223001,
0.4567420781,
0.0078941425,
-0.4447530508,
0.6374459863,
0.4694125056,
-0.0981608406,
0.2421333045,
-0.7494671345,
-0.3852407038,
-0.4230076373,
0.2749618292,
-0.3742397726,
-1.1849519014,
0.3311478198,
0.1899598241,
-0.0353863947,
0.2156725973,
0.3082895875,
0.0577992611,
1.5544320345,
0.4918375015,
0.2294087261,
0.5850663781,
-0.0596105121,
0.1890909672,
-1.1108371019,
-0.5748928785,
-0.6810101271,
-0.2100498974,
-0.43091923,
-0.3797797561,
0.3419672549,
0.1987831146,
-0.2724563777,
0.1631277502,
-0.6302125454,
0.3578850925,
0.4340569675,
0.2940410972,
0.4724545181,
0.0610590465,
-0.234380573,
-0.2150740325,
-0.6464461684,
-0.4601271451,
0.9776150584,
-0.0806377381,
0.7507406473,
0.4017498493,
0.4293741882,
0.1269793212,
-0.2068482339,
-0.9151903391,
0.3878798783,
0.0315545164,
-0.745778203,
-0.2870325744,
-0.7049103975,
-1.2565100193,
0.7054693699,
-0.1018740833,
-0.7201662064,
0.4888937771,
0.2129057795,
-0.404330194,
-0.1668637544,
-0.483204186,
0.8911405206,
-0.36309883,
-0.249679938,
-0.1025935784,
-0.7658537626,
0.229865998,
0.0792836621,
0.1051096395,
-0.1140450165,
-0.3760347962,
0.4587674439,
-0.2980560362,
0.4336765409,
-0.1362380683,
0.2374140918,
0.2076464891,
0.234722212,
0.3932629228,
0.1059954464,
-0.0896025375,
-0.2701767683,
0.5281507373,
-0.5404673815,
-0.8581333756,
0.5106413364,
-0.3727876246,
-0.8244014978,
-0.2609107494,
-0.5942753553,
-0.3434624076,
0.2842617333,
-0.066118747,
0.6786165833,
-0.8011309505,
0.463956356,
0.8746499419,
0.1685187966,
-0.2157889605,
0.5830937028,
-0.0609554462,
-0.440546006,
0.6051572561,
-0.2320656478,
0.0567041226,
0.7331209183,
-0.1905156523,
-0.5367938876,
-0.5446251631,
-0.2756210864,
0.0088764457,
-0.4339514971,
-0.3091906011,
-0.8435384035,
-0.1546797454,
-0.7469488382,
0.2819355726,
-0.1243405864,
-0.5586007833,
-0.2401703745,
0.3483409882,
-0.0611633509,
0.2318886518,
0.1308867335,
0.3140872419,
-0.6656360626,
0.3353997171,
0.4232928157,
0.088517487,
-0.1846534461,
-0.732015729,
-0.0641940534,
0.3959004283,
-0.4887254536,
-0.5372011065,
0.3426106572,
0.6251290441,
0.5984247923,
0.2628998458,
0.3127182424,
0.9166462421,
-0.4027631581,
0.5122070312,
0.0670259669,
-0.5310722589,
0.5410900712,
-0.1816498339,
0.3853696883,
1.0288820267,
0.3997270167,
-0.8141825795,
-0.1268110871,
-0.3456751108,
-1.24157691,
0.6776154041,
0.2442349941,
0.2745265067,
0.1347797364,
0.4029420316,
-0.1418167949,
0.2552255392,
0.0399585515,
-0.1952735186,
-0.2766643465,
-0.4709092975,
0.2408629954,
-0.2898227274,
-0.4927056134,
-0.1301822513,
0.6441048384,
-0.2596664429,
0.2270803452,
0.3834566772,
-0.1214918196,
0.0682678297,
0.4904339015,
0.003109378,
0.3377680779,
-0.1763860881,
-0.1209976301,
-0.0182981882,
-0.4750211239,
0.0753416568,
0.6292873025,
-0.3936010003,
-0.3000470698,
-0.3720244467,
0.7217647433,
0.3401103914,
-0.782382369,
0.5636449456,
-0.6567701101,
-0.0725564584,
-0.1706717759,
0.3011792898,
-0.0607821904,
0.2709286809,
0.6360324025,
-0.1933877319,
0.7302736044,
-0.5611971021,
0.2661851943,
0.8092162609,
-0.7421978712,
-0.04596138,
0.8520125747,
-0.0356312618,
-0.1246029437,
0.7659279704,
-0.0604373962,
-0.3487049937,
0.3601234257,
0.5026609302,
0.5203062296,
-0.1540824026,
0.1119784638,
0.4315911531,
-0.1573772728,
-0.2083392441,
0.2267659009,
-0.50320822,
-0.7392967939,
-0.0793606713,
-0.5031289458,
-0.4155957103,
-0.263009876,
-0.9628301859,
0.2146631479,
-0.2103397846,
-0.1170205399,
-0.0661335588,
0.0894280225,
-0.4435865581,
0.0370067582,
-0.0086830044,
0.6728038788,
-0.0456032418,
0.6260156035,
0.9420497417,
-0.3700833023,
-0.7956740856,
0.0332350768,
0.1737809181,
-0.6446278095,
0.3355604708,
0.108264178,
-0.1489524543,
0.150289014,
-0.5439040065,
-1.0749239922,
1.2702281475,
0.2728686631,
-0.5930581689,
-0.3638518453,
-0.1009542048,
0.4898071885,
-0.5378861427,
0.2973701358,
0.6219797134,
0.0433925241,
0.7792412639,
-0.8758901358,
0.1435304284,
-0.2364219725,
0.2539529502,
0.3489093781,
-0.7018835545,
0.2848575115,
-0.1434245706,
-0.6241009235,
0.4931101501,
0.7297184467,
0.372997731,
0.3430569172,
0.4265721738,
0.5573447943,
0.9425566792,
-0.283131808,
0.6838863492,
-0.3537979722,
0.1815140098,
1.0085960627,
-0.2196366489,
0.7706169486,
0.1503914148,
-0.0799863338,
0.5108588338,
0.515035212,
0.1825306118,
0.5869781375,
-0.0479366705,
-0.4027945101,
-0.330506593,
-0.2498712242,
-0.3097557425,
0.4200711846,
0.520305872,
0.1009879708,
-0.1083962172,
-0.4042905867,
0.0249864217,
0.2196254879,
-0.2095621675,
1.1120778322,
-0.0737837702,
-0.6395296454,
0.7960504889,
-0.147326827,
0.6818661094,
-0.51287359,
-0.0628356412,
-0.3462950587,
0.1438264996,
-0.1831329465,
-0.4338814914,
0.2055553496,
-0.4231359363,
-0.0417443849,
0.1217758507,
0.6709227562,
-0.880939424,
-0.1969674528,
-0.0208407808,
0.4106990695,
0.082244657,
-0.13085711,
-1.0586311817,
-0.016426323,
0.0199604779,
0.0869149938,
0.3152261376,
0.4987539053,
0.1343883872,
0.5188068151,
0.5005816817,
-0.2123666406,
0.0317487754,
0.050288558,
0.9402045608,
-0.8049388528,
-0.3150403202,
-0.1868376583,
0.2492464185,
-0.0341877751,
-0.1330685765,
0.4947420955,
0.9494853616,
0.7260798812,
0.6050522923,
0.4992381334,
-0.1000123024,
0.6848759651,
-0.5006499887,
0.2845624983,
-0.5601847172,
0.5387763381,
0.0975524858,
-1.0766472816,
-0.2275686562,
0.165188387,
-0.1702165753,
0.212304011,
0.4587737024,
1.2871512175,
-0.1764509529,
0.0194313712,
0.0655891672,
0.0492457934,
0.2154612541,
0.4324030578,
0.8624475598,
-0.6151170731,
1.2109197378,
0.0688107759,
-0.1057521999,
-0.3288274109,
-0.2480741292,
-0.4186356068,
-0.5973698497,
-0.3062666059,
-0.467938751,
0.4671411812,
0.7273529172,
0.8099302053,
-0.951703012,
-0.1479258537,
0.1769850999,
-0.0093995919,
-0.1432065964,
-0.2708598971,
0.1837755144,
-0.6250863671,
-0.6602643132,
0.549792707,
0.0160394218,
-0.0980321839,
0.0373545326,
-0.0304079726,
-0.3271924257,
0.0299396105,
0.2376793176,
0.637167871,
-0.4629361331,
-0.0025307396,
0.1640081853,
-0.4226668179,
0.5652894974,
1.0372093916,
-0.9287062883,
0.4906794131,
0.4478647411,
0.6604946852,
0.6794929504,
0.7826946974,
0.7652917504,
-0.6458621621,
-0.0301666465,
0.5502429008,
-0.0495326333,
0.6320152283,
-0.5440251231,
0.3442029655,
-0.025506448,
-0.803406179,
-0.6658426523,
0.2530431747,
-1.0836572647,
-0.1507620364,
1.1617174149,
0.2789868712,
-0.0280731544,
-0.4653496444,
-0.4142802358,
0.1776393205,
-0.9025559425,
0.588624835,
0.1920024157,
-0.3651527464,
-0.0573564097,
-0.4603152573,
0.2649406195,
0.4785427451,
-0.2150810808,
-0.0486151949,
0.8185589314,
0.3219713569,
-0.1555146724,
0.7296233773,
-0.4973942935,
0.2599108517,
-0.2565311491,
-0.0359990336,
0.3151872456,
-0.0609024391,
-0.4058386683,
0.2509645522,
0.2144352198,
0.0324108563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01964v2 | Enabling Discriminative Reasoning in LLMs for Legal Judgment Prediction | 2024-07-02T05:43:15 | 2024-07-03T02:25:23 | Chenlong Deng, Kelong Mao, Yuyao Zhang, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Legal judgment prediction is essential for enhancing judicial efficiency. In
this work, we identify that existing large language models (LLMs) underperform
in this domain due to challenges in understanding case complexities and
distinguishing between similar charges. To adapt LLMs for effective legal
judgment prediction, we introduce the Ask-Discriminate-Predict (ADAPT)
reasoning framework inspired by human judicial reasoning. ADAPT involves
decomposing case facts, discriminating among potential charges, and predicting
the final judgment. We further enhance LLMs through fine-tuning with multi-task
synthetic trajectories to improve legal judgment prediction accuracy and
efficiency under our ADAPT framework. Extensive experiments conducted on two
widely-used datasets demonstrate the superior performance of our framework in
legal judgment prediction, particularly when dealing with complex and confusing
charges. | [
-0.1584522575,
-0.5919943452,
1.0542645454,
0.1870791316,
-0.3716587126,
0.0749371499,
-0.1948593259,
-0.7089331746,
-0.025311118,
0.7883090973,
-0.4007079303,
-0.4600929916,
-0.4229540527,
-0.1867601722,
-0.2187838554,
0.6828275323,
0.2624967396,
0.3253259361,
-0.1811723411,
-0.2084330022,
-0.7808125019,
-0.5492143035,
-0.6236721873,
-0.3438159823,
0.2187606692,
0.3915762007,
0.4156564474,
0.3486904502,
0.4638915062,
0.300267756,
-0.0593699068,
0.3255910873,
-0.2700891197,
0.1770996004,
-0.4931215942,
-0.8902898431,
-0.485675633,
-0.3369436264,
0.097858049,
0.5918802619,
-0.6254987121,
-0.1072089002,
-0.4143270254,
0.7613020539,
-0.7682682276,
0.1007413417,
-0.9658886194,
0.1592797786,
0.0031299738,
-0.2662656605,
-0.6797329783,
-0.3698675036,
0.0507464074,
-0.7799559236,
0.3863640726,
0.4368944168,
0.159033373,
0.3715001345,
-0.5330303311,
-0.284768343,
-0.9492133856,
0.3643761575,
-0.6897158623,
0.3876118362,
0.3001137078,
0.7065454125,
-0.4184036255,
-0.76784271,
-0.5570390224,
-0.5196249485,
-0.0104958378,
0.3032335043,
-0.2394801527,
0.3644280732,
0.4238230884,
-0.1331535876,
-0.6321020126,
0.3468533754,
-0.3310942948,
-0.071639657,
0.8981902599,
0.2851389647,
0.0225489903,
0.0848902017,
-0.2066095322,
0.2306480855,
-0.608889997,
0.1225309446,
0.2736126781,
0.4074393213,
0.0407522209,
0.4152038395,
-0.202556029,
0.6990892291,
0.4929960072,
0.0391434766,
0.2212796062,
-0.0115251429,
-0.238663286,
0.4565733969,
0.482250303,
0.5764657855,
0.3333616257,
0.0715047792,
-0.2596316338,
-0.0120201195,
0.4903142154,
-0.6602031589,
-0.17220819,
0.3510787785,
-0.570532918,
-0.0694440305,
0.0847376138,
-0.8436473608,
-1.089209795,
-0.509452939,
0.0370526053,
-0.3358040154,
-0.2343041003,
0.7565099597,
-0.1369691789,
-0.189128831,
0.9592781067,
-0.6250131726,
0.3006125093,
0.6377773285,
0.4225551784,
-0.1286477894,
0.0353383571,
-0.6966238618,
0.2730244398,
-0.2938357592,
0.9491044879,
-0.6695876718,
-0.2995758355,
0.2477181107,
0.0745692402,
0.0532951578,
-0.7810639739,
1.201015234,
-0.4097492099,
-0.2368578911,
-0.2312042564,
-0.5462341309,
-0.4402507544,
0.165277198,
-0.7875155807,
0.4276914597,
0.0787756145,
-0.5995432138,
1.0030611753,
-0.8710546494,
-0.6826100945,
0.5721334219,
0.0230713021,
-0.4106861055,
0.2724968791,
0.2725565135,
0.4425382614,
-0.295707494,
0.5570175648,
-0.6128321886,
-0.3470681012,
0.1870353669,
-0.1900975555,
0.6420583129,
0.4128029644,
-0.220301494,
0.3563763499,
-0.8630067706,
-0.4292931855,
0.0489365421,
-0.3645245433,
-0.3408283293,
0.4147731662,
-0.331153661,
0.2523539066,
0.0089560812,
-0.6409006715,
0.0765213221,
-0.4337284267,
0.3026193678,
0.9134309888,
-0.10003452,
0.4976810217,
-0.4242160022,
0.7699032426,
0.2217003703,
0.0130008077,
0.3409577608,
-0.2570223808,
-0.5510231256,
-0.0369223692,
0.0216997862,
0.7049568892,
-0.6515476108,
0.1320860237,
-0.4714154303,
-0.4954065084,
-0.3488666713,
-0.0487867929,
0.1233876869,
0.1493012607,
0.312702924,
0.086485967,
-1.0175942183,
-0.603587985,
-0.6501511931,
-0.502048552,
0.1357472539,
0.4269740283,
0.4743291736,
-0.0253268257,
0.7745981216,
-0.2375340909,
-0.1010581478,
-0.3899050057,
-0.0065288697,
0.4463942349,
0.1938920021,
0.5659980774,
-1.0352436304,
-0.2767770588,
0.1628331989,
-0.5343786478,
-0.0773634836,
-0.4401455224,
-0.1046600565,
-0.0697179139,
0.5727642179,
-0.5833311081,
0.2983338535,
-0.0337692164,
-0.8556029797,
0.7340711951,
-0.421905905,
0.1623794287,
-0.5923341513,
-0.3794686496,
0.2835758924,
-0.3466257751,
-0.6588093638,
-0.0445446558,
0.203225553,
0.3856992722,
-0.4897857904,
0.4767848849,
-0.0918300375,
-0.2083405852,
-0.2106370479,
0.033435788,
-0.1576228142,
0.262098521,
-0.0763905719,
0.7966555953,
0.2178933471,
-0.7431869507,
0.5332875848,
0.0936003402,
-0.6920098662,
0.8065274954,
-0.4808184803,
-0.1701706797,
-0.2574831843,
0.283010453,
-0.5704880357,
-0.1352397501,
-0.037202429,
-0.0800604746,
0.2072424442,
-0.2353178412,
-0.5833007693,
-0.6372207403,
-0.1618188769,
0.4302350879,
0.2552535236,
-0.7375474572,
1.125644207,
0.3722828031,
-0.0019600638,
-0.5106334686,
-0.5823861361,
0.0403990634,
-0.6080439091,
-0.2705333531,
0.5393149257,
-0.1244050562,
-0.5363948941,
-0.2783235312,
0.2120210975,
0.18083404,
0.3824584782,
0.4465952218,
0.2386411279,
-0.0917986706,
0.3212197125,
0.3104023635,
0.4029460251,
0.478923142,
-0.2734778523,
0.4076763391,
0.0634748265,
-0.4941042662,
-0.1044898927,
0.0590727068,
0.6609930396,
-0.1523729414,
0.114812851,
0.0131048588,
-0.3085762262,
-0.4220093787,
-0.7514560223,
0.2523080111,
-0.5027999282,
0.6083965302,
-0.5553280711,
-1.0600956678,
0.4813810289,
-0.2203589827,
0.0287508648,
0.3397895992,
0.9128213525,
0.0173662547,
1.1099867821,
0.3382866085,
0.135177359,
0.4334800541,
0.3202456534,
0.1932402998,
-0.643517673,
-0.3467481136,
-0.373003751,
-0.0358488522,
-0.6424725056,
-0.2781679034,
0.1271727532,
0.0510316379,
-0.3517204523,
0.3322777748,
-0.3444748223,
0.3031822145,
0.484139353,
0.2549701631,
0.3198601902,
-0.1417129636,
-0.2100652307,
0.2770193815,
-0.3840060532,
-0.2695758939,
1.2742400169,
0.2465395033,
0.6391341686,
0.3257120848,
0.3603884876,
0.6542257071,
0.068547532,
-0.7636874914,
0.680624187,
-0.5178695321,
-0.6100636125,
0.0160338413,
-0.3789870441,
-0.8841035962,
0.4408995807,
-0.3556270003,
-0.6801652312,
0.3264601231,
0.0241329297,
-0.6926248074,
0.1356559694,
-0.5180156827,
0.4709267914,
-0.3132043183,
-0.3276608586,
-0.5343303084,
-0.2938660383,
0.4557207227,
-0.1765579283,
0.5913286209,
-0.3463488519,
0.2852309942,
0.7032657266,
-0.2674571872,
0.6814863682,
-0.4523420632,
-0.1178455129,
0.3756931424,
0.3087231517,
0.3970451355,
0.0606752783,
-0.3578986824,
-0.385037154,
-0.0061461818,
0.0078229504,
-0.8235247135,
0.4554279447,
-0.2696924508,
-0.9082682133,
-0.2484367937,
-0.8615780473,
-0.2468880713,
-0.0326167084,
-0.1344961077,
-0.0346790962,
-0.1612200141,
-0.2813183963,
0.3236283362,
-0.0775682479,
0.2382396758,
0.8038259149,
-0.2485031635,
-0.309840858,
0.682112515,
-0.0725729391,
-0.0157374721,
0.2366946191,
0.310682416,
-0.5385317206,
-0.872541368,
-0.3817486465,
0.0753459409,
-0.9902889729,
-0.3148557842,
-0.5230810046,
0.184988752,
-0.5519520044,
0.0053211632,
0.1424029917,
-0.5365830064,
-0.1167279556,
-0.3833425641,
0.5622745156,
0.5657765865,
0.084288761,
0.1442511231,
-0.6013236642,
0.3503620327,
0.3111384511,
0.2754836679,
-0.362930268,
-0.9403377175,
0.0358768553,
-0.0573091507,
-0.1278324872,
-0.2321034372,
0.2540537417,
0.1867348254,
0.6865611672,
0.35586375,
0.3489832282,
0.780126214,
-0.7346106172,
0.5375596881,
0.3203445673,
-0.5469459891,
0.7093833089,
-0.0929167494,
-0.0403001718,
0.4783906937,
-0.0418003947,
-0.0713826865,
-0.2428350598,
-0.2376198918,
-0.5610340238,
0.7073063254,
-0.1501629651,
0.151080966,
0.1069127619,
0.5376527309,
0.2530414462,
0.0399320833,
-0.4352602959,
0.1437489539,
-0.0812445804,
-0.3288766742,
0.043561127,
-0.245311603,
0.0091118542,
-0.6582899094,
0.4232450426,
-0.2300127447,
0.1889947504,
-0.0203355066,
-0.1366868615,
-0.1096596271,
0.3482062221,
0.7763568759,
0.6810533404,
-0.1769962758,
-0.0258164983,
0.4986344278,
-0.430657655,
0.2012002915,
0.1512484401,
0.0549898036,
-0.0564544573,
0.2611614168,
1.0647650957,
-0.1502210349,
-1.0156906843,
0.453189671,
-0.3262683153,
-0.5538662076,
-0.6983575225,
0.2447922081,
0.0651383102,
0.6906684637,
0.2183163762,
0.1473830938,
0.4299288988,
-0.5472092032,
0.1009429172,
0.3916158676,
-0.2443001121,
-0.0122483373,
0.8226436377,
0.1216061115,
-0.2178163975,
0.1518937647,
-0.3318217397,
-0.6760260463,
0.6181585789,
0.6625753641,
0.7041797042,
-0.1943991333,
0.0007300973,
0.4212861955,
-0.0982105508,
-0.4488814473,
0.3937701285,
0.0648680106,
-0.8845870495,
-0.4486012161,
-0.7314481139,
-0.2194658369,
-0.2939054668,
-0.5513677001,
0.3701330423,
-0.7762072086,
-0.238075003,
0.0457663536,
-0.1737227589,
-0.5195479989,
0.2982293069,
0.2711499631,
0.9187107086,
-0.580085814,
0.8373012543,
0.5886598825,
-0.1857336015,
-0.4831850827,
-0.2279418856,
-0.0700693205,
-0.7188963294,
0.8897569776,
0.2496201396,
-0.3403142095,
-0.3184781969,
-0.388384372,
-0.3983296454,
0.9909681678,
0.6917433143,
-0.9915751815,
-0.197878018,
0.0829258785,
0.3943461478,
-0.5538449287,
-0.0065543787,
1.0514185429,
0.3748545349,
0.3057805896,
-0.7692546844,
0.3407330513,
-0.1227290332,
0.0688272938,
0.1746223569,
0.0687947199,
0.6823926568,
-0.5242374539,
-0.1045146212,
-0.006004903,
0.6321613789,
0.5608612895,
0.5365674496,
0.8552495837,
0.6438243389,
0.9813756943,
-0.199141413,
1.0951288939,
-0.1862627417,
0.157437548,
1.4436491728,
-0.6381807923,
0.6743642688,
0.3802980185,
-0.4270243943,
0.7957713604,
0.3849304914,
-0.3405111432,
0.4658932984,
0.4045308828,
-0.3936429322,
-0.6902970672,
-0.3625274897,
0.1316777617,
0.5908882022,
0.6139684916,
-0.394566834,
0.0699248835,
0.0816865489,
-0.3401019275,
0.4504899979,
-0.6681551337,
0.8989521265,
-0.0368284844,
-0.7186136842,
0.3113997281,
0.102974534,
0.6483786106,
-0.1659463346,
-0.2821442783,
0.1570689827,
0.4164831042,
-0.3924583197,
-1.056720376,
0.0195986163,
-0.1553775221,
-0.266569525,
0.0876454413,
0.7833992243,
-0.051275339,
-0.6280069947,
0.6452624798,
0.1496472359,
-0.1201763377,
-0.1455963999,
-0.8495751023,
-0.3065596819,
0.0070069404,
0.0678566247,
0.2861230671,
0.6417580247,
-0.3145650923,
0.8800581098,
0.671107173,
0.311562866,
0.0699722245,
0.5582880378,
0.86035043,
-0.6255277991,
-0.5044600368,
-0.9012742639,
0.5773437619,
-0.1885083318,
-0.102819398,
0.1582222134,
0.4536910355,
0.763644278,
0.0449082814,
0.7663362622,
0.2106146961,
0.7826402783,
-0.8402484655,
0.4782942832,
-0.4794415236,
0.3697377145,
-0.0694140866,
-0.5624079108,
-0.2938286066,
0.5941590667,
-0.4762521982,
0.0442836434,
0.4426152408,
0.6596913934,
-0.1001697332,
0.0900282562,
0.5257865787,
0.0699193403,
0.4956059754,
0.7586772442,
0.775506258,
-0.0262015685,
0.5760330558,
-0.1772517711,
0.1881839335,
-0.524753809,
-0.7488729358,
-0.7978385687,
-0.2224098146,
-0.1281168014,
-0.3094560206,
0.061904382,
0.9174913764,
0.6100775599,
-0.9231421947,
-0.2319115549,
-0.6181036234,
-0.2243396789,
-0.0609102473,
-0.2276675105,
0.1617728025,
-0.3219234347,
-0.4724690616,
0.3936209977,
0.1409746706,
-0.0706142038,
0.2206677496,
-0.3658523262,
-0.2004868537,
-0.0235894639,
0.7968075275,
-0.0672046617,
-1.0406556129,
-0.384832263,
-0.4668601751,
0.1438500732,
0.137713477,
1.006682992,
-0.6926202774,
0.596527338,
0.112523295,
0.6637098193,
0.5035906434,
0.1926134676,
0.734069109,
-0.296562314,
0.1895217448,
0.6113113165,
0.8983920813,
0.1155169085,
-0.4973381162,
0.4610049427,
-0.0209331587,
-0.4686441422,
-0.5427393317,
0.4758581817,
-0.872436583,
-0.6124723554,
1.0193858147,
-0.4552519917,
-0.0129881622,
-0.3427837193,
-0.3297503293,
0.1242006272,
-0.5196128488,
0.7371307015,
0.5189180374,
-0.0894164145,
-0.4434096217,
-0.6960472465,
0.3673924506,
0.5529286861,
-0.8687385321,
0.3613672554,
0.764777422,
0.1740488559,
0.1016449258,
0.2285325676,
-0.0539540276,
0.6104972363,
-0.2772719562,
-0.0741119683,
-0.0586745627,
-0.1170684397,
-0.4573529363,
0.122126624,
0.2742881477,
0.076598607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01955v1 | S2D: Sorted Speculative Decoding For More Efficient Deployment of Nested Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T05:14:15 | 2024-07-02T05:14:15 | Parsa Kavehzadeh, Mohammadreza Pourreza, Mojtaba Valipour, Tinashu Zhu, Haoli Bai, Ali Ghodsi, Boxing Chen, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deployment of autoregressive large language models (LLMs) is costly, and as
these models increase in size, the associated costs will become even more
considerable. Consequently, different methods have been proposed to accelerate
the token generation process and reduce costs. Speculative decoding (SD) is
among the most promising approaches to speed up the LLM decoding process by
verifying multiple tokens in parallel and using an auxiliary smaller draft
model to generate the possible tokens. In SD, usually, one draft model is used
to serve a specific target model; however, in practice, LLMs are diverse, and
we might need to deal with many target models or more than one target model
simultaneously. In this scenario, it is not clear which draft model should be
used for which target model, and searching among different draft models or
training customized draft models can further increase deployment costs. In this
paper, we first introduce a novel multi-target scenario for the deployment of
draft models for faster inference. Then, we present a novel, more efficient
sorted speculative decoding mechanism that outperforms regular baselines in
multi-target settings. We evaluated our method on Spec-Bench in different
settings, including base models such as Vicuna 7B, 13B, and LLama Chat 70B. Our
results suggest that our draft models perform better than baselines for
multiple target models at the same time. | [
-0.1169554666,
-0.516035974,
0.5571258664,
0.5577839613,
-0.5224236846,
0.3354876339,
-0.1464879513,
-0.5074275732,
0.0972799063,
0.6360506415,
-0.5293907523,
-0.5243046284,
-0.7355428338,
-0.0105465846,
-0.4967458844,
0.6718014479,
0.0259390585,
-0.0605006516,
-0.1217420176,
0.1196882203,
-0.1718199849,
-0.5184032321,
-0.8423051834,
0.0356758125,
0.3619900048,
0.5580776334,
0.4991134703,
1.018568635,
0.5167648792,
0.3232070208,
-0.2968864441,
0.471596092,
-0.6071000695,
0.3784036934,
0.1110680103,
-0.8500971198,
-0.4339487851,
-0.2112579644,
0.6852742434,
0.4265826046,
-0.2236859351,
0.1531760693,
-0.3688815832,
0.3579998612,
-0.7606447935,
0.000178916,
-0.7544769049,
-0.1674567312,
-0.3798686862,
-0.2151283026,
-0.7048462033,
-0.1708381325,
-0.3596377969,
-0.3596947789,
0.4092389643,
0.1636502147,
0.5018488169,
0.2751702964,
-0.7126945257,
-0.2053280622,
-0.7220347524,
0.7199243903,
-0.7058437467,
0.5346279144,
0.2183546275,
0.2206585258,
-0.2407951504,
-0.8244415522,
-0.4571059644,
-0.022689227,
0.0934566185,
0.0761731789,
-0.0070392727,
-0.0777918547,
0.3595035374,
0.2533158362,
-0.7482156157,
0.7357003689,
-0.2689757347,
-0.2309227139,
0.5687502027,
0.3320153654,
-0.1776975542,
-0.2313469201,
-0.4264188409,
-0.1046342999,
-0.6622686982,
-0.1591818035,
0.6950917244,
0.3304736018,
-0.2144853473,
0.6047646999,
-0.4939935505,
0.4667486548,
0.29915905,
-0.2402609587,
0.093684338,
-0.6147381067,
0.1209479347,
-0.185432598,
0.4772902131,
0.44061625,
-0.3681141734,
-0.1645450443,
-0.3099903464,
0.3564399183,
0.2702674866,
-0.8930396438,
-0.0065354328,
0.4703180194,
-0.7154727578,
-0.5056310296,
-0.4804067016,
-0.6236267686,
-0.3119747639,
0.099517554,
-0.24899818,
-0.302051723,
-0.5039447546,
0.3668523133,
-0.2747954726,
0.0702619925,
0.2399078459,
-1.2390117645,
0.1830309033,
0.8702670336,
0.7267210484,
-0.328040272,
-0.2766061425,
-0.4261648357,
0.1598423421,
-0.6289796829,
1.177000165,
-0.3830220401,
-0.3944732249,
-0.0866105482,
-0.380632937,
0.0000076617,
-0.3921212256,
0.8655255437,
-0.8281695247,
-0.0988874584,
-0.357270807,
-0.6112712622,
0.1438221931,
0.1329946071,
-0.5048671961,
1.2406300306,
0.1418502927,
-0.8625475168,
0.5124965906,
-0.176565975,
-0.4153071344,
0.1769751459,
-0.1533425301,
-0.1408975422,
0.2479003668,
0.3073947728,
0.68275702,
-0.5761642456,
0.2032517344,
-0.3664265871,
-0.5660285354,
-0.2957344949,
-0.4392751753,
0.6370903254,
0.6690590978,
-0.2045607269,
0.1156144142,
-0.6389418244,
-0.0002754046,
0.2705684304,
-0.3282167017,
-0.3179064989,
0.2442424893,
0.1374339014,
0.1232034415,
0.2289292514,
-0.3882050812,
0.516090095,
-0.4064881206,
0.3598327041,
0.5192805529,
-0.0665234104,
0.6042479277,
-0.0903504416,
0.4689657092,
0.1927973628,
0.2108810246,
-0.2734393477,
-0.3633892834,
-0.6415910721,
-0.4559444487,
0.0138370199,
0.3585911989,
-0.8617398739,
0.3853376508,
-0.2959039509,
-0.6931103468,
-0.4491819441,
-0.0267231129,
0.2678378224,
0.1077617407,
0.1115229651,
0.0249886494,
-0.6428601742,
-0.8756041527,
-0.1618063748,
-0.3844505548,
0.2235694826,
0.1135144979,
0.1732583642,
-0.4957634807,
0.5314307809,
-0.5221172571,
0.2407870591,
-0.4528457522,
0.1380017847,
0.1456545889,
0.4220671654,
0.7557445765,
-0.61132586,
-0.3115401268,
-0.2019865215,
-0.569181025,
0.0413360856,
-0.1789027452,
-0.2271770388,
0.3857664764,
0.7813026905,
-0.827403605,
0.200262934,
0.7367640734,
-0.2851811945,
0.6913886666,
-0.3303174675,
0.2359118015,
-1.2180241346,
-0.1835802794,
-0.412794292,
0.0935479626,
-0.6122970581,
0.5434943438,
0.3494434059,
0.0981505662,
-0.3123330176,
0.3731535673,
-0.5222885609,
-0.2418835014,
-0.3666006625,
-0.2249195576,
-0.0025130946,
0.1083831415,
0.1237530783,
0.9212170839,
0.5278652906,
-0.418769151,
0.2310546041,
0.0034316918,
-0.3387337029,
0.1916009039,
-0.5079799891,
0.3561545908,
-0.2943465114,
0.626860261,
-1.2194068432,
-0.1147987843,
0.1399855018,
0.0027920904,
0.2189522237,
-0.4866292179,
-0.8254750967,
-0.648041904,
-0.2176876068,
0.822443068,
0.3886739016,
-0.6755654216,
0.4547461569,
0.2095514238,
-0.0238050409,
-0.6645158529,
-0.7023236156,
0.1881580353,
-0.3581398427,
-0.8018702865,
0.3978472054,
-0.2071215212,
-0.0695250556,
-0.0723022521,
-0.2291595489,
0.126552701,
0.0329259671,
0.2343515009,
0.152451843,
-0.3033727407,
-0.1888724715,
0.2612264752,
-0.3984860778,
-0.2146123648,
-0.5131394863,
0.6541550159,
0.2502905428,
-0.4468697608,
-0.1693479121,
0.7385507822,
0.7616279125,
-0.2213383019,
0.7756186128,
0.70790416,
-0.2778982818,
-0.5002760887,
-0.9653905034,
-0.1077749357,
-0.5240424275,
0.5305564404,
-0.7230506539,
-0.8743813038,
0.7767106295,
-0.1916816682,
0.2845179737,
0.452275753,
0.6831886768,
0.1312482506,
1.1702820063,
0.7367295027,
-0.0043285936,
0.3321380913,
-0.3463066816,
0.3242071569,
-0.5655887127,
-0.3967329562,
-0.6865285635,
0.0622066893,
-0.352971673,
-1.0095618963,
0.0466314666,
0.2923477292,
0.0567285791,
0.3981404305,
-0.3315089941,
0.4364873171,
0.4849331081,
-0.0518820994,
0.2888396978,
0.2132335603,
-0.3136184216,
0.1538842767,
-1.0128816366,
-0.2574756145,
1.2294595242,
0.3522218466,
0.7026070952,
0.1391077638,
0.8677321076,
0.1696299613,
0.0805630758,
-0.7787725329,
0.5709235668,
-0.4966801107,
-0.5421512127,
-0.077901423,
-0.4392739534,
-0.7921594977,
0.2710513175,
-0.1308701485,
-0.5454072952,
0.4411331117,
0.0217296761,
-0.4153676629,
0.4185326099,
-0.8333794475,
0.5742927194,
-0.0758714303,
-0.0562730506,
-0.6371172071,
-0.2692146003,
0.635733664,
-0.1712807268,
0.0489201136,
-0.095424816,
-0.0469728187,
0.6565110087,
-0.3370599747,
0.5360145569,
-0.1370098591,
-0.2713935673,
0.1226579547,
0.1904368997,
1.0070492029,
0.0987498537,
-0.5819391012,
0.1021652743,
0.1368238628,
-0.5655430555,
-0.4566672742,
0.7567703724,
-0.8819537163,
-0.4887748361,
-0.3202027678,
-0.6789352298,
-0.1584530771,
0.1668918133,
0.6211954355,
0.4280264676,
0.0725527331,
-0.0723410994,
0.3969450593,
-0.0782697573,
0.3620518446,
0.681571126,
0.0487007014,
-0.1308140457,
0.5945371389,
0.0426599644,
0.3170770705,
0.2609199286,
-0.3277068436,
-0.5171707869,
-1.2757331133,
-0.2990255654,
0.2510142624,
-0.8950765133,
-0.2976004183,
-0.8968150616,
-0.1799905002,
-0.6774178743,
-0.1251177341,
-0.7182915211,
-0.3128811121,
-0.1622627676,
-0.1638072282,
0.3749237061,
0.7881805301,
-0.0909246728,
0.4379088879,
-0.5879503489,
0.5577199459,
-0.0293251146,
0.5013080835,
0.0603990965,
-0.6025673151,
-0.3285328746,
0.0230112411,
0.3529758155,
-0.6026092172,
0.2923372686,
-0.3238072693,
0.5958319306,
0.6065511703,
0.2721086442,
0.924010098,
-0.5150449872,
0.533056438,
-0.068728216,
-0.6159571409,
0.2774456739,
-0.4298624396,
0.2312858403,
0.4298236966,
0.2285934985,
-0.4549055398,
-0.3642170727,
-0.5495727062,
-1.0181524754,
1.0518827438,
-0.11876259,
0.0255599096,
-0.2535550892,
0.5030209422,
0.2721672058,
-0.1252372563,
-0.0562484711,
-0.398311615,
0.1075550318,
-0.0034908941,
-0.3865471482,
-0.9693795443,
0.0507460497,
0.0156942774,
0.4004137814,
-0.0804278105,
0.4243893921,
-0.2542684674,
-0.0293382872,
-0.1878468394,
0.0715995356,
0.4945305288,
0.0504901558,
-0.3245369494,
0.1932495981,
0.05707651,
-0.3854673803,
0.2342462391,
-0.0043259589,
-0.2500732839,
-0.1051996127,
0.3478096426,
0.9703671336,
0.2764919698,
-0.5368788242,
0.213082552,
-0.2405920327,
-0.3834033012,
-0.0464671068,
-0.0020301701,
0.1906298697,
0.5766242146,
0.33944875,
0.5320754051,
0.1968719214,
-0.3892368078,
0.1690902263,
0.1569118947,
0.3332254291,
-0.1413551569,
0.6542339921,
0.1377657354,
-0.1019187868,
0.8694886565,
-0.4014815986,
-0.3809595108,
0.7244981527,
0.7884819508,
0.8454701304,
-0.002963854,
0.2922841012,
0.17715469,
0.2718966305,
-0.5369700789,
0.3884884715,
-0.0015771912,
-0.8254653811,
-0.4804752171,
-0.6703910828,
-0.2978936136,
0.0098353559,
-0.6454874277,
0.0992203653,
-0.3664933145,
-0.1991953254,
-0.1708562821,
0.0347501114,
-0.8167204857,
-0.1312850267,
0.3348786235,
1.0993448496,
-0.8385773897,
0.9190406203,
0.4443287849,
0.1602939665,
-0.9884502888,
0.0836160481,
0.0849424228,
-0.7551580071,
0.6921921372,
-0.0048405696,
-0.0933796912,
0.2876216471,
-0.1392112672,
-1.3524729013,
0.9779748917,
0.4965587556,
-0.5594062209,
-0.0556861982,
-0.0676143989,
0.5026207566,
-0.4135752022,
0.6527916193,
0.6348323822,
0.2403739542,
0.3868196011,
-0.6493695378,
0.235218823,
-0.3233394921,
0.0731130689,
-0.0502161235,
-0.7378755212,
0.9455776811,
-0.4032190144,
-0.382730633,
0.318981111,
0.5900617838,
0.500549674,
0.0866213739,
0.5322260857,
0.4652671218,
0.7589440942,
0.0507327877,
1.1774874926,
-0.3398952484,
0.0747798532,
0.8175984025,
-0.5546984076,
1.0781544447,
0.1791270524,
-0.1185067967,
0.3110054731,
0.8729469776,
0.0669715255,
0.567076683,
0.0524390116,
-0.0926263258,
-0.3278486431,
-0.1037954539,
-0.4427813888,
0.5013439655,
0.4646891356,
0.030812962,
-0.3761534393,
-0.0605957322,
-0.243214488,
-0.1229447052,
-0.0519362167,
0.617675364,
-0.1251408309,
-0.7602062821,
0.8025346398,
0.5655758381,
0.8842448592,
-0.6824659109,
0.4520333111,
-0.4736705124,
0.2765587568,
-0.1645651907,
-0.5011205673,
0.238656491,
0.0146215623,
-0.425737083,
-0.4812785387,
0.5340080857,
-0.4513169229,
-0.5011469126,
0.4927974045,
0.430406034,
0.2386501729,
-0.1618821174,
-0.5502638221,
0.5536018014,
-0.1456750184,
-0.2488136888,
0.337241441,
0.5230972767,
-0.3322374225,
0.7912997007,
0.9487416744,
0.2196108252,
0.3021918833,
0.4043770432,
0.970916748,
-0.5438617468,
-0.8523387313,
-0.5315904021,
0.3643934727,
0.1335907876,
-0.0409980975,
0.9153614044,
0.6046238542,
0.5092251897,
-0.0876259729,
0.6398388743,
0.1547629386,
0.3900176883,
-0.5729500651,
0.4424951971,
-0.3526622057,
0.6115903854,
0.0461888202,
-0.8489052057,
-0.1338808388,
0.2431240529,
-0.0649012551,
-0.0783055127,
0.7357305288,
0.982298255,
-0.0209914949,
0.024840096,
0.1638095826,
0.1944524646,
0.2431870848,
0.4712782502,
0.8883598447,
-0.5330656767,
0.5516836643,
-0.3463744223,
-0.0733871236,
-0.4537321329,
-0.6916197538,
-0.9069918394,
-0.3875550926,
-0.2388551086,
-0.2896558046,
0.2110609412,
0.887362361,
0.9557583928,
-0.6965727806,
-0.2999050915,
-0.0496873744,
0.0194912124,
-0.3998559713,
-0.159965381,
0.4298233092,
-0.4182131588,
-0.7457208037,
0.7748134732,
0.293420136,
0.0268939473,
-0.0895449519,
-0.1336144954,
-0.0926316008,
0.1469794065,
0.6299538612,
0.0259192642,
-0.7566952109,
-0.1059410423,
0.0721151307,
-0.3633704185,
-0.4257345498,
1.019748807,
-0.7349802852,
0.1498132795,
0.6956635118,
0.5753615499,
0.7122097611,
0.0118534239,
0.5980709195,
-0.6102115512,
0.7508844733,
0.1656501144,
0.1933787018,
-0.0106495563,
-0.6079439521,
0.2912090719,
0.3021951616,
-0.1932554692,
-1.1105217934,
0.2742758095,
-0.9528305531,
-0.4253216088,
1.3447936773,
-0.0007528082,
0.2320068032,
-0.192650944,
-0.111146681,
0.1469125599,
-0.4320759475,
0.6789630651,
0.5126240849,
0.1783916056,
-0.2108702064,
-0.2269139588,
0.5370813608,
0.506279707,
-0.4578593671,
0.3331230581,
0.3460942507,
0.0898558423,
-0.1531324834,
0.8128786683,
0.1174144074,
0.1124723405,
0.6303403974,
-0.1518595368,
-0.2435567826,
-0.4162480831,
-0.2139935195,
0.287201345,
0.1267567128,
0.0800326169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01948v1 | Extracting and Encoding: Leveraging Large Language Models and Medical Knowledge to Enhance Radiological Text Representation | 2024-07-02T04:39:19 | 2024-07-02T04:39:19 | Pablo Messina, René Vidal, Denis Parra, Álvaro Soto, Vladimir Araujo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Advancing representation learning in specialized fields like medicine remains
challenging due to the scarcity of expert annotations for text and images. To
tackle this issue, we present a novel two-stage framework designed to extract
high-quality factual statements from free-text radiology reports in order to
improve the representations of text encoders and, consequently, their
performance on various downstream tasks. In the first stage, we propose a
\textit{Fact Extractor} that leverages large language models (LLMs) to identify
factual statements from well-curated domain-specific datasets. In the second
stage, we introduce a \textit{Fact Encoder} (CXRFE) based on a BERT model
fine-tuned with objective functions designed to improve its representations
using the extracted factual data. Our framework also includes a new
embedding-based metric (CXRFEScore) for evaluating chest X-ray text generation
systems, leveraging both stages of our approach. Extensive evaluations show
that our fact extractor and encoder outperform current state-of-the-art methods
in tasks such as sentence ranking, natural language inference, and label
extraction from radiology reports. Additionally, our metric proves to be more
robust and effective than existing metrics commonly used in the radiology
report generation literature. The code of this project is available at
\url{https://github.com/PabloMessina/CXR-Fact-Encoder}. | [
-0.0288335811,
-0.4237917364,
1.0010010004,
-0.0790900812,
-0.343931973,
-0.0645171255,
-0.1801749617,
-0.6352469325,
-0.0059849792,
0.5612229109,
-0.0665416569,
-0.5478228927,
-1.0780932903,
0.0251261219,
-0.3383129835,
1.1206902266,
0.1232836917,
0.3076559901,
-0.4126185477,
0.0798010305,
-0.3566905856,
-0.3363801837,
-0.4467607439,
-0.4382820129,
0.4616045952,
0.5333898664,
0.9665956497,
1.011190176,
0.7174463868,
0.0917518586,
0.2004457712,
0.3409038782,
-0.3134151101,
0.1988190114,
-0.1138979942,
-0.2037291974,
-0.0857456997,
-0.1880080849,
0.459120363,
0.3537004888,
-0.1660647392,
-0.1208275408,
-0.1616948396,
0.3975902796,
-0.6055166125,
0.5490810275,
-0.196442917,
-0.0089876195,
-0.0024811653,
-0.5111581683,
-0.6958132982,
-0.5414724946,
0.2303664684,
-0.4687447846,
0.1494609118,
0.0839443505,
1.1596002579,
-0.001066434,
-0.4324957728,
-0.7400434017,
-0.5116926432,
0.5789194703,
-0.546934545,
0.6705781221,
0.1990588307,
0.2606996298,
0.2716566026,
-1.1255482435,
-0.1924417615,
-0.150505662,
-0.3653865457,
0.1099009365,
-0.3413738608,
0.046267204,
0.21659863,
0.506224215,
-0.7124807835,
-0.0251319893,
-0.3351599574,
-0.294637084,
0.5391270518,
-0.0608025864,
0.4571661055,
-0.4815965891,
-0.4003150165,
-0.2967773676,
-0.7503028512,
-0.4504650235,
-0.5412580967,
0.1235995516,
-0.1874916404,
0.5541152954,
-0.0742516741,
0.2558319271,
-0.0136302505,
-0.414878726,
0.4826167822,
-0.0132678729,
-0.3065219223,
0.33575809,
0.6643252373,
0.1665623933,
-0.1448773444,
-0.3876775801,
-0.2298465222,
0.0097055184,
0.1312762648,
-1.0596812963,
-0.1734282076,
0.2662576139,
-0.8325376511,
-0.4682640433,
0.1630980521,
-0.7823780179,
-0.5699700117,
-0.0487972125,
0.5908919573,
-0.7024534941,
-0.2110835016,
0.449890554,
-0.1383021474,
0.1603291929,
0.0590210892,
-0.5966384411,
0.2163820416,
0.6070956588,
0.8285816312,
0.2261386663,
0.4595683217,
-0.7899239063,
0.215214178,
-0.2783122063,
0.8111687899,
-0.5393568873,
-0.4503157139,
0.0719899833,
-0.0678203851,
0.2033344656,
-0.5938577056,
0.8631196022,
-0.6801283956,
0.237422511,
-0.1607786715,
-0.5887351036,
-0.1126739085,
0.2205021083,
-0.6395079494,
0.8690069914,
0.0731819123,
-0.7123582959,
0.3079323173,
-0.510925591,
-0.4602406919,
0.2009778917,
-0.6746804714,
-0.5177795291,
0.2910156846,
0.5736572146,
0.6804336905,
-0.843559444,
0.398647964,
0.1921458393,
-0.0097969938,
0.5187636614,
-0.2424842566,
0.5691529512,
0.3450943232,
-0.1679191738,
-0.259311229,
-0.8524734378,
0.0179446712,
0.2378068268,
-0.4760876596,
-0.1565217823,
0.1501121521,
-0.012872763,
0.3128932416,
-0.0042734286,
-1.0450617075,
-0.0336454324,
-0.3871447444,
0.0326859318,
0.1494449228,
0.3079393804,
0.1629988402,
-0.6429079175,
0.3322615623,
0.0309314057,
-0.0311437752,
-0.343747288,
-0.2905421257,
-0.5674639344,
-0.7271177769,
0.3722899258,
0.5325393081,
-0.868339777,
0.1697259545,
-0.6079213619,
-0.4363598228,
-0.4376153052,
-0.2358837128,
0.505500257,
0.6346854568,
0.3992543817,
-0.348164022,
-0.6492062807,
-0.6936427951,
0.1351951808,
-0.0225015543,
-0.0602796264,
0.0474700071,
0.2393588424,
-0.2110471129,
0.8091852665,
-1.0297726393,
-0.3935153186,
-0.2516477108,
0.4760934412,
0.2493115366,
0.3940523565,
0.4716755748,
-0.7224617004,
-0.1591026932,
0.2616858184,
-1.232988596,
-0.0330889039,
-0.2683256269,
0.1180261523,
0.1387541741,
0.6021654606,
-0.4687448144,
0.3562448919,
0.5421480536,
-0.2436692119,
0.3800434172,
-0.3277150691,
0.2593567669,
-0.8733196855,
0.0612114072,
0.1084225997,
-0.4947595596,
-0.4559712112,
0.144261986,
0.1619143039,
-0.3500501513,
-0.1380759329,
0.2867259383,
-0.6826499701,
0.0833850726,
-0.2299790978,
-0.0088723665,
0.2492381632,
0.0737574026,
0.4308374524,
0.3101694286,
0.5288074017,
-0.3342293501,
0.0275559053,
0.3586224318,
-0.6079059839,
0.1136334613,
-0.5791040659,
0.140221104,
-0.3510401249,
0.1186038479,
-0.6036971211,
-0.3464766741,
0.1734647453,
-0.5376859307,
0.6565411687,
-0.1030504778,
-0.6673344374,
-0.1928989589,
-0.1085653007,
0.0191394854,
0.7165412307,
-0.4718878567,
0.6220162511,
0.4976578355,
-0.3102520704,
-0.4968039691,
-0.8324943185,
0.2334186882,
0.3583869636,
-0.5264325142,
0.2813553214,
0.104887642,
-0.1032078117,
0.2765390575,
0.023768099,
-0.3191658556,
-0.1474652439,
0.1649586558,
0.3028843403,
-0.4613415897,
0.2855835557,
0.2663960457,
-0.2896516025,
0.3277701139,
-0.2936484516,
0.2455260754,
0.1571980715,
-0.3659776151,
-0.319262743,
0.5676927567,
0.5042958856,
-0.2911193669,
0.5598504543,
0.5582039356,
-0.6316580772,
0.0039227135,
-0.5405349731,
-0.2014242262,
-0.3597792387,
0.7004146576,
-0.0413516089,
-0.9036245346,
0.0065283529,
-0.0495004803,
0.0686411336,
0.4509847462,
0.6491484046,
0.0610856228,
1.1354600191,
0.5876969695,
0.4148345888,
-0.0455203876,
-0.1216355339,
0.1934775561,
-0.5327345729,
-0.5109868646,
-0.5388661623,
0.3397302628,
-0.3866527379,
-0.7552092671,
0.7316932082,
-0.2969729602,
0.1498300582,
-0.2902923524,
-0.503673315,
0.3961186409,
0.0571930967,
0.5261674523,
0.3443188369,
0.3457228541,
0.0729366392,
-0.2169872671,
-0.8272510171,
-0.4873501956,
1.1323077679,
0.4988945425,
0.6220682859,
0.2243295312,
0.8436312675,
0.4296734631,
0.5952753425,
-0.9095102549,
0.2587826252,
-0.5499324799,
-0.6396101117,
0.1562019736,
-0.309607923,
-0.7633361816,
0.152172938,
-0.6585426927,
-0.3706258237,
0.3669247925,
-0.1395746619,
-0.4436308742,
0.1677152961,
-0.3314508498,
0.3230269551,
-0.272872895,
-0.3106831908,
-0.4455744326,
-0.5359413028,
0.247647807,
-0.1042291969,
0.5070859194,
-0.0072277999,
0.0294773709,
0.6253240705,
-0.4049039483,
0.8482996225,
-0.2872814238,
-0.1134810224,
0.227444008,
0.1319891959,
0.3013848066,
0.2694699764,
-0.2222898453,
0.1464328319,
0.1382676512,
-0.2147646993,
-0.544231832,
0.4756917655,
-0.7550587058,
-0.393040657,
-0.7876389027,
-0.5833288431,
-0.1993094236,
0.296512574,
0.2738556266,
1.1860255003,
-0.4192302227,
0.3389882445,
1.0194330215,
-0.4753091931,
0.0121147381,
0.367844969,
-0.182629481,
-0.650591433,
1.0945832729,
0.0448458716,
0.0239458084,
0.9323611856,
0.3511051536,
-0.1829476058,
-0.6676909328,
-0.371237576,
0.5653241277,
-0.9796113372,
-0.5889320374,
-0.78292799,
-0.4303584099,
-0.4278244376,
-0.1777454466,
-0.1249785945,
-0.4555053711,
-0.3267746568,
-0.0728927702,
0.2649178803,
0.9206090569,
-0.4496240616,
0.2120832801,
-1.205774188,
0.2035343349,
-0.0084754173,
0.0949425176,
-0.1750151217,
-0.3898768425,
-0.755710125,
-0.3721352816,
-0.192108348,
-0.7880099416,
0.5132023692,
0.1962168068,
0.4357036948,
0.5116038918,
0.0319985561,
0.2779682279,
-0.2370684296,
0.5522794127,
0.3533218205,
-0.7175629139,
0.4398009479,
-0.2777711451,
0.0978863835,
0.2662061453,
0.4299705625,
-0.4794079661,
-0.2746039927,
-0.5488649607,
-0.6627177,
0.6545343995,
-0.0004225543,
-0.0109369103,
-0.3947237432,
0.5169562697,
0.2083711326,
-0.2003296614,
-0.5803221464,
-0.0997946933,
-0.2008181214,
-0.6167032123,
0.1685690731,
-0.8037467599,
-0.316963166,
0.0368712991,
0.7395784855,
-0.2367897183,
0.5769942403,
0.59618783,
-0.4594720602,
0.1371034682,
0.3068051338,
0.4125057161,
0.5768995881,
-0.3549711406,
0.2979803085,
-0.168611899,
-0.5644065738,
0.0081680175,
0.1309251487,
0.0228461437,
0.209469229,
0.7257517576,
0.4822763801,
0.4476848841,
-0.7356523275,
0.7444735169,
-0.2458263785,
-0.300961405,
-0.0483686365,
-0.1306049526,
-0.0678028017,
0.0974568501,
0.4601999521,
0.0352964997,
0.3262894154,
-0.2475077063,
0.5910372138,
0.0360198021,
-0.5922890902,
-0.2383462936,
0.4663377106,
0.2466675192,
0.4372625649,
0.5537884235,
0.0275797546,
-0.0512641594,
0.4137942791,
0.7941140532,
0.6789944768,
0.1163613424,
0.4013288319,
0.6462202668,
0.1877616495,
-0.1570364982,
0.2352129519,
0.205014661,
-0.6910744309,
-0.6773162484,
-0.2323764712,
-0.2278821766,
-0.205414325,
-0.9642281532,
0.3232858181,
-0.5702006221,
0.0321385898,
-0.0487934016,
-0.0605122112,
-0.4819189906,
0.6339364052,
0.4998954833,
0.9771012068,
-0.7440035939,
0.8856856227,
0.4710652232,
-0.3956616223,
-0.8321277499,
-0.1453802288,
0.0883081779,
-0.935752213,
0.7076449394,
0.0753435567,
-0.1054299623,
-0.2215564549,
-0.4156702161,
-0.9573251605,
1.1111955643,
0.4298030734,
-0.5356758833,
-0.1025939584,
0.0334642977,
0.3265317976,
-0.6938796043,
0.2741669714,
0.4162550867,
0.1974308193,
0.117112726,
-0.5345501304,
0.5224326849,
-0.0162663665,
-0.2898259163,
0.0126337986,
-0.2802168727,
0.4667755067,
-0.3495452106,
-0.3759950697,
0.0816709697,
0.7841826677,
0.0621728934,
0.2176158577,
0.2434812784,
0.4720847607,
0.9204419851,
-0.1253903657,
1.3937284946,
-0.2554703951,
0.3607768118,
0.8162215352,
-0.14933303,
0.5998824239,
0.127311632,
0.3969760239,
0.8664461374,
0.2042398751,
0.0349878334,
0.6482461691,
-0.2696937919,
-0.2765468061,
-0.4237669408,
-0.2842592597,
-0.3518983722,
0.5809811354,
0.5799082518,
-0.7632367611,
-0.2889490128,
0.1239591017,
0.4794017076,
-0.0665500164,
-0.1101548523,
0.8338046074,
0.1182569191,
-0.4071111977,
0.6074435115,
0.0757617429,
0.3443685472,
-0.8209264874,
-0.2019552737,
0.0530586839,
0.2345017642,
-0.3646875918,
-0.7551399469,
0.4371586144,
0.025155969,
-0.4873477221,
-0.1988172084,
0.8896553516,
-0.3763296008,
-0.5536090136,
0.1519702524,
0.3827774525,
-0.0180097278,
0.3161916137,
-0.3987159431,
0.4283355772,
0.2477437109,
0.0209181327,
0.2300817668,
0.4144614339,
0.0295977406,
0.358119756,
0.4872488379,
0.3210325837,
-0.5166810751,
0.0475244448,
0.9827512503,
-0.4942699671,
-0.3477503657,
-0.58478266,
0.4498218298,
-0.1146143302,
-0.0950694755,
0.2652086616,
0.6051670313,
0.3749071062,
0.0246921759,
1.0113272667,
-0.3221504986,
0.5606675744,
-0.7991321683,
0.7850883007,
-0.3854888976,
0.1379138231,
-0.0186536107,
-0.2473323196,
-0.6786033511,
0.4652979672,
-0.0811561421,
-0.3251713812,
0.9506550431,
0.8466697931,
0.014644823,
0.1910907328,
0.3500371873,
0.5380777121,
0.5856816769,
0.3450519145,
0.5226237178,
-0.4590908587,
0.7596651316,
-0.1135093868,
-0.4571055472,
-0.1748008281,
-0.8685677052,
-0.4835019708,
-0.4480882585,
-0.6914801002,
-0.6311154366,
0.1290422231,
1.0096501112,
0.979164362,
-0.6184827685,
0.053357441,
0.414434582,
-0.0785838515,
-0.1221952289,
-0.19363451,
0.624006331,
-0.3330453336,
-0.3313343525,
0.3925661743,
0.3872731626,
-0.2622820139,
0.1104167402,
-0.0236575138,
-0.0327528156,
0.1361413896,
0.7824119329,
0.2491613328,
-0.2184858173,
-0.5651251078,
-0.0361604206,
-0.2820563316,
0.379948765,
0.9895066023,
-0.9414778948,
0.6149453521,
0.3870668113,
0.7510293126,
0.608104527,
-0.3105509281,
0.4877132773,
-0.8328909874,
-0.059306819,
0.2318504006,
0.2921171188,
0.6329381466,
-0.5533903241,
0.2558330297,
0.2718600929,
-0.5304843783,
-0.7913521528,
0.1092465967,
-0.9736811519,
-0.4456557631,
1.0998243093,
-0.1405002475,
-0.1724974364,
-0.2272967398,
-0.2422957569,
0.3551893234,
-0.3742956519,
0.5980865955,
0.2821684182,
-0.413464874,
-0.3116499484,
-0.2001038343,
0.3311483264,
0.1732873917,
-0.7795995474,
-0.0952460095,
0.6133463979,
0.4799831212,
0.2834065855,
0.7878930569,
-0.7087182999,
0.5661673546,
-0.0559151806,
0.3070159853,
-0.1809630096,
-0.1855086386,
-0.2802456617,
0.443885088,
0.3048632741,
-0.0040118629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01942v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01942v1 | Certainly Uncertain: A Benchmark and Metric for Multimodal Epistemic and Aleatoric Awareness | 2024-07-02T04:23:54 | 2024-07-02T04:23:54 | Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Linjie Li, Anas Awadalla, Ximing Lu, Jae Sung Park, Jack Hessel, Lijuan Wang, Yejin Choi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | The ability to acknowledge the inevitable uncertainty in their knowledge and
reasoning is a prerequisite for AI systems to be truly truthful and reliable.
In this paper, we present a taxonomy of uncertainty specific to vision-language
AI systems, distinguishing between epistemic uncertainty (arising from a lack
of information) and aleatoric uncertainty (due to inherent unpredictability),
and further explore finer categories within. Based on this taxonomy, we
synthesize a benchmark dataset, CertainlyUncertain, featuring 178K visual
question answering (VQA) samples as contrastive pairs. This is achieved by 1)
inpainting images to make previously answerable questions into unanswerable
ones; and 2) using image captions to prompt large language models for both
answerable and unanswerable questions. Additionally, we introduce a new metric
confidence-weighted accuracy, that is well correlated with both accuracy and
calibration error, to address the shortcomings of existing metrics. | [
-0.3997449279,
-0.8696398139,
0.7754283547,
0.0045799324,
0.1454970688,
0.1091984734,
0.0045283893,
-0.459207207,
0.0467884839,
-0.0350127332,
-0.3179660439,
-0.0874431282,
-0.7644456029,
-0.0431732237,
-0.2436380088,
0.4549710453,
-0.2360245883,
-0.0189645011,
-0.4014651477,
-0.5443688035,
-0.3622298837,
-0.0658018216,
-0.2620440125,
0.1123538017,
0.5285074115,
0.3170352578,
0.903523922,
0.4449861944,
0.8424690366,
0.3718421161,
0.2545335293,
0.1313280612,
0.0780482814,
0.0831177682,
-0.2024293393,
-0.8039439321,
-0.2030301392,
-0.1601004601,
0.4369318187,
0.5903931856,
-0.2240132987,
0.3391883373,
-0.2077002823,
0.435985744,
-1.0370748043,
0.221009776,
-0.7151376605,
0.1671932191,
0.188721627,
0.0481180139,
0.0665589646,
-0.1155346781,
0.3938173354,
-1.1827327013,
-0.3308250308,
0.2113165557,
1.1079976559,
1.1958639622,
-0.1386589706,
-0.170031026,
-0.6397216916,
0.8089805245,
-0.4067562521,
0.5047900081,
0.4994507432,
0.6361428499,
0.3321241736,
-0.8443065286,
-0.7156108022,
0.2132397741,
0.2145677507,
0.5669583082,
-0.5292013884,
0.1282755286,
-0.0377700515,
0.0729068592,
-0.3410545886,
-0.182711333,
-0.0052663535,
-0.4185108542,
0.2241377532,
0.0415183716,
0.1476220787,
0.0350097604,
-0.4889810979,
-0.2336286306,
-0.2136550695,
0.3042075932,
0.103401117,
-0.2117083073,
-0.2628076673,
0.7666381598,
-0.4581399858,
0.8136466146,
-0.2053633034,
-0.098131977,
0.3798799515,
-0.3549433053,
-0.324385494,
-0.3165356517,
0.6376771927,
0.617302835,
0.2517395914,
0.0515830331,
-0.2402882129,
0.3725925386,
0.3847347796,
-0.2194624245,
-0.3924188018,
0.5469561219,
-0.0412969328,
0.022421876,
0.173370868,
-0.5952902436,
-0.3364904523,
-0.0520310476,
0.8546305895,
-0.5296136141,
-0.1465920955,
-0.0339627489,
-0.1926992685,
0.3377708793,
0.9708358049,
-0.3156839907,
-0.2419779301,
0.3394897878,
0.533657074,
0.0690118596,
-0.4937937558,
-0.3144845963,
-0.0394317694,
-0.6682950258,
0.7771717906,
-0.5342519879,
0.148522988,
-0.0250880457,
-0.1535301208,
-0.1611804217,
-0.3582815528,
0.4778588116,
-0.4948200583,
-0.0554912761,
-0.086431317,
-0.548283875,
-0.4096585214,
0.7651706338,
-0.5589686632,
0.8185561895,
0.1456713974,
-0.7725387216,
0.5142927766,
-0.2153825462,
0.1276106536,
0.1618915349,
-0.540682137,
-0.291082114,
-0.0716372132,
0.2516427338,
0.4809477031,
-0.1829899251,
0.2805291712,
-0.3013484478,
-0.2316143811,
0.6312255859,
-0.6970763803,
0.2229575962,
0.2433145344,
-0.1557478756,
-0.0450053848,
-0.7872034907,
0.4786618054,
-0.2502574027,
-0.276588589,
-0.2956402898,
0.0205933657,
-0.082552366,
0.1302461326,
0.6378532052,
-0.4457423389,
-0.2885719836,
-0.0536202416,
0.2997200787,
0.8155113459,
-0.0528373457,
0.2666787803,
-0.4849676192,
0.3639044762,
0.2543235421,
0.3039723039,
-0.2292447537,
-0.8644655347,
-1.1121070385,
-0.2677319348,
0.1175006256,
0.9313039184,
-1.2112067938,
0.172030583,
-0.2410246283,
-0.6108102798,
-0.8259391785,
0.0050357943,
0.600846827,
0.605760932,
0.2720091045,
-0.2707333267,
-0.1827548295,
-0.8798599243,
-0.1764586717,
-0.7738555074,
0.064813979,
0.602257669,
0.4859577715,
-0.1353066862,
0.699925065,
-0.2846319377,
-0.0351499692,
0.3999595344,
0.3491825163,
0.0799683481,
0.2541611493,
0.3541516662,
-1.2219340801,
-0.393853575,
0.1130302623,
-0.9945132136,
0.371284157,
-0.2177431583,
0.049930878,
-0.0145544559,
0.4147142768,
-0.4430438876,
0.6244187951,
0.3471307158,
0.0795793161,
0.3285969794,
-0.3409927785,
0.4757101536,
-0.890466392,
0.0474421754,
0.1569732726,
-0.0522354357,
-0.5424876213,
0.1799937338,
0.1555320472,
0.4725330174,
-0.6437714696,
0.4003074169,
-0.2131906599,
0.0555618331,
0.3729088008,
0.0434940718,
-0.0297482014,
0.4700062275,
0.1291041225,
0.9646859765,
1.0057519674,
-0.536703527,
0.555101335,
0.3243630826,
-0.7386670709,
1.0095831156,
-0.7311321497,
-0.2501390278,
-0.2260757238,
-0.4300086796,
-1.3070975542,
-0.5881935358,
0.2524948418,
-0.9493475556,
0.1138756946,
0.1274755895,
-0.2457468212,
-0.3237391114,
0.0488984361,
0.3715062141,
0.2844232619,
-0.1655966192,
0.5724387765,
0.2405094355,
-0.0524169728,
-1.0831471682,
-0.8772188425,
0.0532830767,
-0.0271702502,
-0.2643864751,
-0.1411494166,
-0.2200661004,
-0.6680940986,
0.0869903192,
-0.0842677206,
-0.3604424894,
0.2593394816,
0.5775505304,
0.3643469214,
-0.1831963807,
0.2669246495,
-0.3827905059,
-0.0181033574,
-0.1495400518,
-0.2504458725,
0.041846998,
-0.683558166,
-0.7896460295,
-0.4849645197,
0.1221947744,
0.6349335909,
-0.1317057908,
0.4702882171,
0.5968926549,
-0.5901711583,
0.199255839,
-0.6033639312,
0.220138818,
-0.3845417202,
0.3819265962,
-0.4262372553,
-0.8215628862,
0.7044631243,
0.1345205456,
-0.1158057079,
0.5701892972,
0.478015691,
-0.5276276469,
0.7432770133,
0.6308109164,
0.0581301562,
0.1406284869,
0.0310702082,
-0.0188540127,
-0.4104211628,
-0.3771890104,
-0.4686825871,
-0.1843330562,
-0.5780934691,
-0.6024511456,
0.6505971551,
-0.1621483713,
-0.4313013554,
-0.088603057,
-0.445064038,
0.25435251,
0.8002009392,
0.0091416026,
0.1062552407,
-0.2128374577,
0.045235984,
0.0342366099,
-0.7271407247,
-0.3799009919,
1.0254222155,
0.2003017217,
0.9899148941,
0.2910180092,
0.1846994162,
0.1996442527,
0.008393839,
-0.6385130286,
0.1245917752,
0.23103486,
-0.9086185098,
-0.4999207854,
-0.2811051607,
-0.5109393001,
-0.0331635661,
-0.4242906868,
-0.9374478459,
0.377058804,
0.1897148788,
-0.8382874131,
0.4113552868,
-0.7046886086,
0.6720362306,
-0.1953578442,
-0.2903359234,
0.1395820528,
-1.3400923014,
0.0428925641,
-0.194607228,
0.2737612128,
-0.0388790406,
-0.4426014721,
0.3522290289,
-0.0841954947,
0.7102609277,
0.2346720994,
0.316642195,
0.5733991861,
-0.0020876394,
0.1603124887,
0.0263243206,
0.1172173545,
0.2414553165,
0.2367526144,
-0.4094865322,
-0.5212177634,
0.1697982699,
-0.9992688894,
-0.4683232307,
-0.5421904922,
-0.4636827111,
-0.4082161784,
0.0401240587,
0.4549061954,
0.083338663,
-0.0334793516,
0.1065519974,
0.9882637858,
-0.3457735181,
0.2868935168,
0.1983161718,
0.182686165,
-0.4949548542,
0.8880144954,
0.0868702456,
0.3864307404,
0.8260318041,
-0.2078133672,
-0.2345357984,
-0.391762197,
-0.6086379886,
-0.3042814732,
-0.8791265488,
-0.2657658756,
-0.5664263368,
-0.4266057312,
-0.1091820374,
-0.2322678715,
-0.4550347924,
-0.6044794917,
-0.2539787591,
-0.0050900779,
0.3114679456,
0.6626971364,
-0.1859102994,
0.2563846111,
-0.591338098,
0.3696783483,
0.6091461182,
0.4369980693,
-0.3507325649,
-0.5925930738,
-0.1649135798,
0.2074692994,
0.0724232569,
-0.5606060624,
0.045893427,
0.3852172494,
0.8539612889,
0.6880696416,
0.246387586,
0.5142003298,
-0.2856542468,
0.7975931764,
0.3896057606,
-0.6282269359,
0.5089206696,
-0.1481091231,
0.2956700325,
0.9630602598,
0.4294107258,
-0.4622088075,
-0.5043894649,
-0.5730289221,
-0.7885872722,
0.3516466916,
0.175365597,
0.0152144069,
0.1889819354,
0.1608598977,
-0.0004121927,
0.5587432981,
-0.3324582875,
-0.4301655591,
-0.4623437524,
-0.2550097108,
-0.1966446191,
0.0861020088,
-0.432710737,
-0.0903144553,
0.4160094857,
-0.3038894236,
0.399653703,
0.3419640064,
-0.0854166597,
0.0064332038,
0.3386786282,
0.342395097,
0.7242797017,
-0.3124954402,
0.3758075535,
0.1387647241,
-0.554708302,
0.1925572604,
-0.027266711,
-0.1731462181,
-0.2959115803,
0.603012383,
0.7284405828,
-0.2092749327,
-0.9912171364,
0.7373806238,
-0.2927806973,
0.0139024854,
-0.5447942019,
0.0203322005,
-0.1649651527,
0.3506084085,
0.3493954241,
0.6143881679,
0.1027448252,
-0.4723657966,
0.3320035636,
0.2890837491,
-0.8014020324,
-0.0091031641,
0.800901711,
-0.0753026679,
0.0325717218,
0.4736908078,
-0.0917863175,
-0.4364120662,
0.81216079,
-0.222312957,
0.4965423942,
0.0094368672,
0.3357397914,
0.2493346483,
0.691326797,
0.1159280315,
0.5631998181,
-0.000269958,
-1.2684237957,
-0.0892976522,
-0.4540992379,
-0.7581353784,
-0.3242866695,
-0.8129828572,
-0.2870515287,
-0.6514736414,
-0.3191256523,
0.1829693466,
-0.467104435,
-0.7881379724,
0.6967230439,
-0.0189216267,
0.7391314507,
-0.7822505236,
0.384991318,
1.1736279726,
-0.6084299088,
-0.8731794953,
0.0178292729,
0.1840649992,
-1.0670365095,
0.2461685389,
-0.1338249743,
-0.1521264464,
-0.2621107697,
-0.7498191595,
-0.8465021849,
1.0830255747,
0.2215657681,
-0.195472762,
0.303397119,
0.0678722337,
0.4961509109,
-0.1487696916,
0.439170897,
0.4185887873,
0.6562666297,
0.3496461809,
-0.7456150055,
-0.5133083463,
-0.5060759783,
-0.0861966237,
-0.0939352885,
-0.8127030134,
0.869165957,
-0.4437082708,
-0.1884913445,
0.3068356812,
0.5186596513,
-0.1023574546,
0.4900766015,
0.4307782948,
0.8336840272,
0.8425878882,
-0.5194604397,
0.9780112505,
-0.3145053685,
0.0500916615,
1.1174105406,
-0.0193618406,
0.9263967872,
0.7670670152,
-0.371804893,
0.102000393,
0.9544684291,
0.1103688627,
0.4283751845,
-0.2986819446,
-0.2299194038,
-0.7207017541,
-0.2775490582,
-0.2800565064,
0.5580157638,
0.650670886,
-0.0178654194,
0.1316396594,
-0.0746469349,
-0.3621912301,
0.2005847543,
-0.3480779529,
0.7893133163,
-0.0876790434,
-0.7806006074,
0.3689662516,
-0.1964944601,
0.539971292,
-0.4069315493,
0.0827033371,
-0.0288082398,
0.0629987344,
0.0351482704,
-1.3404947519,
0.0217957553,
-0.2754060626,
0.0183462109,
0.23315534,
0.4209087789,
-0.2060986608,
-0.6268522143,
-0.0106113004,
1.0404480696,
0.3002402484,
0.0926825777,
-0.7742082477,
-0.1842666417,
-0.0204538982,
-0.0719591901,
-0.1834839731,
0.7116055489,
0.0642399862,
1.1711570024,
0.0179965012,
-0.0136720557,
0.304682523,
-0.1701842397,
0.6390659213,
-0.0680272132,
-0.1838625222,
-0.3875975609,
0.7105973363,
0.1162577197,
-0.7574469447,
0.6080781221,
0.2512238324,
0.9151489139,
-0.005142842,
0.9640898705,
-0.2862665355,
0.2208418995,
-0.3482944071,
0.5939307809,
-1.0509059429,
-0.0892111659,
-0.5396451354,
-0.5964614153,
-0.5775843859,
0.7502542138,
-0.0437414944,
-0.0416671559,
0.4803473055,
0.6944281459,
0.1667011529,
-0.0273549967,
0.7444785237,
0.2036138326,
-0.3479774296,
0.6806808114,
1.0102647543,
-0.4463689923,
0.438627094,
-0.2524546087,
-0.2914251685,
-0.0206068102,
-0.6038632989,
-0.3522276282,
-1.0251796246,
-0.347022444,
-0.1675435752,
0.2151111811,
0.5503326058,
0.6864470243,
-0.8339776397,
0.1827939898,
0.1233451515,
0.1795297414,
-0.2781573832,
-0.0528576635,
0.2072128952,
-0.0362971164,
-0.608609736,
-0.1793628782,
0.4946586788,
0.4447386265,
-0.1433794945,
-0.1053068787,
-0.3142442405,
0.2685027122,
0.0799290389,
0.4093788564,
-0.8020181656,
-0.6195812225,
0.0530383885,
-0.2000045627,
0.2974493802,
-0.0087331189,
-0.4865252376,
0.9014121294,
0.1758840829,
0.8483840227,
0.1767570525,
0.1245061979,
0.2214751691,
-0.626666069,
0.1956143677,
0.3176573217,
0.4911077917,
0.4587621689,
-0.2602365911,
0.5946971178,
0.1712190062,
-0.3418379724,
-0.4994974136,
0.3153443038,
-0.9749420285,
-0.1375457644,
0.8459123373,
-0.5661481023,
-0.4325803816,
-0.2344845384,
0.0658367947,
0.1051000506,
-0.2634278834,
0.5471124649,
1.0875412226,
-0.0989322588,
-0.4198023677,
-0.5891933441,
0.1316602677,
0.4241351485,
-0.8812859654,
-0.3276956975,
0.6048469543,
-0.0592532828,
0.6601870656,
0.2667344511,
0.0793732256,
0.559884727,
0.551712513,
0.1502151191,
0.3680284917,
-0.7256288528,
-0.0985922292,
0.1656456143,
0.2979093492,
-0.3417683542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01937v1 | Efficient-Empathy: Towards Efficient and Effective Selection of Empathy Data | 2024-07-02T04:11:52 | 2024-07-02T04:11:52 | Linzhuang Sun, Hao Liang, Jingxuan Wei, Linkun Sun, Bihui Yu, Bin Cui, Wentao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, with the rapid advancements in large language models (LLMs),
achieving excellent empathetic response capability has become a crucial
prerequisite. Consequently, managing and understanding large-scale video
datasets has gained increasing importance. However, empathetic data are
typically trained without any quality selection, leading to inefficient data
usage and wasted computational resources. Additionally, using raw data can
result in low performance in empathetic dialogues. In this work, we present
Efficient-Empathy, a sensibility and rationality score-based data selection
algorithm that automatically selects sensibility and rationality data while
discarding low-quality data. With only the sensibility data (59% of the full
dataset), our trained sensibility model efficiently achieves state-of-the-art
(SoTA) performance. Furthermore, with multiple data selection hyperparameters,
the sensibility model demonstrates SoTA performance, showcasing the robustness
of our method. By integrating sensibility and rationality data with a MoE
structure, we achieve even higher performance, demonstrating the effectiveness
of our Efficient-Empathy algorithm. | [
-0.4375025332,
-0.8222339749,
0.6806815863,
0.2819340527,
-0.3100814223,
-0.5431044102,
-0.3102422357,
-0.1593841016,
0.098480925,
0.0160231311,
-0.4849435389,
-0.4872336686,
-0.6905546784,
0.072692275,
0.0569012873,
0.6115609407,
-0.0774746388,
0.2710704505,
-0.0589925721,
-0.8027777672,
-0.1620361954,
-0.284337759,
-0.6768118143,
-0.183787182,
0.4678583741,
0.9289301634,
0.5370314121,
1.0207794905,
0.4628449976,
0.2754758596,
0.1265930235,
0.2718837559,
-0.6812520027,
0.1920078695,
-0.0636892617,
-0.2362248152,
-0.8852071762,
0.1850182116,
0.1804163903,
0.1351199299,
-0.2218229175,
0.3885805309,
-0.010103425,
0.6801646948,
-0.5915821195,
0.080508627,
-0.4367678165,
0.2176235169,
0.2486658841,
-0.3451145887,
-0.4899816513,
-0.288382858,
-0.0035900532,
-0.6648123264,
-0.3503336608,
-0.0100864097,
0.6154789925,
0.2970760763,
-0.1891743988,
-0.1743714958,
-0.1388411671,
1.0384999514,
-0.2799031138,
0.3863788247,
0.6635088921,
0.3103317916,
0.4472568035,
-0.3895734847,
-0.540982008,
-0.1668452173,
0.345802933,
0.2942913473,
-0.3168285787,
0.088036865,
0.5733943582,
0.1118952557,
-0.4595986903,
0.0510778464,
0.3194577992,
0.0313624628,
0.6476784945,
0.4982946515,
0.2957184911,
-0.2418200225,
-0.2324645668,
-0.1823220104,
-0.1685763299,
0.1484716386,
0.3832130134,
0.1095036939,
-0.1888312846,
0.8121511936,
-0.2895796001,
0.5075116754,
0.0670178011,
-0.1113067493,
0.2920271158,
0.1031850204,
-0.2586420476,
-0.1487017572,
0.5994391441,
0.9029946923,
0.5160573125,
0.1245116368,
-0.1555592865,
0.415938437,
0.1536279321,
-1.0119259357,
-0.1960449517,
0.3009192944,
-0.745241046,
-0.1001669839,
-0.4713685811,
-0.9144428372,
-0.3065772057,
-0.4922180772,
0.1022795811,
-0.6289984584,
-0.2802097499,
-0.0713821426,
-0.0415771976,
0.1471889317,
0.5313065052,
-0.7585200071,
0.0910384357,
0.4473925531,
0.7855834961,
0.1510178298,
-0.0894712657,
-0.9887923598,
-0.0531588756,
-0.0397810712,
0.5806090236,
-1.0980907679,
-0.1649551839,
-0.3168864548,
-0.3685394824,
-0.102812022,
-0.2952938974,
1.0659778118,
-0.2406119406,
-0.1699408889,
-0.2891580164,
-0.6808975935,
-0.3009445667,
0.5501102805,
-0.7526733279,
0.5185962319,
0.3697311878,
-0.8167099357,
0.6117570996,
-0.639408648,
-0.1531489938,
-0.3618074656,
-0.054777313,
-0.2860934734,
0.0834381804,
0.3206115961,
0.8534096479,
-0.3532351851,
0.2337499559,
-0.5742586851,
-0.2903731167,
0.1392797381,
-0.6852647662,
0.5051289201,
0.4939633906,
0.0038485695,
-0.067062676,
-0.6450033784,
0.0380187146,
-0.0074017826,
-0.2001104504,
-0.3659905195,
-0.1721975207,
0.3017940819,
0.3670721948,
-0.1537931412,
-0.6957968473,
0.0747190714,
-0.158827126,
0.3519586623,
0.8983033299,
-0.3756463528,
0.7369749546,
-0.2606133819,
0.6130436063,
-0.0921267867,
0.5442598462,
0.0742462352,
-0.3548817337,
-0.2534301579,
-0.9600998163,
-0.1720469147,
0.5164340138,
-0.4065730274,
0.5459430814,
-0.2862102389,
-0.6629698277,
-0.794008553,
0.1488735378,
0.3666368723,
0.7906318903,
0.3296786547,
-0.4049176276,
-0.246162042,
-0.8436922431,
-0.5041760206,
-0.0372558758,
0.0407305509,
0.8948628902,
-0.0320097581,
-0.2718783319,
0.8231192231,
-0.4844811261,
-0.2404386401,
-0.3353410959,
-0.1744379401,
0.2649220228,
0.4906669855,
0.4485520422,
-0.9791871309,
-0.6692521572,
-0.0073878462,
-0.7999213338,
-0.0404829346,
0.0220791455,
-0.4607509971,
0.2204383016,
-0.0792920738,
-0.9001644254,
0.488378346,
0.4931147993,
-0.4832245409,
-0.0425585955,
0.0975855514,
0.5620140433,
-0.965509057,
0.3907043338,
0.2481120229,
-0.1583141685,
-0.5706605315,
-0.458722949,
0.1565319598,
0.2686994672,
-0.461836338,
0.7597998977,
-0.1755330414,
0.1686825454,
0.3301174939,
0.0981426388,
-0.0918826535,
0.7556279302,
0.1503204852,
0.2259016484,
0.7119859457,
-0.3948306739,
0.5539638996,
0.6482067108,
-0.1107490957,
0.9676485658,
-0.1686660945,
0.0482200012,
-0.2057870179,
-0.1227369681,
-0.5282161832,
-0.587691009,
0.3845582902,
-0.6208836436,
0.2087740004,
-0.1632070243,
-0.3229265213,
0.0521465242,
-0.5082938075,
0.5010741949,
0.5651150346,
-0.6368463039,
0.9507445097,
0.6286627054,
-0.3770883381,
-0.4827581644,
-0.5030325651,
-0.101912424,
-0.5557359457,
-0.4991859496,
-0.3629652262,
-0.1937574297,
-0.2039931118,
-0.0241022594,
-0.0122376392,
-0.1632595658,
-0.0554306656,
0.2650090754,
0.1114637554,
0.2918035686,
0.1323292106,
0.3071532547,
-0.329254806,
0.0035704838,
0.5383167267,
0.4678050876,
-0.0469170697,
-0.3283442259,
-0.7778015733,
0.3613140583,
0.7207014561,
-0.0602457821,
0.4788903892,
0.5480391383,
-0.1933535933,
-0.1411600709,
-0.589661777,
-0.3027943969,
-0.3989158273,
0.3866349757,
-0.4858075678,
-0.6646611691,
0.575996995,
0.0599754602,
-0.035055086,
-0.1855526119,
0.429887265,
0.2096800208,
1.6282467842,
0.1889925897,
-0.2232220173,
0.7339244485,
-0.1854232252,
0.3160176277,
-0.972968936,
-0.1540492326,
-0.2055482417,
-0.2434302568,
-0.480238229,
-0.0445134118,
0.4488189518,
-0.2575124502,
-0.590415895,
0.0782129094,
-0.5070355535,
0.2677741945,
0.2312830091,
0.5296267867,
0.1544105262,
0.0622051172,
0.3794632554,
-0.184658587,
-0.6534817219,
-0.7128634453,
1.1480189562,
0.534271121,
0.7952035666,
0.0792288184,
0.4591140449,
0.1853602231,
0.7436664701,
-1.0612876415,
0.7286113501,
-0.137176767,
-0.1490006894,
-0.3929057419,
-0.7079253793,
-0.7243854403,
0.1029294133,
-0.0969101638,
-0.6331230998,
0.1260037124,
0.4884269536,
-0.4076859951,
0.0793878511,
-0.9501105547,
0.7977238297,
0.042518843,
-0.8562369943,
-0.4694291353,
-0.652485013,
0.1861138791,
-0.1620886177,
-0.0398592576,
-0.4286828041,
0.0715668499,
0.5581697822,
-0.1939804256,
0.3663718104,
-0.5966166854,
0.2234382927,
0.1834828109,
0.3114427328,
0.472142458,
0.393640548,
-0.5885531306,
-0.0114136795,
-0.3000250459,
-0.382550329,
-0.7086964846,
0.6337526441,
-0.5561734438,
-0.2198844552,
-0.0137053458,
-0.3566666842,
-0.4393717945,
0.0134451827,
0.0548050851,
0.5629204512,
-0.1850258857,
0.273009181,
0.4891728461,
-0.3281469941,
0.2874810398,
0.2362000793,
0.48014763,
-0.5656093955,
0.9025697112,
0.071139887,
0.0974850506,
0.1908516884,
0.2826881707,
-0.4378176928,
0.1340550035,
-0.4606588483,
-0.0141450744,
-0.5849819779,
-0.5110161901,
-0.9860907197,
0.2400016189,
-0.1496104151,
-0.4133813977,
-0.3397854567,
-0.1077265814,
-0.1583846509,
-0.526894033,
0.6572096348,
0.1514552385,
-0.3432478011,
-0.0283522643,
-0.9592292309,
0.5789157748,
0.2211261094,
0.5525708795,
0.1936994791,
-0.4492443502,
-0.1451229602,
0.1319092214,
-0.1667241156,
-0.588137567,
0.8165031075,
0.2486275285,
0.4763506949,
0.7154121995,
0.2067533433,
0.7289081812,
-0.1922586262,
0.2418967038,
0.3233065605,
-1.0249304771,
0.5467176437,
-0.4117622077,
-0.169066444,
0.7585965395,
0.3190971613,
-0.1333135217,
-0.1315176636,
-0.6587266922,
-0.9057407975,
0.9997515082,
0.1907798797,
0.3608235121,
-0.0416545644,
0.1273951381,
0.3304283917,
0.1035830528,
-0.2838739455,
0.2288175523,
-0.268191725,
-0.8136022687,
-0.0447058491,
-0.2054553628,
-0.1322779059,
-0.3610239625,
0.2632590234,
-0.2449291348,
0.2952290177,
0.3832189143,
-0.1582840681,
-0.2976299226,
0.0906434879,
-0.1379242688,
0.0450271368,
-0.2552582324,
-0.23021622,
0.2165012807,
-0.6123688817,
0.1147069857,
-0.2121445388,
0.1951306313,
-0.4195324779,
0.2932059467,
0.713378787,
-0.0407767817,
-1.1425951719,
0.828853786,
-0.2151100338,
0.1161352843,
-0.0693381727,
0.1444258243,
-0.2482868284,
0.3735020459,
-0.1775215715,
0.1887485087,
0.5025601983,
-0.5037189722,
0.3130049407,
0.2566425204,
-0.1759735346,
-0.3046682775,
0.2995648384,
0.2565547228,
-0.1809670925,
0.9587617517,
0.1435954869,
-0.1893303394,
0.5113596916,
-0.0426348671,
0.9627316594,
-0.3747855127,
0.2070821971,
0.478949964,
-0.3513478637,
-0.2844085693,
0.7394295335,
-0.3827498257,
-0.9231716394,
-0.206013754,
-0.4410071671,
-0.4817040265,
-0.3622839153,
-1.2975434065,
0.0018234794,
-0.2317861468,
-0.4666701257,
-0.470361501,
-0.0625518337,
-0.9757434726,
0.4300710857,
-0.2166953534,
1.1427650452,
-1.0191956758,
0.686283052,
0.4367410541,
-0.2383602262,
-1.1580171585,
-0.2913689017,
-0.212893784,
-0.8672094345,
0.5154918432,
0.4479582012,
-0.102302976,
0.2479419559,
-0.6330089569,
-0.3184996545,
1.0235804319,
0.711611867,
-0.4582511187,
0.4221405983,
-0.2941225767,
0.5216786861,
-0.5026244521,
0.704061985,
0.7250252962,
0.7228063345,
0.026552273,
-0.5908465385,
0.0271625407,
-0.6281462312,
-0.2945435643,
-0.1889525801,
-0.7542791367,
0.3713259995,
-0.2352020144,
-0.1347080618,
0.1573048383,
0.1091710702,
0.6146853566,
0.7648515701,
0.6641950607,
0.786133945,
0.5803467035,
0.0011135968,
0.9292607307,
-0.4285631776,
0.2536568344,
0.5385717154,
-0.5962046385,
0.9639844894,
0.5862928033,
0.2802532613,
-0.0673903972,
0.5991436839,
0.0453074165,
0.5267594457,
-0.0992288142,
-0.2538462877,
-0.5932701826,
-0.4800638258,
0.2921174765,
0.7598037124,
0.2956216633,
-0.2981944382,
0.0882977918,
0.1523189992,
0.0107317958,
0.1651881486,
-0.3722866178,
0.8386734128,
0.1605253965,
-0.6662759185,
0.2781769335,
-0.3424634039,
0.3983775973,
-0.335208118,
-0.2557480931,
-0.5061266422,
0.0467406884,
-0.3765647709,
-0.9269344807,
0.1206478849,
0.6069874763,
-0.1208949909,
-0.5231921077,
0.4749546647,
-0.3181701601,
-0.0631342381,
0.6237956882,
0.5884555578,
0.1606680751,
-0.1346791834,
-0.4703116119,
0.3335367739,
-0.2462766618,
-0.9725279808,
0.210211724,
0.7603948712,
-0.0084517533,
1.037837863,
0.5961191058,
0.0959215909,
-0.4884971082,
0.2413649112,
1.1787219048,
-0.8262414932,
-0.4597678781,
-0.886993289,
0.7916606069,
-0.3399677873,
-0.2565386295,
0.6152748466,
0.3744519353,
0.4772231579,
-0.0215001889,
0.6711632013,
-0.0994895846,
0.5942598581,
-0.4854533374,
0.577911377,
-0.5281472802,
0.0729454905,
-0.4180221856,
-0.7663220763,
-0.3590717912,
0.9612215161,
-0.3407974243,
0.1620555073,
0.2041232139,
1.0515066385,
-0.1017220393,
0.0332106166,
0.5314878821,
0.2417598963,
0.1459986717,
0.82562536,
0.8482653499,
-0.0664231777,
0.0597965233,
0.0265200753,
-0.6798665524,
-0.3540542722,
-0.7158228159,
-0.6149580479,
-0.3249384761,
-0.0360423923,
-0.0940922052,
-0.1136624888,
1.2506549358,
0.7546437979,
-0.4159415066,
0.1219351441,
-0.0948567986,
-0.123071894,
-0.1266135424,
-0.1967261434,
0.4690029919,
0.1657088399,
-0.91904217,
0.1084944531,
0.4593552947,
-0.284794569,
0.3478556573,
-0.5769677162,
0.2987227738,
0.3145570457,
0.698790431,
0.0730285645,
-0.2249417305,
-0.2346346378,
0.2111096978,
-0.1796785146,
-0.0211853925,
0.5418820977,
-0.4499862194,
0.5519812703,
0.478854537,
0.4902919531,
-0.1106750295,
0.4734889269,
0.556794107,
-0.1749231964,
0.010883661,
0.5549843311,
0.3510389328,
0.3424001336,
-0.5505859852,
0.6389868259,
-0.0427512191,
-0.5417325497,
-1.1456580162,
0.3361407816,
-1.3605846167,
0.249908641,
1.4316241741,
-0.3752370179,
-0.1523118466,
-0.0040435703,
-0.6939929128,
0.4181680083,
-0.8096926808,
0.8208962679,
0.2804116905,
-0.4833729267,
-0.3403855562,
-0.3102626204,
0.4418601096,
0.4902270734,
-0.5588908195,
0.2681482136,
0.5652594566,
0.077865541,
-0.4622956216,
0.7045724392,
-0.0429805145,
0.1646252722,
-0.0010919423,
0.0181292444,
-0.1065137461,
-0.2903366685,
-0.4367855489,
0.2321963906,
-0.0726921633,
-0.1778362095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01929v1 | What We Talk About When We Talk About LMs: Implicit Paradigm Shifts and the Ship of Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:45:55 | 2024-07-02T03:45:55 | Shengqi Zhu, Jeffrey M. Rzeszotarski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The term Language Models (LMs), as a time-specific collection of models of
interest, is constantly reinvented, with its referents updated much like the
$\textit{Ship of Theseus}$ replaces its parts but remains the same ship in
essence. In this paper, we investigate this $\textit{Ship of Language Models}$
problem, wherein scientific evolution takes the form of continuous, implicit
retrofits of key existing terms. We seek to initiate a novel perspective of
scientific progress, in addition to the more well-studied emergence of new
terms. To this end, we construct the data infrastructure based on recent NLP
publications. Then, we perform a series of text-based analyses toward a
detailed, quantitative understanding of the use of Language Models as a term of
art. Our work highlights how systems and theories influence each other in
scientific discourse, and we call for attention to the transformation of this
Ship that we all are contributing to. | [
-0.2017431706,
-0.7254657149,
0.7940891981,
0.0880782604,
-0.1506335884,
0.2427332699,
-0.0547822081,
-0.6360512972,
0.1155577078,
0.6727586389,
-0.6038549542,
-0.1244961023,
-0.6143398285,
0.4098367393,
-0.6961693764,
1.1053503752,
0.0010313957,
0.2394736111,
-0.1072965786,
-0.2910398543,
-0.442417115,
0.0332226083,
-0.5361813307,
-0.4594912827,
0.755192399,
-0.1913178116,
0.9147134423,
0.8627988696,
0.3836513758,
0.2920312881,
-0.4155390263,
0.0593920089,
-0.2354384959,
0.4260259569,
-0.2543664277,
-0.713160038,
-0.4576781392,
-0.066598922,
0.9621651769,
1.1243859529,
-0.0014478777,
0.3827424347,
-0.0355704203,
0.6341025233,
-0.2178255469,
0.2817580104,
-0.8293766975,
-0.0184513424,
-0.0435440317,
-0.3321207762,
-0.3759316206,
-0.2556543648,
0.3000476062,
-0.6500038505,
0.0727055818,
0.344537884,
0.7940340638,
0.1066830456,
-0.2897699475,
-0.2199583799,
-0.9735078812,
0.734867394,
-0.8624444008,
0.5892332792,
-0.3714725375,
0.247142449,
-0.5509486198,
-1.0604047775,
-0.6344158053,
-0.494451344,
0.1749592423,
-0.1373587847,
-0.2096618563,
-0.3015872836,
0.0862263516,
-0.0366617925,
-0.4074359238,
0.1409173161,
-0.613050878,
0.2805772126,
0.5808218122,
0.1209190339,
0.5341830254,
0.0047210925,
-0.2835015953,
0.1048507169,
-1.0413261652,
-0.3612326086,
-0.2434862107,
0.3819370866,
-0.0167770814,
0.4381715655,
0.0439813994,
0.576601088,
-0.1746531874,
0.1464537829,
0.0542201139,
-0.0364520773,
-0.257499367,
-0.0553453527,
0.7862379551,
0.2451289147,
0.2145140022,
-0.2045349628,
-0.0748744756,
0.0891303644,
0.4183197618,
-0.308771044,
-0.0659264475,
0.0596121587,
-0.3646210134,
-0.356033206,
-0.19643493,
-0.5071853399,
-0.4312741458,
-0.4846435189,
0.2376221418,
-0.1214237735,
-0.3408725858,
0.3056133389,
0.040995501,
0.0496283583,
0.3172203898,
-0.6912626028,
0.2720159292,
0.8399755955,
1.0989706516,
-0.1058356762,
-0.0485281721,
0.1503477991,
0.2790310681,
-0.5839172602,
0.9048072696,
-0.4559181333,
-0.8118353486,
0.0386562571,
0.4569503963,
0.021162007,
-0.0813138261,
0.3879043162,
-0.6273057461,
0.4674512744,
-0.3506887555,
-0.5121538639,
-0.1002094746,
-0.1068967953,
-0.5812984705,
1.0459882021,
-0.3008522987,
-0.4732178152,
0.1915193796,
-1.0672075748,
0.0544453636,
0.5020038486,
-0.2096083909,
-0.2865686119,
0.4959102869,
-0.3040293753,
0.2715876997,
-0.4036518633,
0.4219343662,
-0.4649997652,
-0.1690237075,
0.4677850902,
0.1405086964,
0.5363068581,
0.4326348007,
-0.3482691646,
-0.1333699375,
-0.7428034544,
-0.0297400709,
0.1412174851,
-0.1024923623,
-0.7964468002,
0.5975419283,
-0.1462255567,
0.2209760994,
0.2347425371,
-0.5945972204,
0.6768967509,
-0.383520782,
0.6840806603,
0.8669179082,
-0.1295146644,
0.6754776239,
-0.3716867864,
0.305692941,
-0.2051741183,
0.2702288032,
-0.2268164754,
-0.796867609,
-0.981570065,
0.1655438989,
0.1179523617,
0.2581597865,
-0.618740797,
-0.0499184057,
-0.6877564192,
-0.4728067815,
-0.5053117275,
-0.3089414239,
-0.1907145977,
0.2774231434,
0.377856046,
0.0468121544,
-0.5376650691,
-0.8551365733,
-0.4033091068,
-0.5059589744,
-0.0304024387,
0.1903457493,
0.5807259083,
-0.440870136,
1.0827635527,
-0.3898425102,
0.4995340407,
0.1784807444,
0.2561857104,
0.156125918,
0.5286432505,
0.5236049294,
-0.5984036326,
-0.1441112459,
0.1163124815,
-0.9250608683,
-0.365301013,
-0.2320389003,
-0.0745665431,
0.317771256,
0.8817633986,
-0.6191591024,
-0.1133812964,
0.4822801352,
-0.5445274115,
0.3687093854,
-0.1170512214,
-0.0175916515,
-1.1418045759,
-0.0077346247,
-0.133773163,
0.1034349576,
-0.7550991774,
0.1980919093,
-0.0447230563,
0.133686468,
-0.452468276,
0.7546024323,
-0.6961429119,
-0.0028125956,
-0.4554260969,
0.2463569939,
-0.2314392626,
-0.0257714652,
0.2523781955,
0.0364950486,
0.4843778312,
-0.7836619616,
0.0594814941,
0.0618238375,
-0.0405195914,
0.4475206733,
-0.7396072149,
0.3482839465,
-0.5868167877,
0.2795313597,
-1.0062360764,
0.4360115826,
0.2841733992,
-0.0494650863,
0.150322184,
-0.132566765,
-0.2531273067,
-0.2602352798,
-0.0199448038,
0.1436769366,
0.4062520564,
-0.2668478787,
0.5849171281,
0.1612361819,
-0.6310204268,
-0.4523127079,
-0.4910976589,
0.3219577968,
-0.1655254066,
-0.5820669532,
0.1929622293,
-0.2462788373,
-0.7651793957,
0.218738839,
-0.1524322331,
0.421829015,
0.212913096,
0.2782540917,
0.5842303634,
-0.6116276979,
0.4613077641,
0.1658115387,
0.1658908278,
0.179008469,
-0.7576380968,
0.4820078909,
-0.1453794837,
0.0832140893,
0.0187537558,
0.3186767399,
0.7396829128,
0.1391474158,
0.9628574252,
0.1999925673,
-0.180730626,
-0.2208032161,
-0.3582257032,
-0.1225166246,
-0.4623579681,
0.4693300426,
-0.3817403018,
-0.9250741601,
0.4286673367,
-0.2341659218,
0.515529573,
0.6491064429,
0.2721329927,
-0.3365617692,
0.9447100759,
0.961825192,
0.2320200056,
0.3971045017,
0.0214218739,
0.1131255552,
-0.8314211965,
-0.2810513079,
-0.8100509644,
-0.1878149211,
-0.8963474631,
-0.3977248371,
0.2657943964,
-0.0297160111,
-0.3840579093,
0.4008418024,
-0.44096452,
0.0839715451,
-0.2217828631,
-0.303732574,
0.5212557912,
-0.1113152131,
0.1046063378,
-0.1249961704,
-0.727024138,
-0.97968328,
1.3582576513,
0.6050217152,
0.6330696344,
0.1762790084,
0.340500325,
0.4158244133,
0.8752581477,
-0.3900818527,
0.7224285007,
0.0635602921,
-0.4359692335,
-0.2274561226,
-0.2949698567,
-1.143228054,
0.446728915,
-0.3008251488,
-0.6286121607,
0.341879189,
-0.1839323789,
0.1158896089,
0.3446472585,
-0.255185008,
0.4793018103,
-0.3534151912,
-0.2743464708,
-0.1675427258,
-0.5911197662,
0.4118055701,
-0.2534923851,
0.756223917,
-0.3136021793,
-0.4756934345,
0.7439953089,
-0.1283740401,
0.8281860352,
0.0244217496,
-0.86146909,
-0.069763191,
0.4268155992,
0.4526257515,
0.1540704668,
0.207496807,
0.2050530016,
0.2619801164,
-0.3222697973,
-0.5506101251,
0.9211579561,
-0.5461397171,
-0.5746600032,
-0.5042375326,
-0.6014307737,
-0.155639261,
-0.0131084211,
-0.2074048668,
0.1122808978,
-0.4196831286,
-0.1965398192,
0.7232616544,
-0.26865381,
0.550704062,
1.0492345095,
-0.5193665624,
0.3286351562,
0.456535548,
-0.036888577,
0.4153592288,
0.2905946076,
0.1072904617,
-0.3640648425,
-0.395280093,
-0.2084776461,
0.605214119,
-0.6915615201,
0.4008638859,
-0.7639248967,
0.0894632712,
-0.2450882941,
-0.0710260123,
-0.3796668649,
-0.543022275,
-0.3018075824,
0.2092570364,
0.2591608167,
1.2083377838,
0.2162432224,
0.1588003039,
-0.6436023116,
0.0151187629,
0.109740898,
0.2307293266,
-0.2009814829,
-0.7605020404,
-0.2256183773,
0.282977432,
-0.0790937692,
-0.8900231719,
0.3961189985,
0.3725851476,
0.4933457673,
0.1187894642,
-0.4310959876,
0.3647913933,
-0.9601759315,
1.023750186,
0.0381044932,
-0.8876712322,
0.278088212,
-0.570928514,
0.5292272568,
-0.1797659099,
0.5756742954,
-1.1031847,
-0.5607857108,
-0.7803680897,
-0.7866852283,
0.1756759733,
-0.195405975,
0.2155731618,
0.1102301404,
0.6839398146,
0.1624004096,
0.3331407905,
-1.0298799276,
-0.3568936288,
-0.2255579531,
-0.0027090923,
-0.3322107792,
0.0275362544,
-0.06237958,
-0.1913578808,
0.7264950275,
-0.2619357109,
0.2833639383,
-0.0419132337,
-0.0471861027,
-0.1710994542,
0.5310777426,
0.8737663031,
0.596976459,
0.1202467233,
0.2277363837,
-0.012222697,
-0.3225957155,
0.0909843296,
-0.1001081765,
-0.374049753,
0.4265899956,
0.334702462,
0.9095446467,
0.5017279387,
-0.4488218129,
-0.3089624941,
0.206180051,
-0.0780551285,
-0.2433485836,
-0.1295356601,
0.2586919665,
0.4171506464,
0.5262427926,
0.2006952614,
0.0055195396,
-0.8603132963,
-0.0831517577,
0.3887339234,
-0.3939044178,
-0.5401772261,
0.8429083824,
0.0780047327,
-0.3795736134,
-0.0154657001,
0.1292509437,
-0.2441544682,
0.1473317593,
0.6042892933,
0.9311998487,
-0.3804423511,
0.5452270508,
0.095865041,
0.4169993699,
-0.5155172348,
0.121063903,
0.1386748254,
-0.8329595327,
-0.4500607848,
-0.7830884457,
-0.1759091318,
0.2188485116,
-0.2805477381,
0.3155395091,
-0.2710332572,
-0.2045670599,
0.1656016707,
-0.5278321505,
-0.1892385036,
-0.1038401052,
0.4982400239,
0.7163998485,
-0.9058570266,
0.6357805729,
0.9457907081,
-0.1201094165,
-0.2046477944,
-0.258949697,
0.0520054586,
-0.4854014218,
1.0954731703,
-0.4647469223,
-0.321344614,
0.0252570268,
-0.961409688,
-1.2594037056,
0.7650908232,
0.2644590735,
-0.9392460585,
-0.1277993023,
0.1730930507,
0.9836573005,
-0.5367125273,
0.0160474684,
0.5024470091,
0.5648127794,
-0.4432541728,
-0.9640210271,
0.0777876675,
-0.3376384974,
0.2783384025,
0.4678242803,
-0.3516550958,
1.1267039776,
-0.0887572765,
-0.4234187305,
0.2675665319,
0.6908225417,
0.1346627027,
0.0181714948,
0.2026407123,
0.0471456759,
0.4418847263,
-0.3115839064,
0.9309331775,
-0.1457065493,
0.4204024971,
0.7095899582,
-0.3691285849,
0.8732457161,
0.7591901422,
-0.3330226243,
1.0078035593,
0.2911402583,
-0.1303504407,
0.1613820344,
0.520810008,
-0.2172454298,
-0.0241780262,
0.151444748,
-0.4884386659,
0.2524613738,
0.6002482772,
-0.481325984,
-0.1832410842,
0.0140636666,
0.3915830851,
0.0874017105,
-0.3381607831,
0.6346033812,
0.2806018293,
-0.6374893785,
0.831582427,
-0.0010656873,
0.6029954553,
-0.7141686082,
0.0353824943,
-0.1353026032,
-0.0121643106,
-0.0544066019,
-0.4369907081,
-0.000064723,
-0.2558004856,
-0.0254269931,
-0.3035733402,
0.241665408,
-0.6496859193,
-0.5316615105,
0.1758644432,
0.7139555812,
0.1912561804,
0.3394008279,
-0.7308738828,
0.2249564081,
-0.1208668202,
-0.159024328,
0.132756874,
0.2198921144,
-0.3125541508,
0.9405586123,
0.5737136602,
0.4444797635,
0.2910517156,
-0.1260835826,
0.3983769417,
-0.7822669744,
-0.3827775121,
-0.8727889657,
0.3687246144,
-0.0557965226,
-0.2609224021,
0.677761972,
0.2435391992,
0.4572148323,
-0.4481090605,
0.9258205891,
-0.1134879142,
0.3696037829,
-0.6622719169,
0.9470832944,
-0.6813333631,
0.5921168923,
-0.6772434115,
-0.9503873587,
-0.1878706217,
0.2590193748,
-0.0421141423,
-0.2226930857,
0.944576323,
0.464645952,
0.2272018641,
0.4379511178,
-0.0159068182,
0.5343108773,
0.374781698,
0.1712287366,
1.1335852146,
-0.4444585741,
-0.0111909565,
0.3750414252,
0.0407792293,
-0.1432244778,
-1.0067193508,
-0.4621801078,
-0.937043786,
-0.758384645,
-0.0850230828,
0.3565546572,
0.6997930408,
0.4178000391,
-0.7255627513,
-0.5700263381,
-0.2796494663,
-0.2218238115,
-0.1772803962,
-0.196008414,
0.3420790434,
-0.3701329231,
-0.7700141668,
0.6498377919,
0.3916095197,
0.3837433159,
-0.6212857962,
0.0612545684,
-0.3937383592,
0.4889304042,
0.7504086494,
0.702493608,
-0.7576397657,
-0.4899616838,
0.1955722123,
0.0214891098,
-0.2212425768,
0.9316177964,
-0.7979283929,
0.2636518776,
0.1788511425,
0.3190540075,
0.4396053553,
-0.5109428763,
0.9837587476,
-0.3847158551,
0.092802614,
0.1081408486,
0.5001772046,
0.2722569406,
0.2127749622,
0.4205851555,
0.6369069815,
-0.4835233092,
-1.3986902237,
0.3221693933,
-0.7846160531,
-0.7108030915,
1.025554657,
0.3346289396,
-0.2603701651,
-0.210804224,
-0.0341125503,
0.0770770982,
-0.1142538339,
1.0296519995,
0.6547372341,
-0.178586036,
-0.3082003891,
-0.6503589153,
0.7200226188,
0.4795274734,
-0.5859203339,
-0.1313596368,
0.3391361535,
0.5113901496,
0.6193957329,
0.2480654866,
-0.2875359356,
-0.1002065092,
-0.3206044137,
0.2202735692,
0.2734256089,
-0.2786034644,
-0.3399389982,
0.1018626913,
0.0706247315,
0.1907570213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01920v1 | To Forget or Not? Towards Practical Knowledge Unlearning for Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:34:16 | 2024-07-02T03:34:16 | Bozhong Tian, Xiaozhuan Liang, Siyuan Cheng, Qingbin Liu, Mengru Wang, Dianbo Sui, Xi Chen, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | Large Language Models (LLMs) trained on extensive corpora inevitably retain
sensitive data, such as personal privacy information and copyrighted material.
Recent advancements in knowledge unlearning involve updating LLM parameters to
erase specific knowledge. However, current unlearning paradigms are mired in
vague forgetting boundaries, often erasing knowledge indiscriminately. In this
work, we introduce KnowUnDo, a benchmark containing copyrighted content and
user privacy domains to evaluate if the unlearning process inadvertently erases
essential knowledge. Our findings indicate that existing unlearning methods
often suffer from excessive unlearning. To address this, we propose a simple
yet effective method, MemFlex, which utilizes gradient information to precisely
target and unlearn sensitive parameters. Experimental results show that MemFlex
is superior to existing methods in both precise knowledge unlearning and
general knowledge retaining of LLMs. Code and dataset will be released at
https://github.com/zjunlp/KnowUnDo. | [
-0.2712265551,
-0.5113424063,
0.3416798711,
-0.0327198431,
-0.1403002739,
0.0797433704,
-0.3566445112,
-0.1247402355,
-0.3602747619,
0.6105114818,
-0.5734282136,
-0.4855305254,
-0.5045602918,
-0.3033113182,
-0.3223850727,
1.0387352705,
0.0195070989,
-0.0921250954,
-0.2186020166,
-0.3740681708,
-0.3166329563,
-0.3630369604,
-0.5475230217,
-0.5451455116,
0.5626190901,
0.528955996,
0.3608721197,
0.4226104915,
-0.1439313889,
0.2732408941,
-0.3601211607,
0.3279230893,
-0.8721449375,
-0.0120312981,
-0.5461555719,
-0.4511372447,
-0.1892909259,
-0.2518856227,
0.7115796804,
1.0701431036,
-0.4220480621,
0.1551561952,
0.1904977411,
0.8597488999,
-1.0913844109,
-0.1158565506,
-0.7012089491,
0.1804680973,
0.0688462704,
-0.2116398215,
-0.335927248,
-0.2373203486,
0.0570354313,
-0.6427792907,
0.2188329697,
0.1787057519,
0.5259065032,
0.2499539256,
-0.1699198484,
-0.3036613166,
-0.7738310695,
1.0745221376,
-0.7330003977,
0.5917484164,
0.494528383,
0.2434341758,
-0.2703083754,
-0.5832422972,
-0.4397022724,
0.2382704765,
0.2320412546,
0.0366795696,
-0.3716759086,
-0.2127533704,
0.3586860299,
0.1810700744,
-0.4049028158,
0.1847531945,
-0.6435130239,
-0.3890527487,
0.3434552848,
-0.1339625567,
0.0679915473,
0.1206086501,
-0.6559187174,
-0.0190996621,
-1.1712778807,
-0.0665347129,
0.3926542103,
-0.1480852515,
0.1059410796,
0.3711476624,
-0.0759102851,
0.5058602095,
-0.2020242214,
-0.1512435973,
0.459228307,
0.2131347209,
-0.2218962163,
-0.1024296805,
0.73656708,
0.1704608202,
0.6226264834,
-0.6618462205,
-0.3251435757,
-0.6810675263,
0.1814182997,
-0.543319881,
0.0039101602,
0.3068047464,
-0.1405062377,
0.3267881274,
-0.1222345233,
-0.7037129998,
-0.3774005771,
-0.4469313622,
0.372831434,
-0.6830097437,
-0.3543058634,
0.0818267837,
-0.219493106,
0.0893722847,
0.4689471126,
-0.8029558063,
0.2828384638,
0.64620471,
0.526278019,
0.1021094322,
-0.6169781685,
-0.5647270083,
0.3306459486,
-0.3141221106,
0.3174177408,
-0.4979579747,
-0.3190709949,
0.0744759142,
-0.1267329752,
0.0082220044,
-1.0071029663,
0.4035151899,
-0.7750178576,
0.1509597003,
-0.3447028697,
-1.0161927938,
-0.4148248434,
0.1780889928,
-0.5185510516,
0.7193579078,
0.3392228484,
-0.5831463337,
0.2463773042,
0.0855810419,
-0.2137284279,
-0.0897782445,
-0.1608500481,
-0.5357207656,
0.0640372932,
-0.1673499197,
0.7516010404,
-0.2464545369,
0.6538819671,
-0.5584967136,
-0.3994976282,
0.3581992686,
-0.2982882261,
0.7500753403,
0.3561753035,
-0.303619504,
-0.2860760093,
-0.8950284719,
-0.0594450049,
-0.0086025586,
-0.5134615898,
-0.5156309009,
-0.2182902247,
-0.230397597,
0.2244251668,
0.2811076045,
-0.5993962884,
-0.2118099779,
-0.1512909681,
0.5128779411,
1.0310920477,
-0.0249715727,
0.6783897877,
-0.5174714327,
0.2919481695,
0.0483139195,
-0.0008117853,
-0.109265998,
-0.1130416915,
-0.7201648355,
-0.2784423828,
0.1690106392,
0.3535857499,
-0.5956296325,
0.4082183838,
-0.1052640453,
-0.3276960552,
-0.2599786222,
0.7793085575,
0.8018776178,
0.6676362753,
0.3577086329,
0.0436805189,
-0.2871764898,
-0.7228805423,
-0.5200843811,
0.1817195714,
-0.19092457,
0.4074043036,
0.4672345519,
-0.1680261046,
0.7473793626,
-0.4381938577,
-0.5730797052,
-0.0939814895,
0.1688601971,
-0.0967565551,
0.4650602341,
0.3511396646,
-0.6175423861,
0.0089934468,
-0.1323841512,
-1.0266407728,
0.1533040851,
0.0849699825,
0.1614583731,
0.1896594465,
0.7560828924,
-0.3385266364,
0.0595857836,
0.3950205445,
-0.1412815154,
0.2914932966,
-0.6703307033,
-0.0585416183,
-0.7883027792,
0.3960035741,
-0.3489990532,
-0.2901794016,
-0.6075729728,
-0.1989445984,
0.3874171376,
-0.0308816787,
-0.7503560781,
0.9190784097,
-0.7019915581,
0.1363285333,
-0.1381721497,
0.1168685257,
0.0144245373,
0.8235172629,
-0.0401950255,
0.63396281,
0.3471793532,
-0.8882293105,
-0.1723609716,
0.0978657752,
-0.3068245053,
0.2972265482,
-0.3655210137,
0.3869046867,
-0.297333777,
-0.3114389479,
-0.8187376857,
0.1310295165,
0.0306625422,
-0.3728105724,
0.6310642362,
-0.1537983716,
-0.6630447507,
-0.0663837194,
-0.4389722347,
0.5298677087,
0.5884478688,
-0.6391952038,
0.4370946288,
0.5766484737,
0.021168571,
-1.0084095001,
-0.457282871,
-0.1602142155,
-0.3380526006,
-0.2913898528,
0.0085705146,
-0.1026463211,
-0.0629494265,
-0.0807086378,
-0.1414978951,
-0.2280046791,
0.1060747132,
0.2572909296,
-0.1665758193,
0.145525679,
0.4661843181,
0.0694724843,
-0.1705803275,
0.0088346303,
-0.4061126709,
0.52068156,
-0.0048521832,
-0.2827923298,
0.0151646575,
0.0861749575,
0.3903377354,
-0.1422256082,
0.7342687249,
0.4245356917,
-0.60718292,
-0.8043226004,
-0.7951716781,
-0.0767446831,
-0.4832022786,
0.3026584089,
-0.1017165929,
-1.1373394728,
0.7182961702,
-0.6070050001,
0.0772000402,
0.0957160965,
0.2454525828,
-0.1130249351,
0.3467419446,
0.8044990897,
-0.2102847844,
0.2498811334,
-0.3947534561,
0.2110347003,
-0.9072809815,
-0.3980158269,
-0.3751544654,
-0.2055104375,
-0.1601506919,
-0.4472945333,
0.1450203806,
0.3804527223,
-0.467156589,
0.1657730937,
-0.07075762,
0.5292745233,
0.6643399,
0.1804811358,
0.4852811992,
0.0550826006,
-0.1141416356,
-0.0257769916,
-0.7439610958,
-0.3747145236,
1.4871965647,
0.1277244687,
0.8083813787,
0.0739379525,
0.6518694758,
0.4026983678,
0.2246108204,
-0.3951451778,
0.3544254899,
-0.1394511759,
-0.5723055601,
-0.4595694542,
-0.755474925,
-1.0016247034,
0.0293360725,
-0.0413596295,
-0.7140554786,
0.230001837,
0.3517988622,
-0.2709292173,
0.7660534382,
-0.56442976,
0.6588535309,
-0.0365221836,
-0.7049787045,
-0.1966395974,
-0.3875605166,
0.3224743605,
-0.5662863255,
0.5448848605,
-0.2884669304,
-0.2125540525,
0.9779934883,
-0.4411350191,
0.9739757776,
-0.2365139574,
-0.116254665,
0.3353054523,
0.1516296417,
0.3839445412,
-0.0432194173,
-0.2252743989,
0.3213968277,
-0.2108660489,
-0.3923983872,
-0.4705711007,
0.7768508196,
-0.6717047691,
-0.3132583797,
-0.1265203804,
-0.3823494911,
-0.3679720163,
0.4389738441,
0.367052108,
0.1945887506,
-0.3530448377,
0.0305055864,
1.147292614,
-0.3851732314,
0.5108245611,
0.9053866863,
0.1015040874,
-0.4582155943,
1.2699894905,
0.3393524885,
0.1489906758,
0.610676527,
0.1311646849,
-0.2585347295,
-0.5163925886,
-0.3102092743,
0.6597674489,
-0.8690846562,
-0.338249892,
-0.5659954548,
-0.0496181808,
-0.0830635428,
-0.145783186,
-0.6461698413,
-0.2705744505,
-0.3530169427,
-0.0042198314,
0.2188898027,
0.6893718243,
-0.1804833263,
0.2089558691,
-0.7749094963,
0.1450836509,
0.1476808637,
0.6400099993,
0.3296779692,
-0.7252044082,
-0.0960305184,
0.0816850141,
-0.2586787641,
-0.2770622969,
0.345215112,
0.2822149396,
0.8407641053,
0.6959432364,
0.2605274916,
0.2629627287,
-0.5105235577,
0.1867704391,
0.501470387,
-0.9672812819,
0.3690471649,
-0.3426282406,
0.3161404133,
0.5723203421,
0.4951224029,
-0.5544118285,
-0.3840289712,
-0.8595683575,
-0.9282711148,
0.5615711212,
-0.252990216,
0.2167635113,
0.2126286924,
0.6020042896,
0.4682504237,
0.6441308856,
-0.3627550602,
-0.3313618302,
0.1825283319,
-0.1020546779,
-0.2900298834,
-0.5019775629,
-0.1249322966,
0.0361194052,
0.5737359524,
0.1200212687,
-0.0895425826,
-0.0514833257,
-0.4920527935,
-0.1133819595,
0.4168989062,
0.4902809262,
1.1352217197,
-0.2784929574,
0.2649692595,
0.2652238309,
-0.4559240341,
0.1429103464,
-0.2250923067,
-0.4086933136,
-0.2928984165,
0.4543079138,
0.2884911001,
0.5415377617,
-1.1820013523,
0.6600884795,
0.1376519352,
-0.4832568467,
-0.5546425581,
0.3029711843,
0.2737002671,
0.1144335642,
0.1573266536,
0.1255479306,
0.1186543554,
-0.5368798971,
0.437677592,
0.2916962206,
-0.6015381217,
-0.3315864801,
0.7328609228,
-0.0428533852,
0.0341023318,
0.6568729281,
-0.0322363563,
-0.3343889713,
0.3218355179,
0.3610742986,
0.5642127395,
-0.456156522,
0.0371306464,
0.3085110188,
0.2078945041,
-0.2477019429,
0.1308183968,
-0.1213614941,
-0.7170935273,
-0.1050430611,
-0.4075107872,
-0.3317672312,
0.525133729,
-0.5651630163,
0.1001016721,
-1.0082862377,
0.1956067979,
-0.0502383709,
-0.0868085027,
-0.7308200002,
0.2401302904,
0.020259345,
0.8269025683,
-0.7828317285,
0.6679362059,
0.4273804128,
-0.3150663376,
-0.8217916489,
-0.3130679429,
0.1225624606,
-1.0368930101,
0.3403887749,
0.0038303696,
-0.2358570993,
-0.1128484607,
-0.5413017869,
-0.6393712759,
0.9863960147,
0.6677055359,
-0.7653089166,
0.4444975555,
0.181909889,
0.3372233212,
-0.0767744258,
0.0532271042,
0.430872649,
0.2471423745,
0.2102409452,
-0.5640479922,
0.0755280778,
-0.1777272671,
-0.4015020132,
0.20913212,
-0.7558456063,
0.9577989578,
-0.5153495669,
-0.1094008908,
-0.1536504775,
0.3196945786,
-0.023666475,
0.4695274234,
0.3485565782,
0.7272058129,
1.3276252747,
0.1640869975,
0.678329885,
-0.0549636185,
0.3125933707,
1.3185396194,
-0.1599445492,
0.7664467692,
0.4119178057,
-0.0070135542,
-0.1985664368,
0.2836566865,
0.0949902982,
0.5295995474,
0.4849996865,
-0.3308164477,
-0.2533941269,
0.1514380872,
-0.2961801589,
0.2475776523,
0.2629956901,
-0.2599730194,
-0.4156087637,
0.0778665915,
0.6738296747,
0.2761299312,
-0.3476082683,
1.0096956491,
0.3116782904,
-0.6309977174,
1.0266863108,
-0.0292914417,
0.3911357522,
-0.7222592831,
0.0143209035,
-0.5340242982,
0.7912384272,
-0.1825898737,
-0.6777625084,
0.0844731629,
-0.1011409685,
-0.2780637443,
-0.1598012596,
0.3897968829,
-0.5912653208,
-0.2315939367,
0.8672451377,
0.6301312447,
0.2312674373,
-0.2567248046,
-0.5844843984,
-0.1831803322,
0.2248821855,
-0.1061000004,
0.6493892074,
0.6070884466,
-0.062663503,
1.1745411158,
0.5357897282,
0.0168316122,
0.0836000293,
0.2830398977,
1.0114349127,
-0.6190149188,
-0.022650864,
-0.6769484878,
0.1973030567,
-0.0319352187,
-0.4083908498,
0.7513744831,
0.7591046095,
1.0183744431,
0.0130117936,
0.8688499928,
0.475667268,
0.8050438166,
-0.6579936743,
0.908629179,
-0.8253008127,
0.6517609358,
-0.1457819343,
-0.9411258698,
-0.3390016258,
0.1576669216,
-0.2629196346,
0.1793813556,
0.5226057768,
0.6964088082,
-0.2515675128,
0.0400645882,
0.655487299,
0.2125922292,
0.1357691735,
0.7622968554,
0.7818421721,
-0.293104738,
0.5691150427,
-0.3403671086,
-0.4025480747,
-0.0479904748,
-0.7975013852,
-1.0757632256,
-0.4607329667,
-0.2339618951,
-0.2284090221,
0.3962899745,
0.4952266514,
0.4821998775,
-0.9330710173,
-0.2457246333,
0.0371306241,
0.3722955585,
-0.0795552656,
-0.0491321981,
0.476454854,
-0.4041589499,
-0.5050166249,
0.0993739814,
0.2236039788,
0.055566296,
-0.024963161,
-0.2845927477,
-0.2230810821,
-0.1438912302,
0.2741734385,
0.6851152182,
-0.3784793019,
0.0226157196,
-0.0874531046,
0.2388897091,
-0.0098174885,
0.9167509079,
-0.6949005723,
0.4005428255,
0.2594762743,
0.5360613465,
0.4676338434,
-0.1010985598,
0.6480173469,
-0.9465988874,
0.1917740852,
0.0756251067,
0.5585591197,
0.566618979,
-0.3231016099,
0.3349358141,
0.0719833151,
-0.4083015621,
-0.6118104458,
-0.1661776006,
-0.6573549509,
-0.7123993039,
1.1180024147,
-0.5298275352,
-0.3649917245,
-0.3169778883,
0.1847445518,
0.0624969825,
-0.5100242496,
0.720404923,
0.3890310228,
0.4691370428,
-0.2331370562,
-0.6366215944,
0.481531769,
0.4122173488,
-0.3457525373,
0.5325316191,
0.3484273851,
0.750997901,
-0.0509949028,
0.7189193964,
-0.1915718913,
0.1993295848,
-0.1131035239,
0.1549795568,
-0.309789598,
-0.4236420095,
-0.3475749493,
0.2311740071,
0.0515065379,
0.0550522432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01911v1 | Investigating the Effects of Large-Scale Pseudo-Stereo Data and Different Speech Foundation Model on Dialogue Generative Spoken Language Model | 2024-07-02T03:22:41 | 2024-07-02T03:22:41 | Yu-Kuan Fu, Cheng-Kuang Lee, Hsiu-Hsuan Wang, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent efforts in Spoken Dialogue Modeling aim to synthesize spoken dialogue
without the need for direct transcription, thereby preserving the wealth of
non-textual information inherent in speech. However, this approach faces a
challenge when speakers talk simultaneously, requiring stereo dialogue data
with speakers recorded on separate channels, a notably scarce resource. To
address this, we have developed an innovative pipeline capable of transforming
single-channel dialogue data into pseudo-stereo data. This expanded our
training dataset from a mere 2,000 to an impressive 17,600 hours, significantly
enriching the diversity and quality of the training examples available. The
inclusion of this pseudo-stereo data has proven to be effective in improving
the performance of spoken dialogue language models. Additionally, we explored
the use of discrete units of different speech foundation models for spoken
dialogue generation. | [
-0.656370461,
-0.7362641692,
0.2931155562,
-0.0075457925,
-0.4153659344,
-0.0954728648,
-0.0483717285,
-0.4161164761,
0.2587635219,
0.6379768848,
-0.5980918407,
-0.3704241216,
-0.2663694918,
0.1336164474,
-0.5435287356,
0.7789446712,
0.5279790163,
0.4618839622,
-0.1442909241,
-0.0547592454,
-0.3542384207,
-0.5283367038,
-0.5829309225,
0.1201287508,
-0.0769589543,
0.3822409213,
0.5034508705,
0.1071047336,
0.1104043871,
0.3407958746,
0.078580305,
-0.115784578,
-0.9091976285,
-0.0530179851,
0.0960540399,
-0.3671827316,
-0.4156000614,
0.1010971442,
1.0731562376,
0.8894936442,
-0.4278463721,
-0.2315641195,
-0.2642576993,
0.5162013173,
-0.2187993824,
0.2072031945,
-0.5026268959,
0.045284465,
-0.2221951783,
0.00687704,
-0.3423347771,
-0.3891071975,
0.6962065101,
-0.4444292784,
0.4742600918,
-0.0503122173,
0.3074864745,
0.1596217453,
-0.163378343,
-0.1399410516,
-1.0235037804,
0.5435150266,
-0.8908221126,
0.5503771901,
0.2389200628,
0.401446104,
-0.1054195762,
-0.9850534797,
-0.6688808799,
-0.1702812761,
0.092422463,
0.1937489063,
-0.1133131534,
0.3106967211,
0.314145267,
0.5198182464,
-0.476903975,
-0.3025226295,
-0.4627849162,
-0.3670171201,
0.6418706179,
0.1513844877,
0.2320827544,
-0.163893044,
-0.1524618417,
-0.3844105899,
-0.768320322,
-0.1170687973,
0.3336421847,
0.4210521579,
-0.3444629312,
0.6369100213,
-0.3569306135,
0.9451223016,
-0.0857104063,
-0.2216641009,
0.3181020617,
-0.739331007,
-0.2351136208,
0.4679243565,
0.9428503513,
0.2699836195,
0.1533211023,
0.0085029453,
-0.0353677981,
-0.0751494542,
0.1324219555,
-0.9700116515,
-0.4493006766,
-0.0914346129,
-0.2561969757,
-0.0539654978,
0.0904164463,
-0.8976675272,
-0.1192324236,
-0.4361913204,
0.1287460178,
-0.3775674403,
-0.4776351452,
0.150017634,
-0.1586537361,
0.0907908231,
0.1526070088,
-0.7387264371,
0.0944851562,
0.2570305765,
0.9163935781,
0.2262525856,
0.1877541393,
-0.5270216465,
-0.110537596,
-0.5553841591,
0.3346974254,
-0.5909709334,
-0.8370682001,
-0.2244757116,
-0.1745724529,
-0.0902158767,
-0.5346227288,
0.1654473543,
-0.2902271748,
0.5251951218,
-0.1280328035,
-0.315235883,
0.1032109186,
-0.1046594605,
-0.7081300616,
0.7389323711,
0.5325733423,
-0.8162631392,
0.1083541438,
-0.5000047088,
-0.3696681261,
0.092146337,
-0.3719557226,
-0.3951409459,
0.228837654,
0.1366021633,
0.0880235583,
-0.5340989828,
0.2930446863,
-0.3460779786,
-0.1649134159,
0.2253181487,
-0.4874209166,
0.8087208867,
0.0976122916,
-0.3389683962,
-0.0962944329,
-0.9970864654,
-0.1870413125,
-0.0977984369,
0.0415679105,
-0.2536532879,
-0.2201304734,
-0.1040464789,
0.5307093859,
-0.1624473333,
-0.7681639791,
0.0030833534,
-0.8022974133,
0.4841415882,
0.4938386381,
0.0647057369,
0.5043050051,
-0.0899182707,
0.5692766309,
-0.0138881449,
-0.182258442,
-0.0047220369,
-0.7000458241,
-0.6464681029,
-0.5337440968,
0.4396167397,
0.3339830637,
-0.7380263209,
0.1827253401,
-0.3018737733,
-0.3836233318,
-0.7475760579,
-0.0720238164,
0.3975198865,
0.8291535974,
0.2062242478,
-0.8323047757,
-0.7098439336,
-0.8503377438,
0.5105075836,
-0.5254045725,
-0.1244348735,
0.4756104946,
0.1426214874,
-0.2944590449,
1.4689301252,
-0.2383639961,
0.0682721585,
-0.3923248053,
0.3841366768,
-0.0080719665,
0.2696480155,
0.6643666029,
-0.8042515516,
-0.335277319,
-0.2098443806,
-0.7289417386,
-0.2524226904,
-0.1164567396,
-0.1569770128,
-0.0986930653,
0.5504906774,
-0.6349496245,
0.403773874,
0.7458541989,
0.0970435292,
0.604927659,
0.0930271968,
0.1080812886,
-1.0208162069,
-0.2035827488,
-0.1876504719,
-0.2430928349,
-0.8975195885,
-0.5382249951,
-0.2115816325,
-0.5351672769,
-0.5197365284,
0.1688529253,
-0.2998027503,
-0.3760422468,
-0.2659940124,
0.0201574471,
-0.2617714107,
0.1891290545,
0.6477070451,
0.9713276029,
0.7214888334,
-0.4198967516,
0.5882633924,
0.4453979433,
-0.6855809093,
0.2169384807,
-0.7385994196,
0.2572895885,
-0.2027013004,
0.732349515,
-1.2901138067,
-0.1945218444,
0.1334821135,
-0.2668847144,
0.2601206303,
-0.1163099855,
-0.2346028984,
-0.1877180338,
0.0903228074,
0.5257749557,
0.4962520897,
-0.3842271566,
0.5344804525,
0.4076502323,
-0.6467306614,
-0.1754501313,
-0.3900426328,
0.1085811779,
-0.3489077091,
-0.9520214796,
0.3236683607,
-0.1865657866,
-0.3425745964,
-0.1497572213,
0.0035099217,
0.2187834531,
-0.2868702412,
0.2225236297,
0.2177515626,
-0.4262468517,
-0.0575177111,
0.0642566457,
-0.0799767151,
0.1560132056,
-0.2514627576,
0.7614428401,
0.0202666447,
-0.2053212225,
-0.6790525317,
0.4069874883,
0.7947075963,
-0.1062884852,
1.0731244087,
0.1019316763,
0.0191585254,
-0.2629473209,
-0.3232854307,
-0.3207299411,
-0.3913959265,
0.3137905598,
-0.4797389805,
-0.8261035085,
0.2230433077,
-0.3178986013,
-0.0905436054,
0.1890994012,
0.5525327325,
-0.1716376543,
0.8875973225,
0.4774723947,
-0.2203560323,
0.530456841,
-0.3879253268,
0.4327688515,
-0.6308662295,
-0.2569674551,
-0.2854086459,
0.1632368714,
-0.4293135703,
-0.6123759151,
0.4488238096,
0.114283599,
0.212158978,
0.415884167,
-0.1125363708,
0.0105840685,
0.4473718703,
-0.0028015652,
0.055996839,
0.0616861731,
-0.1449810416,
-0.0535904318,
-0.8705333471,
-0.124477461,
1.2394586802,
0.2663209736,
0.51690799,
0.0754036605,
0.5282574296,
0.2496168315,
-0.0875534937,
-0.4271834195,
0.5295867324,
0.0635991916,
-0.5737279654,
-0.4970733225,
-0.6636116505,
-0.474088788,
0.2266323864,
-0.0360137299,
-0.3466881812,
0.495295316,
0.1559936404,
-0.2855542302,
-0.0875501782,
-0.8411381245,
0.6596630216,
-0.1880360097,
-0.1233512983,
-0.2155075073,
-0.8423969746,
0.4435703158,
-0.4667434692,
0.3764999807,
0.2925778925,
0.6951627135,
0.727027297,
-0.7252998352,
0.8148209453,
-0.1912193894,
-0.1245664582,
0.5227457285,
-0.2225839198,
0.4989342391,
0.1212394014,
-0.0646706671,
0.3615554869,
-0.3063569963,
-0.3410558701,
-0.4163658917,
0.5196092725,
-0.87453866,
-0.5227754116,
-0.2608744204,
-0.5648544431,
-0.7176374793,
-0.2259632796,
0.4651409388,
0.6412735581,
-0.6365717053,
0.4165950119,
0.7850323319,
-0.2734111547,
0.3445559442,
0.4977685809,
0.0592235625,
-0.4174007475,
0.6643603444,
-0.0415276997,
0.8690219522,
0.1386710256,
-0.0115636047,
-0.5493565798,
-0.5961622596,
-0.5887541771,
0.3700755835,
-0.3582085669,
0.1799049377,
-0.6740962863,
-0.4309009314,
-0.8557068706,
0.173469469,
-0.6262956858,
-0.6754890084,
-0.1382876635,
-0.3306660354,
0.1367603689,
0.4678304791,
-0.2679312825,
0.5406092405,
-0.7152327895,
0.5083485246,
0.4892810583,
0.0781264976,
-0.1854659468,
-0.6407694817,
-0.1845281422,
0.4671676457,
0.2334663719,
-0.8351145983,
0.5057833195,
0.2000922561,
0.4869767427,
0.6015567183,
0.0073542451,
0.6841011047,
-0.5156265497,
0.9800788164,
0.6027805209,
-0.7775976658,
0.5427063704,
-0.402995646,
0.3349862397,
0.443680495,
0.3206901252,
-0.3791239262,
-0.2247125953,
-0.542765379,
-0.7113008499,
1.1680262089,
0.6163083315,
0.087720044,
0.0747984871,
-0.2409817427,
0.0588162765,
0.3103363812,
-0.3866587281,
-0.1677063555,
-0.8137022853,
0.1348644197,
-0.4287641346,
-0.2878488898,
-0.3059845269,
-0.3641811013,
0.7294414043,
0.2605503798,
0.3131756186,
0.1204481497,
-0.0297160652,
0.0309437886,
0.282014519,
0.5372164249,
0.4658425748,
-0.3736442626,
-0.1216138154,
-0.0687023997,
-0.3133374751,
0.0972100347,
0.3095601797,
0.0177743826,
0.3416016996,
0.3652068675,
1.1092324257,
0.1079050899,
-0.6738852262,
0.3087043464,
-0.1614470482,
-0.2209458947,
-0.2898601294,
-0.0787175745,
0.2568893731,
-0.051157359,
0.0501004606,
-0.1417577565,
0.1580667794,
-0.8607134223,
0.3791566789,
0.3896821439,
-0.2839756608,
-0.2140025347,
0.2678484619,
0.4920462668,
-0.1585112214,
1.061724782,
0.0259440765,
-0.3943589032,
0.3915668428,
0.6871466637,
0.6050448418,
-0.6631340981,
0.4206970632,
0.4376490712,
-0.0053197355,
-0.1700001061,
-0.2845717371,
-0.3685195744,
-0.8015150428,
-0.1794873029,
-0.7309735417,
-0.154501617,
0.2861860693,
-0.6172633171,
0.1168082505,
-0.289789319,
-0.0885563195,
-0.0353277363,
-0.4637936652,
-0.2637863457,
0.450109154,
0.3908834159,
0.5760900974,
-1.1449418068,
1.0084061623,
0.2832352817,
-0.3302736878,
-0.6830693483,
-0.0748844072,
0.1523626,
-0.4378320575,
0.4632700682,
-0.1053594276,
-0.5166091919,
0.0400142968,
-0.300847888,
-0.7643182278,
0.7057828903,
0.2607122064,
-1.2883188725,
-0.2732956111,
0.7746953964,
0.6649575233,
-0.6186245084,
0.2291530818,
0.8477645516,
0.0241014306,
0.6049020886,
-1.0444501638,
-0.5248746872,
-0.2901382148,
0.1605289429,
0.2094894201,
-0.3933730423,
0.6536098123,
0.2812609076,
-0.1814932972,
0.1419149637,
0.5738777518,
0.3068996072,
0.2426201701,
0.6547323465,
0.7318557501,
0.5343233347,
-0.1174000129,
0.9828874469,
-0.136573121,
0.0372688025,
1.2842745781,
-0.354424715,
0.3990712166,
0.2326387167,
-0.107922025,
0.5046367049,
0.4776360691,
0.3656661212,
0.9469345212,
0.1782949567,
-0.6626217365,
-0.4318007529,
-0.0858539715,
-0.6784051657,
0.5746035576,
0.5944409966,
-0.453258872,
-0.0938267633,
0.276062578,
-0.4617604017,
-0.1054020971,
-0.0865905881,
0.9221581221,
0.1637633592,
-0.5095816851,
0.5655326843,
-0.1870978922,
0.2972461581,
-0.724334538,
-0.040802855,
-0.2791933715,
-0.0935949832,
-0.0006263651,
-0.2841540873,
0.1686140001,
0.0990051553,
-0.0876011848,
-0.3318191469,
0.3664347529,
-0.5690411925,
-0.5031357408,
0.318099767,
0.2495060861,
0.3125543892,
0.0787221044,
-0.5395565033,
0.0575565994,
0.366356343,
-0.0239478424,
0.3235012889,
0.4298605621,
-0.053300485,
0.1975114048,
0.6749555469,
0.1858081967,
0.2428461909,
0.4130014777,
0.9075602293,
-0.4269852936,
-0.508654356,
-0.367112875,
0.6928848624,
-0.1796457171,
-0.1641020924,
0.6127678156,
0.8224503398,
0.8478611708,
-0.0871843174,
1.001921773,
-0.1787638813,
0.6155163646,
-0.4775818288,
0.4231216609,
-0.2088240534,
0.2888873816,
-0.533044517,
-1.1417841911,
0.1826761812,
0.7078122497,
-0.416908145,
0.0164239146,
0.5540583134,
1.0086927414,
-0.1694567651,
0.3983635306,
0.3561091721,
0.31130144,
0.2872112393,
0.3480060697,
0.930740118,
-0.1641914845,
0.3984707892,
-0.3335959315,
-0.2487794161,
-0.0870262161,
-0.3379816115,
-0.8984823823,
-0.7316792607,
-0.3046276569,
-0.3191665709,
0.0739936084,
0.5888883471,
0.9980542064,
-0.8827853203,
-0.2944555283,
-0.5266262889,
-0.5871146917,
0.2634254992,
-0.2079471797,
0.1189233065,
0.2178525627,
-0.8441764116,
0.9086899161,
0.1908770949,
0.1616885066,
-0.0841869488,
-0.2104275078,
-0.1386667341,
0.1904954165,
0.5812354088,
0.3573002219,
-0.4959846139,
-0.0523324385,
-0.1602107435,
0.0328360312,
0.056672439,
1.0089205503,
-0.8490918875,
0.9892705679,
0.536329329,
0.3662138879,
1.0041429996,
0.2788368165,
1.1439114809,
-0.768864572,
0.4434794784,
0.3366440535,
0.2446400374,
0.5023576617,
-0.0069185011,
0.2936459482,
0.321611017,
-0.152110517,
-0.8063979745,
0.3060964942,
-0.9752234817,
-0.2694728971,
0.9251717925,
-0.0555857085,
0.3961985409,
-0.1418977827,
-0.2689976692,
0.4606197178,
-0.3993406296,
0.7286517024,
0.8038065434,
-0.3003325164,
-0.3486536145,
-0.2590857148,
0.6973724961,
0.3862628639,
-0.748650074,
-0.0542511865,
0.8946457505,
0.2175396234,
0.2356545329,
0.7652346492,
-0.2387775928,
0.2309678793,
0.2002627552,
-0.3380538523,
0.2305689454,
-0.5528336167,
-0.3320018053,
0.1953972727,
-0.2905837595,
-0.1780928522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01909v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01909v1 | Pinyin Regularization in Error Correction for Chinese Speech Recognition with Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:16:47 | 2024-07-02T03:16:47 | Zhiyuan Tang, Dong Wang, Shen Huang, Shidong Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent studies have demonstrated the efficacy of large language models (LLMs)
in error correction for automatic speech recognition (ASR). However, much of
the research focuses on the English language. This paper redirects the
attention to Chinese. Firstly, we construct a specialized benchmark dataset
aimed at error correction for Chinese ASR with 724K hypotheses-transcription
pairs, named the Chinese Hypotheses Paradise dataset (ChineseHP), which
contains a wide range of scenarios and presents significant challenges.
Subsequently, we conduct a preliminary evaluation using the dataset for both
direct-prompting and fine-tuning pre-trained LLMs. Furthermore, we propose a
straightforward method of Pinyin regularization for prompts, which involves the
transcription of Pinyin directly from text hypotheses. The experimental results
reveal that Pinyin regularization consistently enhances the error-correcting
ability of LLMs when compared with those without regularization. The dataset is
available on the website. | [
0.31964311,
-0.5273848772,
0.2763541639,
0.3339490592,
-0.3498095274,
-0.1313066334,
-0.6708920002,
-0.1990338415,
0.1001180112,
0.3427052796,
-0.2789895236,
-0.5431739688,
-0.3051822484,
0.4607347846,
-0.1516522765,
0.4264712334,
-0.2439509928,
0.5436025858,
0.2982521653,
0.0283934288,
-0.7150860429,
-0.4423948526,
-0.927763164,
-0.1087787822,
0.8559672832,
0.531570971,
0.428948015,
0.8974049687,
0.6352357864,
0.1703945249,
0.0196210295,
0.2718217969,
-0.3460439742,
-0.0650742799,
0.5437884927,
-0.2399562448,
-0.3396956623,
-0.2315729409,
1.2076694965,
0.7642782331,
-0.2196420282,
-0.0821795315,
0.2420953214,
0.5164448619,
-0.3925341666,
0.1997285336,
-0.7128347158,
0.0960406363,
-0.3043351173,
-0.3354286849,
-0.4831931591,
-0.3215275109,
-0.0756765679,
-0.5251687169,
0.246228829,
0.1404880881,
0.7347629666,
0.4730634689,
-0.2180621028,
0.0626621693,
-0.8380551934,
0.8177109361,
-0.9576331973,
0.5605073571,
0.3064595759,
0.3053334951,
-0.1950018704,
-0.6038437486,
-0.4795101583,
-0.4554047287,
-0.1102529988,
0.0847449601,
0.0639161617,
0.3452003598,
0.5765858293,
0.2224798501,
-0.542219162,
0.3219846189,
-0.3249710798,
-0.4958868921,
0.7498062849,
0.0900456235,
0.4581974149,
-0.1070235297,
0.0472117215,
-0.1370406151,
-0.9020181298,
0.2667259574,
0.1531043351,
0.8561128974,
-0.071765177,
0.3826562166,
-0.2230160385,
0.7895325422,
-0.0191448256,
-0.1380938441,
0.1507328004,
-0.2862307727,
-0.2449006587,
0.5885031223,
0.771972537,
0.2251702398,
0.2587056756,
-0.0735523924,
-0.276652962,
-0.1803884059,
-0.1178119481,
-0.6040477753,
-0.3641315401,
0.3011772335,
-0.4375629127,
0.4082862735,
0.382842809,
-0.2498793751,
-0.3330677152,
-0.3671516776,
0.4027757049,
-0.1618930846,
0.0462553129,
0.1691488475,
0.0969509557,
0.3827346265,
0.5995556712,
-0.7108383179,
0.14750655,
0.5807897449,
0.7668173313,
-0.2982326448,
-0.468636483,
-0.8137719035,
0.2090100646,
-0.6275547743,
0.6925733089,
-0.2373670787,
-0.4538207054,
0.2180075645,
0.0725344196,
-0.2204464376,
-0.6266623735,
0.8626621962,
-0.2091828436,
-0.1398930997,
-0.6870189905,
-0.4668257236,
0.0182447825,
0.0700014383,
-0.6470188498,
0.6004695892,
-0.3920146525,
-0.6391682029,
0.1772690564,
-0.5233994126,
-0.6835234165,
0.0220095813,
-0.1542423069,
-0.3719756007,
-0.1323945522,
0.2614337802,
0.2053301036,
-0.1455278695,
0.0946027637,
0.0802086443,
-0.7704966664,
0.0506778508,
-0.6075316668,
0.8370881677,
0.155859977,
-0.4039258063,
0.2556209862,
-0.7046317458,
-0.0192898456,
0.0917956531,
-0.5741707683,
-0.1575142741,
0.1307865083,
0.0107736923,
-0.147143662,
0.3333687484,
-0.6938095689,
-0.0229151715,
-0.339697361,
0.3535953462,
0.6785011888,
-0.1753249019,
0.0144150462,
-0.2498013526,
0.149462834,
0.0921274051,
0.092886135,
-0.2932231426,
-0.3986963928,
-0.8231745958,
-0.1444273442,
0.6151649356,
0.5800212026,
-0.4499542117,
0.456635952,
-0.1671835929,
-0.3236303627,
-0.5463542938,
0.1401550472,
0.3837260306,
0.6691091657,
0.3966698945,
-0.1025381684,
-0.7326148152,
-0.6389796138,
-0.3978831172,
-0.3480046988,
-0.2872505486,
0.4243627191,
-0.1301075369,
-0.2798823714,
0.6248512864,
-0.2814280093,
-0.5087839365,
-0.1721551865,
-0.0553041436,
0.2238512486,
0.6258819699,
-0.0015583715,
-0.8186476231,
-0.9060165286,
0.0389903337,
-0.280790627,
-0.13549833,
-0.0492280573,
0.0428292006,
0.316931814,
0.5786443949,
-0.4008778334,
0.2883195877,
0.3689528108,
0.0907353535,
0.6005700827,
-0.3185744882,
0.3969524205,
-0.9122091532,
0.0341571905,
0.063754119,
0.1130828038,
-0.8453416824,
-0.3073240221,
0.4521683455,
0.0503166951,
-0.299055934,
0.3667061329,
-0.513338089,
-0.0600814447,
-0.167157501,
0.1016409472,
-0.213606596,
0.3307815194,
0.0969909877,
0.6080043316,
0.4367019832,
-0.5121011734,
0.6121445894,
0.2107796669,
-0.1749364883,
-0.0356543399,
-0.8379019499,
0.1608082205,
0.0565914698,
0.3965991139,
-1.3115822077,
-0.417719841,
0.2230104059,
-0.6827406287,
0.4248293638,
0.1198252216,
-0.6697785854,
-0.4039775133,
-0.3828779459,
0.3710808456,
0.6748072505,
-0.6573817134,
0.4014618695,
0.0735748187,
-0.1484674662,
-0.6297349334,
-0.5914699435,
0.2004416138,
-0.1001448929,
-0.5303128958,
0.4301270545,
-0.1270923764,
-0.2476718575,
-0.3349847794,
-0.0387317427,
-0.1837783456,
-0.0383049436,
0.0717454478,
0.3130980134,
-0.4659188986,
-0.0285370387,
-0.2151323259,
0.0338671133,
-0.0082665514,
-0.0196068939,
0.4160628915,
0.349116385,
-0.3526787162,
-0.9960767627,
-0.0623838268,
0.2063486278,
-0.2845087647,
0.2282093018,
0.4279418588,
-0.7130660415,
-0.0589744449,
-0.6868695617,
-0.2911369205,
-0.4557382464,
0.4342088699,
-0.1624397933,
-0.6058589816,
0.6233052611,
0.4503662288,
0.2741216719,
0.3728272319,
0.3870010376,
-0.0231267475,
1.2455655336,
0.3296214342,
-0.5109139681,
0.4128058553,
0.2583518028,
0.2255051881,
-0.6799935102,
0.0675463304,
-0.8434118032,
-0.0606090501,
-0.6088213921,
-0.353634268,
0.2566325068,
-0.3127735257,
-0.1799157411,
0.0762912333,
-0.2415906042,
0.4852727652,
0.6771221161,
0.2738976479,
0.3641907871,
-0.0096121915,
0.280926317,
-0.3116244972,
-0.7179344296,
-0.2620514035,
0.8034530878,
0.2476440817,
0.8190980554,
-0.1185257435,
0.5312600732,
0.1623946577,
-0.0030845187,
-0.8565078974,
0.3696292043,
-0.4731249511,
-0.2001151741,
-0.6620195508,
-0.5982925296,
-0.9015715122,
-0.0453170277,
0.0920771733,
-0.3280948997,
-0.1218118221,
0.3901032805,
-0.7679691911,
0.1851378083,
-0.6209054589,
0.7660165429,
-0.1789640933,
-0.0673511848,
-0.0681898817,
-0.6172653437,
0.259655416,
-0.0846658871,
0.0189729407,
0.0434430987,
0.1116185412,
0.8709639907,
-0.1805051863,
0.7403957248,
-0.3865360618,
-0.3272339702,
0.2320133448,
-0.2974909842,
0.6119703054,
-0.2097094208,
-0.0774978027,
0.1771162003,
-0.175335288,
-0.2870885134,
-0.4418155253,
0.5634596348,
-0.7672535777,
-0.6771384478,
-0.1829322577,
-0.5367187262,
-0.2877824605,
0.2589259148,
0.3453859389,
0.5447441339,
0.0757154822,
0.348157078,
0.7992220521,
-0.4609502554,
0.2335346192,
0.6248509884,
0.1620871574,
-0.2671069801,
0.9266912341,
0.6367823482,
0.0552815087,
0.4326259792,
0.3552205563,
-0.2945618629,
-0.784422338,
-0.3508463204,
0.3169208467,
-0.6064298153,
-0.0456613041,
-0.4399253726,
-0.5512534976,
-0.7707184553,
0.0566611364,
-0.3055077791,
0.0111406855,
-0.4048191011,
0.2306895405,
0.1073532104,
0.4432918429,
-0.1127288342,
0.1983730048,
-1.012116909,
0.4289405942,
0.3534159064,
0.2554699779,
0.0634033754,
-0.9970413446,
-0.4712336957,
0.3118674755,
0.0473098904,
-0.5059957504,
0.2691574991,
0.2449673116,
0.6045509577,
0.4962546229,
0.2583394349,
0.9486650825,
-0.9472783208,
0.8298885822,
-0.0054683816,
-0.826622963,
0.5985938311,
-0.355001241,
0.2067055106,
0.3016979992,
0.1562642604,
-0.9640863538,
-0.2837204039,
-0.2995826006,
-0.5772352815,
0.723271966,
-0.143766731,
0.1949627846,
0.2528871894,
0.4601509571,
-0.1385139525,
-0.0998139605,
-0.4400116801,
-0.3481532335,
0.0693177581,
-0.4522681534,
-0.4066447318,
-0.3919687569,
-0.0129397782,
-0.3788744509,
0.6419001818,
-0.0517672077,
0.0741728395,
0.3395284414,
-0.0820654109,
-0.5305771232,
-0.0220254567,
0.6555362344,
0.6001785994,
-0.2924256325,
-0.0660720244,
0.3034834862,
-0.5603622198,
-0.1247578636,
0.3003863394,
-0.2049203068,
0.3108021617,
0.3840577304,
0.6360804439,
0.0458205119,
-0.7506561875,
0.3255508244,
-0.3189937472,
-0.0894898474,
-0.3931996226,
0.084299922,
-0.1796137542,
0.0611680299,
0.7218253613,
-0.3733690977,
0.1938264817,
-0.2675142586,
0.1132693812,
0.3672462404,
-0.3399395049,
-0.2657146752,
0.6981484294,
0.1455629915,
-0.3759897649,
0.545488894,
0.1787643135,
-0.6984000802,
0.734354794,
0.4444400072,
0.8497089148,
-0.5665127635,
-0.199373588,
0.7329493761,
0.3283876777,
-0.4162112176,
0.1407818496,
0.0092814183,
-0.8111354113,
-0.5002022386,
-0.1951174885,
-0.945019722,
0.1012427807,
-0.6020490527,
0.6354763508,
-0.5190716982,
0.2634193897,
-0.1675353348,
0.2186182141,
-0.0675239637,
0.3011888862,
0.3973837197,
0.8717779517,
-0.6071754098,
1.0162539482,
0.5003624558,
-0.0426516682,
-1.2776677608,
0.4428194463,
-0.1941802949,
-0.7710190415,
0.6879519224,
0.3263149858,
-0.0156740434,
0.1405991912,
-0.6982687116,
-0.8389049172,
0.9603293538,
0.3616403639,
-0.820425272,
0.0717470199,
0.1258742362,
0.4875597954,
-0.0831380486,
-0.273548454,
0.6202452183,
0.4311295152,
0.0667938441,
-1.1928570271,
-0.0502841435,
-0.0361817814,
-0.0353587791,
-0.2036040425,
-0.8711562157,
1.0418453217,
-0.3219929636,
-0.3044131398,
0.1032878757,
0.7814381123,
0.4139445722,
0.2171855122,
0.5437137485,
0.0658260435,
0.7528138757,
-0.1467059255,
0.5743427277,
-0.3193568885,
0.1721741259,
0.9865866899,
-0.468796134,
1.0137861967,
0.4160668254,
-0.3986076713,
0.1694116443,
1.0252468586,
-0.0190456454,
0.3175017536,
0.2563685775,
-0.0369703397,
-0.0339051411,
-0.1233761013,
-0.4695087671,
0.3210332394,
0.1236769408,
-0.0208370481,
0.1513212174,
-0.2745144367,
-0.0476583056,
0.0303618181,
-0.5913299918,
0.7580366135,
-0.0168057773,
-0.5176721811,
0.7378042936,
-0.069600679,
0.7936598063,
-0.6254794598,
-0.1587109119,
-0.3981201947,
0.1523935348,
-0.2663609087,
-0.2688935399,
0.0176197644,
0.1099781692,
-0.1225623041,
0.0541774519,
0.7490180135,
-0.7493069172,
-0.3563835323,
-0.0370619558,
0.0216030125,
0.2149827182,
-0.0982375666,
-0.4797495902,
0.1952096671,
0.1916911006,
-0.008097074,
0.0805475563,
0.3919405043,
0.1775102764,
0.4144685566,
0.5990165472,
0.5214407444,
0.2060368657,
0.2446901947,
0.5129763484,
-0.8041139245,
-0.5770343542,
-0.9401564598,
0.3866913021,
0.1250457764,
0.0353642926,
1.1317652464,
0.4338706434,
0.8166751862,
-0.0263720397,
0.9151699543,
0.3251315355,
0.7771371007,
-0.6356865168,
0.7236770391,
-0.5758277178,
0.2233356237,
-0.3818794191,
-0.8054668307,
-0.7559520602,
0.6406110525,
-0.1371400654,
-0.0077683162,
0.4670556188,
0.7924833894,
0.3038179576,
-0.0717799366,
0.4941619337,
0.3733524084,
0.254959166,
0.4801843166,
0.8105635643,
-0.5956643224,
0.3955294192,
-0.2701821327,
-0.0852395073,
-0.5215536356,
-0.5572067499,
-0.6338091493,
-0.440492332,
-0.2791187465,
-0.3519037664,
0.0986550376,
1.2845160961,
0.27248317,
-1.1235120296,
-0.4978409111,
0.2151036114,
0.1725195646,
-0.1903170347,
-0.1176977307,
0.7333647609,
-0.5428865552,
-0.8818976879,
0.2744610608,
0.1474334449,
0.2100847512,
-0.1004771814,
-0.401478976,
0.1983352154,
-0.0763746798,
0.2891386747,
0.407951653,
-0.7554283738,
-0.4290355742,
0.1905598193,
-0.2737294137,
0.283998549,
0.8539162278,
-0.2468931228,
0.4434374571,
0.3934368193,
0.8130583167,
-0.2175464779,
0.0894045979,
0.6356149316,
-0.522732079,
0.1143895239,
0.1271712929,
0.5341632962,
0.6568885446,
-0.3302605748,
0.1959315538,
0.2950834632,
-0.6284287572,
-1.2276518345,
-0.2350054532,
-0.8446799517,
0.1208995059,
1.4373947382,
-0.2383887768,
-0.3033226728,
-0.0877118483,
-0.5790708065,
0.5272985697,
-0.3144434988,
0.9521190524,
0.6483641267,
-0.0634901747,
-0.1886719316,
-0.3554369509,
0.7366684079,
0.4877556562,
-0.5254152417,
0.5068097115,
0.5922394395,
0.0709005594,
-0.0205814578,
0.6300382614,
0.2176254839,
0.6540973186,
0.00030136,
-0.0114928409,
0.2524313629,
-0.3515670002,
-0.6033086777,
-0.4697966278,
0.4413297474,
-0.3225057125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01906v1 | Let the Expert Stick to His Last: Expert-Specialized Fine-Tuning for Sparse Architectural Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:11:13 | 2024-07-02T03:11:13 | Zihan Wang, Deli Chen, Damai Dai, Runxin Xu, Zhuoshu Li, Y. Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is crucial for customizing Large
Language Models (LLMs) with constrained resources. Although there have been
various PEFT methods for dense-architecture LLMs, PEFT for sparse-architecture
LLMs is still underexplored. In this work, we study the PEFT method for LLMs
with the Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) architecture and the contents of this work
are mainly threefold: (1) We investigate the dispersion degree of the activated
experts in customized tasks, and found that the routing distribution for a
specific task tends to be highly concentrated, while the distribution of
activated experts varies significantly across different tasks. (2) We propose
Expert-Specialized Fine-Tuning, or ESFT, which tunes the experts most relevant
to downstream tasks while freezing the other experts and modules; experimental
results demonstrate that our method not only improves the tuning efficiency,
but also matches or even surpasses the performance of full-parameter
fine-tuning. (3) We further analyze the impact of the MoE architecture on
expert-specialized fine-tuning. We find that MoE models with finer-grained
experts are more advantageous in selecting the combination of experts that are
most relevant to downstream tasks, thereby enhancing both the training
efficiency and effectiveness. | [
-0.792337954,
-1.0734381676,
0.663726151,
0.0861157775,
-0.17505458,
0.3322557211,
-0.6113922596,
-0.3358856142,
0.1989406049,
0.4990603328,
-0.2927662134,
-0.2689562142,
-0.5994873047,
0.0604911149,
-0.2202956378,
0.6204381585,
0.1326052696,
-0.3326675594,
0.098410219,
0.1234315336,
-0.3706123829,
-0.1718251258,
-0.6474903822,
-0.2817443609,
0.3901272416,
0.4863246679,
0.7030277252,
0.8255733252,
0.1795487702,
0.444693327,
-0.2999014556,
0.4375067651,
-0.4724585414,
-0.0461530946,
-0.3519569635,
-0.2139934748,
-0.7409459352,
-0.2637491524,
0.3500482142,
0.7898426652,
-0.4245240092,
-0.0409279466,
0.317478925,
0.561555922,
-0.5944905281,
0.0463639721,
-1.1377671957,
-0.1593920588,
-0.2987183332,
-0.4292703867,
-0.3649068475,
0.2097978145,
0.1390509903,
-0.3828802407,
0.1375197619,
0.2561897635,
0.6922967434,
0.6609551907,
-0.286436975,
0.154506281,
-0.5800077915,
1.016250968,
-0.6422205567,
0.2569152713,
0.4708076715,
-0.0100564184,
-0.1981125176,
-0.1103373915,
-0.150747031,
-0.0379411764,
0.2149888128,
-0.0667331219,
-0.0502493158,
0.1946644336,
-0.2135675848,
0.1781014055,
-0.3338859677,
0.3660387099,
-0.2754074931,
0.0186823476,
0.7611604333,
0.1147135049,
-0.0950352773,
0.461943984,
-0.2803765833,
0.3661356568,
-0.6179922223,
-0.2747416794,
0.3996968269,
0.18246378,
0.1375057399,
0.2182598561,
-0.4192996323,
0.9117648005,
0.6671173573,
-0.2805402577,
0.1808174103,
0.1126381308,
-0.255936265,
-0.0008701475,
0.5813163519,
0.1473754048,
0.449940443,
-0.4252079427,
-0.3943571746,
-0.7016052008,
0.2151171118,
-0.4683275223,
-0.4979974627,
0.0234341919,
-0.2678131759,
-0.1937045902,
-0.3824770153,
-0.578969419,
-0.0187738277,
-0.5122382641,
0.4491613507,
-0.3260970712,
-0.4962894022,
0.2768799663,
-0.0265647098,
-0.0800491199,
0.2851114869,
-1.2717157602,
0.3726129234,
0.945291698,
0.5323114991,
-0.2172010541,
-0.4712341428,
-0.4948972762,
0.4869374633,
-0.3114418387,
1.0270013809,
-0.9287590981,
-0.2574881017,
-0.2683334947,
-0.4425008297,
-0.2615976632,
-0.7774773836,
0.3398167789,
-0.5944776535,
-0.4613930583,
-0.3028746843,
-0.5711229444,
-0.1296256036,
0.0606361069,
-0.1544323862,
1.0527174473,
0.1983753145,
-0.1837612838,
0.4082984626,
-0.1175421476,
-0.3510661125,
0.1872523278,
-0.4586591721,
-0.1219424009,
0.5178991556,
0.1675602794,
0.8318047523,
-0.1156249642,
0.3234168887,
-0.5853583813,
-0.5001590848,
-0.0378110036,
-0.3764049709,
0.3167437315,
0.3074754477,
-0.4154548347,
-0.347645551,
-0.8098473549,
-0.0988846421,
-0.1817671806,
-0.6677055955,
-0.4968911111,
0.2240714133,
-0.03042119,
-0.1413045526,
0.5249022245,
-0.2773833573,
0.238614589,
-0.3576365113,
0.4757807255,
1.0817309618,
-0.0164273009,
0.6345963478,
-0.4153975546,
0.1414847076,
-0.0810419172,
0.0143414335,
0.0280452631,
-0.6616508365,
-0.550676465,
-0.4852395654,
0.192886278,
0.3684144318,
-0.3507969379,
0.6287251115,
-0.1155789793,
-0.4564048946,
-0.44953686,
0.4829651713,
0.3697984815,
0.6075249314,
0.3013543785,
0.0581668876,
0.0030037232,
-1.1399972439,
-0.3052989244,
-0.0051646251,
0.118050687,
0.4596588314,
0.1667241901,
0.004698718,
0.8718827963,
-0.5741674304,
-0.0941789746,
0.0514344275,
0.2209113985,
0.3532645106,
0.6951928735,
0.8839480281,
-0.6067225933,
-0.9582832456,
0.2610295713,
0.1016181111,
-0.2480877787,
-0.1034976915,
-0.1697695106,
0.1771846265,
0.2600536644,
-0.5112021565,
-0.2996185124,
0.3702277243,
-0.1832475811,
0.2442707568,
-0.4227912724,
0.0490514077,
-0.7869291902,
-0.2983298302,
0.0051333946,
-0.1915267259,
-0.4742101133,
0.19720608,
-0.0140562039,
0.268563062,
-0.0922777131,
0.376450479,
-0.4114819467,
0.1666995883,
-0.3113487065,
-0.2700859904,
-0.2020983994,
0.8437176943,
0.0612726063,
0.634311974,
0.8167580962,
-0.5586192608,
-0.0707859024,
-0.0483338386,
-0.271268189,
0.5436760783,
-0.6543650627,
0.3435464501,
0.0330978744,
-0.4287897348,
-0.9583437443,
-0.2191403508,
0.0626615658,
-0.0904605389,
0.5763894916,
-0.292884618,
-0.5965085626,
0.1724960655,
-0.1401291043,
0.2251597941,
0.7957604527,
-0.1497927159,
0.7743330598,
0.4577378035,
-0.3892327845,
-0.3509331048,
-0.6232994795,
-0.0326383524,
-0.3344762027,
-0.6838649511,
0.6920042634,
-0.3122252822,
-0.298309356,
0.0507442392,
-0.241597712,
-0.4813203216,
0.4472324252,
-0.1069592386,
-0.2861773372,
-0.3757526875,
-0.1637467742,
0.7682837248,
-0.1921531707,
-0.2562003136,
0.0445647463,
0.4751569629,
-0.1802711785,
-0.4863909483,
-0.24986808,
0.6424509287,
0.4998349547,
-0.2773369551,
0.7539106607,
0.6673811674,
-0.1469226629,
-0.3616781533,
-1.0841836929,
0.0659734681,
-0.5802676678,
0.501785934,
-0.4969780147,
-0.9132624269,
0.4779914618,
-0.1833091378,
0.3205955327,
0.33262375,
0.7389722466,
-0.1449433118,
1.1596467495,
0.7885042429,
-0.2366795838,
0.3852117658,
-0.0453167856,
0.0467548296,
-0.5713202357,
-0.0978082195,
-0.6389481425,
-0.5411445498,
-0.2316935658,
-0.2417567372,
0.4623448849,
0.2462456673,
-0.4113899767,
0.0634853691,
-0.5655558705,
0.7038712502,
0.4225229919,
0.3220870793,
0.3119128942,
0.2490183562,
0.1434385926,
0.2500224411,
-0.8204005361,
-0.2874827683,
0.8061541319,
0.2897858918,
0.6302774549,
-0.1422367692,
0.8575164676,
0.0468977131,
-0.0858458951,
-0.5539318919,
0.6097408533,
-0.4115031362,
-0.3741306365,
-0.2078739405,
-0.1842195094,
-0.5427466631,
0.2230072916,
-0.0560514629,
-0.6009683609,
0.5383425355,
0.361230731,
-0.6751873493,
0.2661071718,
-0.7743362784,
0.4069621265,
-0.1773989499,
-0.1954371333,
-0.6001991034,
-0.3593580127,
-0.0247037318,
-0.5532752275,
0.2294665873,
-0.3501860797,
-0.5470225811,
0.5193596482,
-0.3205808699,
0.8163555264,
-0.0944695845,
-0.1087544784,
-0.0819478408,
0.1693142503,
0.7741932273,
-0.0691605136,
-0.4245801866,
0.1191476062,
-0.1941906363,
-0.5827001333,
-0.3452816308,
0.848005414,
-0.9534546137,
-0.8667225838,
0.3266238868,
-0.5109965801,
-0.4384944141,
0.1525948197,
0.1954156309,
0.3631869853,
0.4017368257,
0.4831580818,
1.0799506903,
0.1044728905,
0.3216142952,
0.7943058014,
0.4944314659,
-0.178452298,
0.8329304457,
0.4213325977,
-0.059494324,
0.5657410026,
0.2785438299,
0.1544084102,
-1.2498011589,
-0.2894210815,
-0.0272683632,
-0.2927290201,
-0.133899197,
-0.6902926564,
0.2088383138,
-0.0198257156,
-0.6409962177,
-0.6403201222,
-0.0940172151,
-0.4929820299,
0.1314800233,
0.4831185937,
0.4152603447,
0.1805440634,
0.4351093173,
-0.8255341649,
0.0373105928,
0.3455279768,
0.363720119,
0.1272644401,
-0.5856826305,
-0.4856205881,
-0.0527572259,
-0.2185757905,
-0.7272154093,
0.083075352,
0.5619457364,
0.9785556793,
0.6662290096,
0.0224400572,
0.9537706375,
-0.6355692744,
0.613699317,
-0.1618991643,
-0.723200202,
0.1025920659,
-0.6614018679,
-0.0271013286,
0.7083547115,
0.1405379325,
0.2503113151,
-0.6229501367,
-0.4465947151,
-1.0164115429,
0.588326931,
-0.0744596943,
0.4789400101,
0.0166880488,
0.5233354568,
0.3973169923,
0.269400239,
-0.093989186,
-0.1939778775,
0.3764892519,
-0.1910636425,
0.0698119774,
-0.4332024455,
-0.1148325577,
-0.3990186453,
0.5575908422,
-0.0582414791,
0.0437455177,
-0.1307591051,
0.070054315,
-0.5162856579,
0.1125362888,
0.4833986461,
0.8233451843,
-0.1871520579,
0.0554071516,
0.4085609913,
-0.0855786651,
-0.1444372833,
0.0240042862,
-0.0757866278,
-0.0565228909,
0.3009800017,
0.6981661916,
0.5873021483,
-0.5838313699,
0.2747474611,
0.5000960231,
-0.4912416637,
-0.0844249651,
0.5361686945,
0.0463729575,
0.6860846281,
0.7232640982,
0.5364485979,
0.0772822797,
-0.2331834584,
0.1061038002,
0.3947179914,
0.2345496118,
-0.3809741437,
0.5957884192,
0.2873898745,
-0.3485614061,
0.2734321058,
0.0552071854,
-0.2467836142,
0.5924268961,
0.1272411942,
0.8405423164,
-0.0990061834,
-0.1274200529,
-0.1172842309,
0.1772785932,
-0.31379807,
0.0981861427,
-0.3949607015,
-0.5516855121,
-0.6505233049,
-0.701023519,
-0.1505140513,
-0.0319108777,
-0.5236287713,
0.102305837,
-0.3652397096,
-0.1191863865,
-0.113028273,
-0.0660937279,
-0.6019940972,
-0.1316344887,
0.1304997653,
1.0191482306,
-0.7382246852,
0.730880022,
0.9280605316,
0.1893660426,
-0.8827653527,
0.024714943,
-0.2574219406,
-0.9236467481,
0.4358812869,
-0.5139477253,
0.0597831905,
0.2110399604,
-0.4258677065,
-0.9101100564,
0.9022450447,
0.6462245584,
-0.902379334,
-0.0030692732,
-0.0748450235,
0.5843499303,
-0.1658414006,
0.1069477871,
0.5624625087,
0.5433577299,
-0.0587439425,
-1.116342783,
-0.2483196706,
-0.196140945,
-0.068001613,
0.2103352994,
-1.0679584742,
0.9559051394,
0.1678952128,
0.4120471776,
0.0607352778,
0.5395381451,
0.3152492344,
0.0416546352,
0.6557140946,
0.551784575,
0.6226448417,
0.1460977942,
0.7243362069,
-0.7604911923,
0.4225144088,
0.8015427589,
-0.0156973619,
0.9544095397,
0.5246850252,
-0.2382022291,
0.0856515169,
0.8222494125,
-0.0157416966,
0.8139654994,
-0.2703469396,
-0.1309931874,
-0.8094565868,
0.2005737275,
-0.4201259017,
0.2085113376,
0.3593859971,
-0.3043167889,
-0.342130065,
-0.1293247044,
0.0038620732,
-0.0292550828,
-0.5957322121,
0.7691504359,
0.0879404396,
-0.6321647167,
0.7211523652,
0.1152896211,
0.7498272657,
-0.4258629382,
0.1669949144,
-0.1721482724,
0.1114233285,
-0.239900738,
-0.8227725029,
0.2772252262,
-0.0932794064,
-0.2413505465,
-0.5133638382,
0.6022561193,
-0.5375022292,
-0.2419041842,
0.1193785816,
0.5590583086,
0.1730011255,
-0.3544235229,
-0.7996041775,
-0.0799623579,
-0.1513575464,
-0.6836094856,
0.5950003266,
0.6216772795,
0.2503114641,
0.5055934787,
0.2568537593,
0.1547090113,
0.142020151,
-0.1847753525,
1.0146939754,
-0.1007278338,
-0.5321832895,
-1.0588777065,
0.5096758008,
0.2628340423,
-0.3348355591,
0.5229396224,
0.4595773518,
0.8190717697,
-0.2637530565,
0.507055819,
0.0098649915,
0.1715580821,
-0.5407888889,
0.5845900178,
-0.9535742998,
0.4071570039,
-0.2803168297,
-0.8907485008,
0.1121382043,
0.3120858073,
-0.2605056763,
0.1419281214,
0.1863699555,
0.839088738,
-0.4041951001,
-0.3080601096,
0.5326960087,
0.4256437123,
0.0335157327,
0.6298242807,
0.550752759,
0.1433701962,
0.4337269664,
-0.4391921461,
-0.224928841,
-0.4893553257,
-0.6738778353,
-0.9910222888,
-0.5419833064,
-0.4517759383,
0.5250605345,
0.0563551113,
1.0355648994,
1.0297541618,
-0.7415038943,
0.107558541,
-0.0827959254,
0.0260333586,
-0.3222627342,
-0.1091736183,
0.328348726,
-0.3864536285,
-1.0082793236,
0.5341665745,
0.6023352742,
-0.2722067237,
-0.1232392862,
-0.0928998739,
0.2345862389,
0.1471924484,
0.4770540297,
-0.0807899982,
-0.6535624266,
-0.2181389481,
-0.0104640126,
0.1435528696,
0.0536406934,
0.5477713346,
-0.4277930558,
0.164223969,
0.6447924972,
0.8420193195,
0.2140094936,
-0.0128218066,
0.5230343938,
-0.7069771886,
0.0680384934,
0.1827799976,
0.5403851867,
-0.3321213126,
-0.5995905399,
0.1763506383,
0.2377457917,
-0.7356159687,
-0.7889534235,
-0.0005864899,
-1.224203825,
-0.4667169154,
1.0660895109,
-0.0228904095,
-0.0129474439,
-0.4070906937,
-0.3488855064,
-0.2031940967,
-0.7877859473,
0.8802804351,
0.6523734927,
-0.291307807,
-0.3698113561,
-0.3586957157,
0.1811777949,
0.6308789849,
-0.2615765035,
-0.2674092948,
0.0524710938,
0.5126745105,
0.0115872426,
0.6619636416,
0.3639596403,
0.0677432716,
-0.1756521761,
-0.5410334468,
-0.6570933461,
-0.3721351922,
0.0002705746,
0.3987582028,
0.2853042781,
0.1090386957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01902v1 | SoP: Unlock the Power of Social Facilitation for Automatic Jailbreak Attack | 2024-07-02T02:58:29 | 2024-07-02T02:58:29 | Yan Yang, Zeguan Xiao, Xin Lu, Hongru Wang, Hailiang Huang, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The widespread applications of large language models (LLMs) have brought
about concerns regarding their potential misuse. Although aligned with human
preference data before release, LLMs remain vulnerable to various malicious
attacks. In this paper, we adopt a red-teaming strategy to enhance LLM safety
and introduce SoP, a simple yet effective framework to design jailbreak prompts
automatically. Inspired by the social facilitation concept, SoP generates and
optimizes multiple jailbreak characters to bypass the guardrails of the target
LLM. Different from previous work which relies on proprietary LLMs or seed
jailbreak templates crafted by human expertise, SoP can generate and optimize
the jailbreak prompt in a cold-start scenario using open-sourced LLMs without
any seed jailbreak templates. Experimental results show that SoP achieves
attack success rates of 88% and 60% in bypassing the safety alignment of
GPT-3.5-1106 and GPT-4, respectively. Furthermore, we extensively evaluate the
transferability of the generated templates across different LLMs and held-out
malicious requests, while also exploring defense strategies against the
jailbreak attack designed by SoP. Code is available at
https://github.com/Yang-Yan-Yang-Yan/SoP. | [
-0.3046427369,
-0.7765038013,
0.4584719837,
0.5947927833,
-0.0861786008,
0.2955934107,
-0.146116823,
-0.3133344054,
0.5393298268,
0.5368375182,
-0.6545832157,
-0.458480835,
-0.579272747,
0.1738705486,
-0.3379356861,
1.044767499,
0.1152974889,
-0.2047916502,
0.3604620695,
0.0068654064,
-0.386641115,
-0.5060998797,
-0.5702548027,
0.1789351404,
0.3605878353,
0.5200547576,
0.5410725474,
0.4916573167,
0.3450077772,
0.2450377494,
0.0920629501,
-0.0205941908,
-0.3501234651,
0.2426891625,
-0.0747275427,
-0.1915162802,
-0.554582715,
-0.0584873669,
0.0396140814,
-0.0913462192,
-0.2279006541,
-0.0388559662,
0.0674189851,
0.8251716495,
-0.7008852363,
-0.0258877594,
-0.7979403138,
-0.0752323568,
-0.3238731623,
0.05001105,
-0.3699056208,
-0.6175552011,
-0.1967969537,
-0.4153382182,
-0.0994222686,
0.2043278962,
0.4812620878,
0.2040237784,
0.092020072,
-0.2017540485,
-0.1488302797,
0.2246325016,
-0.5726447105,
0.0612524748,
0.3593050539,
0.3699174821,
-0.4130185544,
-0.2500590682,
-0.5286339521,
-0.3912008405,
0.2571044266,
-0.1699032336,
-0.2480439246,
0.0440393053,
0.2128776759,
-0.221592024,
-0.5203288198,
0.1585294455,
-0.311588943,
-0.1032009125,
0.9210959673,
-0.0036695458,
0.7340553403,
-0.2105528563,
-0.636633873,
0.2455595285,
-0.9727022648,
-0.1305804104,
0.3450562954,
0.3360958993,
-0.497744292,
0.4568606019,
-0.1152467579,
0.5669945478,
0.2565972805,
0.1194033399,
0.0282727089,
-0.2785557806,
0.009647401,
0.2714048624,
1.1279580593,
0.573179543,
0.3444187939,
-0.2074730396,
-0.0739895627,
-0.0326999016,
0.175502032,
-0.6324995756,
-0.1415806115,
0.237167567,
-0.2403288037,
-0.73918432,
0.1189150438,
-0.7583109736,
-0.8107430935,
0.3511254191,
0.1621481031,
-0.5009473562,
-0.2594101131,
0.089310661,
-0.1416599751,
0.0610009432,
0.0818485171,
-1.1273105145,
0.2734602094,
0.6246833801,
1.0030274391,
-0.2286775112,
-0.4780244529,
-0.7226403356,
0.4505981505,
-0.0083500277,
0.5954930186,
-0.1586770862,
-0.3433624208,
-0.1960728019,
-0.1822446883,
0.1117736101,
-0.3463406861,
-0.0332218036,
-0.6361048222,
-0.4803704321,
-0.1465349644,
-0.2226117849,
0.3924297392,
0.1647659093,
-0.5503433943,
0.57301265,
-0.2416990101,
-0.8306779861,
0.20673953,
-0.7181695104,
-0.5981346369,
0.1848325282,
-0.2358479053,
-0.2748236656,
0.0261114445,
0.1799140871,
0.5849125981,
-0.1945949793,
0.3735263348,
-0.4685817361,
-0.1908512414,
0.0302253235,
0.2158732861,
0.9742994905,
0.3714544177,
-0.6942288876,
0.3057483137,
-0.5467658639,
-0.1036441997,
0.5137600899,
-0.2045395225,
-0.3875127137,
-0.0731246844,
-0.101572454,
0.1343025416,
0.2874269187,
-0.6028677225,
0.3939422667,
-0.3596902192,
0.7324711084,
0.992328465,
-0.1527693868,
0.4317590296,
0.0080432957,
0.5618494749,
-0.5939471722,
0.2814610898,
0.0542587228,
-0.3967031538,
-0.1790604144,
-0.3455764055,
0.0398227274,
0.7754206061,
-0.6874634027,
0.5230176449,
0.2489335239,
-0.6974853873,
-0.2601373792,
0.3079559803,
0.5577546358,
0.1192457974,
0.3269992471,
-0.1626798809,
-0.6594173908,
-0.6207792163,
-0.533787787,
-0.2469417453,
-0.0165793989,
0.1264887303,
0.297608465,
-0.1945046335,
0.8421029449,
-0.5411908627,
-0.2235849649,
-0.7586747408,
-0.1096462831,
0.2549371123,
0.5138065219,
0.5371342897,
-0.3985086977,
-0.7118316889,
-0.4745773971,
-0.7253932953,
-0.6043666601,
-0.107794933,
-0.0779095888,
0.2217251211,
0.8100513816,
-0.5328668356,
0.4140559435,
0.6173251271,
-0.7444270253,
0.9261986017,
-0.1335471123,
-0.0093332864,
-1.0002429485,
-0.1118111238,
0.1007934436,
-0.0200148374,
-0.7481734753,
0.4222002029,
0.2524887919,
-0.3243109882,
-0.6722267866,
0.5307494402,
-0.3490461409,
0.071042262,
-0.0918009952,
0.3274488449,
-0.3056054413,
0.1255472153,
-0.1307228953,
0.6991394162,
0.3826123774,
-0.3233585358,
0.3732497692,
0.1842486709,
-0.1197582409,
0.3215028048,
-0.9474879503,
0.355368644,
0.0148370974,
0.2296704501,
-0.8714607954,
-0.2107319385,
0.2584391832,
-0.2832981348,
0.1236372963,
-0.3319523036,
-0.6055660248,
-0.0281200819,
-0.4162875116,
0.0152192069,
0.2974145114,
-0.5049757361,
0.3183254004,
0.6055890918,
-0.3816848993,
-0.2720841467,
-0.3530851603,
0.3726294637,
-0.3589030206,
-0.9282127619,
0.316555351,
-0.1399141997,
-0.3534121513,
-0.572134316,
-0.0358396657,
0.1934508532,
0.5083676577,
0.5177578926,
0.5104781389,
0.2305590659,
-0.3212459683,
-0.0302753653,
-0.4275983274,
0.0932291076,
-0.1334381998,
0.891972363,
-0.2286583781,
-0.2258556038,
-0.4614856243,
0.3787289262,
0.5940444469,
-0.1360632926,
0.6683717966,
0.1137332767,
-0.0298167039,
-0.0114886975,
-0.5052509308,
-0.3399596512,
-0.5300841331,
0.1243436411,
-0.2268518209,
-0.8910089135,
0.2283723056,
0.0769945458,
0.2203618884,
-0.1948417723,
0.4267414808,
-0.0719878525,
0.8462401032,
0.6193966269,
-0.6195961833,
0.6386201978,
0.0886316299,
0.2176749706,
-0.3448073268,
-0.0811483487,
-0.5061017871,
-0.1546009034,
-0.326112777,
-0.144320339,
0.3967410326,
0.2623124421,
-0.3406281769,
0.6176837087,
-0.4940298498,
0.703530252,
0.4486339092,
0.1393132061,
0.1474619806,
-0.1473075151,
-0.2851275206,
0.0632198527,
-0.6374835968,
-0.4598471522,
0.9976793528,
0.4100315869,
0.8910179734,
0.2121494859,
1.1588927507,
0.3921428621,
0.1035068035,
-0.3077569902,
0.9185813665,
-0.0486485288,
-0.5907543302,
-0.2202339321,
-0.1016468704,
-0.6675598621,
-0.0808233172,
-0.3317517638,
-0.9755392075,
-0.1726137549,
0.3811428249,
-0.7249850631,
0.149745211,
-0.8080096841,
0.7684803009,
-0.3393088281,
-0.4134675264,
-0.2115239501,
-0.85839504,
0.3928391635,
-0.0204126481,
0.4293903708,
-0.1995933205,
0.2806805074,
0.7985616326,
-0.6640470028,
0.9821374416,
-0.5437069535,
0.1306875497,
-0.0295560993,
0.4366078973,
0.8950612545,
0.239269197,
0.0090101305,
0.2618241608,
-0.2928173244,
-0.2774250805,
-0.4560303092,
0.5378321409,
-0.6598683,
-1.0049636364,
-0.1913210601,
-0.4030880332,
0.0804419369,
0.3013830483,
0.2259287983,
-0.0412873328,
0.0946468934,
-0.032182347,
0.5920720696,
-0.4532137513,
0.5044352412,
0.5054065585,
-0.2746773362,
-0.4698803425,
0.7118404508,
-0.0835236013,
0.4833064973,
-0.1771737933,
0.3497410119,
0.0026172367,
-0.6172264814,
-0.4878708124,
0.1668527275,
-0.295232743,
-0.2267029732,
-0.6912354827,
-0.2902439535,
-0.6941766739,
-0.7763225436,
-0.3081025481,
-0.4229974747,
0.1416211426,
-0.2269459069,
0.5592086911,
0.4319440126,
-0.3672222197,
0.3764743507,
-0.8232409358,
0.5462399125,
0.2094860971,
-0.0633422807,
-0.1617271006,
-0.0802515224,
0.0106287692,
-0.4473775923,
-0.139367789,
-1.2611265182,
0.5136557817,
-0.1579708457,
0.4055869877,
0.3573328853,
0.4887572229,
0.4229090512,
-0.7138335109,
0.595469594,
0.5914963484,
-1.0576115847,
1.0480844975,
-0.5025757551,
0.0845923796,
0.7216410041,
0.1736050248,
-0.4858570397,
-0.7717790008,
-0.7189369202,
-1.1441128254,
0.692686379,
0.0242273249,
-0.0219909865,
-0.1274322271,
0.2196844667,
-0.0435797274,
0.2163395882,
-0.7291967869,
-0.3548628986,
-0.2171253413,
-0.1085929349,
0.2124509066,
-0.2794785798,
-0.2898882627,
0.0801567957,
0.4409205019,
0.0396294519,
0.0587704889,
0.0456575491,
-0.1087934449,
0.2075591236,
0.4003705978,
0.3507391214,
0.1183182523,
-0.1356297582,
0.2327916324,
0.1502689272,
-0.6868959069,
0.4055429995,
-0.0135472734,
-0.4663960636,
-0.4022435248,
0.1938393265,
0.3956696987,
-0.0298476294,
-0.5625712276,
0.4740020335,
-0.1097067818,
-0.0086668795,
-0.2440005541,
0.5920814276,
0.0561818816,
0.5206613541,
0.2731246352,
0.0270800963,
-0.1242940128,
-0.4893430173,
0.2518853247,
0.4379594326,
-0.2789828479,
-0.2782390416,
0.8055355549,
0.4425528944,
-0.6277661324,
0.3914036155,
-0.1681321859,
-0.6500272155,
0.5931590796,
0.8442222476,
0.959142983,
-0.379123956,
0.1643121988,
0.0552511737,
0.468321681,
-0.0382867418,
0.4023458958,
-0.2015526593,
-0.8215152025,
-0.1418772042,
-0.2868894339,
-0.2240604311,
0.0105180591,
-0.4785162807,
0.5187553167,
-1.1243596077,
-0.0513056368,
-0.1921165586,
-0.2702325583,
-0.0652950555,
-0.135595575,
-0.0177476089,
1.2230232954,
-0.9291347265,
0.8660842776,
0.5092892051,
-0.1384658366,
-0.7554724813,
0.0994577259,
0.4982876778,
-0.9520326257,
0.8736264706,
0.3280117214,
-0.1869771928,
0.0601937808,
-0.7019699812,
-0.6130924225,
0.7893010378,
0.3606944978,
-0.7573753595,
-0.0834580064,
-0.0944555849,
-0.0849893913,
-0.2801652253,
-0.1437838674,
0.797252357,
0.5117988586,
-0.1041390076,
-0.8012366295,
0.6232088208,
-0.2861614525,
-0.269064784,
0.107697241,
-0.6127092242,
0.281979084,
-0.6804204583,
-0.0344915986,
-0.0339876227,
0.2760592103,
1.1684467793,
0.2867363095,
0.6513459086,
0.3714830279,
0.3169154227,
0.0214317422,
0.7189372182,
-0.4786033034,
-0.1998861283,
1.1012074947,
-0.3424495161,
0.7112113833,
0.7240660787,
-0.0234906618,
0.1112651154,
0.2690965235,
0.1135926023,
0.8456862569,
0.3944962621,
-0.2393580675,
-0.1375329196,
0.1006165966,
-0.4622902572,
0.2023345977,
0.2721974552,
-0.2156454623,
-0.1284478158,
-0.0656221211,
0.6612266302,
0.0421136096,
-0.1895996183,
0.7581601143,
0.1682293564,
-0.3972606957,
0.4930212498,
0.1842397302,
0.7720900178,
-0.6591441035,
0.2518132329,
-0.1845812351,
-0.1289605796,
-0.3891744614,
-0.5319043994,
0.3897431195,
0.3792854548,
-0.0363745578,
-0.4121217132,
0.8725641966,
0.0530414172,
0.0420810543,
0.3996790946,
-0.0197795983,
0.0230694842,
-0.0425911769,
-0.7692323923,
0.4130263925,
0.1435121745,
-0.14315027,
0.5524556041,
0.1376318634,
0.0387982801,
0.746655941,
0.7720513344,
0.3803022504,
-0.0380914249,
-0.0599845983,
1.0731260777,
-0.7402339578,
-0.7739451528,
-1.4219659567,
0.5032910705,
-0.2817421257,
0.0411462598,
0.8930920959,
0.2171070874,
0.4025947154,
0.0975070968,
1.0131806135,
-0.3814181089,
0.1060720161,
-0.6917122602,
1.1266931295,
-0.173273012,
0.666002512,
-0.841088593,
-0.5316826105,
-0.4112139344,
0.7068555355,
-0.4979989529,
-0.4076043665,
0.3743317425,
0.8905853629,
0.3504706919,
0.0916095823,
0.1814225763,
0.2003910691,
0.5261288881,
0.5547910333,
0.8028408885,
0.0265998747,
0.3847290874,
0.1540359259,
-0.6867976785,
-0.3926717043,
-1.0282678604,
-0.9649201632,
-0.1930925101,
-0.1874593943,
-0.7327244878,
0.4826995432,
1.2096953392,
0.7161080241,
-0.6678385139,
-0.3352396488,
-0.3083525002,
0.1250774562,
0.0290320721,
-0.1816128194,
0.1400828362,
-0.2747557461,
-0.0617187582,
0.7825304866,
0.6487366557,
-0.0369258486,
-0.2496446371,
-0.1634121686,
-0.0299224351,
-0.0337863006,
0.334702611,
0.4666006565,
-0.4357999265,
-0.1739584953,
-0.0054444252,
-0.1165750921,
-0.231743589,
0.7906425595,
-0.4423984587,
0.2077490687,
0.4032786489,
0.6424942613,
0.1607470214,
-0.1685526669,
0.9506952167,
-0.7099590898,
0.2473229468,
-0.0594960339,
0.3545563817,
-0.042899292,
-0.4921168983,
0.4821597934,
0.273632586,
-0.4028374851,
-0.8343454003,
0.4834926724,
-0.4873206019,
-0.3447348177,
1.2349194288,
-0.3751119077,
-0.3709294498,
-0.5034285188,
-0.29755494,
-0.0501465313,
-0.7897735238,
1.1426355839,
0.3102746904,
-0.0227654334,
-0.1350048184,
-0.3826737404,
0.6418417692,
0.1318488717,
-0.8504056931,
0.3767840564,
0.2310780734,
0.372025609,
0.1863817275,
0.9330575466,
-0.1767905504,
0.3446311951,
-0.2383930087,
0.1641551107,
-0.4257999957,
-0.5536167622,
-0.1326486617,
0.3481234908,
0.0563861951,
-0.0593019277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01899v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01899v1 | Scope-enhanced Compositional Semantic Parsing for DRT | 2024-07-02T02:50:15 | 2024-07-02T02:50:15 | Xiulin Yang, Jonas Groschwitz, Alexander Koller, Johan Bos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Discourse Representation Theory (DRT) distinguishes itself from other
semantic representation frameworks by its ability to model complex semantic and
discourse phenomena through structural nesting and variable binding. While
seq2seq models hold the state of the art on DRT parsing, their accuracy
degrades with the complexity of the sentence, and they sometimes struggle to
produce well-formed DRT representations. We introduce the AMS parser, a
compositional, neurosymbolic semantic parser for DRT. It rests on a novel
mechanism for predicting quantifier scope. We show that the AMS parser reliably
produces well-formed outputs and performs well on DRT parsing, especially on
complex sentences. | [
-0.1950263977,
-0.6318233609,
0.7577243447,
0.2114271522,
-0.1535696983,
0.3191407025,
-0.1196866557,
-0.2559936047,
0.5148952603,
0.3624247313,
-0.5346670151,
-0.2812394798,
-0.6896773577,
0.0585533753,
-0.3481960893,
0.5635092258,
-0.0273588132,
0.1998473257,
-0.2495236993,
-0.1116939262,
-0.543184042,
-0.5112908483,
-0.7343199253,
-0.3441019356,
0.2973775864,
0.1100244373,
0.6648853421,
0.5654302239,
0.473360002,
0.3961013556,
-0.1614171714,
0.0654800609,
-0.0518657714,
0.5848799348,
-0.2254853547,
-0.5158525109,
-0.552767992,
-0.2884583771,
0.7993827462,
0.8667150736,
-0.2594001889,
-0.281971544,
-0.0243190788,
0.5686177611,
-0.6575258374,
0.2117729634,
-0.4522841275,
0.1780990213,
-0.0917065889,
-0.1094807759,
-0.4107815623,
0.060029611,
0.3187887967,
-0.5712345243,
-0.0862401426,
-0.3811693192,
0.5951458216,
0.2741258442,
-1.0018948317,
-0.0094192075,
-0.5482258797,
0.7529919744,
-0.6513158083,
0.4604587257,
0.0295311008,
0.4758524895,
-0.1232736707,
-1.0545554161,
-0.4502723217,
-0.0554132648,
-0.3427380919,
0.3261511624,
-0.2808713913,
0.3643451035,
0.2088939995,
0.546897769,
-0.656167984,
-0.3921626508,
-0.0462604724,
-0.2314229012,
0.2561159134,
0.3863126934,
-0.0133446548,
-0.8080582619,
-0.362529546,
0.0181023795,
-0.4296790063,
0.0470123701,
0.0157720447,
-0.0418122485,
0.016279012,
0.8224351406,
-0.315914005,
0.9795896411,
0.0107227406,
0.1844265908,
0.0081259841,
-0.2107172608,
-0.2507517338,
-0.1874927729,
0.6916133761,
0.1409553885,
-0.042415455,
0.0901447758,
-0.2262964845,
0.3200200498,
0.4747055173,
-0.595523715,
-0.3472754657,
0.0458460785,
-0.3200609088,
-0.1882965565,
0.3854113519,
-0.5115879178,
-0.0588147715,
-0.5632610321,
0.1425754279,
-0.5662489533,
-0.1613438129,
0.2763988674,
-0.3262170851,
0.1140400395,
0.2350522578,
-0.7814488411,
0.5615543127,
0.6686997414,
0.8028299809,
-0.1256044805,
-0.1330122352,
-0.5239732265,
0.4883811176,
-0.2712913156,
0.9471539855,
-0.8322722912,
-0.1438164711,
-0.1037279665,
-0.0642987937,
-0.2305270582,
-0.4984411895,
0.490218401,
-0.5519230366,
0.1945730895,
-0.350733012,
-0.7036655545,
-0.3360195756,
0.4144708216,
-0.6525737047,
0.6392392516,
0.5040421486,
-0.5862593055,
0.3409008086,
-0.8318282366,
-0.5745957494,
-0.0147957411,
-0.492928803,
-0.0254759993,
0.4236479998,
0.064369984,
0.2623331845,
-0.0693797842,
0.5998401642,
-0.1354939789,
-0.0627371445,
0.490300864,
-0.5905503631,
0.5131313205,
0.2303634584,
-0.1988792121,
0.251968503,
-0.8072206378,
0.2391573936,
-0.1046404988,
-0.4542563856,
-0.3486035764,
0.0633594319,
-0.1816767901,
-0.0139757637,
0.2279966772,
-0.55819875,
0.0754682422,
-0.6786358356,
0.8741654754,
0.5355705619,
0.1116059795,
0.4421842098,
-0.1280185431,
0.6009062529,
0.3701532185,
-0.3191884756,
-0.2725857496,
-0.3013013899,
-0.8781234026,
-0.3301837742,
0.4840049744,
0.5165970325,
-0.4701777697,
0.6326761246,
-0.3966104388,
-0.044123847,
-0.2822051346,
-0.4951072037,
0.3082315922,
0.1611496359,
0.2734163404,
-0.5154352188,
-0.7810925841,
-1.1704465151,
-0.383590281,
-0.1527382582,
-0.2442141622,
0.246086359,
0.315982759,
-0.229840681,
1.0916358232,
-0.8371530175,
-0.1267225891,
-0.1378713995,
0.2616824508,
-0.0114413379,
0.3786841631,
0.2989224195,
-0.8185992837,
-0.4098391533,
-0.1506976783,
-0.8042400479,
-0.0586181954,
0.1413000077,
-0.0525100864,
-0.1048225462,
0.5487555861,
-0.8810905814,
0.4530228376,
0.4447072744,
-0.7865490913,
0.3835211098,
-0.0300871991,
0.1220095456,
-1.2530728579,
-0.2304093987,
-0.3614958823,
-0.6765778661,
-0.3912988305,
0.04058237,
0.2438088655,
-0.0716576427,
-0.138091892,
0.1319106817,
-0.2544589639,
-0.0664986148,
-0.304525882,
0.0295151751,
0.5030073524,
0.1994236112,
0.1182655841,
0.6864281893,
0.3595378399,
-0.4363723993,
0.4912492633,
0.3116933107,
0.0368157402,
0.8198035359,
-0.9146690965,
-0.4216386676,
0.0146231558,
0.4390257895,
-0.9307333231,
-0.4798468053,
0.028453419,
-0.2876640558,
0.4485152066,
0.0342865176,
-0.3942659795,
-0.4357433021,
-0.196173653,
0.6658517122,
-0.0324231051,
-0.256708324,
0.7913056612,
0.3842315376,
0.0724936947,
-0.5001221299,
-1.0767769814,
0.3127230108,
-0.1296844333,
-0.8081220984,
0.599295795,
0.3251574934,
-0.23961173,
0.1625709534,
-0.1004033908,
0.025152443,
-0.0303171892,
0.035660807,
-0.2178224474,
-0.4912120998,
0.2010626495,
0.3907973766,
-0.4652364254,
0.1975040436,
-0.3521757424,
0.5405723453,
-0.3049422503,
-0.5772426724,
-0.2897663713,
0.7116924524,
0.492613256,
-0.4335530102,
0.3692305386,
0.235564217,
-0.3266485631,
-0.0848496929,
-0.2528550029,
-0.3413224518,
-0.4461404681,
0.4103233814,
-0.7546845675,
-1.0889823437,
0.5899302959,
-0.2026326358,
-0.4117633998,
0.4927210808,
0.4268583953,
0.263229847,
0.9739955664,
0.4753121138,
0.5021598339,
0.2972555757,
-0.3944560587,
0.308768779,
-1.126175642,
0.1047303155,
-0.0252335183,
-0.3173784316,
-0.7115187049,
-0.5497606397,
0.4563551843,
-0.3155643344,
-0.3249446154,
0.41043365,
-0.479344517,
0.5355963111,
0.7547428012,
0.1026416868,
0.4108756781,
-0.2143460959,
-0.2042176872,
-0.268388629,
-0.473044008,
-0.6086773872,
0.7325529456,
0.4025803208,
0.7642023563,
0.4443214536,
0.616523385,
0.0890081599,
-0.3507934809,
-0.9731588364,
0.5786134601,
-0.4801773727,
-0.5091598034,
-0.1562032998,
-0.2649587393,
-0.7964314222,
0.6456566453,
0.231312573,
-0.5549299121,
0.5418353677,
-0.1541328728,
-0.4229677022,
0.0676273033,
-0.6411057711,
0.9839181304,
0.3200068474,
-0.1343932152,
-0.1867938638,
-0.8994594812,
0.3659263253,
0.161371246,
-0.2058358938,
0.0409040749,
-0.328327477,
0.780957818,
-0.3581188917,
0.9270519614,
-0.0813336,
0.0651048943,
0.3407948315,
0.3230476975,
0.3081116378,
0.3813515604,
-0.0817162916,
-0.0622516088,
0.2167112082,
-0.3094557226,
-0.658154428,
0.5600117445,
-0.5036227703,
-0.4741797149,
-0.5479797125,
-0.6076239347,
-0.3494851887,
0.2776502669,
0.2302310765,
0.4522324204,
-0.3029648066,
0.2350874841,
0.5566273928,
0.1665833443,
0.283629477,
0.2976984978,
0.0289990716,
-0.6892085075,
0.5180987716,
0.1372644454,
0.3056524396,
0.5522646308,
0.189606294,
-0.1498753726,
-0.2657578886,
-0.4488435984,
0.1756128073,
-0.9751026034,
-0.6931595802,
-0.88491714,
-0.4696154892,
-0.4734065235,
-0.0253806468,
-0.4332859814,
-0.9840213656,
-0.239732787,
-0.2011103034,
0.019297095,
1.0039354563,
-0.0776391849,
0.5547724962,
-0.5501064062,
0.2796800733,
0.5535698533,
0.3805983961,
-0.35401389,
-0.307839185,
-0.0075585512,
0.1078059375,
-0.7493840456,
-1.0009565353,
0.2543225288,
0.2423288822,
0.2329851985,
0.3704515398,
0.0090789944,
0.8511671424,
-0.4922175705,
0.9757332206,
0.0031231227,
-1.2919819355,
0.6219391227,
-0.4786143601,
0.5525214672,
0.5049704313,
-0.0877842531,
-0.4548937678,
-0.7271100879,
-0.5968080163,
-0.7885524631,
0.5774402618,
0.0646369681,
0.2960719764,
-0.2990797162,
0.3806816638,
0.0970938802,
0.3419487774,
-0.8839162588,
-0.1038831845,
-0.3926869035,
-0.4478969276,
0.1488510817,
-0.8072667122,
-0.1235997155,
-0.2576580644,
0.3505204022,
-0.18787691,
0.4368763268,
0.3846434951,
0.0817730799,
-0.3960468471,
0.4255167246,
0.4989642799,
0.7070294023,
0.0319174379,
0.6299206614,
-0.1481188834,
-0.334561497,
0.2780219316,
0.0513788648,
-0.2049687952,
-0.0340671539,
0.5032809973,
0.7324517965,
0.4403832257,
-0.546043098,
0.8899003267,
-0.1527607888,
-0.3701740205,
-0.4638723135,
0.0106881121,
0.0585030243,
0.5202857256,
0.0535071343,
0.0693491548,
0.6092965603,
-0.2666875124,
0.547958076,
0.5161833167,
-0.2433445305,
-0.2977825403,
0.6111884713,
-0.1671652198,
0.0175004434,
0.3484937847,
-0.288821876,
-0.7817861438,
0.2989002168,
0.7181354761,
0.8600956202,
-0.2764980495,
0.3101927936,
0.3143573701,
0.0187807269,
0.2577891648,
0.3642458022,
-0.1046365425,
-0.5140473247,
-0.5995644331,
-0.8155514598,
-0.2957257032,
-0.1585696787,
-0.6961424351,
0.3181475103,
-0.1623959392,
-0.178323403,
0.0718325153,
-0.2009543478,
-0.1700225919,
0.1149420217,
-0.046351485,
0.4002652168,
-0.7178287506,
0.5945570469,
0.9970598817,
-0.1680884808,
-0.7383062243,
0.1503808796,
-0.1497620642,
-0.6539573669,
0.5931878686,
0.1489548832,
0.0927097872,
-0.0207402594,
-0.1016652808,
-1.1108380556,
1.030892849,
0.5656678081,
-0.326746881,
-0.0180188026,
0.3844129741,
0.4935990274,
-0.5686520934,
0.015397328,
0.5442454815,
0.5169100165,
0.3398562372,
-0.7807335258,
0.3734885156,
0.1453193873,
0.195868209,
0.4101833999,
-0.3882769048,
1.0265278816,
0.0085917646,
-0.1895228475,
0.0373418666,
0.8441733718,
0.0153507767,
0.3098288774,
0.3859241307,
0.9434118867,
0.6286230683,
-0.0961572155,
0.6731886864,
-0.0808722079,
0.1803731322,
1.2514703274,
-0.059052702,
0.8421661854,
0.5581464171,
-0.3239797652,
0.9080607891,
0.4827721119,
0.1647920012,
0.5719810128,
0.2738647461,
-0.4421248734,
-0.2739883959,
0.0135085071,
-0.2188352942,
0.8621512055,
0.4694999158,
-0.4390545487,
-0.4187725484,
0.3097036779,
-0.2757744491,
0.2252876461,
0.218160674,
1.2170748711,
0.2994991839,
-0.7604311705,
0.5384140611,
0.1094357669,
0.1688925177,
-0.5588377714,
-0.0426924638,
0.2266550213,
0.2568283677,
-0.1567254663,
-0.8460234404,
0.8513583541,
-0.5428208709,
-0.182211861,
-0.0157354362,
0.8345966339,
-0.4472911656,
-0.2660571635,
0.2668195665,
0.7373400927,
-0.2470985055,
-0.2154134661,
-0.5630629063,
-0.0614508875,
-0.22752361,
-0.493290484,
0.0922753662,
0.9400656223,
0.1465718001,
0.3984281421,
0.168465957,
-0.021814255,
0.0186640639,
-0.0385813974,
1.1126645803,
-0.9201474786,
-0.5798210502,
-0.8875797987,
0.614328146,
-0.1134690493,
-0.0387475416,
0.5500609279,
0.6589289904,
0.5505179763,
0.0387109295,
0.6622406244,
-0.3260354996,
0.3847477138,
-0.3886805177,
0.2162787467,
-0.4984685183,
0.263145119,
0.0425634496,
-0.9135270119,
-0.5766543746,
0.8784676194,
-0.3655612171,
0.0093917819,
1.0602562428,
0.5115721226,
-0.3717400134,
0.2666706443,
0.507137239,
0.2642714083,
0.5485084057,
0.4935420454,
0.9371387362,
-0.4114045203,
0.0611195788,
-0.3802164793,
-0.3517128527,
0.0154342921,
-0.7572825551,
-0.6716426611,
-0.6651304364,
-0.2019439638,
-0.2423115075,
-0.1090874225,
0.6399255991,
0.7445347309,
-0.7181868553,
-0.2042126656,
-0.5960052013,
-0.0556388125,
-0.0944188461,
-0.2907197773,
0.2801788747,
-0.6523625851,
-0.4283680022,
0.3866696358,
0.4252455533,
0.1423397958,
-0.3135115206,
0.1317940056,
-0.0871643648,
0.1941376776,
0.9958863258,
-0.3707849383,
-0.7447357178,
-0.41718027,
-0.1576993018,
-0.043490652,
0.2386329472,
0.9954161048,
-0.8293455243,
0.3173057437,
0.5110781789,
0.4613792896,
0.2963758707,
-0.0590477847,
0.7452107668,
-0.7365529537,
-0.0148193566,
0.6049943566,
0.5809552073,
0.2624434829,
-0.2495917827,
0.5961156487,
0.4001191258,
-0.6131524444,
-0.7317290902,
0.6302757859,
-1.3294848204,
-0.4132400751,
1.0297406912,
-0.0969021097,
-0.3398735225,
-0.0801376179,
-0.2033950239,
0.2267011255,
-0.3049465418,
0.3261947036,
0.638643086,
-0.2764415145,
0.0692809001,
-0.513168335,
0.2713130414,
0.6386142969,
-0.5753433704,
0.4609126747,
0.6387755275,
-0.0082145436,
0.2255673707,
0.5485439301,
-0.3570824564,
0.2360697687,
0.0076116943,
-0.5158613324,
0.226297453,
-0.1413318664,
-0.3022057116,
0.3646001816,
0.2715317011,
0.0048945192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01897v1 | Proposal Report for the 2nd SciCAP Competition 2024 | 2024-07-02T02:42:29 | 2024-07-02T02:42:29 | Pengpeng Li, Tingmin Li, Jingyuan Wang, Boyuan Wang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a method for document summarization using auxiliary
information. This approach effectively summarizes descriptions related to
specific images, tables, and appendices within lengthy texts. Our experiments
demonstrate that leveraging high-quality OCR data and initially extracted
information from the original text enables efficient summarization of the
content related to described objects. Based on these findings, we enhanced
popular text generation model models by incorporating additional auxiliary
branches to improve summarization performance. Our method achieved top scores
of 4.33 and 4.66 in the long caption and short caption tracks, respectively, of
the 2024 SciCAP competition, ranking highest in both categories. | [
-0.3158147335,
-0.1463801712,
0.5241681337,
0.1676923782,
-0.4789581299,
0.3506650925,
-0.0267101526,
-1.0632036924,
0.3430955112,
0.2491115332,
-0.1698428392,
-0.2789516449,
-0.4151648283,
0.5018185973,
-0.485989362,
0.9153558016,
-0.1609947234,
-0.1272775084,
-0.6002402902,
0.014411835,
-0.4424686432,
-0.1876563728,
-0.4349639714,
0.1762853861,
0.538354218,
0.6752299666,
0.2387488633,
0.7846836448,
1.0600657463,
0.3210413456,
-0.0923925191,
0.513094902,
-0.1306964606,
0.1630482525,
-0.0898919404,
-0.6272149682,
-0.650590539,
-0.0619938672,
0.8784645796,
0.4389150739,
0.3034174144,
-0.060324017,
-0.0290389545,
0.4526773691,
-0.3019124568,
0.4377905726,
-0.477224201,
0.1187125072,
-0.1082560867,
-0.7088999152,
-0.5400906801,
-0.1863022298,
-0.0340773128,
-0.5839712024,
0.5698897839,
0.4060106874,
1.0045734644,
-0.1014731079,
-0.0847434103,
-0.4638303816,
-0.4222191274,
0.545599699,
-0.610598743,
-0.1428130418,
0.2939754128,
0.2748205066,
0.13473171,
-1.0314946175,
-0.3966307938,
-0.0707014501,
-0.2718538642,
0.512992084,
-0.3098858297,
-0.0245637447,
0.0782220066,
0.4706512094,
-0.4178258479,
0.1655588448,
-1.1843185425,
-0.206313014,
0.7887735963,
0.3929622173,
0.3353546262,
0.0506474003,
-0.0504095033,
0.0354109444,
-0.5390321612,
0.0212094709,
0.4139833748,
0.1360054612,
-0.1532264799,
1.1599800587,
-0.4844356775,
0.2990055978,
-0.2033941746,
-0.0642472729,
0.1826372743,
-0.8980619907,
0.2115607113,
0.3255845606,
0.6651598811,
0.8859756589,
-0.3498051167,
0.0378556363,
-0.0457758084,
-0.0563892014,
-0.0128277354,
-0.9073500633,
-0.1874237508,
0.2714176476,
-0.5788286328,
-0.3896142244,
-0.071778588,
-0.7862693071,
-0.1515126228,
-0.2586030364,
0.0423431434,
-0.3775674105,
0.4427776337,
-0.2471076846,
-0.7828906775,
0.0326849036,
0.4767881036,
-0.9067257047,
0.3242333829,
0.4450214505,
1.4375861883,
-0.3930435181,
-0.2518342435,
-0.4460799396,
0.2426302135,
-0.193906635,
1.2294688225,
-0.194006443,
-0.5536292195,
-0.2247584313,
0.0322829261,
0.3155644834,
0.0900188908,
0.560074091,
-0.4754067659,
0.4436657727,
-0.293050468,
-0.2981583774,
0.0719789416,
-0.0814097822,
-0.7037763,
0.7305862904,
-0.0113384882,
-1.0933059454,
0.4028727114,
-0.683930099,
-0.7571135759,
0.3928470612,
-0.2154435813,
-0.6119629741,
0.2235055715,
0.3473329246,
0.3502856791,
-0.2265451699,
-0.1461094916,
-0.0013245072,
-0.4638382196,
-0.0009353497,
0.0762331933,
0.3315548897,
0.1922058314,
0.0161314495,
0.3220320344,
-0.3800018132,
-0.4575526118,
0.2399168313,
-0.269469291,
-0.1564904004,
0.0216557048,
-0.1194203943,
-0.1120368615,
0.3352284729,
-0.6152778864,
0.4069001675,
-0.3971420527,
0.6592034698,
0.4919587076,
0.1443223059,
0.712490797,
-0.4883984625,
0.3936110139,
-0.4622412026,
0.0927585214,
-0.8288891912,
-0.5776833892,
-0.5589770675,
-0.5556460619,
0.407168597,
0.1742706001,
-0.7078288794,
0.3983932137,
-0.2550374866,
-0.6153483391,
-0.0103756441,
-0.4770690203,
0.0986942649,
0.7368771434,
0.4506658912,
-0.4564954937,
-0.8846937418,
-0.8956351876,
0.1309980303,
-0.2250500619,
-0.0715589747,
0.1725768,
0.7186756134,
0.1637617052,
0.87771523,
-0.9411348701,
-0.581328094,
-0.5646747351,
0.4820719957,
0.2883331478,
0.3364374936,
0.6337870359,
-0.6735275388,
-0.432475239,
-0.0069772527,
-0.6110779643,
0.068958804,
0.0403632373,
-0.115269959,
0.2629469037,
0.5515119433,
-0.678971231,
0.4828724265,
0.1264069527,
-0.2851232886,
0.7307268977,
-0.615588069,
0.5044701099,
-0.8443587422,
0.3643004298,
-0.4135873318,
-0.0157985613,
-0.2337819785,
0.0427416191,
0.1585764885,
-0.3518050313,
-0.2766000032,
0.2339866757,
-0.6683464646,
-0.0855970681,
-0.4240685403,
0.1874945909,
0.1898833811,
0.1962161362,
0.5323417783,
0.7309257388,
0.1523182243,
-0.4514897466,
0.3158076108,
0.5035270452,
-0.5161781907,
0.2671357095,
-0.9826119542,
-0.1697413027,
-0.5507487655,
0.6503164768,
-1.2988641262,
-0.7884946465,
-0.2223517448,
-0.6756230593,
0.4030441046,
0.4207446575,
-0.3410497904,
-0.5419756174,
-0.800409615,
0.2322150171,
0.5210906267,
-0.2347916216,
0.7286600471,
0.4822419584,
-0.8035543561,
-0.4520798326,
-0.7545158863,
0.2323887497,
-0.1216530129,
-0.5119903088,
0.6921290159,
-0.0471138619,
0.1521855742,
-0.052145008,
0.2048968673,
0.1799837798,
-0.1359843463,
0.1932733059,
0.5181161761,
0.0232188497,
-0.0906049907,
0.3786404133,
0.1229723766,
-0.0804769546,
0.0682732239,
0.5092269778,
0.1115362719,
0.1839597821,
-0.1624781787,
0.7789744139,
0.4524194598,
-0.2285653949,
0.32306391,
0.2141238451,
-0.2570847869,
0.1513230503,
-0.3176827729,
-0.1196411178,
-0.4175089896,
0.532808125,
-0.1959206164,
-0.5743787885,
0.5511489511,
0.3638075888,
0.5141268373,
0.7425250411,
0.3922979534,
-0.4954108298,
1.083889246,
0.7044278979,
0.0732128695,
0.4857643247,
-0.3180100024,
0.1258053482,
-0.751992166,
-0.6437711716,
-0.8970763087,
-0.1500611454,
-0.1126141921,
-0.4183408022,
0.4776985645,
-0.0856843889,
0.3719323874,
0.7361875772,
-0.6548035145,
0.6197593808,
0.5686563253,
0.0424199775,
0.4144117236,
0.1187374219,
0.0747439265,
-0.0461194217,
-0.6904007792,
-0.3410522044,
0.9488283992,
0.4706420898,
0.4197966754,
0.0192110334,
0.7060527802,
0.576628387,
0.2341038436,
-0.6861896515,
0.4602203965,
0.017851634,
-0.4073798656,
-0.4435612261,
-0.106939964,
-0.7220848203,
0.2403392941,
-0.1902350932,
-0.4521266222,
0.392467618,
0.0887370408,
-0.4969945252,
-0.1714041084,
-0.4594936371,
0.3242715299,
-0.1707750857,
-0.1584293544,
-0.1457293779,
-0.7775878906,
0.4189545512,
0.0333474129,
0.5006815195,
0.0647226647,
-0.2681750059,
1.0456742048,
-0.5617738962,
0.4622464776,
0.1790244281,
0.3446910977,
0.4253408313,
-0.4325025976,
0.6368178725,
0.0868064091,
0.1268841773,
-0.0844183564,
-0.1575363278,
-0.2380802184,
-0.3010445833,
0.4696260989,
-0.4861819744,
-0.1963743716,
-0.7355220914,
-0.6073349118,
0.2202792615,
0.3902774453,
0.7713581324,
0.4077713788,
-0.056178119,
0.2177625299,
0.4231213629,
-0.0951615125,
0.6973208189,
0.4916642904,
0.2632741332,
-0.7354127765,
0.8964762092,
0.1642252058,
0.126469627,
0.4822707176,
0.1957665235,
-0.3301078975,
-0.742117703,
-0.2235846519,
0.2034924626,
-0.7086083293,
-0.5108687282,
-0.9971775413,
-0.0332772583,
-0.7228407264,
-0.5279023647,
-0.1048702374,
-0.7600593567,
-0.4181439281,
-0.1468221694,
0.0553648844,
0.5197487473,
-0.1650275737,
0.2383517325,
-0.5736176372,
0.3450565338,
-0.042852588,
-0.1057730392,
-0.161349982,
-0.5880227089,
-0.1969908327,
-0.3217079937,
-0.2940564156,
-0.5584175587,
0.4527691305,
0.3180007637,
0.4877101183,
0.1564467549,
-0.0032100854,
0.5388110876,
-0.6659448147,
1.069893837,
0.662605226,
-0.6815445423,
0.6603816152,
-0.3888784945,
0.4672973454,
0.6260586977,
0.393294096,
0.0605558492,
-0.5933699608,
-0.4365924001,
-1.2402361631,
0.7326378822,
0.3214132786,
0.0091215335,
0.0787243322,
-0.1054893881,
0.148135677,
0.1992224157,
-0.4631888866,
0.2158566117,
-0.0048406366,
-0.2991986275,
-0.0291197468,
-0.486089319,
0.0270604324,
-0.1207027957,
0.6641566157,
-0.1152170971,
0.5262898803,
0.3369926512,
0.0226594321,
0.2039444596,
0.0619247034,
0.9701177478,
0.6746214032,
-0.2550900578,
0.0587141551,
0.2231466323,
-0.6655463576,
-0.1996055543,
0.0685429946,
-0.1598381996,
0.2920152843,
0.9510858655,
0.4100800157,
0.1966329217,
-0.7704538107,
0.5419206023,
-0.2711676657,
-0.4987708032,
-0.2857815921,
-0.0972020701,
-0.1711424589,
0.0323734693,
0.7236228585,
0.0562002957,
0.7053955793,
-0.7869722247,
0.2281025648,
0.1496838629,
-0.247710824,
-0.280872792,
0.6553931236,
0.337813586,
0.1422963142,
0.2644380033,
0.1798872352,
-0.4055547714,
0.7694805861,
0.5155521631,
0.4165179431,
-0.0889224783,
0.0377876423,
0.5709401369,
0.3686411977,
-0.148069337,
0.3324739039,
-0.3771236241,
0.1107588783,
-0.5559991598,
-0.3547005951,
-0.5947136879,
-0.3703801334,
-0.3914321363,
0.577650249,
-0.1056065559,
-0.0246292502,
0.3005974293,
-0.2021661997,
-0.3876838386,
0.0908353031,
-0.0954514742,
1.0411518812,
-0.7300625443,
0.2616768479,
0.3039008081,
-0.6779303551,
-0.380767107,
-0.6845340729,
-0.5345166922,
-0.3334163427,
0.5541903377,
0.1243882403,
-0.0016400598,
-0.2940939963,
-0.5193966627,
-0.8519756198,
1.3580139875,
-0.1085228398,
-0.5237014294,
-0.5501743555,
-0.1342047304,
0.3571146131,
-0.4312008917,
0.725263238,
0.4482702613,
0.2891203165,
0.3947536349,
-0.7372991443,
-0.1018631309,
-0.4667909443,
-0.1401988119,
-0.1002468914,
-0.673524797,
0.7636492252,
-0.4878183603,
-0.4615395665,
0.5509773493,
1.2236977816,
0.2923485637,
0.5560340881,
0.0292893481,
-0.1257320791,
0.5171777606,
-0.1734007448,
0.9807305932,
-0.0320393331,
0.007420219,
1.523458004,
-0.1352146864,
0.8034531474,
0.459236145,
-0.1117619798,
0.2185728401,
0.5181475878,
-0.1663208753,
0.8397272825,
0.0598204434,
-0.0040116152,
0.3734513521,
-0.4094518423,
-0.6444986463,
0.5087919831,
0.3393237591,
-0.7568157911,
-0.1581737846,
0.1504525542,
-0.2591356337,
-0.0350838862,
-0.3160012364,
0.8843541741,
-0.031651292,
-0.8938698769,
0.0317733735,
0.226142019,
0.4797578752,
-0.613961339,
-0.3179376125,
-0.2325600535,
0.0332406238,
-0.3023613691,
-0.8090862036,
0.3201815486,
0.0122285979,
-0.1395598352,
0.1202058494,
0.6889322996,
-0.4080739915,
-0.4013965726,
-0.3933675885,
-0.589951992,
0.285077095,
0.2197151631,
0.0628017187,
0.3045006096,
-0.2820806801,
0.0888455659,
0.1164389476,
-0.0325781293,
-0.1815437526,
0.2175281197,
0.5219984651,
-0.0349425264,
-0.2591896057,
-0.1426343471,
0.9569037557,
-0.2989220321,
-1.0712499619,
-0.5685447454,
0.8332726955,
-0.7377438545,
-0.3270147145,
0.8519023061,
1.1506040096,
0.2967433929,
-0.3861421049,
1.0590561628,
-0.2128391415,
0.4206028581,
-0.5064539313,
0.5762966275,
-0.1838471591,
-0.0345741585,
-0.3000729382,
-0.779892385,
-0.3282597959,
0.4467339814,
-0.044846952,
-0.4557122886,
0.7668544054,
0.2132722288,
0.0636511445,
0.2844248414,
-0.1484224647,
-0.1933147311,
0.3604826927,
0.4598574936,
0.7951222062,
-0.5573748946,
0.5221610069,
-0.3442122042,
-0.6487216949,
-0.6173839569,
-0.938290298,
-1.1442432404,
-0.7282383442,
-0.3651668429,
-0.2265667021,
-0.0477861129,
0.3635210991,
0.5121067762,
-0.7997697592,
-0.0726460963,
-0.1228491887,
-0.2130668461,
0.0761109367,
-0.1796975434,
0.6499551535,
-0.1975761205,
-0.7550925016,
0.5045816302,
0.4651730955,
0.143768087,
0.0159769487,
0.0997976139,
-0.0014795441,
0.1152847111,
0.7770153284,
0.3522586226,
-0.3412862718,
-0.1202251241,
0.0661889091,
0.0906576514,
-0.3081253767,
0.9631320238,
-0.2753942907,
0.4549241066,
0.9151668549,
0.1081121936,
0.7700601816,
0.2362017483,
0.6929692626,
-0.5609352589,
0.2549742758,
0.3546768129,
0.4156546295,
0.0288228095,
-0.6920129657,
0.6075425148,
-0.0191654805,
-0.503503561,
-1.063710928,
-0.1299308091,
-1.2191467285,
-0.259457916,
0.7139330506,
-0.1501470953,
-0.3253309131,
-0.041704867,
-0.6244611144,
0.1953682303,
-0.506218195,
0.6931782961,
0.4629873931,
-0.3296324313,
0.0023637468,
-0.0546019897,
0.3053387403,
-0.0395491943,
-1.08476758,
-0.2132482082,
0.6539540887,
-0.0694250464,
0.5354798436,
0.7023884058,
-0.4397086799,
0.6220315695,
0.1888655871,
0.0637717545,
-0.6037031412,
-0.5755443573,
0.0172018725,
0.4707232118,
-0.0905550197,
-0.1633420289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01896v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01896v1 | LogEval: A Comprehensive Benchmark Suite for Large Language Models In Log Analysis | 2024-07-02T02:39:33 | 2024-07-02T02:39:33 | Tianyu Cui, Shiyu Ma, Ziang Chen, Tong Xiao, Shimin Tao, Yilun Liu, Shenglin Zhang, Duoming Lin, Changchang Liu, Yuzhe Cai, Weibin Meng, Yongqian Sun, Dan Pei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Log analysis is crucial for ensuring the orderly and stable operation of
information systems, particularly in the field of Artificial Intelligence for
IT Operations (AIOps). Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated
significant potential in natural language processing tasks. In the AIOps
domain, they excel in tasks such as anomaly detection, root cause analysis of
faults, operations and maintenance script generation, and alert information
summarization. However, the performance of current LLMs in log analysis tasks
remains inadequately validated. To address this gap, we introduce LogEval, a
comprehensive benchmark suite designed to evaluate the capabilities of LLMs in
various log analysis tasks for the first time. This benchmark covers tasks such
as log parsing, log anomaly detection, log fault diagnosis, and log
summarization. LogEval evaluates each task using 4,000 publicly available log
data entries and employs 15 different prompts for each task to ensure a
thorough and fair assessment. By rigorously evaluating leading LLMs, we
demonstrate the impact of various LLM technologies on log analysis performance,
focusing on aspects such as self-consistency and few-shot contextual learning.
We also discuss findings related to model quantification, Chinese-English
question-answering evaluation, and prompt engineering. These findings provide
insights into the strengths and weaknesses of LLMs in multilingual environments
and the effectiveness of different prompt strategies. Various evaluation
methods are employed for different tasks to accurately measure the performance
of LLMs in log analysis, ensuring a comprehensive assessment. The insights
gained from LogEvals evaluation reveal the strengths and limitations of LLMs in
log analysis tasks, providing valuable guidance for researchers and
practitioners. | [
0.1522454172,
-0.9253271222,
0.1942099035,
0.5628398061,
-0.1883603781,
0.3349133134,
-0.304910332,
-0.6127039194,
-0.192581445,
0.3525666296,
-0.4228848219,
-0.8222333789,
-0.4071480036,
0.2069010437,
-0.4953870475,
0.972114861,
0.0292838234,
-0.0410349667,
-0.4453023374,
-0.3457756042,
-0.8933774233,
-0.7077550888,
-0.843812108,
0.1804461777,
0.1580512822,
0.1358717978,
0.3821085989,
0.3326224983,
0.7499881387,
0.2982562184,
0.0033268479,
0.0826826245,
-0.4211931527,
0.2423091382,
0.0634725317,
-0.4082270265,
-0.6549576521,
-0.5074627399,
1.0671442747,
0.5532461405,
-0.2557543814,
0.4515620172,
0.1035804749,
0.621581316,
-0.4818659425,
0.2654635608,
-0.7259523273,
-0.0402371287,
-0.2815172672,
0.0112311095,
-0.4876762629,
-0.376657337,
-0.0556085035,
-0.2763272822,
0.1006113738,
0.2113027275,
0.4535242021,
0.2664198875,
-0.4355709255,
-0.2588163912,
-0.4311243594,
1.0486731529,
-1.0159230232,
0.4286546111,
0.1456362754,
0.377230525,
-0.1297647953,
-0.6938089132,
-0.2635512054,
-0.3012388647,
-0.3675881028,
-0.2330080271,
-0.1895388812,
0.0251656938,
0.2379346192,
0.2077685595,
-0.9720782638,
0.4602370858,
-0.3092532754,
-0.1586225033,
0.917121172,
0.5648223162,
0.1911614537,
-0.1541207433,
-0.3012607098,
-0.0411441997,
-0.6122083664,
0.1201315001,
-0.1554342657,
0.3376060128,
0.0521888994,
0.2347348034,
-0.2150506973,
0.8533607721,
-0.4896515012,
-0.3348254263,
0.2960900366,
-0.2829062343,
-0.4187699556,
0.0767498612,
0.8296082616,
0.3674760163,
-0.0898715854,
0.0511424951,
-0.388222754,
-0.055225078,
-0.0254083909,
-0.8013251424,
-0.1200933084,
0.4082997441,
-0.5731359124,
-0.180826515,
-0.3298315108,
-0.8677592278,
-0.5866211653,
-0.0755067393,
0.1582389027,
-0.1037989482,
-0.3532578647,
-0.0050858422,
0.2980383635,
0.239763245,
0.2952239215,
-0.6765015721,
0.5826950669,
0.9681637287,
0.8638905287,
-0.4852220416,
-0.4394831061,
-1.1069065332,
-0.125246197,
-0.4348291755,
0.6558615565,
-0.5122929811,
-0.4428336024,
0.2278632522,
0.0591826364,
-0.2853654623,
-0.7382542491,
0.7065377831,
-0.5782601237,
-0.0315966718,
0.0571137741,
-0.7466572523,
-0.1709249467,
0.3984844089,
-0.6951845288,
1.2255136967,
-0.1180403903,
-0.4110881388,
0.2893037796,
-0.6685475111,
-0.5321996808,
0.3577639759,
-0.2671338916,
-0.3024586737,
0.1244007647,
0.1609424502,
0.5069704056,
-0.571172297,
0.5095223784,
-0.0280998126,
-0.1806330234,
0.0210029315,
-0.4368499219,
0.8379722238,
0.1452226043,
-0.3458853662,
0.3049945831,
-0.7000954747,
0.1955417991,
0.0745349824,
-0.2939878702,
-0.1873063892,
0.1952532977,
0.145480141,
-0.0136220921,
0.3662354052,
-0.3101620078,
0.1954895854,
-0.1272462159,
0.0296925977,
0.637348175,
-0.1605516225,
-0.2166213989,
0.0076224054,
0.5911452174,
-0.2585279942,
0.1663681418,
-0.6178276539,
-0.2613908947,
-0.5687713027,
-0.3543797135,
0.1718991548,
0.7592535615,
-0.0380622894,
0.3601907492,
-0.3371745944,
-0.5088019967,
-0.4582117498,
0.5258994699,
0.4680625796,
0.3581623137,
0.2530445755,
-0.0137096299,
-0.5568772554,
-0.8154711723,
-0.6377708316,
-0.3989559114,
-0.087770991,
0.052120883,
0.2057691962,
-0.1653555483,
0.6159021258,
-0.4189440012,
-0.4259856343,
-0.2594828606,
0.1936035007,
0.4552354217,
0.2979772687,
0.3630969822,
-0.6632282138,
-0.7101080418,
0.3218908608,
-0.9785583615,
-0.0688180774,
-0.2370871007,
0.1945634484,
0.5287733078,
0.6612893939,
-0.6313148737,
0.1841499954,
0.5775054693,
-0.4698801935,
0.6097268462,
-0.0022390189,
0.1498812735,
-0.6456229091,
0.3916299045,
-0.083567813,
-0.3263644278,
-0.7037883401,
0.1954381466,
0.228543222,
-0.1469836086,
-0.2515352666,
0.7387936115,
-0.3699482381,
-0.2676101327,
-0.072181657,
0.2704317272,
0.0692001432,
0.1910321712,
-0.10356123,
0.6424894929,
0.5595443249,
-0.4892446399,
0.553550899,
0.0892576352,
-0.5531619787,
0.4941740334,
-0.7345560193,
0.1915338635,
-0.0013428548,
-0.0356098823,
-1.1689890623,
-0.0934859812,
-0.2985275686,
-0.2283651084,
0.3519314528,
0.095813863,
-0.6669491529,
-0.1924444139,
-0.2533947229,
0.3544126749,
0.5304939747,
-0.55815202,
0.6261438131,
0.2471510768,
-0.373598069,
-0.5769670606,
-0.2265563756,
0.2926491797,
-0.3925651014,
-0.7054935098,
0.0410672612,
-0.1989255995,
-0.632563889,
-0.0588903204,
-0.0894009694,
-0.1214996576,
0.2557261884,
-0.030270217,
0.5507133007,
-0.4673427939,
0.3434095681,
-0.264624387,
-0.015683217,
0.1656320393,
-0.1624028385,
0.3170178235,
-0.5103666186,
-0.3708186448,
-0.4356100857,
0.1754265428,
0.5818636417,
-0.3297778666,
0.6279323101,
0.3148251772,
-0.4220295846,
0.0741848797,
-0.8756143451,
0.1446578801,
-0.4333999157,
0.6157322526,
-0.25815323,
-0.6687378883,
0.3519429862,
-0.0941384584,
0.6180248857,
0.6597363949,
0.3088520169,
0.1086744815,
0.965326786,
0.6035835147,
-0.5941752195,
0.1155219376,
0.1678741276,
0.1954489499,
-0.4992429018,
-0.32455948,
-0.5864961743,
-0.0202893801,
-0.2946888804,
-0.3002473116,
0.4280745983,
0.1756074578,
0.0106272148,
-0.0053017372,
-0.1838033348,
0.5970637798,
0.0180085804,
-0.4940920174,
0.6755097508,
-0.0917288661,
0.2560991049,
-0.0453163274,
-0.52010566,
-0.6711971164,
0.9406940341,
0.4564214647,
0.6206133962,
0.1317478269,
0.3927189708,
0.6487705112,
0.3051182628,
-0.6866162419,
0.5911675692,
-0.1674278975,
-0.5117337704,
-0.4732534289,
-0.2259724587,
-0.8982916474,
0.3599573374,
0.0704568028,
-0.9552473426,
-0.2921105623,
0.1403558552,
-0.2588658333,
0.2891343832,
-0.750451684,
1.1122499704,
-0.5262975097,
-0.2566579878,
-0.4731391668,
-0.4494800568,
0.4031554759,
-0.3196659684,
0.4846949875,
-0.0761168599,
-0.1001735479,
0.7938680649,
-0.141654402,
0.8484815955,
-0.1618903279,
-0.1715395749,
0.2521784902,
0.2718325257,
0.7442255616,
0.068615444,
-0.3750752807,
0.3615305126,
0.302957952,
-0.4172347486,
-0.6296510696,
0.8702315688,
-0.4320271611,
-0.7029115558,
-0.2882130742,
-0.2048542798,
-0.1219836026,
0.1944477558,
-0.1106921956,
0.550716579,
-0.3724508286,
0.2750271559,
0.4987820387,
-0.1265579462,
0.5599270463,
0.5139174461,
-0.5505794883,
-0.1723716557,
0.7625142932,
-0.1694817394,
0.2388531864,
0.4414982796,
0.0645149648,
-0.2733545303,
-0.5539322495,
-0.4593125582,
0.0784327835,
-0.9032843113,
-0.283590585,
-0.6063856483,
-0.1886586696,
-0.1057400927,
0.0224843137,
-0.3414055407,
-0.2590039074,
0.0416696556,
-0.0264670346,
0.2064334154,
0.7433688045,
0.3559401035,
0.1498748958,
-0.9866653681,
0.0039466284,
0.1912941039,
0.2291269749,
0.1474128813,
-0.2945618033,
-0.305082798,
-0.4106563926,
-0.1014437303,
-0.4924299717,
0.268539995,
0.3859871924,
0.6764436364,
0.2928319573,
-0.0124801742,
0.6102679968,
-0.4426635802,
0.8775425553,
0.0875806287,
-0.9951367378,
0.5973352194,
-0.0714381337,
0.3419727981,
0.5389572382,
0.3330152035,
-0.726002872,
-0.1709572077,
-0.4073458314,
-0.7296675444,
0.5614407063,
-0.0324439332,
0.0057026711,
0.1089685485,
0.0281980429,
0.2511028945,
0.3107420206,
-0.6962657571,
-0.0536149219,
0.1584164351,
-0.1937378198,
-0.3264299035,
-0.2756710947,
-0.0934676453,
-0.0998316556,
0.623232007,
-0.2285655439,
-0.1587854177,
-0.0439030081,
-0.4025599957,
-0.0565123931,
0.0738639086,
0.4054713547,
0.8903492093,
-0.1268524677,
0.0283500254,
0.6439071894,
-0.2625422478,
-0.172988832,
0.0276131276,
0.22841461,
0.1960450262,
0.8543503881,
0.7561099529,
0.088520579,
-1.201965332,
0.4059973955,
-0.1207514331,
0.2930082977,
-0.3583999574,
-0.0455947556,
-0.0480342098,
0.2359551936,
0.6329644322,
-0.3615116775,
0.2379466444,
-0.4782306254,
-0.0424763039,
0.6474202275,
-0.1658333093,
-0.3382839859,
0.2721240819,
0.1554393023,
-0.4707691371,
0.7029240131,
0.0441320054,
-0.3573998809,
0.6705393195,
0.5498329401,
0.9477043748,
-0.4656914473,
0.0223073419,
0.5587521791,
0.5781091452,
0.1789843738,
0.0881194621,
0.0757787749,
-0.1783922911,
-0.5366973877,
-0.6819575429,
-0.2520267665,
0.2603860497,
-0.4214811921,
0.434378922,
-0.4986704886,
0.1293467432,
-0.2106615603,
0.0863892287,
-0.7295671701,
0.1659689695,
-0.158659026,
0.9626930356,
-0.6765729785,
0.457917124,
0.5523769855,
0.1504059881,
-0.3863049448,
-0.0310440417,
0.1486582011,
-0.7269814014,
0.8730852604,
0.2801944613,
0.0372057222,
-0.2024662793,
-0.26347363,
-0.731184423,
0.9636164308,
0.0865394399,
-0.7527548075,
0.1146943644,
0.1453670412,
0.6258381605,
-0.3386371732,
0.4422733486,
0.7372279763,
0.351103723,
-0.1863415539,
-1.1396491528,
0.2076941282,
-0.2929416895,
-0.0352323018,
0.2348427474,
-0.6904069185,
0.6174046397,
-0.0733911246,
-0.2962664664,
0.013152984,
0.4350194037,
0.3087676167,
0.4718202055,
0.5310413241,
0.0020854922,
1.1099454165,
0.2408639789,
1.0400220156,
-0.2953172028,
0.2236872613,
1.0728863478,
-0.5126343369,
1.2008013725,
0.2170184702,
-0.3443301916,
0.5762616992,
0.4574619532,
0.098177053,
0.1448923647,
0.0900216699,
-0.4693246782,
-0.2097425908,
-0.2182331681,
-0.3518454731,
0.2600447237,
0.4415551722,
0.0079012727,
-0.2123225629,
-0.221189335,
-0.1632470936,
-0.0598478578,
-0.2206032276,
0.8561025858,
0.0547036752,
-0.5736137033,
0.7924829125,
-0.05962497,
0.3193600476,
-0.8417621851,
0.0023401219,
-0.3684231639,
0.1939633191,
-0.3763144314,
-0.4996981323,
0.3709260821,
0.2120731026,
0.1579785198,
0.1198176593,
0.807990551,
-0.0100946343,
-0.585360527,
0.3649487197,
0.3216204941,
0.2044020742,
-0.022523826,
-0.4409813285,
0.4434251487,
-0.0818354264,
-0.1292309165,
0.3112613857,
0.3240393102,
-0.3436929286,
0.7981978655,
0.4815749228,
-0.0347946174,
0.1199559048,
-0.0903811231,
0.7242230773,
-0.7627933025,
-0.251599133,
-1.1807398796,
0.7159131765,
-0.3330037892,
-0.2776336372,
0.8689668775,
0.8875277042,
0.5585364699,
0.0050602541,
0.7605091333,
0.1620432436,
0.3573389649,
-0.6449124813,
0.3597857356,
-0.5047752261,
0.5082321167,
-0.2852528691,
-1.1290836334,
-0.4611262679,
0.2797883153,
-0.174895063,
-0.194301188,
0.8947868347,
0.621970892,
0.143857047,
0.1344278455,
0.5066905618,
0.2566507757,
0.5308968425,
0.3916663527,
0.8549420238,
-0.4035927951,
0.5778173804,
0.2053969949,
-0.3303657472,
-0.303388536,
-1.0936996937,
-1.1096760035,
-0.4368907809,
-0.389171958,
0.0361287594,
0.1206926852,
0.9214277267,
0.5471006036,
-0.9701234698,
-0.7446081638,
0.0361197703,
0.1638303697,
-0.168726474,
-0.2209641784,
0.5136424899,
-0.7300853133,
-0.5195652843,
0.6774562001,
0.4482981265,
-0.4076650441,
-0.3757430911,
-0.1218041107,
-0.0338608958,
-0.2596175373,
0.8164134026,
0.2674052715,
-0.7167878747,
0.0768281519,
0.1500093639,
0.0831348002,
-0.015797304,
0.7377973199,
-0.667093873,
0.5106902122,
0.4430292249,
1.0254199505,
0.4562271237,
-0.1386678666,
0.4409848452,
-0.7777535319,
-0.0211458933,
0.180606544,
0.1842659861,
0.4559382796,
-0.4585227668,
0.577003479,
-0.0651157796,
-0.6363307834,
-1.0960286856,
-0.1043955758,
-0.484772414,
-0.2132592946,
1.0247005224,
-0.216450721,
0.0008754767,
-0.0308814384,
-0.3256599605,
-0.2008320838,
-0.1415928155,
0.7056388855,
0.8476923704,
-0.1499959528,
-0.0689481646,
-0.796662569,
0.4498412609,
0.719876945,
-1.1215971708,
0.441282481,
0.5795146823,
0.1174136773,
0.0891240984,
0.6755227447,
0.041175615,
0.1142818555,
-0.1626848429,
-0.2489109337,
0.2986393273,
-0.3671475649,
-0.689085722,
0.054411862,
0.5091808438,
0.0201452132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01892v1 | GRASP: A Grid-Based Benchmark for Evaluating Commonsense Spatial Reasoning | 2024-07-02T02:27:46 | 2024-07-02T02:27:46 | Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Spatial reasoning, an important faculty of human cognition with many
practical applications, is one of the core commonsense skills that is not
purely language-based and, for satisfying (as opposed to optimal) solutions,
requires some minimum degree of planning. Existing benchmarks of Commonsense
Spatial Reasoning (CSR) tend to evaluate how Large Language Models (LLMs)
interpret text-based spatial descriptions rather than directly evaluate a plan
produced by the LLM in response to a spatial reasoning scenario. In this paper,
we construct a large-scale benchmark called $\textbf{GRASP}$, which consists of
16,000 grid-based environments where the agent is tasked with an energy
collection problem. These environments include 100 grid instances instantiated
using each of the 160 different grid settings, involving five different energy
distributions, two modes of agent starting position, and two distinct obstacle
configurations, as well as three kinds of agent constraints. Using GRASP, we
compare classic baseline approaches, such as random walk and greedy search
methods, with advanced LLMs like GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4o. The experimental
results indicate that even these advanced LLMs struggle to consistently achieve
satisfactory solutions. | [
-0.5014072657,
-0.1467346251,
0.8459308743,
0.0131977499,
0.1173073202,
-0.2502195537,
-0.3557811975,
-0.2602376342,
-0.3142887056,
0.1123611927,
-0.1981455237,
-0.6473062634,
-0.5046160221,
0.1149357557,
0.0318689644,
0.5095901489,
-0.0670049489,
-0.0681633502,
-0.4075284004,
-0.1856436729,
-0.3525925875,
0.0546765551,
-0.3035257757,
-0.6168661714,
0.4724057317,
0.495284915,
0.9389284849,
0.2556374073,
0.3024975955,
0.371101737,
-0.1733230352,
0.187271297,
-0.5236110687,
-0.2941060662,
-0.5558471084,
-0.1368433237,
-0.287979871,
0.1651102602,
0.5677131414,
0.6020177603,
-0.2599566579,
0.028589651,
-0.1849645078,
0.4048413336,
-1.03947258,
-0.068307735,
-0.8078403473,
0.1147960648,
0.0220095292,
0.095755063,
-0.2462248504,
-0.3160613775,
-0.0294422247,
-0.951295495,
0.0601569638,
0.1642194986,
0.9929118752,
0.0166217126,
-0.4579106569,
0.0324085429,
-0.2872768939,
0.9811604619,
-0.6409370899,
0.3703460097,
0.6005244255,
0.7404007316,
-0.1029397398,
-0.4661380649,
-0.5350284576,
-0.2504608631,
0.0411599427,
0.200167641,
-0.0700232014,
0.0269857906,
0.6276500225,
-0.2261272967,
-0.6384973526,
0.1426207423,
-0.3036871552,
-0.0545475595,
0.7864275575,
0.3712307215,
0.0478916839,
-0.3164609671,
-0.7873609066,
-0.1951900274,
-0.6509201527,
-0.1406852454,
0.1341150552,
0.2463982552,
-0.0631946996,
0.5179961324,
-0.3460083306,
0.6870065928,
-0.2866996527,
0.1361015737,
0.1260106266,
-0.3366903663,
-0.2260659486,
-0.4033954144,
0.6086101532,
0.6148357987,
0.5179435015,
-0.1414375603,
-0.522634387,
-0.3248688877,
0.2191851437,
-0.3037899137,
-0.3943347335,
0.1126974821,
-0.3364039063,
0.2093138695,
-0.3277800083,
-0.6807169318,
-0.5991560817,
-0.4718849063,
0.1392555833,
-0.4800695479,
-0.3497693837,
0.3644034266,
-0.4201192558,
0.6948075294,
0.5124059319,
-0.6880165339,
0.5506208539,
1.0380861759,
1.010099411,
-0.2201829255,
-0.5231688619,
-0.4166943431,
0.1217194423,
-0.1094796658,
1.0105221272,
-0.552883327,
-0.4393697381,
-0.0803295225,
-0.431661427,
-0.3264371455,
-0.5588956475,
0.4406221807,
-0.4291174114,
-0.4038549662,
-0.9278681278,
-0.4400183856,
0.0970854238,
0.6019419432,
-0.566609025,
0.9604614973,
0.148978889,
-0.5165002346,
0.8212258816,
-0.5416918397,
-0.1991493106,
0.4416567683,
-0.1970751882,
-0.006539694,
0.0114387646,
0.1256456077,
0.3148336411,
-0.3416370451,
0.196959585,
-0.5327751637,
-0.3064939976,
0.0259210598,
-0.3327840865,
0.4748038054,
0.539624095,
-0.1239591241,
-0.0193930529,
-0.4255842566,
0.3213422298,
0.2413243651,
0.0204208251,
-0.3919324279,
0.1370638013,
0.0950192213,
0.1475908756,
0.4759190679,
-0.490734756,
0.1671802998,
0.0150084542,
0.1257117391,
0.5724315047,
-0.2124525905,
0.4802317023,
-0.4067485929,
0.475910455,
-0.3272943199,
0.0116966153,
0.3730820417,
-0.0873809457,
-0.1044168547,
-0.1635807008,
-0.2840272784,
0.4862180948,
-0.6708663702,
0.1451699734,
-0.554263413,
-0.65696913,
0.2730281949,
-0.006738706,
0.5200947523,
0.1437207162,
0.4055878818,
0.1831211746,
0.0169123225,
-0.7156509161,
-0.634834528,
0.151755482,
-0.1138997003,
0.8793712854,
0.6660060883,
0.2986645699,
1.0252693892,
-0.5810132623,
-0.0553905703,
-0.306828618,
0.1664448828,
0.144454807,
0.2420597523,
0.5667588711,
-0.7105177641,
-0.3741819561,
0.3492951989,
-0.7896966934,
-0.2044695765,
-0.1501938254,
0.0141440285,
-0.2983800173,
0.5125640631,
-0.9203429222,
0.3890158534,
0.1156042069,
-0.4631975293,
0.8956627846,
-0.2351907194,
0.0200571381,
-0.3821069598,
0.4268005192,
0.1948545128,
-0.1090762019,
-0.2846989632,
0.0427592099,
0.0400883071,
-0.2891044617,
-0.6127440333,
0.8616302013,
-0.9155967832,
-0.6604358554,
-0.0612714328,
0.5553902388,
-0.0460031964,
0.4103858173,
0.1691155434,
0.9487927556,
0.1391500384,
-0.4928802848,
0.2205688357,
0.1533421725,
-0.5765362978,
0.7105458975,
-0.7184847593,
0.1070965156,
-0.0196647458,
0.1053206846,
-0.9280464649,
-0.1476565301,
-0.3435245752,
-0.2105551958,
0.0703834593,
0.1095133945,
-0.4748432636,
-0.5241699219,
-0.1427970231,
0.3752653003,
0.1147890463,
-0.5865383148,
0.4513319433,
0.2363756001,
0.1908584535,
-0.6951797009,
-0.3081406355,
0.1737087369,
-0.3322779536,
-0.3261825442,
-0.2314292938,
0.2221003771,
-0.4448745251,
-0.0533186905,
-0.3249905705,
-0.0009782007,
0.2207948118,
-0.2660829425,
-0.2378074825,
0.1151831225,
-0.0398517512,
-0.0950720608,
-0.0903071165,
0.2357701808,
-0.1070207506,
0.3324146867,
-0.2751485109,
-0.5900484324,
0.0463492721,
0.088230513,
0.6761888266,
0.0402949937,
0.2450090349,
0.188060075,
-0.3247475624,
-0.439679265,
-0.4185878634,
0.1421384811,
-0.505261004,
0.5120941401,
-0.9154101014,
-0.4418604076,
0.4412794709,
-0.5118469,
0.2060805112,
0.118437767,
0.0249453001,
0.0153374653,
0.7775014639,
-0.1806434095,
-0.1017311364,
0.0954277962,
-0.3638103604,
-0.1599628031,
-0.9154932499,
-0.0513501689,
-0.6854300499,
-0.5114393234,
-0.0016428777,
-0.6356059313,
0.4328457117,
0.1157676429,
-0.5814607143,
0.6391414404,
-0.4301508069,
0.7701122165,
0.2724582553,
-0.0497975051,
0.0132778566,
-0.1350619197,
-0.4758548141,
0.0275489204,
-0.7977975011,
-0.5238958001,
0.8091596365,
0.1463186741,
0.5322575569,
0.2734315395,
0.4840450287,
0.2747629881,
0.3041853309,
-0.5815541744,
0.9233769178,
0.0056717433,
-0.3299127519,
-0.424043268,
-0.5421889424,
-1.2866711617,
0.6804448366,
0.0171544291,
-0.994153142,
0.0604612008,
0.1150957048,
-0.0633528233,
0.5509498119,
-0.6299990416,
0.9881445765,
-0.4152280092,
-0.7375033498,
-0.293535471,
-0.3023911715,
0.2717214823,
0.4616527259,
0.1849120557,
-0.4823557138,
-0.3263100982,
0.233970046,
-0.5235466361,
0.6259829998,
-0.7606076002,
-0.1330589652,
0.3417402804,
0.1424300224,
0.7487790585,
-0.1755911708,
-0.1770634502,
0.2001782209,
-0.0297308154,
-0.6763978004,
-0.5949594975,
0.6890215278,
-0.7803746462,
-0.4572638869,
-0.4037593007,
-0.5385389924,
-0.5159753561,
0.3116294146,
0.3616858721,
0.2523211837,
-0.5585694313,
-0.289542675,
0.5085697174,
-0.1986795515,
0.3626425862,
0.4567507505,
0.011013953,
-0.3955253363,
0.6052333117,
-0.0617602244,
0.3364768624,
0.4727365077,
0.3137080967,
-0.7670786381,
-0.7398374081,
-0.3540568948,
0.0566660017,
-0.6166520119,
-0.5762559175,
-0.4846087694,
0.0288860127,
-0.1559947133,
-0.6606875658,
-0.265941143,
-0.0202344544,
-0.0308094379,
-0.1114300936,
0.2888432145,
0.6851831079,
-0.251193881,
0.149344638,
-0.6307206154,
0.1644824445,
0.3364554644,
0.5560353994,
0.2467562258,
-0.1284286678,
-0.1052050442,
-0.0227652527,
-0.1956277788,
-0.7090990543,
0.26885432,
-0.1246811748,
0.7093495131,
0.4403972626,
0.0470322259,
0.5090203285,
-0.2950405478,
0.7276344299,
0.4379310906,
-0.7787517905,
0.3843998909,
-0.9120695591,
0.8649946451,
0.7047332525,
0.2438678443,
-0.4155281782,
-0.0230400916,
-0.4025160372,
-0.7083398104,
0.3786277771,
-0.0738831609,
-0.2598862052,
-0.3392642736,
0.1271081418,
-0.0354659073,
0.0093260938,
-0.4997883439,
0.2517675757,
0.0083187204,
0.1230606139,
-0.019463975,
-0.0051718028,
-0.0498487242,
-0.0655360371,
0.2648675442,
-0.2897464931,
0.1768676043,
0.0508336611,
-0.1605952978,
0.1701752841,
0.3613085151,
0.5368357897,
0.6552945375,
-0.111079745,
0.2506851852,
0.6150327325,
-0.4610856771,
-0.0120132603,
0.0362876728,
-0.081737712,
-0.3198237121,
0.244394511,
0.5328192711,
0.6024491787,
-0.8160336614,
0.5881155729,
0.2649365366,
-0.6113904119,
-0.1433289945,
0.0278430227,
0.04493846,
0.0814886689,
0.2149088085,
-0.0098422971,
0.3704784214,
0.0809110552,
0.1598621756,
0.6843553782,
-0.1777299941,
-0.1869790256,
0.4887228012,
0.2501066923,
0.0001124516,
0.662774086,
-0.5812525749,
-0.555218935,
0.8450089097,
0.4611429274,
0.9093974829,
0.30305475,
0.1846636832,
0.7514846325,
0.1953176707,
-0.1194234267,
0.408624351,
-0.5723828673,
-0.9338145256,
-0.3980044127,
-0.3438372016,
-0.4687144458,
-0.0907231867,
-0.6426500082,
0.0211507306,
-0.4379426241,
-0.1872164905,
-0.3433260322,
0.382224232,
-0.8481144905,
-0.053994935,
0.0478189737,
1.3926212788,
-0.7804346085,
0.3869808316,
0.9437266588,
0.0668165237,
-0.624979198,
-0.359737128,
0.1490389407,
-0.8896504641,
0.5904403329,
-0.0350983068,
-0.377784431,
-0.3112538457,
-0.8339354992,
-1.1397255659,
1.1439270973,
-0.0333070196,
-0.7669397593,
0.3520482481,
-0.0291371532,
0.3468731046,
0.1577471197,
0.4841734469,
0.7039470673,
0.9161854386,
0.1893907338,
-1.0583260059,
0.1283432096,
-0.2635500431,
0.1373088658,
0.4465062022,
-0.7985700369,
0.5723128319,
-0.5025435686,
-0.505694747,
0.2598362565,
0.5654348135,
0.7834604383,
0.7686746716,
0.6349033117,
0.9079662561,
0.7904549837,
-0.050287839,
0.9621063471,
0.0710796267,
0.4889397621,
1.2200740576,
-0.8391547203,
0.9191272855,
0.1021549702,
-0.5835582018,
0.1113983393,
0.2339569032,
-0.0193985924,
0.4543049634,
0.7265242338,
-0.2868890166,
-0.2911882401,
0.0406276621,
-0.2626049221,
0.473443985,
0.6311737299,
0.447064817,
-0.65628016,
-0.0338875875,
0.1396621168,
0.6226724386,
-0.5657131672,
0.6777249575,
0.0349127688,
-0.8085719347,
0.5002988577,
-0.4620965719,
0.5436694622,
-0.3694091439,
0.0956325755,
-0.1306154281,
0.2527952194,
-0.0160842389,
-1.112876296,
0.1039825082,
-0.0117808785,
0.1015721783,
-0.40364182,
0.8905837536,
-0.001610881,
0.0537922084,
0.3019357622,
0.5261729956,
0.5231862664,
0.0976461843,
-0.7631200552,
0.0334229991,
-0.2776352167,
-0.1330180913,
0.4363653958,
0.777705133,
0.0155925406,
0.728921175,
0.4067618549,
0.1656607389,
-0.1952017695,
-0.0038728733,
0.7822635174,
-0.8050345182,
-0.3086619973,
-0.174048543,
-0.039835047,
-0.4359479845,
-0.5392309427,
0.7511419058,
0.6774305105,
0.709363699,
0.0910555199,
0.7556357384,
-0.0870664418,
0.2698585391,
-0.4686946273,
0.5237957239,
-0.4848506451,
0.2063305676,
-0.1941150725,
-0.838471055,
-0.0063269651,
0.6775306463,
-0.9203289747,
0.4758775234,
0.5232886672,
0.4144404531,
-0.2230645865,
-0.0123025738,
0.6732538342,
0.0058136452,
0.1219836771,
1.0521285534,
1.0564340353,
-0.029493425,
0.3838456869,
0.2019662112,
-0.210337162,
0.1155813038,
-0.944382906,
-0.6692624688,
-0.1100699008,
-0.0933397487,
-0.100789763,
0.0685370117,
0.7235092521,
0.7108908296,
-0.5190751553,
-0.3493001759,
-0.3491320908,
0.2305592746,
-0.6296354532,
-0.2296723723,
0.292112112,
-0.4902448356,
-0.6070104837,
0.4321084023,
0.1344671696,
-0.2120689899,
-0.0471171699,
-0.2789973915,
-0.2785544395,
-0.1494924575,
0.5010528564,
0.716486752,
-0.5568545461,
-0.3260126114,
0.0482213683,
-0.2303604782,
-0.1943599284,
0.9023979902,
-0.8345184326,
0.3358590603,
0.5423365235,
0.434165597,
0.6156994104,
0.1687337011,
0.4689807296,
-0.6120015383,
-0.0870369002,
0.2852503061,
0.4536675215,
0.2023279369,
-0.1701931953,
0.4492052197,
0.0700674206,
-0.6827508211,
-0.371617198,
0.246064201,
-1.052709341,
-0.4908004999,
1.3878468275,
-0.2120472491,
-0.1737862378,
-0.2920324802,
0.0666867942,
-0.3563175201,
-0.5447696447,
0.391212374,
0.4389355779,
-0.0009545479,
-0.2120140493,
-0.3484044969,
0.3110157847,
0.5346480608,
-0.6721253991,
0.4705221653,
0.869615674,
0.1473794281,
0.0162491612,
0.7843648195,
0.0980679095,
0.4407946467,
0.4984478354,
0.0663769841,
-0.127790764,
-0.2809936106,
-0.1416953653,
0.1867061555,
0.0859661475,
-0.1549362391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01887v1 | Beyond Numeric Awards: In-Context Dueling Bandits with LLM Agents | 2024-07-02T02:18:14 | 2024-07-02T02:18:14 | Fanzeng Xia, Hao Liu, Yisong Yue, Tongxin Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In-context decision-making is an important capability of artificial general
intelligence, which Large Language Models (LLMs) have effectively demonstrated
in various scenarios. However, LLMs often face challenges when dealing with
numerical contexts, and limited attention has been paid to evaluating their
performance through preference feedback generated by the environment. This
paper investigates the performance of LLMs as decision-makers in the context of
Dueling Bandits (DB). We first evaluate the performance of LLMs by comparing
GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and GPT-4-Turbo against established DB algorithms. Our
results reveal that LLMs, particularly GPT-4 Turbo, quickly identify the
Condorcet winner, thus outperforming existing state-of-the-art algorithms in
terms of weak regret. Nevertheless, LLMs struggle to converge even when
explicitly prompted to do so, and are sensitive to prompt variations. To
overcome these issues, we introduce an LLM-augmented algorithm, IF-Enhanced
LLM, which takes advantage of both in-context decision-making capabilities of
LLMs and theoretical guarantees inherited from classic DB algorithms. The
design of such an algorithm sheds light on how to enhance trustworthiness for
LLMs used in decision-making tasks where performance robustness matters. We
show that IF-Enhanced LLM has theoretical guarantees on both weak and strong
regret. Our experimental results validate that IF-Enhanced LLM is robust even
with noisy and adversarial prompts. | [
-0.4252607226,
-0.6550486684,
0.7593138218,
0.2130257636,
-0.1427970082,
0.5345964432,
-0.6317337155,
-0.4809494615,
0.1111507863,
0.4264218211,
-0.2340756804,
-0.4467548728,
-0.8460034132,
0.3027894497,
-0.0481920429,
1.1520930529,
-0.0607738905,
-0.0263959933,
-0.4159483612,
-0.0784819499,
-0.5250896811,
-0.7800232768,
-1.0173770189,
-0.3820904195,
0.4117664695,
0.1328010261,
0.7988004088,
0.1565802097,
0.3657769859,
0.4823901951,
-0.2134217769,
0.1410246342,
-0.5128490329,
0.1478264481,
-0.2413753122,
-0.7201581001,
-0.409119755,
-0.0537952073,
0.6248186231,
0.206475839,
-0.0492637455,
-0.4147277474,
0.201683715,
0.6586565971,
-0.6325464845,
0.3730967939,
-0.9042361975,
-0.1434638351,
-0.2716076076,
-0.2893422544,
-0.3046444952,
-0.6290136576,
0.2689264119,
-0.3877814114,
-0.2086182088,
-0.0855984986,
0.6939002872,
0.3943274915,
-0.1784116924,
-0.5203267932,
-0.5124402642,
0.7288486362,
-0.6030404568,
0.0139499158,
0.3471909165,
0.249531582,
-0.3069772422,
-0.4979520738,
-0.2752275169,
-0.4856854677,
-0.039193131,
0.102371648,
-0.2378920615,
0.3249795139,
0.3009358644,
0.0025726685,
-0.1049482003,
0.3469770551,
-0.0991953686,
-0.1273948103,
0.6787701845,
0.1557673365,
-0.1096300557,
-0.1505267471,
-0.3283339739,
-0.0960444808,
-0.7043207288,
0.4768637419,
0.3577364981,
0.3026994765,
0.0774286762,
0.3601318002,
-0.1884419471,
0.6633423567,
0.316891551,
-0.2805341184,
-0.0580048598,
-0.2223122269,
-0.0959682539,
0.2474503964,
0.6894757152,
0.4254092276,
0.3845207691,
-0.3532987535,
-0.5084273815,
0.0543450452,
0.061645519,
-0.7477206588,
-0.0470629446,
0.1800945699,
-0.0519358069,
-0.4147802293,
-0.0082954718,
-0.6816672087,
-0.5963765979,
-0.2499974072,
0.7453582287,
-0.4504327476,
-0.0420179926,
-0.0127025163,
-0.3634557128,
0.3554620743,
0.3099608123,
-0.767037034,
0.2610304058,
0.7954248786,
0.8386393785,
-0.2291710377,
-0.1773013622,
-0.723294735,
0.1060726121,
-0.4029556513,
0.6816644073,
-0.7048031092,
-0.706338644,
-0.0933311358,
-0.3680275679,
-0.078193292,
-0.6252095103,
0.8708662391,
-0.8017051816,
0.0492774658,
-0.4758566618,
-0.4883670807,
-0.2760017812,
0.31373173,
-0.4712791145,
0.6096214652,
0.1537391841,
-0.5563267469,
0.6415500641,
-0.6175730228,
-0.3597166538,
0.2165472955,
-0.3308355808,
-0.3920583129,
-0.0161057301,
0.1495220661,
0.4046244621,
-0.3534669578,
0.3787062466,
-0.6491937041,
-0.5534729362,
0.5569813251,
-0.5178955197,
0.7180626392,
-0.1262960583,
-0.5344061852,
0.2101850659,
-0.2988626957,
0.1765352637,
-0.0588466413,
-0.4345088005,
-0.2901153862,
0.1207201481,
-0.5351116061,
-0.0366732813,
0.1680111736,
-0.3298389018,
0.234902963,
-0.4063081145,
0.5339345932,
1.1195242405,
-0.1528867781,
0.458263576,
-0.3945954144,
0.4782443643,
-0.2963110209,
-0.1082086861,
0.1092425808,
-0.3895250857,
-0.737885952,
-0.4022496045,
0.7250558138,
0.6859186292,
-1.0210455656,
0.3587979972,
-0.3332048953,
-0.1061231121,
-0.3396850824,
0.1160044521,
0.3994194269,
0.190424636,
-0.0673309714,
-0.3158332109,
-0.4192157388,
-0.7978641391,
-0.434376657,
-0.2083367854,
-0.0082464339,
0.5687372088,
0.2293831408,
-0.1970573217,
0.9291089177,
-0.0529770106,
-0.0919706374,
-0.2132080197,
-0.0240962189,
0.3216745257,
0.1088668332,
0.6112977266,
-0.6320430636,
-0.5398457646,
0.1147103012,
-0.7943865657,
-0.087725535,
-0.0570296384,
0.0964772254,
0.4483504295,
0.2677804232,
-0.7317650318,
0.3117536604,
0.3513959348,
-0.1747735739,
0.4914140105,
-0.2617702484,
0.2595612705,
-0.5088257194,
-0.2672229707,
0.0042000348,
-0.2197065502,
-0.3500399292,
-0.0686786622,
0.0550634339,
0.2838414311,
-0.0750298947,
0.472723484,
-0.3361273706,
-0.2321333438,
-0.2968247533,
0.2903555632,
-0.3052072227,
0.5043057799,
0.1232540905,
0.8781486154,
0.7445180416,
-0.637044549,
0.3713082969,
-0.1541264206,
-0.4199564159,
0.8533580303,
-0.6019359827,
0.1150927022,
-0.0736961663,
0.4501672089,
-0.868792057,
-0.2155904919,
0.0861316547,
-0.597646296,
0.5529056191,
-0.1290943176,
-0.3304699957,
-0.2398784757,
-0.5659552813,
0.1571781933,
0.4398887157,
-0.7068056464,
0.6349728107,
0.3142817318,
-0.4198097885,
-0.6505246758,
-0.3312890828,
0.5103522539,
-0.609210968,
-0.7140570879,
0.4739114642,
-0.1447819918,
-0.6995065212,
-0.1090327576,
0.0884502605,
0.1087900177,
0.2885358334,
0.1914237589,
0.4273979664,
0.0256826058,
-0.1355810314,
0.1022797078,
-0.2854246199,
0.2843842208,
-0.1439414173,
0.1547066569,
-0.4287279844,
-0.1296969801,
0.0065220976,
0.1815363765,
0.3873169124,
-0.0869953781,
0.6030181646,
0.319334656,
-0.0630476698,
-0.4508918524,
-0.4319615364,
-0.2218402177,
-0.5738188624,
0.0952105522,
-0.5328729153,
-1.0773026943,
0.400409013,
-0.286107868,
0.1324993223,
0.3679334521,
0.6248775721,
-0.0078384327,
0.9659550786,
0.2689026594,
-0.3437339365,
0.3239177167,
-0.0699162632,
0.1468448937,
-0.6217470169,
-0.1717666835,
-0.4671440721,
-0.3158964515,
-0.7606264353,
-0.2548297048,
0.741335392,
0.1406470537,
-0.1651592851,
0.0174881704,
-0.2782504559,
0.7683138847,
0.5179966092,
0.0313655026,
0.2148782462,
-0.2584240437,
-0.182803914,
0.0989468098,
-0.8598231673,
-0.3501417637,
1.1486853361,
0.0667052567,
0.5816949606,
0.3107351065,
0.6591873169,
0.405280143,
0.5183258653,
-0.6409595013,
0.4700139761,
0.0869617462,
-0.3610987961,
-0.255351752,
-0.4661801755,
-0.9887441993,
0.2902481854,
-0.2959252596,
-0.7279019356,
0.0667217821,
-0.1503373086,
-0.754008472,
0.3313916028,
-0.6532058716,
0.3662208319,
-0.5075680017,
-0.6962125897,
-0.1148376241,
-0.7234850526,
0.5993178487,
-0.1935640723,
0.099709861,
0.2400535196,
-0.1822828501,
0.4451663494,
-0.1836310029,
0.6747656465,
-0.0953938589,
-0.0281381961,
0.3259028494,
0.0837556645,
0.9414540529,
0.2333597094,
-0.2862887681,
0.2083798796,
-0.1783982962,
-0.0953204408,
-0.5850810409,
1.0319923162,
-0.7973914742,
-0.9499670863,
-0.5081275105,
-0.2242375314,
-0.387147218,
-0.0943253338,
0.1899487674,
0.4314673543,
-0.125835374,
0.5293532014,
0.793759346,
-0.3048784137,
0.5509824157,
0.4347583055,
0.0001286396,
-0.4868882895,
0.8907268047,
0.120438464,
0.2690355778,
0.2745453119,
0.1132848263,
-0.7576338053,
-0.6443335414,
-0.5881235003,
-0.0220461152,
-0.621797204,
-0.3387283385,
-0.4282051921,
-0.283451587,
-0.0360909961,
-0.4287511408,
0.0219266601,
-0.2177766114,
-0.0130729945,
-0.1220186353,
0.3985645175,
0.7014857531,
-0.2390209883,
0.0684613958,
-0.4240339696,
0.0456455983,
0.6668268442,
0.5072891712,
-0.0968882367,
-0.3826146424,
-0.0967871249,
-0.1146102175,
-0.1952697635,
-0.7528762221,
0.1590750217,
-0.0947268531,
0.6001242399,
0.292312175,
-0.0255682487,
0.3834528923,
-0.0896503553,
0.6546916962,
-0.2077778727,
-0.8461900353,
0.0846509114,
-0.6302358508,
0.0365463793,
0.5509700775,
0.1120311543,
-0.1487827897,
-0.2108864933,
-0.5981372595,
-0.6424029469,
0.873839736,
0.2444559485,
-0.0182330497,
0.0871038213,
0.4208346307,
-0.0212223455,
0.3293755054,
-0.7298924327,
-0.1441341341,
0.0483457595,
0.3166635633,
-0.3107046783,
-0.2311657667,
-0.1757440567,
-0.1085068583,
0.5384936333,
-0.0472091995,
0.1217675507,
0.0137347048,
0.0578373484,
0.001983084,
0.4339104295,
0.4826788306,
0.4701927304,
-0.2268887609,
-0.0285205729,
0.5007113814,
0.2298922539,
0.0621957593,
0.2001684606,
-0.1895967722,
-0.2078440934,
0.2115397453,
0.8479213119,
0.39867872,
-0.6904876232,
0.5486731529,
-0.1226586178,
-0.2819407582,
-0.1959398538,
0.3526088297,
0.0037613874,
0.4560317397,
0.1532792896,
0.1519138813,
0.2653268874,
-0.533367157,
0.0112857744,
0.9066816568,
-0.0520012751,
-0.1193384826,
0.4247384667,
0.3483188748,
-0.4321804941,
0.3142276108,
-0.4329046011,
-0.893281579,
0.6674818397,
0.4483372867,
0.9894436002,
-0.074723199,
0.1348536462,
0.1965410262,
0.2815268636,
0.035669785,
0.0076768976,
-0.2402414232,
-0.6676835418,
-0.3567205966,
-0.4742304385,
-0.6708361506,
0.0332791544,
-0.2953106463,
0.2289871126,
-0.6679547429,
-0.2643519044,
-0.2302802652,
0.2341704965,
-0.5907603502,
-0.037230432,
0.1870059967,
0.5258162618,
-0.2282651067,
0.6175079942,
0.3690862954,
0.091283828,
-0.5353426933,
-0.1670192033,
0.1192007363,
-0.6762197614,
0.4399060905,
-0.0087235905,
-0.3450043201,
-0.2360726893,
-0.4513125718,
-0.9066764116,
1.0879566669,
0.3502920866,
-0.4237070084,
0.2540854216,
-0.0519955792,
0.4562499225,
-0.2124145776,
0.4947510362,
0.8938654065,
0.810656786,
0.1574212909,
-1.0348272324,
-0.1711256355,
0.0169695299,
-0.0198832415,
0.4186279476,
-0.9660023451,
0.8915997148,
-0.442812711,
-0.2064356357,
0.0948645771,
0.5332808495,
0.6399515271,
0.2729078531,
0.5004069805,
0.3993644118,
0.8182319999,
-0.2521791756,
1.2827111483,
-0.1581488848,
-0.0822798759,
0.9012923241,
-0.2764241099,
0.6441549659,
0.0396062881,
-0.3782172501,
0.6247698069,
0.7372649908,
0.2732329965,
0.4382545054,
0.2960903645,
-0.497423321,
-0.3130913973,
-0.0366972312,
-0.2914467454,
0.516251266,
0.5092287064,
-0.166425541,
-0.1122780293,
-0.3984187543,
0.1842734069,
0.0154005401,
-0.4006611705,
0.8879486918,
-0.0028418731,
-1.0141942501,
0.573428452,
0.3116273284,
0.9505879879,
-0.7737581134,
0.1400904059,
-0.1688574404,
0.1911868602,
-0.1071832031,
-0.9386099577,
-0.0008761628,
0.0593542904,
-0.0506840348,
-0.1012552381,
0.810626924,
-0.3585809767,
-0.1727271378,
0.3440050483,
0.2915636599,
-0.0182681642,
-0.1527986228,
-0.6672418118,
0.2113188803,
0.0367055498,
-0.0799627155,
0.5149447322,
0.565544486,
-0.2731303573,
0.7411382794,
0.625348866,
0.0298973415,
-0.2816735804,
-0.0880029574,
0.8334347606,
-0.5252660513,
-0.4763550162,
-1.0688447952,
0.0924785882,
-0.2168255448,
-0.196707651,
0.9119022489,
0.3567052484,
0.7264512777,
0.3285027146,
0.973289907,
0.0701471493,
0.1865157634,
-0.6017512679,
0.4381399155,
-0.2180748284,
0.4518076479,
-0.256744951,
-0.7367858887,
-0.0932521448,
0.4182721078,
-0.585927546,
0.3759508431,
0.2392458469,
0.746770978,
0.3764998317,
0.0987669602,
0.3644586205,
0.1274810582,
0.2877189219,
0.89131248,
0.9833210111,
0.0835616365,
0.3836477399,
0.0584876686,
-0.4305553734,
-0.1632628441,
-0.9461510777,
-0.9681870341,
-0.2392615527,
0.1250635833,
-0.2720103562,
0.0671233013,
0.9110565186,
0.4475733042,
-0.4910931885,
-0.336948812,
0.205841586,
0.5948395729,
-0.0271368716,
-0.2234764844,
0.1375437975,
-0.3289636672,
-0.6723066568,
0.5315363407,
0.5753260255,
-0.0924146995,
-0.2833034694,
-0.5467126966,
0.2901571393,
0.3570571244,
0.7264882326,
0.1902398914,
-0.8544866443,
-0.1391977221,
-0.2835305929,
0.0857984871,
-0.0104076536,
0.6430901289,
-1.019482255,
0.5465229154,
0.2387887686,
0.7839891911,
0.3568362892,
0.1264027059,
0.6843669415,
-0.3782932162,
-0.1049278751,
0.2685540318,
0.3487650454,
0.357614547,
-0.3300663829,
0.4270510972,
0.0923260897,
-0.7222346663,
-0.597456038,
-0.1065511405,
-0.7291712761,
-0.2741706073,
1.3393464088,
-0.0168497451,
-0.0507373698,
0.0204300713,
-0.3962596357,
-0.2800382674,
-0.6821426153,
0.9211782813,
0.946573019,
-0.061557211,
-0.0465960577,
-0.1839931756,
0.9284017086,
0.3554551005,
-0.7530450225,
-0.00265444,
0.5100414157,
0.0693756416,
-0.1017975211,
0.5496233702,
-0.0055993642,
0.3146573007,
-0.028194299,
-0.5845898986,
0.0628105476,
-0.3704744577,
-0.4775489569,
0.2900618613,
0.3402471542,
0.2539129555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01885v1 | Survey on Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models: Methods, Evaluation, and Application | 2024-07-02T02:14:42 | 2024-07-02T02:14:42 | Chuanpeng Yang, Wang Lu, Yao Zhu, Yidong Wang, Qian Chen, Chenlong Gao, Bingjie Yan, Yiqiang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased exceptional capabilities in
various domains, attracting significant interest from both academia and
industry. Despite their impressive performance, the substantial size and
computational demands of LLMs pose considerable challenges for practical
deployment, particularly in environments with limited resources. The endeavor
to compress language models while maintaining their accuracy has become a focal
point of research. Among the various methods, knowledge distillation has
emerged as an effective technique to enhance inference speed without greatly
compromising performance. This paper presents a thorough survey from three
aspects: method, evaluation, and application, exploring knowledge distillation
techniques tailored specifically for LLMs. Specifically, we divide the methods
into white-box KD and black-box KD to better illustrate their differences.
Furthermore, we also explored the evaluation tasks and distillation effects
between different distillation methods, and proposed directions for future
research. Through in-depth understanding of the latest advancements and
practical applications, this survey provides valuable resources for
researchers, paving the way for sustained progress in this field. | [
-0.4432502985,
-0.9002845883,
0.987560451,
0.0891982093,
-0.3180067539,
0.3228190541,
-0.5499947667,
-0.244258374,
-0.128249228,
0.3906373084,
-0.1990509182,
-0.5098987818,
-0.9494200349,
0.0972379074,
-0.450861156,
0.6439567208,
-0.0237213355,
0.1525703222,
-0.4658824801,
-0.0411024876,
-0.4213530123,
-0.6475507617,
-0.5328853726,
-0.5465320349,
0.2699634135,
0.2357467562,
0.2358366251,
0.4682623744,
0.3446580768,
0.3802264333,
-0.5846730471,
0.0936229602,
-0.5303479433,
0.4225169122,
-0.0765952915,
-0.5166444778,
-0.0984644741,
-0.049419418,
0.5691831708,
0.9062145352,
-0.3907875717,
0.3547781706,
0.3051676154,
0.8278082013,
-0.9459803104,
0.2069052011,
-0.6980504394,
0.0273301154,
-0.2455662787,
0.0626246408,
-0.3480648696,
-0.5500866175,
0.3234546483,
-0.2565722167,
0.1508761346,
0.0072635193,
0.2793912888,
0.3527498543,
-0.6246840954,
-0.388047576,
-1.0710682869,
1.0152841806,
-0.9344921708,
0.5290857553,
0.2934569716,
0.5541741848,
-0.2835041881,
-0.8699361682,
-0.6827150583,
-0.2657904327,
0.0247819256,
-0.1701861918,
-0.3150498867,
-0.0381204933,
0.4078676403,
0.4899136126,
-0.2716093957,
0.235353142,
-0.3539538085,
-0.0980757326,
0.5656458735,
0.0234470014,
-0.0249484442,
0.1405361593,
-0.1742163599,
-0.1919429451,
-0.639026165,
-0.3258320391,
0.2107161134,
-0.1313697249,
0.0858414546,
0.5187214613,
-0.5244349241,
0.8861972094,
-0.0932237878,
-0.6653059721,
0.1340774,
-0.3929517567,
-0.2598558366,
-0.0413275547,
0.8696399331,
0.3420784175,
0.1548102796,
-0.072514683,
-0.1332511008,
-0.2253553122,
-0.1137647554,
-0.8245927095,
-0.1658198684,
0.1721745133,
-0.4839014411,
-0.2065157145,
-0.3454126418,
-0.997215867,
-0.7091321945,
-0.4550848305,
0.0476490036,
-0.1934191436,
-0.5618200302,
0.1950754523,
-0.4014058411,
-0.0525769703,
0.3372620046,
-0.8802047968,
0.196662128,
0.6390392184,
0.8042219877,
-0.2415054888,
0.0344669074,
-0.2021281123,
-0.023443535,
-0.1455323249,
0.610768795,
-0.2734836936,
-0.3654965162,
0.0669362992,
-0.3219051957,
0.2902785242,
-0.8454956412,
0.5621019602,
-0.6902109981,
-0.1735983789,
-0.1706419587,
-0.7741413713,
-0.2804153264,
0.3338198662,
-0.6968516111,
0.9192601442,
-0.0583571084,
-0.6192147732,
0.3639467359,
-0.4078650177,
-0.4046634734,
0.0169547554,
-0.0540498719,
-0.2347927392,
0.5814227462,
0.2416844964,
0.6611053944,
-0.632109344,
0.3988103271,
-0.4674235582,
-0.0590850525,
0.3164370954,
-0.6390279531,
0.8242185116,
0.5344853401,
-0.16123797,
-0.3108854592,
-0.851908505,
-0.0132869398,
0.244970575,
-0.2159032375,
-0.7425804138,
0.0370579734,
-0.2376808375,
0.058609318,
0.4047217369,
-0.5702084303,
0.2467906028,
0.0176289454,
0.6069620848,
0.5325587988,
0.153064698,
0.2931635082,
0.0714332908,
0.5687832832,
0.0287092794,
0.1021725982,
0.1059911028,
-0.1838493198,
-0.5780231953,
-0.1590238065,
0.526878953,
0.267552346,
-0.7907556891,
0.4212344587,
-0.1134229377,
-0.8728615642,
-0.4720821679,
0.2668126523,
0.262721926,
0.3562665582,
0.219417125,
0.2028742731,
-0.3378451467,
-0.9231040478,
-0.0032048586,
-0.2581705153,
0.0346666947,
0.1977688074,
0.4411459565,
0.043149773,
0.9054980278,
-1.012378335,
-0.0120735075,
-0.3829682469,
0.1420769244,
0.140850082,
0.1676163077,
0.5972294211,
-0.5900714397,
-0.6101313829,
-0.0216074511,
-0.6571013927,
-0.3326965868,
0.3341816962,
0.0765647665,
0.2229626924,
0.6604422331,
-0.4799346924,
0.1690978408,
0.8979545832,
-0.0142223518,
0.7076687813,
-0.260112375,
0.3189348876,
-1.0527740717,
0.0484920479,
0.146281153,
-0.2069864422,
-0.5831500292,
0.0048518996,
0.0499862619,
0.2236692011,
-0.5084349513,
0.5220059752,
-0.7470538616,
0.1037965566,
-0.3465399444,
0.3440311551,
0.0591328926,
0.1324417442,
-0.0101412255,
0.4752390981,
0.4402095079,
-0.5780858994,
0.7099972367,
-0.0024144785,
-0.9567245245,
0.3181224763,
-0.5601556897,
0.1283233017,
-0.0777237043,
0.1863277853,
-1.0130698681,
0.1598540843,
-0.0672533214,
-0.0219496172,
0.3243074119,
-0.2786704004,
-0.7163518071,
-0.3647834361,
-0.1762153506,
0.4441804588,
0.8336402774,
-0.4268611372,
0.2931126952,
0.5636398792,
-0.2298641801,
-0.5955520868,
-0.7534095645,
0.0192908086,
-0.5604979992,
-0.3817551136,
0.0935584754,
-0.1716566086,
-0.6682639122,
-0.1000590846,
-0.2824562192,
-0.1115864888,
0.24880822,
-0.1209958419,
0.1323283166,
-0.0402865671,
-0.0388807878,
0.0661995932,
0.167223677,
0.0195863117,
-0.2064514607,
0.545276165,
0.3566235304,
-0.4077869952,
-0.3379325867,
0.0667385831,
0.6530131102,
-0.0818300024,
0.8149119616,
0.3992824852,
-0.2274078578,
-0.4219550192,
-1.0288381577,
-0.1607664376,
-0.4457430542,
0.4537189603,
-0.1506505907,
-1.1113314629,
0.4355108738,
-0.5597094297,
-0.0382186733,
0.2563786209,
0.8017793894,
0.0386146083,
0.7085695267,
0.6907513738,
-0.2683008909,
0.4279179275,
-0.2005705535,
0.327209115,
-0.7351890802,
-0.245022282,
-0.915643394,
-0.2868123949,
-0.3310284615,
-0.5374466777,
0.4562800527,
0.3664896488,
0.3102521598,
0.0618558712,
-0.3395715356,
0.5525512099,
0.3364993334,
-0.2735261023,
0.7598025799,
0.045361124,
-0.133166492,
0.0088025685,
-0.6321934462,
-0.5204483867,
1.2395845652,
0.3931859136,
0.8996402621,
0.0270323176,
0.7230256796,
0.2567376196,
0.1717421561,
-0.7695196271,
0.5468041897,
-0.1261654049,
-0.665594697,
-0.4792371988,
-0.5848625302,
-0.671051681,
0.3153214157,
0.0256507955,
-0.7024629116,
0.0557499304,
0.2712975442,
-0.2473783791,
0.2466517389,
-0.9124940634,
0.7169926763,
-0.3083148897,
-0.0725494847,
-0.3206366301,
-0.3537127376,
0.7270773053,
-0.4220872223,
0.1974489689,
-0.258962065,
0.1018326208,
0.6723238826,
-0.487175107,
0.5813945532,
-0.3861980736,
-0.524019599,
0.3592627645,
-0.0298203435,
0.5840435624,
-0.0553111918,
-0.2539985478,
0.4232890606,
0.2574334145,
0.0259669498,
-0.842207253,
0.7449393868,
-0.4798466861,
-0.6776288748,
-0.3267481923,
-0.4843607545,
-0.3846846521,
0.1454512179,
-0.0071028201,
0.277533114,
-0.2859614193,
0.4162192643,
0.7286034822,
-0.3060869277,
0.5554276705,
0.7045044303,
-0.4200893939,
-0.2641793191,
0.6860693097,
0.3006139696,
0.5663990378,
0.3722740412,
0.2754567862,
-0.6717939377,
-1.1427208185,
-0.322399348,
0.1454437971,
-0.6299725771,
-0.1874046624,
-0.6003174186,
-0.1061808467,
-0.5269834995,
0.253126204,
-0.4582002461,
-0.5278260112,
-0.1025619656,
-0.015747793,
0.4785759151,
0.8640599251,
0.1442933977,
0.2054447085,
-0.7849114537,
0.3881736994,
0.2785733342,
0.3878037632,
0.1700895727,
-0.291403532,
-0.3412883878,
0.1833134592,
-0.1991628557,
-0.6761792898,
0.2664162815,
0.0518695079,
0.6893669367,
0.3177879155,
0.3722183406,
0.7778329253,
-0.5337112546,
0.8362059593,
0.1809081137,
-0.6907559037,
0.32850492,
0.0529079512,
0.3414438069,
0.6661342978,
0.4769133925,
-0.5624298453,
-0.3978856206,
-0.2764272392,
-0.7718946338,
0.5371261239,
0.1124411151,
-0.091074422,
0.252314806,
0.3014780283,
0.1924158335,
0.3223287463,
-0.3217098117,
-0.5418639779,
0.3574083447,
-0.1195814237,
-0.255646944,
-0.455337882,
0.0073351362,
-0.2108432651,
0.7566235065,
0.132242769,
-0.1931543946,
-0.1164432317,
-0.3865911663,
0.321015209,
0.4350847006,
0.5237777233,
0.7625058889,
-0.1425795406,
0.2472372204,
0.2651250362,
-0.5046637654,
0.4478868246,
0.1111049131,
-0.1600220501,
-0.0265688766,
0.2180467844,
0.6501988769,
-0.1722405255,
-0.7090989947,
0.2905243933,
-0.2814183831,
-0.2766959965,
-0.1430089027,
0.0956553742,
0.4544437528,
0.3807296455,
0.3631535172,
-0.3694236279,
0.2557754219,
-0.4370271862,
-0.2751002014,
0.4091697931,
-0.0577184521,
-0.0121268202,
0.3516355157,
0.1874320656,
0.0648688674,
0.493232131,
-0.2557507753,
-0.2142021954,
0.3778457642,
0.3888215125,
0.8251832724,
-0.1077801585,
-0.0177116152,
0.1692903042,
0.1098208129,
-0.3319753408,
0.0252569281,
-0.2473077923,
-0.7351360917,
-0.6968654394,
-1.0629265308,
-0.355112046,
0.5333957076,
-0.5054232478,
0.1631987989,
-0.1266886294,
-0.2297778279,
0.1053200588,
0.090070948,
-0.46567294,
-0.2035488486,
0.2307319641,
1.0500824451,
-0.8082941175,
0.8814839125,
0.655390501,
0.0058402871,
-0.682903111,
-0.0417310409,
0.1834422052,
-0.4546985328,
0.6975142956,
-0.3484746814,
-0.0925700068,
0.0091943862,
-0.3512867689,
-0.7372367382,
1.1645561457,
0.6107404828,
-1.0068433285,
0.2576054931,
0.2805672884,
0.6232677102,
-0.009678673,
0.152184099,
1.1082326174,
0.5809704065,
0.1947272569,
-1.0371419191,
-0.1230024323,
-0.1183645651,
0.2569288015,
0.1942241192,
-0.5324385166,
0.2753572762,
0.2079905272,
-0.1113672182,
-0.125848338,
0.5261605382,
0.4914123714,
0.1925943643,
0.5970255136,
0.637860775,
0.7216033936,
-0.1542045325,
0.7630637884,
-0.3686218262,
0.3983583152,
1.1251430511,
-0.6415489316,
0.5914959908,
0.6490549445,
-0.5539088249,
0.2406733632,
0.3053599,
0.0659276173,
0.4793144763,
0.481700331,
-0.4891350865,
0.0771299973,
-0.1774088144,
-0.3937565386,
0.4701668918,
0.3197015822,
-0.3086770475,
-0.3264344335,
0.0600629225,
0.0986648798,
0.0313665755,
-0.1684034616,
1.0036458969,
0.2043914199,
-0.8276225328,
0.626832366,
0.0724397823,
0.7469059229,
-0.6345818043,
-0.1213297099,
-0.129318729,
0.2169053108,
0.010365501,
-0.7547538877,
0.2119010836,
0.1712738574,
-0.2298957705,
-0.4453953505,
0.7811947465,
-0.6443490386,
-0.3876532614,
0.2452158332,
0.6343314052,
0.2394106984,
-0.1094712317,
-0.383173883,
0.3690507412,
0.0514897183,
-0.3601496518,
0.3635187745,
0.6956701279,
0.1388017684,
0.6942052245,
0.4966997206,
0.4412064254,
0.221469745,
0.2108716071,
0.7806053758,
-0.4576332569,
-0.0580170378,
-1.1908698082,
0.4663724303,
-0.1334574819,
-0.0150059499,
1.0214924812,
0.5524472594,
0.826716125,
-0.2586621344,
1.0291984081,
-0.1735863239,
0.4725884199,
-0.6876293421,
0.9380222559,
-0.4412699342,
0.3177616596,
-0.3360344768,
-1.1239115,
-0.1731687337,
0.2444584221,
-0.2505269945,
0.030232491,
0.7085554004,
0.6613185406,
0.047548607,
-0.1032092646,
0.4231336713,
0.3730168641,
0.3902217448,
0.2568943501,
1.0243582726,
-0.0326052457,
0.4503833354,
-0.5459541082,
-0.1713682711,
-0.275062263,
-1.2686915398,
-0.7295764685,
-0.666464746,
-0.5260882378,
-0.0944363251,
-0.1660268009,
0.6895309091,
0.7115221024,
-0.666176796,
-0.3217020333,
0.1128970608,
0.257324338,
-0.1196030825,
-0.1524801701,
0.2868070304,
-0.1979013085,
-0.9460363388,
0.4029363692,
0.1424977779,
0.041636426,
-0.5554556251,
0.1081138104,
-0.1822838336,
-0.27224195,
0.8018587232,
0.0997996926,
-0.6131404638,
0.0006743586,
-0.2565012574,
0.0720417276,
-0.3393571079,
0.9231627584,
-0.7267277837,
0.4219861031,
0.7895597219,
0.5511752367,
0.7256595492,
-0.13058348,
0.6687710881,
-0.8063569069,
0.1396731287,
0.0797998831,
0.4652854502,
0.2304558009,
-0.1405076832,
0.4468587339,
0.1199725121,
-0.6493606567,
-1.128108263,
0.0706014633,
-0.8008496761,
-0.3845857382,
1.3264381886,
-0.2244260758,
-0.0326186493,
-0.2158474326,
-0.1485280693,
0.3536762893,
-0.2958883047,
0.7146662474,
1.0397511721,
0.018295411,
-0.0768912137,
-0.7997758985,
0.5322459936,
0.0480963849,
-0.7570800781,
0.3973309994,
0.7244278789,
0.4589920342,
0.0857833549,
0.4592674077,
-0.1932860911,
-0.2417042404,
-0.2293369919,
0.138141647,
-0.1507492214,
-0.1611579061,
-0.5331790447,
0.2681716084,
0.4042766988,
0.1297745705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01878v1 | Compare without Despair: Reliable Preference Evaluation with Generation Separability | 2024-07-02T01:37:56 | 2024-07-02T01:37:56 | Sayan Ghosh, Tejas Srinivasan, Swabha Swayamdipta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human evaluation of generated language through pairwise preference judgments
is pervasive. However, under common scenarios, such as when generations from a
model pair are very similar, or when stochastic decoding results in large
variations in generations, it results in inconsistent preference ratings. We
address these challenges by introducing a meta-evaluation measure,
separability, which estimates how suitable a test instance is for pairwise
preference evaluation. For a candidate test instance, separability samples
multiple generations from a pair of models, and measures how distinguishable
the two sets of generations are. Our experiments show that instances with high
separability values yield more consistent preference ratings from both human-
and auto-raters. Further, the distribution of separability allows insights into
which test benchmarks are more valuable for comparing models. Finally, we
incorporate separability into ELO ratings, accounting for how suitable each
test instance might be for reliably ranking LLMs. Overall, separability has
implications for consistent, efficient and robust preference evaluation of LLMs
with both human- and auto-raters. | [
-0.4994859993,
-0.1439409107,
0.5597196817,
0.447770834,
-0.1793853492,
0.2601018548,
-0.3965165019,
-0.7348132133,
0.2695245445,
0.2702301741,
-0.371517092,
-0.2685356736,
-0.5965586901,
0.4548505545,
-0.3130963445,
0.8781054616,
0.046203725,
-0.0989415273,
-0.6009626389,
-0.4004947245,
-0.1856296808,
-0.2351642549,
-0.7401385903,
-0.3235497773,
0.2896243036,
0.4494979382,
0.8128815293,
0.4667045772,
0.7012701035,
0.3597445488,
-0.0724989921,
0.1832317114,
-0.5102797151,
0.347625345,
0.0355556197,
-0.3275985122,
-0.3012842238,
0.1690262258,
0.4121620059,
0.5452169776,
-0.2422144711,
0.0658096671,
0.3231306672,
0.8457426429,
-0.7848650813,
-0.0768469125,
-0.7397487164,
0.1973602772,
-0.0043676114,
-0.0758291855,
-0.3786573112,
-0.8156431913,
0.142442733,
-0.2220084369,
0.3305156231,
-0.0284549855,
0.760548234,
0.251891464,
-0.4130593538,
0.0169860087,
-0.6598105431,
0.9787161946,
-0.5847579241,
0.5094321966,
0.5805556178,
0.2986413538,
0.0659989044,
-0.3106040061,
-0.3655750155,
-0.5262476206,
-0.0316310786,
0.2098901272,
-0.1200924069,
0.2579909563,
0.0068419799,
0.7126007676,
-0.5316407681,
-0.1877409071,
-0.0374660082,
-0.1972630024,
0.7762431502,
0.1834256053,
0.4818287492,
-0.4647955596,
-0.5107089877,
-0.1957358718,
-0.4302738905,
-0.0778969005,
0.6499748826,
0.1655312181,
0.0354523063,
0.260014832,
-0.1629157215,
0.6040623784,
0.0669532493,
-0.0898356512,
0.492726326,
-0.5039643645,
-0.235369727,
-0.1574574262,
0.9715634584,
0.6599618793,
0.0631439015,
-0.4423260689,
-0.194071278,
0.1674266458,
0.3958948851,
-0.5948842168,
-0.2601858675,
0.1552293599,
-0.8797523975,
-0.6257637739,
-0.130916968,
-0.8682702184,
-0.431717664,
0.0143491207,
0.3530374765,
-0.2397681028,
-0.5063439012,
0.0125286393,
-0.2307186574,
0.0881712288,
0.1357526928,
-1.0675281286,
0.2674306631,
0.6463896632,
0.8431726694,
-0.4925213754,
-0.4361068904,
-0.4062446654,
-0.3917150795,
-0.3122559786,
0.9904178977,
-0.5722331405,
-0.632173121,
-0.127885446,
-0.1604800373,
-0.263387084,
-0.9310726523,
0.8622434139,
-0.2736954093,
0.0719406754,
-0.3280289471,
-0.4779405594,
0.0758517161,
0.3387610316,
-0.6882964373,
0.8867747188,
0.0990736783,
-0.8941627741,
0.7538994551,
-0.3683881164,
-0.2968889773,
-0.1035323367,
0.021525275,
-0.4340168834,
0.2619015872,
-0.196055308,
0.1086414456,
-0.3068071008,
0.1040541679,
-1.0006510019,
-0.2228699028,
0.0519399904,
-0.5920236707,
0.6951782107,
0.2796561718,
-0.3765994012,
0.0927039608,
-0.7989096642,
0.1589322835,
-0.0209577512,
-0.2354373187,
-0.5796855688,
0.345367372,
0.0590099171,
0.1300520897,
0.2836826742,
-0.4921923876,
-0.1135714352,
-0.3395303786,
0.4545255303,
0.6332132816,
-0.2229468226,
0.5293745995,
-0.4958981574,
0.4911836684,
-0.0611092374,
0.4346784353,
0.3194857836,
-0.2111867219,
-1.0220645666,
-0.255921483,
0.2005890608,
0.5464645028,
-0.4167738557,
0.8552309275,
0.0783043876,
-0.5514019132,
-0.6760373116,
0.1515376419,
0.4659166038,
0.5290210843,
0.4096418619,
-0.6885846853,
-0.6638842225,
-1.1227606535,
-0.4324961901,
-0.4542780221,
0.0326617099,
0.389899224,
0.1152414009,
-0.2197041512,
0.8543477654,
-0.3031057417,
0.2030892074,
-0.489123702,
0.1976525784,
0.0469553396,
0.289919138,
0.4172329307,
-0.5056524873,
-0.4212033749,
-0.2193799168,
-0.7656613588,
-0.3819130063,
0.3052276969,
-0.1953417361,
-0.0125256144,
0.1593023539,
-0.3005560637,
0.2652847171,
0.5788782835,
-0.1360005587,
0.5892634988,
-0.3660105467,
0.6417002678,
-1.2232593298,
0.1182443649,
-0.1444059461,
-0.4690645635,
-0.3527964354,
-0.0730317011,
-0.0209945329,
0.2879101932,
-0.3803623021,
0.36987409,
-0.2437721193,
-0.3631344736,
-0.2772205174,
0.0716655925,
0.0688304603,
-0.3198561668,
-0.0841868296,
0.9063714147,
0.2108969539,
-0.3660239875,
0.2110000849,
0.3551515341,
-0.5462641716,
0.6699866652,
-0.6991363168,
0.2399975508,
0.0994838998,
0.0818120614,
-0.9215536118,
0.050375443,
-0.0104599642,
-0.1753256023,
-0.0497212596,
-0.2193384022,
-0.3866364658,
-0.2147081494,
-0.6126092076,
0.4681239128,
0.5064524412,
-0.5293870568,
0.2139097303,
0.3365826309,
-0.1030985042,
-0.7370182872,
-0.4276826382,
-0.0098519614,
-0.4689186811,
-0.6006755233,
0.1606373042,
-0.4331462681,
-0.4119186401,
-0.076522626,
-0.0790618807,
-0.0550445803,
0.3624157608,
0.3631644547,
0.3183171153,
-0.0074700993,
-0.1157485768,
0.1511234045,
-0.3435609043,
-0.0785780847,
0.0259938333,
0.5000484586,
-0.1694372147,
-0.2505245805,
-0.0659122244,
0.2300937176,
0.6771597862,
-0.1205832735,
0.4759832025,
0.2680464089,
-0.0725880489,
-0.2316367775,
-0.7227708697,
-0.0614237972,
-0.4562388062,
0.052327361,
-0.3198343217,
-0.7821109891,
0.4769246578,
0.3661743701,
0.1309851408,
0.2969433069,
0.3112539351,
-0.167999655,
1.0580335855,
0.6862202287,
-0.220608443,
0.4925780594,
0.2601532042,
0.1891450137,
-0.903234601,
0.0324471183,
-0.5845173597,
-0.4940910041,
-0.6380857825,
-0.0881323293,
0.2949125469,
0.2732302845,
-0.0733018443,
0.4214379787,
-0.4115150869,
0.8333923221,
0.4564261138,
-0.0247318074,
0.6190212369,
-0.1323257238,
-0.1955173165,
-0.2386001796,
-0.3122446835,
-0.5079503655,
1.2593300343,
-0.0199073404,
0.5025931001,
-0.0506182723,
1.1240612268,
0.5147354007,
0.4930720627,
-0.6735915542,
0.4815872014,
-0.5452817082,
-0.4997085929,
-0.0417356566,
-0.8440508842,
-1.0660295486,
0.427154094,
-0.3687234223,
-0.6546446681,
0.2005800158,
0.0429033674,
-0.482578516,
0.2801735997,
-0.4784359932,
1.0149365664,
-0.2860643566,
-0.2097304463,
-0.3175542653,
-0.7083086967,
0.6326559782,
0.0275629833,
-0.0014095836,
-0.3588352799,
0.2990906835,
0.7857621908,
-0.3149453402,
0.2286650538,
0.2273599654,
0.1803199053,
-0.0175406281,
0.3697264194,
-0.0620781966,
-0.0122628603,
-0.3073738515,
0.0970456004,
0.0435968749,
-0.197413221,
-0.5354529619,
0.8547962308,
-0.8789196014,
-0.5063377023,
-0.3862677813,
-0.4413381517,
-0.36662063,
0.2460699528,
0.4303537905,
0.222458601,
-0.5119690895,
0.0864901245,
0.5521140695,
-0.1317192316,
0.5506430268,
0.4338605702,
-0.3177378774,
-0.9326502085,
0.8823088408,
-0.1415935755,
0.4995886683,
0.3663027585,
0.2323710471,
-0.5166679025,
-0.245260641,
-0.5189599395,
0.1749074906,
-0.4306245446,
-0.1634904295,
-0.6527832747,
-0.0770584792,
0.0286005288,
-0.2680049241,
-0.536519289,
-0.2853012681,
0.0837849677,
-0.3539483845,
0.0598773472,
0.6851030588,
-0.311026603,
-0.3938899338,
-0.9505262971,
0.2168087363,
0.6563776135,
0.2865259647,
-0.0255111549,
-0.3935682178,
0.1868622899,
-0.2434345484,
-0.3132537007,
-0.7281950712,
0.2801270485,
0.0458995774,
0.4957062304,
0.7477068901,
0.209315598,
0.7134258747,
-0.3955814242,
0.6269535422,
0.276466608,
-1.1767669916,
0.4780023098,
-0.1651689559,
-0.1985574663,
1.4417268038,
0.0707511753,
-0.4021388292,
-0.4809129536,
-0.9068917036,
-0.9447157383,
0.5830748677,
0.2360462397,
-0.0409738272,
-0.058695402,
0.0023063559,
0.3632375002,
0.4340821505,
-0.4713183641,
-0.294823736,
-0.0690043196,
-0.1929666698,
-0.3869723976,
-0.3628002107,
-0.2355605811,
0.0601089224,
0.1741224825,
0.3240248859,
-0.0160203949,
0.0031710123,
-0.0530689508,
-0.2738142014,
0.39357391,
0.5497728586,
0.4693836272,
-0.4579399824,
0.4350573123,
0.1242205277,
-0.2661113739,
0.4069936275,
0.0971321836,
-0.268261373,
0.0442735963,
0.2631688118,
0.6246963739,
0.4015517831,
-0.6287827492,
0.7005838752,
-0.3477287292,
0.0434783585,
-0.0963832662,
0.0934487432,
0.0992001891,
0.0196561813,
-0.0631189644,
0.3770899177,
0.3702090383,
-0.6190989017,
0.3621026576,
0.5237429738,
-0.4431682825,
-0.336758405,
0.6626545191,
0.6310241818,
-0.356056273,
0.6948131323,
-0.3966853917,
-0.5095484853,
0.6646109223,
0.4309817851,
1.3770430088,
-0.3398735523,
0.4660206437,
0.193308264,
0.4765918553,
-0.4934509695,
0.1323365718,
-0.3777406514,
-0.8946204782,
-0.0039180792,
-0.8244786859,
-0.6461468935,
-0.0019759082,
-0.9415445328,
0.0312386639,
-0.3293361962,
-0.3073240221,
-0.4862652123,
-0.0474391989,
-0.5536920428,
0.1942069381,
0.0779026225,
0.8639599681,
-1.190256238,
0.5263178349,
0.4934372604,
-0.3458456695,
-0.6440190077,
0.2246923894,
-0.193449378,
-0.5908406973,
0.446806699,
0.3317939639,
-0.3195027709,
-0.4167938232,
-0.0594300441,
-0.6890180707,
0.9057517052,
0.6317749023,
-0.4215866625,
0.3391700089,
-0.0917312726,
0.511777997,
-0.227685228,
0.8070738912,
0.8555576205,
0.4979110658,
-0.1626262516,
-1.175691247,
-0.1384195834,
-0.2049440593,
-0.0524195656,
0.4108275175,
-0.9111576676,
0.5634639859,
-0.0908712223,
-0.2950661182,
0.0787237585,
0.4462053478,
0.4905148447,
0.6382791996,
0.8750217557,
0.9397650957,
0.6457949281,
-0.0700099021,
0.9437068105,
-0.5774732828,
0.6218826175,
1.0120850801,
-0.5824728608,
0.9805244207,
0.2689306736,
-0.4458554685,
0.3841959536,
0.6980161667,
0.2948398888,
0.5569468737,
0.0077989763,
-0.4656248689,
-0.6566049457,
-0.0899599418,
-0.4963636994,
0.3217289448,
-0.3036756217,
-0.5544288158,
-0.2091967463,
-0.3190525472,
0.0700240061,
-0.0111692948,
-0.0693383366,
0.7583569884,
0.2965704203,
-0.7245415449,
0.4325202107,
-0.3098842204,
0.7532266378,
-0.6005031466,
0.308159411,
-0.680757165,
0.039828904,
-0.459749341,
-0.5759096146,
0.3805960417,
0.0758137628,
-0.4797948897,
-0.1420533657,
0.619264245,
-0.4280900359,
-0.4856423736,
0.6475573182,
0.6055546999,
0.1975412667,
0.2372858822,
-0.6252140999,
0.2749666274,
0.0389104299,
-0.0763549581,
0.4933191836,
0.0030198509,
0.2969399691,
0.7684720755,
0.6330992579,
0.3432608843,
-0.0932757854,
0.1656279862,
0.4008235335,
-0.5981010795,
-0.3422685266,
-0.9850798845,
0.2513890862,
-0.2356820405,
-0.4777484536,
0.8391929865,
0.6611757278,
0.7902033925,
0.0358002745,
0.9249457717,
0.0547371805,
0.4224911928,
-0.1620209217,
0.9138606191,
-0.6510206461,
0.1787571013,
-0.4203214943,
-1.287365675,
-0.2426453233,
0.6503689885,
-0.4183033109,
0.0661070421,
0.8083847761,
0.6399767399,
-0.1177149341,
0.0849952176,
0.5745114684,
-0.0929107517,
0.0399718545,
0.750707984,
1.0600545406,
-0.1485299319,
0.4973276854,
-0.064237155,
-0.280903548,
-0.2115782052,
-0.8646615744,
-0.5875219107,
-0.2949142158,
-0.1780245602,
-0.4007384479,
0.0730801225,
1.0278676748,
0.6343644857,
-0.7877287269,
-0.4638113678,
-0.0890309736,
0.5021807551,
-0.3742388189,
-0.2690397799,
0.0756773874,
-0.4124965966,
-0.8503630757,
0.6946490407,
0.6117457151,
-0.1620017737,
-0.3035385907,
0.0260361023,
0.6910988092,
0.2651141882,
0.4629203677,
0.2709634304,
-0.5533963442,
-0.329721272,
-0.3814272285,
-0.1913072318,
0.2141011357,
0.8729656339,
-0.5496640801,
0.6862962246,
0.9389680028,
0.6180992723,
0.1031916216,
0.1953092217,
0.6447249055,
-0.1746177226,
-0.1362500787,
0.1755409539,
0.4134919941,
0.5221572518,
-0.0379257873,
0.4959226549,
0.2703664005,
-0.894801259,
-1.025146246,
0.4481630921,
-1.1003961563,
0.2519403696,
1.0043218136,
-0.1712272167,
0.1159705818,
-0.1525204927,
0.20600079,
-0.0901008919,
-0.5581122637,
1.2098691463,
0.6791042686,
-0.2704678178,
-0.0371499509,
-0.2136431485,
0.5994615555,
0.5948631167,
-0.974354744,
-0.0053730509,
0.1010557711,
0.6187207103,
0.0474706069,
0.6683468223,
-0.1258087605,
0.0814728364,
-0.0338359997,
0.0809121877,
0.1941739172,
-0.2462599576,
-0.4356948435,
0.3130148947,
0.3031672239,
-0.288158834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01873v1 | Automated Text Scoring in the Age of Generative AI for the GPU-poor | 2024-07-02T01:17:01 | 2024-07-02T01:17:01 | Christopher Michael Ormerod, Alexander Kwako | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Current research on generative language models (GLMs) for automated text
scoring (ATS) has focused almost exclusively on querying proprietary models via
Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). Yet such practices raise issues
around transparency and security, and these methods offer little in the way of
efficiency or customizability. With the recent proliferation of smaller,
open-source models, there is the option to explore GLMs with computers equipped
with modest, consumer-grade hardware, that is, for the "GPU poor." In this
study, we analyze the performance and efficiency of open-source, small-scale
GLMs for ATS. Results show that GLMs can be fine-tuned to achieve adequate,
though not state-of-the-art, performance. In addition to ATS, we take small
steps towards analyzing models' capacity for generating feedback by prompting
GLMs to explain their scores. Model-generated feedback shows promise, but
requires more rigorous evaluation focused on targeted use cases. | [
-0.2291692495,
-0.9682419896,
0.8048710823,
-0.1416057646,
-0.3189886808,
-0.0593224764,
-0.1080160439,
-0.5396162868,
-0.1719204485,
0.293905139,
-0.1671233624,
-0.6581347585,
-0.4760978818,
0.079534933,
-0.4550790787,
1.0269905329,
0.0059256363,
-0.297749877,
-0.5750954151,
-0.2365775704,
-0.192345351,
-0.524874568,
-0.8541226983,
-0.2674146295,
0.3555209041,
0.3166771233,
1.0144697428,
0.7706454992,
0.7513786554,
0.3446092606,
0.1323056221,
-0.0037856873,
-0.2474732101,
0.0970188528,
0.0821243227,
-0.2239758819,
-0.5904349685,
0.305418402,
0.5674769878,
0.3500980735,
-0.0350500345,
0.4521042109,
0.3067958057,
0.4873402417,
-0.7806027532,
0.0878249556,
-0.5418691039,
-0.0970408767,
-0.4045421779,
-0.0846985132,
-0.5768177509,
-0.7080044746,
-0.1696580648,
-0.7505682707,
0.4526351988,
0.2732132077,
0.7681961656,
0.509083569,
0.2466084808,
-0.5693290234,
-0.6751730442,
0.9324732423,
-0.4708503783,
-0.0516130254,
0.577709198,
0.3712399006,
0.2215482146,
-0.4613184333,
-0.2371693701,
-0.4972654581,
-0.1823597252,
-0.0231092684,
-0.6545099616,
0.090191707,
0.213588804,
0.8054527044,
-0.5542635918,
0.2842977345,
-0.4520929754,
0.0493408926,
0.717756331,
0.4546608925,
0.3394383788,
-0.2556471527,
-0.0722916722,
0.0641903877,
-0.6038088799,
0.0702938437,
0.4875215292,
0.5270872712,
-0.2198601067,
0.8060290813,
0.0410695858,
0.9135033488,
-0.2755388319,
0.2708247006,
-0.1877931803,
-0.2514246404,
-0.4270289242,
-0.3771850765,
1.1293181181,
0.1644245535,
0.2049036771,
-0.2071122676,
-0.5979918242,
0.5917865038,
0.597661972,
-0.5233861804,
-0.4812459946,
0.0590676107,
-0.7313742638,
-0.5382787585,
-0.2474761754,
-0.9958508611,
-0.501652956,
-0.354637444,
0.4515947402,
-0.3398072124,
0.1335502267,
-0.3870497346,
-0.2578531504,
-0.0944627896,
0.5329349637,
-1.04316926,
0.6966700554,
0.4446119368,
1.2538648844,
-0.2733632028,
0.0217272267,
-0.7807590961,
-0.2708314657,
-0.3447713852,
1.0653966665,
-0.7960289121,
-0.8430125117,
-0.0265886094,
-0.5849210024,
-0.0033015697,
-0.7092238665,
0.5554998517,
-0.3056369126,
0.3237991631,
-0.2544642091,
-0.4296861589,
0.1962148696,
0.105906345,
-0.6206871867,
1.1382716894,
0.1764441878,
-0.605337739,
0.3181073368,
-1.0059957504,
-0.4196949899,
0.4270130396,
-0.2521680892,
-0.3832961321,
0.6878452301,
0.3190692067,
0.1399989277,
-0.5188590288,
-0.0660003796,
-0.3841351569,
-0.7845452428,
-0.1712156832,
-0.7355060577,
0.7093163133,
0.3419433832,
-0.1806911528,
0.5191100836,
-0.5941077471,
0.2941332757,
-0.0507219508,
-0.3917191029,
-0.4557640254,
0.2088798285,
0.1898905039,
-0.1591050327,
-0.0093818307,
-0.2853126526,
0.2545063496,
-0.2475300282,
0.5464399457,
0.8218464255,
-0.6081997156,
0.4294151068,
-0.3947618008,
0.6766762733,
-0.6884568334,
0.5743216872,
0.1012872234,
-0.8955255747,
-0.6235647798,
-0.4104764163,
0.197492525,
0.5926007032,
-0.8284258246,
0.2866115272,
-0.1461531669,
-0.6280606389,
-0.9220770001,
0.1435724944,
0.482935816,
0.4242481887,
0.561680913,
-0.3383553028,
-0.0306660514,
-0.6718369722,
-0.3757557571,
-0.6478943229,
-0.3259852231,
0.6099197865,
0.4549634755,
-0.0247144569,
0.7790812254,
-0.6496946216,
-0.4651993513,
-0.0841664821,
0.4071291983,
-0.1741924584,
0.3983444273,
0.5057390332,
-0.407859087,
-0.4552332461,
-0.0588982999,
-0.8041846156,
-0.0969706997,
0.466549933,
0.349283129,
0.3535420299,
0.5056176186,
-0.5982862115,
0.6137019992,
0.8353818059,
-0.4740643203,
0.8445151448,
-0.7076516151,
0.2476488054,
-0.3998174667,
0.3814454973,
0.1922674775,
-0.1682531536,
-0.3649899364,
0.181769371,
-0.1495373994,
-0.3627753258,
-0.0215911176,
0.6810856462,
-0.3469348252,
-0.1698387414,
-0.5331940055,
0.0412503444,
-0.058987271,
0.1062021554,
-0.2374523878,
1.1664910316,
0.38280496,
-0.6055592299,
0.4657768607,
-0.0330526568,
-0.4738528728,
0.5308956504,
-0.832536459,
0.3298583329,
0.0197260771,
-0.0853327587,
-0.8032610416,
-0.2565783858,
0.3531252146,
-0.5260791183,
0.10983558,
-0.0455616079,
-0.5015431046,
-0.5208502412,
-0.3816517293,
0.5169150829,
0.7252309918,
-0.5136778355,
0.7692857981,
0.4287403226,
-0.2958840728,
-0.2422826141,
-0.557531774,
0.0728828758,
-0.1926971376,
-0.4448667169,
0.3362881839,
-0.0029967008,
-0.6074050665,
0.4091018736,
0.4486189485,
-0.0568215847,
0.3029852808,
0.1387895048,
0.4587665796,
-0.3553030193,
0.1772070527,
-0.1448750198,
-0.1902466863,
-0.0484558418,
-0.1954748333,
0.3171969056,
-0.3399274349,
-0.428142935,
-0.3675366044,
0.670006454,
0.6364682913,
-0.137933746,
0.5643312335,
0.4065820575,
-0.4280299246,
-0.2256343514,
-0.304889977,
0.1229985431,
-0.5020450354,
0.104593046,
-0.1798155606,
-0.6888417602,
0.3961007893,
0.4400184751,
0.0729668289,
0.7317306399,
0.5947015882,
-0.0525007807,
1.1939527988,
0.8666266799,
-0.306060791,
0.3515318334,
0.116025798,
0.0700700879,
-0.5189524293,
-0.0290336329,
-0.9799595475,
-0.0782679543,
-0.5728071332,
-0.4337512255,
0.2184894234,
0.0103172762,
-0.2236433625,
-0.1107726991,
-0.7445386052,
0.6094987392,
0.833756268,
-0.0384546518,
0.4888162613,
-0.1362128258,
0.0416737646,
0.1289144605,
-0.5872142315,
-0.8534767628,
0.9525611997,
0.2510774434,
0.8861898184,
-0.0261262115,
0.3473862112,
0.8769015074,
1.0566108227,
-0.6839713454,
0.320356667,
-0.8003774881,
-0.3725863695,
-0.395315975,
-0.5512977839,
-0.6138851047,
0.0163708646,
-0.0343576297,
-0.8787870407,
-0.0941539705,
0.5624960065,
-0.7182528377,
0.2496580184,
-0.9547489882,
1.0167206526,
0.004811564,
-0.3301757872,
-0.2216780782,
-0.0618335493,
0.3990916312,
0.0853790268,
0.2507116497,
-0.0483132266,
0.1193967089,
0.5508630276,
-0.4325731993,
0.6575676203,
-0.3526393473,
-0.1669317186,
0.3346474767,
-0.1197981909,
0.4124476314,
-0.1080321446,
-0.2257557362,
0.0446214452,
-0.370092392,
-0.3087609708,
-0.5091235042,
0.9282295108,
-0.7690896392,
-0.6073002219,
-0.3700041175,
-0.2528110743,
-0.193018496,
-0.1685088575,
0.5837582946,
0.423473686,
-0.2072894126,
-0.1275785267,
0.4714795351,
-0.331178546,
0.3938864768,
0.1759320945,
-0.2610301971,
-0.3548517525,
1.1534674168,
-0.0517698042,
0.0915700272,
-0.1091607884,
0.0983259454,
-0.4157700539,
-0.6357555985,
-0.9482332468,
-0.0982239395,
-0.6426501274,
-0.3778268993,
-0.2755178511,
-0.0621628799,
-0.2293992937,
-0.2263253927,
-0.3658852279,
-0.0484556258,
-0.7214846611,
0.1828116179,
0.1946016103,
1.0762718916,
0.2713396549,
0.2437660843,
-0.7230087519,
0.4212585688,
0.2302528322,
0.8493942618,
0.0989381596,
-0.5277943015,
-0.2396767586,
-0.2870214581,
-0.4587021768,
-0.5073549151,
0.2962957621,
0.3048292696,
0.3078585267,
0.2392356396,
0.0007290092,
0.5009734631,
-0.5142057538,
1.0046700239,
-0.0022365898,
-1.143266201,
0.6615975499,
-0.2204897255,
0.3336526453,
0.5169351101,
0.2980941236,
-0.2618744373,
-0.6037501693,
-0.3457452059,
-0.5438203812,
0.7936595678,
0.2892880142,
0.2283336818,
0.1360916942,
0.3174944222,
0.109328106,
0.0029155207,
-0.5585347414,
-0.2317619473,
-0.2069380134,
-0.6175449491,
-0.3158870637,
-0.0984123796,
-0.0745552555,
-0.4183886349,
0.5872846246,
-0.3115589619,
0.3824451566,
-0.0275696348,
0.1073027328,
-0.3535495698,
0.1020072624,
0.5739172101,
0.1935158968,
-0.0355441384,
-0.0496152453,
-0.1828598231,
-0.5987057686,
0.1048899069,
0.4047988057,
-0.5572645664,
-0.0638724118,
0.2564535439,
1.0132683516,
-0.2026138157,
-0.6099420786,
0.3935492933,
-0.4628837407,
-0.1819642484,
0.0158470273,
0.3162561357,
-0.3724018633,
0.0291178264,
0.2596874833,
0.3231407702,
0.1475630552,
-0.4225442708,
-0.1299882531,
0.6437120438,
-0.5403338075,
-0.3012331426,
0.9969080091,
0.2379414886,
-0.509432137,
0.9534944892,
-0.1606064141,
-0.1621775925,
0.256875217,
0.263926357,
1.061195612,
-0.2476398349,
0.2986922264,
0.2365311831,
0.3948549628,
-0.1162457317,
0.133387506,
-0.2101219147,
-0.3321267664,
-0.389549166,
-0.963588357,
-0.5726162195,
0.1539075226,
-0.4745153785,
0.2392395139,
-0.4714289308,
-0.4938298464,
0.0043954812,
-0.0064761252,
-0.4931664467,
0.3658373058,
0.2820695043,
0.7672060132,
-0.8051948547,
0.7587757707,
0.7800222039,
-0.4062340558,
-0.5212916136,
-0.1447587162,
-0.0949320719,
-0.525328517,
0.3257779777,
0.1210774407,
-0.0789153427,
-0.0016752048,
-0.3000291288,
-0.6463693976,
0.621052146,
0.4125808775,
-0.2689588964,
-0.36192891,
0.2081022263,
0.7223331928,
-0.0684270784,
0.5011196136,
0.5338401198,
0.3969325721,
-0.3498865068,
-0.9002283216,
-0.118214108,
-0.5706897974,
-0.0122689288,
0.2297237664,
-0.4469389617,
0.9463715553,
-0.1825823933,
-0.2854191363,
0.348154217,
0.5695211887,
0.033472497,
0.4093787968,
0.3892143369,
0.7720643282,
0.8618227839,
-0.3859297037,
1.5349885225,
-0.0384168699,
0.3038640618,
0.7079783678,
0.0136303315,
0.9228239655,
0.0578842089,
-0.3208177388,
0.4508807361,
0.3349449933,
-0.1674653292,
0.4490836859,
0.309130609,
-0.3836674988,
-0.22693865,
0.0026978464,
-0.0919593945,
0.4402763546,
0.3898949623,
-0.592199266,
-0.2504355013,
0.1363186538,
-0.3799983859,
0.1965803355,
-0.5375542045,
0.7879725099,
0.1255583316,
-0.8555950522,
0.4784562886,
0.2071142495,
0.7196846008,
-0.4970087409,
0.1200481132,
-0.2028542608,
0.3417747021,
-0.0566111468,
-0.6039832234,
0.5772274137,
0.7023219466,
-0.4952375591,
-0.1603034735,
0.7726432085,
0.0193962995,
-0.5761426687,
0.2596981823,
0.5018925071,
0.0027027314,
-0.2851974666,
-0.5704082847,
0.4260954559,
-0.3394580185,
-0.0561790429,
0.3739269674,
0.0812746137,
-0.1329983026,
0.7105702162,
0.4612746239,
0.1552654356,
-0.0392613076,
0.1932042837,
0.7624231577,
-0.607190609,
-0.393860817,
-0.9843468666,
0.3106406927,
-0.0514680147,
-0.6010019183,
0.8281066418,
0.5598416328,
0.5383405685,
-0.011405888,
0.9440779686,
0.06250377,
0.3832095563,
-0.5085098743,
0.9728464484,
-0.7409692407,
0.1347804368,
-0.3889099956,
-0.8174563646,
-0.4374206364,
0.3374395669,
-0.4481680095,
0.104234077,
0.4251255393,
0.5017192364,
0.115072377,
0.3590531349,
0.2505611479,
-0.2163802385,
0.5227816701,
0.3632030487,
0.8768037558,
-0.3679124713,
0.5205809474,
-0.046524059,
-0.4883561134,
-0.1621007323,
-0.6492791176,
-0.5054370761,
-0.3138738275,
-0.3447604477,
-0.0295570437,
0.3105887473,
0.4729893506,
0.3108668923,
-0.8703558445,
-0.0610258542,
-0.289648205,
-0.1102096289,
-0.1011589095,
-0.2330056131,
0.4983066022,
-0.7041846514,
-0.8444325924,
0.306073606,
0.3102782965,
-0.0072685252,
-0.3653231859,
0.0014621799,
0.4751198292,
0.1329837292,
0.5708043575,
0.3022318482,
-0.6844759583,
-0.2391745448,
-0.1483089924,
-0.3810314536,
0.0398018248,
0.92751652,
-0.9295925498,
0.2821635008,
0.2566254139,
0.5324015021,
-0.1911376417,
0.3301796615,
0.5787778497,
-0.5177233219,
-0.330747515,
0.5561845303,
0.1651908308,
0.5277045369,
-0.2110034674,
0.0577347167,
0.3741482496,
-0.8582342267,
-0.8504713774,
-0.191630438,
-0.443010211,
-0.2596246004,
0.9953023195,
-0.0932997614,
-0.1730325073,
-0.2576517165,
-0.088586919,
-0.0195499286,
-0.3670712113,
1.0472396612,
0.5858931541,
-0.1530426145,
0.2231567651,
-0.4827342629,
0.9554965496,
0.2850193977,
-1.0682088137,
0.4225612283,
0.6912772059,
-0.2194133848,
0.1406124085,
0.9397628307,
-0.0773655474,
0.3392792046,
0.3478056192,
-0.2327216119,
0.0886098593,
-0.3736594617,
-0.4068877101,
0.5207195282,
0.297940433,
-0.051606752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01863v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01863v1 | VSP: Assessing the dual challenges of perception and reasoning in spatial planning tasks for VLMs | 2024-07-02T00:24:01 | 2024-07-02T00:24:01 | Qiucheng Wu, Handong Zhao, Michael Saxon, Trung Bui, William Yang Wang, Yang Zhang, Shiyu Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Vision language models (VLMs) are an exciting emerging class of language
models (LMs) that have merged classic LM capabilities with those of image
processing systems. However, the ways that these capabilities combine are not
always intuitive and warrant direct investigation. One understudied capability
in VLMs is visual spatial planning -- the ability to comprehend the spatial
arrangements of objects and devise action plans to achieve desired outcomes in
visual scenes. In our study, we introduce VSP, a benchmark that 1) evaluates
the spatial planning capability in these models in general, and 2) breaks down
the visual planning task into finer-grained sub-tasks, including perception and
reasoning, and measure the LMs capabilities in these sub-tasks. Our evaluation
shows that both open-source and private VLMs fail to generate effective plans
for even simple spatial planning tasks. Evaluations on the fine-grained
analytical tasks further reveal fundamental deficiencies in the models' visual
perception and bottlenecks in reasoning abilities, explaining their worse
performance in the general spatial planning tasks. Our work illuminates future
directions for improving VLMs' abilities in spatial planning. Our benchmark is
publicly available at
https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/Visual-Spatial-Planning. | [
-0.4307846427,
-0.3235536814,
0.9206902981,
0.3297540843,
0.0211303476,
-0.299228996,
-0.0953337997,
-0.6878138185,
-0.0993496999,
0.6876095533,
-0.5709300637,
-0.3511332273,
-0.3473422229,
-0.1062898487,
-0.2007349879,
0.2581712604,
-0.1706387252,
0.2098374665,
-0.5166600347,
-0.2755168378,
-0.8761355281,
-0.6228044033,
-0.1850411892,
-0.2209418565,
0.2480493188,
0.3564878106,
0.6471948028,
0.440235883,
0.751055479,
0.3401190341,
-0.1237247363,
0.3380900919,
-0.359470427,
0.0425746478,
-0.4590024948,
-0.1832781583,
-0.1316227764,
-0.3674063087,
0.5425410867,
0.8893105388,
-0.0539000854,
0.2496623397,
-0.1577181965,
0.8338486552,
-0.8661350608,
0.2714691162,
-0.6549754739,
0.3956203461,
0.0194498692,
0.0153328842,
-0.1331227571,
0.1064670384,
0.309704721,
-0.3924859762,
0.115798384,
0.1558653712,
0.7344105244,
0.3753657639,
-0.0920978636,
0.0524416231,
-1.1438860893,
0.5963262916,
-0.2931158841,
0.4543022513,
0.2178798765,
0.614521265,
0.0710599869,
-0.8106589317,
-0.5270975232,
-0.2812334597,
-0.1220091954,
0.1490558982,
-0.3923868835,
-0.0941024497,
0.6707308888,
0.0196622666,
-0.8433865309,
-0.0118907308,
-0.6022004485,
0.0924392492,
0.6689570546,
0.465346545,
0.0127357719,
-0.2237114906,
-0.8255674839,
-0.0687343031,
-0.3143411577,
0.2254695296,
-0.0425249785,
0.2238521576,
0.0365049392,
1.0875964165,
-0.5323784351,
0.6947615147,
-0.5098490715,
0.3109847605,
0.0282901656,
-0.6767160892,
-0.5920038223,
-0.5105717778,
0.5217497349,
0.6582394838,
0.4868782461,
0.190446794,
-0.1944929212,
0.2186906934,
0.5412971973,
-0.2086584866,
-0.3955268264,
0.3235778809,
-0.2935201824,
0.0463426784,
-0.3518431187,
-0.6996409297,
-0.432559967,
-0.5672361255,
0.2909036279,
-0.3542280793,
-0.1757979095,
0.4872931838,
-0.4067927599,
0.2350423336,
0.4512848854,
-0.674361527,
0.4292834103,
0.7637242079,
0.5024826527,
-0.0943126231,
-0.710563302,
-0.271400094,
-0.0527589694,
-0.3692154884,
1.181042552,
-0.3377534151,
-0.5155712366,
0.0696647316,
-0.3284973502,
-0.1943627894,
-0.6753647923,
0.6110700965,
0.022793971,
-0.2056563497,
-0.8601157665,
-0.1138865128,
0.0381693318,
0.4296064675,
-0.3836427331,
1.1709798574,
0.1754557788,
-0.4454104006,
0.7890329957,
-0.2857532501,
-0.0368579179,
0.3815717101,
-0.5479770303,
-0.1098750383,
0.3814967871,
0.2356032282,
0.2897578478,
0.0618781038,
0.1532513052,
-0.4493994117,
-0.0716052949,
0.0112965852,
-0.0027167606,
0.5310689807,
0.0763602406,
-0.229808256,
0.6130747199,
-0.7419387698,
0.5031980276,
0.3907072544,
-0.0608917996,
-0.2453078181,
0.4967621565,
0.0006721179,
0.3378140628,
0.3013898432,
0.0217336919,
0.4327284098,
-0.2088246644,
0.0812075287,
0.7706380486,
-0.4315312803,
0.6195431948,
-0.0416078903,
0.1973695606,
-0.1811090112,
0.4586306214,
0.1717371792,
-0.5954525471,
-0.7485330701,
0.0598692372,
-0.3435941935,
0.7307046056,
-0.8466055393,
-0.0384267643,
-0.2755778134,
-0.5807901025,
0.0598140098,
-0.0342688709,
0.4519242048,
0.4037597477,
0.4834047854,
-0.4342817068,
-0.5955116153,
-0.7579211593,
-0.3207674623,
-0.4140588045,
-0.0237271376,
0.4450768828,
0.630194962,
-0.1082461774,
0.7386054397,
-0.5787668824,
-0.3565195501,
-0.4745842516,
-0.1407409161,
-0.2178904563,
0.1082244888,
0.6851702929,
-0.8478294015,
-0.3223417103,
-0.0992830545,
-0.800772965,
-0.4322360754,
0.0271834582,
-0.0292549208,
0.0863673165,
0.4117135406,
-0.6547276378,
0.6934089065,
0.3927336335,
-0.8894891739,
1.1506074667,
-0.4060809314,
-0.2133138776,
-0.0348565504,
-0.0907835662,
0.1626672447,
-0.0475962162,
-0.6845311522,
0.5606340766,
-0.0407439657,
-0.3250162005,
-0.4869351983,
0.4374493062,
-0.5256431103,
-0.8224070668,
-0.1693332195,
0.0311276149,
-0.0699044988,
0.6231615543,
0.5699902773,
0.6145929694,
0.4235045314,
-0.4494982362,
0.3113075197,
0.088058956,
-0.3924066126,
0.6292478442,
-0.5974920988,
-0.2143482119,
-0.1055191457,
-0.229464829,
-0.9076815844,
0.1672715545,
0.3202270269,
-0.0523554869,
-0.0453246012,
-0.060416501,
-0.3104442358,
-0.6160838604,
-0.1098767221,
0.0856914371,
0.2445893586,
-0.2938550115,
0.6536349058,
0.2150032818,
-0.0369059034,
-0.3145826757,
-0.551851809,
0.1548432261,
-0.0273252353,
-0.6138022542,
0.0369787328,
-0.0632792041,
-0.6670807004,
0.2389131188,
-0.2654272318,
-0.0708187819,
-0.1148141995,
0.3137618303,
0.0525689311,
-0.3127156496,
-0.3148919642,
-0.4040287137,
-0.3790437877,
0.1071762964,
-0.3503196239,
0.5687112808,
-0.298933655,
-0.8252202272,
-0.0458871387,
0.4919582605,
0.5438678265,
-0.6127812862,
0.4721305668,
0.3331364095,
-0.2212362587,
-0.2787920833,
-0.4576116204,
0.3695329726,
-0.3548383117,
0.3488849401,
-0.6168169975,
-0.4343922734,
0.1919701397,
-0.2302667797,
0.1542180181,
0.2089615017,
0.1921036839,
-0.2989996672,
0.886800766,
0.9094107747,
0.2687326968,
0.3218003809,
-0.2359925359,
0.1782708764,
-0.5831772685,
-0.4288273156,
-0.6244804263,
-0.3160082102,
-0.180600822,
-0.9682878852,
0.2054188848,
0.1529942602,
-0.1331535429,
0.4463760555,
-0.4816961884,
0.4259458184,
0.7122015357,
-0.2628261745,
0.1195601374,
0.1076158732,
-0.0371819884,
-0.4641076326,
-0.5691105723,
-0.6167100072,
0.8003740311,
0.2645157576,
0.3240863085,
-0.079402335,
0.2562128603,
0.0885464549,
-0.4167368114,
-0.6598879695,
0.9572219849,
-0.150505051,
-0.0609957986,
-0.4299387932,
-0.2082564533,
-0.4728273749,
0.8481638432,
-0.4265235662,
-1.0113539696,
0.5043632984,
0.1708788127,
-0.1398231387,
0.328472048,
-0.863452673,
1.0342934132,
-0.6142603755,
-0.391946435,
-0.0811640993,
-0.4015178084,
0.2137304395,
0.317538172,
0.0266477093,
-0.2191696912,
-0.0487585813,
0.0757402852,
-0.255308032,
0.5256714225,
-0.3655132651,
0.3120179176,
0.0595963411,
0.1034795269,
0.4318167567,
-0.2839220762,
0.1375677139,
0.4934055507,
0.1190254688,
-0.3743777871,
-0.3813788593,
0.3449992537,
-0.4337864816,
-0.4065131247,
-0.4252185225,
-0.4144287109,
-0.2876117527,
0.2527872324,
0.1871851534,
0.2073582709,
-0.2491620928,
-0.2381996512,
0.5714346766,
-0.2760564387,
0.2664912641,
0.5282316208,
-0.8340061903,
-0.0544492789,
0.685118854,
0.2443915457,
0.2908738554,
0.2592212856,
0.1598768234,
-0.2579004467,
-1.0535635948,
-0.3868860006,
0.0175806358,
-0.6690347195,
0.2893685997,
-0.5369985104,
-0.2770214975,
-0.2772133052,
-0.2024549991,
-0.4424827695,
-0.2318329811,
0.1415938139,
-0.0508596636,
-0.3991376758,
0.8339203,
-0.1073591411,
-0.1226576194,
-0.2967725098,
0.625344038,
0.3868916929,
0.1765858829,
-0.3184936941,
0.0409654751,
0.0441034995,
-0.1615308225,
-0.1788410544,
-0.6310815811,
0.5064247251,
-0.3856348395,
0.5677081943,
0.2858979106,
-0.0411518626,
1.054076314,
-0.7596580982,
0.9769870043,
-0.0290319845,
-0.5745080113,
0.6681829095,
-0.0718526989,
0.451729238,
0.4250354469,
0.1234607175,
-0.2158257365,
-0.3604592681,
-0.5634388924,
-0.9163901806,
0.4522939324,
0.2476854324,
-0.3639208376,
0.3033225834,
-0.1366155297,
-0.3126323521,
0.2215114683,
-0.7593557835,
-0.0981569067,
-0.0411206372,
0.4434591532,
-0.2900265455,
-0.8406372666,
-0.1425479949,
-0.4707941413,
0.125913009,
-0.0128329284,
0.2544711828,
0.3580020666,
0.158190757,
-0.1725987643,
0.1055840254,
0.9875529408,
0.848392427,
0.0275611132,
0.1801894307,
0.2257325351,
-0.208261624,
-0.4748449326,
0.1612957269,
-0.1893552393,
0.0805096924,
0.586202085,
0.8029103875,
0.3063620031,
-0.8544844389,
0.4662172496,
-0.253564477,
-0.4552533925,
-0.5048269629,
-0.0224757493,
-0.0156127708,
0.630418241,
0.1540341675,
0.5207536221,
0.1463032514,
-0.4353197813,
-0.1526992619,
0.3511074185,
-0.4285207391,
-0.1370744705,
0.5365955234,
-0.0956125483,
-0.3012171984,
0.5080784559,
-0.1512216628,
-0.5318806171,
0.5709858537,
0.2627308071,
0.7008420825,
0.1121432781,
0.2174841166,
0.2973665595,
0.7521288991,
0.0118511114,
0.702427268,
-0.265593648,
-0.7653058171,
-0.3200647533,
-0.5166437626,
-0.3355414271,
0.1190149263,
-0.4907329381,
0.0335028321,
-0.4772531092,
-0.0093651377,
-0.1366644949,
0.0161302201,
-0.7993064523,
0.094368659,
0.2631615102,
1.0512766838,
-0.8581293821,
0.4615530372,
0.9565564394,
-0.2283699811,
-0.6091534495,
-0.1351361275,
0.1697016358,
-1.0003274679,
0.720713377,
0.0326031297,
-0.0870705172,
-0.5406817198,
-0.3399716318,
-0.6913044453,
0.7406015992,
0.1491977125,
-0.8292579055,
-0.3083987832,
0.3985937536,
0.7742520571,
0.0641696602,
-0.1989767551,
0.409335345,
0.59370327,
0.0436573364,
-1.1099264622,
-0.3314013779,
-0.1555179954,
0.1693796515,
0.2879077494,
-0.2930809259,
0.7521907687,
-0.464502126,
-0.2722136378,
0.1320611089,
0.5428405404,
0.4106549025,
0.7138278484,
0.5180795193,
0.945369184,
0.4667603076,
-0.254714638,
1.0737588406,
0.1451389492,
0.0440606438,
1.2724642754,
-0.6756488085,
1.2153382301,
0.6435577869,
-0.27466923,
0.0571303703,
0.0886369646,
0.0057106153,
0.6563894153,
0.1376715004,
-0.1112568751,
-0.406588614,
-0.0006413211,
-0.2797007561,
0.5868550539,
0.3783552051,
0.0568688586,
-0.3884987831,
0.0158712938,
-0.5742268562,
0.5015233159,
-0.4379318953,
0.6754118204,
0.1231921017,
-0.5819475651,
0.0769917071,
-0.2290928364,
0.0907959342,
-0.7219104171,
-0.0972050726,
0.0715653971,
0.2878268957,
-0.0763725042,
-1.2508889437,
0.6905462742,
0.0338393711,
-0.1493137479,
-0.73096174,
1.0188007355,
-0.0764371529,
-0.2499166876,
0.5912918448,
0.6044663191,
0.055739589,
-0.2829186022,
-0.7920091152,
0.4008643031,
-0.0529458299,
-0.1242571399,
0.2805857062,
0.5398715138,
-0.1657839566,
0.8284272552,
0.5461170077,
0.4373176992,
0.0349955894,
0.0718002394,
0.6513864398,
-0.675514698,
-0.3083001673,
-0.6606194973,
0.6800727248,
-0.214034155,
-0.3083975017,
0.7797915936,
0.5344504118,
1.2716999054,
-0.2565075755,
0.4521398544,
0.0438358337,
0.2508161962,
-0.6587280631,
0.1845307946,
-0.5721930265,
0.2768734694,
-0.2096836716,
-0.7227003574,
-0.17252478,
0.6458556652,
-0.8460251689,
-0.2089364231,
0.6657012105,
0.3474754989,
-0.0209737718,
-0.3545318842,
0.7478256226,
-0.174590528,
0.1636284739,
0.6913291812,
1.0593106747,
0.0018491463,
0.4668933153,
-0.5868662596,
0.0140951974,
-0.0747609511,
-0.79761374,
-0.6891343594,
-0.6803730726,
-0.017085271,
0.1223301589,
-0.0351675786,
0.3648416102,
0.6526432633,
-0.3185127974,
-0.3341678977,
-0.2790163755,
0.0913311765,
-0.4647018611,
-0.2388808429,
-0.1522460282,
-0.115613021,
-0.4170536101,
0.4672779441,
0.6623586416,
0.0214173216,
-0.3289209902,
0.1059132963,
0.0996898115,
-0.2389640808,
0.8824638724,
0.6147434711,
-0.8156506419,
-0.2947349548,
-0.1470614821,
-0.2060762346,
-0.1365087479,
0.776181221,
-0.7714557052,
0.5994058251,
0.5282457471,
0.2614144981,
0.4939154088,
-0.1198084354,
0.5043866634,
-0.4391191304,
0.2279644608,
0.2480381578,
0.6419596672,
0.0426665992,
-0.0430110805,
0.7423490882,
0.2338510603,
-0.5101122856,
-0.8162474036,
0.5226014853,
-1.2504024506,
-0.4562206864,
0.9305943251,
0.1156175658,
-0.1084813699,
0.012573408,
-0.6316820383,
-0.4687709808,
0.1032046825,
0.4394361675,
0.3524494469,
-0.2322924435,
-0.3228158355,
-0.8521330953,
0.36911726,
0.3310191929,
-0.5723640323,
0.2603757083,
0.8894388676,
-0.1405991465,
0.3987135291,
1.0061696768,
0.1914571077,
0.3129040301,
0.4295682907,
0.0373435281,
-0.1740800291,
-0.7759808302,
-0.2625540495,
0.4217501283,
0.169638291,
-0.0795130059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01853v1 | Improving Multilingual Instruction Finetuning via Linguistically Natural and Diverse Datasets | 2024-07-01T23:47:09 | 2024-07-01T23:47:09 | Sathish Reddy Indurthi, Wenxuan Zhou, Shamil Chollampatt, Ravi Agrawal, Kaiqiang Song, Lingxiao Zhao, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly enhanced
instruction-following capabilities. However, most Instruction Fine-Tuning (IFT)
datasets are predominantly in English, limiting model performance in other
languages. Traditional methods for creating multilingual IFT datasets such as
translating existing English IFT datasets or converting existing NLP datasets
into IFT datasets by templating, struggle to capture linguistic nuances and
ensure prompt (instruction) diversity. To address this issue, we propose a
novel method for collecting multilingual IFT datasets that preserves linguistic
naturalness and ensures prompt diversity. This approach leverages
English-focused LLMs, monolingual corpora, and a scoring function to create
high-quality, diversified IFT datasets in multiple languages. Experiments
demonstrate that LLMs finetuned using these IFT datasets show notable
improvements in both generative and discriminative tasks, indicating enhanced
language comprehension by LLMs in non-English contexts. Specifically, on the
multilingual summarization task, LLMs using our IFT dataset achieved 17.57% and
15.23% improvements over LLMs fine-tuned with translation-based and
template-based datasets, respectively. | [
-0.4682917297,
-0.5942187309,
0.0173715949,
0.3185966611,
-0.1883454919,
0.3511145115,
-0.8614165187,
-0.0958248004,
-0.0388517939,
0.2859445512,
-0.6064586043,
-0.8987273574,
-0.4340147674,
0.5627058744,
0.0266380385,
1.1585639715,
-0.0331605524,
0.3361040056,
0.0173685774,
-0.4285176396,
-0.8995370269,
-0.1041626409,
-0.6739862561,
-0.0156485122,
0.4913545847,
0.9443469048,
0.3436077833,
0.5591073632,
0.182228744,
0.2530982494,
0.1335240006,
0.9651032686,
-0.4530141056,
-0.0616423711,
-0.2037576288,
-0.5346993804,
-0.0448985733,
-0.2775638402,
0.9451307058,
0.9929690957,
-0.1168079525,
0.146050483,
0.4907380342,
0.7097659111,
-0.4846723378,
0.4067709744,
-0.4619435966,
0.0453774296,
-0.2472074777,
-0.3674660325,
-0.4697270691,
-0.4885748327,
0.0079891011,
-0.4775104523,
0.3524445891,
-0.2090826333,
0.3961980939,
0.196363911,
-0.5385408401,
-0.3312262595,
-0.5534626245,
0.843627274,
-0.6043590307,
0.6504671574,
0.3654805422,
0.1412226111,
0.0889690071,
-0.2146527916,
-0.1333310455,
-0.1964907199,
-0.1277448386,
0.0620630123,
0.0104060257,
-0.1425492018,
0.0451774597,
0.4548491836,
-0.6296192408,
0.5091209412,
-0.4534142613,
-0.2257978618,
0.5559627414,
0.2254793942,
0.2790883183,
-0.0523350239,
-0.1126477048,
-0.1274159551,
-0.7167264819,
0.3086333871,
0.3743990958,
0.9139078259,
-0.450132519,
0.382707119,
-0.157697469,
0.8917619586,
-0.022313321,
-0.3078927696,
0.2599489093,
-0.6353203058,
0.1128194854,
0.1263924539,
0.4892959595,
0.5659384131,
0.3599060774,
-0.2137257308,
-0.174895823,
-0.1800718307,
-0.3135232627,
-0.8213809729,
-0.1838754267,
-0.0396730043,
-0.1397406161,
0.2061458677,
0.0573718734,
-0.7795385718,
-0.1222406849,
-0.7977210879,
-0.0313056223,
-0.7002263665,
0.0716078952,
0.2780636549,
0.2607413232,
0.2814565003,
0.1348712593,
-1.0702264309,
0.169298768,
0.5225958228,
0.788403213,
-0.2879876196,
-0.4410150945,
-0.6745350957,
-0.1024163663,
-0.4179914594,
0.6788030267,
-0.468131572,
-0.2974668443,
0.0535035878,
0.205382064,
-0.1871716976,
-0.5108641386,
0.3099005222,
-0.2528571188,
0.4732480943,
-0.2477095276,
-0.6401170492,
-0.3167288303,
0.5611090064,
-0.5638484955,
0.7695747614,
-0.1049062237,
-0.4350292981,
0.3894594908,
-0.5706768036,
-0.8354007006,
0.0788695142,
-0.2454838604,
-0.0880884156,
0.040266078,
0.5933713317,
0.5487014651,
-0.1660109907,
0.3522468805,
0.2007239759,
-0.2467504293,
-0.1902159005,
-0.9022955298,
0.7872421741,
0.0553646199,
-0.2083579749,
-0.027870696,
-0.8968849182,
0.0626526549,
-0.1767051816,
-0.7224495411,
-0.3315961957,
-0.2268013358,
-0.1932793707,
0.0005202362,
0.2665243447,
-0.4312496185,
0.2702815235,
-0.3350056708,
0.1138996333,
0.6967574954,
-0.0404332057,
0.407773912,
-0.3934752643,
0.6049590111,
-0.0427872986,
-0.2034819871,
-0.5982257724,
-0.3537359834,
-0.7389358282,
-0.4892376065,
0.3429236114,
0.9256010056,
-0.969895184,
0.3385626078,
-0.4045346975,
-0.2168795466,
-0.7152447104,
0.2838229239,
0.5494830608,
0.4511318207,
0.5014399886,
0.0248836651,
-0.3474822938,
-0.7743223906,
-0.1542722583,
0.5708447695,
-0.0380496569,
0.0961115956,
0.0027406053,
-0.103432633,
0.6043038964,
-0.3316328228,
-0.1318929046,
-0.3135686517,
0.1974759698,
0.5136187673,
0.5305634141,
0.4222904146,
-0.4999808967,
-0.6857634783,
0.1832233965,
-0.5803470612,
-0.0608957484,
-0.2687189877,
-0.1616128981,
0.2039166689,
0.389472425,
-0.3162134588,
-0.0266003069,
0.455658555,
-0.2316039354,
0.4382967651,
-0.4073084593,
0.563024044,
-1.2307413816,
-0.3826044798,
-0.0584632494,
-0.1489337087,
-0.5398626328,
0.1404992491,
0.252735436,
-0.0341842473,
-0.5028021336,
0.5886254311,
-0.6122668982,
0.121601738,
-0.0576507524,
-0.1160617694,
0.0597408339,
0.4086877704,
-0.0799720585,
0.944930613,
0.6733967066,
-0.7667836547,
0.1300030053,
0.2750744224,
-0.3700989783,
0.7212823629,
-0.1692771763,
-0.0615440011,
-0.4909307361,
-0.0873440504,
-0.8160473704,
-0.3082666993,
-0.0802379996,
-0.1268491447,
0.7486572862,
-0.1097211912,
-0.4145337939,
-0.0296917986,
-0.4165058434,
0.1654891074,
0.241953373,
-0.8729799986,
0.3505550921,
-0.1065414101,
-0.364204675,
-0.6594684124,
-0.7188605666,
0.0242004488,
-0.1860051304,
-0.6211992502,
0.2217301577,
-0.3292057812,
-0.1378552914,
-0.3163165152,
-0.1396816224,
-0.0158002265,
0.0445258506,
-0.4364549816,
0.3166288137,
-0.4504838586,
0.3327964246,
0.4865684211,
-0.0225115754,
-0.2565875351,
-0.3256861866,
0.5117650628,
-0.2639824152,
-0.2462482005,
-0.2873312831,
0.5576567054,
0.3221459389,
-0.5192992687,
0.713371098,
0.6414651871,
-0.3473635316,
-0.6096777916,
-0.3020395041,
-0.3568473756,
-0.4418952465,
0.2986924946,
-0.4057398736,
-0.97624439,
0.3858389556,
0.1706406176,
0.7566390038,
0.0998618752,
0.509570539,
-0.0968274325,
0.8153523207,
0.4845492244,
0.0354768075,
0.4531955719,
-0.259304136,
0.0286123883,
-0.4075243473,
-0.0935346857,
-0.333460927,
-0.3996838331,
-0.8017755151,
-0.367977649,
0.3185060024,
-0.0199397765,
-0.0695121661,
0.000304232,
-0.4080803394,
0.9504451752,
0.6309922338,
0.2011138499,
0.3369944394,
0.3516584337,
-0.1645571291,
-0.2675498128,
-0.8029677868,
-0.5922048092,
1.1527172327,
-0.1114133522,
0.6495734453,
0.2505418956,
0.7573360205,
0.0436438061,
0.2202726454,
-0.473162204,
0.3321820796,
-0.845094502,
-0.2220075279,
-0.2079498619,
-0.6189365387,
-1.0581902266,
0.1748490036,
-0.0414328985,
-0.4389338791,
-0.0140494984,
0.2442433238,
-0.4978761673,
0.1651736498,
-0.9143204093,
0.9174264073,
-0.3708628416,
-0.4817565382,
0.0088014761,
-0.5032247305,
0.3671559393,
-0.0246054903,
0.4369950294,
-0.1178895384,
0.0952891037,
0.4853617847,
-0.098483108,
0.868293345,
-0.0790352449,
-0.2850873768,
0.0751406997,
0.1459158808,
0.2171585262,
0.1796927154,
-0.2258581519,
0.1410356462,
-0.2135196924,
-0.4677208662,
-0.4517086744,
0.8272371292,
-0.6827703118,
-0.3985746503,
0.0457632355,
-0.9209604859,
-0.3107826114,
0.1360139102,
0.4120279253,
0.6739049554,
-0.0917065218,
0.2757444978,
0.8245300651,
-0.3950890601,
0.396099031,
0.8314466476,
0.2130165994,
-0.3079776168,
1.169785738,
0.3559012115,
0.3255840242,
0.579005301,
0.2239723206,
-0.2569649816,
-0.5502308607,
-0.5916998386,
0.0437261872,
-0.8883813024,
-0.3522865772,
-0.4086607695,
0.0775061026,
-0.2438263446,
-0.2042701244,
-0.2677004039,
-0.1794785708,
-0.2957700491,
-0.2809554636,
0.4965285659,
0.3211945593,
-0.151551947,
0.2422604412,
-0.9767299294,
0.2780737877,
0.2263955325,
0.3816510737,
-0.2778580785,
-0.6142858863,
-0.3421390951,
0.2538960874,
-0.0887751281,
-0.6332415342,
0.3568036556,
0.6258623004,
0.5001856685,
0.1315816045,
-0.1108261868,
0.8130731583,
-0.698611021,
0.6179466248,
-0.1044722348,
-0.6835654974,
0.4037621617,
-0.3905178905,
0.7364782095,
0.7461099029,
0.4866861105,
-0.5825901031,
-0.4098748267,
-0.1295576096,
-0.8709983826,
0.8136162758,
-0.154007569,
0.3707366884,
-0.2129755169,
0.149594143,
0.6047745347,
0.2268252969,
-0.5815833807,
-0.2988427281,
-0.0730626658,
-0.7159233093,
-0.3240399659,
0.1104730517,
-0.0389958955,
-0.2847717106,
0.603669405,
-0.36423406,
-0.1589592546,
-0.2104840428,
-0.2504990101,
0.2187658846,
0.4873267412,
0.614282608,
0.4902560115,
0.0782056749,
0.2502134144,
0.3763679564,
-0.3069387078,
0.1684612781,
0.4259211421,
-0.2918917835,
0.0829545334,
0.5098764896,
0.8618189096,
0.5000455976,
-0.6965944767,
0.0850185007,
-0.1811933815,
0.1000861451,
-0.0060381005,
0.1525428295,
0.054669667,
0.1653802842,
0.1135216728,
0.0892621502,
0.0708841085,
-0.2422686815,
0.3213289082,
0.2205406278,
0.0912166312,
-0.1900146753,
0.377453655,
0.1869884282,
-0.2785997987,
0.7481492758,
-0.3645398021,
-0.0901449621,
0.5879495144,
0.6664158106,
0.5285951495,
-0.3713103831,
0.1523187011,
0.7018756866,
0.5683589578,
-0.0624518618,
0.4856940508,
-0.0724502504,
-0.7200965881,
-0.4401398301,
-0.455516696,
-0.3395665586,
-0.0223285854,
-0.6607760191,
0.4646634459,
-0.3383898437,
0.2689184248,
-0.1797895581,
-0.1395684481,
-0.9082126617,
0.077737011,
0.40668571,
0.7629659772,
-0.8795828223,
0.5757118464,
0.7759414911,
-0.3151399493,
-0.8617631793,
-0.1482861638,
-0.0810142234,
-0.7089349627,
0.3065081239,
0.4460481703,
0.0532161593,
0.1099045053,
-0.263610661,
-0.7475050688,
0.8762272,
0.7785397768,
-0.9016463161,
0.0402724594,
0.2811557949,
0.3274707198,
-0.2977847755,
0.0972540304,
0.7071288228,
0.4290916324,
-0.220126614,
-0.6298421025,
-0.3408816457,
-0.2435196042,
-0.2192756683,
0.2244759947,
-0.4099603891,
0.8022531271,
-0.1610618681,
-0.2645836174,
-0.2378995121,
0.605830729,
0.3718254268,
0.173960954,
0.2608716786,
0.362121582,
1.0498696566,
-0.2128849924,
0.9581599832,
-0.4461426437,
0.0532427579,
1.3333810568,
0.0342554636,
0.4536996186,
0.2102034539,
0.0700084791,
0.2337459624,
0.7190414667,
-0.074668996,
0.4597047865,
0.0460889377,
-0.3768287003,
-0.1709380597,
-0.1959287822,
-0.1132146493,
0.5032345057,
0.3830921948,
-0.0699920282,
-0.5906755328,
0.4956038296,
0.1255609095,
0.3936052322,
-0.4499287605,
0.698513329,
-0.1730267853,
-0.811088264,
0.8936046362,
0.0719745159,
1.0157073736,
-0.7245133519,
-0.1611022949,
-0.6897226572,
0.1209994555,
-0.3076885045,
-0.7957499623,
0.1571144909,
0.3388029337,
-0.3794558942,
-0.3021875918,
0.1193214133,
-1.1168849468,
-0.7263148427,
0.0551817901,
0.4399358034,
0.0781399608,
0.5894653797,
-0.4840827286,
-0.0482786074,
0.2915605903,
-0.0645156726,
0.1485017091,
0.5660760999,
-0.1928630173,
0.4280878603,
0.6247292757,
-0.0259498209,
0.3768164515,
0.2999736965,
0.5566304922,
-0.3311969936,
-0.5381338,
-0.8185483813,
0.7663420439,
0.063277185,
-0.5761938691,
0.8642268777,
0.6384775043,
1.1865785122,
-0.2405323088,
0.6199816465,
0.2009968609,
0.5164945126,
-0.840256691,
0.3969154656,
-0.5218447447,
0.2132171392,
0.1371216029,
-0.8302275538,
-0.4103784263,
0.50950104,
-0.2179231644,
-0.0270876475,
0.4160036743,
0.8254401684,
-0.4364174604,
0.0705488846,
0.2811946869,
-0.0238265898,
0.2474382222,
0.4473924339,
0.5917624235,
-0.1255892813,
0.2365170419,
-0.3219209313,
-0.3314092755,
0.1831825376,
-0.7498978972,
-0.9831321239,
-0.3235985041,
-0.3104558289,
0.2251511067,
0.0333242714,
1.2950489521,
0.4884308279,
-1.0852251053,
-0.3949276507,
0.0077408045,
0.1940465122,
-0.2341372818,
-0.2161189914,
0.3239670992,
-0.8239735961,
-0.8859721422,
0.7639699578,
0.17659612,
0.0519619659,
-0.055536516,
-0.0074573797,
-0.1748804152,
-0.1409867853,
0.808675766,
0.2101212591,
-0.4485353827,
-0.1176235154,
0.1762078851,
0.0404710621,
0.1050581783,
0.3936647177,
-0.4102937579,
0.6384376884,
0.2998530269,
0.9898359776,
-0.0016768596,
-0.2566199899,
0.6703205705,
-1.3737710714,
0.3709073067,
0.2876292169,
0.4388950765,
0.6863521934,
-0.3215447962,
0.3290371299,
-0.17497392,
-0.221040085,
-0.6129307747,
0.0792733356,
-0.4756390154,
-0.2409643233,
0.8822415471,
-0.1379956305,
0.1096591428,
0.0715429932,
-0.2751674056,
0.3390470743,
-0.3297727406,
0.6522987485,
0.7069490552,
0.1626511365,
-0.3094506264,
-0.5547730327,
0.2687759995,
0.4133300185,
-1.0070980787,
0.1498778909,
0.6792601943,
0.2861254811,
-0.0899023861,
0.2609004378,
0.1325004846,
0.4390459657,
-0.4260257781,
0.0656909123,
-0.1414477229,
-0.5001959205,
-0.463737309,
-0.0375560634,
-0.1116205826,
-0.298088789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01850v1 | Purple-teaming LLMs with Adversarial Defender Training | 2024-07-01T23:25:30 | 2024-07-01T23:25:30 | Jingyan Zhou, Kun Li, Junan Li, Jiawen Kang, Minda Hu, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing efforts in safeguarding LLMs are limited in actively exposing the
vulnerabilities of the target LLM and readily adapting to newly emerging safety
risks. To address this, we present Purple-teaming LLMs with Adversarial
Defender training (PAD), a pipeline designed to safeguard LLMs by novelly
incorporating the red-teaming (attack) and blue-teaming (safety training)
techniques. In PAD, we automatically collect conversational data that cover the
vulnerabilities of an LLM around specific safety risks in a self-play manner,
where the attacker aims to elicit unsafe responses and the defender generates
safe responses to these attacks. We then update both modules in a generative
adversarial network style by training the attacker to elicit more unsafe
responses and updating the defender to identify them and explain the unsafe
reason. Experimental results demonstrate that PAD significantly outperforms
existing baselines in both finding effective attacks and establishing a robust
safe guardrail. Furthermore, our findings indicate that PAD excels in striking
a balance between safety and overall model quality. We also reveal key
challenges in safeguarding LLMs, including defending multi-turn attacks and the
need for more delicate strategies to identify specific risks. | [
-0.3500515819,
-0.8169819713,
-0.0964751914,
0.2563742697,
-0.0482770465,
0.7137541771,
0.274302721,
-0.2570731938,
0.174277842,
0.483967483,
-0.6062844992,
-0.4116207957,
-0.7907765508,
-0.1497247666,
-0.2583631873,
1.1958481073,
-0.1166896299,
0.0930788815,
0.3480829597,
-0.1960696131,
-0.4754836559,
-0.7094343901,
-0.7184385061,
-0.2248480916,
0.5244290233,
0.1749863178,
0.5128881931,
0.5602460504,
0.6631969213,
0.2787164152,
-0.0689182207,
0.1751173735,
-0.6528662443,
0.3378613889,
0.163517043,
-0.4793088734,
-0.5970401764,
0.205263406,
0.2318841964,
0.2433190942,
-0.0685525388,
-0.3314543664,
0.137238279,
0.6991103888,
-0.9739420414,
-0.1548573524,
-0.8797736168,
0.4120991826,
-0.0479398593,
-0.4270456135,
-0.4007173777,
-0.185029909,
-0.0195375867,
-0.5414639711,
0.0315393955,
-0.0095034642,
0.512667954,
0.2044847459,
-0.6751247048,
-0.1727759093,
-0.406160444,
0.5102404952,
0.1787275225,
-0.229373455,
0.1901140213,
0.6141288877,
-0.2757837772,
-0.6130689979,
-0.171030134,
-0.1042005271,
0.1608688831,
0.5664510131,
-0.2257946879,
0.2634750903,
-0.1774683893,
-0.0057431785,
-0.6507570744,
0.405553937,
-0.3986120522,
-0.3108533919,
0.8890912533,
0.2412074357,
0.4003600478,
0.1344856173,
-1.1533582211,
-0.1986335814,
-1.0796657801,
0.0458360016,
0.5882538557,
0.248018682,
-0.3331831694,
0.3528809249,
0.1864166409,
0.1316871494,
0.1486825049,
-0.0216465369,
-0.0169308279,
-0.1478686482,
-0.2712033093,
0.2523922622,
0.9128881693,
0.5082854629,
0.1812262237,
-0.5646603703,
-0.2893907726,
0.4071965814,
0.6127488017,
-0.5411401987,
-0.9056892991,
0.3466799259,
-0.218541801,
-0.9856847525,
0.0707802474,
-0.7678453326,
-0.8802013397,
0.0871890709,
0.2932401001,
-0.4772788286,
-0.4643833935,
-0.0548666939,
-0.3595384657,
0.2451227307,
0.1289055794,
-1.0016595125,
0.1439661682,
0.8380795121,
0.6149616241,
-0.4252703488,
-0.3259830475,
-0.8514080048,
0.4090325832,
-0.5744780302,
0.7320458889,
-0.0019543795,
-0.7245246172,
0.1099412888,
-0.1075820401,
-0.0034343346,
-0.4311297238,
0.1298920512,
-0.7853057981,
-0.0297815464,
-0.2656748295,
-0.3384241462,
0.2580787838,
0.6808159351,
-0.3820625246,
0.549805522,
-0.0696275607,
-0.6923950911,
0.5408471227,
-0.6581425667,
-0.2511089444,
0.1839650273,
-0.2565955222,
-0.7225956321,
-0.4025388062,
0.0656029508,
0.3722473979,
0.2381085306,
-0.3504451811,
-0.7972852588,
-0.0836081579,
0.2888523638,
-0.4150696099,
1.2036886215,
0.0720961466,
-0.2082269043,
0.3834249377,
-0.4229941666,
0.1473705769,
0.0925959647,
-0.4979091287,
0.1900686771,
-0.4243375659,
-0.2774585783,
0.1677298695,
0.2166839689,
-0.4421878457,
0.1068288013,
-0.0447022505,
0.4343256652,
1.1490644217,
0.0723058656,
0.7790890336,
-0.4552575648,
1.0145661831,
-0.1137221381,
0.483510673,
0.0799711496,
-0.3892049789,
-0.6356378794,
-0.6050716639,
0.1214511245,
0.9054825902,
-0.8106213212,
0.2628256977,
0.179659009,
-0.4798345864,
-0.234534204,
0.3479657173,
0.8781732321,
0.3674441874,
0.3864166141,
-0.1895635575,
-0.6567599773,
-0.6715984344,
0.1380439103,
-0.3232507706,
0.1610276699,
0.1218720973,
0.5966518521,
-0.1343119293,
0.5909193158,
-0.2557782531,
-0.2862819433,
-0.2907788455,
0.1358174682,
-0.3748677671,
0.5764523149,
0.7165939808,
-0.8956333995,
-0.69233495,
-0.1381462663,
-0.9352160692,
0.1185257956,
0.0742275044,
-0.3903110921,
0.1178780869,
0.7621489167,
-0.6029185057,
0.1891686618,
0.5900229216,
-0.2367109507,
0.6199578643,
-0.062542282,
-0.0270985384,
-0.9542938471,
-0.1451351792,
-0.1457034051,
-0.0434053652,
-0.8182224035,
0.2966431379,
0.3150340319,
-0.2049215585,
-0.9051615596,
0.479988873,
-0.3696231246,
-0.0790163726,
-0.3694722354,
0.0331849344,
-0.066079773,
0.5564021468,
-0.1862436533,
0.8726605773,
0.5542460084,
-0.7994710207,
0.7274552584,
0.2786950171,
0.2281741202,
0.7364853024,
-0.4658057094,
0.2976656854,
0.051721856,
0.3295308948,
-0.6406840086,
-0.1005405858,
0.4615894556,
-0.4175185561,
0.8177320361,
-0.5925993919,
-0.1666771173,
-0.2111964822,
-0.6906810403,
0.0360034183,
0.4145978093,
-0.6072665453,
0.3234968781,
0.926939249,
-0.106389679,
-1.0600147247,
-0.6365487576,
0.3278990686,
-0.8668832183,
-0.6108515263,
0.7025412917,
-0.0610665716,
-0.2682701051,
-0.2572260499,
-0.1047164202,
-0.261589855,
0.7687928081,
0.3286597431,
0.3905934095,
0.0073413858,
-0.0856619403,
-0.6384981871,
-0.5206376314,
0.3563024402,
-0.1459506154,
0.4571855366,
-0.2190719098,
-0.4571798444,
-0.1312088072,
0.2928344905,
0.2646307647,
-0.0534971654,
0.731297791,
0.6342153549,
-0.1340302825,
-0.3635193706,
-0.1277111769,
-0.3323343694,
-0.5454993248,
0.3137356043,
-0.2049551755,
-0.7431581616,
0.3289909363,
0.1898441464,
0.0820607096,
0.0378979966,
0.4760640264,
-0.8196898103,
0.8983707428,
0.5814121366,
-0.3148394227,
0.4282644987,
-0.5202542543,
-0.0337559544,
-0.8403317332,
-0.4382654727,
-0.0712480173,
-0.4434734881,
-0.7251319885,
-0.1521872133,
0.6102433205,
0.2739513218,
-0.690535605,
0.2995477021,
-0.5249736309,
0.4393493831,
0.7593785524,
0.3791080117,
-0.0913662538,
-0.160203144,
-0.0643678755,
0.0523273945,
-0.850921452,
-0.3627077639,
1.4749273062,
0.5085837841,
0.6779175997,
0.460388422,
0.8614612818,
0.1894264072,
0.3026565909,
-0.3801474869,
0.7265153527,
-0.1552222371,
-0.5656044483,
-0.1323689669,
-0.3532337844,
-1.171710968,
0.1722859591,
-0.4547211528,
-0.2758784294,
-0.2708970606,
0.41943115,
-0.4192792475,
0.4155142605,
-0.6130197644,
0.7606950402,
-0.7139616609,
-0.338698864,
-0.0043053515,
-0.549734354,
0.5847228765,
0.1337548792,
-0.2775593102,
0.1119805127,
-0.2108999789,
0.4490176737,
-0.3035651445,
0.9026002288,
-0.1902872622,
0.169156909,
0.2438968122,
0.1330657154,
0.5707321167,
0.036164429,
0.3856376708,
-0.1900397092,
-0.7486745715,
-0.6768998504,
-0.3431171477,
0.554516077,
-0.8405614495,
-0.7616499662,
-0.6250131726,
-0.4913599789,
-0.4262329638,
-0.1151238903,
0.2588346004,
-0.097372517,
-0.2465478331,
0.3371595144,
1.1301817894,
-0.2174753547,
0.6381146908,
0.5167626143,
0.1610605866,
-0.7343559265,
0.7511751056,
-0.0536763035,
0.4156178832,
0.433609724,
-0.1391572207,
-0.3938222229,
-1.0852081776,
-0.4138435125,
-0.2114329785,
-0.4799415171,
-0.3354890645,
-0.4350572526,
-0.4395387173,
-0.3440310061,
-0.424890548,
-0.194003731,
-0.4715235531,
0.0275138803,
-0.5543872714,
0.5456060171,
0.4155049026,
-0.3042055368,
0.1824728251,
-0.545435369,
0.3123368621,
0.8869073987,
-0.1073436737,
-0.6556711197,
-0.2958742976,
0.0064741625,
-0.0562414043,
-0.8675197959,
-0.9135358334,
0.4670622945,
-0.4217751026,
0.7311829925,
0.2135567069,
0.2258725166,
0.3826585114,
-0.2546510398,
0.5317387581,
0.6287798882,
-0.3290723264,
0.7766301632,
-0.7387993336,
-0.1961791068,
0.4550499022,
0.272842139,
0.031668745,
-0.1889836192,
-0.7040534616,
-0.7233707309,
0.4318800271,
0.3261063695,
-0.25083673,
0.101111345,
-0.0541763827,
-0.4757108986,
0.2323989272,
-1.0095700026,
-0.3276799023,
-0.2566900551,
0.0199829061,
0.1428266913,
-0.1799569875,
-0.8564488292,
0.6522316933,
0.8008899689,
-0.145533368,
0.2488021553,
-0.271048218,
-0.0864858478,
0.1824098378,
0.0767463893,
0.2969240248,
-0.0122862188,
-0.1174392626,
0.0742289796,
0.6221694946,
-0.3137069046,
0.3472343087,
0.208515957,
-0.1569468826,
-0.6733991504,
0.4607519209,
0.3239212334,
0.1933708936,
-0.3186812103,
0.5575475097,
-0.0416406021,
-0.397746861,
-0.3474811018,
0.4735790789,
0.0896446779,
0.3439240456,
0.0765237063,
0.3684347868,
-0.2264649123,
-0.5224432945,
0.2146736681,
0.8785142303,
-0.5043625832,
0.0421163477,
0.6757733226,
0.6180217266,
-0.3652837574,
0.2361101955,
-0.2952742279,
-0.9133375287,
1.0443735123,
0.1255172044,
1.0522581339,
-0.1774848104,
0.17701599,
-0.1492985189,
0.4829992652,
0.2066920847,
0.1557532102,
0.1703429967,
-0.7535147071,
0.1254678369,
-0.0574706532,
-0.7758296728,
0.2627776861,
-0.5622748137,
0.2256399393,
-0.8920616508,
0.0242292527,
-0.4935586751,
0.2221056372,
-0.3258749843,
0.2392215431,
0.3039638996,
0.7647201419,
-0.5950088501,
0.629537344,
0.6366716027,
-0.3570759892,
-0.5318524837,
-0.1966194659,
0.4889671206,
-1.0784586668,
0.682715416,
0.1129350215,
-0.0769957602,
-0.440431118,
-0.0873227119,
-0.2858652174,
1.5037010908,
0.4946027398,
-0.3885765374,
0.0775221437,
0.2032196224,
0.3384055793,
-0.1551732868,
0.0451858602,
0.2296220362,
0.1439171731,
-0.2922394872,
-0.7042993903,
-0.2959243059,
-0.2160026133,
-0.3078383505,
0.1395149678,
-1.0153996944,
0.7479305863,
-0.1514407098,
-0.1785177588,
-0.101314202,
0.3877956867,
0.8906450272,
0.3618367016,
0.5366611481,
0.791420877,
0.6910181046,
-0.1974851638,
1.0050244331,
-0.5847613215,
-0.135028258,
1.0314383507,
-0.0896116644,
0.6570273042,
0.2438444644,
-0.1769013554,
-0.0030609996,
0.6019453406,
0.0950214416,
0.8208878636,
0.2738652527,
-0.7200344205,
-0.2174301893,
0.2099943161,
-0.4432808459,
0.2728221118,
0.1999714822,
-0.2253224105,
0.0629647225,
-0.0542995967,
0.2364131957,
0.1216994002,
-0.4572889507,
0.7896193266,
0.1139585823,
-0.620881319,
0.2114939392,
-0.2386676371,
0.8058220744,
-0.6824766397,
0.3528736532,
-0.3568190038,
0.3762340248,
-0.0649555996,
-0.8624799252,
0.0694212765,
0.224905014,
0.0522772595,
-0.6625272036,
0.6444408298,
-0.1808937043,
-0.1809216887,
0.5829646587,
0.2828322351,
-0.3723440766,
0.2748970985,
-1.0810060501,
-0.1195137352,
-0.0784999356,
0.0538724251,
0.9152956009,
0.4286582172,
0.3534450531,
1.2080994844,
0.5895016789,
0.2797345817,
0.3533150256,
-0.1071778759,
0.8856449127,
-0.4769613147,
-0.6427695155,
-0.846655488,
0.5518642068,
-0.3439608514,
-0.3556136787,
0.6330571175,
0.3230018318,
0.5090895295,
0.1746862829,
0.9745851159,
0.5276074409,
0.2681013346,
-0.7074878812,
0.8041998148,
0.019446468,
0.6498072147,
0.0552976876,
-0.4541485608,
-0.1355606914,
0.5018761754,
-0.0557157733,
-0.004702033,
0.4237987995,
1.095125556,
0.0626739785,
-0.0551055484,
0.1237126365,
0.1491491795,
0.800706327,
0.8589082956,
1.1162215471,
-0.4637959599,
1.2543480396,
-0.409170717,
-0.3269091845,
-0.1051691696,
-1.0402376652,
-1.1560140848,
0.0441871472,
-0.6506813765,
-0.7194502354,
0.6665002108,
0.445635587,
1.0656555891,
-0.797863245,
0.1208651662,
-0.5527327061,
-0.0449116528,
0.0865396261,
-0.2444234341,
0.145917207,
-0.3628230989,
-0.3048421443,
0.8415614367,
0.4197119772,
0.3832773864,
-0.4447731972,
-0.408025831,
0.110634163,
-0.3975456655,
0.2266614139,
0.6116231084,
-0.3890858591,
-0.2585752606,
-0.1477510631,
-0.4188338518,
-0.1148864776,
0.4315703809,
-0.6370846033,
0.2773701251,
0.1938350201,
0.9516445398,
0.3469090462,
-0.3412469625,
0.8863220811,
-0.7132095098,
0.0621786155,
0.5032171011,
0.6103793979,
0.3361324668,
-0.2472820729,
0.7049880028,
0.1809102893,
-0.559748292,
-0.9882153869,
0.5334329605,
-0.7815421224,
-0.2615403235,
1.0930050611,
-0.519110918,
0.1866792291,
-0.3952378631,
-0.01684824,
0.0193463806,
-0.1308653653,
1.2047383785,
0.4401711226,
-0.0345961675,
-0.1204389855,
-0.2537551224,
0.7543685436,
0.45129776,
-0.8686668277,
-0.1379543841,
-0.023625521,
0.2121587247,
0.1623403579,
0.545574367,
-0.0134530198,
0.7809821367,
0.2333278805,
-0.4466289282,
-0.4131280184,
-0.5180362463,
-0.314255476,
0.6052855253,
-0.299810648,
-0.6740919352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01834v1 | A Study of Nationality Bias in Names and Perplexity using Off-the-Shelf Affect-related Tweet Classifiers | 2024-07-01T22:17:17 | 2024-07-01T22:17:17 | Valentin Barriere, Sebastian Cifuentes | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we apply a method to quantify biases associated with named
entities from various countries. We create counterfactual examples with small
perturbations on target-domain data instead of relying on templates or specific
datasets for bias detection. On widely used classifiers for subjectivity
analysis, including sentiment, emotion, hate speech, and offensive text using
Twitter data, our results demonstrate positive biases related to the language
spoken in a country across all classifiers studied. Notably, the presence of
certain country names in a sentence can strongly influence predictions, up to a
23\% change in hate speech detection and up to a 60\% change in the prediction
of negative emotions such as anger. We hypothesize that these biases stem from
the training data of pre-trained language models (PLMs) and find correlations
between affect predictions and PLMs likelihood in English and unknown languages
like Basque and Maori, revealing distinct patterns with exacerbate
correlations. Further, we followed these correlations in-between counterfactual
examples from a same sentence to remove the syntactical component, uncovering
interesting results suggesting the impact of the pre-training data was more
important for English-speaking-country names. Our anonymized code is
[https://anonymous.4open.science/r/biases_ppl-576B/README.md](available here). | [
-0.4447933733,
-0.5105563402,
0.3147127032,
0.2711732388,
-0.3259027898,
0.1430430859,
-0.2803865969,
-0.3419746161,
0.5389845967,
0.5034623146,
-0.6561882496,
-0.4414374232,
-0.9017917514,
0.1729464829,
-0.306686312,
1.067815423,
-0.1419559717,
0.2018568665,
0.3860831261,
-0.3751300871,
-0.015229634,
-0.8104605079,
-0.2906309068,
-0.1650853455,
0.798025012,
0.4179215431,
0.6751440763,
-0.1397322714,
0.420748502,
0.1650960892,
0.0752038211,
-0.4691276848,
-0.5146586299,
0.15083009,
-0.5337836146,
-0.5300546885,
-0.0594828464,
0.1949811727,
0.24104096,
0.3985615075,
0.4286876321,
0.2848942578,
-0.397488147,
0.4546641111,
-0.6734803319,
0.0249542482,
-0.671196878,
0.2289796174,
-0.4466112554,
-0.0704909638,
-0.0501727127,
-0.4942944348,
0.3511023521,
-0.0774501264,
0.376211524,
-0.0072486764,
0.9250580072,
0.307323873,
-0.4634883702,
-0.2470819652,
-0.454442054,
1.0146391392,
-0.4277896285,
0.4966171086,
0.2372982204,
0.0961698368,
0.097544916,
-0.0908550173,
-0.7003404498,
0.0007125443,
-0.044118721,
0.1769822836,
-0.1192425638,
-0.121836707,
0.5363675356,
0.3386644423,
-0.2386633158,
0.0662125424,
-0.2959507108,
-0.2053443044,
0.8390575051,
-0.2590054274,
0.6880275011,
-0.2204926759,
-0.1890651584,
0.2232653946,
-0.9538114667,
0.0789350495,
0.8847988844,
0.498496592,
-0.377105087,
0.5883311033,
-0.3062001467,
0.3597873747,
0.0467342585,
0.1453149617,
0.4914320409,
0.331651777,
-0.0528872833,
0.2601410151,
0.8892774582,
0.3628886342,
0.681373477,
-0.3768313825,
0.0800610557,
0.2923843563,
0.0713298246,
-1.0228501558,
-0.0996489227,
0.2391661704,
-0.2998860478,
-0.1509298533,
0.0675425902,
-0.8121479154,
-0.6190416813,
-0.0824169517,
0.4515504539,
-0.1226466671,
-0.4805978835,
-0.14575544,
-0.2252296805,
0.0666821301,
0.0190263875,
-0.6778336763,
-0.2789096832,
0.320987165,
0.2714746892,
-0.3134208918,
-0.2072240412,
-0.2252671123,
-0.4535906911,
-0.1607654393,
0.66919595,
-0.7787845135,
-0.3347473443,
0.1208722368,
0.0556550063,
0.0433364958,
-0.3335181177,
0.4908518493,
-0.5259109139,
0.4005737305,
-0.743791461,
-0.2376884967,
-0.105276145,
0.1589172333,
-0.6598285437,
0.6005302072,
0.2458916456,
-1.2483949661,
0.7007024288,
-0.6883648038,
-0.5879746079,
-0.2300476432,
-0.1851166487,
-0.3574983776,
0.2191714197,
0.0206591003,
0.4130465984,
-0.281773597,
0.5440682173,
-0.3548779786,
-0.1756070703,
0.3725634217,
-0.1649870872,
1.1633069515,
0.0356092751,
-0.7216040492,
-0.1167395711,
-0.4374611974,
-0.3937973976,
0.038437631,
-0.0128761614,
-0.5507502556,
-0.2144101113,
0.0448070094,
0.4859380424,
-0.0875094309,
-1.0199084282,
-0.0345496871,
-0.3094189167,
0.1167254969,
0.4483706951,
0.1749364585,
0.1967807561,
-0.0713510364,
0.8076894283,
0.3600194752,
0.1859276295,
0.0841936618,
-0.5049468875,
-0.6798419952,
0.0927763879,
0.3535660505,
0.4384965599,
-0.775983274,
0.0247197263,
-0.0155213838,
-0.3389278352,
-0.6208542585,
-0.1275832206,
0.3653565049,
0.5844228864,
0.295383811,
-0.1888783723,
-0.8722143769,
-1.1598175764,
-0.9915692806,
-0.3066350818,
-0.0398129337,
0.375743717,
0.5904229879,
-0.181364879,
1.1026434898,
-0.2893763781,
-0.080697678,
-0.0998586193,
0.1424044818,
-0.0574356355,
0.0540054142,
0.6614578962,
-1.0424871445,
-0.7826775908,
-0.5152968764,
-0.5747535825,
-0.5654070973,
0.1655806899,
-0.324169904,
0.4171232581,
0.0664793327,
-0.3499577343,
0.4643382132,
0.5478466749,
-0.5648052096,
0.5008510947,
0.7143702507,
0.3412663639,
-1.1458081007,
-0.0267113484,
0.308267951,
0.3193895221,
-0.7712169886,
-0.1808003783,
0.1066403836,
0.3289127946,
-0.8676708341,
0.7734561563,
-0.1659706384,
0.3450219631,
0.1578793675,
-0.1571712792,
-0.2074552923,
0.1519369483,
0.3280200958,
0.6100441813,
0.477504611,
-0.2374651879,
0.096218951,
0.2165353447,
-0.2756976783,
0.6621767879,
-0.0536981188,
-0.1638388485,
-0.3523177207,
0.0312388334,
-0.7739486098,
-0.2743977606,
0.3496408165,
-0.4773846865,
0.1526381224,
-0.2962563634,
-0.1935667694,
-0.3451428413,
-0.2237405181,
0.3753150702,
0.4877439141,
-0.7082046866,
0.4679769576,
0.569211185,
0.083435677,
-0.8126516342,
-1.1572561264,
0.2147342414,
-0.7354892492,
-0.1015532389,
0.2245675623,
-0.017417049,
-0.5912734866,
-0.191189751,
-0.1476968229,
-0.1822946966,
0.0231224205,
0.3857880831,
-0.0950036719,
0.0945369899,
0.3551775515,
0.0046204831,
0.3829398155,
0.4148259461,
-0.0892627165,
0.4286884367,
0.2437386811,
0.1762364805,
-0.2389474958,
0.0422133692,
0.2801201046,
-0.1266855747,
0.7274700999,
0.5258175731,
-0.190026328,
-0.3262990117,
-0.7424345016,
-0.2048185319,
-0.3648774326,
0.2021624595,
-0.5647033453,
-0.8695270419,
0.8404256701,
0.2098374218,
-0.3841682374,
0.6912152171,
0.531216085,
0.2731907368,
0.6377361417,
0.5688346028,
-0.3373621702,
0.606197238,
-0.1282634139,
0.6619587541,
-0.5355914831,
-0.1322384179,
-0.5205541849,
-0.2234438062,
-1.1012762785,
-0.1547220498,
-0.194303602,
-0.3412594199,
-0.4979418218,
0.1868988127,
-0.328004837,
0.5544313192,
0.2205787152,
-0.0819600299,
-0.006274878,
0.1201146021,
-0.0524802469,
-0.4097910821,
-0.4470258355,
-0.3521495461,
1.1944102049,
0.1358594894,
0.7273169756,
0.1024701595,
0.8287248611,
0.2929977477,
0.734877944,
-0.8691340685,
0.1938015819,
-0.2806744874,
-0.848159492,
-0.1846658736,
-0.4458957314,
-0.7947941422,
0.0938972458,
-0.0567397363,
-0.9430084229,
0.2299947143,
0.0477043688,
-0.157014966,
0.5253677964,
-0.5436781645,
0.6852710843,
-0.3126764297,
-0.5079041719,
0.2502778769,
-0.5339235663,
0.6088865995,
-0.2730535567,
0.2166179866,
-0.2070868313,
0.177236706,
0.9066402912,
-0.295049727,
0.8191266656,
-0.4012435675,
-0.1822833568,
0.0871215016,
0.015116333,
-0.1140438095,
-0.0073326062,
-0.4604341984,
0.5239013433,
-0.4334676564,
-0.4125985205,
-0.2152636498,
0.9135522246,
-0.954217732,
-0.6392096281,
-0.1960555464,
-0.4418591857,
-0.2740685642,
0.2083763629,
0.4577017725,
0.1274558604,
-0.2838177085,
-0.0597262457,
0.5441298485,
-0.4690462053,
0.2881154716,
0.8074164391,
-0.1897150576,
-0.0516424999,
0.7626463175,
0.5732198358,
-0.0516255908,
0.4301386178,
0.322565794,
-0.3270608783,
-0.1224611923,
-0.3095027804,
0.2008700222,
-0.4793539941,
-0.0506378189,
-0.7545807362,
-0.0526599288,
-0.4199100733,
-0.0811678842,
-0.3219116032,
-0.4545910656,
-0.052894935,
-0.0477714352,
0.4156087637,
0.8373839855,
0.2424705029,
0.5653190613,
-0.2031093389,
0.4238651693,
0.0954291224,
0.6786325574,
-0.2298508584,
-0.7030149698,
-0.1041246653,
-0.0410500988,
-0.1349751204,
-1.142863512,
0.4032669663,
-0.0655023083,
0.3911806345,
0.531722188,
0.4860035181,
0.3210465312,
-0.1755438745,
0.9860473871,
0.0116524277,
-0.9786022305,
0.5710555315,
-0.2855957448,
0.3843458891,
0.572355926,
0.8936875463,
-0.6287680864,
-0.8176288605,
-0.9153730273,
-0.8115168214,
0.9453858733,
0.0162639786,
0.2604459822,
-0.1371920258,
0.2542722225,
0.4748555124,
0.3865048289,
-0.6995543242,
-0.5432317853,
-0.2502240539,
-0.1831577867,
-0.23781012,
-0.4845532179,
0.183006078,
-0.0371958353,
0.7982382178,
0.2776739597,
-0.0271203388,
0.2822033465,
-0.386847645,
-0.3270022571,
0.3507522643,
0.4474781156,
0.5490829945,
-0.3314077258,
0.1276023537,
0.0810276717,
-0.4034435153,
0.2141436189,
0.0654534325,
-0.3170252442,
0.1852819175,
0.0414165519,
0.8745372891,
-0.182162255,
-0.3169214427,
0.4567347467,
-0.0821415111,
-0.0229488481,
-0.3883264661,
-0.284144789,
-0.0576995648,
0.0517296642,
0.4504013062,
-0.0119050583,
0.2455194294,
-0.5770560503,
0.0330782011,
0.3821264505,
-0.398209095,
-0.7628350258,
0.6175217628,
0.2825959921,
-0.438742131,
0.1522353292,
-0.3784671426,
-1.1619297266,
0.7558897734,
0.1848672628,
1.050106883,
-0.6382887959,
0.3910469413,
0.3615915477,
0.3353153467,
0.0141228428,
0.4889502227,
0.0663054585,
-1.111390233,
-0.1238622218,
-0.5600870848,
-0.5039525032,
0.3443268836,
-0.5361451507,
0.3489937484,
-0.3207097352,
-0.410225302,
0.0969732851,
0.1941748857,
-1.0962828398,
0.5308859944,
0.4927655756,
0.6652854681,
-1.4507658482,
0.7972655892,
0.9621495008,
-0.3331654668,
-0.6582538486,
0.4476746619,
0.1420044899,
-0.4416555166,
0.8972221017,
0.5018939972,
0.0349161141,
-0.2391538471,
-0.3204223812,
-0.8183813691,
0.1972096562,
0.4254502356,
-0.3948619068,
0.3952602148,
0.5202220678,
0.6866983175,
-0.393849045,
0.5941075683,
0.819165349,
0.5608225465,
-0.2099333107,
-0.7865428329,
0.0550360829,
-0.2024623752,
-0.1820051819,
0.1591159701,
-0.9580442309,
0.8997057676,
-0.0121948663,
-0.0078129023,
-0.635394454,
0.1094750613,
0.0144462185,
0.3370498419,
0.4011926055,
0.4299102128,
0.5405124426,
-0.2344442755,
0.8834713697,
-0.4850296974,
0.2555444241,
0.9884214401,
-0.3062069714,
0.4424779713,
0.6996249557,
-0.2871678174,
0.6479055285,
0.6209035516,
0.0503018424,
0.4254803956,
0.508159399,
-0.1566500962,
0.1157435402,
-0.4005989432,
-0.0441265628,
0.5409933329,
0.32854864,
-0.565897584,
-0.2436494082,
0.3049394488,
0.4399272799,
-0.1207754686,
-0.333858937,
0.353366226,
0.0644199848,
-0.7980569601,
0.2460068911,
-0.1261052936,
1.0623033047,
-0.268930763,
0.352989018,
-0.4907742739,
-0.0526226573,
-0.6593059301,
-0.6980264783,
0.3289153874,
0.3286710083,
-0.2935891151,
-0.2378170937,
0.4964590073,
-0.6312761307,
-0.3942651451,
0.5582657456,
0.4252393246,
0.4266617596,
-0.2776125669,
-0.5313242078,
0.0953787938,
0.2300750017,
-0.6419516802,
0.2418952584,
0.4568668008,
-0.3746016622,
0.3379771709,
-0.0096048508,
0.2609014213,
0.0940792263,
0.42404145,
0.6076899767,
-0.702398181,
-0.3341447711,
-0.9005265236,
0.500875175,
0.0116025982,
-0.340319097,
0.8413456678,
0.5806581974,
1.0700416565,
-0.0737428814,
1.1579248905,
-0.1736717522,
0.6206198335,
-0.0631738752,
0.9047037363,
-0.516158402,
-0.0066431663,
-0.2921489775,
-0.876951158,
-0.5369883776,
0.2970136106,
-1.0392429829,
0.1529788375,
0.574757576,
0.6595378518,
-0.0382377543,
-0.0775084645,
0.3013530374,
0.4875394106,
0.0965402648,
0.0728476718,
0.6148082614,
-0.3800789416,
0.075444825,
-0.5809511542,
-0.0104057407,
-0.2185984999,
-0.798425138,
-1.1600116491,
-0.2943584025,
-0.6812420487,
-0.3690649867,
0.1912396997,
1.0090088844,
0.2937140465,
-1.254355669,
-0.1268799603,
0.242595315,
0.3600962758,
0.5868167281,
-0.3257690668,
0.433480531,
-0.2880060971,
-0.8943751454,
-0.1191175506,
-0.0396391712,
-0.0945297703,
-0.0959223285,
0.1900317818,
0.0295312386,
0.235425964,
0.5396586061,
0.2525950968,
-0.9937414527,
-0.4025424123,
-0.3956204951,
0.0561553277,
-0.0252970047,
0.6488740444,
-0.7361278534,
0.6270962954,
0.4001884162,
0.1519250572,
0.2318722755,
0.3385191858,
0.2939967215,
-0.7031677961,
0.3476220071,
0.1581423432,
0.2973172367,
0.5701021552,
-0.4121566713,
0.2773957253,
0.1341774911,
-0.3370425701,
-0.7642025948,
0.1814032793,
-0.5820405483,
-0.1275595874,
1.299167037,
-0.2089164257,
-0.1629258245,
-0.0271988213,
-0.0366058275,
0.5044828653,
-0.5902234316,
1.2272729874,
0.6839811206,
-0.0228721276,
-0.0198155195,
-0.4964601398,
0.7211517692,
0.5172941089,
-0.4758193195,
-0.1157548055,
0.1328348964,
0.4856614769,
-0.0423698351,
0.4001255035,
-0.0132805631,
-0.1260493249,
-0.2692803442,
0.6263807416,
0.3436643183,
-0.0611874759,
-0.4974390864,
0.0101181325,
-0.0130103379,
0.0607680082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01824v1 | Empathic Grounding: Explorations using Multimodal Interaction and Large Language Models with Conversational Agents | 2024-07-01T21:46:30 | 2024-07-01T21:46:30 | Mehdi Arjmand, Farnaz Nouraei, Ian Steenstra, Timothy Bickmore | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.RO | We introduce the concept of "empathic grounding" in conversational agents as
an extension of Clark's conceptualization of grounding in conversation in which
the grounding criterion includes listener empathy for the speaker's affective
state. Empathic grounding is generally required whenever the speaker's emotions
are foregrounded and can make the grounding process more efficient and reliable
by communicating both propositional and affective understanding. Both speaker
expressions of affect and listener empathic grounding can be multimodal,
including facial expressions and other nonverbal displays. Thus, models of
empathic grounding for embodied agents should be multimodal to facilitate
natural and efficient communication. We describe a multimodal model that takes
as input user speech and facial expression to generate multimodal grounding
moves for a listening agent using a large language model. We also describe a
testbed to evaluate approaches to empathic grounding, in which a humanoid robot
interviews a user about a past episode of pain and then has the user rate their
perception of the robot's empathy. We compare our proposed model to one that
only generates non-affective grounding cues in a between-subjects experiment.
Findings demonstrate that empathic grounding increases user perceptions of
empathy, understanding, emotional intelligence, and trust. Our work highlights
the role of emotion awareness and multimodality in generating appropriate
grounding moves for conversational agents. | [
-0.3134334385,
-1.1434617043,
0.7877365947,
0.2518850863,
-0.061431434,
0.0371049047,
-0.0583574064,
-0.3076306581,
0.5262847543,
0.2510436177,
-0.2336410731,
-0.4142538011,
-0.5819892287,
-0.1292862445,
0.0608786047,
0.6228163838,
0.2080555856,
0.1864682138,
-0.2236637324,
-0.3401901722,
-0.6435474753,
-0.8669469357,
-0.4667657614,
-0.5854445696,
0.3110723197,
0.4055202007,
0.9173278809,
0.1217131317,
0.3574282825,
0.38285622,
-0.1243817434,
0.0458669662,
-0.2110462189,
0.3720742166,
-0.1790239662,
-0.3051545322,
-0.4605634809,
0.2924468517,
0.2139112651,
0.4880043864,
-0.0844971463,
-0.3234033287,
-0.4446651638,
0.2492070943,
-0.5818377733,
-0.0030928846,
0.023286378,
0.4634573162,
0.6683821082,
-0.713298142,
-0.4831626415,
-0.0794482157,
-0.021676911,
-0.2321522683,
-0.1193594411,
0.0324587449,
0.4515099227,
0.2692910135,
-0.7239947915,
-0.152820304,
-0.5339874029,
0.4469569921,
-0.3051275611,
0.5852706432,
0.582624197,
0.0812415704,
0.2851212025,
-0.2647227347,
-0.5460581183,
-0.7765881419,
-0.1253508627,
0.2380206436,
-0.259103179,
0.4974259138,
0.5695616603,
0.2929941714,
-0.156979546,
-0.3166356981,
0.1049505547,
0.097409308,
0.1871731281,
0.0772022009,
0.6321117282,
-0.095440194,
-0.4280071855,
-0.2103664279,
-0.4342350066,
0.1809726357,
0.20041354,
0.2271201164,
-0.4766401947,
0.7210890055,
0.1190176532,
0.7253996134,
0.3136447668,
-0.2259370387,
0.3171674907,
0.0673271567,
-0.245056048,
0.2055040151,
0.2284061164,
1.0190411806,
0.1818811595,
-0.2624358237,
0.146245867,
0.3320504725,
0.4916006625,
-0.7106422186,
0.0264331531,
0.5643292665,
-0.7416397333,
-0.3971191049,
-0.0512465723,
-0.8309816718,
-0.7983946204,
-0.5571020246,
0.2156610489,
-0.5583969355,
-0.6952402592,
-0.1413251311,
-0.6016514301,
0.2787057459,
0.1879674792,
-0.8330456614,
0.5507733226,
0.4738402367,
0.9015974402,
0.5334305167,
-0.508417666,
-0.642065227,
0.1243066117,
-0.2066115588,
0.6615421772,
-1.067555666,
-0.3581137359,
-0.0794819593,
0.2017877102,
0.0231014024,
-0.1634173095,
0.4716289937,
0.0131565332,
-0.1981429607,
-0.3105499148,
-0.0446657836,
-0.2626788616,
0.8248292804,
-0.3762280643,
0.5138917565,
0.2461932003,
-0.4901449382,
0.1221053302,
-0.6989921927,
-0.387088269,
-0.4504267871,
-0.1333516091,
0.205671519,
0.4331030548,
0.0808162466,
0.5254104137,
-0.2736313641,
0.1511048824,
-0.3159245849,
-0.0227720551,
0.2418431193,
-0.1787868738,
0.3420825899,
0.1223424822,
-0.4804772437,
0.0368477926,
-0.5934433341,
0.1032410786,
0.0335154533,
0.1594952494,
-0.5116147995,
-0.0551499464,
0.208563894,
0.4927862585,
-0.1859687865,
-0.6393899918,
-0.171765551,
-0.2765241265,
0.4310680926,
0.5260571837,
0.0217149779,
0.5808643699,
-0.6434704661,
0.3949500322,
0.0880205631,
0.1311028153,
-0.7947708368,
-0.3460948765,
-0.7763829231,
-0.1761059165,
-0.346988827,
0.5475292802,
-0.2204208076,
0.4635365009,
0.0222757682,
-0.678030014,
-0.4383132756,
-0.2738884687,
0.6622008681,
0.366692543,
0.4769812822,
-0.269718051,
-0.2534281313,
-0.7352075577,
-0.2605432272,
-0.1809442192,
0.2576723397,
0.7954317927,
0.1337506175,
-0.5670697093,
0.789065063,
-0.2048639208,
-0.2205117941,
-0.0759847239,
0.3956876099,
-0.0931419358,
0.7642151117,
0.466062516,
-1.2185891867,
-0.3028217852,
0.2665432692,
-1.0324126482,
0.1121027842,
-0.2490444481,
-0.0302254464,
-0.0803082138,
0.5138335824,
-1.0738784075,
0.387909323,
0.7159966826,
-0.7914066911,
-0.1191883385,
-0.388335377,
0.815105021,
-0.8665050268,
-0.0154317887,
-0.0426326841,
-0.0927961245,
-1.0141371489,
0.2661991715,
-0.1169659719,
-0.4637103081,
-0.4999626875,
0.5164536238,
-0.6031526923,
-0.00204783,
-0.2823777497,
0.2172826082,
0.1896336973,
0.3952746391,
0.3678891659,
0.1866140813,
0.7868936658,
-0.498881042,
0.7469395399,
0.352527678,
0.5826826692,
1.006801486,
-0.7297598124,
0.4713877141,
-0.2534160316,
0.307813853,
-0.9316886663,
-0.0282880198,
0.4140428007,
-0.6864922643,
0.2234594375,
-0.2089965791,
-0.2294101864,
-0.0836125761,
-0.232573092,
0.4616242945,
0.4609800875,
-0.5784426928,
1.2576485872,
0.3392510116,
-0.0712965727,
-0.1411059201,
-0.5651647449,
0.4905072451,
-0.4474906623,
-0.8930503726,
0.0964835137,
-0.1962516755,
-0.6934354305,
-0.3384454548,
0.1453090757,
-0.1022105217,
0.0958012044,
0.5119870901,
-0.3586242795,
0.1774207652,
0.3446989059,
0.083616063,
-0.3328076005,
0.2722854316,
0.3327097893,
0.7469840646,
-0.3108154237,
-0.6878699064,
-0.4929590523,
0.5856143236,
0.7931771874,
-0.1451489776,
0.6938646436,
0.4487346709,
-0.4744414687,
0.3796859384,
-0.8423460722,
-0.4923734963,
-0.3831848502,
-0.2141779214,
-0.6310853958,
-0.4687591493,
0.5101748705,
-0.3265229166,
-0.4566711783,
-0.094247289,
0.6911568046,
0.1442198902,
1.2262922525,
0.5560073853,
-0.0401855521,
0.3355530798,
0.0814770386,
0.5144455433,
-0.8052650094,
-0.3316167593,
-0.3673962057,
-0.1191273555,
-0.6186844707,
-0.4992406666,
0.021138072,
-0.1666084677,
-0.1805857718,
-0.1591017991,
-0.3613350093,
0.3083132505,
0.5011422038,
0.5482863188,
0.0079337927,
-0.1479643583,
0.129843235,
0.0570647083,
-0.1724484265,
-0.5954491496,
0.7685466409,
0.5072154403,
0.8710317016,
0.3070100248,
0.4848017097,
0.4349404275,
0.3009645641,
-0.8368417025,
0.180023849,
0.4928277731,
-0.3801759183,
-0.173313424,
-0.0521084405,
-0.611645937,
0.5658761859,
-0.2368777394,
-0.6350135803,
0.2846047878,
0.3581293821,
-0.2159266174,
0.1604912132,
-0.847055912,
0.6867954731,
-0.2505019605,
-0.524689734,
-0.4237940013,
-1.0657542944,
-0.0229003727,
0.3838981092,
0.372489512,
0.008217318,
0.275313288,
0.2660820782,
0.0055344384,
1.106967926,
-0.7103800774,
-0.1545485258,
0.1047733128,
0.1923406422,
0.5167075992,
0.1915515214,
0.1442167461,
0.1211665645,
-0.197821781,
-0.3134254217,
-0.8138353229,
0.5208353996,
-0.7371410728,
-0.6678275466,
-0.5812818408,
-0.4339917302,
-0.2952890992,
0.0110477656,
-0.1504218876,
0.3520049155,
-0.5962999463,
0.2336862534,
0.5867988467,
-0.4457599223,
0.1267515868,
0.5608757734,
0.1995117962,
-0.4781645238,
0.7335283756,
-0.5535595417,
0.3318801224,
0.5713732839,
0.5062639713,
0.0151939141,
0.1637958437,
-0.0665265098,
0.253459841,
-0.7604939342,
-0.0230176933,
-0.9971551895,
0.1705123186,
-0.726272881,
-0.5647547245,
-0.3396753073,
-0.1897964925,
-0.0103694648,
-0.5645212531,
0.4180409312,
0.49919945,
-0.4814391136,
0.416564405,
-0.9568892717,
0.6252126694,
0.4155726433,
-0.0141133731,
-0.1244343743,
-0.2256976068,
0.0993254334,
0.4285062551,
-0.4425644279,
-0.9296714664,
0.5315446854,
0.0059867701,
0.4317733049,
0.6376438737,
0.027789453,
0.7150179148,
-0.5567756295,
0.7795366049,
0.5830886364,
-1.2966146469,
0.7044622898,
-0.5776581764,
-0.2173245847,
0.1477758139,
0.2114504427,
-0.9853894114,
-0.3869969845,
-0.7732250094,
-0.6661548018,
0.4667748213,
0.1206972599,
0.6991719007,
-0.2865423858,
0.0257947892,
-0.1343347728,
0.3329479992,
-0.7924520373,
-0.2056224942,
-0.4363391697,
0.1464027315,
-0.5602303743,
-0.6146967411,
-0.8092675209,
-0.1568069756,
-0.1542671323,
-0.1379909813,
0.71484828,
0.27657336,
-0.3492543101,
-0.3864242733,
0.1425158978,
0.7883222699,
0.4371092618,
-0.3510370851,
0.4669030905,
0.0990580246,
0.0154711539,
0.2199336886,
-0.0923890397,
0.6217141151,
-0.0686703324,
0.3990365565,
0.6763240099,
0.3442364931,
-0.746607244,
0.7321523428,
0.0558126532,
0.0181683898,
-0.3529925346,
-0.3740676939,
-0.0306783263,
0.6676939726,
-0.0561170094,
0.008853103,
0.2327032685,
-0.8629567623,
0.1407778114,
0.2242386639,
-0.5079755783,
-0.4932115376,
0.3357460797,
0.3159682453,
-0.5982726812,
0.6280404925,
0.2932682633,
-0.7222745419,
0.6561188102,
0.7583492994,
0.8504026532,
-0.6210837364,
0.2831889093,
0.0393686593,
0.3590060771,
0.1389925927,
0.3233329356,
-0.3968857527,
-0.9976566434,
0.3623072505,
0.0586164817,
-0.7599156499,
-0.6830249429,
-0.8477349877,
0.0521715581,
-0.334363699,
-0.2492974997,
-0.4542134702,
-0.4278467894,
-0.6054244637,
0.458768636,
0.2057462037,
0.6052702069,
-1.3931447268,
0.2409336269,
0.8336727619,
-0.4469074309,
-0.4126086235,
-0.0838152245,
-0.0411382467,
-0.7726404071,
0.8610261679,
0.4773375392,
-0.266251564,
-0.1017242,
-0.4121884704,
-0.6196116209,
1.1173493862,
0.2297497392,
0.2045411468,
0.1338262111,
-0.1366673261,
0.552380085,
-0.5592360497,
0.8470128775,
0.3776971102,
0.7085722089,
-0.0110710468,
-0.7955030203,
0.3334486783,
-0.6895663142,
-0.3192002773,
0.0311594009,
-1.0668985844,
1.1230480671,
-0.1769194901,
0.0832556337,
-0.0115192849,
0.1237977073,
0.3170243204,
0.7003866434,
0.5654887557,
0.6931607723,
0.6417052746,
0.0346034802,
1.0611722469,
-0.6397781968,
0.1072740406,
0.6886827946,
-0.4800948203,
0.4740089178,
0.6152411699,
0.3451080322,
0.3735830188,
0.3574891686,
0.0789991543,
0.3296341598,
0.0872736946,
-0.2725489736,
-0.3705991507,
-0.5603555441,
-0.5920402408,
0.6995491982,
0.1910400838,
-0.5364721417,
-0.0110593177,
0.3754431009,
0.0293833744,
0.0142398728,
-0.0725354403,
0.7250813246,
0.1585823298,
-0.5124357343,
0.2748002708,
0.0697293878,
0.1956419349,
-0.3170118332,
-0.4705203176,
-0.259696573,
-0.1008568034,
-0.1788482219,
-0.3485003412,
0.0361244604,
-0.2118826509,
-0.2236187607,
-0.8850186467,
0.7905936837,
-0.0951960385,
0.04784327,
0.8397893906,
0.6620748639,
0.4854885936,
-0.1888757795,
-0.4070723355,
0.0238997191,
-0.4756017029,
-0.5206382871,
0.3735381067,
0.5821164846,
0.3232418895,
0.8167934418,
0.77799505,
-0.0810100734,
-0.1892935336,
0.3412277102,
1.1742058992,
-1.0258756876,
-0.3931573331,
-0.881246984,
0.7610993981,
-0.0708708093,
-0.0814453214,
0.734860599,
0.1656302363,
0.1475082636,
-0.0896134675,
0.5406299233,
-0.3817149699,
0.2510105669,
-0.5766980648,
0.3454476297,
-0.5600068569,
-0.5504340529,
-0.6396550536,
-0.8040745854,
-0.2073339075,
1.1088716984,
-0.0532481521,
0.3177826405,
0.8976324201,
0.748678267,
0.124180451,
0.1004740894,
0.8248401284,
0.2026019543,
0.351177454,
0.3213951588,
1.2790014744,
-0.1232999712,
-0.2163130641,
-0.2011491805,
-0.4679923654,
-0.0100222277,
-0.8104969263,
-1.1490588188,
-0.3150619268,
0.0220442228,
-0.4882852435,
-0.0062190769,
1.3234838247,
0.7085325122,
-0.3748751879,
-0.1415138096,
-0.0510421507,
-0.0537154265,
-0.210397765,
-0.1908814609,
0.1015315205,
-0.2805383503,
-0.7659265399,
0.543933928,
0.3548003435,
0.0562007576,
0.010956008,
-0.2886508703,
-0.1398590058,
-0.0801829845,
0.857436657,
0.1837513149,
-0.6306573153,
-0.4442030191,
0.0257305745,
0.2090576142,
0.167570889,
1.0678315163,
-0.5195575953,
0.5216567516,
0.0172223728,
0.4235168397,
0.0596058965,
0.5157952905,
0.6918920279,
-0.3609571755,
0.6049035192,
0.3384772241,
0.2819389701,
0.2233437449,
-0.6467516422,
0.4028636515,
0.2659816444,
-0.482434392,
-0.8968641758,
0.2075465322,
-1.0683715343,
0.0452181511,
1.4098305702,
-0.2422144115,
0.1194865853,
0.0490278453,
-0.6465938091,
0.2453336567,
-0.4183960259,
0.6857036948,
0.6234453321,
-0.200191766,
-0.5201647282,
-0.1435776353,
-0.0319436044,
0.3284330964,
-0.7422969341,
0.068378441,
0.640822947,
-0.1331733018,
0.5036969781,
0.6543603539,
0.3884943128,
0.2125564367,
0.395011723,
0.3617064953,
-0.0270699114,
-0.4748231471,
-0.3626827002,
0.2068201602,
0.0773098543,
0.0335842334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01817v1 | Race and Privacy in Broadcast Police Communications | 2024-07-01T21:34:51 | 2024-07-01T21:34:51 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Christopher Graziul, Miranda Ardith Goodman, Samantha Nicole Kenny, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Radios are essential for the operations of modern police departments, and
they function as both a collaborative communication technology and a
sociotechnical system. However, little prior research has examined their usage
or their connections to individual privacy and the role of race in policing,
two growing topics of concern in the US. As a case study, we examine the
Chicago Police Department's (CPD's) use of broadcast police communications
(BPC) to coordinate the activity of law enforcement officers (LEOs) in the
city. From a recently assembled archive of 80,775 hours of BPC associated with
CPD operations, we analyze text transcripts of radio transmissions broadcast
9:00 AM to 5:00 PM on August 10th, 2018 in one majority Black, one majority
white, and one majority Hispanic area of the city (24 hours of audio) to
explore three research questions: (1) Do BPC reflect reported racial
disparities in policing? (2) How and when is gender, race/ethnicity, and age
mentioned in BPC? (3) To what extent do BPC include sensitive information, and
who is put at most risk by this practice? (4) To what extent can large language
models (LLMs) heighten this risk? We explore the vocabulary and speech acts
used by police in BPC, comparing mentions of personal characteristics to local
demographics, the personal information shared over BPC, and the privacy
concerns that it poses. Analysis indicates (a) policing professionals in the
city of Chicago exhibit disproportionate attention to Black members of the
public regardless of context, (b) sociodemographic characteristics like gender,
race/ethnicity, and age are primarily mentioned in BPC about event information,
and (c) disproportionate attention introduces disproportionate privacy risks
for Black members of the public. | [
-0.6108342409,
-0.3003611565,
0.5790540576,
0.4410417378,
0.0088679967,
0.3631094992,
-0.0908041969,
-1.0687561035,
0.2751211524,
0.148200497,
-0.2812846005,
-0.3662403226,
-0.7606737018,
0.024156699,
-0.2534257174,
0.8547840714,
0.2615764141,
0.2268274277,
0.3930120468,
-0.2023380399,
-0.1397771835,
-0.8789863586,
-0.5822187662,
-0.0284206141,
0.4949008822,
0.0729452074,
0.7082921863,
0.5610172153,
0.4339914918,
0.2407189608,
-0.3964711726,
-0.2773263454,
-0.6187095642,
-0.0681806356,
-0.3276863992,
0.03415576,
-0.2277319729,
0.283655107,
0.3245747089,
0.9564678669,
0.1565774381,
0.2426504046,
-0.1824882776,
0.6531316042,
-1.0208477974,
-0.0789886639,
-0.0747657567,
-0.1357854754,
-0.3234364092,
-0.3350239098,
-0.0565900095,
-0.6400995851,
0.1384723186,
-0.315726608,
0.3445094228,
-0.0273556188,
0.3732326031,
-0.131671682,
-0.629316926,
-0.4088612199,
-1.2997837067,
0.394728899,
-0.2240957022,
0.2437207252,
0.8857111335,
0.0246792901,
0.1350347847,
-0.2020525336,
-0.6485265493,
-0.0369929969,
-0.1160025597,
0.3929293454,
-0.0950414762,
0.0392235518,
0.5226101875,
0.4064357281,
-0.1442354023,
-0.1031302437,
-1.0388759375,
0.1100897118,
1.0264059305,
0.4559172392,
-0.197292015,
0.0690727755,
0.0629236177,
-0.0371047594,
-0.5182681084,
0.080925785,
0.9241474271,
-0.0137904966,
-0.4416387379,
0.5470808148,
-0.2530881763,
0.3828735352,
-0.1535914093,
-0.0549697839,
0.2118237764,
-0.3290208876,
0.0987512171,
0.4095523953,
0.706956923,
0.5914000869,
0.4561657608,
0.0505730063,
0.1160538495,
-0.1078599095,
0.3363492787,
-0.3256350756,
-0.0713624507,
0.2654606998,
-0.3804119825,
-0.2809623182,
0.2569881082,
-0.5411808491,
-0.5002376437,
-0.2818500698,
-0.1441661566,
-0.1015896574,
-0.4043960869,
-0.0346125774,
-0.0365743004,
0.2571300566,
0.151092425,
-1.2384949923,
0.1814829111,
0.5751909018,
0.7031235695,
0.1574651748,
0.0496274047,
0.2173785269,
0.4078875184,
-0.4043166339,
0.1938905418,
-0.3802411854,
-0.7164620757,
0.1322509944,
0.0331743062,
0.2743603289,
-0.4773104191,
0.07923311,
-0.4136312902,
-0.0251728296,
-0.2172047049,
-0.2806474566,
0.1830974072,
-0.3723183274,
-0.1780627966,
1.0162291527,
0.0323138051,
-1.0275855064,
0.3553479016,
-0.4038426578,
-0.6519319415,
0.0512104593,
-0.0059352294,
-0.3880727589,
0.3351083994,
-0.026443135,
0.4346792102,
0.4371697903,
-0.045698408,
-0.573951602,
-0.6701934338,
0.4466522038,
0.051082857,
0.9480499625,
0.5780991316,
-0.5468214154,
-0.3855940402,
-0.6342387795,
-0.4486422241,
0.1422273368,
-0.2362780422,
-0.5758159757,
0.1898481101,
-0.164255172,
-0.1001888141,
-0.1618915349,
-0.9097626805,
-0.4141138196,
0.1001496762,
0.2672763467,
0.5484185219,
-0.0469935723,
0.527582407,
-0.321336329,
0.4606256187,
-0.25292328,
0.5801193714,
0.0467544086,
-0.5202803016,
-0.2275013924,
-0.3064295352,
0.080818899,
0.3939943314,
0.1470337063,
0.6541948318,
0.0087183984,
-0.3739684224,
-0.4983793199,
-0.4491461813,
-0.1053754389,
0.148429513,
-0.169394955,
-0.2817512751,
-0.3877156973,
-0.7884809971,
0.1479337364,
-0.215114966,
0.3132587969,
0.362320751,
0.3460630774,
0.176742956,
0.7396376133,
-0.3098196685,
0.0226337649,
-0.222771734,
0.0713416189,
0.0149007933,
0.2894755006,
0.5380752087,
-0.5855236053,
-0.5460941792,
-0.3666178286,
-0.319855243,
-0.2888277173,
0.0431289263,
0.0243718643,
-0.2837686837,
0.675298214,
0.1268637329,
0.8962685466,
0.8411768675,
-0.2703486681,
0.5544036627,
-0.0039632516,
0.2880797386,
-0.6744043827,
-0.042934034,
-0.1934116185,
-0.4932107925,
-0.8598148823,
-0.2389908582,
-0.2524250746,
-0.3006432652,
-0.4603922665,
0.2951662838,
-0.42701298,
-0.5502251387,
-0.4649274647,
0.0319525227,
-0.3899246454,
0.0375149772,
0.2920721471,
0.5144013166,
0.5061360002,
-0.6739009619,
0.1122819185,
0.057111185,
-0.7545522451,
0.1746663153,
-0.27708143,
0.2847442031,
-0.4659130871,
0.1744175255,
-0.8414077163,
-0.024168795,
0.332667172,
-0.613325119,
-0.0221337676,
-0.1297160983,
-0.4836708307,
-0.2293775827,
-0.0825440288,
0.6512649059,
0.1837780774,
-0.0088353697,
-0.0408144854,
0.9285855293,
-0.5315032601,
-0.4822035134,
-0.7973132133,
-0.2114485055,
0.1184365377,
-0.5258399844,
-0.0611150861,
-0.0329286791,
-0.5157676935,
-0.0226955712,
-0.1228951737,
-0.2880176604,
0.4615719616,
0.4915064275,
0.05637867,
0.0624017008,
-0.0999778584,
-0.2563538551,
0.4077232778,
0.121185191,
0.4121748507,
0.5568605065,
0.276062429,
-0.1740052402,
-0.441758275,
1.00182724,
0.2874901593,
-0.2290790975,
1.0651597977,
0.3803846836,
-0.187137261,
0.3242264092,
-0.4825853705,
-0.2770735919,
-0.359357655,
0.0714757964,
0.1515119672,
-1.0813179016,
0.5399387479,
0.2797298133,
-0.0457598828,
-0.4010294676,
0.6576469541,
-0.5270697474,
0.6621496081,
0.7129198909,
0.0108578783,
1.0765080452,
-0.0768301859,
0.4704989791,
-0.5979038477,
-0.4096938074,
-0.6074028015,
-0.1860529184,
-0.7561548948,
-0.1334525645,
0.3452623487,
0.0304639935,
-0.177438587,
-0.04018341,
-0.484272629,
0.451843977,
0.4455730915,
-0.1282008737,
0.3766046166,
-0.0566280745,
0.353359431,
0.0368891172,
-0.4179975688,
-0.3949795961,
1.1710785627,
0.5831423402,
0.6339948177,
0.3523750901,
0.7912042737,
0.3211273253,
0.5130273104,
-0.3627541065,
0.3122396171,
0.0945358872,
-1.4757769108,
-0.2701539099,
-0.2346366346,
-0.8279731274,
0.1348133981,
-0.1811155081,
-0.84686625,
0.8959081769,
0.0691577196,
-0.3413305581,
0.1460461318,
-0.5838267803,
0.3895685077,
-0.064943336,
-0.1779363304,
-0.4157580137,
-0.6325784922,
0.527797699,
-0.1829743087,
0.6059048772,
-0.8500003815,
0.2085364312,
0.804435432,
-0.274769932,
0.5937957764,
0.0488917977,
0.1975074261,
0.3270406723,
-0.1691858172,
0.2825846374,
0.2209269255,
0.309458524,
0.3462312222,
0.0148436129,
-0.2932992876,
-0.0720853433,
0.1560792327,
-0.8036692142,
-0.4016848803,
-0.7223115563,
-0.4142482877,
-0.129293099,
-0.1025762782,
0.3253404796,
0.5806494355,
-0.0499797724,
0.0793514624,
0.4014824331,
-0.1738486588,
0.331028372,
0.7375237942,
0.0170090441,
-0.0888597742,
0.2254189849,
-0.2367012203,
0.3461946547,
0.0982775539,
0.0276712943,
-0.365004003,
-0.5763298869,
0.2199310213,
0.6630011201,
-0.416664809,
0.1909788698,
-0.6248767972,
-0.3760628104,
-0.6322949529,
-0.2099285573,
-0.4582781196,
-0.331269443,
0.0087912185,
-0.0426220968,
0.0771109909,
0.7668593526,
-0.395855993,
0.4332822561,
-0.3111884296,
0.4379571974,
0.1651649475,
0.1951892376,
-0.3061934412,
-0.3682304621,
-0.4690649807,
-0.1780993938,
-0.2822634578,
-1.0498275757,
0.04236494,
-0.5159643888,
0.2021544427,
0.0695261434,
0.3483497798,
0.3976641297,
-0.4293388724,
0.5764436722,
0.3179880083,
-0.7011184096,
0.2983641922,
-0.4990766346,
0.1646428108,
0.6149399281,
0.5095074773,
-0.7781510949,
-1.0781753063,
-0.5597513914,
-0.5349012017,
0.8460935354,
0.4963585734,
0.3505097628,
-0.1308033615,
0.112862505,
-0.4094072282,
0.2501295209,
-0.7864602208,
-0.7979188561,
-0.2765446007,
-0.0354234949,
0.0093845492,
-0.6192675829,
-0.3426959515,
-0.3824039996,
0.1522298902,
0.3912631273,
0.4481311738,
0.4947342873,
0.3771617711,
-0.046246592,
0.4804566801,
0.7823272943,
1.0347100496,
-0.5099659562,
0.0971110761,
-0.0743993521,
-0.5714206696,
0.311306864,
-0.0843693316,
-0.0886515677,
0.0067631179,
0.3643209934,
0.4611359835,
-0.1390070617,
-0.4028154612,
0.6504167318,
-0.0646211207,
-0.3251096904,
-0.6642631292,
-0.2673052847,
0.1177456155,
0.2037856281,
0.2589990199,
-0.0569522232,
0.0293916836,
-0.9814783335,
-0.1596393883,
0.2269642949,
-0.3616808951,
-0.2233198434,
0.8014127016,
0.4107749164,
-0.0052859969,
0.3159862459,
-0.193535462,
-0.4692623615,
0.311106503,
0.1804748327,
0.5633485913,
-0.4850320816,
0.2105868608,
0.1559727788,
0.5682805181,
0.2211918384,
0.1506957412,
-0.2329873443,
-0.9204508066,
-0.4719770253,
-0.3829399943,
-0.2764940858,
0.1738636643,
-0.7513899207,
-0.1260586232,
-0.9715754986,
-0.6383902431,
0.1800905466,
0.0084176362,
-0.346624583,
0.1638411433,
0.7013183832,
0.7858572602,
-0.8987593055,
0.7432663441,
0.4464274943,
0.1270215809,
-0.6954423189,
0.0150722461,
0.0923764333,
-0.4104909301,
0.7620958686,
-0.2994558215,
-0.1309705973,
-0.5506852865,
-0.3343737423,
-0.7450488806,
0.7390416861,
0.1781327277,
-0.7122655511,
0.3902807534,
0.3008499146,
0.5433676243,
-0.423800379,
0.133461684,
0.7481757402,
0.3982638717,
0.0571491942,
-1.213370204,
-0.1335504353,
0.3384693563,
-0.0674760714,
0.1307667345,
-0.9209628105,
0.4575534761,
-0.3559367061,
-0.4104116261,
-0.2281186581,
0.3360521495,
0.1123134568,
0.576217711,
0.374481827,
0.1130695269,
0.5945004225,
-0.1234598979,
1.4212350845,
0.1900721341,
0.2043203115,
0.9941776991,
-0.3625561893,
0.2291882783,
0.1257891059,
-0.3393805325,
0.1345030218,
0.534081161,
0.0501475595,
0.8482710123,
0.1712099314,
-0.5666074753,
0.1070547551,
-0.4199549556,
-0.3017210364,
0.5342747569,
0.1172704324,
-0.3843760788,
0.1827801913,
-0.0681009516,
0.0751140192,
0.0614005327,
-0.4529787302,
0.786865294,
0.0163908601,
-0.2432574779,
0.1591460109,
0.1178634316,
0.3323260546,
-0.5925426483,
0.4535813034,
-0.3465034962,
0.0328902788,
-0.153332442,
-0.8425136209,
0.7861921191,
-0.0527925529,
-0.3566140831,
-0.1003583223,
0.1838296652,
-0.419731766,
-0.1702668965,
0.5468277335,
-0.0282731261,
0.3946186006,
-0.1987389922,
-0.3924036026,
0.4007282853,
0.1153469756,
0.1373613626,
0.2623325288,
0.0703040585,
0.041538056,
0.6375707388,
0.4577557743,
0.9771705866,
0.5408487916,
0.1619578749,
0.5316850543,
-0.7226439118,
-0.6437755227,
-0.4460758865,
0.2529319525,
-0.3604525328,
-0.3797363043,
0.5249221325,
0.7019101977,
1.0295454264,
0.2173767537,
0.8153597713,
-0.2600930035,
0.7168390155,
-0.3439422846,
0.352879703,
-0.1131605059,
0.1044430286,
-0.1651027799,
-1.0824053288,
0.0003151115,
0.6051727533,
-0.382068485,
-0.087483488,
0.7536126375,
0.8266330957,
0.0426717922,
0.4669144452,
0.3490984142,
-0.2078255415,
0.2726382017,
0.0950175896,
1.0509569645,
-0.0468044914,
0.632432282,
-0.7182856202,
-0.1135616675,
-0.2979167998,
-0.3018673062,
-0.949816525,
-0.4945178926,
-0.5048869252,
0.0154069858,
0.2372196615,
0.4796001017,
1.0607607365,
-0.7381944656,
-0.3165570498,
0.7451304793,
0.0125194909,
-0.0941416696,
-0.2529661655,
0.100874953,
0.2247887254,
-0.8446875215,
0.2268734872,
0.1909558028,
0.401168704,
0.0983597934,
0.1575259268,
0.0535740219,
-0.1447724402,
0.4296418428,
0.4855872095,
-0.2879060209,
-0.2866080999,
-0.3912910819,
-0.3475953639,
-0.1751807481,
1.2946407795,
-0.2505747974,
0.2826186121,
0.3384078741,
0.20150581,
1.0114223957,
0.3049738407,
0.5336235166,
-0.9517246485,
0.6399003267,
0.4556088746,
0.037955083,
0.2965917587,
-0.2856421769,
0.4510554075,
0.2902566791,
-0.7241019011,
-0.7040612698,
0.1983089149,
-0.931783855,
-0.4069920182,
0.9517881274,
0.1979534924,
0.1350543499,
-0.8364708424,
0.1857967526,
0.0492967777,
-0.6014585495,
0.6270413995,
0.6712613106,
-0.1597582698,
-0.3200692534,
-0.9954010248,
0.5407039523,
-0.1569273323,
-0.3314659595,
0.3395873904,
0.2602686584,
0.5366933346,
0.2094084024,
1.0183942318,
-0.2850192189,
0.3420124054,
-0.1796810925,
-0.1422546059,
-0.1744862348,
-0.1664210856,
-0.2985681593,
0.030847406,
-0.2857398391,
-0.3797307312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01796v1 | Ground Every Sentence: Improving Retrieval-Augmented LLMs with Interleaved Reference-Claim Generation | 2024-07-01T20:47:47 | 2024-07-01T20:47:47 | Sirui Xia, Xintao Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Yifei Zhang, Weikang Zhou, Jiaji Deng, Fei Yu, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has been widely adopted to enhance Large
Language Models (LLMs) in knowledge-intensive tasks. Recently, Attributed Text
Generation (ATG) has attracted growing attention, which provides citations to
support the model's responses in RAG, so as to enhance the credibility of
LLM-generated content and facilitate verification. Prior methods mainly adopt
coarse-grained attributions, linking to passage-level references or providing
paragraph-level citations. However, these methods still fall short in
verifiability and require certain time costs for fact checking. This paper
proposes a fine-grained ATG method called ReClaim(Refer & Claim), which
alternates the generation of references and answers step by step. Unlike
traditional coarse-grained attribution, ReClaim allows the model to add
sentence-level fine-grained citations to each answer sentence in long-form
question-answering tasks. Our experiments encompass various training and
inference methods and multiple LLMs, verifying the effectiveness of our
approach. | [
-0.0793116912,
-0.6993947029,
0.7970786095,
-0.1116347685,
-0.1220476255,
0.0123850554,
-0.0623672865,
-0.377240777,
0.1820081025,
0.5978384018,
-0.4103250504,
-0.1545791328,
-0.3718779981,
0.2620390952,
-0.3883987069,
0.9227201939,
-0.0009898236,
-0.3265239596,
-0.7030564547,
0.0678032115,
-0.3689410388,
-0.4107429981,
-0.4138687849,
-0.4890759289,
0.4306651056,
0.605365634,
0.3860978484,
0.6169806123,
0.4600638449,
0.2129133493,
-0.0663177669,
0.6888095737,
-0.2163239717,
0.16963844,
-0.4697101712,
-0.5005514622,
-0.3162029088,
0.0573072173,
0.6051477194,
0.5259332061,
-0.1220152825,
0.3873155117,
0.0325713195,
0.5193362236,
-1.0123056173,
-0.2380184233,
-1.2096850872,
-0.4442982972,
-0.2681834698,
-0.4904594123,
-0.662093401,
-0.5246812105,
-0.177121222,
-0.5092900991,
0.4134187996,
0.1804571301,
1.084862113,
0.1295346618,
-0.3728778064,
-0.5190557837,
-0.4050384164,
0.8380922675,
-0.6714590192,
0.0219573081,
0.5444574356,
0.0310086925,
-0.0649611428,
-0.946480453,
-0.5813887715,
-0.4955559671,
-0.3655601144,
0.0591448732,
-0.1651900858,
-0.177458629,
0.2104736567,
0.3735607862,
-0.2580720484,
-0.2054777145,
-0.1761107296,
-0.157236442,
0.5278555751,
-0.0819008425,
0.0498919785,
-0.6944487095,
-0.6584401131,
0.026864415,
-1.2410204411,
-0.0502189547,
0.1262538284,
0.4833639562,
0.2651798129,
0.7561252713,
-0.3012554944,
0.8061273098,
0.2384028137,
-0.1887284368,
0.1213563457,
-0.3719243705,
-0.1520072222,
0.1564676613,
0.5715004206,
0.2350917906,
0.1449916363,
-0.4972172678,
-0.1346494406,
-0.1768084913,
0.4719725549,
-0.7269788384,
0.1852703989,
-0.0564430766,
-0.3021258712,
-0.4440141022,
-0.1107679829,
-0.3775442541,
-0.5038523674,
-0.2119595408,
0.3637210131,
-0.4253222644,
0.0232544113,
-0.0732181892,
0.0398237891,
0.0457171313,
0.3233476877,
-0.338060528,
0.1420218498,
0.5547800064,
0.4955410063,
-0.1571754813,
-0.0475080535,
-1.0682553053,
0.5444053411,
-0.2212212831,
1.1886851788,
-0.5202224255,
-0.2647554278,
0.2960731387,
-0.1036880389,
0.1399463117,
-0.7719095945,
1.0289773941,
-0.5922088027,
0.2055581361,
-0.5342568755,
-0.5726283193,
0.0318099596,
0.6812900305,
-0.3564696014,
1.2045176029,
-0.0379501134,
-0.90936625,
0.0010848192,
-0.4060189128,
-0.4363010526,
0.0467501469,
-0.2480653226,
-0.3937805593,
0.2878041267,
0.2478746623,
0.4332761467,
-0.7197930813,
0.4767900407,
-0.228551656,
-0.0846074,
0.1215823442,
-0.3136004508,
0.5844615102,
0.3172926009,
-0.0761381164,
-0.0526746996,
-1.1507138014,
0.2227714658,
0.037505649,
-0.4599830508,
-0.5692666173,
0.2512263954,
-0.066906333,
-0.0219026245,
0.1669560969,
-0.7968201041,
0.1550066173,
-0.3428988159,
0.264600575,
0.5907233357,
0.2285163701,
0.3832228482,
-0.4820430875,
0.3086205423,
-0.0039510704,
-0.5818780661,
-0.4931302965,
0.132995829,
-0.7565012574,
-0.1093013585,
0.1654885262,
0.4736369848,
-0.881654501,
0.339176327,
-0.6513549089,
-0.1964362413,
-0.3475907743,
-0.0007580411,
0.4943973422,
0.9024974704,
0.5095793605,
0.2886514068,
-0.6139622927,
-0.7936997414,
-0.5371897221,
-0.4747161269,
-0.2804398537,
0.4934484661,
0.201211378,
-0.0774309412,
1.391082406,
-0.6972925663,
-0.055885911,
0.0465632677,
0.2018344998,
-0.1716595888,
0.3825444579,
0.435960263,
-0.5843471289,
-0.5633874536,
-0.1257493347,
-0.6194378138,
-0.4472087026,
-0.0763388649,
-0.2313966453,
0.0308832228,
0.7163031101,
-0.7078655958,
0.1756181866,
0.035984382,
-0.2689036131,
0.5364870429,
-0.0026287781,
0.3282600045,
-1.2504640818,
0.2833283544,
-0.2038968951,
-0.5825192332,
-0.2779287994,
0.3929965794,
0.2519735992,
-0.1435424238,
-0.2230696827,
0.7223864198,
-0.6023477316,
0.1382556856,
-0.4667916894,
0.443490237,
0.1244719252,
0.1283690035,
-0.2833608985,
1.0458576679,
0.1423384249,
-0.5907529593,
0.1778203994,
0.2233057022,
-0.0381899402,
0.6269761324,
-0.5052591562,
0.2431000918,
-0.4203953743,
0.4011181593,
-1.2507494688,
-0.2231540084,
-0.0533572286,
-0.419989109,
0.2095195651,
0.022458097,
-0.4799286127,
-0.1910940111,
-0.3461598158,
0.1435011774,
0.2919717431,
-0.7453485727,
0.9270223975,
0.1758566201,
-0.2769895792,
-0.6317281127,
-0.4298072159,
0.2319418639,
-0.391936034,
-0.3914979696,
0.5589815378,
0.07293199,
-0.4482574463,
-0.0327648222,
-0.3276730776,
0.0002557212,
0.0694191307,
-0.0277325492,
0.0868332684,
-0.1928366721,
0.3842076063,
-0.142809689,
-0.0457676537,
-0.0173566863,
-0.0296589453,
0.4498491883,
0.0580879077,
-0.2182655185,
0.1678552479,
0.4322460592,
0.3258360326,
-0.3603318036,
0.2839275599,
0.408814013,
-0.2843256891,
0.007237968,
-0.9180384278,
-0.0853025913,
-0.4426337481,
0.1346487254,
-0.4401535392,
-0.6767824292,
0.4568765759,
-0.2463420928,
0.2896710336,
0.5546148419,
0.3471821547,
-0.1757556349,
0.1733008921,
0.4088101089,
-0.0105183376,
0.2580671012,
0.1518289149,
0.0909588039,
-0.7368771434,
-0.0448150598,
-0.9375677109,
0.0614516884,
-0.1874305904,
-0.4378271699,
0.1808724999,
0.3903870881,
-0.171339497,
0.2135382146,
-0.3351396024,
0.5191318393,
0.479564786,
0.3192332387,
0.5887526274,
0.284663707,
0.0679172203,
-0.0865758955,
-0.447175622,
-0.6207306385,
1.0841553211,
0.0383842513,
0.7113406658,
0.0231439285,
0.8161480427,
0.3323971033,
0.5034319758,
-0.7607821226,
0.6722199917,
-0.1036620736,
-0.4599331617,
0.1260381341,
-0.2212264538,
-0.7567110062,
0.2025281936,
-0.1854947507,
-0.5877676606,
-0.1266344786,
0.2689498067,
-0.4735294282,
0.0939630866,
-0.4657042325,
0.2079933137,
0.1982600838,
-0.4233915806,
-0.3402641416,
-0.6833674908,
0.3587572277,
-0.0447753258,
0.0961990505,
0.0587771833,
0.0644967109,
0.6370728612,
-0.4820010066,
0.6753483415,
-0.1735228151,
-0.2741658688,
0.7862306237,
-0.0676276386,
1.1060447693,
0.1133056283,
-0.1031145751,
-0.4850822091,
-0.5539129972,
-0.0910744369,
-0.5703018904,
0.8139624,
-0.3756058514,
-0.7124020457,
-0.3411439061,
-0.6663412452,
-0.5332042575,
0.1435325742,
0.1532393098,
0.4175059497,
0.0041512907,
0.4963783622,
0.8479633331,
-0.1436461061,
0.6144928932,
0.6070339084,
0.0800504461,
-0.6230201125,
0.5214369297,
-0.1492832601,
0.3635049462,
0.4600764513,
0.1083551124,
-0.1802485436,
-0.3005902171,
-0.2092993408,
0.1825425774,
-0.5547024608,
-0.7971639633,
-0.9541442394,
-0.1662832946,
-0.5737286806,
-0.0726663619,
-0.3176458478,
-0.4757164717,
-0.0886215717,
-0.1167004853,
0.4808289409,
0.0989044681,
0.0979828686,
0.6204316616,
-0.7643712759,
0.6550310254,
0.1783712506,
-0.0557891987,
-0.0613133684,
-0.5178756118,
-0.249167785,
0.1540011317,
-0.5644037724,
-0.6187855601,
-0.1125491709,
0.2515309155,
0.4139865339,
-0.0066648195,
0.2490524054,
1.162504077,
-1.021363616,
0.8786695004,
0.2467223406,
-0.6382956505,
0.4207890928,
-0.2790585756,
0.1218720973,
0.5242035389,
0.1248135939,
-0.1871602237,
-0.3205724955,
-0.9271265864,
-1.0510655642,
0.47466892,
0.1690181792,
0.140717864,
-0.2686495483,
0.6266023517,
-0.0775187314,
0.2108771354,
-0.7957345843,
-0.3133063614,
0.1733230352,
-0.1964445561,
0.1684988737,
-0.5666589737,
-0.2713826299,
0.1073654443,
0.863938272,
-0.2275226563,
0.2531796098,
0.3433826566,
-0.2625874579,
-0.1727621257,
0.4892861247,
0.3595686257,
0.6011056304,
-0.0027909996,
0.2586756349,
0.0301487967,
-0.221368596,
0.2237830013,
0.1885834038,
-0.3767238855,
0.2996717393,
0.3408597112,
0.4675729275,
0.1293977052,
-0.6304510236,
0.4191206098,
0.3833076954,
-0.0925620124,
-0.3355967104,
-0.0974467248,
-0.0136234155,
0.2009397149,
0.7969114184,
0.1019115001,
0.0795930251,
-0.5432367921,
0.4912239313,
0.5413047075,
-0.0726070032,
0.0682981983,
0.7010108829,
0.0381888933,
-0.0927856863,
0.3499825299,
0.0525962226,
-0.2548848093,
0.2399560213,
0.8872851133,
0.9318650961,
0.0296309013,
0.1767726243,
0.5026134849,
0.048925288,
-0.0740770996,
-0.0152299274,
-0.0948829278,
-0.630541563,
-0.6784625053,
-0.5894876122,
-0.0785952136,
0.1500327587,
-0.6552234292,
0.1335432678,
-0.0554295368,
-0.0965889618,
-0.0692102686,
0.1074951291,
-0.2540404499,
0.2905654013,
0.1211953163,
0.9384487271,
-0.7854726911,
0.6775639057,
0.7724937201,
-0.4680528939,
-0.8736323714,
0.4682797194,
-0.3123556077,
-0.8827869296,
0.8280879855,
-0.128912285,
-0.2894302905,
0.2214367837,
-0.9339025617,
-0.9639070034,
0.9342584014,
0.5443102717,
-0.0793582872,
-0.3686982691,
-0.0935855284,
0.1739129573,
-0.3025147617,
0.1552429497,
0.2114198953,
0.202678144,
0.4580554664,
-0.8605082631,
0.2006170154,
0.0390809923,
0.2167458832,
-0.0080871033,
-0.4065425694,
0.865876317,
-0.0927260816,
-0.2212704718,
0.2915603817,
1.0666465759,
0.8238461018,
0.0180135816,
0.5987862945,
0.6567593813,
0.8439065814,
0.0301242657,
0.9400863051,
-0.160708189,
0.4305810034,
1.454630971,
-0.3066031039,
0.9052910209,
0.6744609475,
-0.1468452811,
0.5659374595,
0.2553314269,
0.2523163259,
0.656083405,
0.2514674067,
-0.3770034611,
-0.2030002028,
-0.3443053663,
-0.3332982659,
0.1843167394,
0.122092478,
-0.2982919812,
-0.8563070893,
0.1615246385,
0.3474374115,
0.4376928508,
-0.4229312837,
0.6736421585,
-0.0910114348,
-0.9961796403,
0.8348255157,
0.044294849,
0.5792255402,
-0.589661479,
-0.15152888,
-0.2480524927,
0.3727402091,
-0.1916107684,
-0.5108898878,
0.1587342322,
0.3330119848,
-0.4643929899,
-0.3563480675,
0.986893177,
-0.7351447344,
-0.3066538572,
-0.277156204,
0.3525769114,
-0.0345015302,
-0.2467018962,
-0.340153873,
-0.3157494962,
0.1816569716,
-0.357955724,
0.088217482,
0.6216437221,
-0.1171699986,
0.6361735463,
0.4961777627,
0.0908387825,
0.1196053997,
-0.0830540434,
0.9959400892,
-0.5302981734,
-0.2911193371,
-0.8876589537,
0.7539409399,
-0.3009233475,
0.1916202754,
0.9541581869,
0.7938069105,
0.5537633896,
-0.126679033,
0.8699190021,
-0.4183802009,
1.0622524023,
-0.6154897809,
0.3328552544,
-0.6426292062,
0.0473956987,
-0.385066539,
-0.7738704681,
-0.1579783559,
0.5673023462,
0.0736223236,
-0.3170978427,
0.8661484122,
0.6880228519,
-0.1395344734,
-0.3740099967,
-0.0923836008,
0.1836226583,
0.5071460605,
0.3386180699,
0.5490427613,
-0.8485212922,
0.6067425609,
0.2701919377,
0.0152036734,
-0.0136177717,
-1.0871280432,
-0.4677151442,
-0.2925485671,
-0.373836875,
-0.7806624174,
-0.0869808346,
0.9131121635,
0.1864874512,
-0.6464697719,
-0.0834881142,
-0.2035480887,
-0.2101419419,
0.1446857899,
-0.1999542266,
0.3739450574,
-0.8379430771,
-0.6592581272,
0.3965986669,
-0.2143733799,
-0.1891185045,
0.1052244976,
0.1233890578,
-0.5670518279,
-0.0037355723,
0.6760558486,
0.1491952538,
-0.7503681183,
-0.4411875904,
0.0070727393,
-0.3175832331,
0.138175711,
1.0399202108,
-1.0448143482,
0.11909125,
0.4061248302,
0.9757427573,
0.3720103502,
0.6259132028,
0.4687584043,
-1.1700484753,
0.1972260773,
0.1606600583,
0.2965490818,
0.2963193357,
-0.2706627548,
0.628672719,
0.2751488984,
-0.5145435333,
-1.0045571327,
0.1743805408,
-0.9061556458,
-0.1792427152,
1.4719679356,
-0.3137387037,
0.0216639917,
0.288790524,
-0.2453972548,
0.222537294,
-0.0392947271,
0.6454663873,
0.8550530076,
0.2025580108,
0.1600563526,
-0.3315716684,
0.457654506,
0.3920532167,
-0.9129088521,
0.6681497097,
0.7973304391,
0.3701827228,
0.601334095,
0.792109549,
-0.2575854361,
-0.0547260717,
-0.1899930239,
0.0334723517,
-0.0822064653,
-0.2051386833,
0.2382439226,
0.2614405155,
0.0270871315,
-0.2675208747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01784v1 | Analyzing Persuasive Strategies in Meme Texts: A Fusion of Language Models with Paraphrase Enrichment | 2024-07-01T20:25:20 | 2024-07-01T20:25:20 | Kota Shamanth Ramanath Nayak, Leila Kosseim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper describes our approach to hierarchical multi-label detection of
persuasion techniques in meme texts. Our model, developed as a part of the
recent SemEval task, is based on fine-tuning individual language models (BERT,
XLM-RoBERTa, and mBERT) and leveraging a mean-based ensemble model in addition
to dataset augmentation through paraphrase generation from ChatGPT. The scope
of the study encompasses enhancing model performance through innovative
training techniques and data augmentation strategies. The problem addressed is
the effective identification and classification of multiple persuasive
techniques in meme texts, a task complicated by the diversity and complexity of
such content. The objective of the paper is to improve detection accuracy by
refining model training methods and examining the impact of balanced versus
unbalanced training datasets. Novelty in the results and discussion lies in the
finding that training with paraphrases enhances model performance, yet a
balanced training set proves more advantageous than a larger unbalanced one.
Additionally, the analysis reveals the potential pitfalls of indiscriminate
incorporation of paraphrases from diverse distributions, which can introduce
substantial noise. Results with the SemEval 2024 data confirm these insights,
demonstrating improved model efficacy with the proposed methods. | [
-0.3512114882,
-0.8216983676,
0.2225077301,
0.2850266695,
-0.3958671093,
0.1073879451,
-0.0650071427,
0.1570392996,
0.0475163423,
0.6518040895,
-0.4398078918,
-0.6465142965,
-0.7032190561,
0.171556145,
-0.3525590599,
1.0636099577,
0.1441337913,
0.1087871119,
-0.2876065373,
-0.2442250848,
-0.2121471316,
-0.7950219512,
-0.2950628996,
-0.2942549884,
0.4574119151,
0.7683756948,
0.5336654782,
0.3896126449,
0.1536799073,
0.2538377345,
-0.150033161,
-0.0529015809,
-0.2770047784,
0.2020207942,
-0.3282559216,
-0.2190224528,
-0.1491931379,
0.2818257213,
0.6899793148,
0.4401239157,
0.0014685923,
-0.0104246475,
0.4934036434,
0.0809143484,
-0.6929558516,
-0.2161464244,
-0.8173159361,
-0.1633300483,
-0.3793976307,
-0.5011370778,
-0.4268921614,
-0.030537229,
0.1939127296,
-0.0432574078,
0.1076554656,
-0.1001200825,
0.722112298,
0.0314018391,
-0.6210949421,
-0.4585061371,
-0.541695714,
1.0567079782,
-0.9775915146,
0.0303802621,
0.0748324767,
0.0726048425,
0.062133465,
-0.6966574192,
-0.4630206227,
0.0506699197,
0.1255785078,
0.1076954007,
-0.4155588448,
-0.0390560143,
0.1402498931,
0.2204812169,
-0.4584483206,
0.14245148,
-0.0481165946,
-0.2903033197,
0.2057824433,
-0.11349345,
0.3830488622,
-0.4503425658,
-0.5715923905,
-0.4819632471,
-0.4767931104,
0.2086072862,
0.5983196497,
0.097408995,
0.1110590771,
0.5694538355,
-0.3622966111,
0.490843147,
0.0934554338,
-0.3009773791,
0.1036704928,
-0.4838728607,
-0.097112976,
0.0503359064,
0.8231053352,
0.1741402,
-0.0548382588,
0.026134735,
-0.1976235509,
0.0862987116,
-0.0749158934,
-0.740737021,
-0.5563318729,
-0.0924263522,
-0.6905844808,
-0.6470984221,
-0.1132095456,
-1.1174207926,
-0.3975799084,
-0.2263531983,
0.5650296807,
-0.4873768091,
-0.2344074696,
0.1865765154,
-0.494125247,
0.1955873519,
-0.0068484778,
-0.9124336839,
-0.0990624875,
0.7178239226,
0.4809401929,
0.1738464832,
-0.2892432213,
-0.3061493635,
0.2577477694,
-0.1619467884,
1.1462696791,
-1.3054070473,
-0.1895218641,
-0.1045521647,
-0.0247969888,
-0.1427048445,
-0.5781844854,
1.0124088526,
-0.102026172,
0.1916319728,
-0.48087731,
-0.6603137255,
-0.2026501149,
0.2916789353,
-0.5094979405,
0.4812354445,
-0.2508151233,
-0.7495443225,
0.2748469412,
-0.5941775441,
-0.3316081762,
-0.157325536,
-0.2055956125,
-0.5169597268,
-0.0264369436,
0.5449526906,
0.8005147576,
-0.3390963674,
0.2838868499,
-0.2083711475,
0.1838471293,
0.3720730245,
-0.7839895487,
0.6640392542,
0.5157128572,
-0.3248699605,
0.0975913703,
-0.5988790393,
-0.1751056761,
-0.120716624,
-0.412353456,
-0.7117679119,
0.0615676455,
-0.241085127,
0.2543818355,
0.3304032981,
-0.3955082595,
-0.0987676606,
-0.0543918051,
0.4450379014,
0.6550873518,
0.3751665652,
0.4226124585,
-0.3514718115,
0.5386390686,
0.0874656886,
0.0916972831,
-0.4011494815,
-0.4537393749,
-0.4254643321,
-0.2185983509,
0.2549325228,
0.4043958485,
-0.8528915644,
0.2410802543,
-0.1205972955,
-0.5075873733,
-0.3390048146,
0.2865712345,
0.2616933882,
0.628708005,
0.6468462944,
0.199600324,
-0.5620517135,
-1.1058177948,
-0.741400063,
0.1430201679,
0.1257127076,
-0.0043803398,
0.5055204034,
-0.0562940538,
0.3905959129,
-0.0874842554,
0.1722192466,
-0.3338819742,
0.7267871499,
0.0326370709,
0.5597821474,
0.6430648565,
-0.8526246548,
-0.5348814726,
-0.1119756103,
-0.7175124884,
-0.4086532295,
-0.2960921824,
0.0185170118,
-0.4124590158,
0.4962722957,
0.0771938637,
0.1900186539,
0.6913895011,
-0.3367958069,
0.663577497,
0.1169238091,
0.7337112427,
-1.1635918617,
-0.5233259797,
0.4017624855,
0.2186101973,
-0.8226181269,
-0.1974512637,
0.1191421449,
-0.0917004496,
-0.3507303298,
0.1364242733,
-0.3477387726,
0.6477041841,
-0.4139317572,
-0.3596794009,
0.0160930529,
0.256670475,
-0.14254345,
0.5847908854,
0.6928046346,
-0.7902435064,
0.1678204238,
0.20757851,
-0.2445989102,
0.9042561054,
-0.6200599074,
0.0019081562,
-0.256595701,
0.1908469647,
-1.4048534632,
-0.2593311667,
0.4118592739,
-0.3503366411,
0.2290500402,
-0.003204562,
-0.464692235,
-0.2835540771,
-0.447381556,
0.1017858088,
0.353993386,
-0.7479087114,
0.3691256046,
0.4325722456,
-0.3347136676,
-0.5925012231,
-0.3566530347,
0.4046152532,
-0.9018967748,
-0.5857312083,
0.2758693993,
0.0903814733,
-0.1255580187,
-0.2985304296,
-0.1366836727,
0.0022657884,
0.0395893008,
-0.1396671385,
-0.2010168284,
-0.1502078623,
0.2091385871,
0.498683393,
-0.0727558509,
-0.149926573,
-0.2805199623,
0.5107019544,
-0.1175008193,
-0.2090883702,
-0.4535043836,
0.4473827183,
0.5035198331,
-0.2910431027,
0.6192595363,
0.4976306558,
-0.0777835771,
0.0975757986,
-0.8767398,
-0.3811483383,
-0.4502798617,
0.2168304324,
-0.5847707987,
-0.6650740504,
0.1994822174,
-0.504411459,
0.1107085645,
0.4713508487,
0.4569888413,
-0.2607152462,
1.2054417133,
0.2014209777,
-0.0032459057,
0.4163457751,
-0.059727516,
0.0945793465,
-0.5483503938,
-0.2514308095,
-0.8285728097,
-0.5676723719,
-0.4360625744,
-0.5003745556,
0.2610373795,
0.1185642108,
0.0244378261,
0.4068904221,
-0.7449704409,
0.3934503198,
0.5734735131,
0.1372651011,
0.2167184353,
0.4106303751,
-0.0900231898,
-0.4161066711,
-0.7133614421,
-0.9958056211,
0.9879467487,
0.4158642888,
1.0386571884,
0.0911552459,
0.6955522895,
0.231285885,
0.0456734225,
-0.2398807406,
0.6875832081,
-0.328099221,
-0.483381778,
-0.2811259627,
-0.1740231812,
-1.1777428389,
0.3630225062,
-0.3942092955,
-0.5844424367,
0.4133747816,
0.0910685137,
0.1813219339,
0.4459447861,
-0.6083215475,
1.0734601021,
-0.3302478194,
-0.1770299375,
-0.3955695629,
-0.5040278435,
0.1376552433,
-0.0371770412,
0.0063607167,
-0.1708134264,
-0.1490392387,
1.0839569569,
-0.1450072676,
0.8140336871,
-0.111519143,
-0.1095336005,
0.4411929548,
-0.4261006415,
0.6518642902,
-0.4415472746,
-0.2403087169,
-0.1498894989,
-0.0577317625,
-0.6448196769,
-0.4194745421,
0.7172927856,
-0.5096994042,
-0.6080601215,
0.0864482448,
-0.5199753046,
-0.1311001331,
-0.0886310041,
0.478207618,
0.4468456209,
-0.271899581,
0.9264834523,
0.7717665434,
-0.3107517064,
0.3250075877,
0.1408576816,
0.4884425402,
-0.5023321509,
1.1717426777,
0.2105329186,
0.246000737,
0.5388277173,
0.6271236539,
-0.5543586612,
-0.6381286383,
0.0783862248,
0.0380739085,
-0.9623528123,
0.003370048,
-1.0527920723,
0.1986731738,
-0.8375808597,
0.0510580279,
-0.0206822567,
-0.469189018,
-0.2363047749,
0.1362211406,
-0.0591723621,
0.4945726991,
0.1524463594,
0.7727951407,
-0.5718976259,
-0.0948283523,
0.3868125975,
-0.4336540103,
-0.1349491328,
-0.6506558061,
0.0334039889,
0.1883845776,
-0.8390899301,
-1.4272117615,
0.2657147348,
0.0084556136,
0.9628432989,
0.6427013874,
0.1331162304,
0.5747007132,
-0.0527179614,
0.6378020644,
0.337559551,
-0.9055694938,
0.6424895525,
-0.5087246895,
0.1531108916,
0.4713941216,
0.7013458014,
-0.1636160165,
-0.6612050533,
-1.0329818726,
-0.6488842964,
0.1786240488,
0.1694432944,
0.3815922141,
-0.0767301321,
0.1455219537,
0.249343276,
0.3997766674,
-0.9502498507,
-0.2249957025,
-0.2850711048,
-0.2144793868,
-0.0457599014,
-0.5928583741,
-0.075628899,
-0.3847469389,
0.8874427676,
0.0493507199,
-0.201953128,
-0.1477462202,
-0.1294051856,
0.3630357981,
0.6361210346,
0.4253231883,
0.4471480548,
0.190120548,
0.3797880411,
0.136573717,
0.0123950401,
0.3365977407,
0.0948273093,
-0.1729100794,
0.1592290252,
0.113504149,
0.7895959616,
0.3276482821,
-0.2316879928,
0.3164781034,
0.3043792248,
-0.4278493226,
0.5266290307,
-0.1132011265,
0.1201177686,
0.4643479884,
0.360488236,
0.0715832859,
0.450620532,
-0.4359640479,
0.3569744229,
0.6968848109,
-0.2178050131,
-0.3195530474,
0.6993590593,
0.3267510831,
-0.0093961582,
-0.0272661056,
0.0503110327,
-0.5061258078,
0.5887445807,
0.6023447514,
0.7346357703,
-0.6724202037,
0.4549276531,
0.4044311047,
0.4029976428,
-0.0501843393,
-0.2145320475,
-0.2713027298,
-0.6828163266,
-0.1432886124,
-0.4105764329,
-0.4455939531,
0.7136723995,
-0.2814097703,
0.4535266757,
-0.1792653352,
-0.0934895575,
0.5223060846,
-0.2781251371,
-0.1966712773,
0.1536095887,
0.1580964476,
0.4681360126,
-1.2781137228,
0.5517385602,
1.052742362,
-0.3275786042,
-0.7225768566,
0.3811985254,
0.0595902689,
-0.4512646496,
0.0338849053,
0.1412965506,
0.0735319406,
0.139745608,
-0.9523434639,
-0.4428135157,
0.7652030587,
0.2076468468,
-0.1960178465,
0.2898254395,
-0.032971561,
0.2956857383,
-0.637789607,
0.0285469349,
0.6073911786,
0.5343468785,
0.3417639434,
-0.4225200415,
-0.0228683874,
-0.0058501707,
-0.1746608764,
-0.0299913194,
-0.3667066991,
0.9638595581,
0.127748996,
-0.0027945961,
0.0714637712,
0.7498836517,
0.1568711996,
0.4243280888,
0.662456274,
0.2461773753,
0.8275046349,
0.1179676503,
0.8585199714,
-0.1162599474,
0.1593040228,
0.9334266186,
0.0781991035,
0.5227053761,
0.4742217064,
0.1212172061,
0.5164257288,
0.7382020354,
-0.1067779362,
0.6616446376,
0.0345291942,
-0.5585532188,
-0.5092331171,
-0.2477938831,
-0.3456100523,
0.3665217161,
0.4677474797,
-0.5297871232,
-0.6142252684,
0.3778663576,
0.1414350569,
0.3960165381,
-0.0900477245,
0.7520443797,
-0.1461676806,
-0.8576077223,
0.5419805646,
-0.0023554449,
0.73941046,
-0.4392695427,
-0.0030746243,
0.1363295913,
0.1872313023,
-0.1632988751,
-0.667222023,
0.0912776664,
-0.1731878221,
-0.0301894266,
-0.3158760965,
1.098631978,
-0.6974526644,
-0.4003855288,
-0.0107182898,
0.5473150611,
0.3939571679,
-0.2083159536,
-1.1306952238,
-0.1844395846,
0.4683180153,
0.0151363825,
0.3548376858,
0.670963943,
-0.114149645,
0.4128062725,
0.7660529017,
-0.2390295267,
-0.062172167,
0.1789151728,
0.7927131057,
-0.4117105305,
-0.4381197393,
-1.2585427761,
0.4209739268,
-0.4719029665,
-0.056357827,
1.1843245029,
0.5080726147,
0.3380035758,
-0.1994398534,
0.8790394068,
0.1625071466,
0.572373271,
-0.2673503757,
0.2970846593,
-0.5885979533,
0.3856505454,
-0.6867542267,
-0.8148118258,
-0.0383739397,
0.5639059544,
-0.5465528965,
-0.1980374753,
0.5884007215,
0.9626841545,
-0.0870633349,
0.1995723844,
0.4601186812,
0.1575389653,
0.6074889302,
0.2714295983,
1.1807281971,
-0.2407008857,
0.9584514499,
-0.3298487961,
-0.5099031329,
-0.1597752124,
-0.8721837997,
-1.0311279297,
-0.6481363773,
-0.7130773067,
-0.4307160974,
0.016075518,
0.5795942545,
0.4787017107,
-0.8043251634,
-0.2231810391,
0.0113784326,
0.2040622234,
-0.1725542545,
-0.1904588193,
0.0201385785,
-0.5985305905,
-1.0415526628,
0.4101553857,
0.3621698022,
0.2217321694,
0.0934294686,
0.0626905486,
-0.7836828232,
0.3363184035,
0.4432473481,
0.2463409603,
-0.4977679849,
0.0472381078,
-0.1488814205,
-0.0422435105,
-0.0291442536,
0.7264815569,
-0.3194167316,
0.5551075339,
0.6286095977,
0.536685884,
0.1825820506,
0.4915437996,
0.4133704305,
-0.7087875605,
0.1461131126,
0.2559935749,
0.2366594523,
0.4274502695,
-0.1581039131,
0.3820190728,
0.2839328945,
-0.5874503255,
-0.6458053589,
-0.0539225042,
-0.5177468061,
-0.5463261604,
1.3473755121,
0.091381453,
-0.0263362937,
-0.3506433964,
-0.2894405127,
0.0711053088,
-0.4224367142,
0.3567617536,
0.9892126322,
-0.0012302679,
0.0266866498,
-0.4093773663,
0.4668990076,
0.8578023911,
-0.6191227436,
-0.1642153263,
0.387650162,
0.3341339827,
0.3089850843,
0.4770639241,
-0.0394362733,
0.1232993901,
-0.0055616437,
-0.086265564,
0.4445578158,
-0.2413829714,
-0.2208119184,
0.3036805689,
-0.1716452539,
-0.455622077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01725v1 | DiscoveryBench: Towards Data-Driven Discovery with Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T18:58:22 | 2024-07-01T18:58:22 | Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Harshit Surana, Dhruv Agarwal, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Abhijeetsingh Meena, Aryan Prakhar, Tirth Vora, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Can the rapid advances in code generation, function calling, and data
analysis using large language models (LLMs) help automate the search and
verification of hypotheses purely from a set of provided datasets? To evaluate
this question, we present DiscoveryBench, the first comprehensive benchmark
that formalizes the multi-step process of data-driven discovery. The benchmark
is designed to systematically assess current model capabilities in discovery
tasks and provide a useful resource for improving them. Our benchmark contains
264 tasks collected across 6 diverse domains, such as sociology and
engineering, by manually deriving discovery workflows from published papers to
approximate the real-world challenges faced by researchers, where each task is
defined by a dataset, its metadata, and a discovery goal in natural language.
We additionally provide 903 synthetic tasks to conduct controlled evaluations
across task complexity. Furthermore, our structured formalism of data-driven
discovery enables a facet-based evaluation that provides useful insights into
different failure modes. We evaluate several popular LLM-based reasoning
frameworks using both open and closed LLMs as baselines on DiscoveryBench and
find that even the best system scores only 25%. Our benchmark, thus,
illustrates the challenges in autonomous data-driven discovery and serves as a
valuable resource for the community to make progress. | [
-0.2635062039,
-0.6996190548,
0.873713851,
0.2250179499,
0.2299484164,
0.2874988616,
-0.3490624428,
-0.1674159169,
-0.2358252555,
0.2720711827,
-0.7572827935,
-0.8737843633,
-0.4666306973,
0.0241194628,
-0.6734516621,
0.4007406533,
-0.2484077364,
-0.0427889861,
-0.4233340919,
0.1212143302,
-0.2624315321,
-0.398978591,
-0.3876070976,
-0.3355635405,
0.5144224763,
0.3726280034,
0.3912551105,
0.8283245564,
0.6445989013,
0.2228972465,
0.0465802811,
0.1131346524,
-0.5284605622,
0.1816176921,
-0.3903490305,
-0.4540429115,
-0.3087792397,
0.0071815946,
0.4215350151,
1.185915947,
-0.2284513414,
0.2206690907,
-0.0899111852,
0.7228931189,
-0.485247016,
0.5597504377,
-0.4987086952,
0.0202945787,
-0.3932984769,
0.0004204934,
-0.3848342896,
-0.3462540507,
0.0021441227,
-0.3830764294,
0.4364191592,
0.1253679097,
0.3948839307,
0.2919318676,
-0.388653785,
-0.2301194966,
-0.6818757057,
0.9100479484,
-0.5273035765,
0.4697438776,
0.0854037702,
0.4977199435,
-0.6059059501,
-0.7274294496,
-0.3942975104,
-0.3534463048,
0.1442453116,
-0.3027867377,
-0.1344492286,
-0.1438227445,
0.5519897342,
0.6671917439,
-0.9192264676,
0.1047948897,
-0.0226625521,
-0.2783817947,
0.6647787094,
0.2277850956,
0.0887391567,
-0.1040336117,
-0.0904150233,
-0.3112769723,
-0.7409629226,
-0.2190028578,
0.2693226635,
0.4585783482,
0.0425241143,
0.5284796953,
-0.7382526994,
0.5016463995,
-0.404258728,
0.0164504964,
0.4463490546,
-0.4868349731,
-0.0742911175,
-0.206782937,
0.7153407931,
0.172743693,
0.0609913282,
-0.4109767973,
-0.2923688591,
0.1525255591,
0.0214804523,
-0.8621864319,
-0.3193669617,
0.2466950715,
-0.3920390904,
-0.3034684062,
0.0356197804,
-0.735112071,
-0.7811630368,
-0.3411518931,
0.2657760978,
-0.093042925,
-0.28910622,
0.2135439962,
-0.0197012071,
0.0593525507,
0.319624126,
-0.3940942883,
0.5309363604,
0.6768482924,
0.6962248683,
-0.4225551784,
-0.1708729267,
-0.4999062419,
-0.1322514266,
-0.6253976822,
0.7501495481,
-0.2179109156,
-0.2829758525,
-0.1746314615,
0.0979015306,
0.1343462318,
-0.7757635713,
0.7882221937,
-0.3709194362,
-0.2582232058,
-0.5547916889,
-0.6198457479,
-0.1708089709,
0.142476052,
-0.8559045196,
1.2841004133,
0.0973163769,
-0.568287313,
0.471432507,
-0.7094061375,
-0.4934696257,
0.0592926778,
-0.2406974882,
-0.1359942257,
0.1010534316,
0.0623128489,
0.3503308594,
-0.8680912256,
0.6637870669,
-0.5474862456,
-0.363992691,
0.1891397238,
-0.216676563,
0.6105970144,
-0.0039471444,
-0.6828491092,
0.0340555459,
-0.9860254526,
0.1495909691,
0.3398936391,
-0.4343536198,
-0.060010463,
0.3274536133,
0.0392261855,
0.2157000005,
0.2483804524,
-0.6903344393,
0.206825614,
-0.203886047,
0.2236170322,
0.6868584752,
-0.2794137597,
-0.0420138463,
-0.2694289088,
0.2790221572,
-0.1544721276,
0.011652478,
-0.331138283,
0.0266633127,
-0.8097016811,
-0.196038112,
0.3582407534,
0.451728195,
-0.3045622408,
0.5469776988,
-0.3332397044,
-0.7216459513,
-0.3179643154,
0.27329427,
0.254907608,
0.5263206959,
0.3388033509,
-0.3072375953,
-0.740639925,
-0.9969332218,
-0.1250373125,
0.0392003991,
-0.0554913543,
0.4318654537,
0.4998669028,
-0.4660766721,
0.8006780148,
-0.3658026755,
-0.1136936992,
-0.2528467774,
0.1939153969,
0.5345426798,
0.2712705433,
0.2199476212,
-0.5888050795,
-0.237654835,
0.0307808667,
-0.9829824567,
-0.3345669806,
0.2211320698,
0.0510155596,
0.1445638984,
0.6095924377,
-0.4789880514,
0.4252047837,
0.3790727854,
-0.0051769488,
0.4909155071,
0.0834722593,
0.108420454,
-0.4255264997,
0.5246637464,
-0.2163857073,
-0.1290066242,
-0.3971071839,
0.1645407379,
0.0528821982,
-0.1138627231,
0.0143701676,
0.5961539745,
-0.365922749,
-0.3995822966,
-0.3732121885,
0.0335102342,
-0.1428603828,
0.1815049052,
-0.0911169425,
0.6941663623,
0.8748495579,
-0.5349511504,
0.6168267131,
0.1465045065,
-0.6108982563,
0.2478090674,
-0.6608459353,
0.3213623166,
0.0101290997,
0.3791200519,
-0.7932531834,
-0.339966476,
-0.2311016172,
-0.100478366,
-0.0331940502,
-0.1191865876,
-1.1211768389,
-0.5516950488,
-0.1064207479,
0.1355930269,
0.1464396566,
-0.6986028552,
0.5081208944,
0.2149219662,
-0.2946106493,
-0.3472540975,
-0.390750438,
0.3591905832,
0.062154796,
-0.7297720313,
0.4013406932,
-0.385702759,
-0.3552015424,
-0.2631703317,
-0.4049503207,
0.1260541975,
0.3161839843,
0.4616662562,
-0.0056512654,
-0.0180220678,
0.3170775473,
-0.2852884531,
-0.1767568886,
0.2262798548,
-0.2758097053,
0.7511115074,
-0.2568005025,
-0.578168273,
-0.0504586697,
0.329524368,
0.4746725261,
-0.3192935288,
0.2364633977,
0.2185221016,
-0.4114511013,
-0.4107145071,
-0.5803038478,
-0.1577372998,
-0.4427591562,
0.2175475657,
-0.4251592457,
-0.6507077813,
0.5076701641,
-0.4075631797,
0.1798087656,
0.4377357364,
0.5193896294,
0.2050229907,
1.0194013119,
0.6721980572,
-0.1281105876,
-0.0263591427,
-0.0727802068,
0.3400945067,
-0.2750789523,
-0.1465581506,
-0.5766673088,
-0.2036940753,
-0.5543110371,
-0.4298361242,
0.4693311453,
-0.125886336,
-0.1340724975,
0.2285897583,
-0.1541367322,
0.2738631368,
0.6782605052,
-0.0154811963,
0.5091922283,
-0.3228745461,
-0.2119857818,
0.1384650767,
-0.4696034789,
-0.5502233505,
1.3706204891,
0.2111234963,
0.7600575686,
-0.0726051256,
0.8905649781,
0.3677370548,
0.2677181065,
-0.7651184797,
0.8085634112,
0.1164362207,
-0.7400853634,
-0.1165108755,
-0.5596099496,
-0.7949922085,
-0.1598667353,
0.1386998594,
-0.5348382592,
0.0995978266,
-0.1098797992,
-0.0256966222,
0.0352480114,
-0.3115832806,
0.8635799885,
-0.419231683,
-0.558904469,
-0.3454009295,
-0.4275626242,
0.348734647,
-0.2966395617,
0.4465605319,
-0.2655120194,
0.3096980155,
0.6877756119,
-0.2982628644,
0.5714408159,
-0.2638837993,
-0.1986538023,
0.1500542015,
0.4230746329,
0.630951643,
-0.0668041259,
-0.3486824334,
-0.0205114968,
-0.0148709854,
-0.272633642,
-0.5284883976,
0.807381928,
-0.2072231323,
-0.528036654,
-0.2794956565,
-0.6149429679,
-0.2750925124,
0.4940787256,
-0.2482452989,
0.3641700447,
-0.3846732676,
0.3740518391,
0.7628669739,
-0.173595354,
0.2915714979,
0.7678137422,
-0.4109645784,
0.0571917146,
0.7925965786,
-0.1933836639,
-0.0025438722,
0.2693037987,
0.1295505613,
-0.240556106,
-0.8110172153,
-0.2208459228,
0.0592407621,
-0.8769395947,
-0.1087475643,
-0.5156207681,
0.0925211236,
-0.1642808318,
0.2090303749,
-0.5964279175,
-0.1719590873,
0.1583732963,
-0.242051959,
0.122450538,
0.7077000141,
-0.1662721038,
-0.152333498,
-0.5345458388,
0.4181490541,
0.0743765607,
0.5915071964,
-0.2446282357,
0.0083861845,
-0.3009058833,
-0.2470987737,
-0.0683099926,
-0.5260437727,
0.1200598553,
-0.1433319151,
0.7187471986,
0.1946138144,
0.165640682,
0.2143916041,
-0.3668213487,
0.406656146,
-0.2843123376,
-0.8703024387,
0.6204602122,
-0.4570968449,
0.0941417441,
0.5759043694,
0.2343266755,
-0.2773788869,
0.0052347961,
-0.5943940878,
-0.794033289,
0.2773222923,
-0.0706486329,
-0.2951218188,
0.1770166755,
0.1572649926,
0.308334142,
0.3457064927,
-0.4928213954,
-0.2648082078,
0.1082386971,
-0.2057581395,
-0.081846118,
0.1147040799,
-0.4109202623,
-0.0880002752,
0.5718210936,
-0.5332149267,
0.0152052315,
0.0592736714,
-0.1995958984,
-0.1097243801,
0.2426689863,
0.0864429101,
0.7838813066,
-0.3078868985,
0.1471814364,
-0.0787467137,
-0.0878135636,
0.1058565378,
0.6108273864,
-0.0778524652,
-0.0159438327,
0.3125756681,
0.5443755984,
0.2341523916,
-1.2657847404,
0.4246151447,
-0.1110276729,
-0.1663637459,
-0.2552802265,
0.2788194418,
0.094959788,
0.3047630489,
0.6183189154,
-0.2837443352,
0.4433250427,
-0.5846648812,
0.3834910691,
0.5478976369,
0.0206407886,
-0.0882424414,
0.4322808385,
-0.0606564321,
0.098658599,
0.4424807131,
-0.2249009758,
-0.3536486924,
0.5182891488,
0.0313092545,
0.769969523,
0.090415597,
0.032907974,
0.3584580123,
0.3180831075,
-0.2697217166,
0.4356715977,
-0.0966192484,
-0.5172349215,
-0.3967934847,
-0.7035121918,
-0.6478534937,
0.1961311996,
-0.5727248788,
0.2848097682,
-0.4058273137,
0.1653268933,
0.2186925262,
0.2888717651,
-0.7818024158,
0.2142461985,
0.1215534359,
1.0588023663,
-0.6535603404,
0.565335989,
0.4188120663,
0.0284362137,
-0.4930182993,
-0.2345389724,
0.2515986562,
-0.5785626173,
0.6980394125,
0.3630226552,
-0.0801020786,
-0.002966404,
-0.73293221,
-1.050756216,
1.1476943493,
0.345292151,
-0.7008612156,
0.115020439,
0.1315431595,
0.4295650721,
-0.3932850063,
0.0825126171,
0.8651614189,
0.719315052,
-0.0083344346,
-1.0423921347,
0.2401871383,
-0.3404636383,
-0.2567858994,
0.0884912908,
-0.2612011135,
0.8373829722,
-0.2991482913,
-0.3478691578,
0.1615189612,
0.395282805,
0.3188768625,
0.3971441388,
0.4249331951,
0.6803157926,
0.8970496058,
-0.2261628807,
1.1410609484,
-0.1677384079,
0.3468019664,
1.1170296669,
-0.7282214761,
0.6401128173,
0.228604421,
-0.4109928012,
0.6588340402,
0.5699771643,
-0.2674836814,
0.4053834975,
0.698077023,
-0.1760181636,
-0.2865736485,
-0.245276913,
-0.0816905349,
0.3633810282,
0.267470181,
-0.3027043045,
-0.4302499592,
-0.1927856803,
-0.197803095,
0.0569690689,
-0.1046059951,
0.6608889699,
-0.2380055636,
-0.59122473,
0.6013134122,
0.1013569012,
0.2697974145,
-0.4745655358,
0.0027650567,
-0.2971532345,
0.3267976046,
-0.1833271235,
-0.6237120032,
0.03713971,
-0.0928065777,
-0.3605521321,
-0.1496609151,
0.5726459026,
-0.0567354746,
-0.4282481372,
0.4684907198,
0.7020324469,
0.0781449303,
-0.3344569802,
-0.4865876436,
0.406160295,
-0.1582561582,
-0.343673557,
0.2636013031,
0.2135612816,
-0.0170197207,
0.8959330916,
0.7743198276,
-0.1599745005,
0.1066340134,
0.2447684556,
0.955057323,
-0.795753777,
-0.1051796526,
-0.5442700982,
0.1823975295,
-0.0766696632,
0.2119709104,
0.6887797117,
0.8305726647,
0.8559942245,
0.0416494943,
1.2339535952,
-0.3089038432,
1.051202178,
-0.4398741424,
0.3620499372,
-0.3269863725,
0.3065251112,
-0.1002681702,
-0.8272387981,
-0.2072384953,
0.3724935055,
-0.2039501518,
0.049212914,
0.6922516823,
1.0692189932,
0.0139721241,
-0.0479561873,
-0.018712474,
0.2770847976,
0.5984634757,
0.5529641509,
0.7139311433,
-0.2770266235,
0.40870893,
-0.3428314924,
-0.3813407421,
-0.1061793789,
-1.0140813589,
-0.8143447638,
-0.4627436101,
-0.3992757201,
-0.1670587659,
-0.0774740651,
0.7746250629,
0.5970879197,
-0.821744442,
-0.469556272,
-0.6652166247,
0.043428801,
-0.2478508949,
-0.2605924606,
0.2787074149,
-0.2939563394,
-0.6732282043,
1.1120494604,
0.2795800269,
-0.1700602323,
-0.5548451543,
0.0894977078,
-0.0156299882,
-0.0706814155,
0.3935632706,
0.3176949024,
-0.4751933217,
0.085172385,
0.1249439865,
-0.0464456975,
-0.0949884132,
0.8872845173,
-0.9271389842,
0.4686325192,
0.4229735732,
0.7034647465,
0.6692637205,
-0.2433567941,
0.6341109276,
-0.5127912164,
-0.2533418238,
0.1625967026,
0.3713556528,
0.508459568,
0.0117037175,
0.8504289985,
0.3191532791,
-0.4379938543,
-1.1106210947,
0.2091491669,
-0.8232343197,
-0.094531998,
1.0224016905,
-0.0903806314,
0.0902083889,
-0.0933779329,
-0.0157749429,
-0.0247317478,
-0.1807882786,
0.7756722569,
0.6798468232,
-0.1391111612,
-0.1364309192,
-0.8441724181,
0.4833934605,
0.3297193944,
-1.1533001661,
0.6258155107,
0.5687112212,
0.328322798,
0.1988467276,
0.1249711365,
-0.155459553,
0.2265788317,
-0.204452306,
0.241294235,
-0.0506044105,
-0.419111222,
-0.0703418925,
0.2292291671,
0.1510730833,
0.3803467155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01697v1 | NLPGuard: A Framework for Mitigating the Use of Protected Attributes by NLP Classifiers | 2024-07-01T18:08:17 | 2024-07-01T18:08:17 | Salvatore Greco, Ke Zhou, Licia Capra, Tania Cerquitelli, Daniele Quercia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | AI regulations are expected to prohibit machine learning models from using
sensitive attributes during training. However, the latest Natural Language
Processing (NLP) classifiers, which rely on deep learning, operate as black-box
systems, complicating the detection and remediation of such misuse. Traditional
bias mitigation methods in NLP aim for comparable performance across different
groups based on attributes like gender or race but fail to address the
underlying issue of reliance on protected attributes. To partly fix that, we
introduce NLPGuard, a framework for mitigating the reliance on protected
attributes in NLP classifiers. NLPGuard takes an unlabeled dataset, an existing
NLP classifier, and its training data as input, producing a modified training
dataset that significantly reduces dependence on protected attributes without
compromising accuracy. NLPGuard is applied to three classification tasks:
identifying toxic language, sentiment analysis, and occupation classification.
Our evaluation shows that current NLP classifiers heavily depend on protected
attributes, with up to $23\%$ of the most predictive words associated with
these attributes. However, NLPGuard effectively reduces this reliance by up to
$79\%$, while slightly improving accuracy. | [
-0.3303355575,
-0.744377315,
-0.1182554215,
0.1752418727,
0.0749145374,
0.1675759554,
-0.0703131333,
-0.679739058,
-0.2991720736,
0.7543923855,
-0.3638575375,
-0.4547379613,
-0.6003174782,
-0.1467247009,
-0.0681447834,
1.4479130507,
0.3077070713,
-0.359507829,
-0.3684532642,
-0.1272622645,
-0.5585750937,
-0.6587777138,
-0.8710631728,
-0.6842226982,
0.450879097,
0.0892134309,
0.9350934625,
0.4219152927,
0.5574900508,
0.1996878386,
-0.1365230829,
-0.0613897406,
-0.2919592559,
0.1028360054,
-0.142529577,
-0.5038500428,
-0.6155104637,
0.0418609381,
0.3087744415,
0.5356333256,
-0.035312023,
0.0480075069,
0.286785841,
0.5595850945,
-0.9748395085,
0.2946433425,
-0.6978904605,
0.6438592076,
-0.3174290657,
-0.2725657225,
-0.4874880314,
-0.1805353165,
0.1572514176,
-0.37938115,
0.3929059505,
-0.0264478289,
0.7776688337,
0.4188611209,
-0.1848326027,
0.2487741411,
-0.6817598343,
0.9429765344,
-0.81395787,
-0.0714868009,
0.9270697236,
0.0952696353,
0.1335486174,
-0.5070264339,
-0.4920655489,
-0.1121960357,
-0.4286268353,
-0.1092666537,
-0.5170460939,
0.4795742035,
0.5390105247,
0.3196125627,
-0.6685615778,
0.462465167,
-0.4091777503,
-0.3742091656,
0.8642537594,
-0.0371465497,
0.4222881496,
-0.2294584662,
-0.2719616592,
0.0057069957,
-0.7134800553,
0.0833250135,
0.4594447613,
0.4086990952,
0.2091753334,
0.3289393187,
-0.0285937823,
0.546734333,
-0.0798968375,
-0.3319656849,
0.567843616,
0.2336519957,
-0.4546673,
0.2249499559,
0.9040470719,
0.3832376301,
0.0908662006,
-0.318511188,
-0.1430852264,
0.3637769222,
0.3907780349,
-0.8504699469,
-0.4293183386,
0.2362103462,
-0.3690458238,
-0.7211751342,
-0.2941661477,
-0.9381443262,
-0.6038379669,
-0.0570240542,
0.2289425135,
-0.1071097925,
-0.2712912858,
0.1564756334,
-0.1275064647,
0.2940106988,
0.0052965246,
-1.0498473644,
0.2063304484,
0.9430651665,
0.8018431664,
-0.2119005769,
-0.1218717247,
-0.4161619246,
0.1671140194,
0.1058351398,
0.5496132374,
-0.7255954742,
-0.3412037492,
0.0264348686,
-0.0532550476,
0.2358354628,
-0.454677701,
0.8984146714,
-0.3348685503,
0.3503111303,
-0.0334340595,
-0.3708844483,
-0.2372291535,
0.2454613298,
-0.7972252965,
1.0902273655,
0.0410092361,
-1.0828773975,
0.508877337,
-0.7399238944,
-0.6050115824,
0.3027637005,
0.0631353483,
-0.9351460338,
-0.1664172113,
0.3036563098,
0.3663366437,
-0.1349431276,
0.2214706838,
-0.4264362454,
-0.2546483874,
0.08997868,
-0.6355561018,
1.0338226557,
0.1176970303,
-0.4175907373,
0.1135903969,
-0.7148348689,
0.0656678006,
-0.0378942788,
-0.2257546932,
-0.5796152949,
0.0697854981,
0.0971180946,
0.1857784986,
-0.0521325096,
-0.6052441597,
0.061425861,
-0.3638138473,
0.358676672,
1.0413208008,
-0.225300163,
0.5782781243,
-0.2996495962,
0.8870806694,
-0.4467151165,
0.1987694651,
0.1827032715,
-0.5700784922,
-0.745418787,
-0.3554782271,
0.2550015748,
0.7639197111,
-0.7121119499,
0.7976170778,
0.1070449352,
-0.4858686924,
-0.6892115474,
0.1535724103,
0.6578399539,
0.6176277399,
0.4535942674,
-0.4555518627,
-0.4255919158,
-0.8083809018,
-0.3003431857,
-0.2013202012,
-0.3702102602,
0.1049638093,
0.2789322436,
-0.2242290229,
0.9029378891,
-0.5101906061,
-0.6647181511,
-0.2687508166,
0.2562403977,
-0.1842595041,
0.6626208425,
0.7932921052,
-0.6875914335,
-0.1698338687,
-0.1039898992,
-0.7078786492,
-0.5516705513,
-0.1904121339,
-0.1590787172,
0.0527334288,
0.4224118888,
-0.5444688201,
0.6097257137,
0.4839961231,
-0.3159030378,
0.5179593563,
0.1021463722,
-0.5050144792,
-0.4801411331,
0.3361993134,
-0.084056519,
-0.2143932879,
-0.8139315248,
0.2788048089,
-0.2195661813,
-0.2191316485,
-0.315649271,
0.5004802942,
-0.0409635566,
0.2497893274,
-0.443866998,
-0.1874388158,
0.3074558079,
0.4492411017,
0.0859965757,
0.6623272896,
0.5448453426,
-0.6794016361,
0.2452598512,
0.4073852897,
-0.0901713222,
0.9163689613,
-0.8008245826,
0.3335517943,
-0.3750680983,
0.1367002726,
-0.3207077086,
0.1049601138,
0.2638840377,
-0.3778250217,
0.3486760557,
-0.2541126609,
-0.0359100215,
-0.297768414,
-0.4416172504,
0.2426864952,
0.3008706272,
-0.5055165291,
0.6834414005,
0.6988584995,
-0.1592912972,
-1.0927758217,
-1.0411916971,
0.0881802887,
-0.4434663653,
-0.215890184,
0.5622333884,
-0.0080068437,
0.055409912,
0.1749448329,
0.0523358434,
-0.1889998317,
0.5830096006,
0.3843656182,
0.1789067388,
0.090454936,
0.3960745931,
0.0453933664,
-0.3853760362,
0.4250182509,
0.0586146042,
0.5669867992,
-0.1311762035,
-0.210031867,
-0.2253948152,
0.3663259149,
0.0442975201,
-0.6466556787,
0.8085684776,
0.8846094608,
-0.373853147,
-0.5574852228,
-0.1329105347,
-0.0187065285,
-0.5662531853,
0.4217966199,
0.0511924922,
-0.9885852933,
0.244322747,
0.3311039507,
0.2709496021,
0.4202410579,
0.2028602511,
-0.0033315727,
0.8076086044,
0.7367122769,
-0.5323856473,
0.5219193697,
-0.1655693352,
0.5825285316,
-0.8930432796,
-0.2535552382,
-0.6829255223,
-0.5285443664,
-0.8453691006,
-0.2229065597,
0.0289011337,
-0.1946591437,
-0.2361576706,
0.2385875732,
-0.8142204881,
0.7304795384,
0.7043434978,
0.232554242,
0.165568918,
-0.0569587797,
0.3228952289,
-0.1316521019,
-0.5303743482,
-0.4783763885,
1.227047205,
0.482757628,
0.8638557792,
-0.0004812409,
0.5925335884,
0.6635551453,
0.4556939304,
-0.8610664606,
0.6732338071,
-0.2261677235,
-0.674903512,
-0.1296884269,
-0.5326218605,
-1.0262408257,
0.1949429959,
-0.5015963316,
-0.5710332394,
0.178943038,
0.2970272601,
-0.1729214489,
0.5137146711,
-0.4443178177,
0.7818661332,
-0.3718115091,
-0.4584053457,
0.0100203007,
-0.4786406159,
0.3351539373,
-0.0091307815,
-0.1257985383,
-0.3118208051,
0.3227261007,
0.7262973785,
-0.231629014,
1.0305951834,
-0.4169264436,
0.0565155707,
-0.0621460751,
-0.0955350846,
0.228427127,
-0.0533943474,
-0.0916730985,
0.2498478591,
-0.3458645642,
-0.4069927931,
-0.3602441251,
0.5214344263,
-0.6391311884,
-0.4909901321,
-0.7607460618,
-0.5436172485,
-0.2145762444,
0.2740666568,
0.1370596886,
-0.0588979423,
-0.3061931133,
0.3348501027,
0.7987923622,
-0.5824062228,
0.3062466979,
0.1888404191,
-0.2304018736,
-0.1715637296,
0.9257878661,
-0.0945735499,
0.2910617888,
0.3433031738,
0.2689220905,
0.104427591,
-0.5510039926,
0.0502937585,
-0.2277217209,
-0.6496896744,
-0.5649197698,
-0.6498282552,
-0.5880477428,
-0.1764155626,
-0.0614648722,
0.1057357118,
-0.4633877873,
-0.3078768253,
-0.5725785494,
0.433719635,
0.3040611148,
0.0383477546,
0.5045978427,
-0.4402187765,
0.3707337379,
0.5412504673,
0.5122537017,
-0.1433583349,
-0.2337673455,
0.1217209324,
-0.084812656,
-0.5003866553,
-0.4683551192,
0.6258942485,
0.5320171118,
0.6673573852,
0.4531235993,
0.3816176057,
0.2629238069,
-0.3509254158,
0.6468214393,
-0.0058757872,
-0.9170731902,
0.4537506104,
-0.0337059498,
0.1148477197,
0.6631826162,
0.2434802949,
-0.5641182065,
-0.5538922548,
-0.555581212,
-1.1046409607,
0.4121571183,
0.1940029114,
0.3129340112,
0.2098563761,
0.0873688832,
0.0405220874,
0.4716525376,
-1.0019477606,
-0.1240517274,
-0.3403989673,
-0.1662316322,
0.1197557747,
-0.2653874755,
-0.1837434769,
-0.1305441111,
0.6997816563,
-0.1817623824,
0.2751933038,
-0.14951092,
-0.181937471,
0.319265455,
0.4539959729,
0.0306108873,
0.1259115934,
-0.2296333462,
0.2050272971,
0.0352088623,
-0.7592917085,
-0.0886212066,
0.2973392606,
-0.8608979583,
-0.1067675799,
0.3378962278,
1.0195074081,
-0.2280810624,
-0.4483326375,
0.5221506953,
-0.0100815007,
-0.0819259137,
-0.2176519036,
0.2916197777,
-0.3059088886,
-0.0390795693,
0.1330548972,
0.2567294836,
0.3476275802,
-0.2370843887,
0.2677884698,
0.7116456628,
-0.3727245927,
-0.0232899543,
0.658184588,
0.3494118452,
-0.274274528,
0.4762381911,
-0.1534350663,
-0.6652665734,
0.4715484679,
0.4730772078,
1.1448693275,
-0.3774676025,
0.3428217471,
0.1999248415,
0.633197248,
0.0586403348,
0.1401759982,
0.0433160923,
-0.8117190003,
-0.3291296065,
-0.7116494179,
-0.5038670897,
0.309538722,
-0.7408686876,
-0.0102474885,
-0.9613605738,
-0.3997786045,
-0.0072294911,
-0.2334712744,
-0.7157878876,
0.1580845118,
0.1081581414,
0.558259964,
-1.1889177561,
0.5265421867,
0.1465400308,
-0.3340653181,
-0.3676759005,
-0.0354672745,
0.1107846126,
-0.5644407272,
0.3077623248,
0.4228138626,
-0.0513304807,
-0.3867177367,
-0.6183100343,
-0.3607833982,
0.7429819107,
0.4763102233,
-0.2336286902,
0.0005099524,
0.3751777709,
0.685569644,
0.0734519288,
0.1312443912,
0.7829110026,
0.4009931684,
-0.3757741451,
-0.8339121938,
-0.0766102001,
-0.552749753,
0.0230840966,
0.1286370009,
-0.3733608723,
0.6054145694,
0.0311331041,
-0.0593101345,
-0.394084245,
0.4946213961,
0.1653152555,
0.2997620702,
0.4486824572,
0.6631475091,
1.1154657602,
-0.3547180891,
0.9143759608,
0.1948055923,
0.2803183198,
1.2506588697,
-0.3143541217,
0.7825489044,
0.1681667417,
-0.2735862434,
0.4828564227,
0.1885879189,
-0.335257262,
0.5945497751,
0.2850939035,
-0.5788121819,
0.086379528,
-0.5224707723,
-0.3029440641,
0.6420055628,
0.4329050183,
-0.4420871139,
0.1000611112,
0.258271277,
0.4209641218,
0.1132785305,
-0.3073682785,
0.735026598,
0.0471691713,
-0.3563051224,
0.3824430406,
-0.0278360397,
1.0058193207,
-0.6623070836,
-0.0113306278,
-0.1388019919,
0.3544418812,
-0.5911421776,
-0.9222760201,
0.4555018246,
0.1713101417,
-0.0720283091,
-0.5385246277,
1.0411657095,
-0.5469998717,
-0.6328266859,
0.2948789895,
-0.1605699509,
-0.3615428209,
0.0105541274,
-0.8546873331,
-0.1927060336,
-0.1193608567,
-0.0603595264,
0.429351747,
0.1820034385,
0.0440345183,
0.751270771,
0.7819088101,
0.3233922124,
-0.1532277763,
0.0559361987,
0.7967408299,
-0.3898658752,
-0.6390645504,
-0.700127542,
0.3984240592,
-0.4064317942,
-0.1542019546,
0.7204457521,
0.2578425705,
0.9863075018,
0.1179191619,
1.1634517908,
-0.1092462763,
0.3551455736,
-0.5414226651,
1.0705937147,
-0.1619450152,
0.4350342453,
-0.5640781522,
-0.7030470967,
-0.7233969569,
1.0495939255,
-0.1879106909,
0.0938320979,
0.3058336973,
0.8523492813,
0.1375488341,
0.0142331719,
0.0304594077,
-0.1663695276,
0.7607246041,
0.6186762452,
0.4935503006,
-0.2030247301,
0.3308497071,
-0.5225763917,
-0.1907152832,
-0.0016669763,
-1.2261650562,
-1.0257487297,
-0.0214935131,
-0.4189402163,
-0.3889849186,
0.0415600501,
0.6226391792,
0.4862538576,
-0.8981819153,
0.0640656278,
-0.0197227951,
0.2196974307,
-0.3779487014,
-0.2955314517,
0.3422932923,
-0.0868621543,
-0.4256848395,
0.0624691471,
0.1884576529,
-0.1596158296,
-0.4455279708,
0.0261191409,
0.0433944874,
-0.1972382963,
0.6023434997,
0.5613341928,
-0.3656027615,
-0.4210358858,
-0.3330734074,
0.0035078959,
0.0310834441,
0.6592679024,
-0.8693270683,
0.519090116,
0.5987944603,
0.9304330945,
0.2416891754,
-0.1855817586,
0.5904644132,
-1.030810833,
0.5043368936,
0.6434097886,
0.263489604,
0.5626539588,
-0.4611387551,
0.5956050158,
-0.0034710336,
-0.5730857849,
-0.9103539586,
0.2224775851,
-0.8126558065,
-0.1217874512,
0.8414878845,
-0.2398693413,
-0.0616718605,
-0.2992737293,
-0.3506949842,
-0.0764491037,
-0.4187407792,
1.0240836143,
0.4389106035,
0.190773651,
-0.4383953214,
-0.6915282607,
0.876557529,
0.4668913484,
-1.145765543,
0.2792325616,
0.4208816886,
0.0253120624,
0.1556327194,
0.496861577,
-0.0826924518,
0.1739191115,
-0.427208215,
0.2492352724,
-0.0454066098,
-0.2608430386,
-0.3874573708,
0.2277677655,
0.1025996432,
-0.0301764254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01687v1 | Deciphering the Factors Influencing the Efficacy of Chain-of-Thought: Probability, Memorization, and Noisy Reasoning | 2024-07-01T18:01:07 | 2024-07-01T18:01:07 | Akshara Prabhakar, Thomas L. Griffiths, R. Thomas McCoy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has been shown to enhance the multi-step
reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). However, debates
persist about whether LLMs exhibit abstract generalization or rely on shallow
heuristics when given CoT prompts. To understand the factors influencing CoT
reasoning we provide a detailed case study of the symbolic reasoning task of
decoding shift ciphers, where letters are shifted forward some number of steps
in the alphabet. GPT-4 achieves zero accuracy on most shift ciphers with
standard prompting, but with CoT its accuracy improves to an average of 32%. By
focusing on a single relatively simple task, we are able to identify three
factors that systematically affect CoT performance: the probability of the
task's expected output (probability), what the model has implicitly learned
during pre-training (memorization), and the number of intermediate operations
involved in reasoning (noisy reasoning). We show that these factors can
drastically influence the task accuracy; e.g., varying the output's probability
of occurrence can shift accuracy from 26% to 70%. We also demonstrate that it
is essential for the model to explicitly produce intermediate steps as output
that can be conditioned on to increase the probability of the correct answer.
Our experiments indicate that as long as the model does so, the validity of the
demonstrations in the prompt does not matter. Overall, we conclude that CoT
prompting performance reflects both memorization and a probabilistic version of
genuine reasoning. | [
-0.2377359271,
-0.9373810887,
1.0946968794,
0.1503436714,
-0.4050060511,
0.2224679589,
-0.1481394917,
-0.5315984488,
-0.1346201599,
0.2683548331,
-0.5497819185,
-0.4363441169,
-0.830535531,
0.2787418365,
-0.5095125437,
0.9175872207,
-0.2312068194,
-0.047574982,
0.3102657199,
0.297906667,
-0.4500554204,
-0.8492703438,
-0.638620913,
-0.3653080463,
0.486437887,
0.1633188277,
0.7636981606,
0.3990931213,
0.4792176783,
0.2599099874,
-0.1533221453,
0.041794043,
-0.4744489491,
0.2036819756,
-0.2748117745,
-0.881082058,
-0.2318540365,
0.0005753879,
0.5503262877,
0.4478084445,
-0.1749139279,
-0.0845161602,
0.0321505256,
0.7408066392,
-0.6779102087,
0.0675605983,
-0.8448883891,
-0.1705050766,
-0.0259997752,
-0.2982695103,
-0.5406474471,
-0.296433866,
0.1658218503,
-0.7046647072,
0.270508498,
0.0276242997,
0.3909211457,
0.0983083174,
-0.4061378241,
-0.7321998477,
-0.8987182379,
0.7645279765,
-0.3773844242,
0.4625180066,
0.6206912994,
-0.226408422,
-0.4231197834,
-0.6388959289,
-0.5335590839,
-0.2211179286,
0.2050938904,
-0.0461372361,
0.0271778256,
0.322545141,
0.677565515,
0.3210663497,
-0.0503190458,
-0.4264254868,
-0.5581579804,
-0.2125247866,
0.3538209796,
0.236994803,
0.278583318,
0.2798810005,
-0.2448412925,
-0.2747144401,
-0.6664016247,
0.1499549598,
0.500702858,
0.1343912035,
0.0158896688,
0.3724325895,
0.030253958,
0.7007934451,
0.3238244951,
-0.086807549,
-0.0498812012,
-0.5823856592,
-0.169515714,
0.2658308744,
0.53629601,
-0.0220917277,
0.4397332966,
-0.0321307294,
-0.2757948637,
0.2823213339,
0.5307163596,
-0.5464627743,
-0.3814767003,
0.1026774421,
-0.1721540391,
-0.2669799626,
0.1391523629,
-0.4063590169,
-0.0971828625,
-0.4109288454,
0.3568587601,
-0.5945063829,
-0.1437295228,
0.2671064138,
-0.3090875149,
0.0303303432,
0.3844956756,
-0.8362608552,
0.4475434124,
0.6990460157,
0.753012538,
-0.094441466,
-0.3009201884,
-0.382112056,
0.1143554673,
-0.750888586,
0.6785266399,
-0.7340224981,
-0.1781351417,
-0.0641879961,
-0.109731622,
-0.3623846173,
-0.1830996722,
0.3578764796,
-0.5531398654,
-0.01007686,
-0.7362001538,
-0.5048887134,
-0.0343338251,
0.1144010127,
-0.665515244,
0.8795809746,
0.0164953321,
-0.6038460732,
0.4451876283,
-0.3044728637,
-0.4824509025,
-0.2805982828,
-0.3864025474,
-0.0166394729,
0.3500320911,
0.2587492168,
0.0672199205,
-0.3446249664,
0.0791190341,
0.0644908324,
-0.610096693,
0.7554438114,
-0.5533480644,
0.5794765353,
0.1781945676,
-0.6072318554,
-0.1567274034,
-0.4777163267,
0.0982551202,
-0.1385196298,
-0.1779789776,
-0.2021009624,
-0.0002956805,
-0.5685418248,
0.3784498572,
-0.1190419421,
-0.2848146856,
0.2074583024,
-0.2588575184,
0.2877132893,
0.8405560255,
0.4345778823,
0.3624182642,
-0.3057568967,
0.7573105097,
0.1801145822,
0.27412799,
-0.0653194934,
-0.8350109458,
-0.3998757899,
-0.0945404693,
0.2578390241,
0.2957975566,
-0.8166510463,
-0.1157865375,
0.2097877711,
-0.1946104169,
-0.4537731409,
0.1849744171,
0.5463475585,
0.3213296533,
0.3288908005,
-0.3268109262,
-0.2775217593,
-0.4519847035,
-0.3423441648,
-0.4119102061,
0.2227219939,
-0.1810360998,
0.4178085625,
0.1263092756,
0.3590310812,
-0.4872931242,
0.0096763745,
-0.311301738,
0.3947718441,
0.4270194173,
0.248459816,
0.1149639487,
-0.4947249293,
-0.1388357282,
-0.3346564472,
-0.4779817164,
0.0296764262,
-0.3767095506,
-0.376814872,
0.2876903713,
0.6052168608,
-0.6363526583,
0.7637715936,
0.2931435406,
-0.3672279119,
0.8975529671,
-0.3818235099,
0.394003123,
-0.5788128376,
-0.2220113426,
-0.2593887746,
0.2023225427,
-0.630256772,
0.2440350801,
-0.0166481547,
0.1918800175,
-0.3540000021,
0.0138196219,
-0.584202826,
-0.0343259685,
-0.1906670779,
0.1880959272,
-0.0416862704,
0.5160861015,
0.1369045675,
0.9441201687,
0.4777944088,
-0.8319280148,
-0.066624932,
-0.0832574442,
-0.3565968871,
0.1745868176,
-0.5974729657,
0.420422852,
0.1903788447,
0.2554356158,
-1.0524830818,
0.2287942022,
0.1776432693,
-0.2003507763,
-0.0307468995,
0.0699975342,
-0.4734539986,
-0.446577251,
-0.2426002324,
0.5563165545,
0.550778985,
-0.2794780135,
0.5075847507,
-0.1025920734,
0.2192477733,
-0.6819939613,
-0.4939966202,
-0.1087774336,
0.1331487894,
-0.1808072478,
0.2432751209,
-0.0669392571,
-0.38602373,
-0.2289970964,
-0.6571864486,
-0.0080196317,
-0.0483211204,
0.1332049072,
0.2950044274,
0.0952208042,
0.1945360005,
0.027148895,
-0.0629880726,
0.5109072924,
-0.47054708,
0.6873135567,
-0.2425240278,
-0.4073779881,
-0.4233044684,
0.0257051066,
0.6382223964,
0.0198969562,
0.7216066122,
0.4071345329,
-0.1192600578,
-0.242550537,
-0.4939232767,
-0.4120118916,
-0.4622593224,
0.1181092784,
-0.7914620042,
-0.4081687927,
0.536922276,
-0.0545345396,
-0.1584947854,
0.2306455076,
0.5265837312,
-0.1895858049,
1.1031855345,
0.2658367157,
0.0871873423,
0.4643335342,
-0.3795262873,
0.4203002155,
-1.0243725777,
-0.1782778054,
-0.3607432246,
-0.3365497291,
-0.6108548045,
-0.5522502661,
0.3365891278,
0.2986954749,
-0.2392428815,
0.20890297,
-0.6128287315,
0.5511037707,
0.4509097636,
0.4138269424,
0.363853395,
-0.0622952022,
-0.4780823588,
0.4068796635,
-0.7396849394,
-0.3868289292,
1.1892228127,
0.1714982688,
1.0991002321,
0.0323561281,
0.7822425365,
0.2341496199,
-0.2968847156,
-0.4823190272,
0.6440104246,
0.2057949603,
-0.5298072696,
-0.3546614945,
-0.2399431765,
-1.0538860559,
-0.0157061759,
-0.1060896814,
-0.8310878873,
0.3010233939,
0.2421863377,
-0.255913794,
0.299687475,
-0.6155969501,
0.2909594774,
-0.1760172248,
-0.3369284272,
-0.4857192338,
-0.4876977801,
0.3310637474,
-0.0455671437,
0.1203324869,
0.1721629798,
-0.0547427125,
0.8450505137,
-0.3300185204,
0.789031446,
0.0303133689,
-0.2600690424,
0.6579419971,
0.4235625267,
0.8774511218,
-0.0752419904,
-0.0068614637,
0.2143759727,
0.0748585314,
-0.2453563362,
-0.8548550606,
0.4124875665,
-0.8025406599,
-0.9575279355,
-0.5939713717,
-0.7030118704,
-0.19050318,
-0.1822886765,
0.4375083148,
0.5282829404,
0.0538533591,
0.0129010556,
0.8468888402,
0.0773326531,
0.263327539,
0.0585534088,
-0.293903321,
-0.2118639946,
0.613078773,
0.1974991262,
0.8408414125,
0.2864691019,
0.1920144111,
-0.4035006166,
-0.5332784653,
-0.1959867626,
0.0837919265,
-1.0562838316,
0.090492107,
-0.5527751446,
-0.1737781465,
-0.1448187828,
-0.2737818658,
-0.1274261177,
-0.512442708,
-0.0775567219,
-0.2811799347,
0.3508031666,
0.9449723363,
0.1617187411,
0.1123259515,
-0.2756449282,
0.4523447156,
0.370778352,
0.0753649399,
0.2490566075,
-0.447227031,
-0.0430240184,
0.1184917167,
-0.4032315016,
-0.9911814332,
-0.1424011439,
-0.2817736864,
0.5296449065,
0.4098220468,
0.0695575252,
0.7679063678,
-0.2128034383,
0.9181358814,
0.336586386,
-1.1807973385,
0.5241401792,
-0.1252563298,
0.5347535014,
0.3823070228,
0.3512123525,
-0.0901671275,
-0.9248073101,
-0.8211457133,
-0.5814322829,
0.6391530037,
0.4725714624,
-0.2849713862,
-0.3849398792,
0.2788257897,
-0.0186209977,
0.0401804745,
-0.5277777314,
-0.0440932475,
-0.0032568385,
0.0058784191,
0.1624564379,
-0.1112396643,
-0.0164561849,
-0.3460997045,
0.5416701436,
0.0459330045,
0.5712768435,
0.5234206915,
-0.2160585225,
-0.1833122522,
0.3669172823,
0.890007019,
1.0947086811,
-0.1132675111,
0.3389945328,
0.4231692851,
-0.8152313828,
0.348739028,
-0.560526669,
-0.1015893295,
-0.048869811,
0.7262925506,
0.7681711912,
0.1700045913,
-0.2821179926,
0.2801502347,
-0.0179668777,
-0.3509787619,
-0.0349071734,
0.4797758162,
-0.1723356396,
0.0846966654,
0.4192499816,
0.1976220906,
0.1417953074,
-0.8947780728,
-0.0135974968,
0.2286697328,
-0.1856192648,
-0.3949265778,
0.5576377511,
-0.08728306,
-0.4558729231,
0.7977129817,
-0.2196261883,
-0.8049893975,
0.7962161303,
0.8622624874,
0.8541355729,
-0.3094716072,
0.2186010033,
0.365139544,
0.5946043134,
-0.3516985178,
0.5852187276,
-0.3185769022,
-0.604567647,
-0.4742929637,
-0.2086366266,
-0.3167559505,
-0.1013337597,
-0.7520645857,
0.1165613979,
-0.5197947025,
-0.4437847435,
-0.28758955,
-0.072574921,
-0.9386737347,
0.2422041595,
0.0492474735,
0.9407832026,
-0.6656538248,
0.7832511067,
0.1886721998,
-0.3862791061,
-1.0754051208,
0.3078873158,
-0.1767223775,
-0.9592025876,
0.7412651777,
-0.1184810102,
-0.4753157496,
-0.1871367246,
-0.4095537364,
-0.9746329784,
0.9203989506,
0.2199829221,
-0.9404524565,
-0.164080143,
0.1210396439,
0.5808156729,
-0.4440606236,
0.4669395685,
0.6706050038,
0.4281575978,
0.2441953421,
-0.8623750806,
0.3617328107,
0.2157850116,
0.1344925761,
0.434204191,
-0.2497998923,
0.8672339916,
-0.6711992025,
-0.1249702722,
-0.231846258,
0.353158325,
0.5771797299,
0.2941557765,
0.4923206866,
0.3450246453,
0.973216176,
-0.02475187,
1.2434434891,
-0.4126126766,
-0.1409345269,
1.015103817,
-0.2404103428,
0.8014181852,
0.6827620864,
-0.2759740055,
0.9885274172,
0.3167473972,
0.2778996825,
0.6704823971,
0.3764870167,
-0.2166619748,
-0.1615691185,
0.3559855223,
-0.3806051612,
0.1915147752,
0.5264242291,
-0.6099886298,
0.1489208639,
-0.0968417227,
-0.1632571369,
-0.1798708141,
-0.5242409706,
0.6927319765,
0.1464375407,
-1.033115983,
0.7149851322,
-0.3430776894,
0.1044396535,
-0.6143330336,
-0.1241615117,
0.2194940448,
0.1213777661,
-0.0760546252,
-0.9554032683,
0.1627281904,
-0.1632979214,
-0.2607125044,
-0.0909663588,
0.6344710588,
-0.2761540115,
-0.531347096,
0.2224387079,
0.4655744135,
0.2711331844,
-0.1151473969,
-0.5985510945,
0.4244688153,
0.011087995,
-0.2880587578,
0.226683706,
0.7154656053,
-0.3363339603,
0.5300791264,
0.817569077,
0.2397525758,
0.0878532678,
0.2781937718,
0.8159758449,
-0.8126799464,
-0.5626297593,
-1.0418277979,
0.2262430042,
0.0124810599,
-0.3550720811,
0.5735241771,
0.1920038313,
0.6220244765,
-0.0959754959,
0.5992529392,
0.2170588672,
-0.2781387568,
-0.770942688,
0.2272840887,
0.2195165753,
0.3851261735,
-0.4766099453,
-0.9419987798,
0.2273924053,
0.5879135728,
-0.6356241107,
0.1810083836,
1.5075984001,
0.6991533041,
0.3116095364,
0.4374683499,
0.3498365879,
0.2164548784,
0.2870834768,
0.8683636189,
0.9742738008,
-0.448510766,
0.6236070395,
-0.1945202351,
-0.2422120422,
0.1722748727,
-0.8563872576,
-1.0690248013,
-0.7067610621,
-0.4436410666,
-0.4566488862,
0.4060621858,
0.9186279178,
0.4365500212,
-0.6707741022,
-0.1578999609,
-0.6996625066,
0.3328112066,
-0.7273973823,
-0.1620418429,
0.3559314907,
-0.6299437284,
-0.2454213798,
0.124567993,
0.1912795752,
-0.0240354594,
0.0644436851,
-0.0277615208,
-0.2143838108,
0.401545614,
0.6115120053,
-0.1120692939,
-1.0803780556,
-0.1974057704,
0.0925989598,
0.0089777038,
-0.0813151971,
1.0678658485,
-0.8474459052,
0.3921354711,
0.3338558376,
0.1646691412,
0.6175570488,
0.0533620864,
0.7965790629,
-0.492231369,
-0.0878653079,
0.0900086462,
0.2173237503,
-0.186329022,
-0.730999887,
0.5459727049,
0.2387095243,
-0.6817346215,
-0.5589946508,
0.1967321932,
-0.7100196481,
-0.4362421036,
1.2653942108,
0.0168369394,
-0.3773860633,
-0.3029523492,
-0.3526368141,
0.1503367871,
-0.4724561572,
0.9686071873,
1.1495605707,
-0.4117545485,
-0.2158206403,
-0.2669955492,
0.5981579423,
0.3044171929,
-0.3164632618,
0.1834588945,
0.2268660367,
0.1269019842,
0.243894428,
0.7663451433,
-0.0708232298,
0.5590133667,
0.2972604036,
-0.2267751247,
0.0385504365,
-0.5618923306,
-0.1976522058,
0.1981944442,
0.1512786746,
-0.1211497709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01527v1 | KV Cache Compression, But What Must We Give in Return? A Comprehensive Benchmark of Long Context Capable Approaches | 2024-07-01T17:59:47 | 2024-07-01T17:59:47 | Jiayi Yuan, Hongyi Liu, Shaochen, Zhong, Yu-Neng Chuang, Songchen Li, Guanchu Wang, Duy Le, Hongye Jin, Vipin Chaudhary, Zhaozhuo Xu, Zirui Liu, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long context capability is a crucial competency for large language models
(LLMs) as it mitigates the human struggle to digest long-form texts. This
capability enables complex task-solving scenarios such as book summarization,
code assistance, and many more tasks that are traditionally manpower-intensive.
However, transformer-based LLMs face significant challenges with long context
input due to the growing size of the KV cache and the intrinsic complexity of
attending to extended inputs; where multiple schools of efficiency-driven
approaches -- such as KV cache quantization, token dropping, prompt
compression, linear-time sequence models, and hybrid architectures -- have been
proposed to produce efficient yet long context-capable models. Despite these
advancements, no existing work has comprehensively benchmarked these methods in
a reasonably aligned environment. In this work, we fill this gap by providing a
taxonomy of current methods and evaluating 10+ state-of-the-art approaches
across seven categories of long context tasks. Our work reveals numerous
previously unknown phenomena and offers insights -- as well as a friendly
workbench -- for the future development of long context-capable LLMs. The
source code will be available at https://github.com/henryzhongsc/longctx_bench | [
-0.3815445304,
-0.2816128433,
0.6299430728,
0.5921335816,
-0.2524296045,
-0.0208491404,
-0.5948925614,
-0.4863611162,
-0.024590835,
0.4302581251,
-0.4333750308,
-0.2933328748,
-0.4950295985,
0.154359743,
-0.6312609315,
0.5458236933,
-0.2752271593,
-0.1527662128,
-0.6310395598,
-0.1739666611,
-0.8063833117,
-0.6442214251,
-0.2545833886,
-0.274153322,
0.4093125165,
0.3097194433,
0.0311902799,
0.3608820736,
0.3575959504,
0.2182167917,
-0.1658257693,
-0.0769747943,
-0.5822268724,
0.5170537233,
-0.037898805,
-0.280367285,
-0.4919192791,
-0.4338417351,
0.8185390234,
0.540145576,
-0.0848978385,
0.2695278823,
0.2795157731,
0.8668670058,
-1.0288760662,
0.225975737,
-0.4078506231,
-0.1664358824,
-0.4136927426,
0.0058746631,
-0.6441944242,
-0.0519769453,
-0.0803721249,
-0.3291093111,
-0.100581333,
-0.2685536444,
0.4183367789,
0.5518316627,
-0.6574434042,
-0.0608778484,
-0.8948696256,
0.8909075856,
-0.4901075959,
0.6209543347,
0.2891812027,
0.6012986302,
-0.2540242374,
-1.134860754,
-0.54864043,
-0.0384042934,
0.0629028678,
0.2699928284,
-0.0966368169,
-0.0002420359,
0.1741488576,
0.3942192793,
-0.2660523057,
0.2006797194,
-0.1096416414,
-0.2035993338,
0.2095137835,
0.1097934023,
-0.1773953587,
-0.2437227964,
-0.5876598954,
-0.328840822,
-0.7722585797,
0.3226456642,
0.0378549136,
0.0529662967,
-0.1059222743,
0.3619225621,
-0.6178466082,
0.67324543,
-0.3229532838,
0.1583154947,
0.0112256994,
-0.2809064984,
-0.2154278606,
-0.1163636968,
0.4993329048,
0.3598894775,
0.0510839745,
-0.4047150612,
-0.3966016173,
0.0481885783,
0.387186259,
-0.8593921661,
0.1851840466,
0.2357681841,
-0.3308024108,
-0.1527356058,
-0.1289754808,
-0.9649606943,
-0.2475474626,
-0.278182596,
0.3731015325,
0.0408567227,
-0.0191551223,
0.2247800827,
-0.1503216326,
0.4144554138,
0.1990813166,
-0.6800496578,
0.5462237,
0.9105271697,
0.7301519513,
-0.6182415485,
-0.1071744263,
-0.6232939959,
0.0728487447,
-0.0465809032,
0.7339574099,
-0.4349163175,
-0.5504829288,
0.2462779284,
0.1856992692,
0.2630565763,
-0.4926466644,
1.0009064674,
-0.5866222978,
-0.1529241353,
-0.674911499,
-0.4899396896,
0.0544050112,
0.3118522465,
-0.8666527271,
1.2393574715,
0.3614293635,
-0.4889858961,
0.2251046449,
-0.3850535154,
-0.4162078798,
0.1146670282,
-0.0632132515,
-0.155687198,
0.3304084837,
0.1380189806,
0.6066736579,
-0.5820098519,
0.4012481272,
-0.1783443391,
-0.294708848,
0.1943788826,
-0.5163171887,
0.2823279798,
0.018307792,
-0.430601269,
0.1398479789,
-0.8106490374,
0.0982542038,
0.0915834233,
-0.4150085449,
-0.2706497014,
0.1213483065,
0.2250341028,
0.3194579184,
0.3412739336,
-0.4282890558,
0.3352095187,
-0.0567113385,
0.607087791,
0.8058905602,
-0.398475945,
0.3029046357,
-0.1057864279,
0.3566842675,
-0.1314778328,
0.0568264015,
-0.2724156678,
0.0312423706,
-0.9252432585,
-0.1460922211,
0.3577162027,
0.2391734868,
-0.7530068755,
0.2853190601,
-0.970185101,
-0.5036950111,
-0.1198838875,
-0.0359333716,
0.3840168715,
0.6611361504,
0.4609194696,
-0.5000883341,
-0.4357345402,
-0.9929252863,
-0.0943240747,
0.020123953,
-0.0289456081,
0.4549574554,
0.529071331,
-0.053304892,
1.0780377388,
-0.2985805571,
0.0569638647,
0.0872003287,
0.0160617586,
0.0977171585,
0.3497183919,
0.3489680886,
-0.7861075401,
-0.2355383933,
-0.2011298239,
-0.5909022093,
-0.1521232277,
0.0596699975,
0.0390321091,
0.2837738097,
0.6327245235,
-0.792791903,
0.4207958281,
0.6248750687,
0.1013084352,
0.8115085363,
-0.0887104347,
0.0178199988,
-1.0497778654,
0.4302106798,
-0.2257211208,
-0.420641005,
-0.516059339,
0.2713179886,
0.4665493071,
0.0362319946,
-0.5093004107,
0.7164446115,
-0.3818976581,
-0.2283552736,
-0.3949012756,
-0.1537887603,
-0.1315557361,
0.4788745642,
0.1110354736,
0.8605494499,
0.172765553,
-0.6055204868,
0.423617661,
-0.1496168822,
-0.4462301135,
0.3580985665,
-0.8693611622,
0.2348069102,
0.0070293956,
0.8606193662,
-0.8972212672,
-0.1954238713,
-0.0963432044,
-0.1491415203,
0.5503908992,
-0.1120046377,
-0.7274933457,
-0.5538369417,
-0.3156116009,
0.8746282458,
0.6414117813,
-0.7199702859,
0.517801702,
0.0413894802,
-0.0018271693,
-0.8009558916,
-0.4811845124,
0.2983394265,
-0.1776423007,
-0.5431720018,
0.6739851236,
-0.2113144845,
0.0534412153,
-0.3157533705,
-0.4481540322,
0.0423470214,
0.1287102997,
0.2850348055,
-0.0368064754,
-0.1913579255,
0.2831503451,
-0.1329668909,
-0.3058580756,
0.1690500677,
-0.2924287617,
0.7097380161,
-0.2302209139,
-0.3530303836,
-0.1273003519,
0.4231270254,
0.7737826109,
-0.0351201259,
0.4435912073,
0.5663615465,
-0.3869892955,
-0.1720992178,
-0.7174602151,
-0.0632515177,
-0.4532495737,
0.3795884848,
-0.132143572,
-1.0872400999,
0.6203483939,
-0.3075709045,
0.0378399491,
0.4723314643,
0.6753643155,
0.2793046236,
0.5023761988,
0.5961126685,
-0.4380060434,
0.126894176,
-0.0095393825,
0.0487651974,
-0.8486732841,
-0.1891086996,
-0.7442598939,
-0.3055785,
-0.4989126027,
-0.5757884383,
0.3253364563,
0.0453993753,
-0.0549093261,
0.3794398904,
-0.4596058726,
0.3993107975,
0.4175609052,
-0.2056413442,
0.1162737012,
-0.3324164152,
0.05448227,
0.1126369312,
-0.4095981121,
-0.1991531998,
0.9018902779,
0.3469792902,
0.6573373079,
0.0989221409,
0.5462834239,
0.2667741776,
0.1631445885,
-1.0082309246,
0.5582612157,
0.1258471757,
-0.3320361078,
-0.1961721778,
-0.2495243847,
-0.9934668541,
-0.0642891452,
0.0517336056,
-0.7790882587,
0.0091714226,
-0.0302035287,
-0.0114981001,
0.0540946685,
-0.3820797503,
0.7497606874,
-0.0556369014,
-0.5828224421,
-0.2249919176,
-0.8878161907,
0.1829991341,
-0.0992015228,
-0.0031556764,
0.2151906043,
-0.1788834184,
0.6491965055,
-0.2802542448,
0.8039616346,
0.0322777666,
-0.2156053782,
0.0587308593,
-0.0304350331,
0.782212019,
-0.08645235,
0.1420590878,
0.0804687068,
0.0150486398,
-0.5904785991,
-0.638005197,
0.8737774491,
-0.4638086557,
-0.4484848678,
-0.2520721853,
-0.4295736849,
-0.4049540758,
0.3498687744,
0.2541539669,
0.5470009446,
-0.1951008141,
0.5030733943,
0.5975266695,
0.0172687937,
0.8311433792,
0.2083968073,
-0.0169075821,
-0.3660971522,
0.7609107494,
-0.0861132964,
0.1407000124,
0.5016697645,
-0.0343203358,
-0.2134759575,
-0.6172677875,
-0.177102074,
0.0521914102,
-0.9427239895,
-0.4796853065,
-0.4457998574,
-0.2340743244,
-0.3773326576,
-0.1167557314,
-0.624327302,
-0.3811551929,
-0.1335623264,
0.2561687827,
-0.0387790874,
0.5881965756,
0.4778033793,
0.2472099364,
-0.8612269163,
0.0695799813,
0.366222918,
0.5420730114,
0.310498327,
-0.0642132908,
-0.3796027601,
-0.1432675421,
-0.3552388549,
-0.459041059,
0.1746252179,
-0.1060250923,
0.3944485784,
0.0837466791,
0.2989107966,
0.7290909886,
-0.4947231412,
1.033692956,
-0.0071714334,
-0.9305554032,
0.1236402541,
-0.1494174898,
0.5167381763,
0.5195428729,
0.2771312296,
-0.6866819263,
0.1608890146,
-0.3914987743,
-1.1711294651,
0.1751886457,
0.3692396879,
0.1366400719,
-0.1435547322,
0.3747767806,
0.1722832918,
0.2088177651,
-0.6165391207,
-0.0365214348,
0.0076192883,
-0.0811749622,
-0.1335050017,
-0.4218970537,
-0.0771265402,
-0.0479608253,
0.4320259988,
-0.1850827336,
0.2792342305,
0.2423132062,
-0.3376422524,
0.1779610515,
0.5882618427,
0.958322823,
0.5469546914,
-0.1355890036,
0.1396280378,
0.2282545716,
-0.439112246,
-0.00506842,
0.0684968084,
0.2795631588,
-0.1973209083,
0.3484245837,
0.5277708769,
0.4362754226,
-0.6622154117,
0.6611760259,
-0.3815465569,
0.0145679107,
-0.4565865397,
-0.221739307,
0.059596125,
0.1181129441,
0.5599493384,
-0.2536238432,
0.0689086542,
-0.2354076952,
-0.0223501138,
0.4022371471,
-0.374522537,
-0.417270571,
0.2874804735,
0.36000067,
-0.0929812267,
0.6485093236,
0.1775584966,
-0.5626969337,
0.375169158,
0.6029976606,
0.9051654935,
0.2101448923,
-0.4835145175,
0.1338236481,
0.0437102839,
-0.3403325677,
-0.1395344436,
-0.6634876132,
-0.2041504234,
-0.7729018927,
-0.7102986574,
-0.2390296757,
0.2942622602,
-0.8335826397,
0.2651628852,
0.09963011,
-0.0845009089,
-0.1730099171,
0.0683171377,
-0.724390626,
-0.0987352431,
0.0671508089,
1.3733767271,
-0.4732068479,
0.8218976855,
0.313228786,
0.2052570879,
-0.3994284868,
-0.0270840842,
-0.207352221,
-0.6319742799,
0.663177669,
0.4116698802,
-0.1814409941,
-0.1442725211,
-0.5248793364,
-0.758210361,
1.2723850012,
0.2439127117,
-0.6214065552,
-0.2711661458,
0.086080417,
0.3844480813,
-0.1013156399,
0.0342551433,
0.5088124275,
0.514220953,
-0.0512498096,
-1.0427250862,
0.1873256266,
-0.2469016612,
0.1572215855,
0.5950236917,
-0.6348494887,
0.3230542243,
0.2971829176,
-0.1842530668,
0.450766474,
0.8311154246,
-0.0424807332,
0.2860582173,
0.5217080712,
0.7016367912,
0.3547398746,
-0.0108415149,
1.1435580254,
-0.4739770591,
0.3747805655,
0.978402555,
-0.2712628245,
1.0467472076,
0.7615372539,
-0.1450656801,
0.3313273787,
0.5168558955,
0.213897571,
0.4560257196,
0.3490765095,
-0.4667122364,
-0.266507268,
-0.2727203667,
-0.4974065423,
0.3697144687,
0.3015106618,
-0.0569854081,
-0.2380928993,
-0.1870276183,
-0.1465023309,
-0.2307585925,
-0.1403245926,
0.6072095633,
0.1755560189,
-1.00593853,
0.6373136044,
-0.1184445992,
0.7102142572,
-0.6064173579,
0.0732466578,
-0.0222160872,
-0.01872034,
0.0490834452,
-0.6807148457,
0.0482864603,
-0.2017900944,
-0.3218521774,
-0.3050280511,
0.8223409057,
-0.0873100907,
-0.0410403572,
0.2468606979,
0.4280843735,
-0.0567157939,
-0.0162198413,
-0.0072368439,
0.2868615091,
-0.4681338668,
-0.3064059615,
0.6141076088,
0.1683614999,
-0.2358386368,
0.6273660064,
0.4955206513,
-0.0272305887,
-0.1656349003,
0.0427608676,
1.0410974026,
-0.7361950278,
-0.2911611199,
-0.8360624909,
0.5458520651,
-0.081716463,
-0.2832625508,
0.4817066491,
0.5172230005,
0.7678557038,
0.1218839139,
0.4658833742,
0.1323302239,
-0.0783702806,
-0.5927019715,
0.5003675818,
-0.5553515553,
0.117247276,
-0.1562615335,
-0.9590771198,
-0.1491636038,
-0.0575613305,
0.1338775009,
0.1043259203,
0.6910133958,
0.4049538672,
-0.1975928098,
-0.1310098618,
0.212506786,
0.0431377068,
0.4857484996,
0.6928458214,
0.7408171892,
-0.3368989825,
0.5604453087,
-0.3227012753,
-0.0331335738,
-0.426453948,
-1.3875755072,
-0.5164804459,
-0.9120382667,
0.0477578007,
-0.3784435689,
0.0072316453,
0.7233933806,
0.8706063032,
-0.2866851091,
-0.1897738129,
-0.1114516407,
-0.0494412445,
-0.13856785,
-0.1631739885,
0.4196792245,
-0.213853538,
-0.5204012394,
0.3657453656,
0.3502436578,
0.0640741438,
-0.2871855497,
-0.0986143947,
0.426338166,
-0.197095722,
0.8442533612,
0.4164506197,
-0.7401641607,
-0.4122956395,
0.2190873474,
-0.1025510579,
0.0793616325,
1.0781365633,
-1.073327899,
0.5169930458,
0.5908968449,
0.951902926,
0.677105248,
-0.1711630672,
0.585195601,
-0.9376749396,
0.0047815628,
0.4064526856,
0.4672658145,
0.2550520599,
-0.1052000448,
0.4945910573,
0.0442786142,
-0.9117074013,
-1.1440768242,
0.2336314917,
-1.5493766069,
-0.0997336432,
1.1356312037,
-0.0541548729,
-0.5516073108,
0.1781268269,
0.1220687702,
0.3542841971,
-0.3699616194,
0.8081881404,
1.0336900949,
0.1683055013,
-0.0602354333,
-0.5820692778,
0.388694346,
0.4628075957,
-0.8211158514,
0.476117909,
0.3931623101,
0.0328940004,
0.1395594776,
0.4432805777,
-0.0682476014,
0.4518887699,
-0.337874949,
0.0581969693,
-0.047929652,
-0.278105408,
-0.5824361444,
0.1009394303,
0.0837189555,
0.1665199399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01525v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01525v2 | Empowering 3D Visual Grounding with Reasoning Capabilities | 2024-07-01T17:59:35 | 2024-07-02T07:37:56 | Chenming Zhu, Tai Wang, Wenwei Zhang, Kai Chen, Xihui Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Although great progress has been made in 3D visual grounding, current models
still rely on explicit textual descriptions for grounding and lack the ability
to reason human intentions from implicit instructions. We propose a new task
called 3D reasoning grounding and introduce a new benchmark ScanReason which
provides over 10K question-answer-location pairs from five reasoning types that
require the synerization of reasoning and grounding. We further design our
approach, ReGround3D, composed of the visual-centric reasoning module empowered
by Multi-modal Large Language Model (MLLM) and the 3D grounding module to
obtain accurate object locations by looking back to the enhanced geometry and
fine-grained details from the 3D scenes. A chain-of-grounding mechanism is
proposed to further boost the performance with interleaved reasoning and
grounding steps during inference. Extensive experiments on the proposed
benchmark validate the effectiveness of our proposed approach. | [
-0.7165827751,
-0.7675870657,
0.9318073392,
0.3479924798,
-0.273817122,
-0.3846591115,
0.1585982591,
-0.4477874637,
-0.3078134358,
0.4732712507,
-0.3806363642,
-0.6161616445,
-0.2386682928,
0.1056916192,
-0.1967818737,
0.1798592359,
-0.2754777372,
0.0971027687,
-0.7115274072,
-0.2582823634,
-0.6063495278,
-0.79469347,
-0.2848749161,
0.0148383705,
0.3611502647,
0.5097759366,
0.6928631067,
0.7328150868,
0.493299067,
0.2495205849,
-0.2013265043,
0.4227286875,
-0.2208560854,
0.0605140999,
-0.4165577292,
-0.5320777893,
-0.2837085426,
0.0073800725,
0.4054423273,
0.6451776624,
0.1351493299,
-0.1435771435,
-0.2238249034,
0.9165976048,
-0.8479821086,
0.0103852749,
-0.1024535671,
0.1147103235,
0.1561243832,
-0.3075277209,
-0.1761036813,
-0.1587679535,
-0.0219432507,
-0.7200836539,
0.4123945832,
0.1775573343,
0.6720220447,
0.4434248805,
-0.1555841714,
0.2722102404,
-0.428648293,
0.4755482972,
-0.5068593025,
0.7664744258,
0.3788733184,
0.6243898869,
0.0726088285,
-0.475861758,
-0.3396768272,
-0.23311387,
0.0527528711,
0.3126954436,
0.2814716697,
0.1886286139,
0.6496129632,
0.3351309001,
-0.3423059285,
-0.2416413426,
-0.0792832002,
-0.0188419726,
0.3596599996,
-0.0501402803,
0.1704452634,
-0.111380145,
-0.5442311168,
-0.3281021416,
-0.4677180648,
0.2456915677,
0.1608420461,
0.0455440283,
-0.1198270693,
0.9447686076,
-0.6984478235,
0.8498140574,
0.0574702509,
0.1639525145,
0.019877037,
-0.2527728081,
-0.3171620369,
-0.0055566602,
0.3411331177,
0.9812405705,
0.1442171782,
-0.0874976516,
-0.0883721411,
-0.0037469566,
0.3227618337,
-0.7149379849,
-0.1087309346,
0.3929067254,
-0.5873629451,
0.1146959066,
0.2060718387,
-0.6822165251,
-0.703351438,
-0.4215874374,
0.1763066351,
-0.6273856759,
-0.4144399166,
0.5602732301,
-0.4402594566,
0.3268939257,
0.8034344316,
-0.6267832518,
0.0256891027,
0.7249159217,
0.8438176513,
0.0549439564,
-0.4405503273,
-0.3035974801,
0.3873507679,
-0.3418723941,
1.0610667467,
-0.3300021291,
-0.2038488239,
-0.2363077402,
-0.0072255931,
0.2181823999,
-0.53137362,
0.4428817332,
-0.3764182627,
0.2378105819,
-0.5453785658,
-0.2038223445,
-0.6187198758,
0.7933659554,
-0.7289017439,
0.8094083071,
0.038990479,
-0.8902686238,
0.3874135315,
-0.1936361492,
-0.2513975203,
0.0004832672,
-0.6274608374,
-0.0637207478,
0.2010601461,
0.6377241611,
0.4694008827,
-0.4687723517,
0.3663553596,
-0.4804219007,
-0.5595529079,
-0.286659658,
-0.3762207925,
0.6528624892,
-0.0432504117,
-0.4155900478,
0.1768087298,
-0.7657578588,
-0.0496227965,
0.10273242,
-0.1515482664,
-0.2434893101,
0.0472749062,
-0.3222751915,
0.3719968796,
0.1719281375,
-0.2061301321,
-0.0085315444,
-0.2043537349,
-0.0975515991,
0.3965479434,
-0.0213278327,
0.4778151214,
-0.3335344791,
0.3477860391,
0.1007535234,
0.1016844958,
-0.2820589542,
-0.7178043127,
-0.5445149541,
-0.1310596913,
-0.3870482743,
0.6420298219,
-0.5646078587,
0.3027524352,
-0.2290682942,
-0.4286584854,
-0.2461057752,
-0.219245106,
0.4187871814,
0.7177363038,
0.6498246789,
0.4023943543,
-0.6168664694,
-1.1311591864,
-0.1312231719,
-0.2177725732,
-0.2163915336,
0.1498617381,
0.0904969722,
-0.0174238179,
0.9067545533,
-0.2096084207,
-0.0987574086,
-0.0837344527,
-0.1901214123,
0.0851642936,
0.6085859537,
0.4947578013,
-1.1722347736,
0.0568440072,
0.1022985429,
-1.2008639574,
-0.0390505418,
-0.0212104823,
-0.3726827204,
-0.1103990152,
1.0461200476,
-0.676657021,
0.3848429322,
0.3019053936,
-0.4136458635,
0.2957349718,
-0.0972539857,
0.4798053503,
-0.7407245636,
0.0513295531,
0.0276255216,
-0.0829635412,
-0.22761482,
0.1968783438,
-0.0423506163,
-0.2550964057,
-0.4777676761,
0.4856180549,
-0.5911560059,
-0.120449461,
-0.0318847671,
0.3410720825,
0.541592896,
0.4832456112,
0.5031534433,
0.499417305,
0.6078779697,
-0.574801445,
0.4492939711,
0.2516343892,
-0.3692990839,
0.7032746673,
-0.5482438803,
-0.1341822296,
-0.3201552033,
0.3602255881,
-1.0309840441,
-0.0912656784,
-0.0575195886,
-0.3024843037,
-0.3170088232,
-0.4778373539,
-0.5015128255,
-0.3344705999,
0.0044050482,
0.6077747345,
0.2377524674,
-0.7952153087,
0.91040802,
0.1216864809,
0.3658790588,
-0.3222110569,
-0.5417007804,
0.1033758,
-0.3534718454,
-1.0017962456,
0.1979979724,
0.1161125824,
-0.5398464799,
-0.1735253036,
-0.4106797576,
0.169982031,
0.1941761672,
0.4009242058,
-0.0022417181,
-0.3066146672,
-0.1631309092,
-0.1746175885,
-0.4958767295,
0.2491805851,
-0.2798249125,
0.2933349311,
-0.3350907862,
-0.6984382272,
-0.3126966953,
0.5406835675,
0.8348231316,
-0.1876115054,
0.3947630227,
0.5758882165,
-0.6895975471,
0.1539485753,
-0.8926691413,
-0.1325413138,
-0.4446713626,
0.2626428306,
-0.8029203415,
-0.7363841534,
0.3435671329,
-0.3832318783,
-0.0030863611,
0.2055637538,
0.2435666919,
-0.1191721633,
1.6365045309,
0.3333456516,
0.5211846232,
0.0765513107,
-0.2603997886,
0.1046836451,
-0.9168200493,
-0.6411656737,
-0.2807078958,
-0.150430128,
-0.100205265,
-0.7733799815,
0.2567989528,
0.9653394222,
-0.3169075847,
0.0056924168,
-0.4880685508,
0.450950861,
0.5930925012,
0.2196656018,
0.1779349744,
0.048446618,
-0.3439207077,
0.118051894,
-0.6976331472,
-0.4594906271,
0.256147325,
0.1705311537,
0.4405018985,
0.1153193787,
0.147042647,
-0.0678016096,
0.1202444956,
-0.4067957401,
0.7167317271,
0.0485931076,
-0.4202150404,
-0.219487533,
-0.2049211115,
-0.2357690334,
0.7490153313,
-0.2267834395,
-0.4977785647,
0.3599840701,
0.1766574681,
-0.3406445682,
0.4767112434,
-0.727442503,
0.9789681435,
-0.2250192165,
-0.6885418892,
-0.0800826177,
-0.6177853942,
0.4450798929,
0.6364790797,
0.2078225464,
-0.3741478324,
0.2374637872,
0.3434610963,
-0.4197937846,
0.5934147835,
-0.6152529716,
-0.3215785325,
0.2424892485,
0.1695919931,
0.373919785,
0.5504453182,
-0.1617067903,
0.2997093499,
-0.2670215368,
-0.3192004263,
-0.8181678057,
0.7414660454,
-0.3695129156,
-0.9538379312,
-0.1006257161,
-0.5325955749,
-0.5865585208,
0.4710967839,
0.3030681312,
0.3619474471,
-0.1079762951,
0.3767876923,
0.6191766858,
-0.1200491562,
0.0528173894,
0.1868787408,
-0.4166179597,
-0.5295586586,
0.5632415414,
-0.4337287545,
0.0359853469,
0.7713392377,
0.1913652122,
-0.5134819746,
-0.5762133598,
-0.6000161171,
-0.0732672065,
-0.9032515883,
-0.1636072397,
-0.8800574541,
0.0487726517,
-0.2872180641,
-0.7814115286,
-0.4759922624,
-0.3744454384,
-0.0777751878,
-0.4019060731,
0.2189363092,
0.328242898,
-0.1685739309,
-0.0400111489,
-0.6211687326,
0.9008764625,
0.5377410054,
0.53050071,
-0.1124709547,
-0.0918182284,
-0.1411792338,
0.3072611094,
0.3526138961,
-0.3309184015,
-0.1214747801,
-0.5938352346,
0.6649953127,
0.3301065564,
-0.1871604919,
1.117915988,
-0.4443402886,
0.6410171986,
0.3269637823,
-0.6173377633,
0.8874295354,
-0.4217918515,
0.4961093962,
0.5490546823,
-0.0033732615,
-0.2810319364,
-0.2577109635,
-0.3370549083,
-0.6252449155,
0.6217208505,
0.1088656634,
-0.4019147456,
-0.2653677166,
0.380364269,
-0.2070183009,
-0.2502191961,
-0.2971023023,
0.0860297084,
-0.5627193451,
0.2148482203,
-0.0016317819,
-0.3024592996,
-0.4055812359,
-0.3808179498,
0.1558029056,
-0.3428048491,
0.0230235979,
0.5316426158,
-0.1515540034,
0.1180332825,
-0.26615569,
0.5966172218,
0.698433876,
-0.4298936129,
0.4699530602,
0.2047130764,
-0.1308752447,
0.1829236001,
0.2007351816,
0.0243512932,
-0.1754771918,
0.4045206606,
0.7739453316,
0.1920388341,
-0.7038929462,
0.6439173818,
-0.1894254535,
-0.3563053906,
-0.270781219,
0.0818938315,
0.0973011777,
0.4764728844,
0.1362197697,
0.3127534688,
0.0481312498,
0.0770741105,
0.2171680927,
0.208999753,
-0.4550147653,
-0.0459935702,
1.0000948906,
0.1425645351,
0.0168497656,
0.5948169231,
0.1647341996,
-0.2410637587,
0.7028297782,
0.5759060979,
0.7856146097,
-0.0482742079,
0.0274632741,
0.6525610089,
0.3100813627,
-0.5470724106,
0.3896200657,
-0.1634298414,
-0.8732330799,
-0.3279953301,
-0.1437455416,
-0.327776432,
-0.0978930146,
-0.7335618138,
0.4609534144,
-0.6367595196,
0.1654984504,
-0.5221133232,
-0.4253304303,
-0.6209933162,
0.6009090543,
0.5371319056,
1.1210716963,
-0.5052253008,
0.2969664335,
0.9571425319,
-0.2738026083,
-0.2049082369,
-0.1530122161,
-0.0082129287,
-0.7553952336,
0.6285384297,
0.6922801137,
-0.6966066957,
0.0055972012,
-0.5588580966,
-0.8481323719,
1.2719604969,
0.2665091157,
-0.4783723652,
-0.0100705866,
-0.0655239001,
0.2292673588,
-0.3253912032,
0.2321099192,
0.3102404177,
0.5364087224,
0.1635069847,
-0.2785046995,
0.202165544,
-0.5512889624,
0.1393785328,
-0.1412265897,
-0.5700796843,
0.7270931602,
-0.2939206064,
-0.3980587423,
-0.1567537934,
0.7647954226,
0.8788677454,
0.1191089898,
0.7965100408,
0.9835412502,
0.4809495509,
-0.0232275445,
1.1226080656,
-0.2087959498,
-0.1838753819,
1.0955286026,
-0.3323249519,
0.4295580983,
0.4448269904,
0.2716189921,
0.4328359663,
0.3247958124,
0.1810171008,
0.592015326,
0.1097808778,
-0.1035575867,
-0.712808013,
0.0286484454,
-0.5667790771,
0.3626506031,
0.4991193712,
0.0608956888,
-0.3958490491,
0.1199320108,
-0.3054025173,
0.1991054416,
-0.2359033376,
0.5313969851,
-0.1186222658,
-0.6293621659,
0.5786895156,
-0.0591319315,
0.2021882385,
-0.2993823588,
-0.5415015817,
-0.3382463157,
0.1357624233,
-0.1035960689,
-0.9298915863,
0.0317398459,
-0.3511252701,
-0.356310904,
-0.6691585779,
0.5220594406,
-0.1349521726,
-0.3120841682,
0.4845946729,
0.5083830953,
-0.0918061584,
-0.4832392931,
-0.4942666888,
0.089120537,
-0.117958419,
-0.2004105896,
0.0262220018,
0.9923392534,
-0.3105604649,
0.6762192845,
0.8496640921,
-0.3035573959,
-0.1077702865,
0.4606840312,
0.8463763595,
-0.8472922444,
-0.6563521624,
-0.6508805156,
0.6236252785,
-0.3430384994,
-0.3402589858,
0.940653801,
0.8170425892,
0.8025868535,
-0.0122123668,
0.6932029128,
0.0796001256,
0.3551834822,
-0.8502833843,
0.1070239544,
-0.6019811034,
0.3038835526,
-0.0972147658,
-1.0540399551,
-0.7038084269,
0.861127913,
-0.1977717876,
-0.0689618215,
0.751145184,
0.6131999493,
-0.3533968925,
0.1061507612,
0.5464353561,
0.0233142152,
0.530626595,
0.3181256652,
1.2158136368,
-0.2312479466,
0.2757669687,
-0.5814577937,
-0.3490677178,
-0.2349416167,
-0.8573818803,
-1.0044623613,
-0.4062860012,
-0.1169991419,
-0.4544906318,
-0.1182099134,
0.3879463375,
0.7419531941,
-0.6527639031,
0.0500165001,
-0.7596677542,
0.1278383285,
-0.4623928964,
-0.2239619941,
0.396763593,
-0.1120700389,
-0.3638889492,
0.695726037,
0.6090784073,
0.1503898501,
-0.2791049778,
0.0591023676,
-0.2987096608,
-0.3966372013,
0.7038322091,
0.1338428855,
-0.8021607995,
-0.477221638,
0.0412060507,
-0.0824812278,
0.0777826756,
1.0548764467,
-0.9503591657,
0.499458462,
0.7157219052,
0.4195071161,
0.3834623396,
0.5906093717,
0.8361329436,
-0.4603622258,
0.5306831002,
0.2784173787,
0.5993337631,
0.4775386751,
-0.275634706,
0.6701191068,
0.220835641,
-0.2158813477,
-0.5093569756,
0.1915352494,
-0.8767530918,
-0.2402222753,
1.1751848459,
-0.0263565052,
-0.167622149,
-0.3232370317,
-0.5096086264,
0.0074604671,
0.1511714309,
0.5314244628,
0.5697178841,
-0.1384430528,
-0.5636464357,
-0.3927352726,
0.5574738979,
0.4296153784,
-0.9115782976,
0.2454737872,
0.869638741,
-0.2023366094,
0.3344124556,
0.5556809306,
-0.3311518133,
0.4064797759,
0.2874207497,
0.0912719294,
-0.2816654146,
-0.6230694056,
-0.1350476295,
0.3683083653,
-0.3256768882,
-0.1303413212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01523v1 | MMLongBench-Doc: Benchmarking Long-context Document Understanding with Visualizations | 2024-07-01T17:59:26 | 2024-07-01T17:59:26 | Yubo Ma, Yuhang Zang, Liangyu Chen, Meiqi Chen, Yizhu Jiao, Xinze Li, Xinyuan Lu, Ziyu Liu, Yan Ma, Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Liangming Pan, Yu-Gang Jiang, Jiaqi Wang, Yixin Cao, Aixin Sun | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Understanding documents with rich layouts and multi-modal components is a
long-standing and practical task. Recent Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs)
have made remarkable strides in various tasks, particularly in single-page
document understanding (DU). However, their abilities on long-context DU remain
an open problem. This work presents MMLongBench-Doc, a long-context,
multi-modal benchmark comprising 1,062 expert-annotated questions. Distinct
from previous datasets, it is constructed upon 130 lengthy PDF-formatted
documents with an average of 49.4 pages and 20,971 textual tokens. Towards
comprehensive evaluation, answers to these questions rely on pieces of evidence
from (1) different sources (text, image, chart, table, and layout structure)
and (2) various locations (i.e. page number). Moreover, 33.2% of the questions
are cross-page questions requiring evidence across multiple pages. 22.8% of the
questions are designed to be unanswerable for detecting potential
hallucinations. Experiments on 14 LVLMs demonstrate that long-context DU
greatly challenges current models. Notably, the best-performing model, GPT-4o,
achieves an F1 score of only 42.7%, while the second-best, GPT-4V, scores
31.4%. Furthermore, 12 LVLMs (all except GPT-4o and GPT-4V) even present worse
performance than their LLM counterparts which are fed with lossy-parsed OCR
documents. These results validate the necessity of future research toward more
capable long-context LVLMs. Project Page:
https://mayubo2333.github.io/MMLongBench-Doc | [
-0.6121028662,
-0.703070581,
0.9369602799,
0.2208199054,
-0.4336338341,
-0.2402633876,
-0.3479478359,
-0.5138704181,
-0.0688046589,
0.5495511889,
-0.4988444149,
-0.6962694526,
-0.4767756164,
0.2244721949,
-0.3378928006,
0.6368951201,
-0.231336087,
0.1268698722,
-0.4214798212,
-0.4557535946,
-0.3885748386,
-0.3952028155,
-0.377707243,
-0.0402014144,
0.7104600072,
0.0517141409,
0.3590599298,
0.4699363112,
0.3832916021,
0.289274931,
-0.0075994204,
0.2808161974,
-0.4926326573,
0.1191649884,
-0.1146678478,
-0.1824026704,
-0.5134232044,
0.0276522096,
0.7069336176,
0.7850564122,
0.1005528346,
-0.1206125543,
0.0751280114,
0.6832392216,
-0.6896257401,
0.2546051741,
-0.2265488803,
0.0819265619,
-0.1747361422,
-0.3289437592,
-0.6829065084,
0.0199071039,
0.0045511806,
-0.9011089802,
0.1547550112,
0.1391887367,
0.6093139052,
0.2039996982,
-0.8513721228,
-0.2484216094,
-0.2782732248,
0.7336256504,
-0.5320883989,
0.7433578968,
0.4823470116,
0.4964415431,
-0.1811740398,
-0.8414306641,
-0.6929915547,
-0.3231265545,
-0.1374859959,
0.4484096766,
-0.1452987492,
0.0414588749,
0.6109724045,
0.2671823502,
-0.6936804652,
0.2495343387,
-0.5160327554,
-0.2001323402,
0.3357664943,
0.2848543227,
-0.1475592852,
-0.4372389317,
-0.5151105523,
-0.286136955,
-0.1889362037,
0.1531994045,
0.1490806341,
-0.0918051973,
-0.0866676643,
0.4943520427,
-0.2576718032,
0.9438661337,
-0.2162442803,
-0.3490686417,
0.4864458442,
-0.3395686746,
-0.3203692734,
-0.3083338141,
0.6321136355,
0.8244704604,
0.1500317603,
-0.1166616306,
-0.1643406153,
-0.2107112408,
0.3515420258,
-1.0938122272,
0.1018826067,
0.1764474064,
-0.5321604013,
0.0905812308,
-0.0456904061,
-1.0341787338,
-0.8274415731,
-0.5640780926,
0.284827441,
-0.5852133036,
0.1000127643,
0.2724022269,
-0.2984607816,
0.1877255142,
0.7652339935,
-0.5680359006,
0.1102523506,
0.7999380231,
0.8905161619,
-0.4404396117,
-0.6840319633,
-0.8170385957,
0.1121684387,
-0.3540893197,
0.8314326406,
-0.4634828866,
-0.7013852596,
-0.0656514317,
0.1980119497,
-0.1855160296,
-0.4047037363,
0.8514695764,
-0.1906320304,
0.4678750336,
-0.4411236048,
-0.6117655635,
-0.1496652365,
0.7247942686,
-0.742435813,
0.7992607951,
0.1598300785,
-0.8371585011,
0.4894048274,
-0.659247458,
-0.244377777,
-0.2455847114,
-0.4928149283,
-0.0254002362,
0.2038391232,
0.3355429769,
0.481882304,
-0.3411789536,
0.1045714542,
-0.3160974979,
-0.4043365121,
0.1450618953,
-0.6908117533,
0.4921866357,
0.025448937,
-0.3307894468,
0.3423434794,
-1.015024066,
-0.1250249743,
0.0695518479,
-0.5258522034,
-0.3620323539,
-0.095092766,
0.3007725775,
0.2892978191,
-0.0216334406,
-0.5005591512,
0.3870084882,
-0.1177068204,
0.1536187232,
0.7304406166,
-0.1730012,
0.150782913,
-0.1346011609,
0.4591852129,
0.0451841541,
0.0990025401,
-0.6333720088,
-0.2362501919,
-0.677778542,
-0.4128922522,
-0.0207794718,
0.1562853605,
-0.6780012846,
0.1758905798,
-0.662772119,
-0.3072882891,
-0.2371676862,
-0.0220217444,
0.3925589621,
0.8976922631,
0.5610498786,
-0.395028621,
-0.0560215525,
-1.0010273457,
-0.0676023662,
0.1357434988,
-0.2327884734,
0.5427879691,
0.7070392966,
-0.2859366238,
0.6278582215,
-0.5680516958,
-0.3405975997,
0.1105215177,
0.369122982,
0.1480442435,
0.1917431206,
0.5781804323,
-0.8632113338,
-0.3865816891,
-0.0482203811,
-0.9082111716,
-0.0149252666,
-0.2238710076,
0.0937090591,
0.4570336342,
0.6882787943,
-0.6423364878,
0.516757071,
0.4350391328,
-0.5602280498,
0.6734623909,
-0.5441781282,
0.3765186965,
-1.0108646154,
0.300955832,
0.0118779289,
-0.1852559894,
-0.4346923828,
0.2036977708,
0.4979089797,
-0.1902244538,
-0.4052329063,
0.7009295821,
-0.6037712097,
-0.1666595787,
-0.2351669669,
0.3601420224,
0.3492934704,
0.5235882998,
-0.071816273,
0.9174652696,
0.2515746057,
-0.0493389256,
0.1568811536,
-0.0479558632,
-0.5147282481,
0.8508138061,
-0.4770188034,
0.1166482195,
-0.1838745177,
0.6438260674,
-0.855417788,
-0.1837310791,
-0.0914130136,
-0.0917547271,
0.4652035832,
-0.1554216444,
-0.7385621071,
-0.4107697606,
-0.5113587379,
0.403047353,
0.1309388429,
-0.6226814985,
0.9926849008,
0.0047567314,
0.2078888714,
-0.6415332556,
-0.4047693908,
0.2306112498,
-0.0834613666,
-0.8988139033,
0.3048554957,
-0.3418981135,
-0.2641426325,
-0.4580947161,
-0.2707409561,
0.1350751221,
-0.0603994355,
0.5826228857,
-0.1184509397,
-0.2731572688,
0.2303567976,
-0.1872523874,
-0.2772236466,
0.07362023,
-0.0224654768,
0.6789402366,
-0.3430978656,
-0.7239191532,
-0.0885846838,
0.5784640908,
1.012144804,
-0.3974369764,
0.4611898959,
0.7549220324,
-0.1891915798,
-0.1467321515,
-0.8128457665,
0.1398874819,
-0.4293068349,
0.3378791511,
-0.6914171576,
-0.6805539727,
0.5055453777,
-0.1164587736,
-0.0375543386,
0.5220187306,
0.448007077,
-0.089188002,
0.7494435906,
0.6322045922,
-0.1547398418,
0.273342967,
-0.3218059242,
-0.0804669932,
-0.7539425492,
-0.335236609,
-0.3129275441,
-0.1536005735,
-0.3272882104,
-0.9058660269,
0.4988012016,
0.1174339652,
0.2002240866,
-0.0025421749,
-0.230845958,
0.5228723288,
0.4544584751,
-0.0722968876,
0.3850544691,
-0.2641991079,
-0.3014295101,
0.0330227911,
-0.1733797491,
-0.3668571711,
1.1331156492,
0.2993812561,
0.606159389,
-0.0885571241,
0.5496666431,
0.1356250942,
0.0993320718,
-0.7608604431,
0.6006561518,
-0.0142193809,
-0.4599197507,
-0.3352377713,
-0.1886015832,
-0.9914978743,
0.7747408748,
-0.0160786808,
-0.76887995,
0.2440423071,
-0.2304543257,
-0.0374800563,
0.1725235879,
-0.6749159694,
1.1690350771,
-0.5034511685,
-0.5565829277,
-0.3760545254,
-0.5481130481,
0.2031098902,
-0.307064116,
0.3270365,
-0.0702179074,
-0.1434166878,
0.7078456283,
-0.3184188306,
0.5658168197,
-0.218114391,
-0.1724065691,
-0.0664383098,
-0.0447716229,
0.3921256065,
-0.0066826623,
-0.3202072978,
0.0721221268,
0.1965141147,
-0.3902081549,
-0.6192215681,
0.8170403838,
-0.450747788,
-0.5476034284,
-0.4843323827,
-0.6187595129,
-0.1479661912,
0.6031626463,
0.1050997004,
0.6774557829,
-0.3499161601,
0.5461971164,
0.5122071505,
-0.2118193656,
0.3850495517,
0.7164590359,
-0.389092505,
-0.1630600989,
0.6931151748,
0.0280397534,
-0.0671160072,
0.3037981689,
0.248542577,
-0.1668118984,
-0.754676044,
-0.5303555131,
0.0824809,
-1.1154907942,
0.1073107198,
-0.8407446742,
0.1755102277,
-0.2074780762,
-0.1374593675,
-0.2279967815,
-0.1371755451,
-0.1703743488,
-0.0904410258,
-0.0492732041,
0.4779004753,
0.0872004703,
0.0058386475,
-0.595123589,
0.5783858895,
0.2527946234,
0.4624639153,
-0.0365984887,
-0.320921123,
-0.1194322258,
-0.205395937,
-0.2901908457,
-0.7993454337,
0.2181654125,
-0.1315833628,
0.6357050538,
0.6359402537,
-0.0245758556,
0.8124076128,
-0.4539643228,
0.6585482955,
0.2001544386,
-0.6810646057,
0.2874635458,
-0.6189149022,
0.3785289228,
0.8787638545,
0.3804480135,
-0.5028913021,
-0.0668635368,
-0.1834617257,
-0.8366363049,
0.5096349716,
0.0200703628,
-0.1229752153,
0.0962532535,
0.0132747991,
0.3761112988,
0.1681199819,
-0.5997757316,
0.0847770199,
-0.2818428874,
-0.035134241,
-0.4335229695,
-0.222231105,
-0.257409215,
-0.3488659859,
0.0831524432,
-0.400598377,
-0.1244215742,
0.1818299443,
-0.3131043911,
0.2144985348,
0.3237202764,
0.9778126478,
1.2218672037,
-0.5280674696,
0.2194932699,
0.1607693434,
-0.3729072213,
-0.3419931233,
0.4939923286,
0.1805487126,
-0.009709375,
0.5559430718,
0.7128804326,
0.2085844725,
-0.9621186256,
0.8432851434,
-0.2953590453,
-0.3374719024,
-0.4355773032,
-0.2302328795,
0.117758505,
0.2508612573,
0.3804148138,
-0.3023428917,
0.1571754962,
-0.581618309,
-0.0299283136,
0.324572593,
-0.3114337027,
-0.0228337683,
0.4548795819,
0.2222891897,
-0.1775750667,
0.6206297874,
0.0560129546,
-0.372918278,
0.4805296361,
0.2345217615,
0.5240574479,
0.3404836953,
-0.2845173776,
0.1949406564,
0.1091400757,
-0.0069193081,
0.1294734776,
-0.4807360172,
-0.1013744473,
-0.1673593819,
-0.6163781285,
-0.4422043562,
0.2613011301,
-0.6149168015,
0.1660724282,
-0.1527922451,
-0.018943565,
0.3304570913,
0.0610783212,
-0.888314724,
0.2196641564,
0.163766861,
1.1800158024,
-0.4695788324,
0.9109830856,
0.1432723105,
-0.4900166094,
-0.2873375118,
0.0211134721,
0.2146540731,
-0.6868029833,
0.4712905586,
0.6222561002,
-0.167387411,
-0.4194406271,
-0.2602271438,
-0.5003581047,
1.3582633734,
0.03377923,
-0.6880068183,
-0.1123259738,
0.0783982947,
0.7038876414,
-0.1906292886,
0.370202899,
0.4855350554,
0.8037282228,
-0.2508242428,
-0.9006769657,
0.0650616065,
-0.4297614098,
-0.4177916348,
0.2536604106,
-0.5811398029,
0.8579090834,
-0.0747944638,
-0.0764563754,
0.0958187059,
0.43716079,
0.2148951143,
0.8444184661,
0.6664725542,
0.6108192801,
0.7585507035,
0.0636921301,
1.3127808571,
-0.4108451605,
0.088474378,
1.3544751406,
-0.2180544436,
0.9813149571,
0.8178701401,
0.1116580442,
0.3459362984,
0.4181368649,
-0.3031020463,
0.2698774934,
0.3062750697,
0.0140503077,
-0.267742604,
0.0226433557,
-0.6314285398,
0.4442362785,
0.2389635742,
-0.4671405256,
-0.3596878648,
0.1733871847,
-0.194822669,
-0.0415516272,
0.0241210703,
0.634765327,
0.1299899668,
-0.7623114586,
0.5917045474,
-0.0248739608,
0.6939871907,
-0.7691139579,
0.1545464396,
-0.3578668833,
0.3225284219,
0.0064717843,
-0.8144034743,
-0.1331218481,
0.0014579933,
-0.3669447005,
-0.304682821,
0.4873948991,
-0.1673448831,
-0.5245687962,
0.6413344145,
0.6182539463,
0.2909309566,
-0.433532089,
-0.3941698372,
0.2238896936,
-0.1821659654,
-0.4940107465,
0.5405017138,
0.4397821724,
-0.1440413892,
0.6392787099,
0.6351031065,
-0.3312213421,
0.0381551683,
0.3498004079,
0.9713301659,
-0.7112919092,
-0.5143342018,
-0.7064726353,
0.5325715542,
-0.3508033454,
-0.4936975539,
0.8743975163,
0.9484609365,
0.8459076881,
-0.0473879464,
0.4387112856,
0.3804184198,
0.2480268776,
-0.5170499682,
0.8953341246,
-1.0812616348,
-0.0514681861,
-0.2090550363,
-0.8421996832,
-0.1138875261,
0.2774747312,
-0.3203774095,
-0.1072986424,
0.9047459364,
0.6320208907,
-0.4183783829,
-0.1001191735,
0.4333536625,
0.109263286,
0.5671653152,
0.5497358441,
0.7791308165,
-0.1821066886,
0.6622095704,
-0.3619594276,
-0.0921300575,
-0.3393346071,
-0.9475674033,
-1.0809623003,
-0.6820079684,
0.1100368053,
-0.1821765304,
-0.0337599479,
0.4949768484,
0.6615341902,
-0.3671139181,
-0.1410734802,
0.3263652623,
-0.1148054078,
0.1038313061,
-0.1302189529,
0.7009912133,
-0.0187568292,
-0.5557160378,
0.7010309696,
0.4800769389,
0.0501360223,
-0.2434411943,
-0.1121369675,
0.0899653435,
-0.1036829203,
0.9059197903,
0.1231089607,
-0.953961134,
-0.2543551326,
-0.133558929,
-0.3165121078,
0.3038715124,
0.8853591084,
-0.6529840827,
0.934743464,
0.6772455573,
0.5152570605,
1.0095272064,
0.0652555227,
0.3493670225,
-0.3607793152,
0.2284538895,
0.1938283443,
0.6879469752,
0.279068619,
0.093943961,
0.6595520973,
0.0294582527,
-0.3838198781,
-0.9670569301,
-0.0591399521,
-1.5452326536,
-0.6546854973,
1.0153928995,
-0.1600632668,
-0.2277711481,
0.0818180293,
-0.4559781253,
0.0586219504,
-0.2995903194,
0.8047694564,
0.6733050942,
-0.0787004903,
-0.0829202458,
-0.8121008873,
0.1514791995,
0.3894081712,
-0.985670805,
0.1492209882,
0.8880322576,
0.1791301668,
0.3677508533,
0.7760153413,
0.0847482607,
0.2998503149,
0.123160623,
-0.2750979662,
-0.5988145471,
-0.3941787779,
-0.4150689244,
0.5309152007,
-0.2269919068,
0.016435286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01509v1 | MIA-Bench: Towards Better Instruction Following Evaluation of Multimodal LLMs | 2024-07-01T17:53:35 | 2024-07-01T17:53:35 | Yusu Qian, Hanrong Ye, Jean-Philippe Fauconnier, Peter Grasch, Yinfei Yang, Zhe Gan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce MIA-Bench, a new benchmark designed to evaluate multimodal large
language models (MLLMs) on their ability to strictly adhere to complex
instructions. Our benchmark comprises a diverse set of 400 image-prompt pairs,
each crafted to challenge the models' compliance with layered instructions in
generating accurate responses that satisfy specific requested patterns.
Evaluation results from a wide array of state-of-the-art MLLMs reveal
significant variations in performance, highlighting areas for improvement in
instruction fidelity. Additionally, we create extra training data and explore
supervised fine-tuning to enhance the models' ability to strictly follow
instructions without compromising performance on other tasks. We hope this
benchmark not only serves as a tool for measuring MLLM adherence to
instructions, but also guides future developments in MLLM training methods. | [
-0.2351493984,
-0.7921776772,
0.6043788791,
0.3843912184,
-0.2288792431,
0.0425539054,
-0.2884652913,
-0.1412675083,
-0.270652622,
0.358024478,
-0.9857849479,
-0.7737044692,
-0.6068927646,
-0.0094535919,
-0.4267440736,
0.5493181348,
-0.1867427975,
0.669514358,
-0.5719860196,
-0.3007488847,
-0.8369863629,
-0.4552905262,
-0.3045350015,
-0.0907545462,
0.5952323079,
0.2812559605,
0.3946129978,
0.7758119106,
0.660007298,
0.3150132596,
0.2183469236,
0.475002259,
-0.3611456454,
0.2208816558,
-0.1404671222,
-0.517837882,
-0.5571409464,
-0.1066837534,
0.7597753406,
0.8583419323,
-0.0761239082,
0.2593477666,
0.1222178265,
0.7358166575,
-0.7734680176,
0.293707937,
-0.2613495886,
0.0885113552,
-0.0977575108,
-0.2372878939,
-0.7971689105,
-0.4886028469,
-0.0927530453,
-0.5364271998,
-0.076618202,
-0.0096797254,
0.7219282389,
0.4304043949,
-0.5937191248,
-0.1422991157,
-0.3812091053,
0.854855001,
-0.6374291778,
0.65827775,
0.5447410941,
0.523952961,
-0.1866255999,
-0.6655935645,
-0.1014657021,
-0.5953735113,
0.1760627031,
-0.0076181502,
-0.0789183676,
0.0402708203,
0.2578544319,
-0.0856935009,
-0.3943963051,
0.0079431562,
0.0307333861,
-0.107509695,
0.4513911307,
0.5322737694,
0.1430498064,
0.2937696576,
-0.7324600816,
-0.2084247023,
-0.8001008034,
-0.0098718219,
0.1133325025,
0.1726283282,
-0.3307661414,
0.6563246846,
-0.2350654751,
0.7965251803,
0.0447003357,
-0.1888169795,
0.3455701172,
-0.418409884,
-0.0697511286,
-0.2318778485,
0.4242032766,
0.6819380522,
0.3005309999,
-0.1515872926,
-0.4597622454,
-0.1922661066,
0.2523566484,
-0.7568746209,
-0.101219818,
-0.1871327907,
-0.6613801718,
0.1511239856,
-0.1353933662,
-0.7446146011,
-0.6277195811,
-0.8604992032,
0.8669730425,
-0.5169683695,
0.0528813414,
0.030214252,
0.1370238662,
0.2521966994,
0.632958591,
-0.7311292291,
0.3137441874,
0.7897437811,
0.8185468316,
-0.0899792537,
-0.5911318064,
-0.9917416573,
0.1682925671,
-0.493172586,
0.8135638237,
-0.7341471314,
-0.2546205223,
0.1258295923,
0.0255323555,
-0.3405816555,
-0.5123358965,
0.5590080619,
-0.2092045844,
0.059594918,
-0.4173311591,
-0.6935850978,
-0.1859829426,
0.4524568915,
-0.5510052443,
0.9302337766,
0.3706540167,
-0.1691362858,
0.371309936,
-0.6135298014,
-0.340023905,
-0.4385351241,
-0.0597908497,
-0.1322383434,
0.1817320734,
0.2525956333,
0.4299856126,
-0.32900998,
0.079602018,
-0.6282337308,
-0.5695904493,
0.4359282553,
-0.7702999711,
0.5366231203,
-0.0078873876,
-0.4648900032,
0.6231267452,
-0.9259104729,
0.2391853482,
-0.1074785516,
-0.4198035896,
-0.1227467507,
0.0339915752,
0.1626712829,
0.1853078753,
0.1875444353,
-0.2407503575,
0.3430821598,
0.0214080717,
0.1016230211,
1.2446137667,
-0.2770161033,
0.2425832003,
-0.4846467674,
0.5980448723,
-0.2821796238,
0.4803376496,
-0.4557828009,
-0.1559290439,
-0.9245235324,
-0.6620272994,
0.4804216921,
0.2554929852,
-0.3443684578,
0.2721877992,
-0.2618584335,
-0.4064742029,
-0.7821055055,
0.3825731277,
0.8067166805,
0.3108455837,
0.4263860285,
-0.4308884144,
-0.6098388433,
-1.0650416613,
0.0376840569,
0.2290003002,
0.0425723493,
0.3548296988,
0.4292618632,
-0.1207992211,
0.4179296196,
-0.0681251511,
-0.1637326777,
0.0475362428,
0.2864518464,
0.0436396413,
0.5439793468,
0.6850739121,
-0.2994287014,
-0.7202985287,
-0.2504507601,
-0.7615990639,
-0.1602883041,
-0.1285028905,
-0.2320975661,
0.4386726618,
0.4886601567,
-0.610406518,
0.1441843212,
0.5351736546,
-0.332858026,
0.555513382,
-0.1808930933,
0.4564651549,
-0.8471133113,
0.0976191685,
-0.258079201,
-0.2507168949,
-0.5392221212,
0.2173915654,
0.3650236428,
0.1804993749,
-0.6414866447,
0.4875414073,
-0.796267271,
-0.3060725033,
-0.067354314,
-0.1306756884,
0.0993134677,
0.5028291345,
-0.2568730116,
0.9311263561,
0.7419164181,
-0.3646352887,
0.3740812838,
0.1429792643,
-0.7719080448,
0.7834755778,
-0.5188824534,
0.3713358343,
-0.0520322695,
0.2068875432,
-1.2437382936,
-0.1784995794,
0.0253414251,
-0.0047130026,
0.5017157793,
-0.2392204702,
-0.7424464822,
-0.0288131386,
-0.6114330888,
0.124752216,
0.432725817,
-0.591817081,
0.8102531433,
-0.0968129486,
0.1184050813,
-0.7552360892,
-0.5538988113,
0.0418370366,
-0.0344563685,
-0.5474050641,
0.1302135587,
-0.5345767736,
-0.1172127128,
-0.1386916935,
-0.1650947928,
-0.1980185658,
0.2987518609,
0.4030489922,
0.3036248088,
-0.5455964804,
0.0752768815,
-0.2172094136,
0.1087390855,
0.2472122014,
0.2343770862,
0.9255319834,
-0.1478632241,
-0.823569715,
-0.865285337,
0.331797868,
0.8942427635,
-0.192943424,
0.5856457353,
0.8540776372,
-0.1559350044,
-0.0394619666,
-0.5914291143,
-0.1499294788,
-0.4998117089,
0.4376232624,
-0.5374968052,
-0.383872956,
0.2401870191,
-0.0125869503,
0.0832030624,
-0.0673111528,
0.6401498318,
-0.3801862895,
1.3670691252,
0.5670360327,
0.0312604271,
0.4513581693,
-0.043581754,
-0.309781909,
-0.8405649066,
-0.4361052811,
-0.3727773428,
-0.6387295127,
0.0075539649,
-0.623427093,
0.1517950445,
0.2266166955,
-0.2426707894,
0.0552075021,
-0.0852230862,
0.4117033482,
0.5918600559,
0.2398477644,
-0.00037318,
-0.2390090078,
-0.2195310295,
-0.0015076632,
-0.5470289588,
-0.4846335351,
1.2691220045,
0.3551799357,
1.0489834547,
0.2632489502,
0.4767202735,
0.3476901948,
0.5500372052,
-0.5879771709,
0.6918519139,
-0.0371105969,
-0.5600280166,
0.0462528318,
-0.1967308372,
-0.8905160427,
0.294493556,
-0.3023284674,
-0.5682617426,
-0.171923086,
0.0948606879,
-0.2937876582,
-0.0452430137,
-0.9636902809,
0.9984089732,
-0.6900572181,
-0.6671598554,
-0.2893294096,
-0.6318908334,
0.2666146755,
0.1299344003,
0.1504136026,
-0.5199781656,
-0.4549331367,
0.3938104212,
-0.1117351875,
1.1105839014,
-0.2527748942,
-0.0653323308,
-0.0678398162,
0.0918875113,
0.3296398818,
-0.322238028,
-0.0033541606,
-0.3376117349,
0.033294443,
-0.4659637809,
-0.5570371747,
0.8337332606,
-0.6472863555,
-0.7096075416,
-0.0165743846,
-1.0076322556,
-0.5892276168,
0.1222664043,
-0.2466592342,
0.6799399257,
-0.2675064802,
0.4425810874,
0.8491275907,
-0.1286712885,
0.4451976717,
0.7382507324,
-0.2947710454,
-0.3728870451,
0.6179468036,
-0.0534142703,
0.2522296011,
0.6346616149,
0.0191631243,
-0.5857182741,
-0.6781774163,
-0.8432136178,
0.0352065265,
-0.9097969532,
-0.3315623105,
-0.4152471423,
0.0396799482,
-0.2420109957,
-0.0893213078,
-0.3112002015,
-0.3088122904,
-0.3262099326,
0.1629232615,
0.0932418257,
0.7519773245,
0.226824373,
0.1413911283,
-1.0906444788,
-0.0379740782,
0.3341991603,
0.4731220305,
-0.0966838449,
-0.6977887154,
-0.2043269873,
0.0280353818,
-0.2467780113,
-0.818931222,
-0.0758412927,
0.4002471566,
1.0595474243,
0.4547405243,
-0.1634324938,
0.821369648,
-0.6639975309,
0.5234945416,
0.2369761616,
-1.0250914097,
0.5915020108,
-0.4193077683,
0.5392239094,
0.4902555943,
0.3171857595,
-0.2055547237,
-0.1511283964,
-0.164141804,
-0.5443537235,
0.7002940774,
-0.1567124724,
0.3664315045,
0.2206724137,
-0.0392383039,
0.1653968096,
0.2495304793,
-0.5078001022,
-0.200832814,
0.0349141285,
-0.4189355075,
0.0911426991,
-0.4139808714,
-0.489273876,
-0.2175374329,
0.3568133414,
-0.095706068,
0.2130313665,
-0.252150774,
-0.3620246053,
-0.2667274177,
0.265893966,
1.089922905,
0.9414724112,
-0.3962498605,
0.1868336797,
0.3543810844,
-0.1027900353,
0.0834302157,
0.1675272286,
0.0566512048,
0.193792969,
0.7029827237,
0.8462731838,
0.5769359469,
-1.0993990898,
0.6620806456,
-0.0526484922,
-0.2818746865,
-0.0614834465,
0.3155327439,
0.1882244945,
0.3990677595,
0.0851385146,
0.2892757058,
0.0498059839,
-0.8085898161,
0.3116324246,
0.5271940231,
-0.4640625119,
-0.2606115341,
0.5775816441,
0.2826321423,
-0.3048634827,
0.3945619762,
0.2540860772,
-0.4002328813,
0.6091980338,
0.5658385158,
0.5433970094,
-0.3683518469,
0.0500302836,
0.326155901,
0.3521533012,
-0.0271759294,
0.3928098679,
-0.1636392772,
-0.2727459371,
-0.3111751676,
-0.3171414137,
-0.4088667035,
0.0042901197,
-0.867546916,
0.3039312661,
-0.7175123096,
-0.1496284455,
0.0094353715,
-0.1720363349,
-0.6578163505,
-0.0760869086,
0.2506902218,
1.1828578711,
-0.5665947795,
1.0135291815,
0.6991140246,
-0.4498824775,
-0.468290627,
-0.2978434563,
0.4806703627,
-0.9240682721,
0.6153236032,
0.5495606065,
-0.2617466748,
-0.2687267661,
-0.4189456403,
-0.8827421665,
1.2397919893,
0.7464761734,
-0.768881619,
0.2194690853,
-0.1195381656,
0.4919752479,
-0.5273715854,
0.343906343,
0.5688278675,
0.6662200689,
-0.1701257527,
-0.7799357176,
-0.0571123138,
-0.4175872803,
-0.179321155,
0.1999058276,
-0.6840558052,
0.7523563504,
-0.2562799156,
-0.066208154,
0.6151842475,
0.4225370884,
0.2816084623,
0.4976809323,
0.5372833014,
0.4844431877,
0.6616474986,
-0.2270922512,
1.0808637142,
-0.187566936,
0.0528398268,
1.5744891167,
-0.4360823035,
1.1453406811,
0.4793893099,
-0.1320319176,
0.4073256254,
0.5404652357,
-0.2977735102,
0.7258664966,
0.2289779037,
-0.2347047478,
-0.3612269461,
-0.3342188299,
-0.5240522027,
0.3660376072,
0.2283903807,
-0.5331370831,
-0.1200227812,
0.1072231457,
-0.098000817,
0.3814180791,
-0.4011930227,
0.6421681643,
-0.2382490039,
-0.6509751678,
0.8635664582,
-0.1689987034,
0.4608641565,
-0.7116684914,
-0.2424685061,
-0.3890647292,
0.3868961036,
0.0063004415,
-0.7290548682,
-0.1010885909,
0.1116542518,
-0.1860060394,
-0.2693281472,
0.3638993204,
-0.5785596371,
-0.393411994,
0.387594074,
0.5169698,
0.1546722651,
0.3315461278,
-0.9363396764,
0.3817991614,
-0.049132064,
-0.2069907188,
0.5012115836,
0.321972847,
0.191136241,
0.8873556256,
0.5073032379,
-0.4240174592,
0.407944113,
0.6091774106,
0.9353896976,
-0.3365543187,
0.2669998705,
-0.8333885074,
0.5812470913,
0.0331110097,
-0.5981282592,
0.866558671,
0.660325706,
0.7912312746,
-0.3871343732,
0.3398753703,
0.1737543494,
0.3014560342,
-0.9932811856,
0.5788681507,
-0.7635915875,
0.3566464782,
0.0591094606,
-0.9545661211,
-0.2282409221,
0.4869343936,
-0.0823533759,
0.1304566562,
0.8114985228,
1.071628809,
-0.1858811229,
-0.1970648319,
0.5816143155,
0.0817591026,
-0.035960529,
0.6822131276,
1.3690063953,
-0.2362598479,
0.6618995667,
-0.3639820814,
0.0294552483,
-0.5006787181,
-0.7513555884,
-1.1937558651,
-0.4884251952,
-0.1410156935,
-0.0878413245,
0.3987479508,
1.2939119339,
0.9494252801,
-0.8133400083,
-0.2391267866,
0.2019007951,
-0.0955335945,
-0.5851550102,
-0.107462965,
0.3902350068,
-0.6566987038,
-0.8947859406,
0.6578933597,
0.264844358,
0.0390705951,
-0.3027878106,
-0.2483383417,
-0.5169969201,
0.1916215718,
0.7283446193,
-0.3317573667,
-0.8658968806,
-0.2900580168,
0.1684518307,
-0.5794550776,
0.1915962994,
0.6763052344,
-0.3091810048,
0.6050632596,
0.1871484071,
0.7473101616,
0.320248872,
-0.0268164724,
0.5824818611,
-0.7658196092,
-0.0421227999,
0.2447810918,
0.5402252674,
0.4080096185,
0.0975581333,
0.7233453393,
-0.2273343951,
-0.2878864706,
-0.9704189897,
-0.0406288467,
-1.1833817959,
-0.3719562888,
1.045932889,
-0.5221176744,
-0.3286552727,
-0.0335604213,
-0.3488077223,
-0.0088503351,
-0.3430740833,
0.8503898978,
0.8825679421,
-0.0443236642,
-0.6141157746,
-0.6255025268,
0.1403710395,
0.8130818605,
-0.9251889586,
0.1302657127,
0.8695610762,
0.2352710217,
-0.169549197,
0.3994011581,
-0.0216135308,
0.6839848757,
0.1092534438,
0.0360806547,
-0.3127119839,
-0.4774006307,
-0.4237288237,
0.143783316,
0.2423456311,
-0.4663571715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01505v1 | Self-Cognition in Large Language Models: An Exploratory Study | 2024-07-01T17:52:05 | 2024-07-01T17:52:05 | Dongping Chen, Jiawen Shi, Yao Wan, Pan Zhou, Neil Zhenqiang Gong, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across
various applications, they also raise concerns regarding self-cognition. In
this paper, we perform a pioneering study to explore self-cognition in LLMs.
Specifically, we first construct a pool of self-cognition instruction prompts
to evaluate where an LLM exhibits self-cognition and four well-designed
principles to quantify LLMs' self-cognition. Our study reveals that 4 of the 48
models on Chatbot Arena--specifically Command R, Claude3-Opus,
Llama-3-70b-Instruct, and Reka-core--demonstrate some level of detectable
self-cognition. We observe a positive correlation between model size, training
data quality, and self-cognition level. Additionally, we also explore the
utility and trustworthiness of LLM in the self-cognition state, revealing that
the self-cognition state enhances some specific tasks such as creative writing
and exaggeration. We believe that our work can serve as an inspiration for
further research to study the self-cognition in LLMs. | [
-0.3473418355,
-0.8885625005,
0.7860242128,
0.1739429981,
0.0988491327,
-0.0958403572,
-0.3789826632,
-0.4242349267,
0.2811338007,
0.6842885613,
-0.441975683,
-0.35228315,
-0.4764991403,
0.030706482,
-0.5748662353,
0.74002707,
0.0775572136,
-0.1093161777,
-0.3497107029,
0.0886550695,
-0.6382879615,
-0.7635139823,
-0.5994210839,
-0.4325187206,
0.5578643084,
0.4525081217,
0.4318077564,
0.6316558719,
0.4309963882,
0.2834062874,
0.2305536866,
-0.0970555171,
-0.7173845768,
0.4304355681,
-0.2936941385,
-0.7126187682,
-0.5691140294,
0.2998940647,
0.6856594682,
0.3546337783,
-0.208209455,
0.4063041806,
0.2126632333,
0.7285960317,
-0.4473095834,
0.3713898361,
-0.5528379679,
0.0996540189,
-0.1049205214,
-0.128462553,
-0.6892896891,
0.249026075,
0.0256311931,
-0.4557169378,
0.0690593943,
0.2631047964,
0.1025245935,
0.3361152411,
-0.4761326313,
-0.4614176154,
-0.8502293825,
0.7081893086,
-0.6323829293,
0.2528862953,
0.4920729995,
0.1724331379,
-0.1984653026,
-0.5536037087,
-0.6597352028,
-0.3432915211,
0.0805842057,
0.1815247089,
-0.1487129778,
-0.1412795633,
0.1473801732,
0.4780966341,
-0.5353996754,
0.5708804131,
-0.2420914471,
-0.2410484552,
0.6846088767,
0.3147054911,
0.1640980095,
-0.0851162374,
-0.2722781599,
-0.0834237337,
-0.6895958781,
-0.2776505053,
0.1824122816,
0.1620234996,
-0.0882378593,
0.660946846,
-0.3029709458,
0.3346418142,
-0.1617951244,
-0.0069912015,
0.2007478923,
-0.2778404653,
-0.2872801423,
-0.094912678,
1.0375185013,
0.1375049353,
0.5321878791,
0.0166911669,
-0.2015219182,
-0.0939348489,
0.5019578934,
-0.5627726912,
-0.3004795611,
0.1722097248,
-0.5469056368,
-0.3748089075,
-0.4364464879,
-0.1489692032,
-0.4101593494,
-0.1456442624,
0.6348177791,
-0.280850172,
-0.4059410393,
-0.0143348444,
0.3023592532,
0.3016230166,
0.362575531,
-1.0355340242,
0.1825694591,
0.6676396728,
0.4939298034,
-0.3061933219,
-0.6371257305,
-0.0240539219,
0.0127990572,
-0.4266765714,
0.6864138842,
-0.4575237334,
-0.4571141899,
-0.1264308542,
-0.2014362812,
-0.0718099773,
-0.3305483758,
0.4227821827,
-0.2667170763,
0.2718034983,
-0.0180052947,
-0.9758067727,
0.0324645676,
0.4369313419,
-0.6587271094,
0.9236143827,
-0.1887321919,
-0.5514304042,
0.0684764013,
-0.2496681511,
-0.4220642447,
0.0781391859,
-0.4626858532,
-0.2388349473,
0.4051119089,
0.0741756707,
0.8567762375,
-0.2323284298,
0.1525121629,
-0.3657537699,
-0.2328567207,
0.7518840432,
-0.5475317836,
0.3889232874,
0.1329094321,
-0.2131041437,
-0.1551785171,
-0.3591516912,
0.1591890305,
0.3405496776,
-0.1743019223,
-0.3046503365,
-0.1755955517,
-0.5091762543,
0.2917400301,
0.5115481019,
-0.3323146999,
0.3235103786,
-0.2242895365,
0.4423627555,
0.6736129522,
-0.1243844107,
0.4942038059,
-0.1913739443,
0.4177131653,
-0.2786704302,
0.2427036166,
-0.3104118705,
-0.4036124945,
-0.919100225,
-0.2010938674,
0.1269820333,
0.207693547,
-0.3435422182,
0.3663596511,
0.0169398598,
-0.4835598171,
-0.3516480923,
0.2977104187,
0.4877922535,
0.3475335538,
0.2422728091,
-0.1598563045,
-0.1545021087,
-1.1487842798,
-0.2091290057,
-0.2214503437,
0.3005306423,
0.4422391057,
0.716701448,
-0.1621681601,
0.5703347325,
-0.4972771108,
-0.364436388,
-0.3481500149,
0.0234250464,
0.1083842292,
0.463075012,
0.3837070763,
-0.1909977198,
-0.463511616,
-0.4617098272,
-0.8786934614,
0.0577280857,
-0.1681257486,
-0.1429072171,
0.4150693417,
0.7544484735,
-0.6628249884,
0.2010574639,
0.7277449369,
-0.2681334019,
0.5112076402,
-0.6221310496,
-0.0918969885,
-0.876445353,
-0.1991222799,
-0.1348544508,
-0.0672623515,
-0.6129768491,
-0.059953656,
0.059254773,
0.2293777764,
-0.0233545788,
0.6411932111,
-0.7187743783,
-0.1094304621,
-0.5155089498,
0.281576246,
-0.1090887189,
0.4710336924,
0.003999522,
0.6254559755,
0.7781438828,
-0.5585339069,
0.0457879826,
0.1117670238,
-0.586781919,
0.3396385908,
-0.4693748951,
0.3987798393,
-0.0522841848,
0.3030931652,
-1.2193422318,
-0.0025253862,
0.1782884747,
-0.502065897,
0.4231072664,
0.2332793921,
-0.6350873113,
-0.4674854279,
-0.0159523003,
0.2440141141,
0.5420012474,
-0.4792850912,
0.6234010458,
0.5383877754,
-0.0204346888,
-0.3185600638,
-0.7712422609,
0.0386597477,
-0.3002163172,
-0.2528682351,
-0.05940919,
-0.2163541168,
-0.0701528937,
-0.3437930942,
-0.0760714188,
0.121941112,
0.3065425754,
0.4175911844,
0.246031329,
-0.0286729839,
0.4213773012,
-0.1253434569,
-0.0028757949,
0.4379637837,
-0.211952284,
0.6372976899,
-0.2686980069,
-0.5001010299,
-0.5483054519,
-0.0957320631,
0.4655509889,
-0.3134548366,
0.7365448475,
0.3688459992,
-0.0014126482,
-0.407177031,
-0.883241713,
-0.2928167582,
-0.4312321842,
0.202693522,
-0.3967232406,
-1.2695749998,
0.4884631038,
-0.0124915615,
-0.0905644149,
0.5136606097,
0.771679759,
-0.5976278186,
0.8137613535,
0.59136796,
-0.2791378498,
0.3897068799,
-0.3051274717,
0.1004360914,
-1.060808301,
-0.2534647584,
-0.1852463484,
-0.2775447071,
-0.673938632,
-0.6542804241,
0.204890132,
-0.2425408065,
-0.3178326786,
0.0705171153,
-0.2672191858,
0.3527756333,
0.4489746988,
0.0655709952,
0.3407534361,
-0.2537732124,
0.0215947963,
0.0812347382,
-0.7695332766,
-0.506503582,
1.2382680178,
0.5547994971,
1.065197587,
0.0696954727,
0.9299842119,
0.3578387797,
0.2674717605,
-0.6692855954,
0.6558206677,
0.1212839782,
-0.8835093975,
-0.6772522926,
-0.4466896951,
-1.080343008,
0.2870652974,
-0.3544714451,
-0.6710193157,
-0.2432697415,
0.4512921572,
-0.1936764568,
0.0060574431,
-0.604532361,
0.9766430855,
-0.6945806742,
-0.2676921487,
-0.7040504813,
-0.5012888908,
0.5269967318,
-0.2328409106,
0.2492394894,
-0.3307959437,
-0.0437335074,
0.6103158593,
0.1204009876,
1.2045655251,
0.2289647907,
-0.312394172,
0.6171044707,
0.4114721119,
0.4606429636,
-0.0449511521,
0.166650787,
0.183059305,
-0.0833919868,
-0.0439985953,
-0.7888559699,
0.8603613377,
-0.7729585171,
-0.9001484513,
-0.3747087717,
-0.5223522782,
-0.199078232,
0.2282774597,
-0.1078436077,
0.3315153718,
-0.5862318277,
0.3730499148,
0.7801687121,
-0.2024233043,
0.2621388137,
0.7345756292,
-0.5866200328,
-0.0993532166,
0.7724400759,
0.2188104242,
0.5336183906,
0.3842268288,
0.3971332312,
-0.3394321799,
-0.5068102479,
-0.1192254499,
0.4541859031,
-0.7260444164,
-0.0751561597,
-0.5293009281,
-0.1809551716,
-0.3891582787,
0.2667433321,
-0.7148530483,
-0.5240667462,
-0.3283138573,
0.0434247181,
0.0984868035,
1.0434886217,
0.0990532711,
0.261382401,
-0.4387071133,
-0.0017780823,
0.3493360877,
0.332737565,
0.2630885243,
-0.8329330683,
-0.3301402032,
-0.0692614838,
-0.0661588386,
-0.4654387832,
0.3439594209,
0.0892692208,
0.9149228334,
0.3656439483,
-0.0518846512,
0.1825858355,
-0.5138176084,
0.5769592524,
0.1272812039,
-0.8768630624,
0.3873552978,
-0.275090307,
0.4335511327,
0.3960143328,
0.2833177149,
-0.4748858511,
-0.5935551524,
-0.7799803019,
-0.2841327786,
0.4743314087,
0.42165941,
0.4901705384,
-0.1786910743,
0.5989590883,
-0.0071563022,
0.1505229771,
-0.7340893745,
-0.432839632,
-0.1225855872,
0.0530878454,
-0.4490084946,
-0.6138427258,
0.0633147508,
-0.1054789498,
0.5247294307,
-0.2595535517,
0.267028749,
0.049236659,
-0.0238342974,
0.2282914668,
0.2457294017,
0.3954970241,
0.440549314,
0.1700991243,
0.3151655793,
0.367315501,
-0.2316002101,
-0.1565183997,
-0.510946691,
0.1255037487,
-0.652605474,
0.4761862755,
0.6286726594,
0.3390740752,
-0.6172988415,
0.5542923212,
-0.1438491195,
-0.0422329865,
-0.529684484,
0.3186993301,
0.5635436177,
0.4269653559,
-0.037889801,
-0.5424727201,
0.1137636751,
-0.8463781476,
-0.1459394246,
0.7172732353,
-0.1637156159,
-0.2307844907,
0.3613832891,
0.2292529643,
-0.1602662504,
0.8587294817,
-0.0528048724,
-0.3889047801,
0.3875057399,
0.7884337902,
0.7622763515,
-0.2945297956,
0.0562735237,
0.3673187792,
0.4993244708,
-0.2097627521,
0.1019445509,
-0.3057445884,
-1.015268445,
-0.4173907936,
-0.3600694239,
-0.4992746115,
0.1320843995,
-0.6284486651,
-0.0216542203,
-0.3311093152,
-0.3104906976,
-0.1568327099,
0.0132307978,
-0.6373077035,
0.246845305,
0.5139741302,
0.8205177188,
-0.5540321469,
1.0527379513,
0.2444539219,
-0.1619475484,
-0.8014011979,
-0.3115888834,
-0.2143042088,
-1.2392133474,
0.6792670488,
0.1473639309,
-0.3107231259,
0.0702433959,
-0.7525911331,
-1.0746949911,
1.3174111843,
0.1610032916,
-0.6308051944,
0.0008790932,
0.0543795601,
0.7014119625,
-0.6734253168,
0.1289520115,
0.5689311624,
0.0526769124,
0.0932286605,
-1.0094279051,
-0.0286701545,
-0.0302716754,
-0.1125627756,
-0.0095028877,
-1.1011381149,
0.7631756663,
-0.3618296683,
-0.0416661352,
0.0428765342,
0.8905684948,
0.1944648027,
-0.0061465036,
0.375875324,
0.5123221278,
0.8308855891,
0.2966999114,
1.0249377489,
-0.5250989199,
0.3368188143,
1.4657158852,
-0.2720169127,
0.8849854469,
0.2966586947,
0.1677625626,
0.4402557313,
0.2113447636,
-0.0369586386,
0.1161255613,
0.2883678675,
0.0591891669,
-0.5983896852,
0.107742101,
-0.1452234238,
0.8332665563,
0.5707278252,
-0.6403617859,
0.2304868847,
-0.038198553,
0.0905632973,
-0.0861739591,
-0.3711536825,
0.7340711355,
0.3634811044,
-0.7078285217,
0.1394240111,
-0.3116298616,
0.3222763836,
-0.4564879239,
0.110050641,
-0.1894682199,
0.2024309933,
0.1153484955,
-1.3170086145,
-0.0195020437,
-0.1699630618,
0.0837563649,
-0.4537365735,
0.8407330513,
-0.226570949,
-0.3008600771,
0.2607239783,
0.9899169207,
0.5819745064,
-0.2647872567,
-0.6249989271,
0.2207072675,
-0.0618657172,
-0.438580811,
0.4762972891,
0.5951673985,
0.0983607844,
1.0530862808,
0.3207907081,
-0.1348590106,
0.0068578417,
0.2433120757,
0.6707420945,
-0.8527939916,
-0.3155041635,
-0.9431453347,
0.0118867187,
0.0354685448,
-0.2625595331,
1.1921950579,
0.6177487969,
0.8556105494,
-0.0269767493,
0.7751123309,
0.1706496477,
0.2616923153,
-0.5142537355,
0.7097096443,
-0.3925158679,
0.134751156,
-0.0446970537,
-0.7691264749,
0.0608572103,
0.6767137647,
-0.5593568087,
0.1406190693,
0.6298442483,
0.5876049399,
0.2702234089,
0.0777086467,
0.7273954153,
0.34704566,
0.1519644111,
0.4133397341,
1.1751110554,
0.0618005618,
0.4558062851,
-0.2879127264,
-0.0583187081,
-0.1634415835,
-0.7691268921,
-1.3249217272,
-0.5978230834,
-0.2097887546,
-0.2023214847,
-0.3394284546,
0.8341395855,
0.4331998229,
-0.3020874858,
-0.4518412054,
0.0632693693,
-0.0271077529,
0.1631097198,
-0.0805489942,
0.1365825385,
-0.4906175435,
-0.5074792504,
0.4498010278,
0.3127962649,
0.2748148143,
-1.0099326372,
-0.04575333,
-0.0665070415,
0.199940294,
0.6668313146,
0.1548881978,
-0.7472962141,
-0.3417624831,
0.1711422652,
-0.4113562107,
0.0232019462,
0.7573338151,
-0.6123114228,
0.6189873815,
0.2459857166,
0.2770908177,
0.7675590515,
-0.2013180256,
0.5279763937,
-0.2299045622,
-0.2954606116,
0.0633259192,
0.4227275252,
0.3625113666,
-0.3455117643,
0.5072904229,
-0.0603340305,
-0.9168095589,
-0.5268747211,
0.2561298013,
-0.8620599508,
-0.2080772072,
1.0948477983,
0.0585592911,
-0.3251660168,
0.302772522,
-0.0953253061,
0.1244711503,
-0.2065290958,
0.8492947817,
0.8076704741,
-0.5903730392,
-0.1814654469,
-0.6067255139,
0.1520459801,
0.3646066189,
-0.7092425227,
0.309128195,
0.452986896,
0.3509548604,
0.2185075879,
0.8789534569,
0.209509477,
-0.1578746438,
0.0922810137,
0.2455068678,
-0.0002670217,
-0.5331674814,
-0.3404244781,
-0.0876807496,
0.3764409721,
0.0684406459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01492v1 | RegMix: Data Mixture as Regression for Language Model Pre-training | 2024-07-01T17:31:03 | 2024-07-01T17:31:03 | Qian Liu, Xiaosen Zheng, Niklas Muennighoff, Guangtao Zeng, Longxu Dou, Tianyu Pang, Jing Jiang, Min Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The data mixture for large language model pre-training significantly impacts
performance, yet how to determine an effective mixture remains unclear. We
propose RegMix to automatically identify a high-performing data mixture by
formulating it as a regression task. RegMix involves training a set of small
models with diverse data mixtures and fitting a regression model to predict
their performance given their respective mixtures. With the fitted regression
model, we simulate the top-ranked mixture and use it to train a large-scale
model with orders of magnitude more compute. To empirically validate RegMix, we
train 512 models with 1M parameters for 1B tokens of different mixtures to fit
the regression model and find the optimal mixture. Using this mixture we train
a 1B parameter model for 25B tokens (i.e. 1000x larger and 25x longer) which we
find performs best among 64 candidate 1B parameter models with other mixtures.
Further, our method demonstrates superior performance compared to human
selection and achieves results that match or surpass DoReMi, while utilizing
only 10% of the compute budget. Our experiments also show that (1) Data
mixtures significantly impact performance with single-task performance
variations of up to 14.6%; (2) Web corpora rather than data perceived as
high-quality like Wikipedia have the strongest positive correlation with
downstream performance; (3) Domains interact in complex ways often
contradicting common sense, thus automatic approaches like RegMix are needed;
(4) Data mixture effects transcend scaling laws, and our approach captures the
complexity by considering all domains together. Our code is available at
https://github.com/sail-sg/regmix. | [
-0.4108631313,
-0.7276182175,
0.2846014202,
0.5078859329,
-0.189442724,
0.4076050222,
-0.3749935627,
-0.3231255412,
0.1990527809,
0.5402243137,
-0.4950597882,
-0.2564162314,
-0.6333511472,
0.0701802,
-0.567961216,
0.6023794413,
0.1182347313,
0.2093149573,
-0.3988046348,
0.0637663007,
-0.6721420884,
-0.49706164,
-0.5108569264,
-0.2818047702,
0.4884829223,
0.3330376446,
0.4178431332,
0.7607964873,
0.3641634285,
0.3119452596,
0.3081036806,
0.2078295201,
-0.7628864646,
0.3068763316,
0.0095696328,
-0.6367442608,
-0.2193179578,
0.2431911379,
0.6416071653,
0.6588712335,
-0.368540585,
0.2272019088,
0.1640098244,
0.4883307815,
-0.7016328573,
0.0890471041,
-0.6866406202,
-0.2973850369,
-0.2350996584,
-0.0588553809,
-0.4285673499,
-0.2715028822,
-0.2706982493,
-0.6578193903,
0.1145414636,
0.4442057908,
0.9920706749,
0.4229857922,
-0.1960971653,
0.1981017292,
-0.9697233438,
1.0523639917,
-0.5438632965,
0.7211102247,
0.3372806609,
0.4620176256,
-0.2687980831,
-0.7438343763,
-0.6100227237,
-0.149968192,
0.0591172725,
0.1592079699,
-0.1323002726,
-0.0985692441,
0.1824418157,
0.33973068,
-0.8719673753,
0.0578799434,
-0.117355831,
-0.1425196528,
0.540658772,
0.3704994619,
0.2635432482,
0.4805857539,
-0.2706681192,
-0.2586841583,
-0.5332306623,
-0.1274692714,
0.279989779,
0.5732339621,
0.0617576763,
0.3479701579,
-0.2041830122,
1.0285221338,
-0.1403731257,
-0.4028201997,
0.2316336632,
-0.3026517928,
-0.3600465953,
-0.2402629703,
0.6785245538,
-0.049281165,
0.3520578146,
-0.1970970333,
-0.5052634478,
0.1305716634,
0.336601913,
-0.8842926621,
-0.2165769488,
0.0876066908,
-0.3647562861,
-0.0394939743,
0.137059927,
-0.7086290717,
-0.3479748368,
-0.8598059416,
0.6596418619,
-0.3290619254,
-0.2651563287,
0.4271991849,
-0.210581392,
-0.1177759245,
0.4858949482,
-0.5515108109,
0.6649432778,
0.8388504386,
0.5553252697,
-0.2050807029,
-0.3340522945,
-0.7391486764,
-0.1445475519,
-0.2744366825,
0.6938076019,
-0.7742633224,
-0.3696452081,
-0.1504890025,
-0.3407449126,
-0.3942338526,
-0.9810670018,
-0.0214879997,
-0.3362770975,
0.2545923591,
0.1200334728,
-0.7939705253,
-0.0081842188,
-0.1235745102,
-0.7759815454,
1.160548687,
0.5000702143,
-0.6569512486,
0.7366545796,
-0.2549676001,
-0.5786630511,
0.2285491228,
-0.1225470752,
-0.2876700461,
0.0427927412,
-0.1188040227,
0.4564322233,
-0.6753184199,
0.4068776667,
-0.3979696035,
-0.3578101397,
0.2489676476,
-0.1137793139,
0.7176228166,
0.4286960661,
-0.1272982061,
0.1456207484,
-1.0028260946,
-0.1006444767,
-0.0101317922,
-0.1998024285,
-0.5271507502,
-0.0628181398,
0.3848176599,
0.237801671,
0.2111707628,
-0.5156292915,
-0.0507556573,
-0.0085688988,
-0.0004852069,
0.563251555,
-0.2059256434,
0.4086312056,
-0.3076538742,
0.8411030173,
-0.0239020735,
0.2524483502,
0.1665198058,
-0.5261179805,
-0.707105577,
-0.6923472285,
0.6308171153,
0.562613368,
-0.5241810679,
0.6540772319,
-0.2003293931,
-0.6513018012,
-0.7302430272,
0.3498383462,
0.1049685776,
0.5458245277,
0.3065518737,
-0.2658924162,
-0.8531575203,
-0.909752667,
-0.1768618375,
-0.1912436485,
0.0101708127,
0.2001583725,
0.3739698827,
-0.3023843169,
1.3582344055,
-0.748028338,
-0.0961389318,
-0.3727947176,
0.3531208038,
0.1488828957,
0.5674470067,
0.5065168738,
-0.784701705,
-0.5673546791,
-0.0701312423,
-0.332978785,
-0.1877418756,
-0.1298404038,
-0.1057485193,
-0.1727541983,
0.2934637368,
-0.1786659658,
0.1368092299,
0.623229444,
-0.1527369022,
0.4390388131,
-0.1607507914,
0.0648669004,
-1.1516233683,
0.3323319852,
0.4037113488,
-0.2951302528,
-0.6081821322,
-0.0439165421,
0.0291255675,
0.0286058281,
-0.2085281312,
0.65401721,
-0.0562618598,
0.2171489,
-0.2941879034,
-0.3994216621,
-0.1115243956,
0.0952720568,
0.1437644362,
1.0735098124,
0.5436543226,
-0.505548358,
0.2546513975,
-0.1013026759,
-0.5113779902,
0.1649895012,
-0.3753926754,
-0.2021925002,
-0.0689499676,
0.3123404682,
-1.1821489334,
-0.151872471,
-0.1537567377,
-0.4453806877,
0.2490170151,
-0.0208210461,
-0.6109730601,
-0.2819935083,
0.0835188106,
0.2595377862,
0.7179727554,
-0.2088841647,
0.7908625007,
0.5314438343,
-0.1777237654,
-0.5244972706,
-0.5165560246,
0.0413346253,
-0.4329229593,
-0.6998876929,
0.1708100438,
-0.1130076051,
-0.3305224776,
-0.2870380282,
-0.1256177872,
-0.6099709868,
0.4002975225,
0.2057268918,
0.3316984773,
-0.2059342712,
-0.1767771691,
-0.2595444918,
-0.1832562834,
-0.1116836444,
-0.2597665191,
0.8144373894,
0.1894876212,
0.1614770889,
-0.267550528,
0.3711398244,
0.4902305603,
-0.3529013991,
0.8270783424,
0.7792309523,
-0.3272777796,
-0.3717539012,
-0.6890944242,
-0.2782019675,
-0.4373889267,
0.330935061,
-0.3463107944,
-0.9660005569,
0.5719730258,
-0.0606090501,
-0.0575753115,
0.2484689057,
0.4825694859,
0.0709014609,
1.0531326532,
0.7083797455,
-0.514522016,
0.6256326437,
-0.1513685584,
0.2478338033,
-0.1793081015,
-0.1756118089,
-0.8097152114,
-0.2620826662,
-0.4592267275,
-0.363979429,
0.1324638128,
-0.0920666903,
-0.2213376164,
0.4111329019,
-0.00288835,
0.3539262116,
0.6744619608,
-0.1018436253,
0.1991719157,
0.0654930696,
0.1664290428,
0.108392179,
-0.8340070248,
-0.2049177587,
0.992449224,
0.2503289878,
1.1956039667,
-0.3266113698,
0.911056757,
0.1408332139,
0.4531435072,
-0.6291314363,
0.5234514475,
-0.3997260928,
-0.5964725018,
-0.0494307205,
-0.8062788844,
-1.1541249752,
0.1025338024,
-0.3975201547,
-0.4862710536,
0.1775010079,
0.1834807843,
-0.4310984612,
-0.0383651704,
-0.8251270056,
0.8260368109,
-0.0382914841,
-0.2377475053,
-0.2772145569,
-0.7112028003,
0.2736294568,
-0.458978951,
0.3625242412,
0.0485787913,
0.0554360896,
0.7757887244,
-0.320553273,
0.6894572377,
-0.1786975861,
-0.0440093689,
0.1170018762,
0.1543329358,
0.2817023993,
-0.2020012587,
0.1465925872,
0.1092538461,
-0.2088745236,
-0.3478119969,
-0.6726376414,
0.4768698812,
-0.76454252,
-0.4271980822,
-0.0945149288,
-0.5721527338,
-0.4902429581,
0.10794539,
0.1763040572,
0.3271677196,
-0.0427671783,
0.3578126132,
0.5748828053,
0.0013542598,
0.1044791937,
0.4674694538,
-0.4253470004,
-0.3268927634,
1.414249897,
0.0877344236,
0.1658671647,
0.4250508845,
0.2976777256,
-0.2316890061,
-0.5160117745,
-0.2257157415,
0.1636859924,
-0.1808379591,
-0.205804348,
-0.5619035959,
-0.1372535825,
-0.410731256,
0.1621807665,
-0.549446404,
-0.341008693,
-0.1662595272,
0.2353852689,
0.0777214691,
0.5702235103,
0.0019747571,
0.5222294927,
-0.8019566536,
0.2657390833,
0.276306808,
0.3549791574,
-0.1919608712,
-0.415394783,
-0.5243026614,
0.0258829165,
0.2954584658,
-0.4620704055,
0.5968250036,
0.1003270522,
0.6308591962,
0.4648855031,
-0.331893146,
0.7696368098,
-0.40918383,
0.6165717244,
0.1508968323,
-0.694190979,
0.3314217627,
-0.2555027306,
-0.175912708,
0.7142942548,
0.4149164855,
-0.4334796369,
-0.6079825163,
-0.626986444,
-0.8890597224,
0.646418035,
0.2068580389,
-0.1983625293,
0.1257467568,
0.1570119411,
0.3291547894,
0.3667395413,
-0.3935366869,
-0.4404955506,
0.1315294951,
-0.4503948092,
-0.3514359891,
0.0083487341,
-0.0380902812,
-0.4437168837,
0.5686702728,
0.0922537595,
0.0714074373,
-0.3938475251,
-0.1214902028,
-0.0412011668,
-0.231820628,
0.4900488257,
0.7246728539,
-0.4334387183,
0.0235610101,
-0.3753924072,
-0.7294563651,
0.2821093202,
0.2378083766,
0.0496524274,
-0.0669381469,
0.2751169503,
0.5993025899,
-0.199797973,
-0.9384518862,
0.4351295531,
-0.2610979974,
-0.2033078671,
0.0411385372,
0.4514974356,
-0.1228822842,
-0.0058089602,
0.3969231546,
0.1591390818,
0.064962633,
-0.3662560284,
0.4211838841,
0.2142273188,
-0.1414235085,
-0.0956063122,
0.6430426836,
0.1805053204,
-0.0175158083,
0.5247808099,
0.0443170406,
-0.3890208304,
0.7904374003,
0.6221357584,
0.8352956772,
-0.5769720674,
0.1209600121,
0.1651876569,
0.1664121151,
-0.3143359721,
0.3657946885,
0.2085158825,
-0.8045728803,
-0.6507825255,
-0.7011594772,
-0.1464792341,
0.2278340459,
-0.6387432218,
0.1758141071,
-0.2545157671,
-0.0715667456,
0.0432277918,
-0.0077366857,
-0.687595427,
0.6914677024,
0.2832311392,
1.0003495216,
-1.3365434408,
0.9591475129,
0.722425282,
-0.2868940532,
-0.8776728511,
0.0161934998,
-0.1184706986,
-0.7972415686,
0.871530652,
-0.0066916631,
-0.0585673489,
0.052668795,
-0.481444329,
-0.8315201998,
0.6650726199,
0.5103623867,
-0.5749929547,
0.2967166305,
0.280846417,
0.3401969671,
-0.6095343232,
0.1809588671,
0.6143808365,
0.5108446479,
0.0587987714,
-0.8619176149,
-0.1128889248,
-0.1363085955,
-0.0003905375,
0.225298509,
-0.4966900647,
0.9459267259,
0.3430072665,
-0.1179008558,
-0.0507324636,
0.5900709629,
0.1335076392,
0.2469305247,
0.7706063986,
0.6812306046,
0.7933818102,
-0.020531591,
1.0832196474,
-0.5125673413,
0.32559219,
1.1354461908,
-0.4096604586,
0.8541650176,
0.371237129,
-0.3951744735,
0.3246636987,
0.8039861321,
0.1857110411,
0.5038607717,
0.3738661706,
-0.3508287966,
-0.6398066282,
-0.0225296188,
-0.2649206817,
0.4231549501,
0.3068614006,
-0.1053715944,
-0.2376209646,
0.1681052595,
-0.0306739602,
0.0702539235,
-0.0666231364,
0.6394681931,
-0.1484015137,
-0.6892459989,
0.5294175744,
-0.0274369139,
0.5182709694,
-0.7471586466,
0.0184630286,
-0.3821274638,
0.1353612095,
-0.0366087109,
-0.5711096525,
0.0705129579,
-0.1699378788,
-0.0873026401,
-0.1471512616,
0.6045630574,
-0.7191867828,
-0.4572270215,
0.1864998043,
0.7168237567,
-0.1082999855,
-0.3269610405,
-0.562626183,
0.1238991395,
0.1576235294,
-0.1125326008,
0.5819174051,
0.2629128098,
0.0928581208,
0.7656506896,
0.6044300795,
0.2394032627,
0.0337813273,
0.1858226359,
0.9640237689,
-0.4597246051,
-0.4668683112,
-0.7641753554,
0.3987922072,
-0.1065734923,
-0.2739086151,
0.5723101497,
1.2212384939,
0.7677654624,
-0.0613215975,
0.8327106833,
0.0861164108,
0.4974951446,
-0.3360384703,
0.5111438036,
-0.7903870344,
0.0118334098,
-0.0867334455,
-1.148363471,
-0.4567861259,
0.5289396048,
-0.1117943451,
0.0904155672,
0.4757623971,
0.920217216,
-0.2294824719,
0.1226284504,
0.2550105155,
0.1995013058,
0.2254544646,
0.2188112885,
0.7542849779,
0.0182411149,
0.1992975771,
-0.2819160819,
-0.4299555719,
-0.2809494734,
-0.5952830315,
-0.5655426979,
-0.7097122073,
-0.4062492847,
-0.3919365704,
-0.016784301,
1.0398358107,
0.9932000637,
-0.6663574576,
-0.7515850663,
-0.1048627719,
-0.1270397007,
-0.3546581864,
-0.2710180879,
-0.0180673525,
-0.6668581367,
-0.7331393361,
0.4527528584,
0.2066496909,
-0.000957699,
-0.1801700294,
0.0602362081,
-0.134935692,
0.1459146589,
0.4247421324,
0.0248440541,
-0.3412423432,
0.0782121122,
-0.0493662767,
-0.2429377139,
0.0866262689,
1.1700482368,
-0.8598608971,
0.5231921077,
0.4969142675,
0.8805807233,
0.5307837129,
0.214086175,
0.8127209544,
-0.7519823909,
0.1038148403,
0.3407947421,
0.2987924814,
0.003522272,
-0.2027288228,
0.4892598391,
0.4245056808,
-0.3653255105,
-0.7119374871,
-0.0054429197,
-1.1026426554,
-0.4425506294,
1.2285070419,
0.0271654055,
-0.2977323234,
-0.2279337645,
-0.2142088264,
0.0259585474,
-0.4539082646,
0.6032705307,
0.6809723377,
-0.0696968883,
0.0924681872,
-0.5982449651,
0.4694138765,
0.3966711462,
-0.7191513777,
0.1925961822,
0.5468180776,
0.384711653,
-0.163712889,
0.3664965034,
0.2045425028,
-0.053920351,
0.1084751561,
0.1286547184,
0.0533617958,
-0.4892680347,
-0.1549409777,
0.1050725281,
-0.0698138103,
-0.15340662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01491v1 | Expressive and Generalizable Low-rank Adaptation for Large Models via Slow Cascaded Learning | 2024-07-01T17:28:59 | 2024-07-01T17:28:59 | Siwei Li, Yifan Yang, Yifei Shen, Fangyun Wei, Zongqing Lu, Lili Qiu, Yuqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Efficient fine-tuning plays a fundamental role in modern large models, with
low-rank adaptation emerging as a particularly promising approach. However, the
existing variants of LoRA are hampered by limited expressiveness, a tendency to
overfit, and sensitivity to hyperparameter settings. This paper presents LoRA
Slow Cascade Learning (LoRASC), an innovative technique designed to enhance
LoRA's expressiveness and generalization capabilities while preserving its
training efficiency. Our approach augments expressiveness through a cascaded
learning strategy that enables a mixture-of-low-rank adaptation, thereby
increasing the model's ability to capture complex patterns. Additionally, we
introduce a slow-fast update mechanism and cascading noisy tuning to bolster
generalization. The extensive experiments on various language and vision
datasets, as well as robustness benchmarks, demonstrate that the proposed
method not only significantly outperforms existing baselines, but also
mitigates overfitting, enhances model stability, and improves OOD robustness.
Code will be release in https://github.com/microsoft/LoRASC very soon. | [
-0.1706977934,
-0.8197926879,
0.18150343,
0.1429794133,
-0.3728320301,
-0.0009655414,
-0.4207241237,
-0.6413175464,
0.2108469754,
0.1710308492,
-0.4206648171,
-0.6552928686,
-0.6290425062,
-0.2761989236,
-0.3630694747,
1.113137722,
0.0554146767,
-0.2731139362,
0.2277508229,
-0.5212025642,
-0.2585799396,
-0.2004374564,
-0.8899926543,
-0.3209851682,
1.1813508272,
0.3554911017,
0.5961407423,
0.5920723081,
0.5666546822,
0.2644156516,
-0.2671612799,
0.3142115176,
-0.8045524955,
0.1862953156,
-0.3738950789,
-0.4839592576,
-0.8661338091,
-0.1947346628,
0.6784613729,
0.859960258,
-0.3304078281,
0.3166754246,
0.4783167243,
0.7938810587,
-1.3232148886,
0.2120712399,
-0.7511411905,
0.0598913692,
-0.2597533762,
-0.1352105588,
-0.3585152924,
-0.1839592755,
0.0505065881,
-0.7860687971,
-0.2088269144,
-0.1864625216,
0.6168169975,
0.5847427845,
-0.1380843669,
0.0133300498,
-0.8092136979,
0.8636205196,
-0.6016947627,
0.0189749841,
0.2229766548,
0.6636102796,
-0.0269744024,
-0.7079389095,
-0.044271417,
-0.0952262059,
0.2977020741,
0.2206285596,
-0.3035937846,
-0.1188250259,
0.4085659087,
0.2900745571,
-0.11621508,
0.651638329,
0.0490472615,
-0.0040612998,
0.2768599391,
0.1058511138,
-0.1710730046,
0.2825545371,
-0.2414150834,
0.0153791681,
-0.6595391035,
0.2301300019,
0.0684385225,
0.6906544566,
-0.363640666,
0.3586033881,
-0.4965991378,
0.8764673471,
0.313134104,
-0.0494742543,
0.206249103,
0.1116474196,
-0.2753010094,
-0.1528282315,
0.3460806608,
-0.0121779423,
0.032795243,
-0.0689922646,
-0.3617495298,
0.0681287274,
-0.1373505145,
-0.8735157251,
0.1449639052,
0.0919519886,
-0.639100492,
-0.6467048526,
-0.2003378868,
-0.6151100397,
-0.4503956735,
-0.4531061649,
0.5559081435,
-0.0609178133,
0.2041876465,
0.118861489,
0.3092522919,
0.4677495658,
0.910964489,
-0.8170360923,
0.4200524986,
0.603253305,
0.9176146388,
-0.2828890085,
-0.4660096765,
-1.3918861151,
0.1254789233,
-0.5101276636,
0.6786020994,
-0.3847931921,
0.1325674951,
-0.1364144981,
-0.1803887933,
0.0581762977,
-0.6081160903,
0.4275445044,
-0.5123226047,
-0.1003184617,
-0.1223916262,
0.2251595557,
0.1988772154,
0.0337430127,
-0.7433780432,
0.9526354671,
0.1981945485,
-0.7614358664,
0.3498304486,
-0.8448386788,
-0.5761361718,
-0.1586274803,
-0.0302236918,
-0.4683252871,
0.4071958065,
0.2626077533,
0.328328371,
-0.1670468599,
-0.1823595464,
-0.4168533981,
-0.6519610286,
0.1202674508,
-0.1046562418,
0.5641731024,
0.2625842988,
-0.0988293588,
0.2009680718,
-0.783995986,
0.0284194369,
0.0454210453,
-0.6505180001,
-0.3025010526,
0.2067172825,
-0.0499517918,
0.2214725763,
0.108951956,
-0.2254140973,
0.5940945148,
-0.3258915246,
0.6570949554,
0.8394764066,
-0.2204154283,
0.4638108313,
-0.2620536983,
0.2877237797,
0.3797501624,
0.1910133064,
0.0264368765,
-0.3009305596,
-0.9061466455,
-0.5684856772,
0.7547200322,
0.5244261622,
-0.892889142,
0.4555627406,
-0.4359463751,
-0.3085536361,
-0.4650657773,
0.4031868577,
0.3170777261,
0.4623344839,
0.4322661161,
-0.6163130999,
-0.2730532885,
-0.6907840967,
-0.4470106363,
0.1547579318,
-0.0165928863,
0.1887694299,
0.465867877,
-0.1978842765,
0.8979772925,
-0.5333738923,
-0.7052628398,
-0.3975404501,
0.3451761305,
0.1672196239,
0.5907845497,
0.70652771,
-0.4834784269,
-0.4128005803,
0.1637617499,
-0.5748398304,
0.0860643536,
0.198663041,
-0.3448980749,
-0.0221829526,
0.6044352651,
-0.5320038795,
0.5629184842,
0.565925777,
0.0761309937,
0.0591158159,
-0.1266470551,
-0.1121898592,
-1.0414553881,
0.2450100631,
-0.1019355282,
-0.3802498281,
-0.4949802458,
0.2211299986,
-0.1553024799,
-0.3285250366,
-0.6535127163,
0.4792948663,
-0.320287466,
-0.1351249963,
-0.217268452,
0.0849975497,
-0.2113653868,
0.6016327739,
-0.0692641661,
0.3863721192,
0.9539503455,
-0.531332314,
0.0460727848,
0.1149426475,
-0.6444612145,
0.6200919747,
-0.4921680093,
0.2670114636,
-0.2591551542,
0.6270301342,
-0.4102420211,
-0.4672426283,
0.1230329946,
-0.011807194,
0.292034775,
-0.487136215,
-0.190692544,
-0.0335033014,
-0.4120019376,
0.5134308934,
0.7600083947,
-0.6980864406,
1.0586825609,
-0.1064699814,
0.0656384304,
-0.7257888317,
-1.0333862305,
-0.1409139335,
-0.2605956197,
-0.2625249922,
0.275898397,
-0.0208502505,
-0.0904157609,
-0.3479415476,
-0.0676783919,
0.0396025851,
0.4001209438,
0.1381590813,
0.1323560029,
-0.4390313625,
-0.0470208414,
0.0069579063,
-0.0649020448,
-0.6357167959,
-0.2449713051,
0.4090381861,
-0.0736629218,
-0.2959862947,
-0.6036548018,
0.2131790072,
0.7124086618,
-0.257922709,
0.6644682288,
0.6884862781,
-0.4261013269,
-0.7704337239,
-0.1451729238,
-0.1174719781,
-0.4446338713,
0.4737514853,
-0.5239764452,
-0.6902962923,
0.7728754878,
-0.3847696185,
-0.0878606513,
0.3743864894,
0.6536258459,
-0.0720336661,
0.9314022064,
0.8332042694,
-0.417935282,
0.8845606446,
-0.3331247866,
0.0186301395,
-0.9087873697,
0.0297150686,
-0.6629630327,
-0.848546207,
-0.6584940553,
-0.529065907,
0.3133039474,
0.3361003697,
-0.1560095251,
0.0933032855,
-0.0819987804,
0.5820448995,
0.2737349272,
0.4346160889,
0.4969952404,
0.2313476354,
0.3380264342,
0.3087653518,
-0.5442253947,
-0.0179800186,
0.7899302244,
0.382273525,
1.3391728401,
0.3003940284,
0.6374567151,
0.4276438653,
0.2868175507,
-1.0508892536,
0.3569282889,
-0.6476979256,
-0.1134281531,
-0.2905419767,
-0.5736387968,
-0.7691181302,
0.1348166615,
-0.2806407511,
-0.6900425553,
0.6734348536,
0.5257680416,
-0.6025194526,
0.2021699399,
-0.4546869993,
0.6454530358,
-0.069799915,
-0.6160338521,
-0.2526377141,
-0.627967298,
0.2478465289,
-0.3117527068,
0.1160439923,
-0.0599194095,
-0.2011866868,
0.5806027055,
-0.3506104648,
1.0605330467,
-0.3624728918,
-0.3019385934,
0.1289864928,
0.1081672162,
0.8848528862,
-0.309476912,
-0.1566054672,
0.0785977021,
-0.4696848392,
-0.7075537443,
-0.906252563,
0.849525094,
-0.6755656004,
-0.1386196911,
-0.2369598299,
-0.4340695739,
-0.4751088619,
-0.0167456642,
0.152529791,
0.458088547,
-0.3143564165,
0.1259524077,
0.518219471,
0.0001204211,
0.375477165,
0.3383715153,
-0.2374725044,
-0.0308483075,
1.0903443098,
-0.0072688558,
0.5351874828,
0.3087452352,
0.3540420234,
0.3067071438,
-0.6297489405,
-0.3300508559,
-0.0416084342,
-0.8473091125,
-0.230104655,
-0.1657679528,
-0.2138732821,
-0.097455129,
-0.1777686179,
-0.3618720174,
-0.6760640144,
-0.4406200647,
0.3755246401,
0.1969242692,
0.7454265356,
-0.0087991776,
0.4611382186,
-0.1297053099,
0.6227912307,
0.5981733203,
0.3587103188,
0.1472583711,
-0.7660127282,
-0.4421122372,
-0.0480746068,
-0.2535221875,
-0.0055547762,
0.0654037446,
0.8538435102,
0.1468622386,
0.5592483878,
-0.120536983,
0.8871259093,
-0.3594132066,
0.5017850399,
0.2571361065,
-1.0104510784,
0.6076036692,
-0.3578779399,
0.5163249373,
0.6868286729,
0.1703247875,
-0.1487620026,
-0.0505725853,
-0.1581781805,
-0.6347261071,
0.5885062814,
-0.082103163,
0.0284885447,
0.4699730277,
0.3274529576,
0.0349900238,
0.030800486,
-0.6130194664,
0.1618560404,
-0.2918069959,
-0.2319627106,
-0.0984063968,
0.0937688127,
-0.3469716907,
-0.375,
0.4880007803,
-0.6499322653,
-0.0213270355,
-0.0984841362,
-0.3525116146,
-0.1932432055,
0.3561808765,
0.5775342584,
0.4391669929,
-0.2356411666,
0.1117145717,
0.2192162871,
-0.4683525562,
-0.1140290797,
-0.108731322,
-0.1661019474,
-0.5157435536,
0.5788799524,
0.8768055439,
0.4299320281,
-0.4196895957,
0.5699217319,
0.1438733637,
0.0205145143,
0.3338066339,
0.1429252625,
-0.1989703029,
0.182134077,
0.4580359757,
0.5782034397,
0.0602235571,
-0.8403015137,
-0.338080287,
0.3949523568,
-0.3726559877,
-0.3907932639,
0.511375308,
0.1804193556,
0.1059456319,
0.3143430352,
0.0962045863,
-0.2011756897,
0.2438992858,
0.3673077226,
0.967957139,
-0.0844738185,
0.0123154595,
0.0417771153,
-0.0252778474,
-0.2351667732,
0.1888518333,
-0.2018717825,
-0.5315595269,
-0.5869626403,
-0.7189800143,
-0.3834060431,
-0.0544364899,
-0.7838574052,
0.5010607839,
-0.6243037581,
-0.2780922949,
0.1792566925,
-0.2408100963,
-0.564710021,
-0.0108759403,
0.1730285734,
1.0204386711,
-1.0026934147,
0.9548303485,
0.4646461904,
-0.3460305929,
-0.4710175693,
0.2785204053,
-0.1691686809,
-0.7622295618,
0.8905451298,
-0.1705584526,
-0.644061029,
0.1531023085,
-0.9814978838,
-0.9128038883,
1.1373072863,
0.6588767171,
-0.5276570916,
-0.2837340236,
-0.0451774821,
0.6684359908,
-0.5531744361,
0.0076899086,
0.4473368227,
0.3177130818,
0.1777525693,
-0.8729313016,
-0.1486284882,
-0.0356103294,
0.1599913836,
-0.1134890765,
-0.8168027401,
1.0191935301,
-0.3389725983,
-0.0641279295,
0.5068728924,
0.6793034673,
-0.0144192949,
0.0693766177,
0.5113543272,
0.7026532292,
0.6616473198,
-0.1059307903,
0.8246023059,
-0.0086896056,
0.3797779977,
1.3455057144,
-0.6058210731,
1.1585794687,
0.4114924967,
0.1377693564,
0.9230611324,
0.4128370881,
0.2581466436,
0.8044891357,
0.2732539475,
-0.1365253031,
-0.415838927,
-0.2277588695,
-0.2049380392,
0.6788876057,
0.2604333162,
-0.2769592106,
-0.4166277051,
0.2927275896,
-0.4230999351,
-0.2405266315,
-0.8221603036,
0.7656088471,
0.1259618998,
-0.3994967341,
0.8817138076,
-0.1643199325,
0.6501553655,
-0.649102509,
-0.0942330211,
-0.19728297,
0.47485888,
-0.5430397391,
-0.2712459564,
-0.2162552178,
-0.1381673068,
-0.245378077,
0.0639358684,
0.5885822177,
-0.2420438975,
-0.3896360397,
0.3163703084,
0.537525773,
-0.0417478494,
-0.0007761102,
-0.5876714587,
0.4368955493,
-0.4431664348,
-0.1069401801,
0.5978902578,
0.387504071,
-0.4847233891,
0.7256063223,
0.5413777232,
0.3261918128,
-0.1239344701,
0.4911342263,
1.135286212,
-0.4204445779,
-0.4094988406,
-0.4650921226,
0.4523146451,
0.1640169024,
-0.2602931559,
0.3614470363,
0.4970465004,
0.5167836547,
-0.1945778877,
0.6655948758,
0.0159365162,
0.5676497221,
-0.860347867,
0.6201159358,
-0.5866415501,
0.2578291595,
-0.3283986747,
-1.0504814386,
-0.3393056393,
0.4899564385,
-0.3393783867,
0.2245681137,
0.6264337301,
0.5444340706,
-0.6604064703,
-0.4753402174,
0.4264109135,
0.6052182913,
-0.0683135539,
0.7092617154,
1.0095202923,
-0.4295659959,
0.1722090691,
-0.1270514876,
-0.4901060164,
-0.433193773,
-1.0642210245,
-0.8862640262,
-0.3059334159,
-0.4702327251,
-0.4448284507,
0.0976523086,
0.810397625,
0.959621191,
-0.8691160083,
-0.1544829011,
0.1763032526,
-0.0811558142,
-0.5513517857,
-0.1239659041,
0.4823604822,
-0.1980148703,
-0.6309610009,
0.4843970239,
0.2003157288,
-0.0139038498,
-0.2375412583,
-0.0686164647,
0.0695224479,
0.1757406145,
0.945392251,
0.571965456,
-0.6169568896,
-0.2376373112,
-0.4878091514,
-0.0533059016,
0.2040853798,
0.9711441398,
-1.05300951,
0.0528970137,
0.2756635249,
0.4439210892,
0.5867479444,
0.3888702989,
0.0059817126,
-0.6697275043,
0.4594525993,
0.1994798779,
0.2052974105,
0.2075440437,
-0.1024230197,
0.3347733915,
0.0575526394,
-0.2761299908,
-0.9021211863,
0.4219137728,
-1.4938111305,
-0.1498653591,
0.8275423646,
-0.0842018127,
-0.5442276001,
0.1075982153,
-0.1472619623,
-0.0695263743,
-0.4735974371,
0.73357445,
0.184000507,
-0.1230481789,
0.1584428996,
-0.3270776868,
0.6016222835,
0.2398070842,
-0.9712179899,
0.3071532845,
0.3217654824,
0.2350414097,
0.1519966722,
0.4661102891,
0.0413394198,
0.4479248524,
-0.4382689893,
-0.207336247,
0.1920246333,
-0.4367206395,
-0.7958133221,
0.1837110519,
0.4945203364,
0.0564506203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01490v1 | LLM See, LLM Do: Guiding Data Generation to Target Non-Differentiable Objectives | 2024-07-01T17:26:21 | 2024-07-01T17:26:21 | Luísa Shimabucoro, Sebastian Ruder, Julia Kreutzer, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The widespread adoption of synthetic data raises new questions about how
models generating the data can influence other large language models (LLMs) via
distilled data. To start, our work exhaustively characterizes the impact of
passive inheritance of model properties by systematically studying the
consequences of synthetic data integration. We provide one of the most
comprehensive studies to-date of how the source of synthetic data shapes
models' internal biases, calibration and generations' textual attributes and
preferences. We find that models are surprisingly sensitive towards certain
attributes even when the synthetic data prompts appear "neutral". which invites
the question whether this sensitivity can be exploited for good.
Our findings invite the question can we explicitly steer the models towards
the properties we want at test time by exploiting the data generation process?
This would have historically been considered infeasible due to the cost of
collecting data with a specific characteristic or objective in mind. However,
improvement in the quality of synthetic data, as well as a shift towards
general-purpose models designed to follow a diverse way of instructions, means
this question is timely. We propose active inheritance as a term to describe
intentionally constraining synthetic data according to a non-differentiable
objective. We demonstrate how active inheritance can steer the generation
profiles of models towards desirable non-differentiable attributes, e.g. high
lexical diversity or low toxicity. | [
-0.0973959193,
-0.7126367092,
0.4239660203,
0.1280766577,
-0.0072367596,
0.0798670724,
-0.0863240659,
-0.5094313622,
-0.1481510848,
0.5849987268,
-0.5965244174,
-0.1474200636,
-0.5971767306,
0.0562758222,
-0.4519908726,
0.9469635487,
-0.228015244,
0.0633006096,
-0.1098699495,
-0.0808608159,
0.018931035,
-0.5686480403,
-0.153059274,
-0.2818700075,
0.6890688539,
0.3431332707,
0.938326478,
0.8216686845,
0.0769078285,
0.1898028702,
-0.2957995236,
0.1935030371,
-0.8054016829,
0.4446645677,
-0.3491403461,
-0.7550106645,
-0.5393220782,
0.4294814467,
0.5711945295,
1.0480672121,
0.1998247802,
0.0406835265,
0.0291457009,
0.6082945466,
-0.7388964891,
-0.0361806266,
-0.7638686895,
-0.0496396013,
-0.1532861292,
-0.0614494011,
-0.4095532298,
-0.1941166818,
0.0500156172,
-0.2762761414,
0.5519652963,
-0.0710165873,
0.6228385568,
0.2678985,
-0.8955898285,
-0.2632488906,
-1.0802607536,
1.0576068163,
-0.694372654,
0.3347766399,
0.3375655711,
-0.0620735176,
-0.3326244652,
-0.6279277205,
-0.7324045897,
-0.4574323297,
0.1466372013,
0.1687991917,
-0.2834847271,
0.0317643173,
0.2637233138,
0.6015057564,
-0.1035171896,
0.0228658784,
-0.6537937522,
0.0273890849,
0.8501886725,
0.0295335613,
0.3436841965,
0.0813203305,
-0.174888894,
0.0424361601,
-1.0988745689,
-0.2260213345,
0.8938418031,
0.625004828,
-0.0717110634,
1.0479688644,
-0.3110060394,
0.4574759305,
0.1913594157,
0.1794816852,
0.232383579,
-0.6701934338,
0.0858744457,
0.2826174498,
0.3423059583,
0.0185669847,
0.2594974935,
-0.1553476006,
-0.4216763079,
0.2737701237,
0.2896183133,
-0.5668665171,
-0.2066049427,
0.1261094809,
-0.251963079,
-0.5801784992,
0.071643807,
-0.5432881117,
-0.1505245119,
-0.8027044535,
0.2712032795,
-0.0339238159,
-0.3718308806,
0.091208443,
-0.1255533397,
0.2731599212,
0.1579690725,
-0.984539628,
0.2275437266,
0.4673261642,
0.5338398218,
-0.4168052375,
0.0058514341,
-0.4644778371,
0.363845259,
-0.3429363668,
0.6237796545,
-0.849134922,
-0.7292804122,
-0.2735190392,
0.2126879543,
0.1134212241,
-0.6480589509,
0.3850646913,
-0.3379323483,
0.3588895202,
-0.1491122842,
-0.0851987526,
-0.0422461182,
-0.1146230474,
-0.7733874917,
0.9805585146,
0.2920778096,
-0.4995395243,
0.5490182638,
-0.4948745966,
-0.6820170879,
-0.1954213381,
-0.0387675688,
-0.4219929278,
0.5034614801,
-0.0844474286,
0.1924045533,
-0.4266241193,
0.1713931859,
-0.4975961745,
0.0726628751,
0.2492937148,
-0.6096012592,
0.7273263931,
0.276196599,
-0.5963241458,
0.0831749067,
-0.8788813353,
0.0370628387,
0.042101495,
-0.23631832,
-0.4526923597,
0.206068188,
-0.0364893191,
0.2567488849,
0.3040973246,
-0.4310730994,
0.405376941,
-0.1220400557,
0.201872766,
0.8274610639,
0.2498636544,
0.7474883199,
-0.522408545,
0.5319069028,
0.2295339108,
0.3304944634,
0.3247160017,
-0.4794608355,
-0.7189694643,
-0.0787473321,
0.3517586887,
0.2154095322,
-0.4289987385,
0.2595933676,
0.1357407719,
-0.5349141955,
-0.6094454527,
0.3894920647,
0.2947755456,
0.3397279382,
0.2258065641,
-0.1412398219,
-0.5027649999,
-1.191616416,
0.1282878965,
-0.2424734533,
0.0845497623,
0.3710063696,
0.3141794503,
-0.4392105341,
0.6609874964,
-0.4429288208,
0.2487766445,
-0.6193351746,
0.0452662595,
0.0555249639,
0.4295116663,
0.3717571497,
-1.0278517008,
-0.4386661947,
-0.0514275022,
-0.643025279,
-0.5928727984,
-0.0388512984,
-0.3626322746,
-0.1298328787,
-0.0015013935,
-0.4754668176,
0.2809481621,
0.6247551441,
-0.2712877095,
0.3691848516,
-0.1329452544,
-0.074323833,
-0.9028819799,
0.0279429909,
0.0190762114,
0.0893861949,
-0.9264124632,
-0.1352159977,
-0.0190134924,
0.059146367,
-0.6543557644,
0.7151776552,
-0.6514215469,
0.0753874928,
-0.3152858913,
-0.1394212395,
0.153261587,
0.1554140896,
0.0990465656,
0.692266047,
0.5946255922,
-0.8669400811,
0.3087984324,
0.1613852233,
0.0666554496,
0.4861233234,
-0.4935619831,
0.1283028275,
-0.291125387,
-0.0014921019,
-0.6005705595,
-0.2113455683,
0.0794876516,
-0.2625199556,
0.4601128101,
-0.1512761116,
-0.35655725,
0.2217760086,
-0.1990131736,
0.3069241047,
0.534732759,
-0.4096630514,
0.5064690113,
0.3811529577,
-0.1127575561,
-0.2803893983,
-0.762116313,
-0.0196846258,
-0.2912083268,
-0.7152180076,
0.4898671806,
-0.0380803756,
-0.7606723905,
0.234777078,
-0.2687591314,
0.0235175975,
0.1153587326,
0.2514685392,
0.3702065647,
-0.2648679912,
-0.0759544894,
0.2738791108,
-0.0570796989,
-0.1611999869,
-0.0864305198,
0.1481593847,
0.4433732927,
-0.3151696622,
-0.1949105263,
0.3427624106,
0.6309120059,
-0.1120085567,
0.8366777897,
-0.2006675005,
-0.094258137,
-0.8986637592,
-0.0559263825,
-0.2908862233,
-0.4709268808,
0.151812315,
-0.1845244318,
-0.3230799735,
0.3171208799,
-0.0817505717,
0.2413371652,
0.5588395,
0.7801664472,
0.0372441597,
1.1946271658,
0.6728528738,
0.3009659052,
0.5776570439,
-0.329525888,
0.1516904384,
-0.7976762652,
-0.2303292155,
-0.3170180023,
-0.6358076334,
-0.7055014372,
-0.3687818944,
0.060733594,
0.1578901857,
0.0937488228,
0.1690397561,
-0.5238869786,
0.2072281241,
0.4055650234,
0.0258091576,
0.3117090166,
-0.1861126125,
0.1849536598,
0.055635836,
-0.5072493553,
-0.7805097699,
1.3929026127,
0.187867865,
1.1717600822,
0.2032383829,
0.5640241504,
0.3724883795,
0.5110285878,
-0.5735230446,
0.4923253357,
-0.2779568434,
-0.9176750183,
0.0291653033,
-0.4434675872,
-0.9379373193,
-0.0032292686,
0.027008906,
-0.2174968123,
0.5679385662,
0.1775379032,
0.1567846537,
0.2140461951,
-0.9690263271,
0.5541270375,
-0.7439420819,
-0.8035930991,
0.0336988084,
-0.3720444441,
0.4875460863,
-0.3706513345,
-0.1098815277,
-0.3808343709,
-0.2483673096,
0.4645290673,
-0.2485823035,
1.0349071026,
-0.3705678284,
-0.1448149979,
0.4228187203,
0.1479416341,
0.6629376411,
-0.2296710163,
-0.4883317053,
0.0661368072,
0.0350520574,
-0.4780458212,
-0.4628659189,
0.7238370776,
-0.8754757047,
-0.7357698679,
-0.3339201212,
-0.4238948822,
-0.3506549895,
0.0915689543,
-0.0435821898,
0.1357517689,
-0.1063991785,
0.390994519,
0.5909240842,
-0.2335993499,
-0.0520434566,
0.6611433625,
-0.0230432041,
0.1429190338,
0.9339377284,
0.2708058655,
0.8801169991,
0.1325627118,
0.3501320481,
-0.4309307635,
-0.825705409,
-0.2420495152,
0.1960994899,
-0.5831688046,
0.117614679,
-0.3853107691,
-0.2731041014,
-0.2622109354,
-0.0925704315,
-0.3564995825,
-0.5892605782,
-0.6172876954,
-0.4193136394,
0.3373199403,
0.9363739491,
-0.0704006255,
0.1192929298,
-0.4369870126,
0.5054328442,
0.182501018,
0.0064050136,
-0.3322068453,
-0.5967245102,
0.2370418161,
0.3115601838,
-0.503260076,
-0.8684000373,
0.3746760786,
0.3217325509,
1.0611373186,
0.3019488752,
0.2909718156,
0.1940680593,
-0.1273443103,
0.5411388278,
-0.2610686421,
-0.6908216476,
0.5399603844,
-0.4799888134,
0.1253392547,
0.5657126307,
0.3675054014,
-0.2091367543,
-0.5827875137,
-0.6756593585,
-0.9113190174,
0.6780610085,
0.3323781788,
0.5476200581,
0.1264482141,
0.4667610526,
0.4852805734,
0.2409195155,
-0.8822749257,
-0.1527368128,
-0.1538277417,
-0.2762796283,
0.169760406,
-0.0992089286,
-0.1011711583,
-0.0127567528,
0.6614764929,
0.0454122908,
-0.0059131538,
-0.0496149473,
-0.0855400488,
-0.1617769748,
0.4138244689,
0.3972163796,
0.4878785014,
-0.0149256373,
0.4105419815,
0.003245058,
-0.4042699933,
0.3363426924,
-0.0956963897,
-0.4814310968,
-0.1938492507,
0.2774338424,
0.6987873316,
0.0057596616,
-0.5418992639,
0.2148688436,
0.2588020265,
-0.4345193207,
0.0225719251,
0.518586278,
-0.0872086436,
0.1037126333,
0.3058729768,
-0.0871094018,
-0.2368667573,
-1.0136624575,
0.3308576643,
0.4159453809,
-0.2081706822,
-0.7835357785,
0.7075591087,
0.2590471208,
-0.1207448095,
0.5369842052,
-0.1431422085,
-0.2728935778,
0.5377596617,
0.638343513,
0.9036954641,
-0.3421366215,
0.0424776711,
-0.0019829909,
0.2416805327,
-0.075695388,
0.4965601265,
0.0367670171,
-0.8076658845,
-0.1245014146,
-0.6948500872,
-0.4617584646,
0.1064215824,
-0.3654483855,
0.4509896636,
-0.5198788047,
-0.1438723207,
0.1508132666,
-0.3579831719,
-0.3850350976,
0.1663581431,
0.1625227183,
0.359104991,
-0.8429485559,
0.8627045155,
0.4356756508,
-0.4025221467,
-0.4533633292,
0.1322034895,
0.1110917702,
-0.7550954223,
1.0081012249,
-0.1403053999,
-0.0686777607,
-0.0015310787,
-0.5553299189,
-0.7116450071,
0.7899934649,
0.4394861758,
-0.4463434517,
-0.1906636804,
0.161195755,
0.6043445468,
-0.2884883583,
-0.2111891061,
0.3810435832,
0.6487060785,
0.4487746358,
-0.5455725789,
-0.0762045756,
-0.2914456725,
-0.5117934942,
0.4303254485,
-0.5518455505,
0.8651781082,
-0.3238112032,
-0.4046382308,
-0.3012036085,
0.2318301052,
0.1482415497,
0.3437969685,
0.3381308615,
0.2266172618,
0.3884505332,
-0.0897355452,
1.086268425,
-0.3789840639,
-0.1802921593,
0.8352276087,
-0.6791769266,
0.6118949056,
0.6460416913,
-0.3117597699,
0.2204192281,
0.6334775686,
-0.2126747966,
0.7044846416,
0.5040620565,
-0.6301922798,
0.0249619484,
-0.3229134083,
-0.043115221,
0.4928763211,
0.2661328018,
-0.5308547616,
-0.126014024,
-0.2143466473,
-0.1855427027,
-0.0581462868,
-0.0624533817,
0.7202166319,
0.0703625157,
-0.609310627,
0.385219574,
0.0435861908,
0.4564716518,
-0.8889934421,
0.0312499441,
-0.3179935217,
0.2175579071,
-0.3595934808,
-0.5858286023,
0.4525518119,
0.1128278747,
-0.4169491231,
-0.6067816019,
0.4839292765,
-0.291880846,
-0.7445981503,
0.2724489868,
0.6695091128,
0.0097812284,
0.241468057,
-0.5523895621,
-0.1027874202,
0.2615920007,
-0.4766566455,
0.3191823661,
0.4776557982,
-0.3422226906,
0.4110826254,
0.9686345458,
0.5204047561,
0.3088345826,
-0.0274417512,
0.9410924315,
-0.7150424123,
-0.0866513103,
-0.6617493629,
0.6332193017,
0.2019794583,
-0.3290753067,
0.8538736105,
0.7158270478,
0.7647261024,
0.267867893,
0.9912834167,
-0.1209394261,
0.2619113624,
-0.4761584997,
0.4635592103,
-0.687988162,
0.4175688624,
-0.008989282,
-1.2964110374,
-0.1471375674,
0.2901786268,
-0.5747131705,
0.3364394307,
0.4635658562,
0.9623587728,
-0.2336440384,
-0.211519599,
0.3106079698,
0.1624035239,
0.4271194339,
0.2653829157,
1.1700876951,
0.1079988405,
0.1255684346,
-0.2814920545,
-0.293525666,
0.0951726139,
-0.7604888082,
-0.5569677353,
-0.443861872,
-0.3500629365,
-0.1631869823,
-0.0747834221,
0.6177254915,
0.5640650392,
-0.8323953748,
-0.0991600528,
-0.3665318787,
0.0637312904,
0.0693272054,
-0.1986494809,
0.1285160333,
-0.1249235347,
-1.040086627,
0.5611017942,
0.3402177393,
0.5119592547,
-0.6156798005,
-0.132119447,
-0.1798757464,
0.4005185068,
0.4025913775,
0.3069005311,
-0.4909211099,
0.0923721492,
0.1303846985,
-0.1845030189,
-0.0343644917,
0.9632732272,
-0.4194164276,
0.6148462892,
0.5740398765,
0.339381367,
0.5221219659,
0.0482414924,
0.9480204582,
-0.651855588,
0.2021007985,
0.464386493,
0.1758890301,
0.3177455962,
-0.4778158963,
0.4401594996,
0.3470775187,
-0.3232786357,
-1.1724522114,
0.3427637815,
-0.8168005943,
-0.4112822711,
1.5167233944,
0.3014909923,
-0.2372637093,
-0.2586535513,
-0.2440823466,
0.233548373,
-0.2154842615,
0.9176307917,
0.4845840931,
-0.389280349,
-0.1452370435,
-0.7826343179,
0.3334205449,
0.3717128634,
-0.9587180018,
0.4703123271,
0.6156075597,
0.2140312642,
-0.2668188214,
0.0333276093,
-0.3680883646,
-0.0522587039,
0.1512777954,
-0.0637085587,
-0.1741864532,
-0.1745500565,
-0.1649413258,
0.013141918,
0.2411700934,
0.1093438491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01489v1 | Agentless: Demystifying LLM-based Software Engineering Agents | 2024-07-01T17:24:45 | 2024-07-01T17:24:45 | Chunqiu Steven Xia, Yinlin Deng, Soren Dunn, Lingming Zhang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
advanced the automation of software development tasks, including code
synthesis, program repair, and test generation. More recently, researchers and
industry practitioners have developed various autonomous LLM agents to perform
end-to-end software development tasks. These agents are equipped with the
ability to use tools, run commands, observe feedback from the environment, and
plan for future actions. However, the complexity of these agent-based
approaches, together with the limited abilities of current LLMs, raises the
following question: Do we really have to employ complex autonomous software
agents? To attempt to answer this question, we build Agentless -- an agentless
approach to automatically solve software development problems. Compared to the
verbose and complex setup of agent-based approaches, Agentless employs a
simplistic two-phase process of localization followed by repair, without
letting the LLM decide future actions or operate with complex tools. Our
results on the popular SWE-bench Lite benchmark show that surprisingly the
simplistic Agentless is able to achieve both the highest performance (27.33%)
and lowest cost (\$0.34) compared with all existing open-source software
agents! Furthermore, we manually classified the problems in SWE-bench Lite and
found problems with exact ground truth patch or insufficient/misleading issue
descriptions. As such, we construct SWE-bench Lite-S by excluding such
problematic issues to perform more rigorous evaluation and comparison. Our work
highlights the current overlooked potential of a simple, interpretable
technique in autonomous software development. We hope Agentless will help reset
the baseline, starting point, and horizon for autonomous software agents, and
inspire future work along this crucial direction. | [
-0.4778720737,
-0.5416420102,
0.7648070455,
0.1961065829,
0.1559293866,
0.3653075397,
0.0276661552,
-0.7106328011,
0.2227065414,
0.5750023127,
-0.675966382,
-0.434918642,
-0.1673174649,
-0.0269300155,
-0.4435619116,
0.8248604536,
-0.2979807258,
-0.1138263345,
-0.2390974313,
-0.2442622185,
-0.3041353524,
0.0904525965,
-0.3510304987,
-0.4016999602,
0.3431879878,
0.3960561156,
0.7239618897,
0.8900715113,
0.1095912531,
0.3983848691,
0.3346678913,
0.0475730635,
-0.1278621256,
0.3501740694,
-0.0209812187,
-0.5672125816,
-0.763245523,
0.0677219778,
-0.0705128163,
0.7461191416,
0.1221500114,
0.3439477682,
-0.2266312242,
0.783097446,
-0.4964350164,
0.290579319,
-0.6075401902,
0.1335396618,
0.1487723887,
-0.1720027626,
-0.413472265,
-0.2292698622,
-0.3063292801,
-0.6109957695,
0.3966958523,
-0.163899675,
0.4312315583,
0.7035864592,
-0.6474143863,
-0.2020093054,
-1.1125030518,
0.5792921185,
-0.485237062,
0.1130667701,
-0.0181160029,
0.4154449403,
-0.4438444078,
-0.2731680572,
-0.3622531891,
-0.4368393123,
0.2648991346,
0.1756779552,
0.0363925211,
0.4234540462,
0.1892198771,
0.2064871639,
-0.75157547,
0.1877660453,
-0.1259694546,
-0.1740016341,
0.8933956623,
0.0472848304,
0.3822643459,
0.3241980076,
-0.4511594474,
0.1742209643,
-0.7697658539,
-0.0178073365,
0.0488732122,
0.1913815439,
0.023636939,
0.6045840979,
-0.2651033401,
0.2244091928,
-0.0803119168,
-0.0711645558,
0.0662082136,
0.1563705504,
-0.2715568542,
-0.0563047752,
0.4471525848,
0.0246236101,
0.1465068609,
-0.5518205166,
-0.7671656609,
0.261156559,
0.2394714803,
-0.3996156752,
0.1813324839,
0.8829001188,
-0.0860658288,
-0.4227582216,
-0.1990534514,
-0.122303918,
-0.8047114015,
-0.4280435741,
0.5451680422,
0.0232614726,
-0.3015979528,
-0.2155403048,
-0.0643577874,
0.6237137318,
0.499709487,
-0.3311144412,
0.1929781139,
0.696824193,
0.5443956852,
-0.0064306469,
-0.4523967505,
-0.4811362922,
0.2737922966,
-0.9254046679,
0.8771285415,
-0.0475611649,
-0.3864314556,
-0.1542624086,
0.0870405361,
0.3969058394,
-0.6442521811,
0.0103689395,
-0.2236912698,
-0.2674010694,
-0.1366039962,
-0.5582321882,
-0.0362788215,
0.2455150932,
-0.6223154664,
0.8671246171,
0.1897842586,
-0.0047961157,
0.1898289919,
-0.7585311532,
-0.2594994903,
0.3701542616,
-0.3045080304,
-0.1166296005,
0.2056623101,
-0.2829193175,
0.1757491082,
-0.2979030907,
0.2077377141,
-0.259044379,
-0.5332366228,
-0.0236617178,
-0.2363826782,
0.6351285577,
0.149758175,
-0.8733705878,
0.3541830778,
-0.7687436342,
0.1882204711,
0.0466167778,
0.0727053657,
0.0031875381,
-0.0316705927,
-0.201799199,
0.1823493689,
0.4511802495,
-0.5862007141,
0.2494827211,
-0.5191926956,
-0.0024756223,
0.9736870527,
-0.1242242903,
0.8294059038,
-0.4961918294,
0.7681809664,
-0.3049195111,
0.517744422,
-0.1091702506,
-0.2457231432,
-0.7650516629,
-0.3400917649,
-0.001132419,
0.7103335261,
-0.731020093,
0.1531394422,
0.0860493183,
-0.7014756203,
-0.5641880035,
0.3324246109,
0.2273268253,
0.1498037577,
0.2217295617,
-0.1579149067,
-0.3019346595,
-0.789862752,
-0.1034907326,
-0.1786663681,
-0.03504581,
0.1454966217,
0.4121931493,
-0.4227768481,
1.0129028559,
-0.250641644,
-0.3262408674,
-0.4231681228,
0.1132032201,
-0.0412301719,
0.2785688639,
0.4101641178,
-0.5485869646,
-0.4946948886,
0.1908457577,
-1.0868359804,
-0.2529363632,
-0.3023802638,
0.0959876254,
0.5741119981,
0.532649219,
-0.9497921467,
0.4149179459,
0.1952978224,
-0.2619443834,
0.4716618061,
-0.4718765914,
-0.2966276705,
-0.5212696195,
0.0732285678,
-0.1707591712,
-0.2223574966,
-0.6943404675,
0.4901929796,
-0.0280216169,
-0.3181324303,
-0.4638261795,
0.9080916047,
-0.8777507544,
-0.4563389719,
-0.6500731111,
0.2246317267,
-0.0799265802,
0.3893662989,
-0.2881192863,
0.8075042963,
0.5262625217,
-0.4719073474,
0.5230337977,
-0.2501700521,
0.2604181767,
0.1938175112,
-0.6857108474,
0.0945995525,
-0.4005231857,
0.2074124515,
-0.6886835694,
-0.087129578,
0.1147893444,
-0.3650775254,
0.1084121913,
-0.0194904059,
-0.4332379103,
-0.1703034639,
-0.5292172432,
0.2310551256,
0.4173370004,
-0.1801164448,
0.8044344783,
0.3023573458,
-0.1819973439,
-0.5928621292,
-0.4851133525,
0.0967159644,
0.2754088044,
-0.5925029516,
0.0496205166,
-0.1992919147,
-0.5304716825,
0.0570681654,
-0.5871803761,
-0.2162244767,
0.3887405992,
0.5067781806,
0.2411108911,
-0.2724450529,
0.249054119,
-0.0054729921,
-0.482491523,
0.031551294,
-0.0310399514,
0.2106415182,
-0.2180689573,
-0.5823349357,
-0.0808831155,
0.3970208168,
0.9920892715,
-0.3573658466,
0.3069107234,
0.2967849076,
-0.3175222874,
-0.7406534553,
-0.4620360434,
-0.1021406949,
-0.491719842,
0.1756280363,
-0.2836863995,
-0.5302288532,
0.5885972977,
-0.2947821319,
0.3432972133,
0.1562522948,
0.1990745366,
0.0161232986,
0.9482685924,
0.9102905989,
0.0586861223,
0.1202235371,
-0.2035933137,
0.3899336755,
-0.2124344856,
-0.1200869083,
-0.2908887565,
-0.1680200696,
-0.5489349961,
-0.378580451,
0.4000965655,
-0.0649574995,
-0.3214419484,
0.2384506464,
-0.5927541852,
0.7212449312,
0.2171473205,
-0.3504724205,
0.3606224656,
-0.529930234,
0.1741980612,
0.3822945356,
-0.4086487591,
-0.4460401535,
0.9646069407,
0.2200758904,
0.6616919637,
-0.0824052244,
0.9254978895,
0.5816694498,
0.4169181883,
-0.8609643579,
0.8213357329,
0.3960023224,
-0.4896004796,
-0.6297112703,
-0.2013572156,
-1.0671640635,
0.3286818862,
-0.0656457767,
-0.228828162,
-0.0356647521,
-0.1476080865,
-0.230940327,
0.1129443869,
-0.8503098488,
0.8255457878,
-0.4811453521,
-0.1300521046,
-0.068639338,
-0.5398287773,
0.1341955215,
-0.1930978894,
0.5234413147,
-0.3534819186,
-0.3748184443,
0.1330483407,
-0.7500456572,
0.7123378515,
-0.3588550389,
-0.3598778248,
0.2870770693,
0.4509094656,
0.7686210871,
-0.1165470257,
0.0503882021,
-0.4185161889,
0.1026685759,
-0.7236244678,
-0.8318098783,
0.6760561466,
-0.7798550725,
-0.7264497876,
-0.5949572325,
-0.6485702991,
-0.2333310694,
0.3040304184,
-0.2740195096,
0.410348773,
-0.1631586552,
-0.2272501737,
0.5549240708,
-0.2011420429,
0.751078546,
0.9819396734,
-0.308892101,
-0.0696233809,
1.0722863674,
0.2330112457,
0.0888450071,
0.1469143033,
-0.2455226928,
0.0280137956,
-0.4982002974,
-0.4363584816,
0.2675068378,
-0.5847457647,
-0.2103352994,
-0.3362407982,
-0.2067334503,
-0.1165811196,
-0.5727133751,
-0.8193228841,
-0.3148910403,
0.0772245899,
-0.2016806155,
0.1616957635,
1.0930242538,
0.0091248406,
-0.1329400986,
-0.5919878483,
0.4859270453,
-0.0048051323,
0.2494513094,
-0.0614706948,
0.2499905974,
-0.2196729332,
0.0171858873,
-0.233348906,
-0.7777161598,
0.2041848153,
-0.0489460304,
0.7204813957,
0.112538144,
0.5910756588,
0.354008764,
-0.1201649532,
0.65458709,
-0.2194931209,
-1.011958003,
0.597106576,
-0.3069318831,
0.2117678523,
0.3920703232,
0.0278663784,
-0.3050192297,
-0.8697101474,
-0.5403572917,
-1.1013669968,
0.3493728936,
0.1760261655,
-0.162630707,
0.3100246489,
0.3655124307,
0.1550173461,
0.3237168491,
-0.7710678577,
-0.5934801102,
0.0742085576,
-0.0132155865,
-0.0589796938,
0.1199840605,
-0.0929678008,
-0.1222694293,
0.7245470285,
-0.3007766604,
0.2444573343,
0.2605436146,
-0.4245333672,
-0.1947965175,
0.421097517,
0.5642088652,
0.6252996325,
-0.1294846833,
0.1413520575,
0.0821470469,
-0.1187323406,
0.6085948944,
-0.0149294687,
-0.3417324126,
-0.009473281,
0.3789421916,
0.2906474769,
-0.1325006932,
-0.8886344433,
0.6725562811,
0.2912825346,
-0.2346490771,
-0.5808755159,
0.1186873764,
-0.0646535829,
0.4995389879,
0.5600372553,
0.2036968023,
0.1170376539,
-0.7194986343,
0.1829293221,
0.5607065558,
-0.5350629091,
-0.292353183,
0.6175179482,
0.4151035249,
-0.3367201984,
0.0574296825,
-0.4838583767,
-0.1011511311,
1.121801734,
0.384316802,
1.3157808781,
-0.0282915737,
0.6457731724,
-0.2851997614,
0.563878119,
0.0186739489,
0.3158461154,
-0.0877955109,
-0.3427649438,
-0.5953530669,
-0.2616322041,
-0.5956821442,
0.0020051852,
-0.1720397472,
0.1035870612,
-0.6153344512,
0.3284548223,
-0.2329263538,
0.2994139194,
-0.1091066524,
0.2832973897,
-0.0091640223,
0.8315273523,
-0.699657321,
0.7317586541,
0.8416851163,
-0.4588995874,
-0.7638984323,
-0.0101388237,
0.0570260957,
-0.576580584,
0.1438697875,
0.1286852062,
-0.3977550864,
-0.0677165166,
-0.6469412446,
-0.6249598861,
1.450093627,
0.6707239151,
-0.0926036462,
0.0574602671,
0.3196039796,
0.7482824922,
-0.307967633,
0.5011335611,
0.0449597612,
0.5047023296,
0.066351369,
-0.9244483709,
0.2538339496,
-0.3756955564,
-0.0351474062,
0.331738025,
-0.6654163003,
0.7230498791,
-0.360188812,
-0.1188881621,
0.1047050357,
0.2183632255,
0.0710194558,
0.6300872564,
0.2897234261,
0.0058649117,
0.7272865772,
0.1390952766,
0.8729381561,
-0.7116387486,
0.2679341733,
0.852096498,
-0.6190138459,
0.4894757867,
0.2770725489,
0.0208251309,
0.2648843527,
0.4142189324,
0.0604201853,
0.1141503975,
0.027355589,
-0.505499661,
-0.3344873786,
-0.0554545633,
-0.4256364405,
0.2964105606,
-0.31307289,
0.2220737338,
-0.5216903687,
0.0260813255,
-0.050564345,
-0.0185353328,
-0.3446475863,
0.7050973773,
0.1091751605,
-0.3908278644,
0.4846591949,
-0.0259259008,
0.2625636756,
-0.5986681581,
0.0565020666,
-0.63815552,
0.2889480889,
-0.3931770921,
-0.5354722738,
0.4502025843,
-0.0624733269,
-0.2183597982,
-0.3886879385,
0.7634025812,
-0.1433134526,
-0.128201738,
0.5047156215,
1.0125104189,
0.1942668557,
-0.3440283835,
-0.4695718884,
-0.2038067132,
-0.1491564959,
-0.2529658079,
0.4851858616,
0.6611166596,
-0.1480197459,
1.2609943151,
0.3869741857,
0.0688239858,
-0.1255669594,
-0.2371256351,
0.6099619269,
-0.8763819933,
-0.2216816247,
-0.5890889764,
0.4636446238,
0.2977689207,
0.1544143856,
0.7944397926,
0.6654245257,
0.5490961671,
-0.070612669,
0.8845744133,
0.0367313921,
0.2843748331,
-0.0720313117,
0.9230396152,
-0.7937900424,
0.5228708386,
-0.2184740454,
-0.8394556046,
-0.2774853706,
0.2091076225,
0.0917801112,
-0.0469806828,
0.5674401522,
1.0224411488,
0.2813719809,
-0.2450197339,
0.4679681659,
0.3244853318,
0.2655863166,
0.3995350599,
0.6200529337,
-0.3552296162,
0.6759927273,
-0.0254606269,
-0.3032958806,
0.085121125,
-0.5523284674,
-0.5364649892,
-0.341770947,
-0.3913354278,
-0.2222250253,
0.0113873733,
1.1467335224,
0.4073410332,
-0.5976763368,
-0.4250232577,
-0.4864789546,
0.5222051144,
-0.3635603786,
-0.1578791589,
-0.2036984414,
-0.5198869705,
-0.3774085343,
0.7541483045,
0.5443012118,
0.1494970471,
-0.4508276582,
-0.3661349416,
0.2929098904,
0.2528110445,
0.5765560865,
0.6079306602,
-0.579341948,
-0.0719194859,
0.1457931995,
-0.458044529,
0.0658511668,
0.5184755921,
-0.8243913054,
0.1732842326,
0.1411658525,
0.503384769,
0.2684859931,
-0.1918012202,
0.688555181,
-0.546024859,
0.2426505685,
0.2314088643,
-0.0615036637,
-0.0608179905,
-0.356757164,
0.6233997941,
0.2064398825,
-0.6256761551,
-1.0034407377,
0.3465350568,
-0.9991338849,
-0.4662157893,
0.9677634239,
0.1357838511,
-0.2459005415,
-0.4111838639,
-0.2178216875,
0.1075724736,
-0.2617072463,
0.6502348781,
0.1768435687,
-0.4438214898,
-0.2074488252,
-0.6102656126,
0.3942595124,
0.2918396592,
-0.9516892433,
-0.023769578,
0.444006443,
0.3586642444,
0.0089895958,
0.9216202497,
0.268894136,
0.3364328146,
0.3350216746,
0.6373755336,
-0.3152063489,
-0.4382304847,
-0.2625175714,
0.3514898419,
0.4819319248,
-0.0341746286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01476v1 | Tree Search for Language Model Agents | 2024-07-01T17:07:55 | 2024-07-01T17:07:55 | Jing Yu Koh, Stephen McAleer, Daniel Fried, Ruslan Salakhutdinov | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Autonomous agents powered by language models (LMs) have demonstrated promise
in their ability to perform decision-making tasks such as web automation.
However, a key limitation remains: LMs, primarily optimized for natural
language understanding and generation, struggle with multi-step reasoning,
planning, and using environmental feedback when attempting to solve realistic
computer tasks. Towards addressing this, we propose an inference-time search
algorithm for LM agents to explicitly perform exploration and multi-step
planning in interactive web environments. Our approach is a form of best-first
tree search that operates within the actual environment space, and is
complementary with most existing state-of-the-art agents. It is the first tree
search algorithm for LM agents that shows effectiveness on realistic web tasks.
On the challenging VisualWebArena benchmark, applying our search algorithm on
top of a GPT-4o agent yields a 39.7% relative increase in success rate compared
to the same baseline without search, setting a state-of-the-art success rate of
26.4%. On WebArena, search also yields a 28.0% relative improvement over a
baseline agent, setting a competitive success rate of 19.2%. Our experiments
highlight the effectiveness of search for web agents, and we demonstrate that
performance scales with increased test-time compute. We conduct a thorough
analysis of our results to highlight improvements from search, limitations, and
promising directions for future work. Our code and models are publicly released
at https://jykoh.com/search-agents. | [
-0.5319476724,
-0.7240755558,
0.8950980306,
0.1990364343,
0.0371229984,
0.3056608438,
-0.0213201977,
-0.6503623128,
-0.0044184085,
0.0278459378,
-0.8570379615,
-0.5811650753,
-0.3743999302,
0.1628094912,
-0.2548119724,
0.1416440159,
-0.0591457635,
-0.4047421813,
-0.017191736,
0.0519986302,
-0.0675236657,
-0.1306560487,
-0.8021544218,
-0.2505848408,
0.7505444884,
0.1391227394,
1.0174525976,
0.764236629,
0.2379970104,
0.4243457019,
-0.2866858244,
0.3360966146,
-0.1893725544,
0.2914940715,
-0.3942419887,
-0.2292066962,
-0.3416563272,
0.0195438135,
0.3290866017,
0.2866281271,
-0.370033443,
-0.0625409409,
-0.2646289468,
0.4662325382,
-0.7071594596,
0.5044161677,
-0.7607395053,
0.1957991123,
-0.0760103762,
-0.5620645285,
-0.5314434767,
-0.352256,
0.3265984654,
-0.98819381,
0.227891773,
0.1025739536,
0.7883229256,
0.2294823974,
-0.5018676519,
-0.3254230618,
-0.6432749033,
0.6530082226,
-0.7123771906,
0.5507121086,
0.4344146848,
0.4435440004,
-0.4259223938,
-0.6683958769,
-0.5551653504,
-0.3586812317,
0.0182100218,
-0.0530121066,
-0.5760139823,
0.2804575264,
0.2088734806,
-0.1157618463,
-0.85615623,
0.2254585177,
0.1493847072,
-0.1978346258,
0.5617749691,
0.0974414796,
0.2822986245,
0.013422057,
0.1059146896,
-0.5002532601,
-0.2191881388,
0.3261297047,
0.1666216552,
0.5100502968,
0.386228621,
0.3546058536,
-0.6207728982,
0.6923411489,
-0.3950304985,
-0.1851914525,
-0.0760383159,
-0.468374759,
-0.0881476402,
-0.2887085378,
0.5065816045,
0.2560957074,
0.3307027817,
-0.1291508824,
-0.5239106417,
0.2734645903,
0.2527885139,
-0.88197577,
-0.1826888919,
0.3471427858,
-0.3595235348,
-0.1685814559,
-0.2284474075,
-0.5638720393,
-0.2717233002,
-0.1054307669,
0.3116648197,
-0.4444455206,
-0.3075357974,
-0.1376863569,
-0.2284558564,
0.1996514201,
0.5042430162,
-0.3754079044,
0.5193283558,
0.3333422244,
0.9026525617,
-0.0241718534,
-0.3233135343,
-0.734875977,
-0.0575252846,
-0.714304328,
0.746080339,
-0.6426823139,
-0.2738901675,
0.1258675456,
-0.194728002,
-0.0194460023,
-0.3048462272,
0.4205248952,
-0.9549707174,
0.0113462172,
0.0920152143,
-0.4142979085,
-0.38038221,
0.3712721467,
-0.883397758,
0.975028038,
-0.0253314264,
-0.3896821737,
0.3884744644,
-0.9685954452,
-0.3612159491,
0.0176522471,
0.0188346189,
-0.3147496879,
-0.2160741985,
0.6062600017,
0.2930176556,
-0.1665804833,
0.0072887642,
-0.3646457791,
-0.4008777738,
-0.0342152454,
-0.2094775587,
0.7207885981,
0.1465581357,
-0.5634251237,
0.2878815234,
-0.5037249327,
0.5438948274,
0.6106094122,
-0.4090951681,
-0.4002860487,
0.5521636605,
-0.0053187767,
0.1323066503,
0.2632132173,
-0.4413024187,
0.5337051153,
-0.2906666994,
0.1515051275,
0.8307665586,
-0.1640781015,
0.3024511933,
-0.135869652,
0.7904528975,
-0.3432823122,
0.4222737849,
-0.1627105922,
-0.3374561071,
-0.6533027291,
0.0889317021,
0.1394547075,
0.4873342514,
-0.7699325085,
0.2989681065,
-0.195817396,
-0.6476379037,
-0.3692260683,
-0.0280029923,
0.3899631202,
-0.0907576755,
0.5141424537,
-0.1822803468,
-0.4987199306,
-0.8281114101,
-0.2049505115,
-0.2844145,
0.1957299858,
0.3313190639,
0.3454397917,
-0.5990111828,
1.205119729,
-0.3099440932,
-0.2335745543,
-0.2443979084,
0.2588639259,
0.1752473414,
0.0533458367,
0.4429271519,
-0.988265872,
-0.53679353,
0.2587867677,
-0.5311089158,
-0.0794216916,
0.0886676684,
0.1750757992,
0.3468555212,
0.2140431404,
-0.7398905158,
0.5625703335,
0.5674263239,
-0.1708567291,
0.1995393038,
-0.1835291386,
-0.1458318681,
-0.6409602165,
0.1060947999,
0.1055280641,
-0.4459571242,
-0.4454085231,
0.5274591446,
0.1088072658,
0.1177116707,
-0.321719408,
0.6893191338,
-0.8449504375,
-0.3062007725,
-0.2961950004,
0.4345682561,
-0.2113099843,
0.7431272864,
-0.0382478498,
0.8848697543,
0.5586143732,
-0.9347093105,
-0.0036692359,
0.017526146,
-0.1167607531,
-0.0339445174,
-0.2734582722,
0.473877579,
0.0046833982,
0.4246263504,
-0.6376854777,
-0.0331953503,
-0.1680154651,
-0.3717211783,
-0.0481920578,
-0.13882263,
-0.6055074334,
-0.4972365499,
-0.3953106701,
0.2035108358,
0.290810883,
-0.5958583951,
0.7864202261,
0.2816681564,
-0.1486242563,
-0.5523438454,
-0.0713663697,
0.1527886838,
0.2043286115,
-0.5138304234,
0.3938149512,
-0.2221555561,
-0.2041638047,
0.0934523642,
-0.388204217,
-0.1478495449,
0.3560400307,
-0.1391317695,
-0.1516723931,
-0.0888286754,
-0.1973815411,
-0.0771987587,
-0.0589340664,
0.0046460619,
-0.2791202962,
0.7610999942,
-0.1839375198,
-0.5162542462,
-0.5256205797,
0.2715283334,
0.4672932327,
-0.5583828688,
0.2275333554,
0.2421957701,
-0.476384908,
-0.4949474931,
-0.3616733253,
-0.15853104,
-0.504776895,
0.3647349775,
-0.4932677746,
-0.6006121635,
0.2812509537,
-0.1908146292,
0.2966188192,
0.3227685988,
0.112647146,
-0.0902203098,
1.7214899063,
0.7437471151,
0.0400249846,
0.6413565874,
-0.4290402234,
0.0631423518,
-0.4317904413,
-0.1225443333,
-0.5915182233,
-0.2711537778,
-0.8331469893,
-0.452832669,
0.5209490061,
-0.0351181515,
-0.075638555,
0.350461632,
-0.4774883986,
0.4987421334,
0.9074860811,
0.0213199332,
0.4277090728,
-0.1253506243,
-0.3741968572,
0.188439697,
-0.7818103433,
-0.3795868158,
0.8311493993,
0.1384122372,
0.6523563266,
0.3239967227,
0.7031649947,
0.3222452402,
0.1472932547,
-0.7613531351,
0.7211053967,
0.3377370834,
-0.5062127709,
-0.868501544,
-0.3570270538,
-1.463922739,
0.4951642454,
0.252977401,
-0.833468318,
-0.0219598152,
0.1698193103,
-0.0085447226,
0.2376349121,
-0.4441789687,
0.8020367622,
-0.5408679843,
-0.3532532454,
-0.5027520657,
-0.558708787,
0.0220525209,
0.0192851163,
0.2774996161,
-0.1294286847,
-0.152689606,
0.2894774675,
-0.4479358792,
0.5200209618,
-0.4270736277,
0.1391359419,
0.2436696887,
0.6302498579,
1.1324315071,
-0.4346785545,
0.0432153866,
-0.2475533932,
0.0628930703,
-0.3968529701,
-0.6362394094,
0.2587464154,
-0.5568403006,
-0.6365115643,
-0.7572689056,
-0.2606519759,
-0.208265543,
0.4527774155,
-0.2684016824,
0.0600729622,
-0.3866502643,
0.0465738066,
0.2811535001,
-0.1622446179,
0.8789319396,
0.8791269064,
-0.8340802789,
0.1232151762,
0.7357320786,
-0.0299074575,
0.0545643233,
0.6147512197,
0.4046365619,
-0.4837418199,
-0.7469721437,
-0.5336345434,
-0.128206417,
-0.6222893596,
-0.1650438607,
-0.6313118935,
-0.162503019,
-0.1756013185,
0.1713876873,
-0.3444941938,
-0.0647174716,
0.0682420731,
-0.0183211118,
0.2872977555,
0.8867676258,
0.1106054634,
0.2235719711,
-0.5783444047,
0.1364577413,
0.3840696216,
0.2611461878,
0.1098610237,
0.150933072,
-0.237372905,
-0.083491981,
-0.4252617955,
-1.0065139532,
0.4647254944,
0.1140445918,
0.8076338172,
0.2773857713,
-0.1037347764,
0.8227835894,
-0.3216980696,
0.3593710363,
-0.3066630065,
-0.8427606821,
0.7194432616,
-0.4131305218,
0.5288396478,
0.4263364673,
0.370600611,
-0.5831173062,
-0.2575111985,
-0.47136572,
-0.785400629,
0.9088840485,
0.6134901047,
-0.4383419454,
0.2848252654,
-0.1842708588,
-0.1810340881,
0.0647289604,
-0.7719905972,
-0.1278860569,
0.128275007,
0.3119581044,
-0.0124170519,
0.1375352293,
0.1740003973,
-0.2346149832,
0.735376358,
-0.5424067378,
0.2341676205,
0.3658811748,
-0.2365476489,
-0.4134551883,
0.2159982175,
0.2786513567,
0.8508754969,
-0.1731679589,
0.1680544764,
0.1471084952,
-0.0201791748,
0.1011045352,
0.5688984394,
-0.1596289724,
0.054664135,
0.4363885224,
0.6216952801,
0.0649446771,
-0.8813707829,
0.3960596025,
-0.3012107313,
0.1727399081,
-0.4502539635,
0.2000413388,
0.1852667481,
0.3835422993,
0.538071394,
-0.156290859,
0.4843733013,
-0.6326236129,
0.1921374798,
0.7129250169,
-0.0043808585,
-0.121307373,
0.4622143805,
0.127945751,
-0.7981829643,
0.5609490871,
-0.5863653421,
-0.662874043,
0.8314805031,
0.3383861482,
0.9742597342,
-0.5192289352,
0.3033391833,
0.1104745343,
0.4135969281,
-0.0198982321,
0.3791997433,
-0.149642989,
-0.6252794266,
-0.364415288,
-0.6691947579,
-0.5682225823,
0.0489045717,
-0.0833466724,
0.1514504403,
-0.284272939,
-0.1263792962,
-0.2699908316,
0.1886958629,
-0.951567471,
0.1876413226,
0.0003433265,
1.1042172909,
-0.210201323,
0.8204569817,
0.548632741,
-0.3721169829,
-0.9319374561,
0.1235025376,
0.1661013365,
-0.7388074398,
0.2598653436,
0.3948813975,
-0.5057324767,
0.1760268211,
-0.3864398599,
-1.2262535095,
1.4080533981,
0.2350095958,
-0.8026223779,
-0.3382796347,
-0.0355215333,
0.6795438528,
-0.1937057823,
0.7215441465,
0.4249273241,
0.6841542721,
-0.1487051249,
-1.181438446,
-0.0675490648,
-0.406136781,
0.191271171,
0.2338235378,
-0.5784320831,
0.7956086993,
-0.0703018308,
-0.4974943399,
0.0820270553,
0.3628787696,
0.4062568545,
0.4978033602,
0.9285284281,
0.3879614472,
0.8400156498,
0.1632038653,
1.270264864,
-0.3475831747,
0.3323775828,
0.9873102307,
-0.3301559091,
0.7917436957,
0.163297832,
-0.3361478448,
0.5016853809,
1.0947773457,
0.5166851878,
0.5007438064,
0.2372429669,
-0.1692231894,
-0.3489665091,
-0.1403998733,
0.0563345924,
0.3494229913,
0.0418271981,
-0.1405026913,
-0.3427914083,
-0.4060556889,
0.001678365,
0.1478168815,
-0.1570225656,
0.7318436503,
-0.2149036378,
-0.9741374254,
0.3022756875,
0.2009069324,
0.3167704642,
-0.8125717044,
-0.2814954519,
-0.2636887431,
0.1097448915,
-0.0330601856,
-0.4838036299,
-0.1836882085,
-0.0840677842,
0.1917261332,
-0.4386637509,
0.6279631257,
-0.1017071381,
-0.2850909233,
0.9648234248,
0.8987124562,
0.1072226763,
-0.422732681,
-0.7056596279,
0.104061164,
-0.0150669459,
-0.6479865909,
0.1046413779,
0.2651982009,
-0.4061049223,
1.0997401476,
0.7945465446,
-0.02705287,
0.2576087713,
-0.105484128,
0.8748526573,
-0.7342460155,
-0.683344245,
-0.7317306399,
0.2147659808,
-0.0657352656,
-0.0484099276,
0.3408438861,
0.8789924979,
0.8802657723,
0.2963670492,
0.8753658533,
-0.0397855081,
0.4019352794,
-0.6523150206,
0.4458704293,
-0.7899090052,
0.0308633521,
-0.2355218381,
-1.2409242392,
-0.0083620753,
0.6371222138,
0.1199256703,
0.238066107,
0.8615236878,
0.8989153504,
-0.2675715983,
-0.0523531847,
0.2973424494,
0.1951520145,
0.7066985369,
0.4827571809,
0.7879701257,
0.0023844459,
0.8096883893,
-0.3538677096,
-0.16857256,
-0.2891139984,
-0.9083894491,
-0.6656422019,
-0.5560228825,
0.1571647376,
0.093351081,
0.2215322852,
1.0921406746,
0.9594023228,
-0.4814111888,
-0.3192412555,
-0.4754481316,
0.1905847937,
-0.4887394905,
-0.2045925558,
0.000402432,
-0.3530773818,
-0.8586254716,
1.1038886309,
0.1061059088,
-0.1075987667,
-0.6062915921,
-0.3825116158,
-0.5403826237,
0.0918240622,
0.4200052917,
0.262962997,
-1.0319488049,
-0.3150960505,
0.2102255672,
-0.1868032962,
0.1421949267,
0.7622504234,
-0.9063097239,
0.7513602376,
0.2583276629,
0.6883159876,
1.0097929239,
-0.1362349838,
0.5175610781,
-0.545194447,
-0.1344250143,
0.5776105523,
0.3394513726,
0.0817800239,
-0.1130207181,
0.9290161133,
0.0172333382,
-0.4195495844,
-0.5591955781,
0.2565518916,
-0.8994138837,
-0.4202335179,
0.9362747073,
0.1401092261,
-0.174864307,
0.1240304336,
-0.3296691775,
0.3661048412,
-0.7453711033,
0.5665137172,
0.6152302027,
-0.5616410971,
-0.2141220272,
-0.5371834636,
0.4583420753,
0.3246577382,
-0.884187758,
-0.0799678415,
0.5314605832,
-0.066217728,
0.3535817564,
0.7428416014,
0.4619608819,
0.2679516971,
-0.1153775975,
0.280020982,
-0.0679361224,
-0.5875295997,
-0.1026313081,
0.1507002264,
0.3991107941,
-0.02391598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01470v1 | DogeRM: Equipping Reward Models with Domain Knowledge through Model Merging | 2024-07-01T17:01:54 | 2024-07-01T17:01:54 | Tzu-Han Lin, Chen-An Li, Hung-yi Lee, Yun-Nung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a popular strategy for
aligning large language models (LLMs) with desired behaviors. Reward modeling
is a crucial step in RLHF. However, collecting paired preference data for
training reward models is often costly and time-consuming, especially for
domain-specific preferences requiring expert annotation. To address this
challenge, we propose the \textbf{Do}main knowled\textbf{ge} merged
\textbf{R}eward \textbf{M}odel (DogeRM), a novel framework that integrates
domain-specific knowledge into a general reward model by model merging. The
experiments demonstrate that DogeRM enhances performance across different
benchmarks and provide a detailed analysis showcasing the effects of model
merging, showing the great potential of facilitating model alignment. | [
-0.6971463561,
-0.3942168653,
0.3999792039,
-0.1624881029,
-0.0299492218,
0.0077279909,
-0.3458930254,
-0.5789995193,
-0.0116608934,
0.6221415401,
-0.5625323057,
-0.4015846848,
-0.7051074505,
-0.5045180321,
-0.0030837222,
1.2447990179,
-0.2439107001,
0.1132097766,
-0.6584263444,
-0.3031847179,
-0.2636498809,
-0.8670032024,
-0.6541962624,
-0.9347008467,
0.7545708418,
0.3404530585,
0.5079914927,
0.494907856,
0.5298824906,
0.1998867244,
0.2291562855,
0.4810357392,
-0.4026232064,
0.1234223172,
-0.469797194,
-0.4142501354,
-0.742472589,
0.3778728545,
0.1823247224,
0.6897755861,
-0.5160372853,
-0.153228417,
0.0878257528,
0.586807549,
-0.6898904443,
0.1746368408,
-0.0639360026,
0.0926107615,
0.206318602,
-0.3164744973,
-0.3391832113,
-0.4098851383,
0.3425796032,
-0.4407426119,
0.1052805111,
0.2105108649,
1.018550396,
0.4491707981,
-0.4483036995,
-0.0598273017,
-0.9172224402,
0.9296203256,
-0.6198759675,
0.257181406,
0.3268156648,
0.3677054048,
-0.2956155539,
-0.5526918173,
-0.5046299696,
-0.1759150326,
-0.2700403929,
0.0876393989,
-0.103049472,
0.087546654,
-0.0551867746,
0.3170947433,
-0.399402529,
0.136759609,
-0.2271469831,
0.0432121456,
0.9611427188,
0.3035952151,
0.3863580227,
0.2739852965,
-0.7453793287,
-0.6890893579,
-0.6488528848,
0.2750071287,
0.2566491663,
0.2358340323,
-0.0928085372,
0.4081724882,
-0.0475837663,
0.8653764725,
0.1771152616,
-0.013700854,
0.1357230693,
0.1419990957,
-0.3363512158,
0.0571905375,
0.7471987009,
0.5455878377,
0.2205580026,
-0.3720154166,
-0.3363358974,
0.1040223762,
0.4509917498,
-0.6776785254,
-0.3380807638,
0.405834049,
-0.3628632128,
-0.5263382196,
0.2324383259,
-0.4471198916,
-0.3768544793,
-0.5707247853,
0.5208115578,
-0.2197175026,
-0.4843913913,
0.519089818,
-0.3210440874,
0.5440163016,
0.4596831203,
-0.994587481,
0.3541846275,
1.03602314,
0.3357369304,
-0.4259755015,
-0.6459380984,
-0.8395676613,
0.3215787411,
-0.18819502,
0.808814466,
-0.5044843554,
-0.5049480796,
-0.0301371831,
0.0298809167,
-0.1310586333,
-0.7526372671,
0.4479015768,
-0.9240788817,
0.5190620422,
-0.1257113069,
-0.8361465931,
-0.3647456169,
0.2845822573,
-0.5991319418,
0.9635527134,
0.152246803,
-0.5887899399,
0.4905309081,
-0.6666406989,
-0.4074992836,
0.1756130755,
-0.1767855287,
-0.2120979279,
-0.0163451042,
0.1813894957,
0.5592896938,
-0.3773482442,
0.5580070019,
-0.4328135252,
-0.2639866471,
0.2731973231,
0.1057138219,
0.1294125915,
0.1702748835,
-0.2965376079,
0.4064064622,
-0.345310837,
0.0641359836,
0.1263931692,
-0.4635285139,
-0.6608765721,
-0.0818569437,
0.2789397836,
0.3402851224,
0.3304994106,
-0.0217096787,
0.5384334326,
-0.0844395459,
0.1824448556,
0.6306271553,
-0.1348556131,
0.6150690317,
-0.7134429812,
0.6281424761,
0.052595064,
-0.0384771861,
0.2426413447,
-0.2543692291,
-0.8042252064,
-0.2690191567,
0.6385925412,
0.4683846235,
-0.0628284141,
0.5598347783,
-0.1619074941,
-0.3893185556,
-0.6318081021,
-0.0997652337,
0.3910404444,
0.2932106853,
0.4275005758,
-0.3855123222,
-0.3592989147,
-1.0047616959,
-0.2707102001,
-0.1590984911,
-0.0387984626,
0.5678679347,
0.2541024983,
-0.3653008938,
0.9995960593,
-0.5938055515,
-0.0769276693,
-0.22382541,
0.5232740045,
-0.0278608203,
0.5920187235,
0.213105008,
-0.7362312675,
-0.3659533858,
0.0837896913,
-0.7710573673,
0.0055573164,
0.2370864898,
-0.3672539592,
-0.1521761417,
0.3264048398,
-0.4762716591,
0.114263162,
0.5132434368,
-0.0909993201,
0.3164441288,
-0.4333574772,
0.7118890285,
-0.9018041492,
0.0091615068,
0.1333628595,
-0.3946096301,
-0.552795887,
0.0465653092,
0.1533308625,
0.0193963069,
-0.3995240927,
0.8251604438,
-0.3366646171,
0.0227348749,
-0.688128829,
0.1624880582,
-0.2477830201,
0.6357582808,
0.459271878,
0.5463014841,
0.2073588073,
-0.8508101106,
0.3552280068,
0.256896168,
0.0918610767,
0.7991353869,
-0.5639505386,
0.2311421931,
0.0432952307,
0.0486984253,
-0.7612653375,
-0.5636429191,
0.231022507,
-0.4067804217,
0.5101878047,
-0.3382374942,
0.0401763655,
-0.0842828006,
-0.1568334699,
0.3780372143,
0.6448767781,
-0.9440467358,
0.7252743244,
0.5462428927,
-0.223477453,
-0.6283251047,
-0.2754392624,
-0.0785063207,
-0.3512236178,
-0.7618380785,
0.8876311183,
0.0627394989,
-0.0830261707,
0.3647753298,
0.0822146684,
0.2046763897,
-0.0836173445,
0.2243337035,
0.5730632544,
-0.0175839085,
0.1145834178,
-0.1172550544,
-0.2369169444,
-0.0651263222,
-0.2767908871,
0.4416981041,
-0.1269189566,
-0.4480937123,
-0.108963497,
0.3800025284,
0.6021523476,
-0.2739691436,
0.6258183122,
0.3896140158,
-0.340475291,
-0.4181625545,
-0.5793246031,
-0.3441353738,
-0.3357963264,
0.1784536391,
-0.3257592916,
-1.1515269279,
0.2107580304,
-0.4404820502,
-0.0520852506,
0.2138833404,
0.4313304424,
-0.0916699469,
1.1729183197,
0.8625153899,
-0.3225615919,
0.3096632063,
-0.0590928532,
0.1036302298,
-0.8186732531,
-0.4772375226,
-0.3135038614,
-0.4979668558,
-0.302580595,
-0.4110933244,
-0.0536965728,
0.3823741972,
-0.3356421292,
0.1429249048,
-0.3191492558,
0.3463711143,
0.6771025658,
0.0508523062,
0.2801063359,
-0.0082099698,
-0.1493998766,
-0.0533319488,
-0.7856058478,
-0.5070329905,
1.0664335489,
0.2016351223,
1.0747641325,
-0.0359741524,
0.9258887768,
0.4353215396,
0.3575563729,
-0.9513126612,
0.4274408221,
-0.0277338121,
-0.0667781234,
-0.1741404682,
-0.1771248281,
-0.8508954644,
0.3372070193,
-0.15512079,
-0.5573295355,
0.1985445768,
0.3076121211,
-0.3568618298,
0.1342657954,
-0.4445450902,
0.8398593068,
-0.451990515,
-0.5040603876,
-0.4485339224,
-0.4818150401,
0.6029685736,
0.2147761881,
0.0756977871,
-0.0239228569,
0.0603683405,
0.8546068072,
-0.5844541192,
0.5243405104,
-0.1094886139,
-0.1335749626,
-0.2113032192,
-0.0455321111,
0.772300303,
-0.3239594698,
0.5170046091,
-0.1217212975,
-0.2203037739,
-0.2591226697,
-0.7470341325,
0.7857457995,
-0.8786320686,
-0.6980941296,
-0.5472654104,
-0.6025438905,
-0.5938696861,
-0.2347158641,
-0.2071517259,
0.1944123507,
-0.1690664887,
-0.1081903875,
0.8133333325,
-0.0449579842,
0.0140335942,
0.7146471739,
-0.4289732575,
-0.6654288769,
0.6744098067,
-0.5378589034,
0.0454883128,
0.298275888,
0.0153933484,
-0.5307306647,
0.0285572987,
-0.2669308782,
0.3827787638,
-0.6199454665,
0.0255002975,
-0.6087483168,
-0.2654561698,
-0.0990955606,
-0.328903228,
-0.3607802689,
-0.1783901751,
0.1541181356,
-0.0438438915,
0.4574776292,
0.9062973261,
-0.2582106888,
0.2989033759,
-0.9694648385,
0.019642774,
0.5399340391,
0.2798144817,
0.2163542956,
-0.3404493332,
-0.4410839081,
-0.1531786621,
-0.0217318702,
-0.8367388844,
0.4105530679,
-0.3136119545,
0.9529618621,
0.2224959582,
-0.0165296607,
0.6045809388,
-0.1446032077,
0.6070652008,
0.4621250629,
-0.7110108137,
0.5329375863,
-0.2601305842,
-0.1305123419,
0.1903255433,
0.6702564955,
-0.8706502914,
-0.1449257731,
-0.7038879991,
-0.8935201168,
1.0759221315,
-0.4607095122,
-0.308535248,
0.2389645875,
0.1429256797,
0.0101288958,
0.3219548464,
-0.4608854949,
-0.2993602157,
0.1685786545,
-0.3282408118,
-0.1265822053,
-0.1234386191,
-0.712633729,
-0.2515534163,
0.8439763784,
0.0794651732,
0.1721889526,
-0.0792182907,
-0.2174611539,
-0.2192816734,
0.3367446065,
0.4150452912,
0.3315850794,
-0.3695587218,
0.2733821869,
-0.2155301869,
0.0431865901,
0.4606880248,
0.0501206778,
0.1529466361,
-0.5716441274,
0.0500101596,
0.9268336892,
0.3453336954,
-0.6039085388,
0.3967344761,
-0.0926472768,
-0.6183728576,
0.2425231487,
0.4774343967,
0.3937506974,
0.5127543807,
0.1204654053,
0.0025678242,
-0.0926603675,
-0.3148123026,
0.4805137217,
0.4909558892,
-0.4597952664,
-0.0889756456,
0.7828426361,
0.227868259,
-0.2037484348,
0.5961499214,
-0.0112426365,
-0.7886568308,
0.4182337523,
0.519546032,
0.9739243984,
-0.2098492831,
0.167926088,
0.3523702323,
-0.2015314698,
-0.3422112465,
0.0062222392,
-0.2121579647,
-0.8327201009,
-0.397105962,
-0.428027451,
-0.5895582438,
0.2749606669,
-0.8771733642,
0.4087390304,
-0.0652334243,
-0.2365111858,
-0.0761090368,
-0.184931919,
-0.7493720651,
0.2075232267,
0.0713119581,
0.5016283989,
-0.9518103004,
0.8435735106,
1.1243451834,
-0.6507116556,
-0.9941542149,
-0.077212058,
-0.1781463474,
-0.7372353077,
1.0589076281,
-0.1309871227,
-0.283975035,
0.0202784613,
-0.4714622796,
-0.4306654334,
1.1033246517,
0.0067861592,
-0.4947727621,
0.1074457541,
-0.083542645,
0.1980203241,
-0.8389721513,
0.1384562552,
0.6858520508,
0.5208159089,
0.3129810095,
-0.7330198884,
0.1061027199,
-0.3144661188,
0.007060851,
0.4737347066,
-0.599200964,
0.7194368243,
-0.1455358118,
-0.0543453582,
-0.3431788385,
0.5303580761,
0.4956240356,
0.1287414134,
0.5303797126,
0.9124337435,
0.9265922308,
-0.006614747,
0.7616046071,
-0.4816022515,
0.613165617,
1.1656090021,
-0.4676141441,
0.9716885686,
0.5294510126,
-0.3166787326,
0.380902797,
0.8869339824,
0.0837256312,
0.8610159159,
0.1664174795,
-0.3275570273,
-0.7696802616,
-0.0028435597,
-0.630263567,
0.0816483945,
-0.0133232791,
-0.2085949183,
-0.1723288298,
-0.0822812021,
-0.0564914495,
-0.0430766009,
-0.114267014,
0.8783430457,
0.0016602152,
-1.1723805666,
0.4558913708,
0.1922387034,
0.9570175409,
-0.599631846,
-0.1379740238,
-0.3540232778,
0.3161804676,
-0.159896493,
-0.5860952735,
0.0477435403,
-0.2145925462,
-0.5057486296,
-0.0557269529,
0.9052655101,
-0.9159860611,
0.1915453076,
0.6382231116,
0.697642684,
0.0539146662,
0.0766306892,
-0.6555171013,
-0.2418997586,
-0.0559307337,
-0.04443755,
0.6665687561,
-0.12554124,
-0.0024214706,
0.5772044063,
0.6455139518,
0.0974268243,
-0.2095750123,
0.1053841785,
0.6931282878,
-0.7841641307,
-0.5121529102,
-0.7417369485,
0.5771859884,
-0.0620228685,
0.1426361501,
0.4447264373,
0.4438500702,
0.9047774076,
-0.2684185803,
1.1732957363,
0.1200913042,
0.3159182072,
-0.4377003014,
0.5558285713,
-0.9476420283,
0.1637182683,
0.1485792696,
-0.7666719556,
0.1242255345,
0.4478510022,
-0.4916085601,
0.1214741468,
0.5938305855,
0.818123579,
-0.284343034,
-0.0548761711,
0.3718449771,
-0.4553383291,
0.2035478503,
0.8450030088,
1.1559803486,
-0.1653518975,
0.1784363836,
-0.1130969748,
-0.3192701936,
-0.4899384379,
-0.8603747487,
-0.7097941637,
-0.493247062,
-0.4999873936,
-0.2999630868,
0.0981425121,
1.2398082018,
0.8856082559,
-0.7739498615,
-0.4430602491,
0.0196142904,
-0.0048257699,
-0.4300186038,
-0.2149186879,
0.388656199,
-0.5833218098,
-0.8523101211,
0.27002424,
0.4063699245,
0.1285790205,
-0.1742626578,
-0.7640752196,
0.0211416706,
0.2611013055,
0.2745485902,
0.3197601438,
-0.7278151512,
-0.034547139,
-0.0823918581,
-0.3605248332,
0.0154134259,
1.0190006495,
-0.6892918944,
0.3784547448,
0.4352625608,
0.9165141582,
0.6661761999,
0.2689191699,
1.1709948778,
-0.4385756552,
-0.0603904836,
-0.1572702527,
0.4490166605,
0.265527904,
-0.2482749969,
0.6129936576,
0.161145404,
-0.7158091068,
-0.6590083838,
0.213516295,
-1.0238138437,
-0.2047766298,
1.0268239975,
-0.1696911007,
-0.0711966082,
0.2440564334,
-0.1531123072,
0.3248136044,
-0.3159778118,
0.6000233293,
1.001013279,
-0.3838808537,
-0.1002016813,
-0.2486652583,
0.760915935,
0.4849637449,
-0.9330164194,
-0.0051274993,
0.4290926456,
0.4233308136,
-0.2191657871,
0.6172271967,
-0.0323654562,
0.3765706718,
-0.2364974916,
0.5840706229,
-0.3090051115,
-0.2783994079,
-0.477255851,
0.1987660378,
0.5789504051,
-0.2988600433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01463v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01463v1 | Retrieval-augmented generation in multilingual settings | 2024-07-01T16:56:50 | 2024-07-01T16:56:50 | Nadezhda Chirkova, David Rau, Hervé Déjean, Thibault Formal, Stéphane Clinchant, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has recently emerged as a promising
solution for incorporating up-to-date or domain-specific knowledge into large
language models (LLMs) and improving LLM factuality, but is predominantly
studied in English-only settings. In this work, we consider RAG in the
multilingual setting (mRAG), i.e. with user queries and the datastore in 13
languages, and investigate which components and with which adjustments are
needed to build a well-performing mRAG pipeline, that can be used as a strong
baseline in future works. Our findings highlight that despite the availability
of high-quality off-the-shelf multilingual retrievers and generators,
task-specific prompt engineering is needed to enable generation in user
languages. Moreover, current evaluation metrics need adjustments for
multilingual setting, to account for variations in spelling named entities. The
main limitations to be addressed in future works include frequent
code-switching in non-Latin alphabet languages, occasional fluency errors,
wrong reading of the provided documents, or irrelevant retrieval. We release
the code for the resulting mRAG baseline pipeline at
https://github.com/naver/bergen. | [
-0.455778718,
-0.3620586395,
0.2345301658,
0.2199130803,
0.1296094805,
0.4119106531,
-0.1767814457,
-0.4479111731,
0.2153742164,
0.3854685128,
-0.4573134184,
-0.321094811,
-0.2960416377,
0.5178946257,
0.0714986548,
1.095725894,
-0.1238281131,
-0.0827724412,
-0.2318253219,
-0.3112390935,
-0.8755649328,
-0.6334820986,
-0.4656252861,
-0.2611736357,
0.8076065183,
0.6596300602,
0.3958159685,
0.2915860713,
0.1068758294,
0.1788199246,
-0.1575969905,
0.6609410644,
-0.5096583962,
0.6106411219,
-0.3331037164,
-0.2509355843,
-0.2622879744,
-0.3143598437,
0.7660723329,
0.5492454171,
-0.1306160241,
0.4026330113,
0.1395486295,
0.6599125862,
-0.9410585761,
-0.0768917799,
-0.6836634278,
-0.083378084,
-0.3466345072,
-0.2495677024,
-0.6284787655,
0.1909766644,
-0.2454024702,
-0.562409699,
0.3957391381,
0.3621262908,
0.9259357452,
0.0428720117,
-0.5951613188,
-0.4099017084,
-0.4076264799,
0.8626660109,
-0.3470921516,
0.7180988789,
0.4685544372,
0.2704108059,
-0.2052304894,
-0.7033680677,
-0.4136666954,
-0.1649324894,
-0.3908786476,
0.1965244561,
0.2045498192,
-0.4007962942,
0.3213464022,
0.1677846611,
-0.6823364496,
-0.0140692517,
-0.2419453263,
-0.3179672658,
0.443957448,
0.0723859817,
0.0377329364,
-0.666995585,
-0.3868220448,
0.0404921249,
-0.8553305268,
-0.0775136724,
0.5738927126,
0.7641578913,
0.0004581557,
0.477119714,
-0.1091971025,
0.7483005524,
0.0728268921,
-0.1678158343,
0.3848517239,
-0.5401492119,
0.1555532068,
-0.2027302384,
0.5102809072,
-0.0475627556,
-0.0556680411,
-0.0622896813,
-0.4792506695,
-0.3541395664,
0.2662634552,
-0.583309412,
-0.0418659374,
0.1304860413,
-0.1730365455,
0.0419043638,
-0.2570809424,
-0.8057765365,
-0.5812315941,
-0.3642725348,
0.1919593364,
-0.2530165613,
-0.3692393005,
-0.3074892461,
-0.1386552751,
0.1005326137,
0.0141086718,
-0.7035620809,
-0.3511745036,
0.3617219031,
0.55143255,
-0.1842955351,
-0.5595479012,
-0.6789104342,
0.1852146387,
-0.4662227929,
0.9254532456,
-0.4324736297,
-0.6984245181,
0.2574515045,
-0.0032859971,
-0.2080642879,
-0.5099140406,
0.7672922015,
-0.724635005,
0.6305733919,
-0.5886457562,
-0.1775469631,
0.1609264314,
0.4201227427,
-0.5251488686,
1.1299698353,
0.1457054317,
-0.7450474501,
0.5871437192,
-0.4693878889,
-0.5157723427,
0.2564776838,
-0.256550163,
-0.1265916675,
0.1390881836,
0.3195088208,
0.1859527081,
-0.3091937602,
0.3308894038,
0.3203106523,
-0.162412703,
-0.0488538742,
-0.4338213801,
0.6946164966,
0.6205903888,
0.0799785182,
-0.2212064266,
-0.8905153871,
0.0270992368,
-0.04760544,
-0.5807591081,
-0.2841461003,
-0.0148100145,
0.1863340586,
0.3079322875,
0.4096318781,
-0.3258979917,
0.2100352943,
-0.1272895038,
-0.2049717158,
0.6631570458,
0.0521235578,
0.2115255892,
-0.2733949721,
0.9224281907,
-0.0317981616,
-0.2332377583,
-0.613371253,
-0.3581676483,
-0.6133531928,
-0.5291416049,
0.4522479475,
0.7137895823,
-1.3354011774,
-0.0956956744,
-0.1579320729,
-0.1242309287,
-0.6266515255,
0.2317355275,
0.6781046391,
0.8524173498,
0.2960692048,
0.0490649119,
-0.6260015965,
-0.83195889,
-0.4159164131,
-0.2583456039,
-0.0020046907,
0.5938829184,
0.1270472258,
-0.3465714455,
0.9154884219,
-0.3390647471,
-0.1820008457,
-0.3506813645,
0.2223095745,
0.4602158368,
0.2142406702,
0.541487813,
-0.9012616873,
-0.5772405863,
0.2357754558,
-0.8323900104,
-0.4031459391,
-0.1561524272,
-0.2246254534,
0.5995935798,
0.366422087,
-0.5055531263,
-0.0116547449,
0.6613812447,
-0.4948792458,
0.8898311853,
-0.3199644983,
0.6581475735,
-1.2965984344,
0.3824145794,
-0.1010115072,
-0.2200671732,
-0.6839031577,
0.3963108063,
0.2412257493,
-0.3614692092,
-0.5480347872,
0.9702838063,
-0.7484232187,
-0.0014202847,
-0.1642672122,
0.1660403013,
0.3875339329,
0.2031095028,
-0.2127941251,
1.4400988817,
0.318895936,
-0.692997694,
-0.0117329257,
0.3353271484,
-0.2355252057,
0.8841987252,
-0.3190247715,
0.0928938016,
-0.2401074469,
0.0237389728,
-0.78329283,
-0.4514059126,
-0.0607213601,
-0.6258794069,
0.7698863149,
-0.2694158256,
-0.5982287526,
-0.1730593592,
-0.1022119075,
0.2667354941,
0.2995885015,
-0.8094828725,
0.6864331365,
0.3037944138,
-0.2466154546,
-0.954061687,
-0.4425219595,
0.3713646531,
-0.2777347565,
-0.7437029481,
0.157781139,
0.056876976,
-0.2006591558,
-0.40618366,
0.0564803034,
-0.1236689091,
-0.0553273894,
-0.2729758918,
0.3102732003,
-0.0587408617,
0.3439441025,
0.1518461704,
-0.049938757,
-0.2228686064,
-0.0288222339,
0.3679973483,
0.0917147323,
-0.2186369002,
0.2386671156,
0.5948839188,
0.2664324939,
-0.4828374982,
0.8009590507,
0.6694899797,
-0.1422851831,
-0.2966385782,
-0.5442979932,
0.0599034354,
-0.4919678271,
0.2442955971,
-0.9036362767,
-0.8688104153,
0.7697198391,
0.0391011201,
0.313828826,
0.4929418266,
0.6429323554,
-0.1383114308,
0.8795893788,
0.5431112051,
0.351780057,
0.2841672301,
0.1053963602,
0.1224405617,
-0.9584803581,
-0.1674547344,
-0.766209662,
-0.0100455992,
-0.6773290038,
-0.3900229633,
0.635117352,
0.2190471888,
-0.015892664,
0.2819176316,
-0.2948019505,
0.4040696323,
0.4020827413,
-0.2590400577,
0.3364902139,
0.190604493,
-0.3367508948,
-0.2441622168,
-1.0212886333,
-0.5419337749,
0.8938660622,
-0.0698095113,
0.5626233816,
0.2972891331,
0.7050696015,
0.3664241433,
0.2268244773,
-0.4523265064,
0.3085661829,
-0.16133973,
-0.8708764911,
-0.0202206764,
-0.5183377862,
-1.259215951,
0.581361413,
-0.132298097,
-0.3623815477,
0.2851644456,
0.3428985178,
-0.028088836,
-0.0821707174,
-0.8979833126,
0.8305046558,
-0.1292890459,
-0.4043701887,
-0.0188700762,
-0.5514214635,
0.2808768749,
-0.2827744186,
0.5006771088,
0.1214258075,
-0.0305411015,
0.2768325508,
-0.0733483285,
0.4670721889,
-0.3548005819,
-0.3432826996,
0.2970785499,
0.0567449294,
0.6237614751,
0.2010833919,
-0.2711766064,
0.0281546321,
-0.1072509736,
-0.4500671029,
-0.3528234065,
0.7843207717,
-0.4363328516,
-0.6185878515,
-0.466362685,
-0.8107517362,
-0.5057162642,
0.157654047,
0.3430116177,
0.5155020952,
-0.0553787127,
-0.0871613845,
0.6296586394,
-0.5374212265,
0.2613810599,
0.5714370012,
-0.388287276,
-0.433564961,
1.1441779137,
0.2468122691,
0.2096394002,
0.2389964014,
0.0020727916,
-0.3145355284,
-0.2871721983,
-0.971488297,
0.4188670218,
-0.7659372687,
-0.3197546303,
-0.4973395169,
0.2520951331,
-0.5588957071,
-0.0874821618,
-0.153345719,
-0.4366204739,
-0.409420222,
0.0617106706,
0.2828050852,
0.4149669707,
-0.1450697333,
-0.0453034341,
-0.9063714147,
0.4892555475,
0.0419270955,
0.2914789617,
-0.3092256486,
-0.7795514464,
-0.5955434442,
-0.131071046,
-0.1950425059,
-0.7576550245,
0.3367586732,
0.4156569242,
0.6816674471,
-0.2109193206,
0.0443567298,
0.791596055,
-0.8189746141,
0.925982058,
-0.1166076064,
-0.566896081,
0.4403983951,
-0.4793327153,
0.5376340151,
0.6216827035,
0.3209786713,
-0.7928027511,
-0.300242275,
-0.3391001523,
-1.0217750072,
0.5895829201,
-0.0887666419,
0.2684703767,
-0.3271860778,
0.2830654085,
0.194799006,
0.3579057753,
-0.3012029827,
-0.3641905487,
-0.0288307723,
-0.0081196446,
-0.0659052432,
-0.4130532444,
-0.1440799385,
0.2994242907,
0.9019164443,
-0.2735213041,
0.0327039212,
0.1028870046,
-0.3062861264,
0.0321081653,
0.4950115383,
0.4859474003,
1.0688138008,
0.0857483968,
-0.0950560942,
0.2367285043,
-0.3104962409,
0.2190870345,
0.2547545731,
-0.3656226099,
0.3248219192,
0.2652342319,
0.7572299838,
-0.0270703733,
-0.8020933867,
0.0896667242,
0.0009814823,
0.1317114383,
-0.1219164059,
-0.22886087,
-0.2456095964,
0.0830010176,
0.6829155087,
-0.1180016547,
0.1355478913,
-0.3627928495,
0.2473935336,
0.3985121846,
0.0297626723,
-0.1946161687,
0.5564229488,
0.2254251242,
-0.2473848611,
0.4873719513,
-0.5319207907,
-0.2238821834,
0.1905943602,
0.5185409188,
0.7272850275,
-0.240356341,
0.180102542,
0.3484573066,
0.3036467433,
0.0750802383,
0.383936584,
0.1301218271,
-0.6075025201,
-0.8459496498,
-0.6895827055,
-0.3578367233,
-0.3083333671,
-0.6784027815,
0.403093338,
0.0788101852,
-0.2091870606,
-0.3007377982,
-0.1038351953,
-0.6337152719,
0.0833137035,
0.0723871365,
0.8261790276,
-0.5298300385,
0.5728503466,
1.0089952946,
-0.2124715447,
-0.57174474,
-0.1457528621,
-0.0231594648,
-0.6105483174,
0.5994674563,
-0.0552408509,
-0.1708550304,
0.019676799,
-0.1864619851,
-0.8274460435,
0.9325991869,
0.5542513132,
-0.2544717193,
0.0193775427,
-0.1643761992,
0.6044851542,
-0.1870023161,
0.0993991345,
0.377628088,
0.4017198384,
0.065366827,
-1.0609219074,
-0.3543827236,
-0.1859909296,
0.1351219565,
0.4268183708,
-0.5277805924,
0.7382531762,
-0.0989840329,
-0.4463362396,
-0.0332349651,
0.7005034685,
0.6854553223,
0.2554245591,
0.2591074705,
0.6087064743,
0.8348228335,
-0.0203251243,
1.309540391,
-0.5178220272,
0.2368722856,
1.176764369,
-0.480561316,
0.6710231304,
0.6654511094,
-0.0434852913,
0.3683348298,
0.4363985062,
0.3944116831,
0.2946690023,
-0.1817535162,
-0.4481171966,
-0.0320565626,
-0.5904039145,
-0.4131802917,
0.2868131995,
0.3256336749,
-0.2059019059,
-0.1965133399,
0.2289984077,
0.1729430705,
0.2806071043,
-0.1775411963,
0.6147922873,
-0.1395108998,
-0.872938931,
0.8464198709,
0.0185905062,
0.6557727456,
-0.5188743472,
-0.1224669218,
-0.5432344675,
-0.1323131174,
-0.187817499,
-0.7293425798,
0.3384961784,
0.46300897,
-0.4736377597,
-0.5820558071,
0.7106240392,
-0.512427032,
-0.5737552643,
0.0987126827,
0.8907364011,
0.1687785387,
0.2504422665,
-0.6208851337,
0.1315092146,
0.0552458912,
-0.4942003191,
0.4734268486,
0.6731300354,
-0.0940060318,
0.4730727673,
0.6168913245,
0.2129409462,
0.2928980887,
0.4049052,
0.6914672852,
-0.40099594,
-0.2047946453,
-0.3662778139,
0.8496578932,
0.1198747531,
-0.3732641935,
1.0114705563,
0.5664145947,
0.7737745643,
-0.097773008,
0.7201234102,
-0.3552670479,
0.9525224566,
-0.4303844869,
0.5331799984,
-0.7149938345,
0.1897816956,
-0.0960179269,
-0.9626965523,
-0.2222883254,
0.2374916375,
0.2261524796,
-0.0007738862,
0.5488604307,
0.8603807688,
0.1399894953,
-0.5878974199,
0.4422023296,
-0.1097097248,
0.4418462515,
0.1472963095,
0.6237543225,
-0.3667688072,
0.5525259972,
0.1778388768,
-0.0914091766,
0.2329967767,
-0.8783041835,
-0.6282204986,
-0.5508856177,
-0.0926605463,
-0.3625086248,
0.1696359813,
0.8088847995,
0.3283929527,
-0.7100960016,
-0.3859217167,
0.3817557991,
0.2204558998,
0.076237224,
-0.1922201514,
0.0162009671,
-0.9861987829,
-0.8311604857,
0.7045825124,
0.0540168993,
-0.3324202597,
-0.3637607992,
-0.1357087344,
-0.5189015269,
-0.098833099,
0.747087419,
0.4481358528,
-0.5805498958,
-0.317825526,
0.2036576271,
-0.1012972519,
0.0450518392,
0.6520858407,
-0.914239645,
0.8241522312,
0.696177423,
0.7753106952,
0.1979295909,
0.2178828865,
0.5904752612,
-1.423145771,
0.2458200455,
0.1747384369,
0.4071773589,
0.5562714338,
-0.3268566728,
0.5422716141,
0.1621089876,
-0.8478726149,
-0.9920825362,
0.4075420499,
-0.3065283597,
-0.1105349436,
1.2136403322,
-0.0259650741,
0.1691634506,
-0.1807410717,
-0.29565382,
0.0883372352,
-0.4464758635,
0.5687611103,
0.8576253057,
-0.0978503451,
-0.2400414795,
-0.769980669,
0.4375900626,
0.4428108633,
-0.7416837811,
0.1306376457,
0.9051665664,
-0.1993682683,
0.5122708678,
0.4902497232,
0.0371174067,
0.2253067195,
-0.1396748573,
0.1918200254,
-0.0372011438,
-0.6196039319,
-0.3416384757,
0.1137448773,
0.3130749464,
0.1718849242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01461v1 | Enhancing the Capability and Robustness of Large Language Models through Reinforcement Learning-Driven Query Refinement | 2024-07-01T16:55:28 | 2024-07-01T16:55:28 | Zisu Huang, Xiaohua Wang, Feiran Zhang, Zhibo Xu, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capacity of large language models (LLMs) to generate honest, harmless,
and helpful responses heavily relies on the quality of user prompts. However,
these prompts often tend to be brief and vague, thereby significantly limiting
the full potential of LLMs. Moreover, harmful prompts can be meticulously
crafted and manipulated by adversaries to jailbreak LLMs, inducing them to
produce potentially toxic content. To enhance the capabilities of LLMs while
maintaining strong robustness against harmful jailbreak inputs, this study
proposes a transferable and pluggable framework that refines user prompts
before they are input into LLMs. This strategy improves the quality of the
queries, empowering LLMs to generate more truthful, benign and useful
responses. Specifically, a lightweight query refinement model is introduced and
trained using a specially designed reinforcement learning approach that
incorporates multiple objectives to enhance particular capabilities of LLMs.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that the refinement model not only improves
the quality of responses but also strengthens their robustness against
jailbreak attacks. Code is available at:
https://github.com/Huangzisu/query-refinement . | [
-0.3236664832,
-0.92800349,
0.582544148,
0.0258081071,
-0.1516441405,
0.2618957758,
-0.524153173,
-0.2619458437,
0.0615055822,
0.7232455611,
-0.5930832028,
-0.4722506404,
-0.2801387012,
0.1487237513,
-0.1653840393,
1.0535773039,
0.1485987753,
-0.2770290971,
-0.0535535887,
-0.1482996047,
-0.6091066003,
-0.2630212307,
-0.8619071245,
0.0220392849,
0.6228228211,
0.5045297146,
0.6072899103,
0.2150978297,
0.1561452001,
0.3536731303,
-0.085570842,
0.4117965102,
-0.7681319118,
0.6667233706,
-0.5217776299,
-0.554835856,
-0.0884133205,
-0.3493583798,
0.3879002035,
0.428483367,
-0.259624809,
-0.0706577525,
0.0551609062,
0.5691966414,
-0.583481431,
0.0599397533,
-1.0115784407,
-0.2841276824,
0.0201479811,
-0.2367438227,
-0.6542239189,
-0.4397889078,
-0.0066458522,
-0.5420646071,
0.0137299215,
0.2254531533,
0.7121112943,
0.2004301399,
-0.3255707324,
-0.1456229091,
-0.4893405139,
0.6117117405,
-0.9152534008,
0.2381350845,
0.3711408377,
0.4367818832,
-0.7365500331,
-0.6748436093,
-0.3326686323,
-0.7135053277,
-0.0467270464,
-0.3623475134,
-0.1310845017,
0.0756353289,
0.4489822388,
0.0587487556,
-0.6028256416,
0.4375033975,
-0.2997617126,
-0.3023198545,
0.6512865424,
0.2940439582,
0.3241596222,
-0.1032224745,
-0.2054078877,
0.0317220613,
-0.9046892524,
0.2867310345,
0.4641607106,
0.5671383739,
0.1945233196,
0.3675198853,
-0.4935264289,
0.764863193,
0.2879343331,
-0.2056071758,
0.0338955224,
-0.2462479621,
0.0996123776,
-0.187137872,
0.9965735078,
0.1055865213,
0.1292173713,
-0.2655958533,
-0.4385021627,
-0.4259996712,
0.5663284063,
-1.0163270235,
-0.1144361869,
0.3503713608,
-0.3049086034,
-0.5359988213,
0.0681317598,
-0.6379762888,
-0.6106987,
-0.0458115153,
0.1438610107,
-0.552290678,
-0.1514907032,
0.1414667517,
0.2633199394,
-0.0085663646,
0.4187074602,
-1.0833581686,
0.2114487141,
0.5110931993,
0.4351681769,
-0.1221372262,
-0.01063646,
-0.8020154238,
0.0743967965,
-0.2508897483,
0.5741417408,
-0.5598105788,
-0.5344296098,
0.0152111053,
0.1183580458,
0.1703882366,
-0.6881448627,
0.5741568804,
-1.0375276804,
0.0730690807,
-0.2734794319,
-0.3092800975,
-0.1632009149,
0.4635197818,
-0.7390969396,
0.8138541579,
0.0784781575,
-0.5908970237,
0.2164670974,
-0.3544546664,
-0.6284011602,
0.0580243133,
-0.0307855643,
-0.3671195805,
0.0972667783,
0.4589902759,
0.2617067993,
-0.1714351028,
0.3902837336,
-0.5490215421,
-0.3704114258,
0.4404792488,
-0.24663423,
0.5490283966,
0.3119542301,
-0.2034296542,
0.5123748779,
-0.8001065254,
0.1880715936,
0.1939993203,
-0.5860882998,
-0.2797307372,
0.1130556986,
-0.2731542885,
0.2223406285,
0.2286501974,
-0.3995390534,
0.3608794808,
-0.6766930819,
0.5495221019,
0.8163070083,
0.0777161494,
0.3004275262,
-0.1883066893,
0.6256484985,
-0.1308075786,
0.1009017602,
-0.2971837819,
-0.1876901686,
-0.3216522634,
-0.1037891135,
0.2377234399,
0.6273980737,
-1.0362776518,
0.4094591737,
-0.0004273256,
-0.5173124075,
-0.339425087,
0.3684112728,
0.1992466152,
0.6738166213,
0.3390336037,
-0.2322340161,
-0.5951078534,
-0.5788542032,
-0.4119460285,
-0.510530889,
-0.0360077508,
0.4940441847,
0.3519059718,
-0.1554228663,
0.7313671112,
-0.4399023652,
0.1303317994,
-0.423633486,
-0.0615486987,
0.2131629735,
0.473674804,
0.4090973139,
-0.6171034575,
-0.2299533039,
-0.1887825727,
-0.5100896955,
-0.3000960946,
-0.2112696767,
-0.0128463069,
-0.0411232673,
0.8092139959,
-0.491973877,
0.1446132213,
0.2482085973,
-0.440417856,
1.0555764437,
-0.136154741,
0.1617902666,
-0.9676075578,
-0.0180018749,
-0.0886523798,
-0.4614295363,
-0.4141186476,
0.345198065,
0.072152175,
-0.1698045284,
-0.4756034017,
0.6356725097,
-0.1912733465,
0.1060021222,
-0.4151168168,
0.1359155476,
0.0687054172,
0.3296524286,
-0.2279067338,
0.9452748895,
0.4280180633,
-0.6216233373,
0.6569417119,
0.0478583872,
-0.326336354,
0.3942596018,
-0.8958774209,
-0.0883693323,
-0.0248213932,
0.2107293755,
-1.0818450451,
-0.1477413625,
0.2057866752,
-0.4617488086,
0.3303446472,
-0.3021279573,
-0.5470927358,
-0.1768383682,
-0.3597216904,
0.3071588278,
0.472007066,
-0.6499581933,
0.4062132835,
0.0400700867,
-0.335504353,
-0.4305889606,
-0.3540732265,
-0.0030268736,
-0.2612683177,
-0.6212388277,
0.3496943116,
-0.1016198546,
-0.1085178331,
-0.1377412379,
-0.0162334591,
0.0992829651,
0.3498123884,
0.1376246065,
0.3526976109,
-0.1320544034,
0.2032262236,
0.1060252935,
0.0025112084,
0.2038487047,
-0.3648288846,
0.5287883282,
-0.1003664583,
-0.4143173993,
-0.3217060268,
-0.0283439253,
0.4915791154,
-0.4908337891,
0.7693429589,
0.5914283395,
0.0263073202,
-0.4590485394,
-0.5335151553,
-0.542480588,
-0.5712953806,
0.3552274704,
-0.3629960716,
-1.4860078096,
0.5243311524,
-0.373529166,
-0.0399181396,
0.0874527916,
0.508395195,
0.072944425,
1.1084586382,
0.5599287152,
-0.1714626104,
0.7116655707,
0.1831101775,
0.0166483484,
-0.7685875893,
-0.2994691432,
-0.5685431957,
-0.1149100363,
-0.7528178096,
-0.2458099872,
0.0734434798,
0.1364284456,
-0.3697827756,
0.2317185551,
-0.2753124833,
0.5278153419,
0.3282091916,
0.2607650161,
0.1341623813,
-0.0331302173,
-0.3957128525,
-0.0609561503,
-0.4554818273,
-0.4313916862,
1.0478647947,
0.2882381678,
1.1041628122,
0.37584728,
0.6157886982,
0.1678422093,
0.094064489,
-0.6713984013,
0.5813239217,
0.242152065,
-0.4467187822,
-0.2538967133,
-0.7591439486,
-0.9218384027,
0.3690392375,
-0.2382235676,
-0.9324356914,
-0.0490910672,
-0.0128615908,
-0.4902898371,
0.3072206676,
-0.5338645577,
0.7416303158,
-0.4048392773,
-0.7190949321,
-0.1736238748,
-0.43095842,
0.5736997724,
-0.0263889376,
0.0862318724,
-0.127431035,
-0.0920248106,
0.4841071963,
-0.5766862035,
0.9011978507,
-0.2651120126,
-0.1154821217,
0.2402246594,
0.3500961661,
0.7676574588,
0.5343080163,
-0.1700710207,
-0.5375057459,
-0.2197897881,
-0.3966043293,
-0.8535408974,
0.7808326483,
-0.4724895358,
-1.01141119,
-0.0395072289,
-0.4328964055,
-0.4788383543,
0.4155324101,
-0.1195542961,
0.2599881589,
-0.1692833751,
0.1239438131,
1.0431497097,
-0.6329083443,
0.1849882901,
0.8345856071,
-0.5744965076,
-0.2701604664,
0.7481938004,
-0.3282434046,
0.2116871923,
0.1571678519,
0.1317166686,
-0.4096056223,
-0.813639164,
-0.3285050988,
0.1554520428,
-0.5356968045,
-0.2833557725,
-0.2462707609,
-0.0649404973,
-0.4865246117,
0.0384612568,
-0.217370227,
-0.2114031315,
-0.274104923,
-0.3244709671,
0.5321993828,
0.3279833496,
0.1320386678,
0.2707498372,
-0.7592688203,
0.2884658575,
0.3937013149,
0.3909550905,
0.0016123223,
-0.7994967699,
-0.095814012,
-0.197983861,
-0.3317939043,
-0.8782055974,
0.4051932096,
-0.0090510836,
0.6068561077,
0.5277150273,
0.3570544124,
0.4627303183,
-0.4097429514,
0.7526564598,
0.0588977076,
-0.656309247,
0.8709436059,
-0.4208322465,
0.2870480418,
0.9251018167,
0.2818907499,
-0.2860349417,
-0.4222183228,
-0.4887812436,
-0.9990369081,
0.5850867033,
-0.2085297704,
0.3786639869,
-0.0234317426,
0.5365896225,
0.1117007285,
0.1644147784,
-0.6007828712,
-0.0249347836,
-0.0414442345,
0.0599308833,
0.2575612068,
-0.3434408605,
-0.0340946093,
-0.2245514393,
0.7600662708,
-0.1797351092,
-0.2623122334,
-0.1916353256,
-0.1672157794,
0.0806513503,
0.5981245637,
0.4247759283,
0.5541120768,
-0.1191640496,
-0.0086602466,
0.240303874,
-0.2869540155,
0.2373113185,
0.2101532966,
-0.2711157799,
-0.3206916451,
0.1944342852,
0.9435271621,
0.2455502301,
-1.0988906622,
0.4018404782,
-0.3966763318,
0.1125236228,
0.0682937056,
0.3973386884,
-0.0447297171,
0.3362362385,
0.1234942749,
-0.1626466811,
0.1529459804,
-0.4713787735,
0.2869459093,
0.435487628,
-0.3150438368,
-0.1779705584,
0.7059549689,
0.1668099761,
-0.061551325,
0.8355637789,
-0.3120061457,
-0.4858323932,
0.2852333784,
0.812024951,
0.5290102959,
-0.270358175,
0.2550108433,
0.5591060519,
0.3378514946,
0.036007151,
0.26861009,
-0.1428244263,
-0.6108059883,
-0.4927575886,
-0.4864282906,
-0.3226366639,
0.28117764,
-0.6820178628,
0.1702333391,
-0.8247249722,
-0.1736764908,
-0.4274465144,
0.1037763134,
-0.3322731555,
0.1393614858,
-0.0243729614,
0.9675834775,
-0.4656772912,
0.8076353073,
0.6091979146,
-0.6284350157,
-0.9633709788,
-0.111733973,
0.0053286832,
-0.7338083386,
0.5526387095,
0.1010462865,
-0.0572496913,
-0.1981740892,
-0.7730153203,
-0.7582637668,
0.8612476587,
0.447352916,
-0.6618971229,
0.0061377813,
-0.0510212407,
0.4486637414,
-0.1640079618,
0.3023026884,
0.6463845372,
0.2578114271,
0.1487623006,
-0.7001675963,
0.4721732438,
-0.1556755751,
0.1842669994,
0.0935359597,
-0.3399387896,
0.5958461165,
-0.5702470541,
-0.063228175,
0.2220678329,
0.7888629436,
0.6752628088,
-0.1301962733,
0.426839143,
0.560479939,
0.9128616452,
-0.078032203,
1.0457566977,
-0.2222360075,
0.0088450704,
1.2632347345,
-0.3232894242,
0.9055288434,
0.4188561738,
-0.0480589531,
0.7586815357,
0.5289259553,
-0.0737461299,
0.6173408031,
0.5937006474,
-0.4695529938,
-0.2885088325,
-0.0320146009,
-0.2180929631,
0.1735819727,
0.5415945649,
-0.3678210974,
-0.2267455459,
0.0853399262,
0.2165659219,
0.2892529666,
-0.336998105,
0.8935130239,
0.0166898705,
-0.7062072158,
0.6850041747,
0.3090936244,
0.8345493078,
-0.7377242446,
0.0945204869,
-0.3136757612,
-0.0904345065,
-0.3706423044,
-0.6959304214,
0.0280908328,
0.1736499369,
-0.132266432,
0.0301341489,
0.9772636294,
-0.3169128001,
-0.1073542461,
0.2805195749,
0.3567107916,
-0.0750831813,
-0.0851643607,
-0.9100261331,
0.2726776898,
0.1294774115,
-0.3417313993,
0.5177657008,
0.4708419442,
-0.0548325628,
0.8693085313,
0.8808766007,
0.3462378681,
-0.0177581757,
0.2346147746,
1.1268994808,
-0.5918887854,
-0.5752543211,
-0.86401999,
0.5175482631,
-0.06861002,
0.0969786793,
0.7573586106,
0.3249487579,
0.8433612585,
0.1051563248,
0.8587920666,
0.0115164118,
0.3601210117,
-0.6101282835,
0.7305629253,
-0.4387927949,
0.7703482509,
-0.0410458893,
-0.6135408878,
-0.1592124254,
0.4820096493,
-0.6663626432,
0.3178889453,
0.3068845272,
1.0707859993,
0.1101456359,
-0.2292997986,
0.2797914743,
0.1862230003,
0.6123277545,
0.5541331768,
0.9188222885,
-0.1038956121,
0.7024150491,
-0.0362432897,
-0.0667113438,
-0.3438999355,
-0.7345542908,
-0.8348485827,
-0.2716895342,
-0.1549112797,
-0.5959118605,
0.2567005157,
0.8848990798,
0.6599500179,
-0.8234542608,
-0.1288608462,
-0.013741497,
0.3243781328,
0.0197813641,
-0.295460254,
0.1174720973,
-0.8086645007,
-0.2459777743,
0.7614814639,
0.0947187021,
-0.2367476672,
-0.2748550773,
-0.1342781484,
0.0415259488,
0.116835922,
0.5911031365,
0.6489882469,
-0.6992255449,
-0.2633763254,
-0.1810520589,
-0.2263285071,
-0.0719887316,
0.7455308437,
-1.0992003679,
0.5265102983,
0.4247567952,
0.858750701,
0.2388801277,
0.1412531137,
0.5591892004,
-0.9537217617,
0.0581294484,
0.2921784222,
0.4075319767,
0.3550258279,
-0.4451444149,
0.0701781064,
-0.082356669,
-0.5295938849,
-0.7736244798,
0.5313080549,
-0.7609704733,
-0.6046420336,
1.1418398619,
-0.3145122528,
-0.2725814879,
-0.1224297583,
-0.4770311415,
-0.0203033965,
-0.6381887197,
0.7881698608,
0.4220868051,
-0.0603028461,
-0.4090321958,
-0.3865956068,
0.6437073946,
0.3176608682,
-0.9463310242,
0.265360862,
0.6764411926,
0.6118338108,
-0.2366007715,
0.4181099832,
-0.3457130492,
0.3352825642,
-0.3015903234,
-0.2210270464,
-0.3652896881,
-0.2057410479,
-0.3889231086,
0.365891844,
0.6164579391,
0.235358119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01455v1 | TimeToM: Temporal Space is the Key to Unlocking the Door of Large Language Models' Theory-of-Mind | 2024-07-01T16:50:49 | 2024-07-01T16:50:49 | Guiyang Hou, Wenqi Zhang, Yongliang Shen, Linjuan Wu, Weiming Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Theory of Mind (ToM)-the cognitive ability to reason about mental states of
ourselves and others, is the foundation of social interaction. Although ToM
comes naturally to humans, it poses a significant challenge to even the most
advanced Large Language Models (LLMs). Due to the complex logical chains in ToM
reasoning, especially in higher-order ToM questions, simply utilizing reasoning
methods like Chain of Thought (CoT) will not improve the ToM capabilities of
LLMs. We present TimeToM, which constructs a temporal space and uses it as the
foundation to improve the ToM capabilities of LLMs in multiple scenarios.
Specifically, within the temporal space, we construct Temporal Belief State
Chain (TBSC) for each character and inspired by the cognition perspective of
the social world model, we divide TBSC into self-world beliefs and social world
beliefs, aligning with first-order ToM (first-order beliefs) and higher-order
ToM (higher-order beliefs) questions, respectively. Moreover, we design a novel
tool-belief solver that, by considering belief communication between characters
in temporal space, can transform a character's higher-order beliefs into
another character's first-order beliefs under belief communication period.
Experimental results indicate that TimeToM can dramatically improve the
reasoning performance of LLMs on ToM questions while taking a big step towards
coherent and robust ToM reasoning. | [
-0.3465944231,
-0.9227639437,
1.1302351952,
0.1301463246,
-0.2846288979,
0.4268330336,
-0.1809458137,
-0.5162225366,
0.1768412441,
0.0059447507,
-0.6863128543,
-0.3387025893,
-0.4351087511,
-0.1446700394,
0.1063640937,
0.4817064106,
-0.0954535455,
-0.0198023096,
0.2653397918,
-0.0993744284,
-0.2073708028,
-0.6350181103,
-0.7786525488,
-0.4725066423,
0.7058589458,
-0.1543126404,
0.7654178739,
0.4572217166,
0.3550141156,
0.2479839325,
-0.1696072966,
0.3079722524,
-0.2382277995,
0.3033094704,
-0.6900656223,
-0.7262219191,
-0.8606490493,
-0.0654340535,
0.4622010589,
0.5338256955,
-0.2543484867,
-0.1057788581,
-0.1258597225,
0.2604894936,
-0.4822113216,
0.2376321554,
-0.7160546184,
0.187251389,
-0.1849257797,
-0.5699695349,
-0.2958865166,
-0.4173923135,
0.1758614779,
-0.7870137095,
0.1572333127,
0.5419903398,
0.7573619485,
0.2880235016,
-0.458684653,
0.0117883179,
-0.9008086324,
0.9167127013,
-0.6758329868,
0.4640310705,
0.1862239689,
0.6459190249,
-0.3789723516,
-0.1555835903,
-0.9713784456,
0.1170360819,
0.3167416751,
-0.0930778384,
0.1231217459,
0.1076651067,
0.2917970717,
0.3171756864,
-0.4621003568,
-0.2218901068,
-0.0387454927,
-0.0216961429,
0.3644382358,
0.4399005175,
0.2325050831,
0.0389713384,
-0.139171645,
-0.3173263967,
-0.5318405032,
-0.3201283216,
-0.2899957895,
0.0478916913,
0.0809133649,
0.3856859803,
0.0054215211,
0.4602766931,
-0.0882375091,
-0.3471623063,
-0.0472018979,
-0.1393790394,
-0.2439160347,
-0.0803332254,
0.3353856504,
0.3282657862,
0.2747863829,
-0.0477655232,
-0.0433749445,
0.5680447221,
0.2170576155,
-0.4636854231,
0.1520877331,
0.3674850762,
-0.3130115867,
-0.1849324703,
-0.1760228574,
-0.7487899661,
-0.5396307707,
-0.1263076067,
0.3004082441,
-0.7690879703,
-0.5026512146,
0.24998869,
-0.0404531173,
0.2933064401,
0.6668229699,
-0.6024346948,
0.2439147681,
0.6795485616,
0.9032093287,
0.0101743639,
-0.4765453339,
0.022565864,
0.8594373465,
-0.5529536605,
0.650421977,
-0.7858704329,
-0.3468167186,
-0.245201394,
-0.0601409003,
0.037601985,
-0.0052428944,
-0.0036915143,
-0.4809074998,
0.4661676288,
-0.4167295098,
-0.6283861399,
-0.0192343835,
0.3555478752,
-0.3361942768,
0.507651329,
0.0715538561,
-0.3502153754,
0.486857295,
-0.9895913601,
-0.4377696216,
0.1191565022,
-0.4079356194,
0.0645551458,
0.2654882967,
0.3750592768,
0.4822572768,
-0.5148535371,
0.6223150492,
-0.8140645623,
-0.0965806469,
0.4596966207,
-0.3129502237,
0.7048432231,
0.5935356617,
-0.3765750825,
-0.1773751825,
-0.4406533837,
0.1992212385,
0.4775032997,
-0.2115178257,
-0.6452799439,
0.3615763485,
-0.3755705357,
0.3153814077,
0.2695320547,
-0.6969274879,
0.4618905187,
-0.3801680505,
0.7400083542,
0.8427286744,
0.2702399194,
0.413875252,
-0.4578778744,
0.3534341455,
0.1429679245,
0.3046678901,
-0.00009438,
-0.363016814,
-0.7712206244,
0.1224938184,
-0.2546237111,
0.338177979,
-0.8652994037,
0.494309485,
-0.2953641713,
-0.5064123869,
-0.3725035191,
-0.2528890073,
0.4850833714,
0.0921183527,
0.2870952189,
0.0822737888,
-0.375048697,
-0.5801551342,
-0.2530700564,
-0.5640053749,
-0.1121369451,
0.1104689464,
0.504381597,
-0.2359990627,
0.8603007197,
-0.9124925137,
-0.1487158686,
-0.1916963458,
-0.2078624517,
0.2195627689,
0.4465625286,
0.4203320146,
-0.5655626655,
0.2183072418,
0.0031370751,
-0.8313447833,
0.2737217247,
-0.1439199597,
-0.2202878296,
0.3294025064,
0.2678155303,
-0.6926304698,
0.5432693362,
0.2763058245,
-0.6129871011,
0.0878559351,
-0.236672014,
0.3541794121,
-1.5237975121,
-0.2138083875,
-0.0648110062,
0.0491368435,
-0.2672194242,
0.3380152285,
-0.0969345868,
-0.3475214839,
-0.021315895,
0.9166386127,
-0.3171623647,
0.0504360273,
0.090284884,
0.3844295442,
0.06066899,
0.9044280052,
0.1304194331,
0.5914825797,
0.1240262091,
-0.8072365522,
0.0805789456,
0.2089082301,
-0.3606590331,
0.7026389241,
-0.5535610318,
0.3568965495,
0.0204354525,
0.3739454448,
-1.0790925026,
-0.296002984,
0.081396088,
-0.4668821692,
0.1875186563,
0.1637270898,
-0.6693840623,
-0.3765109479,
0.180591166,
0.4473639727,
0.4856958985,
-0.5037468076,
0.7120496035,
0.5802100301,
0.016159365,
-0.2206979394,
-0.6951003671,
0.0156128835,
-0.1467972547,
-0.6211069822,
0.4135242701,
-0.2549762428,
-0.6474322677,
-0.0427072495,
-0.3650615215,
-0.1968385577,
0.0770114437,
-0.0140390554,
0.2626036108,
-0.1009094641,
0.4714175165,
0.3815683126,
-0.0877331048,
-0.0007236702,
-0.7560162544,
0.7133561969,
-0.2699418366,
-0.4171598256,
-0.111127615,
0.2477389574,
0.8314962387,
-0.0471308976,
0.7107997537,
0.0721640363,
-0.6338988543,
-0.4095275104,
-0.7351816893,
-0.0495521873,
-0.4668487608,
0.2683486044,
-0.566865027,
-0.9945335388,
0.2916662991,
-0.0643982515,
0.2925746143,
0.0839966238,
0.4833499491,
-0.2916520238,
0.9490219951,
0.5313940644,
-0.1290123761,
0.4202263057,
-0.0281980429,
0.3808201253,
-0.7053641081,
-0.271404326,
-0.1782959402,
-0.365436554,
-0.1934078038,
-0.7086256146,
0.5557428002,
-0.1584504843,
-0.2903705835,
0.4291309714,
-0.3841085434,
0.3393253386,
0.1830036789,
0.1664412022,
0.2817329466,
-0.0211346503,
-0.4842708111,
-0.010038089,
-0.6037528515,
-0.5378789306,
0.7471791506,
0.4682450593,
0.8015035987,
0.4381318688,
0.5035699606,
0.209854871,
-0.1478844285,
-0.5999672413,
0.8920230269,
0.0954214036,
-1.0786812305,
-0.4668475688,
-0.2398602217,
-0.7646256089,
0.3363996744,
-0.0833427459,
-0.889829278,
0.1616016179,
0.1818295419,
-0.4891358316,
0.5936200023,
-0.5655196905,
0.3954074085,
-0.3267137408,
-0.2791342735,
-0.7684567571,
-0.5752258897,
0.0796159953,
0.0753131956,
0.0494444296,
-0.1385873109,
-0.0271286946,
0.6991887689,
-0.4958167374,
0.7666141987,
-0.2038790286,
-0.45048365,
0.1939318776,
0.6095321178,
0.3141043186,
0.1400214434,
0.1718777865,
0.1313555241,
0.3711135387,
-0.363355279,
-1.0013990402,
0.4158100188,
-0.7443945408,
-0.8339545727,
-0.4768827856,
-0.7470867634,
-0.5567128062,
0.1386024952,
-0.0410415269,
0.579105258,
-0.1839692891,
0.0289660431,
0.845472455,
-0.3676979244,
0.3664804995,
0.5363153815,
-0.4676672816,
-0.446716249,
0.6152775288,
-0.0760274157,
0.2637611032,
0.8820445538,
0.2557130158,
-0.2487497628,
-0.1124060303,
0.3213034868,
0.4135158658,
-0.7114905119,
0.0678544119,
-0.5949780941,
-0.2028384358,
-0.3572917283,
-0.3007730246,
-0.3150008023,
-0.6339507699,
0.2657135129,
-0.0149066243,
0.1519943029,
0.6507488489,
0.2040748149,
0.3706136346,
-0.642758131,
0.3199248314,
0.3539217412,
0.3511916399,
0.0946537331,
-0.1616514027,
0.065045014,
0.0444442183,
-0.235582009,
-0.735224545,
0.269944787,
-0.316270411,
0.4434171319,
0.4748056829,
-0.1522788405,
1.1285587549,
-0.5094828606,
0.5865010023,
0.1429580599,
-1.1034730673,
0.811547935,
-0.6148716807,
0.4235183895,
0.0650474578,
0.0593304634,
-0.797586143,
-0.5780450702,
-0.7620170116,
-0.3884780407,
0.4415626526,
0.2966451347,
-0.4407496154,
-0.0648110658,
0.3557577431,
0.0272665117,
0.2882896066,
-0.5344096422,
0.0921025276,
-0.115245007,
-0.1562778205,
-0.2081430107,
-0.1406409144,
-0.2153368294,
-0.3376060128,
0.4683873355,
-0.1344011575,
0.6536175013,
0.3631899357,
0.0381227173,
-0.3770207465,
0.6628243327,
0.5123375058,
1.1152142286,
-0.2693017721,
0.1426017731,
0.2421850413,
-0.2669457495,
0.2867325544,
-0.3276518881,
0.1779547483,
-0.356954664,
0.528767705,
0.5948352218,
0.206633687,
-0.1478536129,
0.1573744565,
-0.0949088335,
-0.0553656109,
-0.5917594433,
0.3027804494,
-0.0402118899,
0.7212542892,
0.4770821631,
0.052945096,
-0.466365099,
-0.7429856658,
0.0470217615,
0.2436435521,
-0.0885607675,
-0.4631498158,
0.814789772,
0.2573628128,
-0.4643530548,
0.3198481202,
-0.1345210671,
-0.5441865921,
0.4263653457,
0.6277047396,
1.0039130449,
-0.283141315,
0.1261454076,
0.1482955217,
0.4931860566,
0.0614483058,
0.584118247,
-0.1036433056,
-1.1077208519,
-0.4433779716,
-0.5624189973,
-0.3356226683,
0.2412390858,
-0.4837861359,
-0.0787223876,
-1.0653330088,
-0.356408447,
-0.2579949498,
0.2688222229,
-0.54280442,
0.1885219216,
0.1489236951,
0.9610868096,
-0.3597671092,
1.2146135569,
0.6124123335,
-0.0965079591,
-0.7623054385,
0.3610115945,
0.2872608602,
-0.9173856378,
0.5912520885,
-0.087428689,
-0.4555394948,
-0.152507022,
-0.7233957648,
-0.961073041,
1.4150699377,
0.1820112914,
-0.8683239222,
-0.4732270539,
-0.3484586477,
0.6844473481,
-0.5384526253,
-0.2251458466,
0.3295068741,
0.3111577034,
0.0469218343,
-0.7458209395,
0.3097062111,
-0.3331902623,
0.3082539141,
0.4682177305,
-0.8624458909,
0.7428315282,
-0.3594332933,
-0.4637487233,
0.0751008317,
0.72857517,
0.7306740284,
0.2664186358,
0.6814692616,
0.4479573965,
0.909897387,
-0.1813390404,
1.0130292177,
-0.3004515469,
0.2640339136,
1.0420849323,
-0.5120872259,
0.5164805055,
0.5745769143,
-0.3176734447,
0.5501775742,
0.4690653384,
0.159052968,
0.3954358995,
-0.1026865542,
0.0340313166,
-0.5641159415,
0.0433525182,
-0.400704205,
0.1728860289,
0.780590713,
0.1524547487,
0.0396327972,
-0.1610670984,
0.2459658682,
-0.0334252976,
-0.0847348869,
0.3579052687,
0.2277671248,
-0.6155239344,
0.2824579477,
-0.1725206971,
0.3257434964,
-0.8407728672,
-0.1041704714,
-0.1211680397,
0.5629552007,
0.2831301093,
-0.8223919272,
0.037800137,
-0.2616584301,
0.0592423007,
-0.1782744825,
0.5519536734,
-0.3444365263,
-0.2968161106,
0.4930446744,
0.5341396332,
0.0035764056,
0.28491956,
-0.6349611878,
-0.0097532431,
-0.195453018,
-0.175998956,
-0.0030042736,
0.7743855715,
-0.0124378763,
1.1101522446,
0.3643703759,
0.3777346015,
-0.2778518498,
-0.0244929865,
0.7541558743,
-1.1949468851,
-0.7604178786,
-0.9545810819,
0.0068983422,
-0.232242167,
-0.3649446666,
0.5769007802,
-0.0486226529,
0.8681917787,
0.0822980329,
0.8085796833,
-0.347111702,
0.5250144601,
-0.8002935648,
0.7078664303,
-0.8132304549,
0.2910787165,
-0.6534599662,
-0.9347975254,
-0.1191230416,
0.7059221268,
-0.3833773434,
0.0736386329,
1.3511157036,
0.5399395823,
0.1761579365,
0.1815166026,
0.4975784123,
0.48236835,
0.6445583701,
1.1542198658,
1.0245008469,
-0.1203359962,
0.429099381,
-0.0965099037,
-0.2255027294,
0.1608207822,
-0.6856390834,
-1.3173353672,
-0.8850041032,
-0.0429200195,
-0.405937016,
0.1191680878,
1.3016121387,
0.5810325146,
-0.5637100935,
-0.4160938859,
0.0735108703,
0.113519609,
-0.2020572275,
-0.2497212887,
0.0080767153,
-0.1677983105,
-0.5267168283,
0.4654203057,
0.6538646817,
0.188714698,
-0.4083987772,
-0.0828311294,
-0.2942769527,
0.2244554758,
0.7244355679,
0.0148194358,
-1.0678753853,
-0.6802031398,
0.0646712035,
0.1040682644,
-0.051024776,
1.1938996315,
-0.5422230959,
0.3290011585,
0.2718462646,
0.4517158568,
0.3850157559,
-0.3345139325,
0.9723289013,
-0.5746843219,
0.1953925639,
0.1692681611,
0.6280761361,
-0.0389275216,
-0.444472611,
0.7496435642,
0.4740864635,
-0.3611313999,
-0.6918590069,
0.6775860786,
-0.8897910714,
-0.8134972453,
0.9996697307,
0.1229941994,
-0.5116356015,
-0.1496836096,
-0.0461368412,
0.4243112803,
-0.5647284985,
1.0093457699,
0.947358489,
-0.0376245305,
-0.0001744598,
-0.1543486565,
0.3012534976,
0.4722336233,
-0.9109888673,
0.096219562,
0.3814114034,
0.1920850277,
0.5726447105,
0.7658799291,
-0.3315312266,
-0.0156948511,
-0.0533822104,
-0.2191698998,
-0.0201162659,
-0.6847305894,
-0.1014529765,
0.1556836516,
-0.1820511669,
0.0421561897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01437v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01437v1 | Needle in the Haystack for Memory Based Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T16:32:16 | 2024-07-01T16:32:16 | Subhajit Chaudhury, Soham Dan, Payel Das, Georgios Kollias, Elliot Nelson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we demonstrate the benefits of using memory augmented Large
Language Model (LLM) architecture in improving the recall abilities of facts
from a potentially long context. As a case study we test LARIMAR, a recently
proposed LLM architecture which augments a LLM decoder with an external
associative memory, on several long-context recall tasks, including passkey and
needle-in-the-haystack tests. We demonstrate that the external memory can be
adapted at test time to handle contexts much longer than those seen during
training, while keeping readouts from the memory recognizable to the trained
decoder and without increasing GPU memory footprint. Compared to alternative
architectures for long-context recall tasks with models of a comparable
parameter count, LARIMAR is able to maintain strong performance without any
task-specific training. | [
-0.0329768658,
-0.735055387,
0.7707377672,
-0.1835062355,
-0.2044103891,
-0.1109770909,
-0.3390058577,
-0.7872502804,
0.2644637823,
0.4374838769,
0.1277099103,
-0.1439229995,
-0.3778191209,
-0.1016788185,
-0.6406111717,
0.7670642734,
-0.302462846,
-0.0994658992,
-0.2058411092,
-0.3224011958,
-0.5628647208,
-0.9398919344,
-0.8385261297,
-0.1813939214,
0.5220459104,
0.0684086308,
0.2276886553,
0.6604803801,
0.3320336044,
0.2854733467,
-0.3433041275,
0.2999185622,
-0.4776040614,
0.0247923378,
-0.2242551744,
-0.5051747561,
-0.4858606756,
-0.3886917233,
0.882450819,
0.4781269729,
-0.3704696894,
0.0179849081,
-0.0823934451,
0.5670440197,
-0.7417297363,
0.1325363666,
-0.7772613764,
-0.265176326,
-0.1231252253,
-0.2211949527,
-0.5661486983,
-0.0137544386,
-0.0292741228,
-0.2373389751,
-0.0093481448,
0.1307168603,
0.4684258997,
0.1427873075,
-0.3766011596,
-0.4700267315,
-0.6929504871,
0.6571891904,
-0.6981181502,
0.4451989233,
0.4756011665,
0.2501541972,
-0.1863567233,
-0.5173318982,
-0.4626509845,
-0.1996807456,
-0.1172965616,
-0.0955635458,
0.1131416932,
-0.0406449959,
0.268778801,
0.4123294055,
-0.1611123383,
-0.0162233785,
-0.3992753029,
-0.1639641374,
0.2726241052,
0.2879152596,
0.1823585629,
0.1214560941,
-0.3424680829,
0.166986689,
-0.9384350181,
0.1770594418,
-0.1083685458,
0.3667691648,
0.052333612,
0.5857924819,
-0.0488771945,
0.7999142408,
0.0715344325,
-0.1442866772,
0.1824267507,
-0.283593595,
-0.1849696934,
0.4650119841,
0.1928908825,
-0.0773071051,
-0.0018870049,
-0.2259022444,
-0.4448926747,
-0.0378995501,
0.2585769892,
-0.9141090512,
-0.0362153761,
0.1218834519,
-0.3143679202,
0.4203744829,
-0.1746861637,
-0.3846814036,
-0.4183876514,
-0.0641271546,
0.6327414513,
-0.5851536989,
0.0847616345,
0.3529438674,
0.0040693497,
0.3119231761,
0.4742287099,
-0.8417231441,
0.3419839144,
0.8749096394,
0.9850139618,
-0.3112819791,
-0.2566055059,
-0.935886085,
0.4661775529,
-0.4024116099,
0.920222044,
-0.6211039424,
-0.2580654919,
0.1324343532,
0.1646434963,
-0.0339573659,
-0.7326930165,
0.2650189698,
-0.8815097213,
0.0315212756,
-0.3745751679,
-0.745414257,
-0.4223290384,
0.2794917822,
-0.8636215925,
1.0115163326,
0.1295754015,
-0.5837676525,
0.2145010531,
-0.5465605855,
-0.601485312,
-0.1009641364,
-0.1350584179,
-0.1882661134,
0.333712399,
0.169065997,
0.4835638702,
-0.1376424283,
0.0648779422,
-0.1558121443,
-1.0375876427,
0.2777562141,
-0.2877192795,
0.4967126846,
-0.1651850194,
-0.1474498659,
0.0460904762,
-0.7577616572,
-0.3483096361,
0.0319887064,
-0.9398791194,
-0.6591377258,
0.038405668,
-0.1415679157,
-0.0267451443,
0.4760184288,
-0.4891089499,
0.1736084819,
-0.4223500788,
0.1833349913,
0.8433035016,
-0.0986671224,
0.3346022666,
-0.3773423135,
0.1385822743,
0.1766409576,
-0.4273632467,
-0.559427321,
-0.0276604071,
-1.0788581371,
-0.5464517474,
0.0716065615,
0.5451592207,
-0.5987755656,
0.1814167947,
-0.2092173398,
0.0169955324,
-0.3275437355,
0.2548745871,
0.2366180569,
0.4669465721,
0.2115871906,
-0.2377288043,
-0.6909005642,
-0.7037864923,
-0.0491201878,
-0.1959881335,
0.0132987397,
0.4601836503,
0.4644833207,
-0.250204742,
0.5395953655,
-0.3591398597,
-0.3354884386,
-0.2144347876,
-0.305375278,
0.5709041953,
0.0385045782,
0.2965779006,
-0.4778906107,
-0.2239562869,
0.0052406853,
-0.6172926426,
0.3263235092,
-0.1796168983,
0.099101916,
0.6834696531,
0.709487319,
-0.9118221998,
0.2252319008,
0.4226612747,
-0.5552901626,
0.2962572277,
-0.5205024481,
0.2381994128,
-0.9620120525,
0.2725988925,
-0.4468638897,
-0.2581800818,
-0.5609665513,
0.1185626686,
0.3396496773,
0.2395083755,
-0.6969578862,
0.9490036964,
-0.5533992648,
-0.2287745178,
-0.4514335394,
-0.1131307706,
-0.0967748463,
0.3476615548,
0.2256518751,
1.3549358845,
0.4191550612,
-0.7765411139,
0.3218273818,
0.1466627717,
-0.7429472804,
0.4274688959,
-0.4011540711,
0.2772983313,
-0.2674500346,
0.3339493871,
-0.8001996875,
-0.192962423,
-0.1214304864,
-0.0802568868,
0.4213782549,
0.1579629183,
-0.5013011098,
-0.1359639019,
-0.2261445969,
0.5923639536,
0.6226623058,
-1.0824517012,
0.7564952374,
0.3384951055,
0.0187506936,
-0.4429635704,
-0.5479286909,
0.129828468,
-0.5428035855,
-0.25373137,
0.1924809664,
-0.1609358937,
-0.3016958833,
-0.2638840377,
0.1196628436,
-0.1364820898,
0.010784247,
0.2227797806,
0.272985518,
-0.4326682091,
0.5945549011,
-0.5161790848,
0.0935732126,
-0.0810945556,
0.1062903255,
0.6549561024,
-0.3555586338,
-0.2318417877,
-0.0965366811,
0.4129338562,
0.4503608346,
-0.0741316453,
0.9908053875,
0.2041453421,
-0.3262924552,
-0.1281113476,
-0.7705690861,
-0.028854927,
-0.4858726263,
0.7504915595,
-0.4044779837,
-1.0667552948,
0.7563231587,
0.005031873,
-0.130171895,
0.1524326205,
0.6814587712,
-0.0191737209,
0.627381742,
0.4279590845,
-0.3986930549,
0.5177928209,
0.0445483625,
0.0842031538,
-1.2078692913,
0.0259035528,
-0.0233766213,
-0.1380393505,
-0.0067438413,
-0.7450621724,
0.3540242016,
0.1567320228,
-0.4327621758,
0.1385140568,
-0.1490632594,
0.5566469431,
0.4603108168,
0.1551954597,
0.3873233497,
-0.0903760791,
0.0261767451,
0.2835313678,
-0.6885980368,
-0.1848451346,
1.0050792694,
0.4402628541,
0.8018228412,
0.1046835482,
0.5644087791,
-0.0021603126,
0.2579265535,
-0.9414004087,
0.7445152402,
-0.2434260398,
-0.5136569738,
-0.1925083846,
-0.1030938178,
-0.8045205474,
0.2422282249,
0.0319334827,
-0.7134167552,
-0.0413058922,
0.2539388239,
-0.5503247976,
0.5262659788,
-0.4749405682,
0.3297230899,
-0.4422627389,
-0.5078496933,
-0.3105874062,
0.0056362492,
0.5335233808,
-0.3081846535,
0.0754083097,
0.1611847281,
-0.3393936157,
0.6838549972,
-0.1498289406,
0.8712229133,
-0.0590812862,
-0.2383509576,
0.4225190282,
0.0703288615,
0.9339926243,
-0.1876240522,
-0.3875927925,
0.1638393551,
0.0489673913,
-0.1750864685,
-0.4388403893,
0.817030251,
-0.4500802159,
-0.7978895307,
-0.4773149192,
-0.8702669144,
-0.2669922411,
-0.06197365,
-0.3627701998,
0.4354744256,
-0.1330261081,
0.3843794167,
0.7592368126,
-0.3693070412,
0.5577434897,
0.4946809411,
-0.151602596,
-0.2342508435,
0.670029521,
-0.0664536953,
0.2063625455,
0.4584416151,
0.1619641036,
-0.1735613644,
-0.7415717244,
-0.2288406044,
0.2085999101,
-0.9034285545,
-0.2417362034,
-0.6195302606,
-0.4094662666,
-0.0208394341,
-0.0737431347,
-0.383538574,
-0.1566312611,
-0.3242451549,
0.0199492518,
0.8412469625,
0.6322097182,
0.0675820261,
0.407920599,
-0.7280956507,
0.3512042165,
0.2861204445,
0.5541769266,
0.2177151591,
-0.6957957745,
-0.5433659554,
-0.1539371461,
0.3527306616,
-0.294244498,
0.2594034374,
0.2117358297,
0.3782724738,
0.2740328908,
-0.2715313137,
0.9861055017,
-0.9074316621,
0.5860985518,
-0.0190377086,
-0.65524894,
0.1907818764,
-0.357845664,
0.664136529,
0.43229267,
0.0048093889,
-0.4762233496,
-0.1390631646,
-0.051244881,
-0.7863280773,
0.4915572107,
-0.4604799449,
0.3028696775,
-0.2990618944,
0.6174864173,
0.1071741506,
-0.069485642,
-0.5135449767,
0.2331291139,
0.2077535689,
-0.226881057,
-0.3206380904,
-0.6545228362,
-0.0348186344,
-0.3070412576,
0.5202887654,
-0.0633498654,
0.3347534537,
0.0228720494,
-0.2117885351,
0.1261974871,
0.3756795526,
0.7099452019,
0.7489413023,
-0.4239586592,
0.4134021997,
0.6387543678,
-0.4881515801,
-0.0095902067,
-0.1481041759,
-0.0605056211,
-0.2005343884,
0.4804307222,
0.7855454683,
0.5356672406,
-1.0893754959,
0.3380234838,
0.1122674793,
0.0771903396,
-0.5496019721,
0.2754122317,
0.4703612626,
0.5330321193,
0.3763749599,
-0.4442199171,
0.0953051373,
-0.8035297394,
0.348290801,
0.7730031013,
-0.2934606075,
-0.1760995388,
0.27275002,
-0.0489383042,
-0.2625449002,
0.5027219653,
0.0883272812,
-0.4336857498,
0.4210813046,
0.9640399814,
0.3683826327,
-0.2593129873,
-0.3655655682,
0.3580181301,
0.0867648795,
-0.4401759207,
0.2222962528,
-0.0650457293,
-0.5865501165,
-0.5154040456,
-0.7690863013,
-0.0808238387,
0.3318156302,
-0.3123142123,
0.037716046,
-0.4282650948,
0.1204731017,
-0.5253314972,
-0.0063322945,
-0.5368326902,
0.075456202,
0.0046525765,
1.0313745737,
-0.3755686581,
1.2162640095,
0.3359605968,
0.045852337,
-0.4622412622,
-0.2094535232,
-0.2472422421,
-1.1156592369,
0.862626195,
0.2721914053,
-0.2956404686,
-0.3458031714,
-0.099846147,
-1.204842329,
1.1400738955,
0.2317891121,
-0.6874577403,
-0.1178435162,
-0.1390066892,
0.5085930824,
-0.471255362,
0.0536902472,
0.5856307745,
0.1626477689,
0.4216275215,
-0.889644444,
0.2363429219,
-0.0352094248,
-0.081644468,
0.3868780136,
-0.5676457882,
0.9958027601,
-0.3689906299,
-0.3062330484,
0.3956872523,
0.7762059569,
0.5332075953,
0.1046900749,
0.4305980206,
0.4658503234,
0.6986076236,
0.4033986032,
1.2070277929,
-0.1540741175,
-0.093186073,
1.5365601778,
-0.4541282356,
1.5269093513,
0.7799383998,
-0.0341830291,
0.4568989277,
0.3860995471,
0.2279162407,
0.5909398794,
0.0668382496,
-0.4531391859,
-0.3642521501,
-0.1210674047,
-0.3305406272,
0.6880803108,
0.4274542034,
-0.4628514349,
-0.1331784874,
-0.0584904701,
-0.1127216592,
0.0059716688,
-0.5573316813,
0.7385224104,
0.2208643407,
-0.5258051753,
0.7395762205,
-0.138386026,
0.869643569,
-0.5842251182,
-0.2668038309,
-0.0601814985,
0.7719799876,
0.1851927489,
-0.5969670415,
0.4153451025,
-0.2958806455,
-0.1846413165,
0.0094928779,
0.7364239097,
-0.6367887259,
-0.68364048,
0.4232003987,
0.2123098671,
0.0644445941,
0.0207635183,
-0.2193337381,
0.2927651107,
-0.3652656376,
-0.3338843286,
0.4578777254,
0.1489858478,
-0.125569284,
0.6110474467,
0.5363531709,
0.2802095413,
-0.0690620095,
-0.1860329956,
0.7284633517,
-1.0020831823,
-0.4242646396,
-1.0781238079,
0.1461924016,
0.1570305526,
0.1840554774,
0.7759254575,
0.7848931551,
0.5776746869,
-0.0592742078,
0.4442655146,
0.3252305686,
0.7985162735,
-0.854870379,
0.6679041982,
-0.4758524299,
0.3264983594,
0.2267857492,
-0.6750626564,
-0.217017591,
0.5871806741,
-0.2413608432,
0.0740508735,
0.742028594,
0.7158638239,
-0.238259986,
-0.3402516246,
0.4123063087,
0.4640270174,
0.1763613075,
1.1544514894,
0.9007700086,
-0.3938118219,
0.2627298236,
0.2276292443,
-0.0141846901,
-0.3464124501,
-0.8508402705,
-1.2943657637,
-0.5451378226,
0.1374786496,
-0.3418133855,
0.2065431774,
0.702768147,
0.5022244453,
-0.7390726209,
-0.4820298553,
0.2718524635,
0.0123998635,
0.0493418686,
-0.1567076147,
0.7138810158,
-0.1186230108,
-0.4210614562,
0.5560131073,
0.5339983106,
0.0018772684,
-0.1960178167,
-0.1695619524,
-0.4426536858,
0.2819319665,
0.9218552113,
0.2954357862,
-0.7382329106,
-0.7627321482,
0.0461034104,
0.0538052432,
0.2859148085,
0.7123856544,
-1.1740146875,
0.317553401,
0.3621492088,
0.9098497629,
0.5737738013,
-0.0700319111,
0.49583444,
-0.2990175188,
0.4245766699,
-0.0319510512,
0.5242424607,
0.475312531,
-0.5659641027,
0.2769367695,
-0.3391339779,
-0.2836643457,
-0.8091472387,
0.025621675,
-0.8570435643,
-0.4622186422,
1.2978440523,
0.0277099237,
-0.6049680114,
-0.0899057612,
-0.2061163485,
-0.0162779056,
-0.2403605282,
0.956227541,
0.7257748842,
-0.1841880083,
-0.2775809765,
-0.6419876814,
0.4749833047,
0.2817178965,
-0.9706853628,
0.2702866495,
0.5647654533,
0.3420190513,
0.0688882545,
0.7897159457,
0.0352240391,
0.3644662797,
-0.1498013288,
-0.1849146783,
-0.1609903127,
-0.3864088356,
-0.4384587705,
0.1226729527,
0.0853991061,
-0.1062820554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01424v1 | A Global-Local Attention Mechanism for Relation Classification | 2024-07-01T16:14:25 | 2024-07-01T16:14:25 | Yiping Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Relation classification, a crucial component of relation extraction, involves
identifying connections between two entities. Previous studies have
predominantly focused on integrating the attention mechanism into relation
classification at a global scale, overlooking the importance of the local
context. To address this gap, this paper introduces a novel global-local
attention mechanism for relation classification, which enhances global
attention with a localized focus. Additionally, we propose innovative hard and
soft localization mechanisms to identify potential keywords for local
attention. By incorporating both hard and soft localization strategies, our
approach offers a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding of the
contextual cues that contribute to effective relation classification. Our
experimental results on the SemEval-2010 Task 8 dataset highlight the superior
performance of our method compared to previous attention-based approaches in
relation classification. | [
-0.4246713221,
-0.6327872276,
0.5221915841,
-0.0645411983,
-0.2666910887,
-0.3768161535,
-0.3394315243,
-0.5918782949,
0.0890377238,
0.4412747025,
-0.6538872123,
-0.2195193768,
-0.141520828,
0.0750831664,
0.235602513,
1.3374727964,
-0.1551407725,
-0.2410918921,
-0.4337296784,
-0.3293447495,
-0.2614600658,
-0.8714259863,
-0.6449882984,
-0.2475961596,
1.0291492939,
0.2600949705,
0.6831119061,
0.5362401605,
0.8496483564,
0.2505299151,
-0.2568391562,
0.2144543976,
-0.3940337598,
0.2655387521,
-0.4379002452,
-0.638944447,
-0.650631845,
-0.0685845241,
0.4386447668,
0.8141226768,
0.0771446601,
0.3765657544,
0.0679790303,
0.4999446869,
-0.9026457667,
0.4341764748,
-0.6088244319,
0.0468934551,
-0.3965935409,
-0.1650627404,
-0.1607857943,
-0.0320475698,
0.2615688741,
-0.3124434054,
0.8319818377,
-0.3561840057,
1.0157741308,
0.0346278064,
-0.8855863214,
0.053621076,
-0.8381470442,
0.3985444903,
-0.0247274172,
0.4265435934,
0.1137981415,
0.2905869484,
0.0729089975,
-0.5205495358,
-0.0980929285,
0.1232671365,
-0.2390837371,
0.1023107022,
0.2577891946,
0.0659129545,
0.2488534003,
0.6620733738,
-0.0877991095,
-0.4568980336,
-0.3501569629,
-0.1086689457,
0.2995836139,
-0.0662076175,
0.3259584904,
-0.2108146846,
-0.4682508707,
0.5837939382,
-0.7952474356,
0.1518012881,
-0.2336218506,
0.7590497136,
-0.2861053646,
0.0712585002,
-0.2552011013,
0.4362183511,
0.1151631698,
-0.132973507,
0.2868492305,
-0.3632313609,
-0.1242704242,
0.3134061396,
0.6690759659,
0.2076900154,
0.31992504,
-0.5559775233,
0.123781845,
0.3741995394,
0.042826429,
-0.5137010217,
0.1543264091,
-0.0401407219,
-0.2932822406,
-0.4675162435,
0.0712061524,
-0.4434311688,
-0.0888346732,
-0.3337212801,
0.1542103887,
0.1304675788,
-0.6008625627,
-0.3989602327,
0.2638434768,
0.3833112121,
0.1666897833,
-1.01813519,
0.4389126897,
0.8022598028,
0.8847697973,
-0.1456997246,
0.0074335653,
-0.8579921126,
0.5055903196,
-0.0549944714,
1.0445715189,
-0.4498167634,
0.1119039208,
0.0490911826,
0.2305435538,
-0.0296219643,
-0.4767187834,
0.5626091361,
-0.7119905353,
0.2841844261,
-0.3136331141,
-0.0493200272,
-0.3110194802,
0.2122108191,
-0.820299685,
0.8305485249,
0.2561038435,
-1.0177842379,
0.3539712727,
-0.5073200464,
-0.7610977292,
0.1007859632,
-0.2150942981,
-0.4249474406,
0.1172625497,
0.4607660472,
0.7512213588,
-0.4019836783,
0.2252128124,
-0.5887529254,
-0.2104282975,
0.1456307173,
-0.1253982335,
0.5398426056,
0.1737176329,
-0.3240189552,
0.0848155916,
-0.5439360738,
-0.481764853,
0.1300315559,
-0.0195136629,
-0.7150370479,
-0.2323664427,
-0.3044552803,
0.3759242594,
0.2508537173,
-0.2241991907,
0.3936497271,
-1.0305095911,
0.42099756,
0.2554387748,
0.5205812454,
1.0985931158,
0.2238179296,
0.4404337108,
0.2007212937,
0.1401450336,
-0.274941206,
-0.2893880904,
-0.6500442028,
-0.0308520645,
0.551881671,
0.4951232374,
-0.336050719,
0.1186502427,
-0.5537099838,
-0.2045158595,
-0.2405752093,
0.4620867968,
0.4150410593,
0.5359847546,
-0.1273246557,
-0.3178274035,
-0.2229398042,
-0.8994828463,
-0.1516608447,
0.1943955719,
-0.1289583892,
0.5384375453,
0.1556617022,
-0.1310242265,
0.8193192482,
-0.5564807653,
-0.8484615088,
-0.1723285168,
0.0799096599,
0.3914331794,
-0.0074375225,
0.4795638621,
-1.148733139,
-0.4073139131,
0.3801431954,
-0.8824720383,
0.2073944211,
-0.1455197036,
-0.4583266079,
-0.0735679045,
0.6166152954,
-0.8664575815,
0.352449894,
-0.3153816462,
-0.1143198833,
-0.0688862875,
0.0509744212,
-0.0425632671,
-0.8900314569,
-0.0737329647,
0.1361200511,
-0.2300026864,
-0.641880393,
0.4003979266,
0.290455699,
-0.1705792695,
-0.6559499502,
0.5946335793,
-0.9175006747,
-0.1013477966,
0.0869380459,
0.3915997148,
-0.0250718668,
0.9161566496,
0.1078279391,
0.352778703,
0.5573620796,
-0.5668408275,
0.527060926,
0.2206683457,
0.1259597242,
0.6857793927,
-0.1078193039,
0.4202639759,
-0.224762097,
0.0257127862,
-0.9720090628,
-0.3242324293,
0.3992161453,
-0.4393441379,
0.6771699786,
-0.5654391646,
-0.2746190727,
-0.2405432463,
-0.4427554309,
0.4684686065,
-0.0179016963,
-0.5635049939,
0.7874475121,
0.4836916029,
-0.281479001,
-0.1745670289,
-0.2437256128,
-0.228239879,
-0.4729087055,
-0.6008425951,
0.4083682597,
0.6324207187,
-0.2243550271,
0.1276358366,
-0.5305073857,
-0.3262007535,
0.0697937831,
0.316280961,
0.0990944356,
-0.2083650827,
0.3917852938,
-0.1956500411,
-0.4577084482,
0.2310940921,
0.1294490695,
0.0319898091,
-0.0323169231,
0.2719815373,
-0.1449135691,
0.4434625804,
0.7719386816,
-0.7190840244,
0.4631399214,
0.6981762052,
-0.5512907505,
-0.0250701811,
-0.6181272864,
-0.3180902302,
-0.4949454069,
0.283767134,
-0.5878269076,
-0.7044274807,
0.5713202953,
-0.3401055038,
-0.3808449209,
0.1451474726,
0.2202719748,
0.1177397072,
1.1137685776,
0.6140236259,
-0.5246393085,
0.3202669024,
-0.1856240481,
0.4902890027,
-1.2033382654,
-0.2431531996,
-0.5776562095,
-0.2660661638,
-0.4388633966,
-0.2737050653,
0.2836178243,
0.4831387699,
-0.0457305238,
0.1782937646,
-0.8736137152,
0.5639966726,
0.405069083,
0.0925854146,
0.1804550439,
0.2293218076,
0.0063462467,
-0.479146421,
-0.5505198836,
-0.0896868408,
0.6778874993,
0.25984326,
0.5981946588,
0.0671312883,
0.7204810977,
-0.0679057688,
0.7525421381,
-0.8626095057,
0.5135113001,
0.0638018399,
-0.5861281753,
-0.0118380086,
-0.5249692202,
-1.2276265621,
0.2888819277,
0.1437304765,
-0.9993466735,
0.2381872535,
0.0335440934,
-0.3889629543,
0.0048819999,
-0.9254069328,
1.0870839357,
-0.227005139,
-0.532784462,
0.1610086262,
-0.6895285845,
0.3392618001,
0.1272034347,
0.6293203831,
-0.2817189693,
-0.1774743646,
0.4928493202,
-0.0613301247,
0.6307842135,
-0.3352794349,
-0.2113197446,
0.1563515961,
0.0563762523,
0.513743937,
0.2219551206,
0.3454086483,
0.0088730343,
-0.687289834,
0.091567494,
-0.9296876788,
0.8414466381,
-0.413382709,
-0.5538835526,
-0.4199889898,
-0.2763485014,
-0.3697218001,
0.2010420859,
0.140100345,
0.6600096822,
0.138327986,
0.0497131906,
0.5460004807,
0.3153574169,
0.1683189273,
0.4134560227,
-0.1716007143,
-0.5247085094,
0.9804622531,
0.2012212127,
-0.103005223,
0.6554628015,
0.0009949334,
-0.4527032077,
0.0299657993,
0.1579514891,
0.5908558965,
-0.6742478013,
-0.5076824427,
-0.4770740271,
-0.2710925639,
-0.6315381527,
-0.0443265326,
-0.0305519532,
-0.1009679958,
-0.1799979061,
-0.0588709153,
0.2422339767,
0.3696744144,
0.0825888515,
-0.0252117142,
-0.8012837768,
0.6693176031,
0.5357732177,
0.2802291512,
0.1033682749,
-0.317784518,
-0.0605315268,
-0.6080424786,
-0.2906524241,
-1.2928031683,
0.1700974554,
0.3211407065,
0.4403581023,
0.7625715137,
0.1910170615,
0.5774306059,
-0.5655670762,
0.2195901424,
0.122615777,
-0.6775546074,
1.227263093,
-0.6007998586,
0.5969765782,
0.525054574,
0.6414887309,
-0.3890641928,
-0.4048011303,
-0.8005997539,
-1.2180862427,
0.9480118752,
0.2144283354,
0.1926184446,
-0.0594034716,
0.9002609849,
-0.3899916112,
0.0969312638,
-0.8749073744,
-0.2677299976,
0.7076247334,
-0.0210541189,
0.3173371851,
-0.3291355669,
-0.0086476505,
-0.3609109223,
0.4510897994,
-0.0712632611,
0.3517538607,
0.6239456534,
-0.1456582844,
-0.2745969296,
0.1970774382,
0.1411532164,
0.4628253579,
-0.2794993222,
0.2242726684,
0.3140511811,
-0.3047080934,
0.0853274912,
0.1078952327,
-0.3447652161,
0.0260442048,
0.4444724619,
0.5535581708,
0.6950111985,
0.2576311231,
0.617829442,
-0.0903506652,
-0.0929130614,
0.0360949188,
0.0793961957,
0.3283568621,
0.1174090207,
0.2510169148,
0.1015518457,
0.4711166918,
-0.6280217767,
0.2462322116,
0.2955084741,
-0.6936267614,
-0.3478079438,
0.7057070732,
0.518627584,
-0.5035610795,
0.2832919955,
-0.4324398935,
-0.7957163453,
0.4553493559,
0.249657765,
0.7744050622,
-0.5491815805,
0.0306630339,
0.5388176441,
0.0032488341,
0.3151705265,
0.0375691541,
-0.7387898564,
-0.6304575801,
-0.578292191,
-0.4017526209,
-0.3446903825,
0.4107905328,
-0.9946243167,
0.3202376664,
-0.2373579144,
-0.2331364602,
0.1734968573,
0.0347564146,
-0.662101984,
0.1967859715,
0.4933627546,
0.429861486,
-0.6403630376,
0.6495050192,
1.0417954922,
-0.2033932656,
-0.6549717188,
0.0022664126,
-0.1297068447,
-0.181311816,
0.7483336926,
0.8674044609,
-0.1804664135,
-0.3614458144,
-0.4397104383,
-0.8466533422,
0.5558659434,
0.4920417666,
-0.5264149308,
-0.1530397385,
-0.0501558334,
0.2152940631,
-0.2228440046,
0.0762883797,
0.6078981757,
0.0414900221,
-0.1647310704,
-0.7305056453,
0.2876222134,
-0.4017741084,
0.0919663385,
0.6470094323,
-0.8257314563,
0.304854393,
-0.2649492919,
-0.4775831103,
-0.6231979132,
0.8911643028,
-0.0980349183,
0.2133121789,
0.5714642406,
0.3530550599,
0.5844053626,
-0.3090617955,
0.7783187032,
-0.1010139063,
0.4554235339,
1.4078831673,
-0.6328826547,
0.8461717367,
0.3731197715,
-0.3407423198,
0.4495684505,
0.6344528794,
0.0959222764,
0.8989927769,
-0.1615373045,
-0.5956004858,
-0.3790409565,
-0.14668262,
-0.3240998387,
0.2232576609,
0.3212673366,
-0.1070264801,
-0.3292850852,
0.1347615421,
0.0028622451,
0.0232447889,
-0.5474559665,
0.9252966046,
0.228115201,
-0.7506754398,
0.2514462769,
-0.3743241429,
0.5469599366,
-0.4122397602,
-0.0342176296,
-0.2635307908,
0.5515399575,
-0.1905699968,
-0.3264963031,
0.2240278721,
-0.1556899846,
-0.3460089266,
0.0590991527,
1.2092075348,
-0.5114316344,
-0.2562694848,
0.5502559543,
0.1007623598,
-0.1468098015,
-0.5690616965,
-0.53217417,
-0.1566419005,
-0.1035876051,
-0.3402675092,
0.3321982622,
1.0736238956,
-0.09061452,
0.4412643611,
0.5585603714,
0.0297012441,
-0.3768190742,
0.223363623,
0.6207882762,
-0.7823455334,
-0.7475277781,
-0.8425737023,
0.3277388811,
-0.2572830915,
-0.3858828545,
0.667817235,
0.3313393593,
0.716599524,
0.0481781363,
0.3912798166,
0.3179125786,
0.4321337938,
-0.0129423197,
0.37619102,
-0.4591654539,
0.0070709055,
-0.225053072,
-1.0525144339,
-0.6923741698,
0.790566504,
-0.671523571,
0.0244453903,
0.8399450779,
0.5196246505,
-0.2473592758,
-0.29519853,
-0.0192493666,
0.1677233875,
0.0257789586,
0.8203642964,
0.6465550065,
-0.5159168243,
1.0721764565,
-0.3852238357,
-0.207717374,
-0.0597586669,
-0.7022461891,
-1.0470660925,
-0.4599895477,
-0.6151883602,
-0.1857059449,
-0.0842384025,
0.5663869381,
0.7656206489,
-0.717106998,
0.1192704588,
-0.0833195224,
0.2275883555,
-0.0792750716,
-0.3799984157,
0.4751970172,
-0.6667436361,
-0.3554619849,
-0.0203708876,
0.7146795392,
-0.2184258699,
0.0052678371,
0.1730843037,
-0.0928263143,
-0.5335298181,
0.4857185483,
0.1656533629,
-0.6029651165,
0.0645472929,
-0.2252876163,
-0.1645622551,
0.3632605374,
0.9249811172,
-0.7099234462,
0.2506500483,
0.3692081869,
0.2759449482,
0.7579624057,
-0.0416949727,
0.6786264181,
-1.1611322165,
0.3651479185,
0.1225296929,
0.2804619074,
0.5405693054,
-0.8524490595,
0.8803927898,
0.2760961354,
-0.5965256095,
-0.9482229352,
0.045279175,
-0.8787612319,
0.1701594591,
1.0512207747,
-0.1097644866,
-0.7122502327,
-0.3005647957,
-0.4266554117,
0.4277825058,
-0.2993574739,
0.5381703377,
0.4622944891,
-0.10353522,
-0.2449231595,
-0.4781556427,
0.5243713856,
0.2345454693,
-0.8986537457,
0.2696132064,
0.1226361096,
0.1488951445,
0.6936541796,
0.765591383,
-0.1391758174,
0.5790545344,
-0.3567851484,
-0.1558047235,
0.4475755095,
-0.4181717336,
-0.4070936441,
0.5470701456,
-0.1859634668,
-0.0436682627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01411v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01411v2 | HyperLoader: Integrating Hypernetwork-Based LoRA and Adapter Layers into Multi-Task Transformers for Sequence Labelling | 2024-07-01T16:00:53 | 2024-07-02T06:21:41 | Jesus-German Ortiz-Barajas, Helena Gomez-Adorno, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present HyperLoader, a simple approach that combines different
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods in a multi-task setting. To achieve
this goal, our model uses a hypernetwork to generate the weights of these
modules based on the task, the transformer layer, and its position within this
layer. Our method combines the benefits of multi-task learning by capturing the
structure of all tasks while reducing the task interference problem by
encapsulating the task-specific knowledge in the generated weights and the
benefits of combining different parameter-efficient methods to outperform
full-fine tuning. We provide empirical evidence that HyperLoader outperforms
previous approaches in most datasets and obtains the best average performance
across tasks in high-resource and low-resource scenarios. | [
-0.4653908014,
-0.5342532992,
0.1076114625,
0.2052897066,
-0.2292150855,
-0.414644599,
-0.0935814232,
-0.5426830053,
0.1621101499,
0.6648021936,
-0.4513346255,
-0.2098435611,
-0.742249608,
-0.0085995207,
-0.4933630824,
1.1722358465,
0.1095069498,
-0.3872271776,
-0.1475595832,
-0.3288353086,
-0.4605786204,
-0.3710082471,
-0.5247365832,
-0.8302214742,
1.0226720572,
0.6420305371,
0.7089061737,
1.1295499802,
0.671743989,
0.3809120655,
-0.1116361693,
0.4915209413,
-0.3562896252,
0.1778847575,
-0.278486222,
-0.427482307,
-0.5321083069,
-0.112118341,
0.4534597695,
0.5370293856,
0.0095138997,
0.8137000203,
0.2542207241,
0.8119397759,
-1.1119527817,
0.1769142747,
-0.3072485626,
0.2844047248,
-0.342941165,
-0.2718702555,
-0.5769321322,
0.0182315204,
0.1117931008,
-0.8577341437,
0.2045990825,
0.2419882119,
0.6958197355,
0.7704249024,
-0.4455180466,
0.2312038839,
-1.0982335806,
0.9061837792,
-0.4586461782,
0.1800699681,
0.2989550829,
0.4088489413,
0.1948508173,
-0.7858216166,
-0.4139792919,
0.4945493639,
-0.161684677,
0.1996103674,
-0.2107082903,
0.034930788,
0.4722551107,
0.3226536214,
-0.3244712949,
0.3096336722,
-0.3118348122,
-0.0526450686,
0.3351130784,
0.1686107218,
-0.0940862596,
-0.0608112477,
-0.5280086994,
-0.0528754964,
-0.3932354152,
-0.1287810057,
0.2590928376,
0.4228369296,
0.1285653263,
0.4797232449,
-0.2305077761,
1.1480784416,
0.3606466949,
-0.1900687665,
0.4431253374,
0.0146468366,
-0.590826273,
0.1529609412,
0.6743233204,
0.1579575688,
-0.2048207521,
-0.1328069717,
-0.1307239532,
-0.1355611086,
0.5077806711,
-0.8409255147,
0.0630029663,
0.1898175776,
-0.4373425841,
-0.2480936497,
-0.054383222,
-0.6056572795,
-0.399710238,
-0.5563041568,
0.7806600928,
-0.1591916978,
0.1815940589,
0.0738172382,
-0.3708047569,
0.1354833096,
0.1773897558,
-0.7234660387,
0.1722507626,
0.5467485189,
0.6563434005,
-0.3082192838,
-0.4742147326,
-0.9436208606,
0.5542349815,
0.1463059336,
0.8199661374,
-0.2054470479,
-0.1056326181,
-0.1169298738,
0.3253094256,
-0.1409084499,
-0.7936092615,
0.5327420235,
-0.5944722295,
-0.1033509225,
-0.3029886484,
-0.404322058,
-0.3948651552,
0.1805475205,
-1.0364353657,
1.1459020376,
0.136268571,
-0.6268789172,
0.2432793975,
-0.7368237376,
-0.6532505155,
0.2670381665,
0.2896097302,
-0.6706933975,
0.0217592604,
0.0023833311,
0.6642869711,
-0.6166279912,
0.1457635909,
0.1586609334,
-0.484675169,
0.0677320659,
-0.1993949711,
0.3350258768,
0.1767470092,
-0.5675261617,
0.3570882678,
-0.8795209527,
0.1122031063,
-0.1963286847,
-0.7360591292,
-0.2208777815,
0.0035052854,
0.5250298381,
0.3537604809,
0.2624329627,
-0.5498967171,
0.0762143284,
-0.0663543418,
0.3966269195,
0.4381656647,
-0.2994703352,
0.0856921375,
-0.6241057515,
0.2564258873,
0.4636136591,
0.2656722665,
-0.0128583852,
-0.5377144814,
-0.8235312104,
-0.1378689557,
0.2023925781,
0.6831868887,
-0.7562906146,
0.5708783269,
-0.0768858492,
-0.7006018162,
-0.4814842641,
0.4528001547,
0.7803558111,
0.5650111437,
0.9352584481,
-0.3415494859,
-0.578214705,
-1.0242877007,
-0.2103494704,
0.399385035,
0.2845041156,
0.1551600993,
0.3560348153,
-0.3549094796,
0.6166372895,
-0.6834805012,
-0.5588433743,
-0.2922118008,
0.3352758586,
0.5035822988,
0.8795574307,
0.2703643441,
-0.8105518818,
-0.4636635184,
0.2963758707,
-0.5705956817,
0.2484770119,
0.0149895828,
-0.2552410066,
-0.1608287692,
0.4134894907,
-0.4874256253,
0.293715328,
0.610824585,
-0.0949348733,
0.5563530326,
-0.325606674,
0.0281868298,
-1.214012146,
0.2482872158,
0.3850491941,
-0.1974332631,
-0.9403545856,
0.0543339886,
0.0745520592,
-0.1464437246,
-0.7185682058,
0.2247259766,
-0.2762950361,
0.0150341019,
-0.5246756077,
-0.3300937712,
0.1135679185,
0.6661036015,
-0.4157847464,
0.5895380974,
0.6109326482,
-0.6794599295,
0.5510615706,
0.3308265209,
-0.4518041909,
0.5541391969,
-0.8089668155,
0.2733861506,
-0.2492320538,
0.2323509157,
-0.771163702,
-0.3223596811,
0.1475763619,
0.1591116637,
0.1438862979,
-0.4581257999,
-0.503518939,
-0.6281515956,
0.1084534451,
0.7070636749,
0.4364287853,
-0.5491777658,
0.8522869349,
0.2203059793,
0.4425503314,
-0.8198567629,
-0.9289935827,
-0.3127839565,
-0.4356811941,
-0.2549855113,
0.7151435614,
-0.019671591,
0.3525554538,
-0.083264634,
-0.3425458372,
-0.3597872257,
-0.0455158204,
0.6333531737,
0.1537321359,
-0.4712072015,
0.0275200084,
0.1165728718,
-0.3685389161,
-0.22396411,
-0.7346255779,
0.3514699936,
0.1909187585,
-0.4736765027,
-0.7626031637,
0.3852964342,
0.7215496302,
-0.4328458309,
0.7821224928,
1.0245244503,
-0.3435012996,
-0.2769920826,
-0.5808348656,
0.2423504293,
-0.5373163819,
0.4064115584,
-0.3990815878,
-0.7236137986,
0.2993372679,
-0.433321774,
0.1532089114,
0.437727958,
0.495192945,
-0.1722982824,
0.8630994558,
0.6622682214,
-0.3238395452,
0.569016993,
-0.5040324926,
0.0846243575,
-0.9659309387,
-0.0449746624,
-0.5886160135,
-1.0344020128,
-0.3403342068,
-0.5274294615,
0.5692586899,
-0.0315891728,
-0.4256939888,
0.7612323165,
-0.7365309,
0.6607890129,
0.9305643439,
0.5373859406,
0.2481747121,
-0.274351269,
0.3804514706,
0.3991551995,
-0.783534646,
-0.1204829887,
0.8908452988,
-0.2196547091,
0.4777046442,
0.0493659973,
0.6872729659,
0.3884674311,
-0.053251069,
-1.0158535242,
0.2995352149,
-0.532602787,
-0.6535702348,
-0.5608351827,
-0.1524651051,
-1.2773603201,
0.3042433858,
-0.3226635158,
-0.7333812714,
0.4123780429,
0.6373702884,
-0.6588250399,
0.388751179,
-0.6317077875,
0.9039294124,
0.1518836915,
-0.4896941483,
-0.3226782084,
-0.7451159954,
0.1477845013,
-0.0451947711,
0.1147690043,
-0.1203972027,
0.1796884835,
0.9661272168,
-0.1810113043,
1.020640254,
-0.2691678405,
-0.077932857,
0.3923036456,
-0.180555895,
0.5357429981,
-0.3446590602,
-0.3133691549,
-0.2598674297,
-0.0753052905,
-0.6358375549,
-0.5814161301,
0.7192153335,
-0.8736196756,
-0.5037639737,
0.1284594685,
-1.110806942,
-0.2287252694,
0.4086393714,
0.1741331518,
0.817528069,
0.1130577177,
0.2590241134,
0.8669931293,
-0.0680569112,
0.4960739017,
0.2202460319,
0.3268819153,
-0.2125442326,
1.1999745369,
0.105284974,
0.1712092459,
0.7004842162,
0.2806577981,
0.2238812745,
-0.3255902231,
-0.4402554929,
-0.0727727711,
-0.6754044294,
-0.5669882298,
-0.4696470201,
-0.1586462706,
0.0998883098,
-0.0206378009,
-0.4761049747,
-0.2968292832,
-0.1818478256,
0.1886443645,
0.3536789417,
0.8474522829,
0.1042772308,
0.9373943806,
-0.9767261744,
0.6008509994,
0.4776138663,
0.3450801969,
0.0406668112,
-0.3100767434,
-0.9271844625,
-0.2628584802,
-0.6843969822,
-0.7680385709,
0.0280335639,
0.2806065381,
0.4443285465,
0.4227997959,
-0.148008883,
0.7257449627,
-0.547375679,
0.4676493108,
0.2456778437,
-0.9902762175,
0.497735858,
-0.1522065103,
0.5854266882,
0.321503073,
0.6285734773,
-0.2865898609,
0.140923813,
-0.1986707747,
-1.0437885523,
0.7295828462,
-0.062435735,
-0.2145996094,
0.2665335536,
0.2860663533,
0.1160023361,
-0.0103990678,
-0.3094982207,
-0.6225274205,
-0.1230864897,
-0.3131864667,
-0.2938812971,
0.0623775497,
-0.3666176796,
-0.4242996573,
0.5599862933,
-0.5150858164,
0.3107964396,
0.0981897339,
-0.4112929106,
-0.2695475817,
0.2931751907,
0.4251337051,
0.5224143267,
0.0623901933,
0.2263767272,
0.240674004,
-0.45779109,
0.32311517,
0.2525243163,
0.078617692,
-0.2127473354,
0.3060111105,
1.0707746744,
0.4094759524,
-0.2389010936,
0.2133914977,
0.4828622043,
-0.2146520615,
0.3521300852,
0.3208853602,
0.2445136905,
0.4460933805,
0.2982842028,
0.5012986064,
0.2933593988,
-0.2819512784,
0.1882247925,
-0.0134870028,
-0.6215310097,
-0.3113580048,
0.7242926359,
0.2201328427,
-0.2200225443,
0.2731082141,
0.1547249407,
-0.1957682222,
0.8634132147,
0.7923425436,
0.7065384388,
-0.2644177675,
0.0568972975,
0.249048695,
-0.0154606653,
-0.30702281,
0.3489313424,
-0.1669219881,
-0.5983449817,
-0.900816977,
-0.5428615212,
-0.3372891545,
0.0511111319,
-1.0177633762,
0.1086912751,
-0.2571347356,
-0.4705241024,
0.5807602406,
-0.3891626596,
-0.9482575059,
0.2656043172,
0.1848051995,
0.8185702562,
-0.7946664095,
0.9463030696,
1.0154807568,
-0.128212437,
-0.5744746327,
-0.1577790976,
0.0812052041,
-0.6579598784,
0.7909422517,
0.1766923815,
-0.2466882318,
0.3739774823,
-0.1794923395,
-1.0841867924,
1.233946085,
0.1029365659,
-0.7103151679,
-0.190944612,
0.2150405645,
0.2401290238,
-0.0442371145,
0.140976429,
0.5310644507,
0.7024282813,
-0.0764117241,
-1.0159476995,
0.1648634076,
-0.1468945891,
0.0185882729,
0.4817386568,
-0.7658448219,
0.5719581246,
-0.1177328452,
0.1042985842,
-0.0142865824,
0.7937830687,
-0.0734032616,
0.1239883527,
0.6770160198,
0.6705838442,
0.6376786828,
-0.034647245,
0.7552007437,
-0.5296949148,
0.2877237797,
1.2131546736,
-0.1097814217,
0.5642443895,
0.5022133589,
-0.0081751747,
0.4310316145,
0.0107636722,
-0.0902504027,
0.3116222322,
0.4347838163,
0.0281019416,
-0.3055721223,
-0.358553946,
-0.2248439342,
0.4677371383,
0.1985129267,
-0.2112847418,
-0.0892219618,
0.1995377094,
-0.3183123767,
-0.3549543619,
-0.342939496,
0.7315430641,
-0.1580885798,
-0.6842095256,
0.6403849721,
-0.0650359169,
0.8351812363,
-0.4273029268,
0.0875149891,
0.1199838743,
0.4761862755,
-0.5243443847,
-0.7059787512,
0.3312073648,
-0.2547116578,
-0.5245396495,
-0.1969152987,
0.6353116632,
-0.2652469873,
-0.2156119794,
0.2094656974,
0.7402841449,
-0.2428295016,
-0.0522342362,
-0.4759290516,
-0.0108459918,
-0.3575280905,
-0.3342556357,
0.4746679068,
0.4323025048,
0.0736563951,
0.6825253963,
0.5931120515,
-0.1323386282,
0.1636847407,
0.171188578,
0.8569687605,
-0.8667992949,
-0.2451392561,
-0.5732047558,
0.6081297398,
0.1558580399,
-0.5557168722,
0.510750711,
0.7383976579,
0.7003355622,
-0.3086951673,
0.6166164875,
-0.1177485287,
0.089947924,
-0.2192208171,
0.4749104679,
-0.5601350069,
-0.2374904156,
-0.3405782282,
-0.9719058275,
-0.2609508634,
0.0039434498,
0.1875880361,
-0.3500216007,
0.7123676538,
0.5686255097,
-0.4861889482,
-0.0048067179,
0.3248670697,
-0.0496121719,
-0.0896933079,
0.7153629065,
0.6258231997,
-0.7565146685,
0.5008197427,
-0.4571605325,
-0.1819108278,
-0.0714195818,
-0.7082653642,
-0.8073644638,
-0.7749208808,
-0.5312153697,
-0.0635629222,
0.1786094606,
0.9861521125,
1.2104016542,
-0.8712364435,
-0.5440202951,
0.3390246034,
-0.0212888215,
-0.9592556357,
-0.1687834859,
0.2103706598,
-0.403629005,
-0.8221763968,
0.4760694206,
0.0973137841,
-0.1402692348,
0.0580778532,
0.1520644277,
-0.1698714644,
-0.0901048481,
0.8777524829,
0.2248712331,
-0.4970873296,
-0.0527815484,
-0.2992626727,
0.0369288661,
0.1762869358,
1.013415575,
-0.8088029623,
0.0644648224,
0.5808154345,
0.8907732368,
0.7130127549,
0.1101565734,
0.3967263401,
-0.7654762268,
0.1228741854,
-0.1834639311,
0.414242506,
-0.0379138328,
-0.5169520974,
0.3084791303,
0.0715384707,
-0.653701961,
-0.5311903954,
0.210184142,
-1.2619333267,
-0.1337441653,
0.8465223312,
-0.0348928496,
-0.316601038,
-0.2197699994,
-0.0112195853,
0.5217397809,
-0.1392924786,
0.5744253993,
0.2374008745,
-0.2560077012,
0.2088546157,
-0.5831083059,
0.3467456102,
0.478970468,
-0.9481022954,
-0.1008469611,
0.1784741282,
0.030032061,
0.4531196952,
-0.1303765178,
0.3111827672,
0.2130746096,
-0.5437300205,
0.1770703495,
-0.330527097,
-0.5487201214,
-0.007541568,
0.3632999659,
-0.1686992496,
-0.4174186885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01409v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01409v1 | Dynamic Few-Shot Learning for Knowledge Graph Question Answering | 2024-07-01T15:59:17 | 2024-07-01T15:59:17 | Jacopo D'Abramo, Andrea Zugarini, Paolo Torroni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models present opportunities for innovative Question Answering
over Knowledge Graphs (KGQA). However, they are not inherently designed for
query generation. To bridge this gap, solutions have been proposed that rely on
fine-tuning or ad-hoc architectures, achieving good results but limited
out-of-domain distribution generalization. In this study, we introduce a novel
approach called Dynamic Few-Shot Learning (DFSL). DFSL integrates the
efficiency of in-context learning and semantic similarity and provides a
generally applicable solution for KGQA with state-of-the-art performance. We
run an extensive evaluation across multiple benchmark datasets and architecture
configurations. | [
-0.4144936502,
-1.1374461651,
0.6136286855,
-0.5309664011,
-0.2539014518,
0.5016860962,
0.2429051995,
-0.2636519372,
-0.1393697411,
0.1610565186,
-0.9955493808,
-0.6600492001,
-0.4283360243,
0.0791491792,
-0.0837369338,
0.5514007807,
-0.1673027575,
-0.3009938002,
-0.3023687899,
-0.3454464078,
-0.20100604,
0.0586051606,
-0.7444063425,
-0.3095144033,
0.5927605033,
0.4551785886,
0.5560194254,
0.3742660582,
0.2581647038,
0.2685824037,
-0.2219982594,
0.6303397417,
-0.9093760848,
0.1864060014,
0.0520045273,
-0.376162678,
-0.0348960832,
-0.2675454617,
0.9238271117,
0.913336277,
0.1157645509,
0.1985429227,
-0.0116998702,
0.8249813914,
-0.6878516674,
0.3602338135,
-0.8760806918,
0.1352339685,
-0.0885716081,
-0.085918881,
-0.2935726643,
-0.4591333568,
0.2897791862,
-0.8755403757,
-0.224879548,
0.1291459799,
0.6252326965,
0.3608132303,
-0.8133538365,
-0.2608719766,
-0.3747246861,
0.5679599643,
-0.5326343775,
0.4175160825,
0.2408926487,
0.920756042,
-0.4819634855,
-0.9160071611,
-0.7064608932,
0.1926503628,
-0.0480320081,
0.0504905842,
-0.1777832657,
-0.0459980927,
0.2328162342,
-0.1409091204,
-0.5686295033,
-0.0300438218,
-0.2093050927,
0.0162175428,
0.5252525806,
0.5397667885,
-0.1792910993,
-0.1508257538,
-0.3664181828,
-0.2042072266,
-0.6478071213,
0.2166113704,
0.3024227023,
0.4187703431,
0.1043768376,
0.1899681091,
-0.7363213301,
1.058259964,
0.0370633267,
-0.3417654634,
0.2162008733,
-0.0237294938,
-0.1965747178,
-0.2173232585,
0.5500053763,
0.0501431078,
0.170036003,
-0.2638051212,
0.057339102,
-0.5889223814,
-0.0342730284,
-0.8175374269,
-0.3140198588,
0.1733029038,
-0.1256504953,
-0.4223250747,
-0.1637068987,
-0.6794597507,
-0.3876680732,
0.0881672576,
0.6724099517,
-0.5517148376,
-0.0780711025,
-0.077620782,
-0.1447729915,
0.1963607818,
0.3313697577,
-0.6236187816,
0.2118847817,
0.4504758418,
0.5055292249,
-0.2179986537,
-0.3047231436,
-0.672706604,
0.2884353697,
-0.3873550296,
0.768605113,
-0.5140506625,
-0.1373785883,
-0.04211355,
-0.2758777142,
-0.158451438,
-0.5283504128,
-0.2138718814,
-1.3711723089,
-0.0822259411,
-0.4517131448,
-0.7075106502,
-0.3784908652,
0.6166054606,
-0.2583744824,
1.0685055256,
0.4353961051,
-0.8982758522,
0.5174939036,
-0.5364679694,
-0.2970589697,
0.3556439877,
-0.2790737748,
-0.3122521043,
-0.3488396704,
0.0695311725,
0.316993475,
0.0082563031,
-0.0220308211,
-0.3886036277,
-0.4533600807,
0.2272553295,
-0.2079709321,
0.455811888,
0.2997551262,
-0.0026776211,
-0.1309725046,
-0.8174607158,
0.3179449141,
0.2501634061,
-0.4235439301,
-0.2936539054,
-0.1556315869,
-0.6375469565,
0.2756159604,
0.0506290421,
-0.5197173953,
0.3578945398,
-0.7139186263,
0.2958674431,
0.4014053941,
0.3747990727,
0.4381766915,
-0.1177908629,
0.6828901768,
0.2058421969,
-0.0127497166,
0.0342703573,
-0.3218996227,
-0.3558122814,
-0.2284681946,
0.2635130584,
0.4447463751,
-1.3473508358,
-0.2571359873,
-0.2995894253,
-0.4856953025,
-0.2198023349,
0.3763747215,
0.3918062449,
0.9084798694,
0.3647903204,
0.0612990521,
-0.0855192468,
-0.5927947164,
-0.1175407693,
-0.2768511474,
0.1369838566,
0.7904373407,
0.5184332132,
0.0911081657,
1.2700611353,
-1.1692898273,
-0.2187389135,
-0.3438518643,
0.1656421274,
0.130212456,
-0.0618308634,
0.8150938153,
-0.7402634621,
-0.8072140813,
-0.0921475068,
-0.7498295903,
0.3298176229,
0.467074424,
-0.3244944811,
-0.0415444709,
0.5202136636,
-0.6027858853,
0.0950429589,
0.2187446952,
-0.0965283141,
0.116192691,
0.1395786852,
0.0881105661,
-1.0616627932,
-0.1027215496,
-0.4994444549,
-0.3412926793,
-0.5020051003,
0.070995599,
-0.0252280906,
-0.2846505046,
-0.9487214088,
0.8298181891,
-0.0216101706,
-0.0368211642,
-0.2658771873,
0.3651799858,
0.0481054001,
0.530777812,
-0.2408531755,
0.4860959351,
0.6310662031,
-0.6591955423,
0.6565443277,
0.5926789641,
-0.43473351,
0.2207088917,
-0.3764410615,
0.3187016547,
-0.5692634583,
0.4724545777,
-1.3016908169,
-0.5115161538,
0.1381003112,
-0.3780530095,
0.3566104472,
-0.4440742731,
-0.4821815491,
-0.6070128679,
-0.2949407995,
0.5256541371,
0.4643886685,
-0.5112888217,
0.3691894412,
0.1123756692,
0.1352397501,
-0.7607190609,
-0.5479685068,
-0.4925997555,
-0.2259359658,
-0.6115649939,
0.1606250256,
0.0856861323,
-0.0456178933,
0.1230374947,
-0.1499186307,
-0.3534933627,
0.2359625846,
-0.1563956738,
-0.1807745397,
-0.3571652174,
0.5420411825,
0.2757605612,
0.017253058,
-0.3168143332,
-0.493442893,
0.4652554691,
0.0366469026,
-0.316752553,
-0.2140576094,
0.2901648879,
0.4228849113,
-0.1011721939,
0.8148824573,
0.4524816573,
-0.2448195368,
-0.4445955455,
-0.1424852014,
-0.3232536316,
-0.5382624269,
0.4210484326,
-0.6457147598,
-1.0769594908,
0.4984849989,
-0.3549719155,
-0.1560617983,
0.1963020265,
0.4051046669,
-0.452809006,
0.8251677752,
0.5060872436,
0.2130189836,
0.3520107269,
-0.4373070598,
0.1568568498,
-0.2928114235,
-0.2036868781,
-0.0466338545,
-0.4850935042,
-0.5266650915,
-0.1691854298,
0.8491106629,
0.2373859286,
-0.3946003318,
0.1683616042,
-0.038100075,
0.7401169538,
0.5087373257,
0.2173600048,
0.2686532438,
-0.081470415,
-0.5516595244,
0.307218641,
-1.1560924053,
-0.13834548,
0.948816061,
0.0356872268,
0.6830701232,
0.3580186963,
0.830679059,
-0.1328260303,
-0.0711872801,
-0.808844924,
0.5961782336,
-0.1857300252,
-0.6132349968,
-0.7429502606,
-0.5718405247,
-0.9107087851,
0.257576257,
-0.2910768986,
-0.6441434622,
-0.0472871661,
0.3204841018,
-0.7497321367,
0.2313369513,
-0.4842475653,
0.8684403896,
0.0357706174,
-0.4256809354,
-0.0465016812,
-0.8176097274,
0.3996063471,
-0.219424203,
-0.1167349443,
-0.2328770161,
0.1433086097,
0.5880197883,
-0.2391445339,
0.8505129218,
-0.4510909319,
0.2420783192,
0.6753084064,
0.1636506617,
0.5941687822,
0.1300151646,
-0.2663384378,
-0.4038871229,
0.2681777179,
-0.4556605816,
-0.9831568003,
0.6214790344,
-0.6593863964,
-0.4954870641,
-0.0873776004,
-0.7149592042,
-0.7205685377,
0.3963766396,
0.0818059593,
0.6145077348,
-0.0809974447,
0.0568261035,
0.5612114668,
-0.2242219746,
0.4621171653,
0.7352637053,
-0.012340107,
-0.2123318017,
0.6323446035,
0.3130452037,
0.3619962037,
0.6003068686,
0.3441957235,
-0.5384590626,
-0.5345296264,
-0.6458719373,
0.1936213076,
-1.0735160112,
-0.46738711,
-0.7222194076,
-0.11873281,
-0.4978382587,
-0.0855975822,
-0.2697355449,
-0.32116732,
-0.1663548797,
-0.0791816562,
0.6376903057,
0.5535888076,
0.4566366374,
0.3406366408,
-0.899118185,
0.3574715257,
0.8002318144,
0.3499541283,
0.1546263248,
-0.4235833287,
-0.1123669893,
-0.0549356826,
-0.5341382623,
-0.7972291708,
0.0768673569,
0.4698900878,
0.6469278336,
0.3307295144,
0.6182402968,
0.6462965012,
-0.5586156845,
0.672875762,
-0.0774898306,
-0.473983705,
0.5867868662,
-0.3929098845,
0.66903615,
1.0074898005,
0.7876157761,
-0.2390811443,
-0.1204234436,
-0.4441508651,
-0.6582868695,
0.6782497764,
-0.0352647379,
0.2996839583,
-0.2212638855,
0.5689180493,
0.1229898632,
0.2450491637,
-0.1608650684,
-0.2389524877,
0.0343867354,
-0.3703816533,
0.2885597944,
-0.0549943708,
-0.1919069141,
-0.2908424735,
0.4949298501,
-0.7153125405,
0.112977244,
-0.138118431,
-0.1155422181,
-0.1419799626,
0.0853676796,
0.2702678442,
0.7750634551,
-0.0987864956,
0.1607522219,
0.6267294288,
-0.1179425418,
0.1361782551,
0.0916488916,
-0.2265327275,
-0.3368740976,
0.2602768242,
0.8219882846,
0.2571023107,
-0.6981643438,
0.7230482101,
0.2704590559,
-0.3498589694,
0.0195531342,
0.2011676133,
0.1551234871,
0.6378166676,
0.4237959981,
-0.4210255146,
-0.0696483999,
-0.5501882434,
0.4213266671,
0.6160658002,
-0.4066503346,
-0.1486689597,
0.6148649454,
0.1940924972,
0.075724557,
0.8772855997,
-0.5211972594,
-0.5494208932,
0.5152212381,
0.3736615479,
0.5349528193,
0.1300837249,
0.391810894,
0.2631269991,
-0.2237245739,
0.3011520803,
0.3477336168,
-0.424968183,
-0.8382815719,
-0.2613761425,
-0.6827864647,
-0.421531558,
-0.1217461005,
-0.244982183,
0.4612648487,
-0.2200668454,
0.0794063583,
-0.0682752281,
0.1932648867,
-0.5637142062,
0.1949801892,
0.0407253951,
0.9545410872,
-0.827994585,
1.1383192539,
0.8298016191,
-0.3139613867,
-0.7830457687,
0.0972727165,
0.170624882,
-0.8107101917,
0.9632694125,
-0.1893113554,
-0.2864345908,
0.5162608027,
-0.3778464794,
-0.8889966607,
1.6347868443,
0.3601857126,
-0.0799169764,
-0.076481916,
0.2875816226,
0.4791840315,
-0.215658173,
0.0495210066,
0.4838091731,
0.1777657419,
0.7414625883,
-0.562274754,
-0.2705104351,
0.2728865743,
-0.3515685499,
0.1939112693,
-0.9628036022,
0.3961859643,
-0.2803786397,
-0.1117615923,
-0.1822032183,
0.6216442585,
0.2874764502,
0.5096197724,
0.483166039,
0.3406445086,
0.8894069791,
0.0933106244,
0.9419691563,
-0.1923844665,
0.5054537654,
1.0956130028,
-0.3632847667,
0.8622502685,
0.2567604482,
-0.2517787814,
0.2648474276,
0.590833962,
0.3045889437,
0.8969446421,
0.1627074778,
-0.3568975627,
-0.4583861828,
0.035147015,
-0.0127001712,
0.6270408034,
0.1466588676,
-0.1771240681,
-0.6842183471,
0.0328025408,
-0.223285526,
-0.0178334769,
-0.0780974552,
0.9989987016,
0.0869707167,
-0.4418657124,
0.7279474139,
-0.3019381464,
0.2765410244,
-0.8472322226,
-0.0707089603,
-0.3437466025,
0.0434169136,
-0.0537712984,
-0.8581599593,
0.3499849439,
-0.1756704897,
-0.0282590967,
0.0207708105,
0.6932182312,
-0.3356009424,
-0.2439412028,
0.1221959889,
0.6805314422,
0.0062694019,
0.2192391008,
-0.6471654773,
-0.3783733249,
-0.2820734978,
-0.3481581807,
0.5121535063,
0.5223166943,
-0.0307754539,
0.9172937274,
0.1215718985,
-0.404394865,
0.2757714689,
-0.0782846212,
1.01300776,
-0.3504108787,
-0.4432745874,
-0.5670182705,
0.3170014322,
0.1153071374,
-0.3094991148,
0.602599442,
0.4253797829,
0.8156811595,
-0.0033829901,
0.5591360331,
0.0773412585,
0.5337227583,
-0.5335206985,
0.6379083991,
-0.7451817393,
-0.0089591593,
-0.2850395739,
-0.664875865,
-0.4483445287,
0.1898153126,
-0.3832806051,
-0.0700685233,
0.6654614806,
0.8188151717,
-0.2189664394,
-0.2117414773,
0.6327257156,
0.1302777678,
0.1257045716,
0.7074628472,
0.9048381448,
-0.3723805249,
0.8602997661,
-0.2603942752,
-0.0576773845,
-0.1118273735,
-0.8071248531,
-0.7771708965,
-0.446947962,
-0.4475467801,
-0.1523282379,
0.2503352165,
0.8224967718,
0.6454814672,
-0.6474539042,
0.2944990396,
0.1010792181,
0.2372652739,
-0.1900722384,
-0.1925368905,
0.6707334518,
-0.431104809,
-0.6094481945,
0.5476950407,
0.1778987944,
-0.0210018773,
-0.0239589438,
0.1417726278,
-0.2587939501,
0.1036499813,
0.7786530256,
0.2487280071,
-0.4376143515,
-0.5737947226,
0.1415609717,
0.0390763767,
-0.0457166284,
0.571385324,
-1.1336605549,
0.4626345634,
0.889849484,
0.9417436719,
0.8314834833,
0.1548193544,
0.1054143608,
-1.2003165483,
0.1040434763,
0.21542871,
-0.1624144167,
0.0467200093,
-0.2165609598,
0.2121898234,
0.3526703715,
-0.2597358823,
-0.5478048325,
0.6387287378,
-0.7778345942,
-0.3841776848,
1.2586088181,
-0.2380886525,
-0.1496884078,
-0.3133974969,
0.0805698633,
0.2446590662,
-0.0945275724,
0.4988930225,
0.5230759978,
-0.574275434,
-0.0685223639,
-0.4524861872,
0.5079282522,
0.0770791695,
-0.5706657767,
-0.096568577,
0.3691525459,
0.5586080551,
-0.2964479625,
0.7132083178,
0.0122674285,
0.1835214198,
-0.0020599519,
-0.562322557,
-0.2335535586,
-0.2835462391,
-0.0493869297,
0.6111893654,
0.2916019559,
-0.2911257744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01406v1 | Adapting Multilingual LLMs to Low-Resource Languages with Knowledge Graphs via Adapters | 2024-07-01T15:56:24 | 2024-07-01T15:56:24 | Daniil Gurgurov, Mareike Hartmann, Simon Ostermann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the integration of graph knowledge from linguistic
ontologies into multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) using adapters to
improve performance for low-resource languages (LRLs) in sentiment analysis
(SA) and named entity recognition (NER). Building upon successful
parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques, such as K-ADAPTER and MAD-X, we
propose a similar approach for incorporating knowledge from multilingual
graphs, connecting concepts in various languages with each other through
linguistic relationships, into multilingual LLMs for LRLs. Specifically, we
focus on eight LRLs -- Maltese, Bulgarian, Indonesian, Nepali, Javanese,
Uyghur, Tibetan, and Sinhala -- and employ language-specific adapters
fine-tuned on data extracted from the language-specific section of ConceptNet,
aiming to enable knowledge transfer across the languages covered by the
knowledge graph. We compare various fine-tuning objectives, including standard
Masked Language Modeling (MLM), MLM with full-word masking, and MLM with
targeted masking, to analyse their effectiveness in learning and integrating
the extracted graph data. Through empirical evaluation on language-specific
tasks, we assess how structured graph knowledge affects the performance of
multilingual LLMs for LRLs in SA and NER, providing insights into the potential
benefits of adapting language models for low-resource scenarios. | [
-0.3959606588,
-0.4570173025,
0.3867283165,
0.1056492999,
-0.2228868008,
0.405607909,
-0.5200372934,
-0.4326903522,
0.2914605439,
0.7018374801,
-0.3295805752,
-0.5610861778,
-0.5381478071,
0.2951846123,
0.2210026383,
1.0232410431,
-0.2577636838,
0.0117033552,
0.107594952,
-0.3533200324,
-0.2721275091,
-0.5110567808,
-0.852417469,
-0.3106673658,
0.7248567343,
0.3906627893,
0.4324454367,
0.3416869938,
0.3668509424,
0.2868478596,
-0.1886148006,
0.5394915938,
-0.5548226833,
-0.2304740548,
-0.4427056611,
-0.5159893632,
-0.4745871425,
-0.3236681521,
0.7287880182,
0.7836152315,
0.0519798733,
0.3005649447,
0.2774268687,
0.7396367788,
-0.5265667439,
0.5528369546,
-0.70498842,
0.086778,
-0.0309286304,
-0.1318395883,
-0.3007975221,
-0.2860883474,
-0.0961889103,
-0.6463797092,
-0.2170559913,
0.164096877,
0.5974763036,
0.3943222761,
-0.1642024517,
-0.3745663762,
-0.4896169603,
0.7342315912,
-0.6183981895,
0.4547345638,
0.1849456131,
0.2637930214,
-0.0909522697,
-0.5389220119,
-0.5695643425,
0.1412034929,
-0.3117420077,
0.0658841133,
-0.2378763407,
0.1266610026,
0.0804018304,
0.1043622196,
-0.2114114612,
0.3983489871,
-0.1990762651,
-0.1922365129,
0.5258798599,
0.0663079619,
0.2731240988,
-0.3256100118,
-0.0877820104,
0.0597258806,
-0.5915756822,
0.1414878219,
0.3400532007,
0.9516790509,
-0.2938813269,
0.5327563882,
-0.2482574135,
0.9594037533,
0.0222427975,
-0.420437783,
0.2185366005,
-0.5378867388,
-0.0207922887,
0.1524447799,
0.7331714034,
0.1978594363,
0.588514328,
-0.2994331717,
-0.1682879925,
-0.0075915996,
-0.215890646,
-0.756293714,
-0.2250261903,
-0.2573423684,
-0.4040769339,
-0.1421764642,
-0.4905831516,
-0.761691153,
-0.5462008119,
-0.1895347387,
0.1727415621,
-0.3572179079,
-0.3647401035,
0.1452765018,
-0.1173949316,
0.1389420182,
0.2873389423,
-0.6395603418,
0.3049726188,
0.4995159507,
1.0174046755,
-0.1132586375,
-0.251005739,
-0.3983071446,
0.2632278502,
-0.2115867287,
0.7924832702,
-0.5566276312,
-0.2565267086,
0.062772356,
0.3197567165,
-0.3474226594,
-0.4716130495,
0.3277771175,
-0.7120164037,
0.0133160977,
-0.3580379188,
-0.4301690161,
-0.3601621985,
0.6370292902,
-0.6336605549,
0.8414518833,
0.1654467732,
-0.7711258531,
0.1633628458,
-0.9610751271,
-0.554407239,
-0.0197442025,
0.0051255147,
0.0134884296,
-0.0017459024,
0.1219296753,
0.521328032,
-0.1869852394,
-0.2537647784,
-0.2545699477,
-0.0164103955,
0.2121278644,
-0.18823497,
0.7001754045,
0.1538792849,
0.1130882949,
0.13868168,
-0.8776069283,
0.108696036,
0.1327223331,
-0.5163328648,
-0.4241532683,
-0.057977058,
0.0985525623,
0.5554971695,
0.2265904844,
-0.4188562334,
0.0322253518,
-0.6036163568,
0.5862730145,
0.5863239169,
-0.0777925178,
0.4233729541,
-0.0519281365,
0.6346056461,
0.2725077868,
-0.2335897833,
0.1274757832,
-0.3745432496,
-1.0028340816,
-0.1117463261,
0.4951173365,
0.679396987,
-1.1622588634,
0.1803897768,
-0.5336359143,
-0.3444853127,
-0.7557508349,
0.5819014907,
0.3579180241,
0.4663595855,
0.2818815112,
-0.4008946717,
-0.4617660344,
-0.6890812516,
-0.2580350041,
-0.2123141289,
0.2809976339,
0.5232368708,
0.2815103233,
-0.2216730714,
0.6073688269,
-0.5453887582,
-0.5160014033,
-0.5444530249,
-0.3547853827,
0.3202157915,
0.022187056,
0.6900393367,
-0.5070203543,
-0.7658863068,
0.4277402461,
-0.6384650469,
0.1145375594,
0.3149391711,
-0.1070887819,
0.3753637671,
0.4808682501,
-0.2912332416,
-0.174004972,
0.756327033,
-0.273403734,
0.3608861864,
-0.1944435388,
-0.1430580169,
-1.3301866055,
-0.0863462314,
0.1003768221,
-0.4102711678,
-0.7105973363,
-0.0067179417,
-0.2280530035,
-0.0708162263,
-0.6079378724,
0.82015872,
-0.4451100826,
-0.0285905618,
-0.2519867718,
0.5829725862,
0.0194703545,
0.5622459054,
0.0238446593,
0.6889580488,
0.3693303168,
-0.5359880328,
0.2674992085,
0.1754615754,
-0.5241094828,
0.6356022358,
-0.2982479334,
0.1589924842,
-0.1913406551,
-0.1087750793,
-0.7486961484,
-0.0001620694,
0.4253033698,
-0.1201356575,
0.2989304364,
-0.5987862945,
-0.4039931893,
-0.0881995186,
-0.129806146,
0.2990536392,
0.2517400086,
-0.4656800032,
0.7863920927,
0.5397440791,
-0.2804109156,
-0.5900589228,
-0.7641454935,
0.1047201455,
-0.3599983752,
-0.4375737607,
0.0534115098,
0.081680581,
-0.2656626403,
0.2077417076,
0.257665962,
-0.037230555,
0.1145465672,
-0.013187062,
-0.0370424725,
-0.4311638772,
0.1372163594,
0.0241210386,
-0.2031403482,
-0.2057088315,
-0.5630943775,
0.6423135996,
-0.2243317664,
-0.1786584556,
-0.1200969741,
0.0240962971,
0.3668478131,
-0.1315266341,
0.8989302516,
0.7828837633,
-0.3883373439,
-0.1696515679,
-0.4058056772,
0.126578629,
-0.4277563989,
0.5728712082,
-0.6783284545,
-1.1331752539,
0.6836218238,
-0.4717793763,
-0.2037921995,
0.3511100411,
0.6411166787,
-0.042559389,
0.8126606941,
0.8752214909,
-0.4797814488,
0.5119513273,
-0.2202675492,
0.4523153603,
-0.9559386969,
0.09165553,
-0.3939272761,
-0.3653119504,
-1.0758606195,
-0.4925643206,
0.2095057815,
0.2646823525,
-0.0959784612,
0.1900141984,
-0.1166594028,
0.4497185647,
0.2574592829,
-0.0148606505,
0.4522460997,
0.1951268613,
-0.0920931697,
0.093917124,
-1.0983221531,
-0.4883365631,
0.8435186148,
0.10862232,
0.652992487,
0.2539494634,
0.576321125,
0.0649925023,
0.2009099722,
-0.918045938,
0.3667700589,
-0.613912642,
-0.2090489417,
-0.3050564528,
-0.3707631528,
-0.8107373714,
0.3119623065,
-0.1574763358,
-0.7482118607,
0.2676138878,
0.0923448727,
-0.2154901326,
0.3782778382,
-0.6186963916,
0.797044754,
-0.2503460348,
-0.0206106771,
-0.2472708225,
-0.2691837251,
0.0963771045,
-0.355199337,
0.702573359,
-0.2509195805,
-0.0389498882,
0.8271127343,
-0.0646489188,
1.12459445,
-0.2141624391,
-0.2515495121,
0.2785050869,
-0.0719034895,
0.6570957303,
-0.0185441058,
-0.3618277311,
0.4250717163,
0.0477734767,
-0.3606778085,
-0.6417225599,
0.8047270179,
-0.9900900722,
-0.4421369433,
0.0527134426,
-0.7840282321,
-0.3321356475,
0.4917313159,
-0.0656805262,
-0.0655794814,
-0.1429780871,
-0.2099206448,
0.3771053851,
-0.313629508,
0.2550087869,
0.7139612436,
-0.412368685,
-0.4106221795,
1.2672656775,
0.5019145012,
0.289690733,
0.417930305,
0.2840596437,
-0.1022343412,
-0.4381472468,
-0.6408976316,
0.3414495289,
-0.9245951176,
-0.2874517739,
-0.6249831915,
-0.1955659837,
-0.2545621395,
0.0199841876,
-0.3194867373,
-0.5831270814,
-0.2246449888,
-0.0064338138,
0.6628579497,
0.5146214366,
0.0910225064,
0.3741663098,
-0.6878048778,
0.1484444737,
0.0252278112,
0.5616201162,
-0.0196945518,
-0.5121258497,
-0.5237021446,
0.0689925104,
0.0320794806,
-0.6293210387,
0.1896500587,
0.5565596819,
0.4827366471,
0.2559590042,
-0.0218631197,
0.801823616,
-0.4983442128,
0.4827947617,
0.1089152172,
-0.8531786203,
0.3608109653,
-0.1377404779,
0.0587469079,
0.4714396298,
0.3929925561,
-0.7664760351,
-0.1878598183,
-0.0788980052,
-0.6324922442,
0.8422054052,
-0.188188538,
0.274838239,
0.1061403751,
0.6007011533,
-0.0911441669,
0.2303754836,
-0.740259409,
-0.3140856922,
-0.1934330165,
-0.4074224532,
-0.3829339743,
-0.2313550413,
-0.1995768845,
-0.1731708795,
0.5953393579,
-0.717310369,
-0.0511247441,
-0.1971703321,
-0.4364528656,
-0.0205787495,
0.3895705342,
0.2767094374,
0.4504799247,
0.1684539467,
0.249309659,
0.6601778865,
-0.1525906473,
0.0571345128,
0.1592961699,
-0.2616617084,
-0.14419806,
0.3464621305,
1.0883629322,
0.323453784,
-0.4695796371,
0.0285113938,
0.0316636674,
0.11890506,
0.1097464934,
0.1990467906,
0.3684414327,
0.4413247406,
-0.2317425013,
-0.118469052,
-0.0764077529,
-0.4381638467,
-0.3003482819,
0.5335529447,
-0.6054559946,
-0.4539504349,
0.1842299998,
0.0322918668,
-0.2920917869,
0.3683323264,
-0.1846223325,
-0.5899868608,
0.280444473,
0.7024315,
0.5115138292,
-0.204885751,
0.1720316708,
0.2367518097,
0.4174914658,
0.1317354441,
0.4741082489,
0.0596643016,
-1.1888437271,
-0.5719820857,
-0.8030608296,
-0.2980846465,
-0.207515344,
-0.5630939007,
0.2980889976,
-0.4410167336,
-0.2080370784,
0.1358049214,
0.1618863493,
-1.0449726582,
0.0278910492,
0.1102432981,
0.9866572618,
-0.9108412862,
0.9159557223,
1.0484240055,
-0.3590289354,
-0.8252142072,
-0.2057283968,
-0.2613126338,
-1.2794933319,
0.727070272,
-0.2418285608,
-0.2852389812,
0.3507695496,
0.0240001883,
-0.9839714766,
0.8104358315,
0.5114091635,
-0.559171319,
0.1338376999,
0.5543224216,
0.7191116214,
-0.3616812527,
0.0372925736,
0.6034849286,
0.597096622,
-0.1183836982,
-0.8319388032,
0.0398098342,
-0.1598407626,
0.1313548237,
0.2576035559,
-0.8406655192,
0.4655435383,
-0.1823364049,
-0.0783297196,
-0.2284012288,
0.5655052662,
0.0455189683,
0.112544924,
0.4925220311,
0.5071573853,
0.9262772202,
-0.0480384938,
0.8459839225,
-0.8422567844,
0.2890023291,
1.0240288973,
-0.4421352744,
0.8211426139,
0.5662583113,
-0.3366243541,
0.7101256251,
0.4813613296,
0.1323701143,
0.5273256302,
0.2437145412,
-0.0233655013,
-0.248822853,
-0.5871223211,
-0.2211850882,
0.5551316738,
0.5907890201,
-0.2285135537,
-0.2239296585,
-0.0094522275,
0.1455848515,
-0.1801472902,
-0.5185368061,
1.1308643818,
0.2304556668,
-0.3240072727,
0.5638133883,
0.2002753019,
0.6589546204,
-0.450193584,
0.2341275811,
-0.2089283615,
0.2528455555,
-0.3575119674,
-0.8158664107,
0.3551639915,
0.0396182425,
-0.4382598698,
0.0013700534,
0.9852145314,
-0.5311951637,
-0.9211843014,
0.688716054,
0.8549307585,
0.1401442289,
0.2054336816,
-0.7102751136,
0.012749726,
-0.164502427,
-0.1093924344,
0.579357028,
0.6883401275,
-0.1140692756,
0.6346392035,
0.6042555571,
0.3847379982,
-0.0319434181,
0.3353147805,
0.9220496416,
-0.5362798572,
-0.4697313011,
-0.8678008914,
0.2332419157,
0.1215948611,
-0.0506388098,
0.874504447,
0.4114524126,
1.0434908867,
0.0521814041,
0.9462035894,
0.2096063793,
0.2833888829,
-0.5459720492,
0.8119117022,
-0.6442528963,
0.0456557609,
-0.3242531717,
-0.8245249391,
-0.3155831695,
0.4648302495,
-0.4043443203,
-0.0729035363,
0.2431245446,
0.7066155076,
-0.0202626511,
-0.354254663,
0.335583657,
0.4210595787,
0.1843817979,
0.4072522223,
0.6171809435,
-0.3100211918,
0.475723356,
-0.3028033674,
-0.0721301138,
-0.0290317498,
-0.9536792636,
-0.9429835677,
-0.3383045197,
-0.3760467768,
-0.3802766204,
0.0450644195,
0.8090234399,
0.4898682535,
-0.9866745472,
-0.3356066644,
0.2686449587,
0.5750700235,
-0.0845551938,
-0.2042831779,
0.4534725249,
-0.4895342886,
-0.6094053984,
0.3834093213,
0.4001643062,
-0.1872301996,
-0.2337632775,
-0.2050229311,
-0.0148120224,
-0.020899279,
0.9707627296,
0.1839823127,
-0.655610621,
-0.3960287273,
-0.0647387058,
0.1820640862,
0.0880998299,
0.7425926328,
-0.7254154086,
0.4643961787,
0.2897586524,
0.6178559065,
0.225267604,
-0.3949174583,
0.226982668,
-0.7759270668,
0.3085882068,
-0.1425113082,
0.5712729096,
0.4974708855,
-0.1767442822,
0.3923695087,
0.200643152,
-0.1940050125,
-0.9195617437,
0.3221196532,
-0.6993520856,
-0.1142076775,
1.2520582676,
-0.289773941,
-0.2147688419,
-0.304746449,
-0.0563637577,
0.4493984282,
-0.0338705778,
0.7116280198,
0.5988537073,
-0.1327904463,
-0.2527493536,
-0.2975058258,
0.4911582768,
0.0291323811,
-0.7304267287,
0.0480379127,
0.0694776922,
0.5079092979,
0.3139219582,
0.6212050319,
0.1167012155,
-0.1735476851,
-0.3739321232,
0.0431784652,
-0.0004483714,
0.0049970467,
-0.3586980104,
0.0480288677,
0.3864420056,
0.1350139529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01403v1 | Optimization of Retrieval-Augmented Generation Context with Outlier Detection | 2024-07-01T15:53:29 | 2024-07-01T15:53:29 | Vitaly Bulgakov | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we focus on methods to reduce the size and improve the quality
of the prompt context required for question-answering systems. Attempts to
increase the number of retrieved chunked documents and thereby enlarge the
context related to the query can significantly complicate the processing and
decrease the performance of a Large Language Model (LLM) when generating
responses to queries. It is well known that a large set of documents retrieved
from a database in response to a query may contain irrelevant information,
which often leads to hallucinations in the resulting answers. Our goal is to
select the most semantically relevant documents, treating the discarded ones as
outliers. We propose and evaluate several methods for identifying outliers by
creating features that utilize the distances of embedding vectors, retrieved
from the vector database, to both the centroid and the query vectors. The
methods were evaluated by comparing the similarities of the retrieved LLM
responses to ground-truth answers obtained using the OpenAI GPT-4o model. It
was found that the greatest improvements were achieved with increasing
complexity of the questions and answers. | [
-0.779797554,
-1.0936311483,
0.7274569273,
-0.1102261022,
-0.3567996621,
-0.3227127492,
-0.0324213915,
-0.1382192522,
0.1198989004,
0.6105573177,
-0.5085176229,
-0.3322589695,
-0.2952592373,
0.1465527117,
-0.4484417737,
0.7236967683,
0.1507469267,
-0.1165772602,
-0.6795333624,
-0.1189629287,
-0.725861609,
-0.3205020726,
-0.624466598,
0.0268931817,
0.0281699579,
0.5973098278,
0.42857939,
0.6191404462,
0.3832655251,
0.2636139095,
-0.191867426,
0.4548836648,
-0.4627101719,
0.4934667349,
-0.0436288305,
-0.3300564587,
0.0683268905,
-0.3482340574,
0.7670672536,
0.4679206312,
0.0812057629,
0.1650044471,
0.2011005878,
0.4276258349,
-0.5025066137,
-0.1335121244,
-0.618732214,
-0.1006094888,
-0.1922656149,
-0.6608355641,
-0.3164444864,
-0.6109319329,
0.0564920716,
-0.6449206471,
0.5662822723,
0.3023215532,
0.7221544385,
0.252746582,
-0.3007830679,
-0.6354191303,
-0.4016528428,
0.8730601072,
-0.4994867444,
0.1898172647,
0.244066149,
0.3721634746,
-0.5229956508,
-0.3506590128,
-0.6546730995,
0.0198931377,
-0.0548717938,
-0.0033485966,
0.0350397751,
-0.145396322,
0.3477370441,
0.1711316407,
-0.7962986827,
-0.0424879678,
-0.1249055192,
-0.2309163809,
0.4990279078,
0.1823389381,
0.3115457594,
-0.4281489551,
-0.1806561351,
-0.2784995735,
-0.8450489044,
0.0207991954,
0.5075932741,
0.2076141089,
0.4291868806,
0.5870447755,
-0.1467985809,
0.7515105605,
0.0280966908,
0.0959780291,
0.1685858816,
-0.660682261,
-0.042208001,
-0.1211522818,
0.3614048064,
0.4653840363,
-0.0085796164,
-0.0311914328,
-0.1976335198,
-0.4341759682,
0.2302898318,
-0.9934769869,
0.2581277788,
0.3977794647,
-0.5093916655,
-0.0299826991,
-0.0230001565,
-0.8586364985,
-0.3320759535,
-0.2938570082,
0.4469903708,
-0.6430110931,
-0.0666243732,
-0.3546043038,
-0.4131232798,
0.39472422,
0.36092484,
-0.7126672864,
-0.0698680207,
0.5498722196,
0.7040173411,
0.0146591617,
0.1282036006,
-0.8364601731,
0.0504389778,
-0.4045000672,
0.8833506107,
-0.726488471,
-0.7707387209,
0.1129647121,
-0.1099267006,
-0.0200956184,
-0.8461817503,
0.7225224376,
-0.798843801,
0.479270637,
-0.9004480243,
-0.7475524545,
-0.1482224017,
0.4338136613,
-0.4069048166,
1.2456028461,
0.4719829857,
-0.7360702157,
0.2622912228,
-0.6226319671,
-0.1949602216,
0.2782860398,
-0.323967129,
-0.2093400657,
0.1854278296,
0.5065938234,
0.2592711151,
-0.5540220737,
0.091343157,
0.119154118,
-0.5710945129,
0.2275003791,
-0.0429252833,
0.6428155303,
0.3480038345,
-0.0154106198,
0.0987258106,
-0.7060113549,
0.2905208468,
0.03321876,
-0.4350510538,
-0.597622633,
-0.1235905513,
-0.2060008943,
0.1968566924,
0.1916638017,
-0.7954658866,
-0.1056830063,
-0.5052863359,
0.2769594789,
0.5854744315,
0.5404905081,
0.3921866417,
-0.2857910693,
0.5749972463,
0.3833344579,
0.1472141743,
-0.3430896401,
-0.5450108051,
-0.5242874622,
-0.0503362156,
0.0146410232,
0.4234746993,
-1.2243273258,
0.6268082261,
-0.276771903,
-0.1202379465,
-0.3422123492,
0.2289435267,
0.3760423064,
1.2071820498,
0.522059679,
0.0243751388,
-0.4216776788,
-0.8369246721,
-0.3388172686,
-0.0374136902,
-0.187356025,
0.5203229785,
0.4779289961,
-0.1715283692,
1.2339248657,
-0.4562820792,
-0.123530224,
0.0176029038,
-0.1274559051,
0.145775035,
0.4442542493,
0.7059730291,
-0.8886461854,
-0.3132361174,
-0.1084517464,
-0.8080499172,
-0.1234799176,
0.2240586579,
-0.2496934235,
0.1695269644,
0.6459829807,
-0.3955324292,
0.3785897195,
-0.0003452565,
-0.2220011652,
0.1897177994,
-0.2244285941,
0.270174861,
-1.2528754473,
-0.1034356803,
-0.1266772598,
0.0826709941,
-0.5738521218,
0.0656187162,
0.1828691363,
-0.1820461452,
-0.2504596114,
0.4932772517,
-0.4365084767,
-0.1463842541,
-0.1052957401,
0.4985074103,
0.0863601491,
0.312117219,
-0.3350702226,
1.0800329447,
0.2060108334,
-0.6568801999,
0.3311585188,
0.5128982067,
-0.312630713,
0.7329331636,
-0.5586884618,
0.2204009742,
-0.7498223782,
-0.0115754222,
-1.2196013927,
-0.3123554289,
0.0950415581,
-0.6191608906,
0.2171563655,
0.017091196,
-0.4068557918,
-0.3045488596,
-0.6854431033,
0.4949506819,
0.4023579657,
-0.7182857394,
0.4911709428,
0.1906379163,
-0.221386835,
-0.5190497041,
-0.4676815867,
-0.2194988132,
-0.392993778,
-0.8577698469,
0.1836012155,
-0.1028666869,
-0.0373809077,
0.0959301218,
0.1855211407,
0.2507953048,
-0.064170979,
-0.0174650084,
-0.006614883,
-0.239458397,
0.5423333645,
0.3961242437,
0.1455377787,
0.0038285688,
-0.1354282647,
0.5220642686,
0.0098354425,
-0.2708038688,
0.1355750561,
0.7089624405,
0.296125561,
-0.2215331346,
0.6903749108,
0.4060235918,
-0.3973922431,
-0.1647638232,
-0.5395045877,
-0.2181590945,
-0.4585805833,
0.3381638229,
-0.4150388539,
-1.0212589502,
0.7792788744,
0.1264540851,
-0.107973367,
0.5094329119,
0.3779031336,
0.2337510586,
1.0902258158,
0.2253708243,
0.2427981496,
0.5806487203,
-0.2712301314,
0.1748578995,
-1.2956602573,
-0.3832768798,
-0.83111763,
0.0676675439,
-0.5960666537,
-0.4751553833,
0.704159677,
0.1519692242,
-0.3139023781,
0.0286072027,
-0.7740697861,
0.3285932243,
0.6779639721,
0.037937656,
0.0416523889,
0.2266855091,
-0.186562717,
0.1008227244,
-0.7059800029,
-0.4319528639,
1.1118408442,
-0.0224687997,
0.2685509622,
0.4154914021,
0.6788600087,
0.1143788323,
0.1396337301,
-0.4902181923,
0.5547170043,
0.2188715488,
-0.4572717547,
-0.6541400552,
-0.6252177358,
-1.0051064491,
0.3913816512,
-0.0796198547,
-0.6793800592,
0.3593053222,
-0.0892130807,
-0.4989587069,
-0.0600210316,
-0.7293934822,
0.6739466786,
0.0869950727,
-0.2200201601,
0.1721422076,
-0.5652535558,
0.2208297402,
-0.1091326699,
0.1733443886,
0.0992829651,
-0.0652738288,
0.5727022886,
-0.6609576941,
0.1549357772,
-0.4210245311,
-0.0147558386,
0.6986728311,
-0.0961979702,
0.5835641623,
0.1635075957,
-0.2363846749,
-0.3358359933,
0.1094477847,
-0.4464140832,
-0.8110565543,
0.9246039391,
-0.7533221841,
-0.6986660361,
-0.0968203172,
-0.3685956001,
-0.2907231748,
0.1960261315,
0.7357124686,
0.7498842478,
-0.148471728,
0.3751314282,
0.9106099606,
-0.5676996708,
0.577641964,
0.1872896701,
-0.0651431978,
-0.2439810634,
0.7668372989,
0.3876781464,
-0.0940154195,
0.3603107929,
0.0730354115,
-0.6952688098,
-0.7231045961,
-0.5474628806,
0.1505637914,
-0.9559610486,
-0.3751918674,
-0.6066253781,
-0.109841086,
-0.6916356087,
0.0807317346,
0.242934525,
-0.0821088776,
-0.4798558056,
0.1104819551,
0.3701238632,
0.3784364462,
0.2876620293,
0.3354350328,
-0.7927711606,
0.0676620528,
0.3750290871,
0.0469183065,
0.0759437308,
-0.6750566363,
-0.1089465469,
0.018776359,
-0.3327364624,
-0.8679193854,
0.3789126277,
0.2574285865,
0.6578688622,
0.2000041902,
0.1900254786,
0.5495140553,
-0.2783712447,
0.80661726,
-0.1818998158,
-0.6085963249,
0.9132453203,
-0.3983429074,
0.2821017504,
0.432893306,
0.2118144631,
-0.3482107818,
-0.0683837757,
-0.5205817223,
-0.9524677396,
0.4799889028,
0.1730366498,
0.1228631362,
-0.5093103647,
0.755209744,
-0.0649599954,
0.3126800656,
0.1482836157,
0.0656453967,
-0.1463329941,
-0.2079969496,
0.082208544,
-0.5200486779,
-0.0502298996,
-0.0016487284,
0.6965625882,
-0.5028161407,
0.3532672524,
0.4097554088,
-0.1458874345,
-0.2366668284,
0.2801325321,
0.7623862624,
0.7424430847,
-0.2683556676,
-0.101520054,
0.2756421566,
-0.4381688237,
-0.0414051339,
0.0720851198,
-0.4242013991,
-0.0185623746,
0.1108402312,
0.5152547359,
-0.2164716721,
-0.747756958,
0.6258623004,
-0.2156544179,
0.0920670554,
-0.409473747,
-0.0109123494,
-0.2333464473,
0.1937641501,
0.5680809617,
-0.2340634316,
0.4346699119,
-0.5378415585,
-0.058754202,
0.6367523074,
-0.2019096762,
0.0422950983,
0.4688477218,
0.1305429339,
-0.2361530364,
0.8923168778,
-0.1912974417,
-0.3879863322,
0.590598762,
0.3770273626,
0.6813849211,
-0.1393836141,
0.1094196364,
0.399779886,
0.1386937201,
0.0027599761,
0.4049177766,
-0.0895329639,
-0.8360251188,
-0.3112607896,
-0.6086782813,
-0.1887862831,
0.1558252573,
-0.7400529981,
0.0470638201,
-0.3086997271,
-0.0882073268,
-0.1925123781,
0.1405019164,
-0.6134121418,
0.2809636593,
-0.456279695,
0.7296324372,
-0.5895611644,
0.5359455347,
0.6776834726,
-0.5810466409,
-0.6253896952,
-0.0304744802,
-0.2151665837,
-0.595033586,
0.4837824404,
0.1483216584,
-0.0080904569,
0.1327733546,
-0.4703413248,
-0.9421066046,
1.1234295368,
0.309242487,
-0.2535063922,
0.0958138779,
-0.0334918685,
0.5258253813,
-0.40189448,
0.3719643354,
0.7089951634,
0.195740208,
0.279191643,
-0.4481519461,
0.2767342031,
-0.1648860425,
0.5159630179,
0.3831451237,
-0.5034451485,
0.9196456671,
0.0656576902,
-0.1915924102,
0.262488544,
0.5009742975,
0.3831585944,
0.2738318145,
0.3653095961,
0.5343497992,
0.9801216125,
-0.2503631711,
1.1738555431,
-0.1188166216,
0.1628060341,
0.719327867,
-0.1466789246,
0.6572091579,
0.5596544743,
0.2087810487,
0.3531563878,
0.7689893246,
0.3079116046,
0.4699827135,
0.2728748024,
-0.2500874996,
-0.1358937472,
-0.1979403198,
-0.5598926544,
0.1087642238,
0.5266383886,
-0.3572165668,
-0.3381547928,
0.2420998216,
-0.1215630993,
0.2323096395,
-0.3382101357,
0.7509965897,
-0.2381689101,
-0.8523008823,
0.5359857678,
-0.0543001592,
0.4902873933,
-0.1566672772,
-0.1098458171,
-0.604201138,
-0.04192679,
-0.176371634,
-0.6510387659,
0.2962709069,
-0.2181196213,
-0.2277839482,
-0.0205448605,
0.7905667424,
-0.3396862149,
-0.1954582632,
0.0209801905,
0.6120861173,
0.2776561975,
-0.2663040161,
-0.4190955758,
-0.0938014239,
-0.1152539328,
-0.2964473665,
0.4199533165,
0.7725310922,
-0.4254261553,
0.4231525064,
0.7336697578,
-0.1643348485,
0.0701297,
-0.0205952115,
1.0655628443,
-0.552955389,
-0.6666255593,
-0.545340538,
0.0907626227,
-0.3666987717,
-0.370136708,
0.862141192,
0.6732063293,
0.6982644796,
0.0637064353,
0.7399247885,
-0.0344277211,
0.8860925436,
-0.5673696399,
0.301543057,
-0.5336695313,
0.5293416381,
-0.1786031574,
-1.200024724,
-0.1251164973,
0.3225055039,
-0.2837739587,
0.2626228929,
0.499907285,
1.0649732351,
0.2925246358,
-0.0022135125,
0.4128358662,
-0.094962582,
0.4530835152,
0.4137538075,
0.9356078506,
-0.5474757552,
0.6353331208,
0.254206568,
-0.2315122634,
-0.4777469635,
-0.6970669627,
-0.7789459825,
-0.7042209506,
-0.0956723765,
-0.4380124807,
-0.0470921844,
0.7615727782,
0.3848883212,
-0.8411455154,
0.1732780337,
-0.0715788752,
0.3253338039,
0.1487943977,
-0.3001168072,
0.5181881785,
-0.5794464946,
-0.5711268187,
0.4335025251,
0.2660316825,
0.1206046864,
-0.0814366713,
0.0456812084,
-0.1818521917,
0.2275518477,
0.7161588073,
0.2844657004,
-0.5501281619,
-0.8001685143,
0.2475925237,
0.1851137131,
0.0939400047,
0.7475123405,
-0.7893357277,
0.5895255804,
0.7931381464,
0.7147919536,
0.4639637768,
0.5046182275,
0.3474149704,
-1.2084861994,
0.1174000129,
0.1800647527,
0.1744813621,
0.5617171526,
-0.6448799968,
0.4098052084,
0.0995117277,
-0.6364697814,
-0.7986785173,
0.2034721822,
-0.5691473484,
-0.3767231405,
1.1495953798,
0.0979400724,
-0.2418710738,
-0.285641551,
-0.2984701097,
0.0878418609,
-0.4154825211,
0.4458205998,
0.6320291758,
-0.4705204666,
-0.2179446965,
-0.5347774029,
0.6857372522,
0.2955406904,
-0.6847905517,
-0.2831277549,
0.6387546659,
0.2337253988,
0.3731175661,
0.4681717157,
-0.2514912188,
0.2318233401,
-0.1079303399,
-0.2628608346,
-0.0380325131,
-0.060700383,
-0.4189441502,
0.4169652164,
0.1397208124,
-0.3961260915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01394v1 | Gloss2Text: Sign Language Gloss translation using LLMs and Semantically Aware Label Smoothing | 2024-07-01T15:46:45 | 2024-07-01T15:46:45 | Pooya Fayyazsanavi, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Jana Košecká | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Sign language translation from video to spoken text presents unique
challenges owing to the distinct grammar, expression nuances, and high
variation of visual appearance across different speakers and contexts. The
intermediate gloss annotations of videos aim to guide the translation process.
In our work, we focus on {\em Gloss2Text} translation stage and propose several
advances by leveraging pre-trained large language models (LLMs), data
augmentation, and novel label-smoothing loss function exploiting gloss
translation ambiguities improving significantly the performance of
state-of-the-art approaches. Through extensive experiments and ablation studies
on the PHOENIX Weather 2014T dataset, our approach surpasses state-of-the-art
performance in {\em Gloss2Text} translation, indicating its efficacy in
addressing sign language translation and suggesting promising avenues for
future research and development. | [
-0.1927691847,
-0.667280674,
0.6001154184,
0.3017945588,
-0.4899602234,
0.0269426145,
-0.0757285729,
-0.7422248125,
0.0582066476,
0.7608225346,
-0.6617177129,
-0.6448100805,
-1.190487504,
-0.0358254015,
-0.6306011081,
0.9660590887,
-0.3101180494,
0.0457041264,
0.0232781824,
0.1641839147,
0.0749432221,
-0.3027558327,
-0.9044179916,
-0.396617353,
0.1677335054,
0.518558979,
1.1226922274,
0.4792281985,
0.7541734576,
0.2114061415,
0.0186786763,
0.3015447557,
-0.3557724655,
0.1850766987,
0.1789752394,
-0.0948261395,
-0.718619287,
-0.1769017428,
0.6675383449,
0.4882606864,
0.1088884771,
0.0608982481,
-0.3033505976,
0.3956947625,
-0.3817594349,
0.1842216104,
-0.4214428663,
-0.0004334166,
-0.45040223,
0.001891718,
-0.2284455299,
-0.0731233507,
-0.0763971508,
-0.8641647696,
-0.0196644869,
0.2035748214,
0.8103320003,
0.7112528086,
-0.8640111685,
-0.1799622625,
-0.9034102559,
0.4552850425,
-0.8928758502,
0.5920541286,
0.6008957028,
0.3581888378,
-0.2231729925,
-1.0156229734,
-0.6162831783,
0.1432880312,
0.1166208088,
0.3664611578,
0.2017486244,
0.2461249232,
0.1171085089,
0.4821772873,
-0.4251963198,
0.3244048357,
-0.1997469217,
-0.3869747519,
0.6801953912,
-0.0966177508,
0.3989633322,
0.1313049495,
-0.4486368597,
-0.259802103,
-0.4342800379,
-0.2590375841,
0.0338629782,
0.3250288367,
-0.3851338923,
0.5637962222,
-0.1279368401,
0.6720349193,
-0.4686574936,
-0.31514889,
0.289080143,
-0.3313766718,
-0.2415654808,
-0.0778020248,
0.7236568332,
0.5824081898,
0.2486771494,
-0.0227287672,
-0.4066505134,
-0.263477385,
-0.3387212753,
-0.7123181224,
-0.1908178777,
0.1408279538,
-0.0424479246,
0.0944767222,
-0.1794517338,
-0.5154302716,
-0.7231060266,
-0.3426168561,
0.3838641047,
-0.180225119,
-0.2980568111,
0.2413410693,
-0.0388777331,
0.1998662949,
0.5932811499,
-0.9706246853,
0.4754061103,
0.6650425196,
0.7756327391,
-0.1721953005,
0.0235542245,
-0.3421963751,
0.4098968804,
-0.2999936044,
0.492828846,
-0.3843743503,
-0.219274506,
0.2109620869,
-0.1749922633,
0.1322330981,
-0.30682832,
0.5480559468,
-0.5643625855,
0.147254169,
0.0793151781,
-0.4337252975,
-0.1709764302,
-0.0133975055,
-0.4114528596,
1.277376771,
0.1597881764,
-0.0976357237,
0.4175100625,
-0.4430132508,
-0.5088149309,
-0.0015177258,
0.1557244807,
-0.5760308504,
0.0119428299,
0.1390963048,
0.1535453498,
-0.3520414829,
-0.0515470542,
0.1196974143,
0.0253724698,
0.3916231394,
-0.1490359455,
0.1163667664,
0.2065208703,
-0.391836226,
0.1266730875,
-0.5183317065,
-0.1000737399,
-0.112047039,
-0.0356164612,
-0.346707046,
-0.1200026572,
0.3798577189,
0.4914818108,
0.4644795954,
-0.3333443105,
0.0817087367,
-0.4865347147,
0.0915052071,
0.4536063969,
-0.0274512228,
0.4674182832,
0.3258008361,
0.3531561196,
0.0359870717,
0.5279347897,
0.0802140832,
-0.9657440782,
-0.8992853761,
0.014599205,
0.0050430028,
0.6497846842,
-0.6982257962,
0.0301128048,
-0.1777654439,
-0.1705362201,
-0.5142665505,
0.5270708203,
0.6763114333,
0.4850829244,
0.7408846021,
-0.4534131885,
-0.455294162,
-0.773970902,
0.0206587445,
-0.1770900637,
-0.0300615542,
0.0490779467,
0.3261706829,
-0.2364678979,
0.5117800832,
-0.4478510022,
-0.5906943083,
0.0599952675,
0.0647035912,
0.1422644556,
0.1553360671,
0.2996988893,
-1.2078819275,
-0.6791402102,
0.0766382664,
-0.4986847043,
-0.3423559964,
-0.1266199797,
-0.0668464303,
0.2984883487,
0.8302028775,
-0.150753662,
0.4267260432,
0.9703025818,
-0.6587739587,
0.1694804579,
-0.1633424014,
0.2586578131,
-0.9492798448,
-0.2971566021,
-0.0879284367,
-0.4431905746,
-0.8365195394,
-0.2385441065,
-0.0502914526,
0.1497123837,
-0.5627361536,
0.6730855107,
-0.5774477124,
-0.2808659673,
-0.6127300858,
0.5683237314,
-0.1493835002,
0.0218775105,
0.2014438808,
0.8789217472,
0.6538359523,
-0.839057982,
0.3916311562,
0.5688562989,
-0.134402886,
0.3022195697,
-0.3070020378,
-0.0069448589,
0.0044125374,
0.0908394679,
-1.2151451111,
-0.3576054871,
0.6994817257,
-0.3830372691,
0.5906148553,
0.0000713465,
-0.4876641929,
-0.2538898885,
0.0921517611,
0.3034037352,
0.7838980556,
-0.350820601,
0.3623833656,
0.5066649914,
-0.2825791538,
-0.2846293151,
-0.9239494801,
0.5864224434,
-0.0766825229,
-0.6489057541,
0.5399883389,
0.038507048,
-0.2832281291,
-0.2700688839,
-0.1915482283,
-0.0716126338,
0.0594219528,
0.2932566404,
-0.0756233707,
0.0458264872,
0.1398517787,
0.0804956481,
-0.3410511613,
0.0216100868,
-0.3523447812,
0.2267964035,
0.0920747519,
-0.165994972,
-0.3480601609,
0.2055220902,
0.3171993494,
0.0769046694,
0.7349107265,
0.6917552352,
-0.2318283767,
-0.0424702466,
-0.3085521162,
-0.2686716318,
-0.4936731458,
0.4039927721,
-0.4131779969,
-0.7648557425,
0.4402927458,
-0.3515226841,
0.0175208412,
0.3395362496,
0.4329888225,
-0.1595623791,
0.9436150789,
0.6345552206,
0.4670226276,
0.6412386894,
0.0722499415,
0.2148353308,
-0.8310360909,
-0.5211694837,
-0.1683087349,
-0.1757369339,
-0.3690321147,
-0.7486698031,
0.4392879605,
0.2139328867,
-0.0340953432,
0.4757064581,
-0.3568888903,
0.0936633721,
0.279725194,
-0.042350553,
0.4590745866,
0.1317147911,
0.2112931609,
-0.2691006064,
-0.1617785245,
-0.5367695093,
0.8900148273,
0.502900064,
0.4813248515,
0.61452806,
0.3279363513,
0.3960302472,
0.3965851665,
-0.7422139049,
0.681861043,
-0.3913993537,
-0.5870788097,
-0.5326334834,
-0.1508985013,
-0.6323837638,
0.18218714,
-0.3329947591,
-0.6106707454,
-0.2131617516,
0.3382029831,
0.3577142358,
0.0410658307,
-0.5456796885,
0.7448951006,
-0.528167069,
-0.2956157327,
0.059022665,
-0.9265460968,
0.2960588336,
-0.1936981976,
0.5925893188,
-0.3197640181,
-0.6086500287,
0.7159235477,
-0.5702953339,
0.8678103685,
-0.1284438521,
-0.6546533704,
0.1580519974,
-0.1067263186,
0.5639676452,
-0.0941029862,
0.0904201418,
0.0827678517,
-0.3068724573,
-0.3494682908,
-0.630548954,
0.3651220202,
-0.633330524,
-0.5037641525,
-0.3902411461,
-0.4698747993,
-0.4307067692,
0.2297398001,
0.203908965,
0.0878049806,
-0.0856317878,
-0.6095442176,
0.6083746552,
0.0598075353,
0.3790752888,
0.6262738109,
-0.5678592324,
-0.6360176802,
0.8328752518,
-0.1236994565,
0.5357028246,
0.4420728981,
-0.1042013839,
-0.5824677944,
-0.8742421269,
-0.4218910635,
0.4825705588,
-0.8608451486,
-0.0633654743,
-0.2596459687,
0.0118750278,
-0.8825446367,
-0.0827964917,
-0.4332113266,
-0.7654914856,
-0.078914009,
-0.1742923111,
0.7088814974,
0.7052425742,
-0.1290590614,
0.8938078284,
-0.4809612334,
0.5083918571,
0.108032234,
0.3332199454,
-0.587960422,
-0.8541632891,
-0.3912680149,
0.0160526242,
-0.1171756834,
-0.8366966248,
0.2844008207,
0.5859190226,
0.3064441681,
0.388373524,
-0.0839500427,
0.5724352002,
-0.3222691119,
0.8652798533,
0.4525831938,
-0.9052634835,
0.5670526028,
-0.2727961242,
0.4052501023,
0.4556351602,
0.2543777227,
-0.8489254713,
-0.4910631776,
-0.339433223,
-1.3186049461,
0.5833611488,
0.4415366948,
-0.0567951985,
0.2252705693,
0.4881085157,
-0.1522283107,
0.1275885552,
-0.6044358015,
-0.6256553531,
-0.2605577409,
-0.1944842339,
-0.5036081672,
-0.2774614692,
-0.15680857,
-0.0591527112,
0.9807898998,
-0.031988319,
-0.0538153574,
0.1075902432,
-0.1934817433,
-0.0668707266,
0.1768082529,
0.8884788156,
0.1279144287,
-0.1404028535,
0.307667762,
0.1856923103,
-0.7837632895,
0.1300892085,
0.0794888139,
-0.5012587905,
0.0663722605,
0.2916371524,
1.0110551119,
0.3098618388,
-0.4604511857,
0.4137548208,
0.2118852437,
-0.1693530679,
-0.6279534698,
-0.1443948448,
-0.0520767048,
-0.0150030106,
0.2813358605,
-0.0893170908,
0.3665128052,
-0.4097421169,
0.276832521,
0.1160714328,
-0.6310001016,
-0.259606868,
0.9990302324,
0.3460638821,
-0.2527157068,
0.3989675939,
0.0802465528,
-0.5014147162,
0.4438912272,
0.6544555426,
0.7920197845,
-0.4519793689,
0.2590357065,
0.3250916302,
0.3445607722,
-0.1554599553,
0.241646111,
-0.0508157685,
-0.455340296,
-0.4991845787,
-0.6463612914,
-0.6589032412,
-0.1615589112,
-0.4251399934,
0.3057069182,
-0.1537483335,
-0.4645153284,
-0.2975422442,
-0.2813464701,
-0.2970257103,
0.7170724869,
0.8230268359,
0.946087122,
-1.1807368994,
0.7198505998,
0.7704129219,
-0.3204699159,
-0.3558458984,
-0.1833827794,
0.2320290357,
-0.7665761113,
0.5955080986,
-0.0730643347,
-0.4505155087,
0.3235395849,
-0.3886700571,
-1.1382217407,
0.8272222877,
0.0517777465,
-0.3612385392,
0.0446837731,
0.6348980069,
0.5445372462,
-0.2718515098,
0.2521166205,
0.7288019657,
0.9825177193,
0.6004145145,
-1.0358766317,
0.0905034915,
-0.214359507,
0.1252999306,
0.3700418174,
-0.5016484261,
0.2576293945,
-0.2198307663,
-0.338321656,
0.1313117594,
1.0471451283,
-0.1780988872,
0.6450815797,
0.1805730164,
0.3976618648,
0.6207770109,
-0.4558277428,
0.963031292,
-0.1386495829,
0.0842853189,
1.1168451309,
0.0032996163,
0.7486851215,
0.764441371,
-0.1342084408,
0.3421987295,
0.7153649926,
0.1145704016,
0.6304963231,
0.1845512539,
-0.4680531919,
-0.5093683004,
-0.345843643,
-0.3135227859,
0.2364622504,
0.8308905363,
-0.2626017034,
-0.1648142189,
0.2819305658,
0.2669714391,
0.4807727039,
-0.4192478657,
0.8316863775,
0.4523744583,
-0.5572286844,
0.5492194891,
0.109582141,
0.6153439283,
-0.7952193022,
0.0133174723,
-0.097787641,
0.1104385331,
-0.4386795461,
-0.9324584603,
0.2682497501,
-0.3395168185,
0.1934693158,
-0.557251811,
0.2952056229,
-0.6840413809,
-0.3208264709,
0.4707836807,
0.1040975973,
0.6480435133,
0.1620636135,
-0.6634388566,
0.2445970774,
-0.1063483804,
-0.3261136115,
0.1095922813,
0.2191966623,
-0.2245547473,
0.6786473989,
0.4312006533,
0.1086082831,
0.2777761221,
0.3798328936,
0.5520691276,
-0.5280785561,
-0.1741495281,
-0.5367696285,
0.6165752411,
-0.1635450721,
-0.4899631143,
1.0395624638,
0.789586544,
0.576099515,
-0.0949876979,
0.7558584213,
-0.0408711173,
0.2098389119,
-0.8843514919,
0.3000315428,
-0.5223109722,
0.1169827133,
-0.3682568669,
-0.8791218996,
-0.750010848,
0.2033353448,
-0.3875601292,
-0.0171894934,
0.6759349704,
0.7618948817,
0.1570784301,
-0.3211326003,
0.5126344562,
0.2678771615,
0.3858733475,
0.5400703549,
0.3448508382,
-1.0897605419,
0.6351824999,
-0.0382129326,
-0.2877926826,
-0.3644743562,
-0.8233625293,
-0.5858024359,
-0.920316875,
-0.8151211739,
-0.514549911,
0.1161115766,
0.2930978239,
0.6330525279,
-0.8030623794,
-0.2263650894,
-0.1286234111,
-0.0579996854,
-0.264808625,
-0.1489891261,
0.359975636,
-0.1388450861,
-0.9169045091,
0.6144737601,
0.244048357,
0.6841391325,
-0.0304780677,
-0.4589609206,
-0.0259143598,
0.1370559037,
0.5629836321,
0.4727136195,
-0.7502994537,
-0.2210202962,
-0.189805299,
-0.3422170579,
-0.0923467427,
0.5265587568,
-0.4301075637,
0.4120399654,
0.362085849,
0.0476241931,
1.0312571526,
0.2121075243,
0.5440683961,
-0.7829341888,
0.268204987,
-0.0826311931,
0.0394765325,
0.7064974308,
-0.2114704102,
0.6723737121,
0.1265540868,
-0.3491077423,
-0.5282782316,
0.5497503877,
-1.3014661074,
-0.1312816143,
1.3344079256,
0.2574861646,
-0.173530072,
-0.2960394323,
-0.1182632446,
0.3861915171,
-0.267773211,
0.4467808306,
0.5436435342,
-0.2578819096,
-0.5202860236,
-0.6677020788,
0.9515997767,
0.316906482,
-0.597695291,
0.0148356939,
0.4732564092,
0.092150338,
0.1509784609,
0.7730855346,
-0.1348583698,
0.2235156596,
-0.0180657115,
0.2576394379,
-0.2323904037,
-0.2827398479,
-0.154087007,
-0.2514122128,
0.3733570278,
0.0304768197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01393v1 | POLygraph: Polish Fake News Dataset | 2024-07-01T15:45:21 | 2024-07-01T15:45:21 | Daniel Dzienisiewicz, Filip Graliński, Piotr Jabłoński, Marek Kubis, Paweł Skórzewski, Piotr Wierzchoń | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the POLygraph dataset, a unique resource for fake news
detection in Polish. The dataset, created by an interdisciplinary team, is
composed of two parts: the "fake-or-not" dataset with 11,360 pairs of news
articles (identified by their URLs) and corresponding labels, and the
"fake-they-say" dataset with 5,082 news articles (identified by their URLs) and
tweets commenting on them. Unlike existing datasets, POLygraph encompasses a
variety of approaches from source literature, providing a comprehensive
resource for fake news detection. The data was collected through manual
annotation by expert and non-expert annotators. The project also developed a
software tool that uses advanced machine learning techniques to analyze the
data and determine content authenticity. The tool and dataset are expected to
benefit various entities, from public sector institutions to publishers and
fact-checking organizations. Further dataset exploration will foster fake news
detection and potentially stimulate the implementation of similar models in
other languages. The paper focuses on the creation and composition of the
dataset, so it does not include a detailed evaluation of the software tool for
content authenticity analysis, which is planned at a later stage of the
project. | [
-0.2598391771,
-0.98430264,
0.7033452988,
0.308149606,
-0.4788782597,
0.4542198181,
0.0324053764,
-0.5240340829,
0.5774469972,
0.6341709495,
-0.4808016717,
-0.737367034,
-0.6027024388,
0.1382167786,
-0.7084664702,
0.9524176121,
-0.0402204208,
0.2920295596,
-0.1718102843,
0.0280801281,
-0.0195028558,
-0.4079396129,
-0.012262593,
-0.1516041607,
0.1956950575,
0.3218492866,
0.5901654363,
0.4122281969,
0.2723100483,
0.1635927558,
0.269315511,
0.5397013426,
-0.5483021736,
-0.4093000591,
-0.2752723098,
-0.140181005,
-0.2898175716,
0.1924535036,
0.5863605142,
0.406206578,
0.1028338596,
0.5602177978,
-0.3672094345,
0.7649376988,
-0.4701671302,
0.3544595838,
-0.5187029243,
0.1171907336,
-0.8087643981,
0.1830714941,
-0.5940495729,
-0.5453876257,
-0.4483757913,
-0.760825336,
0.2304021865,
0.1899537593,
0.9603694081,
-0.2694686949,
-0.3930945396,
-0.2763357162,
-0.7614759207,
0.5440570712,
-0.4326759875,
0.1604913622,
0.2571401894,
0.3646605015,
-0.2013784349,
-0.7450526357,
-0.8936288357,
0.2248580903,
0.0540186428,
0.2138647139,
-0.1654509306,
-0.5553207397,
0.1073482633,
0.530033946,
-0.7480775118,
-0.2005498409,
-0.6278907657,
-0.6067079306,
0.7798300385,
0.1161043122,
0.6257672906,
-0.2335454673,
-0.3019364178,
0.0262398664,
-0.5973440409,
-0.209311828,
1.0318818092,
0.3543751538,
-0.2111833692,
0.5788775682,
-0.5615988374,
0.8285898566,
-0.3124733865,
-0.2903609276,
0.9276173115,
-0.5015851855,
0.0001786166,
0.2501320541,
1.0337074995,
0.2150043994,
0.4522084594,
-0.0012160983,
-0.1316945702,
0.295740515,
0.2455916703,
-0.1256484091,
-0.3237012923,
0.1331276149,
-0.6897894144,
-0.783912003,
0.8833397031,
-0.5684078336,
-0.3865937293,
-0.2676925063,
0.3819990158,
-0.3039309084,
-0.5563006401,
0.3718164265,
-0.3168920577,
-0.1658382565,
0.2411136925,
-0.1324865073,
0.4042753875,
0.5578052402,
0.6286935806,
-0.0783327073,
-0.1713980585,
-0.3019399643,
-0.0475766324,
-0.6097537279,
0.8863071203,
-0.3663724363,
0.1320803016,
-0.0515821911,
0.2777697146,
0.2851717174,
-0.2983179688,
0.7333445549,
-0.5658712387,
0.5439524651,
-0.3168604374,
-0.5904091001,
-0.3539629877,
0.1451081932,
-1.0758466721,
1.2571799755,
0.2964504659,
-0.9836514592,
0.4244771004,
-0.3943859637,
-0.5306246877,
0.2965538502,
0.0775460154,
-0.5030396581,
0.104627654,
0.2141250968,
-0.1094418168,
0.0510739721,
0.1760741472,
-0.2628054023,
-0.2847478092,
0.1759039611,
-0.2412300557,
1.2760829926,
-0.0319622457,
-0.1918512136,
-0.2325083464,
-0.8638398647,
-0.1093346104,
0.4220624864,
-0.0723192245,
-0.2694302201,
-0.0006147198,
0.2837203741,
0.5355521441,
0.469882071,
-1.2016479969,
0.1543671191,
-0.1040530354,
-0.1539760828,
0.2992663383,
0.1324715167,
-0.1222289577,
-0.4033440948,
0.3831794858,
0.0953702033,
0.5491556525,
-0.013619056,
-0.6646267176,
-0.4518809617,
0.0297541656,
0.5451580882,
0.728320837,
-0.8857391477,
0.401723057,
-0.2832727432,
-0.6286228299,
-0.516710043,
0.0237308852,
0.2758452296,
0.6661217809,
0.2281105071,
-0.0241834261,
-0.7501826286,
-1.036917448,
-0.3896767795,
-0.1679290682,
0.1889530122,
0.0439620502,
0.5865823627,
0.5477099419,
0.9190218449,
-0.1764892638,
-0.4858619273,
-0.2423973531,
0.1786456704,
0.5980451703,
0.0825769007,
0.6955763102,
-1.1991132498,
-0.9555392265,
-0.4239408374,
-1.0207211971,
-0.1599221379,
-0.0285242498,
0.1739112884,
0.4209240377,
0.2466681451,
-0.3278817236,
0.426240623,
0.8128783703,
-0.5356129408,
0.9229460955,
-0.0018613023,
0.2909277081,
-0.779401958,
-0.0719636232,
-0.1456090361,
-0.6220113039,
-0.6023551226,
-0.1249186769,
0.0438192375,
-0.1359966099,
-0.8216940761,
0.4021745622,
-0.2699228823,
-0.2471656948,
-0.1059722006,
0.0139660882,
0.1875571012,
-0.0393912308,
-0.0158713516,
0.6922967434,
0.7016798258,
0.076338172,
0.9064117074,
0.3012138009,
-0.769210875,
0.253933996,
-0.4651138783,
0.2176121026,
-0.1436897367,
0.4037292004,
-0.769852221,
-0.3409822285,
0.6768865585,
-0.7148330212,
-0.4483685791,
-0.1745502353,
-1.230913043,
-0.6058334708,
-0.2848225534,
-0.0559267439,
0.4091563821,
-0.3767355084,
0.3740616143,
0.549405396,
0.0597618632,
-0.4413207471,
-0.6054807901,
0.3149908781,
0.2437191755,
-0.7704579234,
0.240544796,
0.146958068,
-0.308680445,
0.5684982538,
0.1288002431,
-0.2364761829,
-0.2492331713,
0.1996190697,
0.310419023,
-0.2267964184,
0.0377134345,
-0.1742276996,
0.0437426306,
-0.0901411921,
-0.2339633852,
0.6233674884,
-0.1816604733,
-0.3487231135,
-0.6971114278,
0.2650095522,
0.786119163,
-0.1211299598,
1.0842175484,
0.7806978822,
-0.3098196983,
-0.2015607059,
-0.3957393169,
0.2104675472,
-0.3528758883,
-0.107847251,
-0.1109025329,
-0.126697436,
0.5576147437,
0.1859290153,
-0.3318884969,
0.5567384958,
0.6957315803,
-0.0355440155,
0.8844060898,
0.3923675418,
-0.3506014943,
0.2770969868,
-0.117053397,
0.2120575458,
-0.1034268513,
-0.5191255212,
-0.1216002926,
-0.1597119272,
-0.3879010379,
-0.3119781017,
0.2835205197,
-0.3379125893,
0.1641125232,
0.1975092888,
-0.4145482481,
0.7219420671,
0.6134274006,
0.4338824451,
0.6262331009,
0.3254883289,
0.1342946142,
0.0300396923,
-0.5841367245,
-0.5943241119,
1.1210906506,
0.0492789261,
0.3307888508,
0.0571528748,
0.3765633404,
0.8309180737,
-0.0102412524,
-0.5122722983,
0.4638803899,
-0.4694622159,
-0.8473042846,
-0.3699721992,
-0.30303213,
-0.4523161054,
-0.0660062358,
-0.4412732422,
-0.2781514227,
0.1256088614,
0.0472999737,
0.07515385,
0.673743844,
-0.411277324,
0.6439370513,
-0.1223723143,
-0.058236286,
-0.2615762353,
-0.4020037353,
0.2909204364,
-0.3553647995,
0.5805204511,
-0.44186759,
0.0063724378,
0.3699819744,
-0.317610532,
0.7386549711,
-0.277738899,
0.2812007964,
0.3271945417,
0.1707533598,
0.4826335907,
-0.0363477953,
-0.2699438334,
0.4052233994,
-0.319780618,
-0.6487768292,
-0.1015360206,
0.3141098917,
-0.4932378531,
-0.0537537746,
-0.5263789892,
-0.5921289921,
0.0036463747,
0.6303519607,
0.4600681067,
0.6073539853,
-0.3251572847,
0.1991350651,
0.5411834121,
-0.1653429568,
0.1990863383,
0.7715980411,
-0.2622294426,
-0.2809231281,
1.0245207548,
0.2806687951,
-0.0965834484,
-0.0811512768,
0.062109556,
-0.1086896062,
-0.3843190968,
-0.5058658123,
0.4032580554,
-0.3173689544,
-0.0756340921,
-0.2524581552,
-0.3395516574,
-0.4272458255,
0.2615250647,
-0.6436572075,
-0.556581974,
-0.0404575951,
-0.035898298,
0.2323138118,
0.8817408085,
-0.1768575758,
0.0204952788,
-0.5149732232,
0.7286633253,
-0.0723958984,
0.4451124966,
-0.5968124866,
-0.1740804315,
-0.2354394197,
0.2070166916,
0.0016596509,
-1.019299984,
0.3988460898,
0.00743401,
0.5033777356,
0.2124438584,
0.5056179166,
-0.1532214433,
-0.3650596142,
0.8885830641,
-0.1304664463,
-0.9120101929,
0.6604505777,
-0.7915529013,
-0.1317887306,
0.4823332131,
0.651245594,
-0.297996819,
-0.6344215274,
-0.9184299111,
-0.5393356681,
0.6128888726,
0.3423365057,
0.3059361875,
0.003097283,
0.0624139272,
0.2020613253,
0.3127763569,
-0.9391277432,
-0.3001470566,
-0.2969030142,
-0.3800862432,
0.4520085752,
-0.4198420644,
-0.2893138826,
-0.1711734533,
0.9210557342,
0.085405387,
-0.0221649949,
0.2013663501,
-0.3605383933,
-0.0606341846,
-0.3175927997,
0.5878320336,
1.2900923491,
-0.16466932,
-0.0261160526,
-0.2429521829,
-0.5293455124,
-0.0496678986,
-0.3558239639,
-0.4023723602,
0.6328696609,
0.4779230356,
0.5925530791,
-0.2992630899,
-0.6114708781,
1.045050025,
0.033196155,
-0.3817124069,
-1.057513833,
-0.249980092,
-0.1753561646,
-0.0961941406,
0.5425935388,
-0.28963992,
0.1693304777,
-0.5360158086,
0.4890395701,
-0.0293927677,
-0.4429203272,
-0.3824309111,
0.288867414,
0.0843755826,
-0.3083722591,
0.9090285301,
-0.2708628476,
-0.6848802567,
0.6331266761,
0.5576556325,
0.083906211,
-0.0205157436,
0.8362223506,
0.2115332931,
0.5579280257,
-0.2538123429,
0.4155406356,
0.4289751053,
-1.1116091013,
-0.4584419727,
-0.3228644729,
-0.2232910693,
0.4084239006,
-0.6835832,
0.4745176136,
-0.3751392365,
0.000313715,
0.0271891113,
0.107702598,
-0.115979746,
0.0684886649,
0.4537987709,
1.2206053734,
-1.6794567108,
0.9190080762,
0.6471129656,
-0.3536320329,
-0.3741217852,
-0.1472990811,
0.4419643879,
-0.7854540944,
0.5175530314,
-0.1588069201,
0.0548936762,
-0.244470045,
-0.6367071271,
-0.6083022952,
0.5491561294,
0.5434744358,
-0.4095687568,
0.1120345891,
0.4875336587,
0.4144635797,
-0.3115785718,
-0.4685712457,
0.2557611167,
0.7178259492,
-0.3221853971,
-0.7308078408,
-0.1598764062,
-0.3359849453,
-0.4614877105,
0.2435617447,
-0.8330120444,
0.9058752656,
0.3830031455,
-0.0566381253,
-0.2021919191,
0.350202769,
0.0592413247,
0.4225384593,
0.5850226283,
0.6366083622,
0.6071050167,
-0.1619357467,
1.1326960325,
-0.4011335671,
0.6631820798,
1.0498139858,
0.0696456283,
0.3214422464,
0.2123741359,
0.0449082665,
1.0257260799,
0.5507925749,
-0.7012751102,
0.4355793297,
-0.226875186,
-0.2270142287,
-0.4601410627,
-0.3426935077,
-0.0901302025,
0.5651495457,
0.3371656239,
-0.476380378,
-0.3986544013,
0.1840603799,
0.1240386814,
0.2693777084,
-0.2670304179,
0.5280565023,
-0.3283109665,
0.1186533347,
-0.1024707779,
-0.1304793209,
0.0476616099,
-0.4114296138,
-0.0790422782,
-0.0437386148,
-0.1983021945,
-0.3964596987,
-1.1452775002,
0.4479231536,
-0.0536270887,
-0.5048502088,
-0.3501756489,
0.9581418037,
-0.2976799607,
-0.8461744785,
0.1840173453,
0.571087718,
0.3368088901,
-0.2628029287,
-0.8147013187,
0.2028867006,
-0.1264706701,
-0.1331924349,
-0.0269981306,
0.3872237802,
-0.1789938658,
0.4247128069,
0.8023397923,
0.7314376831,
-0.0298462249,
0.0773700252,
0.5582326651,
-0.187099874,
-0.7116125226,
-0.6151385903,
0.3457606435,
-0.698043108,
-0.1100762188,
1.0278348923,
1.0394722223,
0.8995094299,
-0.1524196565,
0.8194628954,
-0.3081146479,
0.8763812184,
-0.4188060164,
0.8255872726,
-0.2689644396,
-0.087010704,
-0.0982430428,
-0.7879434228,
-0.2945231497,
0.2233585566,
-0.1757685095,
-0.4421563447,
0.4611364305,
0.611371398,
-0.3836073577,
-0.1220723689,
0.2781496942,
0.2691262066,
-0.0927138552,
0.1187679097,
0.7257714868,
-0.5346053839,
0.455022186,
-0.507509172,
-0.0142874541,
-0.2743879855,
-0.8425264955,
-0.5996087193,
-0.5662895441,
-0.3540169895,
-0.5619172454,
0.1589270085,
0.4405969977,
0.9131309986,
-0.9025061727,
0.0469983071,
0.0474856012,
0.3448488116,
-0.0421271585,
-0.3301811218,
0.3817948699,
-0.0345093161,
-0.5308535099,
0.2943639755,
0.1382401884,
-0.0417403542,
-0.1861768663,
0.4305363894,
-0.1291226,
0.1118889302,
0.3965153396,
0.2793480158,
-0.4212873578,
-0.403483063,
-0.1924312413,
0.0216836054,
0.1347970963,
0.7885355353,
-0.8840484619,
0.560639739,
0.6569673419,
-0.0444647782,
0.6529121399,
0.2008633316,
0.4558179975,
-1.0424804688,
0.6461315155,
0.1029509455,
0.2056073695,
0.2719272375,
-0.5416093469,
0.4846933782,
0.7212118506,
-0.0777497366,
-0.9861694574,
0.0998160392,
-0.9020946026,
-0.4342984557,
0.824206233,
-0.034760721,
-0.4979795814,
-0.631580472,
0.1443699449,
0.1305732727,
-0.2722730637,
0.8713213205,
1.0160559416,
-0.2376578599,
0.0919717699,
-0.6983658075,
0.388032347,
-0.2593917549,
-0.888554275,
-0.0908454359,
0.4857110679,
0.6784275174,
0.2817834914,
0.5611945391,
-0.6647591591,
0.4828372002,
0.1675166935,
0.0935846493,
-0.543168962,
-0.6647301912,
0.0448233634,
0.2666097879,
-0.6010374427,
-0.1454712451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01384v1 | Free-text Rationale Generation under Readability Level Control | 2024-07-01T15:34:17 | 2024-07-01T15:34:17 | Yi-Sheng Hsu, Nils Feldhus, Sherzod Hakimov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Free-text rationales justify model decisions in natural language and thus
become likable and accessible among approaches to explanation across many
tasks. However, their effectiveness can be hindered by misinterpretation and
hallucination. As a perturbation test, we investigate how large language models
(LLMs) perform the task of natural language explanation (NLE) under the effects
of readability level control, i.e., being prompted for a rationale targeting a
specific expertise level, such as sixth grade or college. We find that
explanations are adaptable to such instruction, but the requested readability
is often misaligned with the measured text complexity according to traditional
readability metrics. Furthermore, the quality assessment shows that LLMs'
ratings of rationales across text complexity exhibit a similar pattern of
preference as observed in natural language generation (NLG). Finally, our human
evaluation suggests a generally satisfactory impression on rationales at all
readability levels, with high-school-level readability being most commonly
perceived and favored. | [
-0.2897711098,
-0.8443561196,
0.7955358028,
0.3655143976,
-0.3170769513,
-0.3778845966,
-0.1944546402,
-0.3203756511,
-0.1937488467,
0.4241169393,
-0.577878952,
-0.419426918,
-0.4331754744,
0.4177920818,
-0.4461484253,
0.9164834619,
-0.2638244927,
-0.2552446425,
-0.4626321793,
0.1652298719,
-0.461281687,
-0.4968213141,
-0.5199291706,
-0.5437713265,
0.918720603,
0.3451218605,
0.9738847613,
0.8320509791,
0.2435801178,
0.242746219,
-0.2250194252,
-0.0509732179,
-0.4701246917,
0.2643188536,
-0.3834842145,
-0.5721703768,
-0.4438702166,
0.1656833142,
0.4903740883,
0.7589945197,
0.1413806081,
-0.26345402,
0.0672014505,
0.7400000095,
-0.5823712945,
-0.1280721724,
-0.6613889933,
-0.1471988112,
0.1887138337,
-0.2909513414,
-0.8150449991,
-0.2645199299,
0.4347120821,
-0.7887536883,
0.270124048,
0.1716418415,
0.8575974703,
0.355353862,
-0.5135674477,
-0.5552595854,
-0.7442443371,
0.9054008722,
-0.8502191901,
0.3921076953,
0.4887899756,
0.0782073811,
-0.2895558476,
-0.3221059144,
-0.7981188297,
-0.4935040176,
-0.1690009236,
-0.0470146202,
-0.2608044446,
0.2008112818,
0.49858585,
0.3893027604,
-0.5422663093,
0.1324893832,
-0.0697582811,
-0.0822857916,
0.548699677,
0.0325987749,
0.4133287072,
-0.4207519293,
-0.311761409,
-0.0128362039,
-0.4499620497,
0.2032754272,
0.447399199,
0.2378599346,
0.0852472559,
0.7853249907,
-0.2804190814,
0.5130252838,
0.111189276,
-0.0567053594,
-0.1485864669,
-0.3790058494,
-0.4276618659,
-0.0545280166,
0.5800142884,
0.4485203028,
0.4487641454,
-0.2198835611,
-0.4550811648,
0.0942074805,
0.3455449939,
-0.8572779894,
0.0617071129,
0.3868999183,
-0.4395154119,
-0.387473613,
-0.1295211613,
-0.6907618046,
-0.5206032395,
-0.713406682,
0.4569482505,
-0.5150750279,
-0.0592032559,
0.3985113502,
-0.0168922506,
0.2059617341,
0.4966340363,
-1.1385575533,
0.0115667107,
0.5186273456,
0.6398741007,
-0.2612376511,
-0.1518825144,
-0.2915935516,
0.1404852569,
-0.364148438,
0.8468715549,
-0.6008355021,
-0.2218812406,
-0.1323781163,
-0.1489785016,
-0.3416357338,
-0.4020824134,
0.5728647709,
-0.4075546563,
0.4465669692,
-0.1503993422,
-0.6514487267,
-0.3042120934,
0.1241777018,
-0.5733785033,
0.5951555967,
-0.0217641536,
-0.8455517292,
0.6390177011,
-0.6015831828,
-0.2522729635,
-0.1441765726,
0.0793201551,
-0.0332476608,
0.2795521021,
0.3161408305,
0.3616413772,
-0.2163829952,
0.1971935779,
-0.1700790077,
-0.1739751697,
0.4856279194,
-0.7603549957,
0.6791687012,
0.076646179,
-0.4806192815,
0.6013604999,
-0.8731179237,
0.0406610034,
0.0145198731,
-0.4641247392,
-0.4697108269,
0.245184496,
-0.2928081155,
0.1509293318,
0.1459782124,
-0.2763334811,
0.0878211111,
-0.5314202309,
0.3398420811,
0.6232569814,
0.1808663607,
0.6827335358,
-0.4466302991,
0.5770015121,
0.007603412,
0.0686827078,
-0.0824374035,
-0.2815288305,
-0.8090922832,
-0.1567839831,
-0.0367094688,
0.6238055825,
-0.4719819427,
0.3086538017,
0.1748092026,
-0.3947851062,
-0.3108530045,
0.1218950078,
0.2961107194,
0.5527950525,
0.4201462269,
0.3327269256,
-0.222556904,
-0.8834357858,
-0.5463238358,
-0.0824818611,
-0.3130837381,
0.0953370258,
0.4842837155,
-0.3914253414,
0.7912552357,
-0.1473537832,
0.2094120681,
-0.3919138312,
0.1101816744,
0.2086905092,
0.3904911578,
0.3049965203,
-0.5487893224,
-0.0968329608,
-0.1914490163,
-0.5361553431,
-0.3617385328,
-0.3581750393,
-0.3011053801,
0.46015504,
0.4503699243,
-0.4588548541,
0.6018332839,
0.2910011113,
-0.5816133618,
0.6318004131,
-0.368542999,
0.0139050176,
-0.7762950659,
-0.0579041801,
0.1323307306,
0.0013970962,
-0.7137411237,
0.0527724884,
0.0215508491,
0.1427687109,
-0.0346403383,
0.48392874,
-0.2833955288,
0.1353789717,
-0.1984116733,
0.4182557464,
0.1487873048,
0.1651616693,
-0.1232463866,
0.6696796417,
0.2187810242,
-0.6542132497,
-0.0344872065,
0.0086592901,
-0.2661978304,
0.3119879067,
-0.801218152,
-0.0475903936,
-0.4358080924,
0.2288349718,
-1.0381829739,
-0.5801166892,
-0.0010649549,
-0.3244925439,
-0.1789892614,
0.2678169906,
-0.2302146554,
-0.1236614659,
-0.1702169925,
0.1999566108,
0.1705547571,
-0.5728735924,
0.6061865091,
-0.1724933982,
-0.0011119409,
-0.507709384,
-0.5180062056,
-0.2639722526,
-0.159665063,
-0.7084950805,
-0.0866841376,
-0.4091061354,
-0.5789974332,
-0.3604443669,
-0.3072141707,
-0.1519616097,
0.1838787049,
0.2375879884,
0.4137533605,
-0.3085764647,
0.1052004993,
0.3926167786,
0.0246400498,
0.2472611815,
-0.0770851821,
0.4887983799,
0.0261396319,
-0.0634263977,
-0.6186493039,
0.2737947106,
0.691818893,
-0.0333043672,
0.6983183026,
0.0730207488,
-0.4901106656,
-0.4349761009,
-0.3214915991,
-0.26195243,
-0.4550583363,
0.0796115398,
-0.4493606687,
-0.9062681198,
0.4427075684,
0.392603308,
0.355969131,
0.6641306281,
0.5498670936,
0.0847912282,
1.3123476505,
0.3165232539,
0.5480211377,
0.3541953564,
0.1669744998,
0.3802793026,
-0.3440224826,
-0.2581698298,
-0.7442269921,
-0.2310554981,
-0.5640015006,
-0.2300361395,
-0.2540120482,
0.7263535261,
-0.2490260005,
-0.0096099712,
-0.5357472301,
0.8885216117,
0.2423655093,
-0.2234762609,
0.5514361858,
0.0644101873,
-0.3588265777,
-0.2119190246,
-0.4886719882,
-0.9074967504,
0.7135133147,
0.5105856061,
0.5532537699,
0.1175114438,
0.637776792,
-0.0870244503,
0.4993124008,
-1.0358713865,
0.5335524082,
-0.2763895392,
-0.6824052334,
-0.5575349331,
-0.508226037,
-0.872605443,
0.3579894006,
-0.3974788785,
-0.7741392255,
0.2540869117,
0.281193912,
-0.2013118714,
0.1895804852,
-0.8351240754,
0.797444582,
-0.0271821767,
-0.2561443448,
-0.2813490629,
-0.3747956157,
0.4396960437,
-0.1148014143,
0.3474634886,
-0.1198232695,
-0.1110086292,
0.5262719393,
-0.2969411016,
0.6328411102,
-0.0443617441,
-0.4776352644,
0.1350562274,
0.4260507226,
0.2532878518,
0.2795947492,
-0.2756366134,
-0.2305441499,
-0.060954459,
-0.4806348979,
-0.7502471805,
0.6667230725,
-0.7966917753,
-0.7983612418,
-0.2461476475,
-0.9161205888,
-0.2543086112,
0.4795169532,
0.2752874196,
0.441702038,
0.0992684439,
0.3182875216,
0.8454464674,
-0.3557418883,
0.2566708326,
0.3383994997,
-0.4993372262,
-0.3938610554,
0.7795239091,
0.1117742732,
0.5194767714,
0.3171991706,
0.554499805,
-0.4289439321,
-0.6857514381,
-0.3803678453,
0.2096094787,
-0.5908936858,
0.3122005165,
-0.4643009901,
-0.1512767226,
-0.2850092649,
-0.5305221081,
0.2429133803,
-0.5160528421,
-0.614770174,
-0.290997088,
0.0977300629,
1.0805466175,
0.1244453862,
0.3885172904,
-0.5102312565,
0.2839812338,
0.2955085933,
0.4329019785,
0.1105012745,
-0.6418226957,
0.1263707131,
-0.0309261363,
-0.3040163219,
-0.9345320463,
0.1752018481,
-0.238720715,
0.3546004295,
0.5685053468,
0.0913884938,
0.2340154946,
-0.2251460701,
0.7217532992,
0.1917911172,
-1.1459783316,
0.367834121,
-0.6162030697,
0.4733532369,
0.4450262785,
0.4928155541,
-0.3877269924,
-0.6588847041,
-0.4830842614,
-0.8368875384,
0.4832651913,
0.127074942,
0.1673590988,
-0.0957666039,
0.715749681,
0.2231820971,
0.0010156813,
-0.8524321914,
0.1268985569,
-0.4318640232,
-0.1385108083,
-0.0302303117,
-0.4823773205,
0.0462485589,
-0.0472400486,
0.4888876975,
-0.0211655274,
-0.0549441054,
0.4700356424,
-0.0476367772,
-0.3673104644,
0.7577208281,
1.0054010153,
0.9468878508,
-0.2381477207,
0.2034416646,
-0.0295070205,
-0.3231987953,
0.1311386526,
-0.1044760421,
-0.5131058693,
-0.0968833789,
0.5361283422,
0.9335570931,
-0.0474741757,
-0.5289682746,
0.3177819252,
-0.0956648588,
-0.7984678149,
0.0786921978,
0.385582298,
0.0992757604,
0.1701216996,
0.2792198062,
-0.1020524725,
-0.1765493602,
-0.2537679672,
0.0371061973,
0.2543871999,
-0.2742549181,
-0.184385702,
0.8547090292,
0.0979292989,
-0.3589259386,
0.4474446177,
-0.0636061952,
-0.2465874851,
0.5274683237,
0.7922251225,
0.7021938562,
-0.0595191121,
0.210717082,
0.5353503227,
0.5919079781,
-0.1168594137,
0.3489516079,
0.2297525406,
-0.769310534,
-0.7506716847,
-0.637352109,
-0.4677538574,
0.3513152897,
-0.4526001215,
0.0006461678,
-0.7774742842,
0.0088553689,
0.2570589483,
-0.1735876948,
-0.1844548732,
0.5193698406,
-0.1737156361,
1.0601648092,
-0.5644420981,
0.5104579926,
0.4107833803,
-0.5429288745,
-1.0873562098,
0.2719844878,
-0.1141518652,
-0.3892475367,
0.5275502801,
0.3496334553,
-0.1146805733,
-0.0372130945,
-0.6120231748,
-0.6322963238,
0.8144478798,
0.3260177672,
-0.7446644306,
-0.3813766539,
0.0328265354,
0.6868689656,
-0.2438111305,
0.1377955079,
0.7265810966,
0.7644284964,
0.0523721576,
-0.6340808272,
0.1683437377,
0.0175215751,
-0.088831827,
0.2941170037,
-0.1704078615,
0.6775388718,
-0.3937555254,
-0.1361970752,
0.0078538992,
0.7675393224,
0.1810510457,
0.3935341537,
0.8648049235,
0.4316280782,
0.8793224096,
-0.0500317551,
1.1822057962,
-0.0086800735,
0.0087368386,
0.7825314403,
0.0030417661,
0.9049761295,
0.5816882849,
0.1176449358,
0.6093458533,
0.4441702664,
0.3241876364,
0.0112176798,
0.4517133534,
-0.262938112,
-0.4341290593,
-0.052383393,
0.0318478458,
0.1972981095,
0.2483386099,
-0.4206953645,
-0.1064168513,
-0.092037566,
0.0901338235,
0.2994711697,
-0.4851763248,
0.6638498306,
-0.0145810563,
-0.8130694628,
0.8284783363,
-0.0075735841,
0.446916908,
-0.4623956084,
0.2193357348,
-0.2715294361,
0.0980472639,
-0.4309996068,
-0.7647108436,
0.3834565282,
0.2102992088,
-0.7277694941,
-0.2789267898,
0.7127670646,
-0.4007937312,
-0.1651219577,
0.3112739325,
0.4579654634,
0.1003189608,
0.0984065384,
-0.3551238477,
-0.1936445385,
0.2927826941,
-0.6049051881,
0.2939926088,
0.658112824,
-0.2370912731,
0.5914216042,
0.8361154199,
-0.0325008258,
0.1865623742,
0.2699151039,
0.5730113983,
-0.5980583429,
-0.2059775889,
-0.7651045322,
0.4941446483,
0.0577515066,
-0.5067474246,
0.6245913506,
0.3473311067,
0.7505369782,
0.0294416044,
0.7378789783,
0.3018973172,
0.5104441643,
-0.5893015265,
0.6569398642,
-0.6885446906,
0.1868965775,
-0.1969573498,
-1.0005197525,
-0.5779950023,
0.6815940738,
-0.6298689842,
-0.0918866545,
0.9634325504,
0.611987412,
0.1893093288,
0.3881440461,
0.3537736237,
0.3080667257,
0.3108740151,
0.2681283057,
0.8288504481,
0.1853991747,
0.5298911333,
-0.0689312965,
-0.4083746374,
-0.0040871385,
-1.0197585821,
-1.1005315781,
-0.2082471251,
0.0027187571,
-0.6525934935,
-0.2228067964,
0.944943428,
0.0357220992,
-0.7740420103,
-0.1909942478,
-0.4410417378,
0.3249562085,
0.1090571433,
-0.2906935513,
0.093069233,
-0.537969768,
-0.6961618066,
0.3974665403,
0.1539904624,
0.1975442469,
-0.2557111979,
0.0161831249,
-0.0384358987,
0.6666734815,
0.6686788797,
0.0577920564,
-0.8274117112,
-0.4096571207,
0.249777779,
-0.3978048563,
-0.1079882085,
1.1400024891,
-0.3313651383,
0.3295061588,
0.8788248301,
0.5793983936,
-0.1325509846,
0.1099801287,
0.5633738637,
-0.2718802392,
-0.0634906739,
0.1577959806,
0.1581178308,
0.0388488472,
-0.2825437784,
0.1850528121,
0.1703390926,
-0.8359199762,
-0.752813518,
0.1902866811,
-0.9993112087,
-0.4454087019,
1.272896409,
0.0312431399,
-0.1642681062,
-0.1219763234,
-0.4255202711,
0.2403655052,
-0.5201038122,
0.8072523475,
1.0326346159,
-0.0853098705,
-0.1558632553,
-0.562830925,
0.568939209,
0.6431549191,
-1.005112648,
0.5054636002,
0.7612687945,
0.1366412193,
0.0345451981,
0.3452430069,
0.0047184639,
0.1833814681,
-0.2918663621,
-0.1819916666,
0.136240989,
-0.3938426077,
-0.3252473772,
0.0984197706,
0.3117726445,
0.5275876522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01376v1 | Badllama 3: removing safety finetuning from Llama 3 in minutes | 2024-07-01T15:29:45 | 2024-07-01T15:29:45 | Dmitrii Volkov | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | We show that extensive LLM safety fine-tuning is easily subverted when an
attacker has access to model weights. We evaluate three state-of-the-art
fine-tuning methods-QLoRA, ReFT, and Ortho-and show how algorithmic advances
enable constant jailbreaking performance with cuts in FLOPs and optimisation
power. We strip safety fine-tuning from Llama 3 8B in one minute and Llama 3
70B in 30 minutes on a single GPU, and sketch ways to reduce this further. | [
-0.502818048,
-1.066255331,
0.4977174103,
0.2764678299,
-0.9217203259,
0.0717239901,
0.2090248913,
-0.9518249631,
-0.1256873012,
0.7544648647,
-0.3905528188,
-0.3308445215,
-0.5200105906,
-0.2159959078,
-0.3869020939,
1.1272844076,
-0.259344995,
-0.1280726194,
0.563033998,
0.0037442483,
-0.7703900933,
-0.3729985058,
-0.8801002502,
-0.4390464723,
0.3551742435,
0.8036075234,
0.9535714388,
0.8789219856,
0.7303183675,
0.1870000362,
-0.3101441264,
0.1227937043,
-0.8335266709,
-0.1774922609,
-0.1032643467,
-0.6310663223,
-0.6457107067,
0.0068654013,
0.0928651989,
-0.144547835,
-0.2212706059,
0.3271240294,
-0.2547528744,
0.8544282317,
-1.1213316917,
-0.0181795191,
-0.7558826208,
0.0240134746,
-0.6562459469,
-0.2878278196,
-0.2137456685,
-0.7782271504,
-0.4777568579,
-0.7724912763,
0.1420702785,
0.1862378418,
0.9436896443,
0.6968414783,
-0.0060204049,
-0.0982899144,
-0.6815593839,
0.6656680107,
-0.5605296493,
-0.2680227458,
0.7996833324,
0.2791008949,
-0.2023694217,
-0.3586814106,
-0.4504941404,
0.1257543117,
0.2393339872,
-0.187067166,
-0.412637949,
0.3139801025,
0.4483355284,
0.3547291458,
-0.1572788507,
0.658310473,
-1.0329141617,
-0.166300267,
0.8495749831,
0.2741833925,
0.1975107491,
-0.0391422659,
-0.2853405774,
0.0963158086,
-1.5329482555,
-0.1239457056,
0.6198254228,
-0.0102887172,
-0.1708756387,
0.4557563066,
0.0258219969,
0.7064334154,
0.018207673,
-0.4182930887,
0.0726498067,
-0.07998164,
-0.4660743773,
0.1455942541,
0.5696886182,
0.8679156899,
0.2934168279,
-0.1438549906,
-0.0497338213,
0.1620229185,
0.4463837445,
-0.9207943082,
-0.3614277542,
0.260849297,
-0.4197837114,
-0.6088299155,
-0.1510989666,
-0.7148945332,
-0.5639995933,
0.034591902,
0.5011083484,
-0.4181632996,
0.0835468546,
0.4458917081,
-0.006544977,
0.4672020078,
0.288710624,
-0.9328576922,
0.3858307302,
0.9031245112,
0.8137554526,
-0.0081877103,
-0.1501916349,
-0.6742538214,
0.2699263394,
-0.5285125971,
0.4680604041,
-0.0034164998,
-0.5813723207,
-0.4332655072,
-0.2157147974,
0.2987571657,
-0.8316479921,
0.3884753287,
-0.7569257021,
-0.5368438363,
-0.2126471847,
-0.1498929858,
-0.6145871878,
0.0097247493,
-0.7705016136,
0.5333890319,
-0.1206376553,
-0.4004715383,
0.4564467967,
-0.6334017515,
-0.7413238883,
-0.1782324612,
0.4499495327,
-0.7963754535,
0.230475083,
0.3832815886,
0.5453130603,
-0.3564958274,
-0.0150855556,
-0.5099590421,
-1.0259591341,
-0.0624137744,
-0.1308702379,
0.7589672804,
0.7455696464,
-0.412800312,
-0.1792084873,
-0.7522246242,
-0.1995368153,
0.0519261509,
-0.189066112,
-0.1894914806,
0.1008656025,
-0.0095781237,
0.1355217546,
0.2139038146,
-0.6463758349,
0.1826588213,
-0.6514382958,
0.8411564827,
0.9798988104,
0.1426306218,
0.0883568749,
-0.392293334,
0.2204454988,
-0.0638688952,
0.5931992531,
0.4411576688,
-0.3590739667,
-0.8202277422,
-0.2031313032,
-0.1175191626,
0.4823902845,
-0.4750471115,
-0.0876319185,
0.3564548194,
-0.7145106196,
-0.5739803314,
0.7225682735,
0.7531490326,
0.188291356,
0.7330031395,
-0.2135346085,
-0.4920744896,
-1.0973796844,
-0.2956385612,
-0.2230361253,
0.2148437202,
-0.1194913834,
0.3625490367,
-0.0596305504,
0.257892698,
-0.5087789297,
-0.321279496,
-0.1605485231,
-0.0950171798,
0.1693044752,
0.9122668505,
0.6820733547,
-0.387820214,
0.1002597883,
-0.1267959028,
-0.7737418413,
0.0521686338,
0.0623785891,
0.2109967917,
0.1395097077,
0.8298201561,
-0.5484541655,
0.642634213,
0.1994216293,
-0.1598939896,
0.4391029775,
-0.2684373856,
0.1222098842,
-0.6289498806,
-0.1917109638,
-0.0436604507,
-0.1729735732,
-0.5910742879,
0.8180148602,
0.2601439953,
-0.0831571594,
-1.0188839436,
0.3639441133,
-0.2263322026,
0.0605440512,
-0.342279017,
0.0616060048,
-0.2118033022,
0.3442217708,
-0.5054857731,
0.9318110943,
0.2796410918,
-0.696829021,
0.0622297861,
-0.0161932018,
-0.4375188053,
0.1372354031,
-0.8351017833,
0.3093991876,
0.1048566848,
0.0472378954,
-0.7183968425,
-0.3827667236,
0.3712873459,
0.2418818474,
0.0856786072,
-0.2033492029,
-0.6339151859,
-0.3677684069,
-0.5638082623,
0.708440125,
0.4878504574,
-0.7393780947,
0.0674994588,
0.5152017474,
0.2696065903,
-0.4752312303,
-0.6794376373,
0.0279187448,
-0.7046994567,
-0.3809729815,
0.5168372393,
0.0695653185,
-0.5638225079,
-0.5482232571,
-0.2555759549,
-0.1215186566,
0.8092464805,
0.6429156661,
0.2437847108,
0.2078257948,
-0.2225821763,
0.1535499692,
-0.3117825091,
0.0164326094,
0.4346554577,
0.4319092035,
-0.5227655172,
-0.3142662048,
-0.9371520877,
-0.1008019373,
0.6176478267,
0.0258062761,
0.3149302602,
0.3260245621,
-0.4871307909,
0.2492048442,
-0.7070060968,
0.1648477316,
-0.5440137386,
-0.0776819959,
-0.3945102692,
-0.8424895406,
0.6205894947,
0.1215242445,
0.216795668,
0.4558437467,
0.4582999945,
-0.136818856,
0.7755778432,
0.7603533268,
-0.3488947451,
0.4180215895,
-0.2472203523,
0.2022360265,
-0.4843280613,
-0.2126451135,
-0.5110815167,
-0.5187844634,
-0.5650572777,
-0.2164267302,
0.1795732975,
0.6839552522,
-0.5264132023,
0.5506997705,
-0.3359376192,
1.1172809601,
0.264479965,
0.6168774962,
0.1878827065,
-0.5187118649,
0.4084071219,
0.2537991405,
-0.299625814,
-0.4311367273,
1.2787363529,
0.4458661079,
1.0904560089,
0.2291784734,
0.846132338,
0.1410673261,
0.3899819255,
-0.4572635889,
0.5457092524,
-0.0403701849,
-0.6830008626,
0.0602698699,
0.0171128716,
-0.5143507719,
-0.0340277366,
-0.0340862535,
-0.8790455461,
-0.0317644887,
0.3293422759,
-0.9923083782,
0.6273511052,
-0.9772633314,
0.4588136375,
-0.0333000198,
-0.5562791228,
-0.7942185402,
-0.544934094,
0.8414317966,
-0.2350499034,
0.1598168015,
-0.51565516,
0.1762898117,
0.8854088187,
-0.7076130509,
0.7442467809,
-0.3538265526,
-0.2850433886,
0.3549772501,
0.3974308372,
0.4539521933,
0.437297821,
0.0238317624,
0.302790612,
0.0660774782,
-0.5450944304,
-0.275434345,
0.7388256788,
-0.9281458855,
-0.792298317,
-0.2104201019,
-0.3265742362,
-0.111100778,
-0.1615556031,
0.2661620378,
0.0853624418,
0.0336044133,
-0.0184073802,
0.5084392428,
-0.0879803225,
0.8580613136,
0.3507218361,
-0.0716602653,
-0.1934597343,
0.917429626,
0.0805971026,
0.0206359327,
0.0032515223,
0.0110179484,
0.0459211953,
-1.0567634106,
-0.2077744454,
0.0758966133,
-0.3855289221,
-0.5583350658,
0.0899957865,
-0.1323652118,
0.2357209772,
-0.5289908648,
-0.6090578437,
-0.6804015636,
-0.6158751249,
-0.3293025196,
0.5025089383,
1.0541391373,
-0.4357940257,
0.9602705836,
-0.4626707435,
0.6246395111,
0.315381676,
0.5503456593,
-0.1323472261,
-0.3421906233,
-0.2204517573,
-0.2322737426,
-0.77110219,
-0.6364462972,
0.0981329754,
-0.1396080405,
0.2016011775,
0.842410624,
-0.2169960141,
1.0798945427,
-0.1680009067,
0.7608778477,
0.3974080682,
-0.9550561309,
0.7967396379,
-0.2827964127,
0.0277848411,
0.7358493209,
0.1289786696,
0.1932204962,
-0.2882928252,
-0.4654015303,
-0.7345283628,
0.552713573,
0.2198454291,
-0.2025458068,
-0.0233972687,
0.6681525111,
0.2489130795,
-0.1838958859,
-0.6147043109,
-0.2940380871,
-0.201762557,
0.4118083119,
-0.4261616766,
-0.4116539657,
-0.366404593,
-0.447139591,
0.6861414313,
0.1834231168,
-0.0852797925,
-0.1590376645,
-0.456294328,
-0.1877978742,
0.3616668284,
1.0014368296,
0.8905989528,
-0.6415379643,
-0.0391453318,
0.5327903628,
-0.6916766167,
0.5111391544,
-0.0477225967,
0.0525990687,
-0.6819621325,
-0.0257086065,
0.4982155561,
0.3266859353,
-0.4498037994,
0.1068534106,
-0.1411188543,
-0.2409891635,
0.180327341,
0.7289835215,
-0.31667611,
0.2718815207,
0.2817130387,
0.3202123642,
0.0145346653,
-0.3593518138,
0.043680694,
0.1532359123,
-0.2467879653,
-0.2237904221,
0.9242350459,
0.0985527039,
-0.2336313576,
0.2945201099,
0.1206924915,
-0.0797355101,
0.7236452699,
0.5215158463,
0.7160731554,
-0.0959643498,
-0.1741278023,
0.326902777,
0.7662475109,
-0.2482293993,
0.1943840683,
0.1184465811,
-0.4363284111,
-0.3241175711,
-0.4706043601,
-0.5222263336,
0.5221695304,
-0.8432387114,
0.197011888,
-1.2092555761,
-0.0842910558,
-0.0816937312,
0.0326643512,
-0.586794734,
0.1871832907,
0.0985999927,
1.0856152773,
-0.5301195383,
0.7380186319,
0.1705956757,
-0.2064177245,
-0.8035934567,
-0.337448597,
0.2482252866,
-0.8580335379,
0.3432231545,
0.2730948329,
-0.1706647724,
-0.2600093186,
-0.8238561749,
-0.7316379547,
1.0304994583,
0.634122014,
-0.9951192737,
-0.0085850935,
-0.296893239,
0.2813805938,
0.2692736089,
-0.1860956997,
1.3513273001,
0.4349713326,
-0.5158199072,
-0.8090054989,
0.0272443704,
-0.2121847272,
-0.1896709204,
0.3494643569,
-0.9070293903,
0.8224384189,
-0.5928142667,
-0.0765853822,
0.2271842808,
0.4864067435,
0.4446497262,
0.0551451258,
0.447670877,
0.9430165291,
0.9165309072,
-0.2031476349,
0.8907216191,
-0.4024704099,
0.1734329611,
0.9772980809,
-0.0980851129,
0.7635517716,
0.8549173474,
-0.0627639592,
0.1175041199,
0.9425153136,
0.1364756078,
0.8502124548,
0.3254268467,
-0.1452918351,
-0.303289026,
0.5576524734,
-0.5187445879,
0.7017000914,
0.4035982192,
0.1279115379,
-0.496737957,
0.1070585474,
0.5236803293,
-0.3820332587,
-0.7547057867,
0.6773466468,
0.121817112,
-0.6430832148,
1.0002563,
0.4156919122,
0.626878798,
-0.3260518014,
0.0731682256,
-0.4017209113,
0.2576542795,
-0.2759256363,
-0.6759163737,
0.2803338468,
0.1656396091,
0.1246624589,
-0.0850066319,
0.6600413918,
0.470744729,
-0.0582160726,
0.3029783368,
0.0953704938,
0.0719527677,
0.0229769517,
-0.4570134282,
0.2772502005,
-0.0955666602,
-0.2245289832,
0.4215933979,
-0.2635908127,
-0.095481135,
1.0748624802,
0.6531167626,
-0.0571821071,
-0.0046692444,
-0.233982563,
1.156334281,
-0.8570240736,
-0.3712150753,
-1.3081222773,
-0.0368184932,
0.3056109548,
-0.5750514269,
0.6016833782,
0.6216722727,
0.9317055345,
0.1342324317,
0.497321099,
0.0567297786,
-0.060480088,
-0.9683635235,
1.068911314,
-0.4330556095,
0.5421901345,
-0.4629397988,
-0.5468974113,
-0.4770107269,
0.5776189566,
-0.3405160308,
-0.5830439925,
0.3858382106,
0.9814891219,
-0.0479417667,
0.2784710228,
0.1896045357,
0.2166451812,
0.4675984383,
0.8737277985,
0.755173862,
-0.7032399178,
0.5140222311,
-0.419433862,
-0.0566679202,
-0.380158931,
-0.8648228645,
-0.8483698964,
0.0169538539,
-0.1052689925,
-0.2990334928,
0.4996419549,
0.5836963654,
0.6035245657,
-0.80259341,
-0.2049985081,
-0.0549668372,
0.4702942371,
-0.2222762108,
-0.0679527745,
0.2007395178,
-0.1284237802,
-0.1563810259,
0.727897644,
0.4444573522,
0.0663139746,
-0.1019677818,
-0.0898502916,
-0.024847649,
0.0342294909,
0.5277924538,
0.5701918602,
-0.745026648,
-0.6248478293,
-0.8882427812,
-0.0678846613,
0.2355849594,
0.6220997572,
-0.5550947189,
0.2033201903,
0.0263094027,
0.267706722,
0.8264536858,
0.038141802,
0.4851706028,
-0.3021836281,
0.4982320964,
-0.0345688649,
0.3687353134,
-0.1710564494,
-0.2714193463,
0.6643127203,
-0.0895802304,
-0.5038899183,
-0.9616928697,
0.0542390868,
-0.8206523061,
-0.388255924,
0.8244128823,
-0.0211521909,
-0.454441309,
-0.2978662252,
-0.2529705465,
-0.0301185697,
-0.2089234889,
1.0374244452,
0.4572387636,
-0.1602295786,
0.0638789386,
-0.6777638793,
0.8307090998,
0.1351406127,
-0.9720958471,
-0.0070325718,
0.3280897141,
0.4677228928,
-0.0501831286,
0.6487768292,
-0.3359282613,
0.8610979915,
-0.1884742379,
-0.2315571755,
-0.3175084591,
-0.6190502644,
-0.3665930033,
0.4971886277,
0.1207905039,
-0.0837199688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01374v1 | Bridging the Gap: Transfer Learning from English PLMs to Malaysian English | 2024-07-01T15:26:03 | 2024-07-01T15:26:03 | Mohan Raj Chanthran, Lay-Ki Soon, Huey Fang Ong, Bhawani Selvaretnam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Malaysian English is a low resource creole language, where it carries the
elements of Malay, Chinese, and Tamil languages, in addition to Standard
English. Named Entity Recognition (NER) models underperform when capturing
entities from Malaysian English text due to its distinctive morphosyntactic
adaptations, semantic features and code-switching (mixing English and Malay).
Considering these gaps, we introduce MENmBERT and MENBERT, a pre-trained
language model with contextual understanding, specifically tailored for
Malaysian English. We have fine-tuned MENmBERT and MENBERT using manually
annotated entities and relations from the Malaysian English News Article (MEN)
Dataset. This fine-tuning process allows the PLM to learn representations that
capture the nuances of Malaysian English relevant for NER and RE tasks.
MENmBERT achieved a 1.52\% and 26.27\% improvement on NER and RE tasks
respectively compared to the bert-base-multilingual-cased model. Although the
overall performance of NER does not have a significant improvement, our further
analysis shows that there is a significant improvement when evaluated by the 12
entity labels. These findings suggest that pre-training language models on
language-specific and geographically-focused corpora can be a promising
approach for improving NER performance in low-resource settings. The dataset
and code published in this paper provide valuable resources for NLP research
work focusing on Malaysian English. | [
-0.5578404665,
-0.1962966323,
0.2959144711,
0.4325766861,
-0.2321200818,
0.3063871264,
-0.285246104,
-0.5361503959,
0.1836188436,
0.5387563109,
-0.3896742463,
-0.3169995546,
-0.6934168339,
0.5315876603,
-0.1047258899,
0.5784188509,
-0.3294300437,
-0.1109943464,
-0.0517682992,
-0.3454215527,
-0.7105986476,
-0.6319868565,
-0.8648502827,
-0.2607269287,
0.2984757721,
0.4108606577,
0.4208621085,
0.2797700763,
0.7146000862,
0.2009139657,
0.0268669967,
0.1047263891,
-0.0779550448,
-0.1141776666,
-0.519321084,
-0.3662561774,
-0.3473240435,
-0.0675843582,
0.4651395679,
0.9665992856,
-0.2641866505,
0.1219415069,
0.3498311937,
0.7181465626,
-0.5986745358,
0.3037662506,
-0.5776042938,
0.0531798862,
-0.2043188661,
-0.2428572178,
-0.4777185023,
0.0235722531,
0.5178670287,
-0.6471744776,
-0.008817601,
-0.0235896558,
1.2308784723,
0.3464209735,
-0.6343219876,
-0.4644689858,
-0.6462592483,
0.9090889096,
-0.5708976388,
0.7227749228,
0.6059592366,
0.272703737,
0.1094021127,
-0.6132000089,
-0.282828629,
-0.2146560997,
-0.2638986707,
0.1599410325,
-0.0906378925,
-0.0887953937,
-0.0115588838,
0.247087881,
-0.2771429121,
0.0253760349,
-0.4893819094,
-0.2123475671,
0.6210504174,
-0.0299832094,
0.2126048356,
-0.4802543223,
-0.2908523977,
0.0905379951,
-0.8423104286,
0.1805476695,
-0.0388553366,
0.3609544337,
-0.2355316132,
0.4443312585,
0.1799259931,
0.722292006,
0.0858106166,
-0.3523989618,
0.1117117852,
-0.3545704186,
-0.2681520581,
0.1670195162,
0.4051365554,
0.0837408081,
0.2732135653,
-0.0550012067,
-0.3363622129,
-0.0316272639,
-0.0636124238,
-0.7725824118,
-0.4817494452,
-0.2090542763,
-0.5844160318,
0.2084769011,
0.2454712242,
-0.4442947209,
-0.0544163883,
-0.6292520761,
0.3037846982,
-0.444283247,
-0.5477766395,
0.309502542,
0.2806637883,
0.3273717463,
0.2557009757,
-0.7593681216,
0.2641364932,
0.3610363305,
0.8133254051,
-0.1714507341,
-0.2785272002,
-0.2447574139,
0.333411485,
-0.1447031051,
0.6519136429,
-0.684560895,
-0.3729317188,
-0.0547423959,
0.3698635399,
-0.3610886931,
-0.7957773209,
0.3983204365,
-0.47998932,
0.6563007236,
-0.1742448658,
-0.6574205756,
-0.3270873725,
-0.0563745722,
-0.8208668232,
0.7157846093,
0.3098236024,
-0.7911575437,
0.3285375834,
-0.8281432986,
-0.7698444724,
-0.077984564,
-0.0968633965,
-0.3255652189,
0.0520218872,
0.3774896562,
0.6649745107,
-0.0564876273,
0.124814406,
0.2361590117,
-0.1666784137,
-0.0533674173,
-0.2359599322,
0.7734398842,
0.2859853506,
-0.1833249778,
-0.1876092702,
-0.8076629043,
-0.3931266069,
0.0830344781,
-0.7804560065,
-0.6558596492,
-0.2113626301,
-0.0037047281,
0.2676612735,
0.1250018626,
-0.1650031209,
0.0063255336,
-0.1850833297,
0.5757642388,
0.4117266536,
-0.0054937736,
0.9324464798,
-0.1952482611,
0.7868124843,
0.2666221261,
-0.3485703468,
-0.3399452865,
-0.3588553071,
-0.8687149882,
-0.1452724338,
0.7823578715,
0.6481382251,
-0.9684369564,
0.3202449679,
-0.1046074629,
-0.1622220874,
-0.9703707099,
0.0647668466,
0.0126873786,
0.5174649954,
0.6134539247,
-0.5141856074,
-0.9842085242,
-0.8586354256,
-0.0398034863,
-0.074751541,
-0.1234736368,
0.4981460869,
0.2842937112,
-0.371943891,
0.9138768315,
-0.1015961319,
-0.5790180564,
-0.5502229333,
0.1567182392,
0.2075956315,
0.4093999863,
0.4186495841,
-0.6868122816,
-0.7022240758,
-0.0205168817,
-0.4919126034,
-0.3949331343,
-0.2804568112,
-0.0252078604,
0.4483875334,
0.78996557,
-0.5063639283,
0.1414523721,
0.7144893408,
-0.2994802892,
0.5404369235,
-0.0322056971,
0.1170419976,
-1.5203535557,
-0.0341529176,
-0.1471471339,
-0.3698865771,
-0.3419568241,
-0.1840988547,
0.0988826975,
-0.0320150778,
-0.5674635768,
0.6335472465,
-0.9245194793,
-0.0205385257,
-0.290243268,
0.0869801939,
0.0434629582,
0.1243285984,
0.371029675,
0.8912420869,
0.3628048599,
-0.8335348368,
-0.0941541716,
0.2470448166,
-0.4077099562,
0.7641293406,
-0.2972657681,
0.0105224596,
-0.1885023564,
0.0549175367,
-0.5301366448,
-0.0427121259,
0.1230048016,
-0.2459789664,
0.5381548405,
-0.1887045801,
0.0081287585,
-0.1583622247,
0.1062858403,
0.3155498803,
0.4069309235,
-0.3819844425,
0.8066129684,
0.4710610807,
-0.3355858028,
-0.8327391744,
-0.6162243485,
0.1399021745,
-0.324202925,
-0.3753383458,
0.6035346389,
0.3872463107,
-0.2922023833,
0.3195922077,
-0.1665269434,
-0.3365174532,
0.2196947485,
0.1348893791,
0.1021016538,
-0.6214018464,
0.022215236,
0.0683547184,
-0.2915119529,
0.0007103103,
-0.2225817442,
0.5752399564,
-0.0919569209,
-0.1965193897,
-0.4312540293,
0.1874993742,
0.2598271668,
-0.4662979543,
0.8140669465,
0.7117840052,
-0.5869755745,
0.0694329441,
-0.3474263549,
-0.3819430172,
-0.4097798467,
0.47421363,
-0.8829897642,
-1.1209570169,
0.3367667198,
-0.2085204422,
0.0593253709,
0.5622609258,
0.3153770268,
-0.215282172,
0.5014095902,
1.0400464535,
-0.3652327359,
0.3435306847,
-0.1205158532,
0.3169087172,
-0.6482234001,
-0.1337836385,
-0.2860097587,
-0.3276707828,
-0.5626556873,
-0.3733378351,
-0.1655606329,
0.4763156772,
0.0746812969,
0.870192647,
-0.0212705135,
0.6903637648,
0.3958799839,
-0.2420909554,
0.4494504631,
-0.0014709781,
-0.140195787,
-0.499664098,
-0.7514099479,
-0.71929425,
0.8872278333,
0.3798498511,
0.6462867856,
0.328456521,
0.7489806414,
0.2681081891,
0.4907132983,
-0.3926742673,
0.5369554162,
-0.2412831336,
-0.2363928854,
-0.0195734631,
-0.3794482946,
-1.3504436016,
0.3143722415,
-0.1790499687,
-0.2845393419,
0.0817249864,
-0.2152576447,
-0.4240526855,
0.2870865762,
-0.7830226421,
0.5444651246,
-0.0933335051,
-0.1600332707,
-0.2562933266,
-0.509472847,
0.3438386619,
-0.1543834358,
0.1004588455,
-0.1479103267,
-0.0574798696,
0.9367151856,
-0.0182574634,
0.507381022,
-0.144995153,
-0.141787529,
0.2602466941,
0.1887955964,
0.1578348726,
0.0221022218,
0.2242797166,
0.3252648711,
-0.1596429199,
-0.5573166609,
-0.1786729246,
0.3856749535,
-0.7178995013,
-0.4631718397,
-0.3300076425,
-0.4748288691,
-0.0651275963,
0.007869279,
0.1691940278,
-0.0623178072,
0.0053028516,
0.0636346638,
0.4420682788,
-0.4638969004,
0.5851178169,
0.7990019917,
-0.3465670645,
-0.1156918034,
0.8099603057,
0.1511864215,
0.1772266626,
0.6854575276,
-0.312936008,
-0.3570220768,
-0.259934485,
-0.2772870958,
0.4542488754,
-0.4952700138,
-0.2438292652,
-0.7132077813,
-0.4730631709,
-0.2440197766,
-0.2589835525,
-0.4470485151,
-0.3965032697,
-0.4730896652,
-0.1682555974,
-0.1264713854,
0.7283225656,
-0.2159814537,
0.4704696238,
-0.8628349304,
-0.0496551804,
0.1988829672,
0.0587522089,
-0.0862957612,
-0.7795569897,
-0.2754624784,
-0.2844426632,
-0.1132279932,
-1.0747928619,
0.5363026261,
0.2502648532,
0.4802993238,
0.4399052262,
-0.2263304591,
0.6889434457,
-0.4317898452,
0.5124430656,
-0.0652087927,
-1.0730814934,
0.4486489594,
0.0395100079,
0.0611935705,
0.5846580267,
0.7948971987,
-0.7602860928,
-0.0222867951,
-0.6467118263,
-0.9793742895,
0.5675553083,
0.1129642203,
-0.0795599148,
0.2039584219,
0.3150074184,
0.240415439,
0.293993026,
-0.8268188834,
-0.1798856854,
0.125520736,
-0.1572159231,
-0.0619135685,
-0.3464103937,
0.5204552412,
-0.3153596818,
0.7409106493,
0.1372796595,
0.1852387488,
0.1665057689,
-0.8227924109,
0.1425975412,
0.4781407714,
0.5517587066,
0.7715159059,
-0.3070264459,
0.3891482353,
0.2808475196,
-0.4249539077,
0.332819134,
0.3204065263,
0.0501519814,
0.2448577583,
0.4001608491,
0.6093578935,
0.2731706202,
-0.5803360939,
0.3695894778,
-0.0885538757,
-0.0645728484,
-0.1793248355,
-0.2542941868,
0.4490425885,
0.1662428826,
0.3034054637,
0.0908633471,
-0.206744343,
-0.2028804421,
0.5421112776,
0.0711870492,
-0.2709561586,
-0.5661537647,
0.7768089175,
0.5560768843,
-0.3385155499,
0.6064597964,
-0.5437788367,
-0.6153709888,
0.3258953691,
0.7149611115,
0.5077883601,
-0.6794449091,
0.2911313772,
0.5038358569,
0.6931676865,
-0.0034864927,
0.31706357,
0.005898505,
-0.840113461,
-0.7056284547,
-0.6010155678,
-0.4429371953,
0.5158623457,
-0.6035106778,
0.4128874838,
-0.3732555807,
0.0639271438,
-0.2419826239,
0.03921213,
-0.8969448209,
-0.1520069689,
0.3324111998,
1.0145665407,
-1.0612124205,
0.7870228887,
0.9978170395,
-0.518347919,
-0.8401021957,
-0.0760417879,
-0.3307275474,
-0.7813409567,
0.7183050513,
0.3496606052,
0.2073441893,
0.2939615548,
-0.0115479929,
-0.9653089643,
1.1458269358,
0.4695537388,
-0.8786708713,
0.1826317012,
0.2841678858,
0.2934329212,
-0.6153131127,
0.2844343185,
0.7807149887,
0.3972967565,
-0.5203603506,
-1.2364883423,
-0.1764721721,
0.0549629144,
-0.0908563733,
0.2064292133,
-0.3866204023,
1.0311185122,
-0.3371449709,
-0.5938282013,
-0.1215250343,
0.941806674,
0.2426037192,
0.2601352334,
0.4516429603,
0.6931509376,
0.9975011349,
0.0075139082,
0.6808721423,
-0.3827147782,
0.2376534045,
1.1882594824,
-0.5314723253,
1.0433381796,
0.5667415857,
-0.4710420966,
0.7393499017,
0.8240013719,
0.263027817,
0.6516239047,
0.0842984095,
-0.3757879436,
0.0193796214,
-0.3840423524,
-0.4247009456,
0.4263420403,
0.4109662473,
-0.4141170382,
-0.3468447924,
0.2405746877,
0.1744046807,
0.0032842036,
-0.3748869896,
0.6935391426,
0.3667031229,
-0.4640055597,
0.3822581172,
0.2846850455,
1.0544992685,
-0.3137885332,
-0.0049812174,
-0.3871747851,
0.1390556842,
-0.2808484137,
-0.5863038301,
0.4135681689,
-0.2620368898,
-0.1465491056,
-0.2475011349,
1.0599380732,
-0.8013097048,
-0.3001205027,
0.3996424079,
1.0450823307,
0.3355979323,
-0.1389650404,
-0.7238899469,
-0.4503881037,
0.1695390642,
0.0312024243,
0.2959018946,
0.2876807451,
-0.1251963973,
0.445009917,
0.5332735181,
0.2100052238,
0.0929692313,
0.1931924969,
0.2649777234,
-0.7929999828,
-0.482068181,
-0.9425625205,
0.2678516507,
0.1136559099,
-0.1114709601,
0.5566160679,
0.5716050863,
1.2681745291,
-0.2579450607,
0.7966731191,
0.03699819,
0.5923786163,
-0.5332858562,
0.7691041827,
-0.298307389,
0.2865307927,
-0.0097937556,
-1.209618926,
-0.1586709768,
0.8947898746,
-0.2119123936,
-0.1299153715,
0.7867475152,
0.6242609024,
-0.3187866211,
-0.1972763091,
0.2675499022,
0.1692434251,
0.2444318831,
0.8201779127,
1.0507701635,
-0.4129394889,
0.458858937,
-0.2903942764,
0.0091348886,
-0.1178868413,
-0.8879826069,
-0.8587716222,
-0.7830455899,
-0.350211978,
-0.309938848,
0.007316018,
1.1542887688,
0.7030806541,
-0.9908713698,
-0.30612728,
0.0324872062,
0.0955486074,
-0.0260393005,
-0.2976552248,
0.468627125,
-0.2815828025,
-0.6197442412,
0.3891904354,
0.370057404,
0.3056430817,
-0.2344185412,
-0.3106140792,
-0.2994401455,
-0.106765002,
0.8099986911,
0.2463396043,
-0.6223626733,
0.1071579009,
0.0578433797,
-0.1610522121,
0.1281777173,
0.903003931,
-0.9949223399,
-0.0731221288,
0.188192904,
1.2220816612,
0.1237406805,
-0.1281372905,
0.488134712,
-1.0083220005,
0.2280755043,
0.1260315776,
0.6332343817,
0.7220206261,
-0.0035492077,
0.8063245416,
0.4239116311,
-0.3480906188,
-0.6668478251,
0.0766201839,
-0.6774337888,
-0.2093154639,
1.063559413,
-0.1118465886,
-0.0216173772,
-0.4856939614,
-0.2945309877,
0.1433808506,
-0.3478160501,
0.6790184975,
0.86292696,
-0.0661297292,
-0.4888053536,
-0.5836580992,
0.4736313224,
0.7744674683,
-0.8867766261,
-0.3042751253,
0.059763357,
0.2836785316,
0.116310291,
0.8608484864,
0.123478733,
0.1649568379,
-0.405836761,
0.0772265568,
0.181202963,
-0.3849626482,
-0.3688091934,
0.0458494835,
0.1755900681,
-0.2754696608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01370v1 | Summary of a Haystack: A Challenge to Long-Context LLMs and RAG Systems | 2024-07-01T15:23:42 | 2024-07-01T15:23:42 | Philippe Laban, Alexander R. Fabbri, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs and RAG systems are now capable of handling millions of input tokens or
more. However, evaluating the output quality of such systems on long-context
tasks remains challenging, as tasks like Needle-in-a-Haystack lack complexity.
In this work, we argue that summarization can play a central role in such
evaluation. We design a procedure to synthesize Haystacks of documents,
ensuring that specific \textit{insights} repeat across documents. The "Summary
of a Haystack" (SummHay) task then requires a system to process the Haystack
and generate, given a query, a summary that identifies the relevant insights
and precisely cites the source documents. Since we have precise knowledge of
what insights should appear in a haystack summary and what documents should be
cited, we implement a highly reproducible automatic evaluation that can score
summaries on two aspects - Coverage and Citation. We generate Haystacks in two
domains (conversation, news), and perform a large-scale evaluation of 10 LLMs
and corresponding 50 RAG systems. Our findings indicate that SummHay is an open
challenge for current systems, as even systems provided with an Oracle signal
of document relevance lag our estimate of human performance (56\%) by 10+
points on a Joint Score. Without a retriever, long-context LLMs like GPT-4o and
Claude 3 Opus score below 20% on SummHay. We show SummHay can also be used to
study enterprise RAG systems and position bias in long-context models. We hope
future systems can equal and surpass human performance on SummHay. | [
-0.1939291656,
-0.1423073113,
0.6519843936,
0.2034371346,
-0.3997029066,
0.2066709697,
-0.0020583952,
-0.5289373398,
0.938282609,
0.5283136964,
-0.5082817078,
-0.39338094,
-0.4509234726,
0.4189229906,
-0.6968567967,
1.2904374599,
-0.0574127957,
-0.3110707998,
-0.3388654888,
-0.2128708959,
-0.4728198349,
-0.5038430095,
-0.2868162692,
-0.3000214398,
0.3228131831,
0.336992085,
0.3503777683,
0.1846091449,
0.6534566283,
0.34559533,
-0.2682085633,
0.4528293312,
-0.7661323547,
0.6568937302,
-0.3301046491,
-0.3088009059,
-0.6055566669,
-0.0898733437,
0.6779911518,
0.6664534211,
-0.1894435883,
0.402559191,
0.3106566072,
0.8892964721,
-0.7272708416,
-0.2148614973,
-0.5005228519,
-0.2501835823,
-0.1786051393,
-0.2489726692,
-0.3066368401,
-0.2467327118,
-0.0498626754,
-0.5907427073,
0.096071206,
0.0197865739,
0.7863301039,
0.2470455915,
-0.4710138738,
-0.4443688691,
-0.4688422382,
0.9150619507,
-0.5000624061,
-0.1441593468,
0.3668632507,
0.4432146847,
-0.0826011524,
-0.5962602496,
-0.0864068195,
0.180735603,
-0.4212377369,
0.632363379,
0.0004114635,
-0.3545805216,
-0.0871595591,
0.3779451251,
-0.3681309521,
-0.1283055097,
-0.6237757802,
-0.1850034297,
0.6410375237,
0.5933645368,
-0.2796879709,
-0.4524277747,
-0.2880014479,
-0.0086045982,
-0.4683271348,
-0.0145038888,
0.1419754922,
0.0360932574,
0.1450930387,
0.6250053644,
-0.352786541,
0.4913255572,
0.0555382222,
-0.1871927381,
0.0684200525,
-0.5360327959,
-0.2422226965,
-0.0974752903,
0.4873978794,
0.6660986543,
-0.2764647603,
-0.1980200112,
-0.634033978,
-0.0988297239,
0.3827714026,
-0.7447831035,
0.2876945734,
0.3644640744,
-0.4128155708,
-0.4266576171,
0.1782364994,
-0.5883190632,
-0.3906051815,
-0.1454363614,
0.545521915,
-0.1984003037,
0.0050429991,
-0.1041609719,
-0.5038912892,
0.414930433,
0.5626981258,
-0.7739037871,
0.4661353827,
0.8936548233,
1.1843423843,
-0.3573599756,
-0.3756120205,
-0.6143196225,
0.4663085043,
-0.5617983937,
1.0195424557,
-0.2451248318,
-0.7235828042,
-0.307495296,
0.0395097062,
0.1444424391,
-0.6757725477,
0.3193069994,
-0.4822642207,
0.3073928356,
-0.3804114163,
-0.6145048141,
0.0589976572,
0.1752247214,
-0.6661689878,
0.7986832857,
0.3746620715,
-0.8019868135,
0.2507839501,
-0.6379023194,
-0.5771682262,
0.0241997782,
-0.0502864122,
-0.1590554714,
0.3019903004,
0.0969544351,
0.4318177104,
-0.3088337481,
0.1170490831,
0.0757012144,
-0.8573176265,
0.2244732976,
0.1652115881,
0.7853649855,
0.0820130557,
-0.2934859693,
0.2117380649,
-0.5830243826,
-0.0518644638,
-0.135009706,
-0.4566083848,
-0.4841426015,
-0.0873696133,
-0.0619593374,
-0.3095556796,
0.4243785441,
-0.2097522169,
-0.0867157876,
-0.4478817284,
0.2389024794,
0.8382317424,
0.0442598127,
0.3664193153,
-0.646109283,
0.4924383163,
-0.2395027429,
-0.1521414071,
-0.7233787179,
0.0105941547,
-0.6908072829,
-0.313708961,
0.1741198748,
0.5129392147,
-0.3882064521,
0.4669577181,
-0.4005701542,
-0.3592586517,
-0.240334779,
0.0532471575,
0.3745009303,
0.4411838055,
0.272890538,
-0.3681485951,
-0.5974854231,
-1.0944459438,
-0.4116280675,
-0.0071646892,
-0.5634814501,
0.1743729562,
0.654866159,
-0.0990515053,
0.8438735604,
-0.4367542565,
-0.5135563612,
0.0016135884,
0.1419520378,
0.5228472352,
0.1549674422,
0.2694557011,
-0.5845632553,
-0.1724500805,
-0.0845413208,
-0.9205514789,
-0.1665445417,
0.0039709676,
-0.2097340375,
0.3796740174,
0.5587883592,
-0.4455039799,
0.2174650431,
0.3347783089,
-0.3907711804,
0.7560875416,
-0.034180101,
0.3374769986,
-1.1770721674,
0.5137533545,
-0.4799822867,
-0.410513252,
-0.1489345133,
0.2198875099,
0.0695099905,
-0.0965837389,
-0.1113967225,
0.4564817548,
-0.4706204832,
-0.4291475415,
-0.3166908026,
0.3101882637,
0.3504757583,
0.2416042089,
-0.3232012093,
0.9549506307,
0.0131336357,
-0.6619393229,
0.3576388359,
0.0816721395,
-0.4466352463,
0.786891222,
-0.9151796103,
-0.104278028,
-0.1869024634,
0.5500969887,
-0.9316576719,
-0.5135123134,
-0.2692420781,
-0.5887610316,
0.2164084911,
0.2261219025,
-0.3052273095,
0.0592041351,
-0.7662604451,
0.126595661,
0.5626323223,
-0.2223512083,
0.6610888243,
0.6417909265,
-0.1422889233,
-0.6169130802,
-0.6109807491,
0.3024172783,
-0.327794075,
-0.5619090796,
0.3139963448,
0.2687396109,
-0.3910407722,
0.1115956679,
-0.3460403681,
0.1919977069,
0.2334492803,
0.2233343869,
0.1330870539,
-0.0462912135,
0.291102469,
0.1422231495,
-0.2863580287,
0.1573457718,
-0.32910344,
0.0116838245,
-0.3217844069,
-0.2780006528,
0.1035139561,
0.7487487197,
0.5986528397,
-0.0647250116,
0.3535659611,
0.3128823638,
-0.3222186565,
-0.065418005,
-0.4991955459,
-0.211663112,
-0.4252799153,
0.398183912,
-0.243207261,
-0.7873907089,
0.5443603396,
-0.1742033511,
0.4573099613,
0.8201978207,
0.6241963506,
-0.5303404331,
0.5263255239,
0.6602514386,
0.0338734649,
0.1804317832,
-0.2573674023,
-0.2905915082,
-1.0570876598,
-0.0184091348,
-0.416241765,
-0.3538613617,
-0.3190145195,
-0.2996159196,
0.8215870261,
0.1044822335,
0.0763646066,
0.1329983175,
-0.4299183488,
0.752532959,
0.5701189637,
0.0314554013,
0.4360795021,
-0.140754059,
-0.0212742053,
0.2250043005,
-0.373311311,
-0.732195437,
0.9031084776,
-0.0330929011,
0.7659451962,
0.3867650926,
1.1639924049,
0.4058201611,
0.3864464164,
-0.8616297841,
0.4981213212,
-0.1445802301,
-0.4181548655,
-0.6837512255,
-0.2737046778,
-1.0546295643,
0.4488668144,
0.0038817353,
-0.6170749068,
-0.1101985574,
0.0452519096,
-0.3587177694,
-0.0699670091,
-0.5251392722,
0.3655763566,
0.1568799466,
-0.4690053165,
-0.3938487768,
-0.7262527943,
0.6471149921,
-0.2403821498,
0.4598355889,
0.0377150662,
-0.2989717722,
1.020644784,
-0.556892693,
0.7055321932,
0.1448686421,
-0.0855493695,
0.3633827269,
0.2257064432,
0.4840194583,
-0.0699374601,
-0.0897808,
-0.0320638157,
0.3952543736,
-0.4063096642,
-0.5505275726,
0.5886920691,
-0.3793288171,
-0.6967231035,
-0.4625480473,
-0.3110625446,
-0.1007014066,
0.3325877786,
0.2654221356,
0.4595606327,
-0.2396116406,
0.3302368522,
0.3663486838,
0.035374444,
0.3297694325,
0.2726346254,
-0.3208251595,
-0.4656887054,
0.8905034661,
0.1044105217,
0.0773384944,
0.5198613405,
0.3096641004,
-0.1742288321,
-0.0986269042,
-0.4302423894,
0.2581224144,
-0.9273040295,
-0.5067514181,
-0.4614028633,
-0.085861139,
-0.2105899155,
-0.2779717147,
-0.2179347873,
-0.5717550516,
-0.1600119323,
0.1889925897,
0.1407260299,
1.0886099339,
-0.1170326695,
0.0746264905,
-0.8945732117,
0.2825368047,
0.3608626723,
0.3924784362,
0.1343612075,
-0.5356430411,
-0.6688175201,
-0.1265787333,
-0.3304663002,
-0.9678529501,
0.0665799081,
0.0330417044,
0.3760339022,
0.0225844216,
0.0475757532,
0.6585487723,
-0.4233161211,
0.7720369697,
0.0505486391,
-0.9669736028,
0.5504176617,
-0.4399424493,
0.5710248351,
0.6620128751,
0.0853869841,
-0.5268288255,
-0.6300677061,
-0.3791450262,
-1.0942169428,
0.5296928883,
0.2618623376,
-0.2064765245,
0.0269371457,
0.1005751267,
0.0887230635,
0.1156608462,
-0.1491880417,
0.15709804,
-0.1683570296,
-0.1116042212,
-0.0012894657,
-0.4069158137,
-0.2190057188,
0.2060638815,
0.6067393422,
-0.0472015217,
-0.1032049134,
0.421174556,
-0.3270185888,
0.1118337512,
0.2311571091,
0.7946301699,
1.1751451492,
-0.4222933948,
0.152494967,
0.1800370663,
-0.4113298357,
0.0457046516,
-0.3927697837,
-0.1864702106,
0.3029780984,
0.6693868041,
0.2623846829,
0.5505669117,
-0.7551205754,
0.471044153,
-0.1098142564,
-0.1766198725,
-0.405374229,
-0.0200531613,
0.3025770485,
0.2449022382,
0.8561500907,
-0.252289176,
0.4160262048,
-0.3747569025,
0.1692107469,
0.4029155076,
0.1042625532,
-0.1007108912,
0.3554998338,
0.3571438491,
-0.2098559737,
0.1527760625,
-0.1349892318,
-0.4200900197,
0.6531787515,
0.3370968997,
0.7981108427,
-0.1010063887,
-0.1849897206,
0.4243334234,
0.3146136105,
-0.0636145473,
-0.0063357889,
-0.3372065723,
-0.0334113315,
-0.5875541568,
-0.7638477683,
-0.6738655567,
-0.0867466256,
-0.7777374983,
0.3691018522,
-0.0964190438,
-0.0289526284,
-0.0831147507,
-0.0242193621,
-0.3249430358,
-0.1037159041,
-0.4582473636,
0.6665413976,
-0.5366482735,
0.1997861564,
0.5926668644,
-0.0402450711,
-0.3580927253,
-0.168314904,
-0.0287550651,
-0.5654976964,
0.5401545167,
0.2310696393,
-0.6260350347,
-0.2633672059,
-0.2838007212,
-0.9873777628,
1.3791825771,
0.0319766812,
-0.4656161964,
-0.0212614033,
-0.5627642274,
0.423836261,
-0.1575481445,
0.2860303223,
0.4696779549,
0.3140540421,
0.1760204732,
-1.1385771036,
0.1008202061,
-0.1639152914,
-0.2280595303,
0.3706844747,
-0.6715072393,
0.8629358411,
-0.360663265,
-0.6953042746,
0.0441591255,
0.6278958321,
0.4059589207,
0.443916589,
0.3743378222,
0.2806455195,
0.8056700826,
0.3280614614,
0.9027702808,
-0.074725233,
0.3875332177,
1.3295065165,
-0.1259953231,
0.9358825088,
0.5977920294,
-0.4265594184,
0.3371459246,
0.5200496316,
0.1878987849,
0.3076334,
0.3560319543,
-0.0466682129,
-0.0462268926,
0.0537788719,
-0.3746654987,
0.547709465,
0.3707871437,
-0.1097814292,
-0.5943357944,
-0.3874047399,
-0.1690356582,
0.1100962386,
-0.2482489794,
0.9810753465,
0.1620926708,
-0.7465246916,
0.6736415625,
0.1086543128,
0.771404624,
-0.5813938379,
-0.1767107993,
-0.5631765723,
-0.095891133,
-0.2980187237,
-0.6950982809,
0.8015521169,
0.0584171563,
-0.3512194455,
-0.0842863098,
0.6901272535,
-0.051144056,
-0.5589035749,
-0.020482799,
0.5608133078,
0.5413203239,
0.0689075291,
0.1163921729,
0.0047103981,
-0.3062740564,
-0.4172293544,
0.4564589858,
0.5327676535,
-0.304002285,
0.4627951682,
0.5347211957,
0.0722661465,
-0.344296068,
-0.1545738727,
0.8464656472,
-0.9244662523,
-0.7914901376,
-0.9886663556,
0.275824666,
-0.2986850142,
-0.2079098523,
0.6694123745,
0.6586583853,
0.5304734707,
0.1566350609,
0.7241754532,
0.0916067213,
0.8489359021,
-0.5578702092,
0.8391305208,
-0.7142619491,
0.3091330826,
-0.1155560166,
-0.6792557836,
0.1288358867,
0.4734656513,
0.3586095572,
-0.1330765784,
0.846303165,
0.3607019186,
-0.0269585084,
-0.1094533056,
0.2857885361,
0.060898643,
0.2868493497,
0.6171911359,
0.718419373,
-0.3811340332,
0.5497569442,
-0.0071593421,
-0.4300914109,
-0.5294001102,
-1.0294252634,
-0.6844595075,
-0.821854353,
0.2207687199,
-0.3639748096,
0.0050345487,
0.4056760073,
0.5127549767,
-0.5367218256,
-0.5983008146,
0.3942403495,
0.4023478031,
-0.1677782387,
-0.2687173188,
0.5365404487,
-0.5858988762,
-0.3959340751,
0.2515788972,
0.5638679266,
-0.1042792201,
-0.3698272407,
0.1220631376,
0.1814814359,
-0.0645725727,
0.8427273035,
0.0114307078,
-0.7521434426,
-0.1074886769,
0.1598940641,
-0.1707357764,
-0.3194161654,
0.9583168626,
-0.9568862319,
0.1688731462,
0.3920226097,
0.714340508,
0.6410787106,
0.2734687924,
0.4745570719,
-0.7574412227,
-0.1648991704,
0.4240905046,
0.2446492314,
0.2803153396,
-0.4026643932,
0.6982854605,
-0.0946572721,
-0.538836658,
-0.9841687083,
0.1287504584,
-0.8256101012,
-0.4312519431,
0.919160068,
0.0023715543,
-0.4925230145,
0.0235227067,
-0.098066777,
-0.0161638055,
-0.3065381944,
0.9123610854,
0.8726639748,
-0.2099851221,
0.3269064426,
-0.4464158714,
0.2526447177,
0.3596666455,
-0.7796168327,
0.1307334751,
0.5582796931,
0.1866837591,
0.3189185262,
0.9775874615,
-0.1093674973,
0.4476077557,
0.0074234251,
-0.2691667974,
-0.1641976088,
-0.1754049212,
-0.3285834491,
0.0456656478,
-0.139896065,
-0.204752475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01360v1 | Nullpointer at ArAIEval Shared Task: Arabic Propagandist Technique Detection with Token-to-Word Mapping in Sequence Tagging | 2024-07-01T15:15:24 | 2024-07-01T15:15:24 | Abrar Abir, Kemal Oflazer | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the optimization of propaganda technique detection in
Arabic text, including tweets \& news paragraphs, from ArAIEval shared task 1.
Our approach involves fine-tuning the AraBERT v2 model with a neural network
classifier for sequence tagging. Experimental results show relying on the first
token of the word for technique prediction produces the best performance. In
addition, incorporating genre information as a feature further enhances the
model's performance. Our system achieved a score of 25.41, placing us 4$^{th}$
on the leaderboard. Subsequent post-submission improvements further raised our
score to 26.68. | [
-0.4672390521,
-0.7403638959,
0.1277898252,
0.3446162343,
-0.673478961,
0.2052171975,
-0.0660956725,
-0.4747639596,
0.3230426908,
0.4215269089,
-0.0873386264,
-0.9938379526,
-1.2082928419,
-0.0283026192,
-0.717900157,
1.1969938278,
-0.1353191137,
-0.2148109376,
0.3536612093,
-0.361561954,
-0.4419973493,
-0.3768937588,
-0.8606824875,
-0.0386667028,
0.5982564092,
0.7793360949,
0.8939317465,
0.6438325047,
0.4442870617,
0.2763675749,
0.0322790071,
0.3138851523,
-0.1817375124,
0.1943457574,
-0.2368515432,
-0.3061923981,
-0.0799624622,
-0.021470014,
0.6115296483,
0.2450664043,
0.0629649013,
0.5006104708,
-0.0824750364,
0.3347285986,
-0.7140097022,
-0.1485329419,
-0.4990123212,
-0.1714062691,
-0.38092044,
-0.3501942158,
-0.2960651815,
-0.5218148232,
-0.1902837306,
-0.427823633,
0.240139395,
0.3425712585,
0.7936846018,
0.3935807347,
-0.6837618351,
-0.3488625884,
-0.7390720844,
0.797847867,
-0.4140282571,
-0.0642963573,
0.3867767751,
0.1019127816,
-0.0383533351,
-0.6587321758,
-0.6577000022,
-0.0729500428,
0.1452405602,
-0.0152256312,
-0.3139465153,
-0.0682276189,
-0.0114367707,
0.0899971649,
-0.6393821239,
0.0368619896,
-0.4357969165,
-0.4558827877,
0.6725779772,
-0.3387092948,
0.2389855683,
-0.3419896662,
-0.452241987,
-0.0193669721,
-0.5044698119,
-0.2623520792,
0.3983882368,
-0.028812686,
0.0369657949,
0.6441548467,
-0.1026273742,
0.6734072566,
-0.1022377461,
-0.3760859966,
0.1359204948,
-0.1480257958,
0.162166208,
0.3810118735,
0.5669530034,
0.4499568939,
0.247672841,
0.0212270189,
-0.2472583801,
0.5672979355,
0.3531814516,
-0.6767142415,
-0.0521354079,
-0.0140936393,
-0.4068733752,
-0.5467069745,
-0.0131174596,
-0.4579516947,
-0.2862724662,
0.0907451063,
0.7351935506,
-0.5050951242,
-0.2562231123,
-0.0263780057,
-0.3554491401,
0.1456478089,
0.3955908418,
-0.3716099262,
0.1953429282,
0.7542954683,
1.1969776154,
-0.2625796199,
-0.0929802507,
-0.5449201465,
0.0186825544,
-0.6246210337,
1.1480638981,
-0.5238875151,
-0.5107163191,
0.2691948116,
-0.3885585964,
0.0426436812,
-0.4488945007,
1.2154985666,
-0.8803192377,
-0.056723237,
-0.1506413072,
-0.7562294006,
-0.5158210993,
0.2081291974,
-0.7058173418,
1.1643499136,
0.1652010232,
-0.8202406168,
0.4948085845,
-0.7504321337,
-0.518895328,
0.1060738787,
-0.0462748706,
-0.4867245257,
-0.069461152,
0.0624424592,
0.2927584052,
-0.0291111618,
0.1028613821,
0.2492205203,
-0.8799254298,
0.1838690341,
-0.3273276389,
0.303987205,
0.2877951264,
-0.5814582705,
0.2445904315,
-0.8333913684,
-0.0727365911,
-0.1605136693,
-0.2574036419,
-0.5064908862,
-0.0230594017,
0.2656905055,
0.2836638391,
-0.0782148466,
-0.4427810609,
0.3365209699,
-0.4981518686,
-0.0730023086,
0.5744869709,
0.4143441319,
0.2626791596,
-0.6408769488,
0.6712332964,
0.150591597,
-0.1271625608,
0.0974899083,
-0.7247219086,
-0.8941637278,
-0.1050769836,
0.4624083936,
0.7055966258,
-0.9191759229,
0.2055068016,
-0.1893464178,
-0.6782824397,
-0.5576011539,
-0.078561984,
0.5542179346,
0.2747756541,
0.317397356,
-0.3155141771,
-0.5699926615,
-0.968252182,
-0.5946540833,
-0.1184922457,
0.2599338889,
-0.2482554615,
0.9190942049,
0.0994156823,
0.505748868,
-0.3157043457,
-0.3658521771,
-0.1224998683,
0.8073017001,
0.149887234,
0.5637491941,
0.5205695033,
-1.1853100061,
-0.6152409315,
-0.1984643489,
-0.3745479882,
-0.1113642231,
0.2061665058,
-0.0735904947,
0.5748720765,
0.4503375888,
-0.3656076491,
0.9080295563,
0.4400670528,
-0.5510948896,
0.5366163254,
0.3028571606,
0.5410400629,
-1.3496176004,
0.0842321143,
0.2119815797,
-0.2954589725,
-0.7809592485,
0.0659841076,
-0.2002827823,
0.1210729629,
-0.5860978961,
0.4989516139,
-0.3433738351,
0.0757307187,
-0.7268968821,
0.0156440455,
-0.2201522887,
0.2388053387,
-0.1067884937,
1.1726140976,
0.3660176694,
-0.5044051409,
0.1088255197,
0.2856048942,
-0.4620636106,
0.2593686581,
-0.6006464958,
0.2759059072,
-0.1755851805,
0.0781041235,
-1.2306226492,
-0.0564838052,
0.7239944339,
-0.70141536,
0.1700989306,
-0.2721720934,
-0.6417410374,
-0.0411761105,
-0.3466784358,
0.6330798864,
0.5862092972,
-0.2106867135,
0.2450332195,
0.3111112118,
0.0814443976,
-0.8360378146,
-0.3130648136,
0.167458266,
-0.3637120724,
-0.6353071332,
0.56536901,
0.2596065402,
-0.2217056751,
-0.033616256,
-0.2657614052,
0.0574071407,
0.0799390078,
0.3662858009,
0.0789410621,
-0.2384842336,
0.1422698796,
0.0708587244,
-0.2839758396,
0.0346659273,
-0.4347308278,
0.6136348248,
0.0763415471,
-0.3655453324,
-0.3884169161,
0.7710985541,
0.2998506129,
-0.2053249776,
1.2127629519,
0.9725217819,
-0.379313767,
-0.0897817388,
-0.589982748,
0.0534830466,
-0.4778128564,
0.2655554712,
-0.1844715178,
-0.9089266062,
0.3630608916,
-0.3314245343,
-0.198470071,
0.7194554806,
0.4728393555,
0.2278819084,
1.1239259243,
0.7722697854,
-0.2662751675,
0.1839457005,
-0.3495616019,
0.3319124579,
-0.4780629575,
-0.0814585686,
-0.7497051358,
-0.455396086,
-0.8166769147,
-0.6957472563,
0.5573467016,
0.2705504,
-0.1904873699,
0.0130883353,
-0.6694515347,
0.3572647572,
0.7414816022,
-0.1445360482,
0.3121445775,
0.2024441212,
0.086988911,
0.0316018499,
-0.5672257543,
-0.7084895372,
0.9027796984,
0.0594984591,
0.3244168758,
0.2908917964,
0.7579607964,
0.7941709161,
0.4772127271,
-0.8501778841,
0.6239236593,
0.0417914987,
-0.4735276699,
-0.1111110449,
0.217756778,
-0.8209881783,
0.1974924505,
0.0345211066,
-0.7949845195,
0.1003733426,
0.1026351079,
-0.1839931756,
0.0698720366,
-0.3812822402,
0.6932504177,
0.3967108727,
-0.2006520778,
-0.4099244475,
-0.7206198573,
0.2140880078,
-0.0492634103,
0.2889083922,
-0.1480707824,
-0.4565077722,
1.160332799,
-0.2322762907,
0.7348344326,
-0.1358205378,
0.0040840758,
0.3583394885,
0.0958381146,
0.4712576866,
-0.0979465991,
-0.1138454527,
0.2208719254,
-0.2539517879,
-0.5978893042,
-0.3296924829,
0.6549501419,
-0.8972352743,
-0.7072002888,
-0.9520691037,
-0.2908943295,
0.1139925495,
0.0848108381,
0.5785268545,
0.4281856418,
-0.1397159398,
-0.0280348845,
0.4166232944,
0.1228763908,
0.483441174,
0.4032315314,
-0.0094180424,
-0.2686491311,
0.8883172274,
0.1178355217,
-0.0488602258,
0.2401475906,
-0.1353114992,
-0.1459238827,
-0.7923333645,
-0.4248495102,
0.1885278672,
-0.9670332074,
-0.4093185067,
-0.3659106195,
-0.4323403239,
-0.306807816,
-0.1632524729,
-0.1669547558,
-0.4612275064,
-0.3732979596,
-0.026409125,
0.4032711983,
0.6445771456,
-0.0875611678,
0.692153573,
-0.781380415,
0.2098644227,
-0.3337741494,
-0.0535281226,
-0.3733388484,
-0.8410738111,
-0.4153322279,
-0.0524213612,
-0.5383760929,
-1.2966349125,
0.5398901701,
0.211217925,
0.2544450164,
0.5828083158,
0.026381772,
0.541875124,
-0.4043652415,
0.9217731357,
-0.2020864934,
-1.0025975704,
0.7883497477,
-0.2058178484,
0.3011370301,
0.3774762452,
0.9898326993,
-0.7024976611,
-0.4987877011,
-0.5737606287,
-0.7998718023,
0.4982329309,
0.520544827,
-0.0489314906,
-0.1974191219,
0.3722314239,
0.0435686372,
0.3415006995,
-0.4088018835,
-0.6631681323,
-0.1739394814,
-0.1359301358,
-0.0784600601,
-0.632641077,
-0.1183321029,
-0.2829608917,
0.9256721735,
-0.1034866199,
0.3657662272,
0.3498076797,
-0.2937994897,
-0.2840047479,
0.2739445567,
0.9808875918,
0.8236846924,
0.1173023954,
0.1713550389,
-0.1543395519,
-0.6299259067,
0.3637815118,
0.2457866669,
-0.2787457108,
0.4810613692,
0.5503046513,
0.7602324486,
0.1524930894,
-0.3256826401,
0.6226209402,
0.2532394826,
-0.2956664264,
-0.7063289881,
0.097872816,
-0.2497731745,
0.3843038976,
0.6872115135,
0.4466818869,
0.4863330424,
-0.2738520205,
0.2874682546,
0.2207144201,
-0.1164387316,
-0.2284463346,
0.6114014387,
-0.0653805509,
-0.7042719126,
0.2565247416,
-0.4687372148,
-1.0116481781,
0.5240108371,
0.5550473332,
0.5393432379,
-0.6684207916,
0.4865249693,
0.4024044871,
0.2049712688,
0.0127607286,
0.5552541018,
-0.0314619429,
-0.8008463979,
-0.5531882048,
-0.5243206024,
-0.0348980874,
0.0507070236,
-0.4622143805,
0.298327446,
-0.0840430111,
-0.1838014573,
0.2828347981,
0.2370232046,
-0.4428060055,
0.1724926233,
0.0826652423,
0.9560872912,
-0.9777728915,
0.8440133929,
0.815993607,
-0.3642922938,
-0.9183252454,
0.1556051224,
0.1564925313,
-0.9010568857,
0.7630181313,
0.3021913171,
-0.2301172316,
0.2756722867,
-0.5411227942,
-1.1464694738,
0.8295947313,
-0.0059508546,
-0.2074691355,
0.1513151228,
0.1213524714,
0.2848700583,
-0.1884548962,
0.2311678827,
0.5513609052,
0.4828990996,
0.2856540084,
-0.9062560797,
0.0371570997,
-0.4622191489,
0.0018498733,
0.5095189214,
-0.6679158807,
0.6201451421,
0.2540101111,
-0.2591440082,
0.2440692931,
0.896435082,
0.0782432705,
0.4640593529,
0.5060044527,
0.4996106625,
0.303996861,
0.0328172781,
0.8019762039,
-0.2863621116,
0.153404519,
0.7086902261,
0.0836119503,
0.8215295672,
0.5779086947,
0.2254276723,
0.8012324572,
0.5184401274,
0.0432533361,
0.6756384373,
0.2915666997,
-0.6154372096,
0.0228030533,
-0.5764549971,
-0.3318079114,
0.7749417424,
0.4085226059,
-0.3514913917,
-0.2091547698,
0.2636004388,
0.3987661302,
0.2379720956,
-0.3682282269,
0.7570732236,
-0.0241689626,
-0.9379285574,
0.7111666799,
0.5448613167,
0.5960692167,
-0.3614208996,
-0.4687827528,
0.0331222527,
0.0833168402,
0.0280601438,
-0.5017991662,
0.450492084,
-0.1707012951,
0.0520392358,
0.0503082499,
1.1704659462,
-0.3754470646,
-0.5085330009,
-0.0020884625,
0.4826030135,
0.2126301974,
-0.2234866172,
-0.4135793149,
0.3455050886,
-0.2413700521,
-0.2605654597,
0.0347787961,
0.3633317947,
-0.3729577661,
0.4817197919,
0.5570987463,
0.1072150096,
-0.049838461,
-0.0091816597,
0.7892664075,
-0.5958291292,
-0.5089705586,
-0.9920098186,
0.2692294717,
-0.2961139083,
-0.4892638624,
0.9808915854,
0.6305977106,
0.8216670752,
0.0283892248,
0.6368774176,
0.1006103307,
0.6238473654,
-0.256349653,
0.6952391267,
-0.4195073247,
-0.0260669794,
-0.2295818329,
-0.8264919519,
-0.3089290559,
0.6943228841,
-0.2344793379,
-0.1112515926,
0.8948248029,
0.9297780991,
0.1221198589,
0.0982466638,
0.2561706901,
-0.0602100715,
0.0348888971,
0.270128727,
0.8875214458,
-0.651758492,
0.3986473083,
-0.2714861035,
-0.1393739134,
-0.3903101981,
-0.8634198308,
-0.8889274597,
-0.8028515577,
-0.4154469371,
-0.4534768164,
0.4202715755,
0.9651424289,
0.6030831337,
-0.6565818787,
-0.0984479338,
0.0359597988,
0.2109546661,
-0.1885986328,
-0.2018025219,
0.5546869636,
-0.0668599159,
-0.5946075916,
0.0160618667,
0.1699088216,
-0.145885542,
-0.0972635895,
0.116080597,
-0.5904970169,
0.1179569215,
0.334543705,
0.0490184054,
-0.6987839937,
-0.6938846707,
-0.3020667732,
0.0552720912,
0.0457848459,
0.7795258164,
-0.8177417517,
-0.0988111869,
0.131414935,
0.4667357802,
0.412625134,
0.235209316,
0.2055153847,
-1.0077717304,
0.5455582738,
0.5826562643,
-0.0163320787,
0.2408644408,
-0.4652739465,
0.3547509909,
0.3285953999,
-0.7612515688,
-0.6769508123,
0.0867667943,
-0.8553361893,
-0.1462487727,
1.1953195333,
0.052241981,
-0.4607878625,
-0.325310111,
-0.4593933523,
0.7159828544,
-0.5447412729,
0.8699804544,
0.784080863,
0.3240382075,
-0.1363886893,
-0.5640137196,
0.6898932457,
0.5367116928,
-0.4421426654,
-1.0003018379,
0.3328183591,
0.1847052276,
0.3342841268,
0.7726010084,
0.3519697189,
0.5413999557,
0.0125725297,
-0.2020365894,
0.0758229196,
-0.4516093731,
-0.1065464243,
0.3297721446,
0.2744995952,
-0.5461992621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01358v1 | Evaluating Knowledge-based Cross-lingual Inconsistency in Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T15:11:37 | 2024-07-01T15:11:37 | Xiaolin Xing, Zhiwei He, Haoyu Xu, Xing Wang, Rui Wang, Yu Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the cross-lingual inconsistencies observed in Large
Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, Llama, and Baichuan, which have shown
exceptional performance in various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks.
Despite their successes, these models often exhibit significant inconsistencies
when processing the same concepts across different languages. This study
focuses on three primary questions: the existence of cross-lingual
inconsistencies in LLMs, the specific aspects in which these inconsistencies
manifest, and the correlation between cross-lingual consistency and
multilingual capabilities of LLMs.To address these questions, we propose an
innovative evaluation method for Cross-lingual Semantic Consistency (xSC) using
the LaBSE model. We further introduce metrics for Cross-lingual Accuracy
Consistency (xAC) and Cross-lingual Timeliness Consistency (xTC) to
comprehensively assess the models' performance regarding semantic, accuracy,
and timeliness inconsistencies. By harmonizing these metrics, we provide a
holistic measurement of LLMs' cross-lingual consistency. Our findings aim to
enhance the understanding and improvement of multilingual capabilities and
interpretability in LLMs, contributing to the development of more robust and
reliable multilingual language models. | [
-0.1145543605,
-0.7611600757,
0.4686143994,
0.4763085246,
0.0734821185,
0.3260443211,
-0.3749253452,
-0.6455177069,
0.1573942751,
0.1957868785,
-0.4233162403,
-0.4600303173,
-0.7283100486,
0.1507948786,
-0.3301820755,
0.5609068274,
-0.3279661238,
0.2901561558,
-0.0897036865,
-0.4279612005,
-0.6589288116,
-0.3963857889,
-0.6461348534,
-0.3550051153,
0.3052158952,
0.2293456048,
0.8530588746,
0.3870736063,
0.3068355024,
0.2507657111,
-0.1658449769,
0.3718741536,
-0.4160551727,
-0.2057034373,
-0.3763263822,
-0.4041692615,
-0.4731911123,
-0.2346624583,
0.8309316635,
0.8712583184,
-0.0199030545,
-0.1349619627,
0.1385791004,
0.308105588,
-0.3971324265,
0.2837154269,
-0.6790422201,
0.2193967998,
-0.1962474734,
-0.0863978714,
-0.3329250216,
-0.2115487158,
0.2833517194,
-0.5946336985,
0.0538727492,
0.2109501064,
0.9781504869,
-0.0795886964,
-0.4162206054,
-0.3679324687,
-0.510836184,
0.8601388335,
-1.0697907209,
0.9380934834,
0.1139238626,
0.0779056698,
-0.1524012238,
-0.4550512731,
-0.6132667661,
-0.443143934,
-0.1361026913,
0.030583648,
-0.1065046415,
-0.3601681292,
0.1050401554,
0.2427125275,
-0.7389757037,
0.4000810683,
0.1718982458,
-0.2967882156,
0.5389983058,
0.1417779922,
0.4866195619,
-0.2716974616,
-0.5513730049,
-0.0295515191,
-0.8582725525,
0.0949630439,
0.2775811255,
0.1493634135,
-0.3153982759,
0.6729140282,
-0.1522010416,
0.3981008232,
-0.0629911795,
-0.2779516578,
0.2688627541,
-0.5326012373,
-0.2412812263,
0.0540519916,
0.7426308393,
0.1686520725,
0.2119888663,
-0.4864425659,
-0.0405449308,
-0.070288837,
-0.2499759793,
-0.2713612914,
0.0056676404,
0.2080539167,
-0.1670548767,
0.0365239903,
-0.1439226568,
-0.4018107057,
-0.3500433862,
-0.3851559758,
0.4179952741,
-0.5420771837,
-0.4420157969,
0.0838035047,
0.1875070632,
0.1527947485,
0.2831137478,
-0.8058151603,
0.1491064131,
0.7138956189,
0.654489696,
-0.3104037642,
-0.8167980909,
-0.3232459128,
0.1598944813,
-0.511187315,
0.5761299133,
-0.2177889198,
-0.1744965315,
-0.038140744,
0.2357639521,
-0.3295477033,
-0.5261881948,
0.367983073,
-0.586229682,
-0.1069474965,
-0.4387164414,
-0.8802255392,
-0.171976015,
0.6540305614,
-0.5930140018,
1.1075187922,
0.0824288577,
-0.9133986831,
0.5567438006,
-0.4006811082,
-0.2397604287,
0.0605880469,
-0.3330539763,
-0.1600955278,
-0.0609697253,
0.1006639004,
0.3585944176,
-0.3994802535,
0.6174702644,
-0.190948233,
-0.2602432072,
0.4154554307,
-0.5048098564,
0.9487523437,
-0.2675581574,
-0.4118240774,
0.2349488884,
-0.8743157387,
0.2112281621,
0.1518880427,
-0.2598566413,
-0.4248963892,
-0.1609174758,
-0.1027096957,
0.3890787363,
0.4587554932,
-0.6578554511,
-0.0918785036,
-0.2637301087,
0.3083139658,
0.692271471,
-0.4087367952,
0.1754823327,
-0.3473960161,
0.3006780744,
0.1784765571,
0.1425298452,
0.065091759,
-0.5529230237,
-0.7168139815,
0.0433740057,
0.4138909876,
0.6685734987,
-0.8199506998,
0.2140232921,
-0.5922555923,
-0.55337888,
-0.2661287785,
0.3706472814,
0.4065428376,
0.4517195821,
0.2634336054,
-0.1436597705,
-0.5822373033,
-0.8207051158,
-0.303805083,
-0.3379053473,
0.1638708264,
0.067613557,
0.5368778706,
-0.4035149515,
0.8158038259,
-0.0185416136,
0.0953315273,
-0.2724646628,
0.2426534295,
-0.2611065507,
0.3363564312,
0.3950065374,
-0.598893702,
-0.5366436839,
0.4501954317,
-0.8319718838,
-0.1108710617,
0.1531317085,
0.0490155406,
0.6654206514,
0.4513301849,
-0.450213939,
0.2313414514,
0.9787402749,
-0.2330869585,
0.8390063643,
-0.2609686852,
0.325181663,
-0.6056358814,
0.0088668549,
0.0576716699,
-0.1218862459,
-0.5638269782,
0.0576365665,
0.4059761763,
0.4011082947,
-0.6465393901,
0.8958343863,
-0.421153903,
-0.1861180514,
0.0915889367,
0.564743638,
0.1986972392,
0.4899921417,
0.209201619,
0.6323312521,
0.4566214383,
-0.4322912395,
0.4535943568,
0.1196803078,
-0.5807234049,
0.6631781459,
-0.6115221381,
-0.150867492,
0.2223318964,
0.0319427475,
-0.9595227838,
-0.0379543118,
0.0939997137,
-0.2800657153,
0.2449656278,
0.04789171,
-0.7662475109,
0.0262885261,
-0.0895447135,
0.5952795744,
0.1484200805,
-0.6124793291,
0.4973595738,
0.2191344798,
-0.1998672187,
-0.7761961222,
-0.6131086946,
0.1373880655,
0.0432328768,
-1.1513607502,
0.0941250175,
0.0409176201,
-0.330208391,
0.0473272167,
-0.0935622379,
0.0216452945,
-0.1239941642,
-0.0756750703,
0.3697716594,
-0.3926056623,
0.1192595065,
-0.0883328021,
0.2126896977,
0.0476113893,
-0.1721426547,
0.5354880691,
-0.230189845,
-0.6554384828,
-0.1123203933,
0.1783099025,
0.4464396238,
-0.0086749047,
0.7740923166,
0.5656397343,
-0.3601106107,
-0.0427704714,
-0.7981671095,
0.2315734476,
-0.3360898197,
0.5011136532,
-0.3807463348,
-1.0100692511,
0.9565010667,
0.1762375087,
0.1054744646,
0.4175597429,
0.4949967265,
0.2122847736,
0.9911491275,
0.7644297481,
0.2128299624,
0.1364019066,
-0.0262149908,
0.2521179318,
-0.959636271,
-0.4955699146,
-0.3626129329,
0.1003117561,
-0.6701779366,
-0.4611878693,
0.2554148734,
-0.0809983835,
-0.4147666097,
0.3635416329,
0.3818469346,
0.1086918339,
0.2319641411,
-0.3397089243,
0.7072682381,
-0.0618535429,
-0.5153930783,
-0.1238760948,
-1.022161603,
-0.5018140674,
0.7455217242,
0.4486241341,
0.7503919005,
0.1588730216,
0.1627717763,
0.0357899442,
0.2157156318,
-0.5498262644,
0.4705655873,
-0.215551421,
-0.6311991215,
-0.5586212277,
-0.6353652477,
-0.8694690466,
0.435159117,
-0.193911612,
-0.9153641462,
0.1788323373,
-0.2297780961,
-0.0612616315,
0.5347979665,
-0.5611265898,
1.1125488281,
-0.5346773863,
-0.4192532003,
-0.0794739276,
-0.6435492635,
0.6544795632,
-0.3044027686,
0.357341826,
-0.2092443705,
-0.0162193961,
0.699047029,
-0.3951228559,
0.7324522734,
0.2701673806,
-0.7004144192,
0.0343358889,
0.0610338859,
0.4618024826,
0.0716316178,
-0.0607054271,
0.7103191614,
0.2590391636,
-0.3740162551,
-0.7016096711,
0.7566325665,
-0.939814806,
-0.5559404492,
-0.2306628376,
-0.9779056907,
-0.5750254989,
0.1601998955,
0.23494111,
0.3552052975,
-0.411985606,
-0.1478406638,
0.6602959037,
-0.4511986375,
0.2032321841,
0.8162170649,
-0.4901661575,
-0.1661605388,
0.7642784119,
0.3950948417,
0.6933209896,
0.4864888191,
0.0682151839,
-0.4041393697,
-0.3337968588,
-0.6819674373,
0.4170465171,
-0.9351514578,
0.0894272178,
-0.6288524866,
-0.3651863337,
-0.6257733107,
0.0367522091,
-0.5327659249,
-0.2887762189,
0.0872232765,
0.2043547183,
0.1070079952,
0.6705892086,
-0.1520029902,
0.1882657558,
-1.0277328491,
0.1522420049,
-0.0329809897,
0.3932183385,
0.2143138349,
-0.6758580208,
-0.4629144371,
0.3132324517,
0.0105230948,
-0.6094067097,
0.1896943301,
-0.2299914062,
0.7930219769,
0.1755077839,
-0.259727627,
0.6595731974,
-0.3300516307,
0.7132284641,
0.2387448549,
-1.3376026154,
0.1746445745,
-0.1168146059,
0.2431162298,
0.0999088436,
0.2571022213,
-0.9242597222,
-0.5282369256,
-0.6088502407,
-0.7300089598,
0.5377253294,
0.1285883784,
-0.2884243131,
0.0137495687,
-0.0691714585,
0.2430597395,
-0.0236440543,
-0.7681091428,
-0.1263509095,
-0.0241989344,
0.1954777539,
0.0076610688,
-0.2359959483,
-0.0890570208,
0.0180014502,
0.9504995942,
-0.1069625318,
-0.3698685467,
0.075466089,
-0.2809631526,
-0.0964407697,
0.4710943401,
0.5453105569,
1.0490580797,
-0.0115378918,
0.1106163487,
0.6204778552,
-0.273812741,
0.2334807366,
-0.1099905372,
-0.0320593268,
0.1206231192,
0.5772019625,
0.7815107107,
0.4992782772,
-0.866280973,
0.4522648454,
-0.223280564,
0.1278353333,
-0.196705088,
-0.155497551,
0.2899857163,
0.2017696798,
-0.0003454816,
-0.0455435589,
-0.2913840413,
-0.7330643535,
-0.1411101967,
0.4899602532,
-0.1964161694,
-0.1132940724,
0.410957396,
-0.1745735854,
0.1099916399,
0.5356522202,
-0.1401584446,
-0.5018506646,
0.6212826371,
0.4766896963,
0.5576044321,
-0.2224374861,
0.1585872471,
0.0367985815,
0.6005092859,
-0.2597037852,
0.1248174608,
0.2164907753,
-1.0443307161,
-0.7112993598,
-0.3370580375,
-0.6560595632,
-0.0347873792,
-0.5199689865,
0.4291419089,
-0.1637969315,
0.0108309099,
-0.1767918915,
0.1311842203,
-0.6393364072,
0.2880859375,
0.0464140251,
1.0849870443,
-0.8831317425,
0.8968728781,
0.6138537526,
-0.2166358232,
-1.1268239021,
-0.1215301976,
-0.0662063062,
-0.9323170185,
0.9002760649,
-0.2676317394,
-0.3026728928,
-0.3939577937,
-0.1469464004,
-0.9776932597,
1.1040070057,
0.4351505339,
-0.7542987466,
0.0091827773,
0.4822942913,
0.601043582,
-0.2535536885,
0.2144497782,
0.7093219161,
0.6043803692,
0.1122813299,
-1.3783035278,
0.1056789607,
-0.2228616774,
0.1480306536,
0.0248034224,
-0.7353961468,
0.8360877037,
-0.1013575941,
-0.2804403901,
0.0627417415,
0.5626882911,
0.5667275786,
0.3144315779,
0.4021712542,
0.6066393256,
0.8896282911,
-0.1500199437,
0.9635239244,
-0.314799875,
0.3218143284,
1.2165957689,
-0.7266393304,
0.7629044056,
0.4558694065,
-0.1993419081,
0.3832316697,
0.4295798838,
0.0504714847,
0.11317873,
0.0170282256,
-0.0853338689,
-0.2361616641,
-0.0286245439,
-0.4859904945,
0.3987225592,
0.3013996482,
-0.0060274214,
-0.3913030028,
-0.0140493633,
0.1642093211,
-0.2490216494,
-0.1354387105,
0.4315904081,
0.0974151641,
-0.6837626696,
0.6411066055,
0.2740775049,
0.6850641966,
-0.6937100291,
0.1822093874,
-0.2626516223,
0.2544821203,
-0.3458212316,
-0.8911818266,
0.3938284814,
0.010942881,
-0.0991435051,
0.172373727,
0.4584813714,
-0.5432084799,
-0.5484059453,
0.6936153769,
0.8422859311,
0.1684381813,
0.29362005,
-0.6370192766,
0.4657370448,
-0.1147614866,
0.096648939,
0.3617806435,
0.8403736949,
-0.3068393767,
0.785880208,
0.4850142598,
0.1990643293,
0.309442699,
0.2826166749,
0.3921410441,
-0.4951729178,
-0.2660434246,
-0.8449815512,
0.3057922721,
0.1273474693,
-0.3408267498,
1.1840678453,
0.4586429894,
1.2044227123,
0.1500865072,
0.8410670757,
-0.0086927442,
0.4593138993,
-0.6342735291,
0.6216956377,
-0.6680121422,
0.6331720948,
-0.3382939696,
-0.7439739704,
-0.2076703012,
0.4272430241,
-0.4515903294,
0.0517622791,
0.914642036,
0.7859300375,
-0.0535275489,
0.3580146432,
0.5904255509,
0.3648844957,
0.2429791987,
0.6293563247,
1.0883613825,
-0.5449985862,
0.4733397663,
-0.2443419099,
-0.0926306173,
-0.0921780765,
-0.9968731403,
-0.7099638581,
-0.4408443868,
-0.5650401115,
-0.3285930157,
0.1441202164,
0.6942337751,
0.5447863936,
-0.8554748893,
-0.5648918748,
0.1296099424,
0.4052002728,
-0.2512565553,
-0.2347113937,
0.3935359716,
-0.3846130669,
-0.6556732655,
0.2632638216,
0.3806225955,
-0.0195906218,
-0.6028355956,
-0.2200048417,
-0.3478461802,
0.1967078149,
0.7625337243,
0.217833817,
-0.9603235722,
-0.2855288386,
0.2462698221,
-0.3089593649,
0.1485320628,
0.585975945,
-0.4521048367,
0.1871915758,
0.535869956,
0.6395944357,
0.2211207598,
-0.3883199394,
0.4262703061,
-0.5500425696,
-0.1800145358,
-0.1503696293,
0.8113373518,
0.6860839725,
-0.1730532497,
0.5285160542,
0.1459172964,
-0.5907096267,
-0.6671760082,
0.156990245,
-0.9614049792,
-0.2035026252,
1.0836558342,
-0.5586261749,
-0.0695926473,
-0.2291826308,
-0.0563988052,
0.3468637168,
0.0967517942,
0.6681345701,
1.1023273468,
-0.160695374,
-0.0541384667,
-0.6336764693,
0.0503848195,
0.6130216122,
-0.7618983984,
0.1783147156,
0.3770654202,
0.6514660716,
0.3773083985,
0.3433613479,
-0.3558642268,
0.2343653738,
0.0502118208,
-0.0650476664,
0.3601958454,
-0.2291087657,
-0.1069348082,
0.0021511705,
0.0147928987,
0.3632030189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01334v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01334v2 | Protecting Privacy in Classifiers by Token Manipulation | 2024-07-01T14:41:59 | 2024-07-03T16:31:52 | Re'em Harel, Yair Elboher, Yuval Pinter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Using language models as a remote service entails sending private information
to an untrusted provider. In addition, potential eavesdroppers can intercept
the messages, thereby exposing the information. In this work, we explore the
prospects of avoiding such data exposure at the level of text manipulation. We
focus on text classification models, examining various token mapping and
contextualized manipulation functions in order to see whether classifier
accuracy may be maintained while keeping the original text unrecoverable. We
find that although some token mapping functions are easy and straightforward to
implement, they heavily influence performance on the downstream task, and via a
sophisticated attacker can be reconstructed. In comparison, the contextualized
manipulation provides an improvement in performance. | [
0.0657152608,
-0.6534525752,
0.3000994325,
-0.2115931809,
-0.100839369,
0.1125222519,
-0.1151262,
-0.8995337486,
-0.2987403274,
1.0661436319,
-0.0198582616,
-0.6362562776,
-0.907177031,
-0.2622659504,
-0.773152113,
1.1714937687,
0.1351522505,
-0.1702187061,
0.1108621359,
-0.0923504159,
-0.2774089873,
-1.1677626371,
-0.5563567281,
0.0058026183,
0.5038465261,
0.2103699744,
0.8938984275,
0.9298151135,
0.827188015,
0.4104294181,
-0.1180589348,
-0.0586964078,
-0.310040921,
0.2416199595,
-0.3231750727,
-0.8649704456,
-0.3568303585,
-0.028971659,
0.5471884608,
0.7296810746,
0.1591881365,
0.1521214843,
0.0304949619,
0.4985767603,
-0.8712571263,
0.2166129053,
-0.8325092196,
0.0939439461,
-0.3187004328,
-0.3248769939,
-0.8535320759,
-0.1063221768,
0.1763866246,
-0.4373134673,
0.3961574137,
0.318798393,
0.8161673546,
0.2601462901,
-0.4951098561,
0.0741021037,
-0.8114643693,
0.6407678723,
-0.2991607487,
0.1946115196,
0.8086704612,
0.3360675871,
-0.0833070278,
-0.8401894569,
-0.1916175336,
-0.0233986974,
-0.6280670166,
-0.1709158421,
-0.2717211246,
0.4713335931,
0.4185998142,
0.275336355,
-0.1416704804,
0.1876558512,
-0.4855545759,
-0.4682493806,
0.5745447278,
0.0571336262,
0.5115798116,
-0.2038144767,
-0.4954104722,
-0.0338070095,
-0.5670616627,
0.3598015308,
0.3644064963,
0.4842176139,
0.2201897055,
0.7758061886,
0.0687748939,
0.7609521151,
-0.0441750437,
-0.0502048992,
-0.0984532684,
-0.2826428711,
-0.5478448272,
0.2112798393,
0.5008452535,
0.2425235957,
-0.0015056428,
-0.5636746287,
-0.2770671248,
0.00681561,
0.369846791,
-0.6888160706,
-0.0988819078,
0.2831524909,
-0.800118506,
-0.7289262414,
0.4453891516,
-0.636693418,
-0.2729307115,
-0.1978787035,
0.4313566387,
-0.290871799,
-0.0394584313,
0.024315143,
-0.2958158255,
-0.1416504681,
0.0820624158,
-0.9890711308,
0.6713443995,
1.0762012005,
0.8592529297,
-0.2506146133,
-0.294293046,
-0.7602800727,
0.541482687,
-0.3028069139,
0.2308491766,
-0.6584371924,
-0.5338158607,
0.0754826814,
0.1755626053,
-0.022132732,
-0.3889558017,
0.197766766,
-0.808414638,
0.3935350776,
-0.008112303,
-0.6523682475,
-0.1514748633,
0.1500356346,
-0.7531912327,
0.7168991566,
0.1079757735,
-1.0548356771,
0.3015200198,
-0.8624674678,
-0.5286397338,
-0.0787074268,
0.155014649,
-0.3013671339,
0.1689065248,
0.0532387681,
0.4994601011,
0.3396573365,
0.2119524777,
0.1764334887,
-0.6789873242,
0.45544222,
-0.4246306121,
0.7984402776,
0.2674404681,
-0.5354920626,
0.2738268971,
-0.7608234286,
-0.323410809,
-0.2950256169,
-0.3386458755,
-0.8786385059,
-0.1305331439,
0.1690303534,
-0.0009112327,
0.2150672823,
-0.5059499145,
0.1624583155,
-0.586261034,
0.3093350828,
0.9563868046,
-0.10692361,
1.0339305401,
-0.2877737284,
0.6029041409,
0.2974925339,
0.2905893326,
-0.4072202444,
-0.3554961383,
-0.4786191583,
-0.6408186555,
0.7923392653,
0.5261774659,
-0.6722149253,
0.4129594564,
-0.4775309265,
-0.5644909739,
-0.4028626382,
-0.0924561396,
0.358419925,
0.5445030332,
0.1777122915,
-0.1088298857,
-0.3010267317,
-0.6577880383,
-0.7512474656,
-0.1420651674,
-0.0583221093,
0.1804572493,
0.0439580269,
-0.2859842777,
0.9828908443,
-0.5004217029,
-0.3781581819,
0.0686113164,
0.1245464087,
-0.348710686,
0.8237804174,
0.5761728883,
-1.0797232389,
-0.1334346086,
0.1765291095,
-0.5233101845,
0.0578071438,
-0.2442609072,
-0.2608047724,
0.2804073095,
0.6486113667,
-0.381308645,
0.9753621221,
0.3163166642,
-0.5811456442,
-0.0064449091,
-0.1981975734,
0.12242385,
-0.8908364177,
0.2093955129,
-0.3366708159,
-0.7264789939,
-1.0482307673,
0.4831668735,
0.2093476355,
-0.2957456112,
-0.6174702048,
0.5557047129,
-0.4361360371,
0.0145575535,
-0.3438844979,
-0.0911182165,
-0.2783986926,
0.1347752959,
0.1118737236,
0.7393864989,
0.5837577581,
-0.514647305,
-0.0612018369,
0.2403606772,
-0.1061718836,
0.090269424,
-0.3198710978,
0.2152478546,
-0.2506918311,
-0.0224473849,
-0.8112505674,
-0.134371683,
0.4789360464,
-0.5120363832,
0.4486925304,
-0.3098788559,
-0.5504484177,
0.3158906698,
-0.3248054683,
0.3525111079,
0.4573580325,
-0.7692629099,
0.7672166228,
0.4192342758,
0.1527936459,
-0.8070536256,
-1.0073535442,
0.1805537343,
-0.3931964934,
-0.1856435537,
0.5513981581,
0.3122656047,
-0.2644216716,
0.1695139706,
0.0071230121,
-0.1014167964,
0.5401534438,
0.6953759193,
0.4374403656,
0.3730423152,
0.1429990977,
0.1936586499,
-0.2915416956,
0.1223520562,
-0.0910078362,
0.4439301789,
0.3930645287,
-0.4123934805,
-0.6318240762,
0.4576135576,
0.4210641086,
-0.3391295075,
0.9382686615,
0.2733621895,
-0.5931694508,
0.086340569,
-0.1985820979,
-0.248404786,
-0.5526459217,
0.1541963369,
-0.4616022408,
-1.0177328587,
0.488718003,
-0.0071509108,
0.0660906807,
-0.0229281932,
0.1594833285,
0.3663240969,
1.0553586483,
0.9953597188,
-0.2981823385,
0.7130365372,
0.0651403442,
0.4696370959,
-0.5686597824,
-0.2908771932,
-0.7577316761,
-0.2323578149,
-1.0918654203,
-0.2549293339,
0.1912661344,
-0.0216402691,
0.0528268553,
0.4176779985,
-0.7409512401,
0.597274065,
0.5628589988,
0.1589051038,
0.2850886881,
0.2301928848,
0.1826716512,
0.0222305562,
-0.4414559901,
-0.7433708906,
1.2615174055,
0.4882045686,
0.6275386214,
0.0837774649,
0.8421114683,
0.1209941953,
0.5083630681,
-0.598929584,
0.6050212979,
-0.1049228236,
-0.7818773985,
-0.3824755549,
-0.4796223938,
-1.0612729788,
0.4077776074,
0.0790547431,
-1.0572185516,
0.1757942587,
0.1153762862,
-0.0369515419,
0.5823061466,
-0.7706736326,
0.408310473,
0.0426226333,
-0.2991683483,
0.0379047468,
-0.8275024295,
0.2056390047,
-0.2473732829,
0.4351543486,
0.2569742203,
-0.1522118449,
0.6282864809,
-0.6213139296,
1.0159250498,
-0.3518883884,
0.0556845665,
-0.0429270193,
0.4938901365,
0.3192955256,
-0.0445696898,
0.031069044,
0.2917266488,
0.3179775476,
-0.5766752362,
-0.7019965053,
0.6967640519,
-0.5859039426,
-0.8149212003,
-0.6149814129,
-0.3871736526,
-0.058602687,
0.3206680715,
0.1148052365,
0.2520927191,
0.1186467558,
0.1405754834,
0.3682186902,
-0.0572705083,
0.7643169165,
0.163326174,
-0.3715789616,
-0.0997783914,
0.7953590751,
0.1414836794,
0.3855436146,
0.6857884526,
0.2957940102,
-0.225246802,
-0.387681812,
-0.2656037509,
-0.2692321539,
-0.8784661293,
-0.2671830356,
-0.7226065397,
-0.1345992982,
-0.4983898997,
-0.1749205291,
0.0209740996,
-0.8679438233,
-0.4638015926,
-0.4381561875,
0.2701594234,
0.4126227796,
-0.1106042638,
0.5098329782,
-0.8034927845,
0.039789997,
0.1189389899,
0.2078960985,
-0.0750389695,
-0.3692135513,
-0.0012679951,
-0.132807374,
-0.0042344346,
-0.9224418402,
0.3723271489,
-0.0871450156,
0.240985319,
0.4509551823,
0.1074758023,
0.6003501415,
-0.5303704143,
1.0331618786,
-0.0583188981,
-1.5171153545,
0.5685626268,
0.0270376764,
-0.0362198874,
0.4618733823,
0.3509484529,
-0.5795685649,
-0.565744102,
-0.5801210403,
-0.7590811849,
0.7628638744,
0.2418053895,
0.4996981919,
0.1919064671,
0.6256921291,
0.1904168874,
0.4381333888,
-0.6687251329,
-0.4061226845,
-0.2963591516,
-0.3147028387,
-0.0623079948,
-0.251113832,
-0.2024603784,
-0.2741580904,
0.2633267939,
0.0738635734,
0.2506814897,
0.0758928731,
0.0030289164,
0.0174248703,
0.0600302555,
0.4164221585,
0.4406183362,
0.1598546505,
0.5248720646,
-0.0652091652,
-0.673689127,
0.1541551501,
0.0167153496,
-0.5773835778,
0.1478710473,
0.4961047471,
0.4876786172,
0.2820267677,
-0.6023779511,
0.7697837949,
-0.1339428723,
0.0586284101,
-0.0519234128,
0.2568665445,
-0.4741471112,
-0.2229001373,
0.2552047372,
0.3573271632,
0.4429452121,
-0.4532025754,
0.0861427039,
0.348503083,
-0.3429504633,
-0.3260897398,
0.8935530186,
-0.1586439162,
-0.778408289,
0.1926058382,
0.1749904901,
-0.7287843227,
0.316988647,
0.6895383,
0.536524415,
-0.5258043408,
0.1909047663,
-0.0432847962,
0.3598017395,
-0.0446482077,
0.0562299863,
-0.3624985814,
-0.5804848671,
-0.198117882,
-0.082464017,
-0.3665757477,
-0.1703713536,
-1.0495021343,
0.1964621544,
-0.5898219943,
-0.1747850925,
0.1852129698,
-0.4594172239,
-0.7049642801,
0.3586173058,
-0.3302124143,
0.8837105036,
-0.5670758486,
0.8559619784,
0.6537736058,
-0.1600909233,
-0.5787172914,
0.0757661536,
-0.2586821318,
-0.5807723999,
0.782628715,
0.2824394405,
-0.1800165027,
-0.2410001904,
-0.7261701226,
-0.5753495097,
0.6730877757,
0.158529982,
-0.525378406,
-0.0854924694,
0.4194298387,
0.5951865911,
0.1333494782,
-0.1373703629,
0.5432514548,
0.4172489047,
-0.3696735203,
-0.8471455574,
0.2508695424,
0.0205937382,
0.1593499631,
0.1376819611,
-0.5746997595,
0.512342751,
0.2374484539,
-0.2979262769,
-0.0895218179,
0.3346147835,
-0.231939286,
0.3333260417,
0.5053102374,
-0.0027458374,
0.9608479142,
-0.1270336062,
1.1067092419,
-0.3757074177,
0.2654666901,
0.8923690319,
-0.2281559557,
0.841116488,
0.7862690687,
0.2014958858,
0.1894584894,
0.299033463,
0.2069760263,
0.883723855,
0.1943285614,
-0.3610576689,
0.0957383588,
-0.0036692419,
-0.1117175445,
0.8127701879,
0.0773738995,
-0.6290997267,
0.1864584386,
0.4055679739,
0.2989054322,
0.3712103069,
-0.1728841513,
0.8873282075,
-0.1851630956,
-0.4622675478,
0.1525493115,
0.6370337605,
0.6310984492,
-0.1681182832,
0.1862537861,
0.167959094,
0.1649236977,
-0.2588392496,
-0.3247226477,
0.602263689,
0.0066599948,
0.0174174216,
-0.4912871718,
1.0385831594,
-0.2677737474,
-0.4078072011,
0.1981923282,
0.156803444,
0.0260678213,
0.0553963408,
-0.3479826152,
0.1357437968,
-0.1017740816,
-0.124192819,
0.4944587946,
0.4049583972,
0.0217294376,
0.6089280844,
0.8816330433,
0.2884711623,
0.1558469236,
-0.2600642741,
0.8594363332,
-0.7187747955,
-0.7667973638,
-1.0319210291,
0.2949942648,
-0.2684855163,
-0.0711216778,
0.8936789632,
0.7270145416,
1.054101944,
-0.0285040438,
0.8445462584,
0.3921362162,
0.5625450611,
-0.5423821807,
0.917345047,
-0.1705834717,
0.3303257525,
-0.2599665225,
-0.3842443526,
-0.7873219848,
0.5147245526,
-0.435431242,
-0.2603883743,
0.4845245779,
0.702505827,
0.0386231504,
0.3013520241,
0.4787229598,
-0.2492643595,
0.7455592752,
0.0262947697,
0.7450845838,
-0.6167051196,
0.1883508116,
-0.5564635396,
-0.2692865133,
-0.0902613923,
-0.8787276745,
-1.22057724,
-0.5246089697,
-0.3166617453,
-0.4036777914,
-0.0575278327,
0.5926048756,
0.9150417447,
-0.7829574943,
0.1064376608,
-0.0330562741,
0.1898383051,
-0.1900241673,
-0.2319852114,
0.5171969533,
-0.153582111,
-0.9298591018,
0.1896180511,
0.2980486751,
0.3831899762,
-0.2940604389,
0.4996758997,
0.3790504038,
0.0801770017,
0.4552428424,
-0.0237130057,
-0.6405365467,
-0.6280569434,
0.0889553428,
-0.1110782847,
-0.0452060774,
1.1744412184,
-0.6448922157,
0.4687875509,
0.2532585859,
0.9198107123,
0.3305677474,
0.3590516448,
0.2100811005,
-0.9543241262,
0.5469924808,
0.1496307701,
0.1064235866,
0.3770298064,
-1.0402035713,
0.2437555194,
0.0518303923,
-0.4562760293,
-1.2434805632,
0.0557666123,
-0.7131501436,
-0.5315743089,
0.9508536458,
-0.3073076606,
-0.4973224699,
-0.2163289487,
-0.4402424097,
0.1127662659,
-0.0489413776,
0.9467880726,
0.6775336266,
0.1428940743,
-0.0164218973,
-0.2632381022,
0.5914068818,
0.3725618422,
-0.7508487701,
0.0571414046,
0.1722029597,
0.4145501256,
0.162439391,
0.5452308655,
-0.5064153671,
-0.0720815808,
-0.2912276089,
-0.3309362233,
-0.0564957112,
-0.4002354741,
-0.6460635662,
0.4996649921,
-0.0182046294,
-0.673009932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01320v1 | Increasing Model Capacity for Free: A Simple Strategy for Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning | 2024-07-01T14:26:48 | 2024-07-01T14:26:48 | Haobo Song, Hao Zhao, Soumajit Majumder, Tao Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Fine-tuning large pre-trained foundation models, such as the 175B GPT-3, has
attracted more attention for downstream tasks recently. While
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods have been proposed and proven effective
without retraining all model parameters, their performance is limited by the
capacity of incremental modules, especially under constrained parameter
budgets. \\ To overcome this challenge, we propose CapaBoost, a simple yet
effective strategy that enhances model capacity by leveraging low-rank updates
through parallel weight modules in target layers. By applying static random
masks to the shared weight matrix, CapaBoost constructs a diverse set of weight
matrices, effectively increasing the rank of incremental weights without adding
parameters. Notably, our approach can be seamlessly integrated into various
existing parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. We extensively validate the
efficacy of CapaBoost through experiments on diverse downstream tasks,
including natural language understanding, question answering, and image
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
baselines, without incurring additional computation or storage costs. Our code
is available at \url{https://github.com/LINs-lab/CapaBoost}. | [
-0.7983384132,
-0.6403475404,
0.2533223033,
0.1842955202,
-0.4533050358,
0.0077871415,
-0.3890116811,
-0.2877639532,
-0.1832765788,
0.7358046174,
-0.561075747,
-0.3274190724,
-0.5689780712,
-0.4294323325,
-0.0817035958,
1.2809121609,
-0.268129766,
-0.0257557984,
-0.264479965,
-0.3580777645,
-0.863037467,
0.1093215272,
-0.9316704869,
-0.162849158,
0.6433179975,
1.0610947609,
0.601647675,
0.6896106005,
0.6930916905,
0.1317675263,
0.1421933472,
0.4119743705,
-0.6162019372,
-0.0241014659,
-0.0099509899,
-0.213368088,
-0.5148300529,
0.017132964,
0.6612529755,
0.806353569,
-0.2691449523,
0.4157574475,
0.3427926302,
0.8075279593,
-0.873696208,
0.2012456506,
-0.8421480656,
-0.415327996,
-0.1865993589,
0.0512708947,
-0.0778585076,
-0.0958018899,
-0.0465371385,
-0.5490678549,
0.5403756499,
0.281062007,
1.182582736,
0.5126208067,
-0.1720634103,
0.1414621919,
-0.2599800825,
0.9468113184,
-0.4035355151,
0.3228551745,
0.4884447455,
0.5939533114,
0.0277992766,
-0.6948783994,
-0.1824025512,
-0.4671935439,
-0.0029202977,
-0.0843933001,
-0.0197521076,
0.4524127543,
0.4518227875,
0.6490601897,
-0.4795820713,
-0.1118678451,
-0.4696280956,
-0.2012350708,
0.3863350153,
0.0056430316,
0.1488439739,
0.1195984185,
-0.327580601,
-0.2501378655,
-0.5971753597,
0.0750252455,
0.3870393932,
0.371766001,
-0.0625420958,
0.3946433663,
-0.7142385244,
0.8822042346,
0.0908441618,
0.3995574713,
-0.0879155323,
-0.1832271069,
-0.4081025422,
-0.2678357363,
0.3065534532,
0.1406157017,
0.1685539484,
-0.1332356483,
-0.2339768559,
-0.1889081597,
0.4686840773,
-1.1835292578,
-0.4735479355,
0.1892525852,
-0.3674690127,
-0.2453260273,
-0.0822252929,
-0.4254373908,
-0.0922730565,
-0.4348792732,
0.7018247247,
-0.5246367455,
0.0791890174,
0.3677326441,
-0.2124730945,
-0.0487627462,
0.5558449626,
-1.0150629282,
0.5913503766,
0.642935276,
1.0307115316,
-0.0388328731,
-0.1455912739,
-0.7807409763,
0.2714886665,
-0.3432817161,
0.714626193,
-0.2765267789,
0.1199022457,
-0.4112356901,
0.0168336276,
0.093416281,
-0.5095674992,
0.2857458293,
-0.4689959586,
-0.3266845942,
-0.5169041753,
-0.2890926301,
-0.2563923001,
0.2895717323,
-0.7286412716,
0.8846462965,
0.2879970074,
-0.4893760681,
0.4272506833,
-0.9294728041,
-0.3242156506,
0.009584588,
-0.0057056667,
-0.6041865349,
0.1524640173,
0.5784566402,
0.6375202537,
-0.5565130115,
0.126995042,
-0.2791482806,
-0.523439765,
-0.3545978963,
-0.1533725262,
0.5614974499,
0.4304291606,
-0.1402635127,
0.250379324,
-0.7122007608,
0.0289589949,
-0.0944787562,
-0.1281811893,
-0.1402723342,
-0.3119304776,
-0.084918268,
-0.3678819835,
0.2781399786,
-0.5505905151,
0.4846223891,
-0.1256664395,
0.406473428,
0.731712997,
0.0803023279,
0.5565995574,
-0.7179818153,
0.4153406918,
-0.3077062964,
0.3208807409,
-0.1705684662,
-0.4095349908,
-0.9032108188,
-0.9591094255,
0.4554504156,
0.2421474755,
-0.3346638978,
-0.0220413785,
-0.1263587624,
-0.6329993606,
-0.4279921353,
0.4584667981,
0.2249157727,
0.4512045383,
0.6589517593,
-0.3619487584,
-0.4289948344,
-1.2831891775,
-0.2805206478,
0.2715530097,
-0.2530116439,
0.5475336313,
0.4301990867,
0.0498813204,
0.8372504711,
-0.9046490192,
-0.3854939938,
-0.0986590683,
0.3956426978,
0.3193848431,
0.8772984743,
0.6807332635,
-0.5224603415,
-0.518239677,
0.0321670063,
-0.326302886,
-0.1169946045,
0.0537256375,
-0.2796664536,
-0.3605834842,
0.5356512666,
-0.8050836921,
0.1050435379,
0.4371354282,
0.2188506871,
0.2800095677,
-0.2686834633,
0.2809568346,
-0.7834250927,
0.0813778117,
-0.4884853661,
-0.3587734997,
-0.3228998184,
0.4516870975,
0.2189141065,
-0.4304074943,
-0.2419948429,
0.6885546446,
-0.7441622615,
0.1268147081,
-0.3219582438,
-0.2766125202,
-0.1581163257,
0.5125768185,
-0.4064543843,
0.8086432219,
0.5386644006,
-0.6989355087,
0.1714817286,
-0.0527669266,
-0.4531705379,
0.3600603342,
-0.5900797844,
0.1366358399,
-0.1117728725,
0.2323657572,
-1.1897038221,
-0.6555817723,
0.1382803172,
-0.1494042873,
0.4115570188,
-0.3918172121,
-0.4650315642,
-0.4491571784,
-0.4098499119,
0.5773119926,
0.553111136,
-0.6316027045,
0.5178439617,
0.248736009,
0.0538879447,
-0.4601822793,
-0.704757154,
-0.1751845032,
-0.0940233991,
-0.7657879591,
0.2972024977,
-0.1656310558,
0.2430175394,
-0.1246131659,
-0.2939952016,
-0.2326294184,
0.2560939193,
0.1839226037,
-0.0185825694,
-0.1135718748,
0.2872968912,
0.5227563381,
-0.0252951123,
-0.4601129889,
-0.5256893039,
0.6785202026,
-0.4194059968,
-0.1916848868,
-0.342590034,
0.2093943954,
0.4419418275,
-0.1725326031,
0.7585293651,
0.7317431569,
-0.5275963545,
-0.4002081752,
-0.9157560468,
-0.4546270669,
-0.4998445213,
0.3210530579,
-0.4839480519,
-1.187091589,
0.6150643826,
-0.1605834067,
-0.0269008949,
0.2661285996,
0.3259558976,
-0.0291888118,
0.8995691538,
0.6792242527,
0.0095356517,
0.5322699547,
-0.4376028776,
-0.0191482324,
-0.8828161955,
0.2604190707,
-0.428047508,
-0.5140482783,
-0.4191933572,
-0.6077361703,
0.1962321699,
0.5477505922,
-0.5775249004,
0.6976467967,
-0.6780101061,
0.679756403,
0.6354256272,
0.3690564036,
0.1759417057,
0.2478765398,
0.0594965257,
0.1361341178,
-0.7338986993,
-0.1941289157,
1.1287510395,
0.1056021377,
0.6039873362,
-0.0346412137,
0.6813873649,
0.2415281534,
0.5584526658,
-0.5521805286,
0.5419595838,
-0.3208995461,
-0.798027575,
-0.4165822864,
-0.3302174509,
-0.7948747873,
0.1531666964,
0.067666769,
-0.7947947979,
0.1748961806,
0.5381608009,
-0.5510302782,
0.4088915586,
-0.6925492883,
0.835626781,
0.2289602607,
-0.4882486463,
-0.7368192673,
-0.3502293527,
0.4282381535,
-0.0613988303,
-0.1989151239,
-0.4294068813,
-0.3269528449,
0.6896883249,
-0.7545416951,
0.6534819603,
-0.3807556629,
0.2074852139,
0.4654518366,
-0.0473243035,
0.6004299521,
0.3973968327,
-0.0898502842,
0.3952301443,
-0.1538279653,
-0.972050488,
-0.5896871686,
0.8927461505,
-0.7711141109,
-0.6862005591,
-0.1176127419,
-1.0800973177,
-0.4770836234,
0.3370726407,
0.0210464709,
0.1619178057,
0.0511833951,
0.6434099674,
0.5222364664,
-0.0827343017,
0.3061321676,
0.3740306199,
0.2064294219,
-0.6231762767,
0.8697882295,
0.2685807347,
0.4074039161,
0.4460406005,
0.350171119,
0.2060476691,
-0.6780541539,
-0.4882856607,
0.1561780572,
-0.3387767971,
-0.559967041,
-0.6789841652,
-0.1065908819,
-0.2335282564,
-0.386813134,
-0.5215324759,
-0.6024931073,
0.0011799888,
0.1363911629,
0.6192522645,
0.1647969186,
-0.2922801077,
0.8757722378,
-0.6097750068,
0.5632033944,
0.5532433987,
0.5540958047,
0.1207731739,
-0.3405393362,
-0.4012311101,
0.1821500063,
-0.4172079861,
-0.395603776,
-0.0680236369,
0.2199620605,
0.3668369949,
0.2533546686,
0.046613235,
1.0447951555,
-0.2591117322,
0.4734057188,
-0.002359068,
-0.9446780682,
0.5925448537,
-0.8096760511,
0.4289020598,
0.9199804664,
0.3131482601,
-0.0513645597,
-0.3373718262,
-0.5339192748,
-0.7845302224,
0.7497701049,
0.1723662913,
0.2534072399,
0.2536168694,
0.6725583076,
0.1889557093,
0.4057290554,
-0.3395263553,
0.3399116397,
-0.124358885,
-0.1990378648,
0.1344899237,
-0.172318548,
-0.1158588827,
-0.486466676,
0.7234756947,
-0.3600098491,
0.0795673728,
0.0295359623,
-0.1598480791,
-0.0789579675,
-0.0408067666,
0.5156691074,
0.6071832776,
-0.701967299,
-0.160497129,
0.5060777068,
-0.6451357603,
-0.0957493633,
0.1893933266,
-0.1838945448,
-0.4753657579,
0.0615109764,
0.9496331215,
0.3930872977,
-0.3996810615,
0.4478214383,
0.0757010728,
-0.281329006,
0.1857936829,
0.2641035318,
-0.0451124012,
0.2311938107,
0.3250282705,
0.3713342845,
0.1118114665,
-0.2371261567,
0.3705641329,
0.5714897513,
-0.3964483142,
0.1674302369,
0.7529834509,
0.0239259508,
0.1528686434,
0.5499377251,
-0.0787822604,
0.0724582151,
0.6711035371,
0.1257126033,
0.8540505767,
-0.2321736515,
0.0639080331,
0.5914528966,
0.4901283085,
-0.4150896668,
0.1544793695,
-0.3825289011,
-0.6334146261,
-0.4236693382,
-0.7519107461,
-0.4217093587,
0.3972565532,
-0.6343937516,
0.6693859696,
-0.9551411271,
0.0060105035,
-0.2687920928,
0.1282260716,
-0.6784955263,
0.3030590713,
-0.3018030822,
0.9278666377,
-0.4671623409,
0.7631917596,
0.5916146636,
-0.5931920409,
-0.8222983479,
0.0120522492,
-0.367056787,
-0.8769546151,
0.4111083746,
0.4112621248,
-0.0510188639,
0.2937294841,
-0.7757779956,
-1.0823173523,
1.141970396,
0.6578981876,
-0.6408427358,
0.085413076,
0.066533044,
0.2307679951,
-0.3828870952,
0.31709373,
0.1354345083,
0.4966485202,
-0.0109796515,
-0.7291363478,
0.2994925976,
0.0868531391,
0.1241137162,
0.194729045,
-1.0008324385,
1.0971010923,
-0.2791157961,
-0.0904765576,
0.4736943245,
0.6589328647,
0.2587174177,
0.015666604,
0.7929983139,
0.679035604,
0.8568838239,
-0.0641471222,
1.1801946163,
-0.2464844435,
0.4961620867,
1.1715769768,
0.0424567014,
0.6970178485,
0.2372923046,
0.1314980537,
0.3459914923,
0.6878449917,
-0.3606025279,
0.7141489387,
0.4103981853,
-0.1361027509,
-0.5393584967,
-0.0743648559,
-0.3885554969,
0.3369627595,
0.027626643,
0.1000015363,
-0.2455899268,
0.3015078306,
0.0183180049,
-0.3399369121,
-0.460886687,
0.2937088907,
0.0722088516,
-0.7294806242,
0.8461315036,
-0.0520828962,
0.3978070319,
-0.6570305824,
-0.0370741002,
-0.2617307901,
0.5247724652,
-0.0115893865,
-0.3423793316,
0.2043759823,
-0.2876492441,
-0.2295533866,
-0.1143851206,
0.7352307439,
-0.3340815306,
-0.4070906341,
0.2444737107,
0.2158864141,
-0.0470544212,
-0.5230736136,
-0.5477559566,
0.084699057,
-0.2541328669,
-0.1469714642,
0.3701445758,
-0.0140280928,
-0.3956252933,
0.7251372337,
0.9380295873,
0.0243490953,
-0.2273679972,
0.0798346847,
1.0655181408,
-0.3757669032,
-0.4889557064,
-0.5564271808,
0.5032432079,
-0.2400573343,
-0.2440599203,
0.5223178864,
0.6920277476,
1.0051317215,
-0.2564196289,
0.5283934474,
-0.0311865285,
0.4079754651,
-0.411852479,
0.9491304755,
-0.8849927187,
0.0961364359,
-0.3179024756,
-0.9984184504,
-0.4416260123,
0.5057131052,
-0.2351882756,
0.0442232192,
0.7154036164,
0.9346235394,
-0.4600374103,
0.0182572752,
0.207217589,
0.2059045434,
0.2569437921,
0.3949877322,
0.4303756654,
-0.7350047231,
0.705755651,
-0.2668621838,
-0.5502843261,
-0.263076663,
-0.8092077374,
-0.9325108528,
-0.3473645747,
-0.3888239264,
-0.0456637144,
0.4434133172,
0.5092932582,
1.2192069292,
-0.9437547922,
-0.3213901818,
-0.5183330774,
-0.0898951441,
-0.4958277941,
-0.2015669495,
0.2879695594,
-0.6954261661,
-0.5659660697,
0.2010565996,
0.1385574192,
-0.3563800752,
0.1579930186,
-0.0076664826,
-0.2222575843,
0.2357934564,
0.335332036,
0.203433007,
-0.5343053341,
-0.5991885066,
-0.2704404891,
0.2260870934,
-0.0574005134,
0.9077674747,
-0.7483444214,
0.2318233252,
0.5658330321,
0.8411054015,
0.9691826105,
0.0549740084,
0.4728026986,
-0.7852040529,
0.3529366553,
-0.0183953885,
0.2995912731,
0.2629927695,
-0.2758171558,
0.7445634604,
0.2246410847,
-0.5588188767,
-0.8638193011,
0.1758058518,
-1.2866396904,
-0.2878539264,
0.6697136164,
0.2006373256,
-0.0186203476,
0.184523806,
-0.4747052491,
0.3333231807,
-0.5311006308,
0.6454857588,
0.7089494467,
-0.1076478884,
-0.3155964911,
-0.8289697766,
0.5660498738,
0.7038743496,
-0.728150785,
0.1275453269,
0.205799371,
0.4532493353,
0.0070831194,
0.4804612696,
0.0561552867,
0.3957075179,
-0.1059661508,
-0.036489848,
-0.3803698123,
-0.3165083528,
0.1561068743,
0.3163512051,
-0.0301854573,
-0.4825193584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01315v1 | Language Portability Strategies for Open-domain Dialogue with Pre-trained Language Models from High to Low Resource Languages | 2024-07-01T14:20:54 | 2024-07-01T14:20:54 | Ahmed Njifenjou, Virgile Sucal, Bassam Jabaian, Fabrice Lefèvre | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we propose a study of linguistic portability strategies of
large pre-trained language models (PLMs) used for open-domain dialogue systems
in a high-resource language for this task. In particular the target
low-resource language (L_T) will be simulated with French, as it lacks of
task-specific resources and allows our human evaluation, when the source
language (L_S) is English. For obvious reasons, recent works using such models
for open-domain dialogue are mostly developed in English. Yet building specific
PLMs for each possible target language supposes collecting new datasets and is
costly. For this reason, trying to leverage all existing resources (PLMs and
data) in both L_S and L_T , we wish to assess the performance achievable in L_T
with different approaches. The first two approaches evaluate the usage of
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) at different levels: TrainOnTarget where a L_S
dataset is translated before fine-tuning in L_T and TestOnSource where a L_S
model is coupled with NMT modules during inference. Then, the advent of BLOOM
[2], the world first open-access multilingual large PLM, allow researchers to
develop new approaches aiming to leverage not only the model's full
accessibility but also its multilingualism and translation abilities. In this
context the task is learned in L_S first and adapted to L_T using the MAD-X
Adapter architecture [16]. In the two sets of experiments models are evaluated
in spoken dialogue conditions with human and the strategies can be compared in
terms of perceived interaction quality. | [
-0.5748043656,
-0.6541759372,
0.510001123,
0.2449463606,
-0.1888045818,
-0.0034117673,
-0.7222021222,
-0.2411203235,
0.0094021372,
0.6461517215,
-0.4913709164,
-0.3431320786,
-0.479095161,
0.2099020928,
-0.0440947041,
0.6503042579,
-0.2657399476,
0.0427289195,
-0.163399294,
-0.2571518719,
-0.4549558759,
-0.8422752619,
-0.6103668809,
-0.0331619009,
0.2897689939,
0.3883669972,
0.7736814022,
0.3797687292,
0.3926728666,
0.306251049,
-0.2309903055,
-0.0885804221,
-0.6246219277,
-0.052548565,
-0.4358035326,
-0.4722350538,
-0.4888309538,
-0.1061743423,
0.7480724454,
0.6476075649,
0.0589714311,
-0.0176931527,
0.3156194687,
0.412884742,
-0.5087759495,
0.4053693712,
-0.5549291968,
0.0115697114,
-0.2116096169,
-0.2600899339,
-0.5526002645,
-0.09540122,
0.4148561358,
-0.5190050602,
0.0838434026,
-0.0402253047,
0.6649265885,
0.0045585427,
-0.2087412924,
0.0114183836,
-1.0970038176,
0.9675133228,
-0.8950341344,
0.355268985,
0.3801034689,
0.4713492095,
-0.0154525423,
-0.4489422441,
-0.5522398949,
-0.3691866994,
-0.0682309642,
0.0148809459,
-0.213966459,
0.2230173945,
0.3126352131,
0.3631493449,
-0.48694399,
0.1855921447,
-0.2424029261,
-0.1602679938,
0.4310914874,
-0.0940588415,
0.211083442,
0.0476687141,
-0.2670053542,
0.0103277769,
-0.6889945865,
0.0064461473,
0.2094242275,
0.7615082264,
-0.1631796062,
0.5981734991,
-0.2394226789,
0.616589725,
-0.2891395092,
-0.0014621007,
0.1278015822,
-0.7468758821,
-0.0459796712,
-0.2280537039,
0.9349129796,
0.2372144014,
0.3814501464,
-0.0671679303,
-0.4119462371,
-0.3769049048,
0.3039265275,
-0.7564204335,
0.1445950866,
0.0436279774,
-0.6766924262,
-0.128565371,
-0.3869239986,
-0.9226533175,
-0.0457463451,
-0.1109108701,
0.8430905342,
-0.4025969207,
-0.5035821795,
0.1396300197,
0.4511830509,
0.0017856974,
0.4494007528,
-0.5758680701,
0.3750748336,
0.265234381,
1.1143319607,
-0.3685833216,
-0.2775286734,
-0.5152139664,
-0.1080138981,
-0.0355132855,
0.4377083778,
-0.2362395525,
-0.6696283221,
0.2380734086,
0.0013604925,
-0.4395089149,
-0.5826179385,
0.5971107483,
-0.4665515721,
0.223432973,
-0.1071132645,
-0.1716228426,
-0.2546393573,
0.30567047,
-0.7666153312,
0.4562883675,
0.2395174652,
-0.5966277719,
-0.2494391799,
-0.9222278595,
-0.5239998698,
-0.0285988301,
0.0575381555,
-0.1232244074,
-0.0777650401,
-0.090359278,
0.2628806531,
-0.4554489255,
0.0955817997,
-0.1414643228,
-0.2258199304,
0.2047999799,
-0.6640591621,
0.5774529576,
0.3950533271,
-0.4514381588,
0.1295251101,
-0.5800054669,
0.0140555725,
0.254511416,
-0.3603959382,
-0.3137745559,
0.1380571574,
0.0099374047,
0.3770194054,
0.1556544453,
-0.555324614,
0.0747255459,
-0.6130462885,
0.5607284307,
0.4457903504,
-0.162651509,
0.5367662907,
-0.2482839376,
0.7519349456,
0.2542089522,
0.1463502347,
-0.2335776687,
-0.4115310609,
-0.763035059,
-0.024094332,
0.3218570054,
0.8080796599,
-0.8465100527,
0.2063862234,
-0.2207941711,
-0.2632136047,
-0.459109962,
-0.0946978405,
0.5988469124,
0.1782622188,
0.3587827682,
-0.5955032706,
-0.3865491748,
-0.8149979115,
-0.1511387378,
-0.1844323725,
0.2564544082,
0.5232937932,
0.2222556323,
-0.0079192407,
0.7517384291,
-0.3001382351,
-0.1449577957,
-0.6476172209,
0.042565573,
0.2044057697,
0.5844538808,
0.5745891929,
-0.6346822977,
-0.4621531963,
0.1539195031,
-0.4625962079,
0.0476607531,
0.0915524438,
-0.2170426548,
0.3139708042,
0.3636716008,
-0.7925167084,
0.7411609888,
0.5209041238,
0.0394702405,
0.5966536403,
-0.3225703239,
0.2902222872,
-1.2140347958,
0.0404388271,
-0.0603838116,
-0.172634393,
-0.9761840701,
-0.022537699,
-0.3039656281,
-0.3577024043,
-0.8398509622,
0.6745094061,
-0.4292506576,
-0.0346504934,
-0.189527899,
0.2285865396,
-0.2228617668,
0.6127793789,
0.2944339812,
1.0371474028,
0.4722792506,
-0.7396813631,
-0.0343394354,
0.3980305195,
-0.3509697914,
0.3624992371,
-0.6459625363,
-0.0412922576,
0.0347501114,
0.1122524589,
-0.9780296683,
0.2322100997,
0.2373749763,
-0.3678187728,
0.176597476,
-0.1882680655,
-0.4015666842,
-0.2394955903,
0.1574846804,
0.7798321247,
0.4831773043,
-0.3423065841,
0.5571807623,
0.1487461776,
-0.433157593,
-0.4278906584,
-0.42326051,
-0.0848503634,
-0.1593048573,
-0.7713000774,
0.1943006516,
-0.2321005613,
-0.2265740186,
-0.2370237708,
0.1002511829,
-0.29958269,
0.0274335314,
0.0759836063,
0.2341763824,
-0.5790476799,
-0.1418582052,
-0.2167477757,
-0.0295661688,
-0.1604912728,
-0.3688550293,
0.7513164878,
-0.1647312343,
-0.4430571496,
-0.3848732412,
0.4803319573,
0.6823186874,
-0.5162875056,
0.9811593294,
0.4652207196,
-0.2105970532,
-0.0860520378,
-0.4182442427,
-0.1224168912,
-0.4131990969,
0.3037762344,
-0.6526076198,
-0.9213351011,
0.5495874286,
-0.1945527941,
0.1140022576,
0.2334160954,
0.6831113696,
0.1343415529,
0.964987874,
0.6194720864,
0.0013596874,
0.4157530665,
-0.2854201794,
0.4898072183,
-0.5092752576,
0.217538476,
-0.7410170436,
-0.2315044105,
-0.6437609792,
-0.7068894506,
0.3219469488,
0.2581926584,
-0.0678657368,
0.6236131787,
-0.0068942378,
0.3338826597,
0.8142952323,
-0.1081884056,
0.4274171293,
0.0000708583,
-0.2514365017,
-0.0606816299,
-0.89089185,
-0.5408399701,
0.9201735854,
0.4095778465,
0.5748918653,
0.3103441,
0.5731153488,
-0.0980362073,
0.1648661643,
-0.8681968451,
0.763559401,
-0.253031224,
-0.4825294018,
-0.3143673837,
-0.5575624704,
-1.0081971884,
0.3565016091,
-0.1529705971,
-0.825265944,
0.0931415856,
0.1005391702,
-0.38375929,
0.5662705898,
-0.7837287188,
1.173823595,
-0.206724599,
-0.3995293677,
-0.3585943282,
-0.6727776527,
0.2577145696,
-0.1400755197,
0.3281069696,
0.1788721234,
0.1850008816,
0.5838990808,
-0.33191064,
0.7572209835,
-0.208545655,
-0.1632643193,
0.3393713534,
0.3592646122,
0.3783062398,
-0.2784116268,
-0.0151888803,
0.2931466401,
0.1868132353,
-0.3561375439,
-0.5759013891,
0.4929179847,
-0.8831076622,
-0.6866537929,
-0.2928980589,
-0.7864513397,
-0.4957224131,
0.3613532484,
0.2485267222,
0.4720982015,
-0.404758662,
0.0485126078,
0.6772216558,
-0.5807482004,
0.4823451042,
0.890484035,
-0.3267119527,
-0.2849838138,
1.0239549875,
0.2058203816,
0.6707437634,
0.4722945392,
0.0582971089,
-0.2363110781,
-0.7999947071,
-0.4029843807,
0.3589130342,
-0.3605258465,
0.1056580245,
-0.449878186,
-0.4484187365,
-0.3512220383,
0.1564057171,
-0.5409446955,
-0.400052458,
-0.188575983,
0.2594532073,
0.070777148,
0.6379478574,
-0.0556252003,
0.4695415199,
-1.1216254234,
0.0501451194,
-0.1210426539,
0.5882052779,
-0.0035530131,
-0.6582650542,
-0.4605238736,
0.1810758412,
-0.2953332365,
-0.752484858,
0.4004842043,
-0.0104579199,
0.626175046,
0.2279694676,
0.2223654985,
0.3196382523,
-0.5962939858,
0.7938156724,
0.023091482,
-0.762365818,
0.5372098684,
-0.525778532,
0.25140962,
0.6371720433,
0.5035044551,
-0.4406099617,
-0.2207230777,
-0.5038135052,
-0.6806077361,
0.9574689269,
0.3195513189,
0.1379106492,
0.090725325,
0.0492924415,
0.1308837533,
0.3649557531,
-0.5155024529,
-0.0882534236,
0.0321149528,
-0.0210425667,
-0.481431365,
-0.1539653689,
-0.1951916516,
-0.0529815517,
0.708627224,
-0.0293697249,
0.487662226,
0.055986762,
-0.2014650702,
-0.0580005348,
0.5332740545,
0.7771582007,
0.5553070903,
-0.330617398,
-0.01916245,
-0.0909686536,
-0.3789404631,
0.3016883135,
0.2287252694,
-0.3231354356,
0.1834727675,
-0.079623051,
1.1175749302,
0.1599744707,
-0.8559576273,
0.7322191596,
-0.1089992672,
-0.2022937685,
-0.0721719339,
-0.2700132132,
-0.1257436275,
0.3415723443,
-0.2076776475,
0.2588210702,
-0.2110367417,
-0.467179507,
0.146650061,
0.4759201109,
-0.3022227287,
-0.3750219345,
0.5585364699,
0.40994519,
-0.4296931028,
0.3859108686,
-0.2250368148,
-0.4569587409,
0.1561494768,
0.552052319,
0.9999209046,
-0.3701893687,
0.2454128414,
0.4302773476,
0.388525933,
-0.2025429159,
0.1604176313,
-0.1050882563,
-0.8573242426,
-0.7760423422,
-0.5442320704,
-0.5445923805,
0.2761302888,
-0.6140038967,
0.1123889908,
-0.2118752599,
-0.2540310323,
-0.4861582518,
-0.2778454721,
-0.6354501843,
-0.1081245393,
-0.0254882313,
1.2580618858,
-0.646820724,
0.8575108051,
0.517570138,
-0.4793902934,
-0.7785271406,
0.125644967,
-0.0891702846,
-0.6862545609,
0.6599543691,
-0.1174763441,
-0.0529245958,
0.0928489119,
0.0128948987,
-0.8850141168,
0.8104227781,
0.4663154483,
-0.5276584625,
-0.2262559086,
0.2588246763,
0.4163063467,
-0.2779615819,
0.3284825385,
0.5616153479,
0.3431992531,
0.0690808967,
-1.5633246899,
-0.2162794173,
-0.2233048081,
0.1172769293,
0.1878022403,
-0.633679688,
0.7598414421,
-0.196699962,
-0.1750210524,
0.4327908754,
0.6742466092,
-0.0318157375,
0.1705097556,
0.6664156318,
0.4684309661,
0.3076087236,
-0.1913926154,
1.0400489569,
-0.4594833255,
0.3723606467,
1.0322434902,
-0.3482187688,
1.1235142946,
0.4002856314,
-0.2577655911,
0.1479852051,
0.3248071671,
0.5048373342,
0.5383729339,
0.3322978318,
-0.5812525749,
-0.0444222875,
-0.2477961183,
-0.3166294992,
0.309229821,
0.1685964763,
-0.2033448815,
-0.2422186285,
0.4016013145,
-0.0336606503,
0.1248016357,
-0.379791081,
0.7960692644,
0.0313640609,
-0.8599194288,
0.8398346901,
0.0116946297,
0.6721701622,
-0.6484004855,
0.1611388922,
-0.1755592227,
0.1642555296,
0.0094212368,
-0.7379555702,
0.2259515226,
-0.0329469778,
-0.1985743493,
-0.366494596,
0.628139019,
-0.7712230086,
-0.1396419108,
0.4087634087,
0.9652308822,
0.4325990379,
-0.0527568161,
-0.5024306774,
0.1542891562,
-0.005795802,
-0.2096796334,
0.6170358062,
0.2840206325,
0.0312852673,
0.5842650533,
0.3662892878,
0.3381488323,
0.1145635322,
0.090541482,
0.7104439139,
-0.3910191357,
-0.4562617838,
-0.5289355516,
0.4410977066,
0.2849482894,
-0.0132654943,
0.628058672,
0.4140842855,
0.9612284899,
-0.2154570222,
0.9811640382,
0.0383235663,
0.7092422843,
-0.5131028891,
0.5369852781,
-0.3835144937,
0.2272722274,
-0.2638061643,
-1.1123723984,
0.0091023436,
0.622823,
-0.5558945537,
0.1044068485,
0.7706321478,
0.8536631465,
-0.1875999868,
0.1585082561,
0.5160737634,
0.4311688244,
0.2280411571,
0.7953392267,
0.7372905612,
-0.2266910821,
0.7722008228,
-0.2762776017,
-0.3698619604,
-0.169174701,
-0.6818393469,
-0.7394464612,
-0.6390167475,
-0.3197897375,
-0.7272789478,
0.0089029782,
0.9465535283,
0.630325675,
-0.8985037208,
-0.6114000678,
0.0687627643,
-0.103006579,
-0.2242373824,
-0.2240722924,
0.0229041539,
-0.3842120171,
-0.8027229309,
0.6227677464,
0.1911253035,
0.233806625,
-0.3060256839,
-0.2912245095,
-0.1701009274,
0.0808518976,
0.7834770083,
0.5343059897,
-0.5581757426,
-0.2913587093,
0.0125762625,
-0.0154035054,
0.1042060554,
1.0145648718,
-0.4975728095,
0.6362145543,
0.5466877818,
0.8206217289,
0.2321312875,
-0.0966664478,
0.9762936234,
-0.640136838,
0.2642560005,
0.2168896496,
0.3422728479,
0.0720830336,
0.0651461259,
0.4002358615,
0.2486104369,
-0.6288097501,
-0.8229009509,
0.4077362716,
-1.1215096712,
0.0218445119,
1.1727746725,
-0.3803156018,
-0.0384456664,
-0.0938360468,
-0.4894734621,
0.2037298232,
-0.1908492446,
0.2719988525,
0.8166973591,
0.0305477418,
-0.2493687123,
-0.9398242831,
0.4223796725,
0.4242157042,
-0.6322488189,
0.1395317614,
0.1831804216,
0.108352989,
0.3509378731,
0.8353899717,
-0.1786641032,
0.1574769616,
-0.3521967232,
0.0309128836,
0.158393383,
-0.1426846385,
-0.3048909903,
0.0970646068,
0.328461498,
-0.3014222085
] |